Frédéric Chopin - Cello Sonata in G Minor, Op. 65 / Sol Gabetta and Nelson Goerner

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 24 окт 2017
  • Recorded on 17 July 2016 in the Church in Saanen
    Join us and watch the entire concert with Sol Gabetta and Nelson Goerner at: www.gstaaddigitalfestival.ch/...
  • ВидеоклипыВидеоклипы

Комментарии • 101

  • @beepst
    @beepst 4 года назад +113

    Wow, the beginning looks like a painting.

    • @leonardobarba5304
      @leonardobarba5304 4 года назад +2

      yes, someone should make a professional painting out of it.

  • @cunite9263
    @cunite9263 Год назад +8

    These musicians are such geniuses in their performances. Every note played with 100% accuracy and perfection as it's Chopin's music!🤗😘

  • @dbcelloful
    @dbcelloful 5 лет назад +39

    fantastic performance. The vibrato on the last low D...wow

  • @TheKamikraze
    @TheKamikraze 3 года назад +17

    Sol Gabetta. True legend.

  • @Elaneis
    @Elaneis 4 года назад +24

    I love this interpretation! I think one of the best performance of Chopin Sonata!

  • @NiklasFischerComposer
    @NiklasFischerComposer 3 года назад +12

    Great performance of the first movement of the Cello Sonata Op. 65. Being his last published composition, it is interesting to speculate whether Chopin would have continued to explore the use of other instruments besides the piano in his works if only he had lived longer.

  • @kaei830
    @kaei830 2 года назад +3

    この演奏は美しいなあ、こんなにも歌うショパンの演奏は滅多に聴けないと思う。また演奏のお姿、かっこいいなあ。あらためてSol Gabettaのおかげで、この曲の素晴らしさをこころより味わうことができた。本当に感謝です。

  • @MrPGOLIVEIRA
    @MrPGOLIVEIRA 8 месяцев назад +4

    A obra é belíssima e os intérpretes talentosos e de grande sensibilidade. Chopin haveria de gostar de ouvi-los.

    • @guilhermeee123
      @guilhermeee123 5 месяцев назад

      finalmente um comentário brasileiro kkk k

  • @findelka1810
    @findelka1810 3 года назад +45

    1:40 and 4:10 goes into the deepest depths of me and touches unknown, delicate parts.
    This is such a special piece, Chopin takes a different turn here and I regret it so much he didn’t live longer and continued in this direction!
    I mean all his life’s work is divine, but just thinking about the potential here 😭

    • @philipconnelly1505
      @philipconnelly1505 8 месяцев назад +1

      "...unknown, delicate parts"?
      Yuck.

    • @mrantero01
      @mrantero01 6 месяцев назад

      ​@@philipconnelly1505They're talking about their own emotions; delicate, intimate, unknown. There is nothing disgusting or pervy about it.

    • @Felven
      @Felven 2 месяца назад

      @@philipconnelly1505 relax dude its a comment on a music video lol

    • @philipconnelly1505
      @philipconnelly1505 2 месяца назад +1

      @@mrantero01 Stil yuck.

  • @BetterMe981
    @BetterMe981 4 года назад +16

    Wonderful... and as a cellist myself, my favorite sonata in our entire repertoire. Sol is amazing! Side note: the best, most fitting dress I've seen her in.

  • @gerardbegni2806
    @gerardbegni2806 6 лет назад +16

    This is indeed a great rendring of the two soloists in this sonata of Chopin, a great masterwork where Chopin uses of a style rather different than usually. All is great here !!!!!!

  • @irenenaselli2429
    @irenenaselli2429 3 года назад +4

    Goerner y Gabetta un dúo de lujo, maravillosos intérpretes en un Chopin de antología.

  • @christianbrodiez5287
    @christianbrodiez5287 6 лет назад +15

    Interprétation magistrale et grandiose de la part des deux solistes dans cette superbe sonate de Chopin avec violoncelle .

  • @AL-pu7ux
    @AL-pu7ux 2 года назад +3

    THIS is music-making. Exquisite cello playing. The piece never really made sense until now. The cello part propels the work forward harmonically.

  • @wengamy834
    @wengamy834 2 года назад +6

    Of corse they are so amazing. But they couldn’t do it without a excellent page turner .

  • @nareshguliani2345
    @nareshguliani2345 3 года назад +2

    I ever always fortunate getting connected with her

    • @nareshguliani2345
      @nareshguliani2345 3 года назад

      Sorry to write over here the word ever instead of feel written inadvertently

  • @marcosmeloni2392
    @marcosmeloni2392 10 месяцев назад +3

    Que preciosa interpretación ❤

  • @fredericcharpentier5566
    @fredericcharpentier5566 Год назад +1

    Je suis devenu au fil du temps un affreux baroqueux, ne jurant que par William Christie, Spinosi, ou la nouvelle génération, mais cette sonate me touche infiniment, le violoncelle quitte son continuo pour échanger avec le piano, et fait rare, devenir essentiel, alors que je pensais que le piano se suffisait à lui seul. Les jeux de silence et de réponse sont merveilleux. Pour les parisiens, cette œuvre sera donnée dans le cadre du festival des jeunes talents, à Paris le 20 juillet. Je suis curieux de l'entendre. Mais j'adore le violoncelle même si je lui reproche d'avoir un peu éclipsé la viole de gambe. Mais il me semble que c'est la rarissime oeuvre sublime de Chopin, avec une invitation vers un instrument à cordes ;)

  • @rnnyhoff
    @rnnyhoff 3 года назад +4

    Just love her expressive playing ... such a supreme artist, a gorgeous composition, and connected players.

  • @dansingmuch
    @dansingmuch 3 года назад +2

    To get more specific, in this piece Chopin demands a level of intensity that only Sol Gabetta, of all cellists, can bring to it. In this manner, Nelson Goerner succeeds to complement her expression and travels with her emotionally as the feel changes.

  • @raphaelguido5937
    @raphaelguido5937 4 года назад +6

    I'm in love with this piece

  • @aegeanbo
    @aegeanbo 4 года назад +5

    Thank you, it is such a pleasure to attend this concert on RUclips!

  • @jean-claudevincent7933
    @jean-claudevincent7933 Год назад +2

    Excellent, très bon enregistrement !

  • @Jonathon31
    @Jonathon31 Год назад +1

    I know next to nothing here, but this is chilling to the bone. What an incredible venue as well.

  • @jeremiebertho4750
    @jeremiebertho4750 3 года назад +2

    The intro of the piano is amazing !

  • @YuShengHung
    @YuShengHung 4 года назад +6

    Marvelous! Everything is excellent in performing, filming, and recording.

  • @user-lx1it2tv3d
    @user-lx1it2tv3d Месяц назад

    So much beauty !

  • @musikfamilie_kammenos
    @musikfamilie_kammenos 3 года назад +2

    Wonderful!

  • @LuisSousa-cu9zr
    @LuisSousa-cu9zr Год назад +3

    Fabulosa esta intérprete; pianista também excelente.

  • @martinwerner1330
    @martinwerner1330 2 года назад +1

    This performance is full of beauty and truth - transcendent. Also, one of my most favorite cellos.

  • @fredericcharpentier5566
    @fredericcharpentier5566 Год назад +2

    C'est juste sublime et une oeuvre à défendre, en espérant qu'elle rentre dans de nombreux répertoires :)

  • @lorenzamarelli8363
    @lorenzamarelli8363 6 лет назад +1

    Lei mi ipnotizza sempre!

  • @dansingmuch
    @dansingmuch 3 года назад +1

    Beautiful performance by both artists. Of course, Sol Gabetta is marvelous.

  • @christianwitt4471
    @christianwitt4471 6 лет назад +3

    Wonderfull!

  • @bachshafran508
    @bachshafran508 3 года назад +3

    현존하는 첼리스트 중에 그래도 가장 풍부한 소리의 연주를 하는 첼리스트같네요 이름이 난 연주가들 연주 들으면서도 많이 허전함을 느끼곤 했는데 ..
    좋은연주 감사합니다.

  • @tianzonghu104
    @tianzonghu104 5 лет назад +1

    Bravo !!!

  • @pukklemaster4765
    @pukklemaster4765 Год назад +2

    3:50 and 9:00 and 14:09 are so beautiful i love this sonata

  • @Conn30Mtenor
    @Conn30Mtenor Год назад +1

    That is one heavyweight piece of music.

  • @bugatti103
    @bugatti103 2 года назад +1

    Bravo!

  • @fredericcharpentier5566
    @fredericcharpentier5566 Год назад +1

    Sorry for not carring on in english, i'm not fluent in this language. I've read among advices, Chopin equal Piano. But this sonata is very particular, very rare. This piece has been composed betwwen Chopin and Franchome, a cello player. It had comming from frendship Beetween Chopin, Franchome and even Lizt. Just before his death, Chopin asked or wished to ear again this composition. And it was giving ( or granted?)
    I used to be pianist, until my sutdies, and i have difficulties to read correctely "la clef de Fa" Thanks to Covid, i play again ;) Il est difficile de critiquer l'interprétation de Sol Gabetta, que j'ai toujours en tête comme la plus grande violoncelliste depuis Jacqueline Dupré. Je ne sais si cette dernière à joué cette œuvre, et j'ai quelques difficultés avec les enregistrements antérieur aux années 1980. Il y a quelques semaines, j'ai entendu salle Gaveau Camille Thomas et Julien Brocal au piano, j'ai été conquis.

  • @ivanbeshkov1718
    @ivanbeshkov1718 3 года назад +1

    There is no better cello sonata. I always look forward to this quiet moment 2:45

  • @roberthuber5589
    @roberthuber5589 Год назад +1

    Bravissimo

  • @markjahn6205
    @markjahn6205 4 года назад +3

    멋지다...

  • @daponte18
    @daponte18 4 года назад +6

    I love the way she plays this first movement of the Chopin Cello Sonata. Beautiful tone and engaging musicality. Great accompanist as well.

    • @dansingmuch
      @dansingmuch 3 года назад +3

      Debra, if you'll listen closely there is no "accompanist" here. They are two artists playing together providing equal contributions. That is not to take away Sol Gabetta's unique artistry which no other cellist can come close to achieving. In small group works like duos, trios, etc., this notion of "accompanist" must be dispelled. I doubt whether these great composers thought in those terms.

    • @matthewbergey7153
      @matthewbergey7153 3 года назад

      Accompanist. Lol

  • @dartoisrobert8897
    @dartoisrobert8897 4 года назад +2

    Belle sonate avec pour ces 2 musiciens dont la merveilleuse Sol GABETTA.

  • @josebaviera74
    @josebaviera74 6 лет назад +5

    Impresionante !! 2 cracks

  • @daponte18
    @daponte18 3 года назад +4

    Lovely playing and interpretation!

  • @marcosPRATA918
    @marcosPRATA918 3 года назад +1

    Com sensibilidade...

  • @fredericcharpentier5566
    @fredericcharpentier5566 Год назад +1

    ( euh pour le côté Baroque , ne pensez pas que j'oubliais Alarcon, mais je suis surtout sur Mademoiselle Duval; heureusement rejouée par Camille Delaforge et son ensemble Il Caravaggio. ON ne connait pas son prénom. Cette sonate pour violoncelle de Chopin me fait le même effet d'extrême rareté ;)

  • @RockStarOscarStern634
    @RockStarOscarStern634 4 года назад +1

    Gstaad Menuhin Festival & Academy There's even a version for the Violin, but I need to get a Violin if I'm ever going to be playing the Violin versions of Cello sonatas I can find.

  • @NareshNaresh-lr9nq
    @NareshNaresh-lr9nq 3 года назад +2

    Whenever I come to this masterpiece it seems as if Jacqueline is there

  • @niklausgaschen9858
    @niklausgaschen9858 4 года назад +4

    You listen to Chopins last work . So dark.

  • @datdat5654
    @datdat5654 2 года назад +8

    5:10 was Chopin quoting Liszt B minor Sonate? lol

  • @user-mg3lx6iz4i
    @user-mg3lx6iz4i 2 года назад +1

    무대는 성당이거나 교회당인 것 같은데, 이런 생각을 해 봅니다. '저기에서 예배를 드린다는 광고가 나가면 이렇게 많은 사람들이 모일까?' ...내 생각 자체가 공감을 얻을 수 없겠지만... 어떻든 우리 인생의 귀와 감성에 더 친근한 음악회는 인산인해를 이룬다고 해도 결국 소리도 사라지고 여운도 냉정한 현실에 먹히고 무대도 낡거나 잊혀지고 말겠지요

  • @user-rg6to2mt8s
    @user-rg6to2mt8s 4 года назад +2

    Originally this video was a full movement. Why is there only 1st movement???I want to more movements...!😭

    • @Menuhinfestival
      @Menuhinfestival  4 года назад +2

      Could can find the entire piece (and concert!) on www.gstaaddigitalfestival.ch/en/video/sol-gabetta-plays-chopins-cello-sonata-in-g-minor-op-65/
      Best wishes

  • @takeshik5950
    @takeshik5950 Год назад +1

    Only Sol Gabetta is good for Chopin

  • @fullofdance3732
    @fullofdance3732 6 лет назад +12

    I committed a crime of lèse majesté: I played this sonata at 75% of speed. It became absolutely arresting, far more than at actual speed. I love Sol Gabetta, it seems she would become one with her cello, if she only could. But here, it's everything far too rushed, I barely can make out Chopin's unmistakable style. Yes, every artist is entitled to his own "reading", I completely agree with that. But every listener has its own preferences too...

    • @5iveR4ptor
      @5iveR4ptor 5 лет назад +3

      very delicate comment

    • @scruffysean3640
      @scruffysean3640 4 года назад +5

      I don't know... I'm a cellist too, and I am a bit ashamed to admit it, but this sonata has always bored me to tears. Until, that is, I watched Ms. Gabetta's and Mr. Goerner's performance. Never before has this sonata seemed so alive to me, so full of sincere expression. This is a unique piece among Chopin's works, and in my opinion it's such a challenge to bring it off effectively.

    • @robetech1
      @robetech1 4 года назад +7

      @@scruffysean3640 Nobody phrases like Sol Gabetta. Everything she does brings a totally new approach to the work. I too have been a career cellist (59 years)
      and I have never heard anyone deliver all the genres totally differently--as they should be. Her Shostakovich is incredible.

    • @BetterMe981
      @BetterMe981 4 года назад +1

      FullOFGrace... interesting. I usually don't like the tempo anyone takes on this sonata, but I LOVED Sol's, I thought it was perfect. Well, because it's the same speed I play it. The reason is because then the Largo movement makes sense, and actually can be played as slowly as is required (a true Largo) to make it so beautiful. When the 1st movement is too slow, the Largo suffers and the whole things just sounds draggy, IMHO.

    • @BetterMe981
      @BetterMe981 4 года назад +5

      @@scruffysean3640 Oh I'm so glad you got to hear this, then! I have loved this sonata since I discovered it at age 15 (I'm a professional cellist in my 50s now). I found it in a music store, bought it, started tackling it at home, then took it to my teacher to ask him to teach it to me. He laughed, lol, saying, "Ohhh, there's just too much music in that piece, it exhausts me." LOL. But that's what I loved about it. It seems to take a different emotion at every turn. He did teach it to me over the next few years. And I love it now just as much as over 35 years ago. Sol really gets this piece.

  • @FreeSkillsStyle
    @FreeSkillsStyle 3 года назад +4

    Why does he needs switching pages? Just remember it lol

  • @markchentx
    @markchentx 5 лет назад +7

    Dear camera person, it is a cello sonata, please balance the aiming of your lens.

    • @lunairepierrot5420
      @lunairepierrot5420 4 года назад +4

      Well you need to know ...
      Chopin mainly composed piano music...
      So it implies that piano...is much more important than solo instruments... the cameraman did 50/50,
      So he was smart...

    • @BetterMe981
      @BetterMe981 4 года назад +8

      Mark... The parts are actually equal. Camera person knew exactly what he or she was doing.

    • @BetterMe981
      @BetterMe981 4 года назад +7

      @@lunairepierrot5420 lol... well, "much more important than solo instruments" is... well.. wrong, lol. But yes, it was done 50/50 as it should.

    • @gerardnoest1831
      @gerardnoest1831 4 года назад +6

      Awful camera, especially the tedious switching back and forth. What is wrong with aiming the lens at both musicians at the same time? And just leaving it there!

    • @wylqh_
      @wylqh_ 3 года назад +1

      well the camera focused on the instrument which are having the melody so its pretty well balanced actually.

  • @harrystanton7702
    @harrystanton7702 3 года назад +2

    Wow that's a big violin

    • @nerrdinho
      @nerrdinho 3 года назад

      That’s a Cello

  • @YouTubeChannel-nf2nw
    @YouTubeChannel-nf2nw 4 года назад +4

    is this his last song

  • @VoidCosmonaut
    @VoidCosmonaut 4 года назад +3

    Chopin = piano
    Chello breaks it for me

  • @NareshNaresh-lr9nq
    @NareshNaresh-lr9nq 3 года назад +2

    She's a carbon copy of Jacqueline due pre, indeed

    • @winter2may
      @winter2may Месяц назад

      No Jacqueline was gentle, Sol is a bit more rushed and certainly not as gentle

  • @mr.p5446
    @mr.p5446 3 года назад +1

    It’s a nice work but for sure not his best one. It’s a little hard to understand the line of thought behind it. The theme is a bit confusing . I love Chopin and dedicated 19 years to his work . I love him very very much! But unfortunately, as far as this specific sonata , and if you can subjectively compare it with Schubert’s Arpeggione sonata ( played with the cello) Chopin falls short . His piano of course of spotless !

  • @niklausgaschen9858
    @niklausgaschen9858 4 года назад +1

    And so pathetic!