I'd like to know wich criteria did u use to choose that Phantomatic Trinity... Let's say this is your choice for USA market and USA music industry, cause there singers in the rest of the world that are much more better that whose listed here..
@@tasosGRvocals worldwide know?? I guess that you made it... USA made... Believe me the rest of the world don't agree at all... So call it in the right way... The most famous worldwide singers.????? No... Not at all sorry... And where are those singers now??? We have amazing singers better that those 3, same period, still performing... No... Those are not the worldwide singers sorry
Imagine Whitney Houston, Mariah Carey, and Celine Dion being in one group, and sing together. No one can beat the VOCAL TRINITY when they're singing together 😍😍😍
Me too!! When it's between three such excellent vocalists, one does simply get to enjoy the excellence and choose his favourite!! Thank you for watching!! 🥰😍
Singers nowadays can only wish they have a tiny fraction of what these three ladies had in their prime. Whitney, Celine and Mariah were incredible back then and will always be remembered as among the best!
They are certainly legendary, and for many good reasons, but let's not bring down younger singers. Samara Joy, Gabby Samone, Jai'len Josey, Faouzia, Morissette Amon, etc. are comparable to them, and some of them even surpassed the Trinity in certain areas.
@@БогданЗелинский-ю9зEvery singer has a weak point or something that could be fixed. But saying those singers are comparable to the Vocal Trinity in their prime...I love Fouzia to death but no. Her voice isn't something that hasn't been heard before or makes her stand out. And it's not me being rude or anything...just pointing out what I hear and see and what many others would probably agree with. But those singers you named are definitely good
C5 - Celine C#5 - Mariah D5 - Celine Eb5 - Whitney E5 - Whitney (this one was the hardest for me to decide) F5 - Mariah F#5 - Mariah G5 - Celine Honestly one of the best selections I've seen in a vocal trinity comparison video!
@@leumamk5259 Yeah I don't know what happened with the audio clips for the intro and the first Whitney C5, I guess they were badly compressed by the editing program 😕
C5 - Whitney (Power!!!) C#5 - Celine & Mariah & Whitney (Resonance and OUTPUT FOR CENTURIES) D5 - Celine (She owns the note) Eb5 - Whitney (She ATE and left no crumbs) E5 - Mariah (There's something ICONIC about that rasp) F5 - Whitney & Mariah (Just wow, Mariah hitting F5 like it's absolutely nothing and whitney eating that note for lunch!) F#5 - Celine (She ROCKS DIVA) (Mariah kinda squeezed the note and Whitney wasn't personally at her best) G5 - Tie (Mariah's iconic hero note, Whitney using glissando to G5 and EATING, Celine's LEGENDARY VH1 note)
Whitney - Trained her voice to its fullest to share her talent with the world Celine - Used her voice to its fullest to be one of the best performers Mariah - Took the most risks with her voice to pave her own way
I was introduced to music through Celine Dion then Mariah then Whitney. Mariah became my favourite cause she writes her music and her tone hasalways felt like a warm and cozy embrace. But all 3 of them are/ were talented beyond words. They represent excellence in their very own way. Contrary to popular belief, they don't sound the same, they all have distinct runs, styles and strengths. For me, no one can ever top the trinity even though there's many other amazing vocalists out there. I have nothing but love for those 3 uniquely gifted women.
Whitney has the best tone and timbre and the best and most powerful mid-tones. Celine has the best sustain on the high notes. And Mariah has the best musicality, agility and sophistication. All three seem to me to be excellent singers, however I think Mariah set the bar very high with the dynamism of her voice, her high notes with many complicated glissandos. And excellent low notes. Technically and musically I think Mariah was more prodigious, although interpretatively Whitney and Celine gave better performances.
Each one has his own opinion, comparison between three such great singers basically becomes a matter of taste when all of them are so good, thank you for watching!! ☺️
@@tasosGRvocals from your reaction to mariah comments i can see that you have a favorite trying to pull the "well all of them are good" you didn't say that when someone said Mariah was best wich shes definitely under Whitney vocally but your right everyone is obligated to their own opinion i do feel thats a bit contradicting though
@@FoundmyLoveinPortofino I do have a favourite and I don't deny it. I'm not saying that someone is better, but that I have a favourite. I adore and cherish all three of them, they are my queens. I have even done a separate video for a Mariah concert to show that I do love her too 👑
@@vingo0070 complex vocals??? those copy and pasted vocal sessions are show to he fraudulent with acapella and “most girly” she sounds like a man check her neck it might be an adams apple😂
@@lucasfrost3256 Yea you should read description,she chose her own favorite notes.Whitney's F#5 here is better than Mariah's.She cant support F#5s.Mostly her support is on Daydream era.
@@lougomes2912 Whitney used fuller approach which is way harder than brightened belts,only one of those F#5s from Mariah is supported,the rest are tensed.You clearly don't know what ur talking about.
I love how even on identical notes, each of them sounds powerful, yet distinct from one another. All three have something very special. Vocally my favorite is Whitney - Nobody has combined sweet and smooth with power and depth better than her. Her voice was truly exeptional in quality and clarity. In term of musicianship, Mariah wins - She has written so many iconic tracks, people really don't appreciated just what a competent songwriter she really is....AND she has that insane level of range and agility that few other humans can match. Celine sits somewhere in between the two, vocally speaking. All three are legends!
@@Xelth4 So, technically speaking, Both Mariah and Celine have a lot more quality in low notes and better agility than Whitney. Plus, Mariah has the biggest range and Celine the best support. I can't see what you mean with "technically speaking"
@@AndreRodrigues-qd6cu they don't have better agility than Whitney in chest voice at all. Whitney just didn't overdo it with chest voice runs as much as Celine and Mariah did it. And many of their chest voice runs (Mariah's and Celine's) were often inaccurate and not every note of the run was perfeclty clear. On the contrary, all Whitney's runs are perfectly produced. Both in chest and head voice. And we all know that agility in chest voice is much more difficult than agility in head voice-mixed voice.
They all obviously hit notes that are otherworldly but it's that tone that Mariah has. You see 1000 videos of Whitney & Celine imitators that come close their their sounds they almost fool you but I've yet to hear someone mimic Mariahs tone that way.
@ChiChisWorld there is one and only Morrissette Amon if you watch her cover of one of Mariah's song which is (Against all odds) damn she sound more like Mariah
@@jackkiima7089 I am well aware of The Phoenix. She's for me the best vocalist of her generation. But, she does not sound like Mariah. She's definitely her own shining star though.
Idk, I’ve never really heard anyone sound exactly like Whitney or Mariah. People say Glennis and Belinda sound like her in the middle, but to me, they sound no more similar to Whitney than Tori Kelly and Ariana sound to Mariah.
Celine and Whitney definitely belts better, plus Celine has the best head voice, her middle voice is quite masterful too. Although the two doesn't have whistle, they outshine Mariah in the other registers which is why they stand a chance against Mariah. I simply think people overexaggerate Mariah's whistle in contrast to Celine and Whitney's singing capabilities.
@@shotoizuku6394 Whitney has better head voice than Celine,Whitney had control all of her Dynamics and carry better operatic ring than her. Mariah's "overexaggerated" fits to the melody.Using whistle is not overexaggerated,unless it doesn't fit on her.Whistle is a stylistic singing style.
@@bestvocalsbyvocalists849 I didn't say the whistle was overexaggerating though, girl, your reading comprehension. Also, Celine has the best range of belting as well as her head voice even past her prime when it comes to non-operatic style, why would you include operatic to non-operatic? That's not how it works.
celine and mariah’s (post-prime!) resonant C5s whitney’s iconic GLOA and mariah’s iconic make it happen C#5s celine D5 queen whitney Eb5 queen, love celine’s TPOTD and mariah’s hero runs celine’s ease in that E5, whitney and mariah’s phrased E5s yas celine and mariah’s multiple F5 runs whitney’s sustained G5, celine’s iconic G5 run, and mariah’s beautiful tone in hero G5 iconic and legendary vocalists. love your selections!!!
@@Diego_Santa It really is, I always value and appreciate Kaji's opinion, he is the best!! 🥰💖 And thank you very much for watching too, I'm glad you liked it 😍😍
me as a Céline fan: C5 - Céline (resonance and vibrato) C#5 - Mariah (resonance and ease for days) D5 - Céline (it's her note) Eb5 - Céline (I know Whitney had vibrato and ease but i just love how much resonance and power Céline had) E5 - Whitney F5 - Mariah F#5 - Whitney/Céline G5- Céline
@@mikeg1211 Lol, you can't accept facts. Mariah has the best legacy, not the best voice, but they really have differences, catalogue among them all. Not dicrediting whitney and celine, they are all great so stop the fucking hatred towards talented woman when you clearly can't and envy.
@@tasosGRvocals It really is! I wish people used it in their vocal comparisons and compilations. So thank you so much for showing Céline's talent to the world ❤️
Whitney and Celinen stood out to me the most here. Excellent execution for the most part on all ends. Perhaps Celine was the most 'consistent' out of them, and based solely on that alone, she wins in this video.
Well yeah Celine and Whitney vocal types are best for belting. Mariah not so much but her vocal type allows for those whistle notes. They each have their strengths. Personally, while I love Whitney’s full rounded belting, my favorite is Celine’s powerful, piercing, sustained belting. It hits my soul like lightning
No trinity will be like this one for me, this is the original one!! But it would be awesome for us to have I our future lifetime three such influential female singers with absolutely staggering voices!
This Is Real Authentic Pure LAST Vocal Trinity ever!!.... But i Prefer Céline Dion!!... Because, She Is Everything!!! She the Best!!! On the Stage she's a Phenomenal Performer Vocalist!!! A Beast!! She's Out of This World!!!.... INCOMPARABLE!!....
I'm so glad with this video.. for me no more comparison with the three they both excelled on their own uh unique and golden voices.. By the way, nice pick of video
@@bestvocalsbyvocalists849 I know her cuz I'm a fan of her but I don't think that Lisa has the best belts although she's amazing and I think that she's better than Nippy technique wise. Lisa is the greatest female vocalist of all time imo.
@@mikel4531Whitney is a better midbelter and used way more impressive approach,but "technique" its Lisa,she produce better resonance than her,more consistent.She dominates upper belts and lower belts. I agree,she's the greatest vocalist by a female artist along with Vivian Reed.
Céline Dion has the Best and MOST Beautiful Voice of all Times in Music!!!!!..... She's a Truly Vocalist and WORLD Music Diva!!!..... She's the Unique Queen of LasVegas!!!.... On the Ranked of Vocal Trinity for me Is on the #2.... Whitney at #1, Céline at #2, Mariah at #3.... This Is my Opinioni!!!
Mariah is always so gorgeous, even if she couldn't sing or write songs she still would've been world famous based on looks alone, God was inspired when He created her.
vocality, agility and resonant its Celine Dion up to this years your Whitney dies at early she proved herself when shes still alive while Mariah cant belt anymore seeing her performances today its eeriee while Celine doing great 😘❤️
These are the three greatest female voices and these three also has a lot of the most toxic fans who like to compare them for each other. Lets all just be thankful they graced the music industry and brought good music and influenced a lot of artists.
@@bestvocalsbyvocalists849 japan saving all my love for you 1991? And i dont know about the f#5 u give good love, it may be better technically but her tone back then was so thin compared to 90's Whitney and especially 94's whitney tone that we all love. Personally I would pick f#5 yokohama 1991 note
Whitney's Eb5 is the most iconic sustain note of all time. Mariah's phrasing G5 in Hero is the most perfect G5 ever of all time. Celine Dion's D5 is super balanced, the D5 master reigner.
@@angelxemotions9102 thin? Celine's vocal cord is much thicker than Mariah. If you're talking about F#5 in divas live yes they are thin. But not her G5. Aretha tried to follow but Celine's F5 and G5 are more powerful.
@@bestvocalsbyvocalists849 Do you mean her known sustained E5s that are used in every single video? I didn't want to use those but I know them and tbh I don't particularly like them xD
@@bestvocalsbyvocalists849 i prefer the he, i believe eb5 belts. I dont like the E5 belts of this song as much
Год назад+3
According to clips on this video: C - tie C♯ - tie D - Celine E♭ - Whitney E - Whitney F - Whitney F♯ - Mariah (Whitney's was a half step lower) G - Whitney (there's a debate whether the key was a major C or B, but if it was a major C, then it's Whitney - if not, it's a toss up between Celine and Mariah)
celine's C5 wins at 0:26. I would prefer another C5 from Whitney, this is not as impressive as many other C5 notes from her. Mariah's C5 is truly one of her best if not her best live C5. Whitney's G5 wins everyone. And I don't know if it's a G5 though or F#5. Cause if it's a G5, this means she raised saving all my love for you song TWO semitones which is very unlikely, she raised it one semitone in some cases like 1985 letterman but never two semitones
Now does Anna Vissi have any note from a C5-E5 that compares to their performances of those same notes? Yes I know Anna Vissi is a mezzo-soprano and the Vocal Trinity consists of sopranos, but just for the fun of it how do Anna Vissi's belts/mixes compare from a C5 to an E5?
@@mps4447 Oh well she certainly does! She has a much lower voice, but in the C5-D5 area she has had note attempts that could give these ladies a run for their money. Especially with C5s! Above D5 though the difference is vast.
✌️☝️🙏Objective vocal analysis🙏☝️✌️ C5 - Celine and Mariah (both amazing tone, resonance and power, Celine’s vibrato was fantastic and Mariah’s resonance was surreal!) C#5 - all three legends were equally great! Point each! D5 - Celine (the most powerful and opened vocal, D5 is just her note) Eb5 - all three were phenomenal. Whitney’s gorgeous vibrato, Celine’s incredible power snd Mariah’s unreal ease and flexibility! Well deserved point each! E5 - Whitney (amazing full and rich sound, well supported) F5 - Whitney (same reason) F#5 - Mariah (the healthiest technique, Whitney was also amazing but Mariah was more free and relaxed in these upper area) G5 - Whitney and Mariah (both technically effortless, well supported and free)
@@mariahcareydaydreamera2526 Whitney's G5 is an F#5 and its not tensed its natural tension,the other tension is obstructive tension which is the bad tension..Name what obstructive tension did Whitney have there?its just chestier and fuller,with that kind if density and volume.She managed to do that so sure call her effortless heavy approach as tensed compared to neutral and curbed approach.
C5 - D5 mariah carey is effortless and celine has the best vocal Eb5 Whitney wow, the power of celine Dion wow E5 : they all are effortless F5 : they all mastered it F#5 : Mariah Carey and Whitney the vowel wow celine Dion what a powerful voice G5 : what a perfect and powerful mix voice
Mariah fan btw C5- tie (celine's was held longer but mariahs was more resonant i cant choose) C#5- mariah D5- celine Eb5- whitney (though celine's resonance and mariah's tone were amazing) E5- tie (mariah, whitney) F5- mariah F#5- tie (mariah, celine) G5- tie (ALL OF THEM) Theyre all so amazing its crazy they were all even alive at the same time, we dont get good singers like them everyday.
All three of those ladies are excellent at the craft of singing. Yet, for me, Whitney stands out as the brightest in the bunch. Her voice was so amazing!
@nathanieljohnson5908 Mariah is a mezzo soprano, she already said that. You can believe it seeing how her voice goes deep with facility, and hit notes a little lower than the other 2
@marcello759 Take in notes the talking voice. Her voice is deep. I'd say she's a contralto/mezzo with high range potential, just as Celine is a soprano with low range potential
Whitney’s Voice Celine’s Live Performing Skills Mariah’s songwriting Put these three qualities together and you get the perfect Main Pop Girl (MPG) this world has ever seen.
Celine does still sound really good. If you’d like to check out Mariah still killing it live I’d look at her 2019 vocals of You Don’t Know What To Do / Smotions medley, or Hero in 2019/2020 live. A lot of her agility and vibrato is still there when she’s a rested, her upper register and breath control is just not there as before.
Subjective . Celine focused on her high mixed belts . But her overall tone , nasality and super heady high mixed voice doesnt sit well with me . Also Mariah has nodules and Celine doesnt . I much prefer Mariah’s strong mid resonant belts and whistles and tone than showing off super heady nasal high notes lol . I hope you didnt forget Whitney has passed away .
@@hyun808 You clearly haven't listened to Céline then. Her lows, C#5s, ofc upper belts, headvoice etc are superior to Mariah even today. Mariah's voice has a lot of constriction save for a few lucky moments. Céline's nasality isn't a problem as she can control it well. It's her accent after all. And she has hit grounded and free c#5s TODAY, something Mariah can't do. Ofc she has her whistle, but she is barely ever resonant. Bless her - her nodules are to blame.
I don't like singer oversing (like Xtina, Jennifer Hudson, Beyonce...with all the " yeah yeah yeah~~~") but when Whitney did it, it sound amazing. her voice just nice to listen for most ppl in general.
This is great vocal video. You didn't use no lip sync note by Celine or Mariah. Whitney rarely lipped, so yeah. I also would've used Mariah's F5's from SNL & Grammy's 92 tho.
I tried not to use the single most used clip for each note of theirs, but still use popular clips, that's why I didn't use for example the C5s from It's All Coming Back to me now, or the Imagine D5, or the All By Myself Eb5, or the Love Can move mountains F5s from Celine, the America the beautiful C5, the underneath the stars D5, the if it's over E5 and F#5s for Mariah, or the All at once C5, the D5s where she yells "Love", the sustained E5s that I don't remember which song they are from, or the you give good love F#5 for Whitney!! I still used very popular clips though, I chose my favourite note of every one and used it!!
It’ll always be Whitney for me. Incredible technique, great interpretation, emotive, powerful, love most of her catalog. Celine and Mariah are talented, but they don’t do it for me like Whitney does.
C5 : Celine ( THE PIERCING RESONANCE IM DYING OMG ) C#5 : Whitney ( she is incredible at c#5 notes ) D5 : Celine ( It's her note and that's enough as an argument lol ) Eb5 : Whitney ( best Eb5 ever ) E5 : Whitney ( the core and the tonal quality that remains perfect and untouched-unchanged even with phrased belts 😍 ) F5 : Whitney ( the core up there ) F#5 : Mariah ( her note but Whitney's was so great too and Celine's, so hard to choose, but if it was " if it's over " F#5 i would go with Mariah without second thought, but im glad u didnt include in the video the same overused note ) G5 : Whitney ( core and chest projection up there, tone still remains and anyone can say it's Whitney's note, voice doesnt become thin compared to most female singers' G5 notes )
if we have to compare the trinity .at .20 years . young; I think celine will have the one with the most piercing voice on the notes above E5 at 20 years old then houston and at the end carrey at 20 year (((( I don't speak at 25 and 30 be careful ))))))) for the average middle notes........ I think that houston will be the most powerful and the strongest then............ between celiine and carrey (at 20 years) I think that celine will still have this piercing voice in addition which makes a difference. she sings with her mask may be???? for the bass low notes, carrey is superb .... then houston and at the end dion . .low notes I think it is linked to this fine and clear voice of celine, it lacks weight despite supporting more than the other 2 the head voice, houston the queen then dion
The video was gotten down briefly due to copyright claims on Celine's G5. Unfortunately I had to mute it for the video to be available again 😔
I'd like to know wich criteria did u use to choose that Phantomatic Trinity... Let's say this is your choice for USA market and USA music industry, cause there singers in the rest of the world that are much more better that whose listed here..
@@Francesco71rm I didn't make the trinity, this is the worldwide known vocal trinity. Idk who made it, but I love the singers.
@@tasosGRvocals worldwide know?? I guess that you made it... USA made... Believe me the rest of the world don't agree at all... So call it in the right way... The most famous worldwide singers.????? No... Not at all sorry...
And where are those singers now??? We have amazing singers better that those 3, same period, still performing... No... Those are not the worldwide singers sorry
And by the way you didn't answer to my question.. That was wich criterias did you choose to decide they are the best singers.
@@Francesco71rm I didn't make it, that's the worldwide known vocal trinity.
The Voice - Whitney Houston
The Powerhouse - Celine Dion
Songbird Supreme - Mariah Carey
True!! 🥰
Yesss🔥
finally Celine has a title
@@laskei only her hardcore fans created that.
@@royalpanther6391 lol
Imagine Whitney Houston, Mariah Carey, and Celine Dion being in one group, and sing together. No one can beat the VOCAL TRINITY when they're singing together 😍😍😍
It would be a dream come true if they had made a song together all three of them!! 😍
it wouldnt happen because the Earth will shake and tear all human out to space because the greatness of them is so powerful.
Divas live 1998 mariah voice is too low compare to celine voice, celine win big against marriot
This is so good. I dont even see this as a battle, just a compilation of excellence. Thank you for sharing
Me too!! When it's between three such excellent vocalists, one does simply get to enjoy the excellence and choose his favourite!! Thank you for watching!! 🥰😍
My favorite is whitney, but they are all very good.
yesss! 💯 love these three queens!
This is the best comment so far
finally, a great comment in which there Isn't a comparison between these vocal legends. ❤
At their best, these three ladies rightfull reigned; they delivered some of the most beautiful and extraordinary vocals known to mankind 👑👑👑
Exactly!! 👑🥰💞
Singers nowadays can only wish they have a tiny fraction of what these three ladies had in their prime. Whitney, Celine and Mariah were incredible back then and will always be remembered as among the best!
Very well said!! 👏
They are certainly legendary, and for many good reasons, but let's not bring down younger singers. Samara Joy, Gabby Samone, Jai'len Josey, Faouzia, Morissette Amon, etc. are comparable to them, and some of them even surpassed the Trinity in certain areas.
@@БогданЗелинский-ю9з Their voice is not developed enough even to be compared with them.
@@БогданЗелинский-ю9з who are they?
@@БогданЗелинский-ю9зEvery singer has a weak point or something that could be fixed. But saying those singers are comparable to the Vocal Trinity in their prime...I love Fouzia to death but no. Her voice isn't something that hasn't been heard before or makes her stand out. And it's not me being rude or anything...just pointing out what I hear and see and what many others would probably agree with. But those singers you named are definitely good
C5 - Celine
C#5 - Mariah
D5 - Celine
Eb5 - Whitney
E5 - Whitney (this one was the hardest for me to decide)
F5 - Mariah
F#5 - Mariah
G5 - Celine
Honestly one of the best selections I've seen in a vocal trinity comparison video!
Really nice choices!!! ❤️🥰⭐
Whitney's F5 and Whitney G5 tho. This im changing high note doesnt lie...
That Whitney's Eb5 is literally iconic and unmatched
@@minakanushi0099 and its not even her best Eb5
@@Xelth4 highly agree with you!! That F and G were STUNNING!
4:28 the fact that two of the trinity are there makes this performance iconic
And not only them, legend Aretha too!!
@@tasosGRvocals legend is too low for her
@@MarcArianator13 True that!!
The C5 of Mariah, my ears are still ringing, it was so good 😭
Post prime and for me her best C5!! ⭐
RIGHT LIKE THE RESONANCE OMG
@@jonathan_8100 YEP! Certainly one of her best C5s
Céline's was also pretty resonant, and probably Whitney's too, but the audio quality wasn't that great.
@@leumamk5259 Yeah I don't know what happened with the audio clips for the intro and the first Whitney C5, I guess they were badly compressed by the editing program 😕
C5 - Mariah
C#5 - Mariah
D5 - Celine
Eb5 - Whitney
E5 - Whitney
F5 - Mariah
F#5 - Celine
G5 - Celine
Three incredible women and vocalists 🥰
Great choices!! ☺️☺️😍
Mariah is in superior level.
👑
C5 - Whitney (Power!!!)
C#5 - Celine & Mariah & Whitney (Resonance and OUTPUT FOR CENTURIES)
D5 - Celine (She owns the note)
Eb5 - Whitney (She ATE and left no crumbs)
E5 - Mariah (There's something ICONIC about that rasp)
F5 - Whitney & Mariah (Just wow, Mariah hitting F5 like it's absolutely nothing and whitney eating that note for lunch!)
F#5 - Celine (She ROCKS DIVA) (Mariah kinda squeezed the note and Whitney wasn't personally at her best)
G5 - Tie (Mariah's iconic hero note, Whitney using glissando to G5 and EATING, Celine's LEGENDARY VH1 note)
Great choices!!! 😍🥰
That F#5 was Whitney at her best.She was at her prime,but she has better F#5s than that
Wait, Mariah's E5 wasn't 'Vision Of Love' it was her song 'Someday'. Idk if I'm reading it wrong or what 😫
Celine is a powerhouse diva. Amazing!
I adore heeer 🥰😍😍😍
Powerhouse Queen
Like seriously Celine Dion my all time icon but I love all they are all amazing
Whitney - Trained her voice to its fullest to share her talent with the world
Celine - Used her voice to its fullest to be one of the best performers
Mariah - Took the most risks with her voice to pave her own way
Queens, all of them 👑👑👑
You know them well.
Mariah did not take the most risks. Especially in a live setting.
@@The_Truth- You do know that singing in any form or way is literally the opposite of what doctors recommend to people with nodules right?
@@shikaii9912 Do you know how many people sing with nodules are doing just fine? Not every doctor recommends not to sing. So lets no tell that lie.
Whitney was special. She had power, heart, and soul in everything she sang. Just beautiful
Her smile was everything 😍😍
That’s exactly celine
@@goldranger5182 girl bye
Mariah is the one who was special, as she had what the two others had and beyond both vocally and musically.
I was introduced to music through Celine Dion then Mariah then Whitney. Mariah became my favourite cause she writes her music and her tone hasalways felt like a warm and cozy embrace. But all 3 of them are/ were talented beyond words. They represent excellence in their very own way. Contrary to popular belief, they don't sound the same, they all have distinct runs, styles and strengths. For me, no one can ever top the trinity even though there's many other amazing vocalists out there. I have nothing but love for those 3 uniquely gifted women.
You said it perfectly!! 😍🥰
👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Whitney has the best tone and timbre and the best and most powerful mid-tones. Celine has the best sustain on the high notes. And Mariah has the best musicality, agility and sophistication. All three seem to me to be excellent singers, however I think Mariah set the bar very high with the dynamism of her voice, her high notes with many complicated glissandos. And excellent low notes. Technically and musically I think Mariah was more prodigious, although interpretatively Whitney and Celine gave better performances.
Each one has his own opinion, comparison between three such great singers basically becomes a matter of taste when all of them are so good, thank you for watching!! ☺️
@@tasosGRvocals from your reaction to mariah comments i can see that you have a favorite trying to pull the "well all of them are good" you didn't say that when someone said Mariah was best wich shes definitely under Whitney vocally but your right everyone is obligated to their own opinion i do feel thats a bit contradicting though
@@FoundmyLoveinPortofino I do have a favourite and I don't deny it. I'm not saying that someone is better, but that I have a favourite. I adore and cherish all three of them, they are my queens. I have even done a separate video for a Mariah concert to show that I do love her too 👑
mariah has the the most complex vocal out of all.... plus shes the most girly vocal out of 3
@@vingo0070 complex vocals??? those copy and pasted vocal sessions are show to he fraudulent with acapella and “most girly” she sounds like a man check her neck it might be an adams apple😂
C5 - Mariah!
C#5 - tie..all of them were great!
D5 - Celine
Eb5 - Whitney!
E5 - Whitney!
F5 - tie
F#5 - Mariah/Whitney
G5 - Celine’s was just too iconic!
Whitney - 5
Mariah - 4
Celine - 4
Interesting choices!!! 🥰
love it but respectfully and without basing on these clips alone. F#5 is OWNED by Mariah. The 1992 If its over Grammy Performance is a solid evidence.
@@lucasfrost3256 Yea you should read description,she chose her own favorite notes.Whitney's F#5 here is better than Mariah's.She cant support F#5s.Mostly her support is on Daydream era.
@@bestvocalsbyvocalists849 Not it isn't. Mariah's F#5 are far more impressive. There you come again talking without knowing your facts.
@@lougomes2912 Whitney used fuller approach which is way harder than brightened belts,only one of those F#5s from Mariah is supported,the rest are tensed.You clearly don't know what ur talking about.
I love how even on identical notes, each of them sounds powerful, yet distinct from one another. All three have something very special.
Vocally my favorite is Whitney - Nobody has combined sweet and smooth with power and depth better than her. Her voice was truly exeptional in quality and clarity. In term of musicianship, Mariah wins - She has written so many iconic tracks, people really don't appreciated just what a competent songwriter she really is....AND she has that insane level of range and agility that few other humans can match. Celine sits somewhere in between the two, vocally speaking. All three are legends!
That what made them the legends they are!! 👑👑
Whitney is the absolute best. God kissed her throat and said this person will have the greatest voice on earth ( male or female )
Queen!! 👑👑
With these three legends, we can't ever say words like sure or absolute. This is your personal preference.
@@AndreRodrigues-qd6cu it's not my personal preference. Vocal technique is not personal preference. It's objective
@@Xelth4 So, technically speaking, Both Mariah and Celine have a lot more quality in low notes and better agility than Whitney. Plus, Mariah has the biggest range and Celine the best support. I can't see what you mean with "technically speaking"
@@AndreRodrigues-qd6cu they don't have better agility than Whitney in chest voice at all. Whitney just didn't overdo it with chest voice runs as much as Celine and Mariah did it. And many of their chest voice runs (Mariah's and Celine's) were often inaccurate and not every note of the run was perfeclty clear. On the contrary, all Whitney's runs are perfectly produced. Both in chest and head voice. And we all know that agility in chest voice is much more difficult than agility in head voice-mixed voice.
This is by far the best vocal showcase of the vocal trinity.. please do more of this ❤
@@aruichika3434 Thank you so much! I've already made videos of them about HV and low notes, they're in my channel!!
They all obviously hit notes that are otherworldly but it's that tone that Mariah has. You see 1000 videos of Whitney & Celine imitators that come close their their sounds they almost fool you but I've yet to hear someone mimic Mariahs tone that way.
@ChiChisWorld there is one and only Morrissette Amon if you watch her cover of one of Mariah's song which is (Against all odds) damn she sound more like Mariah
@@jackkiima7089 I am well aware of The Phoenix. She's for me the best vocalist of her generation. But, she does not sound like Mariah. She's definitely her own shining star though.
Nobody sounds like Whitney
@@nathanieljohnson5908 ruclips.net/video/n4wZLAzzfMg/видео.htmlsi=h6UCVJovTGt2k2rw
Idk, I’ve never really heard anyone sound exactly like Whitney or Mariah. People say Glennis and Belinda sound like her in the middle, but to me, they sound no more similar to Whitney than Tori Kelly and Ariana sound to Mariah.
Great video i always love Whitneys thick and full belting range
Celine soaring and rounded belt
And Mariah bright and effortless belt
Thank you very much!! 🥰💞
I always prefer belts with core😍😍
Celine and Whitney definitely belts better, plus Celine has the best head voice, her middle voice is quite masterful too. Although the two doesn't have whistle, they outshine Mariah in the other registers which is why they stand a chance against Mariah. I simply think people overexaggerate Mariah's whistle in contrast to Celine and Whitney's singing capabilities.
@@shotoizuku6394 Whitney has better head voice than Celine,Whitney had control all of her Dynamics and carry better operatic ring than her.
Mariah's "overexaggerated" fits to the melody.Using whistle is not overexaggerated,unless it doesn't fit on her.Whistle is a stylistic singing style.
@@bestvocalsbyvocalists849 I didn't say the whistle was overexaggerating though, girl, your reading comprehension. Also, Celine has the best range of belting as well as her head voice even past her prime when it comes to non-operatic style, why would you include operatic to non-operatic? That's not how it works.
celine and mariah’s (post-prime!) resonant C5s
whitney’s iconic GLOA and mariah’s iconic make it happen C#5s
celine D5 queen
whitney Eb5 queen, love celine’s TPOTD and mariah’s hero runs
celine’s ease in that E5, whitney and mariah’s phrased E5s yas
celine and mariah’s multiple F5 runs
whitney’s sustained G5, celine’s iconic G5 run, and mariah’s beautiful tone in hero G5
iconic and legendary vocalists. love your selections!!!
Thank you very much!! I'm glad you liked it!! 🥰🥰🥳
@@tasosGRvocals celine’s sstbthd C5 and tpotd Eb5 are heavily underused. glad to see them here
@@iicedcoffeerv And they are among her best!! 👑
TPOTD Eb5!!! You really chose amazing clips 😫😫
She absolutely slaughtered in that one!! Thank you so much for your kind comments!! 🥰🥰🥰
Mariah is just out of this world 😍
🥰😍👑
Great compilation
Thank you very much!! 🥰😍
@@tasosGRvocals that’s like the biggest compliment you can get from him, the compilations master lol (btw I rly enjoyed the video!)
@@Diego_Santa It really is, I always value and appreciate Kaji's opinion, he is the best!! 🥰💖
And thank you very much for watching too, I'm glad you liked it 😍😍
Whitney and Céline’s resonance in the D5-E5 range gives me goosebumps
Exactly!! Their resonance is staggering!! ❤️😍
me as a Céline fan:
C5 - Céline (resonance and vibrato)
C#5 - Mariah (resonance and ease for days)
D5 - Céline (it's her note)
Eb5 - Céline (I know Whitney had vibrato and ease but i just love how much resonance and power Céline had)
E5 - Whitney
F5 - Mariah
F#5 - Whitney/Céline
G5- Céline
Really nice choices!! Thank you for watching!! 🥰😍❤️
Mariah was just unparalleled. Incredible.
Queen!! 👑
Well if this video shows one thing as that none of them was unparralleded against theo ther two
The other two were unparalleled on their way as well
She was actually the worse of the 3 here lol
@@mikeg1211 Lol, you can't accept facts. Mariah has the best legacy, not the best voice, but they really have differences, catalogue among them all. Not dicrediting whitney and celine, they are all great so stop the fucking hatred towards talented woman when you clearly can't and envy.
Celine is so underrated!
Great job tostos
Celine is underrated indeed!! Thank you Geooorge 😍😍😍
Because they always use her worst clip and out of era vocals on the other videos so they can be biased
sold 220M albums.idts!
Atleast you used most of the clips that are rare and not overused most on the vocal showcase video channel, ❤️❤️❤️❤️
Thank you!! 😍❤️🥰
C5 - Celine
C#5 - mariah
D5 - celine (love her tone here)
Eb5 - whitney (legendary)
E5 - Mariah
F5 - Mariah
F#5- whitney and mariah
G5- mariah and celine
Overall 3 celine and 2 whitney and 5 mariah
All Queens!! 👑💖👑
I love your note choices. Especially Céline's C5! It's so underrated.
Perhaps they don't use it as much because it's only audio, but it's absolutely perfect!!
@@tasosGRvocals It really is! I wish people used it in their vocal comparisons and compilations. So thank you so much for showing Céline's talent to the world ❤️
@@avec-toi Thank you for your kind comments!! It's comments like these that motivate me to continue 😍🥰💖
@@avec-toi most of the versuses video are made of mariah they always choose celine’s worst clip and out of era vocals.
@@goldranger5182 Huh?Worst?they're actually better than Mariah's clips
Whitney and Celinen stood out to me the most here. Excellent execution for the most part on all ends. Perhaps Celine was the most 'consistent' out of them, and based solely on that alone, she wins in this video.
Queens!! I adore Celine and Whitney!! 😍🥰
The Powerhouse Queen
Well yeah Celine and Whitney vocal types are best for belting. Mariah not so much but her vocal type allows for those whistle notes. They each have their strengths. Personally, while I love Whitney’s full rounded belting, my favorite is Celine’s powerful, piercing, sustained belting. It hits my soul like lightning
@@danielbenitez6985Mariah was the vest in acrobatics and upper phrasing, also melismatic singing, cause she could offer much more than the others
@@PhilHarmmer lmfaooo no thats all Whitney and im being unbiased. Whitney phrased g5s and f5s way more than mariah
I love them, I hope we have the future trinity with the same quality. I will wait for that.
No trinity will be like this one for me, this is the original one!! But it would be awesome for us to have I our future lifetime three such influential female singers with absolutely staggering voices!
They make singing look so effortless 😭😩🤩
They doo, but it's not 😅😅❤️
only seems easy until you sing the same note LOL
So lucky to live in an era when all these three superstars existed.
Very well said 👏
Love them all but Mariah's always been favorite.
It's just a matter of favourite between these three!!
Putting that Whitney Eb5 in here is so unfair to any other singer bc of how damn perfect it is 😂 Jokes aside, this was great!
Hahahah, it was exceptional indeed, thank you!! ❤️
They are all incredible and it's so hard to choose
Indeed!!! That's why they are the trinity, it's not about choosing the best at this point, but your favourite one!! 😍🥰
Whitney is incomparable.❤❤ She is totally "The voice"
👑👑
Absolutely the best. “The Voice”!
This Is Real Authentic Pure LAST Vocal Trinity ever!!.... But i Prefer Céline Dion!!... Because, She Is Everything!!! She the Best!!! On the Stage she's a Phenomenal Performer Vocalist!!! A Beast!! She's Out of This World!!!.... INCOMPARABLE!!....
I adore Celine Dion too!! 😍😍😍
Always be Mariah for me!
😊😊
I'm so glad with this video.. for me no more comparison with the three they both excelled on their own uh unique and golden voices..
By the way, nice pick of video
Thank you so much!! 🥰💞
Those notes for mariah seems so easy for her she is from another level ♥️
🥰😍💞
True back when she had a voice she was unbeatable
she still has the voice baby
Celine dion-Vocal Powerful
Queeeen!! 👑
Whitney is the best belter I've ever heard in my life imo, the Goat, the Queen 👑💖✨
Whitney is absolutely great!!! 👑👑😍
@@bestvocalsbyvocalists849 I know her cuz I'm a fan of her but I don't think that Lisa has the best belts although she's amazing and I think that she's better than Nippy technique wise. Lisa is the greatest female vocalist of all time imo.
@@tasosGRvocals Definitely 👑💖✨
@@bestvocalsbyvocalists849 notice how mikel said imo. aka, in my opinion.
@@mikel4531Whitney is a better midbelter and used way more impressive approach,but "technique" its Lisa,she produce better resonance than her,more consistent.She dominates upper belts and lower belts.
I agree,she's the greatest vocalist by a female artist along with Vivian Reed.
Céline Dion has the Best and MOST Beautiful Voice of all Times in Music!!!!!..... She's a Truly Vocalist and WORLD Music Diva!!!..... She's the Unique Queen of LasVegas!!!.... On the Ranked of Vocal Trinity for me Is on the #2.... Whitney at #1, Céline at #2, Mariah at #3.... This Is my Opinioni!!!
And it's respected!!! Thank you for watching!! 🥰😍
Queen of Love Songs
Queen of Ballads
Divine Powerhouse
Mariah is always so gorgeous, even if she couldn't sing or write songs she still would've been world famous based on looks alone, God was inspired when He created her.
She was gorgeous indeed, she could have been a model ❤️👑
@@tasosGRvocals great video btw, those Whitney C#5 and Eb5 notes sent chills down my spine. May she rest in peace!
@@rbmaia5 Thank you so much!! Yeah, these notes were perfect 💯
vocality, agility and resonant its Celine Dion up to this years your Whitney dies at early she proved herself when shes still alive while Mariah cant belt anymore seeing her performances today its eeriee while Celine doing great 😘❤️
Karma 😌
Honey Whitney smoked Celine Dion to this day 😂😂
@@NkazimuloNxumalo-p9x smoke? Celine voice is much more powerful and piercing 💯
Amazing! My ears have been blessed :)
Awe thank you so much for watching!! 🥰😍💞
These are the three greatest female voices and these three also has a lot of the most toxic fans who like to compare them for each other. Lets all just be thankful they graced the music industry and brought good music and influenced a lot of artists.
I agree, let's appreciate them, they are all among the greatest!!
Most of the toxicity comes from lambs... look at how they swarm every comment that doesn't put Mariah at #1 💀
@@kim-sunwooi agree
C5 tie
C#5 Mariah
D5 Whitney and Celine
Eb5 tie
E5 Whitney and Mariah
F5 Mariah
F#5 Celine and Mariah
G5 tie they slayed
⭐🥰😍❤️
Mariah is the best and Greatest singer of all time! The queen of all singers!
🥰😍❤️👑
You chose the best notes well done 🥰
Thank you very much!! 💖🥰
Not the best,they all have better belts especially Whitney.
@@bestvocalsbyvocalists849 which notes would u pick for whitney lol
@@Xelth4 F#5 for you give good love,G5 from Saving all My love,I think,Love will save the day F5s are better than this F5 of Whitney.
@@bestvocalsbyvocalists849 japan saving all my love for you 1991? And i dont know about the f#5 u give good love, it may be better technically but her tone back then was so thin compared to 90's Whitney and especially 94's whitney tone that we all love. Personally I would pick f#5 yokohama 1991 note
Mariah the best
❤️😍🥰⭐👑
0:41 The people felt that resonance!
Definitely ❤
Mariah 👑
🥰❤️👑
For me, celine and Whitney carries an extraordinary aura that nobody can ever get like words can't describe it, but mariah is good too
I agree tbh 🥰
Mariah' voice ia has something special i cant describe
Whitney's Eb5 is the most iconic sustain note of all time.
Mariah's phrasing G5 in Hero is the most perfect G5 ever of all time.
Celine Dion's D5 is super balanced, the D5 master reigner.
🥰😍❤️👑
Celine’s G5 placement is way more pleasing to the ear
@@danielbenitez6985DEFINITELY not💀. If anything hers was very thin and it wasnt even supported.
@@angelxemotions9102 thin? Celine's vocal cord is much thicker than Mariah. If you're talking about F#5 in divas live yes they are thin. But not her G5. Aretha tried to follow but Celine's F5 and G5 are more powerful.
@@angelxemotions9102 mariahs g5 was definitely thin. even her eb5 was thin😭
They're all so good, I can't decide
They are all amazing!!! 👑🥰
1:40 LMAO 😂
Where was it funny 🤔
@@tasosGRvocals The kid was like: 😳"mama get me outta here"... 🤣🤣
@@royalpanther6391 Ooooh xD He definitely wasn't aware of what was going on 😅
😂😂@@tasosGRvocals
All three sounded great!
The three standards of a golden voice!! ❤️
C5 - Whitney
C#5 - Mariah
D5 - Celine
Eb5 - Whitney
E5 - Mariah
F5 - Celine/Mariah
F#5 - Mariah
G5 - Mariah
Vocal trinity forever 💕
🥰🥰
Whitney's phrased E5s 🧎♂️. So effortless.
My favourite E5 of hers!! 🥰❤️
@@tasosGRvocals you should watch He,I believe..she sustained resonant E5s
@@bestvocalsbyvocalists849 Do you mean her known sustained E5s that are used in every single video? I didn't want to use those but I know them and tbh I don't particularly like them xD
@@bestvocalsbyvocalists849 i prefer the he, i believe eb5 belts. I dont like the E5 belts of this song as much
According to clips on this video:
C - tie
C♯ - tie
D - Celine
E♭ - Whitney
E - Whitney
F - Whitney
F♯ - Mariah (Whitney's was a half step lower)
G - Whitney (there's a debate whether the key was a major C or B, but if it was a major C, then it's Whitney - if not, it's a toss up between Celine and Mariah)
Nice choices!!! ☺️☺️
celine's C5 wins at 0:26. I would prefer another C5 from Whitney, this is not as impressive as many other C5 notes from her. Mariah's C5 is truly one of her best if not her best live C5. Whitney's G5 wins everyone. And I don't know if it's a G5 though or F#5. Cause if it's a G5, this means she raised saving all my love for you song TWO semitones which is very unlikely, she raised it one semitone in some cases like 1985 letterman but never two semitones
Celine all the way
Celine ❤❤❤
Queeeeeen 👑👑👑
Now does Anna Vissi have any note from a C5-E5 that compares to their performances of those same notes?
Yes I know Anna Vissi is a mezzo-soprano and the Vocal Trinity consists of sopranos, but just for the fun of it how do Anna Vissi's belts/mixes compare from a C5 to an E5?
@@mps4447 Oh well she certainly does! She has a much lower voice, but in the C5-D5 area she has had note attempts that could give these ladies a run for their money. Especially with C5s! Above D5 though the difference is vast.
✌️☝️🙏Objective vocal analysis🙏☝️✌️
C5 - Celine and Mariah (both amazing tone, resonance and power, Celine’s vibrato was fantastic and Mariah’s resonance was surreal!)
C#5 - all three legends were equally great! Point each!
D5 - Celine (the most powerful and opened vocal, D5 is just her note)
Eb5 - all three were phenomenal. Whitney’s gorgeous vibrato, Celine’s incredible power snd Mariah’s unreal ease and flexibility! Well deserved point each!
E5 - Whitney (amazing full and rich sound, well supported)
F5 - Whitney (same reason)
F#5 - Mariah (the healthiest technique, Whitney was also amazing but Mariah was more free and relaxed in these upper area)
G5 - Whitney and Mariah (both technically effortless, well supported and free)
Thank you for watching! 🥰
Mariah's G5 has tension but in moderation,so I would say it's just passable support but not true support.
@@bestvocalsbyvocalists849 I don’t hear any tension on Mariah’s G5. If there’s any possible tension, i’m 100% sure it’s not more than on Whitney’s G5😉
@@mariahcareydaydreamera2526 Whitney's G5 is an F#5 and its not tensed its natural tension,the other tension is obstructive tension which is the bad tension..Name what obstructive tension did Whitney have there?its just chestier and fuller,with that kind if density and volume.She managed to do that so sure call her effortless heavy approach as tensed compared to neutral and curbed approach.
@No One It is because of the brightness and lightness(weight)of her belt,it has lesser weight,she was using neutral/balance approach.
C5 - D5 mariah carey is effortless and celine has the best vocal
Eb5 Whitney wow, the power of celine Dion wow
E5 : they all are effortless
F5 : they all mastered it
F#5 : Mariah Carey and Whitney the vowel wow celine Dion what a powerful voice
G5 : what a perfect and powerful mix voice
@@GlorieuxMantuidi 👑👑👑
Mariah's voice is more pleasant to ears. Superb.
☺️☺️
too good wish i could sing so free like that
They're legends for a reason!! 👑
Mariah fan btw
C5- tie (celine's was held longer but mariahs was more resonant i cant choose)
C#5- mariah
D5- celine
Eb5- whitney (though celine's resonance and mariah's tone were amazing)
E5- tie (mariah, whitney)
F5- mariah
F#5- tie (mariah, celine)
G5- tie (ALL OF THEM)
Theyre all so amazing its crazy they were all even alive at the same time, we dont get good singers like them everyday.
There won't be another trinity!! 👑
@@tasosGRvocals of course not, theres so no one who can parallel them
All three of those ladies are excellent at the craft of singing. Yet, for me, Whitney stands out as the brightest in the bunch. Her voice was so amazing!
Queen Whitney 👑👑
Uma mezzo soprano e duas sopranos. Essa trindade deveria ter feito um CD juntas. Maravilhosas
They're all sopranos
@nathanieljohnson5908 Mariah is a mezzo soprano, she already said that. You can believe it seeing how her voice goes deep with facility, and hit notes a little lower than the other 2
@@af12034 she didnt say she is mezzo. She told she is contralto but I dont believe this. For me, she is soprano
@marcello759 Take in notes the talking voice. Her voice is deep. I'd say she's a contralto/mezzo with high range potential, just as Celine is a soprano with low range potential
For me, vocal classification doesn't matter. She is an excellent singer@dominicwileman
3 great lyric sopranos!!
👑👑👑
Céline forever and always
Our Queen!!! 👑👑👑
Whitney’s Voice
Celine’s Live Performing Skills
Mariah’s songwriting
Put these three qualities together and you get the perfect Main Pop Girl (MPG) this world has ever seen.
Omg my favourites
My favourites too!! ☺️😍
I remember u. You were the one who promoted this channel to Adam who has " justthevoice" channel and he reacted to one of this person's videos!
@@Xelth4 Yes! I sure am. I love promoting Greek singers to RUclipsrs 😀
I love all of them❤There's no need to compare or to hate.
Exactly!! They're all brilliant!! ❤️
and the only one who is still slaying it is miss Céline Dion
That's a very true fact indeed, I can't wait for her return 🥰🥰🥰
Celine does still sound really good. If you’d like to check out Mariah still killing it live I’d look at her 2019 vocals of You Don’t Know What To Do / Smotions medley, or Hero in 2019/2020 live. A lot of her agility and vibrato is still there when she’s a rested, her upper register and breath control is just not there as before.
Not just vocal but also sales and networth
Subjective . Celine focused on her high mixed belts . But her overall tone , nasality and super heady high mixed voice doesnt sit well with me .
Also Mariah has nodules and Celine doesnt .
I much prefer Mariah’s strong mid resonant belts and whistles and tone than showing off super heady nasal high notes lol .
I hope you didnt forget Whitney has passed away .
@@hyun808 You clearly haven't listened to Céline then. Her lows, C#5s, ofc upper belts, headvoice etc are superior to Mariah even today. Mariah's voice has a lot of constriction save for a few lucky moments. Céline's nasality isn't a problem as she can control it well. It's her accent after all. And she has hit grounded and free c#5s TODAY, something Mariah can't do. Ofc she has her whistle, but she is barely ever resonant. Bless her - her nodules are to blame.
3:46 Mariah was playing the piano for Whitney. haha
Loool the hair 😂
Queen Whitney ❤
Goddess 👑👑
Lightning striking- all three in the same era! We had it good!
🥰👑😊
I don't like singer oversing (like Xtina, Jennifer Hudson, Beyonce...with all the " yeah yeah yeah~~~") but when Whitney did it, it sound amazing. her voice just nice to listen for most ppl in general.
Her tone was absolutely fantastic 💞🥰
Shirley Bassey, Mariah Carey Joan Jett and Donna Summer are my favorite ones.
Live I prefer Shirley and Donna, studio I prefer the other two.
I see!! Great choices, though we differ a bit in taste 😛
This is great vocal video. You didn't use no lip sync note by Celine or Mariah. Whitney rarely lipped, so yeah. I also would've used Mariah's F5's from SNL & Grammy's 92 tho.
Thank you!! Yes I wanted to use just live and not dubbed notes!!
Can we get a video showcasing the different tonal qualities of their voices?
For F#5 I feel like for Whitney you could’ve used her F#5 in YGGL (London 1986) and for Mariah, if it’s over at the Grammys of course!!
I tried not to use the single most used clip for each note of theirs, but still use popular clips, that's why I didn't use for example the C5s from It's All Coming Back to me now, or the Imagine D5, or the All By Myself Eb5, or the Love Can move mountains F5s from Celine, the America the beautiful C5, the underneath the stars D5, the if it's over E5 and F#5s for Mariah, or the All at once C5, the D5s where she yells "Love", the sustained E5s that I don't remember which song they are from, or the you give good love F#5 for Whitney!!
I still used very popular clips though, I chose my favourite note of every one and used it!!
I miss these types of epic vocalists
@@denapitter38 Ah me too, staggering powerful vocalists that are immensely popular don't happen these days 🥲
It’ll always be Whitney for me. Incredible technique, great interpretation, emotive, powerful, love most of her catalog. Celine and Mariah are talented, but they don’t do it for me like Whitney does.
Everyone has his own taste!! I adore Whitney as well!! 🥰😍
My Opinion:
C5 - Celine
C#5 - Mariah
D5 - Whitney
Eb5 - Whitney & Celine
E5 - Celine
F5 - Mariah
F#5 - Whitney
G5 - Whitney & Celine
Great choices!! 😍😍
C5 : Celine ( THE PIERCING RESONANCE IM DYING OMG )
C#5 : Whitney ( she is incredible at c#5 notes )
D5 : Celine ( It's her note and that's enough as an argument lol )
Eb5 : Whitney ( best Eb5 ever )
E5 : Whitney ( the core and the tonal quality that remains perfect and untouched-unchanged even with phrased belts 😍 )
F5 : Whitney ( the core up there )
F#5 : Mariah ( her note but Whitney's was so great too and Celine's, so hard to choose, but if it was " if it's over " F#5 i would go with Mariah without second thought, but im glad u didnt include in the video the same overused note )
G5 : Whitney ( core and chest projection up there, tone still remains and anyone can say it's Whitney's note, voice doesnt become thin compared to most female singers' G5 notes )
Great choices!! 🥰😍❤️
I prefer Whitney's F#5 than Mariah's.I prefer Celine's G5 over Whitney,Whitney did not touch G5,its a F#5
@@bestvocalsbyvocalists849 Tuner shown G5 for Whitney
@@bestvocalsbyvocalists849 i have to give something to Mariah too lol. Mariah is only with one note left
@@tasosGRvocals I checked mine too with tuners they're F#5
In terms of tone for me:
C5 - Mariah
C#5 - Whitney
D5 - Celine, maybe Mariah
Eb5 - Whitney, maybe Celine
E5 - Mariah, maybe Whitney
F5 - maybe Whitney and Celine
F#5 - Mariah
G5 - Mariah and Celine
Nice choices!! 🥰
if we have to compare the trinity .at .20 years . young; I think celine will have the one with the most piercing voice on the notes above E5 at 20 years old then houston and at the end carrey
at 20 year (((( I don't speak at 25 and 30 be careful )))))))
for the average middle notes........ I think that houston will be the most powerful and the strongest then............ between celiine and carrey (at 20 years) I think that celine will still have this piercing voice in addition which makes a difference. she sings with her mask may be????
for the bass low notes, carrey is superb .... then houston and at the end dion .
.low notes I think it is linked to this fine and clear voice of celine, it lacks weight despite supporting more than the other 2
the head voice, houston the queen then dion
I not necessarily agree with everything but thank you very much for watching and commenting your thoughts 😍🥰💖❤️
Celine and Mariah C5 still ringing in my ears LOL.damn girls !
@@HoangGracy they were soo good!! 👑💯
Mariah songbird Carey >>>>>>>>>
💞🥰😍
I love all three of them. Celine is number one ❤
For me too!! 👑👑👑