Songs that don't have a chorus

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 20 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 8 тыс.

  • @june-iy2pd
    @june-iy2pd 2 года назад +5969

    Bohemian Rhapsody is a smart song, because instead of having one part stuck in your head, you've got all of it stuck in your head at once

    • @andregalvao5739
      @andregalvao5739 Год назад +76

      HEEL YEAH! BY THE END OF THE YEAR NOBODY WILL KNOW THE NAME "QUEEN"

    • @wozaow
      @wozaow Год назад +65

      ​@@andregalvao5739?

    • @ZERO-rq6cy
      @ZERO-rq6cy Год назад +86

      @@andregalvao5739 YOU WILL FOREVER BE KNOWN AS THE MAN WHO LOST QUEEN

    • @ZERO-rq6cy
      @ZERO-rq6cy Год назад +31

      @@Ronythethird I love it nontheless

    • @willydawookiee1163
      @willydawookiee1163 Год назад +33

      @@Ronythethird because it’s not the most overrated song of all time

  • @gavinmitchell1328
    @gavinmitchell1328 3 года назад +5425

    The Sound of Silence by Simon and Garfunkel is a great example of a strophic piece. It just ends every verse with the title of the song.

    • @42069TV
      @42069TV 3 года назад +110

      I usually thought the last line of each verse was a Chorus.

    • @malimusimu5641
      @malimusimu5641 3 года назад +280

      @@42069TV No, that's called a Refrain

    • @42069TV
      @42069TV 3 года назад +33

      @@malimusimu5641 oh okay.

    • @LadyVoldemort
      @LadyVoldemort 3 года назад +62

      Also "Where Have All The Flowers Gone" and "Scarborough Fair". I'm not sure about "Paint It Black" though...what category is that song? It's pretty repetitive...

    • @cobgod1415
      @cobgod1415 3 года назад +13

      Megadeth's "In My Darkest Hour" doesn't have a chorus either, 5 verses, not even a single repeated vocal part ever

  • @RicardoAlmeidatm
    @RicardoAlmeidatm 3 года назад +5049

    I love how Jesus of Suburbia is just a solid block of sound

    • @adonaiyah2196
      @adonaiyah2196 3 года назад +100

      🟨🟥🟩🟪🟦

    • @LRM12o8
      @LRM12o8 3 года назад +250

      That really surprised me. Neither the song nor the album sound flat or distorted imo, but it looks like a deafening wall of sound here!

    • @Mandude4200
      @Mandude4200 3 года назад +106

      I saw it live, we initially had rafters seats, but we snuck down to the mosh pit and this song started playing the second we got down there, it was truly amazing

    • @nicktreleaven4119
      @nicktreleaven4119 3 года назад +110

      @@LRM12o8 From about 2000 much rock music released heavily used level compression so the dynamic range was maxed out throughout despite quieter sections being in the raw recording. Thankfully I think that production trend has abated somewhat since then

    • @Audiablo
      @Audiablo 3 года назад +11

      @@nicktreleaven4119 think anything by Metallica post-2000

  • @alchemyrecords657
    @alchemyrecords657 Год назад +1029

    Perfect example: Nutshell by Alice In Chains.
    Intro - Verse 1 - Verse 2 - Outro solo
    Despite being so simple, it's so powerful at the same time

    • @joebyren7566
      @joebyren7566 Год назад +47

      In a nutshell that's what nutshell is

    • @KursedEarth79
      @KursedEarth79 Год назад +7

      Good example , I thought about nutshell when I first clicked this video

    • @jakubwspaniay2867
      @jakubwspaniay2867 Год назад +30

      I would say that this "ooh" part could be classified as chorus

    • @Napkin_story
      @Napkin_story 6 месяцев назад

      @@KursedEarth79 same. im not even lying that song is why i thought this video was in my recomended lmao. the build up to the guitar solo outro is all the energy it needs to stay interesting

    • @NonstickMilk
      @NonstickMilk 6 месяцев назад

      Interstate Love Song - STP

  • @marcuspaul0815
    @marcuspaul0815 3 года назад +3921

    This is what „rhapsody“ actually means: an episodic piece of music.

    • @kaimcmanus9608
      @kaimcmanus9608 3 года назад +162

      According to my music dictionary, rhapsody means: a free-style composition usually in one movement, often based on folk melodies

    • @laplelp7780
      @laplelp7780 3 года назад +41

      @@kaimcmanus9608 isnt that the same

    • @aocplusme5676
      @aocplusme5676 3 года назад +5

      Dematotic shuttupp

    • @kitsune630
      @kitsune630 3 года назад +21

      @@kaimcmanus9608 so technically, Bohemian Rhapsody isnt even a rhapsody at all.

    • @アヤミ
      @アヤミ 3 года назад +24

      @@kitsune630 Every Liszt Hungarian Rhapsody has at least 3 movements with the second one repeating once. Isn’t that cool

  • @nisalpeiris1714
    @nisalpeiris1714 Год назад +757

    Queen has many songs with atypical structures, not just Bohemian Rhapsody. March of the Black Queen, Prophet's Song, Innuendo etc are great examples.

    • @SnowghostFilms
      @SnowghostFilms Год назад +22

      You could also add Somebody to Love and Love of my Life to that list of chorusless Queen songs, but there’s also probably more I haven’t hear yet.

    • @chincherojo7479
      @chincherojo7479 Год назад +9

      If I remember correctly, Innuendo has a relatively normal AABA structure, A being a verse and a chorus; and B being the bridge, except it is very long and has a Spanish guitar solo

    • @Paulnap
      @Paulnap Год назад +13

      Queen has a lot of example but Prophet's song starts with the actual chorus and repeat it several times. All instances has little variations but it sounds like a chorus.

    • @TenthAvenue94
      @TenthAvenue94 Год назад +8

      My Fairy King is another example (and one of their finest moments).

    • @sq1tl
      @sq1tl Год назад +9

      @@SnowghostFilmsYou can say the “somebody, ooh somebody, could anybody find me somebody to love” is the chorus

  • @stephenkelly3459
    @stephenkelly3459 3 года назад +1344

    House Of The Rising Sun. A really brilliant song but it just goes round and round. A song that only has one part, repeated over and over. In The Animals version Eric Burdon lifts the vocals now and then but it doesn't have a chorus

    • @housefoundation1
      @housefoundation1 3 года назад +26

      I always thought that the first lines were the chorus and also when that part repeats later on

    • @leavi2520
      @leavi2520 3 года назад +5

      Yeah, lots of other folk songs are like that.

    • @suntexi
      @suntexi 3 года назад +3

      Watch out for the 2nd inversion F7. I've only ever heard it in the Animals' cover, and never in pub bands'. Alan Price was master of his Vox continental Mk 2.

    • @bompibjorn6177
      @bompibjorn6177 2 года назад +2

      Why so popular, why still rememberd after so many years…… it is soooooo ggggod…

    • @PhilomathBret
      @PhilomathBret 2 года назад +4

      This was in his list of folk songs.

  • @drewcampbell8555
    @drewcampbell8555 Год назад +158

    Always thought the structure of Baba O'Riley was unlike any other song I've heard. Weird but brilliant.

    • @erikaaaaa2882
      @erikaaaaa2882 6 месяцев назад +12

      I agree; I think the tension is released with "teenage wastland" at the end, but I don't think that's a chorus either

  • @ericallen2370
    @ericallen2370 3 года назад +9147

    Tbh I burst out laughing when Jesus of suburbia sound waves were just a block

    • @diaet
      @diaet 3 года назад +582

      Several decades of compression technology and dynamic Standards later...

    • @Xpndable
      @Xpndable 3 года назад +341

      That's funny, I almost burst into tears, it's so sad to see the dynamic range just destroyed like that

    • @SayItAintTso
      @SayItAintTso 3 года назад +356

      @Absolute Zero as a rock producer, I fully agree!! But some mastering engineers truly go overboard. I don’t think Jesus of Suburbia suffers from this tho

    • @Cristalskulle
      @Cristalskulle 3 года назад +34

      @Absolute Zero I agree I think it goes well with the genre :)

    • @Cristalskulle
      @Cristalskulle 3 года назад +7

      Me too 😂

  • @floedsje
    @floedsje 3 года назад +665

    A little over a year ago I went to a public toilet and while washing my hands I saw some text on the mirror: wash your hands as long as the chorus of bohemian rhapsody. Seven minutes later I left completely confused.

    • @Scoldy_
      @Scoldy_ 3 года назад +58

      This feels like illegal information

    • @nigeldepledge3790
      @nigeldepledge3790 3 года назад +55

      The most confusing part is that it's a six-minute song...

    • @teddybaker4759
      @teddybaker4759 3 года назад +80

      @@nigeldepledge3790 A minute spent trying to figure it out.

    • @Devinanim
      @Devinanim Месяц назад +7

      Me personally I read the graffiti on the bathroom stall like the Holy Scripture of the shopping mall

    • @davesims7917
      @davesims7917 Месяц назад +1

      You left confused and with REALLY clean hands

  • @thateverettguy2991
    @thateverettguy2991 2 года назад +1571

    Time by Pink Floyd is a solid one, and I think it really contributes to feeling and message, the sense that you can never go back and time keeps moving on without you.

    • @ikenshnikenable
      @ikenshnikenable 2 года назад +144

      Most Pink Floyd songs

    • @manonmrx2741
      @manonmrx2741 2 года назад +30

      @@ikenshnikenable yeah they don't give a shit

    • @jonathanplatt6559
      @jonathanplatt6559 2 года назад +54

      I would say that one arguably does have a chorus, although the lyrics of the choruses are different.

    • @christatler7378
      @christatler7378 2 года назад +9

      Sheep

    • @jansmitowiczauthor78
      @jansmitowiczauthor78 2 года назад +34

      God would I love him to analyze the 37 different parts of Dogs! Or Shine On [full 25 minutes].

  • @samjay1768
    @samjay1768 Год назад +29

    I am not a professional but really do love and aim to understand music. I watched this and was completely blown away. You are brilliant at picking songs apart and teaching how they are constructed and developed. AMAZING thank you.

  • @jan279
    @jan279 3 года назад +734

    My favorite Elton John song is probably Tiny Dancer. Yeah, it has a chorus, but I like the long buildup before it gets to the chorus. I think it's a fantastic trick that gets the listener on a relatively longer state of tension for a more satisfying release.

    • @DeKevers
      @DeKevers 3 года назад +12

      David happened to make a video on this

    • @fredlorek7349
      @fredlorek7349 3 года назад +8

      Five Years by David Bowie also takes a while to build up to the chorus.

    • @Bubdiddly
      @Bubdiddly 3 года назад +11

      Not exactly the same extent, but Got to Get You Into My Life by the Beatles always makes me think they’re gonna scream “GOT TO GET YOU INTO MY LIFE” after that first verse, and that makes that line hit so much harder

    • @moneywiz9470
      @moneywiz9470 2 года назад +3

      Replace everytime he says 'tiny dancer' with 'Tony Danza'

    • @Tweej
      @Tweej 2 года назад +1

      @@moneywiz9470 ok Pheobe

  • @sergeyd5777
    @sergeyd5777 3 года назад +653

    Led Zeppelin - Stairway To Heaven
    Marty Robbins - Big Iron
    Roger Waters - almost any song from his solo albums

    • @nr1229
      @nr1229 3 года назад +46

      I always thought of stairway having two semi-choruses, being: "and she's buying a stairway to heaven" and "and it makes me wonder" because these two phrases are repeatet that often.

    • @hippycow1006
      @hippycow1006 3 года назад +15

      Marty robbins also had el paso

    • @ryanbarros7583
      @ryanbarros7583 3 года назад +13

      @@nr1229 I think that would be classified as more of a bridge. I’m not very knowledgeable of music but that’s what I believe it would be called, because it is written to lead into a chorus, which is what a bridge does, but instead continues the song instead of hitting a chorus

    • @t-bo2734
      @t-bo2734 3 года назад +6

      "Tomorrow Never Knows" & "A Day in the Life."

    • @t-bo2734
      @t-bo2734 3 года назад +1

      "After the Gold Rush" & "White Moon."

  • @KestrelHarper
    @KestrelHarper 3 года назад +900

    I LOVE songs without a chorus because they feel more like a story, more interesting, and less like the composer is just filling time.

    • @abbeybelanger8118
      @abbeybelanger8118 2 года назад +11

      One of my favorite songs is "You Never Give Me Your Money" from the Beatles and its the wierdest but coolest song ever!

    • @brown9671
      @brown9671 2 года назад +7

      You can still tell a story with a chorus, it can be foreshadowing then later explained, it can change meaning after every verse, stuff like that

    • @CoingamerFL
      @CoingamerFL 2 года назад

      I've made quite a few songs without a chorus (or any repeating section) and most of them dont have one because they are meant to be played on a rhythm game, and having a chorus or a repeating section doesnt make a lot of sense in that context.

    • @abbeybelanger8118
      @abbeybelanger8118 2 года назад +1

      @@CoingamerFL That's really awesome dude. I've only just started songwriting but I'd love to create a song like this. Any tips maybe?

    • @shomershabbos6291
      @shomershabbos6291 2 года назад +1

      @@abbeybelanger8118 i love this song, but it's hard to seperate it from the entire medley, "mean mr mustard" and polethene pam" are also two quircky gems

  • @coolbrotherf127
    @coolbrotherf127 Год назад +37

    Handlebars by the Flobots is a good one. The song builds on the main idea from the beginning without replacing the first verse until the very end of the song.

  • @autonomouscollective2599
    @autonomouscollective2599 2 года назад +774

    I’m curious about REM’s Losing My Religion. Certain parts kind of sound like they could be a chorus, “That’s me in the corner” or “Oh no, I said too much,” but they never resolve into a defined ending. If a chorus creates a sense of release, you never get that with this song. There’s a feeling of tension throughout the song, almost like you wish he would finally break into a chorus but he never does.

    • @23h109hh
      @23h109hh Год назад +118

      "I thought that I heard you laughing" is probably the "chorus"

    • @joshwantstotravel9516
      @joshwantstotravel9516 Год назад +30

      Weve played that in our school band recently and i know what you mean. Though both lyrically and musically there is a chorus, i doesnt feel much like one

    • @froggary
      @froggary Год назад +18

      I love REM and I've noticed quite a few songs of theirs that don't have a clear-cut chorus. Some of my favourites are Find The River, We Walk and Tongue.

    • @samanteater
      @samanteater Год назад +4

      ​​@Dustin Void I think it's because the non-verse parts are so short and there's no dynamic/chord shift between them and the verse, so it feels like one continuous verse looping back on itself that just happens to end with the same lines.

    • @BrunoEwok
      @BrunoEwok Год назад +10

      Losing My Religion does something really cool to obscure its structure. The verse is broken into two sections. The second verse puts the two seconds in reverse order. Then there's a mini-post-chorus, half a verse, the chorus, and the mini-post-chours.

  • @TheMagikalJazz
    @TheMagikalJazz Год назад +431

    A lot of Led Zeppelin's songs throughout their discography have instrumental choruses and those can be solid examples

    • @ILJ68
      @ILJ68 Год назад +29

      My brain went to Kashmir and then Stairway to Heaven first

    • @cloudkitt
      @cloudkitt Год назад +18

      And of course they're still looking for that confounded bridge.

    • @dust-dog
      @dust-dog Год назад +6

      'Over the Hills and Far Away'?

  • @MM-vs2et
    @MM-vs2et 3 года назад +382

    Arctic Monkeys - The Ultracheese
    Thundercat - Them Changes
    Radiohead - Weird Fishes
    Paul Mcartney - Backseat Of My Car
    David Bowie - Lazarus
    Some more examples for you people looking for chorus-less songs

    • @fractalez
      @fractalez 3 года назад +26

      Hotel & Casino is amazing

    • @Max-zn7md
      @Max-zn7md 3 года назад +10

      You never give me your money

    • @codypower4298
      @codypower4298 3 года назад +12

      them changes kind of has a chorus

    • @wiggledixbubsy98
      @wiggledixbubsy98 3 года назад +6

      Parquet Courts - Black and White
      Parquet Courts - Sunbathing Animal
      Parquet Courts - Instant Disassembly
      Parquet Courts - Raw Milk
      Parquet Courts - Stoned and Starving

    • @lobster9059
      @lobster9059 3 года назад +4

      Dream Sweet In Sea Major

  • @10thdoctor15
    @10thdoctor15 Год назад +41

    Other examples of episodic/story songs are ELO's Mr Blue Sky (although there are a few lines that return), Queen's Somebody to Love and New Order's Blue Monday.
    Queen's Hammer to Fall and Crazy Little Thing Called Love are strophic, just with a solo in the middle.

    • @jorgito93700
      @jorgito93700 Год назад +6

      Doesn't Mr Blue Sky have a clear chorus with the "Mr Blue Sky please tell us why" section?

    • @10thdoctor15
      @10thdoctor15 Год назад +1

      @@jorgito93700 I don't know if a chorus can be one single line that repeats, and not in regular periods

    • @jorgito93700
      @jorgito93700 Год назад +1

      @@10thdoctor15 I mean there's plenty of songs with a chorus that's just one line that repeats, often being the title. We Will Rock You by Queen is the first one that comes to my mind.

    • @10thdoctor15
      @10thdoctor15 Год назад

      @@jorgito93700 That chorus is the line twice, which is sung three times; I'm talking about a line that just appears more than once in the song, not a whole chorus.

    • @elizabethm7163
      @elizabethm7163 5 месяцев назад +1

      Blue Monday definitely has a chorus.

  • @dougthemoleman
    @dougthemoleman 3 года назад +190

    For some reason, Over The Rainbow has always felt like Chorus, Chorus, Verse, Chorus to me. And I've never even questioned that interpretation.

    • @trebleboost7
      @trebleboost7 3 года назад +15

      Me too. I almost think the A section in these songs would work as a traditional chorus.

    • @dougieboxell6505
      @dougieboxell6505 3 года назад +3

      Me too, and I like your first name

    • @VincenzodeLeon
      @VincenzodeLeon 3 года назад +7

      Technically considered Chorus Chorus Bridge Chorus, because the Verse is actually “when all the world...” that you usually don’t hear performed outside the musical

    • @sean_mccadden
      @sean_mccadden 3 года назад +3

      I believe (and I could be wrong) that the line “Somewhere over the rainbow” is actually considered a “refrain” which is a word or phrase that is repeated but not in a way of a chorus since the following lines are changed.
      “Somewhere over the rainbow
      Way up high”
      “Somewhere over the rainbow
      Bluebirds fly”
      It’s debatable though

    • @VincenzodeLeon
      @VincenzodeLeon 3 года назад +1

      @@sean_mccadden Yeah, refrains are typically short phrases and such like in blues songs, so your calling the phrase a refrain I'm tempted to agree. But the whole 8-bar sections would be the choruses

  • @Myrtone
    @Myrtone 2 года назад +247

    A remarkable example not yet mentioned is Nena's most famous song, 99 Red Balloons. This is not only without a chorus but with long instrumental parts between them. Instrumental parts that long are common in German rock and German electronica.

    • @miro2742
      @miro2742 Год назад +4

      It has that instrumental chorus

  • @w.geoffreyspaulding6588
    @w.geoffreyspaulding6588 3 года назад +406

    Stairway to Heaven by Zeppelin is certainly one of the most famous examples of a huge rock song that has no chorus. I was actually expecting you to use that song as your leading example....but Bohemian Rhapsody is a bloody good choice too....

    • @Arrica101
      @Arrica101 3 года назад +43

      I'm pretty sure led zepplin are notorious for blocking videos, probably why they weren't featured. I would agree it is arguably the most famous song ever without a chorus

    • @fractalez
      @fractalez 3 года назад +1

      @@Arrica101 They wouldn't block him, but demonetize him

    • @edwardcardona717
      @edwardcardona717 3 года назад +28

      @@Arrica101 Whereas Queen typically let stuff go all the time. I will always love that about them

    • @3006khz
      @3006khz 3 года назад +8

      A lot of led zeppelin songs don't have a chorus..

    • @fractalez
      @fractalez 3 года назад +13

      @@edwardcardona717 I worked translating songs, and I agree completely with this. Queen even let you use their offical videos!

  • @arielgioino
    @arielgioino Год назад +23

    Dear David, I have realized through some other music RUclipsrs, that the role of the chorus in contemporaneous pop or trap changed completely (e. G. Billie Eillish). The old funcion of the chorus, that used to be more melodically or more energetic, is in current music more often a drop in intensity, melodic movement or even tempo. It'd be great if you can do a video about it! 😊Keep the great content

  • @azalago
    @azalago 2 года назад +949

    I love how "episodic" generally means "songs that are at least 6 minutes long."

    • @nobodyqwertyu
      @nobodyqwertyu 2 года назад +17

      It has nothing to with the length of the song.

    • @thomasmannia
      @thomasmannia 2 года назад +69

      @@nobodyqwertyu It was a joke.

    • @the_most_ever_company
      @the_most_ever_company Год назад +70

      what "episodic" really means is "songs that will probably be accused of being progressive rock"

    • @TheChrisSimpson
      @TheChrisSimpson Год назад +8

      @@the_most_ever_company Listen to The Decline by NOFX. 18 freakin minutes long. no chorus, episodic narrative style. Not quite prog rock... (but as progressive as punk gets i guess).

    • @joelebruno
      @joelebruno Год назад +5

      @@TheChrisSimpson Listen to Bring The Sun by Swans

  • @moritzandreasbahgat4843
    @moritzandreasbahgat4843 2 года назад +59

    A Day In The Life is a good example for an AABA and Instrumental Chorus Song; First two sections is John singing about the Car and the War, then there is the build up and Paul's part, again the instrumental, then it returns to John's Part with the Holes, build up again, the final release is the 30 Sec.- 1 minute long Piano chord.

  • @MACHINArebirth
    @MACHINArebirth 2 года назад +201

    When I was a teenager one thing that really attracted me to the Smashing Pumpkins music was the fact they'd often completely change the lyrics in each chorus

    • @OMW2FYBRQ
      @OMW2FYBRQ Год назад

      What do you mean like they keep the same rhyme skeme and just change the words or completely change the chorus

    • @lele-qr4cy
      @lele-qr4cy Год назад +5

      ​@@OMW2FYBRQi guess the person said they change just the words but i may be wrong

    • @UrianErreErre
      @UrianErreErre Год назад +12

      ​@@lele-qr4cy Yes, mostly only the lyics change

    • @inktvisje575
      @inktvisje575 Год назад +4

      can you give song titles that are examples of this?

    • @FACEL1FT
      @FACEL1FT 6 месяцев назад

      @@inktvisje575today

  • @zachservello7846
    @zachservello7846 2 года назад +387

    i love sultans of swing having an instrumental chorus in the iconic riff, perfectly creating a chorus in a chorus-less song

    • @Captain_Bottles
      @Captain_Bottles 2 года назад

      Yeah! It’s a fantastic tune, I was about to mention it too! :D

    • @XxNoMErcY99xX
      @XxNoMErcY99xX 2 года назад +25

      But it kinda has a chorus, doesn't it? It's really short but the "we are the sultans, we are the sultans of swing" is pretty much a chorus, isn't it?

    • @pc_panic
      @pc_panic 2 года назад +1

      @@XxNoMErcY99xX u right

    • @nicholasharvey1232
      @nicholasharvey1232 2 года назад +2

      I would consider "Cars" by Gary Numan to be yet another song with an instrumental chorus. When the key changes from A to D, that serves as the "chorus".

    • @OldDemonTooth
      @OldDemonTooth Год назад +1

      @@XxNoMErcY99xX Yes. This distinction of having lyrics or not is silly. What if a completely instrumental chorus just has a "yeah!" at the end? Is that NOW a different type of section of song? No. Choruses do NOT need lyrics.

  • @clarkrrr
    @clarkrrr 3 года назад +588

    The one song without a chorus I immediately think of is Rocky Raccoon by the Beatles. Super underrated!

    • @Croix1
      @Croix1 3 года назад +41

      the piano section does kinda serve the purpose of a chorus. i love that song though

    • @clarkrrr
      @clarkrrr 3 года назад +5

      @@Croix1 oh yeah, forgot it was in there twice lol

    • @ganeshapsychedelicrock4027
      @ganeshapsychedelicrock4027 3 года назад +14

      Isn't the "Da da da da da da da da" part of Rocky Racoon the Chorus?

    • @libradawg9
      @libradawg9 3 года назад +16

      I think that's the instrumental chorus he's talking about. Hey Jude and Day in the Life were the first ones that I thought of.

    • @samanthanowell9655
      @samanthanowell9655 2 года назад +2

      My favourite Beatles track of all time!

  • @makilegacy
    @makilegacy 3 года назад +355

    "Love is a losing game" by Amy Winehouse is one of my favourites without a chorus.

  • @phunkymind23
    @phunkymind23 4 месяца назад +6

    Songs like Dancing Queen and Does Your Mother Know have an ABBA structure.

  • @messnet6706
    @messnet6706 3 года назад +1600

    That Jesus of Suburbia waveform is the thing of nightmares. Compressed to hell and back again

    • @Alberto-ny7kf
      @Alberto-ny7kf 3 года назад +251

      the contrast with bohemian rhapsody's waveform is so harsh its funny

    • @Howitchewstofeel5gum
      @Howitchewstofeel5gum 3 года назад +73

      Still not as bad as Californication

    • @castrucciocastracani0
      @castrucciocastracani0 3 года назад +88

      @@Howitchewstofeel5gum every RHCP is compressed as f**k, I don't understand it

    • @Howitchewstofeel5gum
      @Howitchewstofeel5gum 3 года назад +70

      @@castrucciocastracani0 I'm not sure I agree. Californication and By the Way are veeery bad in that regard (which is frustrating because the music itself is amazing), you can really hear the clipping all over the place. Stadium Arcadium sounds *much* better and BSSM is an absolute masterpiece production-wise. The rest of their catalogue I don't really listen to tbh, but I can't imagine that the first couple of records were that heavily compressed, since they still came out in the 80s.

    • @markowalski1
      @markowalski1 3 года назад +31

      @@Howitchewstofeel5gum It wasn't until they started working with Rick Rubin on Blood Sugar Sex Magik. I don't know what changed with Stadium Arcadium but it definitely has the beset production

  • @ravel111
    @ravel111 2 года назад +170

    I’m surprised that Bjork was not mentioned in this episode. She has numerous songs with atypical structures, both with and without choruses. You’ve Been Flirting Again, Bachelorette, All Neon Like, Pluto, All Is Full of Love, 107 Steps, An Echo A Stain, Show Me Forgiveness, Oll Birtan, Submarine, Sonnets / Unrealities XI, Ancestors, Midvikudags, Vertebrae by Vertebrae, Pneumonia, My Juvenile, Moon, Dark Matter, Hollow, Sacrifice, Mutual Core, Solstice, History of Touches, Black Lake, etc the list goes on and on. She deserves a mention in a topic such as this.

    • @LuizVitor
      @LuizVitor Год назад

      YEEES!!!!!

    • @mariol2116
      @mariol2116 Год назад

      MY SONG DONT HAVE CHORUS ruclips.net/video/uOCeF-ls4wE/видео.html

    • @thalesmatheus6011
      @thalesmatheus6011 Год назад

      bachelorette does have chorus

    • @LuizVitor
      @LuizVitor Год назад

      @@thalesmatheus6011 agree, it’s the “im a fountain of blood” verse?

    • @BlindingSun_
      @BlindingSun_ 2 месяца назад

      @@LuizVitorno that’s the verse

  • @jamiepacemizzi2822
    @jamiepacemizzi2822 3 года назад +126

    Another well-known song that has an instrumental chorus is "Sultans of Swing"

    • @lord_of_m3mes333
      @lord_of_m3mes333 3 года назад +9

      Fade to Black by Metallica also has an instrumental chorus.

    • @heelbradley7407
      @heelbradley7407 3 года назад +8

      I feel like when they end each set of lyrics with "we are the Sultans of Swing", that is sort of a low-key chorus. I would be fine to be wrong there.

    • @jamiepacemizzi2822
      @jamiepacemizzi2822 3 года назад +4

      @@heelbradley7407 Yeah I guess you could say that, but to be honest he only uses the phrase "Sultans of Swing" once if I recall correctly. The other times he says "they play creole" and "London town". But in any case, I would say it is more or less instrumental since it just a phrase of 2 syllables between the pre chorus and chorus

    • @gaffer2602
      @gaffer2602 6 месяцев назад +2

      ​@@jamiepacemizzi2822yeah. "way on down south, London town", "The Sultans, they play Creole", and "we are the Sultans of Swing"

  • @victorymansions
    @victorymansions Год назад +4

    The Smiths' 'Barbarism Begins At Home' is arguably without chorus. It has repeated sections, but they aren't in the common chorus structure.

  • @cjshardcorepunkmusicvault8474
    @cjshardcorepunkmusicvault8474 3 года назад +395

    The Sound Of Silence is just a 5 stanza poem set to music. No intro, no outro, no chorus, no guitar solo

    • @djgrab1
      @djgrab1 3 года назад +6

      There it is! Thanks CJ

    • @sinclairheiny813
      @sinclairheiny813 3 года назад +10

      Definitely one of the best song ever written

    • @sourisvoleur4854
      @sourisvoleur4854 3 года назад +3

      Pretty much the form of a Child ballad (albeit with fewer verses)

    • @walrusgumboot
      @walrusgumboot 3 года назад +8

      It does have an intro and outro, and while no chorus it’s verse does have two distinct sections that adds contrast and variety

    • @sourisvoleur4854
      @sourisvoleur4854 3 года назад

      @@walrusgumboot - Please explain about the intro and outro - it just starts immediately with the singing.

  • @devenscience8894
    @devenscience8894 3 года назад +317

    I first noticed Johnny Cash as the guy to have many songs without a chorus. "A Boy Named Sue" being a good example.

    • @lucasduque8289
      @lucasduque8289 3 года назад +28

      A boy named sue is a good example, being a song telling a story. It also has the factor of the constant repetition of the verse "life ain't easy for a boy named sue" during the first half.
      But the song isn't Johnny's, it's actualy a cover. Don't remember who did the original, though.

    • @justintime2502
      @justintime2502 3 года назад +26

      @@lucasduque8289 You are totally right. It was written by Shel Silverstein

    • @ezramalzbender7934
      @ezramalzbender7934 3 года назад +1

      Dylan as well

    • @peternancoz3031
      @peternancoz3031 3 года назад +3

      Several Harry Chapin song also are story telling songs without a chorus.

    • @erwingouw3162
      @erwingouw3162 3 года назад +1

      GhygjhggCg
      Ik om
      Ma klcpnxxnl m v. A x jx

  • @sadlytemporary4143
    @sadlytemporary4143 3 года назад +400

    White Rabbit by Jefferson Airplane is easily AAAA, and the A's just get progressively bigger.

    • @moe45673
      @moe45673 3 года назад +14

      Isnt it more AABA? That "when men on the chessboard" part is definitely not A

    • @Breeze1
      @Breeze1 3 года назад +9

      aaaaaaAAAAAAA

    • @ultrakool
      @ultrakool 2 года назад +9

      it has a b. don't believe me? then go ask alice. I think she'll know.

    • @sadlytemporary4143
      @sadlytemporary4143 2 года назад +1

      @@ultrakool yeah, you aren't the first to point that out to me. In retrospect, it's definitely not actually AAAA, but it isn't what I'd call a chorus either, and I thought the comment was funny

    • @CoingamerFL
      @CoingamerFL 2 года назад +1

      @@sadlytemporary4143 aabaaabaAABAAABAAABAAA

  • @alloallie
    @alloallie Год назад +10

    One of my favourite songs ever is a combination of the AABA and an instrumental chorus: Year of the Cat by Al Stewart. One of the reasons I love that song so much.

    • @exploringwithk
      @exploringwithk 5 месяцев назад +1

      I was thinking of that one! Love that song!

  • @TheNameOfJesus
    @TheNameOfJesus 3 года назад +162

    I was searching through my ABBA songs for songs written in AABA form, so that I could point out the irony here, and instead I seemed to have found quite a few ABBA songs in AAAA form. P.S. Thanks for the information.

    • @neilgibbons2532
      @neilgibbons2532 3 года назад +4

      Did you try ACDC or MCJZ

    • @TenisJr
      @TenisJr 3 года назад +25

      tbh everytime I see the AABA structure it takes my brain a second to remember we're not talking about ABBA

    • @blackforest2808
      @blackforest2808 3 года назад +3

      @@neilgibbons2532 damn it, ya beat me to it hahahaa

    • @williama.walker2287
      @williama.walker2287 3 года назад +6

      Somebody reading these comments should be challenged to write an ABBA ABBA song.

    • @luiszuluaga6575
      @luiszuluaga6575 3 года назад

      Aaaah..!☝🏼😃

  • @caitlyn294
    @caitlyn294 2 года назад +269

    The Wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald by Gordon Lightfoot is another really good example of a song with no chorus. The lyrics and the story is what makes it such a great song.

    • @dannyboy6668
      @dannyboy6668 Год назад +5

      That song came to my mind too

    • @adabofeverything7120
      @adabofeverything7120 Год назад +11

      Sad he passed away yesterday. 😭💔

    • @steveklemetti8035
      @steveklemetti8035 Год назад +2

      The music was the chorus as it was repeated

    • @DrawtheCurtains
      @DrawtheCurtains Год назад +4

      @@steveklemetti8035 repetition isn't the only criteria for a chorus lmao

    • @tomflorio3639
      @tomflorio3639 Год назад +1

      Good example! Also, it is in danger of falling victim to the same issue as Squeeze's "Up The Junction" (another story song that David points out in the video) - that being the repetition of the same bars over and over again becoming boring. I grew to appreciate TWOTEF over the years, but as a kid I'd turn the dial whenever it came on the radio, bc I got sick of that same cadence in every lyric.

  • @blueshrimpy
    @blueshrimpy 3 года назад +186

    I'm pretty sure The End. by MCR doesn't actually have a chorus, but still a lot of buildup that never gets any release until the song that plays right after it on the album. They blend into each other perfectly, I think that's pretty neat!

    • @buttercup0747
      @buttercup0747 3 года назад +20

      Yees mcr! They have a few like that, such as (i think) “it’s not a Fashion statement, it’s a Deathwish”

    • @blueshrimpy
      @blueshrimpy 3 года назад +15

      @@buttercup0747 Oh yeah, I think you’re right, though he does repeat the “I’m coming back from the dead…” lines, it doesn’t seem like an actual chorus- also whatever the fuck Demolition Lovers’s song structure is lmao

    • @johnathanpumpernickel5532
      @johnathanpumpernickel5532 3 года назад +6

      i also think welcome to the black parade doesn’t have one either but i haven’t listened to that song in a while

    • @buttercup0747
      @buttercup0747 3 года назад +4

      @@blueshrimpy i love demolition lovers

    • @blueshrimpy
      @blueshrimpy 3 года назад +20

      @@johnathanpumpernickel5532 The “we’ll carry on” part seems pretty chorus-y to me, could be wrong though lol

  • @makotoplush9776
    @makotoplush9776 Год назад +41

    Roundabout by Yes is a strange one because the "I'll be the roundabout" does sort of count as the chorus which is mostly the only line repeated however the song always keeps you interested by changing up how the instruments sound and by the middle point, changed the instrumental altogether

    • @adri_mirn
      @adri_mirn 5 месяцев назад +1

      I don't think it's really fair to include prog rock bands on this list, because the purpose of this genre is basically exploring all of the unusual music structures and technics. Progressive music would deserve an entire video for itself.

    • @atomdecay
      @atomdecay 2 месяца назад

      BRB, rewatching JoJo now

    • @andrewlloydpeterson
      @andrewlloydpeterson Месяц назад

      "mountains come out of the sky" is the chorus. It Repeats at least 2 or 3 times i think

  • @rumrstv
    @rumrstv 3 года назад +243

    The LAs song There She Goes is basically one long chorus. Nothing but endless payoff and yet never gets boring.

    • @HowToGames1
      @HowToGames1 3 года назад +2

      Seems you have great music taste there mate! Scousers and music, heavenly combo

    • @graham9851
      @graham9851 3 года назад +5

      That’s a great song

    • @kylestevensanders
      @kylestevensanders 3 года назад +2

      I learned about this song from Mac DeMarco

    • @em-cj2zw
      @em-cj2zw 3 года назад +2

      yes!! more las appreciation!!

    • @joelbizzell1386
      @joelbizzell1386 3 года назад +5

      Just like heroin, really.

  • @pop52jo43
    @pop52jo43 3 года назад +217

    My favorite example would be "Human Sadness" by the voidz... each section feels like a stage of emotional progression through some catastrophic event! whether that's an apocalypse in the literal sense, or just a personal "end of the world"/descent into madness, it's almost like the stages of grief. No chorus to speak of

    • @nathaneckman2607
      @nathaneckman2607 3 года назад +8

      Such a good song. Casablancas is the perfect voice for it

    • @ethanm2000
      @ethanm2000 3 года назад +3

      One of the most perfect songs ever

    • @piercedimare6782
      @piercedimare6782 2 года назад +2

      it does have a chorus, the da da da, da da part

    • @rizahaykel
      @rizahaykel 2 года назад +4

      human sadness does have a chorus, "...there is a field, i meet you there" part

    • @CalebIsBlue
      @CalebIsBlue 2 года назад +2

      it definitely has a chorus. The chorus lyrics are, "Beyond all ideas of right and wrong, there is a field
      I will be meeting you there," repeated twice. The chorus comes three time after the first, third, and sixth verse. The first two even have a very similar backing melody, only the first is cut off near its end. The final chorus is much bigger than the first two, but definitely still a chorus.

  • @OrlyYahalom
    @OrlyYahalom 3 года назад +197

    John Lennon: God, I don't wanna be a soldier, crippled inside
    The Doors: Riders on the storm, LA woman, The end
    David Bowie: Space oddity

    • @sotis1756
      @sotis1756 3 года назад +8

      Riders on the Storm has a semi chorus

    • @ean1245
      @ean1245 3 года назад +28

      Space Oddity definitely has a chorus in "Here am I sitting/floating in/'round my tin can".

    • @sotis1756
      @sotis1756 3 года назад +1

      @@ean1245 ah you're right! Haven't heard the song in years

    • @ean1245
      @ean1245 3 года назад +7

      @@sotis1756 and I would advise you to listen to it again since this song is legitimately great

    • @craigbroadfoot1851
      @craigbroadfoot1851 3 года назад

      @@sotis1756 It’s more of a repeating blues-type structure and as much an instrumental song as anything, maybe with an ‘instrumental chorus’.

  • @DaninMaine
    @DaninMaine 5 месяцев назад +6

    Somewhere Over the Rainbow IS a chorus. The verse starts with "When all world is a hopeless jumble..." the part we all know is called the chorus in the 32 bar form.

  • @jasonremy1627
    @jasonremy1627 3 года назад +76

    Every Breath You Take is a great chorusless one. It's got that three-level AABA structure, where each A section is a mini AABA structure, and then each main AABA part is nested inside an larger AABA format. It's a really fun song to pick apart.

    • @tiemenscholten3755
      @tiemenscholten3755 3 года назад +10

      Wow I had to look up if Every Breath You Take really didn’t have any choruses. Mind blowing actually, it seems like the song has a repetitive chorus in my head haha

    • @jasonremy1627
      @jasonremy1627 3 года назад +6

      @@tiemenscholten3755 it's repetitive, but it's not really a chorus. It just has these 3 different parts that it organizes in this cool way.

    • @sebastiano728
      @sebastiano728 3 года назад +6

      Tbh, though I understand the mechanics that make up the AABA format, as long as it repeats itself, I often just consider the B section the chorus. Like "Oh can't you see / You belong to me..." or in Yesterday "Why she had to go? / I don't know, she wouldn't say". They repeat itself, but aren't considered choruses because they don't have the catchy lyric people remember, like the "I'll be watching you" repeating itself at the end. The only other distinction I can find between a repeating B section and a chorus is that while verses feel like they're leading up to a chorus, B sections often feel more like bridges, working as a counteract to the verse, rather than its payoff.
      Also, AABA songs often have the hook be in the first line of the verse. Every Breath You Take, Yesterday, Somewhere Over the Rainbow and Blue Skies all have the title of the song be the first line of each of their A sections.
      Lastly, though it does contain a chorus, the structure of Oh-bla-Di Oh-bla-da reminds me of the AABA songs listed. We got an obvious verse and chorus, but the "In a couple of years they have built a home, sweet home" feels like a repeating bridge (or, consequently, like the B sections in the AABA songs).

    • @deliusmyth5063
      @deliusmyth5063 3 года назад +3

      It's a fractal structure. And if you want to get really silly, the phrase “Every breath you take” is itself AABA.

    • @carlo4594
      @carlo4594 3 года назад +2

      No Reply by the Beatles does the same thing. An AABA for where each A section is its own AABA but with slightly different lyrics each time.

  • @nicholasselke5214
    @nicholasselke5214 3 года назад +96

    I’ve seen many examples in the comment section that I thought of, but one band that I’d like to highlight would be The Doors. On their first album, “The Crystal Ship” and “The End” are without choruses and differ immensely in structure and length of the song. “The Crystal Ship” is less than three minutes long while “The End” is close to 12 minutes and can easily keep your attention throughout

    • @kate-kw2xl
      @kate-kw2xl 2 года назад +3

      I was hoping for someone to mention The End (and the Doors)!

    • @LynkJDL1
      @LynkJDL1 2 года назад +6

      The Soft Parade too

    • @PedroBenolielBonito
      @PedroBenolielBonito 2 года назад +1

      Best opening song for any movie, ever (Apocalypse Now)

  • @riogdl
    @riogdl 3 года назад +103

    Am I really gonna be the first one to mention... “A Day in the Life”? Cheers, from Guadalajara, Mexico. Big fan, mate.

    • @DavidBennettPiano
      @DavidBennettPiano  3 года назад +35

      "A Day In The Life" certainly has an erratic structure and, although it has got some repeating sections, I don't think we ever get anything close to a typical chorus! 😁

    • @emanuellandeholm5657
      @emanuellandeholm5657 3 года назад +10

      @@DavidBennettPiano Revolution #9.

    • @noahford9605
      @noahford9605 3 года назад +8

      @@emanuellandeholm5657 you can’t really have a chorus if the song doesn’t really have lyrics other than random scatterings of noise

    • @emanuellandeholm5657
      @emanuellandeholm5657 3 года назад +1

      @@noahford9605 Infidel!

    • @sunkintree
      @sunkintree 3 года назад +1

      @@noahford9605 Did you watch the video or are you just stupid? The youtuber himself said choruses can lack lyrics. Jesus christ. Stop spreading bullshit.

  • @operatic9537
    @operatic9537 Год назад +1

    Muse - Starlight
    Intro - Verse - B section/Elaborated intro ("hold you in my arms...") - Half verse - "Pre-chorus"/C section ("I'll never let you go...") - D section ("Our hopes and expectations", serves as a kind of anti-chorus) - B section - Half verse - C section - D section but more climactic - Slightly altered B section/Outro

  • @KansaiSamurai
    @KansaiSamurai 3 года назад +233

    If a strophic song is really bad, could we call it cata-strophic? Thank you, I'm here all week...

    • @jeffthebracketman
      @jeffthebracketman 3 года назад +7

      Try the veal...

    • @jennifermorris6848
      @jennifermorris6848 3 года назад +6

      Hi Dad

    • @muenchhausenmusic
      @muenchhausenmusic 3 года назад +2

      Gold right there, this video was basically one hell of a perfect setup just waiting for you XD XD XD

    • @allthatyoutouch3164
      @allthatyoutouch3164 3 года назад

      @@jennifermorris6848 😂

    • @KillarneyMark
      @KillarneyMark 3 года назад +2

      Or if it’s about the world turning, it would be geostrophic. OK, that one’s a bit more niche.

  • @izzyn9000
    @izzyn9000 3 года назад +196

    STAIRWAY TO HEAVEN, too doesnt have a chorus🙌🏾🙌🏾🔥🔥

    • @aliciamarie2414
      @aliciamarie2414 3 года назад +1

      Love your profile photo!

    • @diopappa
      @diopappa 3 года назад +6

      Well, at least I'm not the only fool to think it's crazy not to mention this song in this category (which one though?)

    • @lbarnesmusic
      @lbarnesmusic 3 года назад +13

      It does have the “ooh, it makes me wonder” part though, although it simply feels like a bridge that has a reprise tbh

    • @kaiser_ua
      @kaiser_ua 3 года назад +7

      Kashmir?

    • @larshamelijnck4400
      @larshamelijnck4400 3 года назад

      @@diopappa I think it's some sort of combination of episodic and story-telling

  • @whataheavenlywaytolive
    @whataheavenlywaytolive 3 года назад +94

    I really love I Know the End by Phoebe Bridgers, epic chorus-less song.
    I also know that with 42 coldplay tried to write a song without a chorus and it's a pretty good song.

    • @pheebsvegetable
      @pheebsvegetable 3 года назад +1

      I Know The End is one my favorite songs ever, i immediately thought of this!

  • @panosmosproductions3230
    @panosmosproductions3230 10 месяцев назад +3

    Johny cash made some songs that don’t have a chorus. The ones that I know about are Ira Haze, pickin’ Time, and Don’t Take Your Guns to Town. Ira Haze actually is an example of 2 in 1 because it’s both a story telling song, and has a line of lyrics that repeats throughout the song.

  • @sierrahues
    @sierrahues 3 года назад +56

    man you must have like 0% chance of monetization with all these famous songs. ur a saint for it

    • @longinuscyclone213
      @longinuscyclone213 3 года назад +5

      yeah this man deserves what support he gets on patreon and so much more

    • @samuelthecamel
      @samuelthecamel 3 года назад +6

      He's very careful with using alternate renditions of songs and only playing them for short periods of time, so I doubt it

  • @stevolopez
    @stevolopez 6 месяцев назад +1

    I knew there was a reason I subscribed to you. You are the best music analyist and teacher. You include music of all genres, including electro... wow! Finally! I'm starting to produce music. I'm watching you constantly to get pointers. Thank you, thank you! RUclips is the best!

  • @lourlopezsk
    @lourlopezsk 2 года назад +20

    I know nothing about music but this is brilliant! Bohemian Rhapsody and Jesus of Suburbia are two songs that once they start playing I have to listen to them all, I can't pause them, it just doesn't feel right. This explains a lot! Mindblown. Thank you! Greetings from Argentina

  • @xijinvegg
    @xijinvegg 3 года назад +490

    I don’t know if im correct, but isn’t Stairway to Heaven by Led Zeppelin a song with no chorus?

    • @ramiabdalla2661
      @ramiabdalla2661 3 года назад +28

      yeah, you seem to be correct, nice

    • @cletusbeauregard1972
      @cletusbeauregard1972 3 года назад +67

      Most of Zeppelin's songs didn't have choruses after Robert Plant took over the lyric writing. He just didn't like them.

    • @stellartoad
      @stellartoad 3 года назад +1

      Yeah

    • @PedanticTwit
      @PedanticTwit 3 года назад +24

      @Zbigniew G When he said, "perhaps the most famous example of a through-composed song is," I immediately started to say _Stairway to Heaven._ Was kind of left with a Spock raised eyebrow. I always heard Stairway more than Bohemian Rhapsody on the radio.

    • @alexanderbinkert181
      @alexanderbinkert181 3 года назад +38

      I think he might not have included it because Led Zeppelin tends to copyright claim videos that use their songs.

  • @tadhgshiels6948
    @tadhgshiels6948 Год назад +4

    Ice Cubes today was a good day is a great example of an instrumental chorus

  • @davidmockbro
    @davidmockbro 3 года назад +36

    I wish you mentioned Billy Joel’s Scenes from an Italian Restaurant!
    Even before watching this I though the label for that song structure was “Episodic”

  • @zerocool1981
    @zerocool1981 3 года назад +78

    You can find some examples in Iron Maiden songs too.
    In example "The trooper" has an instrumental chorus made by the guitar riff that is also the hook of the song.
    Or in "Hallowed by thy name", again the hook is the guitar riff and I think it can be considered as through-composed because it can be split in 4 sections where the differences are in the tempo. Every time the song goes to the next section, it doubles the tempo that is what gives the song the dynamics, till the very last part where the tempo goes back to the one in the first part.

    • @wombi04
      @wombi04 3 года назад +2

      The Rime Of The Ancient Mariner...

    • @SarimFaruque
      @SarimFaruque 2 года назад

      I count The Trooper’s “oh oh oh” as a chorus, but I agree that Hallowed be thy Name is chorus-less.

    • @DragonGrafx-16
      @DragonGrafx-16 Год назад

      @@wombi04 Good song... anyway that is an example of a storytelling song.... but most Iron Maiden songs are storytelling songs even the ones that have choruses.

  • @slawless9665
    @slawless9665 3 года назад +43

    Dreams by The Cranberries has kind of an "instrumental chorus" but the instrument is Dolores' incredible voice doing its thing.

  • @FanTazTiCxD
    @FanTazTiCxD 4 месяца назад +1

    Knights of Cydonia by Muse is one of the greatest chorusless songs! It goes like this:
    Intro
    Instrumental verse (melody played on guitar)
    Instrumental verse 2 (key has now changed discreetly by +4 semitones)
    Verse with lyrics (key now changed by +8)
    Intro section again (key has changed by +12 thus going back to 0)
    B acapella section (builds up...)
    B climax section with both vocals and instruments

  • @santvanni_prod
    @santvanni_prod 3 года назад +132

    I thought you would mention Stairway to Heaven. You can maybe call the last part a chorus but it never repeats itself, it’s just a continuous way up in energy. Just like climbing a stairway

    • @marcofearg9956
      @marcofearg9956 3 года назад +8

      That was the first song i think of

    • @GGNotes
      @GGNotes 3 года назад +36

      "Makes me wonder" is the chorus.

    • @DavidBennettPiano
      @DavidBennettPiano  3 года назад +60

      I was actually going to include Stairway but, as another commenter has pointed out, it actually does have a chorus! The "Make me wonder" bit. 😊

    • @GGNotes
      @GGNotes 3 года назад +15

      @@DavidBennettPiano Thanks, David! "Makes me wonder" is not as catchy as choruses normally are, but it's definitely "part B", and repeated more than once, so yes it qualifies as chorus. Thank for another great video!

    • @DavidBennettPiano
      @DavidBennettPiano  3 года назад +29

      @@GGNotes Yeah, it's not an obvious chorus at all! I actually made an entire graphic for Stairway because I was going to include it in the video until I realised that it did technically have a chorus!

  • @iamjacksfakeband
    @iamjacksfakeband 3 года назад +35

    -Car Seat Headrest are like legendary for long songwriting but also great episodic songwriting. Beach Life In Death is like the major one, but also High to Death, The Ballad of the Costa Concordia, and The End of Dramamine
    -I've only listened to The Microphones in 2020 a few times now, but I think it counts. As the entire album is one song, it's sort of in a realm of its own, but I think it fits as like a story telling song with like a musical A and B section.
    -Handcuffs by The Front Bottoms is a story telling song that also has an instrumental chorus.
    -Cloud Cult has several. A few I can think of are When the Water Comes to Life (which I think manages to hold attention through just building the atmosphere and tension), You'll Be Bright (which is sort of episodic), A Good God and Alien Christ are also sort of instrumental chorus in a way
    -A lot of 22, a Million by Bon Iver is an interesting approach to songwriting in a lot of ways, but a lot of songs on that album don't really have a chorus exactly.

    • @aftonh6592
      @aftonh6592 2 года назад

      yes!! i came to the comments to mention car seat headrest!

  • @taylord7644
    @taylord7644 3 года назад +89

    mgmt has a lot of chorus-less songs: Siberian breaks, flash delirium, the handshake, in the afternoon, metanoia...like half of their songs have interesting structures with no chorus.
    also 'this must be the place' by talking heads, and 'cause' by Rodriguez are great ones

  • @eoincoveney6531
    @eoincoveney6531 7 месяцев назад +1

    Everything in its right place/ Radiohead has no real chorus or even pre- chorus. Instrumental choruses: Do you think I’m sexy/ Rod Stewart. Rapture/ Blondie. Jump/ Van Halen. Really like your channel, btw!

  • @eduardozepol2000
    @eduardozepol2000 3 года назад +34

    Metallica was criticized for going "mainstream" on the Ride The Lightning album because of the song Fade To Black. Ironically it was the only song with no lyrical chorus (besides The Call Of Ktulu, which is an instrumental) you know, when having a chorus automatically made you sell out

    • @mr_m3d
      @mr_m3d 3 года назад +3

      Finally someone mentions this.

  • @moyerr
    @moyerr 3 года назад +77

    I’ve been wondering about “I Don’t Want to Know” by Fleetwood Mac. That song honestly feels like it has two choruses and no verse. Both the “I don’t wanna know the reasons…” and “Finally baby…” parts feel like hooks in their own right, and they’re each repeated multiple times

  • @stevenking4617
    @stevenking4617 2 года назад +31

    Over The Hills And Far Away was the song that got me interested in irregular structures. Doesn't really fall into any of these categories, it's almost a through-composition, but not really because it kind of has short verses that repeat. Kind of an A-A-A-B-B-B-C-B-A reprisal... Kind of. It's always fascinated me and it freed me up early on to play around with song structures in ways that my peers weren't.

  • @classicalplayalongs6154
    @classicalplayalongs6154 Год назад +1

    Interesting topic, very instructive overview. Btw, in Jesus Of Suburbia, I believe both parts I and II have a regular Verse1-Chorus-Verse2-Chorus structure in themselves.

    • @gaffer2602
      @gaffer2602 6 месяцев назад

      Yeah, but a chorus is throughout the entire song. I think most parts of it have that structure

  • @MegaMattMorris
    @MegaMattMorris 3 года назад +81

    'The Wreck of the Edmond Fitzgerald' is a great example of a song with an instrumental chorus

    • @liebnub
      @liebnub 3 года назад

    • @casey6556
      @casey6556 3 года назад +4

      It’s pretty strophic too - the music is fairly similar across each verse, though sung a bit differently (much like some recordings of House of the Rising Sun)

  • @CompletelyCr
    @CompletelyCr 3 года назад +117

    Scenes from an Italian Restaurant, by Billy Joel, springs to mind as a song without a "proper chorus."

    • @DavidBennettPiano
      @DavidBennettPiano  3 года назад +23

      Great song! 😀

    • @labscimaster
      @labscimaster 3 года назад +15

      It it wasn't for its length, I'm sure Billy Joel would be remembered for that song, and not Piano man. I wonder whether its complexity also made it less memorable than Piano man. It is a much better song, IMO.

    • @MuzixMaker
      @MuzixMaker 3 года назад +1

      Italian Restaurant is through-composed IMO

    • @gaffer2602
      @gaffer2602 6 месяцев назад

      ​@@labscimasterPiano man isn't that much shorter

    • @tysmasher9515
      @tysmasher9515 2 месяца назад +1

      I’m a huge Billy Joel fan as was desperately scrolling through the comments to find someone to mention it 😂

  • @Thelpmoe
    @Thelpmoe 3 года назад +955

    the waveform of the greenday song is a meme in itself

    • @DavidBennettPiano
      @DavidBennettPiano  3 года назад +210

      Yeah, I was quite surprised by that! Product of the "loudness wars" I imagine! en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loudness_war

    • @pulykamell
      @pulykamell 3 года назад +70

      Hah. I was about to comment, HOLY HYPER COMPRESSION BATMAN! and see it's been dutifully noticed. Good job, internet.

    • @G60syncro
      @G60syncro 3 года назад +17

      First thing to spring in my mind as well!! How am I to know where one section ends and the other begins!!

    • @jrurbbehdidiwdnndjduw85eos73
      @jrurbbehdidiwdnndjduw85eos73 3 года назад +18

      I didn't expect paranoid android to have so many over compressed moments

    • @grunions9648
      @grunions9648 3 года назад +26

      That's 2005 baby!

  • @hunterotails2015
    @hunterotails2015 24 дня назад +2

    Hallowed Be Thy Name, Fade To Black, War Pigs are some of my faves without a chorus

  • @doctormojo
    @doctormojo 3 года назад +831

    The song that just builds monotonically - White Rabbit.

    • @hifijohn
      @hifijohn 3 года назад +30

      I was just going to say that Im surprised he didn't mention it.

    • @TroyJakubiec
      @TroyJakubiec 3 года назад +19

      In Dreams - Roy Orbison

    • @jakephocas1396
      @jakephocas1396 3 года назад +3

      Of course!

    • @DavidBennettPiano
      @DavidBennettPiano  3 года назад +142

      Great song and great example! I often think that song is over way too quick! The "When the men on the chessboard
      ..." section could have easily been a chorus if the song had a longer structure! 😀

    • @Howitchewstofeel5gum
      @Howitchewstofeel5gum 3 года назад +9

      Monotonically or maniacally?

  • @fritzholsteen598
    @fritzholsteen598 3 года назад +20

    When You Sleep by My Bloody Valentine has always been my favorite example of an "instrumental chorus." The ascending guitars, melodic synth and wonderful release are instantly recognizable and equally as beautiful.

  • @swansonjoe7121
    @swansonjoe7121 3 года назад +43

    I think this channel is teaching me how to experiment with song structures (songs with only verses, songs with only 2 chords etc.) but at the same time I don't want to become lazy with just writing lazy songs with 1 chord. These videos explain how to add spice to them so they do not become boring

    • @track1219
      @track1219 3 года назад +2

      I know; I feel the same way!

    • @HappyBeezerStudios
      @HappyBeezerStudios 3 года назад +1

      A song with only 1 chord can't be lazy. Because it takes much more effort to make it sound good. You can't just climb and fall to build and release tension.

    • @michaelwaynemartin3291
      @michaelwaynemartin3291 3 года назад +2

      Limitations breed creativity. I got good at picking cos I was such a clumsy strummer. Learn what you can then go back to jazz or whatever and apply it. Boom, your non musical friends will be well impressed.

    • @sunkintree
      @sunkintree 3 года назад

      @@HappyBeezerStudios "lazy people aren't lazy because it takes more effort to be a good person"
      Bruh, lazy people are just lazy. They're not trying to be anything, that's why they're lazy. That's the whole thing. Lmao.

    • @xRedstoneCraftx
      @xRedstoneCraftx 3 года назад

      Listen to Thank You (Falettinme Be Mice Elf Agin) by sly and the family stone. It uses a single E7(#9) chord “the Hendrix chord” and single groove for 4:48 without ever getting boring.

  • @GiovanniMinelli-i2f
    @GiovanniMinelli-i2f 4 месяца назад +3

    We can consider as well rapper's "freestyles", when they publish songs that are only a long verse rapped without choruses or only one at the ending

  • @j.s.7335
    @j.s.7335 3 года назад +17

    When you gave Clarity as an example, I thought for sure you were wrong about it not having a chorus. So I listened, and of course you are correct. Clarity gives a lot of clarity as to what constitutes a chorus versus a refrain. It's a very structurally complicated song--which is why I think it so fascinated me when it came out.
    The three sections of the song, as you laid out (verse, build-up, drop) can be broken down further, and then it becomes clearer that the refrain is used both as the latter part of the build-up, and then again as the latter part of the drop. Plus, the drop has a build-up within it. Whew!
    Verse
    Build-up: pre-refrain, refrain
    Drop: instrumental, instrumental build-up, refrain
    Verse
    Build-up: pre-refrain, refrain
    Drop: instrumental, instrumental build-up, hybrid instrumental/refrain, refrain

  • @dhpbear2
    @dhpbear2 3 года назад +253

    ""Now the chorus comes in, but nobody knows why, except Mozart - and he's dead." - Victor Borge

  • @GurimujoJagajaku
    @GurimujoJagajaku 3 года назад +185

    Can't forget about Floyd. Wish You Were Here, Time, Money, Eclipse, Dogs, and so many more.

    • @DavidBennettPiano
      @DavidBennettPiano  3 года назад +39

      Good examples 😀

    • @yobrepus
      @yobrepus 3 года назад +39

      A lot of prog doesn't have choruses :-D

    • @GurimujoJagajaku
      @GurimujoJagajaku 3 года назад +19

      @@yobrepus of course. Floyd was just the easiest and most obvious answer lmao

    • @robertolanzone
      @robertolanzone 3 года назад +7

      Regardless of other songs that fit in the categories he listed, I'm surprised he didn't mention the typical "one verse only" structure of many rap songs (mostly in the 80s and 90s). They just rap a continuous long verse that never repeats throughout the song

    • @BlobsterBuddy
      @BlobsterBuddy 3 года назад +8

      If you look at Money instrumentally, then it does have a more distinct verse-chorus structure

  • @drewstephenson
    @drewstephenson Месяц назад +1

    The Trapeze Swinger and White Rabbit spring immediately to mind as very different examples.

  • @clf400
    @clf400 3 года назад +119

    Haha the differece between Bohemien Rhapsody and JoS shows the loudness wars and why you should leave headroom

    • @sourisvoleur4854
      @sourisvoleur4854 3 года назад +3

      It really jumps out at one.

    • @jack002tuber
      @jack002tuber 3 года назад +7

      Max Headroom

    • @frmcf
      @frmcf 3 года назад +2

      @@jack002tuber Or Min Headroom in this case :)

    • @nikolajmadsen1002
      @nikolajmadsen1002 3 года назад +1

      What's JoS?

    • @clf400
      @clf400 3 года назад +3

      @@nikolajmadsen1002 Jesus of suburbia

  • @craigtillman5988
    @craigtillman5988 3 года назад +31

    Not since I minored in music - 20yrs ago, has Music Theory has been so detailed, yet captivating, and dare I say entertaining. This has to be on of the best YT Channels/Contact Providers. Thanks DBP!

  • @WastedPo
    @WastedPo 2 года назад +108

    I love the song "There She Goes," and I've always thought of it as a song with ONLY a chorus, but no verses. However, after seeing this video, maybe it also falls into the "without a chorus" category. Maybe it's the AABA structure.

    • @RockyStradlin
      @RockyStradlin 2 года назад +8

      The La's!!!

    • @PedroBenolielBonito
      @PedroBenolielBonito 2 года назад +2

      @@RockyStradlin You mean Sixpence None The Richer... xD
      Also, that DOES have a verse: 'she calls my name, she calls my name...'

    • @fleshrags
      @fleshrags 2 года назад +3

      i guess a song that always is at a climax never reached a climax

    • @shoveitupyourtube
      @shoveitupyourtube Год назад +4

      @@PedroBenolielBonito Sixpence was a cover though. The La’s was the original.

    • @PedroBenolielBonito
      @PedroBenolielBonito Год назад +2

      @@shoveitupyourtube I know that...now. Never did growing up.

  • @needfoolthings
    @needfoolthings 5 месяцев назад +3

    Don't Stop Believing is probably the most poppy/popular of these.
    Took me decades to realize there isn't a chorus.

    • @paulblichmann2791
      @paulblichmann2791 5 месяцев назад +3

      It's just a chorus that happens to have the same background chords and riff.

  • @badwilliesmail
    @badwilliesmail 3 года назад +89

    "The Wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald" by Gordon Lightfoot (possibly an instrumental chorus between verses but definitely a story telling song in the folk tradition).

    • @phoenixferris6667
      @phoenixferris6667 3 года назад +3

      Yes!! And definitely one of Lightfoot's best songs

    • @leslieortenzi8875
      @leslieortenzi8875 2 года назад +2

      I think this is a classic example of a strophic format-perfect for the story-telling it does. Like an old folk song in an ancient sea-faring village!

    • @joelp5093
      @joelp5093 2 года назад +2

      It's amazing how that song immortalized an event that the world would have quickly forgotten about otherwise.

    • @bigredswims
      @bigredswims 2 года назад +2

      No joke, this was the first song where I had an epiphany and said to myself, "Hey wait a second... there's no chorus!"

  • @gustavojacobina9796
    @gustavojacobina9796 3 года назад +31

    There are two really famous brazilian songs from "Legião Urbana" that are both episodic and story telling songs. They are named "Eduardo e Mônica" e "Faroeste Caboclo", and both tell really long life stories. The most amazing part is that if you are somewhere in Brazilia, home town of the old band, and start playing any of these songs, lots of people will stop by and sing along, even though they are a 6 minute and 9 minutes song, respetcively.

    • @gabrvalete
      @gabrvalete 3 года назад +2

      Pensei em Faroeste Caboclo na hora rsrsrs rsrs

    • @SquirrelSeb84
      @SquirrelSeb84 3 года назад +2

      Faroeste Caboclo was the first I could think of. Amazing song.

  • @stephenpower8723
    @stephenpower8723 2 года назад +52

    David Bowie loved a chorus but his early stuff had numerous examples. The Album "The Man Who Sold The World" has quite a few.

    • @Yawnyaman
      @Yawnyaman 2 года назад +10

      Ashes to Ashes is arguably a bit like this too. Two long verses, just sharing a final refrain, with a coda. Bowie came up with some brilliantly constructed songs.

  • @Anthony-ob5fy
    @Anthony-ob5fy Год назад +3

    Two great example of this are Rime of the Ancient Mariner and Dance Of Death, both by Iron Maiden. Not a single chorus, and the only part of the instrumental that returns is the main riff or melody from the beginning, coming back near the end to close out the piece. Both are musical and compositionall masterpieces in their own right as well.

    • @tylerk4231
      @tylerk4231 29 дней назад +1

      Up the iron \m/
      The Parchment is definitely one of em, and so might Hell On Earth.

  • @maggie..
    @maggie.. 2 года назад +87

    el paso by marty robins is my favorite example of this, i feel like by telling a story it holds your attention a lot more than a different song with a heavy chorus

    • @jbjacobs9514
      @jbjacobs9514 2 года назад +8

      Down in the West Texas town of El Paso, I fell in love with a Mexican girl...ICONIC!

    • @ScoundrelSFB
      @ScoundrelSFB 2 года назад +3

      Incredible song. One of the best story tellings in songs.

    • @haydenanderson5539
      @haydenanderson5539 2 года назад +2

      Can further recommend 'Faleena' an 8:20 story from Faleena's pov

    • @mariol2116
      @mariol2116 Год назад

      MY SONG DONT HAVE CHORUS ruclips.net/video/uOCeF-ls4wE/видео.html

  • @HowardLeaderman
    @HowardLeaderman 3 года назад +82

    Just Like Heaven amazes me with its lack of chorus, it's one of those driving songs that just moves and amps up.

    • @jackvalentino2125
      @jackvalentino2125 3 года назад +14

      I feel like a huge amount of Cure tracks follow the no chorus rules haha. Nearly every song off of Disintegration doesn’t have a chorus

    • @ChasMusic
      @ChasMusic 3 года назад +2

      You don't consider "You and me just like heaven" to be a one-line chorus?

    • @Astfgl
      @Astfgl 3 года назад +6

      The Cure really seemed to go out of their way to avoid choruses in their songs, yet they always managed to keep things varied and interesting. It makes their songs harder to grasp, but also that much more intriguing and replayable.

    • @HowardLeaderman
      @HowardLeaderman 3 года назад +2

      @@ChasMusic There is a melodic refrain between verse 2 and 3 that's breifly reprised at the end, but it hardly counts as a chorus.
      Also, he says "You, just like heaven" just once at the end of the song.

    • @HowardLeaderman
      @HowardLeaderman 3 года назад +1

      @@jackvalentino2125 True, but lovesong clearly had that intrumental one, and that's the only track I would consider a "pop song". Just Like Heaven is very pop and accessible despite being without a chorus, a testament to Smith that he wrote such an engaging pop song without the classic device.
      There's a lot of music in the more post punk or Gothic scene without hooks, but the style of Just Like Heaven compared to that makes it more impressive as a chorus-less song. (not that it's my favorite cure song or anything.)

  • @EduardoSuarez-zq3qn
    @EduardoSuarez-zq3qn 3 года назад +59

    Lullaby by The Cure is an excellent example of an instrumental chorus

    • @matiasarteaga4548
      @matiasarteaga4548 3 года назад +5

      That short guitar line in since I’ve been loving you by zeppelin too

    • @raithrover1976
      @raithrover1976 3 года назад +4

      Party Fears Two by The Associates is another that springs to mind. Feels Like Heaven by Fiction Factory?

    • @raithrover1976
      @raithrover1976 3 года назад +1

      Just listened to Feels Like Heaven and it does have a chorus that pretty much comprises the title being sung a few times. Great track though.

    • @Supergoddad4live
      @Supergoddad4live 3 года назад

      I would suggest listening to Jimi Hendrix's 'Third Stone From The Sun' - it has an excellent returning chorus with a lot of other stuff going on

    • @MarksUkuleleTips
      @MarksUkuleleTips 3 года назад +3

      Close To Me by the Cure would be an instrumental chorus too if I'm hearing it right in my head.

  • @chasebethersonton5169
    @chasebethersonton5169 10 месяцев назад +4

    Love this!
    I really need a whole series / playlist for these variations in structures.
    It helps me so much on my own projects.

  • @bobhible6140
    @bobhible6140 3 года назад +25

    In Dreams by Roy Orbison is a brilliant and classic through-composed song. Seven none-repeated sections, building and building to the crescendo. Fantastic!

    • @budfoon
      @budfoon 3 года назад +3

      Running Scared & Blue Angel too!

    • @georgecolombo
      @georgecolombo 3 года назад +3

      I posted this one a moment ago but see now that you beat me to it. Great song and an excellent example. You put it perfectly.

    • @musicauthority7828
      @musicauthority7828 Год назад +1

      Roy Orbison was a brilliant song writer. and of course one of the greatest singers of all time. Fred Foster of Monument records described the song. as having a verse that built all the way to the end of the song with a huge climax. Foster said that was one of the first times that a song had written. with that unconventional style of song writing.

    • @baseche9253
      @baseche9253 6 месяцев назад

      Perfect example! 👍

  • @OwensDrumming
    @OwensDrumming 3 года назад +158

    A lot of Rush songs don’t really have choruses… they’re meandering masterpieces

    • @redpig6878
      @redpig6878 3 года назад +4

      I was thinking that going into this video

    • @CreeperSkullDZ
      @CreeperSkullDZ 3 года назад +2

      ayy a rush fan

    • @SarahElisabethJoyal
      @SarahElisabethJoyal 3 года назад +8

      I mean in prog you kind of expect that

    • @zappawench6048
      @zappawench6048 3 года назад +14

      Yay! A fellow Rush fan! You have excellent taste in music, dude.
      So sad that Neil Peart has passed away. I had a little cry when I learned he had passed on, because that means the no more of their magical music. However, their output as a band was prolific, and we are so fortunate that there is still so much of their marvellous music available for us to enjoy and appreciate. I like to think that Neil is now reunited with his wife and daughter who went before him.
      RIP Neil Peart, you were amazingly talented and will always have a place in the hearts of the millions of fans whose lives you touched, improved and inspired.

    • @albertofichera4154
      @albertofichera4154 3 года назад +1

      2112...

  • @rome8180
    @rome8180 3 года назад +55

    Leonard Cohen and Tom Waits both have a lot of strophic songs. I feel like to be a strophic songwriter you have to be an excellent lyricist, which they both are.

  • @whatsunderthetable
    @whatsunderthetable 5 месяцев назад +6

    I was thinking that EDM is one of the most prominent genres that often forgoes the chorus, and then you brought out a classic !!
    very infomative video