I think we can all agree these three women are all impeccable vocalists, unique and excellent in their own way and shouldn’t be compared to each other. Additionally, all three have utmost mutual respect for each other.
@ Agreed; Three incredible voices/women. To add to that, what all three have endured in their personal lives for me is the cherry on top. Mariah’s racial identity, being almost drugged and sold to a pimp by her sister, her jealous mother, whom both really passed. Whitney’s toxic family, dad suing her before he died, husband, and sad illness with substance, and alienation from racial criticism, and Celine’s recent struggle with seizures and her illness. These women work so hard and all artistically paved the way, despite their trials and hardships. Even the greats are humans too
@@nunyabiz3668even the greats are human too? They're just singers, not Mozart or Beethoven. And it's not like they wrote their own music. And as for their personal lives. We all go though tough times.
@djc836 1. Mariah cowrote and coproduced most of her hits and albums. 2. Whitney was responsible for live orchestration and arrangements in a way that David Foster, and Merv Warren have noted. 3. Celine is also a stellar performer with a lot of genre versatility able to sing songs in multiple languages. All are incredible *artists* Also disgusting of you to negate their adversity because of their starpower.
@@kevinstar6176 Can you detail how Céline has better support than Mariah? Because Céline's low notes were not that rich to my ears. It always seemed to me like she'll go sharp.
@@aldrin8376 Mariah tends to depress and lower her larynx so much. Better watch "Ain't no other fan" about who's the best in the vocal trinity. Though some of his information is invalid but he is one of the most accurate, almost 100%. He showed and explained why Celine has the best lower register among the three followed by Mariah and Whitney being the weakest.
I think the comparison needs to stop. While all these videos are made with good intention, at the end of the day, we’re talking about 3 singers with incredible voices and they’re all incredibly skilled. The differences are in their styles, none of them sings like the others, they all sound very different from one another. Everybody just has their favorite because of personal preferences and then they bring down the others. Can’t we all agree that they are just amazing singers who are each so unique and bring so much individuality and personal style to singing, and there’s no reason to be comparing them at all?
@@tylermills4812 and then when people argue about technique it bothers me more, I’m not saying I’m always right and they’re always wrong, just that everybody has different opinions on technique, even among professional voice teachers, that’s just the way it is. Nobody ever agrees and everybody always thinks their way is the only way
lows - mariah > celine > whitney mid belts - whitney > mariah/celine high belts - mariah > whitney > celine high mixed - celine > mariah > whitney head voice - whitney > celine > mariah whistle - mariah, mariah, mariah 😭 but then we get into other things like celine being the best at sustaining and having hella resonance, mariah having the best agility and whitney having the best vibrato & power
@@instrumentsmrti Whitney has sustained notes for 20 seconds. Then she’s held a not for 17 seconds and immediately held the next note for almost the same amount. Whitney had excellent breath support.
@@GarageStudio7 Same. I will die on the hill that Mariah’s upper belt is superior to Whitney’s. Whitney has always sounded more pushed (regardless of whether her technique is better than Mariah’s) up there than Mariah and she never possessed the brightness nor retained the tonal quality that Mariah does up there. Her voice just blooms and explodes up there. People are going on and on about sustaining notes, but phrasing and enunciating lines in the upper belt is much trickier than simply holding it, imo.
#1 Whitney Houston. #1 Mariah Carey. All queens. #1 Celine Dion. 👑 👁️ 👁️ 3❤🎉. OMG, this is the first time I got so many likes slayyyyyyyyyyyyy omgggg Why are you still here 🤨 👁️👄👁️
Can you do Vocal trinity's strength? Personally for me: Mariah: Musicality, melisma and agility, range and tone Celine: Consistency, support, power and well mixed upper belt, a great technical singer Whitney: power, the best phrased belter, well supported belt, can sing opera Definitely can add more because they really truly are that amazing
My opinion: I’ll do two measurements: technique and tone in each register Technique: Lows:Celine>Mariah>Whitney Midbelts:Whitney>=Celine>Mariah Upperbelts:Whitney>Mariah>Celine Headvoice:Whitney>Celine>Mariah Whistle:Mariah and that’s it> Whitney chirps every now and then I guess Tone: Lows:Mariah>Celine>Whitney Midbelts:Whitney>Celine>Mariah Upperbelts:Mariah>Whitney>Celine Headvoice:Whitney>Celine>Mariah Whistle:Mariah only
@ romanarts6645 Thank you. The debate I had on another thread in this video wore. me. out. lol. I had to stop my guitar practice just to get my points across and defend my statements. Glad someone can at least *respect* what I have to say.
@@Annabelganhell no. Lows - between Celine and Mariah Mid and upper belts - Whitney Head voice: Whitney (she’s known for it) Mariah head voice is underdeveloped in my opinion and she’s often pitchy in it. Celine’s is good but Whitney’s is super controlled and operatic.
the way i completely agreed with each ranking 😭 im glad u created a high mix category tho out of fairness for celine. cause she mainly uses twang in her upper belting register speaking of that, the trinity really are one of the best singers yet they’re not the standard when it comes to upper-belting mixing. their predecessors and contemporary singers have a better understanding & utilize mix better !
Yeah and the way they added a category for whistle specifically for Mariah knowing fully well both Celine & Whitney dont have/ or very limited access to this range.
She wasn't nasally early in her career she's been singing for over 50 years. We have now learned that that nasal aspect of her singing was due to the stiff person syndrome that she did not know she had so she found a new way of singing that was easier on her larynx. If you watched her first performance in 4 years at the Paris Olympics she was not nasally.
@@nunyabiz3668Absolutely not…Whitney’s tone is much more velvety and smooth than Mariah’s. Also when singing live in their prime Whitney was not only able to reach notes, she sustained them. Mariah would touch a note then flee for her life. Early on in her career, people all said Whitney had a 5 octave range and even today some certified vocal coaches say she did. To understand Whitney you have to listen to her from 1985-1987 live especially singing songs like He, I Believe and I Am Changing. There’s a reason why with far fewer albums Whitney has more awards including being inducted into the Songwriters Hall of Fame after only 5 years of her debut. Whitney was the only one to consistently sing live throughout her career…only using lip sync when it was not her choice. But then she refused to do so saying if they didn’t let her sing live she will not show up to any television appearances. Whitney is the only one who had full control of her voice…from the lower register to her head voice. Being able to use your vibrato throughout your range is incredible. Thats why both of the other ladies cite Whitney as a major influence on them becoming a singer.
@ jobuck879 I myself am a huge Whitney fan (even though you’ve tried to tell me I’m not a Whitney fan due to objective remarks about her vocal condition in the 90s), so you’re definitely *not* telling me anything new. Your sustainability past E5 remark is something I have been just as, if not more vocal about than you. I cannot stand it when people say Whitney could not belt properly past Eb5; It is a huge ignorance to her live catalogue/performances. Tone is incredibly subjective. Many people prefer Mariah’s tone in that region, and that’s ok. Mariah incorporated upper-belts (in my humble opinion) more consistently *in the studio* and creatively into her work than Whitney did *in the studio* Now technically, yes, Whitney was far more versatile with the upper register, had more chest participation, could phrase, sustain, apply vibrato, and was more consistent on a grueling tour schedule, which is basically just regurgitating what I already said: Whitney had the better technique live there. Whitney live is another topic since she was consistently out performing her own studio work, but let’s not discredit others who are subjectively more impressed by one area of voice from Mariah. Whitney and Mariah are both incredible, and there’s nothing wrong with other’s having a preference.
@@nunyabiz3668 I don’t mind others having a preference, it’s when they state that preference as a fact that I don’t accept. When people put their personal preferences or opinions and try to make it a fact is when I have to show how there’s a difference. Just like I did with you on another video. Preferences are ok, just don’t push it to the fact level.
All the top song charts will be the 3's song repeated 😂 No-one today can compete with their vocal range and power (except maybe Adele but she's only know to sing one type of music, ballads. So we can't really know her full range and vocal abilities) and their music composition and production will be original, godly - nothing that today's singers/ musicians can make by themselves (most of them rely heavily on outside help that their album has way too long of a list of names involved).
@@DDSizeBraAdele isn’t nowhere near the great singers with her bad technique though. The fact that she even got surgery for her ruined voice speaks for itself. I think the closest singer or maybe even comparable is Beyoncé in this generation. She has an excellent technique and control along with her vocal acrobatics.
@@Mommyyriah true Whitney’s mid belts are better when she goes above EB five it kind of gets uncomfortable Mariah, is the queen of EB5 Whitney is the queen of c#5 a5 and I feel like Mariah’s lows should be first
@@Mommyyriah That does not make her less better than everyone in the trinity above Eb5.
Месяц назад+7
@@AuygayhuHnhuquyhq Whitney’s belting voice only got more inconsistent from F# and above. Still, her resonance was pretty much the same up to G. She carried this saxophone-like resonance to the top of her range, as she did in her mid belts.
The 3 are almost impecable on the voice control in every register, the thing is the tone for me Mariah has a tone that never anyone have replicated, she has a sweet airy, but powerful the same time and very resonant voice, there are many people that I watch sound like Celine or Whitney but never a Mariah one
You tried it... even with the high belts. you think Mariah hitting G5s EASILYY in her records back in the day meant she couldn't do higher live? all her songs were simply too difficult to be including songs above G5 in her concerts.
Were they inspired by her? Yes. Does that make them less than? No. Does that mean they don’t have their own identity? No. Was Whitney their only influence? No. All three are incredibly in their own ways so let’s not make this about who the “ultimate diva” is and just enjoy the discussion of voice.
Glad it’s fair and not uses Dubbed performances of Mariah. Most epecially the mostly used performances of the dubbed Madison Sqaure Garden of Mariah. They always use this to compare to other singers👏🏼 This is the right comparison! All undubbed! Raw!
I agree with the upper belt ranking. I'm not hearing how Whitney's upper belt is supposedly "better" than Mariah's. Mariah's upper belt has always sounded more impressive and superior to Whitney's. The overtones and the tonal brightness that Mariah achieves as she blooms in the upper belt is something I haven't heard from any other singer. Whitney's upper belt has never really impressed me all that much; neither has Celine's for that matter. Their mid-belts, on the other hand, are an absolute marvel.
I think it depends on the performance for both of them; they both have nights where they're on fire and off nights as well in the upper register. I would say Whitney had the better technique for sure, but Mariah had a more optimal tonality for her catalogue that many prefer, which I can see.
@@nunyabiz3668 Better technique how when Whitney sounds significantly less freer, much thinner and more pushed up there than Mariah? Like, how is Mariah's technique up there supposedly inferior when she flat out sounds like her voice blossoms up there as opposed to Whitney? What is this supposed superior technique that makes Whitney sound pushed up there, while Mariah floats up there?
@ Antonio-vw8pp I get what you’re saying, but there are a few reasons: 1. Because tonality doesn’t equate to technical prowess. Mariah has a more forwardly resonating placement and lightens her chest more up there, which for pop music, people prefer. 2. Push doesn’t equate to strain. Belting in its definition is a pushed sound. It isn’t meant to be a light buoyant coordination in every situation. 3. Mariah had glottal attack, and thus, restriction past E5. Yes, glottal attack allows for a piercing sound, but it doesn’t allow the voice to stabilize and maintain up there. Not denying that she sounds immaculate up there, but that isn’t technique. 4. Whitney was more consistent on these notes, with more chest engagement, and a better execution of release. She could phrase, sustain, add vibrato (which indicates there isn’t a constriction in the throat), and/or add distortion up there, and she was more consistent while putting on shows with these notes. Mariah had the better *tone* which was more optimal and creatively placed into her musicality Whitney had the better *technique* which allowed for versatility and consistency up there
@@Antonio-vw8ppI mean… Mariah’s inconsistency in her upper belts and the longevity of her ability to do that speaks for itself. Whitney had a better technique, almost like a male opera singer with superb chest coordination.
@Antonio-vw8pp Well, the truth is Whitney was technically better in her upper belts. Mariah's tone could sound more flattering to you since her voice type tonally shines more in that area. But that doesn't change that Whitney was better from an objective point of view. Whitney had much more chest participation, could sustain, could phrase and apply vibrato to her upper belts, none of which Mariah demonstrated in her abilities. You can like her tone more up there since again, her voice type shines more there tonally, but Whitney is technically superior in the upper belts
𝗟𝗼𝘄𝘀: 𝗠𝗮𝗿𝗶𝗮𝗵. Even at her declined vocal capacity, she still slay low notes. 𝗠𝗶𝗱 𝗯𝗲𝗹𝘁𝘀: 𝗪𝗵𝗶𝘁𝗻𝗲𝘆. I guess everybody agrees on this part, no need to explain why. 𝗛𝗶𝗴𝗵 𝗯𝗲𝗹𝘁𝘀: 𝗠𝗮𝗿𝗶𝗮𝗵. Celine is more consistent, but during Mariah’s vocal prime, her placement and resonance cannot be matched by Whitney and Celine. 𝗛𝗶𝗴𝗵 𝗺𝗶𝘅𝗲𝗱: 𝗖𝗲𝗹𝗶𝗻𝗲. Definitely not Whitney. Mariah did some G#5 and A5 but it’s just not her thing. 𝗔𝗴𝗶𝗹𝗶𝘁𝘆: 𝗠𝗮𝗿𝗶𝗮𝗵, no question. 𝗛𝗲𝗮𝗱 𝘃𝗼𝗶𝗰𝗲: Whitney > Celine > Mariah 𝗠𝘂𝘀𝗶𝗰𝗮𝗹𝗶𝘁𝘆: 𝗗𝗲𝗳𝗶𝗻𝗶𝘁𝗲𝗹𝘆 𝗠𝗮𝗿𝗶𝗮𝗵. Impeccable phrasing and creativity, not to mention she’s also an accomplished songwriter who composed 18 number 1s.
@@tylermills4812 And You forgot the whistles that it is of course only Mariah Carey!!!! "The supreme songbird" according to Guinness World Records....
Whatever. All I know is that whoever the lady was who performed these songs live: "Saving All My Love For You" 1985, "Didn't we almost have it all" 1987, "The Greatest Love of All" 1990, "All the Man that I Need" 1991, "I Loves You Porgy, And I am Telling You, I Have Nothing" 1994, "This Day" 1995, and "Why Does It Hurt So Bad" 1996. She's the best, because she moved me more than any other singer I've heard live...the only other performances that had a hint of this lady was whoever she was who sang "Hometown Glory" 2009 and "Someone Like You" at the Brits in 2011. I just know how I felt listening and watching. That's all.
not necessarily, mariah did an A5 (lipped) and arguably Bb5 (studio), on the other hand, whitney actually did multiple A5s during live performances, but she didn't have fully controlled over that register.
@@kevinstar6176 yeah, Whitney has Bb5 live, I would not count studio and lip, but it is not debatable that Celine is the only one in the trinity who can do a C6 and C#6 mix almost of her most recent performance
@@nobodycares775 yes it’s exactly that, when it’s that high, if it is mix it would be very head dominant most likely, but I’m just saying in this context I don’t think it’s mixed she is just giving it a brighter tone. But I’m not gonna argue about it because everybody on RUclips has a different definition of all the vocal terms I’m just stating what I believe she was doing.
@@karlboland9666 sound a little pushy isn't necessarily a bad thing and actually whitney's upper belting sound pushy only occasionally; whitney using heavy coordination in her upper belting(what is more difficult), also she is more consistent than Mariah (whitney's highest consistently supported note in belting is F5/F#5)
@@karlboland9666 Whitney sounds "pushy" because her upper belts had much more chest participation than Mariah's which is already more impressive, Mariah has more freedom up there naturally due to her voice type, but she never had the technique/skill for the upper belts that Whitney had, Whitney could phrase her upper belts, sustain them, again had chest participation which is soooo hard, and she could apply vibrato all the way upto G5. Mariah wasn't able to do any of that in her upper mix, she was technically inferior up there. But her voice did sound more at ease due to her higher voice type
@@romanarts6645 It's interesting to me the numerous different opinions I hear on this site regarding singing. I've heard from others (With as much confidence as you) that Whitney pulled chest voice, and was wrong to do so as it's sternous on the voice, that the veins in her neck were a dead giveaway she strains. And hasn't Mariah sustained an F5 in Stay in Love? Phrased her upper belts in If It's over and Fly like a Bird? From being on YT for years, the one thing I've learned is that opinions on here, are just that. Opinions lmao.
Céline is the greatest of all Times. Don't never and ever compare her with Mariah, maybe Whitney, but Mariah Can never be at the same level that Céline. Céline is so incredibble
Whitney has the best scale out of the three, from top to bottom. Mariah and Celine go lower with their voices with more ease because they’re not projecting in full voice. In the undubbed audio of ‘You And I’, Mariah’s low notes were very breathy and almost inaudible, and not very in tune. Whitney almost always sang in full voice from top to bottom. Whitney also has the most balanced belting scale - an even resonance from top to bottom. Celine has more ease from G5 and up, but only because she thins her voice out more. Whitney went up there with a more balanced sound. Head voice goes to Whitney, although Celine is close. And both Celine and Whitney do not have a whistle register.
Strange and soul-refreshing to see a simple and honest non black person 😭 Whitney's the best and never pushed harder to become the best she just always The best from tone,pure power, vocal range,soul, stage presence,live singing and delivery Love all of them too
GOAT... WHITNEY THE INCOMPARABLE
💞
Celine Dion is my Queen ❤❤❤
I think we can all agree these three women are all impeccable vocalists, unique and excellent in their own way and shouldn’t be compared to each other. Additionally, all three have utmost mutual respect for each other.
@ Agreed; Three incredible voices/women.
To add to that, what all three have endured in their personal lives for me is the cherry on top. Mariah’s racial identity, being almost drugged and sold to a pimp by her sister, her jealous mother, whom both really passed. Whitney’s toxic family, dad suing her before he died, husband, and sad illness with substance, and alienation from racial criticism, and Celine’s recent struggle with seizures and her illness. These women work so hard and all artistically paved the way, despite their trials and hardships. Even the greats are humans too
@@nunyabiz3668even the greats are human too? They're just singers, not Mozart or Beethoven. And it's not like they wrote their own music. And as for their personal lives. We all go though tough times.
@djc836
1. Mariah cowrote and coproduced most of her hits and albums.
2. Whitney was responsible for live orchestration and arrangements in a way that David Foster, and Merv Warren have noted.
3. Celine is also a stellar performer with a lot of genre versatility able to sing songs in multiple languages.
All are incredible *artists*
Also disgusting of you to negate their adversity because of their starpower.
Whitney, Celine, Mariah. ❤️💚💙
IF YOU TALLY THIS AND SCORE IT 1-3. HERE’s THE RANKING:
1. CELINE 13 pts
2. WHITNEY 12 pts
3. Mariah 11 pts
Whitney
Whitney
Whitney
Mariah Carey 👑
Maturing is realizing all three are number one and appreciating having two of the three still here with us
Amen!
celine❤
Whitney❤
Mariah❤
I can't choose because they are all great
I think Mariah should take the #1 spot for the lows
mariah can go lower, but "technique-wise", celine has more support.
Celine has free notes down to D3 and is more consistent in E3 while Mariah was consistent at F#3 and tends to lower her larynx as she goes lower.
@@kevinstar6176 Can you detail how Céline has better support than Mariah? Because Céline's low notes were not that rich to my ears. It always seemed to me like she'll go sharp.
its naturally much bigger and rich so yeah...
@@aldrin8376 Mariah tends to depress and lower her larynx so much. Better watch "Ain't no other fan" about who's the best in the vocal trinity. Though some of his information is invalid but he is one of the most accurate, almost 100%. He showed and explained why Celine has the best lower register among the three followed by Mariah and Whitney being the weakest.
Whistle register if not used frequently actually can disappear, mariah really used it well and often by developing it further
Mariah is best over all others.
Mariah is everything
I think the comparison needs to stop. While all these videos are made with good intention, at the end of the day, we’re talking about 3 singers with incredible voices and they’re all incredibly skilled. The differences are in their styles, none of them sings like the others, they all sound very different from one another.
Everybody just has their favorite because of personal preferences and then they bring down the others. Can’t we all agree that they are just amazing singers who are each so unique and bring so much individuality and personal style to singing, and there’s no reason to be comparing them at all?
@@Singer7771 Tbh I’m tired of the comparisons too. All they do is bring about stan wars. I’m over it.
@@tylermills4812 and then when people argue about technique it bothers me more, I’m not saying I’m always right and they’re always wrong, just that everybody has different opinions on technique, even among professional voice teachers, that’s just the way it is. Nobody ever agrees and everybody always thinks their way is the only way
@@Singer7771 Exactly! You hit the nail on the head.
lows - mariah > celine > whitney
mid belts - whitney > mariah/celine
high belts - mariah > whitney > celine
high mixed - celine > mariah > whitney
head voice - whitney > celine > mariah
whistle - mariah, mariah, mariah 😭
but then we get into other things like celine being the best at sustaining and having hella resonance, mariah having the best agility and whitney having the best vibrato & power
@@instrumentsmrti Whitney has sustained notes for 20 seconds. Then she’s held a not for 17 seconds and immediately held the next note for almost the same amount. Whitney had excellent breath support.
@@jobuck879 never said she didn't
@@instrumentsmrti But saying Celine is the best at sustaining notes is incorrect. Whitney is the best at sustained notes. Especially live.
Excellent analysis! This is spot on.
@@GarageStudio7 Same. I will die on the hill that Mariah’s upper belt is superior to Whitney’s. Whitney has always sounded more pushed (regardless of whether her technique is better than Mariah’s) up there than Mariah and she never possessed the brightness nor retained the tonal quality that Mariah does up there. Her voice just blooms and explodes up there. People are going on and on about sustaining notes, but phrasing and enunciating lines in the upper belt is much trickier than simply holding it, imo.
#1 Whitney Houston.
#1 Mariah Carey. All queens.
#1 Celine Dion.
👑
👁️ 👁️
3❤🎉.
OMG, this is the first time I got so many likes slayyyyyyyyyyyyy omgggg
Why are you still here 🤨
👁️👄👁️
No one has commented 😢
😭
@@AuygayhuHnhuquyhq 👀
@@AuygayhuHnhuquyhqNow i did it
This is so annoying. Take the likes and go! No need to edit the comment
I love celine dion voice very mesmerizing and beautiful
You will never be forgotten, Nippy.....✨️💜✨️
No.1
Can you do Vocal trinity's strength? Personally for me:
Mariah: Musicality, melisma and agility, range and tone
Celine: Consistency, support, power and well mixed upper belt, a great technical singer
Whitney: power, the best phrased belter, well supported belt, can sing opera
Definitely can add more because they really truly are that amazing
Finally someone who appreciates Mariah Carey 's upper belt♥️
My opinion:
I’ll do two measurements: technique and tone in each register
Technique:
Lows:Celine>Mariah>Whitney
Midbelts:Whitney>=Celine>Mariah
Upperbelts:Whitney>Mariah>Celine
Headvoice:Whitney>Celine>Mariah
Whistle:Mariah and that’s it> Whitney chirps every now and then I guess
Tone:
Lows:Mariah>Celine>Whitney
Midbelts:Whitney>Celine>Mariah
Upperbelts:Mariah>Whitney>Celine
Headvoice:Whitney>Celine>Mariah
Whistle:Mariah only
@@nunyabiz3668 yess, i really agree!
The only correct ranking
@ romanarts6645
Thank you. The debate I had on another thread in this video wore. me. out. lol. I had to stop my guitar practice just to get my points across and defend my statements. Glad someone can at least *respect* what I have to say.
@@nunyabiz3668 been there lol
@@nunyabiz3668 they will still com and attack you even though you are super correct
Low : Mariah
Middle : Whitney
High : Mariah
ABSOLUTELY.
Sadly no. Lowest:Mariah
Lower - low : Céline
Low_ mid low: Whitney
Mid to high: Céline
Higher not head voice: Céline Dion
HIGHEST: Mariah
@@Annabelganhell no. Lows - between Celine and Mariah
Mid and upper belts - Whitney
Head voice: Whitney (she’s known for it) Mariah head voice is underdeveloped in my opinion and she’s often pitchy in it. Celine’s is good but Whitney’s is super controlled and operatic.
Upper belts go to Whitney
@@blah5528 no
Celine's river deep mountain high is so wow! 💪🥰😘
Celine For Long Notes
Mariah For Whistle
Whitney For Vocal
Excelentes todas. Mi favorita: Mariah Carey ❤️👏🏻
the way i completely agreed with each ranking 😭
im glad u created a high mix category tho out of fairness for celine. cause she mainly uses twang in her upper belting register
speaking of that, the trinity really are one of the best singers yet they’re not the standard when it comes to upper-belting mixing. their predecessors and contemporary singers have a better understanding & utilize mix better !
yeah, a lot of people tend to put her upper belt and her mix in the same category, which is impossible, she used totally different techniques.
Yeah and the way they added a category for whistle specifically for Mariah knowing fully well both Celine & Whitney dont have/ or very limited access to this range.
Agreed. Only disagreement is that Whitney was last for the “mixed” belts not second. I don’t think she was better than Mariah or Celine at it.
A voz ,a interpretação, a potência de whitney pra mim não tem comparação!
Celine dion it gives me goosebumps with her powerful resonance
The Most Impressive about Mariah is that she is singing with Nodules, like wtf...that need her props too. love the 3 queens
Please watch “The Resonance of Celine Dion Part 2-4” under (John De Leon). Maybe you can see some performances of Celine that you didn’t know exists
1.Mariah Carey. - complete octaves/Piano
2.Celine Dion
3.Whitney Houston
That’s not true Mariah lowest note b#2 piano Loest note c0 Mariah highest C#7 piano highest c10
@@AuygayhuHnhuquyhq thatis incorrect aswell.. the piano's highest is a C8 and mariahs highest note is an F#8, and her lowest note is an F2
@@martimpascoal2931 wrong
Oh, so you’re telling me she can sing the whole octave
@@martimpascoal2931 I just searched it up, and it said that Mariah can’t sing the whole octave
Nobody beat Whitney in clearity
PERFECT!
I love these three and agree with all of their statements.
My favorite is Céline, but the three are unbeatable when it comes to VOCAL!
My issue with Celine is, she gets too nasal sometimes.
She wasn't nasally early in her career she's been singing for over 50 years.
We have now learned that that nasal aspect of her singing was due to the stiff person syndrome that she did not know she had so she found a new way of singing that was easier on her larynx.
If you watched her first performance in 4 years at the Paris Olympics she was not nasally.
@@Mntguy-nr9vl Naah her nasal tone has been since from day one
Let's not pretend that Mariah wasn't nasal either. Even more so than Celine
@@TalvanePorfirio She wasn’t.
@@tylermills4812 She was especially in 1996 and afterwards.
Great video! I only disagree with upper belts.
exactly!
Mariah has the brightest sounding and most impressive sounding upper belts, regardless of whether Whitney is technically better up there.
I agree with this. I think upperbelts go
Technique: Whitney>Mariah>Celine
Tone:Mariah>Whitney>Celine
@@nunyabiz3668 I agree.
@@nunyabiz3668Absolutely not…Whitney’s tone is much more velvety and smooth than Mariah’s. Also when singing live in their prime Whitney was not only able to reach notes, she sustained them. Mariah would touch a note then flee for her life. Early on in her career, people all said Whitney had a 5 octave range and even today some certified vocal coaches say she did. To understand Whitney you have to listen to her from 1985-1987 live especially singing songs like He, I Believe and I Am Changing. There’s a reason why with far fewer albums Whitney has more awards including being inducted into the Songwriters Hall of Fame after only 5 years of her debut. Whitney was the only one to consistently sing live throughout her career…only using lip sync when it was not her choice. But then she refused to do so saying if they didn’t let her sing live she will not show up to any television appearances. Whitney is the only one who had full control of her voice…from the lower register to her head voice. Being able to use your vibrato throughout your range is incredible. Thats why both of the other ladies cite Whitney as a major influence on them becoming a singer.
@ jobuck879
I myself am a huge Whitney fan (even though you’ve tried to tell me I’m not a Whitney fan due to objective remarks about her vocal condition in the 90s), so you’re definitely *not* telling me anything new. Your sustainability past E5 remark is something I have been just as, if not more vocal about than you. I cannot stand it when people say Whitney could not belt properly past Eb5; It is a huge ignorance to her live catalogue/performances. Tone is incredibly subjective. Many people prefer Mariah’s tone in that region, and that’s ok. Mariah incorporated upper-belts (in my humble opinion) more consistently *in the studio* and creatively into her work than Whitney did *in the studio*
Now technically, yes, Whitney was far more versatile with the upper register, had more chest participation, could phrase, sustain, apply vibrato, and was more consistent on a grueling tour schedule, which is basically just regurgitating what I already said: Whitney had the better technique live there.
Whitney live is another topic since she was consistently out performing her own studio work, but let’s not discredit others who are subjectively more impressed by one area of voice from Mariah. Whitney and Mariah are both incredible, and there’s nothing wrong with other’s having a preference.
@@nunyabiz3668 I don’t mind others having a preference, it’s when they state that preference as a fact that I don’t accept. When people put their personal preferences or opinions and try to make it a fact is when I have to show how there’s a difference. Just like I did with you on another video. Preferences are ok, just don’t push it to the fact level.
Mariah the whole package ❤
I'm a LAMB.
I do not compare them. I enjoy them.
I feel blessed to have been able to enjoy their PRIME TIME.
We were so lucky, God bless them!!!
I loved Whitney i just wish she had a good normal life wo the drugs and her life wo toxic people. She was soo good in her early years.
Todas as 3 são incríveis. Não tem como compara-las. Cada uma é simplesmente perfeita. Mas. confesso que Whitney era fora da curva.
Whitney rainha ❤❤❤❤🎉🎉🎉❤❤❤
Mariah is still good at eveything, even Adele would agree...
So random
not really and adele? you couldve used a great vocalist
Mariah Carey's whistle hahaha... Runaway winner!!!! 💯💯💯🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭♥️♥️♥️🎶🎶🎶
Mariah is best
Low - Whitney > Mariah > Celine, Mid - Whitney > Celine > Mariah, Upper belt- Whitney > Mariah > Celine, High mixed - Whitney > Mariah > Celine > Head voice Whitney > Mariah > Celine, Whistle - Mariah > Whitney = Celine.
Whitney's voice moves me like no other!!!
Anyone in the comment section saying that upper belts don't belong to Mariah, should watch her performance 1992 Police Athletic League.....
Precisely
I wish they all made a collaboration during their prime. Imagine a song with these 3.
All the top song charts will be the 3's song repeated 😂 No-one today can compete with their vocal range and power (except maybe Adele but she's only know to sing one type of music, ballads. So we can't really know her full range and vocal abilities) and their music composition and production will be original, godly - nothing that today's singers/ musicians can make by themselves (most of them rely heavily on outside help that their album has way too long of a list of names involved).
@@DDSizeBraAdele isn’t nowhere near the great singers with her bad technique though. The fact that she even got surgery for her ruined voice speaks for itself. I think the closest singer or maybe even comparable is Beyoncé in this generation. She has an excellent technique and control along with her vocal acrobatics.
mariah's whistle register gave me chills
1.MARIAH. 2WHITNEY 3.CELINE
Only Mariah Carey!!!!!!! ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️ She's the QUEEN!
Whitney Houston is No.1!✨️💜✨️
Lows - Mariah
Mid belts - Whitney
Upper belts - Mariah
High mix - Celine
Head voice - Whitney
Whistle register - Mariah
I think the best versions of the songs Mariah sung live on SNL were the best live performances of those songs
No 1 Mariah, you don't change reality.
MC ❤
celine’s C#3 sound well supported to me in that video, but im no expert at all.
yes, but are E♭3's
@@henriquecordeiro2891 its C#3-Eb3-C#3, ive mistaken the 2nd note
Above Eb5 Whitney reigns supreme.
I actually prefer her mid belts
@@Mommyyriah true Whitney’s mid belts are better when she goes above EB five it kind of gets uncomfortable Mariah, is the queen of EB5 Whitney is the queen of c#5 a5 and I feel like Mariah’s lows should be first
@@Mommyyriah That does not make her less better than everyone in the trinity above Eb5.
@@AuygayhuHnhuquyhq Whitney’s belting voice only got more inconsistent from F# and above. Still, her resonance was pretty much the same up to G. She carried this saxophone-like resonance to the top of her range, as she did in her mid belts.
@@AuygayhuHnhuquyhq
Mariah would be killed by nippy’s Eb5’s.
The 3 are almost impecable on the voice control in every register, the thing is the tone for me Mariah has a tone that never anyone have replicated, she has a sweet airy, but powerful the same time and very resonant voice, there are many people that I watch sound like Celine or Whitney but never a Mariah one
You tried it... even with the high belts. you think Mariah hitting G5s EASILYY in her records back in the day meant she couldn't do higher live? all her songs were simply too difficult to be including songs above G5 in her concerts.
Mariah ❤
1. Whitney: with soul in the heart
2. Mariah: Amazing
3. Celine: good voice but cold
Good voice but cold?
2:03 where can I watch the full video of whitney she was SNAPPING
ruclips.net/video/OLKSfdYcRXY/видео.html
@@kevinstar6176 yasssssssss
My favorite is Queen Mariah ❤
1 - Mariah
2 - Whitney
3 - Celine
Agreed, but I always had more connection to Celine than to WH...
Whitney Houston
Celine Dion
Mariah Carey
Celine 1 Unique
Mariah 2 Whistle
Whitney 3 Power but overrated
@@Axelnegronperez Whitney 1 Tone
Mariah 2 Whistle
Celine 3 inspired by Whitney.
@@The_Truth- Celine 1 Unique
Mariah 2 Whistle
Whitney 3 Power but overrated
Damn! Whitney 🔥🔥🔥🥇🥇🥇🥇
Whitney is muva!! Period! The best to EVER pick up a microphone!
Mariah Carey has the most beautiful voice and resonance, she's above those two
she doesnt have squillo like Whitney and Celine so she doesnt have real resonance
1. Whitney Houston
2. Inspired by Whitney.
3. Inspired by Whitney.
*and outsold whitney
@@kevinstar6176 By a hair, wow what an achievement.
Were they inspired by her? Yes. Does that make them less than? No. Does that mean they don’t have their own identity? No. Was Whitney their only influence? No. All three are incredibly in their own ways so let’s not make this about who the “ultimate diva” is and just enjoy the discussion of voice.
@@nunyabiz3668 I said what I said. If you don’t like it. You can make an appointment,l to kiss where the sun doesn’t shine.
@ The_Truth-
Mmmk. What a logical rebuttal
Nr 1: Whitney, Nr 2: Mariah, Nr 3: Celine.
Glad it’s fair and not uses Dubbed performances of Mariah. Most epecially the mostly used performances of the dubbed Madison Sqaure Garden of Mariah. They always use this to compare to other singers👏🏼
This is the right comparison! All undubbed! Raw!
Wow Mariah...❤❤❤
Mariah is definitely the best in lows
I agree with the upper belt ranking. I'm not hearing how Whitney's upper belt is supposedly "better" than Mariah's. Mariah's upper belt has always sounded more impressive and superior to Whitney's. The overtones and the tonal brightness that Mariah achieves as she blooms in the upper belt is something I haven't heard from any other singer. Whitney's upper belt has never really impressed me all that much; neither has Celine's for that matter. Their mid-belts, on the other hand, are an absolute marvel.
I think it depends on the performance for both of them; they both have nights where they're on fire and off nights as well in the upper register. I would say Whitney had the better technique for sure, but Mariah had a more optimal tonality for her catalogue that many prefer, which I can see.
@@nunyabiz3668 Better technique how when Whitney sounds significantly less freer, much thinner and more pushed up there than Mariah? Like, how is Mariah's technique up there supposedly inferior when she flat out sounds like her voice blossoms up there as opposed to Whitney? What is this supposed superior technique that makes Whitney sound pushed up there, while Mariah floats up there?
@ Antonio-vw8pp
I get what you’re saying, but there are a few reasons:
1. Because tonality doesn’t equate to technical prowess. Mariah has a more forwardly resonating placement and lightens her chest more up there, which for pop music, people prefer.
2. Push doesn’t equate to strain. Belting in its definition is a pushed sound. It isn’t meant to be a light buoyant coordination in every situation.
3. Mariah had glottal attack, and thus, restriction past E5. Yes, glottal attack allows for a piercing sound, but it doesn’t allow the voice to stabilize and maintain up there. Not denying that she sounds immaculate up there, but that isn’t technique.
4. Whitney was more consistent on these notes, with more chest engagement, and a better execution of release. She could phrase, sustain, add vibrato (which indicates there isn’t a constriction in the throat), and/or add distortion up there, and she was more consistent while putting on shows with these notes.
Mariah had the better *tone* which was more optimal and creatively placed into her musicality
Whitney had the better *technique*
which allowed for versatility and consistency up there
@@Antonio-vw8ppI mean… Mariah’s inconsistency in her upper belts and the longevity of her ability to do that speaks for itself. Whitney had a better technique, almost like a male opera singer with superb chest coordination.
@Antonio-vw8pp Well, the truth is Whitney was technically better in her upper belts. Mariah's tone could sound more flattering to you since her voice type tonally shines more in that area. But that doesn't change that Whitney was better from an objective point of view. Whitney had much more chest participation, could sustain, could phrase and apply vibrato to her upper belts, none of which Mariah demonstrated in her abilities. You can like her tone more up there since again, her voice type shines more there tonally, but Whitney is technically superior in the upper belts
𝗟𝗼𝘄𝘀: 𝗠𝗮𝗿𝗶𝗮𝗵. Even at her declined vocal capacity, she still slay low notes.
𝗠𝗶𝗱 𝗯𝗲𝗹𝘁𝘀: 𝗪𝗵𝗶𝘁𝗻𝗲𝘆. I guess everybody agrees on this part, no need to explain why.
𝗛𝗶𝗴𝗵 𝗯𝗲𝗹𝘁𝘀: 𝗠𝗮𝗿𝗶𝗮𝗵. Celine is more consistent, but during Mariah’s vocal prime, her placement and resonance cannot be matched by Whitney and Celine.
𝗛𝗶𝗴𝗵 𝗺𝗶𝘅𝗲𝗱: 𝗖𝗲𝗹𝗶𝗻𝗲. Definitely not Whitney. Mariah did some G#5 and A5 but it’s just not her thing.
𝗔𝗴𝗶𝗹𝗶𝘁𝘆: 𝗠𝗮𝗿𝗶𝗮𝗵, no question.
𝗛𝗲𝗮𝗱 𝘃𝗼𝗶𝗰𝗲: Whitney > Celine > Mariah
𝗠𝘂𝘀𝗶𝗰𝗮𝗹𝗶𝘁𝘆: 𝗗𝗲𝗳𝗶𝗻𝗶𝘁𝗲𝗹𝘆 𝗠𝗮𝗿𝗶𝗮𝗵. Impeccable phrasing and creativity, not to mention she’s also an accomplished songwriter who composed 18 number 1s.
Spot on. Agree with everything here.
@@tylermills4812 And You forgot the whistles that it is of course only Mariah Carey!!!!
"The supreme songbird" according to Guinness World Records....
Whistle: Mariah...Control: Whitney....Belt: Celine....OVERALL: Whitney, her technique, range of emotions, etc. Couldn't be touched
Mitiche tutteeee , ma Céline ❤ unica❤
U could have used des conner G#5 peak in 1992 for mariah
i believe its f#5 and slightly sharped to g5
@@kevinstar6176 g5 flat g#5! Been proven
@@Mommyyriah not really, u can prove it urself if u got piano in ur home
@@Mommyyriah no on calls it a G#5 except you. It is a f#5 that peaks at G5 and it is barely a squeak like most of her top notes..
@@odumosuolusegun2781 a piano shows that, not me
Mariah is the Music Industry
Whatever. All I know is that whoever the lady was who performed these songs live: "Saving All My Love For You" 1985, "Didn't we almost have it all" 1987, "The Greatest Love of All" 1990, "All the Man that I Need" 1991, "I Loves You Porgy, And I am Telling You, I Have Nothing" 1994, "This Day" 1995, and "Why Does It Hurt So Bad" 1996. She's the best, because she moved me more than any other singer I've heard live...the only other performances that had a hint of this lady was whoever she was who sang "Hometown Glory" 2009 and "Someone Like You" at the Brits in 2011. I just know how I felt listening and watching. That's all.
Обожаю!!!!! Мои 3 любимые, обожаемые певицы!!!
Whitney
Celine is everything
Mariah’s G5 on hero live 1996
Celine has the best mixed belt register
Mariah has the best lows & whistle register
Whitney has the best chest belts & Headvoice
THE "ONLY"SINGER IN THE WORLD WHO HAS 7 CONSECUTIVE HITS... NO ONE HAS EVER EVER DONE THAT UP TO NOW. "WHITNEY HOUSTON"
It is funny when above G#5 celine placed first since she is the only trinity who can mix as high as sixth octave lol 😂
not necessarily, mariah did an A5 (lipped) and arguably Bb5 (studio), on the other hand, whitney actually did multiple A5s during live performances, but she didn't have fully controlled over that register.
@@kevinstar6176 yeah, Whitney has Bb5 live, I would not count studio and lip, but it is not debatable that Celine is the only one in the trinity who can do a C6 and C#6 mix almost of her most recent performance
@@nobodycares775unless if I’m thinking of the wrong video, that Celine C6 was just brightened head voice, I wouldn’t call that mixed.
@@Singer7771 because C6 is high mix, upper mixing is M2 mechanism, same mechanism as head voice
@@nobodycares775 yes it’s exactly that, when it’s that high, if it is mix it would be very head dominant most likely, but I’m just saying in this context I don’t think it’s mixed she is just giving it a brighter tone. But I’m not gonna argue about it because everybody on RUclips has a different definition of all the vocal terms I’m just stating what I believe she was doing.
Upper Belts- Whitney>Mariah/Celine
yes, but i think is more accurate Mariah=>Celine (or Mariah>Celine)
That's interesting. Why Whitney over Mariah? I've always thought Mariah had much more freedom up there. Whitney's always seemed very pushy to me.
@@karlboland9666 sound a little pushy isn't necessarily a bad thing and actually whitney's upper belting sound pushy only occasionally;
whitney using heavy coordination in her upper belting(what is more difficult), also she is more consistent than Mariah (whitney's highest consistently supported note in belting is F5/F#5)
@@karlboland9666 Whitney sounds "pushy" because her upper belts had much more chest participation than Mariah's which is already more impressive, Mariah has more freedom up there naturally due to her voice type, but she never had the technique/skill for the upper belts that Whitney had, Whitney could phrase her upper belts, sustain them, again had chest participation which is soooo hard, and she could apply vibrato all the way upto G5. Mariah wasn't able to do any of that in her upper mix, she was technically inferior up there. But her voice did sound more at ease due to her higher voice type
@@romanarts6645 It's interesting to me the numerous different opinions I hear on this site regarding singing. I've heard from others (With as much confidence as you) that Whitney pulled chest voice, and was wrong to do so as it's sternous on the voice, that the veins in her neck were a dead giveaway she strains. And hasn't Mariah sustained an F5 in Stay in Love? Phrased her upper belts in If It's over and Fly like a Bird? From being on YT for years, the one thing I've learned is that opinions on here, are just that. Opinions lmao.
1. Mariah
2. Whitney
3. Celine
Whitney has support in all registers,
Мне не важна техническся сторона ,совершенно.мне важны чувства,рождаемые во время прослушивания.Только пение Уитни трогает меня.
Ok but Mariah Carey is whistle note queen
Minnie, Chante?
No she is not
@@Yourlocalcatlover-rz6ks Minnie?
@@AuygayhuHnhuquyhqhe probably meant Minnie Riperton, the ultimate Whistle Queen, even better than Mooriah
I’m pretty she’s has gone a G5 or G#5 live on one of her through the rain performances
lipped/pre-recorded
Céline is the greatest of all Times. Don't never and ever compare her with Mariah, maybe Whitney, but Mariah Can never be at the same level that Céline. Céline is so incredibble
I agree
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣😅🤣😅🤣🤣🤣😅🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Okay Whitney with that whistle 😂😂😂
Whitney has the best scale out of the three, from top to bottom. Mariah and Celine go lower with their voices with more ease because they’re not projecting in full voice. In the undubbed audio of ‘You And I’, Mariah’s low notes were very breathy and almost inaudible, and not very in tune. Whitney almost always sang in full voice from top to bottom. Whitney also has the most balanced belting scale - an even resonance from top to bottom. Celine has more ease from G5 and up, but only because she thins her voice out more. Whitney went up there with a more balanced sound. Head voice goes to Whitney, although Celine is close. And both Celine and Whitney do not have a whistle register.
That’s so true, but you have to appreciate Mariah and Celine too. I love all of them because they have their own unique differences.
@@AuygayhuHnhuquyhq I absolutely appreciate them. Three phenomenal singers who cannot be replaced.
The undubbed audio isnt real tho😭 and mariaj just naturally has a much richer low range,,,like a fucking A2 is a fucking usable note for her
I see u on nippy twitter a lot u and timmy and in comment sections lol
Strange and soul-refreshing to see a simple and honest non black person 😭
Whitney's the best and never pushed harder to become the best she just always The best from tone,pure power, vocal range,soul, stage presence,live singing and delivery
Love all of them too
what song is that one that says: “never did jt live” from mariah
the g#5 part of "fly like a bird"
CELINE all the time