@Elaine Stewart because being white has nothing to do with cognition. Nor do the powers at be care for righteousness. If they did, it wouldn't be what you see today. What makes you think the next 5 years will be different when they have been doing the same thing for millieniums?
Think Hawley's message is clear that big Tech Google just can't go on monopolizing every person with their piece of technology making them super rich and dependent by violating our privacy.
It's fascinating to see how different these question/answer sessions go when the politician asking the questions knows something about technology. It's the complete opposite of the Facebook session we saw recently.
@reality check how does a non government agency have a right to do this? This argument just made even less sense. The government has a legit security reason for doing it. They even keep it away from corporate and other countries the best they can. You're talking that it's the same thing and it's nowhere even close. This CORPORATION is selling your information. Not only that but refusing to allow you to disallow tracking. The only thing they should know about me is what I post for the public to see. Everything else. My apps? What I view online? That should be cached on my phone not in their databases. The Geo location should only be utilized when I open an app that requires it to function. These are so very very very far from the same conversations
The more I see of Senator Hawley, the more I like him. He's a sharp guy and the kind of leader we're in need of as these tech giants keep pushing their underhanded initiatives.
I believe he agrees in the freedom of the internet and the right to privacy. He's on the right side. The people who want the government to control the internet are the ones who want to hold the [Pen]
BS about what google said. Phone calls and many other services worked just fine before smart phones. They also don't need to collect data 14 times and hour just because you want to use your phone 2 hours later or check a map. It's bs anyway because it's not like these services are running all the time. Why would you have to wait to load a map and not have all points where you have been listed instantly considering they are recording it all and have the data already? I can use google maps just fine on a desktop or laptop with no geo location at all. Lies and more lies!
You think google maps on desk or laptop doesn't use geo location? Google maps isn't the issue though. Every reasonable person can conclude that when you open google maps, your location is used. I'd reasonably assume that 99% of the time anyone opens google maps they don't open it to see what's on the other side of the world, so it's consumer friendly to open with the area around you. This also happens on desktop. Again, that's not the issue. The issue is not using any service that uses geo-location, and phones still send geo location 14 times per hour.
@reality check Oh.. you're actually all over this video crying about the NSA. Reality check for you: Most people don't give a damn if the governmental NSA does this. They keep it for themselves and can use it to protect us from terrorism amongst various other things. Another reality check: Google sells this fucking information. Get off here. Everyone and their mother knows about NSA and majority of normal people are okay with it. Maybe ask why people are ignoring you.
Yeah, why can't the phone just use your location as needed when you open a map app? What do they need our location for all the time? Why do they have to lie about it? Just tell the truth Google!
@Jeremy Edwards it could roughly calculate your location within a 3 mile radius and later down to a quarter-mile radius,. now that know EXACTLY where you are
Thank u Josh fr highlighting why we in MO. sent u in place of Claire ( butt friend of Hillary) to the senate. We r so proud of your stance fr our President and fr Patriots....
@@ShowerCurtain1 The mindset as a whole.. Like "Progressive". The name itself is pretentious form of slander that suggests all those that are not "Progressive" don't make progress... ... yet they are too dense to realize that often, progress ISN'T a good thing.
i mean, it is complicated though. If the phone doesn't know what towers it has available it is unable to receive a phone call or text message. This isn't a 'google' thing, this is actually legitimately how all cellular devices have worked since invention. That said, Google using that data (which cannot meaningfully be turned off unless you want the phone to become a brick without the ability to call or text while in your pocket) to run ads to you is probably not ok.
Thank you for pressing the issue on this Senator Hawley. We must have an #InternetBillOfRights to protect the public from the predatory actions of these technology companies when it comes to privacy, and also to ensure our freedom of speech online.
I am so glad I found this! Huge instant fan of Hawley. After seeing this and also Senator Hawley’s grill session with Google (K.Bhatia) . WOW!!!!!! Well done Senator!!!
Great job Senator Hawley. Only recently discovered your videos here because of your involvement in the Google hearings. Even though I live in Florida I'm proud to have you representing the American people and wish you were my representative.
This is kurwa awesome! More grilling, please. These corporate execs think they are above law. They should be constantly and harshly reminded that they're not.
So confident, so to the point, a great force of interviewing, and motivated to get to the answers. I do believe, and am disheartened by going to the next question, moving on from accountability from “ the hot seat” , how do we ever know if the enquirers are ever answered?
lol you quite literally did sign up for this. When you clicked "I agree" in the terms of service on your phone, you agreed to anonymous data collection. If you didn't want it, you should have read the terms of service.
@@davidk8893 Yeah bs, like anyone has time for that, never even mind that it's hard to even function in today's society without using google services. That doesn't mean that google can demand what they want from the consumer. On the contrary, they should never have become as powerful as they are in the first place.
@@blubblubber9460 "yeah I don't have time for that" is not a valid excuse to get out of a contract. That would be like refusing to pay a plumber because you didn't feel like reading his hourly charge. By clicking "I read these terms and agree" you made a legal statement that you have read, understand, and agree to all the terms in the agreement. I don't necessarily agree with everything Google does, but you can't complain about having your data collected if you signed a legal agreement allowing them to collect it.
@@davidk8893 Most people know that google monetizes their data, that's not the point. It's about how Google uses the data and in what quantity, and what kind of expectations they raise at the same time. Collecting geodata with location tracking turned off is the chief example. One shouldn't be required to read through the terms of service to find out about that. Reading the terms of service in detail for all kinds of google services takes hours after all, understanding it in full probably takes weeks unless you posess sufficient knowledge in both law and technology. It's just completely absurd to expect people to do all that. And I guarantee you, if they'd actually make a law that only people who understand google terms of service are allowed to use the service, google would vehemently be against that, because that would probably mean they'd lose 99% of their customers. You see exploiting the lack of time and energy, laziness and ignorance of people can work both ways.
Mr. Hawley thank you for holding big tech responsible but you have to go further. Stop asking them if they will agree to a third party audit, DO IT. Now is not the time to ask the same questions over and over for a 3 years, it's time for ACTION. Please.
So it all boils down to they don’t believe in freedom of speech nor do they believe in your freedom of choice.. Gives a whole new meaning to the land of the free.
Wow, powerful... I knew google isn't to be trusted, but that is scarey the extent they just admit to... I am very grateful to have Josh Hawley fighting for us! Thank you Josh Hawley. God Bless you!
Finally a Senator who makes me proud to be from Missouri. No I don't agree with everything his Party does, but he is knowledgeable and articulate and he is a much better speaker than Claire was and Blunt is.
The fact of the matter is that he is in no way knowledgeable. If he was, he would know the difference between the two types of tracking being discussed here: Location history, and anonymous location data. The former can be turned off quite easily, and is off by default. The latter can also be turned off by turning off the location button on the top of your screen in android. If he were to let the Google employee talk for more than 10 seconds, then maybe he would be able to explain the difference, but he keeps getting cut off. This is a prime example of paranoia due to technological ignorance.
Thank you Senator, you are indeed terrifying in the greatest of ways. This well placed tenacity on the side of logic and reason is why I recently switched from blue to red.
THIS IS THE REAZON THAT I LOVE AMERICA!!!!! YOU ARE INCREDIBLE!!!! No matter who you are, no matter how much money you have, no matter how much power you have, if you do something bad or that's not right, You're going to be investigate and they're going to punish you! This is the reason that America is a GREAT GREAT country!!! God bless America!!!!!
One reason why I so admire and respect senator gowdy! I so believe if I was located in his state instead of Oklahoma there is absolutely no way i would be struggling with the horrible anti trust situation I am now! These big tech companies genuinely destroy people and their personal life with the real sick disrespectful Shit they are allowed to get away with! I’ve been so terribly affected and yet I’m completely treated like I’m the damn criminal! We live in a wicked sick world
Be strong Josh and don't ever lose your momentum and energy because inevitably someone is going to try and take it from you. Our government needs so many more of your kind in its ranks. God bless Senator Hawley for slamming the hammer when no one else would.
They certainly are using it to direct ads! Who else has had ads directed to them based on a face to face conversation while the phone was simply sitting nearby. Excellent job, Mr. Hawley!
One can only dream of a Senate full of Hawleys
I live in St. Louis and I am so happy he won and Claire is gone.
@Groove Crusader Go back to mommy!
It's all talk. They still do what they want.
@Elaine Stewart There's nothing to be proud of.
@Elaine Stewart because being white has nothing to do with cognition. Nor do the powers at be care for righteousness. If they did, it wouldn't be what you see today. What makes you think the next 5 years will be different when they have been doing the same thing for millieniums?
Great job senator Hawley. You let me be proud to be an American. Thank you.
bro care Please explain!
Think Hawley's message is clear that big Tech Google just can't go on monopolizing every person with their piece of technology making them super rich and dependent by violating our privacy.
Holy shit, never heard of this guy before but he's a savage! I'd want him on my team.
He's my senator and I know him to be selectively conservative like most Republicans.
I helped get him elected
If you’re in American and even beyond, he’s on your team✔️💪🙌 Legend
It's fascinating to see how different these question/answer sessions go when the politician asking the questions knows something about technology. It's the complete opposite of the Facebook session we saw recently.
Jason Dunn research! Craziness
That's why we need to place term limits on these senators. Alot of the elderly senators do not understand technology.
A lot of young ones don't know
@reality check Does not make it right for a coporation that is not a government facility to do so as well.
What is your argument here?
@reality check how does a non government agency have a right to do this? This argument just made even less sense. The government has a legit security reason for doing it. They even keep it away from corporate and other countries the best they can.
You're talking that it's the same thing and it's nowhere even close. This CORPORATION is selling your information. Not only that but refusing to allow you to disallow tracking. The only thing they should know about me is what I post for the public to see. Everything else. My apps? What I view online? That should be cached on my phone not in their databases.
The Geo location should only be utilized when I open an app that requires it to function.
These are so very very very far from the same conversations
Senator Hawley Rocks the House! I wish we had more intelligent public servants like him
The more I see of Senator Hawley, the more I like him. He's a sharp guy and the kind of leader we're in need of as these tech giants keep pushing their underhanded initiatives.
I believe he agrees in the freedom of the internet and the right to privacy. He's on the right side. The people who want the government to control the internet are the ones who want to hold the [Pen]
snooze alert on Senator Snark
BS about what google said. Phone calls and many other services worked just fine before smart phones. They also don't need to collect data 14 times and hour just because you want to use your phone 2 hours later or check a map. It's bs anyway because it's not like these services are running all the time. Why would you have to wait to load a map and not have all points where you have been listed instantly considering they are recording it all and have the data already? I can use google maps just fine on a desktop or laptop with no geo location at all. Lies and more lies!
You think google maps on desk or laptop doesn't use geo location? Google maps isn't the issue though. Every reasonable person can conclude that when you open google maps, your location is used. I'd reasonably assume that 99% of the time anyone opens google maps they don't open it to see what's on the other side of the world, so it's consumer friendly to open with the area around you. This also happens on desktop. Again, that's not the issue.
The issue is not using any service that uses geo-location, and phones still send geo location 14 times per hour.
@reality check Oh.. you're actually all over this video crying about the NSA. Reality check for you: Most people don't give a damn if the governmental NSA does this. They keep it for themselves and can use it to protect us from terrorism amongst various other things. Another reality check: Google sells this fucking information.
Get off here. Everyone and their mother knows about NSA and majority of normal people are okay with it. Maybe ask why people are ignoring you.
Yeah, why can't the phone just use your location as needed when you open a map app? What do they need our location for all the time? Why do they have to lie about it? Just tell the truth Google!
your old phones used SMS to tell where you were just like google is doing now there is no way for the phone to work with out doing it old or new
@Jeremy Edwards it could roughly calculate your location within a 3 mile radius and later down to a quarter-mile radius,. now that know EXACTLY where you are
"I know it's difficult to understand"
-"it's not complicated" well done Senator!
Senator Hawley has Google by the tail.
May God watch over him.
We fully agree with Tucker Carlson FASCISTBOOK TWATTER Google needs to be broken up!!!!
Yes but let's not lose focus, start with Google because they're the worst, the most powerful, and the most in bed with government.
Simple. Remove immunity NOW. No immunity until they stop political censorship and steering.
Senator Hawley has a bright future. I’m praying for him and his family ❗️
Dude... He doesn't grill them...
**He sends them to HELL!**
They belong somewhere worse, like going really hungry to a Burger King with missing buns.
But HELL is ok too I guess.
I think many of the people at Google originated from hell.
Thank u Josh fr highlighting why we in MO. sent u in place of Claire ( butt friend of Hillary) to the senate. We r so proud of your stance fr our President and fr Patriots....
Wow thank you senator!! Get him! We need more like you.
"Guys, I know this is complicated"
He's not talking to senator Feinstein anymore.
@@ShowerCurtain1 The mindset as a whole.. Like "Progressive". The name itself is pretentious form of slander that suggests all those that are not "Progressive" don't make progress...
... yet they are too dense to realize that often, progress ISN'T a good thing.
i mean, it is complicated though. If the phone doesn't know what towers it has available it is unable to receive a phone call or text message. This isn't a 'google' thing, this is actually legitimately how all cellular devices have worked since invention. That said, Google using that data (which cannot meaningfully be turned off unless you want the phone to become a brick without the ability to call or text while in your pocket) to run ads to you is probably not ok.
@@fdafdafdafadfddfffwe The phone only needs to be able to ping the tower. It does not need to know where you are standing within a few feet.
Bo Hunt, absolutely right. And pinging has nothing to do with data collection unless you deliberately tie the two together.
Thank you for pressing the issue on this Senator Hawley. We must have an #InternetBillOfRights to protect the public from the predatory actions of these technology companies when it comes to privacy, and also to ensure our freedom of speech online.
Well said and I agree totally.
Senator you have earned my respect.
Only found this out from infowars, couldn't find this video anywhere else. Why am I not surprised?
And youtube doesn't seem all too eager for people to see this, either
It was recommended to me but it’s been a long time from when it was uploaded
Senator Hadley is amazing!!!!
Dyanne Gavin Who's Senator Hadley?
Beat out claire mcclaskill for senate from MO.
Ted Cruz But younger
I am so glad I found this! Huge instant fan of Hawley. After seeing this and also Senator Hawley’s grill session with Google (K.Bhatia) . WOW!!!!!! Well done Senator!!!
Thank You!! So sharp! A Senator who has sense to go with his smarts! God bless ya.
Great job Senator Hawley. Only recently discovered your videos here because of your involvement in the Google hearings. Even though I live in Florida I'm proud to have you representing the American people and wish you were my representative.
Lol.. not complicated at all. Cell phones worked just fine without google services when the damn things were the size of a purse and weighed 3 pounds.
This is kurwa awesome! More grilling, please. These corporate execs think they are above law. They should be constantly and harshly reminded that they're not.
LOVE YOU, JOSH HAWLEY! THANK YOU AND GOD BLESS YOU!
Hawley,Jordan,Cruz,Gram,Trump are starting to restore my hope for our government. Love you guys
GOD BLESS AMERICA.........PATRIOTS ARE HERE READY........SEE YOU SOON...AS YOUR GO TO YOUR HOME.....SEE YOU AT YOUR HOME....SOON>.
And Ron DeSantis
this guy is on track..! if you like hotel california... hit like :)
Sen Hawley sure made this guy look like the weasel he is.
TWATTER banned me first then my husband. Lol 😆. Within a few minutes I was back on TWATTER under a different name and different phone number. Lol 😆
You make me proud to have voted for you. Sadly weasel words is all you will ever get no matter what
MA Wilson right again
So confident, so to the point, a great force of interviewing, and motivated to get to the answers. I do believe, and am disheartened by going to the next question, moving on from accountability from “ the hot seat” , how do we ever know if the enquirers are ever answered?
I am so glad i voted for Hawley he is awesome!
I had not known about Sen. Hayley. This guy’s great.
all talk, no action. these hearings are nothing more than theatre.
@Raven Hatfield a civil war sounds a bit extreme don't ya think
Thank you Senator Hawley... yes, we didn't sign up for this! GoogleShame!!
lol you quite literally did sign up for this. When you clicked "I agree" in the terms of service on your phone, you agreed to anonymous data collection. If you didn't want it, you should have read the terms of service.
@@davidk8893 Yeah bs, like anyone has time for that, never even mind that it's hard to even function in today's society without using google services. That doesn't mean that google can demand what they want from the consumer. On the contrary, they should never have become as powerful as they are in the first place.
@@blubblubber9460 "yeah I don't have time for that" is not a valid excuse to get out of a contract. That would be like refusing to pay a plumber because you didn't feel like reading his hourly charge. By clicking "I read these terms and agree" you made a legal statement that you have read, understand, and agree to all the terms in the agreement. I don't necessarily agree with everything Google does, but you can't complain about having your data collected if you signed a legal agreement allowing them to collect it.
@@davidk8893 Most people know that google monetizes their data, that's not the point. It's about how Google uses the data and in what quantity, and what kind of expectations they raise at the same time.
Collecting geodata with location tracking turned off is the chief example. One shouldn't be required to read through the terms of service to find out about that.
Reading the terms of service in detail for all kinds of google services takes hours after all, understanding it in full probably takes weeks unless you posess sufficient knowledge in both law and technology. It's just completely absurd to expect people to do all that. And I guarantee you, if they'd actually make a law that only people who understand google terms of service are allowed to use the service, google would vehemently be against that, because that would probably mean they'd lose 99% of their customers.
You see exploiting the lack of time and energy, laziness and ignorance of people can work both ways.
not just American but Australia too
Well said. Way to stay on topic. I completely agree with Senator Hawley.
Thank you so much Senator! I'm Francis from the Philippines.
Google needs to be checked! As well as Facebook and Twitter.
this guy is brilliant!
Mr. Hawley thank you for holding big tech responsible but you have to go further. Stop asking them if they will agree to a third party audit, DO IT. Now is not the time to ask the same questions over and over for a 3 years, it's time for ACTION. Please.
Great job. Hold their feet to the fire. Thank You Senator Hawley.
Outstanding
We need more people like Senator Josh Hawley in every country especially in my country Australia. God bless you
I absolutely hate Google!
Much respect from Canada Senator Hawley
I see this guy as the future President of the US 👌
THIS NEEDS TO BE CHANGED!!!!!!!!!! WE HAVE NO PRIVACY ANY MORE!!!!!!!!!
And here it is, 3 years later and they are still doing the same thing.
So it all boils down to they don’t believe in freedom of speech nor do they believe in your freedom of choice..
Gives a whole new meaning to the land of the free.
Fantastic!
You're doing a great job, sen. Hawley. The world depends on people like yourself.
Keep it up from Bulgaria !
Notice how none of our comments are being removed !! This is the backbone we need today and you are iconic Hawley!!
Thank you senator ♥️
Wow, powerful... I knew google isn't to be trusted, but that is scarey the extent they just admit to... I am very grateful to have Josh Hawley fighting for us! Thank you Josh Hawley. God Bless you!
Wow, Just WOW! 😮
I always have my Location Info turned OFF & thought it is OFF. Apparently not. 😟 Hmm.
God Bless you, Sen. Hawley! 🙏☺️
Booooom!!!! Smack in the face like a boss!!
I love Sen Hawley!!!
hey i care so much about these debates, thank you for really opening our eyes as a community! banter is good!
This is deeply entertaining to watch. I may have to start watching these meetings more.
WE NEED HIM........ASAP...... A FUTURE CONSTITUTIONAL KENNEDY PRESIDENT!!!!!!!!@@@$#@!!
Finally a Senator who makes me proud to be from Missouri. No I don't agree with everything his Party does, but he is knowledgeable and articulate and he is a much better speaker than Claire was and Blunt is.
Blunt what a disappointment..
The fact of the matter is that he is in no way knowledgeable. If he was, he would know the difference between the two types of tracking being discussed here: Location history, and anonymous location data. The former can be turned off quite easily, and is off by default. The latter can also be turned off by turning off the location button on the top of your screen in android. If he were to let the Google employee talk for more than 10 seconds, then maybe he would be able to explain the difference, but he keeps getting cut off. This is a prime example of paranoia due to technological ignorance.
I suspect perjury. Josh is my senator I may call his office tomorrow and see what evidence the company provided to support their claims.
Senator Hawley for president 2024
Sen. Hawley 🇺🇸
Love the way you get them stuttering..... every time 🤣
Amen to that!!!!
Good job ! Unbelievable information!
Liked and subscribed.
Hawley you rock
Thank you Senator, you are indeed terrifying in the greatest of ways. This well placed tenacity on the side of logic and reason is why I recently switched from blue to red.
WELL DONE SIR, WELL DONE 💯
THIS IS THE REAZON THAT I LOVE AMERICA!!!!! YOU ARE INCREDIBLE!!!! No matter who you are, no matter how much money you have, no matter how much power you have, if you do something bad or that's not right, You're going to be investigate and they're going to punish you! This is the reason that America is a GREAT GREAT country!!! God bless America!!!!!
Thank you Sir.
I find Senator Hawley to be
The Most Articulate
Politician we currently have!
Location services are vital when making 911 calls and for locating lost or stolen phones.
I hate it when I get home from the store and my cell phone rings in and asks me "How did you like your trip to Wal-Mart?"
RIGHT ON, Hawley!!! :D
I love this. This is how I grill my children when they are lying
This is awesome and should be seen by all Americans
that was brilliant Senator. thank you for defending the public
One reason why I so admire and respect senator gowdy! I so believe if I was located in his state instead of Oklahoma there is absolutely no way i would be struggling with the horrible anti trust situation I am now! These big tech companies genuinely destroy people and their personal life with the real sick disrespectful Shit they are allowed to get away with! I’ve been so terribly affected and yet I’m completely treated like I’m the damn criminal! We live in a wicked sick world
Senator Hawley is a boss.
More people need to hear about it facebok do the same
The kind of American that makes me wish I was American!
Senator Hawley is on fire! Great job!
I'm not even from Missouri but damn, I'm so happy this man in congress.
I have location history enabled by choice...however, it is unsettling to know that I would still be tracked even if I had not opted into it
Hawley is amazing, he should elect for American president. He can, he is very smart and clear minded,
Be strong Josh and don't ever lose your momentum and energy because inevitably someone is going to try and take it from you. Our government needs so many more of your kind in its ranks. God bless Senator Hawley for slamming the hammer when no one else would.
👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
It’s Time True Americans
Senator Hawley you are the man 👍
Broski never thought I would find a dope senator. You got my support
This guy is straight up fire!
Senator Hawley is the MAN!! Takes no B.S. and makes them squirm in their seats with their untruths.....love it!!!!
They certainly are using it to direct ads! Who else has had ads directed to them based on a face to face conversation while the phone was simply sitting nearby.
Excellent job, Mr. Hawley!
Josh is the kind of man we need in Congress. I'm proud to have voted for him.
They want to know everything about us,and do not want us know anything about them.
I wish we had some MPs like you in the UK you just keep fighting for the people and they will back you up
I like this senator. He said with Google.You can check out anytime you like but you can NEVER leave.
Well done. How presumptuous of the Googleite to insist "it's complicated". No.
Get them Senator Hawley!👍