LIVE: The Trial of Chad Daybell Day 29
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 21 сен 2024
- #daybell #eastidahonews #truecrime
This is a livestream of day 29 in the Chad Daybell trial.
Let us know if you have questions and where you are watching from.
► Subscribe to East Idaho News: www.youtube.co...
► Support East Idaho News: www.eastidahon...
► Download our free app: marketplace-red...
► Like us on Facebook: / eastidahonews
► Follow us on X: / eastidnews
► Follow us on Instagram: / eastidahonews
► Get East Idaho News merch: www.eastidahon...
► Subscribe to our free newsletter: www.eastidahon...
God! Prior is nasty. Exhuming Tammy was not an affront to the family and I’m sick of him insinuating such. She was exhumed due to a murder investigation.
DUG!! UP!! OUT !! OF THE GROUND!!! Voice gets louder and gravellier
Exactly! The affront to Tammy would be to allow her murderer to get away with his crimes.
I dont know what point he thinks he is making, as every time he says it, he just reinforces to the jury that her kids didn't give a toss about her, and were quite happy to let her murderer go free. They don't care that she was murdered, its all about Chad, like so what if he killed her!
No respect for their mother
Hi GiGi! I'm so sick of Prior repeating "When they dug up Tammy from the ground" every single chance he gets. It sounds terrible and he knows it! That's why he says it. It creates a picture of a couple of grave-robbers desecrating her resting spot for sinister purposes or something. When in reality it was professionals trying to seek justice for the poor woman. I agree.
You know who wouldn't care about knowing what was on their Moms autopsy as soon as given the opportunity to learn whats on it? Someone who already knows how they died, thats who.
Right. We’ve waited this long, we’ll just wait longer. 🤦🏼♂️ This defense was a joke.
@@parisite99Seriously. I can't even believe that Chad thought he would have a chance in h3ll
You got that RIGHT!!!
He does have at chance in Hell!
Exactly! That’s what I said today, she already knew how her mother died….by Alex and her father.
Am I the only person that believes Emma implicated herself as an accessory? During her testimony, she said that she was checking for the direction of the wind for Chad. I'm sure she knew why he needed that information.
I agre!
I grew up in rural Idaho. You HAVE to check for wind-speed and direction when you are going to conduct controlled burns on ditch and canal banks in order to protect yours and other peoples properties. From what was said, the smoke and fire would have gone over to where Emma was living. Covering for her father meant that if it came over her way she could report that it didn't thus protecting him. ( allegedly)
She implicated herself as a liar. No chance she did that search
I do believe she was an accessory AND she totally covered up for her father. She does have an oedipus complex with her father…her witness comments sounded like she herself would have made a better wife for her father. Creepy family dynamics all around. I personally believe that Chad wanted to be a polygamist for the 2nd coming. He was just trying to figure out how he could manipulate that!
Emma was the biggest liar on the stand.Her brother right after her !
Love the school witness. She completely contradicts Emma. JP is trying to bully her but she clearly outsmarted him.
Oh she was having none of his bullying or rudeness. Don’t mess with a good teacher ever❤
@@joycekane9024 ❤️
Knowing that Garth was closest to his mother, Chad let Garth find his dead mother and then forced him to lie about it.
How about because Chad was ‘sleeping’ upstairs…? And they don’t want anyone to know the fact that he and Tammy were basically already estranged…
Garth is a grown man.
Garth choose to lie for his adulterous, serial murder father.
I wonder if that’s why he didn’t look at Chad during his testimony!
@@jillb7234hmmmm, good catch, i had not noticed
@OutWestRedDirt exactly, they don't get a pass because he is the offspring of Chad Daybell,They all should be charged with perjury
Priors last 5 minutes did not help his client in anyway. Made himself out to be a thug.
Last words are forever words
JP is a thug
Yes, that deputy seemed very humble and deferential.
A big bully
none of priors minutes ever helped his client, especially the 3 paid witnesses that reaffirmed what the states experts said. And also when he called tammy's death a murder. and he bills $350 an hour for that shoddiness.
He is trying to save Chads life I believe he knows in his heart he is guilty. Pryer is getting paid to do a job so Chad has to have a decent defense to not win on any appeals.
Chad, Emma and her husband Joe, and Garth need to be held accountable for their lies and involvement in Tammys death! My grandmother had a saying here in Mt., "They need to have their feet held to the fire". Considering the treatment of Tylee, the word fire is SO appropriate here.
I grew up in Idaho, that quotation was used by my family. All of the parents and aunts, uncles, and grandparents. Poor sweet Tylee and J. J. EVERY time I hear about anything to do with their torture and murder in the court proceedings, I cry and cry and tell them 'how sorry I am that you were betrayed and murdered by parents and family. "
Indiana here, and yes we still use that saying. Thanks for the reminder. Very appropriate! 👍
yes Emma Joe and Garth especially need some consequences! They were clearly involved after we heard their testimony/lies!! I think Emma helped kill people in my opinion!
"To the [fire]." Damn, that is so true. Shivers. 😢
Listening to the missing portions of Tylee today 😢 WTH is wrong with these Daybell kids???
Wouldn’t it be the most delicious karma if Chad was found guilty on every charge on June 9?
I think he will!
He will be 😂
I'd do the happy dance 💃💃💃
June 9th? Sorry im old, cant keep track of dates.
That would be great!!
I think the kids def know more than they are telling to cover for their evil dad.
I think the defense attorney is tone deaf for thinking further analysis about Tylee’s body parts is going to score him points.
I think it just solidified to the jury of ALL the trauma and DESTRUCTION that poor Tylee and her bones WENT THROUGH at the time of her death. I feel it was a BAD MOVE on Priors part!
He mis spoke when he started that statement but he got it past the state! He said, could you please circle the bones missing from her burial site! He wasn't there!! The bones he saw were on a table he can't say what was missing from the ground but the question went without objection, so he wanted the jury to think its proof her bones were somehow moved and they forgot to put some in the hole! None of what this man was there to say could have anything to do with that. But prior got the question out..
I was curious how describing that all Tylees limbs etc are missing is not an advantage to the defence at all -unless it's to say the missing limbs were taken disposed of by 😮 someone else somewhere else -
@jcarroll135 my 1st thought was dumbells text saying he burnt all the raccoons limbs
He is doing his job. By insinuating that Tylee's body had to have been burned at such a hot temperature for so long for her bones to be missing, that it was not possible to do that on Chad's property.
I have not heard of many such kids who do this to their own mother. These are truly evil kids.
From all accounts Tammy wasn't nasty. There appears to be no justification for kids hostility toward their mother.
They are brainwashed. Chad has had a hold on them their whole lives.
Just cash from daddy to lie . @@OutWestRedDirt
Deep in their fathers cult - poor Tammy 😢
I think so 2. Oh my my . Just creepy crazy
"My kids are good at keeping secrets," I hope the jury remembers Chads words.
I'm trying to catch up, was that statement ever offered as testimony?
@@TriciaEllingerYes, there was a married couple. Wife testified first, then her husband. It was the husband who told about this statement.
I heavily suspect LB is saving that golden nugget to repeat in closing arguments! That would be a nice mic drop moment!
@@TriciaEllingersomeone said that Chad said that to them. I wanna say it was Jason.
@@vihmake The Gardners, maybe
What was the purpose of the forensic anthropologist other than to traumatise family again. Prior is disgusting
He wanted to plant reasonable doubt. He wants to argue it was possible Tylee’s body was burned somewhere else, so it couldn’t be Chad. 🤦🏻♀️
But I have to agree with the traumatizing her family once more. But in a sick way, he’s effective counsel for defense.
To try and put doubt in the juror's heads that Chad could not have burned Tylee's remains hot enough/long enough in a simple fire pit on his property - since so many of her bones were missing.
Insinuating an accelerant was used which was not found (or a hotter fire) was needed. I didn't like it either, but he is doing his job.
@@AmeliasMiMiwe wrote the same thing at the same time. 😊
All Prior did was ....at the end of the trial to show verbally to the jury the DESTRUCTION of Tylees body! This actually, I feel, HELPED the prosecution! Prior was better off not bringing these facts to the forefront of the juries mind, AGAIN.
@@marygoff3332 🤣👍🏻👍🏻 indeed we did. Too cool. 😎🫶🏻
Absolutely love Lindsey Blake. The prosecution team has been so on point, professional and prepared.
She totally reminds me of Camille Vasquez from the Depp trial. VERY smart and quick as a whip!
@@kateashby3066was just about to write that🤗
Yes, Lindsay Blake is very professional and performing her role as Prosecutor very effectively 👏👏👏
These four people, Charles, Tammy, Tyler, and JJ, deserved better. Poor Tylee had no one to turn to, no one. She was betrayed by all the close adults in her life, including those Melanie's.
😞
If only Tylee had known her best chance was to team up with Charles and get her mom locked away in a mental hospital. Maybe, at the very least, Charles and the kids would still be alive.
@@moonchild645 I was just thinking this, how sad that the person she was said to fear the most by Lori, was the one person trying to protect and help her 😢
Agreed 💯
Garth’s friend dropped a bombshell. WOAAH! So Garth found his mother and no where in sight of Chad. 🤯
Where did you see this?
I’m late to this. Can you explain more about Garth finding his mother?
@melissanelson628 it came from the 2nd rebuttal witnesses. Guy who worked with garth at haunted house.
That statement about garth finding his mother was brought up when prosecution did cross on Garth himself. Garth told a few different stories, that's why there was a 2nd grand jury because of that.
That’s a lie chad was there in the house
There are so many people who should be held accountable in this ...but I bet they won't be. ..💜
Emma and Garth, Gibb, Zulema tho Zulema's testimony was helpful so I'm ok with her getting immunity. I think Gibb was a hostile witness in Chad's trial. I don't think Gibb deserves immunity... she kept saying she didn't remember anything, that made me mad.
@TheChesireKat don't forget melani palawski... also Julie Rowe....who imo is the initial sidekick of chad...
Did I miss Julie row on stand? Omg
Indeed
@@christydurbin9277 oh no can u tell me which day please il go back x
If I had children at that school where she is teaching I would remove them, up and leave to another area with another school. It is disgusting. I wouldnt let my children around her.
What if she all of a sudden would think my child was dark? Chad said there were children in their Sunday school class that were dark. And they even named names! Nate said he would not name the names on courtroom insider news show. Nate is wonderful like that.
I heavily suspect she’s going to have a really rough time in life now that her entire town has seen her on the stand. A very hard time. Frankly I don’t know how she will even keep her job. Kids (her students) talk and gossip too! 🤷🏻♀️
OMG, anybody who has kids in Emma’s school, best be getting their kids out of there.
Garth too.
I would immediately call for their removal or withdraw my kids.
I know people whose children are in Emma's class and she's a good teacher.
@@JenniLynn1218I seriously doubt her teachers union or the law allows them to fire her just because they didn’t like her testimony. And if they did she could sue the town into bankruptcy. She won’t be fired. But she’s going to be miserable with EVERYONE talking about her and her k!ller father. And parents pi$$ed off and wanting to pull their kids from her class. I suspect it will be bad.
@@carollynnharris5604ok 😂
When prior says ok…ok… after the witness answers it makes me cringe
And somehow 90% of the time he has a "bite and an edge" to his voice.
he is sooooo cringe and disgusting!!!! With everything he says!
“Okaaay, okaaaay” 🤮
@@My2centsarenecessarylmao I didn’t see your comment until after I posted mine^ “okaaaaay” 😂😂😂
It's ok. We all want to slap him into next week, IMO
The injuries to poor Tylee’s body- how angry or insane does someone have to be?!? What point was there to breaking her jawbone 6 places?! Horrific
That absolutely broke my heart! Why??? 😫
I think they might have been chopping big bones down to smaller pieces to help them disintegrate. Gruesome 😢
Tylee was tortured.
The horrific pain that beautiful young lady suffered is heart breaking. The anger of the attack is inconceivable. We have to believe justice will prevail for Tylee, JJ and Tammy 😢
@@cariel1253& Charles 💙
If I were Chad, after today, I would be begging the prosecution for a plea deal!
Prior came across as a pouting toddler who just dropped their sucker.
YES. Oh judge it's looking bad, can I plea after all this? Ah, NO
@@inthesun3884 nope, if the prosecution wants he can take a plea at any time.
I think nate said that he could try to make a deal if the state would agree. Don't remember what the cot of was tho.
Prior does this because it’s intimidating and it’s supposed to throw off the witness and turn them into a blubbering
I’d!ot. It also makes it seem like he’s offended by their “dishonest” answers as if he is the one in the right and they are liars (he is using psychology to manipulate the jurors). Unfortunately for him- all of these witnesses remained very calm, cool, and collected, and made his client look very bad with their answers 😂
@@franklinanderson9687the prosecution won’t do that this late in the game so yeah- it’s def too late. Esp cause defense is LOSING big time.
Did anyone else think that Emma's voice was much more fluent in the taped meeting with the police office compared to her testimony (rehearsed) voice
Yes, there was a huge difference. She sounded like a likable human being, rather than a robot.
Yes, I noticed that as well!
Yes!! She was no longer a step ford wife!! And if we notice this then so did the jury. Unfortunately I don’t think they are allowed to re-listen ti the recording. I think they just get the transcript 😢
Chad made sure Tammy couldnt be recucitated he waited hours to report it.
I believe Emma and Garth lied through their teeth to save daddys life. Emmas entire time on stand was a fake embarassment and totally coached.
I have a gut feeling that Garth didn’t lie to protect dad from being seen as a murderer. I suspect that dad told him to keep his secret that he and Tammy were sleeping in separate beds as that would bring Shame to the family. So Chad told him to say X. Garth thinking he was just protecting his dead mothers honor, kept this secret and then was locked in by threat of imprisonment is he deviated from it. Emma? That girl KNOWS what happened. I’m all but certain. Garth was supposedly the closest to Tammy out of EVERYONE in that family. He bawled his eyes out at the funeral and was in shock on the 911 call. I just don’t think he’s bad… just got suckered by his dad is all. 😢
I don't think she was coached much. I think the lies came from her.
Good Lord, they are a strange family .
They are all weird
😂
They are like the an LDS version of the Adam's family. If the Adam's family thought they were Warlocks sent by God. Such a strange bunch
@@TeaSpiracy In the land of zion here and they are the same as 99% of all these "Doomsday" saints of the Latter Days! Many (including mine) still believing chad could be innocent & his kids are wonderful -
The unbelievable rudeness of Chad’s attorney to Tammy’s coworker….. I can’t. Truly shameful.
She didn’t let herself get affected by it at all though, she rocks in my eyes.
That really was rude, sarcastic and condescending. Doubt he scored any points with the Jury.
That’s his job. To rattle and throw off the witness. They (defense lawyers) all do it. The ones who win cases anyways. “Don’t hate the player, hate the game” 😉
Chads kids are right out of Children of the Corn.
For real!
Children of the cash after daddy paid them off.
@@desertsunset8025 I bet LD$ got their 10% so kids could keep their temple recommends !
I’m rather impressed how Judge Boyce is running the show.
You GO! JUDGE BOYCE!!!
I agree, he's an excellent judge and runs his court room very professionally.
Judge Boyce is a keeper. He was Judge at Lori’s trial, as well. Very keeps a proper Courtroom, listens to each side of an issue. And rules fairly. And accordingly. I respect and honor his service
Thank you, Judge Boyce! .
Was just thinking this yesterday. Truly takes his duty seriously.
He’s VERY sharp. Frankly I LOVED his ruling not to allow that detective to be a rebuttal witness since he watched the trial and that goes against the rules. Sure it would be nice to hear from him again, but judge B didn’t allow it because he knows damn well that the prosecutors don’t need his testimony to bring this case home and if he DID let him take the stand, it could give Chad a great reason to overturn the verdict on appeal. So even when he decides something that is a loss for us, it’s actually to protect us from a successful appeal. For a small town judge he’s AMAZING. 😭❤️🔥
Any distance respect I had for Prior was totally extinguished in his last cross examination of the detective. Absolutely the worst way to end his day.
I’m glad it was as he probably made the jury feel the same way. I’m glad he is who he is. Let’s not mistake him for Chad and Lori. We all dislike him and I’m grateful for it
Safe to say the jury hates him at this point.
Hopefully the jury hates Chad.
So Joe and Garth get away with Perjury plain and simple. And also Emma. And now law enforcement has been defamed and called a liar. Sickening 🤢🤢
The cop will survive.🙄
And the world 🌎 knows the TRUTH
Emma, Joe and Garth will have to live with the lies they have told. Few places to hide from what they have done. Chad was happy to destroy their futures and they were happy to do so.
The detective sounded kind. I felt bad for him, and there is no excuse for Prior to have treated him so despicably.
Welcome to court. That’s how it goes. The jury gets to decide who is telling the truth and it won’t be chads ppl. Unless there is HARD evidence that someone lied under oath, they can’t prosecute based on a hunch.
The veil has lifted on all his lies.
I've never seen this addressed: She was found at 1 am. She was in rigor mortis at 6 when they called. WHY DIDN'T GARTH CALL 911 AT 1 ????
What do you mean she was found at 1am? They've always claimed they called when they found her. She was dead long before they supposedly realized. No one said they found her at 1am. Or are you going by his coworkers testimony? 🤔 can you elaborate? Thank you.
I think, based on the co-workers testimony, that she was dead downstairs by 1am. Chad was ‘asleep’ UPSTAIRS, having completed the dirty deed, abetted by Alex Cox, whom he had earlier collected from Salem Church to get the job done. (During which time Alex turned his phone off). Based on the circumstantial evidence provided, and which the Defense have been so desperate to disprove, it would seem that Chad had been sleeping upstairs for some time (which would lend credence to the fact that he and Tammy had become somewhat estranged), or perhaps he just snored loudly! I don’t think he expected Garth to find her until morning, and when he found her earlier, asked him to hold off so he could maintain the facade of the ‘marital bed’…. I don’t think Garth lied for nefarious purposes.
@@TheQueenofConstantiaaccording to Prior there is NO upstairs.
Another lie by defense.
NOTE ON "Comedy of errors" remark. That was a courtesy. Far preferable to saying, "It seems like you and your siblings have been avoiding us."
The last thing that anyone needs is the family making a scene at an exhumation. There was a court order to have the body exhumed, so, it was going to happen whether the family liked it or not. The medical examiner doesn't need the family yelling at her while she is trying to do her job. Especially when the family already made it clear that they didn't want an autopsy. If a family member were to physically act out in an attempt to prevent the exhumation, which may likely occur since they don't want the autopsy, law enforcement would have to restrain or arrest them. Nobody wants that because they are victims. Law enforcement is under no obligation whatsoever to inform the family. This is a murder investigation!!! I wish that the prosecution had made this clear to the jury. They didn't address it at all.
And any of this family are potential suspects. You don't ask murder suspects if you can explore possible evidence 😮
I’m confused as to why Prior thinks discussing how a family member died as being so, so private that it is never spoken about to anyone. I’ve lost both parents and have often mentioned to many people, friends and even strangers how they died. People often ask and I have often asked others who mentioned the death of a family member, I don’t think it’s that private.
I agree. I am happy to share these details with anyone who shows interest, about family members and any close friends who have passed. It's a normal part of life
The RACOON and BRANCHES WERE TYLEES BODY. 😡 In his Text to Tammie, Chad said, “ FUN TIMES!” WHAT A SICK HUMAN !!!
Wow. Garth’s testimony completely contradicted. Wow.
Garth’s coworker sure brings up a fact that supports the Daybell kids being dishonest about that night. This is consistent with how we as the public took their demeanor in testimonies.
Garth should go to prison for lying on the stand.
He definitely needs to be held accountable as well as Emma
That’s not a thing. Perjury isn’t the same as not telling the truth. They have to prove his INTENT and also prove it WAS a lie. unless he admitted to someone he was going to lie- they can’t prove it. Hence why perjury is not prosecuted 99% of the time.
@@kateashby3066 thank you, I wasn’t sure about all that or how it works
How sad that Tammy's own children sided with dear old dad and his wicked bimbo. For the first time I think the kids just might know a lot more than what they portray. 😢
ALL five children were on a news show supporting their FATHER.
Pryor looking at the jurors everytime he thinks he has one over the witness is ridiculous.
I TOTALLY agree!! He kinda turns away from the person testifying and faces the jury..as much to say to the jurors.. look at me! Did you see what I just did there? Like he’s SOOOOO proud of himself😝😝😝😝😝😝😝😝😝
❗️Very accurate and astute observation. Prior annoyed me through the entire trial by doing this. I also noticed that his witness, Emma, also did this throughout her time on the stand. More coaching by Prior?
Although it may be impossible to identify the bones in the fire pit the big question why would bones of any kind be in the fire pit? Who burns pets and animals before laying them to rest in a pet cemetery? Emma's testimony raises more questions and she should be called on it. She is either lying for her dad OR knew more about the kid's disappearance. She made a negative remark in one of the recorded tapes in reference to Colby that raises question regarding her knowledge of Lori's personal relationship with her children. It's my belief Emma, Joe and Garth would fail a polygraph test if given one.
That is what I was thinking; why would it make any difference who could or couldn't identify a specific part of a 16 years old girl's fragmented bones? It just shows how horrifically she was treated. It is unimaginable.😪
I found that part interesting too “dad, we aren’t Colby” (insinuating that she knows that Colby is a leech and a bum. Had she even MET Colby yet?! Or was this 100% B S that Lori told her! I hate to say this but my dad was a narcissist kinda like Chad and my sister is just like Emma- a self righteous narcissist!
I was amazed by Emma having a seemingly normal work friend who knew and liked her mother.
Me too…but she NEEDS her.
O my gosh, that woman still considers Emma a friend!?
Do you think maybe Emma is being brainwashed by Chad? Lindsey brought up the jail calls, she talks to him everyday. He’s sly, he is planting thoughts, opinions and memories. That does not excuse the callousness towards Tammy, but she grew up with a manipulator. Just my opinion. It’s very sad for everyone. Now Tammy’s family lose all of her kids and grandchildren too.
@@tammyduncan9677I am always torn when it comes to stuff like this.
Indoctrination and brainwashing are powerful tools.
But at some point, I just don’t care anymore. Too bad, so sad.
Lies are lies, wrong is wrong, and if anyone is able to be fooled to that degree, they are just as unsafe to be in society as Chad himself.
If you can get people to believe absurdities, you can get them to commit atrocities.
@@tammyduncan9677she’s only been in his cult since she was born so yeah… she’s a tad brainwashed 😉 she’s also a hat is known as “the golden child”. The golden chikd is the narcissist parent’s favorite kid. And yes- narcs do have favorites. It’s whoever is more like them and is willing to be their “flying monkey”. Emma is just like her dad at this point.
A bit on Perjury from an old, retired criminal defense lawyer/ prosecutor....
The crime of Perjury applies when a person KNOWINGLY AND INTENTIONALLY makes statements under oath in order to intentionally mislead or deceive the Court (meaning the Judge, the jury, and the opposition.) People ARE fallible. We DO forget details or mis-remember things.
So LEGALLY, there's a pretty big burden in proving Perjury, rather than simply being mistaken.
Also, some people who don't remember parts of events sometimes "fill the gaps" in their own minds. They can convince themselves these things are factual. Again, not Perjury.
BUT. In cases like this, where there's already a VERY strong indication of family members having been "coached" or that they colluded to "get their stories straight," THAT IS PERJURY. It's also WITNESS TAMPERING.
But again, the bar is pretty high to reach the CRIMINAL level of Perjury.
Correct.
Thank you for that explanation, it really helps a layperson like me!😊
Good info ! Thanks for clearing up the terminology for me. 😊
Thank you
Thank you, would co-conspirators be a better approach or obstruction of justice? They need to be held accountable!
Anyone else think the son n law was out of line and disrespectful during his testimony? "I'd choose any other profession over being in law enforcement". I didnt take that as a compliment. Also sidenote, wasnt it Chad who suggested to Tammy that it was probably a paint gun when she csme into the house that October night after the attempted shooting? So was Garth in on this scheme with his dad, further selling the idea of the "paint gun" to law enforcement by placing his call, EVEN though his mom had already placed a call....
He was just stating his opinion. How is that disrespectful?❤
He's a weird guy. Did you know that about a week or so after the children were discovered, he went to Facebook marketplace and posted a photo of his compost pile and wrote "Free compost need gone because I'm moving."
So yeah even though we know it was from his kitty corner to Chad's house and not Chad's, it seems a little strange that he was trying to get rid of a pile of dirt. Considering his family members just had 2 kids in their dirt.
These people have no situational awareness at all. Very odd.
@@Chirpy_Chirpu interested in buying a white tent?
@@donotrobme9295 Wow! Ok, No thank you Sir. 😂
I thought that comment by Emma's husband should have been stricken from the record for combative or argumentative. Totally rude about the law enforcement professionals who are now permanently traumatized by this case and the bodies they recovered. They are/were doing their jobs. Chad, his mistress, and her brother killed and attempted to kill 5 people who will never have a chance to complete their lives.
I just want ONE of these witnesses to say that Tammy was “dug up out of the ground” to find out if she was murdered and to obtain justice for the victims!!
There are so many other people who should have been accountable and aren’t ,but I’ll settle for a guilty verdict on all charges for Chad!
I hope they charge Emma daybell with lying because she did a Ton on the stand.
It amazes me how Chad just sits there in his own world, as if he's watching a movie about people he's never been involved with. It's just unreal!!!!!
I am behind and listening to Prior questioning the officer or detective about approaching Emma to give her her mom’s autopsy report. I loath Prior! He can do his job without being a pompous, rude, narcissistic A$$ and BULLY and I can guarantee he has just dug his grave even deeper and that by now the jury loathes him as well!
He is a narcissist
I wonder if the jury know he’s an allegation of rape against him? How he’s allowed to practice, I’ve no idea! Mind you. My Irish friends remind me if Trump can make it to president it’s no surprise at all really sad😢
I’m grateful he is. He is helping the guilty to be found guilty. If he did what u r saying the jury might be more torn
Would you rather the defense attorney be this sweet, nice, upstanding gentleman that the jury LOVES? In case such as this, when you know the defendant is guilty as all hell, I prefer their attorney be unlikable. But that's just my opinion.
@@moonchild645 I’ve heard and seen a lot of defense lawyers over the years and I get they need to do their job, but Prior tops it in being an absolute jerk, degrading, rude, a BULLY, narcissist than any defense attorney I’ve EVER seen!!! So sweet? NO! Absolutely not! Polite, reasonable, not talking over everyone and interrupting the judge and trying to bully people? That’s not necessary and absolutely not acceptable behavior in my book! Definitely not professional. But thank you for your opinion, and this is just my opinion. Nothing more. Cheers!
Garth told a lot of stories. Who knows the truth? No one will ever know. That type of character will define him for the rest of his life.
You folks in that school where Emma works better get your kids out now.
Out of Garth’s too
I don't understand ANYONE letting their children be taught by these people!!! People who are brainwashed in a cult, generally aren't good teachers of young minds.
I wouldn't want my kids to associate with any of the Daybells.
She's okay living in a house with kids buried in the yard, probably wouldn't want her near other kids.
Not surprised he is not taking the stand. Chad knows it’s best not to and he doesn’t need to go into his portal to figure that out.
Good job Lisa! You stuck to the truth and didn't let the defense bully you!!!
Lisa
Defense Counsel tried to be aggressive with rebuttal witnesses. TOO aggressive, to the point of being insulting, derogatory, and making false statements regarding previous testimony.
Juries don't like that. They ALREADY don't like Emma or Prior/Pryor.
Also, Mattingly stated early on he wasn't involved in the case when Tammy was EXHUMED. Defense, over and over, kept trying to put him in it. That ticks people off.
I know it sure ticked me off! Prior was a bully to every rebuttal witness today!
Why would this guy lie about what garth said he would have no reason too
I think this statement HELPED THE PROSECUTION!
He wouldn’t know to lie or which way to go anyway bc they’re not watching all the testimony.
I am a bit surprised that all these good LDS Dumbell kids are such liars
I don't think they are "good LDS". They've all been twisted by being told all their dad's delusional ideas...including being able to keep secrets & classify darkness in others!
Yeah, I thought the same thing. We're taught to tell the truth. Maybe Chad told them it was OK to lie because he got a revelation it was OK in this instance. 🤪
I see a strange dark aura round chad, do you think he needs casting?
I think he needs casting down to Hades!
Yes please text Alex. I mean Ray.
Him and his storm
Wait...are you sure he isn't shedding? Lol!
Hee hee😁
I would like to mention Charles,the first victim of this insane trio..he was begging for help with his crazy ex wife .... nobody listened
He wasn’t the first victim. He was like third or so
This reminds me of the Alex Murdaugh case where Paul’s friend heard Alex on the phone, right before Paul was murdered. Then Alex claimed he wasn’t there. The friend testified to the truth of the matter. It’s admirable that these kids stand up for the truth and for justice!
I get Prior's dislike for recalling the officer. But they didn't say that Prior called the officer a "liar", it was Emmas husband that called the officer a "liar".
@@Chirpy_ChirpIt has nothing to do with feelings. It is who is more credible. The police officer called to follow up on a 911 call or the salty son-in-law who openly despises all police officers ("Any other profession" guy).
Chirpy, I think you need to pay attention. The cop had no say in this matter, he may not even be aware. The prosecutors are trying to show that Garth lied on the stand. Garth had the opportunity to say that the cop might have been confused and there would likely not be much of an issue but he was adamant that the cop deliberately untruthful. If he had said “lied” I think Boyce would have allowed him being recalled. I think he said lied just in a slightly more politically correct way.
Seems like one of the testifying parties could be here in comments
Emma and her hubby should be held in contempt for lying , they're are just as guilty as Chud for Tammys death.
If nate gets this i want to say thank you i work late so sometimes i dont understand these testimony so i get on after work at 11 pm at night because i no nate will help me understand and i wont miss anything of the day thank you for all your hours years and time on this trial. And erica is a lovley young lady leeqnn
Emma has purged herself several tines... She should be changed!!
Oh prior … you can try what you want but EM still lied to LE … her dad is still guilty as hell….
Prior in his own words in court said Tammy was found murdered 1-2 days ago.
He sure did!
Chad would have been scanking around with Lorrie.While Cox did his dirty work.
Before I explain my thought, I will note that I do believe that co-worker who said Garth told him he was the one who found his Mom dead with no one around. The part im having a hard time with is the "why" behind why exactly Garth changed his story. Obviously its bc Chad told him to but why?
If Chad said "Hey Garth you need to tell everyone that I was there and called for your help" etc; (aka the story we all know)... but why?
The only thing I can come up with is this: Chad allowed Alex entry and left the home so Alex could kill Tammy.
Perhaps Chad was scared his kids would see him with Alex in the home and that would be blatantly suspicious, given the time and the fact it would have been when Tammy died.
Maybe Chad really wasnt there but he didn't want to look suspicious for being mysteriously gone in the middle of the night/morning so he asked Garth to lie and made the story we've all been told.
Think about it- it would look extra suspect if the police were told Chad wasnt there. Considering he lives there, and that was his Wife and pattern.
I think Chad left and Alex went in to kill her. Then while Chad was still gone, Garth discovered his Mom dead. Chad probably didnt think Garth would notice, he probably assumed it would appear as if Tammy was just sleeping. especially that early in the morning. Im sure Chad had a plan to "discover" Tammy himself. But instead Garth noticed first.
This leaves us with so many new questions in this already complexed and incredibly nuanced case.
One thing I do know: Chad and his kids are not believable. At all.
What do you think?
Was Tammy‘s body found in the cozy cone or in the bedroom of the main house? If it was in the cozy con, then it would be easy for Alex to just come in and kill her without anyone really hearing a struggle. It would’ve been easy for Chad to do it as well, but he was too, scared of being caught and Alex did tell Zulema that he wondered if he was the fall guy.
Cellphone data would help, if any. Slug Daybell and Alex Cox must have known what time Garth was finishing his shift at the Haunted House that night, Garth said he finished at various times depending on how busy it was. Slug and Cox wouldn't have wanted Garth to walk in and catch them in the act of murder, so did they contact Garth "What time do you finish work tonight?" There is no call data for this though ....
@@MikedeGarry unless Chad really did leave the house and was parked somewhere where he could see Garth coming home while Alex did the dirty work. Sometimes it feels so frustrating that will never actually know all the details of what happened…
I think that Chad would never lower himself to commit an act of murder; he’s an exalted one, remember! I hope he goes to prison for the rest of his life as I’m positive he directed this whole theatre of madness, but he would not lower himself to commit murder and risk tarnishing his eternal soul (Mormons are big on eternal souls) they got Alex to do all the killing, and they were probably only involved in the disposal for some insane last rites purpose. His family seem very complicit on what was going on. But answer me this! I always resented that this happened just before covid, I’m 100% sure that his kids have all sat in quarantine believing he’s right about the end of days. How do you convince them otherwise? A very rare, once in a century pandemic..
True. @@MikedeGarrybut he had other kids living there too. Maybe he didn't want his other kids to see him with Alex? But yeah no call data is strange. I really wish Chud didn't shut off his location. I can't believe he was smart enough to do that but not tell Alex to shut HIS off.
That also is another sign Alex was really about to be a "fall guy."
I don't believe much about what Zulema says, but I've always believed that fall guy statement. It just makes sense. On so many levels.
I think yesterdays testimony did nothing but bore the jurors. In the end, Wood’s cross just reiterated all the previous testimony.
Ugh. I hate when the state fails to object when Pryor does things like qualify the conversations this woman who worked with Tammy and Emma had as "deep" and "meaningful." At no time did she say their conversations were "deep" or "meaningful." 🤨
Yes, he kept trying to put words in her mouth, I hope that it was obvious to the jury.
@@MadgeGreenIt has annoyed me that Prior has attempted to do this throughout the trial😡😡😡 often followed by words such as ‘is that fair?’😡😡😡
I can say honestly that if my parent was accused and all the evidence shown that he was a cheater and a liar, I would never disgrace my mother by taking his side. Something very wrong with these kids and the family as a whole. And you CALL YOURSELF CHRISTIANS??
They may call themselves Christian’s if they want but they’re a few bolts short by a long shot.
John Prior, IMO, has lost sight of what he is supposed to be doing, defending Chad. Taking an attitude with every witness doesn't prove Chad wasn't involved. He just gives me bad feelings. I wonder how the jury views his hostile tone.🤨🤔
Would Alex be considered a serial killer? Is there a number?
4 and possibly a 5th with Joe Ryan.
If I were a juror on this case, I’d think Prior calling in the last witness today (the examiner who looked at Tylee’s charred bones), didn’t help Chad at all. I’d be sitting there thinking, it’s probably more than likely Chad was able to set fire to Tylee and burn that much of her in the time frame. He knew how. He’d worked around mortuary science for many years. He’d know exactly what heat source to use and what accelerant if any to use (such as plenty of wood if not gasoline, etc). He knew exactly how to do this, what to use and where in fact to get his hands on material, tools and equipment to do so.
On a previous testimony the burning of bones with an accelerate was on Chad's property. Even IF only several burned bones were found to be burned on Chads property, it makes NO sense to burn part of Tylee in one place and then to burn another part of Tylee somewhere else. Sorry for being so blunt.
@@tatianagutierrez6536 absolutely agreed!
PEGGY!! ATTN PEGGY! I have a question for Nate. When Zulema was testifying, the Marshall whispered something to the judge. A few minutes later, the Marshall went and whispered something to Zulema. Does anyone know what all that was about?? Thanks in advance! Watching from North Dakota by the way.
Remember when JP was doing his cross and he stopped and said, “what do you have in your hands, are you looking at something?” She said no, help up her hands. I think she was just wringing her hands due to nerves. The bailiff made of went and checked just in case to take a look or it was telling her to speak more into the mic and see if she needed help? That’s all I can think of. Unless maybe she was looking at someone present? Was noticed and they said something. If it was major, I think they would’ve called a sidebar.?
@@jaycees9287Thank you
Thank you! Just seems kind of strange to whisper to the judge first. I'm going to go back and look at that testimony and see what I can see. Thank you for responding back to me! Appreciate you!
Really the judge allowed a lot of crap from prior! Wth!!! I guess the good news is I had no idea he could make me despise his client even more!
Boyce has been very careful with the defense as it’s a capital case and if the sentence is death there will be many appeals and he wants to make sure he doesn’t give them reasons to overturn
Prior said Tammy allegedly passed away. Nothing alleged there she definitely passed away
🤦🏽♀️
Emma didn’t want to know because she already knew in my opinion
Prior please just give it up! Your trying to defend evil
It’s his job! It’s what he is paid to do! Do you want a system where majority rules your guilty and you can’t defend yourself? Do you want an attorney that does his job if you’re accused of a crime guilty or not guilty?❤
@Therapistmind Prior probably cant stand Chad & knows he is guilty. But he's a defence lawyer & getting paid to do his job. Everyone is entitled to a fair defence...even this evil piece of work.
@@Chirpy_Chirp What you just said 😂
Give up? Lol That's his only redeeming quality is that he remarkably seems to be giving it his all. His personality and approach are irritating and cringe but he's not a narcissist doing this for kicks.
@@Chirpy_ChirpI disagree a bit. Prior has been an ass and a bumbling moron the whole case. He’s over stepped so many times and with his stupid speaking objections…the man should be disbarred!!
It sure makes one wonder if Chad went to the church and drove Alex to his home to help him kill Tammy. After she was asphyxiated, he perhaps was taking Alex back to the church when Garth came home and found her, with Chad nowhere to be found. Long discussions with Chad since them have reshaped memories of both Garth and Emma to fit the narrative they wish to believe, as the alternative is just too awful for them.
Interesting and plausible
I agree with you there.
Brillant! A strange car in the driveway would promote suspicion. Chad dropped Alex back off at his car, in the meantime, Garth came home, but before being able to call 911 Chad came back in and probably pretended to be panic stricken and to get her back on the bed or whatever. In his usual manipulative way, Chad convinced Garth of another lie and a Garth fell for another it. Chad began displaying his dupers delight smile as soon as his back was turned.
Prayer really thinks he’s Perry Mason 😂
Yes! I keep thinking that this guy has watched too many old TV shows. This is his big moment. Nevermind that his client is going to, and should, get the DP.
Prior or Prayer???
Prior said "when she allegedly passed". I'm pretty sure it's not alleged lol.
That's because he knows it was murder. He said so yesterday.
I thought the same thing!
JP keeps harping about why police didnt contact kids in so maby months why didnt any of the kids including Emma try to contact police for autopsy results?if that was me and my mother suddenly passed in same circumstances as Tamny u can bet i would of been on the phone DAILY. Emma didnt reach out cause she already knew how tammy died.
I can’t believe there aren’t more comments. This was a killer day.
Chad is looking around the courtroom. I wonder why? My stomach is upset hearing about blunt-force trauma.
So Emma, Garth, and the husband all lied and got caught, but Pryor is gonna cry they want to impeach them?
Chad, put this in order and say aloud - goose my cooked is.
Prior's face is something to behold at the end.
I would like to know why they didn’t ask Emma about her conversation to her Dad they day the police found the kids remains on his property? Why didn’t Emma act surprised about what they found? If it was I the question about what’s going on and I know that I would be more upset if I knew my father had nothing to do with this. I would be freaking out .
Someone please I’m begging you timestamp?! I’m trying to watch this and Karen read and I’m losing my will!
Karen Read trial isn't on today is it?
Reed trial is hard to watch. Their courts are extremely unprofessional.
No Read trial today
What do you want a timestamp of?
@@lindaaitken7679no but there’s only so many names and absolute fool attorneys I can keep up with 😴
Id like to know if Emma and Garth are familiar with the ability to travel through the portal?? And if they can see through the veil?😂
I can't believe Emma thinks that "evil spirit" she had inside of her was cast out. It appears to still be there. She's dark 9.8. Someone text Alex. Or Ray. Whatever they call him 😂
I can see JP’s sphincter muscle twitching.
Which one, the lower one or the one on his face? Lmao
😊😆😂😭🤣
Chads guilty of murder as all get out. Lets consider for a second he is absolutely innocent of these crimes....yet even sn innocent person with a fraction of a soul would have some reaction during the trial while pictures are shown and patholofists talking about the brutal murder of the dsughter of the woman he so loved. Especailly as a father of his own kids.....but no tears for his fake wives dead kids! He is guilty!
You know what we HAVEN'T heard during this trial? It's "Quite honestly, Your Honor" from Prior! 😂😂😂
Why did Chad tell Emma to make sure to move the mattress?
Never seen Chad more engaged in the trial
2:55:36 Look Prior has wrong information, it was 3am in Garth’s testimony not 3pm
Thank you Garth for lying, I think you probably helped your mom. He was probably conflicted with telling the truth or to lie because of fear of his dad, but who knows maybe he knew what he was doing all along after all.
So prior is saying the body was burnt somewhere else snd then placed in the back yard?! Prior has lost his mind!
Prior is just scrambling at excuses in an attempt to confuse jurors. Shame on him.
Looks to me that Emma wasn't interested in knowing what her mother's autopsy results were, she only wanted to be able to forewarn her dad.