The extremely depressing thing is ... it'll likely take years before XPS/windows laptops catch up in most aspects, and even when they do on paper you just know they'll half-ass it somehow. Like Dell did with their speakers technically being pretty good but actually distorting badly and rattling at certain upper-bass frequencies. Also don't trust them to do proper FALD control in all circumstances... At least we still get upgrade-able RAM and storage I guess... sigh...
XPS pops more because of the way windows handles colours. System-wide consistency is much better on Macs and the OS redirects the colour profile of the picture. If you go back and watch all your comparisons this has always been the case. I had both the laptops and only when you open two images in a colour managed application, the differences between the two are minimised
I think benchmarks tell only half the story. As a professional photographer that switched from the XPS to the Macbook this year, I can tell you the difference is not in the export times but in the every day use. In Lightroom the way you can work on the MacBook and how instant the previews are once you change a setting or brush a region is just not matched by Windows unfortunately, even on a powerfull desktop. That is the main reason I actually changed. Render times and export times don't matter as I can do something else like reply emails on my tablet or phone or run them through the night. But every day use is far more important. Also because i switched from a Samsung phone to the Iphone, the level of integration is insane and it just makes your life so much easier.
YES! The lihgtroom responsiveness is MUCH faster on a the M1 even compared to my HP Zbook Studio G8 i9 with A5000 GPU. Yet none of the shallow youtube videos mention this and only repeat the same export time test as everyone else.
do you work in 3D i.e. blender, maya? I ve been watching very mixed reviews about that use-case. Most say the optimisation sucks and is not comparable to working on windows
I have a 10 year old XPS 15z running W10 that I sometimes use Lightroom Classic on. Zero lag on sliders with any size file. 100megapickles, 400MB 16-bit tiff etc. Are you guys not working on 1:1 previews or something?
@@jamwright Sliders maybe but what about scrolling and loading images from the catalogue? all windows machines ive tried show lots of lag compared the M1 macbooks
Wow, the benchmarks were a bit shocking. On top of that, the Macbook wasn't plugged in and was running on almost half the power. Over the years for me, a cool and quiet laptop trumps anything. I STILL can't get over the notch on the Macbook though.....ooof. I have the 2019 16in Macbook and that new notch is something else to me lol.
It may have changed but I thought the increased vibrancy was down to the OS. Windows had gamma set to 2.2 and macOS was 1.8. So running Windows in Bootcamp always made the screen look better
Please look at consumer reviews on the XPS17. A host of issues that I’m currently dealing with. Opted for Dell because Mac wouldn’t run all programs needed for my daughter college engineer courses. $$$$$ Now only a few months after purchase it is glitching. Touchpad, screen, running hot. Dell asked that we return for repairs. Promised to return in 5 days. Now they are telling me it will take longer for repairs due large number of repairs they have pending. No definite date. Now I have to purchase another computer so she doesn’t fall behind.
That pop u talking about is Color profile issue on xps it reproduces the normal RGB profile as p3( boosted) …but on mac that won’t happen bcoz that not right way ..so it reproduce RGB as RGB , and not boost it to p3..but if u go and see the picture p3 contents on web, the story will change.And your room is will lit ,so you obviously can’t see the deeper blacks of mini led…
I don’t know if you’ll see this or not, but I’m in need of a new laptop. Everyone in my family loves apple for laptops phones etc. Since I’m in college I need a laptop that keeps up with me. Which laptop should I get? Thanks!
There’s an app you can get now for the macs that lets you increase brightness to over 1000 nits in standard mode, would help with the lack of pop maybe
I went a different route and bought an Alienware X17 1080p 360hz 3070 and MacBook Pro 16 M1 Max so both are good for work or fun in different ways but did consider this combination.
I am willing to sacrifice cool and quiet laptop for a 3080 GPU. I sold my gaming laptop to get a new one and I am stuck with a 16 inches mbp and all i can do on it is work.
This is soooo true. Loud fans, bad battery life, and uncomfortable heat really bring the experience down. My intel 2019 16in Macbook suffers greatly lol
Even the display on my Dell XPS 9570 4K from 2018 seems to pop a bit more when looking at non-HDR content. It's a different story when viewing HDR content though.
well, considering the glare and reflections on the XPS, i would have hard time using it in a cafe, places where I prefer to work... this has always annoyed me on glossy screens, make them unusable for my eyes, and I've always preferred matte screens that are dimmer. Mac's screen, in terms of reflections, looks somewhere between glossy and matte... I think once they optimise the 3D applications, Mac will be ideal, but not for now... I guess, skip M1 and wait for M2..
Ive owned both Mac and Dell. The build quality and quietness of the Mac trumps the Dell hands down. Add to that just how exceedingly powerful the M1 chips are, I mean it's no contest UNLESS you play games and then your better off going Dell
I agree but it makes me wonder y apple doesn’t incentivize game developers to make games for their platform or better yet make an apple console, cause that will enable them to sell their services to a wider audience as well as grabbing more market share from the pc market, cause I feel a lot of people don’t like windows they just deal with it cause that’s their best bet to play games on
It doesn’t look like M1 will beat Nvidia cards for 3D work unfortunately, as apple opted for boosting video editing in the hardware, and has no hardware ray tracing. I do photography as well as 3D now, so I’d love be wrong, but I think my next desktop will have to be a PC unless apple makes more of an effort to support 3D apps like Blender, Unreal Engine, Maya etc in the hardware and not just the software. look at the render difference when Optix is enabled in Blender on Nvidia cards, it’s huge.
The apps will need to be optimize for the M1 lineup. The alpha build of blender does way better than the stable version on the M1 chipsets. The same applies for the rest of the apps.
@@kshitizjha yer totally, but still miles behind Nvidia's Optix options. I think the M1's are great, and they will continue to get better with support, but I think they will still need some form of raytracing cores to compete with Nvidia etc. I'm sure M1max Duo etc, will have great specs, but then the cost will be double that of a similar PC build. I hope I'm wrong, but I feel like it may be a while before Apple focuses in that area.
Awesome review, mate. I can always depend on your impartiality! I ordered the 16" M1 Pro (base model); still waiting. I'm moving to it from the XPS 9500 (10th gen i7, 32 ram, uhd+). Hoping the Mac will smoke it in content creation. 🙏🤞
@@JimKanaris for me yes, and I am not anti Apple (using a M1 Air now) but price wise, its a bit ridiculous for the Macbook pros. ProArt with Ryzen 9 5900X | 64GB | 2TB | RTX 3070 | 120HZ | 100% P3 | Full size SD Express 7 | upgradable RAM/SSD, HDMI 2.1 | 2x USB C 3.1 | 2x USB A 3.1 | Wifi 6 for 2399$. No brainer. Against 16GB | 512GB, old HDMI 2.0, old SDHC for 2499$. Joke. And soldered SSD.
It would be nice to know the prices of these machines! The XPS may be a better deal if it is so much less expensive than the M1 Max. How well does the base model M1 Pro 16" fare against the XPS? And the prices?
Tried configuring it similar to the M1 Max MBP, ended up being more expensive though.Plus 3060 isn't = M1 Max. Waiting for the CES versions to drop, but yeah, unlikely to be any cheaper.
it's not, most people choose one laptop, they both can do stuff I need, but Mac does it better (in my case) - and mostly because of Mac OS, not because of hardware
I have a question about the displays. One thing I know when comparing the iPhone to the galaxy is that the galaxy comes from the factory set to a default of "Vivid". The colors are far more saturated and some might think that’s a good thing. The iPhone doesn’t have any modes to set the color. When I view a photo that I have edited on a calibrated color accurate display (Eizo CS2730) the colors on the Samsung are disgustingly over saturated and makes the photo look like a cartoon. It pains me that people are viewing my photo on that setting. The iPhone 12 pro is very close to looking like what it should. So even though the Samsung might pop and have some crazy colors being displayed it is kinda shitty until you go in to the display settings and set it to Normal. Then it better matches what most peoples color accurate displays should look like. My question is, does the Dell come with a default that is similar (vivid on the Samsung phones) setting as the OLED Samsung displays? If so can you set it to normal and compare. Also how do these displays compare when you actually calibrate them to display accurate color? One of them is actually correct and better looking once they are properly calibrated. An over saturated display might be pleasing to some people. For professionals it’s shit. Kinda like walking in to a store to look at tvs and they all look different. But which one is actually correct. None really until you calibrate them.
@@TallyHoTech I thought so myself but was unsure after I saw the typography animation which I've only ever seen at an Apple keynote haha. Love it though 😆
@@zeniktorres4320 absolutely, I hate glossy too. but I checked out the Macbooks screens in a shop, and it wasn't as bad as I expected. Its not the same glossy as in other screens glossy, everyone's eyes may perceive it differently, so one should always check for yourself.
@Garrus Vakarian The new g14 is a very impressive device and I may buy it. They should have switched to usb-c charging which goes up to 240w and added usb 4.
As long as you have not installed Linux on the non-Apple machine, I doubt that it is of any use for a Pro User... also worth mentioning: The M1 has the same performance either with and without being connected to power; and a way better performance per watt. Not Intel Chip can compete with that.
I do not have any hopes of getting a windows laptop any time soon. They still have not figured the scaling part out. Windows 11 is a bugged and slow mess. Just wow.
I’m looking all over RUclips for OLED vs MacBook Pro 14 screen comparison, because not all OLED are created equally. I just want to see an XPS OLED or asus OLED vs mini led comparison.
Don't the colors on the XPS "pop" more just because, by default, it is set to display its full gamut - which is 100% AdobeRGB as measured by Notebookcheck? The MBP 16 M1 "only" covers 88% of AdobeRGB per Notebookcheck also. Did you have both set to the same color gamut? Like comparing P3 vs P3 and sRGB mode vs sRGB mode. This all breaks down anyway with Dell because Premier color used to (probably still does? Let us know!) cause significant color banding when controlling color gamut. So if I don't need to be in AdobeRGB mode (which most people don't) but rather in sRGB (still the standard for nearly everything non-HDR) then with Dell, you either deal with horrible banding or with cartoonish colors...
I’m running 2-3 virtual machines concurrently as well as Davinci resolve 4K editing and my 64gb ram mbp doesn’t even sweat! However my colleague who got the 32gb ram one can easily do the same so I’d say 64gb isn’t needed at all!
@@solidsn2011 thanks for providing the experience. I used up all the memories in 32g/1tb and safari and final cut freezes so that’s why I return the standard M1 max and the Final Cut Pro takes up 700g for a single project. That’s why I’m thinking 64g2t is a better choice. In your opinion, is it a waste of money for spending the extra $800?
@@AndysTV are you sure it’s not the memory leak problem of Safari? With the latest update I did on my machine I don’t have this problem. As to if it worths the extra money to upgrade, as I told you for what most people do it doesn’t but you’ll have to judge that according to your workflow and experience. If I could turn time back I would choose 32gb ram and 4tb ssd instead of 2Tb as 4K videos can take up a lot of space!
I have a 16” MBP 2021 24 core 32 gigs. It games amazingly for what I have, Civ vi etc. do you foresee more support for games now that macs can truly hang in terms of gaming?
I have a 2019 16in MBP. I was thinking of trading mine in and getting the 14in, but that notch really bothers me. Does the notch bother you, or have you gotten use to it?
@@RyanDunton not at all. Never had an issue with it getting in the way as the top becomes a black line and it blends in with gaming. In regular use and editing you forget it exists in 2 minutes. Go try one at an Apple store and you’ll see what I mean
SORRY TO SAY; BUT I HAVE A HUGE ISSUE AND IT IS NOT FIXED BY DELL !!! I AM TALKING ABOUT 5K DELL PRECISION ___ KEYBOARD !!!! SO SIMPLE; BUT KILLING THE DELL !
Doesn't USB-C tap out at 100W? Might want to check the actual wattage that's being used to charge the laptop. I know my M1 Max MBP 16" is unable to keep up if I'm charging thru USB-C and I'm gaming. Probably why Apple created their own charging standard again...I hear though that USB-C is doubling the power wattage with the new revision, another round of stupid cable replacements Zzz...
Why are RUclipsrs always pushing MacBooks? They are a distant 4th in laptop marketshare both globally and in the US. Lenovo and HP sell 3x as many laptops and Dell sells 2x as many laptops as Apple.
@@TallyHoTech yeah the ironic part is, I was about to return my MacBook 16inch to keep XPS 17. for the reasons u mentioned in the video. One day before I was about to return (had initiated the return on apple website) dell webcam not working anymore. Maybe dell is not meant to be.
It’ll be a much more interesting comparisons with 12th gen Intel or the latest Ryzen chips. Not sure Dell will level the playing field with displays. Genuinely pleased I swapped from a MacBook Pro to XPS. With better battery and performance, I think the XPS will be the perfect machine. Great video
@@stoychotrenchev4443 better for you. It's good that you enjoy it. MacOS cannot even multitask with multiple windows open next to each other. That's so frustrating for me. Have a watch of this. ruclips.net/video/cfsNO14hikA/видео.html
For best value: Macbook Air M1, good display, good body, good keyboard, excellent battery life. For more advanced users: ProArt with Ryzen 9 5900X | 64GB | 2TB | RTX 3070 | 120HZ | 100% P3 | Full size SD Express 7 | upgradable RAM/SSD, HDMI 2.1 | 2 USB C | 2 USB A for 2399$
HDR is such a pain in the ass with windows and they need to get it sorted. That said, its too simplistic to say this is just a pro comparison. "Pro" what?? I'm a professional that uses my laptop almost exclusively, and no i don't need to bake videos for youtube. I'm really tired of youtube rendering bakeoffs as though thats the only usecase for "pros". Also gaming makes Apple a non-starter for me at this point, I don't care how good thier hardware is. Like most people these days, I don't maintain a "work" laptop separatley from my personal one so current needs are much broader than are ususally represented by most reviews and I hope that changes. In my world between these two devices the XPS 17 is the only real option. Obviously there is a smaller creative group where the macbook wins hands down.
Show of hands... how many of you buy a laptop for video editing and Blender? Out of 36,000 people... I see.... 4? Ok, nice. Very relevant benchmarking then. Thanks.
No one tell information like you did : I follow all but you ; Give information in easy way .. Emphasize on very important things and explain it to an idiot ..like the screen Notice something we all notice it but we don’t have explanation and why ! Which you did , the screen again ( why windows screen looks better ! ) And we never need to see your face , for now at least . So in behalf of all nerds in the web , I thank you .
@@TallyHoTech I’m really sorry about that …that was my mistake….although my point is most windows laptop will upscale RGB profile to P3 profile…..so that pops more….it doesn’t mean it was right…bcoz MacBook only presents P3 contents as P3 like HDR video or p3 photos on websites ….can check for yourself on some p3 colour gamet test website on both laptop you will definitely understand….by the way you are doing great videos ..I don’t mean you were wrong 👍🏼
This is an amazing time for the computing world. Apple will hold an advantage for years to come until Intel and AMD move to SoCs. Apple has a 10 year head start since developing A1 chips on their iPhone lineup. Apple just needs to scale the M1 architecture with minor improvements going forward to hold the lead.
![Gucci Mane & Sexyy Red - You Don't Love Me [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/j7IBqyFKT4c/mqdefault.jpg)
Some other things of Note:
👉Mac has better speakers
👉Keyboards are both great
👉Mac has better track pad
The extremely depressing thing is ... it'll likely take years before XPS/windows laptops catch up in most aspects, and even when they do on paper you just know they'll half-ass it somehow. Like Dell did with their speakers technically being pretty good but actually distorting badly and rattling at certain upper-bass frequencies. Also don't trust them to do proper FALD control in all circumstances...
At least we still get upgrade-able RAM and storage I guess... sigh...
@@RedBeardedRabbit you do not need so much power . People who use Windows dislike Macos .I am one of them , I will be happier on xps then on a Mac
I would like to see dell xps 17 with 12 gen vs MacBook Pro 16 ? That would be a fair fight .
Mac has better notch
@@RedBeardedRabbit totally. on paper PC laptops look amazing
XPS pops more because of the way windows handles colours. System-wide consistency is much better on Macs and the OS redirects the colour profile of the picture.
If you go back and watch all your comparisons this has always been the case. I had both the laptops and only when you open two images in a colour managed application, the differences between the two are minimised
I think benchmarks tell only half the story. As a professional photographer that switched from the XPS to the Macbook this year, I can tell you the difference is not in the export times but in the every day use. In Lightroom the way you can work on the MacBook and how instant the previews are once you change a setting or brush a region is just not matched by Windows unfortunately, even on a powerfull desktop. That is the main reason I actually changed. Render times and export times don't matter as I can do something else like reply emails on my tablet or phone or run them through the night. But every day use is far more important. Also because i switched from a Samsung phone to the Iphone, the level of integration is insane and it just makes your life so much easier.
YES! The lihgtroom responsiveness is MUCH faster on a the M1 even compared to my HP Zbook Studio G8 i9 with A5000 GPU. Yet none of the shallow youtube videos mention this and only repeat the same export time test as everyone else.
do you work in 3D i.e. blender, maya? I ve been watching very mixed reviews about that use-case. Most say the optimisation sucks and is not comparable to working on windows
@@batmanonholiday4477 no, I do photo and video editing and the worflow is much better than Windows.
I have a 10 year old XPS 15z running W10 that I sometimes use Lightroom Classic on. Zero lag on sliders with any size file. 100megapickles, 400MB 16-bit tiff etc. Are you guys not working on 1:1 previews or something?
@@jamwright Sliders maybe but what about scrolling and loading images from the catalogue? all windows machines ive tried show lots of lag compared the M1 macbooks
Wow, the benchmarks were a bit shocking. On top of that, the Macbook wasn't plugged in and was running on almost half the power. Over the years for me, a cool and quiet laptop trumps anything. I STILL can't get over the notch on the Macbook though.....ooof. I have the 2019 16in Macbook and that new notch is something else to me lol.
I don't even notice it. It quickly disappears from your view
It may have changed but I thought the increased vibrancy was down to the OS. Windows had gamma set to 2.2 and macOS was 1.8. So running Windows in Bootcamp always made the screen look better
Thanks for the Tip
How does that work? What does it mean?
this is not better.
@@nnnnnn3647 How so?
Please look at consumer reviews on the XPS17. A host of issues that I’m currently dealing with. Opted for Dell because Mac wouldn’t run all programs needed for my daughter college engineer courses. $$$$$ Now only a few months after purchase it is glitching. Touchpad, screen, running hot. Dell asked that we return for repairs. Promised to return in 5 days. Now they are telling me it will take longer for repairs due large number of repairs they have pending. No definite date. Now I have to purchase another computer so she doesn’t fall behind.
don't worry dell switches your device out pretty fast for a hardware issue
Really cool you film in HDR, I notice it on my iPhone where the video is so much brighter than the comments section and stuff below it lol
That pop u talking about is Color profile issue on xps it reproduces the normal RGB profile as p3( boosted) …but on mac that won’t happen bcoz that not right way ..so it reproduce RGB as RGB , and not boost it to p3..but if u go and see the picture p3 contents on web, the story will change.And your room is will lit ,so you obviously can’t see the deeper blacks of mini led…
Yer try but this same compared to X1, Legion 7 and G14
I don’t know if you’ll see this or not, but I’m in need of a new laptop. Everyone in my family loves apple for laptops phones etc. Since I’m in college I need a laptop that keeps up with me. Which laptop should I get? Thanks!
There’s an app you can get now for the macs that lets you increase brightness to over 1000 nits in standard mode, would help with the lack of pop maybe
I went a different route and bought an Alienware X17 1080p 360hz 3070 and MacBook Pro 16 M1 Max so both are good for work or fun in different ways but did consider this combination.
Noice one
I really hate alienwares
@@albanos.13 who cares
I will say it time and time again, having a quiet and cool laptop is incredible. Done with personal windows laptops until that happens.
crapple has rotted the mind
I am willing to sacrifice cool and quiet laptop for a 3080 GPU. I sold my gaming laptop to get a new one and I am stuck with a 16 inches mbp and all i can do on it is work.
Intel secure TSMC 3nm production on 2023. I don't you need wait long.
@@benchen2227 does that mean 2024 into devices? Genuine question.
This is soooo true. Loud fans, bad battery life, and uncomfortable heat really bring the experience down. My intel 2019 16in Macbook suffers greatly lol
Even the display on my Dell XPS 9570 4K from 2018 seems to pop a bit more when looking at non-HDR content. It's a different story when viewing HDR content though.
Exactly
well, considering the glare and reflections on the XPS, i would have hard time using it in a cafe, places where I prefer to work... this has always annoyed me on glossy screens, make them unusable for my eyes, and I've always preferred matte screens that are dimmer. Mac's screen, in terms of reflections, looks somewhere between glossy and matte... I think once they optimise the 3D applications, Mac will be ideal, but not for now... I guess, skip M1 and wait for M2..
Ive owned both Mac and Dell. The build quality and quietness of the Mac trumps the Dell hands down. Add to that just how exceedingly powerful the M1 chips are, I mean it's no contest UNLESS you play games and then your better off going Dell
💯
I agree but it makes me wonder y apple doesn’t incentivize game developers to make games for their platform or better yet make an apple console, cause that will enable them to sell their services to a wider audience as well as grabbing more market share from the pc market, cause I feel a lot of people don’t like windows they just deal with it cause that’s their best bet to play games on
@@kevinmesto608
Tell that to office people and regular people lol
They just want a cheap laptop
It doesn’t look like M1 will beat Nvidia cards for 3D work unfortunately, as apple opted for boosting video editing in the hardware, and has no hardware ray tracing. I do photography as well as 3D now, so I’d love be wrong, but I think my next desktop will have to be a PC unless apple makes more of an effort to support 3D apps like Blender, Unreal Engine, Maya etc in the hardware and not just the software.
look at the render difference when Optix is enabled in Blender on Nvidia cards, it’s huge.
The apps will need to be optimize for the M1 lineup. The alpha build of blender does way better than the stable version on the M1 chipsets.
The same applies for the rest of the apps.
@@kshitizjha yer totally, but still miles behind Nvidia's Optix options. I think the M1's are great, and they will continue to get better with support, but I think they will still need some form of raytracing cores to compete with Nvidia etc. I'm sure M1max Duo etc, will have great specs, but then the cost will be double that of a similar PC build. I hope I'm wrong, but I feel like it may be a while before Apple focuses in that area.
Really helpful and detailed review. Many thanks. :0)
Awesome review, mate. I can always depend on your impartiality! I ordered the 16" M1 Pro (base model); still waiting. I'm moving to it from the XPS 9500 (10th gen i7, 32 ram, uhd+). Hoping the Mac will smoke it in content creation. 🙏🤞
It will scream….. silently. You’re gonna love it
Should have waited for the new Proart.
@@chromaticvisuelle Not so clear cut. Rarely is. Plus, waiting isn't always an option. ruclips.net/video/aCveopqDkRM/видео.html
@@JimKanaris for me yes, and I am not anti Apple (using a M1 Air now) but price wise, its a bit ridiculous for the Macbook pros.
ProArt with Ryzen 9 5900X | 64GB | 2TB | RTX 3070 | 120HZ | 100% P3 | Full size SD Express 7 | upgradable RAM/SSD, HDMI 2.1 | 2x USB C 3.1 | 2x USB A 3.1 | Wifi 6 for 2399$. No brainer.
Against 16GB | 512GB, old HDMI 2.0, old SDHC for 2499$. Joke. And soldered SSD.
Also those benchmarks are very specific. Many cases where a RTX 3070 would destroy a m1 Pro or Max.
It would be nice to know the prices of these machines! The XPS may be a better deal if it is so much less expensive than the M1 Max. How well does the base model M1 Pro 16" fare against the XPS? And the prices?
With the XPS you can get it way cheaper if you wait for deals
32 GB, oled, i9, 4gig ram video. ( Best one) I payed ONLY 2498
Tried configuring it similar to the M1 Max MBP, ended up being more expensive though.Plus 3060 isn't = M1 Max. Waiting for the CES versions to drop, but yeah, unlikely to be any cheaper.
@@justanut rtx 3060 still slaps lol
Apple macbook has a higher resale value over a couple years like 4-5 years? still worth a lot...
apples and oranges just get what suits your needs and enjoy WWWOOOOFFF great video man
Bang on mate
it's not, most people choose one laptop, they both can do stuff I need, but Mac does it better (in my case) - and mostly because of Mac OS, not because of hardware
One question: did you use the Dell Color app to choose the screen colorspace?
I have a question about the displays. One thing I know when comparing the iPhone to the galaxy is that the galaxy comes from the factory set to a default of "Vivid". The colors are far more saturated and some might think that’s a good thing. The iPhone doesn’t have any modes to set the color. When I view a photo that I have edited on a calibrated color accurate display (Eizo CS2730) the colors on the Samsung are disgustingly over saturated and makes the photo look like a cartoon. It pains me that people are viewing my photo on that setting. The iPhone 12 pro is very close to looking like what it should. So even though the Samsung might pop and have some crazy colors being displayed it is kinda shitty until you go in to the display settings and set it to Normal. Then it better matches what most peoples color accurate displays should look like.
My question is, does the Dell come with a default that is similar (vivid on the Samsung phones) setting as the OLED Samsung displays? If so can you set it to normal and compare. Also how do these displays compare when you actually calibrate them to display accurate color? One of them is actually correct and better looking once they are properly calibrated. An over saturated display might be pleasing to some people. For professionals it’s shit. Kinda like walking in to a store to look at tvs and they all look different. But which one is actually correct. None really until you calibrate them.
Yes the Dell comes with full gamut as standard. You can tone it down if you want
Hey mate,
Just out of curiosity, what do you use to do your graphs and animated typography to present your results ?
Your gonna laugh. Keynote on Mac
@@TallyHoTech I thought so myself but was unsure after I saw the typography animation which I've only ever seen at an Apple keynote haha.
Love it though 😆
Great review! Are both screens equally reflective or glossy?
A slight edge to the Mac but both are as good as glossy gets
I think with XPS you can have a matte option... which I prefer.
@@zeniktorres4320 absolutely, I hate glossy too. but I checked out the Macbooks screens in a shop, and it wasn't as bad as I expected. Its not the same glossy as in other screens glossy, everyone's eyes may perceive it differently, so one should always check for yourself.
@@batmanonholiday4477 You're right there it definitely not as bad
@@zeniktorres4320 probably but I never like the matted displays as they seem to reduce apparent screen resolution
Did you use software or hardware encoding in Premiere test?
Seeing the aliasing on the wallpaper of the xps makes the MacBooks look better to me.
wouldnt waste time on the Dell in this case...now if they'd go with the Ryzen 6900HS and a 6600s then that's a good start for em.
Yer 12 Gen around the corner
@Garrus Vakarian I can guarantee it won't have Ryzen.
@Garrus Vakarian The new g14 is a very impressive device and I may buy it. They should have switched to usb-c charging which goes up to 240w and added usb 4.
As long as you have not installed Linux on the non-Apple machine, I doubt that it is of any use for a Pro User... also worth mentioning: The M1 has the same performance either with and without being connected to power; and a way better performance per watt. Not Intel Chip can compete with that.
what color profile did you have the XPS set to? Vibrant, or RGB? I find vibrant will pop more but the colors are not natural.
I do not have any hopes of getting a windows laptop any time soon. They still have not figured the scaling part out. Windows 11 is a bugged and slow mess. Just wow.
Nice. Both look fantastic machines; win-win.
Cheers!
Woof! Bang on mate
What colour is this macbook 16 in the video?
Silver or space grey?
I’m looking all over RUclips for OLED vs MacBook Pro 14 screen comparison, because not all OLED are created equally. I just want to see an XPS OLED or asus OLED vs mini led comparison.
Outstanding audio quality - Straight to the point - Simple and understandable information. New sub!
Wooof you destroyed my eyes again🤣 You need to give us some warning if the video is in HDR
😎
Fun comparison. Thanks
Welcome
Don't the colors on the XPS "pop" more just because, by default, it is set to display its full gamut - which is 100% AdobeRGB as measured by Notebookcheck? The MBP 16 M1 "only" covers 88% of AdobeRGB per Notebookcheck also. Did you have both set to the same color gamut? Like comparing P3 vs P3 and sRGB mode vs sRGB mode.
This all breaks down anyway with Dell because Premier color used to (probably still does? Let us know!) cause significant color banding when controlling color gamut. So if I don't need to be in AdobeRGB mode (which most people don't) but rather in sRGB (still the standard for nearly everything non-HDR) then with Dell, you either deal with horrible banding or with cartoonish colors...
Curious how is battery life hours on XPS 17 4k touch?
I myself ordered and have tested it now. It was not good. I had purchased the i9 12900HK, rtx 3060 4k touch panel. Horrible battery life and heavy.
This is the video I need! Do you think 64G is needed for M1 Max?
What do you do? 32 is definitely enough for 90% of people
@@TallyHoTech I mostly use it for final cut pro but I Safari is using quite a lot ram. I like to open final cut and capcut both at the same time
I’m running 2-3 virtual machines concurrently as well as Davinci resolve 4K editing and my 64gb ram mbp doesn’t even sweat! However my colleague who got the 32gb ram one can easily do the same so I’d say 64gb isn’t needed at all!
@@solidsn2011 thanks for providing the experience. I used up all the memories in 32g/1tb and safari and final cut freezes so that’s why I return the standard M1 max and the Final Cut Pro takes up 700g for a single project. That’s why I’m thinking 64g2t is a better choice. In your opinion, is it a waste of money for spending the extra $800?
@@AndysTV are you sure it’s not the memory leak problem of Safari? With the latest update I did on my machine I don’t have this problem. As to if it worths the extra money to upgrade, as I told you for what most people do it doesn’t but you’ll have to judge that according to your workflow and experience. If I could turn time back I would choose 32gb ram and 4tb ssd instead of 2Tb as 4K videos can take up a lot of space!
For non gamer and people who do content creation the MacBook pro 14/16 is the best!
Yep. As long as you use Apps made for Apple silicon
The MacBook is better, by far. Gone are the days of having your laptop sound like a hair dryer
I got the 14” M1 pro with the upgraded 10 core. Not sure why people want the 16” specs are similar, anything I might information I might be missing?
screen real estate, some of us just need it I wish I could use a smaller display
Which one is the best?
I have the XPS 17 I9 gen 12 7920 64GB, is this the same?
I have a 16” MBP 2021 24 core 32 gigs. It games amazingly for what I have, Civ vi etc. do you foresee more support for games now that macs can truly hang in terms of gaming?
I have a 2019 16in MBP. I was thinking of trading mine in and getting the 14in, but that notch really bothers me. Does the notch bother you, or have you gotten use to it?
Lol gaming on a Mac
I like silent Cub and football manager
@@RyanDunton not at all. Never had an issue with it getting in the way as the top becomes a black line and it blends in with gaming. In regular use and editing you forget it exists in 2 minutes. Go try one at an Apple store and you’ll see what I mean
@@TallyHoTech I’ll have to see what Silent cub is. Thanks
I really wish Dell went the direction of Apple with the screen. I HATE the OLED on my 9510 (really wish I got the 4K instead).
SORRY TO SAY; BUT I HAVE A HUGE ISSUE AND IT IS NOT FIXED BY DELL !!!
I AM TALKING ABOUT 5K DELL PRECISION ___ KEYBOARD !!!!
SO SIMPLE; BUT KILLING THE DELL !
I wonder about comparing cost
Doesn't USB-C tap out at 100W? Might want to check the actual wattage that's being used to charge the laptop. I know my M1 Max MBP 16" is unable to keep up if I'm charging thru USB-C and I'm gaming. Probably why Apple created their own charging standard again...I hear though that USB-C is doubling the power wattage with the new revision, another round of stupid cable replacements Zzz...
Why are RUclipsrs always pushing MacBooks?
They are a distant 4th in laptop marketshare both globally and in the US.
Lenovo and HP sell 3x as many laptops and Dell sells 2x as many laptops as Apple.
Lol, Lenovo
My brand new XPS 17 webcam broke down in 3 days. I returned it
Ooof
@@TallyHoTech yeah the ironic part is, I was about to return my MacBook 16inch to keep XPS 17. for the reasons u mentioned in the video. One day before I was about to return (had initiated the return on apple website) dell webcam not working anymore. Maybe dell is not meant to be.
It’ll be a much more interesting comparisons with 12th gen Intel or the latest Ryzen chips. Not sure Dell will level the playing field with displays.
Genuinely pleased I swapped from a MacBook Pro to XPS. With better battery and performance, I think the XPS will be the perfect machine.
Great video
Yep I agree. Can’t wait for the new CPUs
@@stoychotrenchev4443 ‘better’ is a subjective term. For me, Windows 11 is better.
@@stoychotrenchev4443 I’m far more familiar with Windows. It multitasks much better than MacOS. I like touch and I like the choice of device.
@@stoychotrenchev4443 better for you. It's good that you enjoy it. MacOS cannot even multitask with multiple windows open next to each other. That's so frustrating for me. Have a watch of this.
ruclips.net/video/cfsNO14hikA/видео.html
@@stoychotrenchev4443 well if I wanted to play, it’d be on a Windows PC eh, not a Mac 👌😉
more saturation =/= better display.
I thought the new one (intel gen 12) was out. Waiting to see that comparision.
For best value: Macbook Air M1, good display, good body, good keyboard, excellent battery life.
For more advanced users: ProArt with Ryzen 9 5900X | 64GB | 2TB | RTX 3070 | 120HZ | 100% P3 | Full size SD Express 7 | upgradable RAM/SSD, HDMI 2.1 | 2 USB C | 2 USB A for 2399$
hows the heat and battery life on the asus computer?
I’m waiting for AlderLake gen 12 versions of the XPS LINE,
Dell really needs to consider AMD option
The only thing the PC has over the Mac is the GPU but the rtx 3060 in the Dell is a joke
Never ever buying an XPS again
HDR is such a pain in the ass with windows and they need to get it sorted. That said, its too simplistic to say this is just a pro comparison. "Pro" what?? I'm a professional that uses my laptop almost exclusively, and no i don't need to bake videos for youtube. I'm really tired of youtube rendering bakeoffs as though thats the only usecase for "pros". Also gaming makes Apple a non-starter for me at this point, I don't care how good thier hardware is. Like most people these days, I don't maintain a "work" laptop separatley from my personal one so current needs are much broader than are ususally represented by most reviews and I hope that changes. In my world between these two devices the XPS 17 is the only real option. Obviously there is a smaller creative group where the macbook wins hands down.
I agree. HDR is F’ed in Windows some great points
Compatibility wise go with the Dell
Noice
which has truer colors - "pop" is meaningless
Show of hands... how many of you buy a laptop for video editing and Blender? Out of 36,000 people... I see.... 4? Ok, nice. Very relevant benchmarking then. Thanks.
Wake me up when M1 doesn't suck.
No one tell information like you did :
I follow all but you ;
Give information in easy way ..
Emphasize on very important things and explain it to an idiot ..like the screen
Notice something we all notice it but we don’t have explanation and why ! Which you did , the screen again ( why windows screen looks better ! )
And we never need to see your face , for now at least .
So in behalf of all nerds in the web , I thank you .
Hii thanks for deleting my comment still you are not right…
I don’t delete comments.
@@TallyHoTech I’m really sorry about that …that was my mistake….although my point is most windows laptop will upscale RGB profile to P3 profile…..so that pops more….it doesn’t mean it was right…bcoz MacBook only presents P3 contents as P3 like HDR video or p3 photos on websites ….can check for yourself on some p3 colour gamet test website on both laptop you will definitely understand….by the way you are doing great videos ..I don’t mean you were wrong 👍🏼
"M1 pro comparable to a rtx3080." 😂 Ok mate
This is an amazing time for the computing world. Apple will hold an advantage for years to come until Intel and AMD move to SoCs. Apple has a 10 year head start since developing A1 chips on their iPhone lineup. Apple just needs to scale the M1 architecture with minor improvements going forward to hold the lead.
With those prices they will not be the lead.
na and is close intel will fall behind cause of temperatures
The biggest difference between these two is the OS. Windows is and will always be crap
The DELL XPS screen 'pops' because it's over saturated.
Wow, Dell 17" with 12gen intel will kick m1max ass, sad that I prefer apple environment...
even your charts are in HDR, lol
Yer. You have to or it looks weird SD + HDR together
STILL A DELLL... CASE CLOSED.
Shu yerda ham Windowsni zaryadlashyapti 😸
i love iy
First
Woof
XPS 17 is trash sir