PolarPro Variable ND Filter Showdown: Which Is Best For You?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 22 июл 2024
  • So, you’ve decided to level up your videos by investing in a high-quality ND filter? Nice. I personally love the PolarPro Peter McKinnon Edition filters, but they come in two varieties: 2-5 stops and 6-9 stops. Both are incredible, but they serve different purposes, so let’s compare them and find out what purposes each filter is best suited for!
    •PolarPro Peter McKinnon Variable ND Filters-
    •2-5 Stop:
    geni.us/DWcPui (Amazon)
    •6-9 Stop (I use this one since I film at extra wide apertures):
    geni.us/bLqrsU (Amazon)
    Time Markers:
    0:00 - Filter Overview
    1:27 - Unboxing & Features
    3:02 - Basic Comparisons
    5:24 - What 2-5 vs. 6-9 Looks Like
    6:20 - Filming in Bright Light Outdoors
    9:02 - Side by Side Comparisons
    10:23 - Do You Really Need "High End" Filters?
    Episode 157: PolarPro ND Filter Showdown 2-5 Stops vs. 6-9 Stops
    » Ready to start your own podcast? Check out The Podcaster Playbook, my step-by-step DIY course to help you launch your show!
    podcasterplaybook.com
    -----------------------
    Affiliate links mean I earn a commission from qualifying purchases. This helps support my channel at no additional cost to you.
    -----------------------
    ----------- CONNECT -----------
    🎯 Subscribe! bit.ly/TEPsub
    Instagram & Twitter: @sodarntom
    Main Site: himynameistom.com
    My Podcasts: himynameistom.com/podcasts
    Patreon: / tombuck
    Become a Channel Member: geni.us/joinchannel
    ----------- MUSIC -----------
    •Artlist.io (2 Extra Months Free): bit.ly/enthusiasmartlist
    •Epidemic Sound (30 Day Free Trial): share.epidemicsound.com/enthus...
    ----------- VIDEO GEAR -----------
    •Canon EOS R (main camera): geni.us/0jnes1y (Amazon)
    •Sigma 24 1.4 Art (main lens): geni.us/uvi3Fy (Amazon)
    •Canon RF 50 1.8: geni.us/Zw30tt5 (Amazon)
    •Canon 16-35 f4 IS: geni.us/h1Ys (Amazon)
    •Canon 24-105 f4 IS: geni.us/ecnKnN (Amazon)
    •DJI Mavic Mini: geni.us/Eh92 (Amazon)
    •ATEM Mini Video Switcher: geni.us/YDcRX (Amazon)
    •ATEM Mini Extreme ISO: geni.us/CCj5xl (Amazon)
    •Elgato CamLink 4K: geni.us/vddHN (Amazon)
    •Ecamm Live for Streaming: geni.us/ecammtom
    ----------- AUDIO GEAR -----------
    •Rodecaster Pro (for podcasts): geni.us/9MKJ (Amazon)
    •Rode PodMic: geni.us/EHeTTM (Amazon)
    •Rode Videomic NTG: amzn.to/2ZKrHTh (Amazon)
    •Rode Boom Arm: geni.us/shr0 (Amazon)
    •Rode Wireless Go: geni.us/LvzUSM (Amazon)
    •Shure MV7 USB/XLR Mic: geni.us/shuremv (Amazon)
    •Shure Super 55 Mic: geni.us/ulcA (Amazon)
    •Shure SM7B: geni.us/tepsm7b (Amazon)
    •Cloudlifter Signal Booster: geni.us/b26l (Amazon)
    ----------- LIGHTS, TRIPODS, & GRIP GEAR -----------
    •Nanlite Forza 200 (Key Light): geni.us/9Ofr (Amazon)
    •Aputure Light Dome Mini (for key light): geni.us/vf5O (B&H)
    •Falconeyes Flexible LED Light: geni.us/j4ENw (Amazon)
    •Small Nanlite RGB Tube Lights: geni.us/nanlite (Amazon)
    •Big Nanlite RGB Tube Lights: geni.us/nTwBU (Amazon)
    •Aputure MC RGB Light: geni.us/IuE4 (Amazon)
    •Impact C-Stand for Lights: geni.us/k97w66m (Amazon)
    •Manfrotto Tripod Head: geni.us/tGhCPR (Amazon)
    •Manfrotto 055x Tripod Legs: geni.us/qMO2 (Amazon)
    •Motorized Slider: geni.us/mQXB7BB (Amazon)
    •Overhead Camera Rig: geni.us/grpT (Amazon)
    •GlideGear Prompter: geni.us/7K04A (Amazon)
    -----------------------
    - Who Am I? -
    Hi! My name is Tom Buck. As a lifelong A/V nerd, I’m here to help you level up the audio and video quality of your streams, podcasts, puns, and videos. I was a high school Digital Media teacher for 11 years, and I started this channel in 2017 as a project to share my enthusiasm for digital media and teaching others while having fun along the way.
    New videos are uploaded every Thursday morning, and more often when possible!
    •Read my Ethics Statement about objective reviews, sponsored content, and brand partnerships: himynameistom.com/ethics
    -----------------------
    #PolarPro #Filters #Lenses #NDFilter
    -----------------------

Комментарии • 179

  • @tombuck
    @tombuck  4 года назад +6

    Time Markers:
    0:00 - Filter Overview
    1:27 - Unboxing & Features
    3:02 - Basic Comparisons
    5:24 - What 2-5 vs. 6-9 Looks Like
    6:20 - Filming in Bright Light Outdoors
    9:02 - Side by Side Comparisons
    10:23 - Do You Really Need "High End" Filters?

  • @MSladekPhoto
    @MSladekPhoto 4 года назад +6

    This is so helpful! The shots outdoor showing with/without and the different settings was so helpful to SEE what they do, rather than just talk about it. Thanks!

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  4 года назад +1

      I’m glad that helped! I was kind of worried it wouldn’t make sense. 😬

  • @allissmart
    @allissmart 4 года назад +1

    Thanks a lot! I've been searching for so long for someone to compare these 2 filters properly and now I finally found your video. Keep up!

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  4 года назад +1

      I'm happy it was helpful!

  • @ShinjoTV
    @ShinjoTV 4 года назад +5

    This is the video I was waiting for the whole years! I couldn't make decision between 2-5 & 6-9 for my sigma 16mm f1.4 (w/ a6400). I'm leaning toward to 6-9 stop after watched this. Thanks man!

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  4 года назад

      It’s a great fit for a 1.4 👍

  • @becknepomuceno3793
    @becknepomuceno3793 4 года назад +13

    i think this is the most accurate review for the nd filter,

  • @TommyIdaho
    @TommyIdaho 2 года назад +1

    Best ND filter review and technical guide out there. You totally get it. Thank you.

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  2 года назад +1

      Thank you! It's always tough to find the right filters, so I'm glad this is helpful. A friend of mine has the magnetic Freewell variable filter and it's so easy to use, but it's pretty darn pricey.

  • @jdb_rl
    @jdb_rl 4 года назад +3

    just got my 2-5 filter delivered today, can’t wait to start testing it out!

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  4 года назад

      Yes! It’s absolutely worth the price.

  • @CarlosCastillo-ud6dl
    @CarlosCastillo-ud6dl 4 года назад +1

    You finally answered my question about what ND filter would I need for sunny days. Great video!

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  4 года назад

      Awesome! Since this video, I did invest in my own 2-5 stop version that I like to pair with my f4 lenses outside. But the 6-9 stop version is WONDERFUL for really wide open apertures.

  • @AaronFilmsStuff
    @AaronFilmsStuff 4 года назад +1

    Great video!!! Fun and informative is what people need. Love what you’re doing, and love the enthusiasm! 😜

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  4 года назад

      Thanks Aaron! That means a lot. 👍

  • @PaulFeinberg
    @PaulFeinberg 4 года назад +1

    Nice video! Awesome that you got a filter sent to you from Polar Pro! Love your handwritten titles very original. Funny I did an ND Filter video this week. Yea no Peter McKinnon though lol those are super nice.

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  4 года назад

      Thanks Paul! I appreciate the kind words 👍

  • @EverydayFamilyFL
    @EverydayFamilyFL 4 года назад +3

    Polar Pro you rock. Way to support those creators on the rise like The Enthusiasm Project. Super stoked for you. Congrats, and great video. Your quality is amazing, and we love learning from you.

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  4 года назад +1

      Thanks as always! The people at PolarPro are awesome- they first reached out to me a long time ago, before 500 subscribers, and have always been supportive since then. Plus I’ve been using their stuff for years, even before I had a channel 👍

    • @EverydayFamilyFL
      @EverydayFamilyFL 4 года назад +1

      @@tombuck Wow, thats great to hear. Its not all about the biggest channels... Those on the way up get recognition too. Love this platform for that reason. Some may disagree, but I think opportunities are out there for all of us.

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  4 года назад

      Absolutely they’re out there. There’s plenty of room!

  • @andrewsytek
    @andrewsytek 4 года назад +1

    Thanks! I was stuck between these two, but just picked up the 6-9!

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  4 года назад

      I’m glad it helped!

  • @BENRATZON
    @BENRATZON 4 года назад +1

    Botherrrrrr you are incredibly informative exactly on the spot and really creative with your show.... Loved it and subscribed my friend (great content) cheers from Israel :)

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  4 года назад

      Thank you Ben! I really appreciate all the support! Hello from California!

  • @MASTEROFSAND
    @MASTEROFSAND 3 года назад +1

    Really helpful and detailed video. Thank you Tom!!! ❤😎👌

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад

      I really appreciate that, thank you!

  • @berendvanrossum4585
    @berendvanrossum4585 3 года назад +1

    This tells me I need the 2-5. Nice review man.

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад

      I'm so glad it helped you decide!

  • @whiterock1865
    @whiterock1865 2 года назад +1

    Great review very useful to see the differences. I’ll be going with the 6 to 9 being here in Texas!

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  2 года назад

      Glad it helped! Texas is bright and hot so 6-9 is probably a good choice 👍

  • @tukirahamed
    @tukirahamed 3 года назад +1

    I am going to subscribe your channel because of this video. I was always confuse what to choose. But I am clear now. Your bright studio setup is amazing. Keep making good content brother. 🇧🇩

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад +1

      Wow, thanks so much! I'm glad it helped- I was definitely confused too at first.

  • @markbenavides3345
    @markbenavides3345 4 года назад +1

    Super easy to follow. Thank you for the video.

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  4 года назад

      You’re welcome! 😎

  • @braveandnew7817
    @braveandnew7817 4 года назад +1

    lol. I was just standing at Unique Photo yesterday trying to decide which to buy. Now I know. Thanks bud!

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  4 года назад

      Awesome! I’m glad it helped!

  • @PhantomPeach
    @PhantomPeach 4 года назад +2

    This was the perfect video I was look for

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  4 года назад +1

      I'm so glad to hear it!

  • @strophotoandvideo3365
    @strophotoandvideo3365 3 года назад +1

    Great video! I have the 67 and 77 2-5 stop and love them!

  • @essychan
    @essychan 3 года назад +1

    Thanks for this video! Great comparison between the 2/5 and the 6/9 stops. I was in doubt but thanks to your video I just ordered the 6/9. I mostly need the ND filter for outside shooting and I love to film at F1.4. And when it's too much anyways, I'll just crank up my ISO a bit on the Sony A7III.

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад +1

      I think you made the right choice. The darker filter will be great for f1.4 👍

    • @essychan
      @essychan 3 года назад

      @@tombuck Hi Tom. I got the 6-9 stops and super happy with the choice. Now I have a new “problem”. I’m not sure to add it to my filter wallet, all nice together, Or use the included protection. How do you store it?

  • @jeremy.miller
    @jeremy.miller 3 года назад +1

    Love your dog 😍 we just got a golden pup and he looks so similar to yours! And great video by the way, just picked up the mist 6-9 filter!

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад +1

      Goldens are the best. If yours is the one in your profile picture, he’s adorable. Ours just has no idea he’s 80lbs and runs around like a maniac. 😁

    • @jeremy.miller
      @jeremy.miller 3 года назад +1

      @@tombuck it sure is! He’s a great pup, but he definitely has that same attitude 😂 doesn’t realize he’s huge and jumps all over people every chance he gets. They’ve gotta be the most social breed. But we love em so much!

  • @KaiTiura
    @KaiTiura 4 года назад +1

    Nicely done review. I have the 2-5 and am thinking of getting the 6-9. The two-pack with both is only $449, which is a great deal opposed to buying them separately. Wish I'd thought it out more before buying the one. The quality is amazing. Maybe I'll get the set and offer the 2-5 to a friend for $200 and spread the love.
    Nice to see Polar Pro support you, you're a great reviewer!

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  4 года назад +1

      Thanks Kai! I. Also looking at buying a 2-5, even though I mainly use the 6-9. They’re just so good!

    • @mishyq808
      @mishyq808 4 года назад

      @ Kai Tiura where can I find the set for that price??

    • @KaiTiura
      @KaiTiura 4 года назад

      mishyq808 www.polarprofilters.com/products/variable-nd-mckinnon?variant=22163634880596 You have to preorder right now though, out of stock I guess...

  • @photographybydash
    @photographybydash 4 года назад +1

    Funny because I just received both and was thinking about the same thing lol. Great content

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  4 года назад +1

      Thanks! I’d love to see your perspective on the filters 👍

  • @rashidhazim
    @rashidhazim 4 года назад +1

    Awesome comparison and breakdown! I gotta ask.. where did you get that shirt? Looks super cool

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  4 года назад

      It's from the Canon booth at VidCon 2018

  • @ForGabeAndSammy
    @ForGabeAndSammy 4 года назад +1

    Best review I've seen!! I wanna use it primarily for long exposure shots during the day and around sunsets. My lenses go 2.8 at it's widest so I'm thinking of getting the 2-5? Or should I get the 6-9?

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  4 года назад

      It really depends on how long you want your exposures to be. If you’re going over 25 seconds. I’d get the 6-9. I even have an ND1000 from polar pro, which is ridiculous but great for suuuuper long exposures.

  • @MarlonOrellana
    @MarlonOrellana 3 года назад

    what if you shoot at 120? or 60fps? will the 2-5 be fine with 1.4?

  • @quiztasiarocks
    @quiztasiarocks Год назад

    Hey Tom, hoping you can help. I have a Bmpcc 6K g2, and those cameras suffer from ir pollution so my question is; should I get a fixed IRND and then add diffusion like mist filters on top of that, or just get an ir cut filter, then add diffusion and a VND on top.
    Apart from needing more filters, are there any differences between fixed and variable nd’s to know about?

  • @MKTtribe
    @MKTtribe 4 года назад +1

    Your videos are good! 👌👌👌👌👌👌👌👌👌

  • @Lunatflowers
    @Lunatflowers 3 года назад

    very informative. thank you.

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад

      Glad it was helpful!

  • @selasiamepo7077
    @selasiamepo7077 4 года назад +1

    Very informative

  • @DanCBearded
    @DanCBearded 4 года назад +2

    Man that Broll is crispy

  • @serranopro_
    @serranopro_ 4 года назад +1

    Does anyone know if the section between the polarpro logo and the number 2 act as a uv filter (no darkening) or does it always have some darkening?

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  4 года назад

      There’s ND “darkening” all the time when the filter is attached 👍

  • @louisrivera9710
    @louisrivera9710 2 года назад +1

    I’m using the EOS R with the 85mm f1.8 and this video just made me realize I need both 😂😂😂 great info sir !!!!

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  2 года назад

      You definitely can't go wrong with both on a 1.8 lens. Hope you're liking the 85mm! I got one at the end of last year and really wish I hadn't waited so long. It's an amazing focal length.

    • @louisrivera9710
      @louisrivera9710 2 года назад

      1.2*

  • @JimmyAlioto
    @JimmyAlioto 2 года назад +1

    Are you able to use a lens hood? if not are you getting lens flare? Great video btw. Is 100iso native to the R6? My c300 is native iso 800. So this might make a difference on which vnd filter to get? correct me if i'm wrong!!

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  2 года назад

      I THINK the R5's native ISO might be 640? I'm not 100% sure though. You cna still use a hood with these, but it does become tougher to adjust them/see the settings on the filter.

  • @georgios_georgiou
    @georgios_georgiou 4 года назад +1

    Seems like great content but I would like to ask a question: Will the 2-5 version let you get away with it if not shooting photos at high noon at f1.4? I mean I keep using my sigma 30mm f1.4 primarily for photos shouldn't the shutter be enough to compensate?? 🤔🤔

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  4 года назад +1

      Yes, if you’re not trying to get ultra long exposures with your photos, that should work just fine.

  • @Sam-kw9wd
    @Sam-kw9wd 4 года назад +1

    Hi! Quick question. Does the 6-9 have the same ability as the 2-5 in regards to turning it down to 0 without taking off the filter?

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  4 года назад +1

      I wish it did, but neither of the McKinnon edition filters have a 0 setting.

  • @N0MADproduction
    @N0MADproduction 4 месяца назад

    I like the 6-9 for my FX3 since I want to be filming at 24fps, but I wonder if the same apply on my Tamron 17-28mm F2.8 since its far from F1.4

  • @thai_le_foto
    @thai_le_foto 4 года назад +1

    Awesome examples man! Did you color grade the examples at all? I'm about to order the 6-9 because my Tiffen gives an INSANE green cast on my Sony A7iii /cry, it's a pain in the butt trying to white balance it with my presets already made and still doesn't give me the normal look I use because the white balance is different.

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  4 года назад +1

      No color grading. These are straight from the EOS R 👍

    • @thai_le_foto
      @thai_le_foto 4 года назад +1

      @@tombuck Awesome thanks!

  • @bodhicsutoros
    @bodhicsutoros 3 года назад +1

    I shoot almost all my stuff at f1.8 but I normally shoot at 50fps and 100fps
    what would you recommend
    great review btw!! best one I've seen for these filters by far

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад

      If you're outdoors at 1.8, I'd definitely recommend the 6-9 stop filter.

  • @sarinasoriano2408
    @sarinasoriano2408 3 года назад +2

    Quick question, would the 6-9 filter be too dark during morning/sunset time shooting video at 60 FPS 120 shutter speed?

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад

      Depends on your aperture. Anything below 2.0 should be fine.

  • @HomesickMac
    @HomesickMac 2 года назад +1

    You're never out of luck with Tom Buck (sincere appologies for the pun), what a coincidence, I've just ordered the 6-9 and was watching another video… Then yours came as suggested… Great, and I might even be right with my choice. At first, I thought of getting the 2-5 because the main scenario would be indoors, but then I thought that I should get the 6-9 because of future work outdoors. Like, make sure I cover those needs first. Hell, I maybe do go and buy the 2-5 so I'm covered. This is defo money well spent and an investment as well. Cheers!

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  2 года назад

      I saw your comment in a chat yesterday! They're great filters. I went with the 6-9 initially because I usually shoot at f1.4, but it's very handy to have both.

    • @HomesickMac
      @HomesickMac 2 года назад

      @@tombuck I took the Mist version, so curious how that works indoors... The 2-5 option will wait a little..

  • @jonathannewman4899
    @jonathannewman4899 3 года назад +1

    Just the nd video I needed

  • @MajBurke
    @MajBurke 4 года назад +8

    Im sure that you've answered this already but i just wanted to clarify. I know that you put 2-5 for if you are shooting at above 2.8 and 6-9 if below that. My though is where should i be if i'm primarily shooting at 2.8 specifically? While trying to research for Variable ND's I always seem to find that trying to find a ND suitable for 2.8 is always the dead middle between two separate products or the ones that sit in the middle aren't too highly recommended. Great video though! Always nice to see new faces in this genre

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  4 года назад +5

      I think you’re right about being smack dab in the middle. I live in the desert, so when I film outside it’s REALLY bright. If I were filming primarily at 2.8, I’d probably go with the 6-9 just to be safe. If you’re not filming in high-noon ultra bright conditions, the 2-5 should be good. Some people also use their ND filters to add dynamic range when filming indoors- I’d recommend the 2-5 for that as well.

    • @creatioexnihilo4125
      @creatioexnihilo4125 4 года назад +2

      If it's too dark you have always the possibility to increase the iso a bit.

    • @matnetik
      @matnetik 2 года назад

      @burke what did you end up going with? In this same boat, mainly shooting at 2.8, I live in SoCal so it’s pretty sunny most of the time, thinking 6-9 as Tom said

  • @LiToCoasterCouple
    @LiToCoasterCouple 4 года назад +1

    We are looking at getting the R with the 24-105 F4 and mainly shoot during the day. The next lens we will invest is a 16-35 f4. Keeping in mind that we will be mainly shooting in log so iso is at 400. What would you suggest getting knowing we will shoot widest at f4? We only have budget for 1 of the 2 filters :/

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  4 года назад +1

      If you’re outdoors with an iso of 400 and I’m assuming you’re keeping the shutter speed at something like 1/50, then I think the 6-9 stop is probably the way to go 🤔

    • @LiToCoasterCouple
      @LiToCoasterCouple 4 года назад

      The Enthusiasm Project Allright thanks!

  • @Alils350
    @Alils350 3 года назад +1

    I don’t know which filter 2-5 or 6-9 to buy for my Sony a7siii with 24mm gm and 16-35gm

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад +1

      It’s tricky. With a 2.8 lens, you’ll like;y be ok with the 2-5 stop, but if your primarily shooting at 2.8 in bright sunlight, then the 6-9 might be smarter just to be safe.

  • @robertpizzo5681
    @robertpizzo5681 3 года назад +1

    I have a Nikon Z6 with a 24 - 70mm kit lens - I use for video but also for landscape photography. I love the long exposure look on water. Usually out at mid-day if I am with someone (hard to get others up with me early in the am). Video usually 1080p f/4, sometimes 4K. Which would you recommend? 1-5 or 6-9? Im looking at the PM VND w/ Mist 2.

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад +1

      Honestly, I would probably go with the 6-9 even though you’re using f4, since it’ll be midday.

    • @robertpizzo5681
      @robertpizzo5681 3 года назад +1

      @@tombuck thank you for the quick reply, I will go with your recommendation!

  • @glennparker8247
    @glennparker8247 3 года назад +1

    I am currently loving shooting wide open but I also shoot inside a lot. which would you go with for that?

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад

      Inside, I would think the 2-5 should be fine.

  • @creativesymon
    @creativesymon 4 года назад +1

    This is one of the ONLY useful videos on these two products. All others just blow smoke up PM's backside and show a few shots. As awesome as he is...that's not what's needed. Your vid was exactly the info people need. Perfectly executed outside examples of their differences and you should be repeatedly thanked. Thank you x 10 :) I bought both because I'm filthy rich* and I know I'll need the options.
    *I'm totally not rich! Ha! Just a bit stoopid to spend £500 on just 2 filters :)
    BTW: For those who understandably can't stomach the cost...I 100% recommend the K&F Concept Slim Variable at around £50 for an 82mm. It's absolutely brilliant for the price, super slim (maybe more than these), has hard stops and perfectly cut threads. The thread on my 3 is 82mm with an 86mm front thread. These Polar Pros had better blow them out of the water...but I fear not.

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  4 года назад

      Thanks for the kind words and helpful recommendation! These really are good filters in their own right. I did end up buying the 2-5 stop for myself just so I can always be prepared. Definitely worth the investment. 👍

  • @creatioexnihilo4125
    @creatioexnihilo4125 4 года назад

    Very good review, thanks! When you have 2 lenses with differently filter size (77 mm and 82 mm) is it possible to get a step up ring to use the filter for both lenses? And when yes, should I buy the 82 mm?

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  4 года назад

      Yes, that's totally possible and a great way to add in some versatility!

    • @creatioexnihilo4125
      @creatioexnihilo4125 4 года назад +1

      The Enthusiasm Project thanks, and you would buy the bigger one?

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  4 года назад +1

      I think it’d be best to get the biggest and then step down. Unless you have a lens you’re planning to buy, then see if that diameter matches with one of the current lenses and get that size.

  • @klotsinga9774
    @klotsinga9774 2 года назад +1

    I am shooting in Germany, on an FX3, with a 16-35mm, mostly outside and open wide at 2.8 -- would I go for the 6-9?

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  2 года назад

      You could probably get away with either of them. If it's really bright and you're always at 2.8, then the 6-9 is probably the best bet.

  • @41vids
    @41vids 3 года назад +1

    Is it a bad idea to get the edition 1 (since they are cheaper now)? I know they made external changes, but is the quality of the actual results of photos and videos the same for both edition 1 and 2? That’s all I care about, please help!

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад

      I haven't used the Version 2 myself, so I can't say. Both og my filters are the originals and I like them a lot (plus they're expensive, so I'm not looking to update them any time soon). The image quality is outstanding, but they do sometimes shift things to be a little warmer in color temperature. Fortunately that's an easy fix and hasn't been a real problem.

    • @41vids
      @41vids 3 года назад

      Tom Buck thanks for the reply! So in order to fix that warm hue it gives, do you just adjust the temperature meter to fix that?

  • @thomaslarmit6434
    @thomaslarmit6434 4 года назад +1

    9:57 hold on! This part had me kind of confused;
    You see, I probably am going to buy a 24-105 f4L canon lens, But i'm curious to see if the 2-5 stop ND would cover up nice exposure at stop 5 with f4. but since you changed your F to F/1.4 between the 2 shots at that exact comparison, I don't know if the 2-5 filter would cover up my sunny day shoots outside, or that I really need the 6-9, hoping the 6 start stop wouldn't be too dark of an image.

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  4 года назад +1

      Ahh, I see (sorry for the confusion). I would say that the 2-5 stop filter will be fine for f4, but if you’re planning to do really long exposures, then stick with the 6-9.

  • @shotsbybotts51
    @shotsbybotts51 4 года назад +3

    okay so with a 24-70 2.8 , I'm always shooting a 2.8 , never really a 4, I'm thinking mainly outdoors, I just moved states so I don't know how bright it can get during summer and what not, I heard getting the 6-9 is the better stop regardless because if it's too dark then you can just bump the ISO up instead of the 2-5 for it being too bright and having to crank the shutter speed, I'm still trying to figure out which one to get

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  4 года назад +2

      The 6-9 is smart if you plan to shoot at 1/50 shutter speed.

    • @shotsbybotts51
      @shotsbybotts51 4 года назад +2

      The Enthusiasm Project okay, cause I plan on shooting a lot during the summer, and going into cities. So if I shoot anything below or a 1/50 you would recommend that, what about something like a 1/200 and up shutter speed ?

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  4 года назад +2

      It’s a tough call, I think either could work. I started with the 6-9 and added the 2-5 later on.

    • @shotsbybotts51
      @shotsbybotts51 4 года назад +2

      The Enthusiasm Project okay, did you find yourself pushing the ISO in case If it was too dark. Grain is pretty easy to fix, sorry for all the questions , but I’m just curious as to what worked for you. Thank you so much for responding

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  4 года назад +1

      I haven’t found it to be an issue outdoors. I’ve only had to do that when filming something with a lot of contrast, like under a shaded patio with a bright background, or inside with a bright window.

  • @sapiannitin
    @sapiannitin Год назад +1

    Need your recommendation - I like Peter's edition however do you think Polar Pro Basecamp may be a better choice which serves overall purpose instead of getting different filters for different thread sizes?

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  Год назад +1

      That's a great question! I think a lot has to do with how comfortable you are using a larger setup. A matte box adds quite a bit of size and weight, but also a ton of versatility.
      If you want to keep things compact, then you can always use adapter rings for your lenses (basically get the largest filter size you'll need and then use step down rings to make it fit any smaller lenses you have).

    • @sapiannitin
      @sapiannitin Год назад

      @@tombuck Thank you so much for spending time and your reply. You earned one subscriber:)
      Any recommendation for a step down ring, I hope you mean step up ring? Of course Polar Pro must not be selling them if so I will be curious to know why people would buy different size filters and spend money instead of buying largest possible one with a step up ring.
      Not sure if there would be any other reason than people having pots of money :)

  • @mattisrobowski
    @mattisrobowski 4 года назад

    Quote: "This is not a which is best Review".... The Title: "Which is best for you?"
    Well played!:D
    Nice Video! Thanks for the Help to choose!

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  4 года назад

      Haha, touche! I guess there's a difference between a definitive "best" and a best for specific needs/situations.

  • @JromePo
    @JromePo 4 года назад +1

    great review. can I ask a question about the rotation of the filter? is it kinda hard to rotate or is it kinda loose?

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  4 года назад

      I would say it's in the middle. I think PolarPro has done a slight revision, and the newer filter I have feels better than the older one 🤷🏻‍♂️

    • @JromePo
      @JromePo 4 года назад +1

      I am planning to buy one soon do you think it is better to go for 6-9 stops for my f1.8 prime and f2.8 zoom lens?

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  4 года назад

      If you’re planning to use wide apertures like that most of the time,the 6-9 is probably best 👍

    • @JromePo
      @JromePo 4 года назад

      Thank you.

  • @brandonlazo
    @brandonlazo 3 года назад +1

    Hi! For slog3, what would you recommend me?

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад

      My semi-uneducated opinion says that it’s more about your overall exposure rather than picture profile. If you’re using a wide aperture in bright light, definitely get the 6-9 stop.

  • @PeterPengKrogh
    @PeterPengKrogh 2 года назад +1

    Interesting that at f4 filter 2-5 it's still overexposed at 10:02
    If i were to choose one filter, wouldn't it be safer to get the 6-9 for bright days? and for less bright days just increase the ISO a bit

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  2 года назад

      If you’ll be in bright light at 2.8 and under (maybe even f4 too), then the 6-9 is the way to go. 👍

    • @PeterPengKrogh
      @PeterPengKrogh 2 года назад

      @@tombuck Thanks for the reply! I think I'll get just that :)

  • @kiddd74
    @kiddd74 2 года назад +1

    I’m using a 24mm f1.4 GM, with my Sony A7C. I have to keep my shutter at 1/200 so I can use catalyst browse. Do you think I could get away with the 2-5stop ND, since my shutter is higher all the time. Yes I’m a f1.4 manic also..lmao

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  2 года назад +1

      If you're outdoors in super bright daylight, then it might still be overexposed. If you're not filming at high noon or in super sunny conditions, the 2-5 could work well.

  • @mohammedalsane66
    @mohammedalsane66 4 года назад +3

    dude you did such a good job at reviewing but just imagine... I STILL CANT DECIDE 😭😭

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  4 года назад

      It’s a tough decision! If you’re doing a lot of work wider than 2.8, I would recommend the 6-9.

    • @mohammedalsane66
      @mohammedalsane66 4 года назад +1

      @@tombuck I currently have an F4 lens so I think I might go with the 6-9 but again I'm still holding back cuz I don't want it to be waaaay too dark. Never thought that deciding on which ND filter to get would be that hard lol.

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  4 года назад

      I totally understand 🤦🏻‍♂️

    • @shawndavismedia
      @shawndavismedia 3 года назад

      I literally has the same idea until I went through the comments and saw yours 😂.

  • @sottheaphoeurng9044
    @sottheaphoeurng9044 4 года назад

    Hi sir. Is it okay to use with ultra wide angle like 16-35 f4?

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  4 года назад

      Absolutely it is!

    • @sottheaphoeurng9044
      @sottheaphoeurng9044 4 года назад +1

      The Enthusiasm Project because many people use cheap filters on their wide angle lens then it has white color around picture.

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  4 года назад

      If anything, these make the color temperature a bit warmer, but that’s easy to fix either in camera or editing.

  • @StevenAlvarez
    @StevenAlvarez 2 года назад +1

    Thanks!

  • @becknepomuceno3793
    @becknepomuceno3793 4 года назад

    what aperture did you used @ 8:11?

    • @becknepomuceno3793
      @becknepomuceno3793 4 года назад +1

      i saw the example at 9:53 thank you so much, i will choose 6 to 9 stop for may f1.4 lens

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  4 года назад

      Glad it helped! The higher ND is definitely a good choice for wider apertures.

  • @anuraj5295
    @anuraj5295 3 года назад +1

    2-5 stopes is good during evening at 1.4?

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад

      If it’s not a bright evening, you’ll probably be able to get by with it.

    • @anuraj5295
      @anuraj5295 3 года назад

      @@tombuck tnks

  • @normannavarro7212
    @normannavarro7212 3 года назад +1

    What time of the day is this shot?

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад

      This was between 1 and 2pm, if I remember right. I wanted to wait until the brightest, harshest light of the day.

  • @stefankoen
    @stefankoen 4 года назад +1

    I’m going to go film in Antarctica soon. EOS R + RF 24-70 f2.8 and RF 35 f1.8. Do you recommend the 6-9 at f2.8 because I shoot a lot at 60fps 125ss? Thanks!

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  4 года назад

      Wow Antarctica! That’s awesome. I think the 6-9 would be the smart option.

  • @WillShrop
    @WillShrop 3 года назад

    Do you really need ISO at 100 though? Modern day cameras can handle a few stops worth of ISO very easily.

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад

      That's true, and depending on your picture profile your camera might perform better at a higher ISO, but in general, I still like keeping it as low as possible.

    • @WillShrop
      @WillShrop 3 года назад +1

      @@tombuck True, there's better dynamic range at ISO 100 as well.

  • @nicholastoo858
    @nicholastoo858 4 года назад +2

    Right now I need to decide if I should buy the ND kit or a PS5.

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  4 года назад +1

      Wow, those are VERY different choices! The PS5 looks sweet, but the ND kit will let you create rather than consume. 😉

    • @nicholastoo858
      @nicholastoo858 4 года назад

      @@tombuck Just purchased the kit. The idea to make'em work for the PS5, that way I can have both.

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  4 года назад +1

      Smart plan!

  • @tmangkim
    @tmangkim 4 года назад +1

    They should make one with 3-7 stops

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  4 года назад

      I wonder if that’d be possible without getting an x pattern?

  • @autoza442
    @autoza442 3 года назад +1

    I already sub your channel.
    Last week I watch " 16-35 f4 vs 16-35 f2.8 lll " in your channel, and now I already buy 16-35 f4 is
    Today I watch this video, I think tomorrow I will spend money $299.99. I'm sure hahahaha

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад +1

      Haha, hopefully the tools are useful and within your budget 😬

    • @autoza442
      @autoza442 3 года назад

      ​@@tombuck I need to say " Thank a lot brother, your video are very useful for me and other "
      :]

  • @Akreem
    @Akreem 4 года назад +1

    Atleast the cheap filter catch Ufo in the sky 😀👍

  • @orestes1984
    @orestes1984 Год назад

    Yeah a 2-5 stopper is useless in daylight in a country with a reasonable amount of daylight. I don't know why people recommend them for daylight use. I've only ever found an ND5 useful in late afternoon or early morning sunlight. If you're going to shoot in the middle of the day you need the 5-11 stopper.

  • @frostybe3r
    @frostybe3r 4 года назад +1

    You barely have 17k subs but they gave you a free filter? Wut.

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  4 года назад +1

      PolarPro is really good about supporting creators. 👍

    • @frostybe3r
      @frostybe3r 4 года назад +1

      @@tombuck 2-5 is fine for f4 yeah

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  4 года назад

      Yeah, it works great.