Rebel Moon - Part One: A Child of Fire Review
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 14 дек 2023
- Rebel Moon - Part One: A Child of Fire, reviewed by Hanna Ines Flint. Narrated by Max Scoville.
Despite a great ensemble cast, Zack Snyder's space opera is let down by a derivative patchwork script, mediocre action sequences and a superficial story that fails to live up to its expansive promise.
#RebelMoon #Movies #IGN 
Развлечения
This movie is like a watching all the cut scenes for a game you’ve never played.
Perfectly summed up, too many slow mos
I'm sure the 4 hour long director's cut fixes everything
No,you have to wait for Rebel Moon3's 5 hour Extended Fandome Cut for the true mastery to be revealed
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Hopefully we can buy it on 4k Blu-ray?
Release the snyder cut!!
Not again please
Giving the movie a 4 and then promoting your interview with the director is insane 💀
Bad movie is a bad movie, man.
It’s not IGN’s fault the movie was bad. They doesn’t mean they cancel interviews they’ve scheduled weeks in advance.
@@UserAme99 For sure, just feels weird
I'm suprised they had the cojones for that.
@@UserAme99IGN shouldn’t be trusted with most of their movie reviews anyway.
I’m not a fan of ign but giving a movie a 4 and promoting the interview with the director is a 10 on 10 lol.
DEAD
That means IGN actually has some integrity.
look at all the people defending a movie they hadnt watched
4/10 is still pretty generous
I'd give it a 3 because it's sooo generic and boring
Snyder is not a great storyteller. Just great visual director. He needs to partner with someone who can tell a great story.
agreed his movies look great but the story needs improvement
But not himself
He did. That's why dawn of the dead is his best film
So this is worse than the Star Wars sequels? Riiiiight. Suuuuure.
He should honestly be a cinematographer
Ah they almost made it 3 minutes without bringing up an MCU comparison. So close!
IGN gave Thor Love and Thunder 7/10.
They gave Man of Steel a 9/10. What now?
they gave the Snyder Cut an 8/10
She hulk 8/10 ... my point need to see then decide
They gave the Marvels 8/10
Gave man of steel 9/10
They gave the marvels an 8/10
Because The Marvels deserves it.
@@Vantud391Sure it did......
Lol no @@Vantud391
The Marvels is a 5 at best lol 😅
@@Vantud391 It doesn't. They also gave The Rings of Power an 8
At least this time, Snyder can’t blame Netflix for interfering with his “glorious” vision
Absolutely. The movie speaks for itself. Though he has an uphill battle to face... Hollywood does not like this guy. 😬
You say that like the Snydercut isn't way better than the Josstice league.
@@GutzOverFearis that why Hollywood keeps giving him hundreds of millions? He is an elite Hollywood director, owns a production house, his wife was a Hollywood executive. He is not an outsiders you think he is.😂😂😂😂😂
@@t.a6159 All of that is fair and accurate but it seems he's not as much of an industry sweetheart as say Rian Johnson or James Gunn. The point is he gets used as a regular punching bag because he doesn't conform. Which actually makes him more respectable. You have to admit his haters are a special kind.
@@GutzOverFearIf you think he is not conforming then Spike Lee must be an alien from another dimension.
“How many si-fi tropes do u want?”
ZS: “yes!” * snorts mountain of coke *
His fans * shucks his ballz while he does coke *
He should have made Space Scarface instead
Shits hilarious.
Prompt: write a space opera using highest grossing franchises as sources
@@kchikweteand that’s how you come up with rebel moon
We need a 24-hour snyder cut
Too short 😂
@@jean-pierre5221I would take snyderverse any day over pandaverse
People who like Snyder's movies for the writing might have lacked some air at birth.
These are the same guys who gave The Marvels an 8/10. Stop doing reviews IGN.....please
Cry moe Snyderbro lol
Ign is a variety of reviews, so this comparison doesn’t really work unless it is the same reviewer
That was done by a different reviewer lmao
So...? 🤷♂️
And? IGN still give them a tool to rate things....they are all the same fools, fooling fools like you
Y’all gave rise of skywalker a 7. I don’t believe you. Lol
they gave Man of Steel 9/10.
And the Snyder cut an 8
Sounds to me like another movie that should've been a TV show
No, because Snyder's visual effects approach is far from budget friendly
@Joseantonio-op5oc This guy directed part 1 on a budget of just 83 million USD. It isn't a budget heavy film
It is a show you num num lol
Or a video game, really.
@@sheepdogprotector5154 oh really? a 134 minute show called "Part One"? 134 minutes? who are you calling a num num
welp IGN was right...
It felt like a tubi movie with a higher than usual budget.
review definitely hates Snyder 😂... could have given a simple review...but bro did a passive aggressive review on it
He did give a review on it. You're just mad because the review wasn't positive.
@@homelander7742 I'm not mad bro🙏🏼😅
@@KUCHIYAMAanimations
Ummm...yes you are. You're in the comments section attacking the reviewer.
Watched it. 4-5 is spot on.
whats with the passive aggressive quips ? sounds personal
Everyone pls watch the movie for yourself, nowadays reviews dont show the true potential of the movies that are reviewed
@@Vilik711there is a woman with lava swords on her arms and this man is worried about the logic of Black Widow 2.0
@@Vilik711so basically black widow, gamora, nebula, cat woman, Harley Quinn, mm yeah
Wait so the movie not out yet and folks who haven't seen the movie hating on it?..How?
it is basically how RUclips comments work now unfortunately
Don't know.
Just they way people are now.
The internet…🤷🏽♂️
And folks who havent seen it are defending it? How?
Apparently some "Critics" have seen it and are bashing it and some "Causual" goers have seen it and like it?
Who has the most to gain from this, Joe Average or the Big Corporations with critics in their pockets?
Didn't expect that, need to watch and see for myself.
right cuz cant trust who rates she hulk 8
Same.. these the same clowns that love the marvels and she hulk
Nice to be a personal opinionated human again huh
@@ParichayJadhavSINCE1996 They Gave Man of Steel 9/10, and Snyder Cut 8/10. Whats ur point?
He should've left everything under obscurity in order to keep everyone's imagination do the rest then proceed to slowly world build as sequels goes rather than an expository dumping
Is he actually going to make part 2 now? Or the video game tie-in? Or will he abandon the IP? lol
He has almost 2 hours done on 2 said at premiere and extended cuts to do...
Marvels 8
Thor love and thunder 7
Idk man something tells me that IGN just isn’t qualified 😂😂😂😂
they gave Man of Steel 9/10. Say it again?
Why don't make it a limited series
Not a fan of Snyder but this reviewer sounds like he hates the director lol
Has Tag release the Zack Snyder ultimate directors cut of Rebel moon part 1 Is about to trend world wide.😅
Zack Snyder would do well to mimic how organically and subtly a film like _Mad Max: Fury Road_ handles exposition and world-building. (Well, that uses voiceover in its opening too, which isn't subtle, but the rest of the film is a more relevant example.)
not everything needs to be subtle, it's fine to give overt-vert exposition at the start of the film. Plenty of phenomenal movies have done that as well.
They have she hulk an 8/10. Let that sink in to ur brains
And Man of Steel a 9/10.
@@sudevsen that movie is more like a 10/10
They gave Man of Steel 9/10. Sink that too
@@Joseantonio-op5oc one of the only accurate ratings ign has ever made tbh
Snyder lost his mojo after Watchmen
*After Dawn of the dead
After Man Of Steel
The problem is that he thinks he can write, which he can't. He should stick to just being a director.
Turns out doing shot-for-shot remakes of comicbook panels makes you a poor choice fir original stories.
@@sudevsen His action scenes only worked in 300 and Watchmen. The rest of his movies feel like his version of Bayhem
I'm sure he won't come back for an interview for part 2....I don't believe for a second this is a film that deserves a 4.....
Oh ye of little faith 😂
Yeah, I'd say it deserves even lower. Snyder has a horrible track record and this doesn't look like the exception to the rule at all.
4 is too generous
It doesn't deserve a 4 it deserves a 1. They are kissing up to the director by giving it a 4.
@@thunderbear82 uh huh
This would have been a great video game
It definitely has that generic sci-fi feel so many games go for.
It feels like a worse version of Mass Effect 2.
Why is this interviewer so angry? And why can’t they read their own words? Yikes all around.
Everyone in here who hasn’t seen the movie is silly to argue. Comes out in a few days why not wait and see instead acting a fool
because people love to jump onto the hate train it's so much easier than waiting to see the film themselves and deciding. apparently now movie critics are never wrong or don't have their own bias. plus some people never intended to watch this, but again people love to pile on the hate
@@Nighthunt01 and apparently critics are also wrong when they don't like a movie someone's hyped about
@@k--music it's just another person's opinion of an art piece, but yeah that also happens
Its not a marvel movie so why would IGN give it a higher rating? X
Was it Jupiter Ascending that bad?
there should be a moratorium on big bad empire vs rebels movies/shows.
They gave it 4/10. Really unexpected
For a Snyder movie? Think is absolutely expected
@@lukegill6908Snyder cut 8/10
@@user-fj3yh7ws5yNot a theatrical movie.
Dude Its Zack Snyder, that means all style and no substance, no story, no fleshed out characters... Deluded fans like you have no idea.... the guy hasn't made anything decent for a very long time. Man of Steel was ok, but only due to Henry & the soundtrack.
@@drumnbassdan I’m not a Snyder fan lad relax
Zack Snyder already said it’s a Moshe to everything Sc-fi and the 7 Samurai. ( Declaimer is out there )
There is only 1 imperium and that is the one ruled by Him on Terra ! Ave Imperator !
I'm more excited to see
When are we going to admit Snyder is mid?????
If anything synder is overhated lol
Jon Watts is "mid"
Snyder ruined two potentially 1,5 billion-dollar films.
Snyder is not mid, he’s just hack at this point
And he gave barbie the best movie of 2023😂 what a joke
They gave Man of steel 9/10. was that a joke too?
Yeah it was
Anyone else notice all the blurry scenes?
Still gonna watch it. At least he tries his best to put his art out there
"Art"
@@jesusgallegos3655 "Best"
@@jesusgallegos3655he succeed more than you
So did Ed Wood.
@@Simone489 that does not mean that every movie is art
I'm still going to watch it
Battlefield Earth got a worthy successor.
😂
Battlefield Earth is at least fun to mock.
Its more like a Valerian or Jupiter Ascending.
Remember that IGN gave The Marvels an 8/10.
It has 10% on Rotten Tomatoes my man. Who cares.
...and they gave Man of Steel 9/10
Correction, a different reviewer gave it a 8/10
So...?🤷♂️
Remember that these are not the same people reviewing it
Zack Snyder made another bad movie? Surprising…
So we are taking corporate sellout IGN's word as truth now? Lol, you guys go from enabling WB' corporate greed in screwing over Snyder and now this?
@@memecliparchives2254 calm down
@@memecliparchives2254Least obsessed Znyder fan
@@KokongLeast obsessed Snyder hater
@@memecliparchives2254Shut down bot
Now review the 4 hour version
Omg engagement from ign like wbd holding ZSJL snyder cut hostage on max ಥ‿ಥ
Ign low score means must watch 😂
Since when?
Famous last words.
Your funeral 🤭
Exactly 😂
Wow, a lot of hate in this review. lol. Really makes me want to watch your interview with the director. lmao
Its Zack Snyder, that means all style and no substance, no story, no fleshed out characters... Deluded fans have no idea.... the guy hasnt made anything decent for a very long time.
You really don’t have the pulse of the viewers. You are reviewing it based on a purely intellectual aspect. Most people will just watch it this for the visuals, the story will just be the icing on the top of it.
there was this version were ppl didnt rly hit edited for ppl with problems, maybe who knows.
An intergalactic sci-fi movie with high tech era. The first minute of the movie was farming using a peasant animal, so bad.
But Barbie is IGN Movie of 2023. Ok
Barbie is more well made than the majority of blockbusters coming out of Hollywood.
Barbie is a fun movie though?
@@TZ19999 Yeah... No it's not
@@TZ19999no it’s not… not by a long shot
Barbie is fun af tho
IGN has no credibility for a long time
They actually seem to be one of the more generous reviews for this, plenty of reviewers have given it 20-25. 40 is above the metacritic average
Not going to take IGN-word for it. Definitely going to watch It when it comes out, can't trust their review on anything these days is not like they can do a better job. And also
When we watch it, we should give it our own ratings.😎
if it helps - most other reviewers did not like it either, even the more reputable ones
Okay thanks u 👌
Based on reviewer's points it sounded like a 6/10. Surprised it got a 4 🤔
Honestly, the movie itself is only 20 minutes long but due to the fact that Snyder loves his slo-mo montages the movie stretches itself to just over the 2 hours mark.
Bro yes!! It’s a meme at this point
Wasn't it a different take to go from the threat of violence against a woman scene to what was happening to the guy?
I'll never take an ign rating seriously 😒... I'll watch it for myself when it comes out... thank you
Def watching it I'll likely love it too, I'll be drinking.
Cope
Then why did you watch the review?
@@Alexcmlindquisthahaha exactly
@@Alexcmlindquist Who said they watched the review?
How did Lucas borrow from Dune?
Haven't seen it yet, but this has to be extremally bad for it to have a 4 when so many unwatchable movies got 7 and up here. Otherwise they might have have something against the director. I'll find out the 21st.
I'd say a 4 is pretty fair. Awful movie in every way.
Wait for the 48 hour Snyder Cut 😂
Waiting for the Snyder heads to defend this and call it his masterpiece
One of the makeup artists in this film actually went to high school with me
IGN does not like Zack Snyder apparently.
They're not alone today
Why is this reviewer comparing this movie to other movies??? 🤨
The first section is “Star Bore” a lot of bots aren’t going to be happy.
tbh I'll probably still watch it
The boos mean nothing when you've seen what makes them cheer
4 is generous. Snyder cannot write.
You know what is missing in this movie? Martha. He should have added more Martha.
7 years later and Marco over here still gets scared thinking of BvS. It’s just a scene man, it can’t hurt you!
@@getdabbd0n let me guess, your mother is also Martha.
@@MarcoR6 you shouldn’t say that scawy name for your own sake, Marco :0 Go change your pee pee diapers and watch some fantastic 4 or something ok?
@@getdabbd0n I'm not afraid of Marthas... I'm afraid of what Snyder does to them... alone, at night. The guy has serious issues. Poor Martha. Or Marthas.
"WHY DID YOU SAY THAT NAME?!"
It would be much more fitting for him to do Star Wars than to create his own universe because from these images and the story it is clear that it is another world that someone created through current trends and also hard to believe just because he wasn't sure if people would enjoy it otherwise. You can do either a Marvel/DC-like where everything is crazy or a world with rules where it makes sense why everyone behaves and fights this way like Dune, StarWars, StarGate etc.
After the heat JJ and Johnson got for their movies, Snyder would literally be lynched in public if he got his own Star Wars movie.
@@GutzOverFear yeah he'd completely ruin the art style beyond repair
@@artembiyun423 Forget the artstyle the narrative would go into divisive directions. Unless it was nothing to do with the original characters and trilogy then maybe there's something there. Safer option for him to do his own thing at Netflix.
@@GutzOverFear even with disney star wars, Zack Snyder has to go in the corner and play with his own crayons
We need more Star Wars type original IP like Rebel Moon
365 days Director cut will fix it
Normies can’t comprehend Snyder movies.
Woah woah, IGN, where do you get off. 4/10?
That’s waaaay too generous.
How was Cyberpunk again eh IGN? You're all full of it.
4? Its like the trailer and the actual show have nothing in common...cant wait to get let down!
Imagine your pitch being so bad that Kathleen Kennedy turned it down.
Just FYI that ign also gave ‘The Marvels’ 8/10 .. so make of it what you will
Why are you reviewing this movie if you don't like zack snyder films
If it was a disney or marvel movie that 4 will quickly become an 8
If it is a Zack Snyder movie a 2 will become a 4, it seems they are pretty consistent.
@@masakazuishiguro8525 you know that isn't true.
there aren't many zack film that critics have loved more than fans, however there are plenty of marvel and disney movies that critics have rated highly but have flopped as they weren't loved by fans.
Release the Sandler cut
Roadhouse
This show is so fake! The opening scene looks like a stage with a back drop and then you get the village. That also looks like a model and does not feel real. What a disappointment in the first forty five minutes.
zach really needs to work on his scripts or just leave the story/narratice entirely to another group and focus on visuals
Sofia, Hopkins & Djimon deserve much much better projects
This is the first I'm hearing of this movie.
Must be fun not to have Twitter
Ooh ! Low rated movies is usually my thing ^^
IGN has always diss Zack Snyder movies so im not surprised
I’m sure the Snyder Bros will leave perfectly reasonable comments.
Sure, and those who hate Snyder will leave reasonable comments too.
Call out both sides if you want to look at least impartial lol.
There are zealous Snyder fans and zealous Snyder haters.
@@memecliparchives2254 but it's so much easier to dismiss someone as a fanboy, doesn't matter what they actual say.... people love to jump on the hate train
... Of course it was bad. Zach Snyder hasn't made anything worth watching since 300... Stop allowing this guy to make stuff.
4 out of 10 is about right
It was really bad