The History Of Karachi ~Muslim,Hindu, Christian, Parsi, and Other Minority Communities |Junaid Akram

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 27 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 1,6 тыс.

  • @ameyakatrekar7509
    @ameyakatrekar7509 Год назад +355

    My grandmother was from Karachi... There were a lot of Maharashtrian Hindus in Karachi. Pre partition days had good engineering colleges only in the twin cities of Karachi and Mumbai ! ... Ganesh Festival, Mahashivratri, Diwali and Dusshera was celebrated with great pomp in Karachi... Unbelievable but true !

    • @ShariqNisar-zt2si
      @ShariqNisar-zt2si Год назад +8

    • @fawwadshafi9555
      @fawwadshafi9555 Год назад

      These festivals are still celebrated in Pakistan
      ruclips.net/video/ixdYxReueHY/видео.html

    • @rubabslifevlogs486
      @rubabslifevlogs486 Год назад +7

      Founder of Pakistan our leader Qaid e azam Muhammad Ali jinnah k 14 nukaat mien shamil Tha k sindh ko Bombay se alag ker diya Jaye aur Karachi sindh k under mien Ata means before partition Bombay and Karachi sath sath thay

    • @rohitkulkarni8576
      @rohitkulkarni8576 Год назад +18

      My grandfather is also from Karachi. His family migrated to Mumbai during partition.
      Our family is Marathi and during partition there were 25-30 thousand Marathi people in Karachi

    • @highplatform1649
      @highplatform1649 Год назад

      Pakistan is a graveyard of civilisation and heritage. They have whitewashed it with Islam. They don't even own MohenjoDaro

  • @aliosama7816
    @aliosama7816 Год назад +314

    Thank you Junaid bhai for your dedication toward the betterment of Pakistan. I as a Muslim applogise to All the Minorities of Pakistan. We really are ashmed of these so called Muslims who are disturbing Minorities that are living in Pakistan.

    • @Health-Blitz
      @Health-Blitz Год назад +8

      What Minorities ..
      99.5 % are Muszaalim

    • @KararaJawaab
      @KararaJawaab Год назад +31

      Bhai Jaan. 1000 Saal Se Same Strategy Hai Aap Logo Ki.
      5 Musalman Hire Kiye Hai Apologize Krne K Liye Aur 10 Musalman Hire Kiye Hai Kaafiro Ko Maarne K Liye.
      Police Bhi Tum, Chor Bhi Tum. Wah Kya Mast Strategy Hai Aap Logo Ki.
      Band Kro Naatak. Jao Kisi Hndu Ki Property Pr Kabza Kro. Yahi Sunnat Hai.

    • @dykmaybesakib3796
      @dykmaybesakib3796 Год назад +1

      @@KararaJawaab strategy Bhai ye to Tere mo se pehle baar sun the Hun

    • @humanworld7774
      @humanworld7774 Год назад +1

      @@KararaJawaab
      Y kisne kaha aesa hota to Pakistan k parliament me lyincher riots terrorist hote indian parliament me nhi or aaj ek bhi na bchte

    • @KararaJawaab
      @KararaJawaab Год назад

      @@dykmaybesakib3796 Han Bhai. Tumne Sahi Samjha. Ye Kaafiro Ko Maarna, Convert Krna. Ye Sab Ek Strategy Se Hota Aya Hai.
      For Example - Muhammad Ali Jinnah Ek Modern Khyal K Insaan The. Sharab Peetey. Ladkibazi Krte. Ameer Wali Life. Namaz Padhna Bhi Nhi Ata Tha. Vo Hnduo Se Nafrat Nhi Krte The.
      Lekin Jinnah Ne Political Goal Ke Liye Ek Game Khela. Musalmano Ko Daraya, Unko Bola Ki Hndu Kha Jaenge. 1935 Me To Jinnah England Me The. Vo Politics Chhor Diye The. Fir Wo India Aye Aur Sirf 7-8 Saal Nafrat Failaya. Aur Pakistan Bna Liya.
      Pakistan Bnane Se Pahle Jinnah Bolte The Ki Hndu Muslm Ek Sath Nhi Rah Skte. Pakistan Bnane K Baad Jinnah Ne Bola Ki Hndu Muslm Sab Ek Sath Rah Skte Hai. Jinnah Ne To Sikho Ko Bhi Invite Kiya Pakistan Me. Jinnah Ne Bola Ki Sikh Pakistan Me Mil Jao. Pura Punjab Pakistan Me Merge Krdo.
      Junagarh Me To Majority Hnduo Ki Thi. Un Hnduo Ko Bhi Pakistan Me Milane Ki Baat Krne Lage.
      Dekho Kaise Pakistan Banne K Baad Jinnah Ne Sare Mazheb Walo Ko Pakistan Me Invite Krne Lage. Uske Pahle Vo Bolte The Ki Hndu Muslm Sath Nhi Rah Skte.
      Isi Ko Strategy Bolte Hai.
      Musalmano Ne Hamesha Aisa Hi Kiya Hai. Kaaafir Bol Kr non-Muslm Ko Maro Aur Luto. Jab Sala Maal Loot Liye To Baad Me Apologise Krne Ka Naatak Kro. Islam Aman Ka Mazheb Hai. Koi Jabr Nhi. Ye Sab Bongiya Maarna Suru.
      Agar Musalmano Ko Sach Me Apologise Krna Hai Wo Looti Hui Jameen Jaydaad Wapas Krdo non-Muslm Ko. Real Apology To Wahi Hogi Na?
      Jao Un Hndu Ladkio Ko Azaad Krdo Jinko Miya Mitthu Ne Unka Jabran Mazheb Tabdil Kiya. Hai Himmat? Bano Sacha Musalman. Sirf Lips Service Na Kro. Kuch Real Practical Kr Ke Dikhao.

  • @deepak4156
    @deepak4156 Год назад +121

    I really appreciate your efforts Junaid Bhai. Not because that I am a Hindu who lives in Karachi, but also as a Pakistani citizen. It is very important to pass on our history and culture to the next generation. We all must do our part to improve it.

    • @trendingtashu7377
      @trendingtashu7377 Год назад +1

      Deepak perwani...

    • @abhijithcheneri7827
      @abhijithcheneri7827 Год назад

      Disclosing his identity won't be safe , i'd day

    • @pikachue602
      @pikachue602 Год назад

      Just get converted and eat a cow ...
      What will you do with history and culture when u know ur future is dim and it is more useless to talk about your future gen ,if it is a girl she is born to be doomed and if a male death will be the future ..
      Better get converted or runaway

    • @pikachue602
      @pikachue602 Год назад

      @@kashmirisrael23 dubja jamjam mein middle east k na Pak bhoot

  • @peaceharmony1943
    @peaceharmony1943 Год назад +85

    There was a Restaurant and hotel established by a Sindhi Family of Karachi in 1892 by the name of "Sindh Islamia Hotel" in Old town near Bunder Road (Wood Street). Although owned by Muslims they never served any cow meat for more then hundred years. Their owners were Sindhis who lived with Hindu community since 1853 and always respected them even after 1947. The hotel was sold to another Muslim who broke the tradition in 1998 and started serving cow meat. This shows that the community that grew up with Hindu community had deep ties and respect for the one another.

    • @umairakhter3446
      @umairakhter3446 Год назад +1

      My Father was used to had lunch from Sindh Islamia Hotel

    • @hoshiarsingh6523
      @hoshiarsingh6523 Год назад

      Very good information about Karachi and harmony between all religious communities.

  • @saifuddin7187
    @saifuddin7187 Год назад +27

    Lots of thanks to all christains
    ,parsi people and Hindu everyone people of Karachi city who participated in Karachi development in every aspect

  • @thinkinganame6173
    @thinkinganame6173 Год назад +488

    I studied at NED University and want to thank Parsi community for such a nice gift to a non-deserving nation

    • @IndoPakCanvas
      @IndoPakCanvas Год назад

      Very well said! Pathetically hate filled crowd. They hide it well though, eh?

    • @Jamharis1
      @Jamharis1 Год назад +13

      What do you mean by non-deserving nation? Bro you are from this nation its your identity feel proud of it. If you want something to be change then you should change yourself first.

    • @saitandale8482
      @saitandale8482 Год назад +36

      ​@@Jamharis1BC tum Sach Mai layak nahi ho 😢 tumhe koi help Karo Or tum uska ahsan rakho 20 % Minority ko 1.6 % kar diya or aisa baat kar rahe ho sharm bhi nahi ati hai

    • @Munda-kashmiri
      @Munda-kashmiri Год назад +19

      We stand as a nation ?
      What we have done with our city Karachi I have seen many old people’s who now live abroad they cry 😢 because they were born in Karachi before partition when they discuss about old Karachi tear’s come out because they have seen better Karachi 🙏

    • @IndoPakCanvas
      @IndoPakCanvas Год назад +4

      @@Jamharis1 No kaka. I am not from your cess pool. Pass but I'll throw you some advice, you are systematically erasing or should I say trying to erase their legacy but failing. You are though in debt and fragmented. Keep at it.

  • @rosheenhasan6398
    @rosheenhasan6398 Год назад +37

    it is very important to discuss who really shaped Karachi as a metropolitan city... thanks, Junaid to highlight such matters in such an era where people don't recognize the contributions of non-muslims who were real gems to Karachi👏👏

  • @MLanjekar
    @MLanjekar Год назад +195

    The grandfather of our typical hindu neighbour was born in Karachi in 1940s. He had very few childhood beautiful memories. Further his father settled down in Maharashtra, India. He had narrated those stories with great emotions.

    • @raghavan1067
      @raghavan1067 Год назад +3

      Typical ka kya matlab tha??

    • @TariqQureshi39
      @TariqQureshi39 Год назад

      I always feel sad for those people who had left their home and hope that your grandfarther is good in health. My grandfather left Agra and I alsways enjoy stories told by my elder uncle, who has a few memories of that time.

    • @pmishra786
      @pmishra786 Год назад +2

      @@TariqQureshi39 your uncle left Agra by choice. There was no Choice for Hindus in West Punjab, Sindh or KPK. There is a difference.

    • @TariqQureshi39
      @TariqQureshi39 Год назад +1

      @pmishra786 not really
      At that time thinks were changing dramatically

    • @pmishra786
      @pmishra786 Год назад +3

      @@TariqQureshi39 whatever those conditions Were they weren't as bad for the Hindus. Agra is in UP and the state still has 20% Muslim population while Sindh which has most Hindus in Pakistan is , Hindus are just 5-6%. Condition were difficult fr Hindus.

  • @Sk-nb3yl
    @Sk-nb3yl Год назад +52

    Beautiful video. I don’t even want to call them minorities. They are all Pakistanis who made a mark in their relevant fields. These are all amazing people and deserve to be respected and appreciated

    • @tejubaiyabemisaal808
      @tejubaiyabemisaal808 Год назад

      Yet you shameless Pakistani's eradicated your minorities. Pakistan is not a country but idiots gathered together in name of religion and had made this place a living hell.

    • @raghavan1067
      @raghavan1067 Год назад

      Woh hee hai minority pakistani nhi

    • @hunk3891
      @hunk3891 Год назад

      Call them londis. That is what you do.

  • @samuelkhokhar1609
    @samuelkhokhar1609 Год назад +83

    Respect from heart 🫡
    Junaid Bhai never disappoints and always give us excellent and logical analysis 👍

  • @peekabo4577
    @peekabo4577 Год назад +24

    The real history is unlocked. Thank you Junaid for putting in so much effort.

  • @hata1349
    @hata1349 Год назад +439

    Karachi was peaceful untill minority was majority, thats the truth

    • @prayasgupta702
      @prayasgupta702 Год назад +1

      Muslims bring destruction...wherever they go...its a fact😂

    • @nikhilkille8978
      @nikhilkille8978 Год назад

      u summed it up.. thats the truth.. medival era arabic cult is good in ruining things .

    • @humanworld7774
      @humanworld7774 Год назад +17

      Lol india is so peaceful haryana
      Mostly lyincher terrorist in indian parliament no punishment on gujrat muzaffarpur riots pahlu Khan tabrej lyincher

    • @gaurav32257
      @gaurav32257 Год назад

      ​@@humanworld7774riots happen in muslim majority areas like nuh , haryana. Violence is in dna of muslims because most of them have converted on tip of sword.

    • @chandrakanthotkar7262
      @chandrakanthotkar7262 Год назад

      ​@@humanworld7774Count atrocities on Hindus as well. You see one side there is other side to riots as well. Hindu Muslim riots is ongoing phenomenon from last 200 years. Nothing new

  • @vir8788
    @vir8788 Год назад +28

    Left that country at early age and I never regret I wish all the minorities leave that place and go somewhere where they can live fully without hiding their identity that city is no more the city where we minorities used to live.
    Musharaf well said pakistan ka khudahafiz

  • @saifalibadruddin1453
    @saifalibadruddin1453 Год назад +22

    And some people still have courtesy to say that minotries are respected. People need to get out of this bubble and stand with these communities. Great initiative by Junaid Akram and Team.

    • @varunkhugshal9049
      @varunkhugshal9049 Год назад

      They are kafir , and do shirk, anyway have to go to jahanum, what's with couple of more years.

  • @ganeshvaylon
    @ganeshvaylon Год назад +29

    Proud to be Hindu

  • @kabeerfaqeer7395
    @kabeerfaqeer7395 Год назад +101

    As a Hindu minority i can surly relate to each and every thing that has been addressed in the video, i'hve always heard the old time stories from my father, of how United thigs were back then, but as the time has passed,the thinking and perceptions of each individual has be so judgmental about the minorities,after contributing so much in the wellbeing of the city, todays minorites stands no chance of equal respect like others, the fear of celebrating the festivals or having them done publicly always has a terror in our heats that any moment things can go wrong, My respect for Junaid sir for highlighting these facts, Kudos ♥️

    • @anshumanpanda1227
      @anshumanpanda1227 Год назад +4

      One day, we will again be akhand brother. Bharat Mata ki Jai.

    • @FreddieMurphy746
      @FreddieMurphy746 Год назад +10

      ​@@anshumanpanda1227Don't be naive.

    • @i.ashisss
      @i.ashisss Год назад

      Your name says it all .... 😅

    • @ishwardevi134
      @ishwardevi134 Год назад +8

      ​@@anshumanpanda1227akhand bharat me 24 crore Pakistani 18 crore bengaladeshi + 22 crore indian muslim
      ko india me leke
      Muslim majority country banana h india ko tujhe?
      Ullu ke patthe

    • @anshumanpanda1227
      @anshumanpanda1227 Год назад +1

      @@ishwardevi134 Maine Akhand shabd ka prayog kiya, Ghazwa e Hind nahi. Samajh me aaya me kya bol raha hun, ya samjhana padega?

  • @neerajnankani6367
    @neerajnankani6367 Год назад +12

    Today i respect you even more than before junaid sir ❤️❤️
    Sitting in tears

  • @aliquraishi3525
    @aliquraishi3525 7 месяцев назад +2

    Very informative video of my city, Karachi.

  • @harshwardhandadhich6639
    @harshwardhandadhich6639 Год назад +20

    Respect to you junaid 👏
    I am an indian and here we have good connect and respect for the minorities, they arent treated like minorities, i hope people like you and deepak perwani ji become leaders of pakistan and bring proper law and order and finsh the army rule in pakistan, pakistan needs to understand and get mature.
    Love from india 🇮🇳

    • @tableflipper7364
      @tableflipper7364 Год назад

      Under every muslim video i see thousands of indians saying terrorist and making fun of islam and you are saying minorities aren't treated like minorities?

    • @MegaNainaa
      @MegaNainaa 10 месяцев назад

      Sorry to say, not anymore with the Moodi government Hindutva are taking the lead and discrimination for the minorities.

  • @majiskani
    @majiskani Год назад +12

    💔
    Thank u Sir for such type of informative masterpiece. It's a Tribute to the contributions of Non-Muslim citizens of Pakistan.

  • @hassannaeemgoraya8052
    @hassannaeemgoraya8052 Год назад +16

    Thank you Junaid bhai for showing the perspective of minorities. This video actually depicts our true history and showed the same culture and values which we had shared from years, but unfortunately forgotten now 😔. Respect every religion equally and let the sense of tolerance prevails. Aamen 🙏

    • @hunk3891
      @hunk3891 Год назад

      Buut parasti bhi?

  • @shoaibhashmi2411
    @shoaibhashmi2411 Год назад +111

    As a Muslim I feel ashamed in front of all other religions that prevail in the city, being born in 2000 I've always heard stories about how Karachi and its people were and sadly the more I study the deeper my grief gets.

    • @DonzaiNoHana
      @DonzaiNoHana Год назад +17

      This is not Karachi's story. Islam gobbles all local cultures and faiths alike. You people do not even have your names in native languages but in Arabic and Farsi just because it gives you that vibe of being of foreign origin rather than a convert.

    • @the-wanderer-01
      @the-wanderer-01 Год назад +2

      @@DonzaiNoHana Do you see the average Pakistani wearing thobe and ghutra? Or doing dabke instead of bhangra?
      As for names, you will find a variety. You will find Mustafa and Jasrat... Iqbal and Dinesh... and so on.

    • @the-wanderer-01
      @the-wanderer-01 Год назад +7

      You are not responsible for what happened, so there is no need to be ashamed.
      But if you do nothing to try and improve the situation, then you do have something to be ashamed of.

    • @DonzaiNoHana
      @DonzaiNoHana Год назад +5

      @@the-wanderer-01 Ab converts hain, kuch to baaki reh gaya shukar hai Hindu past ka jaise Haldi-Mehendi, Surkh joda - symbol of fertility and suhag. maulviyon ka bas chale to bhangra bhi ban kardein aur woh Dabke dalwayein, huzoor ki koi sunnat bhi nikaal denge jaise KPK mein lal surkh jode pe fatwa hai as un-Islamic.

    • @DonzaiNoHana
      @DonzaiNoHana Год назад +1

      @@the-wanderer-01 I may not be responsible but it brings shame that my fellow brethren defend a desert cult of illiterate thug from 7th Century and that is THE PROBLEM. The economy, illiteracy, poor HDI etc. all can wait unless of course you dig your graves only to discover oil in occupied Balochistan.

  • @educativedaily
    @educativedaily Год назад +21

    Blunt and on point video....Thank you Junaid bhai.. kudos to you..for being unbiased.

  • @chillrelax5056
    @chillrelax5056 Год назад +46

    Thanks for these useful and eye-opening videos that show mirror to common people in Pakistan !
    Keep up the good work !

    • @mohammadfaraz664
      @mohammadfaraz664 Год назад +1

      ​@@ajitdesai-ed2obkyure bhout paisa toh india ke gareeb hinduo do jiska pass toilet nahi khana nahi k

    • @mohammadfaraz664
      @mohammadfaraz664 Год назад

      @@ajitdesai-ed2ob nahi 60 cr ma sabse zyada hindu hi hai waha gareeb nanga punga aur waise bhi musalman musalman ki madad karleta tum ko tumhare log bhi nahi puchta ye hai sanskari religion

    • @i.ashisss
      @i.ashisss Год назад

      ​@@mohammadfaraz664😂😂 waahh waahhh khud ke baat kardiye

    • @mohammadfaraz664
      @mohammadfaraz664 Год назад

      @@i.ashisss haa Teri hi baat ki gandu sanskari gurukul gobar chap chatta yaha south tum log chatta bulaye yaha. Ke musalman

    • @GanjiSwag
      @GanjiSwag  4 месяца назад

      Thanks so much 😊

  • @Naturelovers954
    @Naturelovers954 Год назад +63

    At that time karachi looks like much better than now.😭

  • @bertstours
    @bertstours Год назад +13

    Echoes of bygone days,. Karachi was fun when there were a lot of parsis around. I studied at BVS and lived a block away surrounded by parsi compounds. Karachi in the 70s was amazing, I was a kid then but remember the feeling.

  • @DenJaVlogs
    @DenJaVlogs Год назад +147

    As an indian i feel sorry for pakistanaise minorité. Also as a minorité in india i feel proud and blessed to be born in india with so much diversity

    • @lightlelochzain6904
      @lightlelochzain6904 Год назад +13

      I honestly feel sorry for anyone born in India OR Pakistan. India is changing unbelievably fast but we still see remnants of true hatred in diff communities. Pakistan is just stuck in a state of hatred, destruction, downfall, and repeat. This honestly is sickening seeing the united India was such a peaceful nation for different communities for so, so long...

    • @lightlelochzain6904
      @lightlelochzain6904 Год назад +4

      Btw not hating on the two countries, im a Pakistani and almost all of my social circle online is indian. I just hate the societal hate that forms the two countries

    • @pmishra786
      @pmishra786 Год назад

      ​​@@lightlelochzain6904united India was peaceful? You need to learn some historical events to check if it was peaceful. It was not. We (India) are a much peaceful nation now by any measure. It was better to cut the gangrene from our land. Pakistani and Indians have different psyche & we are happy that Pakistan got removed from our land.

    • @lightlelochzain6904
      @lightlelochzain6904 Год назад

      @@pmishra786 lmao wow ok.
      Also we didn't separate from "your land" united India got divided into two separate nations, do not make it sound like one part separated. And in any case I ain't here to fight you but as far as I know there's a huge societal gap in how you treat Muslims and Hindus. Do not come crashing into someone, ty.

    • @pmishra786
      @pmishra786 Год назад

      @@lightlelochzain6904 becauSe it was one community that wanted partition. And the same community is enjoying the fruits of partition. I'm quite happy to see Pakistan implode. A nation built on hatred was destined to fail. Enjoy 🤣

  • @MeemBaay111
    @MeemBaay111 Год назад +11

    Excellent! Thank you to Junaid Ji for this excellent documentary and for letting minorities speak for themselves. You are a class act! If Pakistan wants to be considered a modern metropolis, a force to be reckoned with and to have status on the world stage then it will have to tackle its own history. It will have to start telling the truth about its founding and founders and stop living in a fantasy world where we are ever the victims without ever acknowledging our role as an aggressor. It is shameful that we are easing the past contributions of minorities as well as attacking them in the present! It is a failure of political will, to tell the truth, that has put us where we are. We should be ashamed of every one of Pakistan's leaders as none have even tried to deal with the issue of minorities, equal rights are human rights. We will be nothing until we learn to treat people with respect and dignity regardless of race, religion or creed. We expect to have this when we live in the West so it is time to practice what we preach!

  • @AhsanMushtaq-n8h
    @AhsanMushtaq-n8h Год назад +4

    Junaid Bhai Respect from heart!
    I'm so embarrassed right now, for our elders actions and priorities.

  • @zainalvi9206
    @zainalvi9206 Год назад +5

    Thank you sharing this ! Coming from a St.Patrick's I felt the same way.

  • @chaitanyakashive9930
    @chaitanyakashive9930 Год назад +9

    This video might upset many people, especially in government, army or radicalists. May god protect these people and Junaid bhai. 🙏 Also, it takes courage to talk about such a sensitive topic in Pakistan, take a bow Junaid bhai. Just stay safe, please.

  • @mrkeshav736
    @mrkeshav736 Год назад +7

    India Pak Bangladesh main Sabse Pehle Majority Hindu Hai The...Bahi...

  • @V4LE.--14N
    @V4LE.--14N Год назад +9

    The past actually happened, but history is only what someone wrote down.
    Thank you, Junaid.

  • @ahsanpanjwani8661
    @ahsanpanjwani8661 Год назад +9

    Massive respect junaid bhai!

  • @malihariaz3535
    @malihariaz3535 Год назад +5

    This video is an eye opening message to the many of us. I wasn't aware of the sacrifices these communities have given for Karachi especially. Thankyou for bringing out such content when its needed the most. I appreciate your efforts!👏🏻

  • @skmohasinahmed
    @skmohasinahmed Год назад +1

    Great great great job.I am an Indian.I always want hear from the minorities of Pakistan. I requested you earlier lots of times. Now you have brought them. Keep doing this.

  • @artbyraabie
    @artbyraabie Год назад +32

    I'm just 24 and I'm just in tears. The pain in their voice. It's just so heartbreaking. I wanna say I'm sorry. As a Muslim Pakistani. I'm sorry. Ham ek zalim qoam hain.

    • @SarojEkka-zc3nq
      @SarojEkka-zc3nq Год назад +1

      Yes true.....muslim in majority is definitely a trouble other communities

    • @varunkhugshal9049
      @varunkhugshal9049 Год назад

      They are kafirs who do shirk, they deserve it, they anyway have to go to jahanum forever, bit practice is necessary.

    • @sudhanshu3379
      @sudhanshu3379 Год назад +2

      You guys are hope for Pakistan and the whole world see Kazakhstan, Turkey, Indonesia, UAE etc Pakistan can become like them and maybe india and Pakistan will trade with each other one day

    • @nazifarahman9198
      @nazifarahman9198 Год назад +1

      Qawm mein kharabi hain ya soch mein? Islam ane se pehle bhi toh ap yehi qawm they tab tolerance kyun tha? Soch kisne badla? Sochiye

    • @ajaysonune1625
      @ajaysonune1625 Год назад

      🙏🙏

  • @Arsalan0011
    @Arsalan0011 Год назад +10

    I believe this era will be the revival of history & our genuine identity.. Hats off to you Junaid!

  • @vintagejock3951
    @vintagejock3951 Год назад +3

    Thank you for this. As a minority I appreciate your efforts.

  • @mrudulapawar5972
    @mrudulapawar5972 Год назад +1

    Meri nani Pakistan karachi se hai, wo yaha Maharashtra ke kokan region se belong karte hai before partition they used to trade and had a well settled business in karachi, unfortunately 1947 main unko vapas yaha ana pad gaya pr aaj bhi wo vaha ki bhot sari baate batate hai jaise ki unka school, school ka uniform jitna unko yaad hai ya gharwalo ne kabhi batayi hogi tb wo 8 saal ki thi abhi 84 years ki hai, unko bhot acche se yaad hai wo lok kitna taklif zelke yaha tak pohche na khana pina har time dar main rehna na thik se nind. Nani ke father ne bataya tha unko bhot sare lok jababadari convert kiye gaye vaha pr aaj ye koi kabul nahi karega
    Anyways you are doing good work keep it up

  • @arhamrehan7994
    @arhamrehan7994 Год назад +8

    I like your work MashaAllah ❤

  • @H27624
    @H27624 Год назад +133

    Pakistan is destined to fail. Great work Junaid. People have forgotten real history of this land.

    • @affankhanchannel7168
      @affankhanchannel7168 Год назад +5

      You are destined to fail

    • @juvansoul
      @juvansoul Год назад +16

      ​@@affankhanchannel7168ik truth hurt bro.

    • @tusharsangtani8874
      @tusharsangtani8874 Год назад +4

      ​@@affankhanchannel7168you can't digest the truth .

    • @saadmaqsood227
      @saadmaqsood227 Год назад +10

      Don't be Hopeless, at least Believe in Positive. This was bound to happen because Pakistan's foundation were laid on a religion and NOBODY DARES TO SPEAK AGAINST IT. Whole world teaches their children science, maths and builds their logical thinking but in Pakistan we ARE teaching our children science but also inculcating superstition through islamyaat subject and even worst our qualified people listen to stupid religious fanatics which you call ULEMA, this believe in superstition kills their innovation, curiosity and creativity. Then they can be easily manipulated. This is how simple it is. But now people are awakening due to social media and they know that real Islam was never a religion it was a government (DEEN with currency DEENAR).

    • @saadmaqsood227
      @saadmaqsood227 Год назад +1

      خواہش سے نہیں گِرتے پھل جھولی میں
      وقت کی شاخ کو میرے دوست ہلانا ہو گا
      کچھ نہیں ہو گا اندھیروں کو بُرا کہنے سے
      اپنے حِصّے کا دِیا خود ہی جلانا ہو گا
      اُمیدیں یوں نہ توڑو تُم، کہ یہ قانون ہے ربّ کا
      سَحر لازم ہے گویا شب میں کِتنی ہی طوالت ہو

  • @AmitKumar-ur6qc
    @AmitKumar-ur6qc Год назад +87

    Thanks Junaid for making such videos... Unfortunately state policies are not pro-minority due to orthodox Islamist culture. But this is a great effort to make people aware and make them tolerant towards all minorities including shias and ahmedis.

    • @Maazyousfzai
      @Maazyousfzai Год назад +4

      I agree with you my friend but there is something I want to aware you. Everyone are not same like you are Thinking there is literally people who support all minorities and . Actually 70% state administration is Shia not a sunni

    • @prayasgupta702
      @prayasgupta702 Год назад +4

      @@Maazyousfzai tabhi to pasmsnda h...funds hi nhi milte

    • @Maazyousfzai
      @Maazyousfzai Год назад +2

      @@prayasgupta702 wahi yr fund milain toh woh bhi ghayab hojaty Hain

    • @gthang7714
      @gthang7714 Год назад +2

      Same in India. There you are supporting that

    • @indianhacker1958
      @indianhacker1958 Год назад

      ​@@gthang7714 come to India buddy here muslims have more rights than Hindus, Sikhs, christiietc

  • @Azishahmed021
    @Azishahmed021 Год назад +15

    Amazing documentry. Sad to hear that Karachi is not a diverse city anymore.

    • @comesthru
      @comesthru Год назад +1

      Pakistan has intense animosity for non-Muslims so why should Karachi be any different.

    • @zh1148
      @zh1148 Год назад +1

      The woman is bullshiting. Karachi is still a diverse. Although most of what is said in this video is true and Karachi is not as diverse as an Indian metropolis would be, it is by far the most diverse place in Pakistan and still has a sizeable Hindu and Christian population plus other communities. Also many temples and churches are intact and thriving. This video is 80% correct but also 20% pure bullshitting.

  • @MrArt4321
    @MrArt4321 Год назад +3

    Respect for this men Dil say💕💕💕

  • @anaszia2158
    @anaszia2158 Год назад +13

    Pakistani Muslims moving abroad and living in countries where they should be a minority. But not a single day they have felt like a minority. Heart breaks looking at the current structure of Karachi.

    • @RahulMishra-ld2bo
      @RahulMishra-ld2bo Год назад

      Because Pakistani are fake muslims. Real muslims like people of Saudi and UAE will never do this. You Pakistanis are the main reason why some people hate Islam religion. No religion teaches hate. Due to the radical mindset of your army you made a beautiful and peaceful religion in such a state. Shame on you and your army establishment.

  • @GOKUBLACK-xq4is
    @GOKUBLACK-xq4is Год назад +3

    Love & Respect from INDIA 🇮🇳🙏🇵🇰

  • @zohaib-004
    @zohaib-004 Год назад +2

    Great video juniad bhai ❤

  • @sawaisingh2003
    @sawaisingh2003 Год назад +3

    Best Documentary ❤❤❤

  • @rizwankhankhan8637
    @rizwankhankhan8637 Год назад

    Great effort from Junaid Akram for showing real faces of Karachi history ye sub Kuch before 60s Ka Karachi he is k baad is shahar par UN bherion ki nazar is shahar par aisi Pari k city ki prime locations par Kabhi DHA k NAAM par or Kabhi cantonments k NAAM par or kahin security ke NAAM par makhsoos log kabiz hote chale gai or aaj Asal Karachi or is k Asal waris is shahar KO khairbad keh kr is mulk se hi kahin or shift ho gai ye he is shahar Ka NOHA

  • @taimoorkhan1309
    @taimoorkhan1309 Год назад +3

    Thank you so much junaid bhai for a this type of valuable content. I know a very few people would like to watch this video but this is the real work the meaningful content. Really appreciated. Keep doing the good work. ❤

  • @usmankhan-bv4dy
    @usmankhan-bv4dy Год назад +2

    finally you took a step for the betterment of our city appreciated sir.

  • @deveshupadhyay5333
    @deveshupadhyay5333 Год назад +5

    My grandmother was from Karachi and she came here in india through a boat because of the fear of riots and massacre.. and then shifted to Mathura and now living in Lucknow... She misses her home city..

  • @sheharyarzahid4728
    @sheharyarzahid4728 Год назад +2

    This is the best video you have made. This gave me chills. Keep making videos like these.

  • @chxeeshanjutt
    @chxeeshanjutt Год назад +32

    Much much respect for all Pakistani beyond their religions n beliefs

    • @Myanmartiger921
      @Myanmartiger921 Год назад +3

      Osama shaheed keh liyeh respect 🫡

    • @sergeantmajorgross
      @sergeantmajorgross Год назад

      ​@@Myanmartiger921mera ❤️da pakad le

    • @EvolveYourBrain
      @EvolveYourBrain Год назад

      You respect them for what? Decimating the minorities who built that nation. They broke their very own backbone and now after 76 years they realise their crime but it’s too late now

  • @theycallmek_
    @theycallmek_ Год назад

    Thankyou for speaking and standing for themm!!!

  • @lionelmascarenhas1586
    @lionelmascarenhas1586 Год назад +88

    Reasons to love my country more 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳

    • @ahmadreza4132
      @ahmadreza4132 Год назад +3

      Congratulations you dream on! In 2060 water dare to inter Grate India 🇮🇳 will go somewhere else!!

    • @blackwolf5947
      @blackwolf5947 Год назад +15

      True but Lets always be aware that same things dont happen in india. Because I see similar patterns following in our country.

    • @hashiraden
      @hashiraden Год назад +3

      Bro Sindh was a different country before British attacked it

    • @worldindex1569
      @worldindex1569 Год назад

      First stop genocide of Muslim

    • @gthang7714
      @gthang7714 Год назад

      Attack on minorities In India. Killing is daily routine and that from Government is increasing . What are you even proud of?

  • @arjumandemistifyy
    @arjumandemistifyy 11 месяцев назад +1

    I genuinely pray that we go back to our roots. Let Karachi be the diverse city it was. Let our communities be celebrated, let them shine like they were supposed to

  • @1143npatel
    @1143npatel Год назад +6

    I am happy that we Indians preserve precious Parsi community

  • @SilentPlague57
    @SilentPlague57 10 месяцев назад +1

    Thanks a lot Junaid Akram Sir 🥰 for disclosing the Bitter truth and Forgotten History of our Community and Acknowledging that what HINDU, PARSEES & CHRISTIAN Communities have given to this City KARACHI & our Country ❤‍🩹 When Father Mario praised my Saint Patrick's High School i feel Proud about that thing because I'm an Ex.Patrician♥......Day by Day Pakistani society is becoming ignorant and Karachi is ruining 💔

  • @MuhammadSalmanQureshi-s2e
    @MuhammadSalmanQureshi-s2e Год назад +5

    Amazing content Junaid Bhai, Respect from heart ❤❤
    It is obligatory for the citizens to know and respect the history of the land on which they migrated after the freedom because it was not our land, they welcomed us and share their land with us with an open heart>

  • @NasirQureshi-o9b
    @NasirQureshi-o9b Год назад +2

    Superb documentary. Second Pakistani content that made me feel I don't need a Netflix subscription anymore

  • @kengaming7936
    @kengaming7936 Год назад +26

    In my upbringing, not just in Karachi but across Sindh and even the entirety of Pakistan, I've observed remnants of Hinduism on walls. These include symbols like 'Om', which have been partially defaced by locals. Even in Shikarpur, where I live, there's a hospital named R.B.U.T Civil Hospital. The acronym 'R.B.U.T' stands for Rai Bahudar Udhawdas Tarachand Civil Hospital.

    • @drodro7672
      @drodro7672 Год назад +2

      Shikarpur used to be a Hindu majority city, like most urban areas of Sindh.

    • @kengaming7936
      @kengaming7936 Год назад

      @@drodro7672 Yes sir, You are right

  • @Rizwan-Ali
    @Rizwan-Ali Год назад +1

    Well done, this is amazing. Looking forward to seeing more of this.

  • @amitnarkar5682
    @amitnarkar5682 Год назад +6

    Commendable... for your efforts... kudos... only you know how courageous this for uploading this video

    • @amitnarkar5682
      @amitnarkar5682 Год назад

      Technically as a viewer.... well shot nicely edited video. God bless your team

  • @mrthinktv6380
    @mrthinktv6380 Год назад +1

    Bohat alaa kaam kiya junaid bhi. Appriciated

  • @ahmadhussain7840
    @ahmadhussain7840 Год назад +25

    I am also a proud alumni of ST Patrick High School, Karachi. Proud patrician, proud DJarian and a proud NEDian.
    Even there was no discrimination among us in 80 and 90s. Thanks to the Zia era for “extremism and religious intolerance” as a gift. Dictatorships are worst for any nation.

    • @hunk3891
      @hunk3891 Год назад

      Pakistan studies?

  • @zaidyahya6305
    @zaidyahya6305 Год назад +2

    Great initiative and great video

  • @the_bhartiya_spirit
    @the_bhartiya_spirit Год назад +31

    Being from the oldest civilization of 10000 years We Hindu always have done great to humanity irrespective of 1000s of year of Suppression..... Proud to be a Hindu....hell we will rise and will restore peace and Faith and Ram Rajya 🚩🇮🇳🚩

  • @davebhojwani9120
    @davebhojwani9120 Год назад +17

    Great factual history of our beautiful city and its founders . We all are citizens of Pakistan and should be treated equally regardless of their race and Religion.

    • @1525boy
      @1525boy Год назад +4

      If that’s what you really believe then there should be no “Pakistan.”

    • @abracadabra16234
      @abracadabra16234 3 месяца назад

      Parachinar 😂😂😂

    • @YasirPandit123
      @YasirPandit123 2 месяца назад

      ​@@1525boyindian hindu bots...here...
      Nafrati chintu

    • @1525boy
      @1525boy 2 месяца назад

      @@YasirPandit123 Your mother 🤡

    • @YasirPandit123
      @YasirPandit123 2 месяца назад

      @@1525boy I expected this from your hindu religion...🙏🙏🙏
      Yes hindu religion teaches this

  • @Abdulqadir-fb3yq
    @Abdulqadir-fb3yq Год назад +6

    Sir you are doing great work .. these all communitys play an important role for our country & specially for karachi city.. these all communitys are very peaceful❤ ..

    • @KararaJawaab
      @KararaJawaab Год назад +3

      Peaceful Kaha Hai? Abhi 2-3 Mahine Pahle To Ek Hndu Doctor Ko Maar Dala Tha Aap Logo Ne.

  • @muhammadowais3502
    @muhammadowais3502 2 месяца назад

    A heartfelt appreciation to the Christian, Parsi, and Hindu communities of Karachi for their significant contributions to the city's development throughout its history.

  • @navinbhatia
    @navinbhatia Год назад +5

    Kudos Junaid! 👏👏👏well made video. I missed you being in the video actually interviewing these Hindu, Christian, Parsi and local people. Pakistanis have forgotten that these three communities and many others built Karachi before Pakistan was created or Islam introduced here. Best part is the people dont even realize what they have lost and are still losing with all the hatred and bigotry. Thanks for all your well intentioned good efforts for these sad people. I'm happy my ancestors left Thatta in 1947 for a better place. A suggestion to tone down the background music in such serious videos its too loud.

    • @hunk3891
      @hunk3891 Год назад

      🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

  • @anooaga4276
    @anooaga4276 Год назад

    What an eye oper... frank... honest.... ndaring.... salute to all the team..... hope now someone sowhere takes a bold step.... nbring back unity.... faith.... decepline.. n respct n peace....

  • @zaheer74ful
    @zaheer74ful Год назад +4

    Salute to all other Faith people who Colebrated in making of Pakistan ❤

  • @SUPERNVA-gr4sr
    @SUPERNVA-gr4sr Год назад +4

    Junaid you are a gem❤

  • @moviegoerfacts
    @moviegoerfacts Год назад +5

    Now I am ashamed as a Muslim. I deeply apologize for everything.
    But there is one thing i want to say that this generation of Karachiites is respectable and responsible for bright future of Communal Harmony and prosperity.
    I❤ Karachi

    • @Doomedgorilla
      @Doomedgorilla Год назад

      Don't be ashamed as a Muslim but be ashamed as a Pakistani

    • @dhruvmodi1
      @dhruvmodi1 Год назад +1

      ​@@Doomedgorillayou yourself need to read history first then:) why was that nation carved out of India in first place? Why does it call itself islamic republic? Dude, we are done with covering bs let it be what it is... Make peace with it

    • @himanshusrivastava2025
      @himanshusrivastava2025 Год назад

      What harmony? There’s no minority to speak of left now.

    • @comesthru
      @comesthru Год назад

      What bullshit.

  • @arhamsarfaraz3177
    @arhamsarfaraz3177 Год назад +1

    This is a heart-wrenching piece of truth, being a Karachiite it hurts to see our city decay losing all the glory it once was known for.

  • @usmanuddin5892
    @usmanuddin5892 Год назад +21

    Karachi ko Jewish, Hindus, Christians and Parsis nay banaya hai. Hum Muslims nay to barbaad he kiya hai 😢

    • @Health-Blitz
      @Health-Blitz Год назад +3

      Muslims nahi, MusZaalim Bolo 🥰

    • @Health-Blitz
      @Health-Blitz Год назад +4

      It's written in more than 4000 year old Hindu texts about the Demon Tripurasura who comes back as Mahaamad ( Mohammed ).

    • @RahulMishra-ld2bo
      @RahulMishra-ld2bo Год назад +4

      ​@@Health-BlitzDon't hate any religion. This is not good.

    • @rajatbhaskar6995
      @rajatbhaskar6995 Год назад +1

      Isme naya kaya hai

    • @akhtarshahbaz6951
      @akhtarshahbaz6951 3 месяца назад +1

      Karachi is still amazing koi burbad nahe kia

  • @umairkhaanfilms337
    @umairkhaanfilms337 Год назад

    Wow! Thank you for this video, Junaid!

  • @RY-gg2dm
    @RY-gg2dm Год назад +3

    This one deserves a Oscar

  • @alisterdsouza9432
    @alisterdsouza9432 Год назад

    Junaid Bhai Yeah Video Dek Kay Aankhin Num hogayee.... Mera Shair Meri Jaan Karachi .... Ka Satya Naas Kar Diya!

  • @gaurav32257
    @gaurav32257 Год назад +10

    Godrej is parsi family mumbai which owns majority land in mumbai they have thousands of businesses and employ lakhs of people. This is what happens when majority is not muslim.
    'India is secular because of hindu majority " - vajpayee

    • @Nozarks1
      @Nozarks1 Месяц назад +1

      Tata too. And they are known for their charity schools and hospitals. They give back to community.

  • @muhammadwaqaskhalid2169
    @muhammadwaqaskhalid2169 Год назад +1

    Thank you Junaid bhai for this video. It's time the truth comes out openly

  • @sabihmushtaq1266
    @sabihmushtaq1266 Год назад +2

    Fall from Grace. Karachi was one of the most precious, most lovable, most humble, most diverse, and whatnot, but alas, it has become a piece of trash. It was so safe, so comforting and so easy to wander around the city in night's light.

  • @tarundughria2791
    @tarundughria2791 Год назад +1

    Thank you jaunaid bhai for recognising our ancestors contribution to karachi.

  • @bhupenderkumardsaklani1501
    @bhupenderkumardsaklani1501 Год назад +3

    Late Shri Prakash kewalramani had a girl school in Karachi 7 storey high in those days
    Post independent he came to India in Mumbai and started school in Wadala named Sitaram Prakash High school
    All the teachers and principals and staff was from Karachi Pakistan

  • @bawa987
    @bawa987 Год назад +1

    Allah ka shukar hai hum India m hai, thanx Junaid Bhai showing ugly truth, as a Indian I feel so bad for those minorities stay in Pakistan,

  • @asimanwar3867
    @asimanwar3867 Год назад +7

    Thank you Junaid bhai for highlighting this aspect of karachi. Hope we would see better times ahead where people can feel secure as a Pakistani and not judged on the basis of ethnicity, race or religion. I hope that time will come.

    • @hunk3891
      @hunk3891 Год назад

      🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

    • @xijinping9024
      @xijinping9024 Год назад

      Now Pakistan cannot prosper because hypocrite Pakistani invested in terrorism not in education whereas india is destined to become the 3rd largest economy after 2024...
      This is the reality of Pakistan 😂

    • @comesthru
      @comesthru Год назад

      You are joking, right?

    • @asimanwar3867
      @asimanwar3867 Год назад

      @@comesthru no

  • @prateekraisinghani4578
    @prateekraisinghani4578 Год назад +1

    My dadi narrated stories about her pada in Karachi pre partition. Showed her this video which brought tears in her eyes.

  • @sagarparte
    @sagarparte Год назад +2

    I am Maharashtrian. We had relatives that stayed in karachi for work and lived there before partition. Karachi originally belongs to Kholi community. Kholi community which is also the original people of Mumbai.

  • @rahmatquadri2602
    @rahmatquadri2602 Год назад

    We migrated to Karachi in 1948. I wish I had a camera. Didnot know, this will be the fate of Karachi. I worked with a Parsi for 21 years. A thorough gentleman and always true to his words.

  • @aashutoshrana1779
    @aashutoshrana1779 11 месяцев назад +3

    The demographics of Karachi in 1945 ( a year before the direct action day ) was :- 53.17%🕉️, 35.44%☪️, 7%✝️, 4.39% ( parsi , sikh , jain Buddhist etc). After partition genocide and migration occurs and many hindus left Karachi, Out of 3 lakh only 61k hindus left there as hindu, others migrated or converted to Islam, in the year 1980 the growth rate of Hindus and Christians drop nearly 10 times from its actual previous growth rate and in 2020 the demographics of Karachi is 97.03%☪️, 1.96%✝️,0.86%🕉️, 0.15% others

    • @kunal_19
      @kunal_19 26 дней назад +1

      ☪️ANCER SPREAD VERY FAST

  • @ahmadjunaidnizami4336
    @ahmadjunaidnizami4336 Год назад

    OMG, it's an eye opening video. Thank you for enlighten us about the history.

  • @rajendrawandhare9114
    @rajendrawandhare9114 Год назад +14

    Imagine the loss pakistan incurred,The Sindhi trader community who were from Karachi, Hydrabad r so brilliant in business,inspite of loosing all property in Pakistan,They r richest community in India.

    • @jeetuhasrajani1625
      @jeetuhasrajani1625 Год назад +1

      So true!!

    • @TabraizBajkani
      @TabraizBajkani Год назад +2

      CM Sindh Ayub Khuhro tried everything to protect Sindhi Hindus but Liaquat Ali Khan kicked him out. Liaquat wanted to fill Karachi with muhajirs which changed demography of Sindh which resulted in Sindhi Urdu riots of 92

    • @paulomi9351
      @paulomi9351 Год назад

      ​@@TabraizBajkanimemons are converted sindhi lohanas
      Lohanas community descendants of raghuvanshi or raghukul or suryawanshi
      Jinnah was lohana with surname thakkar whose grandfather converted
      Memoni language originated from kathiyawad
      Kutchi and sindhi language are siblings
      With culture , people have also lost their mother tongue , their own civilization roots.
      Ancient scripts, languages, ancient wisdom and lot of things gets lost
      Actually foreign invaders always colonized natives first by imposing foreign language.
      While there is nothing wrong in learning new language but imposing Urdu and looking down upon everything else to justify creation of pakistan and associate everything with arab ,turk ,Mongols and outsiders too was suicidal as people do not own their own country.
      The most problematic thing with indian sub continent region muslim is that they don't connect themselves with the country in which they reside or don't recognise their own motherland as there own .
      Something which you don't own whole heartedly, you would not be able to serve your country or motherland selflessly either .
      Parsis blend with people of subcontinent and don't associate themselves with Iran or Persia
      But this problem is sadly with indian sub continent region muslims .
      So there is constant identity crisis and mental conflict which is worsened due to two nation theory of partition based on religion.
      You are not able to even own your local heros or ancestral history or civilization.
      Even after so many years, yet people of continent want to look upon invaders and colonizers as their hero while civilizational history of this land itself is way ancient
      There are so many multiethnic multilingual and multicultural diversity in pakistan. But you don't even care that religion is just one aspect of one's identity. There is so much to individuals personality, culture and tradition.
      Human being is social animal and cannot leave in isolation.

    • @paulomi9351
      @paulomi9351 Год назад +3

      ​@@TabraizBajkanithere were even jain temples and jain families which migrated to india along with jain tirthankaras idols while temples are converted or broken or turned even into public toilets
      Now Jain's have no history or even mention of their presence or contribution .
      Most of jain merchants and traders built temples, dharmshala and also pathshala
      There is entire ecosystem which works in and around temples
      Temples were not just places of idol worship but from artisans who carved to those who maintain manage and take care of that temple,all get employment along with pure vibrations and blessings of the diety
      There were bhojnalaya where poor people could get food free or at minimal cost
      There were dharmashala for travelers to rest and stay
      So from person working in community kitchen to cleanliness and maintenance to sculptors to priest maintaining daily rituals and taking care of idols , everyone gets empowered.
      Rather those temples were so rich due to donations that invaders looted those ancient temples 😂

  • @mollyv4908
    @mollyv4908 Год назад +1

    Quality Content + Courage= Junaid Akram

  • @harisahmed3044
    @harisahmed3044 Год назад +33

    Thankyou, to all the people of different beliefs for contributing to a non deserving nation.

    • @Jee_Lo
      @Jee_Lo Год назад

      Non deserving nation? Asal nation he ye log hen who are contributing well for Pakistan.

    • @jahanvipatel1984
      @jahanvipatel1984 Год назад

      Aur banao PAKISTAN.....total useless country

  • @hassankali
    @hassankali Год назад +3

    I am glad you made this. I am well aware of this history but it’s hard to make people understand.

  • @HistoryOfRevolutions
    @HistoryOfRevolutions Год назад +1

    Very valuable documentary. Good interviews and insights

  • @KazimAli-q1f
    @KazimAli-q1f Год назад +7

    As a karachiite , I personally feel like creation of Pakistan has really ruined the orignality of my city , we feel like karachiites are oppressed and my identity is a karachiite , I would honestly step up for a seperation movement against pakistan