The song directly describes the band and their cohesion. There was a time when they could neither with each other nor without each other. They were also on the verge of separation. But they've found a way, that is was true friends do, and it's gotten better than ever.
You are describing the video. The song lyrics have a different message. Why should a song about bonding have the line "With you, I'm alone, too"? The song Haifisch is about the bond of the band.
@@tosa2522 If you don't understand each other and you constantly disagree, then you feel left alone. Then you feel alone in this band. That's what the song says. And Haifisch is not a counterexample, so it's not an argument. It will surely surprise you, because there can also be several songs with similar themes at the same time. Furthermore, you will be surprised that both songs did not come out at the same time. This in turn means that time has passed and situations change.
Lindemann's lyrics usually have nothing to do with the band, and that's also the case with "Ohne Dich". The videos often deliberately convey a different image. The only lyric the band developed together was Rammstein, the rest came exclusively from Lindemann and he often simply wrote down lyrics that had been lying in a drawer for years or had been published in his lyric books. with slight variations. "Without you I can't be, Without you, With you I'm also alone, Without you". It describes an emotionally unfulfilled love that hurts both in the longing and in the closeness that is sought but not emotionally reciprocated.
@@tosa2522 Band problems, toxic love relationship, some say it´s about drug addiction, maybe a bit of everything. There are often different layers and meanings in the lyrics of Lindemann. It´s art and everyone is free to interpret it in their own way.
For me, as a 60-year-old Austrian, this video has nothing to do with mountaineering or relationships. It reminds me of the stories of my late father, who survived the war on 3 fronts for two and a half years from 1942 to 1945. The soldier drags a wounded comrade with him until the goal is reached. Maybe I'm just too old to interpret it differently.
That's the great thing about Till's lyrics, everyone can draw something different out of them, because everyone has had different experiences in their lives, right?
For me this video and song is about almost unachievable dream/purpose in life. The climbing at very fight is really dangerous, and people know the risks before starting it, but they want to achive the highest point anyway. It their dream, they very want to do it at all cost. In depth of the souls, everyone wants to do smth greater than themselves, ro chase the dream, without it people feel like their lifes are not complet. But at the same time reaching to the dream might be very hard, takes a high risk. People, who want to achive the highest point understand, that their dream can cost their lifes or many sufferings from the injuries, but they can't live without trying to be closer to their dream. And in the video, Till is suffering, but in the scene in the tent, Till is chill and confident, so his friends. Instead, they helped him to do the last steps to the dream, where he peasfully died. "Without you I cannot be" - when you have a high purpose, you always think about it and want to achive it. And at the same time, life without it seems to not have purpose and sense, empty. "With you I am alone to" - is about things you must sacrifice for dream. Sometimes it is only time, but in other cases it can be your connections to the closests, isolation, changing you life completely, and as in the video death, high level of risk.
One of my favourite Rammstein songs, and one of my favourite Music Videos of All-Time in general (and I've been collecting them for pretty much forty years).
The song ist about the relationship between the band members of Rammstein and also can be seen as expressing mourning over the loss of a loved person. Rammstein wanted to break up one or the other time and that is why they had even therapy sessions. But they always decided to stay together. For Heitmann (film direktor of this video) , the emotional message in the video is very important; "Ohne Dich" shows unity in the band. Richard said that the most important thing is to stick together, everything else is irrelevant.Therefore Rammstein is one of the few Bands that have managed to play in the same line up and with the same members for almost 30 years since they were founded. The funny thing is that Flake (Keyboarder) still denies that he is a member of Rammstein, because he actually never wanted to be part of Rammstein from the start because the music was too "simple" for him. Till and Richard always wanted to start solo careers. In addition, the Rammstein members constantly argued about every song, every video and every live show, how it could be done better. It actually almost came to a break up with the "Mother" video. Till shot the video alone without really involving the other band members. Rammstein not only had one group therapy with a psychologist over the years, but nevertheless they could never be without each other There were 5 or 6 ideas for this video. Some of the band members wanted to make a video at sea, others wanted to make it in the mountains. Richard wanted to make a video based on Hans Christian Andersen's "The Little Match Girl" because it was the only fairy tale that made him cry, but the idea was rejected.. According to Joern Heitmann (film director), this is the most emotionally engaging video he has ever made with the band. For the video, the band members grew beards, because in the mountains there is no time to shave. Flake was the only one to have an artificial one. During the making of, Till can be seen wearing a shirt which makes fun of Flake and his beard. The climbing scene was shot on one of the climbing walls next to a parking lot, and the band could go as high as they wanted to. The band was accompanied by an experienced climbing team who taught them how to correctly climb the wall. The video was shot at +20 degrees. The snow was artificial, and the snow storm was created with the help of machines. Emanuel Fialik's assistant expressed his concerns about whether any of the band members would get hurt while shooting a video in the middle of the tour. Heitmann claimed that no one would have been able to stop Till from playing the falling scene. The original idea was that Flake would have to carry Till together with Schneider at 3,400 m above sea level, which was physically impossible for him. Richard admits that everyone always fights for their own scene when shooting videos and everyone wants to be able to play a part, so it's hard to work with them on the set.
11:00 - there's a making of video with subtitles if you're interested in how/where it was filmed, more on the concept etc. Its quite a funny behind the scenes video, Flake is grumping about being unable to carry Till like a dead weight 🤣
The video was shot in Kaunertal and on the Pitztal Glacier in Tyrol. The director was Jörn Heitmann, who has already directed the songs "Sonne", "Mutter" and "Amerika", among others.
One of their best songs. My favorite nevertheless is Stirb nicht vor mir, partly in German, partly in English language. Highly recommended for your next comments.
Wolfgang explained it right…“Guten Nachmittag“ sounds strange…whereas „Guten Morgen“ (until 12am) and „Guten Abend“ (from 6pm) is very common. Also very common in the northern part of Germany is „Moin“ which you can say all day long
Things didn't matter to him anymore before he climbed the mountain. But when he died he was with his closest friends. Sometimes an accident is a welcomed thing.
A song that my wife and I listen to very often. Just because of the lyrics! It says so much and yet so little... BTW: The video was shot in Tyrol in Austria. I was already in the Austrian Alps, the view is phenomenal! Unfortunately, I'm afraid of heights and could not everywhere with up. - A small music recommendation from me... try "Null Positiv" - "Independez" or "Kollaps" or "Trauma"... or some other songs from them. Best way are the official videos!
Good to see 🐺 better... This one in my knowledge was soon after they had a break in the band, beautiful video. Great reaction 👋 Location: Kaun Valley and on the Pitz Valley glacier in Tyrol, Austria.(Might have typing issues)
Die Rückkehr des Wolfsmanns! Lasst das Wochenende weitergehen. Good to see you both. For the record, I still blame Wendy Byrde for everything, especially poor Ruth!
great reactions👏👏👏 ..,, what a stunning band ✌ i would like you to visit and react VM from alffy Rev : " Wonderland Indonesia 2 : the sacred nusantara & : Wonderland Indonesia 2 "PERFORMANCE VERSION" by Alffy Rev with All Artist .. its culture-music blended in modern instruments. ** both VM are materpiece , . 🔥🔥🔥 you'll be amaze 💥💥 best regard from Indonesia 🙏🙏🙏
It should be: Good Morning - Guten Morgen Good Afternoon - Guten Mittag Good Evening - Guten Abend Good Night - Guten Nacht Good Day - Guten Tag Enjoy your dinner - Guten Appetit (🤣) ....... according to a Dutchman 😉😎 (learned at school half decade ago 😃)
To my understanding, the main character has a broken heart and his buddies worry about him and try to better his mood by taking him on a mountain trip. He finally uses the situation and commits suicide. His friends help him to get to the summit, For a German this touches something positive we buried with all the negative from WWII: the cohesion of a group of males in the face of death. Each one ready to give his life for his companion. WWII veterans got tears in their eyes when they were talking about those experiences. I remember speaking up against this: "You have killed people in the name of Hitler.." And whole thing went up in screaming and yelling. Maybe It's not that easy. The poet Heiner Müller once dropped a line: "Back when I was twenty and owner of the truth"... Best wishes from Berlin ( I miss the animals!)
Whether for a good cause, or an evil cause, people devoted to each other bring out the same emotions. Their trials and their deaths aren't diminished simply because they were on the wrong side. We all have regrets in life. I'm rather blessed that I'm ethnicity German, but born in America. I can still recognize the evils of the Nazis, but I can also recognize the heroism and bravery of German soldiers fighting for their country. If only the Schwarze Kapelle succeeded. Unfortunately, both the American and British governments rejected their attempts to work together, and the best hope of stopping the Nazis from within died with Admiral Canaris.
After long time not understanding the lyrics, I finally decided that the song is about a man who killed his girlfriend and buried her in the woods (firs). That is where he last has seen her. He returns to her grave and when he opens the grave in the trench, his breath stops from the smell. But it does not help, withour her he is lonely, but with her dead body, it is the same.
I have a lot of respect for all the members of Rammstein. They are that rare example of unity and that any disagreements and difficulties can be overcome together. This song and video is about that. Yes they had to see a psychologist and as a result they're together for more than 20 years. And it hurts even more for me as an old Nightwish fan that around same time they couldn't overcome disagreements and difficulties in band and broke up so badly that they were almost enemies. They had been at school together since they were kids, sang and performed together, studied music together and lived in the same town.
That was a great reaction you two did. And the analysis was spot on in a way. When Till wrote the lyrics, he was thinking about drug addiction, respectively drug withdrawal. With love from Germany🤘😎
That's the great thing about Till's lyrics, everyone can draw something different out of them, because everyone has had different experiences in their lives, right?
Видеоклипы
That's the only song I don't listen to anymore. This song was played at the funeral of my son (was only 27 years).
I’m so sorry. One of life’s greatest pains that no one can understand unless they’ve experienced it. Blessings, peace and comfort to you - Suesue
oh dear!
So sorry about that!!
Take care, love from Sweden.
So sorry to hear that. Love and comfort from Bavaria/Germany 🥨🍻🙏🏞️🕯️
The song directly describes the band and their cohesion. There was a time when they could neither with each other nor without each other. They were also on the verge of separation. But they've found a way, that is was true friends do, and it's gotten better than ever.
You are describing the video. The song lyrics have a different message. Why should a song about bonding have the line "With you, I'm alone, too"? The song Haifisch is about the bond of the band.
@@tosa2522 If you don't understand each other and you constantly disagree, then you feel left alone. Then you feel alone in this band. That's what the song says. And Haifisch is not a counterexample, so it's not an argument. It will surely surprise you, because there can also be several songs with similar themes at the same time. Furthermore, you will be surprised that both songs did not come out at the same time. This in turn means that time has passed and situations change.
@@TomTomson81 Ok, I now understand how you come to your conclusion.
Lindemann's lyrics usually have nothing to do with the band, and that's also the case with "Ohne Dich". The videos often deliberately convey a different image. The only lyric the band developed together was Rammstein, the rest came exclusively from Lindemann and he often simply wrote down lyrics that had been lying in a drawer for years or had been published in his lyric books.
with slight variations.
"Without you I can't be, Without you, With you I'm also alone, Without you". It describes an emotionally unfulfilled love that hurts both in the longing and in the closeness that is sought but not emotionally reciprocated.
@@tosa2522 Band problems, toxic love relationship, some say it´s about drug addiction, maybe a bit of everything. There are often different layers and meanings in the lyrics of Lindemann. It´s art and everyone is free to interpret it in their own way.
Another Masterpiece ❤ Rammstein are the best band ever 🔥🔝
Agreed Anna!!
For me, as a 60-year-old Austrian, this video has nothing to do with mountaineering or relationships.
It reminds me of the stories of my late father, who survived the war on 3 fronts for two and a half years from 1942 to 1945.
The soldier drags a wounded comrade with him until the goal is reached.
Maybe I'm just too old to interpret it differently.
That's the great thing about Till's lyrics, everyone can draw something different out of them, because everyone has had different experiences in their lives, right?
That's actually how I interpret it as well. The thoughts of a soldier in the middle of war, thinking of his family and brothers in arms
@@LifeisFoo also a great song. Love Dire Straits.
For me this video and song is about almost unachievable dream/purpose in life.
The climbing at very fight is really dangerous, and people know the risks before starting it, but they want to achive the highest point anyway. It their dream, they very want to do it at all cost. In depth of the souls, everyone wants to do smth greater than themselves, ro chase the dream, without it people feel like their lifes are not complet. But at the same time reaching to the dream might be very hard, takes a high risk. People, who want to achive the highest point understand, that their dream can cost their lifes or many sufferings from the injuries, but they can't live without trying to be closer to their dream. And in the video, Till is suffering, but in the scene in the tent, Till is chill and confident, so his friends. Instead, they helped him to do the last steps to the dream, where he peasfully died.
"Without you I cannot be" - when you have a high purpose, you always think about it and want to achive it. And at the same time, life without it seems to not have purpose and sense, empty.
"With you I am alone to" - is about things you must sacrifice for dream. Sometimes it is only time, but in other cases it can be your connections to the closests, isolation, changing you life completely, and as in the video death, high level of risk.
Love how Sue‘s face froze for almost the whole song
It did ???
Another masterpeace of Rammstein 😎
One of my favourite Rammstein songs, and one of my favourite Music Videos of All-Time in general (and I've been collecting them for pretty much forty years).
Nobody says 'Guten Nachmittag!' in Germany. It's simply 'Guten Tag!'
The song ist about the relationship between the band members of Rammstein and also can be seen as expressing mourning over the loss of a loved person. Rammstein wanted to break up one or the other time and that is why they had even therapy sessions. But they always decided to stay together. For Heitmann (film direktor of this video) , the emotional message in the video is very important; "Ohne Dich" shows unity in the band. Richard said that the most important thing is to stick together, everything else is irrelevant.Therefore Rammstein is one of the few Bands that have managed to play in the same line up and with the same members for almost 30 years since they were founded.
The funny thing is that Flake (Keyboarder) still denies that he is a member of Rammstein, because he actually never wanted to be part of Rammstein from the start because the music was too "simple" for him. Till and Richard always wanted to start solo careers. In addition, the Rammstein members constantly argued about every song, every video and every live show, how it could be done better. It actually almost came to a break up with the "Mother" video. Till shot the video alone without really involving the other band members. Rammstein not only had one group therapy with a psychologist over the years, but nevertheless they could never be without each other
There were 5 or 6 ideas for this video. Some of the band members wanted to make a video at sea, others wanted to make it in the mountains. Richard wanted to make a video based on Hans Christian Andersen's "The Little Match Girl" because it was the only fairy tale that made him cry, but the idea was rejected.. According to Joern Heitmann (film director), this is the most emotionally engaging video he has ever made with the band.
For the video, the band members grew beards, because in the mountains there is no time to shave. Flake was the only one to have an artificial one. During the making of, Till can be seen wearing a shirt which makes fun of Flake and his beard. The climbing scene was shot on one of the climbing walls next to a parking lot, and the band could go as high as they wanted to. The band was accompanied by an experienced climbing team who taught them how to correctly climb the wall.
The video was shot at +20 degrees. The snow was artificial, and the snow storm was created with the help of machines. Emanuel Fialik's assistant expressed his concerns about whether any of the band members would get hurt while shooting a video in the middle of the tour. Heitmann claimed that no one would have been able to stop Till from playing the falling scene.
The original idea was that Flake would have to carry Till together with Schneider at 3,400 m above sea level, which was physically impossible for him. Richard admits that everyone always fights for their own scene when shooting videos and everyone wants to be able to play a part, so it's hard to work with them on the set.
11:00 - there's a making of video with subtitles if you're interested in how/where it was filmed, more on the concept etc. Its quite a funny behind the scenes video, Flake is grumping about being unable to carry Till like a dead weight 🤣
The video was shot in Kaunertal and on the Pitztal Glacier in Tyrol. The director was Jörn Heitmann, who has already directed the songs "Sonne", "Mutter" and "Amerika", among others.
I’ve been watching lots of you Rammstein videos lately and they’re always awesome keep it up!
Cheers from a a French Canadian.
This is one of my favorites from them!!! BTW Tarja does a fantastic cover of this if you would please react to it
One of their best songs. My favorite nevertheless is Stirb nicht vor mir, partly in German, partly in English language. Highly recommended for your next comments.
Will do, thanks Rob!!
Ihr seht beide so schön aus! just a compliment dears, cool reaction
Danke!
Suesue is right: "Guten Tag" is correct. You can say "Guten Nachmittag", but it is a little strange. Love your reactions!
Now he’s going to constantly say Guten Nachmittag just to irritate me ! 😂😂😂
Wolfgang explained it right…“Guten Nachmittag“ sounds strange…whereas „Guten Morgen“ (until 12am) and „Guten Abend“ (from 6pm) is very common.
Also very common in the northern part of Germany is „Moin“ which you can say all day long
@@derechtenorden2410 Moin also being said in mine Dutch Saxon dialect.
@@derechtenorden2410 Thanks!
This is a great video...I love the drama the whipping wind creates. The band does as many of their own stunts as allowed.
Im a simple man, i see Rammstein I click like
Another good one! You guys are knocking them out of the park 😎🤘
great reaction, great song 😍 more Rammstein pls🤘🏻
it is so funny, that there are so many german viewers like me, who want to see a foreigners reaction to "a german product"....
I love all of you
Kuss
Such an emotional song! 😢
Thanks , great song. Bye from the Netherlands….goeden middag 😄
The song is about depression, about someone who doesn't want to live
Great reaction ❤️
Things didn't matter to him anymore before he climbed the mountain. But when he died he was with his closest friends. Sometimes an accident is a welcomed thing.
A song that my wife and I listen to very often. Just because of the lyrics! It says so much and yet so little...
BTW: The video was shot in Tyrol in Austria. I was already in the Austrian Alps, the view is phenomenal! Unfortunately, I'm afraid of heights and could not everywhere with up.
-
A small music recommendation from me... try "Null Positiv" - "Independez" or "Kollaps" or "Trauma"... or some other songs from them. Best way are the official videos!
Thank you for listening to one of my favourite songs
Very welcome!!!
Good to see 🐺 better... This one in my knowledge was soon after they had a break in the band, beautiful video. Great reaction 👋
Location: Kaun Valley and on the Pitz Valley glacier in Tyrol, Austria.(Might have typing issues)
love your reaction :) The video takes place in Austria, and there is actually a Making of video on Rammsteins official channel.
the shot was in the Austrian Alps
Rammstein rulez, best german band ever !!!! and i love your reaction ❤
Robert Reed, Troy Donockley, Simon Phillips & Angharad Brinn - Sendlinger's Song
Amazing song!!! There is a video with the making of of this song and it's worth to watch it.
DAYUM! So bummed I missed last night’s show.
Die Rückkehr des Wolfsmanns! Lasst das Wochenende weitergehen. Good to see you both. For the record, I still blame Wendy Byrde for everything, especially poor Ruth!
I agree - she became evil by season 4. And I loved Ruth 💕 - Suesue
great reactions👏👏👏 ..,, what a stunning band ✌
i would like you to visit and react VM from alffy Rev :
" Wonderland Indonesia 2 : the sacred nusantara & : Wonderland Indonesia 2 "PERFORMANCE VERSION" by Alffy Rev with All Artist ..
its culture-music blended in modern instruments.
** both VM are materpiece , . 🔥🔥🔥 you'll be amaze 💥💥
best regard from Indonesia 🙏🙏🙏
Waiting for " Haifisch offcial video " reaction after all these videos :)
It should be:
Good Morning - Guten Morgen
Good Afternoon - Guten Mittag
Good Evening - Guten Abend
Good Night - Guten Nacht
Good Day - Guten Tag
Enjoy your dinner - Guten Appetit (🤣)
....... according to a Dutchman 😉😎 (learned at school half decade ago 😃)
Thx !!
Rammstein videos sometimes have a different twist than the original song.
To my understanding, the main character has a broken heart and his buddies worry about him and try to better his mood by taking him on a mountain trip. He finally uses the situation and commits suicide. His friends help him to get to the summit, For a German this touches something positive we buried with all the negative from WWII: the cohesion of a group of males in the face of death. Each one ready to give his life for his companion. WWII veterans got tears in their eyes when they were talking about those experiences. I remember speaking up against this: "You have killed people in the name of Hitler.." And whole thing went up in screaming and yelling. Maybe It's not that easy. The poet Heiner Müller once dropped a line: "Back when I was twenty and owner of the truth"... Best wishes from Berlin ( I miss the animals!)
Whether for a good cause, or an evil cause, people devoted to each other bring out the same emotions. Their trials and their deaths aren't diminished simply because they were on the wrong side. We all have regrets in life.
I'm rather blessed that I'm ethnicity German, but born in America. I can still recognize the evils of the Nazis, but I can also recognize the heroism and bravery of German soldiers fighting for their country.
If only the Schwarze Kapelle succeeded. Unfortunately, both the American and British governments rejected their attempts to work together, and the best hope of stopping the Nazis from within died with Admiral Canaris.
❤❤Tarja Turunen Ohne Dich (metall church) pls
👍😍
Please do Klavier.
I concur
I stay my lady till the end , thats every morning we lough together and so on ... i know what life's
all about .
After long time not understanding the lyrics, I finally decided that the song is about a man who killed his girlfriend and buried her in the woods (firs). That is where he last has seen her. He returns to her grave and when he opens the grave in the trench, his breath stops from the smell. But it does not help, withour her he is lonely, but with her dead body, it is the same.
I would recommend (if not reactet):
"Radio" and "Ich will" (Videoclips,).
🍺
Video Pitztal Austria😎
I have a lot of respect for all the members of Rammstein. They are that rare example of unity and that any disagreements and difficulties can be overcome together. This song and video is about that. Yes they had to see a psychologist and as a result they're together for more than 20 years. And it hurts even more for me as an old Nightwish fan that around same time they couldn't overcome disagreements and difficulties in band and broke up so badly that they were almost enemies. They had been at school together since they were kids, sang and performed together, studied music together and lived in the same town.
Sue your German 👍
Yasssss!
THANKS !!!!! Checkout TARJA'S beyond exquisite cover performed at the Wacken Metal Church !!!!
💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘 !!!!!!
Will do! Thanks Larry!!!
Time for the Next sad song- Lindemann live in Moscow- home sweet home
Karl, do you have a link with English subtitles?
@@SueSueandthewolfman the Song is in english
That was a great reaction you two did. And the analysis was spot on in a way. When Till wrote the lyrics, he was thinking about drug addiction, respectively drug withdrawal. With love from Germany🤘😎
glad wolfman is better
Det er et billede på et samfund hvor man tager sig af hinanden.
Give me tears.
Bless you
It's about drug addiction ✌️
No, it's a song about the band sticking together.
Ok fellow, what have YOU smoked today?
Yes, with and without drugs you are alone.
That's the great thing about Till's lyrics, everyone can draw something different out of them, because everyone has had different experiences in their lives, right?
😄
A Non-reaction, video, if it were.