Can I Pray Tarawīh With A Virtual Imam? | Ask Shaykh YQ #59
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 18 сен 2024
- This Ramadan will be a very different one!
Question: Can I pray Tarawīh With A Virtual Imam?
Date Recorded: April 14th, 2020 | EPIC Masjid, TX
Please LIKE, COMMENT, & SHARE!
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Credits:
Outro Nasheed: 'The Good is Still Alive'
Link: tiny.cc/outrona...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Shaykh Dr. Yasir Qadhi - Official Social Media Pages
Facebook: yasirqadhi
Instagram: yasir.qadhi
Twitter: yasirQadhi
Snapchat: snapchat.com/add/yasir.qadhi
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
© Shaykh Dr. Yasir Qadhi - Official RUclips Channel
Salam shaykh Yasir for always clarifying these issues. May Allah bless and protect you.
As Salaamu Alaikom wah Rahmatullahi wah Barkaatuhu, ALHUMDULILAH I am from South Africa AHMED FAIZAL AZIZ, I LOVE YOU BROTHER FOR THE SAKE OF ALLAH AZZA WAJAL, LOVE YOUR CLEAN , CLEAR CUT EXPLANATION, NO BEATING AROUND THE BUSH , MAY ALLAH SUBHANA WAHTALLAH EXCEPT ALL YOUR EFFORTS AND DUAS N BLESS YOU SHEIK YASIR QAHDI
Alsalaam alaikom. The footnote applies to me as a revert to Islam. I have very little Qur'an memorized and with other difficulties it becomes very difficult to pray without assistance of a broadcast or recording. In fact, this is how I learned Al Fatiha, to play the video (faced down that I couldn't see) over and over again with my every salah. One day I found myself reciting independently and it was pretty much the happiest day of my life thus far. Alhamdulillah. I've tried to do two or eight rakat for taraweh prayer on my own, but it hasn't been fruitful. I'll keep trying because I want to please Allah subhanahu wa ta'ala. I will not rush to the easy way, but it's a comfort to know if I need help I can get it in order to pray.
Your efforts will be enormously rewarded by Allah. May Allah bless and raise your ranks in Jannah.
The Prophet (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) said: “The one who is skilled in reciting Qur’an will be with the noble, honourable scribes and the one who recites Qur’an and falters therein, and finds it difficult, will have a double reward.”
Narrated by al-Bukhaari (4937)
Allah Azzawajal will reward you immensely for your efforts my sister Wow Ma Sha Allah Barak Allah May Allah keep you steadfast Ameen 😍😍😍
May Allah swt reward you.Your explanation is on point. Wow may Allah make me one who can articulate at least a fraction like you.Alhamduliah I understand what you are saying .My heart feels the truth. May Allah swt always guide you ameen.
MashaAllah Doctor Shaikh Yasir Qadhi’s presentations are always a great academic treasure for those who seek complete knowledge with understanding, Alhamdulillah!
Seeing some of the comments make me think that some people just like to be told(as if we obey 😉), instead of thinking and making informed decisions on their own.
May Allah always keep Shaikh Yasir Qadhi and all great scholars guided, safe, honored, and blessed. May Allah be pleased with him and reward him abundantly- Aameen ya Rabb ul Aalameen!
May Allah bless you and reward you for all your teaching
Ohhh shaykh, 13:30 was a priceless moment. Can't stop laughing. What an amazing explanation. Alhamdulillah. May Allah expand your life.
Sheikh Dr Yasir Qadhi, an ocean of knowledge. May Allah bless you in this life and the hereafter. Aameen
Great explanation but at times I feel that we complicate matters for ourselves for no reason... perhaps in the same spirit as our brothers from Bani Israel back in the day. Keep it simple, folks; Allah wants ease for you!
Inner Voice i so second this. Things needs to be simple. There should be no debate about this. These are exceptional circumstances. God is the almighty. Counsels or not our intentions to do good and praise God is the only answer.
I would watch Ask Shaykh YQ #58 in which he discusses the origin of Tarawih and why a lot of fiqh councils do this.
May Allah Bless you Dr Qadi
Jazaaka Allah khaïr
Thanks shaykh for discussing this issue.
Thank you so much for this. May Allah SWT bless you abundantly!
Thank for you making this video. I was looking for this information.
The last 4 minutes of this video is just wow...sheikh yasir qadhi for president
May Allah bless you. JazakAllahu Khairan fi dunya wal-akhirah...
Alhamdulillah
Imagine if it is allowed, then all fard prayer can be done at home or mosque livestreaming Mecca imam on the same time zone.
ماشاء الله
You in a simple topics longed so much 😍
Alahu akbar
Ma sha Allah
Allah hi offege, allah give you success and safety.
Rasoolullahi صلى الله عليه وسلم
obviously preferred his followers to pray at home .. secondly this VT fatwa opens the door for new frontiers for Bid'a .. then, it may be argued that virtual jamah is more apt for Jummah prayer as it is a compulsory congregational prayer... unfortunately we find in Islamic history that daring " scholars " have often been reasons to divide the Ummah ... I appeal to all my brothers and sisters to disregaed such thoughts when, on this issue following the tradition of our Nabi صلى الله عليه وسلم
is clearly uncomplicated.
Assalamu alaikkum Jazakallah khair Sheikh
Instead of moulding to these abnormal , deliberate situations , one must fight to bring back the normalcy.you are opening the door to innovation.
Nusrat Shahid what’s normal?
It's not innovation in the middle of a pandemic. Dont be ignorant. Dont you think everyone wishes we could go to the masjid. Buts it's for everyone's safety to stay put.
bisma baig i agree with you. its not an innovation if something is decided upon based on a pandemic current situation, and them when everything goes back to normal we can go back to the normal rules. As long as long we are not adapted to the new way.
Allāhumma ṣalli wa sallim ‘Alā Sayyidinā wa Mawlānā Muḥammadin Khayril-khalqi kullihim. Āmīn.
JazakAllahukhair This question needed a clarification ans it was done at the correct time
This is the beauty of Islam.. as this is just an opinion of Shaykh Yasir and the fiqh jury and the majority.. and if someone does.not.agree.with his opinion.. he/she can follow the opinion of Shaykhs such as Shaykh Shabir Ally and other some prominent shaykhs who holds the other opinion .. as we all understand taraveeh is not a.necessity but prayers such as Eid salaah there would be a bid doubt as what to do. May be in that scenario the other virtual opinion.is good
Is there any new updates this year? Can we pray at home with our imam live in the UK?
Exactly ..whoever knows the Quran and Taraweeh...They Offer their Own Prayer ....whoever doesn't knows much about Quran and willing to offer prayer ..he can follow it thinking he is doing his own salat by listening to virtual imam..not as a jamat
MashaAllah Shaykh Yasir Qadhi is that your recitation in the beginning .. ?? It beautiful Alhumdulillah !!
جزاکم الله
Brother , take a position . don't confuse masses. This telecast should have been finished in 5-7 minutes. No virtual salah or traweeh. Period
I find it very suspicious that women have been praying upstairs, downstairs and in whole different buildings here in the US for decades and no one had anything to say about it being invalid.
Yet when men are affected, the fiqh councils get together to outlaw it. Can someone speak up for desegregating the masajid so that the female congregants can see the imam too?!
From what I know, it isn't an obligation for woman to see the imam. Just the voice and to be within the mosque limits. I'd try not to be suspicious of these respected scholars. They're trying their best.
Segregation is required in a Masjid, free mixing is not permitted in Islam.
Jazakallah khairan !
AOA WRWB Shaykh,
What about leading by one of the family member with open Quran ?
Nice explanation Mashallah, looks like our brother Hamza Abbasi would be disappointed with it.
😂😂😂😂
@@XYZ-ny3uk I guess it happens with everyone in the beginning. You're full of passion and somehow make your own mind about "how stuff works" (including religion), and want to press in favour of your own ideology. We should remain impartial (as much as possible) and always seek out the true understanding of Islam regardless of our emotional affiliations.
Allah knows best.
According to the hadith quoted in this video, in order for jamaat, voice of imam to be heard or row should be visible. Isn't both possible through live video streaming?? 🤔
You have to be standing shoulder to shoulder in congregation, something you can't do in virtual stream.
You need to consider the location. You are not in the vicinity and may not behind the imam. Also if you just by to be heard and visible just for learning, the playback will be OK then but consider not as jamaah.
Looking at a screen is not the same as seeing a row and hearing a sound through a speaker is not the same as hearing someone's voice.
@@Believer1995ofGod What if you can congregate with 3 adult males?
@@SM-ly5tf you can congregate like that, have one person lead the prayer and the other two form a saff
Salam Shiekh, after watching your video, some questions come to my mind and could you please explain: If someone is following virtual imam then how he/she will maintain the khoshu and khuzu of his/her prayer?...This will lead people to start doing all types of things like for example using devices to play the Quran during salah or performing prayers on conference calls using zoom meetings...don't you think you are opening a pandora box here...Also did you seek advice with Mufti Azam Dr.Taqi Usmani in this regard? What is Mufti-e-Azam opinion in this regard?
Salaam Shaykh...I'm in Guyana South America...I follow your congregation for Taraweeh..I hope the time difference will be accepted...we break fast at 6:04 and I join the taraweeh 10:30...is that ok?
Can I ask questions concerning islamic jurisprudence to a virtual mufti? - oh. awkward
What will happen if live broadcast goes off by internet problem or electric problem in the middle of Salaht.
Just continue on your own, just like you do if you join late. Big deal.
May I recite from almushaf whhen prYinh Taraaweeg
Shuayb Gallo yesss you can
why else are we making high complex VR headsets?
I don't think you can do a proper prostration with one of those on lol
They are also VIRTUAL reality not physical, which Sheikh explained
@@hiiammoot 😂😂😂😂😂
Assalamualikum, How do I ask question to the shaykh? Can some one let me know ?
Email him
Salam Allah
What about jum'ah salah during Pandemic?
Two rows that means women are not in Jamaa always.
He said there needs to be a connection for it to be considered jamaa. Women pray behind the men in the same vicinity so it's considered congregation no matter how far women are from the imam since that connectivity exists .
While praying what if there is a power failure 😁
Well, if it's night time you'll probably be in the dark. If it's not then don't worry about it.
I'm not clear. Can any1 plz make it clear?
Which is,
Does the one who is following virtual Imam (even though in reality he is not, as the Shaykh said) need to recite Surah Fatiha by himself according to this Fiqh which he was talking at the end?
Jazzak Allah Khair
Yes , recite Surah fatiha
I sometimes wonder, do people who ask these type of questions really interested in learning their religion? This is a 3rd grade Islamic school question smh
What about praying in different floors in a Masjid? Is that Jama'ah Valid?
yes
@@mahmoodsayeed4 Reference?
Of course it is not allowed
Does shaykh Yasir allow performing jumaah at home with family under current circumstances ❓
Pray Duhur at home with family
@@majidhussain3896
Actually I am praying juma'a at home, coz there is lots of ulama that allow that under the current situation
If I’m not mistaken, the minimum people for juma’a are 20 people.
@@YeahAkka
Pardon me for saying you are mistaken and correct the same time❗❗❗
You are correct that some ulamaa did mention 40 ppl and different numbers as a condition for performing juma'a, but the mistake is these numbers have no evidence from Quran or Sunnah, actually juma'a is derived from jama'a, and Jama'a is performed by 2 ppl and up....
How to ask?
JAK
What about praying Jummah at home, in light of present circumstances?
@Hedz Almador according to???
Salafis will say you can but one of the conditions of the Hanafi School is the juma must be open invitation. So your home needs to be open to anyone to join.
@Hedz Almador but he didn't say that you can pray jumu ah in your home.
@@007kash007 brother no. They don't say that.
We can not Pray Jummah at home.
Walahu Aalam.
Asalamualikum sir . I asked this question in the comments section on your other video but it wasnt answered. Anyway my husband is a student in madina Islamic university and he says that any games involving dice نرد is Haram as it is stated in a hadith that I can't recall .but he said whoever plays with dice is like putting his hands in the blood and flesh of a pig. Please clarify this as I know in Pakistan many of my relatives are addicted to ludo .
Your Pakistani relatives probably follow the Hanafi view, they have two main opinions: 1) Dice games aren’t allowed 2) That games that use dice for gambling and involve real money aren’t allowed, those that use dice but are skill based and don’t involve gambling and money then it it allowed. The second opinion is followed by most Hanafi imams I know. For more info on the Hanafi view refer to the following links: ruclips.net/video/vdhtdazoL0A/видео.html and islamqa.org/hanafi/askimam/17715
@@abdulhakim9537 Would monopoly be allowed?
Sajid Yes if no actual money is involved and it doesn’t consume your time islamqa.org/hanafi/askimam/28635
👈🏾👌
The foot note was stupid.Really
Be brave man. If you think it is right then say it!
I am sorry but how stupid it is to say that you happen to go into ruku with the imam and just happens to do this and that. Who are are you kidding? Allah? Seriously?
Its exactly like the yahoodi used to do on saturday to catch fish.
Salam SYQ,
I am very disappointed with this video.....
You talk about you are not comfortable with the opinion of following a Jamaah while being miles away......
I mean for Ibadaat, there should be clear cut evidence to back up a Hukum.....
I don't know why you have to even mention such flawed opinion based on personal point of view......
Just stick to the Daleel Sharii and be firm on it....Ibadaat are not issues that you can compromise on.....
Remember the first knot to be undone in Islam was the Khilafah and the last know to be undone is Salaah.....
Other than that Allah knows best....
And what is your position and the references for it ya sheikh?
just do what I do: listen to the Quran recitation on RUclips and pray your own Taraweeh at your own pace. no need for an Imam! :D
u cant pray like tht.the recording on the youtube is in the past.hope u was joking and if u was u shuld stop.
You don't recite Quran in salah? You just listen to ur mobile?
@@shahul8222 yes, and I read the English translation at the same time
@@AvatarAang926 im sorry to say this. Your prayers are invalid. You cant do that in prayer. You can't recite Quran in any other language in salah. And in salah either you or the imam leading you has to recite the Quran. You cant just listen to tapes and pray.
@@AvatarAang926 we can't invent new things in our religion. We have to practice how Allah and his messenger taught.
LOL the purpose of this video is really silly and should be common sense. This yasir guy I see him alot and I see a bunch of sheep following him and his every word. 🤨
Many people pose this question every year so it's not silly. And the sheikh answered it in accordance to the majority scholarly opinion and emphasized on the correctness of that opinion several times.
regardless of what it is, its very ignorant and insolently of you to humiliate a person, a muslim brother and yet a Qari.... you ought to ashamed of what you write. Ask Allah for forgiveness for your hypocrisy before its too late. and also if you dont like him or agree with him then no one is forcing you to listen to him. You can take your ignorance and hibernate in deep end of your cave.
shegufta sultana sorry you say but you are a 🐑 and I’m trying to wake you up not everything he says is true and actually you’re the hypocrite here ... I’m a hypocrite towards yaser but you are a hypocrite towards your deen ... May Allah guide you on the right path and wake you up ..
shegufta sultana go listen to sheikh Imran hosein and enlighten yourself listen to real sheikhs real qaris... get outa my face with your bs