Kurt-Lee Arendse HORRIFIC Aerial Challenge On Beauden Barrett | South Africa vs All Blacks 2022
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 30 сен 2024
- This was another horrible incident in the game just like the Faf de Klerk head injury, this one was worse because it was just a stupid challenge by Kurt-Lee Arendse that could've resulted in serious injury to Beauden Barrett. I have no idea what he was thinking as he had absolutely no chance to get the ball. I know Kurt-Lee Arendse is not a dirty player, but he needs to be suspended for multiple weeks for this. Stuff like this is what red cards are for, not accidental head clashes.
I also have to give props to the ref and tmo for handling this perfectly. It was quick and decisive, they did not need to see 10 minutes of replays to come to the conclusion that this was a red card. They deal with it instantly.
But more importantly, it seems that both players seemed to be okay after going off the field. This could've easily been a lot worse for both players. Let's hope they make a fast and healthy recovery. 
Спорт
It was scary to see B.Barrett landed on his neck. Hope the two players are alright now.
Yip..speedy recovery to both...
Hopefully Arendse learns from this and doesnt do it again. Very reckless and just cant do that. He did it twice during this game and Barrett was lucky, could have been much worse. Glad he's alright.
He's a young lad motivated and pure adrenaline he will learn and get better great to see both players 👍 ok
@@jacksingh4033 deserves his match ban hope that motivates him to learn how to play in Arial situations
Listen springboks are playing great rugby remminnest in mid 90s but better great captain and a great young hungry team future bolds well
@@jacksingh4033 um okay, nothing to do with the video but okay
@@jacksingh4033 ?
The way he landed made me gasp
Ag man it wasn't that bad
Everyone in the bar I was in gasped, was nasty.
@@timeundertension1823 crackhead comment
Yoh in the bar I was in as well. People had their hands on their heads and were gasping as well.
@@timeundertension1823 it was bad
Arendse making illegal contact in the air at these three times during the game and getting away with it. Playing possum when he realized his reckless play had done damage. Had he been warned on the first, he wouldn't have been able to continue. Never had an idea of where the ball was on each occasion, head always down at contact.
Exactly! The Boks first try came with Arendse doing similar tricks, just not as flagrant in the first half, but violations nonetheless.
Your just jealous because the Springboks are acctually winning new zealand
@@thrillingboys2062 Haha, yeah when you are willing to break the rules where ever you can to win , doesn't exactly reflect a competent team.
@@wearetruth7116 what about the goat of cheating mr Sir useless Richie Macaw. Only reason he was any good is because he was a cheating scumbag that got away with it. How does it feel to have the shoe in the other foot eh???
Huh. Sounds like Mealamu and Umaga back in their day, so fair play.
Fair play to both teams for realising the seriousness of the situation and keeping everything calm and focused on the injured players, the aftermath could have turned ugly in a heartbeat especially when you factor in the score and the time remaining, NZ could have easily decided that they had more chance winning a fight than they did winning the match but they kept their cool as did the Boks. Absolutely horrendous challenge but classy reactions from both sides
Lots of respect between All Blacks and Springboks players. Even when they go earn big bucks in Europe, the Kiwi's and Saffas stick together.
Boks should've just pulled a play from the Graham Henry playbook and told them to stop whining and carry on.
Well, Arendse deserves suspension even though that was just a mistake as South Africans we had to approve the Red card
Mistake yes, therefore reckless. His suspension should be at minimum 3 months. The speed he hits the defending player is atrocious.
He needs to learn the dangers of tackling reckless like that
Could have killed BB .
@@lonelyspyro2124 3 months !!! Nah, that's too much. This was accidental. Reckless yes, but accidental.
NAI you laf only a few games max
@@thej-man4283 he literally could have killed Barrett with a horrible reckless challenge. If he wasn't a man of his stature and new to international rugby people would be calling for his head. This merits a long suspension. 3 months is appropriate.
I really hope BB is ok, as that was one of the scariest falls I've seen in a match. Similar to that one Willie Le Roux took a while ago.
He should have been off at the 10 minute mark as he had no chance of catching that high ball either. In fact he flew past the ball on that occasion. Just as dangerous and reckless.
Yes he did a similar thing in the first half to Jordie Barrett. Very reckless and dangerous.
Exactly! Thank you! It wasn't as flagrant, but a violation just the same!!
well no, the first one, he did what any player does, he tried to go for the ball and disrupt the player. AB's do it Aussie do it England do it, but here you complain that a South African has done it, and now it's a problem. if that's the way you want to play it, ban all players from jumping to go for the ball. but don't whine just because a South African player did it, don't see any comments like this on other games where other players do the same thing. funny that?
@@Ghoulza I disagree, so do SA referees! From their website:
Illegal actions
· A player jumps without really contesting for the ball. For instance, he is jumping into the player who is trying to catch the ball mainly to disrupt the reception of the ball.
· A player is not really contesting for the ball. For instance, he is running into the player who is trying to catch the ball mainly to disrupt the reception of the ball.
So clearly Ardense's act in the 10th minute was illegal.
So, yes, I'm having a whine, justly so, as your Refs agree with me!
@@fidget2020 well if you actually watch you'd see he made an attempt to contest the ball. Ie legal as per the paragraph you referenced. Seriously if you going to try make a point actually know what it is and how it works before posting or you just look like a twit
Almost ruined one of our best players Life, neck breaks can be life changing. Very foolish move when you already wining the game too no need for that crazy gymnastics
very bad and I hope he's better now
I'm a South African but that was very wrong
I really hope both of them are fine including faf at the beginning, as a South African that is a clear red no questions ask. Kurt Lee is a star in the making
I have no issues with the red card and we are lucky that there are no serious injuries as far as I am aware. However in the context of rugby I think it is a farce. How do you decide that you are now pulling out of contesting the high ball. You are running towards the contact point and your eyes are on the ball, if you are not watching the ball you will not be able to catch it so the challenging player is in a no win situation if anything goes wrong. In my opinion either ban the up and under totally or bring in the rule that it must at least go 40m to minimize the risk of incidents like these. As a side note - one of the better ref and TMO combinations I have seen for quite awhile, clear and decisive decisions and instructions clearly communicated to the players.
He didn't jump, if he genuinely thought he had a chance of catching the ball, they would've collided together in the air. But they didn't, Ardense didn't jump, therefore he didn't contest for the ball and was in no position to catch it. What you should do if you don't think you'll get there in time is to slow down, let them land and make a dominant hit just after they land.
@@fergusoh5092 exactly. If he looked up and jumped this wouldn’t be anything
He jumped for the sake of jumping with his running momentum.. anyone jumping for contention would have matched the height of the opposing jumping player.. which isn’t his fault, he’s just not an aerial cognitive player, that comes with experience..
I agree on the ban of the up and under. Will force more running rugby. The red cards will never end otherwise.
He did push it too far. He should know to back off a second or two earlier; he is playing at top level
As an All blacks fan I will say it seemed Arendse was looking at the ball until the last moment when he saw Barret's Body looming in front of his head and he threw his arms up in instinctual self-defense. Just like knock-ons or bad passes even the best players in the world will occasionally misjudge time and space and mess up their tackles or kick chases. See Ta'avao vs. Ireland in test match 2 this year.
These incidents may need to go heavily punished with red cards so players take extreme caution to avoid unsafe incidents, even if it means not contesting kicks properly, in the case of Arendse, or missing tackles completely, in the case of Ta'avao.
But these errors which are minor in physical margin, if not in the results highlight how critical the 20-minute red card rule is. If this had happened in the first 5 minutes under IRB rules the All blacks may have won the game, and anyone who watched the game today could tell you that would have been an unfair punishment for one member of a team getting to a spot and jumping half a second later than his opponent.
Finally someone who is not a casual you are doing the Lord's work man and I'm 100% agreeing with you cause it annoys me how people expect international players to play this fast paced game while their tired and when they make a mistake which is not protecting their opposition they get punished heavily for it
He also did a similar act on Jordie earlier in the match that he got away with.
I agree with the "20min and a sub can come" on red cards for these and the accidental head contact incidents, while keeping straight red for malicious actions.
It is in the interest of the game and competition as well as attempting to look after the safety of the players.
I agree to a point. 20mins reds I think are good for accidental stuff, but this tackle is straight red all day and it deserves to be the entire game if it happens in the 5th minute.
Barrett could easily be a quadriplegic after that. A red card is nothing compared to what could of been.
Doesn't matter. You're on the ground, you must bear responsibiliy since you're the player with solid ground under your feet and the ability to control yourself. The ball was won by Barrett and he was taken out, maybe not maliciously, but certainly recklessly by 14 Green.
ALL reckless acts on the field are sanctioned by a red card under Law 9.11 of World Rugby's "The Laws Of the Game".
He makes no attemp to catch the ball, just the man and hit him with hes knee
Looked cynical
It was a definite red and careless. However, I really, really don't believe this one was malicious. It was a young player, wet behind the ears with regards to international rugby, making a mistake. (*Edit - a huge mistake. Watching that again, that was so close to potential paralysis. I don't think anyone could make Arendse feel worse than he already does. Horrible.)
I hope Barrett is alright. So nasty to watch.
Arendse is definitely not a dirty player. But it was a bad mistake that could've resulted in a very serious injury. So I think he should get a suspension as well. I definitely don't think Arendse had malicious intent, but it was just a bad decision whereas earlier in the game he made some great aerial challenges. This was was just misjudged and he should be punished. That is the risk you take.
@@tasanalytics Yeah dude - I'm inclined to agree. I just hope that this doesn't set him back in the eyes of the selectors and he has to wait an age before donning the jersey again. He had an awesome game barring this - so much better than the second Welsh test. Much more proactive than Kolbe had been.
@@tasanalytics as a Springbok supporter I agree, nothing malicious but deserves punishment, it is a challenge we are going to face with our style of play but fair enough
As a Bok supporter I agree. In that situation, if you are not, and cannot be, 100% committed to going for the ball, it’s best to slow down and let the other player get the ball. Then carry on from there. If you are 100% committed, and things go south, then it’s an incident. If not committed, and you try to back out in the middle with that close-your-eyes-and-hope-for-the-best-brace fashion, and take your opponent out like this, then a red card is the best possible outcome.
Agreed but very dangerous and reckless, could of made him paralyzed
I get the feeling Arendse will get a huge ban for this and will be held up by world rugby to make an example. Not excusing it at all just saying, we'll see what happens in the disciplinary committee
You right. World Rugby always make an example of a Bok player to perpetuate the impression that Bok players are dirty players. This incident is a red card all day and maybe a few games suspension. But this is his first so i dont think it will be that harsh.
More bans for the violent boks please. Let's make a real example of them and bring the hammer down on their incessant violent, dangerous, cynical play.
@@bodhid Hopefully they are even more violent towards the All Blacks this weekend .
Nothing wrong with him....he knew he was in the wrong, that's why he stayed down.... definitely a suspension
I agree. I see it happen in football so often when a player takes a key player like Barrett out, they act all injured to lessen the guilt.
But I call bull shit on that.
He led in with his shoulders on Barrett, not with his arms outstretched to catch the ball.
Cynical play and cynical play acting afterwards.
Suspension.
Nah, the slow mo looked like the impact was pretty hard on him too, plus the fall, confirmed after the game that he suffered a concussion, and is also suspended for 4 weeks.
@@Mad_Intellect thanks for that I stand corrected. Well I hate to see him get injured but he definitely deserves a suspension for his recklessness.
Very dangerous play by Arendse that could have resulted in serious injury to both players. Broken neck, serious concussion, broken back, broken collarbone, you name it. He did a similar thing to Jordie Barrett in the first half when he had no chance to catch the ball but collided with the defending player. He deserves a few weeks suspension, but given World Rugby's inconsistency at the judiciary lately in the England v Australia and Ireland v New Zealand series with numerous mistakes made, who knows what will happen.
Careless challenges against a player in the air are serious, potentially lethal. Refs are far too lenient about this... Compare how they (rightly) penalize relatively slight contact in the air at line outs.
Agreed Paul. Players get cited and receive bans for no arms tackling that results in shoulder to head contact , which are dangerous and can cause concussion but this could’ve paralysed Barrett and the only punishment received is being sent off.
@@jamespilcher2231 a Red is the Maximum a Ref can dish out on the Field !
he did everything by the Book.
the Citing Committee afterwards
actually gave him a Suspension !
and rightly so !
May I also add, I was impressed by the immediate concern shown by the ABs for the SA player, even though he was at fault and one of their team was badly hurt.
That was frightening. Really bad from Arendse
Dom poes maak
If Barnes had reffed this game, it would have been ruled an absorbing collision and he would only have given a yellow card ;-P
Oh I see what you did there ;)
Omfg. An absorbing tackle. Haha... unbelievable.
Actually Barnes may have given Barret a red card too for making direct contact with Arendse's head :-D
Man he could have been paralysed from that kind of fall. The offender should be banned for a few games for that.
Oh? Not just a tackling class like the NZ prop did?
Why tf would you ban him for an accident? When your rules allow players to jump and contest high balls
@@BigBroKuma the south african player was in no clear position to catch that ball so he shoulve pulled out. thats the rules.
Man,the boks could have flogged the ABs, maybe we should ban them for a couple of weeks
@@BigBroKuma He was never in the position to catch that ball and he is lucky that it didn't turn nastier for barrett. He will be punished quite rightly.
Clear red card. And if you look at his arial battles for the evening there was never a clear indication that he went for the ball
there was in the beginning you see he has his eyes on the ball go look at it again 🙄
This is the kind of player that has NO place in rugby, this kind of player needs to go. BAN
Oh keep your nappy clean..I've seen way worse than this
Is your name really Horace..shame boet
@@sakabula2357 lol you're funny... is your name really sakabula? Hahahahahahaha
@@horacehhelmsley9375 No its not
@@horacehhelmsley9375 is your name really Horace
@@horacehhelmsley9375 Are you related to Prince Andrew?
Yeah, that was a clear red card
Nope. Looked clean to me.
One of the things I noticed in their last two meets…they charge in on a high ball recklessly, was only a matter of time
Just saying
Fuc that's the worst I've seen. He should be out for the whole season. Barrett could of had his neck broken on that fall.
Poor nz supporters nothing in it wasn't accidental
@@mathewrichards7309 nice one Karen.
Yes but using that logic we could say Caleb Clarke should be out for the season for a knee in DeKlerk's face. Arendse, Van Der Merwe and Kolbe are not big tall guys - its dead easy for them to end up under someone. You have to consider all the circumstances. Rugby in the Cape Flats is about skill - not hurting people.
@@bunnychowmuncher lol that makes no sense. De-Klerk put his head into the wrong position got himself knocked out lol.. Ardense is coming in off the wing to contest for the high ball but doesn't end up contesting and basically takes Beauden out in the air! One is and accident the other is deliberate! In saying that I don't agree with Ardense having to sit out the rest of the season but he will probably miss 5 weeks max?! might get back before the Northern tour?!
Jordie Barrett did the same thing last year either against Aus or Argentina and didn't even get sighted. Looks like it matters only when it's against a NZ player.
Beauden barrett is hard!! Most players would be lying on the ground for 20 mins after that! He was up after 5 min! 😉
That’s because he wasn’t faking it unlike the other guy
@@peteturner4427 the other guy hit his head against the Barret's hip. He was out cold. Clearly not faking it
@@chrr7139 cool so it will be a 3 week stand down for a phantom concussion and then a 26 week ban for the hit on BB.
@@number8962 all I said was that he wasn't faking it, I know what he did should result in a ban
Under the current laws a horrendous challenge and an awful outcome for both players.
The cure is simple - change the law and make it illegal of any player to leave the ground in fielding a kick. Defending or attacking player. It is that simple.
Eventually everything will be illegal under your logic. So what's the point of rugby? Scrap all the new rules and bring back one, dangerous play. Referee decides and not hamstrung by words.
I'm trying to find an objection to this modification, but I can't. It would be less of a spectacle but far safer and still allow for a contest. Good idea.
@@robinclarke9978 The game of Rugby is a game played on the ground with the ball in hand.
It is not a game of aerial ping pong.
Make leaving the ground to field a kick illegal (PLAYER SAFETY) bring back a ground level only call of "MARK" and then from the resulting kick to touch (if the kick is to touch) award the lineout to the kicking side.
This will eradicate mindless kicking from the the game and bring back running rugby. Running rugby - the point of the game.
The only problem with the suggestion is that you're making it impossible for a smaller or shorter player. You will have to be tall to play behind the line catching bombs
@@matt4148 Reed my reply to Robin Clarke.
When you remove entirely every single reward for kicking (attacking kicking) you will bring back smaller, attacking running full backs- Percy Montgomery , Christian Cullen, Andre Joubert and Damien McKenzie of more recent times.
Very bad from Arendse, should've waited for Barret to land.
yes it was an awesome chase (kick is only as good as the chase) timing his hit as Barret landed would have been the better option. Maybe he will learn from that, such a great player
He's a rookie plus he thought he could contest and misjudged Barrett's position as his eyes were on the ball just rewatch the clip and look at where he is looking its bad but let's not act like this isn't a rookie that made a mistake
@@BigBroKuma yeah true, should've let that one go 🤦🏾♂️
To excited his emotions took over him
Definitely intentional
Defo Red Card...but SA UTTERLY dominated All Blacks over 80 mins
Arendse was having a brilliant game until this moment, it's a shame. Hope him and Beauden are all okay after this! 🙏🏼
He was throwing himself carelessly the whole game. He had it coming
@@aripapa4794 Like the Blitzbokke he is way smaller than his opponents. These guys don't try and take people out. Rugby in the Cape Flats is all about looking for gaps and seeking to pass. Its not hard hit stuff.
@@bunnychowmuncher Did you even watch the game😂😂 Every time the ball was up he jumped carelessly. Take a look at the injury replay, he didn't even have his eyes on the ball
@@aripapa4794 Oh please man - these wings from the Cape Flats are like 75kg.
Maybe that is why your rugby is in decline.
Last week in the Commonwealth games these guys drove Fiji back like Italian tanks and the Fijians were twice their size.
Maybe you should start focusing on supporting your soccer team. This is clearly becoming R rated viewing for you. This is like us complaining about being manhandled by Damien McKenzie - its laughable.
@@aripapa4794 So Caleb Clarke was marking Arendse and he was too much to handle for Clarke? LOL Ok then
Clarke "Hey Curtly please go easy on me - all 78kg of you - I'm the guy who has the socks with the vertical stripes. I'll give you a 100 bucks if you don't hurt me"
Clarke took out DeKlerk with his knee - you don't see us making a big deal out of it.
You've clearly become soft and whiney since we left Super Rugby. Thats for sure.
DeKlerk was out greeting everyone afterwards.
It was a really horrific timing on the contest so no arguments on the red card there
I’d love to know what Ardie Savea said to the ref
Yeah, me too - pretty strong reaction from the ref.
He should get 10 weeks..
And Angus Gardner should get an uppercut.
Serious payoff for Arendse, 4 week holiday and he's taken out the ABs only weapon for next week!
If your eyes are kept on the ball at high speed, its not easy to stop nor do you see whats infront when looking at the ball... So im sorry to say but i can understand why he made the accident and so bumps Barret in the air..
Barret made a full recovery and will be playing this weekend.
Was a horrible incident see two all blacks players went to the springbok player to vent their anger then immediately they saw he was heavily injured also and then they check if he is also ok. Tough game but we want all players to be healthy afterwards also great win to the boks
That was ridiculous, he should get a 5 or 6 week suspension. Barrett could have been paralysed.
Poor nz supporter there was nothing in it
@@mathewrichards7309 Dropped as a child?
@@mathewrichards7309 The guy is a clown, albeit a brave clown. You can’t just run into every aerial contest without any thought for player safety. Barrett could have been paralysed, one day someone will be from a similar incident. He will be suspended…….no doubt about it. I suggest you grow up,and learn something about the game.
@@mathewrichards7309 Your dad should have pulled out
I don't think it was intentional or malicious but so damn reckless and careless
This was inevitable. Im afraid its the result of SA over employing the kick and chase. Our guys are becoming the best at running at mach 1 and getting airborne under the high ball for the catch/tap back. Any kick thats a tad too deep will cause our backs to chase and jump even more desperately, leading to these incidents. The tactic works but this is a major risk. Refs will definitely be VERY alert and unforgiving after this incident.
This is the worst one I’ve ever seen
Then you probably don't watch a lot of rugby. There's been far worse, even though this is a horrible one
@@tiaanduplessis3189well clearly you know nothing at all.
You could see Arendse flying in - I just thought slow down as he came in closer! My worst thoughts happened and both players ended up in the worst possible situation. But that's the game these boys put their bodies into some scary positions.
As a Kiwi watching it was understandable why Kurt Lee jumped like that. He can really get up their but I think he realised he wasn’t gonna out jump Beauden and so he braced.
@@MRRBOKK think so too, he just came in way too fast, I don't think their was any malice. I hope theyre okay.
No malice whatsoever. But we did see lunatic recklessly trying to get a ball he was never going to get.
No malice, just stupidity. Be honest here, it’s stupidity. If you’re a wing at that national level, you should understand speed/momentum in contesting high balls better than any one of us couch potatoes. Nobody was standing in his way preventing him from ducking out. Instead he maintained speed. You can say he has eyes on the ball but literally it doesn’t take half a brain cell to know a box kick will be taken by the fb/fh standing at the back.
@@tywoods7234 I agree with you. He saw BB jumping. He could avoid the incident by swerving away
He played Barrett in the Air and acts like he was injured!
You really are empty upstairs ne??
There was nothing wrong with Arendse. He just laid low to avoid confrontation from ABs and ref. Empty upstairs yourself?
@@eamonnmcloughlin129 your argument shows me that you have nothing between your ears. Maybe watch netball instead. Cheers
@@JMouton Youre right. There is nothing between my ears. You must have virtual, x ray specs on to see that. I congratulate you sir.
Clearly was injured. Got his bell rung properly and was even hauled away in the stretcher cart iirc. Still no excuse for the awful play tho
That's just reckless man, poor Barrett, he landed hard 🤔 you can't take a man out by his legs while he is in the air, bad tackle
BB is my favorite player, but I do believe that the SA wing couldnt slow down and I think his reaction was a bit slow but I think he was jumping for the ball but realized he couldnt get up to barretts height
NO excuses ... his eyes were on the ball ... when BB came into his sight he does try to turn and avoid collision ... this has happened more than once over the forty plus years of rugby that I have watched .... I doubt any player deliberately tries to injure another .... its easy to sit on the side line and make comments ... you are not on the field .... now days the games are played at high speed ... just go back and check the footage ... in my opinion ... the new rules are the problem .... currently if a player jumps up they cannot be touched .... that is a risk the jumper is taking .... surely change the rule .... no jumping to get a high ball ... so what ... if the game slows down a few seconds ... less players would get hurt ...
Do we have any idea on the status of Arendse?
His okay.
How did u find out
Nothing wrong with him.
Classic tactic of staying on the floor when you’ve clearly been stupid and reckless.
@@Potters73 keyboard expert. Would love to see you get up after a shot like that.
@@Potters73 What a shite take Arendse failed the concussion protocol straight after, if you have watched some of the bad hits on Arendse in the past you will know he never stays down.
1. Look, it wasn't malicious, but it was a really stupid challenge. He was clearly in control of his actions. It didn't happen TO him. I'd expect a decent ban to send a clear message that dangerous stupidity, however accidental, won't be tolerated.
2. I reckon Ardie gave Angus a mouthful about how it could've been avoided if he'd "effing pinged Arendse in the 1st half" for his not dissimilar challenge on Jordie.
He was doing so well up until then. :(
Yes he was playing a great game.. Just young and very enthusiastic, nothing malicious!!!!
He did the same thing to Jordie Barrett in the 10 minute and didn't get pinged for it. He was fucking lucky is what he was.
Boohoo... Cry me a river😭😭😭😭
Barrett acknowledged that his teammates that were supposed to protect him DIDN'T DO THEIR JOB.
Look at Ginger taking photographs instead of protecting his teammate.
Yes, it was bad timing on Arendse's part, but share the blame when it's due.
There was an incident where Barrett kicked a Wallaby in the face when he jumped to catch a Gary Owen. Accidentally...yes, but accidents do happen.
Get over it 🤬🤬🤬
He nearly broke his neck mate, are you an idiot?
Definitely reckless at the highest level.
Arendse does not have my sympathy, he was reckless.
It's easy for someone who doesn't play the game to talk shit about a rookie who's adjusting to the speed of international Rugby and playing against one of the top 5 teams in the world
@@BigBroKuma top 10 lol
@@BigBroKuma how is he talking shit its the truth, Rookie or not.
Yeah you and you know better that's why you're in the team
Mike Tyson once said "everyone always has something to say until they get punch in the face."
Beginning to despise the way we play, all we play is brute force and it’s not the way, we got beat by England having a fresh team and we were reckless in that too. That move was just pure idiotic on our behalf. No wonder the rest of the world is starting to hate us
When you look at these in real time its hard for people to run different lines at the last second. Not malicious at all just like Caleb Clarke's knee happened to connect with Faf DeKlerk's head by mistake. In saying that though the red card was the right call. Arendse is not a malicious guy. Has played all his URC and other games for the Bulls in the spirit of the game.
I AGREE! ARENDSE IS NO A MALICIOUS PERSON. THE FAF INJURY WAS ON PURPOSE , THAT PLAYER LIFT HIS KNEE IN THE FACE OF FAF, HE SAW FAF COMING.!! IT IS A CONTACT SPORT AND THIS TYPE OF INJURIES CAN HAPPEN.
@@vjmightyw I disagree Caleb Clarke did not try hurt De Klerk. His knee met with DeKlerks head simply due to the way Faf fell.
When Caleb gets interviewed you can tell he is a nice genuine guy. His father Eroni was a great player and clean too.
We tend to forget that these guys are friends off the field. I think some people got a bit emotional over both incidents and neither was intentional in my opinion.
@@vjmightyw 😂😂what are you saying mate😂
Recklessness is ALWAYS a red card in rugby. Law 9.11 for reference. You'll find it on page 55 of the digital law book.
@@vjmightyw 🤣 do you really think that was intentional?
Wasnt in realistic position to catch the ball or attempt to catch it. didnt attempt to bring the opposing player down safely.
Red Card.
He jumped for the sake of jumping with his running momentum.. anyone jumping for contention would have matched the height of the opposing jumping player.. which isn’t his fault, he’s just not an aerial cognitive player, that comes with experience..
it's about protecting the player who is in the air no debate recognize the situation, re- position and re-adjust technique.
the SA player was never in a situation were he would of outjumped barrett, i know his eyes were fixed on the ball end of the day he made a bad decision and put beauden in a life changing situation was a poor read, lack of judgement and care from the SA player it's a red card and suspension for sure very dangerous
Honestly the refs a reejz
this how crazy wayne barnes is,it odviuosly accidental but he gives it a red card
This play deserves full time red card and suspension for months. This SA winger’s challenge seems so crazy. Similar things can happen in the amateur level but the intensity is totally different. Top players must understand they can possibly kill opponents.
You must be Australian
Kurtlee definitely in a position to contest beauden barret makes contact with his hip on arendses head and doesn't even have the ball in hand just saying...
What the hell was arendse thinking?
Bro if you've never played competitive Rugby don't speak on how exhausted players react in the last 10 minutes of a game against one of the top 5 teams on the world
if the ref wont protect your players then the team better start doing it ..the hard way !
Springbok supporter here. That was a bad , bad mistake.
Totally agree with the red, no question on it, but how freaking sad was it to see a ref giving a red to a player out cold...
Nah there was fucken good who cares
Gardner is not known for his style or class. Mostly his poor reffing. This was one of his better games tho.
What do you reckon , Should’ve given him a pat on the back? 😂😂😂
What else could he do
Happened to a kiwi prop in the Ireland series
I do think he was contesting legally. However, the states occur and I believe the referee made the right decision. A red card wars certainly justified. You can see him only concentrating on the ball as he goes up he realize that somebody ahead of him.
I thought he wasn't getting the red by the way your captions are suggesting force red 😂😂😂
This happened so quickly, competition is tough and each player are eager to perform. How do you stop yourself midway or change direction? Things can go wrong in a split second. Adendse is a fast runner so if he held back a bit and hit Beauden the moment he landed on his feet it would have been hailed a brilliant tackle. Now instead Arendse is being crusified, do not think that if quite fair. And this is happening more and more. Perhaps the rules should be changed that players no longer can jump for a high ball except in the line out.
You cant just blindly leap without an appreciation of your chance of actually contesting. Its simply a skill that players have to have otherwise we will get players being paralyszed.
@@MrAhuapai Agree if you look at a lot of the more experienced wingers they tend to keep an eye on both the ball and opposition contesting for the ball! Some just slowing down to anticipate a drop ball or tackle. Much safer
He did exactly the same thing to Jordie Barrett in the 10th minute and should have been yellow carded but the TMO never looked at it.
If people can no longer jump for a high ball, how is it any safer for them to get clattered as soon as they catch it?
@@stevenmcalister826 because they're on the ground. You can't tackle in the air, so at least with a legal tackle once you've landed, you won't end up in a wheelchair for the rest of your life. Kurt-Lee Arendse will spend a lot of time on the sidelines for this reckless, stupid and careless challenge in the air on Beauden Barrett.
Horrid collision either way and glad he's OK. Suspension reasonable but could have been 5 matches instead of 4... What astounds me is the newest excuse for the All Blacks loss: Boks dependence on the high ball. So what, are they not allowed to kick the ball high simply because the All Blacks are struggling?
Its not easy to Defend whatever Side.Sori for Both Players.Hope these Players are all On WCA and Registered for Life at WHO.Its a High Risk.
Rugby is not for ballerinas . Foul play red card, move on. Or watch the Kardashian's.
Inexperiece, youth... trying perhaps too hard to impress and perhaps a tiny bit of arrogance... He'll be fine Mate! Perhaps also remind him he does not have to be a Cheslin Kolbe..
Why are ppl complaining? He got a red car. It was justified. If fowl play happens you get punched, just AUE wannebies cry when thy do something wrong and thy get caught red handed.
Australia is a wast of time in rugby, get them out is dragging rugby to a low point.
Horrible collision and era in judgment, there’s no excuse for what happened however I played the zoomed out clip in slow motion and Caleb Clarke interferes with Kurt-Lee while he’s still got eyes on the ball, he 100% would have been able to contest if he wasn’t hindered. Doesn’t take away from the fact that Kurt-Lee should have been more aware but players screening their own player should also be blown more often. Glad both players are okay.
I seriously doubt that this was intentional on Arendse’s part.
At the speeds that the game is played he had a split second to decide whether to contest or not.
In this case he clearly got it wrong, and so deserved the red, but the margin between a successful contest and a dangerous collision is so narrow that it can go either way.
I really don’t envy either the players having to make those decisions, or the ref or TMO having to judge them.
12 weeks minimum
Or maybe tackling class? Or does that only apply to AB players?
Red Card was the correct decision and his ban should keep him out of the remainder of the Rugby Championship. He needs to go away and look at that aspect of his game, and make the corrections. He will be a great future Springbok.
It's not the coach the players aren't good enough - they're kidding themselves.
Not nice for the 2 player's I think it was more clumsy than any malleus in it . handled very quickly by the ref no one can have any problem with his call. This is why rugby is so good why can't different sports use tmo
No intention to catch the ball. His eyes were following the ball so he could prepare for impact. Normally on a situation like this, when the ball is close, body shifts, hands above head ready to catch.
This situation player has his elbows below shoulder. Just aweful!
He knew exactly what he was doing there. should be a long long ban. It could have caused very serious injury.
That number 14 shouldn't be allowed to play rugby again that was delibrate and his intent was to hurt the player. Dirty grub tactics from sa
Should a be twelve week suspension mitigated down to nine awful and highly dangerous technique
Arendse should be ashamed. Shocking challenge. Hope he is banned for at least six weeks.
My question is why did Arendse jump into it? When he could see Barrett in the air, surely stay down and protect yourself from a hip to the head!
It was NOT intentionally done. KLA is not a dirty player...
He should get 5 red cards for that reckless play. Sure he is keen to make an impression but that was simply dangerous.
I hope that both players recover quickly.
Go and have another look at Faf's injury. That knee wasn't an accident.
He'll get a lengthy ban for that for sure. Hope they both okay though.
@@dougerrohmer 🙄
@@dougerrohmer yes he lift that knee in the FACE OF FAF!!!!!!!!!!!!!! THAT PLAYER SHOULD HAVE GOT A RED CARD TO.
It wasn’t the first time during this game player were taken out in the air. Even the tmo didn’t do his job
When are you talking about exactly? I did not see any taking out in the air any other time in the game? There was fair contesting definitely which is 100% allowed.
That's pretty sick. Clear cut dangerous.
Hope hes banned for a long time. Cheating also afterwards, pretending to be injured.
Yeah either have to outlaw competing for high ball or these type of incidents will happen. Only takes a small moment to mistime and people get hurt.
These referees are more about.their ego than actually officiating. They always get things wrong
Holy shit. I grabbed my neck just watching that.
Though this was a horrible mistake by Arendse I think a lenghtly ban should be issued, this was as dangerous as it gets.
ban jumping, accidents will happen otherwise
Good discussion from ref no complaints from me. Look he was to slow down and then make the tackle, but in heat of that moment his timing was out. Lessen learned I hope
If he was penalised one of the first two times he did it,it may not have happened!!!
Thats what i was thinking earlier when he took out Jordie Barret not a realistic attempt to get the ball. But its a fine line. Seems the all blacks are getting pinged for nothing though alot
Yes he did another reckless challenge to Jordie Barrett in the first half.
At this stage of the game the Boks kept kicking the ball high when instead they had the All Blacks on the backfoot and needed to run it through their backs.
Arendse should of known better, it's the chasers responsibility to protect the players. Awful tactic to take out a all blacks key player. Easy to say wish both a recovery but let's get real people.... Arendse was absolutely careless.
It was malicious intent as he knew that he had no chance but went ahead with his action.
That kick was too far out to contest.
These kick and chases are reckless when it's a hit and hope.