For All Mankind - Moon Marines vs Russians
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 22 апр 2021
- (Season 2 Finale)
With two of the Marines currently stationed at the lithium mining site, the rest of the three Marines at Jamestown Base decide to launch a counteroffensive in an attempt to draw the invading cosmonauts out of the base. The resulting skirmish leaves the nuclear reactor malfunctioning, with it beginning to overload. 
Игры
![NOSFERATU - Official Teaser Trailer [HD] - Only In Theaters December 25](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/b59rxDB_JRg/mqdefault.jpg)
My teammate just got hit, let me just casually walk toward him with my gun pointed at the floor
Right? Like whatever
I completely agree. I don't understand his logic there
Thats what i was thinking, you’d think they would know a thing or two about clearing angles too
my friend just got downed,
i revived him now we're heading southbound
Just revive him🙄🙄😒😒
All of a sudden I understand why the keeping space demilitarized is such a huge thing - out in the harsh vacuum of space, there is simply no room for screw-ups, let alone for hostile foreign relations.
There’s always a secret gun locked away in a safe somewhere 😀. It’s no secret that they have been trying to but bases on the moon since B U S H Admin, and mine for resources! Even nuked a part of the 🌙 long ago! Old documentaries suggest in early missions, they saw UFO around, and saw something on the moon, and were warded off! Reason why they left and stopped going for a while!
@@mdarks4117 the funniest shit I've seen in a while, thanks.
@@mdarks4117 Soviets did brought guns to space though. But their purpose is to fend off hostile animals back on earth once the cosmonauts land in a forested region in the soviet union where they have wait to get rescue.
@@redrevise4668 it's still done in today's Soyuz missions.
@@redrevise4668 they even brought a defensive cannon on a space trip once, presumably to fend off American invasion... They test fired it once as well.
What's funny is these marines are actually former fighter pilot. Marine naval aviator are required to undergo infantry training before entering flight school
I feel like people forget this, they’re not random grunts pulled from combat units, they’re fighter pilots who became astronauts and then had to become soldiers
ALL Marines regardless if they are the cook, mechanic or a clerk has basic infantry training. These guys should have been training constantly while on the moon JUST in case this may happen.
Why is that funny? Every pilot goes through basic weapons and SEAR, VFMA guys are no more experienced. Only difference is they fly shittier jets.
@@Excalibur01 They have been training but their mission to take the mining site was pushed forward so they are still way undertrained. This kind of combat really requires someone with the skill set and training of a Navy SEAL since they know how to tactically operate in difficult and confusing environments. These guys operate at the skill level of a cadet pulled from a military academy and sent to the front lines They know the basics and theory of combat but are woefully unprepared for the real thing.
@@przemekkozlowski7835 I would be less critical with them, this is what the first time ever of humans having a battle in outer space, there is alot of unknowns that no one is able to take into account until certain events happen, trial by error.
"We're sending it to space, don't you think we should put a laser or something on it?"
"Nyet. Rifle is fine."
Laser sights didn't exist back in the height of the Cold War, so the "gear" he was equipped with are fine tbh
@@basesttoilets This part of the show is set in 1983. The first practical weapon laser sight was the LPC Model 7, which entered production 1978. There wouldn't be anything anachronistic about a laser sights in this scene.
🤦
@@xxfalconarasxx5659Just because they existed didn’t mean they were common
@@matthewjones39 It's the space program and it is set in an alternate history universe where technology has advanced significantly more than it did in our universe. They can get laser sights if they really wanted them.
Chad cosmonaut going full auto as soon as he knows he is going to die
Which is kinda weird since it takes a bit more fine control to set an AK to full auto.
@@Excalibur01 I'd recon he was in full auto the whole time and only tapped the trigger, or he did actually manage to push it back up to full auto when he get's hit. His AK also lacks a buttstock as you also see on AK's found in police cruisers in russia, so they can be fired from the car or any other tight room. That does take some good training to do effectively.
He probably was more heavily trained than his comrades. Perhaps VDV or even KGB Spetznas. Without the afghanistan war, those would probably seek out other opportunities to be at the tip of the spear again.
@@jamesmortimer4016 It's possible that these guys were sent to the moon in anticipation of a stand off with America. Also it's not stockless. The stock is folded. Also weird that none of these are AK74s but AK47s
@@Excalibur01 It's a weird mix. The stock and dustcover are 74, the muzzlebreak and mag look more AKM but 7.62 would make more sense anyways and the AKMS used to bw the go too weapon for vehicle crews before the 74u came along... Far more interesting, the full stock version one of the cosmonauts is carrying is black...
Seems like the guys in the props department spwnd most of their time on the M16's
he also manages to take some vital systems with him
Call of Duty: For All Mankind
Imagine that terror. That the only way you can deal with a threat is if you see it, no way to contact anyone outside your comms system and if something comes from behind you’re done. The silence would be deafening
Refund activision so they can make this, and if they manage to somehow make a game of "increase tension, deplete of pants" atmosphere, then id say its a good idea
Assasian creed : for all mankind
after cold war I kinda don't want any game
I need that!
God it's amazing how they got the obsolute silence of space warfare down. Literally terrifying
Was about to say how scary armed warfare in space is..
Must’ve been a real saving grace for the budget 😏
Space Marines are now real. If we don’t get real footage a trainees shooting on the moon Imma riot.
to be honest you would hear something, each gunshot expel some gaz and they reach you pretty quickly. The sound is different tho.
There is also a more indirect way of transmiting sound via the ground and the walls you touch (even if its very very low volume).
You would NOT hear anything, the gas expelled is extremely tiny and would expand and dissipate....To the person firing you MIGHT “hear” something when you fire due to the vibrations traveling up your suit to your helmet...The expanse nails it with talking in space by touching the helmets together so the sound waves from their voice travel through the helmet.
This is why you don't fire guns in a God damn spaceship
Or near a moonbase
This is why you cover avenues of approach
This is why you don't militarize space in the first place
Or you use shotguns instead of rifles. Someone didn't watch "Outland".
@@danielpickrell8311 The dude didn't provide rear security. Rookie mistake
“COD: Ghosts” memories are coming back.
That game was fucking stupid though. Cod ww2 was infinitely better
@@nickz5849 Nah, Every CoD Campaign is better then any Battlefield
@@nickz5849 Ghosts was a good game better than ww2
@@nickz5849 ghosts was way better. I wish there was a sequel tho.
Ghosts was too random of a cod. It didnt tie in any of the previous cods. The only reason it came out was because they *had* to make a new cod for that year cause the date was coming up. It was so unnecessarily random
Moonrines vs Spacenaz, fixed the title for ya XD
this. please put this
i really dont know what they execpeted lmao... normal marines vs spetznas lmao... they would get mopped and did get mopped
@@UniversalPlaysPage Yeah they should’ve sent SEALS. SEALS would’ve more easily adapted to the new environment and given Spetznaz a run for their money
Comment of the Year goes to this....👏👏👏
@@angadsingh9314 Real life isn’t a video game. You don’t have stat tables on spetsnaz and SEALs and throw it together to see who wins. None of what you think matters, actually matter, and you don’t even know what spetsnaz means. You realize there’s like a dozen different groups that are spetsnaz? It’s just a blanket term for “special forces”
Somewhere, sometime, a drill sergeant is yelling at a recruit to wait for the damn firing solution.
your a men of culture
Ah, whenever I visited the Citadel, I had to listen to that Drill instructor hammering his recruits on firing solutions
@@julianW1993 "THAT IS WHY SERVICEMEN CHUNG WE DO NOT "EYEBALL IT""
As we all know,
SIR ISSAC NEWTON IS THE DEADLIEST SONOFABITCH IN SPACE!
I like how they’re using m4’s that looks specifically made for space combat but the russian was just using a standard AK, I guess in every universe AK’s are extremely reliable
Da, rifle is fine.
😂😂I never realized that till now. 😂😂😂😂
Lmao
Comrade, should we upgrade rifle to fix ergonomic issues, or at least add some upgrades for space combat? NYET! RIFLE IS FINE!
they look like pretty normal m16s to me, aside from the few gizmos they got on there
Damn amogus 2 looks pretty epic ngl
Moorines Sus
When Red (Army) sus
cant esacpe gaame
A- moon- gus
Lmfao
“Vance is down”
Proceeds to walk towards where Vance got shot from.... without raising said rifle.
Dumb series
That's my PUBG logic when i saw my downed teammate and rushed towards him, without healing of drinking, not paying attention to my surroudings, while my gun is holstered behind me, with my other 2 teammates very far away, that's why I lost so many times playing Classic.
They ought to get some competent military advisors on this show ...
like any military commander would be able to tell you how to properly fight... in large, cumbersome space suits in an environment where your only form of sensory is your eyes.
@@BenMan8881 You can't even look around without turning your entire body. Most earthside infantry training would just give you loads of bad habits: Vance probably counted on being able to hear the Russian coming ; Coupled with the lack of drill, that killed him more than anything else.
@@paulzuk1468 what killed him was his lack of control over his area of responsibility. In small team in an area where blue for does not control access, you maintain security in every possible direction, including the direction you came from.
Vance stupidly maintained a low security posture down a corridor where an eye and barrel already pointed instead of watching the flank.
The other idiot in his team saw his buddy go down and for some reason, which only makes sense to POG and noncombatants, held his weapon at low ready instead of shouldering his rifle.
Either they sent incompetent personnel to respond to this emergency or they sent incompetent and untrained personnel to this emergency.
I'm not making a shot at you, but this scene hurts my blue cord and embarrasses the Marines they are supposed to portray.
@@infblu3808 I can't really disagree, but...they were, in fact, all POGs :)
@@infblu3808
I mean, those guys panicked and shot to death an unarmed civilian not as far as two episodes ago without actually seeing clear and present threat, i. e. weapon. Clearly their training is very lacking.
As the wise medic once said: "Zis is your fault..."
Exactly
Amature hour. Rear guard not even looking at the rear, russian going lone wolf. AMATURE HOUR
I know right! I was like, REAR SECURITY, ASSHOLE! Watch your 6!
Well it was the crap Marine that shot an unarmed Cosmonaut that started this mess.
These guys aren't actually marines, they're simply astronauts who are qualified marine aviators. That also explains why they handled that situation earlier so poorly.
@@RashaKahn That Marine was justified. I'm not saying it was right but it was justified under the circumstances. The Russians didn't have to escalate. They were not justified in a full on assault.
@@nikolakaravida4087 Marine Aviators are still Marines. All Marines no matter what jobs they go on to do had to undergo basic training, which includes combat training.
i wanna see gigantic battle with thousands of US space marines and 1000s of russian space soldiers.
Watch the space battle in Moonraker. Equally horrifying.
watch moonraker...lol
We all know it wouldn't work like that.
@@Excalibur01 just like that
ruclips.net/video/jwsRFHKXH84/видео.html
Space is more for research and science rather than our political problems and nationalities. That is why no country can claim a planet as their own.
So Tracy couldn't find a flashlight or anything. Also what kind of Marine wasn't watching his corners? He was tunnel vision in one direction and didn't watch his ass. He knew he couldn't hear anything and his head should have been on a swivel the whole time. Also they should NOT of had their lights on, that gives away their positions.
@RingSight91 Then what was Gordo using to light stuff with in that scene?
This show is dumb
@@memeneuver8821 yes it is
@@Excalibur01 no it’s not it was just a dumb thing for Vance to do
Keep in mind these aren't regular ground Marines
They were Marine aviators, pilots. They're not experts on ground combat, let alone in a vacuum with a bulky suit.
ridiculousness of this whole show aside, when the guy on rear security doesn't do his job...
Yeah, no kidding.
to be fair, he can't hear anything outside of his suit, so there's not a whole lot he can realistically do if he doesn't actually see the threat
@@Tank50us you raise a fair point, but thats also exactly why he should still be looking at the rear, where no one has eyes on, especially when thats the main way in and out of the complex
@@Tank50us Rear guard focuses on the rear, this is 6-year old stuff.
@@Tank50us The fact that he can't hear what's behind him makes it even more important to use his eyes to look behind him CONSTANTLY
Moonrine VS Spacenaz
No, soviet kosmodesant (spaceborne troops).
Or Voiska Kosmicheskogo Basirovanya (space-based troops)/ KDV - Kosmicheskie Desantnye Voiska (space landing forces)/Sily kosmicheskogo naznacheniya - kosmnaz (Space forces)/ Group " K" or "L" (GRU).
And IRL (I think so) moonrine and soviet troops prefer melee combat (and Soviet laser revolvers).
@@user-wn7bp1oh3k it was a joke...
Lols
@@user-wn7bp1oh3k tried at first космодезант but космодесант seems better.
Hipster fuck vs. real shit.
Hipster fuck loses.
Fuck Apple.
This here was by far one of the most impactful shootings on TV.
And the reason is simple. It's not over the top. It's very reductive in fact. Yet it felt more impactful becuase of context and the nature of it being silent. Very well done, this scene resonated with me exactly as I imagine the directors wanted it to
And this is why if history went down this road, they'd have the option of putting in magazines loaded with frangible ammunition. Designed to break up on a bulkhead but penatrate anything less. Boarders may not give a shit, but you don't want to turn your own station into swiss cheese while defending it.
Fun history fact. In ww2, the US made a .30-06 frangible round for anti air practice. A specially armored plane would tow a target soldiers would shoot at. Major pucker factor, but from what I read, it actually worked.
we all know this spacenaz with AK is very cool even it kills 2 people in a unpressurized moonbase
spacenaz vs moonrines
@@jimmywest8684 dude with AK was like defensing bomb in dust 2 while 1vs3 clutch
In that vacuum, you are dead, instantly, not even time to feel pain.
The gun splatter on the mask would not happen, it all exits through any puncture site and all your body fluids go straight to gasses.
The reverse happens in steel pressure suits, the very high water pressure debones your skeleton and forces any soft tissue into your steel helmet, through the tiniest pinhole, anywhere on the suit. All it needs is a hole, large enough for molecules of H2O to pass through.
@@jmikronis7376 i am sorry my problem. My english level is a little bit low. I was confused about pressurized/unpressurized (forgot the meaning of un-). Finally you are right
@@jmikronis7376 .. no?
The nice reality is, actual astronauts and cosmonauts are probably the friendliest people around. They would see each other as fellow pioneers, doing great things for science.
But then again. In this show they're not really friendly scientists astronauts. They're marine pilots sent to space. Plus it's the height of the cold war.
Basically all im saying is that I dont think irl Chris Hadfield would be so cool to the idea of fighting other fellow astronauts.
yeah, i really dislike the whole idea of astronauts with guns
Same pov here. I doubt that there would be any fighting up there nor would there really be a point. Since this isn’t some imperialist proxy war that the USSR and USA could play chess with, it would be a bit more catastrophic and dangerous.
Astronauts with guns is also a really terrible way to conduct lunar warfare. Spacesuits are terribly bulky. I also feel that in this setting America should probably have anticipated a Russian attack and prepared their defenses a little better, at least if they're sending up Lunar Marines. It is extraordinarily expensive to send stuff to the moon.
Then an american astronaut shot an unarmed soviet cosmonaut, we all know which one started the jamestown crisis.
@MARSbar
RE: "They're marine pilots sent to space."
Why would Marine pilots be sent to the moon to fight a ground action? Why not Marine infantry?
I am watching this again. The Russians were being smart. They had NO lights on, not even their head lights. The Marines have both the lights on the rifles on and the lights on their suits. They might as well be painting a target on their fucking heads. Once Lopez noticed Vance was down, he should have either pied the corner better or took cover and waited for the Russian to come to him, at least getting down to a knee so he can be more stable with shooting.
@Vladimir Putin Exactly. They're making the US look more bad guys than the Russians, which is bullshit
@Vladimir Putin Right, that's why the Russian was wandering around completely alone.
The US is idiotic...
@@aurora5422 Then stop using the US social media
@@Excalibur01 Nope. The social media is for all people. because the world doesn’t revolve only around Americans
I guess this means Webster and Lopez are going to be teaching new platoons of moonrines because they are now the undisputed experts at space combat.
God help them
@@Excalibur01 the first thing you need to do is take your helmet off and stand in front of the reactor control computer...
Top bad they didnt fo anywhere further other than killing off Lopez off screen
the M16A2s the moon marines have are probably highly modified, whereas the russian AKs are probably just normal AKs lmao
Minus using wood for some parts on the AKs and are using high grade material like the ARs.
@@CTC41392 AKs are typically made of carbon steel while M16s are made of an alloy
It's actually not entirely A2s. You can tell the carrying handle rear sight is an A1. The stocks are from the carbines. So it's a bit of a frankengun
No need to modify an AK, it's so well designed and made it's effective everywhere, even on the moon 🤣
@@michaelspencer8024 as thousands have said,
"NYET, RIFLE IS FINE!"
I like the fact that the fire arms don't make noise, because of course there's no air for sound to travel, some movies still leave sound when in space and it just ruins the authenticity of it
So there would still be a little noise for whoever fired the rifle, as they would brace it against themselves. The vibration against the suit would travel through the air inside, so there would be at least some noise. But for those around there wouldn’t be any sound, as shown, just a flash, kick, and impact.
I feel like they should have had some muffled sounds though, since while there is virtually no atmosphere for sound waves to travel through, sound should still be propagating through the astronauts' bodies, and through the floors and walls of the building.
sound can still travel through solid objects so there would be some very quiet sounds
Well, that’s not quite true. The gases created by the gunpowder provide a way for sound to propagate. As long as that gas cloud reaches you, you’d hear it briefly.
Funfacts :Did you know that songs is louder than the firing of bullets in space
Well, yeah. That’s how noise in a vacuum works...
Oh wait did I not get a joke-
All my active and prior military dudes are punching the air right now watching that scene.
I'd imagine bayonets would be real handy for space combat situations especially close quarters
Are these guys really marines? like bruh where was rear security
They are not. They are regular astronauts that were pilots in the Marine Corps. They were the only people trained to go to space with gun training available and US decided to send them quickly.
Yup. There's not grunts. They're fighter pilot who happened to have basic infantry training
@@muazazman3999 real basic training for sure, but i guess being in space makes shit harder
@@Szpareq Even the cooks know infantry tactics. It's not their job but ALL Marines are riflemen. Even the most boot ass Marine knows about rear security
@@Excalibur01 “Even the most boot fucked marine knows danger close” - Generation Kill
General incompetence is surprisingly easy to slip into, even with how ridiculous this show can be. I imagine pilots would forget key CQB tactics, even basic ones, if their training was never renewed or drilled into them. Though I am fairly certain this is a case of bad writing that can conveniently be written off as incompetence, lol.
"Oh my buddy is on the ground most likely dead. The guy who shot him just be around the corner. Let me LOWER MY WEAPON as I round the corner and get shot."
Why the hell did he not keep his gun up when he rounded that corner?
Bet they would have survived if she’d stayed hidden
Fools. All of them. All of us.
ay, no full auto on the moon
Everybody astronaut knows that sound doesn't travel in space but this woman doesn't
she was desperate
they probably could have heard it through the station it self.
Well what would she have done? Just sit back and enjoy the bloodbath? Beside, marines were touching station, which can work as medium.
You could still feel vibration in taps in the vaccum
@@inigobantok1579 no, you can’t. You feel vibration (physical energy) through matter (air for example). Vacuum does not have medium to transfer physical energy through. You can however “hear” by touching something that can transmit said energy.
What a fantastic show this is, it must be one of the best shows of the last few years, but unfortunately few have heard of it.
I like how he called the americans "Moon Marines" but the Russians just "Russians"
The show doesn't really clarify what branch of the military they are part of, if they even are soldiers, and not just angry cosmonauts with guns.
@@xxfalconarasxx5659 two episodes before this the americans shot two cosmonauts so its likely the latter.
Frangible bullets were a thing in the 80s. They can puncture soft materials but shatter on anything hard.
after the crispy cosmonaut incident i am surprised that the spacenaz aren’t rocking mags full of tracer or incindiary
It's not like either side was expecting full on conflict on the moon. Things escalated
@@Excalibur01 Also, frangibles would have trouble penetrating body armor. Now, the Soviets aren't wearing any...but can you be *sure* about that? It's the Moon, space suits are heavy but not *that* heavy and could easily be uparmored. Especially the comparatively light and agile Soviet ones.
@@paulzuk1468 they would need to redesign it
Hey man can you post a video of the ending scene in season 2?
He might have some trouble with the nirvana copyright
PLEASE, can u do video with that Gordo back on moon scene? With back in black playing in background?
Always be aware of situations from various surroundings not just 1.
Ak47 cosmos model works in all conditions even in moon dirt
So easy, a child can use it, And they do.
Why was the Spacesnaz guy wandering around completely alone?
I know right. There were like 10 of them
@@Excalibur01 Exactly, you'd think they'd at least form buddy teams, not one guy wandering off solo.
He probably got pissed off and ran out alone to confront the Americans. I'm pretty sure he was the Russian Commander too if I'm putting the plot together I've seen through clips.
@@bloodraven1190 In the same episode earlier, the Russian commander said to leave that hallway a vacuum to cover their flank, so they were aware of it. You don't "run out alone" in a space suit.
@@Excalibur01 Didn't catch that part, my bad.
"It's Nerf or Nothing!" Not just a good ad slogan, but sound advice for settling disputes while surrounded by hard vacuum ;)
i like how tracy still tried to talk to them and make noise from inside the room even though they wouldnt be able to hear her because of no air
Possibly the worst display of basic common sense ever created why was no one watching the rear in a battle.
He should of had his eyes glued to the rear because he couldn't hear around the corners. And also TURN YOUR FIGHTING LIGHTS OFF!
OMG 😮 not the nuclear reactor primary cooling pump!!!
If it's the "primary" cooling pump, that implies there's a secondary/backup cooling pump. So I can only assume that everything turned out fine.
@@OphisUK could also mean there are more than one pump and they need it all
instead of making it 1st pump or 2nd pump
Well I just watched the episode in full. There was a secondary back up pump but it had been re rerouted to something else secretly!!
@@OphisUK it's possible that the primary cooling cycle is itself cooled by a secondary one. Neither is redundant.
@@IblameBlame It's cooling pumps all the way down.
Okay I have to rant for a second, many of you may think that them using no sound is more scientifically accurate it's not. Sound can still be transmitted through the surfaces that they're standing on and or contacting. If you want a good example of this watch the expanse the demonstrated excellently. When she was tapping on the window when he was leaning against it he would have heard her hitting the door. He would have also been able to hear the footsteps and the movement through his shoes due to the vibration transmitted.
I like how the guns actually don’t make sound, it makes everything much more realistic
The minor characters in For All Mankind are more interesting and memorable than the main characters in Star Trek Discovery.
My friend has one of those Tarkov Adidas Altyn helmets, but damn, he gonna be jelly if I get a spacenaz one
note to NASA: put radios in every room, like Star Trek.
The cosmonauts are in a far better position. They've all likely had more firearms experience to begin with, they're also using shorter, stockless long arms inside what is a very cramped CQB environment. Their suits and helmets, whilst perhaps being less advanced and intricate are never the less considerably less bulky in what is effectively room clearing and corridor work.
I wouldn't agree that they're any less advanced ; Building ANY suit capable of this level of mobility on EVA, no matter how crude-ish looking, requires advanced materials and design. More advanced than we currently have in the original timeline, in fact.
Their suits and helmets are idiotic: a takeoff and reentry suit with a high altitude interceptor helmet. In season 1 the Soviet cosmonaut wore a realistic spacesuit very similar to the real world Soviet lunar suit.
@@IblameBlame I have a feeling it's done for no other reason other than to make the astronauts and cosmonauts completely distinguishable for the sake of the show which is a shame because they wouldn't have looked completely similar anyway.
@@CoffeeFiend1 exactly. It's an insult to the viewer's intelligence. In season one the Soviet suits we're kinda orange-beige while the US ones were white. Different national, agency and mission patches on the suits helped to distinguish between them.
@@IblameBlame What if the Soviets here just chose to go with the helmet design?
This scene is so funny, the astronauts falling over and not being able to hear the bullets just makes it so hilarious
You don’t hear bullets firing in space.
They’re in space where there is noise you dolt. It’s not hilarious, it sad that you never were taught that.
I mean, how would you depict soldiers having a firefight in a negative atmosphere environment on a hard sci-fi show?
you'd think the nuclear reactor coolant pump wouldn't be run by a single IC
You'd think it would scram at the first sign of trouble.
It actually wasn't, there was another one as redundancy.
Man, Season 2 was so cool.
What you really need is some lights on the side of your helmet that fail to illuminate anything but do one hellava job in giving away your own position
Why russians, not soviets? There were 15 republics in USSR, and Russia was just one of them. There could be latvian, kazakh or ukrainian cosmonauts.
And why are US citizens are called americans? There are 50 states in the USA, they should be called Texans, californians and so on
You think the Soviets would send other people not Russians into space to represent them?
@@Excalibur01 US brainwashing mashine works great, as far as i can see. 4th russian cosmonaut was born in Ukraine
@@user-qn3xu5ee3t they actually did in real life
@@Excalibur01 ussr sent lots cosmonauts of other nationalities, not just russians. You should check it
It's like she's trying to do Matthew mcconaughey but failing miserably.
What's considered as Matthew-McConaughey-ing?
@@thestudentofficial5483 Her voice?
@@thestudentofficial5483 I think he's referring to that one scene in the movie Interstellar at the end. Not gonna spoil it for you if you haven't watched it.
@@taiyipan3138 I've watched Interstellar so many times but still don't get what 1340 meant 😅
@@thestudentofficial5483 not 100% but it could be the part in the tesseract where Cooper was trying to talk to his past self and Murphy??
Ah yes, literal astronauts completely forgetting that sound does not in fact travel through the vacuum of space... wtf
Grazie per aver pubblicato queste scene tratte da questa grande e fantastica serie TV che in Italia non credo sia ancora disponibile. Ciao !!!
I have already looked in Russia. Moreover, it has already been translated into Russian.
c'è su Apple TV (è prodotta da Apple) ed è anche doppiata in italiano.
@@MattiaMonticelli Grazie !!! Non lo sapevo !!!👍👍👍😉😉😉Ciao !!!👋👋👋
C'è in Italia, non spoilerarti niente.
Guardala su Apple TV+, hai 7 giorni gratuiti o se hai un dispositivo apple acquistato da poco 1 anno gratis, poi 4.99€ al mese.
@@matteoclementi Another reason to learn Russian, we have everything for free, legally and 4 hours after the example in the USA. Italy, what are you doing?
The entire moon is available with just a few people on it, yet they fight over the smallest territories.
They didn't really fight for a territorie, they breached in there to get one of the Russians Cosmonauts which got injured by the Americans.
There was verified water in Shackleton Crator, a major component for longevity on the moon. The cost to scout out other locations would be astronomical.
it’s the only crater with water: the stuff that plants crave
@@brauliob hehe astronomical. because theyre in space
@@brauliob so it cost less to start a nuclear war over this, instead of just looking in some other places.
" he just shot him"
You mean like y'all shot those 2 unarmed cosmonauts on a peace mission?
They probably think this was unwarranted too, tsk tsk tsk.
Who the fuck puts a piece of paper in a giant, armored,, metal case that takes 10 seconds to reach into?
good idea to go around with a flashlight when visual is the only way of acquiring location of target xD
where do i watch this?!
Gordo had a fucking flashlight. Tracy should have asked for it and used it to signal Vance to watch his 6
Bro, pls stop looking at every little mistakes that have been made. It is ment to be a tragedy and those won't happen when everything went perfect.
@@magomadr It's not nitpicks. It's just bad writing for the sake of drama
They ought to have short carbines for inside the base, those A2s are too long.
I mean its hastily ordered to retake the base so they don't really have an option.
Hell maybe in the next season where it probably take place in the 90s, they'll send US Astroanuts with rifles fit for CQC and the M16s due to the fact that most of the moon is b a r r e n and thus it'll have some use but something like a MK-18 or something would be used for Moon Base Security
@@hamoodhabibi1579 yeah, what I mean is I dont think you need a full length rifle even outside on the rocks, a short Colt Carbine would've been more ideal. The cosmonauts can fold the stock on their AKs, which is handy for inside the modules
@@hamoodhabibi1579 Shorty M16s did exist in this time period. In fact because in space, there is no air and gravity is less, they could actually use short M16s better like the Colt M733 or 723. There are several examples of the time period.
I love the fact theres no sound except for what they are saying over the radio. No one gets that right.
Goodbye Bob T-T
I guess they didn’t bring frangible bullets
They probably weren't accounting for a fight in close quarters
Lmao wporst marines ive ever seen, dude even told him to make sure to watch his sector dont get famous, and then he doesnt watch his lmao
Rear security isn't watching his rear...fucking amateur hour
Is this before they shot to cosmonauts or after
If you gonna fight in space...be ready for space
MoonMarines vs SpaceNaz
Just a short thought, due to the impracticality of shouldering an m16 while in a space suit, wouldn't the sights be more, open, like an eotech or something?
Optic laser sights weren’t really that advanced or miniaturized back then, but those would be far more practical.
Bear in mind this is the 1980's
Standard issue rifles didn't have optics
It would be impossible to get behind any sight in the American style space suits if the rifle had a stock. The Russian guy had it right using a gun with no stock so he could aim down sights
Hey let’s go into a fire fight but not watch my back and just act like I’m in a laser tag battle
Turn your goddamned head, even an 8-year old playing paintball knows to look around.
Except you can't. Your peripheral vision in a space suit is blocked...you'd have to turn your entire body to look around
Bruh, this happened because they shot unarmed Russians trying to reach for a translator card
@F Off I like your reasoning
No sounds in space. Got it, The Expanse? Try this before claiming yourself the most realistic sci-fi show ever.
Yet this scene shows just how unrealistic it is. The space part is right but soldiers never operate like that. Marines and Army grunts would never make a mistake like that.
there are no sounds in spane in The Expanse...
@@Predator42ID I mean, okay, this is probably the writers not caring all that much, but on the other hand can you *really* claim that they would *never* make a dumb mistake?
Like, seriously, remember how SEALs storming Patilla Field in Panama decided to not take any rifles with them? Because pfffft no way these dumbass panams could possibly spot us ELITE COMMANDOS approaching the hangars!
And remember, those aren't really grunts, they're aviators pressed into the role of infantry because the US needed a few rifles on the Moon RIGHT NOW and these were the only astronauts with any infantry training at all. Sure, every marine a rifleman yadda yadda yadda but these skills are perishable, if you don't drill them you lose them. Plus, the environment is *incredibly* different, most infantry training would give you bad habits for the Moon: for example, most soldiers rely heavily on their hearing, but on the Moon *there is no sound*, so you literally can't hear the other guys coming ; Your peripheral vision is heavily limited in the suit, too, and you really can't "look around" without turning your entire body.
@@paulzuk1468 But that would make it even more so. These Marines would be so paranoid at every corner and be constantly looking behind them.
@@Excalibur01 I mean...yeah, but then again I've read about people who dropped incredibly important safety precautions because they were a minor inconvenience. If people can neglect locking out controls before crawling into deadly factory equipment, I bet some Marines could start to look arround less than they should because they have to turn like 50kg of suit every time they do.
And so, five years into the future, Vance's death will be the cause of USMC drill instructors yelling at recruits every time they get lazy like that :P
But as I wrote above, the writers probably didn't go that granular when considering the choreography of the entire thing, so it's just fun speculation.
I’m so tired of uber incompetent militaries in media man
This would be a great training for exactly what not to do in CQB
so in the title they're just Russians but we're moon marines? Aka in soviet Russia space is not empty but pure ruski
Because all soviet People were called russians
It's not what they meant
But that US troops are called Moon Marines and Soviet ones are just called Russians
Make you think that Soviets did not send any Space Spetsnaz on the moon, just regular Russians
the US troops were called moon marines because they were marine aviators selected for a deployment on the moon
Soviets likely had a similar name, but one they didn't deign to announce, the marines never announced they were marines to the Soviets either
Man these replies... just one major SWOOOOOSH
How cool if this is an "among us" game
Fuck no.
shut up please
Cringe but like not long ago a Russian cosmonaut and American Astronaut had a fight resulting in the Cosmonaut getting badly wounded.
I want a game of this
But should the recoil throw them away? Or are those not fire gun
Who was the initiator of the conflict in these series?
P.S. So basically all sides messed up big time. Just like in real life. Surprisingly grey for american series featuring soviet union...
P.P.S. Thanks to everybody answering! I hope that such events will never go out between our countries!
USA
@@johoreanperson8396 like always....
If you want to go back to the beginning of time, the Russians started it by stealing our mining site and then we took it back and then they decided to set up something over the site, which can be only seen as spying or at the very least, trespassing. We told them to fuck off but instead of raising their hands in surrender or gesture that they aren't a threat, the Russians instead back away towards a box, open the box and reach inside it. Marines didn't take the chance and shot them.
@@Excalibur01 both sides kind of fucked up lol
> USA set up secret Lithium mine
> Since it's secret and undeclared, any seizing is technically not "stealing" because "nobody own it" in the first place, so USSR did that
> USA, who is angery, dropped some marines on the mine. USSR having no weapons retreated.
> But USSR still decided to mess around the mine, setting up something which prompted investigation by the marines. Cosmonauts told the marines they weren't doing anything sus but get shot, 1 dead, 1 in custody.
> USSR decided to go full Call of Duty on USA
Голливуд в войнушку не наигрался...((
Да
Да(
Опа, таки нашёл коммент. на русском. 🙂 Читал некоторые комм.-ии выше на английском, некоторые критикуют. А как кино - пойдёт, даже вон звук стрельбы отрубили, чтобы реальнее была киношка.
Space Spetsnatz my beloved
Soviet Union... No way.
Moon Marines vs One Russian.
1:45 pretty sure that was some kind of war crime
No war crimes in space
Not really. You are allowed in the rules of combat to finish off the enemy. Cops aren't allowed to finish off a suspect.
@@donjon5442 In space no one can here you crime.
@@Excalibur01 actually thats not true in combat if the enemy is alive before he hits the ground you therefor how to render aid no matter what
No its not? They are just double tapping him.
an intro to space combat...
the other scene where the russian tried to grab a translation card was sad like ik they're bad and all but what if they needed extra water food and or fuel? it just breaks my heart
I am more disappointed that the Marine didn't get to use the 203. Would have loved to see what a 40 mike mike does in space
They should behave pretty much the same as they do on Earth, but without the pressure wave (because no atmosphere). The energy of the 40mm round would be converted into heat/light and kinetic energy of the fragments. The lower gravity would also help the fragments travel further. So no shockwave or noise, but more severe and widespread damage from the fragments. Maybe it would be like getting hit with a shotgun round.
Pretty sure it would be really dangerous. The shrapnel could fly back at you.
@@nikolakaravida4087 Then why give a Marine a grenade launcher if they never wanted him to use it?
@@Excalibur01 parachute flares...
@@davidthompson7723 parachutes in a vacuum
To tell you the truth I'm Sporting for the russians
They ended up loosing i guess lol
lmao when they were shot through the window they would instantly all die from lack of oxygen and certainly would not be able to escape.
“Don’t get famous” is one of the most deep lines I think I’ve ever heard in this series. Ik there are good ones, but the fact they know their death would make them “famous” is weird and sad