Это видео недоступно.
Сожалеем об этом.
The History of Karachi, Part 1, From Ram to Alexander
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 14 янв 2024
- References
Memoirs of Seth Naomal Hotchand
The History of India, as Told by Its Own Historians
The Muhammadan Period · Volume 1
By Henry M. Elliot · 1867
"Sita's Sisters- Women of Ramayan " by Kiran Kane Published 2017
And all of Hanuman’s men
put this temple together again, Express Tribune
Kurrachee: Past, Present And Future 1890
By: Alexander F. Baillie
DISCOVERIES OF NEOLITHIC SETTLEMENTS IN MALIR RIVER VALLEY, SINDH, PAKISTAN
Dr Shamshad Akhtar
Muhammad Rafique Dhanani
ARCHAEOLOGICAL FIELD RESEARCH IN PAKISTAN SINCE INDEPENDENCE: AN OVERVIEW
M. Rafique Mughal
Pakistan Archaeology
Number 8-1972
Muhammad Ishtiaq Khan
Karachi in the Mirror of History, Usman Damohi
_____________________________________________________________________
CHAPTERS
Intro : 00:10
Stone Age Settlements in Gadap and Malir 1:35
Abdur Rauf Khan's Work in Karachi 2:51
Cognitive Revolution in 3:50
Konkar, Khadeji relics 6:31
Malir relics 7:00
Indus Valley Civilization in Karachi 9:04
Ram Chandra in Karachi 10:27
Alexander in Karachi 13:55
Alexander's Heaven 17:30
Nearchus and Alexanders Exit 19:29
Morortobara 22:00
Hanuman in Karachi 23:14
The old Port of Karachi 24:15
Was Debal actually Karachi 26:00
Lenin 28:56
The destruction of Debal 30:15
Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @shafaatali007
Would like to apologize for 2 mistakes in this video
1st: Narrating the Story of Ramayana, I said that Ram's sister-in-law (Mandavi) wanted Ram to be exiled. This unfortunately is not the Ramayana version but a version of a book I read a few years ago titled "Sita's Sister- Women of Ramayana" by Kavita Kane. There was a mix-up and I humbly apologize for the religious sentiments hurt by this line.
2nd: Although the location of the Shakti Peetha in Balochistan is right, the area mentioned is not Mastung but Lasbela district.
Please issue a video on this..!
Also work on narrating with right bullet points!!
I have a lot of respact for you and I know you possess a lot of different talent...
Infact we worship ART??
Hope you know Afghanistani Regime used to kill all kind of ART by killing Artists....!!
We never support all this...!!
We love art that is why some people also worship some artist also..!!
I request you just read your Last 5-11 ancestor history...!!
We are brother from thousands of year!!🙂
Please read more and more before any video appearances !!
I am your admirer for your different talent...!!
May I know how do you choose the writers or authors for information??
14 years banwas was of the pandavas. banwas ( voluntary exile)
Ram Chandra ji ki Kahani Apne Galat batai.. Ram Ji ki Soteli Ma ne apne bete ko takht dene ke liye Ram Chandra ji ko Unki Takhtnashini se ak rat pehle hi Vanwas Bhejne ka Vachan liya tha.. Apne Valid ke vachan ko Nibhane ke liye vo Vanwas gae the .. Jinke sath unki begam Sita or Chhota bhai Laksham bhi Gae the.. Vahi Vo bhai jise Raja banane ke liye Ram ko Vanwas bheja gaya.. usne Bhi Tkht lene se Mana kar diya or Ram ke nam se hi Raj chalaya , jab tak ki Ram Vanwas se Vapas nahi aa gae ..Ramayan ke Iraq se Japan tak Aashar milte hai.. Yaha tak ki bohot se western Historians Mante hai ke Greek Devtaon par Bhi Indian Kahaniyon ke kirdaron ka Asar Dikhta hai.. Ramayan Ko Valmiki ji ne likha tha, Magar ye Kahani Itani Kadeem kahani hai, Or Japan tak feli hai, isliye iske Sekadon version milte hai.. Jinme se North india ke zyadatar log Mugal dor me Likhi gai Tulsi Das ji ki Ramayan ko follow karte hai or TV , Films me Vahi dikhai jati hai ..
Factual error- Lord Rama's stepmother conspired to give exile not brother. Infact, all 4 brothers are one soul!
Bro the fact a Pakistani even knows something about his own pre-Islamic history is a WIN for us. I’ll give him a pass for not know the details….
@@thinkingcitizen bro in reality ram is myth. to itna detail mai baat nahi hosak te hai. i respect ram but koi historical proof nahi hai unka. bus tum hara darm grant chodkar .
@@Tony_stark_453then Adam is also myth ,Hawa is also myth Abraham is also myth
@@Tony_stark_453Bhai myth mtlb jhooth nhi hota. Myth ka mtlb hota hai Jo sach aur jhooth ko Mila k Banta hai. Humari Sanskrit se purani koi known language nhi aur sabsey purani likhi books humari he hai toh hum kisi or ki taraf kyu dekhne humari history k liye, jab voh likhna padhna nhi jantey thay shikar ker k jeetay thay tum humari sari books baccha baccha yaad karta tha, humko unlogo se certificate ki zarurat nhi hai
@@Tony_stark_453 just because there’s no proof doesn’t mean it’s myth. Before 1800s, there was no proof of Bacteria and Germs because research had not been done yet. But that DID NOT mean Bacteria and Germs is a myth before discovery!
Apppreciated,In the era of peoples getting millions of views showing their families,when you know you don't get so many likes/views with these videos still making efforts & giving knowledge. keep it up we need peoples like shafaat ❤
Wonderful. I had read many versions of the Ramayan, I believe there are over 300 with Buddhist Ramayan, Indonesian Ramayan, Thailand Ramayan and of course Chinese, Bhutanese and Burmese Ramayan, Jain Ramayan, 10-12 Urdu Ramayan, but never knew of this aspect of the shakti Peeth and Ram temple in Karachi.
A minor correction, Ram was not thrown out by his brother, but his father Dahsrat had three wives and his third wife wanted her son to rule (King Bharat) and when he found out, he refused and ruled with Ram’s sandals on the throne to return when Ram fullfilled his father’s promise. Of course, Sita gets abducted by Ravan and he than travels south to retrieve her. Also Asoka was from the Maurya dynasty, Guptas came after in the 1-2 CE and is described as the golden period. The maurya’s basically united India 2500 years back, starting with Chandragupta Maurya (not Gupta) and his political head -Chanakya or Kautilya, than his grandson Asoka.
Wonderful and Well Done. Allahahafiz, Jai siya ram.
Tum salo Hindus ka yehi prblm hai kisi Kat…..e ne likha tujhe Jai Sri Ram jo tu. Allah hafiz likhra hai
No proof of Ram in your scriptures.
@bannedone3ice138 which scriptures are you referring to?
@@bannedone3ice138 what, heard of a little thing called Ramayan- lol.
@@rohandev1444 Ramayan wasn’t written by Ram. Your own Hindus don’t know who Ram is.
Bhai ne 70-75 thousand years pehle se history batana shuru kiya hai, aur aadhe ghante ke ander pura timeline cover kiya hai. Massive respect.
Correction- Shri Ram was exiled by his step mother not Bhabhi. His stepbrother Bharat never accepted shri ram kingdom even when Shri Ram was exiled to jungle for 14 years.
Dear Shafaat, brilliant, I am surprised, I thought you are just an entertainer, but you are well educated, well read person, considering your age. Please keep up this good and informative task. Actually I am always interested in the history of Karachi, brought up since birth in Karachi, I am over 60. I wish you all the best.
keep up making these sort of historical videos. Awesome stuff.
Karachi and whole ofPakistan has so much potential to market and sell its historical aspect to attract all sorts of tourism. Really sad that this isn't even in the list of things our real leaders want to do.
None of the things and none of the leaders. They all fighting for themselves sadly.
Correction sir, ram ji ke bhai bharat kabza nahi karte hai. Story goes like this king dashrath had 3 queens one of them was kaikeyi she was given 2 boon by king dashrath. She was manipulated by female servent called manthra, and she asked dashrath to give exile to lord ram for 14 years and future king should be her son bharat instead of elder son lord ram, so lord ram accepted it and went to the forest while bharat came to ayodhya later and he found out his elder brothers lord ram and laxman with sita ji went to exile. He went to lord ram in forest and asked them to come back but lord ram refused it as it was order of his father king Dashrath, then bharat told lord ram that he will rule ayodhya as servent of ram, and lord ram will rule ayodhya as real king after he comes back. 😊 I hope you got it right.
How refreshing to hear a Pakistani giving a speech without once mentioning "Islam" or "kafir" or "hindu dushman" ! I suppose thanks are due to you for a wonderful speech!!
Dear Shafaat, I'd like to share an intriguing tale about Nani ka Mandir in Hingol, known as Hinglaaj Mataa. Legend has it that during the war for Sita's freedom between Ram and Rawan, Rawan, a devoted disciple of Shiv ji Maharaj, was defeated and killed. In order to absolve himself of the sin of slaying such a devout follower of Lord Shiv, Ram was advised by the gurus to embark on the Hinglaaj Yatra. Following their counsel, Ram Ji undertook the pilgrimage to Hinglaaj Mata, where he offered his hair in a gesture similar to the tradition observed during Hajj.
00:02 The history of Karachi is not limited to recent cultural events, but dates back to ancient times.
02:39 The work of Mohammad Abdul Rauf Khan Sahab in identifying ancient sites in Karachi and surrounding areas.
07:35 Karachi's history intertwines with the Indus and Harappan civilizations.
10:57 Ramchandra ji decides to spend 14 years in exile as penance
15:44 The army had two return route options: along the river to the sea or moving along the coast and reaching back to Greece.
17:49 British officers tried to decode the names of areas in Karachi to find Alexander Haven.
22:33 Karachi's historical significance and diverse population
24:46 Karachi's early history is a complex mix of Hindu and Buddhist influences.
28:57 Lenin's primary cult vasion was in Sindh.
31:08 Debal faced a devastating flood and wave, leading to widespread destruction and loss of life
You summed it up😅
@@ShafaatAli007 just keep on eye on engagement graph in your channel dashboard
Thank you Shafat for this Amazing history videos, after this a lot of people like me will be interested in history and preserve this valuable knowledge.
Honestly honestly this content was so interesting since History is my one of the favorite subject and I really appreciate your research and work, I not even expected that how old and curious places exist in my city Karachi 🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻
Zardari conquered karachi in 2000 BC along with Alexander the great . 😂 this is also the part of sindh history
😂
Oss time Bhutto tha? But ...butto zinda zror ho ga😂😊
😂
Zardari Baluch Tribe is the largest Tribe ruling Sind for 400 years appointed by Nader Shah from Iran. Zardari are Shia Baluchs but they used to be Sunni as well as Ismaili don't be a racist when it comes to history.
These people's just want to say no Balochs no Sindhis we are the one and only😂@@ChefbyMistake
Excellent and very interesting unfolding of complex historical layers
Glad you enjoyed it
Excellent podcast Shafaat sb. First ever history of Karachi with authentic references. Really appreciate your efforts.
Thanks for listening and Liking
@@ShafaatAli007 It is my special interest subject. Is it possible to connect?
This is the content that sensible people appreciate and should be promoted....keep making these videos and let people like me learn more from your knowledge..
Much appreciated!
بہت عمدہ ۔۔۔اگلے حصہ کا شدت سے انتظار ہے ❣️
Sindhi fishermen are the oldest population of Karachi. You can find them on Khadda market lyari, Gizri, Ibrahim Hyderi, Rerhi Goth, Younusabad hawksbay, Manora. According to them, there were seven fishermen brothers called “Morro(name you mentioned)” in their ancestors, and these brothers were actually sons of “Mayi Qalaati (Woman of Qalaat) after known as “Mayi Kolachi”.
Edit: There is a seven people graveyard located on Gulbayi maripur road called “مورڑو بھائیوں کی قبریں”
@@tausifhassan445 they are Sindhis not balochs. Ancient Sindh covered huge areas from Makran to Kutch, from Khuzdar and Kachhi & Sibi to Jaisalmer and Barmer, from Karachi to Sulaiman ranges and til Multan. It was all Sindh.
And Mai Kolachi was a Sindhi med woman (fishing tribe), she along with her family came to deybal for fishing, she originally was from Kulanch Valley of makran, which back in time was Sindh.
Even today it is majority Sindhi jadgal population.
@PavitShokeenandhbhakt please stop this typical Teasing hate , no need to remind people. This is not political channel, such a sahem that you are commenting here on a channel which isnt discussing any politics . please behave maturely.
@@sahilsingh6048Chal bhag khoteistani Bhagat
@@ScindianLadyou are 100 percent right brother. I'm very happy to see that you know the history of sindh and sindhi people. Salute 🫡
@@tahaabdullah1751 thank you, I wish very Sindhi also read and know about history, instead of listening to others, because they only tell the history which suits them.
There are so many Sindhi origin people in balochistan which are entirely labeled as balochs just because they live in balochistan.
It's funny how a Sindhi origin tribe from balochistan who spoke Sindhi language and migrated into today's Sindh province calls themselves baloch, when infact they are of same race as Sindhis.
Whole of Makran (including iranian makran), Lasbela, Khuzdar, Kachhi plain region (9 districts or so), Kohe Sulaiman this whole was Sindh, inhabited by Sindhi jats (jadgals), Sindhi mohana, Mallah, mirbahar (Med), Sindhi Rajputs (Gichkis), Sindhi Gurjars (Lunds), Sindhi Sammats (Numria etc), even many Sindhi hindu dewans after becoming muslims now call themselves balochs or Brohis for example Mengals were Sindhi agarwal hindus, back time were included among jadgals, today they think they are balochs. Very sad.
And that's the same thing for South Punjab, Kutch and western Rajasthan.
Pls Pakistan may hindu worship places jo ancient history say hai us per High light video banayeay
I think this is the best history telling of karachi. Well researched. Comprehensive. Looking forward for the other parts as well.
شکریہ شفاعت بھائی
بہترین کام کیا ہے آپنے کراچی کی تاریخ پر۔
Oh my God! Khush reho bhaai! Mazzzaaaa aa gayaaa! I loved each bit of it bro! Lookout forward to the sequels.
PS: I am architect and teach history, so chasss hi aa gui!!!
Your this podcast for sure is gonna be one of the teaching extra informal resources and the way you have compiled all the relevant research is commendable.
Selemat rehye, Allah Paak bless you with more beneficial knowledge, amen.
Much duas your way, QT
beautifuly explained, Shafaat if possible add some visual inserts to make it more informative . great video
Karachi a city within a subcontinent : city full of sindhis, baloch, pashtuns, delhi walay, rajhisthani, bengali, bihari,marathi, madrasi, punjabi, siraiki, mysori, (up, mp, hyderabad) urdu speaking, kashmiri, afghans, irnians this is how diverse my city is
This is how diverse your city was 😂😂😂
all due to partition
You missed Marathi people from Maharashtra India. 😊
Not anymore😢
Very well done. Lots of new information about Karachi. Keep up the good work!
Thanks a ton
Loved it , Shafaat Bhai
I can't believe the level of knowledge you have got. needless to mention I loved the way you used every Hindu figure with so much respect. Love you, mate.
Ishita are you really a hindu and indian if yes than you would have easily found at lest 10 mistakes, If you want I can help you with time stamp.
I know obviously, but he was respectful and knew something usually most Pakistani don't know @@ankushyadav6814
Very Impressive narration. Please continue doing more such historical Vlogs . May Allah bless you.
Thank you, I will
مجھے پہلی دفعہ کراچی کی تعریف تاریخ کے ساتھ یوٹیوب پر نظر ائی ہے ، شُکریہ شفات ( shafaat)
Thank you so much and you did the best and also ou also explain very well. superb welldone
Keep it up bro excellent work please use historical prictures and maps of specific areas of you talking about during the video waiting for part 2 please maximize the time during of video
I would like to correct you on Ramayan.
Ram's brother, Bharat was not jealous of Ram. Ram's step mother and Bharat's mother, Kaikeyi made Ram leave Ayodhya because she was instigated by her maid, Manthara.
Whenever I tell people of Karachi about their history, they either start hating me or believe that i am just showing off. Nobody believes on it. The history is interesting, but the present is extremely sad.
Pakistanis comes from an ancient people and Pakistan is the land of the ancient Sindh (Indus) Valley Civilization ❤
NAMASTE.JAI SHRI RAM🕉🕉🕉🕉🕉🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🛕🛕🛕🛕🙏🙏🙏🔱🔱🔱😊😊😊😊😊😊🔱🔱🔱🙏🙏🛕🛕🕉🕉🚩😊🔱🙏🛕🛕🛕🚩😊🕉🚩
🔱🙏🛕🛕😊😊🕉🕉🚩
Jak , really appreciate ur work, keep it up. From Canada
Dear Shafaat shb you are doing good job very informative knowledge and information. Appreciated. Keep it up. Like it.
You have no idea how much these valuable comments mean to me. For every single video there is a huge effort on reading books, research papers, archives and articles. Comments like yours make me feel lighter
Accidentally I saw you video. I could not believe what a wonderful work . I will be waiting for your next video. Well done 👍
Thank you so much 😀
Bhai sahib your story of Ram as narrated by you is totally wrong. It wasn’t the brother of Ram or his wife who sent him to the 14 years vanwas but the stepmother of Ram who got Ram’s father to agree to this.
ڏاڍو سٺو شفاعت ڀاءَ / buht alla shfaat bhai
Keep up the good work 👍 Jai Hind, Vande Mataram 🙏
Now a days there are so many problems in Karachi. But I love Karachi I don't why but I love it with my core of heart 🙃
Really can't see Karachi like this and InshaAllah we all will not leave Karachi like this. 😢
I was waiting for this video since you discussed this with giaz. Maza aya ♥️
Imagine how Lyari river was not long ago. Clear running water, wild life on the banks. Just a beautiful place to be. Sad how it looks now.
This is same era ending in Malir River 😢
It’s not only Lyari whole of Karachi has turned into a garbage dump…sadly
Sir you are doing a great work. Please keep it up.
Dear Shafaat...congratulation and thank you for this presentation...I always thought of you as a young comedian ..But obviously it is not the case..As a old karachieite living in UK since last 30 + years I am glad that we have young people like you , who are not stereo type and are intellectually ambitious...Good of you keep doing what you are doing . Specially with your unique way of lightly humorous tinge .
Great effort 👍history is such a fascinating subject, its unfortunate that our school curriculum hardly talks about pre Islamic era.
So adorable… History of Karachi told in such an interesting manner. Thanks Shafaat Ali.
Great Stuff..Would like you to give such Presentations of our history, in Universities. And do work on other cities. Maybe from Gawadar to north.... ⬆. All the best..!
Waiting for part two, if possible could we be a bit more detail oriented and use map when talking about movements. In order to get better idea. Great work brother 👍
Keep it up!
Noted!
Barat Takhat par kabija nhi karta hai. Shree ram ke father ne promise kiya tha Barat ki mam mandodari ko (because of manthara) . Barat ko mam ke ghar par tha usko to pata hi nhi tha. Ram vanvas ram ke promise jo dasarath ko kiya tha , ki bajase gaye.
@@ShafaatAli007Barat Takhat par kabija nhi karta hai. Shree ram ke father ne promise kiya tha Barat ki mam mandodari ko (because of manthara) . Barat ko mam ke ghar par tha usko to pata hi nhi tha. Ram vanvas ram ke promise jo dasarath ko kiya tha , ki bajase gaye.
Kindly note correction: 'Bharat ki maa Kaikeyi' (Mandodari was Ravana's wife)
Videos like these deserve millions of views and likes rather than videos titled (aj bache ka naam rakha) (biwi k sath laraiiii.) (6 million subscribers ganja challenge complete)
Very nice effort to bring the history into such importance.
Excellent, enjoyed this a lot, i dont ever comment on videos but more content like this please
Good subject. Appreciated from India.
Zbrdst!!!!! Tasub c pak history.
Shafaat appp k ilim ko salam hai.. urdu speaking mein is age mein app jesa ilim zaheen broad minded banda mene nahi dekha ❤
Bohot hi acha topic hai shafaat bhai ,,good job..
Excellent effort Shafaat Ali sb, well done 👍 looking forward to history of different areas of Karachi going forward.
As a Karachiite its very intriguing, excited for the next part.
Thanks
What a treat to watch!
Great stories and awesome way to explain. I GAVEYOU 5 STARS
Very thankful for the effort you have put into this video. I pray that Allah grants you multiple times more reward for your effort.
Zabardast @shafaat Bhai awesome work very interesting and knowledgeable
I highly appreciate your effort and may it bring some understanding of this legendary history. And it would be a benchmark in academia as well. Respect for you.
Wait is on for part 2 shafaat bhai
Inshallah on Saturday
Very Interesting and well researched history of Karachi.Keep it up!Waiting for the next Part.
Shafaat Bhai would request you to please say the years and dates in English too, as most people get confused in the dates and years in Urdu,like 326.
Hope you can cover the full history of Karachi till now,from being the Capital as envisioned by Mr.Jinnah.Mr.Jinnah dream of Karachi as a progressive city was very sadly killed by Ayub Khan by shifting the capital from Karachi, to being Treated like an Orphan Now! Thank you.
Wonded ful information. Well done
Mari is a Sindhi word meaning castle/Palace or multi storey building, so if there is a three storey building it will be "Trimari/Trimar" and if its a four storey building then it will be called "Chomaari/Chomar" in Sindhi.
There are many folk Sindhi songs in which the "Mari" word has been used, for example, a Sindhi folk song:
Umar! Mu na waran tuhjun "Mariyun" (plural) Alla.
Meaning: Oh Umar! I don't like your castles and palaces.
A Sindhi Sehra (wedding folk song):
Ehya "Marri" te dekharyo, jeh me kunwar wethi aah.
Meaning: Show us that castle or building in which the bride is sitting.
Sindhi poem (Paiso ladhum pat tan) also uses this word in one of its lines:
Kako wetho "Mari" me, dang lagus darhi mein.
Meaning: Uncle was sitting in a building, and he got stung on his beard.
So it's not a Balochi or brahui word. Maybe it also got to used in balochi and brahvi.
As Balochi and brahui have a lot of Sindhi and Urdu words, especially in Makrani and Sulaimani. As much as that, some experts call them a mix of Sindhi and balochi.
This topic has been discussed in pretty decent detail by Elliot in his book in 1867. He is of the opinion that the word Mari or Mauri got into the Nomenclature by the Baloch roots of it. Probably focussed more on the word Kiya instead of Mari. Thank you so much for your special comment
@@ShafaatAli007 Elliot definitely got confused with the first word Kiya, as it's probably a Balochi word but not "Mari"
Bai maza aya bht aaala asaaan alfaaz me Karachi discover krdia. Ha kch history Hinduism se related shafaat bhai se Aage peeche hogai hogi Jo history inhe mile to koi Pakistan ya India ka Brother or sister mind na kre qk Yeh region ek hi tha JB Hindu Muslim boundaries me bate hue na the. Or Karachi me Hindu temple bht shaaandaar bane hue hai or sab purely safe hai at every event. Hope our indians fellows will enjoy when they visit Karachi. We welcome u all
Great work please never stop with the conquest to uncover history. You will always have a diligent supporter in me. Lots of prayers
Please use animations and maps to illustrate the story for those who dnt know the geography of the area
It will b a great help for better understanding
Trying my best on it
@@ShafaatAli007Barat Takhat par kabija nhi karta hai. Shree ram ke father ne promise kiya tha Barat ki mam mandodari ko (because of manthara) . Barat ko mam ke ghar par tha usko to pata hi nhi tha. Ram vanvas ram ke promise jo dasarath ko kiya tha , ki bajase gaye. Bharat to Ram ko lene gya. Ram ki Charan paduka lekar aaya unko raj gaddi par rkha kar shasan kiya
@@ok-uq1pxshe was kaikae ( कैकयी) .
Love from India ❤️🇮🇳.Very Informative
There was a little mistake that she was Ram's Step mother who wanted his son to Rule over Awadh.👍
Apna itihas jaan na bahot jaruri hai. Thodi bahot mistakes hain bt very well delivered 👏 🇮🇳 KASH IS KHITEY K LOG AAPSI EKTA BHAICHARE KO SAMAGH SAKAIN
شفاعت علی
You ar my best ancer
BEST SPEEK.........
Thanks a lot for this talk. You are touched by The Mother of The Land and The Transcendental. Pranam
Ramayan galat kaha apne , unke Bhai neh une nahi beja vanvas , it was his stepmother, All the brothers were known for their love and respect for their brother Ram. Infact when Ram goes to vanvas the brother(Bharatha)who rules the country ruled by placing the chappal of lord Ram in throne .
Good 👍 information Bhai
This is exceptional shafaat Bhai. Keep it coming. This is the first time I'm learning about my City
Buhut maza aayaa, intizaar rahay ga doosri qist ka. Buhut behtereen or mushkil Kaam Kia hay aapnay. Khush rahain Aabaad rahain. Aameen
I really enjoyed the videos as it's very informative and the way you explained. Your urdu and its accent are both great.
Well done 👍🏻,, waiting for next part.
Zabardast kaam zabardast videos
Great job.....um speachless....keep doing this...keep informing us about our own land❤❤
Very lovable video made on our history,as we know India Pakistan share same history,and nuval harrari book is summarised reference to history of mankind.I visited national museum Delhi,I love our history telling who were our ansesters....
Hindus past are very mystic and exciting 👍
بہت بہترین۔ اپ کی اس ویڈیو سے بہت جانکاری ہوئی، شکریہ👍
Hello I did not quite get the reference to debal's destruction, would appreciate the mention thanq
Fantastic research Shafaat sahab, never thought Karachi has such massive history with Hindu religious figures, temples & Greeks armies. Arabs conquest of Sindh and events thereafter till 1947 are discussed and taught in academia but noone mentioned these amazing facts like you did in this Vlog. Proud to be Karachiite.
man you are doing a great job
So nice waiting for another session keep it up Sindhi Brahmin from India
Correct your story about Ramchandraji . Bharat's mother Kekayee is step mother of Ram. Bharat's nanny Manthara poisons Kekayee's mind to ask Dashratha Ram's father to send Ram to exile and make Bharat the king. Ram being a dutiful son left the throne of Ayodhya for his brother Bharat and went to the forest for exile for fourteen years.
i will correct you on Ram's story
RAM's step mother RANI KAYKAI she was from Sindh royal family got jealous and asked her husband to give Ram Banbas for 14 years ... and announce Bharat as King of the Ayodiya
sadly u stated Ram's brother captured the crown and his wife disliked Ram ...
which is totally incorrect narration of the Rammayaan Katha ...
i do like u intellectual level, depth of u intense research... and profound understanding of the history mythology and traditional stories of local people ...
please kindly verify my statement and if i am correct please do provide the correction in u next video
thank you so much
Just the way there are supporters of Rawan, there are also the haters of Mandavi as well. It's sometime difficult to choose a closer to truth narrative. Some see her as incarnation of Lakhshmi , some see her as a prime beneficiary of Ram's exile.
But you are right in anyway, onus of Kaikaye and Manthara's doing can not be put on Mandavi alone. She at maximum could have been the facilitator, nothing more
@@ShafaatAli007
i dont know why u are bringing extra characters of the Ramayana
as far as Bhagwan Raam's Bunvas is concerned bottom line there are no two ways to tell this epic story details....
the one correct and common narrative is aka
Rani Kaykai and her loyal servant insecurities jealousy and greed to have power in the kingdom caused this sadden moment ..
where Rani Kaykai emotionally blackmailed her Husband .. by removing all her jewelry which was a must for a wedded women to wear as she is a " SHUAGAN"
when Raja Dashrat saw her beloved wife Rani Kaikaye in this bad state of without jewlery and other must articles of wearing by a wedded Queen of such a powerful kingdom...
she said she will wear all those things or she will be presentable only if Raja Dashrat gave him a unbreakable word of promise to fulfill her wish and he will comply anything she ask ...
Raja gave her word and than she asked " I want Ram 14 years of BUNBAS no question asked and Bharat her son will be sat on the thrown during all this time "
RAJA completely out of shocked caught between wall and her demand
out of the Raja's honor and dignity of his promise he announced exactly what Rani Kaykai stated or asked
APPARENTLY the bunbas was for only Bhagwan Raam but Maata Seeta said she wont let her husband go onto this journey without her joining and Lakshman argued that he will must join his older brother ...
Bharat was not in the town at that moment but when he came back he was utterly upset with her mother and refuse to sat on the thrown
when Bhagwan Raam found out this he messaged his brother to carry on the matter of the state and do work for the prosperity of the common people
Bharat was so loyal to Bhagwan Raam he never set on the thrown out of respect but rather sat on the foot step of the thrown on the floor out of utmost locality respect and love for his older brother Bhagwaan Raam through out 14 years of HIS absence
so what u stated in the clip that his brother captured thrown that was the most incorrect and saddening statement totally misrepresenting the honorable honest loving loyal character of Raja Bharat
my request was to correct this particular part and share the story the way it is ...
my only humble request ... did not wanting to make u look bad or uninformed ... i think u are brilliant and i actually got shocked and amazed to see an such a intellectual intelligent platform to have such critical topics to discuss in such polite way ...
i like your sweet calm yet assertive confident casual look..
u fit in and capture attention across from the diversified age group starting from young
& hip, professional middle age and more serious retired age group people equally
in simple words u are a dam captivating personality ....
love it what u do and please carry on the good amazing job and service u provide to viewers through u platform
KUDOS
KUDOS
KUDOS
BRAVO
BRAVO
BRAVO
i hope u understand my admiration and respect for your intellectual hard work u do and only reason for my correction was not to call you out but hate to see u making u self fool
or if u are speaking on an international forum ... u dont make fool out of your self
nothing negative or under the egoistic intent ....
hope to see more great intellectual informative clips from u end
Good Luck and thank you for your prompt response
shows u humility and honorable personality
Alex
Thank you so much for such generous words. First and foremost I am guilty as charged. I have not used the Valmiki's Ramayana as it was but instead relied on a book by Kavita Kane's Sita’s Sister - About The Women Of Ramayana published in 2017.
The book has painted almost everyone with a brush of scepticism and has put the onus of Kaikaye's behaviour on Mandavi as she believes that she was the prime beneficiary of the Bharat's accession to the throne. No matter what her version is I agree with you and think it is not right to not produce the exact version of Ramayana to my audience.
@@ShafaatAli007
indeed u are a true honest humble and really intelligent individual ...
i am honored by u kind response and u last two sentences that it is not right not to present correct picture of Ramayaan to your loyal listeners
those words shows that u intentions are honest ...
and according to Sanarthan Dharma tradition i offer u a VARDAN
" may u be blessed with Wisdom directly from the Maata Saraswati The Goddess of knowledge wisdom and intellect "
TATHA ASTOO / SO BE IT
i truly pray for u success prosperity health and safety of u physical / spiritual existence
AMEEN !!!
Thank you again for taking time from u busy life reading my response and respond to it !!!
HAR HAR MAHA DEV !!!
@@ShafaatAli007 you should relay on authentic version of ramayana which is valmiki ramayan or ramcharitra manas.
these authors write stories with their own perspective and twisting the real thing. it's not some random story but a religious book which is read and passed in indian families since ages.
Eagerly w8ing for part 2
Awesome research and great presentation
Great work Brother
Cannot understand what you say, but going through the comment can follow the context. Good to see revival of old ties. Let us (from Sri Lanka) hear about the king Porus (or Paurusha) who ruled the northern area of Bharatha from Peshawar and supposed to have geven the best fight to Alexander the great. His children supposed to have founded the colonies of Sinhale (Sri Lanka, Serendib, etc...).
BTW, I had lots of professional colleagues from this area (from India, too) working in West Africa.
بات کراچی کی ہو اور چینل سبسکرائب نہ ہو تو بات ادھوری جائے گی۔
سبسکرپشن اور لائک۔
بیان کراچی کی اجرت۔
شفاعت بھائی آپ کا شکریہ۔،🇵🇰
RAJ DAHIR WAS FROM KASHMIR AT THAT TIME FROM SEA TO KASHMIR WAS CALLED BECAUSE SINDHU RIVER WAS THERE . FIRST BOOK OF WORLD RIG VEDA WAS WRITTEN ON BANK OF SINDHU RIVER. SANSKIRT WAS CREATED AT SUWAT BY RISHI PANANNI