Jon Snow becomes Lord Commander of the Night Watch | Game of Thrones

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 3 дек 2022
  • The votes were cast, and Jon and Alister were tied. But Maester Aemon cast his vote in favour of Jon Snow. Jon became the 998th Lord Commander of the Night Watch.
    Game of Thrones (GoT)
    Creators: David Benioff, D.B. Weiss
    Stars: Emilia Clarke, Peter Dinklage, Kit Harington, Sophie Turner
    Original network: HBO
    Distributor: Warner Bros. Television Distribution
    Christopher (Kit) Harington - an English actor who is widely known for his role as Jon Snow in the HBO epic fantasy television series Game of Thrones.
  • КиноКино

Комментарии • 374

  • @TheNatequendo
    @TheNatequendo 9 месяцев назад +1135

    "He is the commander we turned to when the night was darkest" is such a raw cold line

    • @nex2says112
      @nex2says112 9 месяцев назад +10

      I was wondering why no one mentioned it in comment sec, that gives me chills all the time.

    • @petersphilip2783
      @petersphilip2783 6 месяцев назад +4

      Nothing beats this comment. It gave me chill and so much admiration for Sam and how good GOT was.❤️

    • @Nulcha
      @Nulcha 2 месяца назад +1

      Yeeees!

  • @RoverCaptain
    @RoverCaptain Год назад +2723

    Maester Aemon changing the world’s fate in one action.

    • @remembergandhi5583
      @remembergandhi5583 Год назад +104

      He did that many Times.

    • @ar3039
      @ar3039 Год назад +227

      In the show he won by a slim margin.
      In the books though, Jon snow won by an overwhelming majority. After many rounds of voting with the forerunners being Janos Slynt of Castle Black, Ser Denys Mallister of Eastwatch, and Cotter Pyke of Shadow Tower, nobody seemed to have a clear majority, however Janos Slynt seemed to be gaining ground after every round of voting. To prevent Slynt from becoming the Lord Commander, Samwell Tarly convinced Cotter Pyke and Denys Mallister's men to cast their votes to Jon Snow and break the deadlock, since both were not too fond of Slynt either, both knew that their vote share was slowly slipping away, and they both would eventually lose out to Slynt. They however saw a common ground in Jon. Their combined vote shares saw Jon win easily by a thick margin in the next round of voting. And thus, Jon Snow, the 16 year old bastard by Ned Stark, ended up becoming the 998th Lord Commander of the Night's Watch.

    • @codyvandal2860
      @codyvandal2860 Год назад

      @@ar3039 by the time he is elected he is like 19 though is he not?

    • @ar3039
      @ar3039 Год назад +31

      @@codyvandal2860 Many under-18 characters from the books were "aged up" (because of obvious reasons!). In the books, Jon snow was born in 283AC, which made him almost 16-17yrs of age when he took up reins of the Black, Daenerys was 15-16 yrs old when she commanded the unsullied and conquered the slaver cities, and Sansa Stark was only 12 when her father was executed.

    • @ppv1780
      @ppv1780 Год назад +2

      Aemon**

  • @abridges6499
    @abridges6499 11 месяцев назад +622

    " Lying in a puddle of his own makin' " gets me every single time!

    • @elessartelcontar147
      @elessartelcontar147 11 месяцев назад +35

      Even Aemon is quietly laughing like "Samwell doesn't need dragons to get that bitch BURNED"

    • @Whitehouse7814
      @Whitehouse7814 2 месяца назад +1

      what does it means

    • @kiwiwarlord8152
      @kiwiwarlord8152 Месяц назад +2

      @@Whitehouse7814 He pissed himself

    • @devanov3103
      @devanov3103 25 дней назад +2

      @@kiwiwarlord8152 It's called a tactical puddle, so any wildling trying to attack him would slip.

    • @johnpauloracion1040
      @johnpauloracion1040 22 дня назад

      @@devanov3103 I LAUGHED SO HARD AT THIS, COFFEE CAME OUT MY NOSE

  • @pradyumn2692
    @pradyumn2692 Год назад +653

    998th Lord Commander - Jon snow.
    999th - Jon snow Zombie mode
    1000th - Jon Snow again after being stripped of his throne by Bran.

    • @messiha666
      @messiha666 Год назад +46

      No fair! How come 'e gets to be Lord Commander thrice in a row, eh? Buggerin' politicin', I tells ya!

    • @scottmatheson3346
      @scottmatheson3346 8 месяцев назад +23

      so much for term limits

    • @billyboblillybob344
      @billyboblillybob344 8 месяцев назад +30

      Edd was in there somewhere...probably 999 or 1000....

    • @ashishhoodamitti1169
      @ashishhoodamitti1169 7 месяцев назад +5

      u forgot his frnd who was given the castle by jon when jon joined war

    • @billyboblillybob344
      @billyboblillybob344 7 месяцев назад

      @@ashishhoodamitti1169 See my comment above yours...

  • @flightofthebumblebee9529
    @flightofthebumblebee9529 Год назад +1363

    It was actually really cool the way Ser Allistar agreed with everything that Samwell said about Jon, but only pointed out the obvious (which was indeed true) that Jon had a very soft spot for the wildlings.
    If Jon and Allistar could've worked together, they could've done some amazing things.

    • @MrSam1804
      @MrSam1804 Год назад +38

      I don't think so, cuz Allistar's idea of a night's watch was warped, and wildlings were it's true eney in his eyes.

    • @flightofthebumblebee9529
      @flightofthebumblebee9529 Год назад +88

      @@MrSam1804 yes but imagine the things he dealt with and had to endure for 20 years. How many friends he watched killed, farmers and villages destroyed etc. Ollie has every reason to despise the wildlings too (even Tormund). If Ser Allistar could've taken a real chance trusting Jon Snow instead of betraying him, I think they could've rallied the Wildlings and joined forces and manned every single castle on the wall together, and kept the Night King and Army of the Dead from ever getting past the wall.

    • @jpval3484
      @jpval3484 Год назад +65

      If only Allistar knew Jon was from the bloodline he loyally served.

    • @ShacolateClown
      @ShacolateClown Год назад +3

      @@flightofthebumblebee9529 its weird how he did not ''want'' to understand. i thought he saw the white walkers and still disagree for some reason

    • @syedaleem6679
      @syedaleem6679 Год назад +11

      Right. Especially considering he was a loyal Targaryen supported & was close to Rhaegar. If only he got to know Jon was Raeghar's son.

  • @_myst_4267
    @_myst_4267 3 месяца назад +144

    I love how even Aemon smiles when Sam roasts Slint.

  • @maclain728
    @maclain728 Год назад +1146

    Seriously one of the most wholesome moments on the show. Sam showing he’s a true friend and Jon finally get credit and recognition for all the work he’d done
    God this show was amazing

    • @flightofthebumblebee9529
      @flightofthebumblebee9529 Год назад +20

      Even with the rushed final 2 seasons, I still love this series. It just peaked with season 4 that's all.

    • @anonymousgara8415
      @anonymousgara8415 6 месяцев назад +1

      Please don’t use God in vain. Thank you, may God bless you and everyone. ❤

    • @ChickenWings103
      @ChickenWings103 4 месяца назад +1

      Gods*

    • @elih9700
      @elih9700 4 месяца назад +2

      @@ChickenWings103 And the 7 hells lol.

    • @hadikhan5197
      @hadikhan5197 16 дней назад

      I guess D&D knew that Sam telling jon being Targaryen wouldn’t amount to much later on, so they gave him this

  • @NewVegasNerd
    @NewVegasNerd 11 месяцев назад +359

    Ser Alliser's greatest flaw was his inability to set aside his hatred of the wildlings, especially given the nature of the threat posed by the White Walkers. Perhaps if he had been at Hardhome with Jon, he would have reevaluated his viewpoint. Humans have a very difficult time letting go of their hatred.

    • @Agentshadling
      @Agentshadling 11 месяцев назад +26

      He fought for King Aerys, he hates Jon for being the bastard of the man who helped overthrow the king.

    • @ssark9187
      @ssark9187 8 месяцев назад +8

      ​@@Agentshadlingwhile john is the son of that same king. Ironic

    • @KleinAB
      @KleinAB 5 месяцев назад

      Rhaegar, but whatever@@ssark9187

    • @aryanrudra24
      @aryanrudra24 5 месяцев назад

      ​@@ssark9187Grandson **

    • @pavarottiaardvark3431
      @pavarottiaardvark3431 4 месяца назад +1

      Given that Jon makes him First Ranger, he's probably hoping that Ser Allister learns more about what is actually beyond the Wall

  • @randomlyentertaining8287
    @randomlyentertaining8287 Год назад +523

    Half those clapping probably did so just for Sam having the balls to speak up.

    • @peterdo5047
      @peterdo5047 Год назад +26

      He spoke what most were thinking but weren't ready to face the consequences for supporting John Snow.

    • @souravpaul2179
      @souravpaul2179 Год назад +1

      He spoke quite a lot of times

  • @dunkelwalde695
    @dunkelwalde695 Год назад +145

    Sam absolutely slayed Janos Slynt here. 💀💀💀☠☠☠

    • @KaraokeNig
      @KaraokeNig Год назад +3

      Like someone else said Slynt must have been of Targaryen bloodline because nobody could survive such a burn.

    • @jadehaze7939
      @jadehaze7939 Месяц назад

      SAM THE SLAYER YEEAH

  • @msrraju4694
    @msrraju4694 Год назад +1543

    Master Aemon choose jon snow because he knows the prophecy, "when the white walkers comes, A Targaryen must lead all the people of Westoros to defend it."

    • @princeomari7
      @princeomari7 Год назад +89

      Only the kings and heirs were told about this. Aemond was never expected to take the throne so it’s unlikely he knew

    • @talissoncavalcante6581
      @talissoncavalcante6581 Год назад +88

      @@princeomari7 He was quite close with his brother Aegon V, it's not impossible that Egg told him the prophecy when Aemon decided to follow Bloodraven to the Wall.

    • @stvdagger8074
      @stvdagger8074 Год назад +108

      Who told Maester Aemond that John was a Targaryean? Unless John smells distinctly Targaryen, there is no way that he knew who John's real father was.

    • @kamicloudss
      @kamicloudss Год назад +6

      Since when is his name “Aemond”?

    • @jakestark2483
      @jakestark2483 Год назад +13

      @@stvdagger8074 there is alot of foreshadowing including his care of Jon to suggest he knew but you are correct there is no absolute conformation he knew at all. As far as we know from what we've seen he didn't. Tho it would be cool

  • @johnobrien3373
    @johnobrien3373 Год назад +415

    if you’ve read the books, you’d know that Ser Denys Mallister also would have been a great choice for Lord Commander, he’s a great leader for real.

    • @SantomPh
      @SantomPh Год назад +81

      he was also very old and might have died within a year. He gives his votes to Jon, which is what really helped him win.

    • @CxerRy96
      @CxerRy96 11 месяцев назад +16

      I always found it a little odd/uncomforable how the show only gave him like 1/5th of the votes, it just never sat right

    • @LegitBacKd00rNiNJa69
      @LegitBacKd00rNiNJa69 10 месяцев назад +1

      yeah and if you've read the books his orthodox ways spawned Mance Rayder

    • @certifiedredditgenius
      @certifiedredditgenius 7 месяцев назад +5

      Hilariously enough, in the books I believe he commanded Eastwatch, not the Shadow Tower. The guy who commanded the Shadow Tower was a great fighter but also a dick.

    • @theloremaestro5498
      @theloremaestro5498 2 месяца назад

      I'm curious can you elaborate?

  • @cjmars822
    @cjmars822 Год назад +187

    And with that tie breaking vote, Maester Aemon unknowingly sentenced Jon Snow to his death lol

    • @Monizious
      @Monizious Год назад +1

      It's "Jon". Even youtube auto generate subtitles can write his name right.

    • @Xachy
      @Xachy Год назад +12

      @@Monizious Damn man you sure corrected him. I wouldn't have known otherwise.

    • @devanov3103
      @devanov3103 25 дней назад

      @@Monizious It's "auto-generated", professor.

  • @develynseether4426
    @develynseether4426 Год назад +235

    I think that's Ser Alliser weakest moment. He knew Jon had the support to oppose him so he had to get a dig in and try to upset the balance. Dick move.

    • @siriusczech
      @siriusczech Год назад +18

      We are currently having presidential elections in Czech republic, second round between two candidates.
      One is a retired army general, hero who led his men on voluntary misson to save French soldiers in 90s on Balkans, respectful member of NATO institutions and quite chilled and skilled diplomat with tons of experience.
      His opponent is agricultural magnate, a billionare, that doesn´t know common things from even a 5th grade of elementary school, though instead of humble saying "I don´t know" he attacks everyone with counterquestions and discussions fauls, refusing to answer and bringing instead unrelated topics. A guy, who through massive PR campaign gotten into politics and currently profits generally from poorest and socially disadvantages people to be voted for - all thanks to massive populism using lies and clamining he works for people, while at the same time people work in his companies at minimum wage and at bad conditions barely making up standards done by law.
      It you would have though that the billionare stands no chance, you might be surprised that first round they were tied in range of statistic mistake (though there was a choice from 8 people there). Second roung coming this weekend and what ser Alliser did was dirty, but at least in boundaries. Our oligarch candidate spits shiet wherever he goes, trying anything to disgust as many democratic voters to not go vote in second round while at the same time does his best to appeal to more radical wings. This even lead to a diplomatic faux paux, because there is a war next to NATO´s border and this fukker even told he wouldn´t order our troops to come to help of our neighboring country in case they needed, all because he wants to appeal as "anti war" and "pacifist" to distinguish from former army general.
      I hope that "our Jon Snow" will win here, too, because dirties campaing has never been seen before in my country. Especially when it is running from only one side, the generel´s side plays more positive ways.
      Watching this scene reminded me of reality i live in too much

    • @OhHeBustin
      @OhHeBustin Год назад +2

      @@siriusczech damn

    • @Daydy377
      @Daydy377 Год назад +5

      @@siriusczech Good luck amigo

    • @siriusczech
      @siriusczech Год назад +1

      @@Daydy377 60:40 against populism, lies and oligarchism. John Snow has won!
      Funny thing: populistic candidate claimed researches are manipulated and encouraged everyone to go bet in favour of his victory. Tons of his sheeps went for it due to high course. Now they want their money back, claiming it was their money for vacation, pension or crucial money. 😀 that's how we live here

    • @observantsnack6397
      @observantsnack6397 Год назад +13

      @@siriusczech To those who read this comment in the future, the general ended up winning, which presents hope for the future. Congratulations to you, from your polish neighboors, we sincerely hope General Petr Pavel continues to serve your country well on his new presidential position.

  • @yourstrulytk12
    @yourstrulytk12 Год назад +70

    "he might be young but he's the commander we turned to when the night was the darkest."

  • @mjalcantara3825
    @mjalcantara3825 5 месяцев назад +11

    lord janos friends in court will not allow how sam roast him in this meeting

  • @perra7749
    @perra7749 4 месяца назад +17

    "Can't argue with any of that"
    *proceeds to argue*

  • @christopherfoley8322
    @christopherfoley8322 Год назад +63

    I do like how they try to make Jon promoting Thorne to first ranger as a peace offering, when in the book Stannis told him he needs to get both him and Slynt away from there, so he pretty much wanted to send Thorne to his death beyond the wall, and Slynt far away to another tower

  • @chazmascias4259
    @chazmascias4259 Год назад +148

    kind of ironic that Sir Alisor was a Targaryen loyalist but hated Jon lol

    • @perra7749
      @perra7749 Год назад +6

      Well, obviously he was completely oblivious to that fact.

    • @Jdb63
      @Jdb63 Год назад +22

      @@perra7749 Doesn't take away from the irony

    • @perra7749
      @perra7749 Год назад +1

      @@Jdb63 Tbh, I agree with you. I do wonder, though, if Ser Alliser actually knew about Jon's real parentage, would he actually care for Jon? Seeing as Jon was still half Stark, and Ser Alliser loathed them all.

    • @MrSam1804
      @MrSam1804 Год назад +5

      @@perra7749 I believe, if assume he'd believe that, he would switch and support Jon, the kind of people like him are loyal to what they believe it, right or wrong.

  • @saradhiv3467
    @saradhiv3467 Год назад +36

    Jon had brilliant hype men around him. First Samwell and then the Onion Knight Davos.

  • @wisepalaz
    @wisepalaz Год назад +46

    Jon to Sam: "Just stop it! She's my Queen!"

  • @Freddyfrm18
    @Freddyfrm18 11 дней назад +2

    I love that Master Aemon laughed when Sam was talking about Sir Janos cowering with Gilly and baby Sam 😂😂😂

  • @laker_fanatic3985
    @laker_fanatic3985 8 месяцев назад +11

    Sam is one hell of a hype man

  • @skyserf
    @skyserf Год назад +192

    Jon should have been King.

    • @realBatman-89
      @realBatman-89 Год назад +11

      We'll see how they can salvage the character with the new series

    • @MrJayson204
      @MrJayson204 Год назад +9

      He dun wanit

    • @aryansingh1525
      @aryansingh1525 Год назад

      @@realBatman-89 hope he invades King's Landing and beheads Bran the Broken motherf*cker

    • @sebiieex
      @sebiieex Год назад +6

      @@realBatman-89 I have faith the prophecy will come true with the new show. i’m hoping the true threat wasn’t the night king

    • @gx_y3540
      @gx_y3540 Год назад

      @@realBatman-89 new series??

  • @dr.wolinsbelt
    @dr.wolinsbelt Месяц назад +5

    1:51 Maester Aemon approves of that sick burn.

    • @cadengericke5652
      @cadengericke5652 4 дня назад

      Master Aemon is such a good character in the show

  • @datemasamune2904
    @datemasamune2904 2 месяца назад +3

    “Maester, you already voted.”
    Aemon: It’s already in there. Nothing I can do.

  • @RealCheemsJr.
    @RealCheemsJr. Год назад +224

    In the books it was a landslide for Jon and he wasn't even present for the vote lol.

    • @SantomPh
      @SantomPh Год назад +29

      Ser Dennys also gave his votes to Jon

    • @sbvish2000
      @sbvish2000 Год назад +11

      For on screen drama lol

    • @Daydy377
      @Daydy377 Год назад +6

      That explains his silence

    • @gsd1922
      @gsd1922 Год назад

      Where was he?

    • @yoda9256
      @yoda9256 3 месяца назад +4

      @@gsd1922out beyond the wall reuniting with Ghost and contemplating whether to take over Winterfell or not

  • @sebiieex
    @sebiieex Год назад +178

    i hate that jon wasn’t in a position of power for long. he was the lord commander for a season. half of his stint was spent on the mission to hardhome. when he was king in the north it was for a season, most of it was spent on dragon stone. hopefully we see more in the Snow series.

    • @GhANeC
      @GhANeC Год назад +1

      Snow series?

    • @sebiieex
      @sebiieex Год назад

      @@GhANeC pretty self explanatory

    • @flybeep1661
      @flybeep1661 4 месяца назад

      @@sebiieex No, pretty dumb because there's not much heard of it and is likely never going to happen. You just can't say much about because you also know fuck about it. Nothing self explanatory about it you muppet.

    • @preds43
      @preds43 29 дней назад

      ...I've got bad news

  • @77chotu77
    @77chotu77 Год назад +20

    Alliser Thorne is actually a Targeryan loyalist...
    Wonder how he would have reacted had he known Jon is a Targeryan and heir to the throne...

    • @elplagas3279
      @elplagas3279 Месяц назад +2

      He probably wouldn't believe it, even if Sam showed evidence. His hatred for Jon would blind him just like his hatred for wildings

  • @SkepticalChris
    @SkepticalChris 3 месяца назад +3

    considering the size of the room, its amazing anyone could even hear Sam speak when he gave his monologue

  • @danterik9781
    @danterik9781 9 месяцев назад +9

    Man he should have left Denys Mallister in command when he went for Hardhome and took Thorne with him.
    Just imagining Thornes reaction to the undead army and the even larger army of wildlings that all joined the undead in a few minutes just has to turn his brain upside down. Maybe he would wonder and think ''why would Bran the Builder Stark build a 200m tall, 500km long and 100m thick Wall to keep out regular PEOPLE!?!?''
    Ignorance is wild

    • @BatmanHQYT
      @BatmanHQYT 11 дней назад

      I would've fucking loved to see that.

  • @christopherfoley8322
    @christopherfoley8322 Год назад +61

    I wish they would have shown Samwell doing his political wheeling and dealing like it was in the book, the way he got two of the other candidates who hated each other, vote for Jon Snow because they both didn't like Thorne. Samwell was at his best in this part of the book, and they only show a small fraction of it.

    • @madelinegarber7860
      @madelinegarber7860 9 месяцев назад +2

      Oh totally agreed. It was great. And Mormont’s raven.

    • @certifiedredditgenius
      @certifiedredditgenius 7 месяцев назад +4

      Looking for this comment because great as this scene was, the books did it so much better, showing that Sam is intelligent and knows how to play the game. Also, Jon had no idea that Sam was going to make him Lord Commander until it happened. I also liked how there was wayyyy more candidates and it drug out over many days, with many more brothers changing their votes as candidates were removed.

    • @christopherfoley8322
      @christopherfoley8322 7 месяцев назад +1

      @@certifiedredditgenius exactly, Sam might not have been a good soldier, but he would have been great getting the houses of the North and Riverlands to come to Jon's aid if he wasn't sent away to become a maester.Its a shame his father just looks past him. I dont think he needed to send Samwell to the wall, i'm sure he would have stepped aside for his brother and would have made an excellent advisor for his brother

    • @certifiedredditgenius
      @certifiedredditgenius 7 месяцев назад

      @@christopherfoley8322 Logically, you're right, it doesn't make sense. But it adds to Randyll Tarley's character that he did. A no nonsense guy who only places value in strength. Also, I think GRRM just didn't want Sam around when Jon died because logically Sam would also have to die.
      Tbh, it sucks that the whole series wasn't finished when D&D got their hands on it because GRRM is such a master storyteller and his books, unchanged and put to film, would truly have been a work of the century.
      Can't wait till Winds comes out

    • @ishmaelkhaled
      @ishmaelkhaled 5 месяцев назад

      ​@@certifiedredditgenius⁰
      😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊

  • @srulys1747
    @srulys1747 Год назад +39

    Shame maester Aemon didn’t vote for Denys Mallister, i was rooting for him

  • @___yeeshu___
    @___yeeshu___ Год назад +1

    Thanks for this clip....

  • @officialthomasjames
    @officialthomasjames Год назад +9

    Sam’s speech is all time.

  • @fanxingkong3409
    @fanxingkong3409 Год назад +5

    What a speech by Sam!

  • @stuffsackstacked
    @stuffsackstacked Месяц назад +12

    I LOVE how not 1 single man questioned Janos hiding and wetting his pants😂😂

  • @iloveads123
    @iloveads123 Год назад +19

    Aemon is the great grand uncle of Jon and he had the decisive vote
    Nepotism.....

    • @SantomPh
      @SantomPh Год назад +1

      Aemon didn't know Jon at all, get off your fake high horse

    • @iloveads123
      @iloveads123 Год назад +12

      @@SantomPh here's an animal who doesn't understand sarcarsm:

    • @SoupSultan
      @SoupSultan Год назад

      @@SantomPhit’s a joke you goof

    • @chandankumarchand6686
      @chandankumarchand6686 Год назад +3

      @@SantomPh dude it's a roast 🤣🤣

  • @Prashantsingh-zi7yu
    @Prashantsingh-zi7yu Год назад +7

    One of the best scene of GOT❤

  • @johndaman6322
    @johndaman6322 Год назад +7

    Look how Oliver was happy XD The Irony !

  • @TheStudderman
    @TheStudderman 9 месяцев назад +3

    Im surprised Thorn didnt start shouting, “This election was rigged, I wont except it”

  • @janzalud216
    @janzalud216 11 месяцев назад +5

    man that was some story. glory days of GOT.

  • @Seb_geek.9
    @Seb_geek.9 Год назад +20

    How different things would’ve been if aemon had been king instead of his brother.

  • @evanmcdonald9134
    @evanmcdonald9134 23 дня назад +1

    Sam manipulated the vote pretty hard in the book. They had voted for 10 days in a row and nobody had gotten 2/3 of the vote (the amount needed to win) and Stannis told them they were being forced to vote that night once and for all. Sam went the day before and lied to both the men who were in the lead (there were 4 real contenders) and told them that Stannis was going to support their rival (each other) if they didn’t get 2/3s that day and that they could pull their support to Jon instead. He also trained all the ravens to say “Snow” like Lord commander Mormonts raven used to and put one in the kettle which was being used to count the votes. When they took the top off of the kettle, it landed on Jon’s shoulder and squawked snow a bunch of times kinda as a seal of legitimacy.
    All in all it was politicking as politicking tends to be, but it definitely involved a lot of subversion and lying unlike the show where he was elected more off of his full merit for the position

  • @ShaunHopkinsAVFC
    @ShaunHopkinsAVFC 7 дней назад

    Took real guts for Sam to handle that the way he did. Underrated

  • @prototypetwo4042
    @prototypetwo4042 9 месяцев назад +17

    Heartbreaking to know a lot of those men ended up regretting their choice later on, even though it was absolutely the right one to go with.

  • @derekb1605
    @derekb1605 6 месяцев назад +3

    The wire... Game of thrones.. the sopranos... Martin... Greatest shows ever!!!

  • @brian1923
    @brian1923 Год назад +42

    This scene is as close as gets to the book being the script for the show. The dialogue and the order of scenes are almost identical to the book.

    • @jdeck7803
      @jdeck7803 Год назад +11

      Not at all. Sam's scheming is omitted completely.

    • @sachin251998
      @sachin251998 11 месяцев назад +1

      Jon wins the vote by a landslide in the books.

    • @Arcanomist
      @Arcanomist 11 месяцев назад +7

      It's not really accurate as it could've been from the book.
      -No Sam scheme
      -Aliser spoke in favor of janos NOT the other way around
      - Mormonts Raven sat on Jon's shoulder too

  • @laboheme4395
    @laboheme4395 8 месяцев назад +1

    I need to re watched GOT again

  • @akshaysudhi8706
    @akshaysudhi8706 Год назад

    1:56 Sam the slayer truly!!! 😂

  • @markd9318
    @markd9318 Год назад +18

    He also became the simp lord of the north

  • @TheEnergizer94
    @TheEnergizer94 2 месяца назад +2

    3:50 what a waste of a perfectly suitable vase

  • @2amBreakfast
    @2amBreakfast 6 дней назад

    This is a huge moment for Samwell Tarly. He started out a coward but it took courage to speak up at this moment - not only to nominate Jon but also to roast the fuck out of Janos Slynt.
    What a character arc. He starts out a pathetic wimp with no backbone. By the end, he's slaying white walkers, dissing the former commander of the King's Landing city watch for pissing himself, and making some pretty decent contributions to the war against the dead.

  • @user-gu9mf6kz8b
    @user-gu9mf6kz8b 18 дней назад

    The Nobel Prize in Westeros should have been given to Measter Aemon. Incredible character. Also, everyone was waiting for Sam to nominate Jon.

  • @timhinfort1171
    @timhinfort1171 Год назад +7

    I Always forget that Sir Allister speaks after Sam. And even though He hates John from his point of view he makes a good point.

  • @Kriegerdammerung
    @Kriegerdammerung 9 месяцев назад

    If the tokens were Thorne-Snow-Mallister, the votes would have been 28-30-10. Not only there was no "tie" but maestre Aemon even gave Jon an extra vote. :/

  • @ms.t3286
    @ms.t3286 11 месяцев назад +4

    2:35 He's the Commander we turn to when the night is darkest😌

  • @paulsmith-ll9vg
    @paulsmith-ll9vg 9 месяцев назад +3

    when your jon snow, and you go and meet the wildlings, and not only is this bravery beyond compare, and especially as since the dawn of time everyone in the north has no doubt been telling everyone about how these savage people can never be tamed or approached if you value your life, and yet not only did jon snow meet them and find a place among them, and all without losing his head from his body, he also fell in love with one of them. and if you too are in the presence of a red headed she devil who both wants to kill you, and take you to her bed, and yet you survive, and this is no doubt another reason why jon snow is a great man, and would be the only choice to be the next lord commander.

  • @gook5219
    @gook5219 2 месяца назад

    Jon: I don't want it. Ser Allistar is muh commanduh

  • @samuelakpan103
    @samuelakpan103 День назад

    Sam was part of Jon destiny’s. A key element of the prophecy foretold.

  • @jaradkureshi1763
    @jaradkureshi1763 11 месяцев назад

    Samwell Tarlys interruption made him the Lord Commander of the Nightswatch!!

  • @Kermodo
    @Kermodo 2 месяца назад

    I liked how this transpired in the books a little more

  • @freeloaderuser6793
    @freeloaderuser6793 Год назад +6

    Gods the writing was good then. Sam really carried the team lol

  • @omaratilanos
    @omaratilanos Месяц назад +1

    Dennis Mallister: The Ross Perot of Castle Black 😬

  • @Crusher888
    @Crusher888 Год назад +9

    I wonder why all original Got scenes were deleted

  • @bewarethechameleon
    @bewarethechameleon 2 месяца назад

    how to make something as mundane as voting and politics into such an exciting and emotional scene is truly mind blowing

    • @BatmanHQYT
      @BatmanHQYT 11 дней назад

      I take it you've never watched a political drama?

  • @j.k.ravshanovich
    @j.k.ravshanovich Год назад +8

    Season 8 still breaks my heart

    • @soccerplyr8
      @soccerplyr8 Год назад

      I'm not sure how any of the actors didn't speak up during the script reading. Like it's the last season they can't do much even if you do speak out against the script. Still need to act out your scenes. Actors should have stood together for a better script.

    • @Novabunny_
      @Novabunny_ 9 месяцев назад

      So many things broke my heart that year…😔

    • @gook5219
      @gook5219 2 месяца назад

      It boils my blood

  • @rebuttalc2075
    @rebuttalc2075 10 месяцев назад

    Kept his enemies closer

  • @bigbob1699
    @bigbob1699 Год назад +5

    In the book, Sam was great in getting Jon elected.

  • @Carl96739
    @Carl96739 3 месяца назад

    Look at the comparison in the writing in this scene compared to the last two seasons.

  • @anyamazing7619
    @anyamazing7619 Год назад +2

    JON!! JON!! JON!!

  • @Real-Ruby-Red
    @Real-Ruby-Red 2 месяца назад

    Sam standing up for himself was the turnaround point for sam for me.

  • @samxyx
    @samxyx Год назад +4

    Who knew the Night's Watch invented democracy?

  • @achabotte
    @achabotte 6 месяцев назад

    Jon Snow drank that glass empty a good 3 times in this clip.

  • @jonathanfourten9556
    @jonathanfourten9556 Месяц назад +2

    the biggest upset for me in this scene, was the way they broke the clay pot the votes were in. the votes went in easy enough, they wouldve come out just as easily.....why break the damn pot??!! when will we find out what ever happened with the shards...were they reassembled? were they thrown out? COME on!

  • @muslimbrotherhood8
    @muslimbrotherhood8 Год назад +2

    two Targeryans at the edge of Westeros................. the conqueror would have been proud

  • @slipperyjohnson7016
    @slipperyjohnson7016 9 месяцев назад

    I feel like they could have just dumped them out! lol

  • @ColonBurns
    @ColonBurns Год назад +2

    He was blind, he put it on the wrong one

  • @Mayeur000Donz
    @Mayeur000Donz Месяц назад

    998th, huh?
    George is either planning something big for the 1k Captain, or it's gonna be an ironic move, and it's a scarecrow or something.

  • @NeilFraser
    @NeilFraser Год назад +37

    The "first past the post" voting system doesn't work for more than two candidates. They should have eliminated the third-place candidate and revoted.

    • @SantomPh
      @SantomPh Год назад +17

      In the books Ser Denys gives Jon his vote, which swings the election totally against Ser Alliser. Jon doesn't even realize he was a candidate

    • @bunglewungle261
      @bunglewungle261 Год назад +1

      First past the post voting is stupid anyway. Everyone voted, one got more votes, that's all that matters.

    • @SantomPh
      @SantomPh Год назад +1

      @@bunglewungle261 you are explaining exactly what FPTP means lol

  • @jakarhess7129
    @jakarhess7129 9 месяцев назад

    Season 8 Jon wouldnt have smiled.

  • @gavinbarnum9458
    @gavinbarnum9458 Год назад +3

    Ser Denys Mallister let's goo

  • @unclejimmymedia
    @unclejimmymedia 8 месяцев назад

    Sam’s come back was epic!!

  • @authenticopinions401
    @authenticopinions401 Год назад +2

    The Lord Cammanda!

    • @devanov3103
      @devanov3103 25 дней назад

      Not to forget "DA KINGINANORF!"

  • @ccink3931
    @ccink3931 11 месяцев назад +2

    3:30 still cant understand wtf this was lol why break it? Just flip it upside down 😂

  • @rohanpadile6678
    @rohanpadile6678 9 месяцев назад +1

    targaryen helping targaryen!!

  • @Gratios
    @Gratios 11 месяцев назад +1

    Always bet on family😂

  • @sahidsk1013
    @sahidsk1013 6 месяцев назад

    only if sir alester knew whi jhon really was , he would have himself started the march to the kings landing

  • @damianwang4991
    @damianwang4991 3 месяца назад

    It's actually way more impressive that he won when you consider that aside from Sam, all of his friends on the Night's Watch are dead.

  • @wandersonfrancisco8494
    @wandersonfrancisco8494 Год назад

    Good times...

  • @scottmatheson3346
    @scottmatheson3346 8 месяцев назад +1

    4:06 stop the count!

  • @RobertClolery
    @RobertClolery Месяц назад

    In the book, Sam pulled all the right strings to get John elected.

  • @salsanacho
    @salsanacho 11 месяцев назад

    If Ser Denys Mallister wasn't a candidate, I wonder how many of those votes would be for Thorne vs Snow.

  • @user-pf9cq3dm2z
    @user-pf9cq3dm2z 7 часов назад

    It’s been a long time, but didn’t Commander Mormont’s raven shout out “Snow!” or something?

  • @rahulsrivastva5267
    @rahulsrivastva5267 3 месяца назад

    First seed of democracy

  • @amandahedwig1333
    @amandahedwig1333 8 месяцев назад

    They didn't chose him like this in the books. I read that scene atleast five times.... They chose John in absentia. He came back to find he's been chosen while he was battling with the decision of going to be King in the north by stannis baratheon's order. Asaaaaaaargh, this is so annoying...

  • @michaelhofer7536
    @michaelhofer7536 5 месяцев назад

    Samwel tarly prime

  • @birdbangbobaruni
    @birdbangbobaruni 11 месяцев назад

    Her name is Gilly

  • @rajupetasaikiran7984
    @rajupetasaikiran7984 9 дней назад

    ned would be proud of jon!!!!

  • @colin8696908
    @colin8696908 11 месяцев назад

    they talk like they are brothers but Jon eventually kills both opposition leaders.