Best Catfish Bait Challenge! (Hotdogs VS Dough Bait!)

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 26 окт 2019
  • We decided to see if Hotdogs are better bait than the Catfish Dough bait that you can buy at Walmart.
    What do you think is the better catfish bait?
    If you like my content and would like to help out, you can buy me a coffee here - www.buymeacoffee.com/fxY9qwJER
    Please Subscribe and Ring that Bell!
    Follow me on Instagram and Facebook - @JosephHarrickFishing

Комментарии • 135

  • @DMVWhiskerKing
    @DMVWhiskerKing 4 года назад +14

    Before this starts I'm going for hotdogs but should of bought cheese hotdogs . That doughbait smells like poop and looks like it too . And for both I use a bait needle and put them on treble hooks 😉🤙 The power baits work nicely too but are very strong smelling . And yes catfish will eat corn no problem just like carp but mostly channels or bullheads on corn. Dude when you opened the poop baits I just started laughing when you said smells like shit I'm over here going told you so lmao 🤣👌Man that first one dang that hook almost got him . And than one on the power bait they do work 😉🤙 the next he got was on a hotdog right so 2 hotdog and one power bait. Double up you got a hotdog cat ☺️🤙 and he got one on oh wait both rods of his . Channels are feeding. And bam your hooked on the hotdog again . He surely was bleeding a bit . Normally if you dip them in the water and pull them back out the blood stops. You got another dog cat lol beef and cheesedogs are best but they eat all hotdogs . And ya hooked on the doughbait 😉👌 Yeah the poop bait sucks lol hotdogs with the Win like I figured . And yes the power bait works that poop magic bait does suck badly . Great episode. Is there a river with Flats and Blue cats near you ? Love to see you pull a 50 + cat out the water 😎👍👍

    • @5050fishing
      @5050fishing  4 года назад +2

      Haha yea screw that shit bait lol! I have a few legit Blue catfish trips coming up! Maybe the 50 plus will happen. 🤘

    • @DMVWhiskerKing
      @DMVWhiskerKing 4 года назад +2

      @@5050fishing I wish you luck its feeding time for them blue before winter comes . Get on them brother . Be watching out 😎👍 Have a great night .

    • @5050fishing
      @5050fishing  4 года назад +1

      Thanks bro, You too!

  • @bigdaddy_d381
    @bigdaddy_d381 4 года назад +9

    Just wait till he smells it 😂

  • @connorroberts1884
    @connorroberts1884 3 года назад +11

    i literally caught 8 catfish today on that cheap magic bait. I guess it's pretty subjective, depending on where you are and how you're fishing

    • @5050fishing
      @5050fishing  3 года назад +2

      You would have caught 80 with hotdogs 😂

    • @connorroberts1884
      @connorroberts1884 3 года назад

      @@5050fishing interestingly enough, I went to the exact same spot with hotdogs yesterday and only got like 2 bites all day. it's definitely subjective, like it depends on where you are, water clarity, etc. but the magic bait definitely did better than hotdogs at my location. hotdogs did stay on the hook a little better though

    • @crimsontide1980
      @crimsontide1980 Год назад

      I'll be honest, I've never used hotdogs before lol. But you can probably guess what I'll be using next time I go. I've used chicken livers, cut bait, large minnows, goldfish, even a few different varieties of this stink bait, even used nightcrawlers, surprisingly those have worked well a few times when nothing else worked. Definitely gotta try hotdogs.

    • @jakesens5999
      @jakesens5999 Год назад

      Yeah great Scott's a good dough bait i use it with a glow tip bobber at night and as soon as it hits the water im on, liver and cheese, and whopper shad are the best in my opinion

  • @fishingwithvin
    @fishingwithvin 4 года назад +11

    I've caught some of my best channels on cut bait fresher the better but for big flathead's live three to four inch bluegills.
    This year was super tough for them where I live so midsummer I started Bass fishing again.

    • @5050fishing
      @5050fishing  4 года назад

      I like cut shad and live suckers

  • @purpleraine33844
    @purpleraine33844 2 года назад +10

    I've never caught a catfish on Corn either Mate but I heard it's great for Carp

  • @kiteman357
    @kiteman357 3 года назад +4

    Circle hooks are the way to go for cats. They literally hook themselves. Nice side by side. I use hot dogs and corn and boilies on a hair rig with circle hooks.

  • @sebastiancarlson1838
    @sebastiancarlson1838 2 года назад +3

    Just caught 3 catfish today using hotdogs,minced garlic,garlic powder,chicken breast and 3 packets of grape kool-aid

  • @MagnusSentDooM
    @MagnusSentDooM 2 года назад +3

    Those stink baits are great for clearing your crowded fishing spots......guy came next to me and did that(luckily I was leaving anyways 😂) but I knew what he was up to. He kept the bait open, added water, sat next to me and kept mixing it for like 10 minutes.

  • @PHFishingBiking
    @PHFishingBiking 4 года назад +10

    👍 Yea that stuff stinks... try cutting up 1 inch cubes of beef heart next time!

    • @5050fishing
      @5050fishing  4 года назад +1

      I might try that. The next vid like this might be livers vs hotdogs.

  • @WesleyAPEX
    @WesleyAPEX 4 года назад +14

    Those catfish are skinny. You should put some clams and snails in the pond to fatten them up. They clearly aren’t getting enough forage.

    • @5050fishing
      @5050fishing  4 года назад +2

      Yea it’s not our pond but we were talking about that.

  • @nanditapalit4768
    @nanditapalit4768 3 года назад

    how to purchase online this fishing product, link plz.

  • @lantzwilliams243
    @lantzwilliams243 3 года назад

    What setup yall use?

  • @MIKEDOG620
    @MIKEDOG620 4 года назад +3

    You don't need a treble hook. The hot dogs will stay on a single barb. I do it all the time and just had to adjust to a smoother cast.

  • @trevorward1762
    @trevorward1762 2 года назад

    This is aweaome man

  • @TheLifeOfMattJackson
    @TheLifeOfMattJackson 4 года назад +6

    You already know about the dogs bro..... No contest at all!

  • @llcantujr
    @llcantujr 3 года назад +3

    I used hotdogs for years. Kids are able to hook their hotdog bait easier than worms or dough bait. The cheaper the hotdogs the better. Even better if you leave the hotdogs out overnight. Nice and stinky and oily to leave a trail in the water.

    • @fattd9725
      @fattd9725 Год назад

      I microwave it makes it lil more sturdy

  • @Bash-hw3ox
    @Bash-hw3ox 2 года назад +5

    Imma say this right now, I've been doing really well with Magic Bait liver and cheese balls. Stays on the hook alright could be better but the smell is god awful and they love it. If there's channel catfish where your fishing they should bite on it.

    • @jakesens5999
      @jakesens5999 Год назад

      Liver and cheese is great i suggest you try whopper shad works just the same but doesn't smell as bad

  • @miguelbarrero5572
    @miguelbarrero5572 3 года назад

    How do you bait a hotdog on a treble hook? Do you cut 3 pieces and cover each point? Or you cover 2 and leave one exposed? I always use a single hook and never a treble hook, can you please explain how you do it?

    • @5050fishing
      @5050fishing  3 года назад

      I just push the eye of the treble up through the bottom of the hotdog

    • @miguelbarrero5572
      @miguelbarrero5572 3 года назад

      @@5050fishing thank you, I'll try that 😀

  • @naminaoberhausen2131
    @naminaoberhausen2131 11 месяцев назад +1

    Nice fish you caught. I have never used the liver and cheese before but I have used magic baits shrimp and chicken blood. It works well. I've used hot dogs before. I like it better than magic bait. It's caught more fish on hot dogs than magic bait. Yesterday I was fishing with hot dogs and caught two fish off of the hot dogs. From Jordan

  • @strangescottvoiceacting5351
    @strangescottvoiceacting5351 3 месяца назад

    At first I was surprised that hot dogs make such a good bait for catfish, but then I remembered my dad and I used to do trot-line fishing, and he would put pieces of liver on his hooks. That's how we caught a 20lb flathead catfish.

  • @MegaNafo
    @MegaNafo 4 года назад +17

    I wish you make this video a few years ego , I bought that crap and didn't catch even 1 catfish so far , thanks

    • @5050fishing
      @5050fishing  4 года назад +3

      Haha yea man it seems like complete junk lol

  • @trevorvechinski2071
    @trevorvechinski2071 4 года назад +2

    I used dough which was chicken liver and it smelled but it still works

  • @robertlear2735
    @robertlear2735 3 года назад +4

    I have caught a lot of fish on Magic Bait - chicken live flavor or shad flavor

    • @5050fishing
      @5050fishing  3 года назад

      I will have to give them another try

  • @bankfishingislife5484
    @bankfishingislife5484 10 месяцев назад

    i was thinking of trying hot dogs on my trotlines lol. wonder how good they would do for less then 20 dollars i can bait 500 hooks. if i drive to dam and get bait its like 10 in gas and like 2 hours fishing so hot dogs would be a little cheaper overall. just not sure if they catch as good as fresh skipjack.

  • @crimsontide1980
    @crimsontide1980 Год назад +1

    Damn I need to come out to yalls spot to catfish, they're literally jumping out the lake, had 3 fish hooked at the same time. I got a couple good spots but I'm not getting this much action lol. Soon as you said you were stepping in cow shit I knew you had a good spot

  • @kirk.818
    @kirk.818 3 года назад +1

    If you don’t like treble hooks I use gamakatsu nautilus hooks or the tournament grade drop shot hooks

  • @mytechsarecool6001
    @mytechsarecool6001 4 года назад +7

    Hey Bro I tried using those it stinks but it actually got me a catfish Thxs for telling us about this and I just sub Edit: I used the dough bait

  • @ATOUTDOORS
    @ATOUTDOORS 4 года назад +2

    KILLER MAN, WONDER WHAT YA CATCH WITH SOME LEGIT CAT BAIT?

    • @5050fishing
      @5050fishing  4 года назад

      There are supposed to be some big ones in there.

  • @TripFishingMyLife
    @TripFishingMyLife 4 года назад

    Done.. Nice video

  • @boondockinron9263
    @boondockinron9263 3 года назад +2

    I use magic bait in California, Arizona and Nevada. It is great and catches plenty catfish
    The one I use is Crayfish with chicken blood. All the others do not work so well or not at all.
    Give it one more try with crayfish and chicken blood please. It may work for you. Nice video and keep your lines tight
    Old Man Ron
    Boondockin Ron

    • @5050fishing
      @5050fishing  3 года назад

      Thanks, I will have to give that a try.

    • @crimsontide1980
      @crimsontide1980 Год назад

      The chicken blood bait is money, it's the only one I'll use after trying the others. Liver and cheese works good too but chicken blood works great. I'll usually rig up 2 cat lines, one with chicken blood bait and the other I'll usually use cut bait or chicken livers, and I'll usually catch at least 5 or 6.

  • @WashedKevin
    @WashedKevin 4 года назад +1

    what do u use for recording?

  • @ShadyDisguise
    @ShadyDisguise 3 года назад +1

    7:50 I was expecting the fish to belly up lol

  • @phiology1983
    @phiology1983 4 года назад +6

    I use the stink dough as a lure. Hot dog marinated in asian fish sauce over night works everytime

    • @5050fishing
      @5050fishing  4 года назад +1

      How do you use it as a lure?

    • @phiology1983
      @phiology1983 4 года назад

      @@5050fishing I'm sorry I meant, using them to attract catfish. Like throwing those dough in the water around the pond or near your area, so those cats will start hunting for bait.

  • @jmurphy68463
    @jmurphy68463 4 года назад +3

    That doughball out fishes hotdogs 40 to 1 out here.

  • @manup8022
    @manup8022 3 года назад

    To be completely accurate catfish school up in one area. . Should’ve rotated the bates on the rod holder. See if the mr catfish would catch a fish where the hotdogs was and vice versa.

  • @overallguy8538
    @overallguy8538 4 года назад +3

    I nearly caught a 10lb+ catfish I was taking out the water snapped the line off of fresh cut bream head and hot dogs work like the smell of pizza at new york the catfish never get tired of them (did anyone get the joke? Lol) well thx on the review I was wondering if I should get some of the dough balls but I know now possible not I'm prob still gonna try them but thanks again merry christmas (if you celebrate) and have a good new year (2020)😊

  • @Ryotenian7826
    @Ryotenian7826 3 года назад +1

    Hey man, if it stinks, the catfish will love them

  • @natetucker386
    @natetucker386 3 года назад +2

    Best stink bait is probably chicken liver

  • @fortnitehub9239
    @fortnitehub9239 2 года назад +1

    I wish I could use hotdogs 😔 but every time I do the turtles get to them first

  • @tre8906
    @tre8906 2 месяца назад

    I love that magic bait chicken blood and liver works for me great

  • @fishingwithryanjabo2815
    @fishingwithryanjabo2815 4 года назад +3

    You should use circle hooks instead of trebles

    • @5050fishing
      @5050fishing  4 года назад

      Ryan Jablonowski we tried. Circles wouldn’t keep the hotdogs on. I always use circles when on the rivers and lakes when I’m using Cutbait.

    • @fishingwithryanjabo2815
      @fishingwithryanjabo2815 4 года назад

      I fish with hot dogs pretty much every single day and I’ve also ran into that problem

  • @boredyoutuber420
    @boredyoutuber420 2 года назад

    Lmao 😂 idc what hooks I got I’m going fishing ✌️

  • @giantmidget8337
    @giantmidget8337 4 года назад +1

    Y'all should test hotdogs against livers.

    • @5050fishing
      @5050fishing  4 года назад +1

      Been thinking about doing that

  • @markhannan2569
    @markhannan2569 3 года назад

    I have the magic bait chicken liver and chicken blood dough bait and it smells like rotten fish and dog food a little but it works

  • @odd_el_toxico_g-coin_logis8474
    @odd_el_toxico_g-coin_logis8474 3 года назад

    Never had any luck on those baits ever, I know they work, people catch fish all the time, but I just stick with love or dead animal baits.

    • @5050fishing
      @5050fishing  3 года назад

      Yea I don’t have much faith in them lol

  • @robertvarela7299
    @robertvarela7299 4 года назад

    That Walmart bait the night crawler one catches catfish quick

    • @5050fishing
      @5050fishing  4 года назад

      I will have to try it

    • @robertvarela7299
      @robertvarela7299 4 года назад +2

      @@5050fishing it's same makers of the bait in Walmart but the night crawler one it stinks bad smells like cat piss and mildew dead worms lol but works

  • @THEBLACKANARCHIST
    @THEBLACKANARCHIST 4 года назад

    Good

  • @LloydBlake89
    @LloydBlake89 4 года назад +1

    I catch fish on dough balls and I don’t use treble hooks

  • @billyshedd9969
    @billyshedd9969 2 года назад +1

    I’ve caught a 21 pound catfish on power bait

  • @asherbumguardner9776
    @asherbumguardner9776 3 года назад +3

    I have caught my personal record for catfish and any fish with magic bait

  • @swaybelly3212
    @swaybelly3212 Год назад

    You had 2 poles baited with hot dogs, but only 1 pole each baited with the other baits, in a pond that has basically been baited with hot dogs in the past.... not really fair.

  • @Jjason601
    @Jjason601 Год назад

    👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻

  • @LloydBlake89
    @LloydBlake89 3 года назад

    Ive caught one catfish with the dough

  • @iloveadventuretime1
    @iloveadventuretime1 2 года назад

    Honestly I've had my best luck with worms and cheese dip bait. Like the shit you get in that bucket

  • @perrybaden1991
    @perrybaden1991 2 года назад +1

    I try both of them hot dog work the best with red Kool-Aid but the dough bait naw 👎

  • @michaelcrawford4207
    @michaelcrawford4207 2 года назад

    Have you ever used Hot Tamales candy?

  • @nope4673
    @nope4673 3 года назад

    Actually meet me is the best way to catch catfish 😜

  • @boredyoutuber420
    @boredyoutuber420 2 года назад

    It says rite there liver and cheese

  • @boredyoutuber420
    @boredyoutuber420 2 года назад

    Should I get the hotdogs with cheese ?

  • @boomersooner3187
    @boomersooner3187 Год назад +2

    The magic bait only works for me in little sewage streams, but in a lake I don’t even get a bite on it, I usually just use shrimp and worms tho

  • @michaelwolf71
    @michaelwolf71 3 года назад

    I heard that the hotdogs should be some what rotten

  • @jerseycowboy1
    @jerseycowboy1 3 года назад

    Better to test in the lake enivorment not a pond

  • @bowfishingfalcon1162
    @bowfishingfalcon1162 3 года назад

    Those catfish are starving

  • @achm010
    @achm010 4 года назад +2

    really your actually not useing the way i use it i put worms+dough+hotdogs+very old food = pretty good sized catfish on the other end of the line

    • @5050fishing
      @5050fishing  4 года назад

      I will have to give it a try

  • @NCR_Ranger115
    @NCR_Ranger115 3 года назад +1

    Bro fishing with glizzys 😳

    • @5050fishing
      @5050fishing  3 года назад +1

      Catching some Glizzy Goblers

  • @justamanandhisvan
    @justamanandhisvan 2 года назад

    Just caught a 22 pound 3ft and a 18pound 2.5ft blue cat on that magic bait. It'smells like literal shit. Like liquid beer shits and dog food. It works tho

  • @nickespinoza4362
    @nickespinoza4362 3 года назад

    Channel Catfish

  • @stevevasquez2080
    @stevevasquez2080 4 года назад

    Glizzy gobla

  • @billyshedd9969
    @billyshedd9969 2 года назад

    It is power bait

  • @Yelladog78
    @Yelladog78 2 года назад +1

    An old woman I know who catches a lot of catfish uses hotdogs but cuts panty hose and puts them inside it and she does good, no monsters but consistent with catching fish

  • @scottm2244
    @scottm2244 2 года назад

    Bro you should never use treble hooks on fish your going to release come on man. Great video though.

  • @joelwcarter8058
    @joelwcarter8058 2 месяца назад

    be more careful when releasing fish

  • @joelwcarter8058
    @joelwcarter8058 2 месяца назад

    use chicken liver next time

  • @frefmcgwn
    @frefmcgwn 2 года назад

    chicken

  • @DanielHebert-kk5sc
    @DanielHebert-kk5sc 6 дней назад

    Stink bait like Charlie’s is the way to go. Magicbait is garbage

  • @johnhammondhammond1657
    @johnhammondhammond1657 4 года назад

    Bro you look just like my brother adam it's really weird. And he even Has tattoos to lol.

    • @5050fishing
      @5050fishing  4 года назад

      Or does he look like me....? 😳

  • @DanielSmith-tt6zw
    @DanielSmith-tt6zw 2 года назад +1

    Way too much talking about non sense get with the program

    • @5050fishing
      @5050fishing  2 года назад

      Well it’s my program so I can talk about whatever I want…. 🤷🏻‍♂️

  • @crappiebucks4125
    @crappiebucks4125 4 года назад

    Pretty boring

    • @5050fishing
      @5050fishing  4 года назад +1

      👀

    • @cuzican8675
      @cuzican8675 4 года назад +2

      Crappie Bucks then watch something else Tard 😂 acting’s like he made yiu watch it