Without risk there is no reward

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 25 ноя 2024
  • If you’re struggling, consider therapy with our sponsor. Click here: betterhelp.com... for a discount on your first month of therapy.
    If you have questions about the brand relating to how the therapists are licensed, their privacy policy, or therapist compensation, here is an overview written by the RUclips creators behind the channel Cinema Therapy that goes into these topics: / addressing_the_betterh...
    Watch our video "Why we’re leaving the United States FOREVER (in our 50s!)" here: tinyurl.com/2h...
    Thank you to both my sons for their beautiful video contributions. Check out their channels: ‪@Skymography‬ and ‪@nathanieldrew‬
    And find me here on Instagram: / be.neaththesurface
    Thanks as always for your support. 🙏😁
    All items below are Amazon affiliate links. This means I receive a small commission if you make a purchase when clicking on anything below, at no additional cost to you (that is, no change in price):
    Camera equipment:
    Main camera: amzn.to/43BmTiw
    Secondary camera: amzn.to/3x2SWf9
    All-in-one lens: amzn.to/3xisYV0
    35mm F1.4 lens: amzn.to/49rFVJT
    16mm F1.4 lens: amzn.to/49gkrQ3
    Tripod: amzn.to/3IWrUJi
    Motorized slider: amzn.to/3PFk8ag
    Lighting equipment:
    Soft lights: amzn.to/3VBCHzR
    Versatile stands: amzn.to/4audBaw
    Video light: amzn.to/49faKRP
    Softbox: amzn.to/4abZNlg
    C stand: amzn.to/3VBC615
    In this video, I explore how taking more risks is transforming my life in my 50s. Drawing from personal experiences, I share moments when I dared to step outside my comfort zone and the powerful lessons I learned from those decisions. I also break down a formula I developed to help me (and you?) understand better the process of risk-taking, which is instrumental to living a richer life.
    I then dive into the challenges of droning (yes, droning!) and navigating French culture and the language, both of which have brought up in me high levels of fear and anxiety. But I’ve come to realize that without embracing these fears and discomforts and taking more chances, I simply cannot fully experience the freedom and fulfillment that I crave.
    Join me as I explore why taking more risk is so crucial to living a fuller and freer life.
    #TakeMoreChances #RiskTaking #TransformYourLife #LivingFearlessly #LifeAfter50 #EmbraceTheFear #PersonalGrowth #SteppingOutOfComfort #FearlessLiving #DareToDream #DroningAdventures #FacingFears #LivingInFrance #FrenchCulture #LanguageLearningJourney #ThrivingAfter50 #FreedomAndFulfillment #CourageOverComfort #LifeLessons #SelfDiscovery #LivingFully #LifeTransformation #MidlifeReinvention #TakingRisks #ChallengeYourself

Комментарии • 404

  • @nathanieldrew
    @nathanieldrew Месяц назад +80

    Fantastic video. You seem so much freer speaking here than in your previous videos!! Very brave of you to do this, I found it refreshing. Beautiful emotion at the end. Also 3:25 made me laugh, glad you didn't cut that out.
    Sport mode all the way!!!!

    • @BeneaththeSurfaceYT
      @BeneaththeSurfaceYT  Месяц назад +21

      Haha, yes, all thanks to you! You were also a driving force in me opening up in front of the camera. You've been pushing me in that direction for a long time. I finally got it, how to loosen up and just speak, be my imperfect self. Which is perfect as it is. :) If I could just keep getting out of my way...

  • @janetturner9607
    @janetturner9607 Месяц назад +27

    Please do more of this style and approach. Being so vulnerable and showing your personal process. Very relatable. Thank you!

  • @eileencronk7520
    @eileencronk7520 Месяц назад +27

    You have no idea how your openness and vulnerability inspires and encourages me. I am a Latina woman breaking, at 63, the shackles of my subconscious cultural constraints. Giving myself permission to re-child myself is challenging but so rewarding! Onward! Growth at any age is good.

    • @BeneaththeSurfaceYT
      @BeneaththeSurfaceYT  Месяц назад

      So great to hear, that's awesome. Best of luck and thanks so much for your support! 🙏😁

    • @libbydavis2554
      @libbydavis2554 21 день назад +1

      Well done, Eileen!!! Keep up the good work! Re-childing is worth it at any age!

  • @jenniszafranski6360
    @jenniszafranski6360 Месяц назад +10

    YES. Do more of this! I think you are tapping into something people our age (50's) can relate to and need. I am here for it.

  • @elizabethfelton1973
    @elizabethfelton1973 Месяц назад +3

    I have never been able to sit in that place of fear, so I often leap. Which is what I did seven years ago when I moved to Mexico. I had met a Mexican guy and after six months of back and forth, went for it. I knew some Spanish, his English was better, and then three years later we broke up, and that's when the fear that you are talking about rose up, because I had allowed him to manage the things that were easier when you were fluent. Thank goodness for my therapist, who doesn't just try to alleviate the pain, but actually dig down into the bedrock through various approaches. What I've come away with is, whatever happens, I can find the solution, wherever I go I am home. The part I still work on, and it sounds like you might too, is the idea if something goes wrong, it's your fault because you lost control/missed something/weren't aware; I continue with, it's a mistake, we may be responsible, but we still make mistakes. Love watching you and your family because of the depth of inquiry, thanks for that!

    • @BeneaththeSurfaceYT
      @BeneaththeSurfaceYT  Месяц назад

      Thank you and good luck with your own continued search. 🙏

  • @t200b-i7k
    @t200b-i7k Месяц назад +9

    When you said that you're "fearful" my first thought was; That CAN'T be!! Especially after following your journeys moving out of the US. You both seem like the most adventurous, courageous people out there!! Thanks for such a transparent view of things! Blessings.

    • @BeneaththeSurfaceYT
      @BeneaththeSurfaceYT  Месяц назад +2

      Thank you. Yeah, the excitement of moving to Europe was so great that it carried me through. Easiest of the scenarios. 😁 Thank you for your support! 🙏

  • @wildflower3302
    @wildflower3302 Месяц назад +57

    Love the new format..great work! You have a sparkle in your eyes in this video. Bravo. I completely get where you are coming from, as I am a lot like you. We moved from Washington State to France last year, to north eastern Brittany. Your move shows that you are, in fact, a brave soul, as the moving process, being an expat, and day to day life here is fraught with challenges (and so worth it). You don't have to see the whole path before you take your first step.

    • @BeneaththeSurfaceYT
      @BeneaththeSurfaceYT  Месяц назад +8

      Very true. That undertaking (moving to France) is STILL kicking our asses! Thank you so much for your support. 🙏😁

    • @shinyshinythings
      @shinyshinythings Месяц назад +3

      Hear, hear, from a fellow Washingtonian in France!

    • @wildflower3302
      @wildflower3302 Месяц назад

      @@shinyshinythings Bon soirée! Where and when did you settle in France?

  • @lyndaplancarte4895
    @lyndaplancarte4895 Месяц назад +15

    Always love watching you and your family...I am not good at taking risks. Have always had jobs that were ruled by laws and regulations...very black and white. Now retired and residing alone I have felt like I wasn't living, just existing. I was in such a rut...have been seeing a therapist to deal with many issues over time. Some discussion re my taking a leap of faith to get out and meet people, join groups, get out and enjoy life essentially. Have never really traveled and a friend basically told me to go somewhere so...I booked a flight to go across the country to visit a friend of 62 years who resides in Boston. It felt great to book the flight and on some days I am excited and on others my anxiety of traveling alone gets the better of me. I am my own worst enemy but will keep trying to put one foot in front of the other to get myself through the excitement versus anxiety to finally enjoy a trip. I feel like you with your drone and your trips to the coffee shops. I just have to do it for myself...so I will prepare myself for one week in Boston. Thank you for somewhat helping me light the fire under my bottom to get me to step out side my confort zone!! Wish me luck!!

    • @BeneaththeSurfaceYT
      @BeneaththeSurfaceYT  Месяц назад +2

      Love what you wrote! Best of luck with your adventures, I know you will do great. 😁 And so appreciate your lovely support. 🙏

  • @maryjanelarson9045
    @maryjanelarson9045 Месяц назад +16

    I've often found with a shift in perspective, when I look at something new as an experiement without an expectation of outcome... "lets see what happens" the experience is much more fun and I always expand my comfort zone. I prove I can do more than my scaredy brain wants me to believe.
    I also enjoyed the more relaxed approach to this video. Well done for stepping into the fear and ending up in a more joyous place.

    • @BeneaththeSurfaceYT
      @BeneaththeSurfaceYT  Месяц назад +1

      Thank you so much and so true what you've shared. Words to live by. Really appreciate your support. 🙏

  • @Catherine-xr6dr
    @Catherine-xr6dr Месяц назад +15

    Love the warmth of this new style. Kudos for taking the leap. I have also enjoyed your more curated/art house style as well, but it's nice to see the human being come to life behind the lens. Keep it up! I'll watch either style.

  • @sabrinacortellini6922
    @sabrinacortellini6922 Месяц назад +3

    In France for almost 15 years, curiosity save my life from confort zone and despear, there's such beauty in showing vulnerability, only way to connect with another soul and similar experiences, thank you for your honest sharing, priceless !

  • @princessdaaahlingamor5798
    @princessdaaahlingamor5798 День назад +1

    18:40 I LOVE that you didn’t use a script!!! Although it’s scary, it actually helps us connect better with you! Thanks!

  • @TheMisschrisaz
    @TheMisschrisaz Месяц назад +5

    This new format really suits you. You said you were nervous but it came across as effortless. I can really relate to this video because of the changes in my and my husband’s life right now. We’re building a house in Maine to get away from Arizona summers and I’ve had to conquer my fear of power tools lol. I still get nervous using that saw but I’m out here doing it like a boss 😂.

    • @BeneaththeSurfaceYT
      @BeneaththeSurfaceYT  Месяц назад +1

      Nice! Continued success! Appreciate you watching and leaving your thoughts. 🙏😁

  • @frenchmakoti
    @frenchmakoti Месяц назад +8

    In answering your question: The biggest risk I have ever taken was leaving behind South Africa, my motherland, a career in banking and aviation, our home, family, friends and everything I ever knew. We moved to Europe (3years in Belgium and now a year in France) with only 6 suitcases....its a long story😅😅 but what a journey! Challenges, tears, laughter, growth, fear, worry, opportunities, love, wins, peace.....too many to count. Thank you both for sharing your journey🩵🩷

    • @BeneaththeSurfaceYT
      @BeneaththeSurfaceYT  Месяц назад +2

      Haha, yes, it's all that rolled into one, isn't it? Good for you to take chances. And thanks for your lovely support! 🙏😁

    • @MsLinda165
      @MsLinda165 Месяц назад +2

      Wow, that's really a story. Would love to hear more. I moved from one province to another, and can say the same. Even though I stayed in the same country, it may as well have been across the world. I had one suitcase, and I mistakenly thought Canada was the same all over. It certainly is not. Climate, culture, history, economy...all are varied from one province to another, and come with its own challenges and hurdles.

    • @MoniqueDiCarlo
      @MoniqueDiCarlo Месяц назад +1

      Left my motherland 24 years ago, by myself and moved to the US. Single again and now planning a move back to Europe (not my mother land, different language and culture). I’m scared but so excited at the same time! I hope to share it all here on RUclips 😊

    • @frenchmakoti
      @frenchmakoti Месяц назад

      ​@@MoniqueDiCarloI cannot wait to witness your journey! Let me follow you right away! Wishing you all the best with your move. ​@MoniqueDiCarlo

  • @chickolat
    @chickolat 22 дня назад +1

    I am 43 and been feeling stuck. I also moved (not France) but a place that I didnt think would be difficult to adjust but 2.5 years later and I am still struggling and resorted to feeling "stuck". I started seeing a therapist 2 months ago because of a sudden heart wrenching event and to process grief. But through it old stuff is coming out and strugglig to process. I want to fix it right away but i cant. Videos like this (its not a bad thing) always shows snippet of the journey and when the person has reached the other side giving the viewer inspiration. But what it doesnt show is the months or years it can take to get to the other side. Or the journey in itself is the other side - the fact that we even decided to take the journey. You gave some inspiration and thank you for a non-scripted version of you.

    • @BeneaththeSurfaceYT
      @BeneaththeSurfaceYT  22 дня назад

      It can take a very long time, indeed. But we do make slow progress as we go along if we are intentional and put it in the time. Did you watch my other videos digging deeper into some difficult times in my life?

  • @eddyinet
    @eddyinet Месяц назад +19

    Just a raw brain dump after watching this: I've been following Nathaniel since he was living in Mexico, then your channel since he introduced it to us, and now your wife's just a few months back and I just have to say I'm super proud of you specifically. Your personal growth through the minimal lens of YT is quite drastic compared to the rest of your family and being a man of similar age as yourself with two kids... huge props my friend. 👊🏼

    • @BeneaththeSurfaceYT
      @BeneaththeSurfaceYT  Месяц назад +1

      Thank you so much. So appreciate your support. 🙏😁

    • @ambientlife2271
      @ambientlife2271 Месяц назад +1

      I didn't know Cecilia has a channel, can you please share the link?

    • @eddyinet
      @eddyinet Месяц назад

      @@ambientlife2271 @anartistslifeyt

    • @BeneaththeSurfaceYT
      @BeneaththeSurfaceYT  Месяц назад +2

      @@ambientlife2271 Haha, look up An Artist’s Life 😁

  • @Ponzuu28
    @Ponzuu28 Месяц назад +7

    I can totally relate. I have always walked on the safe side of the street however a few months ago I finally put my house on the market moved back to the city and it’s exactly where I envision myself this time last year. Little issues have come up, but I have learned to let go and not be worried about the outcome because it always works out.!!!! I can easily talk to people however it’s getting your jacket and shoes on and actually getting out there. I’m not afraid now , I’m doing little steps every single day. Love your channel and keep on keeping on.❤

    • @BeneaththeSurfaceYT
      @BeneaththeSurfaceYT  Месяц назад +1

      Awesome comment, and yes, it does always work out. Good for you, and thanks for the lovely support! 🙏😁

  • @crocha1081
    @crocha1081 Месяц назад +3

    What good questions these are. Definitely food for thought.

  • @katandantonio
    @katandantonio Месяц назад +13

    Love the new format. It feels more authentic and organic

  • @alanriddell8404
    @alanriddell8404 Месяц назад +6

    Excellent message and a really great job.

  • @jesse4689-o2l
    @jesse4689-o2l 16 дней назад +1

    You have an amazing ability to speak from the heart, which why so many people want you to do more of these.

  • @pjeloka
    @pjeloka Месяц назад +3

    Amazing. I'm 12 years behind you and following you in many of your footsteps. This was great. Really made me process how we grow as we age.

  • @pb9401
    @pb9401 Месяц назад +3

    You just walked on to the plank and jumped! Now you’re swimming! Well done you! Love this format I feel like you are having a conversation with me!

  • @Aghinia
    @Aghinia Месяц назад +3

    This video got played after your son's new video... and I thought, two new videos in a day?? Lucky me!! Although I'm not 58, I can understand this feeling after neglecting my inner child for so long. Thanks for making such a relatable, thought provoking story! 👏

    • @BeneaththeSurfaceYT
      @BeneaththeSurfaceYT  Месяц назад +1

      Haha, yes, and my youngest almost published too! It’s a strange thing now being a RUclips family. 😁 I’m glad this resonated with you. Wishing you all the best and thank you so much for your support. 🙏

    • @Aghinia
      @Aghinia Месяц назад +1

      @@BeneaththeSurfaceYT OHH even more exciting!!! I can't wait to see!! Absolutely, love your beautiful family! 🙏🙏

    • @BeneaththeSurfaceYT
      @BeneaththeSurfaceYT  Месяц назад

      @@Aghinia Thank you! You are so sweet! ❤️😁

  • @dionline88
    @dionline88 Месяц назад +2

    This was wonderful!! You seemed more human, sorta like me instead of a 'pro RUclipsr' who knows how to do everything, making me seem like a bumbling idiot for even wanting to try taping myself some days.
    I don't have any issues talking with people only because I know the vast majority of people are nice and will try to be helpful, especially for someone asking what there is to do in the area. But I'm weird because I love routine. I can occasionally go off-script but it's always nice to get back to just doing me and what I do on an everyday basis. Luckily my hubby is the same way, we're boring and we love it! But I sure do like to see someone else trying new things - hence the reason I subscribe to your and Nathaniel's channels. The pure joy you two are able to put into a video is an awesome thing to behold. It must run in the family!!

    • @BeneaththeSurfaceYT
      @BeneaththeSurfaceYT  Месяц назад

      Thanks for watching and for your wonderful support. 🙏😁

  • @KarenKaiser
    @KarenKaiser Месяц назад +7

    Beautiful photography and your heartfelt, authentic message. Definitely a success and definitely worth my time as I sit on the precipice of a major life change. As always... thank you.

    • @BeneaththeSurfaceYT
      @BeneaththeSurfaceYT  Месяц назад +1

      How sweet of you, thank you for your lovely words, and wishing you all the very best. 🙏

  • @soliel8999
    @soliel8999 Месяц назад +1

    Man, I've been waiting for the right conditions. Thanks for saying that.

  • @inspirational_moments_4u
    @inspirational_moments_4u Месяц назад +8

    Thank you for your video and I really appreciate the free style content!

  • @joanns5250
    @joanns5250 Месяц назад +15

    Bravo! If this was you unscripted, give us MORE! Your way of thinking, your experiences are a revelation to me, illuminating a path I might never have discovered on my on. Thank you!

    • @BeneaththeSurfaceYT
      @BeneaththeSurfaceYT  Месяц назад

      Thank you so much. 🙏😁

    • @Julie-i1n
      @Julie-i1n Месяц назад +1

      Great video! I love your channel et Cecilia's. It is so nice to hear perspectives from people of my own age! And I totally relate to your "social" challenges. Once I am out, all is good. But it is the step to go out that is really tough. And I am rarely disappointed in taking that leap (but I have to admit I am always glad to come back to the nest 😂). I would be very interested in hearing your thoughts on the "years wasted" with our fears, our anxiety. I am 51 and I look back and I feel I have wasted so much time (even though I know it was my path) and it makes me so sad. I snap out of it quickly and move on but once in a while, it gets to me. Does that happen to you? And as an idea for your channel, try to find other RUclipsrs our age and share their wisdom with us 😂!!! Thanks for your great work. Bonne chance avec ton français. Je suis dans la même situation que toi mais pour moi c'est l'espagnol!!

    • @BeneaththeSurfaceYT
      @BeneaththeSurfaceYT  Месяц назад

      @@Julie-i1n Te contesté! :)

  • @Anne-Lene74
    @Anne-Lene74 Месяц назад +7

    I always enjoy your videoes, espescially the depth. You spark curiosity and the desire to go deeper into interesting questions. Thank you😊.

  • @Jpage.artist
    @Jpage.artist Месяц назад +2

    It looks like Rapeseed - it's used to make Canola oil.. and plant meal.("Canadian" and "ola) which is actually a commercial name as the word "rapeseed" (plant) seems a bit ,well aggressive....The French translation for "rapeseed" is "colza"~ for "rapeseed oil" it's "huile de colza"....It could also be alfalfa- some sub species have a yellow flower. Sholty is a true yellow-flowered alfalfa. - used for animal feed and soil conservation...Hope that is helpful. : )

    • @BeneaththeSurfaceYT
      @BeneaththeSurfaceYT  Месяц назад +1

      Very educational, thank you!

    • @Jpage.artist
      @Jpage.artist Месяц назад

      @@BeneaththeSurfaceYT you're welcome! it's the curse of being an educator....incidentally, and to answer one of your many other questions-yes this style of presentation feels more natural... as for the other questions-I dig the way you've mapped out your formula-I'm still working on my own (with ,as usual a plethora of thoughts and whatnots...)!

    • @BeneaththeSurfaceYT
      @BeneaththeSurfaceYT  Месяц назад

      @@Jpage.artist 🙏😁

  • @creatorbard
    @creatorbard Месяц назад +2

    Oh yes! This translates beautifully. Inspirational. Thank you.

  • @activityenthusiasts
    @activityenthusiasts Месяц назад +3

    As a 31 year old who struggles with great amounts of overthinking & perfectionism, this entire video resonated deeply for me. And actually just the message I was needing today, thank you so much!
    Also we feel the same stress and fear as you do when flying our drone haha.

    • @BeneaththeSurfaceYT
      @BeneaththeSurfaceYT  Месяц назад

      You're very welcome and thank you as well! Looks like droning stresses a lot of people out... 😩

  • @MirandaHorger
    @MirandaHorger Месяц назад +2

    Kudos for taking the risk and letting go. Doing that for a RUclips video is HUGE! Way to challenge yourself. Making mistakes is important! That's how we learn and grow. Cheers to embracing more dissatisfaction with your comfort zone!

  • @janinedavidparker9407
    @janinedavidparker9407 Месяц назад +2

    Just subscribed after watching this video! Thanks for your vulnerability. I have watched a few of your other videos and enjoyed them but you really came through on this one!

  • @robynhudgens7820
    @robynhudgens7820 12 дней назад +1

    I love your thoughts on pushing yourself emotionally and I’ve been watching you both over the last 2 years and your physical and emotional journeys. Very inspiring and thought provoking. I’d love to move to France

    • @BeneaththeSurfaceYT
      @BeneaththeSurfaceYT  11 дней назад

      Thank you so much for your lovely words. 🙏 You can do it! 😁

  • @CarolynJohnson-fi3ot
    @CarolynJohnson-fi3ot Месяц назад +4

    I'm very happy with the content of this video! Right after you posted the "I no longer want or need friends" video RUclips started sending me more of the same content -- people in their 50's and 60's saying that they no longer have friends & they say they're happy about it. It's tempting to say that. It's even easier to feel that way when you have a spouse and children. But it "protects" us from so much that life has to offer. After the pandemic so many people I know don't feel as engaged in life, myself included. I have to force myself to dress up and go places. I'm so happy your therapist pushed you out the door 😂. P.S. drone photography looks like a blast!!

  • @Valentina-L44
    @Valentina-L44 Месяц назад +1

    The bond and the respect you guys have for each other is so precious and beautiful. It’s like being a soul family 🪽

  • @journeytothemosthigh5021
    @journeytothemosthigh5021 Месяц назад +8

    You made the video a while ago about not having friends and I feel as if you are a friend o me because I resonate with both you and your wife with many things that you’ve spoken about. It’s been a challenge for me navigating through this new world of advanced technology and just seeing the death of so much that was great. I can’t express the gratitude of these videos because I realize that I’m not alone. Many of us gen xer’s are having a hard time. We do feel alone, we are all trying to figure things out and work through things. I moved back to my home country, Panama, because I lost my home over a year ago in the states. I’ve been very isolated for a few different reasons and I realize that it’s not good. I do want to eventually move elsewhere but I know that I have to unload this hurt and really devastation before I can move on. This video and all of your other videos have been extremely helpful. Thank you!

    • @BeneaththeSurfaceYT
      @BeneaththeSurfaceYT  Месяц назад +1

      Thank you so much. I wish you all the very best! 🙏

    • @G..G..
      @G..G.. Месяц назад +2

      Panama is beautiful. I used to live there for a year and traveled the entire Country. It's full of culture and nature. You're blessed to be from there...Enjoy it while you have it.

    • @journeytothemosthigh5021
      @journeytothemosthigh5021 Месяц назад

      @@G..G.. It was even more beautiful 40 years ago. So much has changed. I barely recognize it. It was the best kept secret.

    • @G..G..
      @G..G.. Месяц назад

      @@journeytothemosthigh5021 I hear you on that.... they still have delicious meals for like $2 that's not fast food?

    • @journeytothemosthigh5021
      @journeytothemosthigh5021 Месяц назад

      @@G..G.. a bit more like $6.00. Depends where.

  • @nadynekasta
    @nadynekasta Месяц назад +3

    I love your new approach to your videos, Josh! It's very natural, and feels fresh and organic. Lately, before starting something, I've been asking myself how I can infuse it with more fun. It sounds similar to what you're talking about in terms of playfulness. Anyway, please keep sharing. I very much enjoy yours, your wife's and your son's videos and perspectives on things. Bravo à toute la famille!

  • @markgrimes2237
    @markgrimes2237 Месяц назад +1

    Josh, I have to say this was one of my favorite videos to date. Real, candid, authentic and I think "no script" does very well for you. There's something to be said for more in the moment dialogue that makes for content that very much connects. And, all the pre-production work just goes away, bonus for that. Keep up the great work. Be well.

  • @regisnyder
    @regisnyder Месяц назад +1

    I’ve always put off driving out of town because of fears not knowing what would be around the bend waiting for me, literally. I had to know what was ahead before I took off driving. I picked my nephew up from college years ago; I wasn’t familiar enough the route so I was a nervous wreck driving back home. I was doing 20 miles less than speed limit! That’s how much fear crippled me until I drove to Chicago and ended up on the city’s highways and that wasn’t the plan! I did so well, I feel I can tackle NYC’s traffic!!!

    • @BeneaththeSurfaceYT
      @BeneaththeSurfaceYT  Месяц назад

      Nice! What’s “on the other side” is always full of wonderful surprises. Thanks for watching. 🙏😁

  • @MishaElRusito
    @MishaElRusito Месяц назад +4

    Congratulations on your courage and thanks for sharing! I used to be afraid of talking to people but when I moved to Mexico, the people were so friendly and relaxed about everything, my fears disappeared. I could just scream or burst out laughing in the middle of the street without any care for what people would say now lol

    • @BeneaththeSurfaceYT
      @BeneaththeSurfaceYT  Месяц назад

      Nice. The environment you're in can make all the difference. You're still there, right?

    • @MishaElRusito
      @MishaElRusito Месяц назад +1

      @@BeneaththeSurfaceYT Definitely. Yes, still here but next year I'll be living in other countries as well. Looking for my perfect country that would click with me just like it did for you and France :)

    • @BeneaththeSurfaceYT
      @BeneaththeSurfaceYT  Месяц назад

      @@MishaElRusito Nice, man. Which places are you considering?

  • @reech00
    @reech00 Месяц назад +1

    So much of this resonates with me. My wife and I, in our 50's, recently relocated to the Algarve for part of each year. She is absolutely fearless in encountering Portuguese people and language, which allows me to hover on the sidelines and let her have the challenging conversations. I need to do exactly what you're doing - get out there on my own, have my own interactions, and bring my experience of this fantastic place to a different level. Challenging myself to speak more will add confidence in so many ways beyond the nuts and bolts of learning the language. Loved the script-free format!

    • @BeneaththeSurfaceYT
      @BeneaththeSurfaceYT  Месяц назад

      You’ve got this! Let me know how it goes. Thank you so much for your lovely words and your amazing support. 🙏😁

  • @vargavideo
    @vargavideo Месяц назад +3

    Generous share - thank you!

  • @Mgenao76
    @Mgenao76 20 дней назад +1

    Amazing content!!! Love what you’re sharing with us all! Thank you! ❤

  • @rachel-b8d
    @rachel-b8d Месяц назад +1

    I’m so glad I found your channel - I’m a classical musician and a Gemini. My life has been constant change in 4 different European countries and off I go again next year! Maybe I won’t have time to finish my journey before I get to the end! I guess I’m an ‘anywhere’ person! A great relief to discover like-minded people in our crazy world. It’s a good feeling to hear someone say it’s ok to live one’s life on the move.

  • @venuskirby8243
    @venuskirby8243 Месяц назад +5

    Thank you for sharing ❤. I feel like you are speaking to me!

  • @mylittleocchio
    @mylittleocchio Месяц назад +3

    I really like your formula. It resonates. For me the key is to get to the heart of what I really, really want and to make absolute sure that whatever I'm pursuing is truly for me. In the past, I've gone for things that were more about the status quo (job, house, etc.) and less about my hearts desire. Now I make sure that the thing I want is what I want. I also give myself permission to pivot if I get into it and realize it's not for me. I too struggle with getting out into the world. Lots to unpack there. I might just try the coffee shop challenge. Low stakes way to be in the world. Thanks for sharing with us all. Best to you.

    • @BeneaththeSurfaceYT
      @BeneaththeSurfaceYT  Месяц назад

      Yes, passion will carry you far. If you can focus on what you love, that's an amazing driver. Thanks for pointing that out. And yeah, funny how the coffee shop challenge is low stakes for you. As I describe, not for me! Fascinating how that works. What are some areas that have been challenging for you? Really appreciate your support. 🙏😁

    • @mylittleocchio
      @mylittleocchio Месяц назад

      The coffee shop challenge is only low stakes in that it’s not cost prohibitive for me and I can easily bail if I need to. Very high stakes in being amongst the people because I have lots of social anxiety. Really want to manifest friendships with people who are on the same wavelength. Slowly learning how. Meaningful work is another area that is challenging for me. Trying to find a way to contribute without being overwhelmed.

  • @elvira.dramsmeier2076
    @elvira.dramsmeier2076 Месяц назад +2

    I love all your videos but this one was so much more genuine. Especially after you talked about looking for your drone I had a smile on face until the end. My daughter moved to France three years ago and I am still deciding if I want to retire in France or Spain. It truly surprises me to hear you say that you are moving outside your comfort zone to go to a cafe and mingle with the locals but on the other hand you are producing great videos for everybody to follow you. However, keep up the great work :)

  • @L1felocked
    @L1felocked Месяц назад +1

    I like the formulaic approach. I find it helps to just take opportunities given or identified. All the factors in your formula seem to impact my willingness to take these opportunities, so it's a helpful observation.

  • @elmog0218
    @elmog0218 Месяц назад +2

    LOVE this new approach! Definitely less ‘in the box’. The integrity of your stunning visuals is still intact. You always leave me wanting to see more, but then so very grateful for what you are sharing and for the quality.
    Funny how deliberate and structured your stepping outside of your comfort is. Hearing/seeing what you have started to do brings me to realize that I have been doing (loads less intentionally!) the same in order to pull myself out of a ‘lowest common denominator’ style of rut.
    35yrs ago I ski raced in an amateur club.
    So I decided it was time to learn how to snowboard. All on my own, at 67. Well… I fell…. A lot!!! 🤣 lesson learned.
    Now, on the regular, my greatest joy is playing in ensembles where in rehearsals, I have no idea which of my 3 instruments I will be asked to play! Just ‘put me in coach’ is my personal moto! No complaints! Just DO it! … and I’ve improved my playing, & reading tremendously!
    I traveled alone to Italy, and was a student in Venice for 2 weeks for music that i didn’t particularly like. Had to use my dusty 40yr old college level Italian language skills. …. And I THRIVED!
    Now I want to know why Finland is the happiest country and if it is possible for that happiness to transfer to a solo traveler!!! Let the adventures begin….and continue!!
    Wishing you the best with your French! Practice improves EVERYTHING!!

    • @BeneaththeSurfaceYT
      @BeneaththeSurfaceYT  Месяц назад +1

      Great comment. Love what you shared. Very inspiring! Wishing you all the very best and thank you so much for your support. 🙏😁

  • @katesmith1233
    @katesmith1233 Месяц назад +1

    Great video. Very daring of you to put this one out😀.

  • @larsborishansen192
    @larsborishansen192 Месяц назад +2

    Thank you, Josh!
    This came to close for comfort :) Thank you for your openess and reflections - you and your family is truly an inspiration. You give me a lot to think about, and from thinking comes changes - which I truly needs - keep up the good work.
    Greetings from another introverted :)

    • @BeneaththeSurfaceYT
      @BeneaththeSurfaceYT  Месяц назад

      Thank you so much, and best of luck with the changes. 🙏😁

  • @vibrantly50
    @vibrantly50 Месяц назад +1

    I found this very helpful. I love the parts you broke down involved in risk taking. My husband and I moved to Portugal 3 years ago. We are now preparing to move about 30 minutes north to a new city - where we won’t know anyone and there are far fewer expats.
    I find myself living with a low level anxiety daily. And that’s not how I want to live my life!
    I’m also an artist - and I want to create my own style and sell my work internationally.
    I think I need a therapist! 😉

    • @BeneaththeSurfaceYT
      @BeneaththeSurfaceYT  Месяц назад

      Support is always good! Good luck. I know you will do great. :)

  • @emilycorbin785
    @emilycorbin785 Месяц назад +2

    I loved everything about this! Many people will be able to relate to the trap of fearful thoughts and overthinking, myself included. Thank you for sharing!

  • @wendywilson-fall3230
    @wendywilson-fall3230 Месяц назад +3

    Bravo! I can relate. I travel a lot, and when I was young I didn't mind being by myself. After years of being married, after my divorce I have had to re-learn how to 'play' and to be by myself. Your reflections were encouraging.

    • @BeneaththeSurfaceYT
      @BeneaththeSurfaceYT  Месяц назад

      Great to hear. Yes, it is indeed a re-learning process as we age. Best of luck and thanks for your support! 🙏😁

  • @leonardolopez4950
    @leonardolopez4950 Месяц назад +1

    All of your videos are great but you seem way more genuine and sincere in this one 😊

  • @janastribe
    @janastribe Месяц назад +1

    I follow you Nath and Cecilia since last year from the portugal experience. you are an amazing family, incredibly gifted in different ways. we are almost the same age and can relate with the fear to step out the confort zone. please keep up sharing, it is very inspiring.😊

  • @deana4793
    @deana4793 Месяц назад +6

    I absolutely love your videos! ❤

  • @ailsawalker7896
    @ailsawalker7896 Месяц назад

    Hi, I have never commented on your channel before….but here goes.
    I am a single female in my late 50’s who took a leap of faith six years ago moving permanently to the Auvergne, (France) leaving Scotland, my friends & family behind. I had had enough of “conforming” & needed to prove to myself that I could go it alone & live in another country. I was relatively comfortable speaking French ( I would NOT have made the commitment had I not had some grasp of the language)
    Life has had its challenges but I have never once regretted my decision. My dogs have opened new horizons for me. Thanks to them, on my dog walks I have made new friends ( French, Dutch & British) I have also had work carried out by French locals which has in turn only served to enhance my experience here. Like your wife, I am not at all comfortable with driving around French cities….but the life I lead now is way more fulfilling on account of the new friendships I have made, the lifestyle & what I have managed to achieve over the past few years. Long may it continue……🤞😬

  • @frenchmakoti
    @frenchmakoti Месяц назад +2

    Ohhh mannn!! I needed this message! Let me get out there right now! Brilliant video🎉 Merci🙏🏾

    • @BeneaththeSurfaceYT
      @BeneaththeSurfaceYT  Месяц назад +1

      So great to hear! Go get 'em!! Haha. Merci à toi. 🙏😁

  • @dgroenewald3257
    @dgroenewald3257 Месяц назад +1

    Thank you for this video. It definitely resonated with me. Excellent content. Good luck with the journey!

  • @LaFrenchie
    @LaFrenchie Месяц назад +1

    This was wonderful, and yes , it felt very authentic, genuine and vulnerable . I have the same issue and have lived in many different countries. And in each new country I live, it's like starting the process all over again. Yet, every time, I grow and that's a great feeling.

    • @BeneaththeSurfaceYT
      @BeneaththeSurfaceYT  Месяц назад +1

      That is awesome! Love hearing that. Thank you so much for your support. 🙏😁

  • @JoJo-vz5uy
    @JoJo-vz5uy Месяц назад +1

    I’m really done with the US too. I’m born and raised in beautiful Transylvania and cannot wait to move back!

    • @BeneaththeSurfaceYT
      @BeneaththeSurfaceYT  Месяц назад +1

      Do it! 💪 Best of luck and thanks for watching. 🙏😁

  • @Daneiladams555
    @Daneiladams555 Месяц назад +1

    ive recently become a painter, and trying new things and taking risks are needed, and many of them are successful, lots of learning from this. taking risks is where its at

  • @AmericaninFranceFinance
    @AmericaninFranceFinance Месяц назад +3

    Oh, I loved it "this way"! I could feel the unscripted version let out the more authentic version - thanks for sharing your true self with us despite the risk. :) It inspired me to book my next solo trip I'd been putting off (for some intangible "it's more comfortable at home" feeling)... so Barcelona, here I come! :)

    • @BeneaththeSurfaceYT
      @BeneaththeSurfaceYT  Месяц назад +1

      Nice! Love it! Have a great time. And thanks so much for your support. 🙏😁

  • @debbiegordon7684
    @debbiegordon7684 Месяц назад +2

    What an awesome video, it truly resonated with me, thank you for putting yourself out there and sharing, I know it must have been very difficult. I am the lone semi-extrovert in my family of introverts and your personality reminds me so much of my husband's. He is 65 and struggles with a lot of the same issues, he would prefer to stay at home and not bother...but we're making progress as you did. This Thursday he is supposed to go to a local men's group, fingers crossed he enjoys it and keeps going. I look forward to watching more of your videos. Good luck on finding your happiness! :)

    • @BeneaththeSurfaceYT
      @BeneaththeSurfaceYT  Месяц назад

      Thank you! I’m sure it will go great for him. I’ll send out some good vibes. So appreciate your support! 🙏😁

  • @brendaoquin
    @brendaoquin Месяц назад +1

    Wow, this could not have come at a better time. I feel stuck, dissatisfied, and want to have fun. But do what? Where? Loved this so much! Thank you.

    • @BeneaththeSurfaceYT
      @BeneaththeSurfaceYT  Месяц назад

      And thank you! Get creative. Make a list of things you would love to do. Pick the top one. Let that passion drive it. Sit with the feelings that come up. Explore it (if you don't mind me giving you ideas...). Perhaps something with a friend for support? That can be helpful. In any case, thank you for watching and for your support. 🙏😁

  • @TaniaKitchen-o4s
    @TaniaKitchen-o4s Месяц назад +1

    50 year old single Australian female here. As I get older I’m looking through life through two lenses after years of fear. 1. What is the worst that can happen. 2. Will this matter 12 months from now and finally say YES to more things. I’ve finally realised after years of fear I’m finally entering into the era of embracing life and just bloody doing it. Bravo Josh!

  • @ld7876
    @ld7876 Месяц назад +2

    I really enjoyed your video. We're all imperfect humans. We all need to laugh at ourselves, love ourselves, and forgive ourselves for our beautiful imperfections.

  • @rowandowland1391
    @rowandowland1391 Месяц назад

    Having also moved to Europe in my 60s I can appreciate the isolation you can experience. In Australia things were much easier, the language of course helps. Here in Europe where language is a barrier to making connections I have found hiking, cycling and garden shows a wonderful way to connect with people who share common interests. I don't seek anything more than a simple connection, a hello, and have a nice day is enough for me. As my partner says 'just get out there'

  • @carlafini2527
    @carlafini2527 Месяц назад +2

    I really enjoy your content. It nudges me to take more chances and realize that there is so much to learn and do at any time in your life. Just continue to challenge yourself, as hard as it may seem. Thank you!

  • @nmcclanahan969
    @nmcclanahan969 Месяц назад +2

    First thing, thank you for the exquisite choice of music! And congrats on your spontaneity, you did really well without a script! I can relate a lot to having this inner fear that many times blocks me. I used to be more fearless when I was younger. I'm more cautious now. I'd like to think it's my life experience teaching me that it's not always a good thing to jump with my head forward into everything that crosses my mind or my heart. Adjusting to a new culture is difficult and it takes time. It's funny how much we are stuck in our ways of doing things and how difficult it can be to unlearn and relearn other ways of doing things. As always, you've given me a lot of food for thought.

    • @BeneaththeSurfaceYT
      @BeneaththeSurfaceYT  Месяц назад

      So true that we get stuck as we get older, and it’s on us to get unstuck. That’s part of the growth process. Thank you so much for sharing your thoughts and for your support. 🙏😁

  • @karlie.86
    @karlie.86 Месяц назад +1

    Your content is on fire lately! (but it has always been pleasant to watch)

  • @stuartoconnor538
    @stuartoconnor538 Месяц назад +2

    Another amazing video, very helpful and enjoyable.

  • @hodaradwan8366
    @hodaradwan8366 Месяц назад +1

    I love your videos your a fantastic teacher and story teller . Your extremely honest and honorable .

  • @TomScryleus
    @TomScryleus Месяц назад +3

    Great video! Im 42 and I recognize that feeling of unrisky life.
    Also so funny you mentioned the drone. I just bought the dji neo, and its always a scary experience (but so much fun).
    Ps. Your youtube skills are excellent (from youtuber to youtuber)

    • @BeneaththeSurfaceYT
      @BeneaththeSurfaceYT  Месяц назад

      You can do it! 😁 Thank you so much, and wishing you all the best with your channel. 🙏

    • @TomScryleus
      @TomScryleus Месяц назад +1

      @@BeneaththeSurfaceYTyou too

  • @LockerRichieRich
    @LockerRichieRich 23 дня назад +1

    Yes, I really like this freestyle side of you. The openness and vulnerability is like one soul is speaking to another. It inspires me to not over think stuff which usually will usher in fear. I was also thinking…It’s your scripted versions that brought you to this place. Both belong in your toolbox. Keep up the good work, you guys are so great… Put it on a T-shirt “Sport Mode All The Way”Thanks, Lisa

  • @glony01
    @glony01 Месяц назад +1

    thank you for sharing … being vulnerable is not easy.
    i took the biggest risk of my life by selling everything that was stable and moving to another country. i’m in now country #2 and will be moving to country #3 by end of the year.
    although i lost all my savings… i am somehow surviving without needing to move back.
    my sense of freedom is more important to me than having house or a car (they seem more like chain ⛓️‍💥 & balls)
    There are days where it’s lonely bc i feel many don’t understand.. but i get over it and become grateful that i’m living life and not stuck in an office wondering about life elsewhere 😌🙏

    • @BeneaththeSurfaceYT
      @BeneaththeSurfaceYT  Месяц назад +1

      Sounds perfect! Good for you! Thanks for watching. 🙏😁

  • @kirstenjohnston4259
    @kirstenjohnston4259 Месяц назад +1

    I have always loved watching your videos but I knew something was different within 30 seconds of you speaking! I couldn't place what it was until you explained it, but wow, this video was simply that much more incredible! I agree with so many of the comments that have been posted, but I think the main thing is that you are a natural storyteller, who draws the audience IN. Your voice, cadence, natural pauses, etc made it not only easy to listen to you, but thoroughly enjoyable. I love this format - hope you keep it up! Also, your equation - brilliant!!!

    • @BeneaththeSurfaceYT
      @BeneaththeSurfaceYT  Месяц назад

      Wow, thank you so much! What a lovely comment. Truly appreciate it. 🙏😁

  • @MoniqueDiCarlo
    @MoniqueDiCarlo Месяц назад +1

    Much better! You appeared much more approachable and kinder than in your previous vids. Fear and anxiousness can make a person very rigid, stiff, and maybe even cold. The film maker in you probably wants to work on a script, scenes, structure etc. But here you want to share your life and life is the opposite of a script. As I’m working on the preparation of a RUclips channel these are some of the things I’m working on. It’s important to continue to just enjoy it all.

    • @BeneaththeSurfaceYT
      @BeneaththeSurfaceYT  Месяц назад

      Thank you, Monique, really appreciate your words. Best of luck with your channel. What will you be covering?

  • @virsanib
    @virsanib Месяц назад +1

    Hey, qué vídeo tan interesante! Admiro vuestra iniciativa de salir de vuestra zona de confort y atreveros a vivir en Europa!
    Me ha recordado mucho la decisión que tomé hace algo más de un año de venir a vivir al norte de Italia desde España, nada más jubilarme. Al igual que vosotros, vendí mi casa y me deshice de la gran mayoría de mis cosas materiales. Fue una decisión muy meditada pero no exenta de riesgo, miedos, imprevistos, porque todo eso lo hice sola (bueno, con mi gata) pero hablando con la gente, aprendiendo el idioma, viviendo en una pequeña comunidad en la que la gente es abierta y solidaria me ha abierto muchas puertas y me ha permitido la integración que anhelaba. Y estoy muy orgullosa de las dificultades vividas porque he podido comprobar mi propia transformación hacia un estado de satisfacción. Estoy segura de que me encontraré otros miles de desafíos, pero estoy lista para resolverlos.
    Muchas gracias por tu sinceridad! Adelante! Gracias!

    • @BeneaththeSurfaceYT
      @BeneaththeSurfaceYT  Месяц назад +1

      Muy buena tu historia. Mil gracias y toda la suerte para vos! 🙏😁

  • @dwighthyde
    @dwighthyde Месяц назад

    Love this! Thanks for sharing.

  • @LifewithErnee
    @LifewithErnee Месяц назад +1

    Great content and format. Teaches me to keep working at getting out of my comfort zone and really live. Thank you

  • @annareggio2451
    @annareggio2451 Месяц назад

    Love all of your videos. Both old and new formats.

  • @yvevela7822
    @yvevela7822 Месяц назад

    Very interesting video, had to think while you were explaining and I learn. Thank you.

  • @pastorita911
    @pastorita911 Месяц назад +2

    I loved it .. gracias por todo lo que compartes, tú y tu esposa son una inspiración para mí .. 😊🥰

  • @ohnaspangenberg4271
    @ohnaspangenberg4271 Месяц назад +1

    Well done - enjoyed the video!!

  • @honeyaddisababa
    @honeyaddisababa 22 дня назад +1

    Day by day when I see your content I enjoyed so much and learn a lot thanks for the best content

  • @KimberlieOtt
    @KimberlieOtt Месяц назад +1

    It was beautifully authentic, you did great!

  • @user-jp4sc7iy6p
    @user-jp4sc7iy6p Месяц назад +5

    This resonated with me very much. I’m a retired empty nester who moved back into an urban area and I’m challenging myself getting involved with activism and arts classes. It can be intimidating and frustrating. I just say to myself, just try it, what do you have to lose?

    • @BeneaththeSurfaceYT
      @BeneaththeSurfaceYT  Месяц назад +3

      That mindset can indeed help. Treating it as an experiment, giving it a chance and seeing what happens! So much can be learned, and it will always (guaranteed) be so different than what you thought... Good luck!

  • @helenwilcox2338
    @helenwilcox2338 Месяц назад

    I really enjoyed this new format (and the subject matter). It provided a warmth that was well-suited to the topic. Thank you for sharing your insights!

  • @AngeliqueMJS
    @AngeliqueMJS Месяц назад +1

    Love and totally get your nifty formula!! You’ve articulated exactly how my recent big changes happened and ones in the past. Very recently moved to a new city across the country and left a long term relationship that unfortunately had completed its life cycle. Thank you for sharing your thoughts around change/risk/possibility 🙏 You really touched me in this video because I could see your natural personality expressing itself. While your ‘scripted’ videos were intelligent, this has much more depth. It has an aliveness and warmth to it that is very endearing. So, please continue! You have lots of welcoming support for it here!

    • @BeneaththeSurfaceYT
      @BeneaththeSurfaceYT  Месяц назад

      Such lovely words. Thanks you so so much! I am moved by your comment. 🙏❤️

  • @ambientlife2271
    @ambientlife2271 Месяц назад +1

    We are about to move from Australia to New Zealand and your videos were a big motivator in making the decision (especially the one in which you were talking about how you were done with the US. ) I too am European born and eventually want to end up back there and I see the move to New Zealand as a stepping stone. Thank you so much for sharing your vulnerability and I do like your formula 🙂

    • @BeneaththeSurfaceYT
      @BeneaththeSurfaceYT  Месяц назад +1

      Thank you so much and best of luck with your own adventure! 🙏😁

  • @guspadilla9191
    @guspadilla9191 Месяц назад +1

    This is your best video! Thanks for sharing & keep up the good work!

  • @lifeinthetreehouse
    @lifeinthetreehouse Месяц назад +1

    Love the realness of this video. Awesome!

  • @jjdicarloutube
    @jjdicarloutube Месяц назад

    Always enjoy your content. I have a saying - go towards what scares you. I’m not an adrenaline junkie but I learned as a small child the regret of not doing something because I was too scared to do it. There is something very fulfilling about pushing past fear and coming out on the other side. You do it over and over and you eventually realize this isn’t so bad. I’ll try a quick story - I used to be in sales. Day 1 in the field cold calling and I was crippled with fear. And I hated that. As I sat in my car trying to muster the courage to go into an office building, I decided to trick myself. I told myself over and over, I’ve done this a million times. Done it so much I was bored of it. When I finally got out of my car, I did my best to do a casual stroll, leaned against the wall of the elevator as if I was headed back to work after a lunch break, sauntered casually into the first office, then made my first call. And it wasn’t so bad. I told myself I’d do this all day and get past it. And I did. As you’re sitting at a cafe or out and about in public, do a little acting. What does a person look like who does this routinely? How do they walk? How do they sit? And those who don’t give a shit about getting things wrong - how do they speak? And so on … it worked for me … You’re an observant guy. On your best cafe visit, do some copying and mimicking. And keep the content coming. We love you and your journey. And bottom line, you’ve got Cecillia. With her, all things are possibles.

  • @GreenWitch1
    @GreenWitch1 Месяц назад +2

    I guess I don’t have those feelings. Ive moved around a lot. I moved to Hawaii 6 years ago & forced myself to come back to Florida a few months ago to finish the renovation on my Airstream so I can move past it. Ive never been anywhere I don’t speak the language, so I can’t relate (unless moving to Miami counts). Good on you for continually challenging yourself to get out of your comfort zone!!

  • @K_B_H_
    @K_B_H_ Месяц назад +1

    The yellow flowers are rapeseed plants which is what canola oil is made from. I love seeing fields of them. Stay trying, trying is good.

    • @BeneaththeSurfaceYT
      @BeneaththeSurfaceYT  Месяц назад

      Thank you. 🙏 And yeah, I've come to learn that. Here you see it as colza, which I'd never seen before (all mayonnaise products use it, which drives us nuts because we love the true olive oil version, so much tastier!).