I remember one incident from my college (IIT BHU). One of the professors tried doing something wonderful, by starting open book exams and focussing on the application part of the course, rather than simple theory. With the help of another young professor, he added many courses that are more relevant to the current day. Even though they were offered as an elective subject, many students appreciated his effort for actually caring about their career. However, he was heavily criticized by the administration to the extent that he left within 3 years of his tenure. He was very helpful even after he left the college, and I am very grateful to have him as one of my professors.
I am currently studying in a Canadian Institute and I had completed my bachelor's from one of the top commerce college in my city.. In just one semester I learned what I didn't learn in three years of my bachelor's. Our education system needs to be reformed and we need to vote right people.
Prajakta education system is better there because they don't have issues like reservation and they have surrendered to Christianity so no drain of brain in that country because let it grow independently. Our Very Big Brain Scientists are killed unanimously and we can't do anything. So your parents should have votted for the right government.
My elder brother was doing his Phd in Mathematics at Jadavpur University but he left the university because of the professor under whom he was doing a reserch. My brother did most of the paper work and solved many formula but his profesor took all the credit😭. Didn't even print his name.
@@kaishk1091 still better than any other college in terms of return of investment. Btw a student got placed in Google in Singapore for 1.1Cr/annum from JU. Not any IIT/NIT/IIIT/other private colleges. Out of 80 scientists selected for workshop in Stanford, 42 were from West Bengal and 20 were from JU(others were from Calcutta University, Scottiish Church, Presidency University etc)..remaining 38 were from other states.
I am also a professor in a well known university in Asia . I agree with your video . I observe that in university 99% students only want syllabus .....they don't want intellectual approach.....They don't like discussion on national & international issues . They are not aware about social issues. But I should appreciate your homework Good luck .....
The needs and the pressure on a student are enormously different here. The financial, home, parental setup is completely different to the rest of the world. Couple that with the poor quality and just general poverty in the education sector, and that's what you get. A student who does the learning for the heck of it, and tries to get out of here as fast as he can.
because some people & politicians don't respect them, politicians' only dream is to divide Hindu Muslims..slowly many INDIANS will leave INDIA if this goes on. INDIA ko sirf history books mein freedom mila hain but in reality it's a big JOKE
jitne bhi iitians hote h ya toh coaching krte h ya job krte h videsh mein jake ya mit mein professor ban jate h ...muzhe samjh ni aya arvind kejriwal yaha reh kese rhe h politics jaha modi ji ke toxic andhbhakt h
Like it goes, if u are a genius in india then you have 2 choices: • live in this country trying to reform things that refuse to be reformed. U lose everything in course and die penniless. • leave this country and go to a country that values you. You will not change india but get everything you ever deserved: respect,money, recognition and most of all value. There are some exceptions, but the choice is obvious for most.
@@mukundkushwaha8213 when the time comes, yes, kyonki ye desh bahut pyaara hai mujhe aur mai inn politics aur 50 saal purane caste, religion waale same agendas ke saamne chunte hue nahi dekh skta. Kahin se koi hope nahi dikhti, bas development ke naam pe jahan government ka sole motive hona chahiye ki saare youth ki energy channelise krke desh ke liye use kro, taaki engineering graduates ko 9000 rupay mahine ki naukri na krni pde, woh bas naye pul, murti, pichli sarkar aur obselete schemes jinse 4 logon ko fayda hua Gina dete hai.arre kisaanon ke account mein paise mat daalo, aur IITs aur nits banao, jahan wo apne bacche ko padhwa sake, taaki unka ladka parivaar aur desh, dono ki takdeer badal de.
When a indian see a successful indian in west : proud to be a indian 🇮🇳 Only time when we feel patriotic is when someone achieve something their own but can't realise why he/she are not archiving the same level of success here
@@musicstudy7610 commi and Marxism is the real reason for this They go to west which is capitalistic And indians hate capitalistic We have a culturally right wing government but this stupid government is not economically right
I’m a physics student with an immense love for the subject. I asked my teacher how can I get into research, he tells me I have to do phd but even after that, It’s not sure if I’ll get a chance to do research. I have to get into top colleges to get into research or else I’ll end up being a lecturer. Even if I get into research, I will face alot of troubles because our country does not have even the most basic but important equipments required to carry the research. This made me change my decision and now I’m having to change my career path even though I love physics. I will still keep myself updated regarding this subject but I cannot choose this as my career as it won’t be as beneficial to me as compared to my input/hardwork. This is the reason why a lot of students leave our country or change their career and opt for something which gives more benefits to them.
@@jaymahakaal5354 cannot do that bro. Bahar ka degree lenge toh India me mostly uska use nhi hota ya fir usko utna importance dia nahi jata. Besides, I already talked about the equipments issue. So even if I try to research in India, I will face alot pf setbacks. Govt should invest more in our education and research facilities, only then normal people like us will get avenues to do something unique for our nation
@@noelsmaison685 if u can't do ur research here properly then go outside n learn..if possible come back n help the other students so they can learn too..this trick was used by Chattrapati Shivaji Maharaj against Portuguese so the people of Hinduvi Samrajya can learn how to build better n magnificent war ships to battle with invaders..🙏🙏🇮🇳🇮🇳
Me too. I left India, 8 yrs served as professor (Temp Post), still government did not created permanent post for that subject. My age is passed over to get government job. Politics, After I finished my Ph.D, I went to the same college to get hired for same subject, but the Principal told your education is not valid to teach the same subject. After his retirement I got the same job. Low salary, No salary for many months, No job grantee, Rarely get Exam duty to earn additional income. I am sorry, I miss teaching, now settled in USA, but I now my students are very good professor in the same college, and I am proud of them.
*Escape india. And enter a capitalist and meritorious society like the west where your caste doesn’t ensure your admission into college, promotion, govt job and insecurity of getting into jail from SC ST act.
@@MAC-vi7fy USA has reservations for Black's and Native Americans and India's reservation is nothing compared to USA but still USA is successful so stop blaming reservation blame the political party
When I reported my professors in my college, even my friends didn’t support me in the fear of losing degree. I passed with flying colours as I never worried about internal marks. But another fact is there were some professors who were silently supporting me. They never gave up on me. Throughout the course, I only mastered the way of clearing exams. Learnt nothing.
@@ARUNKUMAR-gh6zp kyunki sponsors se bohot paise milte hai aur ye sab reasearch karne me bohot mehnat lagta, aapke liye ye sponsor clips distracting ho skta hai , par bohot log ke kaam bhi aata hai. sabke perspective se socha karo, nahi pasand to hum log skip bhi kar skte wo clip.
Aslong as stupid politicians in India have upperhands in every thing including education bright people will leave I rememner thr wsy BJP brigade ie Amit Shah and Modi attacked Amartya Sen and Banerji .It is beyond belief.BJP will drive every body out There was no apology for saying Amartya Sen charging plane fare on govt account which was a lie
@@saipruthvi8535 nah just want to tell you that many students join IITs in a rat-race. So, how do you expect them to react ? Also, ghar ki murgi daal barabar. Atleast, IITs will give you hands-on knowledge on latest technology, latest syllabus, enough time to work on your side hussle and the best launchpad for your career in the country. Atleast, in IITs profs help you to connect to foreign universities. The only solution is resetting the education system and resetting the rat mindset.
@K nikhilesh Vaibhav Krupakar who will provide them good pay ? The corporates ? The sole purpose of corporates in India is do cost cutting by paying less to their employees. Only few corporates are exception.
Both for money, achievement and politics in research institute/university. Of course the other thing is funding. As an ex-student of a premium research institute, I can tell you that our educationist are egoist. Some of them cannot bear the shear politics of the university/research institute. Many wanted to live abroad and earn in dollar/pound/euro. It is also noted that most of the premium journal like Nature, Science etc are all Western Centrist. They have a huge bias for Western (Japanese included) researchers, it is very easy publish a paper in Nature if that was written by a premium institute from Europe or America. Same goes with the international prestigious awards. Lastly, because of funding. We need more funding for research, but that depends on the Economy. But again, we need our institutes more professional and capitalist. American universities use the capitalist model of research. There is a huge pressure on publishing papers on the professors. If they cannot meet enough they will be sacked. If this model is applied in Indian university, there will be more funding from both university and private companies. I please keep you eyes open of the leftist propaganda. Like the professors cannot do research as they wish, is a total bullshit. Many of them in institute, I have seen as idle in spite of having funding.
I am getting my PhD in the US now but I have completed my bachelor's and Master's from India. When I got my full scholarship offer from a US university, one of my father's friends (who was a professor at Rutgers university in the US but now has returned to India) told my parents, "If you love your son, advise him to stay in the US. There is no respect or tolerance for brilliant scholars in India. It's a country that runs on "Hard work, not Harvard" or "Jugaad is better than actual expertise" type mindset. No one appreciates merit here. Returning to India is the biggest regret of my life". And having lived, researched and taught here in the US for 4 years now, I fully agree with him. I wholeheartedly want to now apply for jobs as a professor here at some university after graduating. Studying and teaching in the US makes you truly happy from within. It helps you find meaning and purpose in what you do and how you live your life. India can never ever offer that level of professional satisfaction, happiness or level of respect.
@@sayanchatterjee355 They bring their IDEOLOGY with them, we don't want to create a TOXIC political environment here especially in educational institutes.
To be honest Indians have the capability to dominate the world, sadly most of the learned scholars/ intellectuals/ entrepreneurs are leaving India mainly because of pressures and circumstances created by Politics. God bless India
I am in Japan doing my civil engineering my friends are really good in discussions about future opportunities, I feel like I will become something here. And more importantly I get free animes to watch. 😁
I can proudly say I am studying in a college in a branch where the faculties themselves say "attendance leke kya karoge I will give you attendance but understand the topic clearly, padho, samjho nai samjh me aye to pucho". Where the HOD reiterates the basics of class 8 happily to the weakest students without making fun of them encouraging them to be better but not the best. Where homeworks don't exist. I like how they are trying to be the right in a country full of wrongs and somehow I ended up here.
If u are a fresher. It might happen to you. Generally teachers do it to freshers in the 1st semester. After that they will become attendance sucking creatures who don't wanna teach and will take leaves for stupid reasons. If not, you are in a really awesome college. Keep it up
In our country degrees are just suffixes, you don't get much knowledge in the college lectures. Professors are more adamant on making students attend 100 percent lectures rather than focusing on their teaching skills. There is little to no environment which promotes research in the country. I want to write research papers but I am only stuck in the assignments which require no thinking and just require copy pasting stuff from here and there. It's highly unfortunate for us to have such a weak education system where curiosity is killed.
I agree but partially true ,he here is speaking about the same problem about how we lack GOOD teachers bcuz the GOOD ones leave INDIA , in thier pursuit of knowledge which the GOVT. fails to provide here!
I have been living in US for 5 years now. My plan was to come back, work on my startup there, but instead, I am working on it in US. Every time I thought of coming back, I see all this crap and I am like, there's no way I am going back.
@@himanshutomar3330 That's right. We are not following any rules in India. Because it's not in our nature to follow rules. It's like in our DNA. In America, you see others following the rules, you feel good about it and you follow it yourself. America has it's own set of problems but most of them are first world country problems. It's a big upgrade.
@@himanshutomar3330 what rules? Government is shit at implementing rules. Traditional rules? No I'd rather not follow the "Indian culture" which is not even Indian.
@@stobit2519 Wow. You want govt to control your behaviour? Govt's job ends at controlling crime. It's not govt's job to tell you not to litter, tell you what you can and can't do. Do you want an authoritarian state?
You missed the whole point. Dedicated Professors don't care about pay. They will help create the infrastructure. The video brought out actual reasons why the Professors left.
@@highartalert6927 This is not any fairyland where u do good for someone selflessly so wake up from ur dreams and Bollywood Yeh duniya hai jo haath mei hai woh bhi cheenke kha jayegi So better care for urself cuz when u will be sitting like a begger no one is gonna help u Im only saying that sab apna apna dekho see where u, ur finances and ur life will grow Don't take these emotional drama created by politicians of any political party so seriously Sab ek jaise hi hai So run after ur own growth in all aspects And if ppl see growth in other countries they would go there Agar india mei kuch nhi rakha hai toh jayenge hi
per capita of india and uk is totally different while india has 3000 dollars per head income whereas uk has 45000 dollars per head but think about the slavery and destruction they caused. they are only rich because our ancestors blood and sweat. they provide money which they stole in terms of salary
@@aryabhandkar9148 bro everyone knows that they looted us ... But today it doesn't matter to anyone today....that is past.... Today they will see the overall growth of country.... Even according to me today we should concentrate on our conditions
@@shivang5138 it’s very easy said ,but u don’t know what is conditions or working tactics politics. Which at the end of day is frustrating On salary aiims doctor are getting same pay as we , but working environment and security is far Salary in private sector is far better in India But although work ethics tactics security is same there
@Sayan Gope no offence but money also matters in real life After a hectic duty , your innerself wants a warm nice meal from swiggy ,but when u you know it’s not gonna happen and u just cook ur Maggi and sleep .
@@shivang5138 so many government doctors live in the fear of getting beaten up by patients' family or being forced to pay hefty fees or serve for years in a remote village far from their home without basic healthcare facilities, it's not just about money.
@@joyrainbowdress yes u r right in pandemic there were so many cases that doctors are getting killed. I mean why? ppl should know their value and praise them instead of killing them 😔
Mr. Mangal sir, my father is a chemistry researcher and professor in US. Your point about the lack of funding and the lack of capability is very true. There is not equipment to do research like in US. When he was doing PhD, he had to ask someone to operate machines and do assays for him, even when he could learn to use equipment himself. The machines were scarce and there was no one there to fix them. If he wanted to run large experiments, he never got permission. And when permission isn’t received, research doesn’t occur, which is why drug research in India dramatically declined over the last 20 years. What the comments say about teaching is also true. He says that PhD students in India today write bogus thesis and still get degree, and don’t even have skills to succeed in field. He says that Indian PhD students are less skilled in research than US 3rd year BSc students. Even after postdoctoral studies, these students are far inferior to students with no PostDoc in the West.
Exactly, during my undergraduate at Canadian University, I worked with a post doctoral from IACS Kolkata. He mentioned universities in India don't even let their Masters students get hand on experience due to limited resources, and here I was 3rd year undergrad working on projects, attending symposiums and writing papers for publication. Brilliant guy, had passion for chemistry
I am seeing this with my own eyes.Two of my professors, are leaving in next 5 months, and both of them taught extremely good..and were excellent researchers
But there is a good thing. Experts like you read so much and understand things and then explain in simple words to us.. that is really helpful for us. a big thank you... bcoz you contribute to make this country more beautiful and developed.
3 bengalis in the intro- 1.Abhijit Banerjee 2.Ashok Sen 3. Amartya Sen - for the last 65 years he is living outside but still remains a Indian citizen. জয় হিন্দ। বন্দেমাতারাম।
@Shreya Chakraborty Still we are doing great. Check out the list of Shanti Swaroop Bhatnagar award.Our problem is - we do not want to recognize our heros.
I pursued my bachelor's from Delhi University and Masters from Delhi school of Economics. I have cleared JRF NET in 2020 June. Now I'm trying to get some scholarships so that I could go in some west country. Why? Because there is no opportunities, jobs or respect in this country.
That's why I think they say ki do your PhD in foreign countries even the central govt. recruits professors in iits or iims who studied from foreign universities
Indian politics is worst. Anpad log desh ko chalaenge toh ye hi haal hoga na. Yaha education toh sirf ratto aur exams me likho. Ab log berozgar nahi honge toh aur kya honge. Indian politics is all about religion, India-pakistan. They don't focus on important issues like increase in poverty, crimes, unemployment, pollution, population, sexual violence, corruption etc... 😖
let me tell u 1000cr funding announce hua a budget mai for startups... last 2 weeks mai 6-7 unicorns hui hai.... and logically population itna jada hai toh unemployment to rahaga hi and crimes kis country mai nahi hota .. hama every day US mai koi na koi open firing ki khabar aati hai.... Education sirf ratna sa milti toh loog IIT advance mai paas nahi ho pata , UPSC clear nahi kar pata .... STart yourself logically padho sab samaj ayaga....
@@explorer2.035 unemployment rate in India is 6.9% and in us it is 3.5%. For your kind information unemployment rate is not affected by population of the country it is simply the ratio of unemployed population upon total population.
@Shreya Chakraborty and yet people keep leaving India all the time irrespective of who is ruling. I guess the logic of correlating brain drain with fascism is illogical
After finishing my ms in us, i came back to india to start my own venture. 10 years later, i am now back in the us and hope to settle anywhere but home.
Every time i see your video i feel like i know nothing..My mind could never think this...Everything seems complex..Thank you for educating us Our youth need people like you..KEEP GOING
Truth is we live in a society where parents wants their child to be taught by a best teacher but neither students wants to be teacher nor parents supports their child to be teacher
I have a friend attending Ashoka and from his point of view, it is actually comparable to foreign universities. The curriculum is way better than what outdated garbage we study at engineering colleges
@@massive_d they do offer engineering courses as well don't they? And as far as I know they offer financial aid. You might want to double check that as I am not sure
@Youth India That isn't the point of innovation or research is it? The point is for you to get world class education that will propel you to create placements by yourself. Have you missed the entire point of the video lmao?
Most of the professors whom you have given as examples became professors AFTER they left India. And also not just professors, many engineers also leaves India after graduation. The CEOs and many engineers in senior positions of large tech companies in USA are also Indians.
Finally, HE MADE A VIDEO ON AN IMPORTANT TOPIC. (I DOESN'T MEAN THAT, HE DON'T MAKE VIDEO OF IMPORTANT TOPIC. EVERY TOPIC ON WHICH HEAD VIDEO ARE IMPORTANT) THANKS BRO! EDIT: HEY! YOU ARE BECOMING MORE FREQUENT THAN EVER. IT'S NICE. I LOVE TO WATCH & ENJOY YOUR VIDEO.
Educated brain wants to achieve best what it deserves... Many of my friends have a startup with good turnover better than a google selected btech...but headlines still highlight"google ne diya 1 crore ka package".
@@LokeshKumar-yd3qk lmao the package is not fake. Just the cost of living is higher there so it won’t make much difference if your earn 1.5 CRORES there, it’s the same as earning 20-25 lakhs here.
My School....had extremely, absolutely epic teachers!! When we were in class 8, Physics teacher, shows up to demonstrate cosmic rays, and radio communication systems. If ny one asked about the syllabus, he would say, "to hell with your puny books. This is science, it cannot be bound, has no language"...a year goes by, cheaper and very young people are brought in as faculty, who knew nothing but the book and the syllabus, and those teachers that, even after retirement were in this school, teaching us...had daily conflicts with them. They must've thought to themselves, "I've had a successful career, complete life, why will I do this?"....literally, within 6 months, all of them left. And now there are teachers that google the answers of our queries, and answer the next day.... Indian Education system is done for! Its the individual's credit always!!
In our college... College passouts are teaching us lol. They don't even have a teachers training like in goverment colleges. They hire these people for 10,000 rupees and they teach us.
@@DANTE-kv7mv and first tier colleges take in only people above 95%. I missed admission in DU even after scoring 94%. Then wtf am I supposed to do then
@@indianflippingart9593 it depends on your preference You could have got a tier 1 college with a not so good course But a good course in tier 2 college
I am a post graduate in zoology. Teachers say good career options in zoology are not available in India and will have to move abroad....Same gies with Environ science..They say this cuz it was extremely difficult for them to find a job even after scoring good. By scoring good I am not just talkng about marks, they are extremely brilliant and has a good hold over the subject..
Thanks brother for touching this most common and underrated topic...all the best minds leave india...even a child can tell why Thanks for the excellent content 👍
One thing is that people when they are here..their talents aren't recognized but when they go out, and grind make it on their own.. and get successful.. Indians start claiming them as if they always believed in them, look the CEO of google Microsoft is indian yada yada.. but this is like partners in profit. Like you didn't give them that platform to grow they had to grow on their own. Hate it when ppl bring that into an argument.
Agreed, when the student is not doing well here : "bekar ha Kisi kaam Ka Nahi h jaldi se degree Puri Kar, Shaadi Kara denge". When he becomes successful in foreign countries : "oh he is Indian, you know what I taught him when he was in school" Selfish af :/
Thanks mohak ... Its my serious concern ..not only professor but also technocrats . doctors, econimist etc... See we left raghu ram rajan a brilliant person and kept a normal person as RBI governor
Really relevant issue. We need to spread such awareness. Im sharing such videos /channels to my friends. This wil strengthen our democracy and real freedom
America not develop in a year but they think India should be develop in a few year to became america but those Indian who left over country and settle in america .. Wants India to clean and putting zero effort for clean india mohak mangal never talk about 70 year and zero smart city ?? Why
Lack of funding in research, low pay-scale, less number of PhD seats are forcing students also to leave India and pursue their studies abroad. I, myself, is an example of it. Thanks for the video #MohakMangal #Sochbymohakmangal. Even students doing PhD in India are not happy with their stipend irregularities. For example, CSIR-Net qualified students are given their stipends in three-five months delay, as a result, they face difficulties in managing their basic living costs.
Whatever may be the field of work we are doing , when you are trying to improve your life and putting in the work but you are moving no where it really sucks . And you look around and you see country itself going no where with the thought process and attitude we have, it really pushes you to edge . Finally When you see you can have a way better quality life and work life in other countries you want to go for it.
From an Indian settled in Canada After always wanting to settle back in India these are the reasons that have made it unimaginable for many like me to settle in India and serve our mother land. I really hope it changes one day, And the brightest talents in our country can take humanity forward.
@@anmolsrivastava1712 It was the 2nd toughest exam, it now 5th. By the way it's not the point to discuss. To have a better future in india we need more best of the best prof. Rather than any civil servants.
Only 2 of my undergrad classmates went back to India and joined IITs. Most of them are working outside India. It isn't that they don't want to go back. It is easy for them to find a position in other countries than in Indian academic/research institute due to crazy Indian politics during recruitment. After doing PhD and few years postdoc with publications in top tier journals, you not qualified to get a job in India because they want to hire someone backed by their director and senior professors.
As a media student I just to say,we have to make an educated legislative system and we should be aware about for whom we are voting. Every problem has a root , We as a rational people should cut that.
I just saw an article about how the Himachal Pradesh teachers aren't allowed to criticise the government whilst teaching... The Academic Freedom of this country is in negative 📉
मुझे याद है की 12 कक्षा मे जब 'sound waves' पढाया जा रहा था, तब बार बार हमारे physics teacher एक शब्द पर अटक रहे थे और उसे वो गुइतार कहके pronaunce कर रहे थे। बाद मे पता चला की वो शब्द गुईतार नही गिटार (guitar) था। ये हालत है निमशहरी स्कूलो की।
@@vikrantdhanavade8005 पर फिर भी। क्योंकि बस एक शिक्षक गिटार नहीं बोल सकता, ये उसकी बुद्धि को नहीं दर्शाता। क्या वो शिक्षक सही से नहीं पढ़ाता था? आप हमे ये बताए।
@@Apurv007 NUST is on its list? And lums btw i m from pak but want to study abroad however even the unis in europe have a lower qs rankin then the ones in pak
I am not a big intellact but after graduation i am thinking contantly about leaving this country forever and settle somewhere in north america or western europe. But finances does not allow. Now, this nation feels like a big jail where we can not speak anything about truth in public.
Because research facility,respect,lifestyle and science community is very good there.Not only this international recognition becomes easy when you are in such country.
I have heard that a few Universities who cannot hire a professor ask *post graduation students to take classes while paying them the fees of a safai worker* . the rest salary goes in the pockets of authorities..
At the end of the day, these academicians need a good life and a good salary, in the early decades of independence in our country , that just wasn't there, so they left. Now things are better for sure, but a long way to go, hopefully our bright minds stay here and realise the full potential of country.
The most important thing is the freedom to do what they want in their subject. A person who has done a PhD in a subject CANNOT be directed by someone in the ministry who has no background in the subject whatsoever. Science is still now fine(not for long though) but social science (like econ and pol sci) has always been strangled in India. No doubt economist leave. That's the economically and politically right thing to do XD. At the end of the day parties which prey on the fears of people (Congress(fear of poverty), BJP(Hindu khatrein mein hai)) can never support education. That's an economic equilibrium. Academia can only thrive in a liberal society
yes bhai. i am a 16 year old student, when all students of my age don't know what to do, or get in the herd of pre-defined paths for good jobs, i want to be an astrophysicist.... its my childhood dream, as i only think about the universe, as it is the supreme thing, the actual reality.... but but.... also i want the credit to go with my country India, and not some other country (note: i think some might think that why work in india when universe can be studied anywhere, for that country doesn't matter, but for me it also matters ! ) i want to lead a good life in India with my family but research and salaries are not good, this demotivates me for the fact that ----> why should i study for 10-12 years and get phd etc. and still get paid less with lesser opportunities, when studying nicely now and that too for just 4-5 years can get me a high paid job? this bothers me. now some might say do whatever you want to do dont see all this and blah blah.... well what will i do then, sit at home with phd in hand that too in ASTRONOMY !!! wtf :( i want to earn nicely, and lead a good life amongst my countrymen, and i want all my tax money to go to India, i want to really see India as a true superpower, not the SO CALLED SUPERPOWER WITH HINDUTVA GOONS :\ pata nhi kya hoga desh ka, by the way India is a young country (as per citizens age)... so many people are educated and still unemployed and unhappy, LAGTA HAI EK CIVIL WAR YA REVOLUTION AANE HI WAALE HAI JAB MAIN 30 KA HO JAUNGA !!! Panik :(
Our education focuses on lessening the burden on students, but increasing the burden on teachers, with their exploitation. Teachers are forced to go to schools and to take online classes from there, expected to do all the accounts and management work themselves with literally half the pay they were getting. The conditions of the teachers are not good, especially the primary school teachers.
Lessening the burden on students... Bro u serious get into any engineering clg and students will tell u Our professors treat us like literal garbage for no reason One of my professor threw someone's journal only because he drew the diagram on the second page and not on the left hand side of the first He literally had to redraw tht whole bs within 10 mins to get some stupid marks Faculties say themselves tht they want their lives to be easier so it is expected from students to suffer by doing bs assignments which r copy pasted These assignments (weekly) for 5 theory subject and 5 practical makes 10 assignment/practical submission per week Which makes no sense faculties already know the content of it is copy pasted so they don't even bother looking into it There r few exceptions but the odds of such professors who genuinely do their work and teach with passion r rly hard to find
i Think people in comment section have taken his message in a wrong way he is spreading awareness to make the place a better place , not encouraging to leave the place
many people who pursue research that is Bsc Msc leave india and pursue higher studies from abroad. what else can we expect when the salary of research people is very less in india ? 😓
Isn't it feels broken to see person's who can mould india in better way were sent out....i jus googled Abhijit Banerjee he's now a india-born naturalized American economist💔
I have worked for four years in a pharmaceutical company in India under low salary, exploitation, reservation, company politics, poor labor laws. In the end, I move to Japan for a better life!
they are cases of exploitation and company politics in japanese companies too against foreigners specially south asians. not every grass is greener on the other side
Away from family and ur birthplace for quality. Congrats may god u sucess and u know after many year how ur sucess ia going to turn into ash in ur mouth. Mark my words.
Man you are doing a great job by making such amazing videos and reaching out this knowledge to general public Keep it up I know it takes a lot of effort to do such research work for making such video
![Seungmin "그렇게, 천천히, 우리(As we are)" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/kAzmhLHePqU/mqdefault.jpg)
I remember one incident from my college (IIT BHU). One of the professors tried doing something wonderful, by starting open book exams and focussing on the application part of the course, rather than simple theory. With the help of another young professor, he added many courses that are more relevant to the current day. Even though they were offered as an elective subject, many students appreciated his effort for actually caring about their career. However, he was heavily criticized by the administration to the extent that he left within 3 years of his tenure. He was very helpful even after he left the college, and I am very grateful to have him as one of my professors.
That's so sad. You will rarely find these kinds of professors in Indian universities.
In such cases they should start a tuition center, I'm pretty sure many'd flock there!, Bureaucracy is what is causing all this displeasure.
We had open book exams in US universities.
he should open a tution
It happened in IIT Mumbai......we can't do innovation....I studied in MIT USA after that and I met him there.....In IIT Mumbai I can't do out of box
Innovation is something our parents and many teachers get heartstroke from
Haha they think only docs and engineers exist in this world.
So true bro.... But this is really sad😢
Ha to apne konsi innovation kari
Ya phir apko innovation karne se roka gaya
👍
Yeah that's very relevant with this video . Yeah sure . w0kE
I am currently studying in a Canadian Institute and I had completed my bachelor's from one of the top commerce college in my city.. In just one semester I learned what I didn't learn in three years of my bachelor's. Our education system needs to be reformed and we need to vote right people.
What are the major differences?
@@debasish9964 reservation nhi hain toh classmates aur professor dono badhiya😂
Yes u need to vote Papu ,he can make our clg bankok
And who are the right people?
Prajakta education system is better there because they don't have issues like reservation and they have surrendered to Christianity so no drain of brain in that country because let it grow independently.
Our Very Big Brain Scientists are killed unanimously and we can't do anything.
So your parents should have votted for the right government.
Now I feel bad that how we used to make fun of our teachers in school days, eventually I realized that people like me make them quit their job.
🙏🙏🙏
You must hurt in order to know , fall in order to grow, lose in order to gain, cause life's greatest lesson are learnt through pain.
@@gamingotaku1703 ~ Pain
I feel PAIN
@oof just keep on giving excuses
My elder brother was doing his Phd in Mathematics at Jadavpur University but he left the university because of the professor under whom he was doing a reserch. My brother did most of the paper work and solved many formula but his profesor took all the credit😭. Didn't even print his name.
খুবই দুঃখের বিষয়।। আশাকরি আপনার দাদা ভবিষ্যত এ উন্নতি করবে।
Jadavpur university is a communist college
@@kaishk1091 abhi wo bhi politics se divide karo... kuch toh sharam karo yaar...
@@kaishk1091 still better than any other college in terms of return of investment. Btw a student got placed in Google in Singapore for 1.1Cr/annum from JU. Not any IIT/NIT/IIIT/other private colleges. Out of 80 scientists selected for workshop in Stanford, 42 were from West Bengal and 20 were from JU(others were from Calcutta University, Scottiish Church, Presidency University etc)..remaining 38 were from other states.
So he didn't get his degree?
I am also a professor in a well known university in Asia .
I agree with your video .
I observe that in university 99% students only want syllabus .....they don't want intellectual approach.....They don't like discussion on national & international issues . They are not aware about social issues.
But I should appreciate your homework
Good luck .....
This SOCIAL JUSTICE WOKEISM is what's destroying the US & it's university campuses, we don't want that here.
@@Albetroz1415 BRUH
@@Albetroz1415 Ok college dropout.
@@AryanSharma-qj4eu ok snowflake, you wanna fight fAsCiSm with me? 😂😂😂
The needs and the pressure on a student are enormously different here. The financial, home, parental setup is completely different to the rest of the world. Couple that with the poor quality and just general poverty in the education sector, and that's what you get. A student who does the learning for the heck of it, and tries to get out of here as fast as he can.
because some people & politicians don't respect them, politicians' only dream is to divide Hindu Muslims..slowly many INDIANS will leave INDIA if this goes on. INDIA ko sirf history books mein freedom mila hain but in reality it's a big JOKE
Correctly said
100 Million new born in india 2020-2021
70 saal pe freedom nehi tha?
jitne bhi iitians hote h ya toh coaching krte h ya job krte h videsh mein jake ya mit mein professor ban jate h ...muzhe samjh ni aya arvind kejriwal yaha reh kese rhe h politics jaha modi ji ke toxic andhbhakt h
But if these type of things continue why would any person want to stay
Not just professor, millionaires, intellectuals also leaving India. Because now there is no space for free ideology.
Like it goes, if u are a genius in india then you have 2 choices:
• live in this country trying to reform things that refuse to be reformed. U lose everything in course and die penniless.
• leave this country and go to a country that values you. You will not change india but get everything you ever deserved: respect,money, recognition and most of all value.
There are some exceptions, but the choice is obvious for most.
MOST??
I think you meant everyone
@@paramsodha7936 no I meant most.
Iss desh ka naseeb hain ki abhi bhi Dr. Nambi jaise log hai
Tum bhi jaaoge kya?
Aap bhi jaane ki taiyaari me ho lagta hai
@@mukundkushwaha8213 when the time comes, yes, kyonki ye desh bahut pyaara hai mujhe aur mai inn politics aur 50 saal purane caste, religion waale same agendas ke saamne chunte hue nahi dekh skta.
Kahin se koi hope nahi dikhti, bas development ke naam pe jahan government ka sole motive hona chahiye ki saare youth ki energy channelise krke desh ke liye use kro, taaki engineering graduates ko 9000 rupay mahine ki naukri na krni pde, woh bas naye pul, murti, pichli sarkar aur obselete schemes jinse 4 logon ko fayda hua Gina dete hai.arre kisaanon ke account mein paise mat daalo, aur IITs aur nits banao, jahan wo apne bacche ko padhwa sake, taaki unka ladka parivaar aur desh, dono ki takdeer badal de.
When a indian see a successful indian in west : proud to be a indian 🇮🇳
Only time when we feel patriotic is when someone achieve something their own but can't realise why he/she are not archiving the same level of success here
Sadly if they use freedom of expression they will be declared anti-nationals, tukde-2 gang, commi, Marxist, etc.
😔😔😔😔
an*
And that the successes there is adding to their economy but nothing here😭
Dude u will see them only in capitalistic countries.Doesn't Indians hate capitalism?
@@musicstudy7610 commi and Marxism is the real reason for this
They go to west which is capitalistic
And indians hate capitalistic
We have a culturally right wing government but this stupid government is not economically right
I’m a physics student with an immense love for the subject. I asked my teacher how can I get into research, he tells me I have to do phd but even after that, It’s not sure if I’ll get a chance to do research. I have to get into top colleges to get into research or else I’ll end up being a lecturer. Even if I get into research, I will face alot of troubles because our country does not have even the most basic but important equipments required to carry the research. This made me change my decision and now I’m having to change my career path even though I love physics. I will still keep myself updated regarding this subject but I cannot choose this as my career as it won’t be as beneficial to me as compared to my input/hardwork. This is the reason why a lot of students leave our country or change their career and opt for something which gives more benefits to them.
@Abhi Raj bro me already tybsc me hu. Mera last semester hai, iske baad physics graduate ki degree hath me ayegi
main bhi same
go study outside but return here invest your skills here, what you'll learn from other country
@@jaymahakaal5354 cannot do that bro. Bahar ka degree lenge toh India me mostly uska use nhi hota ya fir usko utna importance dia nahi jata. Besides, I already talked about the equipments issue. So even if I try to research in India, I will face alot pf setbacks. Govt should invest more in our education and research facilities, only then normal people like us will get avenues to do something unique for our nation
@@noelsmaison685 if u can't do ur research here properly then go outside n learn..if possible come back n help the other students so they can learn too..this trick was used by Chattrapati Shivaji Maharaj against Portuguese so the people of Hinduvi Samrajya can learn how to build better n magnificent war ships to battle with invaders..🙏🙏🇮🇳🇮🇳
Prof. HC VERMA. Despite being a well-known Gold medalist Physicist, A patent holder, He taught at Patna university which was not even in NIRF RANKING.
Yes He is IIT Kanpur retired Professor
130 crore logo ke desh mei sirf 1 hi naam bata pa raha hai bhai,khud dekhle haalat
@@Chiragchhabra07 Hc verma to bhai famous hain. There are a lot of IIT professors Jo yahan padha rahe hain. Salute to them.
Lekin baat to sahi kahi
Exceptions are always there
@@Vikas-zd1rj yep
Day by day this channel is becoming incredible
Still carryminati has more success 😔....SAD
Ha carry minarti gali jo deta hai !! Right ??
@@JUICE-ie6oi Thats coz of Indian youth are more attracted to filth than good content..
And country's situation is really concerning
@@gulammohiddin5747 not only Indian youth you ignorant
I think you are the first guy who cover this underrated sensitive topic
Me too.
I left India, 8 yrs served as professor (Temp Post), still government did not created permanent post for that subject. My age is passed over to get government job.
Politics, After I finished my Ph.D, I went to the same college to get hired for same subject, but the Principal told your education is not valid to teach the same subject. After his retirement I got the same job. Low salary, No salary for many months, No job grantee, Rarely get Exam duty to earn additional income. I am sorry, I miss teaching, now settled in USA, but I now my students are very good professor in the same college, and I am proud of them.
Sir u made great decision I hope u r not regret
Somebody rightly said "Biggest achievement in India is to leave India."
Edit: Wow 4k likes... Unexpected..
Punit pania said till now the greatest achievement in this country is to leave it
*Escape india.
And enter a capitalist and meritorious society like the west where your caste doesn’t ensure your admission into college, promotion, govt job and insecurity of getting into jail from SC ST act.
Same problem in bangladesh brother :((
100% true
@@MAC-vi7fy USA has reservations for Black's and Native Americans and India's reservation is nothing compared to USA but still USA is successful so stop blaming reservation blame the political party
When I reported my professors in my college, even my friends didn’t support me in the fear of losing degree.
I passed with flying colours as I never worried about internal marks. But another fact is there were some professors who were silently supporting me. They never gave up on me.
Throughout the course, I only mastered the way of clearing exams. Learnt nothing.
That's why my Uncle living in USA has always directed me to move to USA right after my bachelor. Now I get that point. 🤨
go there and save your life & career
@yr USA companies hv INDIAN bosses,okRACIST? what's ur take on reservation
It's the primary reason why ppl leave
@@HariKrishna-lk5wx lmao wha jake natives aur blacks ks reservation dekh k royenge
Thats amazing do it man ! You have a uncle there you already have a foundation there go for it!!
@@sirantisocial9681 unhe bhi 40 percent reservation milta hai colleges m naukriyo m ???
"Kitab ka jawab kitab se hi milna chaiye "
~ Golden words
Man I miss atal ji
tbh I didn't understand this. can u pls explain?
@@siddhishinde.575 Meaning: A response to a book should be a book. In short, stop beating up the professors and authors for what they write. lol
@@gulammohiddin5747 maybe I'm dumb or something. I still don't understand the book part
@@siddhishinde.575 if u dont agree with someone, counter their words with facts, not violence, 🙏🙏🙏
He always comes up with unique topics .
Yes...He emphasis on real issues...
लेकिन आज कल ए बंदा भी adware बन गया है
लेकिन आज कल ए बंदा भी adware बन गया है।
@@ARUNKUMAR-gh6zp kyunki sponsors se bohot paise milte hai aur ye sab reasearch karne me bohot mehnat lagta, aapke liye ye sponsor clips distracting ho skta hai , par bohot log ke kaam bhi aata hai. sabke perspective se socha karo, nahi pasand to hum log skip bhi kar skte wo clip.
But he gets the analysis so wrong.
Just look at our education minister, God save india.
Astrology Should replace Science
- Once a Legend Said😂😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣
@@carotid8210 lol do you even know who discovered zero , trignometry , geometry an astrologer Aryabhatt
@@jaysuryakandari3850 lol do you know , who gave this statement... Poor guy.
@@carotid8210 yes said by ramesh pokriyal nishnk
@@jaysuryakandari3850 that's what I mention there.... Not Aryabhatta......
Why is this channel so much underrated
Come on. It was once underrated but now it's not.
Kyunki biased chize dikhata hai
Bcz he is not a asslicker
Ha bs nearly 5lakh log hi to jante hai isme kya bari baat ho gyi
@@esterpine lo bhai lr lo ab isse koi mai bs comment padh k maze lunga 😌😌😌
"Why do India's best professors leave India?"
we already know the answer
Aslong as stupid politicians in India have upperhands in every thing including education bright people will leave I rememner thr wsy BJP brigade ie Amit Shah and Modi attacked Amartya Sen and Banerji .It is beyond belief.BJP will drive every body out There was no apology for saying Amartya Sen charging plane fare on govt account which was a lie
@@rakhimukerji7937 Actually Amartya Sen/ Abhijit Banerjee, left india long before Modi came to power.
@@anuragbanerjee2879 That pretty much sums up that India was a hell hole since the time of its independence.
@@anuragbanerjee2879 situation is still the same
@@jayeshmonlbs Look at the faculty list of Askoka, a lot of young guys are coming back
People say IITs are the best. Please learn the reality. Students have no voice there. Professor can literally destroy your life.
Then exchange seats with private college students.
@@kamalkumar7978 Thats your solution for problem in IITs?
@@saipruthvi8535 nah just want to tell you that many students join IITs in a rat-race. So, how do you expect them to react ?
Also, ghar ki murgi daal barabar.
Atleast, IITs will give you hands-on knowledge on latest technology, latest syllabus, enough time to work on your side hussle and the best launchpad for your career in the country. Atleast, in IITs profs help you to connect to foreign universities.
The only solution is resetting the education system and resetting the rat mindset.
@K nikhilesh Vaibhav Krupakar who will provide them good pay ? The corporates ? The sole purpose of corporates in India is do cost cutting by paying less to their employees. Only few corporates are exception.
@Vexxter depends on which IIT ur talking about
Because we and our polititions didn't respected them.
Jb padhe likhe logo ko frk nhi prta to
Politicians ki to rhne hi do 🙃
respect*
Both for money, achievement and politics in research institute/university. Of course the other thing is funding. As an ex-student of a premium research institute, I can tell you that our educationist are egoist. Some of them cannot bear the shear politics of the university/research institute. Many wanted to live abroad and earn in dollar/pound/euro. It is also noted that most of the premium journal like Nature, Science etc are all Western Centrist. They have a huge bias for Western (Japanese included) researchers, it is very easy publish a paper in Nature if that was written by a premium institute from Europe or America. Same goes with the international prestigious awards. Lastly, because of funding. We need more funding for research, but that depends on the Economy. But again, we need our institutes more professional and capitalist. American universities use the capitalist model of research. There is a huge pressure on publishing papers on the professors. If they cannot meet enough they will be sacked. If this model is applied in Indian university, there will be more funding from both university and private companies.
I please keep you eyes open of the leftist propaganda. Like the professors cannot do research as they wish, is a total bullshit. Many of them in institute, I have seen as idle in spite of having funding.
we do , but only if they deserve that respect...🙄
Bro u may not but I respect my college professors
It's not only professor leaving India, many like including me trying to leave India and settled in countries like the US, UK, Canada, Europe, etc.
Where do u stay
That's all good, but with this kind of English you'll have a hard time clearing IELTS for immigration.😅
@@bikrambhattacharya6524 quality joke, I laughed 👍🏻
@@bikrambhattacharya6524 bruh 🤣
I also want 😭
I am getting my PhD in the US now but I have completed my bachelor's and Master's from India. When I got my full scholarship offer from a US university, one of my father's friends (who was a professor at Rutgers university in the US but now has returned to India) told my parents, "If you love your son, advise him to stay in the US. There is no respect or tolerance for brilliant scholars in India. It's a country that runs on "Hard work, not Harvard" or "Jugaad is better than actual expertise" type mindset. No one appreciates merit here. Returning to India is the biggest regret of my life".
And having lived, researched and taught here in the US for 4 years now, I fully agree with him. I wholeheartedly want to now apply for jobs as a professor here at some university after graduating. Studying and teaching in the US makes you truly happy from within. It helps you find meaning and purpose in what you do and how you live your life. India can never ever offer that level of professional satisfaction, happiness or level of respect.
Are there any Bengalis who don't leave Bengal? We don't want more of you down south please just all go to America instead 🙏
@@Albetroz1415 Why? What's the harm in Bengalis being in South India?
@@sayanchatterjee355 They bring their IDEOLOGY with them, we don't want to create a TOXIC political environment here especially in educational institutes.
@@Albetroz1415 What kind of toxic ideology do they bring?
To be honest Indians have the capability to dominate the world, sadly most of the learned scholars/ intellectuals/ entrepreneurs are leaving India mainly because of pressures and circumstances created by Politics. God bless India
😣😣😞😞sad reality
@Daud Khan only rich going USA than how they can saw our poor people there
The fact that Your said ' dominate the world' means you are not well educated as an Indian. We are from India not China to"dominate others"
Why dominate ??? Why every poor or developing country wants to dominate????
@@vinukaushik29may yeah
Reality is every Indian wants to leave India
Thanks to system 👍
I don’t want to because I will change the system when I finish my university studies
@@BestOfPodcast_45 me too. I will leave india after my education
@@svn9482 don't let this decision turn into despair, cause at some point it will happen.
@@kamartaj3010 Goodluck for future
@@BestOfPodcast_45 good luck for future
Although I’m not a big talented person, but still I feel more free and independent living abroad
I am in Japan doing my civil engineering my friends are really good in discussions about future opportunities, I feel like I will become something here.
And more importantly I get free animes to watch. 😁
@@shubhamrane0 bro that's amazing
I can proudly say I am studying in a college in a branch where the faculties themselves say "attendance leke kya karoge I will give you attendance but understand the topic clearly, padho, samjho nai samjh me aye to pucho". Where the HOD reiterates the basics of class 8 happily to the weakest students without making fun of them encouraging them to be better but not the best. Where homeworks don't exist. I like how they are trying to be the right in a country full of wrongs and somehow I ended up here.
What college bro
Sad to hear you study in dreams 😓😭
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
If u are a fresher. It might happen to you. Generally teachers do it to freshers in the 1st semester. After that they will become attendance sucking creatures who don't wanna teach and will take leaves for stupid reasons. If not, you are in a really awesome college. Keep it up
@@mohammedubed7000 not a fresher. I'm in the 4th semester and their behaviour didn't change overtime.
👍
In our country degrees are just suffixes, you don't get much knowledge in the college lectures. Professors are more adamant on making students attend 100 percent lectures rather than focusing on their teaching skills. There is little to no environment which promotes research in the country. I want to write research papers but I am only stuck in the assignments which require no thinking and just require copy pasting stuff from here and there. It's highly unfortunate for us to have such a weak education system where curiosity is killed.
I agree but partially true ,he here is speaking about the same problem about how we lack GOOD teachers bcuz the GOOD ones leave INDIA , in thier pursuit of knowledge which the GOVT. fails to provide here!
And one more thing just focus on your syllabus only।
@@shyamjakhete2285 I totally agree with you.
That's not the case everywhere, I am doing my mbbs from aiims bhopal & our professors are quite good and friendly.
@Amatya Ucran if only I could do my Assignments in 10 minutes. 🙃
I have been living in US for 5 years now. My plan was to come back, work on my startup there, but instead, I am working on it in US. Every time I thought of coming back, I see all this crap and I am like, there's no way I am going back.
Bro with all respect tell me how many u follow the rules in India ... Not throwing garbage ... But in america u behave like a gentleman wow
@@himanshutomar3330 That's right. We are not following any rules in India. Because it's not in our nature to follow rules. It's like in our DNA. In America, you see others following the rules, you feel good about it and you follow it yourself. America has it's own set of problems but most of them are first world country problems. It's a big upgrade.
Don't come bro . Its a shitty place
@@himanshutomar3330 what rules? Government is shit at implementing rules. Traditional rules? No I'd rather not follow the "Indian culture" which is not even Indian.
@@stobit2519 Wow. You want govt to control your behaviour? Govt's job ends at controlling crime. It's not govt's job to tell you not to litter, tell you what you can and can't do.
Do you want an authoritarian state?
Glad you are bringing these quality videos more frequently.
I'm not surprised...low pay, poor infrastructure, obviously professors will leave
You missed the whole point. Dedicated Professors don't care about pay. They will help create the infrastructure. The video brought out actual reasons why the Professors left.
@@highartalert6927 this is not an ideal world.... You need some good salary for your hard work and also for your basic life
@@highartalert6927 This is not any fairyland where u do good for someone selflessly so wake up from ur dreams and Bollywood
Yeh duniya hai jo haath mei hai woh bhi cheenke kha jayegi
So better care for urself cuz when u will be sitting like a begger no one is gonna help u
Im only saying that sab apna apna dekho see where u, ur finances and ur life will grow
Don't take these emotional drama created by politicians of any political party so seriously
Sab ek jaise hi hai
So run after ur own growth in all aspects
And if ppl see growth in other countries they would go there
Agar india mei kuch nhi rakha hai toh jayenge hi
per capita of india and uk is totally different while india has 3000 dollars per head income whereas uk has 45000 dollars per head but think about the slavery and destruction they caused. they are only rich because our ancestors blood and sweat. they provide money which they stole in terms of salary
@@aryabhandkar9148 bro everyone knows that they looted us ... But today it doesn't matter to anyone today....that is past.... Today they will see the overall growth of country.... Even according to me today we should concentrate on our conditions
Man, this is the best way to put a sponsorship through a topic. Totally convinced to install the app.
🇺🇲: Planning to increase vaccination
🇨🇦: Focusing on fighting covid
🇩🇪: Focusing on boosting economy
🇮🇳: Didi....OOO....didi...
🇨🇳: Started mass vaccination, going to overtake USA economically....
@@balajip6405 lol🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@balajip6405 india have LoL ministers 😆😆🤣🤣
@@balajip6405 rumba rumba
🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
Man,swadesh is one of the most underrated movie of Shah Rukh Khan-
Zero TWO!!
DARLING IN THE FRANXX
I HAVE WATCHED THIS ANIME.
IT'S A GOOD ANIME.
YOUR BACK STORY MADE ME CRY.
LOVE YOU ZERO TWO!
@@div2954 you good bruh?
@@div2954 weed energy?
But the story is so fake. Nobody leaves a high paying job in the USA to come to India, except for retirement.
@@manandhiman1010 No!
I didn't drug
Me and my friends are doctors , just completed our degree and due to current status we daily share ideas about going abroad 😔
@@shivang5138 it’s very easy said ,but u don’t know what is conditions or working tactics politics. Which at the end of day is frustrating
On salary aiims doctor are getting same pay as we , but working environment and security is far
Salary in private sector is far better in India
But although work ethics tactics security is same there
@Sayan Gope no offence but money also matters in real life
After a hectic duty , your innerself wants a warm nice meal from swiggy ,but when u you know it’s not gonna happen and u just cook ur Maggi and sleep .
@@shivang5138 so many government doctors live in the fear of getting beaten up by patients' family or being forced to pay hefty fees or serve for years in a remote village far from their home without basic healthcare facilities, it's not just about money.
cheer up
@@joyrainbowdress yes u r right in pandemic there were so many cases that doctors are getting killed. I mean why? ppl should know their value and praise them instead of killing them 😔
Mr. Mangal sir, my father is a chemistry researcher and professor in US. Your point about the lack of funding and the lack of capability is very true. There is not equipment to do research like in US. When he was doing PhD, he had to ask someone to operate machines and do assays for him, even when he could learn to use equipment himself. The machines were scarce and there was no one there to fix them. If he wanted to run large experiments, he never got permission. And when permission isn’t received, research doesn’t occur, which is why drug research in India dramatically declined over the last 20 years.
What the comments say about teaching is also true. He says that PhD students in India today write bogus thesis and still get degree, and don’t even have skills to succeed in field. He says that Indian PhD students are less skilled in research than US 3rd year BSc students. Even after postdoctoral studies, these students are far inferior to students with no PostDoc in the West.
Why are you scaring me bro!!!! 😥
I'm about to give CSIR.
The PhD thing is true unless you've done your PhD from IISc, IISERs or other premier research institutes.
Exactly, during my undergraduate at Canadian University, I worked with a post doctoral from IACS Kolkata. He mentioned universities in India don't even let their Masters students get hand on experience due to limited resources, and here I was 3rd year undergrad working on projects, attending symposiums and writing papers for publication. Brilliant guy, had passion for chemistry
@@shinkoshine9490 😂sad Life
Man you are blooming.. the content, presentation and selection of topics is excellent..
Hats off to soch team
I am seeing this with my own eyes.Two of my professors, are leaving in next 5 months, and both of them taught extremely good..and were excellent researchers
But there is a good thing. Experts like you read so much and understand things and then explain in simple words to us.. that is really helpful for us. a big thank you... bcoz you contribute to make this country more beautiful and developed.
3 bengalis in the intro-
1.Abhijit Banerjee
2.Ashok Sen
3. Amartya Sen - for the last 65 years he is living outside but still remains a Indian citizen.
জয় হিন্দ। বন্দেমাতারাম।
@Shreya Chakraborty Still we are doing great. Check out the list of Shanti Swaroop Bhatnagar award.Our problem is - we do not want to recognize our heros.
I pursued my bachelor's from Delhi University and Masters from Delhi school of Economics. I have cleared JRF NET in 2020 June. Now I'm trying to get some scholarships so that I could go in some west country. Why? Because there is no opportunities, jobs or respect in this country.
Best of luck
Suggestion: Go to Europe
@@paramsodha7936 i support that
Wish you luck. NET is the most useless exam as it has negligible weightage when it comes to API scores.
Very good choice. It will also help in your mental health 👍.
That's why I think they say ki do your PhD in foreign countries even the central govt. recruits professors in iits or iims who studied from foreign universities
Indian politics is worst. Anpad log desh ko chalaenge toh ye hi haal hoga na. Yaha education toh sirf ratto aur exams me likho. Ab log berozgar nahi honge toh aur kya honge. Indian politics is all about religion, India-pakistan. They don't focus on important issues like increase in poverty, crimes, unemployment, pollution, population, sexual violence, corruption etc...
😖
And also about sexual violence
let me tell u 1000cr funding announce hua a budget mai for startups... last 2 weeks mai 6-7 unicorns hui hai.... and logically population itna jada hai toh unemployment to rahaga hi and crimes kis country mai nahi hota .. hama every day US mai koi na koi open firing ki khabar aati hai.... Education sirf ratna sa milti toh loog IIT advance mai paas nahi ho pata , UPSC clear nahi kar pata .... STart yourself logically padho sab samaj ayaga....
@@explorer2.035 unemployment rate in India is 6.9% and in us it is 3.5%. For your kind information unemployment rate is not affected by population of the country it is simply the ratio of unemployed population upon total population.
@@explorer2.035 so please stop saying that population of India is reason for higher unemployment
@@explorer2.035 and what you said about education is absolutely right
Why do professors leave india?
The same reason why EINSTEIN leave GERMANY
Wow india has been a fascist country even when congress was ruling too? This is some god level logic!
यह coincidence वाकई चौंकाने वाला है !!
@@surajs5913 did I say that india was not a fascist country during Congress period .
@@noel5544 don't mess with him these people don't think before writing comments
@Shreya Chakraborty and yet people keep leaving India all the time irrespective of who is ruling. I guess the logic of correlating brain drain with fascism is illogical
I got into Ashoka University , but due to the this resignations and their concern for no freedom of speech. I rejected.
After finishing my ms in us, i came back to india to start my own venture. 10 years later, i am now back in the us and hope to settle anywhere but home.
I am in Canada and I will never go back to India ...😔...even if I want to we cannot ...no prospects for me and husband ...
What we Want: MIT
What we Have : WU
@Dong Singh whatsApp university
We do have MIT.
It is Manipal Institute of Techno-
@@white-demonn madras institute of technol-
Yea this is so true... Not only professors but also good students..... Like all of the cream layer of india is shifting to foreign countries😢😢
Every time i see your video i feel like i know nothing..My mind could never think this...Everything seems complex..Thank you for educating us
Our youth need people like you..KEEP GOING
Literally everything you wrote Is right
But still we have top professor and graduates of WhatsApp university 🤣🤣
True brother..😂
😁😁😁😁😁
😂😂😂
😂
LOL 😂😂
Truth is we live in a society where parents wants their child to be taught by a best teacher but neither students wants to be teacher nor parents supports their child to be teacher
I have a friend attending Ashoka and from his point of view, it is actually comparable to foreign universities. The curriculum is way better than what outdated garbage we study at engineering colleges
True. But this incident has shown that even Ashoka is not free from the evils of Indian higher education completely.
@Youth India Maybe we can create something on our own or get a job ourselves with that world class education.
Ashoka is liberal arts college, how can you compare that to engineering colleges ? Plus the fees is atleast 10 times of the norm
@@massive_d they do offer engineering courses as well don't they?
And as far as I know they offer financial aid. You might want to double check that as I am not sure
@Youth India That isn't the point of innovation or research is it? The point is for you to get world class education that will propel you to create placements by yourself. Have you missed the entire point of the video lmao?
Most of the professors whom you have given as examples became professors AFTER they left India.
And also not just professors, many engineers also leaves India after graduation. The CEOs and many engineers in senior positions of large tech companies in USA are also Indians.
Best example CEO of pepsi and Google
Time for educated Indians to be united. Don’t let emotion control logic.
Finally,
HE MADE A VIDEO ON AN IMPORTANT TOPIC.
(I DOESN'T MEAN THAT, HE DON'T MAKE VIDEO OF IMPORTANT TOPIC.
EVERY TOPIC ON WHICH HEAD VIDEO ARE IMPORTANT)
THANKS
BRO!
EDIT:
HEY! YOU ARE BECOMING MORE FREQUENT THAN EVER.
IT'S NICE.
I LOVE TO WATCH & ENJOY YOUR VIDEO.
👍👍
When did I GOT 105 LIKES.
@@mn-bb2of zero two
Is such a good anime😭😭
Educated brain wants to achieve best what it deserves...
Many of my friends have a startup with good turnover better than a google selected btech...but headlines still highlight"google ne diya 1 crore ka package".
It sucks man...i also want to be job creator not an employee
Those are fake package if you convert it to dollars it will be different.
Startup ka naam bata taki sbko pata chale.
@@LokeshKumar-yd3qk lmao the package is not fake. Just the cost of living is higher there so it won’t make much difference if your earn 1.5 CRORES there, it’s the same as earning 20-25 lakhs here.
@@saline6244 that is what he meant
My School....had extremely, absolutely epic teachers!! When we were in class 8, Physics teacher, shows up to demonstrate cosmic rays, and radio communication systems. If ny one asked about the syllabus, he would say, "to hell with your puny books. This is science, it cannot be bound, has no language"...a year goes by, cheaper and very young people are brought in as faculty, who knew nothing but the book and the syllabus, and those teachers that, even after retirement were in this school, teaching us...had daily conflicts with them. They must've thought to themselves, "I've had a successful career, complete life, why will I do this?"....literally, within 6 months, all of them left. And now there are teachers that google the answers of our queries, and answer the next day.... Indian Education system is done for! Its the individual's credit always!!
In our college...
College passouts are teaching us lol. They don't even have a teachers training like in goverment colleges. They hire these people for 10,000 rupees and they teach us.
No offence but you must be studying in a tier 3 tier 4 college
@@DANTE-kv7mv I'm not sure. It's definitely not a 3rd tier. It's a 2nd tier. Not a 1st tier.
@@DANTE-kv7mv and first tier colleges take in only people above 95%. I missed admission in DU even after scoring 94%. Then wtf am I supposed to do then
@@indianflippingart9593 which college btw??
@@indianflippingart9593 it depends on your preference
You could have got a tier 1 college with a not so good course
But a good course in tier 2 college
Best Brand integration ever!!!! This is the first time I didn't even try to skip it.
I am a post graduate in zoology. Teachers say good career options in zoology are not available in India and will have to move abroad....Same gies with Environ science..They say this cuz it was extremely difficult for them to find a job even after scoring good. By scoring good I am not just talkng about marks, they are extremely brilliant and has a good hold over the subject..
Thanks brother for touching this most common and underrated topic...all the best minds leave india...even a child can tell why
Thanks for the excellent content 👍
I agree with the points about education budget, lack of private university, lack of funding for reasearch.
This is the reason youtube tutorials and platforms like udemy coursera etc gained traction
One thing is that people when they are here..their talents aren't recognized but when they go out, and grind make it on their own.. and get successful.. Indians start claiming them as if they always believed in them, look the CEO of google Microsoft is indian yada yada.. but this is like partners in profit. Like you didn't give them that platform to grow they had to grow on their own. Hate it when ppl bring that into an argument.
Agreed,
when the student is not doing well here : "bekar ha Kisi kaam Ka Nahi h jaldi se degree Puri Kar, Shaadi Kara denge".
When he becomes successful in foreign countries : "oh he is Indian, you know what I taught him when he was in school"
Selfish af :/
It's hypocrisy of a typical Indian People
Thanks mohak ... Its my serious concern ..not only professor but also technocrats . doctors, econimist etc... See we left raghu ram rajan a brilliant person and kept a normal person as RBI governor
Really relevant issue. We need to spread such awareness. Im sharing such videos /channels to my friends. This wil strengthen our democracy and real freedom
I donot lose hope. Like many people have the American dream, I have my dream and dreams for India will never die. They will exist in every generation.
America not develop in a year but they think India should be develop in a few year to became america but those Indian who left over country and settle in america .. Wants India to clean and putting zero effort for clean india mohak mangal never talk
about 70 year and zero smart city ?? Why
That's the spirit ❤️
@Velvet Thunder I am not support of bjp and congress tell me when China and India are in same in economy why china bets us under which government
@Velvet Thunder or one thing Im forgot u say worst in bjp can u tell me 70 year of fulling and provide a single smart city
Just like how the best students from India leave India.
Scientific temper in people is gradually decreasing
I watched two non skippable ads back to back and didn't closed the video.. means it is worth watching.
"Let us secrifice our today so that our children can have a better tomorrow"
- APJ Abdul Kalam
Man, such an eye-opening topic👍👍
Keep up the great work
Damn I became a big fan for your intro 🤩
Lack of funding in research, low pay-scale, less number of PhD seats are forcing students also to leave India and pursue their studies abroad. I, myself, is an example of it. Thanks for the video #MohakMangal #Sochbymohakmangal. Even students doing PhD in India are not happy with their stipend irregularities. For example, CSIR-Net qualified students are given their stipends in three-five months delay, as a result, they face difficulties in managing their basic living costs.
Great work as always. Everything in India has got worse after 2014. From ginger rank to freedom to this.
Whatever may be the field of work we are doing , when you are trying to improve your life and putting in the work but you are moving no where it really sucks . And you look around and you see country itself going no where with the thought process and attitude we have, it really pushes you to edge . Finally When you see you can have a way better quality life and work life in other countries you want to go for it.
Than why our professor leve country?? what's wrong with them
From an Indian settled in Canada
After always wanting to settle back in India these are the reasons that have made it unimaginable for many like me to settle in India and serve our mother land.
I really hope it changes one day,
And the brightest talents in our country can take humanity forward.
Fun Fact: IAS get for respect in India as compared to PhD Holders.
IAS are far more educated than our politicians
@@anmolsrivastava1712 not than Prof. Like Amartya Sen.
@@kashettyavp upsc is second most toughest exam in world . You need to be highly intelligent to paas that exam
@@anmolsrivastava1712 It was the 2nd toughest exam, it now 5th. By the way it's not the point to discuss. To have a better future in india we need more best of the best prof. Rather than any civil servants.
@@kashettyavp if civil servants start working properly then we don't need these fool politicians
Only 2 of my undergrad classmates went back to India and joined IITs. Most of them are working outside India. It isn't that they don't want to go back. It is easy for them to find a position in other countries than in Indian academic/research institute due to crazy Indian politics during recruitment. After doing PhD and few years postdoc with publications in top tier journals, you not qualified to get a job in India because they want to hire someone backed by their director and senior professors.
The time is right for talented Indians to expand worldwide, striving for 30% population and 20-30% governance representation globally.
As a media student I just to say,we have to make an educated legislative system and we should be aware about for whom we are voting. Every problem has a root , We as a rational people should cut that.
I just saw an article about how the Himachal Pradesh teachers aren't allowed to criticise the government whilst teaching...
The Academic Freedom of this country is in negative 📉
Again a good example of The fact that Not the government but the people are the main problem
मुझे याद है की 12 कक्षा मे जब 'sound waves' पढाया जा रहा था, तब बार बार हमारे physics teacher एक शब्द पर अटक रहे थे और उसे वो गुइतार कहके pronaunce कर रहे थे। बाद मे पता चला की वो शब्द गुईतार नही गिटार (guitar) था। ये हालत है निमशहरी स्कूलो की।
Hamari Teacher 👩🏫 AND ko college mein AAND bolti thi. 🤣🤣🤣🤣
😂😂😂
@@rahulghodmare5394 aand 😀😂
यह घटना कोई भी शिक्षक की बुद्धि को नहीं दर्शाता। यदि आप कोई बड़े अमेरिकी प्रोफेसर को कोई चीनी शब्द बोलने के लिए बोलेंगे तो वे नहीं बोल पाएँगे।
@@vikrantdhanavade8005 पर फिर भी। क्योंकि बस एक शिक्षक गिटार नहीं बोल सकता, ये उसकी बुद्धि को नहीं दर्शाता। क्या वो शिक्षक सही से नहीं पढ़ाता था? आप हमे ये बताए।
Me: Complaining about Indian professors leaving India.
Also Me: Doing Internship in RIKEN.
Are you IITIAN brother??
@@PeterWayne77 No, and even if you are you can't get accepted at RIKEN
@@PeterWayne77 As Riken allows only those who have completed their education from an Institute associated with it
@@PeterWayne77 And there is no Indian Institute in the list of RIKEN, And for surprise there are 2 Pakistani Institutes in list
@@Apurv007 NUST is on its list? And lums btw i m from pak but want to study abroad however even the unis in europe have a lower qs rankin then the ones in pak
I am not a big intellact but after graduation i am thinking contantly about leaving this country forever and settle somewhere in north america or western europe.
But finances does not allow.
Now, this nation feels like a big jail where we can not speak anything about truth in public.
Because research facility,respect,lifestyle and science community is very good there.Not only this international recognition becomes easy when you are in such country.
I have heard that a few Universities who cannot hire a professor ask *post graduation students to take classes while paying them the fees of a safai worker* . the rest salary goes in the pockets of authorities..
In India people really know how to protest and make the government struggle in doing development activities. Great 👍
At the end of the day, these academicians need a good life and a good salary, in the early decades of independence in our country , that just wasn't there, so they left. Now things are better for sure, but a long way to go, hopefully our bright minds stay here and realise the full potential of country.
The most important thing is the freedom to do what they want in their subject. A person who has done a PhD in a subject CANNOT be directed by someone in the ministry who has no background in the subject whatsoever.
Science is still now fine(not for long though) but social science (like econ and pol sci) has always been strangled in India. No doubt economist leave. That's the economically and politically right thing to do XD.
At the end of the day parties which prey on the fears of people (Congress(fear of poverty), BJP(Hindu khatrein mein hai)) can never support education. That's an economic equilibrium. Academia can only thrive in a liberal society
yes bhai. i am a 16 year old student, when all students of my age don't know what to do, or get in the herd of pre-defined paths for good jobs, i want to be an astrophysicist....
its my childhood dream, as i only think about the universe, as it is the supreme thing, the actual reality....
but but.... also i want the credit to go with my country India, and not some other country (note: i think some might think that why work in india when universe can be studied anywhere, for that country doesn't matter, but for me it also matters ! )
i want to lead a good life in India with my family
but research and salaries are not good, this demotivates me for the fact that ----> why should i study for 10-12 years and get phd etc. and still get paid less with lesser opportunities, when studying nicely now and that too for just 4-5 years can get me a high paid job? this bothers me.
now some might say do whatever you want to do dont see all this and blah blah.... well what will i do then, sit at home with phd in hand that too in ASTRONOMY !!! wtf :(
i want to earn nicely, and lead a good life amongst my countrymen, and i want all my tax money to go to India, i want to really see India as a true superpower, not the SO CALLED SUPERPOWER WITH HINDUTVA GOONS :\
pata nhi kya hoga desh ka, by the way India is a young country (as per citizens age)... so many people are educated and still unemployed and unhappy, LAGTA HAI EK CIVIL WAR YA REVOLUTION AANE HI WAALE HAI JAB MAIN 30 KA HO JAUNGA !!!
Panik :(
Our education focuses on lessening the burden on students, but increasing the burden on teachers, with their exploitation. Teachers are forced to go to schools and to take online classes from there, expected to do all the accounts and management work themselves with literally half the pay they were getting. The conditions of the teachers are not good, especially the primary school teachers.
Lessening the burden on students... Bro u serious get into any engineering clg and students will tell u
Our professors treat us like literal garbage for no reason
One of my professor threw someone's journal only because he drew the diagram on the second page and not on the left hand side of the first
He literally had to redraw tht whole bs within 10 mins to get some stupid marks
Faculties say themselves tht they want their lives to be easier so it is expected from students to suffer by doing bs assignments which r copy pasted
These assignments (weekly) for 5 theory subject and 5 practical makes 10 assignment/practical submission per week
Which makes no sense faculties already know the content of it is copy pasted so they don't even bother looking into it
There r few exceptions but the odds of such professors who genuinely do their work and teach with passion r rly hard to find
i Think people in comment section have taken his message in a wrong way
he is spreading awareness to make the place a better place , not encouraging to leave the place
many people who pursue research that is Bsc Msc leave india and pursue higher studies from abroad.
what else can we expect when
the salary of research people is very less in india ? 😓
In india Top University is whatsapp University
So These Professors didn't qualify
What's whatsapp university?
@@tiredboy4168 It is a sarcastic way to tell people who learn from whatsapp forwards
Isn't it feels broken to see person's who can mould india in better way were sent out....i jus googled Abhijit Banerjee he's now a india-born naturalized American economist💔
I have worked for four years in a pharmaceutical company in India under low salary, exploitation, reservation, company politics, poor labor laws. In the end, I move to Japan for a better life!
Have a good life
Best decision brother 👍👍
Nice decision
they are cases of exploitation and company politics in japanese companies too against foreigners specially south asians. not every grass is greener on the other side
Away from family and ur birthplace for quality. Congrats may god u sucess and u know after many year how ur sucess ia going to turn into ash in ur mouth. Mark my words.
Man you are doing a great job by making such amazing videos and reaching out this knowledge to general public
Keep it up
I know it takes a lot of effort to do such research work for making such video