@@darknessanddistance4469 Call me crazy, but I always wondered what would happen if Fritz had been kind to the monster. After all, they were both "handicapped" and outcasts. Perhaps Fritz would be the monster's master, and do his bidding (Sort of like Ygor in the Son of Frankenstein).
@@toddholmes4480 it seems very strange to me also, but evil begets evil even in the real world. Consider all of the molested children who have become child molesters, case in point
TheHero136 has dogoyototyyyyoyyoydodyyooyoyodyoyodyyodyodydodoyddodyyodyodyydodyodyydoydogoddoydoydoyodoyyyydodydoydoyyyyddoyyodydydodyoydoyyydodyoodoyyodyodydoyodyyodyddoydoydyyodgdydyodydoyodydyeyeeeettytt
Thank you so much for addressing the lax safety standards in Frankenstein's lab, regarding the self destruct lever. OSHA requires all lab self destruct levers to have at least two safety interlocks to prevent unintentional actuation.
A biographer said that Karloff always refused to discuss his childhood, the implication being that he may have been bullied or abused because he had East Indian blood on his mother's side, which made his skin tones darker than usual for an English boy in a culture that was so class and color conscious. I suspect he brought this to his portrayal of the Creature, which made it so memorably poignant.
He was an air raid warden in London during WWII. The children loved him. They were not afraid of the bombs because Frankenstein was protecting them. Everybody who worked with Karloff described him as a true and kind gentleman. Great man, great actor.
Videos like this make me really appreciate James as a creator. You can tell he’s passionate about the movies and games he talks about outside of character. While I’ve found myself moving away from the reviewers who play angry characters, I always come back to James. Even older AVGN episodes that I’ve seen countless times are still entertaining because now I have the context of the passion he puts into his videos.
The monster can be called Frankenstein, it's even in the book: "At length the thought of you crossed my mind. I learned from your papers that you were my father, my creator; and to whom could I apply with more fitness than to him who had given me life?" The monster self-identifies as the doctor's son and everything that goes with it, including his name.
Whale’s introduction of the Monster in Frankenstein is brilliant. Showing him from the back, then a closeup, then a tighter closeup, in complete silence. I can just imagine what a shock his appearance must have been to audiences back in ‘31.
I don’t know why, but Dwight Frye should have been one of the main Universal monster actors. I honestly think that he has a haunting laugh and could have been a good main villain.
Excerpt from Mary Shelley's early draft of Frankenstein: "And before the creature disappeared into the shadows, I heard him call from the darkness: "You can call me Frankenstein if you want to, I really don't mind!""
Mary Shelley didn't even write Frankenstein, she was dating Lord Bryon at the time, who in a drug and alcohol binge in a lake cabin, wrote the story then released it under her name. It's like the Beatles with the white album, he wanted to see if his work would still be a hit without his name attached.
@@A_Black_Sheep94 Mary Shelley did write Frankenstein though it was published anonymously in 1818 and republished in 1831 with her name added in but she was not dating Lord Byron, it was her future husband Percy Shelley.
@@A_Black_Sheep94 This is pure bullshit that's easily debunked. Lord Byron and Percy Shelley are two seperate people. There's no arguing about this. Mary primarily wrote Frankenstein but her husband Percy Shelley altered it. We have enough existing evidence to know what she wrote and what Percy wrote. Furthermore, Frankenstein was never published under Byron or Percy's name and was initially published ANOYMOUSLY until future publications in the 1830s credited Mary as the author.
So let me get this straight the Dracula, Frankenstein and wolfman movies all take place in the same universe? Does that mean this is the original cinematic universe?
@Devonte Huntley As long it gets done the way they way it was done with Boris Karloff. Scary, not too gory and with a thinking man's storyline. Then it would. be a good movie.
Devonte Huntley Don’t forger they already brought out and remade The Wolfman in 2010 with Benicio Del Tor, so I’m not sure what they will do with that. The next movie in the Dark Universal was supposed to be Jekyl and Hyde but scrapped it.
Karloff is such a menace yet so sympathetic and some what relatable. He’s been kicked around all his life so when he died in the book it is actually a sad moment.
@@ernestoa3140 big? You meet famous? Colin Clive was very well known. He appeared opposite Bette Davis as well. HIs death was considered a very great tragedy at the time. If Clive's acting ever seems over-the-top to you, remember that Henry Frankenstein is supposed to be hysterical. Often his acting is both subtle and charismatic.
A nice little retrospective. Thank you. The original '31 FRANKENSTEIN is a film with no music. During the pandemic, I painstakingly adapted a score which I believe really takes the film up a notch. I did the same thing with the '31 DRACULA, and prefer watching both films with the music. IMHO, the absence of a film score is one of the primary elements alienating modern audiences from these films.
I imagine it’s a reference to paradise lost, the epic the book was loosely based off of when Eve originally rejects Adam since she’s supposedly much more attractive than he was
I see it as deeper than that. The monster is seen as hideous even to other monsters. Revealing the prejudice and ignorance in human instincts. The Bride judges him only on his appareance, not even realizing she herself is just as grotesque. It reminds me of the blind old man in the novel, the blind man gets a chance to get to know the monster's friendly character because he doesnt reject him on his appearance. but then some son (iirc) enters the hut and goes apeshit on seeing a monster. it's tragic in that, while they were literally made for eachother, the bride doesn't realize they're the same, but also that she doesn't look beyond his appareance. At the same time shattering the cliche of "being made for eachother" all together. Most people have probably met someone that made them think they were made for eachother. But the other person doesn't agree. Are you then still made for eachother? Whether or not two people are actually arent perfect, or one of them simply doesnt realize it, it's a very recognizable theme.
I can't really explain it but everyone I know just loves the bride. I think it's because she's very beautiful but also looks quite haunting. Plus you can't forget that scream.
I finally broke down and bought Universal's Frankenstein Legacy Collection on DVD and loved every minute of it. Every horror buff needs to see these pictures. There's a reason these are classics.
In Abbot & Costello Meet Frankenstein, Dracula tells the doctor they meed a brain for the Monstsr thay will "have no will of his own". That is why they want Wilbur's brain, so the Monster will be easier to control.
Fun fact, in Germany a lot of monster films are named "Frankenstein" in reference to the monster, even if the monster is actually for example Godzilla! -- so they took the idea of "Frankenstein" being the monster and have seriously run with it.
Tony Horo Another example I can think of is how most southern US states, like Texas for example, call every type of soda “coke.” Things like this happen all the time with household names.
In a very real sense, Dr. Frankenstein is the father of the creature. This would technically give the monster a surname of Frankenstein. Especially given the implication that the monster is, with regards to mentality, a new being with no prior memories from the previous owner of his brain. Had he maintained his previous personality, like Steve Austin from the 6 million dollar man, I’d argue otherwise.
When I was a kid Frankenstein was already 35 ,40 years old but I still liked it ,it was a good movie, as for the abnormal brain, my uncle made me laugh -- he told me that brain came from a surfer dude, COWABUNGA!!!👌👍💪🏄♂️
I'd like to add something that makes the opening of Bride of Frankenstein even more amazing imo that James left out. The couple The Monster kills at the beginning are the parents of the little girl he drowned in Frankenstein, and I think it's kinda funny in a twisted way how he killed them all the same way and drowned the entire family
One could argue that the monster is Frankenstein's child, since the Doc is the one who gave him life, which would make his surname Frankenstein as well. Having two characters named Frankenstein would be confusing to the readers and viewers, so the monster is just referred to as such. Ironically, that caused much more confusion over the years when The Bride of Frankenstein came out.
Especially so in the 1930s to the 1960s. The studios would bend over backward to keep their money making talent, but just as quickly toss the less talented.
I think "Igor" being thought of as Dr. Frankenstein's assistant likely has its' origins in the "Monster Mash" song, as opposed to "Young Frankenstein."
Regarding the cars vs horse and buggy, parts of Europe didn't have cars as late as the 40s in the balkans and other areas, probably just a small poorer village (?)
Even in the United States. And horse transportation co-existed with autos in my area up until the 1950's. Garbage collecting vehicles , because of their constant stopping and standing were often drawn by horse.
Love Cinnemasacre in October and I absolutely love this video. James, I'm really hoping you'll do a video of this length on the Hammer Frankenstein and Dracula films. In fact, I'm not above begging: Please James...PLEASE do a Hammer Horror Film expose`.
Great movies, watch them every October. Love the reviews, although I always crack up when James tries to figure out continuity in the films from the 30's and 40's. When these movies were made, you saw them in the theatre once, then it would be years before you saw the next one. There wasn't TV broadcasts or video tapes for people to watch the films over and over and notice things. Remembering details from a movie you had seen two years earlier without a refresher is pretty difficult.
Monster Madness is one of my favorite parts of the month. I'm sad you've stopped making new episodes but watching these old ones in a compilation are great too!
I love videos where James just talks at length about something he's really enthusiastic about. Some of the most authentic and entertaining stuff on RUclips.
"The Lever!!!" two reasons were examined; one Whale (who loved being absurd) wrote it as a quick way to tie the ending up by "killing them all" including Henry!; another, from Donald F Glut's writings, implied it was a way to get rid of evidence (grave robbing, murder, harboring a fugitive, crimes against nature) if their efforts were discovered by the authorities (and a great way to off the cops at the same time!) the reason Henry and Elizabeth are allowed to live are both to show the Monster as a noble hearted creature compared to his cohorts and to allow more sequels for what was a depression era goldmine!!
Though I've been a big fan of the Universal film studio monsters ever since I was a kid ages 7 or 8, both the Frankenstein monster and the Wolfman happen to be my top favorites of all. Besides having numerous film books on the Universal Frankenstein films, I like drawing him as well.
I think I know how Dracula and The Wolfman came back in House of Dracula. When the sun descended, maybe Dracula was revived, and The Wolfman could have been revived when he was hit by the Full moon again after his death. That would have been a decent way to solve that plot hole.
Not quite, the monster sardonically compares himself to Adam when he’s talking to Frankenstein, “I ought be thy Adam, but am instead thy fallen angel.” Frankenstein on the other hand calls his creature terms such as “Monster” “Wretch” “Fiend” “Devil” “Daemon” Never “Adam.” One main ironic theme of the novel is that Frankenstein’s creation makes his creator as much of a wretch and a figure cut off from humanity as the monster is.
Usually during "Halloween season" (October basically) I would binge watch stuff like Treehouse of Horror and old Monster Madness, thanks to James combining old episodes I just wave to watch whatever he puts up. Monster Madness is so not over!
I really enjoy your reviews and history lessons on horror movies . I think posting old review on to RUclips for people to view is great. Your reviews have inspired me to watch and collect all the old classics
the way i see it everybody just calls the monster Frankenstein because that was the name of his creator, just like you'd share your parents' name at birth.
When I was a child, they used to play all the Universal Monster Movies on AMC once or twice a year. Couple that with the Crestwood House orange monster books from my local library and I was hooked on these. AMC rarely showed the "House" movies, though, so I don't have quite as many pleasant memories of them. Anyway, this is a great overview of these films. Very much of their time, but I still enjoy them.
Technically, the monster *can* be called Frankenstein. In the novel, he refers to Viktor as his father. So, by technicality, he *can* be called Frankenstein.
A lot of the actors they reused in the Universal Horror franchise we contracted they were promised so many roles and Universal decided that they should use them in horror franchise than anything else because their look was perfect for the timeline of Frankenstein. Had to edit as I forgot to say excellent video and that the Universal Horror franchise was and always will be my fav as I remember watching these movies when I was 5 or 6 they used to show them on BBC2 on a Friday and Saturday and I was allowed to stay up and watch them as we would camp out in our living room and watch them every weekend. From then on I became a horror fan and still am today!
After all these years, I think Son of Frankenstein has actually emerged as my favorite of the original 3 to watch. I absolutely love it. The supporting cast is just so phenomenal. Well, cept the kid of course, but I forgive.
I think it’s kinda funny that one of the only versions of Frankenstein that doesn’t kill the monster is the original book, he just sort of disappears at the end
@@davidbanan. He mentioned at the end of the story that he would be building a funeral pyre for himself, Although how that would work out in the arctic I have no idea. 🤔 Maybe wood from wrecked ships frozen in the ice out there?
I love all those universal movies, Dracula was my favorite. The Spanish version is very well made also. And bride of Frankenstein, one of the hunters is caridine.
Incidentally, the Frankenstein's machine made a re-appearance in of all things rock band Kiss' 1976 Destroyer tour but was taken off due to its expense of running.
There really is a decent defense of the discrepancies between House of Frankenstein and House of Dracula, which I'm kinda surprised you didn't bring up. Both Dracula and the Wolfman have been shown to come back to life under the right circumstances, leaving Ol Frankymon to be brought back the same way he was when he was found in sulfur and ice. Yeah, there is a missing movie in between, but really they don't need it. Wolfy has the moon shine on him and Drac just has the sun go down. I"m genuinely perplex that you didn't notice that. You put so much thought into the rest.
To the question of why Fritz is mean to the monster I always took it as Fritz enjoying finally having superiority over someone else, in a bully kid kind of way.
To me, the grim beauty of the story in the book is that Frankenstein creates a perfectly sound human being, but a physically repellant one. He just wanted to connect with someone like we all do, but everyone saw him as a monster, even his creator, so he eventually became a monster. I respect the films, but the whole "Normal" and "Abnormal" brains thing takes away from the point of the original story of the creature becoming a monster like we all can.
Anyone else hear *Dr.Clitoris* every time he mentioned the guys name? A buddy overheard me watching this and asked if that's what he said and now I can't unhear it.
I love the 1931 Frankenstein movie. Those 1930's horror movies are classics and I still enjoy them today. Yes they may not be scary anymore but fans like me still love them.
Doctor Frankenstein is the true monster. He creates life, then rejects it. He plays God, then refuses to acknowledge his creation. He risks everything, breaks the laws of nature and then rejects his child-like creature for not living up to his own ideals. He refuses to see the life he made as anything other than a creation that should exist within *his* parameters. He can't see his own creation as actually living, as his own person. Victor Frankenstein is the true monster.
The end of Frankenstein 1931 WAS tacked on. It was supposed to end at the burning windmill, but the suits at Universal wanted the audience to walk out leaving a little comforted.
Dude I'm so glad because I've been watching some of these old classics on peacock, and apparently a lot of these cut out scenes are still in this version.
I was just sort of listening while working, so I don't know if the movie being referred to as seeming anachronistic because of the presence of horses and buggies is the one with the Cajuns in it, but horses and buggies were in regular use in fairly rural south Louisiana during the early to mid 1900s as attested by my relatives who were there.
I'm with Linkara. The monster IS named Frankenstein. Partly because pop culture is just going to continue calling him that whether you like it or not, and more importantly, because the monster could be considered Dr Frankenstein's offspring and therefore inherits his surname. It's also just a cooler sounding name than anything else the monster has ever been called.
i always chalked Fritz tormenting the monster to someone who'd no doubt been kicked his whole life finally found someone "lower"
Same.
That makes sense
1-2-3!
@@darknessanddistance4469 Call me crazy, but I always wondered what would happen if Fritz had been kind to the monster. After all, they were both "handicapped" and outcasts. Perhaps Fritz would be the monster's master, and do his bidding (Sort of like Ygor in the Son of Frankenstein).
@@toddholmes4480 it seems very strange to me also, but evil begets evil even in the real world. Consider all of the molested children who have become child molesters, case in point
“Dracula’s on the run from the cops” might be the funniest thing I’ve heard all day.
They're after him because he didn't pay his taxes.
Well I would say that Dracula has some "grave" problems.
TheHero136 has dogoyototyyyyoyyoydodyyooyoyodyoyodyyodyodydodoyddodyyodyodyydodyodyydoydogoddoydoydoyodoyyyydodydoydoyyyyddoyyodydydodyoydoyyydodyoodoyyodyodydoyodyyodyddoydoydyyodgdydyodydoyodydyeyeeeettytt
@@Brainwave101 Enjoy Yoshi as your cell mate, Drac
I guess he forgot to bribe them with his blood money...
Thank you so much for addressing the lax safety standards in Frankenstein's lab, regarding the self destruct lever. OSHA requires all lab self destruct levers to have at least two safety interlocks to prevent unintentional actuation.
I'd kick it up to three
Being in construction and being familiar with OSHA, I find this comment amusing
Don't worry, it only matters if there's an Inspector.
Idk man, my secret evil lab’s self destruction level passed the test with just one. And I’ve only had 5 incidents! (Curse you Perry the Platypus…)
Especially in your secret illegal lab where you store monsters.
"Karloff throws Carl off." This made me laugh so hard.
nop
@@williamwu8858 Nop?
@@williamwu8858 nop?
Nop
That*
Haha, I always thought the Abnormal brain thing was only a joke in Young Frankenstein. Didn't know it was actually in the original movie.
Correction: the brain in Young Frankenstein is an abby normal brain. Now walk this way!
@Devonte Huntley Because he is an abomination maybe?
@Devonte Huntley He wasn't evil, just misunderstood!
"Are you saying that I put an abnormal brain in a 7 foot tall, 54 inch wide GORILLA!!!???"
A biographer said that Karloff always refused to discuss his childhood, the implication being that he may have been bullied or abused because he had East Indian blood on his mother's side, which made his skin tones darker than usual for an English boy in a culture that was so class and color conscious. I suspect he brought this to his portrayal of the Creature, which made it so memorably poignant.
barbara brooks also I read his dad was half Indian
awesome tidbit
Poor guy. Your blood and skin tone doesn't hurt anybody
He was an air raid warden in London during WWII. The children loved him. They were not afraid of the bombs because Frankenstein was protecting them. Everybody who worked with Karloff described him as a true and kind gentleman. Great man, great actor.
@@michaeljudge5089 He had a tea break every afternoon during filming, with a silver tea service, linen napkins, et alia.
Videos like this make me really appreciate James as a creator. You can tell he’s passionate about the movies and games he talks about outside of character. While I’ve found myself moving away from the reviewers who play angry characters, I always come back to James. Even older AVGN episodes that I’ve seen countless times are still entertaining because now I have the context of the passion he puts into his videos.
The monster can be called Frankenstein, it's even in the book:
"At length the thought of you crossed my mind. I learned from your papers that you were my father, my creator; and to whom could I apply with more fitness than to him who had given me life?"
The monster self-identifies as the doctor's son and everything that goes with it, including his name.
Not specifically, only metaphorically
@@rufust.firefly2474 No, actually specifically.
Isn't the creature named adam
@@The_Sharktocrab he only really compares himself to Adam (“…I should be thy Adam…”) not really naming himself Adam.
In Son of Frankenstein the Baron laments that the townsfolk refer to the creature as "Frankenstein".
"Son..." Is such an underrated classic. Definitely my favorite of the Universal Horror movies.
I like it a lot too!
I agree!!! It's awesome!!
I don't mind the reuse of actors. It's kind of like a cameo appearance
All your classic Frankenstein reviews in one video. Thank you, James.
Whale’s introduction of the Monster in Frankenstein is brilliant. Showing him from the back, then a closeup, then a tighter closeup, in complete silence. I can just imagine what a shock his appearance must have been to audiences back in ‘31.
I don’t know why, but Dwight Frye should have been one of the main Universal monster actors. I honestly think that he has a haunting laugh and could have been a good main villain.
If only there was a ballad written for him
@@greggotti9740 FUNNY
Well if he did play one he would've died half threw
Excerpt from Mary Shelley's early draft of Frankenstein:
"And before the creature disappeared into the shadows, I heard him call from the darkness:
"You can call me Frankenstein if you want to, I really don't mind!""
Mary Shelley didn't even write Frankenstein, she was dating Lord Bryon at the time, who in a drug and alcohol binge in a lake cabin, wrote the story then released it under her name. It's like the Beatles with the white album, he wanted to see if his work would still be a hit without his name attached.
@@A_Black_Sheep94 Mary Shelley did write Frankenstein though it was published anonymously in 1818 and republished in 1831 with her name added in but she was not dating Lord Byron, it was her future husband Percy Shelley.
@@heartlandqueen82You know Lord Byron is a pseudonym that he used right?
@@A_Black_Sheep94 No. There was a real Lord Byron, George Byron. And Mary Shelley was the daughter of William Godwin and Mary Wollstonecraft.
@@A_Black_Sheep94 This is pure bullshit that's easily debunked. Lord Byron and Percy Shelley are two seperate people. There's no arguing about this. Mary primarily wrote Frankenstein but her husband Percy Shelley altered it. We have enough existing evidence to know what she wrote and what Percy wrote. Furthermore, Frankenstein was never published under Byron or Percy's name and was initially published ANOYMOUSLY until future publications in the 1830s credited Mary as the author.
Basil Rathbone is such a bad ass name.
i cant decide if the spelling of rathbone would be better as wrathbone or if its just better being a homophone
All of these classic actors had badass names
@@bentramer682 They're the reason the names are badass!
So let me get this straight the Dracula, Frankenstein and wolfman movies all take place in the same universe? Does that mean this is the original cinematic universe?
Yes indeed
Yes. Original is best
Yup. Not like DC's or Marvel's different universes. Only one universe in Universal's Monster movies. That's the way it should be.
@Devonte Huntley As long it gets done the way they way it was done with Boris Karloff. Scary, not too gory and with a thinking man's storyline. Then it would. be a good movie.
Devonte Huntley Don’t forger they already brought out and remade The Wolfman in 2010 with Benicio Del Tor, so I’m not sure what they will do with that. The next movie in the Dark Universal was supposed to be Jekyl and Hyde but scrapped it.
Karloff is such a menace yet so sympathetic and some what relatable. He’s been kicked around all his life so when he died in the book it is actually a sad moment.
These villagers, man... They're like Pros by now...
LOL
I mean defeating Frankenstein's monster probably nets you a lot of exp.
They have a glass cabinet with pitchforks and ready-light torches.
I could just imagine a kid saying, "mom, he's making monsters again!"
Mom: All right. Time to bring out the family heirloom again."
Offer the villagers some emeralds
The bride's hair is like that because of the electricity
Or an old version of marge simpson
Am I the only one who loves acting of Colin Clive?
Nope
His performance is elegant with a hint of viscous
Not a big actor without doubt
Yes, especially in mad love Peter Lorre
@@ernestoa3140 big? You meet famous? Colin Clive was very well known. He appeared opposite Bette Davis as well. HIs death was considered a very great tragedy at the time. If Clive's acting ever seems over-the-top to you, remember that Henry Frankenstein is supposed to be hysterical. Often his acting is both subtle and charismatic.
A nice little retrospective. Thank you. The original '31 FRANKENSTEIN is a film with no music. During the pandemic, I painstakingly adapted a score which I believe really takes the film up a notch. I did the same thing with the '31 DRACULA, and prefer watching both films with the music. IMHO, the absence of a film score is one of the primary elements alienating modern audiences from these films.
Thats interesting, do you have a link to a file we could play along with them?
Where’s the link
I disagree. It's the lack of color and old effects. Films don't need music to most people, they just need consistent sound l
An original score or repurposed?
all these movies could have been avoided if Igor hadn't dropped the normal brain.
Garrett Goolsby You mean Fritz
*Igor Fritz...* yeah, that'll be my stage name, my... pseudonim!
@R M abby normal's brain
Abby someone?
This comment chain is hilarious.
Why did the bride reject the Monster?
They where made for each other!
Literally.
Oh, I thought you just answered your own question... Sometimes love just doesn't work out LMAO.
I imagine it’s a reference to paradise lost, the epic the book was loosely based off of when Eve originally rejects Adam since she’s supposedly much more attractive than he was
I see it as deeper than that. The monster is seen as hideous even to other monsters. Revealing the prejudice and ignorance in human instincts. The Bride judges him only on his appareance, not even realizing she herself is just as grotesque.
It reminds me of the blind old man in the novel, the blind man gets a chance to get to know the monster's friendly character because he doesnt reject him on his appearance. but then some son (iirc) enters the hut and goes apeshit on seeing a monster.
it's tragic in that, while they were literally made for eachother, the bride doesn't realize they're the same, but also that she doesn't look beyond his appareance. At the same time shattering the cliche of "being made for eachother" all together.
Most people have probably met someone that made them think they were made for eachother. But the other person doesn't agree. Are you then still made for eachother? Whether or not two people are actually arent perfect, or one of them simply doesnt realize it, it's a very recognizable theme.
Johnny Skinwalker LOL damn, that escalated quickly.
I can't really explain it but everyone I know just loves the bride. I think it's because she's very beautiful but also looks quite haunting. Plus you can't forget that scream.
Hisssssss
I finally broke down and bought Universal's Frankenstein Legacy Collection on DVD and loved every minute of it. Every horror buff needs to see these pictures. There's a reason these are classics.
In Abbot & Costello Meet Frankenstein, Dracula tells the doctor they meed a brain for the Monstsr thay will "have no will of his own". That is why they want Wilbur's brain, so the Monster will be easier to control.
Ask Chick if Wilbur is easy to control. 🤣
The opening sequence of BRIDE is brilliant
Fun fact, in Germany a lot of monster films are named "Frankenstein" in reference to the monster, even if the monster is actually for example Godzilla! -- so they took the idea of "Frankenstein" being the monster and have seriously run with it.
That's pretty much like in the later 80's people in US called everyvideogame 'nintendoes'
Tony Horo Another example I can think of is how most southern US states, like Texas for example, call every type of soda “coke.” Things like this happen all the time with household names.
@@wyatthines8690 No they don't, That's a northern/Canadian thing.
I’m no expert, but the Wikipedia page “Names for soft drinks in the United States” states the generic use of “coke” is a Southern term.
@@GrizonII No we say soda.
In a very real sense, Dr. Frankenstein is the father of the creature. This would technically give the monster a surname of Frankenstein. Especially given the implication that the monster is, with regards to mentality, a new being with no prior memories from the previous owner of his brain. Had he maintained his previous personality, like Steve Austin from the 6 million dollar man, I’d argue otherwise.
its a science experiment not pinocchio he never claims to be its father.
@@justinw947 still can be named after it's creator. The towns folk would naturally name him as such.
Karloff is heartbreaking as the monster I always feel a question of why is this happening to me He has heart
My theory is Ygor was the hanged man in the beginning of Frankenstein. The same one who Fritz cut down from the gallows.
The neck was broken. But Henry said the brain is useless, indicating it was damaged. So how could he be alive?
Maybe James was right: he's immortal
Agreed!👍🏻
wait did they use that body for anything or just disguard it?
@@jackhamilton9604 nope. Henry Frankenstein just said that the brain was useless because the neck was broken.
@@Aust51989 who knows, could have been Ygor then
When I was a kid Frankenstein was already 35 ,40 years old but I still liked it ,it was a good movie, as for the abnormal brain, my uncle made me laugh -- he told me that brain came from a surfer dude, COWABUNGA!!!👌👍💪🏄♂️
So you were born in the 1850s??
I'd like to add something that makes the opening of Bride of Frankenstein even more amazing imo that James left out. The couple The Monster kills at the beginning are the parents of the little girl he drowned in Frankenstein, and I think it's kinda funny in a twisted way how he killed them all the same way and drowned the entire family
One could argue that the monster is Frankenstein's child, since the Doc is the one who gave him life, which would make his surname Frankenstein as well. Having two characters named Frankenstein would be confusing to the readers and viewers, so the monster is just referred to as such. Ironically, that caused much more confusion over the years when The Bride of Frankenstein came out.
If you study film history, you'll learn about the original studio systems. All actors were contract players, thus the reuse of actors.
Hollywood has always been an insiders club.
Especially so in the 1930s to the 1960s. The studios would bend over backward to keep their money making talent, but just as quickly toss the less talented.
cheaper by the dozen back then
Frankenstein and Bride of Frankenstein were on TCM last night! Woo come on with the Monster Madness!!
I think "Igor" being thought of as Dr. Frankenstein's assistant likely has its' origins in the "Monster Mash" song, as opposed to "Young Frankenstein."
Regarding the cars vs horse and buggy, parts of Europe didn't have cars as late as the 40s in the balkans and other areas, probably just a small poorer village (?)
Even in the United States. And horse transportation co-existed with autos in my area up until the 1950's. Garbage collecting vehicles , because of their constant stopping and standing were often drawn by horse.
Love Cinnemasacre in October and I absolutely love this video. James, I'm really hoping you'll do a video of this length on the Hammer Frankenstein and Dracula films. In fact, I'm not above begging:
Please James...PLEASE do a Hammer Horror Film expose`.
Great movies, watch them every October. Love the reviews, although I always crack up when James tries to figure out continuity in the films from the 30's and 40's. When these movies were made, you saw them in the theatre once, then it would be years before you saw the next one. There wasn't TV broadcasts or video tapes for people to watch the films over and over and notice things. Remembering details from a movie you had seen two years earlier without a refresher is pretty difficult.
Monster Madness is one of my favorite parts of the month. I'm sad you've stopped making new episodes but watching these old ones in a compilation are great too!
I love videos where James just talks at length about something he's really enthusiastic about. Some of the most authentic and entertaining stuff on RUclips.
Frankenstein is the monster's name. His father was Frankenstein. Making him a Frankenstein. That's kinda how names work.
James knight and what’s his forename? His father’s was Victor.
when does he claim to be the monsters father? its not pinocchio its a science experiment.
@@MabuseXX Adam.
And Frankenstein is a monster! Boom!
@@ajzeg01 the next person who calls Adam will receive my foot kicking out of their cell phone and smacking them across the face
Weird to see this because growing up I am sure it was spelled Frankenstain
Lee May good one
Nah dude it was spelled frankensteyn
I see what you did there :D
In my universe, it is spelled Frankensteiyn.
In my universe, the scientist is Dr. Themonster, and his monster is called Themonster's Frankenstein.
"The Lever!!!" two reasons were examined; one Whale (who loved being absurd) wrote it as a quick way to tie the ending up by "killing them all" including Henry!; another, from Donald F Glut's writings, implied it was a way to get rid of evidence (grave robbing, murder, harboring a fugitive, crimes against nature) if their efforts were discovered by the authorities (and a great way to off the cops at the same time!) the reason Henry and Elizabeth are allowed to live are both to show the Monster as a noble hearted creature compared to his cohorts and to allow more sequels for what was a depression era goldmine!!
Though I've been a big fan of the Universal film studio monsters ever since I was a kid ages 7 or 8, both the Frankenstein monster and the Wolfman happen to be my top favorites of all.
Besides having numerous film books on the Universal Frankenstein films, I like drawing him as well.
I think I know how Dracula and The Wolfman came back in House of Dracula. When the sun descended, maybe Dracula was revived, and The Wolfman could have been revived when he was hit by the Full moon again after his death. That would have been a decent way to solve that plot hole.
I'll take it
Bryan Egelhoff's Animation Tech Nation makes sense to me
Frankenstein is his last name, the monster is called Adam but calling a scary thing Adam isn't the best plan.
Makes sense he’d call the monster Adam
Not quite, the monster sardonically compares himself to Adam when he’s talking to Frankenstein,
“I ought be thy Adam, but am instead thy fallen angel.”
Frankenstein on the other hand calls his creature terms such as “Monster” “Wretch” “Fiend” “Devil” “Daemon”
Never “Adam.”
One main ironic theme of the novel is that Frankenstein’s creation makes his creator as much of a wretch and a figure cut off from humanity as the monster is.
Usually during "Halloween season" (October basically) I would binge watch stuff like Treehouse of Horror and old Monster Madness, thanks to James combining old episodes I just wave to watch whatever he puts up. Monster Madness is so not over!
I really enjoy your reviews and history lessons on horror movies . I think posting old review on to RUclips for people to view is great. Your reviews have inspired me to watch and collect all the old classics
Needed a self-destruction leaver there because the self-destruction botton wasn't invented yet?
how about dials and switches?
The doctor is named Frankenstein, and he gives the monster his name. Problem solved.
Professor Fuzzymuffins i never remember him giving the monster his name, neither in the book nor the films
It can be inferred that since the monster is his creation, the monster is his child in a way. Thus, it inherits his name.
the way i see it everybody just calls the monster Frankenstein because that was the name of his creator, just like you'd share your parents' name at birth.
The Gaming Paladin Someone mentions that in son of Frankenstein. The villagers refer to the monster as Frankenstein.
More than anything, the name FRANKENSTEIN ideally suits the monster
I think it's hilarious Bela lugosi didn't want to do Frankenstein but still did plan 9 from outer space
Morphine is a helluva drug.
@@donaldronson1387 true
Karlof said the Frankenstein monster was his best friend, I reckon it didn't harm his acting career.
The lever, at the end of BRIDE, was a baseball bat.
I've also heard my lever referenced to as baseball bat like.
Interesting fun fact
@@minemaster1337 but is it true?
I love love love your classic horror movie reviews. They are the greatest movies ever made.
When I was a child, they used to play all the Universal Monster Movies on AMC once or twice a year. Couple that with the Crestwood House orange monster books from my local library and I was hooked on these. AMC rarely showed the "House" movies, though, so I don't have quite as many pleasant memories of them.
Anyway, this is a great overview of these films. Very much of their time, but I still enjoy them.
"You have booped your last boop" "AHHHHHHHHH"
More
🤐
and those boobs!!
Technically, the monster *can* be called Frankenstein. In the novel, he refers to Viktor as his father. So, by technicality, he *can* be called Frankenstein.
A lot of the actors they reused in the Universal Horror franchise we contracted they were promised so many roles and Universal decided that they should use them in horror franchise than anything else because their look was perfect for the timeline of Frankenstein.
Had to edit as I forgot to say excellent video and that the Universal Horror franchise was and always will be my fav as I remember watching these movies when I was 5 or 6 they used to show them on BBC2 on a Friday and Saturday and I was allowed to stay up and watch them as we would camp out in our living room and watch them every weekend. From then on I became a horror fan and still am today!
It’s knowledge to know Frankenstein is the doctor but it’s wisdom to know Frankenstein is the monster
After all these years, I think Son of Frankenstein has actually emerged as my favorite of the original 3 to watch. I absolutely love it. The supporting cast is just so phenomenal. Well, cept the kid of course, but I forgive.
I think it’s kinda funny that one of the only versions of Frankenstein that doesn’t kill the monster is the original book, he just sort of disappears at the end
i think he went and comited suicide if i remember correctly
... lost in darkness and distance.
@@davidbanan. He mentioned at the end of the story that he would be building a funeral pyre for himself,
Although how that would work out in the arctic I have no idea. 🤔
Maybe wood from wrecked ships frozen in the ice out there?
Really appreciate the information and criticisms you give. Well done.
I saw Frankenstein, Bride and Son because of you James. Thank you.
I love all those universal movies, Dracula was my favorite. The Spanish version is very well made also. And bride of Frankenstein, one of the hunters is caridine.
This movie makes me feel bad for the monster. Especially when he’s screaming in the burning windmill.
This narrative is truly stunning and thorough. I enjoyed the quips and thoughts I thought myself. Thanks for your candor.
THOMAS EDISON MADE FRANKENSTEIN'S MONSTER INTO A FILM!?!?!
Thomas Edison *WAS* a monster.
It's on RUclips. Look up Frankenstein 1910
Not the best Frankenstein movie (in my opinion), but it is pretty creative
I am so glad you make these!! makes october so much better! I didnt grow up with these movies so it is great to hear you live through them
I like to think of the "Igor" character as kind of being a composite of Fritz, Renfield, and Quasi-moto
I agree completely that Son of Frankenstein is awesome. Very atmospheric, and great characters.
Incidentally, the Frankenstein's machine made a re-appearance in of all things rock band Kiss' 1976 Destroyer tour but was taken off due to its expense of running.
"Everything but the kitchen sink explodes" GREAT commentary! LOL.
What if there's a parallel universe that's exactly the same as ours, except it's called *Frankenstain*
Magus Dear God... That's horrifying
Oh shit
IT WAS BARENTSTEIN!
Kept watching James videos while I was in hospital thanks for the entertainment james
I've literally watched this video like 30 to 40 times. Lol
Same here
Perhaps, it might be wise to get a life?
"The jury came in, had a trial and hanged fritz before he changed his name to Igor"
Yes
There really is a decent defense of the discrepancies between House of Frankenstein and House of Dracula, which I'm kinda surprised you didn't bring up. Both Dracula and the Wolfman have been shown to come back to life under the right circumstances, leaving Ol Frankymon to be brought back the same way he was when he was found in sulfur and ice. Yeah, there is a missing movie in between, but really they don't need it. Wolfy has the moon shine on him and Drac just has the sun go down.
I"m genuinely perplex that you didn't notice that. You put so much thought into the rest.
This was fantastic. Thanks so Much! These are some of my fav movies since i started watching them as an 80’s kid
"Woof Frankenstein" is all I can hear.
I feel the same way about Son of Frankenstein too.
It's easily become my favorite movie in the franchise.
To the question of why Fritz is mean to the monster I always took it as Fritz enjoying finally having superiority over someone else, in a bully kid kind of way.
Damn! I misread the title! I thought this was the Hammer Frankenstein movies! Which I’m only now realizing James hasn’t posted to RUclips yet!
Any one else think of resident evil 4, when you see the pictures of the villagers, marching towards the castle, with burning torches.
*loads Red 9* Ok, it's game time
Frankenstein's Monster on ATARI 2600 (Let us not forget)
Brian's Man Cave indeed we should never forget
"How about it's ass? It's AAASS!!"
Was this the origin of the mad scientist self destruct switch? The Bride of Frankenstein?
To me, the grim beauty of the story in the book is that Frankenstein creates a perfectly sound human being, but a physically repellant one. He just wanted to connect with someone like we all do, but everyone saw him as a monster, even his creator, so he eventually became a monster.
I respect the films, but the whole "Normal" and "Abnormal" brains thing takes away from the point of the original story of the creature becoming a monster like we all can.
Exactly, and to further parallel; the the doctor is physically "acceptable" and has been treated normally yet becomes internally immoral and repellent
Anyone else hear *Dr.Clitoris* every time he mentioned the guys name? A buddy overheard me watching this and asked if that's what he said and now I can't unhear it.
I love the 1931 Frankenstein movie. Those 1930's horror movies are classics and I still enjoy them today. Yes they may not be scary anymore but fans like me still love them.
The villagers are the worst monster.
Doctor Frankenstein is the true monster. He creates life, then rejects it. He plays God, then refuses to acknowledge his creation. He risks everything, breaks the laws of nature and then rejects his child-like creature for not living up to his own ideals. He refuses to see the life he made as anything other than a creation that should exist within *his* parameters. He can't see his own creation as actually living, as his own person.
Victor Frankenstein is the true monster.
The end of Frankenstein 1931 WAS tacked on. It was supposed to end at the burning windmill, but the suits at Universal wanted the audience to walk out leaving a little comforted.
awesome video and love its all combined together, but the background music is kinda distracting and not helping the mood. imo
Dude I'm so glad because I've been watching some of these old classics on peacock, and apparently a lot of these cut out scenes are still in this version.
"But it's actually Fri-it wasn't until the third film..." LOL
I was just sort of listening while working, so I don't know if the movie being referred to as seeming anachronistic because of the presence of horses and buggies is the one with the Cajuns in it, but horses and buggies were in regular use in fairly rural south Louisiana during the early to mid 1900s as attested by my relatives who were there.
These movies have the continuity of a Tom & Jerry episode
I'm with Linkara. The monster IS named Frankenstein. Partly because pop culture is just going to continue calling him that whether you like it or not, and more importantly, because the monster could be considered Dr Frankenstein's offspring and therefore inherits his surname. It's also just a cooler sounding name than anything else the monster has ever been called.
Sed-a-Give!
josh bentley83 "oh do you like it? I'm not one for desserts but this is excellent."
"Who are you talking to?"
"You. You just made a yummy sound"
That's what Abby Normal said!
BLUCHER!
I have seen your reviews before of course. But all together...Really nice!