By far the best discussion I've watched recently. Truly bitter truths. The 10 mins summarized the problems very well. Patriots have also become chest thumping, vain, clueless, lazy people - me included. We continue to live off the glory of our ancestors - who worked very hard, more than anything else. Today, we don't even understand the meaning of "Done." The top 1% is holding the bottom 99% down. These bitter truths are bitter pills we all need to take if we want to be net generators of anything.
The current administration heads need to listen to you guys with open eyes and ears and mostly with open mind and kind heart for the sake our country's future. Thank you to Rajiv ji and Mukesh Ji 🙏
This is one of the most powerful, profound conversation ever of Rajiv Malhotra with someone, as successful and true Indian patriot and down-to-earth as Shri Mukesh Chattar, who is pained to state the bitter truths about the failure of Indian elites, politicians, industrialists, academicians, so-called intellectuals (better referred to as bankruptuals) to come to grasp with the realities, who all had their heads in the sand, who refused to see the reality, who were in perpetual denial, who have had no vision, who are not able to capitalize on the intelligence of Indians. If Narendra Modi does not watch this video, he's going to miss out on something very very profound, something that is close to his heart and something that somehow is not included in his visionary agenda. Very sad if he is not shown this. Rajiv Malhotra's love for India and his tapasya touch your heartstrings. Notwithstanding the cold-shouldering by the ruling elite for so many years whom he supported wholeheartedly since 2014, he is still not giving up in trying to reach out to them. The shrill to save India is coming straight form his heart is so loud and being echoed by so many well-meaning people, that if it does not reach Narendra Modi, it's India's complete misfortune. And, it must be made clear that a person of the extraordinary caliber like Rajiv Malhotra is born perhaps once every few hundred years. By keeping him away from Narendra Modi, the so-called patriots have caused harm to India that they profess to love.
Having lived in China for a few years, I can certainly say that business capital and entrepreneurs are available in China very easily. The government actively promotes and tacitly supports Chinese entrepreneurs to invest and setup projects in collaboration with Foreigners. This provides them with knowhow, work ethics, systems and also lends softpower as these foreigners' success stories are given wide coverage. Awards and recognition ceremonies are abundant creating an air of achievement and success. Apart from political space, one feels China ecosystem works very closely with creators to setup and excel.
Rajivji I appreciate your great concern and your efforts in highlighting India's weaknesses. It is only strong and powerful minds that will be prepared to face and overcome it. You are awakening like minded Indian's around the world. Thank you.
So spot on. Education has devolved, indian schools and colleges do more harm than good. Teaching has become a career for failed graduates, it is not even just the money but bureaucracy and hierarchy. Teachers spend a lot of time and effort in confusing the student and covering up their own complete incapablities. I would prefer to have gone to a teacherless university program.
I was invited to observe a private school in India. I won't go into details out of respect for the people involved in the project. I just found it amazing to learn that some of the teachers who teach in such environments don't even know the fundamentals of their particular subject matter and this aspect is widely acknowledged by the people running the school. They told me this happens in every school in the town (and this is a popular union territory mind you, not some remote village in India). Everyone knows this problem exists across India but they feel powerless because to attract good teachers to town-schools means you have to pay them a premium and that is not possible for modest schools in the country. So in this manner, the children are often taught wrong things. The education system in India is basically a hangover from the colonial times which is why our filtered history, our concept of governance, our laws, social sciences, "moral science" and grading system etc reflect the same outdated British factory model of education. Our children are basically brainwashed from a young age to think highly about British Generals and Viceroys and Aurangazebs of the world while they learn very little about ancient Indian kings, about ancient India's own contributions to metallurgy, mathematics, astronomy, philosophy etc... so children grow up with a heavy inferiority complex and are made to think everything 'good' comes from the West. These same children who are taught some poor fundamentals in a rigid school environment are asked to "innovate" as adults which is not possible. Innovation comes from opening the door to creativity and curiosity in a child - it comes from critical thinking and creative thinking which are both there naturally in children but is suppressed by the outdated school models we have in place. Unless the way we educate our children changes radically, India will snail along in a slow pace trying to catch up to a world that is moving far ahead into AI and beyond. Unfortunately our politicians and common-man are still playing games with castes and slogans whereas communist-authoritarian-harsh regimes like China don't have to deal with redtape and corrupt bureaucratic levers to impose basic policies and laws. Here in India, to even change one small policy you need to fight for 10 months with opposition parties and the media. Just see how much drama a simple "farm law reform" created in this country. That is why we don't progress - we are still trapped in our petty divisive games and our media is only interested in adding fuel to the fire to improve its own ratings - they are least interested in seeing the country grow. Ancient India was a hub of knowledge but modern India is a graveyard for the same. I appreciate what Rajiv and others are doing in their work to educate people but I am afraid many Indians don't even have a basic awareness of these deep problems - they are busy consuming Bollywood dramas.
Gem of an interview. The best in the series. Candid views from the master visionaries. Hope the whos-who of the government wake up and smell the danger. 1. Unskilled youth could be a liability. We are tending towards Vishwa-coolie, not Vishwaguru. 2. We need to have a wholistic view from pure research to manufacturing. Integrate industry-education-research. 3. Define done at all steps from the fund allocation to implementation to ROI realization. AI based technologies will prove a bane if we don't act NOW.
Bought the AI book. Its Very interesting.i clearly Understood what is AI , machine learning , big data , how algorithms keep improving as data is fed, only after starting to read the book. Still in the 1st chapter , such an interesting read with simple, understandable explanation.
Military(Kshatriya) + Academics(Brahmin) + Industries(Vaishya) == Success ....USA N CHINESE, JAPANESE understand this. We are still stuck in mis translations of our whole ecosystem! After watching so many scholars , I found you a genuine one, Mukesh ji. I totally agree that there are many jobs which can be created very easily for common man.
As you have discussed , same we can do for agriculture industry for palm oil raw material.. the amount of important is huge ,we are consuming but not growing at home , it needs both government and corporate efforts
Rajiv ji and Mukesh ji, thank you very much for this wonderful and soul-shaking conversation and it should shake up and wake up many of us to get up and get our act together. We have a real shortage of top class visionaries, strategic and pragmatic thinkers, and leaders in many prominent fields, levels and technologies. We have many intelligent, clever and motivated individuals, but they are dispersed, fractured, lacking in certain product development skills, financial and economic skills (for example, how to generate value and capital), lacking a common platform to share their ideas a d work collaboratively, are risk averse due to the basic mindset, and thereby operating in silos and not collectively moving forward. A critical mass of confident tech leaders with risk taking appetite, who are ready to get their hands dirty in solving problems, and are capable of inspiring people is the need of the hour. We need Kalams, Dhawans, Bhabhas, Sarabhais, Swaminathans, in certain key scientific areas and we can achieve significant results.
couldn't be more bitter..It opened my eyes. I can't thank you enough for saying truth as it is. Great examples, Very informative, useful n thought provoking. Thank you so much MukeshJi and RajivJi. Waiting for more conversations like this🙏
Watch this tape several times and take seriously every word that is said. This is the critical message that the powers that be need to understand, appreciate, and, most importantly, PUT INTO EFFECT.
20:48 This point is gold. I hope this is understood by more Indians. There is no loss of dignity in absorbing from out-groups. In fact, this is the foundation of all successful societies of all time. This whole trade-off young people seem to think they _have to_ make between re-igniting the Indian civilization vs being technologically savvy is completely unnecessary. In fact, not creating a blend between the two (civilizationalism & scientific leadership) will debilitate the efforts of both pursuits. The Chinese have created a synthesis of the two & had mutually reinforcing results.
Sir, I like everything you say, but what I like most about you is, you ask or put emphasis on the right question and its answers. what are the present and clear danger, you know it very well. the sad part is India, at least in open social media not aware of it at all. therefore, I think I will try to translate your video into Bengali. so at least a portion of Indians in the local language will be able to learn about you. some other guy must do the same in Hindi, Marathi, etc local language. or else we are all doomed.
One of the best dialog I watched in a long time. We should run this in all IITs / IIMs as well as big s/w and engineering corporates for opening their eyes and motivate! For PMO and all IAS Babus, they must listen to it and given tasks to REDEFINE ‘DONE’. Thank you Rajiv Ji and Mukesh Ji!
I'm from one of the best private colleges in India. The IT education there sucked for the most part. A few professors were good, but they were the exception. My Cryptography professor made us memorize encryption algorithms rather than teach us why they were good, and how to make our own. This is just one example out of many.
I think... and with the conviction of some sort... that NaMo and his team MUST be working on it. Problem is the Indian Bureaucracy and the Highly Corrupt Opposition morons.
Knowledgeable, higher calibre ministers could have been inducted, but were deliberately excluded. The NEP is mediocre, and counterproductive, especially with the emphasis on Western inspired Humanities even in the IIT's. Niti Ayog is headed by vainglorious, low commitment Westernised Oriental Gentlemen. Political dominance over the territorial state is the obsession of the leadership. They apparently seek validation from India's civilizational enemies. No Hindu grievance be it RTE or temple management has received the slightest attention, whilst the PM is available for settlement of inter denominational disputes amongst Kerala churches. No committee to review the Colonial Marxist history. Madrasas and the communal universities receive the highest ever encouragement.
@@thrinethran2885 You nailed it Thrinethran ji. I have my own story to share.But, I must say, most Bhartiya are like that including RM. They pile up their success on the shoulders of others and ditch the supporter when they have climbed up the ladder. Chinese are dependent on State machinery, so cannot ditch and run away.
Hard Facts. extremely enlivening talk show . highly inspiring. Rich disscution on high level. India has very far to go, to achieve. This Movement Book of Artificial intelligence of yours will steer, streeger Indian intellectuals. (Somehow at present I m passified, scaptical , weather India can do upto that high)
Indians have become "Vishwakooli" instead of "Vishwaguru" -- Rajivji is just so sharp and precise in his observations! Wow, I was just blown away by this one statement.
Lack of vitality, ambition and perspective at the top. Consequent lack of education mobility and motivation for the rest. Hadn't Swami Vivekananda spoken of almost the self - same condition in the country?
viswa coolie is the right word ... this was there during British rule as well ... the Indians as British soldiers ... the clerks and baboos and the zamindars and collectors and the police and the bureaucracy
Sir, some steps had been in Lithium Batteries Sector. A new company namely Khanij Bidesh India Limited. It was incorporated by three state-owned companies NALCO, Hindustan Copper and Mineral Exploration Limited. Khanij Bidesh India Ltd will acquire strategic mineral. assets like Lithium and This company inked a pact with a firm in Argentina. Together they'll hunt for reserves. Chile and Bolivia are the two other potential sources.
What an eye opening, insightful discussion. Amazing clarity and vision. Thank you Rajivji 🙏🙏🙏 for this. Very grateful. How I wish this is viewed by PM Modi directly himself and if that happens there may be possibility of action and course correction. Otherwise it is a great great risk the country is heading to. Bankruptuals aptly summarizes most of the bureaucrats and technocrats in the corridors of power.
Rajiv jee & Mukesh Jee you both great innovative, seasonal thinkers with great vision. Educate others, change thinking but at the same time put a seed to start some thing that will produce bigger return on investment like VC fund. Involve business leaders in India. That is non linear thinking as Mukhesh jee told. You love, passion, vision are simply great. Fortunate to be part of good sangam people like you.
Narayan Murthy has invested his profits from Infosys on Cloudtail which tied up with Amazon to sells retail products ... what vision of Indian entrepreneur !
Mukesh Ji is twin brother of Rajiv ji. Fortunately he is living in Bharat and supporting our nation Rajiv ji might be living outside of Bharath but he wants our country to excel in science and technology I hope 1% of Indians who have resources listen to these advises and make Bharat great again. Jai hind.
Rajivji have you hear of (Padma Shri) Sridhar Vembu? He is working (or at least trying to) build the sorts of deep tech capabilities discussed here, from rural areas in Tamil Nadu. Would love a discussion between the both of you.
We need experienced, wise entrepreneurs like Shri. Rajiv Malhotra ji and Shri. Mukesh Chattar ji to direct and guide the Indian government programs to improve science, technology & manufacturing in India.
Sir with deep respect,Mukheshji's comment that ""Modiji is trying his best but the people around him aren't "" doesn't fly. You dont become a great leader because you work 20hours rather ur ability to identify right people put them in right positions, empower them and having the vision,conviction to deliver..these make one a good leader..I support modi, but i have to say he comes across as a big time centralized control freak..as a result after 7yrs of huge mandate you dont even see a team of 10people there..only modi and 2-3other close ministries..even nitin gadkari rajnath r cut to size..so this ardent blind bhaktism to Modi is very troubling..
Rajiv Sir, one request to you. Could you please also publish these eye opening video discussions with Hindi (and perhaps Marathi, Gujarati, Tamil & Telugu) dubbing and subtitles, just like many of the English videos of Sadhguru do, so they reach the hearts of grass root level vernacular audience across Bharat? That is bound to spread awareness and action from the right people due to deeper impact on local politicians, industry owners, decision makers and other influential people. Thank You!
Great thoughts. I am wondering how be we overhaul the administration, I was checking and came to know that only about 60 seats are available to open merit meant for IAS and the curriculum of IAS and rot that is set there how can it be rebuilt
Grants is important topic. Indian colleges have grants. But the professions have no pressure/incentive to create something. Govt puts too much money directly into college. Hence being lazy is okay. Hence the isolation is continuing. Rajiv ji touched very important topic.
It's time for all the students, universities and all technocrats should put pressure on NITI Aayog. As policy makers understand and listen to only vote banks, we all should come together and raise voice and put pressure...
The reason why your recommendations are not being implemented by the Govt, The main reason why the people surrounding Narendrabhai have big aversity to your "basic understanding", is that, the IAS parasites are ingrained with leftists ideology and they carry viral fear of losing their exclusive power they so much enjoy as the stooges of the colonial system. The only way out is to learn from Gurudev Swami Ramdev who is spearheading constant constant innovation, every day each day in Patanjali through his purushaarth. PLEASE DON'T DISOUNT HIS EFFORTS AS BUSINESS. I see tremendous innovation in his major products which are clearly several order of magnitude ahead that could survive the lethargic gravity of leftists.
Pragmatic Discussion. Thanks to both. Kindly share your thoughts on the Indian L1 mentality - Awarding projects to the lowest bidder, and asking other bidders to match L1 if they want a piece of the action.
The system described was the system in the India the richest country before British sabotaged and decimated it making India the one of the poor countries on the planet. We have to regain, reorganise and go forward. We have the capacity and what is required is a government with a vision and a commitment to achieve a goal, something that was missing for almost sixty years of governance since independence. Thankfully, Modiji is a visionary with a mind of a missionary!
We should stop calling ourselves software super power. Sir, u r right when you say that big I T companies failed to invest in future technology and remained satisfied with their high profits.
All your videos make me so mentally restless Rajiv ji! What can each individual do to change this situation ? Could you please be kind enough to make us aware what would be that I can do to try and make these bitter things into better things.
Indigenous Indian Programs like Surabhi and Turing Point have inspired generations of Indian to discover and explore. Those TV program have uplifted the whole society by shifting the perceived mindset around innovation from threat to progress. These days people are taking great interest in Culinary art because of life style channels and food video bloggers. Similarly, People are taking interest in Dance, Aerobics and Yoga. Unfortunately, India don't have quality indigenous egalitarian Discovery, Geo & Science channels. Some of the channels that exist are perceived as pseudo science and occult science such that rational minds don't connect with them.
its unfortunate that what you say is 100% true. I wanna ask what can i do as a student to contribute and help india. I wanna take matters in my own hand rather than wait for the government.
Collebratio. of academia community integrated with industry and university ... listening to this it just strikes that what are Veda teaches us .. everything is integrated ... u can’t isolate ..
Few appear better remnants of the colonial past than the Niti Ayog brass, and it is no accident that great ideas from original thinkers gather dust with, or alongside, those people.
Sir, I read a lot about Peak oil. That the petroleum reserves in the world would be depleted very soon. But I don't see any concern in the Indian think tanks. Is imminent depletion of Petroleum reserves a reality or a hoax.
Can India partner/invest in Taiwan semiconductor industry in exchange for standing with them against China? With Indian brains working w Taiwan could gain India some lost ground in semiconductors. India investing in AI, pharma, avionics, digital egovernance as your earlier guest mentioned yesterday will provide well paying jobs and help quell some of the destructive breaking India forces. Better jobs, opportunities can uplift everyone and then why would anyone want to kill the goose that lays the golden egg?
I prefer not to compete with China in areas where they are naturally and physically better. Large scale manufacturing, I prefer to leave it up to China and India focus on other areas. I see a huge scope for "entertainment/hospitality" industry in future. Indians could do a better job here.
I would rather question the premise of carbon reduction by one third .... the climate change is something that may change over hundreds of years due to several factors and that has happened in the past ... now the movement of masses to the cities are more responsible for the environmental menace than anything else ... this climate change is thus a corporate agenda and the surveillance society ... if masses were scattered in villages then the cost of surveillance would have been humongous ... we can just change the way we think about climate and then change the narrative on battery technology ... the hazard of battery waste is going to another menace and it cannot be perceived as a only thing to run after
I know my comment won't get a like but I will once again state facts. India is in league of super power now. Few examples I will share in all areas of technology that the guest pointed out. There are many many examples but I will only state a few. Materials : last year's test of drdos hypersonic missile is a shinning example. I believe india thanks to drdo is now leading the world in hypersonic technology. The successful test of drdo hyoersonic vehicle required very powerful computing capabilities to test very complex algorithms that works in hypersonic flight. Plus development of all the new complex electronics, guidance, navigation and control systems. Because electronics, guidance navigation and control system that works with super sonic missiles would fail to work in a hypersonic vehicle. All flight control laws and algorithms that work at supersonic speed which themselves are complex won't work in a hypersonic flight regime. For a hypersonic vehicle to cruise you require a scram jet engine. In this very complex propulsion system the hypersonic wind that comes into the combustion chamber has to be burnt with the fuel at supersonic speeds. Most of the time flame gets extinguished. Now drdo has succeed in developing. It is a major breakthrough in propulsion technology, aero dynamics technology and a major breakthrough in technology of materials. As hypersonic vehicle travels the temperature reaches as high as 1500 degree Celsius on the skin of the hypersonic vehicle. To sustain such temperatures drdo had to develop materials like carbon carbon silicon carbide and other wide variety of super alloys and other things who's information is not available in public domain. In order to craft such futuristic hypersonic vehicle you need very complex machinary and very highly skilled man power. Artificial intelligence : Our genius scientists have developed many advanced technologies. Mars space craft also called mom was a completely autonomous. It could take its own decisions without requiring any human intervention. As time delay between signal from mom to earth is more than 20 minutes. So our Mars space craft was capable of self diagnostics and recovery. It was capable of correcting any errors in the system by itself and executing all of its functions with remarkable precision. Looking after the health of all the sub systems components and instruments while guiding controlling and navigation space craft at the same. Plus before our Mars mission was launched the entire journey of the space craft including all of its systems how they are functioning waa simulated through very complex computer simulations. An entire path the space craft would take was chalked out. So even without going to Mars our genius scientists with help of their advanced technologies were able to simulate all of these aspects. Japan with quote unquote with far superior fabrication technololgy haven't been able to achieve such accomplishment. Chinese fiber glass mock ups as semiconductor chips. on army day this year india showcased state of the art swarm drones technology. These drones are all self aware. one drone does not follow the other drone. each drone have the ability to take their own decisions based on threat. It uses adaptive artificial intelligence, edge computing, network centric approach, satellite based technologies, remote sensing many advance sensors image processing etc really complex stuff thar even I cannot explain. Quantum technology : Drdo last year shocked the world by sucesfully demonstrating quantum communication. Secure communications are vital for defence and strategic agencies worldwide and distribution of encryption keys from time to time is an important requirement. Sharing of keys over the air or wired links requires encryption which in turn requires encryption keys to be pre-shared. The DRDO had undertaken the project for development of the technology exclusively for Indian armed forces. The work being done at DRDO will be used to enable start-ups and SMEs in the domain of quantum information technologies. The technology will also serve to define standards and crypto policies that can leverage QKD system in a unified Cipher Policy Committee (CPC) framework for more secure and pragmatic key management for current and future military cryptographic systems. Drdo has established a galium nitride foundary that will be very helpful in area of electronics, sensors , radars etc. China is a communist regime that is very insecure. People who are most insecure make most noise. Everyone wants to manufacture things in china because labour is dirt cheap and with no labour laws. Labour can be exploited to the hearts content by communist regime. Western countires are masters of propaganda and psychological warfare. China has now heavily invested in psychological warfare. They know how to win in minds of people. China hasn'twon even a single war either at land air or sea. While indian armed forces have the most decorated post world war 2 millitary history. Yet most indian believe china can actually win a war against india. Well chiense have won the war in the mind. I sincerely hope china continues to manufacture stuff for the world. Chiense have destroyed their ecology and their environment. These computer rams circuits what not is some of the most toxic industries the man has ever known. India must carefully choose what it should manufacture in large scale. And make wise decisions for our environment.
With due respect to Mukesh ji..he said Namo has that passion but others around him lack.but sir a great leader's one of the quality and success also depends on the kind of team/teams he/she builds...lot of social engineering electioneering on top of it good will towards modi is what is driving his success...othewise Modi's governance is extremely centralized around his core coterie of 4-5ministries that's it..all second rung leaders are just tweet masters..there is no institutions building, no discussions or debating ideas...just u left wing u right wing u hindu u muslim kind of twitter wars.....from tunnel to train to statues opening to satellite launching modi will be there will lot of PR..the problem we have today is lack of objective analysis on both so called right and left....I still suppport Modi, but he is also at fault on how he built his governance style and wasting mandate and time...
SIR.THE TRUTH IS ,I AM SORRY TO SAY THE GOVERNING FACTORS (PERSONNELS) ARE LACKING IN HONESTY.AND LOT OF LEAKAGE OF FUNDS & INVESTMENTS.SELFISHNESS AND NARROW MINDEDNESS.ETC.ETC.
China could do what they did in last 40 years is because they had a dictatorship rule by CCP ... there is no point in comparing that with a democracy like India who were not only poor but the nationalistic feeling s were fractured
Some wrong facts here. Indians are doing high-end work also. IBM's India team also is doing high-end work. It is wrong stereo-type that US based Indians are doing high-end and Indian people are doing only low end. IBM setting separate entity for AI and Cloud. India will have big center. But even high-end work is done for foreign roadmap. So, Vishwa-coolie is correct word, even for high-end work. Real gap is your work Rajiv ji- Real gap is low self esteem, Being Different etc. This makes big difference in having courage to chart own path. There is huge incentive for being lazy and low risk taker. The money inflation due to services sector has killed all sectors.
Bureaucracy need to change bcoz people are willing govt is willing but bureaucracy is not and biggest reason is there syllabus which is so socialist and left leaning they didn't all this
![Lethal Company Music Video 🎵 "Follow The Orders" [VERSION A]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/QeooZB4Z7RA/mqdefault.jpg)
![Twenty One Pilots - “The Line” (from Arcane Season 2) [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/E2Rj2gQAyPA/mqdefault.jpg)
By far the best discussion I've watched recently. Truly bitter truths. The 10 mins summarized the problems very well. Patriots have also become chest thumping, vain, clueless, lazy people - me included. We continue to live off the glory of our ancestors - who worked very hard, more than anything else. Today, we don't even understand the meaning of "Done." The top 1% is holding the bottom 99% down. These bitter truths are bitter pills we all need to take if we want to be net generators of anything.
I'm a Bharatian working in Germany. Every word mentioned in this conversation is true and an eye opener. My pranam to Rajivji and Mukeshji.
The current administration heads need to listen to you guys with open eyes and ears and mostly with open mind and kind heart for the sake our country's future. Thank you to Rajiv ji and Mukesh Ji 🙏
66xàdgo i
h hhhhhhhhhb
This is one of the most powerful, profound conversation ever of Rajiv Malhotra with someone, as successful and true Indian patriot and down-to-earth as Shri Mukesh Chattar, who is pained to state the bitter truths about the failure of Indian elites, politicians, industrialists, academicians, so-called intellectuals (better referred to as bankruptuals) to come to grasp with the realities, who all had their heads in the sand, who refused to see the reality, who were in perpetual denial, who have had no vision, who are not able to capitalize on the intelligence of Indians. If Narendra Modi does not watch this video, he's going to miss out on something very very profound, something that is close to his heart and something that somehow is not included in his visionary agenda. Very sad if he is not shown this. Rajiv Malhotra's love for India and his tapasya touch your heartstrings. Notwithstanding the cold-shouldering by the ruling elite for so many years whom he supported wholeheartedly since 2014, he is still not giving up in trying to reach out to them. The shrill to save India is coming straight form his heart is so loud and being echoed by so many well-meaning people, that if it does not reach Narendra Modi, it's India's complete misfortune. And, it must be made clear that a person of the extraordinary caliber like Rajiv Malhotra is born perhaps once every few hundred years. By keeping him away from Narendra Modi, the so-called patriots have caused harm to India that they profess to love.
Having lived in China for a few years, I can certainly say that business capital and entrepreneurs are available in China very easily. The government actively promotes and tacitly supports Chinese entrepreneurs to invest and setup projects in collaboration with Foreigners. This provides them with knowhow, work ethics, systems and also lends softpower as these foreigners' success stories are given wide coverage. Awards and recognition ceremonies are abundant creating an air of achievement and success. Apart from political space, one feels China ecosystem works very closely with creators to setup and excel.
Rajivji I appreciate your great concern and your efforts in highlighting India's weaknesses. It is only strong and powerful minds that will be prepared to face and overcome it. You are awakening like minded Indian's around the world. Thank you.
Shocked and truly saddened to see this video has only 600 likes after 2 weeks. We get what we deserve and I pray we will not remain coolies.
Absolutely true. Hope these series of lectures open the eyes of the people who matter.
So spot on.
Education has devolved, indian schools and colleges do more harm than good. Teaching has become a career for failed graduates, it is not even just the money but bureaucracy and hierarchy.
Teachers spend a lot of time and effort in confusing the student and covering up their own complete incapablities.
I would prefer to have gone to a teacherless university program.
ెెె
You are talking about state of private schools where as the condition of government schools is werse then that's
I was invited to observe a private school in India. I won't go into details out of respect for the people involved in the project. I just found it amazing to learn that some of the teachers who teach in such environments don't even know the fundamentals of their particular subject matter and this aspect is widely acknowledged by the people running the school. They told me this happens in every school in the town (and this is a popular union territory mind you, not some remote village in India). Everyone knows this problem exists across India but they feel powerless because to attract good teachers to town-schools means you have to pay them a premium and that is not possible for modest schools in the country. So in this manner, the children are often taught wrong things.
The education system in India is basically a hangover from the colonial times which is why our filtered history, our concept of governance, our laws, social sciences, "moral science" and grading system etc reflect the same outdated British factory model of education. Our children are basically brainwashed from a young age to think highly about British Generals and Viceroys and Aurangazebs of the world while they learn very little about ancient Indian kings, about ancient India's own contributions to metallurgy, mathematics, astronomy, philosophy etc... so children grow up with a heavy inferiority complex and are made to think everything 'good' comes from the West. These same children who are taught some poor fundamentals in a rigid school environment are asked to "innovate" as adults which is not possible. Innovation comes from opening the door to creativity and curiosity in a child - it comes from critical thinking and creative thinking which are both there naturally in children but is suppressed by the outdated school models we have in place. Unless the way we educate our children changes radically, India will snail along in a slow pace trying to catch up to a world that is moving far ahead into AI and beyond.
Unfortunately our politicians and common-man are still playing games with castes and slogans whereas communist-authoritarian-harsh regimes like China don't have to deal with redtape and corrupt bureaucratic levers to impose basic policies and laws. Here in India, to even change one small policy you need to fight for 10 months with opposition parties and the media. Just see how much drama a simple "farm law reform" created in this country. That is why we don't progress - we are still trapped in our petty divisive games and our media is only interested in adding fuel to the fire to improve its own ratings - they are least interested in seeing the country grow. Ancient India was a hub of knowledge but modern India is a graveyard for the same. I appreciate what Rajiv and others are doing in their work to educate people but I am afraid many Indians don't even have a basic awareness of these deep problems - they are busy consuming Bollywood dramas.
Gem of an interview. The best in the series. Candid views from the master visionaries. Hope the whos-who of the government wake up and smell the danger.
1. Unskilled youth could be a liability. We are tending towards Vishwa-coolie, not Vishwaguru.
2. We need to have a wholistic view from pure research to manufacturing. Integrate industry-education-research.
3. Define done at all steps from the fund allocation to implementation to ROI realization.
AI based technologies will prove a bane if we don't act NOW.
Bought the AI book. Its Very interesting.i clearly Understood what is AI , machine learning , big data , how algorithms keep improving as data is fed, only after starting to read the book. Still in the 1st chapter , such an interesting read with simple, understandable explanation.
Military(Kshatriya) + Academics(Brahmin) + Industries(Vaishya) == Success ....USA N CHINESE, JAPANESE understand this.
We are still stuck in mis translations of our whole ecosystem!
After watching so many scholars , I found you a genuine one, Mukesh ji. I totally agree that there are many jobs which can be created very easily for common man.
As you have discussed , same we can do for agriculture industry for palm oil raw material.. the amount of important is huge ,we are consuming but not growing at home , it needs both government and corporate efforts
Rajiv ji and Mukesh ji, thank you very much for this wonderful and soul-shaking conversation and it should shake up and wake up many of us to get up and get our act together. We have a real shortage of top class visionaries, strategic and pragmatic thinkers, and leaders in many prominent fields, levels and technologies. We have many intelligent, clever and motivated individuals, but they are dispersed, fractured, lacking in certain product development skills, financial and economic skills (for example, how to generate value and capital), lacking a common platform to share their ideas a d work collaboratively, are risk averse due to the basic mindset, and thereby operating in silos and not collectively moving forward. A critical mass of confident tech leaders with risk taking appetite, who are ready to get their hands dirty in solving problems, and are capable of inspiring people is the need of the hour. We need Kalams, Dhawans, Bhabhas, Sarabhais, Swaminathans, in certain key scientific areas and we can achieve significant results.
This is, by far, the best hard hitting criticism of Indian psyche in the 21st century !!
It’s a train wreck in slow motion.
couldn't be more bitter..It opened my eyes. I can't thank you enough for saying truth as it is. Great examples, Very informative, useful n thought provoking. Thank you so much MukeshJi and RajivJi. Waiting for more conversations like this🙏
Watch this tape several times and take seriously every word that is said. This is the critical message that the powers that be need to understand, appreciate, and, most importantly, PUT INTO EFFECT.
20:48 This point is gold. I hope this is understood by more Indians.
There is no loss of dignity in absorbing from out-groups. In fact, this is the foundation of all successful societies of all time.
This whole trade-off young people seem to think they _have to_ make between re-igniting the Indian civilization vs being technologically savvy is completely unnecessary.
In fact, not creating a blend between the two (civilizationalism & scientific leadership) will debilitate the efforts of both pursuits.
The Chinese have created a synthesis of the two & had mutually reinforcing results.
Sir,
I like everything you say,
but what I like most about you is,
you ask or put emphasis on the right question and its answers.
what are the present and clear danger, you know it very well.
the sad part is India, at least in open social media not aware of it at all.
therefore, I think I will try to translate your video into Bengali. so at least a portion of Indians in the local language will be able to learn about you.
some other guy must do the same in Hindi, Marathi, etc local language. or else we are all doomed.
One of the best dialog I watched in a long time. We should run this in all IITs / IIMs as well as big s/w and engineering corporates for opening their eyes and motivate! For PMO and all IAS Babus, they must listen to it and given tasks to REDEFINE ‘DONE’. Thank you Rajiv Ji and Mukesh Ji!
I'm from one of the best private colleges in India.
The IT education there sucked for the most part. A few professors were good, but they were the exception.
My Cryptography professor made us memorize encryption algorithms rather than teach us why they were good, and how to make our own. This is just one example out of many.
I think... and with the conviction of some sort... that NaMo and his team MUST be working on it. Problem is the Indian Bureaucracy and the Highly Corrupt Opposition morons.
Agreed but government should hold the bureaucrats accountable to get the required outcomes. But they have not done that
Knowledgeable, higher calibre ministers could have been inducted, but were deliberately excluded. The NEP is mediocre, and counterproductive, especially with the emphasis on Western inspired Humanities even in the IIT's. Niti Ayog is headed by vainglorious, low commitment Westernised Oriental Gentlemen. Political dominance over the territorial state is the obsession of the leadership. They apparently seek validation from India's civilizational enemies. No Hindu grievance be it RTE or temple management has received the slightest attention, whilst the PM is available for settlement of inter denominational disputes amongst Kerala churches. No committee to review the Colonial Marxist history. Madrasas and the communal universities receive the highest ever encouragement.
@@thrinethran2885 In agreement with you.
What's the assurance that NaMo isn't clueless on how to handle it.
@@thrinethran2885 You nailed it Thrinethran ji. I have my own story to share.But, I must say, most Bhartiya are like that including RM. They pile up their success on the shoulders of others and ditch the supporter when they have climbed up the ladder. Chinese are dependent on State machinery, so cannot ditch and run away.
Thank you Rajivji and Mukeshji.
Hard Facts. extremely enlivening talk show . highly inspiring. Rich disscution on high level.
India has very far to go, to achieve. This Movement Book of Artificial intelligence of yours will steer, streeger Indian intellectuals. (Somehow at present I m passified, scaptical , weather India can do upto that high)
Indians have become "Vishwakooli" instead of "Vishwaguru" -- Rajivji is just so sharp and precise in his observations! Wow, I was just blown away by this one statement.
I wish big players like Infosys, TCS wipro now need to come together and have a brain storming session and act fast
Lack of vitality, ambition and perspective at the top. Consequent lack of education mobility and motivation for the rest. Hadn't Swami Vivekananda spoken of almost the self - same condition in the country?
What a beautiful highend futuristic conversation..India surely have to look into this matter seriously.
China has a one-party dictatorial rule. India has multi-party Parliamentary democracy. This makes a huge difference.
viswa coolie is the right word ... this was there during British rule as well ... the Indians as British soldiers ... the clerks and baboos and the zamindars and collectors and the police and the bureaucracy
Sir, some steps had been in Lithium Batteries Sector.
A new company namely Khanij Bidesh India Limited. It was incorporated by three state-owned companies NALCO, Hindustan Copper and Mineral Exploration Limited.
Khanij Bidesh India Ltd will acquire strategic mineral. assets like Lithium and This company inked a pact with a firm in Argentina.
Together they'll hunt for reserves. Chile and Bolivia are the two other potential sources.
Yes, Kabil is working with the right governments of the lithium triangle
@@updateexpert and also a Lithium Battery Factory is to be setup in Gujarat.
The respect for Shakti is what we need to resurrect. Great session Sir.
Indian Science and technology Minister should listen to Mukesh ji and his ideas.
Our P. M and his Ministers and secretery should talk like him.
What an eye opening, insightful discussion. Amazing clarity and vision. Thank you Rajivji 🙏🙏🙏 for this. Very grateful. How I wish this is viewed by PM Modi directly himself and if that happens there may be possibility of action and course correction. Otherwise it is a great great risk the country is heading to. Bankruptuals aptly summarizes most of the bureaucrats and technocrats in the corridors of power.
I see Rajiv ji is really into this
Rajiv jee & Mukesh Jee you both great innovative, seasonal thinkers with great vision. Educate others, change thinking but at the same time put a seed to start some thing that will produce bigger return on investment like VC fund. Involve business leaders in India. That is non linear thinking as Mukhesh jee told. You love, passion, vision are simply great. Fortunate to be part of good sangam people like you.
Simply brilliant! crisp and spot on accurate views by the guest and of course by Rajiv ji!
Narayan Murthy has invested his profits from Infosys on Cloudtail which tied up with Amazon to sells retail products ... what vision of Indian entrepreneur !
Perfectly said - mechanical engineering, material science, precision machines, chemicals etc form the foundation.
outcome studies. not allocation alone.
Mukesh Ji is twin brother of Rajiv ji. Fortunately he is living in Bharat and supporting our nation
Rajiv ji might be living outside of Bharath but he wants our country to excel in science and technology
I hope 1% of Indians who have resources listen to these advises and make Bharat great again. Jai hind.
Rajivji have you hear of (Padma Shri) Sridhar Vembu? He is working (or at least trying to) build the sorts of deep tech capabilities discussed here, from rural areas in Tamil Nadu. Would love a discussion between the both of you.
We need experienced, wise entrepreneurs like Shri. Rajiv Malhotra ji and Shri. Mukesh Chattar ji to direct and guide the Indian government programs to improve science, technology & manufacturing in India.
Sir with deep respect,Mukheshji's comment that ""Modiji is trying his best but the people around him aren't "" doesn't fly. You dont become a great leader because you work 20hours rather ur ability to identify right people put them in right positions, empower them and having the vision,conviction to deliver..these make one a good leader..I support modi, but i have to say he comes across as a big time centralized control freak..as a result after 7yrs of huge mandate you dont even see a team of 10people there..only modi and 2-3other close ministries..even nitin gadkari rajnath r cut to size..so this ardent blind bhaktism to Modi is very troubling..
Rajiv Sir, one request to you. Could you please also publish these eye opening video discussions with Hindi (and perhaps Marathi, Gujarati, Tamil & Telugu) dubbing and subtitles, just like many of the English videos of Sadhguru do, so they reach the hearts of grass root level vernacular audience across Bharat?
That is bound to spread awareness and action from the right people due to deeper impact on local politicians, industry owners, decision makers and other influential people. Thank You!
Great thoughts. I am wondering how be we overhaul the administration, I was checking and came to know that only about 60 seats are available to open merit meant for IAS and the curriculum of IAS and rot that is set there how can it be rebuilt
Grants is important topic. Indian colleges have grants. But the professions have no pressure/incentive to create something. Govt puts too much money directly into college. Hence being lazy is okay. Hence the isolation is continuing. Rajiv ji touched very important topic.
done defined by budget allocation ... very true ... and then corruption gobbles the rest up
Plz accept my gratitude for bringing this perspective to us... Indeed bitter for better ahead.
Infy and other guys must be indebted to you.
Simply Excellent.
Well explained. " Done" is the problem.
It's time for all the students, universities and all technocrats should put pressure on NITI Aayog. As policy makers understand and listen to only vote banks, we all should come together and raise voice and put pressure...
I wish these kind of videos go viral in India
Good idea. Why dont you spread this link to your friends theiugh social media
The reason why your recommendations are not being implemented by the Govt, The main reason why the people surrounding Narendrabhai have big aversity to your "basic understanding", is that, the IAS parasites are ingrained with leftists ideology and they carry viral fear of losing their exclusive power they so much enjoy as the stooges of the colonial system.
The only way out is to learn from Gurudev Swami Ramdev who is spearheading constant constant innovation, every day each day in Patanjali through his purushaarth. PLEASE DON'T DISOUNT HIS EFFORTS AS BUSINESS. I see tremendous innovation in his major products which are clearly several order of magnitude ahead that could survive the lethargic gravity of leftists.
Well said. Infestation by the result of 70 years of reservation candidacy in all organs of Govt...
Naman Rajiv ji
Pragmatic Discussion. Thanks to both. Kindly share your thoughts on the Indian L1 mentality - Awarding projects to the lowest bidder, and asking other bidders to match L1 if they want a piece of the action.
The system described was the system in the India the richest country before British sabotaged and decimated it making India the one of the poor countries on the planet. We have to regain, reorganise and go forward. We have the capacity and what is required is a government with a vision and a commitment to achieve a goal, something that was missing for almost sixty years of governance since independence. Thankfully, Modiji is a visionary with a mind of a missionary!
We should stop calling ourselves software super power. Sir, u r right when you say that big I T companies failed to invest in future technology and remained satisfied with their high profits.
Loved it, thank you!
All your videos make me so mentally restless Rajiv ji! What can each individual do to change this situation ? Could you please be kind enough to make us aware what would be that I can do to try and make these bitter things into better things.
All IAS/IPS and Government Officers children must Compulsorily study in Government schools. Then see what happens
Excellent discussion sir
As a nationalist I am glad that someone is addressing these issues.
जब स्वतंत्र भारत घरघरमे, विद्यालयमे, मंदिरमे, कार्यालयमे, तब कुछ हो सकता है।
Indigenous Indian Programs like Surabhi and Turing Point have inspired generations of Indian to discover and explore. Those TV program have uplifted the whole society by shifting the perceived mindset around innovation from threat to progress. These days people are taking great interest in Culinary art because of life style channels and food video bloggers. Similarly, People are taking interest in Dance, Aerobics and Yoga. Unfortunately, India don't have quality indigenous egalitarian Discovery, Geo & Science channels. Some of the channels that exist are perceived as pseudo science and occult science such that rational minds don't connect with them.
The defination of Done ...and the way mukeshji gave eg of u don't grow spices.....also how china built on the information..cyber coolies ..
Know your where your heart is
That is democracy you need to be audible being effective is secondary or sometimes not needed just see past 70 years
Yes, a democracy where the majority has been ostracised and have to fight for same rights as minorities!
@@k.bhatta4257 same rights?, they have to fight to survive forget same rights they are even not safe
Hydrogen vehicle..very useful..and motivational speech
Let us hope for the best & prepare for the worst.
its unfortunate that what you say is 100% true. I wanna ask what can i do as a student to contribute and help india. I wanna take matters in my own hand rather than wait for the government.
You can do work for development of your paternal village.
Great insights.
We need True Patriotic Professionals to build New India!
👍👍👍👍👍 Words can't weigh their Dedication.
Nice
Collebratio. of academia community integrated with industry and university ... listening to this it just strikes that what are Veda teaches us .. everything is integrated ... u can’t isolate ..
Few appear better remnants of the colonial past than the Niti Ayog brass, and it is no accident that great ideas from original thinkers gather dust with, or alongside, those people.
👍👍👍
Namaste
Sir, I read a lot about Peak oil. That the petroleum reserves in the world would be depleted very soon. But I don't see any concern in the Indian think tanks. Is imminent depletion of Petroleum reserves a reality or a hoax.
*Cabinet ministers ko Rajiv ji ko hi follow karna chaahiye.*
Can India partner/invest in Taiwan semiconductor industry in exchange for standing with them against China? With Indian brains working w Taiwan could gain India some lost ground in semiconductors. India investing in AI, pharma, avionics, digital egovernance as your earlier guest mentioned yesterday will provide well paying jobs and help quell some of the destructive breaking India forces. Better jobs, opportunities can uplift everyone and then why would anyone want to kill the goose that lays the golden egg?
In India since industry does not give grants to academia they take grants from Ford Foundation :)
36:00 toatally agree with you sir
Why both of you could not take up these matters to our Prime Minister directly? There is no time to waste.
I prefer not to compete with China in areas where they are naturally and physically better. Large scale manufacturing, I prefer to leave it up to China and India focus on other areas. I see a huge scope for "entertainment/hospitality" industry in future. Indians could do a better job here.
How can we collaborate to change this situation. Shouldn't like minded people come together to lead desired change
Audio of guest speaker is poor
I would rather question the premise of carbon reduction by one third .... the climate change is something that may change over hundreds of years due to several factors and that has happened in the past ... now the movement of masses to the cities are more responsible for the environmental menace than anything else ... this climate change is thus a corporate agenda and the surveillance society ... if masses were scattered in villages then the cost of surveillance would have been humongous ... we can just change the way we think about climate and then change the narrative on battery technology ... the hazard of battery waste is going to another menace and it cannot be perceived as a only thing to run after
I know my comment won't get a like but I will once again state facts. India is in league of super power now. Few examples I will share in all areas of technology that the guest pointed out. There are many many examples but I will only state a few.
Materials : last year's test of drdos hypersonic missile is a shinning example. I believe india thanks to drdo is now leading the world in hypersonic technology. The successful test of drdo hyoersonic vehicle required very powerful computing capabilities to test very complex algorithms that works in hypersonic flight. Plus development of all the new complex electronics, guidance, navigation and control systems. Because electronics, guidance navigation and control system that works with super sonic missiles would fail to work in a hypersonic vehicle. All flight control laws and algorithms that work at supersonic speed which themselves are complex won't work in a hypersonic flight regime.
For a hypersonic vehicle to cruise you require a scram jet engine. In this very complex propulsion system the hypersonic wind that comes into the combustion chamber has to be burnt with the fuel at supersonic speeds. Most of the time flame gets extinguished. Now drdo has succeed in developing. It is a major breakthrough in propulsion technology, aero dynamics technology and a major breakthrough in technology of materials. As hypersonic vehicle travels the temperature reaches as high as 1500 degree Celsius on the skin of the hypersonic vehicle. To sustain such temperatures drdo had to develop materials like carbon carbon silicon carbide and other wide variety of super alloys and other things who's information is not available in public domain. In order to craft such futuristic hypersonic vehicle you need very complex machinary and very highly skilled man power.
Artificial intelligence : Our genius scientists have developed many advanced technologies. Mars space craft also called mom was a completely autonomous. It could take its own decisions without requiring any human intervention. As time delay between signal from mom to earth is more than 20 minutes. So our Mars space craft was capable of self diagnostics and recovery. It was capable of correcting any errors in the system by itself and executing all of its functions with remarkable precision. Looking after the health of all the sub systems components and instruments while guiding controlling and navigation space craft at the same. Plus before our Mars mission was launched the entire journey of the space craft including all of its systems how they are functioning waa simulated through very complex computer simulations. An entire path the space craft would take was chalked out. So even without going to Mars our genius scientists with help of their advanced technologies were able to simulate all of these aspects. Japan with quote unquote with far superior fabrication technololgy haven't been able to achieve such accomplishment. Chinese fiber glass mock ups as semiconductor chips.
on army day this year india showcased state of the art swarm drones technology. These drones are all self aware. one drone does not follow the other drone. each drone have the ability to take their own decisions based on threat. It uses adaptive artificial intelligence, edge computing, network centric approach, satellite based technologies, remote sensing many advance sensors image processing etc really complex stuff thar even I cannot explain.
Quantum technology : Drdo last year shocked the world by sucesfully demonstrating quantum communication. Secure communications are vital for defence and strategic agencies worldwide and distribution of encryption keys from time to time is an important requirement. Sharing of keys over the air or wired links requires encryption which in turn requires encryption keys to be pre-shared. The DRDO had undertaken the project for development of the technology exclusively for Indian armed forces.
The work being done at DRDO will be used to enable start-ups and SMEs in the domain of quantum information technologies. The technology will also serve to define standards and crypto policies that can leverage QKD system in a unified Cipher Policy Committee (CPC) framework for more secure and pragmatic key management for current and future military cryptographic systems.
Drdo has established a galium nitride foundary that will be very helpful in area of electronics, sensors , radars etc.
China is a communist regime that is very insecure. People who are most insecure make most noise. Everyone wants to manufacture things in china because labour is dirt cheap and with no labour laws. Labour can be exploited to the hearts content by communist regime.
Western countires are masters of propaganda and psychological warfare. China has now heavily invested in psychological warfare. They know how to win in minds of people.
China hasn'twon even a single war either at land air or sea. While indian armed forces have the most decorated post world war 2 millitary history. Yet most indian believe china can actually win a war against india. Well chiense have won the war in the mind.
I sincerely hope china continues to manufacture stuff for the world. Chiense have destroyed their ecology and their environment. These computer rams circuits what not is some of the most toxic industries the man has ever known. India must carefully choose what it should manufacture in large scale. And make wise decisions for our environment.
With due respect to Mukesh ji..he said Namo has that passion but others around him lack.but sir a great leader's one of the quality and success also depends on the kind of team/teams he/she builds...lot of social engineering electioneering on top of it good will towards modi is what is driving his success...othewise Modi's governance is extremely centralized around his core coterie of 4-5ministries that's it..all second rung leaders are just tweet masters..there is no institutions building, no discussions or debating ideas...just u left wing u right wing u hindu u muslim kind of twitter wars.....from tunnel to train to statues opening to satellite launching modi will be there will lot of PR..the problem we have today is lack of objective analysis on both so called right and left....I still suppport Modi, but he is also at fault on how he built his governance style and wasting mandate and time...
SIR.THE TRUTH IS ,I AM SORRY TO SAY THE GOVERNING FACTORS (PERSONNELS) ARE LACKING IN HONESTY.AND LOT OF LEAKAGE OF FUNDS & INVESTMENTS.SELFISHNESS AND NARROW MINDEDNESS.ETC.ETC.
🙏🙏 नमस्कार किस कृपया इसका हिंदी वर्जन में प्रसारित करवाइए गा
China could do what they did in last 40 years is because they had a dictatorship rule by CCP ... there is no point in comparing that with a democracy like India who were not only poor but the nationalistic feeling s were fractured
🚩Har Har Mahadev 🚩
All democracies must unite to defeat regimes of dictators like communist or religious theocrati fascist extremist type.
Some wrong facts here. Indians are doing high-end work also. IBM's India team also is doing high-end work. It is wrong stereo-type that US based Indians are doing high-end and Indian people are doing only low end. IBM setting separate entity for AI and Cloud. India will have big center. But even high-end work is done for foreign roadmap.
So, Vishwa-coolie is correct word, even for high-end work.
Real gap is your work Rajiv ji- Real gap is low self esteem, Being Different etc. This makes big difference in having courage to chart own path.
There is huge incentive for being lazy and low risk taker. The money inflation due to services sector has killed all sectors.
After 21:45
🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏👍
Bureaucracy need to change bcoz people are willing govt is willing but bureaucracy is not and biggest reason is there syllabus which is so socialist and left leaning they didn't all this
Hiii sir