She looked perfect it wasn't about her look.. The thing that was off about her. Hera Wouldn't allow them to disarm a bomb like that. In a hospital room
The thing i realized is that when an actor with dark eyes wears light colored contacts it always looks off. Look at Jessica Alba in the second Fantatic 4 or Brandon Routh in Superman Returns. I think its because the iris doesnt move and you subconsciously notice it and it makes the actor look like a doll. Donthey make colored contacts that are less opaque?
I’m guessing the more transparent it is, the less effective- especially on camera and under lights where color gets tricky. You’ll always lose something in the process of filming it and have to compensate
@@IAteFire I wonder if there's a way to accommodate for that though, like maybe going for a colour value brighter or darker than you want to an equal degree that the person's actual pupil is the other way, for instance
@@alalalala57 they are supposed to move, if you seen the clone wars cartoon show, ahsoka tano for example head tails move……. In Star Wars basically this is their hair basically..
I know they are artists but I cannot help but think that colored foundation like from the brand Sunset Makeup would have helped it look more natural and less cakey 🤔
Imagine making a super cool costume, hours to paint the skin and overall makeup a whole team to work on every single detail, and then use the cheapest eye contact lenses 😂
The contact lenses was one thing that was annoying to me. Don't get me wrong, I enjoyed the show. But the contact lenses constantly made me feel like Hera is an artificial thing :( I understand they wanted to mantain the bright colour looks of their irises like they had in the Rebels, but I always thought about them as an artistic representations of "real human" colours in Rebels. Everyone there had bright irises. So I would expect Hera and Ezra to have a more decent human-like colours in a live action set. At least in Ezra's case. I don't quite understand it, SAbine had normal colour even though she also had something a little bit more extravagant in the animated series. Anyway, as I said, a minor thing.
Hera is in my top 10 Star Wars characters, I just don’t think the casting fits man. Definitely due to the writing in some parts and she’s not horrible but the look and demeanour is just off, I don’t see Hera. Dark eyes being changed to light eyes is always off putting too for some reason, there’s just a way to tell. There’s a couple fan castings out there that I think would’ve been a better fit like Cobie Smoulders possibly but it’s a big ask to go in the makeup chair extra early for multiple hours every day and an actor has to be willing to do that so massive props to Mary
Something was off about her look. Maybe it’s when the outfit looks more like cosplay than natural states for the character. We didn’t see Hera in normal clothes, her without the cap, etc. That lends more realism and immersion than cartoon accurate looks and outfits. IMO.
@jonc2914 The Ahsoka series but if you didn't watch the entire Rebels series and the entire original trilogy and the entire of the clone wars series it won't make sense.
Would have preferred Kerry Washington as the actress her voice matches so perfectly. And then they could make Elizabeth winstead play duchess satine with her husband Ewan McGregor in some flashback scenes in Kenobi
@kyleharrell6624 what's funny to me is that I always used to think that Rosario Dawson would make a great live-action Hera. I just felt like her bone structure suited Hera's well. Then she got cast as Ahsoka, and she looked great as Ahsoka too! So idk anymore...
Frfr. I had no idea that- that was John McClane’s daughter/the huntress/the last survivor of 10 Cloverfield lane but not the last survivor of the apocalypse maybe? I had no idea until this video & now I’m flabbergasted
was distracted on the show with the makeup because it was uneven around the mouth. it's like she took a bite between shots and wiped her mouth with a napkin and nobody noticed to retouch it. there was flesh tones that needed to be greener.
And they messed it up so bad. She didn't look like Hera, didn't act like her. It's almost like the actress married to obi wan Kenobi got the part for other reasons than casting fit
So, instead of blaming the writer or director (Dave Filoni) for the dialogue or the look, you insinuate it's because MEW is married to Ewan McGregor? Filoni is an awful live action director, none of his live actions have looked or sounded good, but you still decided to blame the actress.
@kinoko5566 Hera already existed in the cartoon. MEW was nothing like Hera and should never have been cast in that role. There is no way she ever is able to do a version of Hera, it would be like asking Jack Black to play Michael Corleone. I haven't blamed her, it's not her fault she was there from nepotism, it's rarely the person's fault they are a nepo pick. Doesn't change the facts
I've come up with a term that helps me determine whether a game is for me or not: the point of no return. Once I get to the point of a game when I've engaged in all the systems including combat, exploration, crafting, etc., I know exactly what the game has to offer. It can take one hour or five hours, but once I hit that point I'll either drop it or keep going.
Just a reminder; Mary Elizabeth Winstead, quite literally broke up Ewan McGregor’s marriage…. To the point that his own children have said that she is an awful woman…..and while yes Ewan is also to blame…. Mary 1000% knew that he was a married man and had been since 1995 😂😂 so yeah; I also think her only reason for being in this franchise is because she’s shtooping him
Thwy should have talked with the people who did gamoras make-up for gotg, and they should not have contacts that are just one colour completely, they should make them look the same way actual eyes are. I find it weird that they are a big production with big backing and still doing mistakes that have already been solved by others
I'm still comfused at how Cosplayers do 50x better than this in quality on a very minimal budget for their hobby, and a multi-million dollar show ends up looking equal to a last-minute Spirit halloween costume. The twi'lek in Book of Boba Fett even looked better than this, Hera is a main character and they just didnt even try, it's so disheartening. Star Wars aliens are so amazing and theyre continuously getting downgraded in their portrayls and designs in the big, high-profile shows, and yet the side projects get amazing SFX love and care. What is happening.
it always looks off when you go from animated character to live action. you should design it like they went from live action to animated. and then making an advanced civilization with tech that they can traverse space with dressed as WW2 bomber pilots and cowboys is comical.
It would have been much better with black eyeballs and red brown irises don't know why just would more realistic for that divergent humanoid type or maybe yellow iris
He says that could be a challenge it's not for everyone try installing antennas on skyscrapers because that's what I've done for the past 7 years that's a challenge that's not for everyone.
The clothes were just too shiny and new looking. It threw me off every time I watched. You should be more like the guys on Andor. They do everything perfect or it seems that way.
@@SuperJetsfan4life I am not sure if the two can be compared. Andor is set during reign of the Empire. People are at sort of at war. Ahsoka is set post empire during the new republic so it's a lot more peaceful (beside Thrawn being back on the rise).
What did you think of Hera's overall look and makeup in Ahsoka? Anything you'd like to see done differently in Season 2??
Maybe just don't have a 2nd season. The 1st wasn't very good
She looked perfect it wasn't about her look.. The thing that was off about her. Hera Wouldn't allow them to disarm a bomb like that. In a hospital room
Like to see it cancelled
@@namogel67 oh grow up....they're going to have a second one. And this is the show that gave us Clone Wars Hayden. Be thankful
@@FIRING_BLIND it was a pretty terrible girl boss show
Kermit said it best it’s not easy being green
haaya
It's not easy being greensy
And the cake still made it to the final product!
My man
hehehe
@@jayd2407 Glad I wasn't the only one who noticed. The cameraman walked a fine line.
@@jayd2407 it sure did but that’s a different kinda cake 💀💀😏😉 it’s the kind all of us gents would love a piece of 😏😏
Fr fr
The thing i realized is that when an actor with dark eyes wears light colored contacts it always looks off. Look at Jessica Alba in the second Fantatic 4 or Brandon Routh in Superman Returns. I think its because the iris doesnt move and you subconsciously notice it and it makes the actor look like a doll. Donthey make colored contacts that are less opaque?
I’m guessing the more transparent it is, the less effective- especially on camera and under lights where color gets tricky. You’ll always lose something in the process of filming it and have to compensate
In the wise words of Bob Ross, light colors on dark colors make them pop more, the same vice versa
@@userunknown4331he would be so proud you shared knowledge based on color application from his teachings and your deductions 💙
@@IAteFire I wonder if there's a way to accommodate for that though, like maybe going for a colour value brighter or darker than you want to an equal degree that the person's actual pupil is the other way, for instance
Hera's eyes in the Show had a very distinct colour, so I guess they just really wanted to be as close to that as possible.
What i hate is they keep making all these head tails stiff as a board
They're not supposed to be flabby, I think.
@@alalalala57 they are supposed to move, if you seen the clone wars cartoon show, ahsoka tano for example head tails move……. In Star Wars basically this is their hair basically..
@@horrorxlove2726Ahsoka is a different species though and hers store memories
@@skeletor4436yeah but she was in the show my guy so I'm assuming they're talking about both of them
Twi'lek lekkus are different, they are less rigid than Togruta lekkus but they definitely move
they need to start designing contacts with images of real eyes to start with. Its uncanny valley when contacts stand out so much.
She's an alien little boy
its an alien why would they want it to look like real eyes
@@nak3dxsnake my friend she's an alien. There's not supposed to be any canny in the first place
She's hot regardless of the makeup
I know they are artists but I cannot help but think that colored foundation like from the brand Sunset Makeup would have helped it look more natural and less cakey 🤔
That brand has some controversy attached I thought
Or like adding some dimension to the face. They need a cosplayer makeup artist consult on set.
@@eerielconstantine5051 oh no! What happened? I really liked their stuff-they have a great range of products and colours of them
Imagine making a super cool costume, hours to paint the skin and overall makeup a whole team to work on every single detail, and then use the cheapest eye contact lenses 😂
Whoever did the green make up for Gomora, should've done it for Hara. The make up was still visible and the contact lenses looks cheap and obvious
indeed
The contact lenses was one thing that was annoying to me. Don't get me wrong, I enjoyed the show. But the contact lenses constantly made me feel like Hera is an artificial thing :( I understand they wanted to mantain the bright colour looks of their irises like they had in the Rebels, but I always thought about them as an artistic representations of "real human" colours in Rebels. Everyone there had bright irises. So I would expect Hera and Ezra to have a more decent human-like colours in a live action set. At least in Ezra's case. I don't quite understand it, SAbine had normal colour even though she also had something a little bit more extravagant in the animated series. Anyway, as I said, a minor thing.
@@ondrejkauzal8969 exactly my thoughts
🤷♂️ if you say so 🤪
Idk Gamoras was immensely obvious. Especially the wig and the make up
"Hey, what's that on your jacket ?
Is that the Purina logo ?"
She's gorgeous 😍
Hera is in my top 10 Star Wars characters, I just don’t think the casting fits man. Definitely due to the writing in some parts and she’s not horrible but the look and demeanour is just off, I don’t see Hera. Dark eyes being changed to light eyes is always off putting too for some reason, there’s just a way to tell. There’s a couple fan castings out there that I think would’ve been a better fit like Cobie Smoulders possibly but it’s a big ask to go in the makeup chair extra early for multiple hours every day and an actor has to be willing to do that so massive props to Mary
Something was off about her look. Maybe it’s when the outfit looks more like cosplay than natural states for the character. We didn’t see Hera in normal clothes, her without the cap, etc. That lends more realism and immersion than cartoon accurate looks and outfits. IMO.
@@RaoGung yeah removing the cap would’ve added more immersion imo. We see many twilek with full caps.
Her poor acting skills?
@@Me-qp8vz touch grass
All Mary's Husband Ewan Had to do was Grow a Beard and wear a Brown Robe for His Stars War Character.
The makeup is, pretty good but those Lekku looked like props throughout the movie and were WAYY too short.
@@theCantinafan I agree, compared to Ahsoka’s they looked cheaper imo
@@CantinaTalkSWahsoka's already looked like the same foam material the citizens of Lazytown were made out of
What movie??
@jonc2914 The Ahsoka series but if you didn't watch the entire Rebels series and the entire original trilogy and the entire of the clone wars series it won't make sense.
And it worked fabulously! ❤
It dead ass looked like makeup.
You guys really tested my crush on this chick.
@@gskate117 🤣
they crushed it, oh dear never mind,
there are more like her in a galaxy far far away
I love elizabeth, she is beautiful ❤
Damn I want a Green Girl Now!
Google Susan Oliver my young friend - I've wanted one for a while :D
Relax son it’s just makeup
I didn’t particularly picture a live action Hera like this, but it was okay
Mary is so beautiful. Even in green she looks good.
I low key had a crush on Hera when i was a kid tho.
This show bring me two of my lovely crushes in my life: Hera and Elizabeth.
She’s one of my dream celeb 😍
Wicked took this make up as a "what not to do"
I'm glad they still do makeup instead of just changing her in post 😅
Would have preferred Kerry Washington as the actress her voice matches so perfectly. And then they could make Elizabeth winstead play duchess satine with her husband Ewan McGregor in some flashback scenes in Kenobi
@kyleharrell6624 what's funny to me is that I always used to think that Rosario Dawson would make a great live-action Hera. I just felt like her bone structure suited Hera's well. Then she got cast as Ahsoka, and she looked great as Ahsoka too! So idk anymore...
@applejuice565 yeah I thought so too into they casted her as ahsoka so I had to change it
I saw a couple fan castings saying Cobie Smoulders and I think that would’ve been great too.
still hot
super hot
God. You mindless unthinking primitive. All you're able to process is how "hot" she still is. I despise you non sentients.
You can paint her all you like, Mary still looks hot 😂
Still looks caked on
I think they did an awesome job, even my 1080p tv from like 2013 at best saw its detail Twas awesome
Yeaaaah it still looked like makeup.
A Failure is still Failure
Lady can where the life into the character. Front and back.
No wayyy. That was her playing that role? 😮😮😮
One thing I gotta say is her character looked really well done. Great job! I miss it.
Even as an alien she looks so fine
A excellent job
This is Mary Winstead?? Wow I totally didn't recognize her
Frfr. I had no idea that- that was John McClane’s daughter/the huntress/the last survivor of 10 Cloverfield lane but not the last survivor of the apocalypse maybe? I had no idea until this video & now I’m flabbergasted
You didn't spot her bad acting...
@@Me-qp8vz I didn't even watch this to be honest, just saw random clips and pics here and there
was distracted on the show with the makeup because it was uneven around the mouth. it's like she took a bite between shots and wiped her mouth with a napkin and nobody noticed to retouch it. there was flesh tones that needed to be greener.
They did a great job with her make up but dropped the ball on her kids where they just went "Colour his hair green? Yeah F it that will do"
Skin look realistic.... Gives a space pilot turned general goggles
Wtf are these comments
Right? Kids and their new dumb words 😂 I'm old
@@Arkid77777 I’m not even sure anymore…
@andrewdillard5961 Not very skibidi of you. Honestly, L rizz, bruh.
Are you triggered?
@@andrewdillard5961 fr🤣🤣🤣 I'm like wtf 😂 these new words sound so stupid
They did an amazing job with Ewan Mcgregor’s wife with the makeup and how she portrayed Hera. Well done
ramona flowers is obi-wan's wife?????
@ Mary Elizabeth Winstead played Hera
Love that obi wan Kenobi's wife is also in star wars
Ramona, this is getting out of hand!
Totally cosplay! Her face is very round... looks very human.
If only the story department worked as hard as the art department 😢
The only thing I was paying attention to was the background music and I was like that sounds like meow mix
Those tails are just handles for holding on
Can't wait for Season 2. Seeing Hera and Ezra and maybe Zeb be part of the crew of The Ghost in live action would be great.
So if you care to find me… Look to a Galaxy Far Far Away.
And they messed it up so bad. She didn't look like Hera, didn't act like her. It's almost like the actress married to obi wan Kenobi got the part for other reasons than casting fit
So, instead of blaming the writer or director (Dave Filoni) for the dialogue or the look, you insinuate it's because MEW is married to Ewan McGregor? Filoni is an awful live action director, none of his live actions have looked or sounded good, but you still decided to blame the actress.
@@kinoko5566 do you really think nepotism isn't a thing in Hollywood?
@kinoko5566 Hera already existed in the cartoon. MEW was nothing like Hera and should never have been cast in that role. There is no way she ever is able to do a version of Hera, it would be like asking Jack Black to play Michael Corleone.
I haven't blamed her, it's not her fault she was there from nepotism, it's rarely the person's fault they are a nepo pick. Doesn't change the facts
Bruh, shut your whiney ass up. You neckbeards are such fn pussies crying about dumb shit
I saw a couple fan castings saying Cobie Smoulders and I think that would’ve been great too
She rocked it
By rocked it you mean boring and forgettable then yes
To whom it may concern- Birds of Prey 2 please
I've come up with a term that helps me determine whether a game is for me or not: the point of no return. Once I get to the point of a game when I've engaged in all the systems including combat, exploration, crafting, etc., I know exactly what the game has to offer. It can take one hour or five hours, but once I hit that point I'll either drop it or keep going.
What the fuck are you talking about
What about her cake? We want more cake!
Flabby saggy cake, all yours!
I still wanted Vanessa Marshall as hera 😢😢
What is it about Green sci-fi chicks being so dame alluring even at its simples right here.
Just a reminder; Mary Elizabeth Winstead, quite literally broke up Ewan McGregor’s marriage…. To the point that his own children have said that she is an awful woman…..and while yes Ewan is also to blame…. Mary 1000% knew that he was a married man and had been since 1995 😂😂 so yeah; I also think her only reason for being in this franchise is because she’s shtooping him
You can't break up a marriage that was meant to be.
She was a great Hera
Less lipstick, softer lip tones, softer eye tones, less head gear, imo.
I prefer the work that was made for the girl of the same specie in the sanctuary of the boba fett seriez
❤️
If only the writers and storytellers put in the same effort the makeup team did
Thwy should have talked with the people who did gamoras make-up for gotg, and they should not have contacts that are just one colour completely, they should make them look the same way actual eyes are. I find it weird that they are a big production with big backing and still doing mistakes that have already been solved by others
It really looks like makeup.
Star wars rebels was the first Star wars show to to really introduce me to Starwars itself....
I'm still comfused at how Cosplayers do 50x better than this in quality on a very minimal budget for their hobby, and a multi-million dollar show ends up looking equal to a last-minute Spirit halloween costume.
The twi'lek in Book of Boba Fett even looked better than this, Hera is a main character and they just didnt even try, it's so disheartening.
Star Wars aliens are so amazing and theyre continuously getting downgraded in their portrayls and designs in the big, high-profile shows, and yet the side projects get amazing SFX love and care. What is happening.
Passion
Hera was hot, even though she's green.
Just from the green smile i noticed
Gwan PAIN Ramona
Ha ha!! Realistic 😂😂
She looked ok but
monotone acting like the lead.
Obi-Wan Kenobi is one lucky Jedi that’s fs 😅😍😵💫
A shame that they couldn't comprehend that the ear covers are actually supposed to be covering the side tusks
it always looks off when you go from animated character to live action. you should design it like they went from live action to animated. and then making an advanced civilization with tech that they can traverse space with dressed as WW2 bomber pilots and cowboys is comical.
It still looks like cake
That series does look more like a cat walk.
Literally everytime direcors want green characters 💚 💚 💚
They completely changed the shape of her head and she looked like the wish version over the animation
count dooku:
It would have been much better with black eyeballs and red brown irises don't know why just would more realistic for that divergent humanoid type or maybe yellow iris
He says that could be a challenge it's not for everyone try installing antennas on skyscrapers because that's what I've done for the past 7 years that's a challenge that's not for everyone.
Thought she looked good except the color of the contacts was unnatural. Ezra’s contacts were also a little too intense.
Obi wans girl 😂😂😂
They did a much better job in Wicked 2024
'Gulp 😍
When did Opie become a Makeup guy 😂
"We wanted the skin to look realistic"...Brah
I still see Ramona Flowers
were cake and sushi also painted green
The clothes were just too shiny and new looking. It threw me off every time I watched. You should be more like the guys on Andor. They do everything perfect or it seems that way.
@@SuperJetsfan4life I am not sure if the two can be compared. Andor is set during reign of the Empire. People are at sort of at war. Ahsoka is set post empire during the new republic so it's a lot more peaceful (beside Thrawn being back on the rise).
Why would you have crappy clothes if you are in the military and not scrubbing around on some backwater world?
The big thing were the eyes were just off
Hate to say it but I actually think it only looked bad because of the way the eye shadow was applied like it doesn’t look right
Obi Wan is a lucky man.
Her acting was great😍🍑
Was it?
Go Woke Go Broke 😂😂
Green is in this year
Scott better watch out cuz Obi-Wan is now 1 of the X's
Check our government
We’ve been dividing ourselves while they make things more difficult and more chaos.