The most important take away and the crux of the whole debate is what Dr. Kaiser Bengali said: to improve the state by improving the democracy, role of people. I strongly believe that without that thousand such debates will not change a thing unless people get politically involved. It has to move beyond intellectual into political activism. This is what Brabari party aims to do. We also appreciate that Dr Kaiser Bengali was kind enough to have a session at our forum. Barabri Party is only political party which is trying to bring such discussions down to grassroots.
Dr.kaiser Bengali mentioned that the first thirty years were the development of the economic era. I remember Dr Maboob Ul Haq speech in karachi University about 22 families, which later became a political slogan that paved the way of economic disaster.
The Punjabi Landlord and Punjabi dominated military are responsible for fragmentation of the society, marred economy , disintegration of the country and division in religious lines
I disagree about Dr Bangali's opinion about MNS. MNS plays the role of Estb guy when in opposition, for example, during 2008 - 13, and also post 2022 which still continues. However, when in power he confronts, I agree. But I guess that more a fight for power than a fight for rights.
Kaiser Bengali is not a communist. He is free market guy. lets dont misunderstand free market vs crony capitalism. Free market kills any abuse by market player by giving level playing field, while crony capitalism kills competition. by keep on badgering him as left, nadeem is forcing him accept that he is not for capitalism. Almost true free market is USA where educated people like bill gates, elon musk, bezos, warren buffett can become rich while in crony capitalism we have ambani, adani, monarchies of Middle east , Onsi Sawiris of egypt etc who are rich.
Pakistan problems has these solutions 1- Free and fair elections by evm- vvpat technology or other advanced technology 2- Referendum on either the political system in pak should be based on presidential or parliamentary system. 3- Divide every province of pakistan into two parts north/south and on basis of better administration (north punjab/south punjab, North sindh/ south sindh) Etc- And give Provincial status tooo Gilgit Baltistan and Azad Kashmir 4- Jooo bheee natural resources hain pak mee petrol,gas,coal unnnn seee anne waleee revenue usss district kaa 70% tak share unnnkeee pass hogee yane unnn natural resources see anee wala revenue kaaa 70% wooo district ki elected govt rakhegi rakheengee baki federal govt or province koo sirf kuch heee hisssa milegaa. 5- Pure pakistan meee ek standard digital or fixed tax policy banaou jismeee 15 seee zyada tax naaa hooo direct or indirect or 10lac seee kam.kamane walae peee tax naa hooo or food item peee 5% seee zyada tax naa hoooo or in taxes kooo bant deeya jayee 5- taxes kooo federal govt kooo 5- taxes provincisl govt 5- taxes municipal govt koooo 6-NFC award kooo change kiyeaa jayeee budget kaaa revenue kaaa share 70-75% federal govt appne pass rakhee (provinces appna tax revenue khud collect karee) or isske sath PFC(provincial finance commision)districts koo milne walee paisee or District financial commision (jooo district govt aggey villages or tehsils koooo deee) 7- Pure pakistan directly elected districts govts and village govt(panchayat raj/india) kee election hooo or constitution mee jese pm or cm kee roles or powers likhee hain wesee hee mayor ki powers or responsibility likhh deee jayee (water, sewrage Police, cleanliness) or tax collection jese water tax property tax, motor vehicle tax, service tax, sab mayor collect kareee or local govt kaa subject provinces see leekeee federal govt keee pass or election bhee unke election commision karwayee naa kee provinces. 8- Pak mee yeee Ethnic based qota system govt jobs mee khtam karkee sareew recuritment 100% css exams or merit or ussske professional degree based peee hooo or pak meee single national curriculum laggo kese karna hain usski planning kiiyee jayee 9- The federal and provincial election should be held seprately(Matlab provincial or federal govt kee election ek din peee naa hooo) There should be a gap of 3 months To 6 months 10- Abolish care taker govt 11- Remove perks, privillages, Protocoals, benefits of every beaureacrate, lawmakers(mna), judges, Military officers. 12- Restoration of student unions 13- Protection of agriculture land from urbanization
The most important take away and the crux of the whole debate is what Dr. Kaiser Bengali said: to improve the state by improving the democracy, role of people. I strongly believe that without that thousand such debates will not change a thing unless people get politically involved. It has to move beyond intellectual into political activism. This is what Brabari party aims to do.
We also appreciate that Dr Kaiser Bengali was kind enough to have a session at our forum. Barabri Party is only political party which is trying to bring such discussions down to grassroots.
Good work. State and state apparatus need to listen such debate. But, I do not think no one care to listen such energetic debate.
Keep it up!
Much informative session sir
Excellent, May Almighty Allah bless guidance to our Government's
Allah hasn’t done anything till now . Pray to IMF n China
Another great interview.
Can we get Dr Qaiser's this report on controlling Govt Expenditures please
We need several more discussions between Dr Nadeem ul Haque and Dr Kaiser Bengali on issue by issue solutions
Dr.kaiser Bengali mentioned that the first thirty years were the development of the economic era. I remember Dr Maboob Ul Haq speech in karachi University about 22 families, which later became a political slogan that paved the way of economic disaster.
👍👍👍
Great debate sir
The Punjabi Landlord and Punjabi dominated military are responsible for fragmentation of the society, marred economy , disintegration of the country and division in religious lines
This is a very informative discussion
I disagree about Dr Bangali's opinion about MNS. MNS plays the role of Estb guy when in opposition, for example, during 2008 - 13, and also post 2022 which still continues. However, when in power he confronts, I agree. But I guess that more a fight for power than a fight for rights.
Audio quality is very poor nadeem Mic has that awful sound. Please have a good mic
Kaiser Bengali is not a communist. He is free market guy. lets dont misunderstand free market vs crony capitalism. Free market kills any abuse by market player by giving level playing field, while crony capitalism kills competition. by keep on badgering him as left, nadeem is forcing him accept that he is not for capitalism. Almost true free market is USA where educated people like bill gates, elon musk, bezos, warren buffett can become rich while in crony capitalism we have ambani, adani, monarchies of Middle east , Onsi Sawiris of egypt etc who are rich.
Exactly correct
Thanks for putting this out, many people equate capitalism with crony capitalism only
👍👍
Everything is good but sound is not clear🎉🎉 ❤️ so can't understand most of it
Pak is unlucky despite having lucky intellectual Kaiser
Pakistan problems has these solutions
1- Free and fair elections by evm- vvpat technology or other advanced technology
2- Referendum on either the political system in pak should be based on presidential or parliamentary system.
3- Divide every province of pakistan into two parts north/south and on basis of better administration (north punjab/south punjab, North sindh/ south sindh) Etc- And give Provincial status tooo Gilgit Baltistan and Azad Kashmir
4- Jooo bheee natural resources hain pak mee petrol,gas,coal unnnn seee anne waleee revenue usss district kaa 70% tak share unnnkeee pass hogee yane unnn natural resources see anee wala revenue kaaa 70% wooo district ki elected govt rakhegi rakheengee baki federal govt or province koo sirf kuch heee hisssa milegaa.
5- Pure pakistan meee ek standard digital or fixed tax policy banaou jismeee 15 seee zyada tax naaa hooo direct or indirect or 10lac seee kam.kamane walae peee tax naa hooo or food item peee 5% seee zyada tax naa hoooo or
in taxes kooo bant deeya jayee
5- taxes kooo federal govt kooo
5- taxes provincisl govt
5- taxes municipal govt koooo
6-NFC award kooo change kiyeaa jayeee budget kaaa revenue kaaa share 70-75% federal govt appne pass rakhee (provinces appna tax revenue khud collect karee) or isske sath PFC(provincial finance commision)districts koo milne walee paisee or District financial commision (jooo district govt aggey villages or tehsils koooo deee)
7- Pure pakistan directly elected districts govts and village govt(panchayat raj/india) kee election hooo or constitution mee jese pm or cm kee roles or powers likhee hain wesee hee mayor ki powers or responsibility likhh deee jayee (water, sewrage Police, cleanliness) or tax collection jese water tax property tax, motor vehicle tax, service tax, sab mayor collect kareee or local govt kaa subject provinces see leekeee federal govt keee pass or election bhee unke election commision karwayee naa kee provinces.
8- Pak mee yeee Ethnic based qota system govt jobs mee khtam karkee sareew recuritment 100% css exams or merit or ussske professional degree based peee hooo or pak meee single national curriculum laggo kese karna hain usski planning kiiyee jayee
9- The federal and provincial election should be held seprately(Matlab provincial or federal govt kee election ek din peee naa hooo) There should be a gap of 3 months To 6 months
10- Abolish care taker govt
11- Remove perks, privillages, Protocoals, benefits of every beaureacrate, lawmakers(mna), judges, Military officers.
12- Restoration of student unions
13- Protection of agriculture land from urbanization
Long live Pakistan 🇵🇰❤️
ruclips.net/video/fjQR9r7vKN8/видео.htmlsi=iDIXLRAaomNmn9VQ