Roy Keane, Jamie Carragher and Gareth Southgate discuss England's loss to Italy at Euro 2012. Keane criticises Gerrard so Carragher tries to defend him.
Onmysheet yeah true, they normally shy away from that subject, but it was now rare to find top quality playmaker (except rooney) in the ENGLISH premier league, thats embarrassing
@@notreal1477 you make your own luck and we made ours by playing on the front foot and dominating. You can’t complain about how you lose when you have four times fewer efforts at goal than the opposition. If we’re gonna be reductive and boil it purely down to refereeing decisions, what about the fact the free kick they scored was never a foul and that Kane should’ve had a pen in normal times? The salty reaction from the wider football world is very revealing
Southgate was easily the most succinct and knowledgable, not to mention sensible, of these three pundits. I'm starting to think he might actually do a decent job of the England job. Dropping Joe Hart is a fine start.
when i was a youngster in the mid 90's i was playing football at a decent school level and for other teams. But the coaching back then was terrible.. and i knew it even back then. All the coaches looked for in players was strength and pace. all they wanted was the players to run down the wing and cross the ball. no imagination, no skill. just 100% focus on pace and strength. İ would always attempt back heals and flicks but each time i was told to stop. İ was even taken off the field once for doing a successful back heal becuase ı had been warned not to. skill and technical ability was coached out of young players in favour of strength and pace. so it doesnt surprise me that we are miles behind other nations regarding skill and technique.
As we have seen the England team over the years, 95% of the players just play with aggression with no technique. (Gerrard, (Lampard), (Beckham), (Scholes), even Heskey. The only skilful players have been Rooney and Owen.
So weird watching this in 2020, when the guy to the left is the funniest pundit in the world, the guy in the middle probably the best (along with Gary Neville) and the man on the right is the England manager and has brought them to two semifinals😂
The weakest german team in decades though north Macedonia beat them too potentially Gareth will get us into the final without playing against a decent team
@@kco212 leave off… “worst German side in years” that a week before beat Portugal 4-2(could have been 7). Can say the same nonsense that your saying about any team but you still have to beat them.
@Mo Luther He’s not a great manager England only beat Croatia because they’re old now. And England aren’t good enough to beat Scotland And England only won the group cause it was an easy group and they’ve only scored 2 goals (and Kane isn’t scoring). And England only beat Germany because it’s the weakest Germany side. And Ukraine were rubbish and that’s why England got past them. And Denmark were robbed even though England had more possession, more shots, more shots on target and were fouled more. Or …Gareth Southgate actually knows what he’s doing and is working to that plan.
@@emilymcplugger Ah yes,two semi finals and one final,but he's not a great manager Please name 5 England managers who have done better than him,from all time..
@Plastic Iron The third Er …I can’t. That’s my point. Gareth Southgate has now won more knockout games at major tournaments than any other England manager. More than Sven Glenn Bobby Graham Terry Kevin Steve Fabio Roy Sam Don And Ron. People can come up with excuses for getting further but he still is the first England manager to get England to the Euro championship final. We appear to be the only country in the world to take pleasure from putting our team down when they make it far in a competition.
Southgate has massively improved the side whether people like it or not. No one expects England to even do well in tournaments these days, but so far that is 3 semi finals in 3 years, 2 for major competitions (not sure if nations league counts). People will complain about the teams they faced also, but England were crashing out in the round of 16 to the likes of Iceland and I'm pretty sure that the likes of Colombia, Sweden, Croatia (whom beat England), Germany and maybe even Ukraine are all better teams.
@@pena1197 So true. Finally someone talking sense. I have been watching these videos again to remind myself how bad if was. I think that is why that song became so popular as that first line: "Looking back on when we first met. I cannot escape and I cannot forget" rings true to every England fan!
@@carlybishop6160 Not to mention there was a point that England couldnt even qualify for a tournament (Euros 2008), then losing in the first round after group stages (euro 2012) and the same after in 2016 to Iceland. In the world cup it's been the same story also, knocked out in the first round after group stages (2010), finished bottom of the group stages in 2014 (where a finished Italy, not the best of Uruguayian teams and minnows Costa Rica finished above England). Notice how it's been the same story over and over again right up until Southgate got appointed, his first major tournament (Semi finals in the 2018 world cup - massive improvement already), 3rd place in the Nations League (the pattern of consistency starting to form - though can't break that semi final deadlock and in fact a semi finals curse is beginning to form as opposed to a group stage curse or a round of 16 curse lol), and now 2nd place in the Euros, first finals in 55 years with countless of different managers not being able to even once get into a final within that long timeframe. Every tourney so far there's literally been an improvement - not a step sideways or step back; WC2018: 4th, Nations League: 3rd, Euro 2020: 2nd. Was the closest to winning it aswell, the fact it went to penalties meant that the game wasn't decided by a result but by a 50/50 lottery chance in penalties, shows how far England have come through.
Watching this after England just beat Denmark. Just blown away by the difference in the feelings towards the national team. Gareth Southgate has drastically changed the culture and thinking around English football and the national team. Thoughtful in his considerations about his own team's strengths and weaknesses, as well as smart tactical and personnel decisions- which has led to England being a genuinely competitive and courageous team. He's led with such humility, thoughtfulness, compassion and boldness and established a joy playing for England not rooted arrogance and hostility towards others which is returned with a fierce loyalty from the players- dude's been incredible.
I'm curious how you feel today going into the World Cup next? Still think Southgate has changed the culture? I can't wait to see Harry Maguire slipping over every match until we get knocked out by Switzerland or Cameroon.
He still has changed the culture. Although, the quality of his coaching and quality of the players is somewhat questionable. Watching them against Germany was revealing when comparing them with Brazil, Argentina and France. Not knowing the best team and also starting players who aren't in form
It's why, despite feeling we need better, I just can't hate Gareth Southgate. He's rebuilt my faith and enjoyment watching England and I can't thank him enougu
+AnderHerrera21 He talks exactly the same. If you're British, you should be able to understand 90% of what he says no matter what part of the UK you're from.
@King FuckFace yeah I'm still proud of what we did that summer and the amount of buzz it created was unreal but to comment that we are reaping our rewards is stupid
Funny how everything comes around, and what happened then has happened now in 2024 Except Southgate is at the helm. Hopefully we improve in this tournament I really hope we do.
The possession was more a choice than anything else. Parking the bus instead of being unable to retain the ball. However I agree it needs to improve. We have technical players coming through now. No excuses
Roy talking about England like he was some captain fantastic player for Ireland. Funny he didn't mention about himself walking out of his nation when we needed him, before a major tournament started.
9 years later from sitting in that chair, Southgate is about to lead England in a European Championship semi final at Wembley. And got England to a World Cup semi final.
@@rooneye Its embarrassing. I've heard people this week on phone ins still not having him and saying England haven't played anyone. And these are England fans ffs.
Euro 2012 wasn’t that bad compared to 2014 and 2016. Wow 2018 the man sitting in that studio well done Gareth you proved me wrong! Go again Euro 2020... Wembley! BRING IT HOME! 🏴🦁🦁🦁
Embarrassing yes but Ireland aren't even a strong footballing nation as England. It's not our number 1 sport. England have had high expectations on their backs yet they have underperformed most of the time.
You're surely not comparing Ireland to England in terms of football? England has a huge world acclaimed league, invest hundreds of millions in football and a huge catchment population. Ireland has around five million people and rugby is by far the most popular sport. Ireland qualifying for and being competitive in past world cups and European championships was really the pinnacle of expectations for Ireland. It's not Roy Keane who is saying England have all the best players and are going to win the euros with ease
@seanq5223 so Keane can just bitch about England without any comeback? The population thing is so pathetic - you don't hear English people playing the population card when they lose at cricket to India - a country with 26 times as many people as England. Is there no Rugby played in England? If the Irish Love Rugby so much, then how come they've only won four grand slams and lost more games than they've won.
One game. Remember how close Italy were to losing to Austria. I think the pressure got too much. But look at their games leading up to. It just looks such a different England than ever befoee
@@carlybishop6160 "how close" was that? A Marko Arnautovic "goal" which was miles offside? Enough with those narratives, Italy had the best chances in this game but somehow because Austria were better for 20-25 minutes out of 120, the perception is that Italy were close to losing. As for England it's too easy to say it was "just one game" when that game happened to be the first time they were coming up against a technically superior opponent. The same would have happened earlier had the drawn not allowed them to avoid France, Spain and Belgium.
@@oldskoolmusicnostalgia England can keep the ball when they want to. I think England were lured into a false sense of control, that despite Italy turning up the heat, they could just keep defending and see out the game. In extra time when England had composed themselves slightly, they found themselves to be a bit more dominant on the ball. England are a side that can dominate possession; but you need the right players on the pitch and a more attacking mentality. Had the game remained 0-0 for a longer period I think England would've had more of the ball.
Southgate actually knows what he’s doing. Anyone who thinks that getting to the semifinals in 2018 was a fluke is dead wrong. Roll on Euro 2021. ITS COMING HOME 🏴
@King FuckFace We lost because we got tactically exposed and had no creative midfielder to dictate the play. Nowadays we do, it's just about how solid we can be at the back. We won't win the tournament, but we'll be better equipped to face the bigger teams
@King FuckFace i'm talking about from the 2018 world cup to now. Players such as Maddison, Grealish, Foden etc. are all better and more creative players than the likes of Lingard and Alli
The thing is, he didn't have a very good squad selection available to him for 2018, but still he picked the best he had. I don't think Mclaren, Capello and Hodgson did the same.
Watching this after England beat Croatia 1-0 in the Euros 2020. If I could tell my younger self 2 things it would be; 1) buy loads of crypto 2) trust in Gareth
Back then, maybe. But not now. For starters we've had 4 Premier League teams in the Champions League final for 3 of the last 4 years. We've had world class managers tell the public that the Prem is the toughest league to compete in. It's the most funded league in Europe also.
think of it foden and mounty and saka watching this coming thru imagine the culture shifte gareth saw it even the we were always gonna be disappointed until the next generation came thru and technique was higher on the coaching list
So interesting to listen to Southgate in this. This is after the plan he brought out with the FA and the year before he started with the U21s and helped developed the English DNA which is now used at every level of coaching in this country. All of which tackles those issues. It is almost like when he says: "Not in 2 years time", he means: I have a plan which I am working on but I will need about 6 years for you to even start seeing any results.
I reckon he probably knew about unfit, average and overrated players being picked for the national team by the England managers at the time due to not having many good English players to pick from. As well as being much more careful with his squad selection, he has helped develop better English footballers, and you can see how they played much better under him.
Well done to England u21s for winning world cup recently now if they can move on to senior side but I also say more English players in your top 5 clubs is a must to compete in champions league too many foreigners for me
Game awareness isn't something that can be tought to 6 or 7 year olds, that isn't the solution at all, game awareness is something that comes with players analyzing their own games and styles.
Well its easy being a pundit m8 you can literally say what you like but yeah southgate has done a good job with England overall I dont think we will win the euros tho m8? 😁😁
keane "going down with cramp after an hour shows where the players are at... MENTALLY". Is keane aware that cramp isn't a mental condition? It's the opposite You can be well up for it, raring to go, full of energy, but if your muscle involuntarily cramps up then you're done. It's not like you can think positively and the cramp will magically disappear.
Its 2021 and England against Italy in the final had less possession with 35%, less shots with 6 and shots on target with 2. Interesting way to look at things from another perspective. One would argue there hasn't been any progress.
Some bloke had a whole conspiracy about southgate's pragmatic style and it's frustrating me cos I forgot what he said and I can't find his comment🤣. Something to do with us conceding a goal and falling apart in the big games idk.
Stop being arrogant. Recognise that other players from other countries can kick ball. Relax and in so doing give the young people playing a chance to relax and give their best. I've seen some good players in recent years but they never seem to enjoy playing the game.
Looking back now it never occurred to me at the time just how poor the group of players were back then, most of the players with quality were way past their prime
And overrated too. Current crop of England players are far more comfortable on the ball and technically superior to supposed “golden generation” - That generation used to play hot potato with the football and looked petrified to be in possession of it and couldn’t wait to get rid of it. The current England side would smoke them, both technically and mentally. The Golden Generation was bullshit. Overhyped big names that used to get their arses handed to them whenever they met a good side. Put it this way, you never saw the likes of Barca or Real clamouring to sign these supposed superstars did you? - They were only (over)rated in England, not anywhere else.
They were piss poor because, the only good players available at the time were Rooney, Gerrard, Lampard, John Terry and Ashley Cole and they were past their best, also Rooney was a striker and couldn't score at a world cup until 2014.
Has to bee a foreigner cap on the Premier League, can see a time when there are no English players playing in the Prem. We got one of the best most exciting leagues but only because of the best foreign players at the big clubs. Young English players can hardly get a look in. How many English players are in Seria A or La Liga?
just because you get rid of a foreign player like aguero or pogba doesnt mean an english player is now gonna be as good as them. a foreigner cap will only reduce the quality of the league, wont make your national team any better. the cream will always rise to the top, look at players like rashford or sterling. foreign players didnt stop them from getting into their teams' starting 11 because they're talented.
It might force english teams to develop young players instead?. Look at La liga, the top 2 teams earn 80% of the total league revenue. In turn it forces the 'lesser' teams in the league to develop its own talent ie. athletic Bilboa
@@bare1330 Probably, but then as the quantity of English players in the EPL has been declining over time, there has to be a link. England managed to find quite a lot of good players for their teams in the 1990s and early 2000s and there were more English players in the EPL back then.
Well if you pay attention here, he hinted at the plan he is implementing and when he expected to see results. I think he is currently on track with his own personal targets. It’s quite clear that of all the panel here, he is the most rational,considered pundit here and has honestly assessed England’s issues and how to fix them. We are seeing the results of this now
I'm not convinced Southgate is better than Capello or Ericsson - but listening to this he is clearly an intelligent guy who understands the grass roots of English football and realized what needed to be changed
Funny how this has come up in my recommendations now, 2 weeks away from the 2018 World Cup and Gareth Southgate, who is sat here as a pundit is our manager haha!
I don't think Gerrards cramp was anything to do with his mental strength. Keane's talking shite! But typical no one will call him out on it cause they are shit scared of him
@@ForestDa1865 exactly mate he will never make a good manager. he has 0% people skills combined with never thinking he's wrong which is one of the worse combinations you could have in a person
I don’t get how Southgate can get any negativity? He’s such a realistic guy and is a smart England manager, has to have a place at the top or near the top of the English FA (after his managerial career) he’s been a big part of England’s improvement
100% agree with southgate, when he said most creative players in the EPL are mainly foreigners
Finally someone has said it. The BBC pundits have always danced around the subject.
Onmysheet yeah true, they normally shy away from that subject, but it was now rare to find top quality playmaker (except rooney) in the ENGLISH premier league, thats embarrassing
gerrard was creative
he's right
I agree
Carragher nearly had a stroke when Keane called out Gerrard 😂😂
He just set him straight
Overrated?
@@fooli91 Dumbass?
@@postrock3374 gerrard is England's best mid
@@Keenangoal na
“What do England need to do better in major tournaments?”
Southgate: Hold. My fucking. Waistcoat.
Well the answer was start diving🧐 hope Italy score a contentious winning goal, lets see if this "who cares" mentality persists then.
@@notreal1477 you make your own luck and we made ours by playing on the front foot and dominating. You can’t complain about how you lose when you have four times fewer efforts at goal than the opposition. If we’re gonna be reductive and boil it purely down to refereeing decisions, what about the fact the free kick they scored was never a foul and that Kane should’ve had a pen in normal times? The salty reaction from the wider football world is very revealing
@Ben Evans Exactly, just because we are doing well right now!
@@notreal1477 just like the penalty decision they got against us a few years back in a 1-1 draw.
@@notreal1477 Salty tool. Italy have been diving and cheating for years more than any Nation, you plank.
Southgate was easily the most succinct and knowledgable, not to mention sensible, of these three pundits. I'm starting to think he might actually do a decent job of the England job. Dropping Joe Hart is a fine start.
Red Pill Mackerel is it home yet mate?
And Pickford!
Yeah explaining that coaching 7 year olds won't help England in the next 2 years is very insightful 😂
Southgate is an atrocious manager
Terrible Manager.
when i was a youngster in the mid 90's i was playing football at a decent school level and for other teams. But the coaching back then was terrible.. and i knew it even back then. All the coaches looked for in players was strength and pace. all they wanted was the players to run down the wing and cross the ball. no imagination, no skill. just 100% focus on pace and strength. İ would always attempt back heals and flicks but each time i was told to stop. İ was even taken off the field once for doing a successful back heal becuase ı had been warned not to. skill and technical ability was coached out of young players in favour of strength and pace. so it doesnt surprise me that we are miles behind other nations regarding skill and technique.
Were your back heels beneficial to the team in any way lol
thanks for sharing that John
As we have seen the England team over the years, 95% of the players just play with aggression with no technique. (Gerrard, (Lampard), (Beckham), (Scholes), even Heskey. The only skilful players have been Rooney and Owen.
Beckham was also a technical player
Onmysheet nah, scholes had technique, but the players around him didnt, all they did was whip a ball in the box
So weird watching this in 2020, when the guy to the left is the funniest pundit in the world, the guy in the middle probably the best (along with Gary Neville) and the man on the right is the England manager and has brought them to two semifinals😂
Yep. And that studio is now probably the best in the world. Those chairs are the most comfortable in the world.
Two semis?
@@shahee6579 nations league
*3
@MonsterGames now three semi finals 😉
Who’d have thought the guy sitting on the right would help England beat Germany 2-0 in a major tournament
The weakest german team in decades though north Macedonia beat them too potentially Gareth will get us into the final without playing against a decent team
@@kco212 leave off… “worst German side in years” that a week before beat Portugal 4-2(could have been 7). Can say the same nonsense that your saying about any team but you still have to beat them.
@@kco212 weakest German side that trashed Portugal who beat France (if it wasnt for the france penalty which shouldn't of counted)
@@kco212 The weakest team with the likes of Neuer Rudiger Goretzka Kimmich Kroos Muller Gnabry Gosens Gundogan etc... Such a weak side
@@pena1197 He didn’t say weak, he said weakest which is true.
This Gareth Southgate bloke speaks sense. He should be made England manager
@Mo Luther
He’s not a great manager
England only beat Croatia because they’re old now.
And England aren’t good enough to beat Scotland
And England only won the group cause it was an easy group and they’ve only scored 2 goals (and Kane isn’t scoring).
And England only beat Germany because it’s the weakest Germany side.
And Ukraine were rubbish and that’s why England got past them.
And Denmark were robbed even though England had more possession, more shots, more shots on target and were fouled more.
Or …Gareth Southgate actually knows what he’s doing and is working to that plan.
@@emilymcplugger Ah yes,two semi finals and one final,but he's not a great manager
Please
name 5 England managers who have done better than him,from all time..
@Plastic Iron The third
Er …I can’t.
That’s my point.
Gareth Southgate has now won more knockout games at major tournaments than any other England manager.
More than
Sven
Glenn
Bobby
Graham
Terry
Kevin
Steve
Fabio
Roy
Sam
Don
And Ron.
People can come up with excuses for getting further but he still is the first England manager to get England to the Euro championship final.
We appear to be the only country in the world to take pleasure from putting our team down when they make it far in a competition.
@@emilymcplugger ah,I get you now by your 1st comments last point
I think its safe to say in hindsight that he shouldnt ever been made england manager lol
Southgate the G proving himself right 6 years on
King FuckFace we have the best young national team in the world at the moment u mong
Jake and Hes wasting their talent by playing 8 defenders in one match
King FuckFace yep
@@snakehddjj6103 lol no he's not
What cause we made a semi because of the easiest possible route ever?
Keane is 100% right. And I'm English
And so am i
@King FuckFace 😃😃
@King FuckFace yeah, but I wasn't surprised that we got beaten by Croatia.
@King FuckFace why cant fans get excited? Thats what footballs about.
When wales got far in the euros their fans were loving it yet didnt win it
On Gerrard? Lol
That bloke on the far right gonna bring football home in a couple of weeks.
Tommy Robinson?
Don’t get ahead of yourself
Hes gonna go home alright😂
Has it ever been home?
@@F1ukez 😂😂👏🏼
I love Roy Keane, straight talking. Carragher wasn't having his pal Stevie mee criticised lool
2011-2016 was a dark era. Who would have thought Southgate would be potentially leading us to a final
The five years previously wasn't any better either
1998-2016 was a dark era
Southgate has massively improved the side whether people like it or not. No one expects England to even do well in tournaments these days, but so far that is 3 semi finals in 3 years, 2 for major competitions (not sure if nations league counts). People will complain about the teams they faced also, but England were crashing out in the round of 16 to the likes of Iceland and I'm pretty sure that the likes of Colombia, Sweden, Croatia (whom beat England), Germany and maybe even Ukraine are all better teams.
@@pena1197 So true. Finally someone talking sense. I have been watching these videos again to remind myself how bad if was. I think that is why that song became so popular as that first line: "Looking back on when we first met. I cannot escape and I cannot forget" rings true to every England fan!
@@carlybishop6160 Not to mention there was a point that England couldnt even qualify for a tournament (Euros 2008), then losing in the first round after group stages (euro 2012) and the same after in 2016 to Iceland. In the world cup it's been the same story also, knocked out in the first round after group stages (2010), finished bottom of the group stages in 2014 (where a finished Italy, not the best of Uruguayian teams and minnows Costa Rica finished above England). Notice how it's been the same story over and over again right up until Southgate got appointed, his first major tournament (Semi finals in the 2018 world cup - massive improvement already), 3rd place in the Nations League (the pattern of consistency starting to form - though can't break that semi final deadlock and in fact a semi finals curse is beginning to form as opposed to a group stage curse or a round of 16 curse lol), and now 2nd place in the Euros, first finals in 55 years with countless of different managers not being able to even once get into a final within that long timeframe. Every tourney so far there's literally been an improvement - not a step sideways or step back; WC2018: 4th, Nations League: 3rd, Euro 2020: 2nd. Was the closest to winning it aswell, the fact it went to penalties meant that the game wasn't decided by a result but by a 50/50 lottery chance in penalties, shows how far England have come through.
Watching this after England just beat Denmark. Just blown away by the difference in the feelings towards the national team. Gareth Southgate has drastically changed the culture and thinking around English football and the national team. Thoughtful in his considerations about his own team's strengths and weaknesses, as well as smart tactical and personnel decisions- which has led to England being a genuinely competitive and courageous team. He's led with such humility, thoughtfulness, compassion and boldness and established a joy playing for England not rooted arrogance and hostility towards others which is returned with a fierce loyalty from the players- dude's been incredible.
I'm curious how you feel today going into the World Cup next? Still think Southgate has changed the culture? I can't wait to see Harry Maguire slipping over every match until we get knocked out by Switzerland or Cameroon.
He still has changed the culture. Although, the quality of his coaching and quality of the players is somewhat questionable. Watching them against Germany was revealing when comparing them with Brazil, Argentina and France. Not knowing the best team and also starting players who aren't in form
It's why, despite feeling we need better, I just can't hate Gareth Southgate. He's rebuilt my faith and enjoyment watching England and I can't thank him enougu
@@josephkerrigan733 😂😂😂
Idiot.
I thought every englishman hated him? He made england play the most boring fotball in the history of the sport
Fucking hell! looking back, Carragher has improved his English and became more understandable since then
+AnderHerrera21 He talks exactly the same. If you're British, you should be able to understand 90% of what he says no matter what part of the UK you're from.
+Azrael I am but if you compare this to now, he has adapted his accent slightly
***** Perhaps, sounds exactly the same to me.
Carragher talks gibberish.
@@NinetayFour 90% lmao
Weird watching this now that Gareth Southgate is England manager. What a man
@AdmiralOddSock He's alright
@AdmiralOddSock terrible yeah? The people who hire managers know a lot more than you.
@AdmiralOddSock the best England manager in 55 years
@AdmiralOddSock he’s a better manager than than Roy hodgson and Fabio Capello for example
Southgate knew all along. It's coming home lads.
is it fuck,CMON CROATIA!!!!!!!!!
No, it’s not!!! 😂😂😂😂🇭🇷🇭🇷🇭🇷🇭🇷🇭🇷
A Hasnath I agree.
Haha...
coming home early
How amazing this is now. Southgate talking about how he wanted to change things, six years on how he is reaping the rewards
@King FuckFace love the delusion of english football fans
England should've reached the final easily. They would've lost to France anyway but being runner up is a perfect start.
@King FuckFace A perfect start for Southgate's career as manager.
I'm English and I find this comment cringey as hell. Until we win either the euros or the world cup you can't say anything else is a 'reward'
@King FuckFace yeah I'm still proud of what we did that summer and the amount of buzz it created was unreal but to comment that we are reaping our rewards is stupid
Funny how everything comes around, and what happened then has happened now in 2024 Except Southgate is at the helm. Hopefully we improve in this tournament I really hope we do.
well said keane gerrard is the only person who really trys for england without him there shit
They're*. England are shit. I'm English and i think our national team is quite tragic
@AdmiralOddSock Scholes in midfield wouldn't have made a difference
What an appointment southgate has been. By far the best decision the FA have ever made.
Well this aged well.😭
This aged very well 😂
Getting all these past critical videos about England's performances ever since England drew with Denmark 😂.
36% possession
And out on Penalties to Italy.
Identical to tonight’s final loss.
Its always on penaltys for us 🤦🏾♂️
The possession was more a choice than anything else. Parking the bus instead of being unable to retain the ball. However I agree it needs to improve. We have technical players coming through now. No excuses
Yes, just happened to have met Italy later this time. The evisceration would have happened earlier were it not for a favourable draw.
@@oldskoolmusicnostalgia I mean we went to ET vs them and the only goal they scored was a set piece so…
@@oldskoolmusicnostalgia difference being that England had the players to play much better in 2020 yet most of them were on the bench.
Southgate looks like the goblin from Harry Potter and the deathly hallows.
We’ve just beat Denmark 2-1 😎
You just lost 🇮🇹😎
@@nein236 touché
@@nein236 unnecessary man
You’ve just drew to Denmark 1-1 😊
@@nein236how was the 2022 World Cup xx
And look at Southgate now 🤴🏻 it’s coming home!
England will beat Croatia on pens and lose to France 3-1.
I predict these things!
No, it’s not.
Not even in the final. And you’ll finish fourth behind Belgium.
LoL
its a shame he doewnt know the best formation to get the best outof the players in particular Kane and Sterling
@@predictivetextisforaunts nob
Roy talking about England like he was some captain fantastic player for Ireland. Funny he didn't mention about himself walking out of his nation when we needed him, before a major tournament started.
Amazing watching this now! Come on Gareth! Bring it home!!!!
7 years on and Southgate has become that which he seeks to destroy
Lol
9 years later from sitting in that chair, Southgate is about to lead England in a European Championship semi final at Wembley. And got England to a World Cup semi final.
And yet the idiots in them comments are STILL disrespecting the man. England fans are fucking IDIOTS.
@@rooneye Its embarrassing. I've heard people this week on phone ins still not having him and saying England haven't played anyone. And these are England fans ffs.
Weird seeing 4 people sat so close.
Funny watching this now when we're having exactly the same problems with Southgate as manager.
that Gareth Southgate spoke well. wonder what he's up to these days?
First Englishman to screw up a penalty shoot out as a player and a manger
Gerrard made it in the official Euro 2012 team of the tournament so he must have done something right.
Not according to UEFA and their team of the tournament. Look it up for yourself.
owendagreat1 we won 2 games out of the 4 and they weren’t great at all, no idea how gerrard got in that team
Jacob Pickerin he was the only one trying
@@owendagreat1 Gerard was one of the reasons why England had not achieved. He was not good enough.
@@robertpirsig5011 Yeah neither was scholes or rooney
This is so weird watching now when Carragher and keane are the main lads on sky now
I really like Roy talks sentence all the time
Euro 2012 wasn’t that bad compared to 2014 and 2016. Wow 2018 the man sitting in that studio well done Gareth you proved me wrong! Go again Euro 2020... Wembley!
BRING IT HOME! 🏴🦁🦁🦁
*2021, outdated
Phil Foden was 11 at this time and I was still a teenager!
Just been recommended this after England's 1-1 draw with Denmark in euro 24 😂😂. I kidd you not
this video was southgate's cover letter for the england job
What does Keane have to say about Ireland losing to Armenia, Luxembourg and Cyprus?
Embarrassing yes but Ireland aren't even a strong footballing nation as England. It's not our number 1 sport. England have had high expectations on their backs yet they have underperformed most of the time.
You're surely not comparing Ireland to England in terms of football? England has a huge world acclaimed league, invest hundreds of millions in football and a huge catchment population. Ireland has around five million people and rugby is by far the most popular sport. Ireland qualifying for and being competitive in past world cups and European championships was really the pinnacle of expectations for Ireland. It's not Roy Keane who is saying England have all the best players and are going to win the euros with ease
@seanq5223 so Keane can just bitch about England without any comeback? The population thing is so pathetic - you don't hear English people playing the population card when they lose at cricket to India - a country with 26 times as many people as England. Is there no Rugby played in England? If the Irish Love Rugby so much, then how come they've only won four grand slams and lost more games than they've won.
Can't believe the fella on the right will take us to the final. Times flies
2:43 nothing has changed in 9 years. Italy kept the ball the same way in Euro 2020 final. Clearly Gareth didn't learn anything
One game. Remember how close Italy were to losing to Austria. I think the pressure got too much. But look at their games leading up to. It just looks such a different England than ever befoee
@@carlybishop6160 "how close" was that? A Marko Arnautovic "goal" which was miles offside? Enough with those narratives, Italy had the best chances in this game but somehow because Austria were better for 20-25 minutes out of 120, the perception is that Italy were close to losing.
As for England it's too easy to say it was "just one game" when that game happened to be the first time they were coming up against a technically superior opponent. The same would have happened earlier had the drawn not allowed them to avoid France, Spain and Belgium.
@@oldskoolmusicnostalgia England can keep the ball when they want to. I think England were lured into a false sense of control, that despite Italy turning up the heat, they could just keep defending and see out the game. In extra time when England had composed themselves slightly, they found themselves to be a bit more dominant on the ball.
England are a side that can dominate possession; but you need the right players on the pitch and a more attacking mentality. Had the game remained 0-0 for a longer period I think England would've had more of the ball.
@@oldskoolmusicnostalgia So Germany and Croatia didn't count?
he doesnt play hes just the manager
Our possession was almost the exact same against Italy in Euro 2020. Ridiculous.
Southgate actually knows what he’s doing. Anyone who thinks that getting to the semifinals in 2018 was a fluke is dead wrong. Roll on Euro 2021. ITS COMING HOME 🏴
Agree
@King FuckFace We lost because we got tactically exposed and had no creative midfielder to dictate the play. Nowadays we do, it's just about how solid we can be at the back. We won't win the tournament, but we'll be better equipped to face the bigger teams
@King FuckFace i'm talking about from the 2018 world cup to now. Players such as Maddison, Grealish, Foden etc. are all better and more creative players than the likes of Lingard and Alli
The thing is, he didn't have a very good squad selection available to him for 2018, but still he picked the best he had. I don't think Mclaren, Capello and Hodgson did the same.
Watching this after England beat Croatia 1-0 in the Euros 2020. If I could tell my younger self 2 things it would be; 1) buy loads of crypto 2) trust in Gareth
Hes right about the media overrating the premier league
Why u saying this now after England have their best squad in years
Back then, maybe. But not now. For starters we've had 4 Premier League teams in the Champions League final for 3 of the last 4 years. We've had world class managers tell the public that the Prem is the toughest league to compete in. It's the most funded league in Europe also.
Someone had to say it, at least Gareth Southgate was completely honest.
SOUTHGATE YOURE THE ONE
Jacob Pickerin you just turn me on
Laurence's Daddy Football's coming home again!
Shaf No, it’s not.
i94Rules you freak
Who’s here after Southgate resigned, and it still didn’t come home
think of it foden and mounty and saka watching this coming thru imagine the culture shifte gareth saw it even the we were always gonna be disappointed until the next generation came thru and technique was higher on the coaching list
So interesting to listen to Southgate in this. This is after the plan he brought out with the FA and the year before he started with the U21s and helped developed the English DNA which is now used at every level of coaching in this country. All of which tackles those issues. It is almost like when he says: "Not in 2 years time", he means: I have a plan which I am working on but I will need about 6 years for you to even start seeing any results.
I reckon he probably knew about unfit, average and overrated players being picked for the national team by the England managers at the time due to not having many good English players to pick from. As well as being much more careful with his squad selection, he has helped develop better English footballers, and you can see how they played much better under him.
And now Gareth is in charge and he stills plays defensively 😂
Yet they play well for him
@@Pdmc-vu5gjaged badly
6 years later its coming home
captain mike topping No. it’s not haha!
@Wawawa considering England have one genuine foreign born player raheem sterling and he is Jamaican, seems to make sense
That fella on the right seems to know his stuff.
He might know how to bring the bastard home if given the chance...
doubt it tbh
@@jaxob_5850 doubt (2x)
Funny how so many people have been recommended this, this close to England's first final in 55 years, with one of those in this video as manager.
Why have I been recommended this after Italy just beat us
0:44 the legend Southgate has us in the semis of the euros
I tell you what Southgate seems to know what he’s talking about … bit of a left field pick but maybe give him a go see how he does?
Now the dude is manager and got England to a Semi Final, not bad.
Cause of the teams they played in the world cup
If you’re not first, you’re last
Well done to England u21s for winning world cup recently now if they can move on to senior side but I also say more English players in your top 5 clubs is a must to compete in champions league too many foreigners for me
Game awareness isn't something that can be tought to 6 or 7 year olds, that isn't the solution at all, game awareness is something that comes with players analyzing their own games and styles.
Used to think southgate was a shit pundit. The guy is a genius. Happy for him.
Well its easy being a pundit m8 you can literally say what you like but yeah southgate has done a good job with England overall I dont think we will win the euros tho m8? 😁😁
keane "going down with cramp after an hour shows where the players are at... MENTALLY".
Is keane aware that cramp isn't a mental condition? It's the opposite You can be well up for it, raring to go, full of energy, but if your muscle involuntarily cramps up then you're done. It's not like you can think positively and the cramp will magically disappear.
I think he was implying that the players faked cramps becoause they were scared to play
here in 2021 and Southgate thoughtful approach is magic
he got cramp just after the hour mark ''roy keane voice''
Gerard Ward lack salt in diet lol
Its 2021 and England against Italy in the final had less possession with 35%, less shots with 6 and shots on target with 2.
Interesting way to look at things from another perspective. One would argue there hasn't been any progress.
Some bloke had a whole conspiracy about southgate's pragmatic style and it's frustrating me cos I forgot what he said and I can't find his comment🤣. Something to do with us conceding a goal and falling apart in the big games idk.
@@safcjoe7062 Southgate is shit. So is England 🤣
Does anyone else notice how ITV was the only network who went to Ukraine and Poland while BBC and the others networks stayed home?
Evident he is capable of managing a team. Look at the way he spoke compared to Carragher and Keane.
This Gareth Southgate guy could be future England manager and Euros finalist
Carragher should come with subtitles,the spittin scouser 😂
Stop being arrogant. Recognise that other players from other countries can kick ball. Relax and in so doing give the young people playing a chance to relax and give their best. I've seen some good players in recent years but they never seem to enjoy playing the game.
Just realised, Carragher was still playing at that point. No wonder he was defending his Liverpool teammate.
as he should lol, he was in the team of the tournament
Looking back now it never occurred to me at the time just how poor the group of players were back then, most of the players with quality were way past their prime
And overrated too. Current crop of England players are far more comfortable on the ball and technically superior to supposed “golden generation” - That generation used to play hot potato with the football and looked petrified to be in possession of it and couldn’t wait to get rid of it. The current England side would smoke them, both technically and mentally. The Golden Generation was bullshit. Overhyped big names that used to get their arses handed to them whenever they met a good side. Put it this way, you never saw the likes of Barca or Real clamouring to sign these supposed superstars did you? - They were only (over)rated in England, not anywhere else.
They were piss poor because, the only good players available at the time were Rooney, Gerrard, Lampard, John Terry and Ashley Cole and they were past their best, also Rooney was a striker and couldn't score at a world cup until 2014.
Who else got this recommended after euro 2020 final😭😓
haha Carragher still talking with that scouser accent. I remember when he started working at Sky he had to have English speaking lessons.
We’re in the final!!!
Has to bee a foreigner cap on the Premier League, can see a time when there are no English players playing in the Prem. We got one of the best most exciting leagues but only because of the best foreign players at the big clubs. Young English players can hardly get a look in. How many English players are in Seria A or La Liga?
just because you get rid of a foreign player like aguero or pogba doesnt mean an english player is now gonna be as good as them. a foreigner cap will only reduce the quality of the league, wont make your national team any better. the cream will always rise to the top, look at players like rashford or sterling. foreign players didnt stop them from getting into their teams' starting 11 because they're talented.
It might force english teams to develop young players instead?.
Look at La liga, the top 2 teams earn 80% of the total league revenue.
In turn it forces the 'lesser' teams in the league to develop its own talent ie. athletic Bilboa
@@66kaisersoza *Bilbao. Lol!
@@bare1330 Probably, but then as the quantity of English players in the EPL has been declining over time, there has to be a link. England managed to find quite a lot of good players for their teams in the 1990s and early 2000s and there were more English players in the EPL back then.
What does mentality have to do with getting a cramp?
What’s the thoughts on Southgate now from England fans? From an Irishman, he seems to have the players backing him and knows how to get a job done
Well if you pay attention here, he hinted at the plan he is implementing and when he expected to see results. I think he is currently on track with his own personal targets.
It’s quite clear that of all the panel here, he is the most rational,considered pundit here and has honestly assessed England’s issues and how to fix them. We are seeing the results of this now
Some people watch cat videos for 10 hours... me I watch Roy Keane commentary
Fast forward and England fans now want Graham Potter at the wheel 😂
England players are typecaste as defenders or forwards etc. Foreign players seem to have the ability to play anywhere with good passing ability.
22grena I beg your pardon
JAMIE! ROY! SHUT UP!
We want to hear what Gareth’s got to say.
It’s amazing that after all this from Gareth he managed England and stifled all creativity
I'm not convinced Southgate is better than Capello or Ericsson - but listening to this he is clearly an intelligent guy who understands the grass roots of English football and realized what needed to be changed
That guy on the right talked some sense. I wonder what happened to him?
0:15 what the actual fuck came out of Carra’s mouth? 😭😭😭😭😭🤣🤣🤣😂😂😂😂
Recommended after a shit show against Iceland...
Keane spot on
That Southgate could do a good job as England manager you know…
Funny how this has come up in my recommendations now, 2 weeks away from the 2018 World Cup and Gareth Southgate, who is sat here as a pundit is our manager haha!
Roy Keane is the man. I can listen to him talk about football all day
Can you imagine Carragher as England manager. 😂 😂 😂 😂
I don't think Gerrards cramp was anything to do with his mental strength. Keane's talking shite! But typical no one will call him out on it cause they are shit scared of him
@@ForestDa1865 exactly mate he will never make a good manager. he has 0% people skills combined with never thinking he's wrong which is one of the worse combinations you could have in a person
Roy Keane great player, but sometimes he goes a little over the edge and is very bias.
Not really if Manchester United or Ireland are poor he hammers them.
I don’t get how Southgate can get any negativity? He’s such a realistic guy and is a smart England manager, has to have a place at the top or near the top of the English FA (after his managerial career) he’s been a big part of England’s improvement
Carragher has come on fair way from this appearance lol.
Does anyone have a translator for Jamie Carragher?
Even a translator would find it hard to understand Carragher.
Says the man who leans out of his car window and spits over a kid now that's embarrassing
am i the only one that pisses myself laughing when Jamie Carragher says "Embarrassing"