Dimash is a Rarity! It's a God given gift and, secondly, it's human's hard work along with dedication. A gift because Dimash has longer vocal cords (interview of a vocal coach Emre Echelen with Dimash) and a perfect pitch (interview of his grandmother Miua who took him the first time to a music school at the age of 5). A hard work and dedication because Dimash (from his various interviews): - does not smoke or drink alcohol, - does not eat spicy foods/drink fizzy drinks much, - went to the night clubs only 2-3 times in his life (too noisy; loud music unpleasantly hits his ears drums), - surrounded by friends and family with music background - studying music and singing from the age of 5 (overall 20 years of his life out of 24 were devoted to vocal/music training), including: - 7 years in music school (piano, choir, solfeggio, music literature/history, etc.), - 3 years in Zhubanov music college, - 3-4 years in Shabyt University of Arts. - his mother is a professional singer (currently a lead (soloist) in a folk ensemble of Aktobe) - Dimash citation: 'Almost every day I spend 2-3 hours on vocal training only. Of course I have some days I am not feeling inspired, although I am not kind of person who rests 3 days to work just a day'. - He won numerous local and international awards - Many respectable, professional , well-known in the music industry pop and opera singers, composers, musicians from different parts of the world acknowledged him, amongst them head of Astana opera (who sang in La Scala) Maira Muhammed kyzy, Safina (Italian tenor), Albano (Italian singer), Lara Fabian, so on. Head of Chinese pop using industry said Dimash has super human abilities. Yet, people say Dimash lip sinc. Let's try to identify these people: Online vocal coaches/online singers?! Do we know them? Do they have diplomas in those fields? Have we heard of their students? I tend to think Dimash improvises every time just because of certain mood at a time, or adjusting his voice if he's unwell, or gets excited by cheers his Dears give him. It came across my mind that he may do it because he gets upset that all his hard work gets blames in lip sinc. The path he has chosen is extremely hard. He is a such Rarity that people question his insane vocal abilities and trying to diminish his range, technique or emotional delivery. Or simply stating it's a playback, lip sinc, voice editing, post-production, etc.
He just way too good, almost unbelieveably perfect at his singing/performance that people threw lipsync accusation at him :v well, even if you're near perfect you still can't please everyone apparently. Human will always be unsatisfied :/
I'm very glad for the technical problems to the next song...Adagio...he proved that he is not lip sinch...Dimash is an unbelievable singer..out of this world my friend...he is just the best.
you will be surprised, but this is a live performance. Music in the recording, backing vocals in the recording, and Dimash live. The organizers of the concert posted information about this. Plus, for the native speaker of the Russian language, some nuances of his pronunciation are clearly audible. As for breathing, Dimash perfectly controls it, since from childhood he is engaged in swimming, besides he studied classical opera singing, where a lot of time is devoted to the ability to work with breathing.
Yeah sorry it is very clearly lip synced, you can’t have the exact same breaths in the exact same spots and the exact same tone with no differences whatsoever and it not be lip synced
Hi my friend, Dimash will never playback at his live show. I told u a truth about his refusing lip-synch in China. He caught a bad cold in January this year. At the same time he had to take part in two TV shows. One was a small award ceremony. The host told us that Dimash was very sick and the director advise him not to come. But Dimash appeared on the scene and sang acappella. Dears who were on the scene cried. It's hard to finish singing half a song but Dimash made an effort and asking for our forgiveness.The host told us that Dimash was too sick to sing. But he insisted on refusing to lip-synch.. ( The director had allowed him to do that because his very sick situation) It’s not the end of the story. Dimash withdraw from the other program on the next day which was more important and well paid. The show would broadcast to the hold nation by a famous and important TV Channel. And the show was a Pre-recorded Show. Do u know what its meaning? A singer was allowed to playback if he had reasons to do that in an important show which was Pre-recored. But Dimash withdraw from the Pre-recording. He world rather lose money for breaking the contact of performance. We have many fancom of the rehearsal and the formal performance. We can hear out the tiny different details at the last part of the song. We believed that Dimash didn’t playback on the live show. We were told by Dimash's father that Dimash had to lip synch once When he was still young. All Of us know that.
bird night he has proud of singer. Due people jealousy n unfriendly he gain his strength n getting stronger. How amazing his vocal improvement now. He never stop learning.
and its the fcking internet. . if you search for anything you will find it ... search for some shit like is breathing air dealdy.. and you will find it ... so ofc they are searching for any shit .. especially when it goes about the best singer in the world
If you watched his rehearsal fully you must clearly see difference between of them. In rehearsal he sang the second part of the song in soprano but only two rows and other two rows was in baritone again, but in the A-studio concert he sang this part totally in soprano voice, also he sounded Russian words differently, because it’s not his native language
It was live, Frank 🤦♀️! I clearly hear the difference in the pronunciation of certain words! And check his arabic parts at the end, they are also different!
It was lip synced, it’s not a bad thing idk why people are so quick to push back at it. It’s very clear it’s a lip sync cause even the finite details like the breathing in the same place with the same tone, it’s the same
I Worship Gays And Satan You are unbelievable, commenting on multiple videos merely “saying” he’s lip syncing.. I don’t get how you can have a negative view towards the worlds greatest singer alive? Maybe to have ever lived, considering he perfectly sang the Diva Dance, with a male voice. Like, did he do a cover better than your favorite singer could dream of? 😂 Actually, your username says it all. 🙄
I Worship Gays And Satan And even if he did Lip Sync, I don’t care? ... he’s still the best voice this world has seen. Which is not just my opinion, but the belief of enough fans, vocal artists and judges to make it a fact. Your opinion is your own, please keep it to yourself.
I Worship Gays And Satan And so many Russian speakers have came out stating he is not lip syncing because they can easily notice the slight differences in his tone and voice. Which English speakers are not be able to spot. Yet you argue against it? No Dimash Is Perfect 😂😂 LoL
I remember one of a vocal coach in a reaction video said that even though a singer did a lip sync, they still have to record it with their voice. Technology can't make someone without technique suddenly becomes a great singer. Technology just to improve or to polish their voice. Well, I agree with him. Lip sync or not, it's still dimash who sing it. And he nailed it..
@@NanaNana-hb5hb Not all lip sync use the studio version of the song, especially if they want to record the "live" feeling to match the audio with the performer and with the stage. Different stage gives different acoustic characteristics, which may or may not match the studio version. For partial playback use, it's even more crucial to have authentic playback accompanying the live performance. Using studio version sometimes give unbalanced sound mix. Unless tested that using the studio version sound similar enough or be drowned by concert goers screams/claps/etc.
I've read that A-Studio and Dimash haven't rehearsed together and that's why there are two tapes, one for A-Studio and one for Dimash. In concert they both sang and played live! Dimash is a perfectionist, he brings every detail to absolutism...he controls his voice in a way no one else can..I don't care if it was his rehearsal track or if he sang live. I'm happy to accept both. But I'm surprised how two little things made you so easily come to a such conclusion? And what about the movements of hands, body, head? They coincide very strongly! Even the hand movements captured by the camera separately are the same both on stage and in rehearsal..And besides, Dimash is a good swimmer, he controls breathing both as an opera singer and a swimmer! So your arguments didn't convince me at all...
I like that you accept him regardless if it's live or not. Same for me As far as body gestures etc. You can still feel the song and move your body while it's playback. So that's not an argument. Just accept its playback and be happy about it. If u want real proof that's its playback I can show you
Anis Berhil please do. I remember online vocal coach Tristan tried to provide Lip sinc/auto tune proof for SOS song at Singer 2017 on the computer software. He showed the software checks of the long straight note to prove it was auto tuned. However paused right before the vibrato should have come... proving otherwise.
@@assemkilybayeva7388 Tristan is crazy guy, he didn't prove anything. Anyone can easily realize sochi was a playback not by judging the song itself. I agree that dimash almost make it impossible to realize it's lip sync. I'm guessing he still sing but the recorded sound is so major compared to his voice. Just open sochi performance on your computer. Open rehearsal video.a phone or different device. Try to play them with lot of trials and error until dimash start singing same time in both videos. Then you'll realize it's one sound coming from both devices. No change whatsoever!
Anis Bernhil, the song is very slow with an easy rhythm. Dimash's singing should coincide with pianist/composer of the original song (A-Studio) and other band members plus the playback music. So they have to be synchronized carefully. Please have a very close-up fancam from Galina Ul'anova: ruclips.net/video/DI5od3TbYQs/видео.html. You can clearly see his mouth, neck, chest movements when he breathes from a close distance. Please see in the comments someone named Анастасия Мау saying that organizers themselves published as "live performance". Thank you for your attention Ps in addition, you can find my 3 arguments for this song performed live in the comment section. Cheers
We, Dimash' fans, accept him as he is. Even if he sings to the soundtrack, which he never does, it does not detract from his dignity. And your mistake is that you're trying to find something that can't be found . Because you hear and you work, you deal with ordinary people. But when you realize that he is unusual, that he is unique, his natural data plus his titanic work - it all brings Dimash to unattainable height. So you are saying that it is impossible at one and the same place to take a breath or exhale. He does it with a unique accuracy. That's when you understand his uniqueness and accept it, that's when you will not dig and look for what is not, but instead enjoy his unique singing. Personally, I'm absolutely not against if he sometimes uses the sound recording to save his voice, to protect the ligament... Because I want him to sing for a long time... And he works on wear and tear...Even at the closing of the Vitebsk festival, when all the singers were singing the final song to the soundtrack, Dimash was standing among them without a microphone and was just smiling, because he doesn't sing to the soundtrack.
THE VOCAL LEXICON, if you are a vocal coach, you know how to perform a professional composition analysis to identify the use of the phonogram. What you told is funny, but not scientific. Dimash perfectly knows Russian, but easy accent vsetaki is. So the pronunciation at the rehearsal and at the concert does not always match. There are other differences ... I think, to determine the synchronization you need to use the appropriate hardware and software, and not guessing on the coffee grounds. I do not have anything against synchronization if necessary, but I against looking for synchronization where it does not exist.
Anis Berhil I wrote that the "analysis" on the video can not be proof. If there is a desire to prove, do it right or do not do it at all. You know something, I know something. But as long as we do not provide scientifically grounded arguments, people have the right to doubt. And have the right to believe in what they think is right.
Anis Berhil nothing wrong. it was live. Dimash’s dad said to director in the beginning (rehearsal): he’s gonna sing it first time, let’s give him time. And Mr.Revzin answered: yes, of course, but we don’t have any time
When the singer sings high notes, his larynx goes up, and the hole is formed in the throat under the larynx. Try to get the following effect when you're lipsyncing.
what are you talking about???? lip sync? people can't you just believe that Dimash is not just ordinary singer as you are he is a genius he can sing absolutely identical in rehearsal and live performance. he is capable. stop making rumors out of nowhere just to promote your channel.
No doubt Dimash is extraordinary. However, *generally speaking,* extraordinary and lip sync aren't mutually exclusive. Do I believe Dimash's extraordinary-ness extends to millisecond second timing? Maybe, but most likely not. Is it possible that's what happen here? Always. Will finding out Dimash lipped here change me into liking Dimash less? Nope. Will finding out Dimash didn't lip here change me into liking Dimash more? Now that's impossible 😁 . I already crowned him the King. King, not God ;) .
I believe that Dimash is a precision singer fully capable of perfect timing in rehearsal and in concert, to the millisecond. The key to his vocal success is precision, it is everywhere in his songs. He pays attention to the most finite details in every aspect of the human voice and brings mastery to perfection. His dedication to precision is unequalled. I agree with Ulviya Rahimova.
Great Music Dilettante No one says that he is a God, but it is not right to drag someone's hard work through the mud just because you had an impression that he was lip syncing. That is all I wanted to say. Have a nice day
@@ulviyarahimova8452 Maybe you've never called him a god, but others have, or treat him like one, apparent by the way they comment, or even used verbatim the word "god". Granted, that behavior is not limited to just Dimash. All fandom seem to have a few of these, people who diefy the artist/actors/sport figures/politicians/etc. About that dragging mud thing, I don't think that was what TVL Frank did. He gave his honest analysis with zero bashing whatsoever. People who are offended by lip syncing still don't comprehend it's the very same artist who recorded the performance. They say they understand, but deep down they don't get it.
common, he is trained how to manage the breathing, however exactly the pronunciation shows these are two different live performances, the way he pronounce "daj mne" (give me) and further lyrics sounds very differently. But you can hear it only if russian is your mother tongue. Check some videos of his english lyrics performances, that would be more professional from your side
@@anumbrella8598 я не слышу никакой разницы в "зелье". Could you give me another moment to compare, cause I don't hear any difference? Maybe I was too fast with conclusions. I like Dimash. I don't care if it is just a playback. Everybody knows, that in Russia most of the shows are playback, and not because people cannot sing
first time in zelie в "зелье" sound L was very hard, very kazach style, while in second time L was more tender, but definitely strong accent - this is what makes 100% sure these both are different perfomances
@@LavendelGreen that's what happens when you love dimash blindly and don't wanna accept this is playback I feel sorry for people who are like that. I love him too and have no problem knowing this is lip syncing
I listened both rehearsal and actual performance over and over countlessly and I realized that some hard parts are too close or the same which might indicate lip-sync, but I also realized that some parts are different; at some points, pronunciations varies. I'm not professional, but the breath timing really proves lip-sync? he is a professional singer, not a kid to miss rhythm. another vocal coach, Emre Yücelen mentioned in his Unforgettable Day(Gakku) analyse video that his stage presence, mic holding position etc must be pre-prepared with exact these words: "he is not just a singer, he is a storyteller, a man on the street"; knowing that makes me think that "maybe", we know that this arrangement is totally different from the original A-Studio song, the additions, runs and also that breath to give effect/depth to the song "maybe" pre-prepared and I don't really get it why its timing should be different if there is a purpose to make that breath sound at that exact timing which also "suits rhythm", gives him a small break space etc. I'm neither professional nor amateur, I'm just a random guy on the planet and I don't really know too much about technical stuff, but I can't really understand how breath timing proves lip-sync. If you said that arabic motif part is lip-sync, yeah, I could understand that because it requires more energy, plus it's hard to do exactly the same way for the second time, but breath timing... :S you counted, 1-2-3-4, and that indicates rhythm, right? professional singers miss rhythm occasionally? :S breath timing seems more likely weak link to the lip-sync at best, instead of exact proof. :S
theres a possibility theres 2 versions 1 for the rehearsal and 1 for the actual official performance hes very smart but its not the first time a rehearsal has been off check out the very beginning of auld lang syne rehearsal he looks like he lipsynced slightly too late but theres a reason for that one is because the Chinese new year festival is the biggest event of the year so he was probably forced for his lack of mandarin and for this performance its also possible he was forced I have heard from other Dimash fans that its very common in Kazakhstan and Russia to lipsync but since he has got so popular he doesn't lipsync no where as much as before since he wasn't expecting to get popular so the only times he does lipsync is when forced mainly
china banned lip-sync. it is forbidden and it is "crime". there are regulations and institutions that controls whether someone lip-sync. so, lip-sync in china is not very common. other effects can be used though, but not lip-sync.
lol yes but they get a fine they don't care they make a ton of money from them events a woman was caught in 2016 at the Chinese festival its really that common its only if you have a fail then they will get a fine and like I said that is worth nothing for them :D the woman even said she would do a better job lipsyncing next time
@@bullypunch8253 😂😂😂The lady's respond made me LOL 🤣🤣🤣 Thanks for that 👍👍👍. At the same time, it reminds me how investment bankers also practises the same way. They do unethical banking practises, mostly unnoticed, and when caught, even when fines are in the billions, that's a mere slap on the wrist as they've already made many, many folds of that for years. Now I'm bummed ☹ .
I love your channel and your vocal breakdowns and usually agree with you but this time I think you are overthinking things. I strongly believe Dimash didn't lipsynch on this and here's why. Yes, he is forced to lipsynch occasionally when he's performing a duet with someone, but even then he usually sings over his own recordings. However, this wasn't his only performance that day. They only had the monitors on at the beginning of his performance of Adagio and they had to turn up his microphone to the speakers because the audience couldn't hear him. It's definitely a live screw up. ruclips.net/video/3XcXMYiJx_I/видео.html Dimash has perfect pitch along with his unbelievable vocal control. This is how he can sing a song several times and it sounds virtually identical. It is much like a pianist playing a piece of sheet music they have practiced a hundred times. They can make each performance sound identical because muscle memory comes into play and unless a conscious effort is made to alter a portion, the song will sound the same. I believe this is the reason Dimash has started performing every song he sings a little differently than in a previous performance because many people were saying that he had to be lipsynching for them sound the same every single time. I don't know of another singer who is capable of this so it is understandable that some people don't believe it is real. I just watched another vocal teacher talk about Dimash after seeing him live and meeting him in person. I think you would enjoy hearing what he has to say about Dimash's voice after hearing him live. It's very interesting! ruclips.net/video/wT8cow20K64/видео.html Take care and keep up the good work! 😙💕
hi smylyface can I show you a video can you explain it ik you made a video about Dimash lipsyncing before and putting the rumours to rest but can I show you the video? also I do believe his adagio is live but the sinful passion might not be because its in Russian but since adagio is in English they don't care since there main audience only speaks Russian :) theres other times I believe he has lipsynced but on the same show he has also sung live for example is Slavic bazaar 2015 SOS is live blizzard again is live and daididau hes lipsyncing his old autotuned song watch the first 2 and then watch daididau then you will notice also if you like to have the link to the performance im talking about reply and I want to see how you explain it :)
BullyPunch A sound engineer put his rehearsal audio and performance audio through a computer to compare his vocals. They are similar but not the same. It was live.
yes ik that person its dilettante and he said quite the opposite if you check the comments also i have found a tugan zher performance which shows the autotuned runs he makes with his mouth maybe lipsynced basically he autotunes his runs and lipsyncs them very noticeable in his oy zhailau old performance and i think he used it in 1 of his song when he was around 13 he also used it in his daididau theres even an official video of it and you can tell it was overautotuned theres has been a video of a Chinese youtuber exposing his diva dance bastau where he does autotuned like runs there and its not the first time either but since he doesn't lipsync much anymore that's why he used a whistle there in his shenzen concert instead and in singer2017 was staccato i can show you the unforgettable day (i meant tugan zher im a lil tired lol) performance right now but i put in a separate comment or this message might not show up
you see the link? in that performance you can tell he was a lil bit too happy and wasn't concentrating much on his lipsinging and didn't put his mouth to the mic fast enough
This is official programme issued by organizers of the festive for each day... I am posting it for the first day for all those unbelievers who try to prove that Dimash sang soundtrack. Live broadcast of the creative evening of a'STUDIO and the 1st day of the competition from the concert hall "New Wave Hall" in the Olympic Park of Sochi. The timing for the convenience: 00: 00: 03 last preparations 00:04:25 Arrival of the members of the jury of the contest "New wave 2018" Director of MUZ-TV Arman Davletyarov, composer of Dimitris Kontopoulos 00:17:35 Weaning "New wave" 00:19:04 Keti Topuria and A'studio - Remember this (live) 00:23:00 Hello leading of Timur Rodriguez and Baigali Serkebayev 00:26:50 Philip Kirkorov - Night-girlfriend (live) 00:35:40 Leonid Agutin and Tomas N Evergreen - Julia (live) 00:43:32 Interactive for the audience hall of the New Wave Hall from co-host Sergei Demidov and Victor Abrahamian 00:46:20 Alsou - Love-the river (soundtrack) 00:52:53 Sergey Lazarev - Still in love (live) 01:00:01 Alekseev - the rainy Season (live) 01:05:15 Timur Rodriguez - S. O. S. (live) 01:10:20 The Jigits - Unloved, Soldier of love (live) 01:15:38 Julianna Karaulova - Stop the night (live) 01:22:37 Dimash Kudaibergenov - Sinful passion (live) !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 01: 29: 30 Thanks to the sponsors of the competition from the host Timur Rodriguez 01:31:20 Victoria Zhuk, Anton Belyaev and Therr Maitz band - Fly away (live) 01:37:59 Keti Topuria and A'studio - Fashion girl (live) 01:42:01 Interactive experience for the audience hall of the New Wave Hall from co-host Sergei Demidov and Victor Abrahamian 01:44:35 A STUDIO Keti Topuria and all the stars - White river (live) 01:47:00 fireworks! 01:50:31 Thanks to the sponsors of the competition from the world's leading Timur Rodriguez, Sergey Demidov and Victor Abrahamian
If you think that 2 LIVEs are almost the same is difficult? is lip-sync? I will say, you are wrong, this is very easy do it for Dimash. I give you a example. You can look for < ocean over the time > on youtube, and compare to MV and LIVE Performance versions. I am sure you can't hear the difference between the two, Similarity is almost 99%. But for people who understand Chinese, I can fully know that he is LIVE Performance. Because his pronunciation is completely different in 2 versions. As someone in the comment said, "Sinful Passion" He is LIVE, Because the pronunciation of rehearsals and performances 2 versions are completely different. I even can see his throat moving and changing, and blue veins appear in his throat. These are impossible to appear in lip-sync. I won't say that he has never do a lip-sync, he has, but this is not what he can control, when he is required to do it. BUT, "Sinful Passion" performance is LIVE, I am only referring to the facts and the truth, no matter what you think.
@Just want the Best voiceWhen Dimash sang Ocean Over the time in live, He had known that It was the only chance for his dears to hearing the song. He gave us a perfect version with better pronunciation to review. He was over criticized by Chinese pronunciation before.
Dears, can we please respect Dimash's wishes and not engage in arguments or try to prove something? We who love him know what his work ethic is. I honestly don't care what other people think. He speaks to my heart and my soul and that's enough for me.
May I ask, if lipsync, then why still needs to rehearsal before performance? For me I don't think it is lipsync. How you rehearsal (practice) to sing the song. Then when you go on stage perform the song of course will be the same.
@@TeaOnTue Very true. One can even argue, it takes more practice to perfect a lipped performance than actually sing live without worrying the exact9 millisecond you have to move your mouth, jaws, lips, etc. A simple yet fun exercise to proof that is to record your own singing, then record your attempt lipping to that first recording :) .
You are correct, as just you can't proof it's not lipsync simply because there was rehearsal either. From a logical debate standpoint, this is called an impasse. In other words, rehearsal (or the absent of it) is not a valid indicator to conclude whether or not someone lip sync or not.
True... Lipsync mostly playback from the singer's song. So they know exactly the song. So rehearsal just for koreo n stage blocking. Not check sound n singing..
But u miss a thing... When he said to the audiance after sing tht song... Did u notice tht the mic echo and sound similiar with the mic sound when he sang
Как дошли до этого? Уже людям не интересно наслаждаться его пением, а только волнуются фонограмма или нет. Как обидно, вы же все прекрасно знаете его способностей. Для тех, кто не знал, когда Димаш был на "I am singer", в его родном городе Актобе решили на одной радиостанции один день посвятить Димашу и каково было их удивление, коода они не нашли готовых записей, позвонили к его маме, на что она ответила никогда не было обходимости в этом, он всегда поет вживую. И они искали его песни с телевизионных записей. Прошу перевести это для иностранных слушателей. И не нужно просить реакционеров распознать фонограмма это или нет, скоро все превратится только в такой хайп.
Гугл перевод: How did they get there? Already people are not interested in enjoying his singing, but only worry about the phonogram or not. How insulting, you all know his abilities very well. For those who did not know when Dimash was on "I am singer", in his native city of Aktobe they decided to devote one day to one radio station to Dimash and what was their surprise when they did not find ready records, called his mom, on what she answered there was never a need for this, he always sings live. And they searched for his songs from television records.
Gracias por la información, se música y canto nivel bajo pero tengo buen oído y tempo, es fácil darse cuenta de la genuina voz de DImash, que para las competencias lo hace perfecto tanto que personas inescrupulosas inventan mentiras como que hace playback, no señores los que inventan no pueden aceptar que hay un ser humano que dedico su vida entera a perfeccionar su canto, el nació para cantar, desde los dos años ya participaba en eventos locales, quisiera que ya no se hable mas de ese tema, tratando de desprestigiar, nosotros hemos averiguado mucho a traves de los fan clubles mundiales , los kazajos y rusos, por eso estoy de acuerdo con Nurgul Ibrayeva. nuestro Dimash es auténtico le duela a quien le duela, el seguirá su camino lleno de éxito y su voz que tiene para ampliar mas su rango vocal, hará historia, he dicho.
How did they get there? Already people are not interested in enjoying his singing, but only worry about the phonogram or not. How insulting, you all know his abilities very well. For those who did not know when Dimash was on "I am singer", in his native city of Aktobe they decided to devote one day to one radio station to Dimash and what was their surprise when they did not find ready records, called his mom, on what she answered there was never a need for this, he always sings live. And they searched for his songs from television records.
Друзья, вам не кажется что некоторые реакционеры, такие как THE VOCAL LEXICON за счет Димаша стараются продвинуть свой канал? Какая вам разница, поет под фонограмму артист или вживую, если вы знаете, что этот артист может это спеть даже без микрофона? Я удивлена. Мне лично все равно, поет он под фонограмму или вживую. Он настоящий артист и Человек с большой буквы, несмотря на свой юный возраст. Это его голос и он не обманывает своих слушаталей, увеличивая свои головые данные. Он талант, признайте это и перестаньте пжл мусолить эту тему, это по меньшей мере оскорбительно. Уважайте труд Артиста!!!
Это больные люди. Это разновидность навязчивости. Вряд ли они могут справиться со своим состоянием. Наверно, нам придется сталкиваться с этим снова и снова. Им кажется, что это так естественно, петь под полную фонограмму, как принимать душ или бриться, и это для них просто веселое развлечение: определять, липсинг или нет, и обмениваться мнениями, какие песни или концерты еще липсинг, а какие нет. Они не понимают, что оскорбляют артиста. До них это не доходит, сколько не объясняй!
У этого реакционера еще есть видео где он сравнивает Ди с какой то певицей( имени не помню) кто лучше берет свистковые или головные ноты,не знаю как называются правильно.Вот тоже спрашивается для чего ?Ведь делал же раньше просто реакции ,хорошие,мне нравилось,теперь опустился ищет чего то,копается,сравнивает.Хайпит мужик ,я отписалась от него,надеюсь многие фаны Димаша так же сделают,и пусть находит себе подписчиков.В детектива решил поиграть.А главное эти записи тоже гуляют с репетиции везде вот их теперь будут всем сувать хейтеры.
вот ради эксперимента вогнала оба видео в программу, и там слышна разница сильно, даже не для русскоязычного; просто эмоциональная подача слегка разная, кое-где разные ноты. При том официальное заявление организаторов, что выступление было живое, - игнорируется. ну Адажио они конечно уже не могут так загнобить хоть какая то польза от криворуких звукорежиссеров
Готовьтесь - скоро таких видио будет валом. Если кто не в курсе, то в интернете работает целая армия фрилансеров, которая пишет "правильные отзывы", заливает "правильное видео" и делает массу иных не очень порядочных, но очень хорошо оплачиваемых вещей.
Лучший комментарий под этим "анализом" от Натальи Макаровой: "Под видео с прямым эфиром этого концерта на ютуб был расписан тайминг, с указанием имени артиста и как он будет петь (живьем или под фонограмму). Так вот, под фонограмму на вечере А-Студио пела только Алсу. Уважаемый вокальный тренер, не нужно искать подвохов там, где их нет. Как -то нелепо Вы выглядите при этом. К тому же, посмотрите видео с репетиции этой песни." Подписываюсь. Всего-то нужно зайти по ссылке и увидеть. Прямая трансляция творческого вечера группы A’STUDIO и 1-го конкурсного дня из концертного зала «New Wave Hall» в Олимпийском парке Сочи. ruclips.net/video/frvEkvoTz_k/видео.html Тайминг для удобства: 00:00:03 Последние приготовления 00:04:25 Прибытие членов жюри конкурса "Новая волна 2018" Директора МУЗ-ТВ Армана Давлетьярова, композитора Дмитриса Контопулоса 00:17:35 Отбивка "Новая волна" 00:19:04 Кети Топурия и A’STUDIO - Помни это (живьём) 00:23:00 Приветствие ведущих Тимура Родригеза и Байгали Серкебаева 00:26:50 Филипп Киркоров - Ночь-подруга (живьём) 00:35:40 Леонид Агутин и Tomas N’Evergreen - Джулия (живьём) 00:43:32 Интерактив для зрителей зала New Wave Hall от соведущих Сергея Демидова и Виктора Абрамяна 00:46:20 Алсу - Любовь-река (фонограмма) 00:52:53 Сергей Лазарев - Ещё люблю (живьём) 01:00:01 Alekseev - Сезон дождей (живьём) 01:05:15 Тимур Родригез - S.O.S. (живьём) 01:10:20 The Jigits - Нелюбимая, Солдат любви (живьём) 01:15:38 Юлианна Караулова - Стоп, ночь (живьём) 01:22:37 Димаш Кудайбергенов - Грешная страсть (живьём) 01:29:30 Благодарность спонсорам конкурса от ведущего Тимура Родригеза 01:31:20 Виктория Жук, Антон Беляев и группа Therr Maitz - Улетаю (живьём) 01:37:59 Кети Топурия и A’STUDIO - Fashion girl (живьём) 01:42:01 Интерактив для зрителей зала New Wave Hall от соведущих Сергея Демидова и Виктора Абрамяна 01:44:35 A’STUDIO, Кети Топурия и все звёзды - Белая река (живьём) 01:47:00 Салют! 01:50:31 Благодарность спонсорам конкурса от ведущих Тимура Родригеза, Сергея Демидова и Виктора Абрамяна
Hi Frank..did you are last night performance Adagio???? You should watch..the mic was not working...no sound...and Anyway what was the point if all this ???? You are saying that he is not an amazing Singer , Unique and One of the best??? Because if you brought up this ...you just opened the door for the green of envy haters....You saw Dimash singing without a mic..and without any kind of effect..pitch PERFECT .. And is not that us... his fans can't take the fact that sometimes he is required to lyp sync...it is because of that people want to take his merits and put him down.. Lyp sync or not I want to see anyone daring to do a cover of one of Dimash song...
LOL you opened a can of worms with this one. But I know you did it because you believe it is true. As for me, I don't particularly care whether Dimash lipsynced at Sochi or at other venues. (Yeah, I'm a vocal ignoramus.) Because even if he does lipsync, he would only do it with material he has already sung in the studio. It's still Dimash. And his glorious transcendent crazy-awesome vocals. (Love ya, Dimash!) For the record, I believe he sang it LIVE.
First of all, I'd like to say that I love your React videos. Thank you Jang for your great work here.👍👍👍 ❤The song is just fantastic and phenomenal.❤ I also do not care if many say he's just lip sync. How many musicians sing like that and where it is just taken like that. We all know Dimash his performance and what he can show on stage. I'm from Germany and sometimes it's hard to understand the text. ❤ But if you can make Dimash feel his music and his voice, then it does not matter which language it is. The goose bumps are there and you just want to close your eyes and listen to the music.❤ And that's what makes Dimash fantastic, he can just enchant people for a brief moment when he sings. There is no day I am not here on RUclips to listen to Dimash and when I hear some songs two or three times. It's always awesome and I'm glad that Dimash is there and he shows how people can dream and forget all worries for a little while. Dimash you're the best, keep it up.❤❤❤ And please, watch the Video from Gloria Wu: [ENG SUB]Dimash PhantaCity
Here is ruclips.net/video/frvEkvoTz_k/видео.html the full version of this concert with timing. After the name of the singers write they sing live (живьем) or phonogram (фонограмма). 01:22:37 Димаш Кудайбергенов - Грешная страсть (живьём) (Dimash Kudaibergen - Sinful Passion (Live)) If the time is the same, this means that Dimash is working on every pause and breathing for the drama of the song. When Dimash sings S.O.S., he always makes a loud sigh at the end of the song. But we know, that it's live.
Why do we even bother finding out if it was lip synced? I believe Dimash would only sing live but this is not the point. Lip sync or not he’s the ONLY person who can ever sing this song the way it was presented! I don’t believe there’s another artist out there who can ever sing this song the way Dimash can! So if we all love Dimash, then we should stop the war now and just keep loving and supporting him no matter what! I know I will! ❤️
Thank you! Yes stopping the war seems like a good suggestion to me too. And yes no one can sing this song the way he did no matter what technological help they use
You are dead wrong this time...There is an official list of who sang live and who sang playback...and guess which group Dimash was...this list was printed before the actual performance that day...this was intended for sound engineers info only.....I also looked at Dimash's neck muscles, Adam's apple....as you should know if singer goes up in voice sound, the Adam's apple disappears or moves up ...check the video again...this is 100% live performance...end of discussion...
1.There are songs Dimash prefers not to change, like Adagio or Belovejskaya push'a. This is not enough to draw a conclusion it's a playback. Simply because there was a similar situation with 'Ocean over time'. Official MV for that song was suspiciously identical to its live version on a Great Chinese Wall, performed later same year. However, Chinese people heard substantial difference in pronunciation (Live 'Ocean over time' has in fact much better Chinese than the Official MV. This proved there was no lip sync. Besides, why would Dimash improvise on a newly arranged by Erlan Bekchurin (he arranged all Dimash's songs for Singer 2017) song like this, if he had never sung it in public before? 2. This is the first time Dimash 'sets foot' on a big stage of Russia. He was invited by a producer of that "New Wave" contest, a respectable maestro, composer, Mr I.Krutoi, meaning basically the official recognition of Dimash by the Russian music industry moguls. 3. Under the official full A-Studio music band evening RUclips video there is timing of each singer with a note whether this singer performs live or not. Only once famous singer Alsu was reported (not live). FYI: famous A-Studio music band originated in Almaty (Kazakhstan). Pianist Baigali Serkebaev is a composer of this song's original.
For those curious to see the graphical representation form: ruclips.net/video/iT4A2PVzVFc/видео.html ( Dimash - Sinful Passion - Sochi - Audio Comparison of Rehearsal and Fancam ).
There are videos of him singing at little gatherings. Which proves how great he is. Singing in a big space , its essential to have reverb ,especially reflective reverb.
Could you please react to his performance for Adagio at the same venue (Sochi) where his mic was having technical issue and tell us if he lip sync????DKIFC/SG
@@lailanis1 it's not true. There are differences between the rehearsal and the performance. Someone did a REAL comparison that went really in depth and there were many differences. In timing, melody, pronunciation etc. They're small, but they're there.
Hey Frank, you know I love you so much but this is very romantic song and he always show us his breathes, so when you sing a song you must know where you will breath or not :) Just my opinion but you judged him so quick I guess :) He can do lip sync of course, but its not neccessary, he has a violin in his cords haha :)
Well now you put your foot in your mouth....Do you not realize by now, that there are people who start these rumors because they are anti-fans or just malevolent....It is so very difficult for these people to recognize that Dimash is as good as he is...If they (or the person they are a fan of) can't be that good, Dimash must be cheating....You will notice from our Russian Dears..that they could tell the difference... Sorry to say, you should have left this one alone.....
Take the Lip Synching rumors and shove it....we all know he sings live and he can sing identical...he didn't from the rehearsal to the performance...he changed the end....so sick of this....this is not the reason I came here...I came for your reaction...not whether or not to prove someone one right or wrong...Bye....
Watch at 2:58 in the show, you can see his tongue flutter while holding a note with vibrato. If he was really lip syncing, I don't believe that would happen. Also wouldn't his larynx basically stay in the same position during the song if he was lip syncing ??
*IN A PERFOMANCE IN CHINA(LAST YEAR) HE WAS WITH COLD,BUT HE WANTED SO MUCH SING THAT HE'S WAS SWEATING,HE WAS PALE,IT'S SAD TO SEE THAT PERFORMANCE,IN SOME PARTS...HE ALMOST GAVE UP BUUUUT...HE SING LIVE...AND THIS IS NOT HEALTHY!I THOUGHT THAT HE WOULD PASS OUT THERE!SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO IF HIM DO LIP SYNC ON DAY...SO WHAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAT??IF ONE SINGER DO LIP SYNC ONE DAY...WHAT??*
almost a lifetime of dimash was spent just to practice singing, even he went through his childhood just to practice singing and learning musical instruments ... after all his hard work from children until now, and now he has become a great singer, very clear lip syncing is not an option for him ... you who say dimash is 8 wonders of the world, why now you doubt the ability to sing above the reach of other singers? it is very ironic that you declare something that cannot be proven accurately, even your statement can harm your reputation and dimash credibility ... sorry you should not judge others only from your point of view, which is not necessarily the truth ...
In the grand scheme of things does it really matter if he lip synchs? It is still his voice, It is not changed. A true dear knows he can sing like that live. And a true dear would think no less of him. Go Dimash!!
What kind of nonsense did I just see? I looked through almost all of Dimash's performances, and the only one where he sang with a phonogram was his performance at the opening of the Universiade.
Exacting a specific way to sing is the mark of a professional. A singer, dancer, athlete, laborer, etc. that are great at what they do have a "down pat" way of execution of their task. It is muscle memory. A game plan. Can you imagine expecting dancers to change up their count, go on 3 instead of 4 this time or an infielder's precise movement needed for a successful double play. My father/coach worked our infield until it was second nature. Backlash is hard to take but things grow and evolve when there is friction and if processed in a positive way can produce a pearl such as a grain of sand and a oyster.
Seriously who gives a fuk ? He doesn't have to prove himself anymore and he will always be one of the greatest and most gifted performer of my Z generation. I have learnt to accept that Dimash will always have the same ole same ole group of haters trolling , disseminating each and very one of his performances no matter how good he performed. A true fan will cherish and support him no matter what, till time immemorial. God Bless Dimash Kudaibergen !
PROOF THAT HE DOESNT LIPSYNC THIS PARTICULAR PERFORMANCE : ruclips.net/video/iT4A2PVzVFc/видео.html Pay attention closely to the red and purple lines... the peaks... the thickness of the lines... etc if he lipsynced those red and purple lines would look EXACTLY the same. It is even so clear in 4.45 to 5.00. So different!! 😉😉
What are you talking about!!! How can you make such statement based on your opinion...just because the timimg is close does not make him lip sync...is it NOT POSSIBLE that he is so good that he can replicate the timing almost identical??? just because you or anyone else have not seen it done by another singer does not mean it can not be done...same idea that just because we have not heard anyone that can sing the range that Dimash can do...then we say it is not real...come on guys...lets not make statements UNLESS you can prove it 200% based on facts rather than based on your opnion and own analysis !!! I am truly disppointed in your statement in your video....I use to enjoy very much on your reaction but this is just not right !!!! How can you count manually with your fingers and call it scientific conclusion...come on really....???
He would rather not sing or pretend to sing，because he strictly demands himself, his rehearsal will be the same as the live.But if you listen carefully, you will hear many different details.
So this has been bothering me, i tried to sync both performance as much as i could, you can ear that they overlap perfectly, ergo they're a recording. Check it out for yourselves: www.youtubemultiplier.com/5c05b4b407587-sound-comparison-dimash.php
Hi there I thought that was what you meant, just need to hear your confirmation ... this half arse wannabe vocal coach needs to take back what he said here.. thanks darl :)
You see, his fans can eat you alive when you say something slightly bad about Dimash. But it's up to you, to tell the truth and be hated or just pretending that dimash isn't faking his singing as everyone else to get likes and views
This performance was part of 2 hours concert tribute to the 30th anniversary of A-Studio group. It is Kazakh/Russian group based in Moscow. All Russian pop stars, including Dimash, performed covers of this group songs. Below is the link to the entire concert put out by the person affiliated with this festival. In the first post he put the list and timing of each performer and also put in the brackets if the performance was live or recorded. It is in Russian and I don't want to translate the full list because it is only contains time and names of the singers and indication (live or recorded). My point is Dimas is listed as a "live performance". Also comparing 2 videos, on the rehearsal Dimash sings longer the run at the end, in the live performance he cut it short, although music continued. Because it is mix concert with about 13 performers I can assume it might be per-recorded in order not to interrupt the flow of the concert, but most likely Dimash sang over that record, otherwise concert organizers would not call it live performance. Nevertheless, I respect your opinion Dear The Vocal Lexicon! Thanks for the honesty.
One more point, this is one of the most viewed music festival/ contest in Russia held annually in city of Sochi. It includes performances by famous and established pop stars and the song contest of the new singers. Most audience is more interested in the star's performances rather than contestants. Dimash was not contestant but invited as a guest performer like other Russian pop stars. Dimash is not known to the Russian audience, therefore, again he had to do a showcase to demonstrate all his vocal abilities and range and impress Russians. It was the first time for him to perform before the large Russian audience. It would be strange if he did lip syncing while trying to introduce himself and prove himself before the large Russian audience that watched him not only in Sochi city but on the major Russian TV. Russian media would immediately call him baloney, if he lip sang, none Russian media did.
I am not expert in sound and stuff. But at the end of the rehearsal you can see man in shock. It is sort of director/producer of the show. Why to be shocked if he is not live. At the end of the actual performance there is a man giving standing ovation. It is executive producer. Again why would he bother if Dimash wasn't singing live. BTW, it was like 3 hour show and Dimash only one who got standing o from him. Must be sign
iam not gonna even finish ur vedio to say this sir " Dimash never did nor will he ever lip synch or auto tone etc etc etc " READ MY LIPS !! 😊 i rest my case ☺️ hello ? seriously ? how dare ... this guy is a legend on his own !! people just cnt accept the fact that Dimash can do only what he can do !!!! duhhhh shame on those who do accuse such !!!
And too...Even if a single chance he was.....ummmm he still sang just like that..in rehearsel....no added crap....to begin with soooooo.....ummm lip syncing to his master piece that he literallly did hours before...does it reallly matter. But people will alwaysss try to put down someone who is perfect no matter what...always someone negative....but back to dimash.....watch his throat...his mouth....his lips.... Listen to e act sounds n words I relistened to this etc.....and i clearly hear the difference so i dont believe he did. Hes proven to us time and time and time again hes a perfect live singer no fakeness about his talent and abilities
I wondered if it was lip synced this time, as so many similarities and the music track was largely recorded anyway in my opinion. But I think his body language shows live singing. I always look at his eyebrows strangely enough, as his face is so expressive. 😌😩However, I don't think it takes anything away from him if he synced. He's still on the way to becoming a LEGEND! Thank you for clarifying points raised 🙏🏻💐
Regardless if it's live or recording... I doubt D lipsync but instead sang with the recordings in this performance.. and to make the same sound and effect above the recordings at the precise timing is commendable.. Thus, I believed he sang live but over the recording (as there are fans who went to watch the show live) which is fine as well.. still loving those notes coming from him..
Great analysis! I KNOW! It's difficult to determine if he is lip synching or not. When I was in choirs, back in the day before computers, I remember being rehearsed and rehearsed and rehearsed to practically identical perfection...particularly with where the breath will be and how much it is to be enunciated or accented to pace the song and to afford a breath off phrase. I think it's more the actual hearing of Dimash's breath is deliberate as part of the feeling of the song "Sinful Passion". The gasping breath of passion. Therefore, it would occur perfectly at the same time. His words are deliberately breathed in a gasp and a whispered breath--as if close to a lover's ear--nearly throughout the entire song. During all of his videos, I watch Dimash breathe. He has so many technical approaches to breathing. I'm most impressed with the ones that look like he's breathing clear to the bottom of his feet (and they're silent to the mic). That's when he really sustains a note/riffs/phrases. I'd say his breathing mastery is the foundation to his singing...along with instantly shaping his vocal cords in any position.
для русскоязычных он говорит и делает вывод на основе своего анализа что Димаш спел под фанеру. но я как то не очень доверяю "специалисту" сидящему на табуретке на фоне стены окрашенной дешевой краской.
Я не слышу разницы в акценте. Прослушала обе версии 976677 раз. Это однозначно плюсовка. Хотя , какая разница. На закрытии он всем показал, на что способен,несмотря на бардак со звуком.
Mister coach are you really a professional? You had 100 arguments/proofs to show that he is singing live and 1 very weak argument that goes against it and you used it to conclude this? Furthermore, producing the same sound and breath is not an argument ,in Dimash's case especially he is classically trained , you know what it means and a perfectionist on top of that, with rare musical qualities you have already highlighted yourself in your previous videos. Any person who has minimum knowledge in singing should know that It is NOT impossible for a singer to produce the exact same sounds. You know Dimash isn't just any singer... Why haven't you taken account of those for your analysis here? You know how important the words of a person of influence like you have but you neglected that, you didn't go till the end of the analysis and did't mention all the factors and actors and all the other possibilities .... which in my eyes showcases your lack of professionalism ..really disappointing. I am not offended by your final" judgement", that is your opinion and im fine with it but the process towards that judgement is to blame indeed. There are many close up fancams of this performances , you may want to watch them .. who knows, maybe you have accused somebody wrongly and lead others to believe on falsehood with this influence of yours and you would like to clear up things someday...
yeah... his analysis isn't satisfying... Dimash is already trained... He know perfectly the timing for his singing... and this analysis of him lip sync is based on wrong knowledge. I wonder if this person is actually a vocal coach or just a self-claim one.
Funny analysis and what you say is not true 😊in reality this is a live performance , As being Russian I clearly see the difference between words and his pronunciation especially give me , (For foreigners if you knew Russian language you will understand the difference)since for Dimash Russian is second language this difference is obvious , the fans were on his repetition I believe in words and reviews of people who saw him live ☺️and not people from the screen . And as many says Our Russian genius composer Igor Krutoi invited Dimash on this event and he wouldn’t give standing ovations for lip synce, you didn’t saw his adagio rehearsal , it’s interesting for me will you claim that his adagio rehearsal lip sync too ?😊 because it’s obvious live , don’t know why you bring this lies on your channel ? Enjoy his singing instead of spreading rumors . Unsubscribed , i don’t want to watch Rumors Отписывапюсь не хочу слушать Сплетника для меня он умер как реакционер, ну а вокальным коучем и подавно никогда не был (кто он ?? человек по ту сторону экрана) Я верю людям, которые сидели в метрах от Димаша на репетиции и сказали ,что это живое выступление, ну а репетиция адажио доказала, что Димаш поёт в живую! Зачем полез с этой темой , зависть пробилась? или продвинуть свой канал? одного индийского реакционера нам уже хватило он потом угрозами и обвинениями в Димаша сыпал , всякий бред про таблетки писал, угрожал что что-то там распространит - ужас!. Нет уж хватит.
It is very unnecessary to make a video about the use of technologies in the songs that Dimash interprets (my clear opinion), we know that today it is impossible to escape from this technology, even for Dimash. Even though I'm so lazy in music, I know a singer can not always sing live. However, this does not diminish at all the charm that this young Kazakh talent has shown to the world's quantum. Here in Brazil there are singers who start singing well from day to night ... that's a shame and a lie. But Dimash no, he is an eighth wonder of the world. Long live at Dimash.
DID DIMASH Lip Synch LIKE SOME SAY? I Do Not Attempt To Watch This Video For Obvious Reasons. I am my own judge of what I see and hear in a performance and certainly do not rely on 'some say doubters' and, particularly from a vocal coach's perspective, he should not rely on 'some say doubters' which this seems the case to verify an opinion. This kind of posts can only court controversy. Miracle: An event described by those to whom it was told, by somebody who didn’t see it.
Sir,you must look Dimash sing sinfull passion from fancam The Pearl of Dimash Hongkong Fan Club.it makes me 100% Dimash performance live.not lipsync.please u react.
Ребята, не верьте очередному "разоблачителю". Димаш поёт в живую. Это на 100%. Под фанеру он пел только на открытии Универсиады в дуэте с Зариной Алтынбаевой (надеюсь, правильно написал), во всех остальных выступлениях - только живой голос. Да и подстава (или лажа) с микрофоном во время исполнения песни "Адажио" 9 сентября на "Новой волне" вполне доказывает то, что никакой фонограммы там и не было. Товарищ мог бы проверить ту дезу, которую он решил здесь ретранслировать. Диз ему за это.
You really should make some research before posting your opinion based on absolutely nothing relevant. Lots of coments already stated why Dimash DIDN'T lip sync but I'll give you one more: The member of the band and the composer of this song (the pianist) was there and I really don't think they would do it. No way. Besides, have a look at how he moves his body, when he wets his mouth and how he opens it as well. Not to mention his Adam Aple.
He may used lip synch ... I*m not sure. But if its the case, I dont mind.. cause its his voice and he have a great talent. He is the BEST! Tanks for you reaction, you do a great job!
COACH .......We ....we Are DON'T CARE....what Other People Think ABOUT DIMASH......MILLIONS PEOPLE OUT THERE .....LOVE DIMASH ......WHY YOU'RE WAITED YOUR TIME FOR THOSE PEOPLE ....THEY'RE DON'T KNOW WHAT THE MUSIC ARE ....COMON..IT 'S FOR REAL???🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔
Lipsync didn't need rehearsal n checksound, didn't need to check out the mic. It is pre recorded so you don't have to sing just learn your koreo n stage blocking. The most that everyone forget it was the feel. He got the feel better than his rehearsal. When he sang that forest song at vitebsk, wow amaxing Improvisation you know he did exactly the same part at 2016 already.. Actually it is not difficult to See the differences between singing and pretended to sing. Idol group's lover must expert about this.. Why don't we Analyze he was lipsync or not in his MV?
Вот, под этим видео автор пишет, кто как поет. Некоторые - под фонограмму. А Димаш - "живьем", как автор изволит выражаться. Новая Волна 2018. Полная версия HD (05.09.2018). Творческий вечер группы A’STUDIO. ruclips.net/video/frvEkvoTz_k/видео.html
Disappointing. and insulting not only towards Dimash's hard work but also to all those professionals who met him and saw him live and acknowledged him. Now what are you doing? With a limited knowledge, making claims, starting rumors.. I suggest you to learn more about singing first because one never has total knowledge, there is always more to discover and two, about Dimash ,before making ANY claim, he isn't just a voice or a singer. His sensitivity and comprehension of music is far more advanced than you think. Many senior singing teachers and other respected professionals said that he is a musical genuis, that they see him as equal and some seniors even said he was superior to them. Honeslty sir do review yourself please. Do watch other fancams of this song,you will see that your argument about the same breath and same sound isn't even an argument, Dimash masters breathy singing, he is pitch perfect, he has perfect control over his whole instrument in its tiniest details. Disclaimer ; im absolutely not offended when lip-sync and playback and autotuned is used. But when it's not it's just not. no matter people's different opinion. There is only one truth and there is no point in debating about the truth
You answered your own disclaimer with another disclaimer. Lol Again, he only showed the perfectly played backtrack that was used and it was obvious. Can Dimash sing? No doubt. Can artists lipsync and get caught? They do! I mean look at the Mariah and she still sound the same whether its "live" or from her decades old recordings. LOL
C A obvious? Don't think so, since there is a process to follow to be able to judge whether a singer lip syncs or not, and even with that one can't guarantee at 100% that judgement will be correct if it's based on a audio recording. To make sure, you should 1) be at the live concert 2) have educated ears and eyes ( 3)ask for mic's audio )
What to argue, if there is reliable information? Whoever wanted, found and saw. ruclips.net/video/frvEkvoTz_k/видео.html Live broadcast of the creative evening of A'STUDIO and the 1st day of the contest from the concert hall "New Wave Hall" in the Olympic Park in Sochi. Timing for convenience: 00:00:03 Last preparations 00:04:25 Arrival of members of the jury of the contest "New Wave 2018" Director of MUS-TV Arman Davletyarov, composer Dmitry Kontopoulos 00:17:35 The "New Wave" 00:19:04 Keti Topuria and A'STUDIO - Remember this (live) 00:23:00 Greeting of the leading Timur Rodriguez and Baigali Serkebaev 00:26:50 Philip Kirkorov - Night-girlfriend (live) 00:35:40 Leonid Agutin and Tomas N'Evergreen - Julia (live) 00:43:32 Interactive for the spectators of the New Wave Hall from co-host Sergey Demidov and Victor Abramyan Alsu - Love-river (soundtrack) 00:52:53 Sergey Lazarev - I also love you (live) 01:00:01 Alekseev - The rainy season (live) 01:05:15 Timur Rodriguez - S.O.S. (live) 01:10:20 The Jigits - Unloved, The Soldier of Love (live) 01:15:38 Julianna Karaulova - Stop, the night (live) 01:22:37 Dimash Kudaibergenov - Sinful passion (live) 01:29:30 Gratitude to the sponsors of the contest from the host Timur Rodriguez 01:31:20 Victoria Zhuk, Anton Belyaev and the band Therr Maitz - Fly away (live) 01:37:59 Keti Topuria and A'STUDIO - Fashion girl (live) 01:42:01 Interactive for spectators of the New Wave Hall from co-host Sergey Demidov and Victor Abramyan 01:44:35 A'STUDIO, Keti Topuria and all the stars - White River (live) 01:47:00 Salute! 01:50:31 Gratitude to the sponsors of the contest from leading Timur Rodriguez, Sergey Demidov and Victor Abrahamyan
Hi, there is timing list of A'studio evening, according to it, only Alsu used Lip-sing, of course, it just timing, you can not believe it, but officialy, he sang live. And I liked your video! It great, that you actually tried to analyse this issue, thinking is always better than blind love.
as much as I respect WWrahmania also known as ME ntertainment the only things she got rid of was the comments who said anything that could ruin her evidence she is just like many of the ppl who disliked this video one sided also rehearsals don't mean nothing he could have 2 different studio version 1 for rehearsal 1 for the official performance its like his old unforgettable day song he has 2 versions that sounds exactly the same but 1 of them has an extra run
just started thinking about it but I also believe she might have blocked me so no one can see my comments if that's true then shes definitely one of those one sided fans because I have never ever said anything that would get me blocked I don't swear in this community everything I say I always back it up with why Dimash might have done it and always find a good reason why he would lipsync and im not one of those ppl who say he cant sing which is obviously not true I believe he will take over the world with his voice
even the performances that i believe are lipsynced give me goosebumps believe me you are right i would faint but im just giving you explanations and i even have 3 lipsync fail + playback fail videos and 1 of them was hard to find which might be proof to tell you that rehearsal fancams and moving larynx and being their in person means nothing at all it could still be lipsynced :) Vitas lipsyncs also very common in Russia just like Kazakhstan and hes no where near as good at lipsyncing as Dimash and he got away with it for 15+ years and ppl still believe he doesn't lipsync
I could care less what jealous salty people say. 1. He is clearly gifted, one among billions, to have natural talent, willpower and privilege to train since he was 5 yo 2. Now that we agree that he is one of so many, we have to accept the fact that for the accusation of lypsinc to work, he has to sing that song perfectly beforehand. Next, what makes people think that while for others it's impossible to have the same breathe during singing, it's extremely possible for him? Especially when we know that he clearly can control his breath perfectly (the screams, the whistle tone and all). He managed to be able to do things that nobody in the world thought to be possible, and yet, he did.
Незнаю , всегда мы с супругой смотрели его реакции.Если ,честно из за Димаша! Если он так оскорбляет Димаша! Надо,просто он него отписаться ХОРОМ! и он поймет,что сделал ошибку!
I like u lex but will not waste my time with this cuz why would he lip sync when he is taking over the world besides adagio In closing ceremonies was just as live! If I believed everyone about lip syncing he would never sing a song live cuz it has been said about hello, songs on singer every song so who actually sings for dimashi! This is just jealous rumors!
Don´t forget the intimate airport interview- ``He (Dimash) said that he has a pretty normal attitude to criticism. And he feels very bad when his fans attack any kind of criticism expressed towards him turning it all to a horrible experience. He worries about that a lot and considers this kind of behavior unworthy.´´ Some parts of this comment section looks very close to a horrible experience to me. We´re not helping him at all. Frank was respectful and I get this feeling that Di wouldn´t like all this unpleasantness. Some comments are very respectful while others, sadly, are not.
isabel fahlen there is a difference between cticism and accusations. Mind you Dimash's team ALWAYS cleared up any false accusations towards them that were a threat to his integrity and career. You are not helping him either by accusing him of lipsync you know ? Don't use Dimash's honest words to defend blameworthy things. Why should one be able to criticize others and others no be able to criticize that person? Stop hypocrisy please...
I have not shared my opinion on this matter anywhere because I realize how many things I´m ignorant of. I love and respect my Di, I would never EVER accuse him of anything in public. Where did I write he lip-syncs? Nowhere. And I´m not defending anyone, just stating what I observe. Di always behaves politely and respectfully, some of these comments are not. But as you say, if his team always clears up false accusations, then how on earth can all these angry comments be of any further help for him? From what I see some haters only use them as fuel for their fire, saying we´re crazy fanatics. We all know too little, Di and his team with the proper knowledge will take care of it in the proper way.
isabel fahlen what do you mean??? Nobody cares about what haters say neither does Dimash. I said Dimash's team clear up the matters that aims to destroy his reputation and career cause it is illegal in the first place and things can end up at court. Stupid haters will always find bad things to say no matter what even turning good things into bad. That's why we don't care. But seeing bad things said among the fans is more shameful and protecting "fans" that say bad things using Dimash's speech instead of denouncing them isn't ok either !
I will NOT protect ``fans´´ who say bad things about him. Never. Stupid haters will always find bad things to say no matter what, whatever comments we write to try and defend him they will inevitably turn to their own advantage, accusing us of ``blind ignorant fan-girling´´. That´s why I´m not comfortable either when dears discuss matters like these in public forums like youtube. I seriously worry about him. I agree that not saying anything is bad, but some comments here are worse than not saying anything at all. This video has now been published (nothing I can do about it) and I´m trying to think rationally what respons from us will benefit Di the most, and I´m not sure denouncing accusers in this manner will have any profitable impact. It won´t change the minds of haters, it won´t change the minds of dears who love him. It will just make us look (for want of a better word) a bit desperate to prove our point
What an interesting analysis! Thank you, Frank! I consider myself a big fan of Dimash and I'm not shocked if he didn't sing live. Like you said musicians have lots of reasons to lip sync, so I believe they did it for his best. And.. We all know what he is capable of! :)
Fr PHILIPPINES the end part of the rehearsal is different from the actual.. so you mean to say, the accompaniment or the orchestra were just joking there.. or a drawing? Seems youre using dimash for your channel.. “little learning is dangerous” this is you..that event was a prestigious one. I dont think so the organizers will allow such kind..
In my opinion if it was a lip sync, then at least it should be known to the organizers, sound specialists. If this were true, they would be the first to tell it to the whole world.
For a 2 hours plus concert, I'm okay if the singer lip-sync 1 or 2 songs since they have to protect their voice. But not the whole concert through. But recording or not, he is still the one singing. Listened to him live and recorded, I'm okay either or since he can actually sings. 👌👌
Dear sir, I'm so disappointed in you 😔😔 I thought you can be more professional in analyzing. I thought you know that there are a lot of things that need to be taken into consideration to prove a lipsync. 😥😥😥 You let someone got into your head and you made a video using her method. That's not fair!! You are a vocal coach. I expect better from you. I thought you will be analyzing his mouth, jaw, tongue, reverb, etc. But counting? 😧😧 You are not an amateur but why does your argument so amateurish?? Just saying. I hope you read all the comments here and think about a lot of things. You have done well in ruining someone's reputation. I'm not saying he has never done a lipsync (he did it in KZ when he was young and there was a universiade performance), but to accuse a 100% LIVE performance of lipsync... 😡 He has worked hard for this, to achieve perfection, and you just slapped him on the face with this video!! 😔😔 all his efforts have gone to the gutter. Great!!
I would like to mention that the individual who claimed that he was lip syncing based his comment upon listening to his rehearsal of this song and in parallel listening to his live performance claiming that they are precisely the same in every aspect, for me it does not diminish anything from our great Dimash but your opinion would be interesting, thank you
So what you're saying is..... you rehearse to then sound different during the live show? Never heard of this. When I had my band and we rehearsed we played it and I sang exactly the same during the live performance. Only if I was sick or had a bad day would I sound different, but other than that, you rehearse for a reason dude. If he did lip sync then it is what it is, but you sound extremely confident that this was a fake performance, interesting , from someone that has seen him soooo many times. Dimash even said it , he doesnt like to lip sync.
![Dimash Kudaibergen - 'Adagio' & 'Sinful passion' both live and lip-sync comparison [New wave 2018]](/img/1.gif)
Dimash is a Rarity!
It's a God given gift and, secondly, it's human's hard work along with dedication.
A gift because Dimash has longer vocal cords (interview of a vocal coach Emre Echelen with Dimash) and a perfect pitch (interview of his grandmother Miua who took him the first time to a music school at the age of 5).
A hard work and dedication because Dimash (from his various interviews):
- does not smoke or drink alcohol,
- does not eat spicy foods/drink fizzy drinks much,
- went to the night clubs only 2-3 times in his life (too noisy; loud music unpleasantly hits his ears drums),
- surrounded by friends and family with music background
- studying music and singing from the age of 5 (overall 20 years of his life out of 24 were devoted to vocal/music training), including:
- 7 years in music school (piano, choir, solfeggio, music literature/history, etc.),
- 3 years in Zhubanov music college,
- 3-4 years in Shabyt University of Arts.
- his mother is a professional singer (currently a lead (soloist) in a folk ensemble of Aktobe)
- Dimash citation: 'Almost every day I spend 2-3 hours on vocal training only. Of course I have some days I am not feeling inspired, although I am not kind of person who rests 3 days to work just a day'.
- He won numerous local and international awards
- Many respectable, professional , well-known in the music industry pop and opera singers, composers, musicians from different parts of the world acknowledged him, amongst them head of Astana opera (who sang in La Scala) Maira Muhammed kyzy, Safina (Italian tenor), Albano (Italian singer), Lara Fabian, so on. Head of Chinese pop using industry said Dimash has super human abilities.
Yet, people say Dimash lip sinc.
Let's try to identify these people: Online vocal coaches/online singers?! Do we know them? Do they have diplomas in those fields? Have we heard of their students?
I tend to think Dimash improvises every time just because of certain mood at a time, or adjusting his voice if he's unwell, or gets excited by cheers his Dears give him.
It came across my mind that he may do it because he gets upset that all his hard work gets blames in lip sinc.
The path he has chosen is extremely hard.
He is a such Rarity that people question his insane vocal abilities and trying to diminish his range, technique or emotional delivery.
Or simply stating it's a playback, lip sinc, voice editing, post-production, etc.
nice analysis.
its lip sync
He just way too good, almost unbelieveably perfect at his singing/performance that people threw lipsync accusation at him :v well, even if you're near perfect you still can't please everyone apparently. Human will always be unsatisfied :/
dimash sucks, he lip syncs cuz his can't pronounce english language songs.
I'm very glad for the technical problems to the next song...Adagio...he proved that he is not lip sinch...Dimash is an unbelievable singer..out of this world my friend...he is just the best.
In this version of Adagio he sreams a lot and he strains. Great screamer! hahaha
Another idiot that has no clue about singing, but follows Dimash's wonderful talent. Why? Because you've never heard anyone sing like this. Idiot.
you will be surprised, but this is a live performance. Music in the recording, backing vocals in the recording, and Dimash live. The organizers of the concert posted information about this. Plus, for the native speaker of the Russian language, some nuances of his pronunciation are clearly audible. As for breathing, Dimash perfectly controls it, since from childhood he is engaged in swimming, besides he studied classical opera singing, where a lot of time is devoted to the ability to work with breathing.
Anastasia, can you tell where exactly the organizers posted this information? It's very important.
ruclips.net/video/frvEkvoTz_k/видео.html
its russian.... no subs..... so... how are we supposed to understand?
its lip sync
Yeah sorry it is very clearly lip synced, you can’t have the exact same breaths in the exact same spots and the exact same tone with no differences whatsoever and it not be lip synced
Hi my friend, Dimash will never playback at his live show. I told u a truth about his refusing lip-synch in China. He caught a bad cold in January this year. At the same time he had to take part in two TV shows. One was a small award ceremony. The host told us that Dimash was very sick and the director advise him not to come. But Dimash appeared on the scene and sang acappella. Dears who were on the scene cried. It's hard to finish singing half a song but Dimash made an effort and asking for our forgiveness.The host told us that Dimash was too sick to sing. But he insisted on refusing to lip-synch.. ( The director had allowed him to do that because his very sick situation)
It’s not the end of the story. Dimash withdraw from the other program on the next day which was more important and well paid. The show would broadcast to the hold nation by a famous and important TV Channel. And the show was a Pre-recorded Show. Do u know what its meaning? A singer was allowed to playback if he had reasons to do that in an important show which was Pre-recored. But Dimash withdraw from the Pre-recording. He world rather lose money for breaking the contact of performance.
We have many fancom of the rehearsal and the formal performance. We can hear out the tiny different details at the last part of the song. We believed that Dimash didn’t playback on the live show.
We were told by Dimash's father that Dimash had to lip synch once When he was still young. All Of us know that.
bird night he has proud of singer. Due people jealousy n unfriendly he gain his strength n getting stronger. How amazing his vocal improvement now. He never stop learning.
and its the fcking internet. . if you search for anything you will find it ... search for some shit like is breathing air dealdy.. and you will find it ... so ofc they are searching for any shit .. especially when it goes about the best singer in the world
He do a lip synch in some tv shows that everyone do it. But never see he do it in live shows.
its lip sync
@@viniciusjesus2867 I didn’t think I would ever say this, but...Jesus? Shut up.
If you watched his rehearsal fully you must clearly see difference between of them. In rehearsal he sang the second part of the song in soprano but only two rows and other two rows was in baritone again, but in the A-studio concert he sang this part totally in soprano voice, also he sounded Russian words differently, because it’s not his native language
In which minute/part?
It was live, Frank 🤦♀️! I clearly hear the difference in the pronunciation of certain words! And check his arabic parts at the end, they are also different!
an umbrella yeah the Arabic style was even better in the sound check
It was lip synced, it’s not a bad thing idk why people are so quick to push back at it. It’s very clear it’s a lip sync cause even the finite details like the breathing in the same place with the same tone, it’s the same
I Worship Gays And Satan
You are unbelievable, commenting on multiple videos merely “saying” he’s lip syncing.. I don’t get how you can have a negative view towards the worlds greatest singer alive? Maybe to have ever lived, considering he perfectly sang the Diva Dance, with a male voice.
Like, did he do a cover better than your favorite singer could dream of? 😂
Actually, your username says it all. 🙄
I Worship Gays And Satan
And even if he did Lip Sync, I don’t care? ... he’s still the best voice this world has seen. Which is not just my opinion, but the belief of enough fans, vocal artists and judges to make it a fact.
Your opinion is your own, please keep it to yourself.
I Worship Gays And Satan
And so many Russian speakers have came out stating he is not lip syncing because they can easily notice the slight differences in his tone and voice. Which English speakers are not be able to spot. Yet you argue against it?
No
Dimash
Is
Perfect
😂😂 LoL
I remember one of a vocal coach in a reaction video said that even though a singer did a lip sync, they still have to record it with their voice. Technology can't make someone without technique suddenly becomes a great singer. Technology just to improve or to polish their voice. Well, I agree with him. Lip sync or not, it's still dimash who sing it. And he nailed it..
Seriously where do people think a recording came from?
He sang live dear...
ain't rite from heaven😂😂if they pre recorded before, why didn't they release it as a single? People are so funny
@@NanaNana-hb5hb Not all lip sync use the studio version of the song, especially if they want to record the "live" feeling to match the audio with the performer and with the stage. Different stage gives different acoustic characteristics, which may or may not match the studio version. For partial playback use, it's even more crucial to have authentic playback accompanying the live performance. Using studio version sometimes give unbalanced sound mix. Unless tested that using the studio version sound similar enough or be drowned by concert goers screams/claps/etc.
Great Music Dilettante I don't care about playback music. At least the vocal is live. .you better check whole video that night. 😊😊
I've read that A-Studio and Dimash haven't rehearsed together and that's why there are two tapes, one for A-Studio and one for Dimash. In concert they both sang and played live! Dimash is a perfectionist, he brings every detail to absolutism...he controls his voice in a way no one else can..I don't care if it was his rehearsal track or if he sang live. I'm happy to accept both. But I'm surprised how two little things made you so easily come to a such conclusion? And what about the movements of hands, body, head? They coincide very strongly! Even the hand movements captured by the camera separately are the same both on stage and in rehearsal..And besides, Dimash is a good swimmer, he controls breathing both as an opera singer and a swimmer! So your arguments didn't convince me at all...
I like that you accept him regardless if it's live or not. Same for me
As far as body gestures etc. You can still feel the song and move your body while it's playback. So that's not an argument.
Just accept its playback and be happy about it. If u want real proof that's its playback I can show you
Anis Berhil please do. I remember online vocal coach Tristan tried to provide Lip sinc/auto tune proof for SOS song at Singer 2017 on the computer software. He showed the software checks of the long straight note to prove it was auto tuned. However paused right before the vibrato should have come... proving otherwise.
@@assemkilybayeva7388 Tristan is crazy guy, he didn't prove anything. Anyone can easily realize sochi was a playback not by judging the song itself. I agree that dimash almost make it impossible to realize it's lip sync. I'm guessing he still sing but the recorded sound is so major compared to his voice.
Just open sochi performance on your computer. Open rehearsal video.a phone or different device. Try to play them with lot of trials and error until dimash start singing same time in both videos. Then you'll realize it's one sound coming from both devices. No change whatsoever!
Anis Bernhil, the song is very slow with an easy rhythm. Dimash's singing should coincide with pianist/composer of the original song (A-Studio) and other band members plus the playback music. So they have to be synchronized carefully. Please have a very close-up fancam from Galina Ul'anova: ruclips.net/video/DI5od3TbYQs/видео.html. You can clearly see his mouth, neck, chest movements when he breathes from a close distance. Please see in the comments someone named Анастасия Мау saying that organizers themselves published as "live performance". Thank you for your attention
Ps in addition, you can find my 3 arguments for this song performed live in the comment section. Cheers
We, Dimash' fans, accept him as he is. Even if he sings to the soundtrack, which he never does, it does not detract from his dignity. And your mistake is that you're trying to find something that can't be found . Because you hear and you work, you deal with ordinary people. But when you realize that he is unusual, that he is unique, his natural data plus his titanic work - it all brings Dimash to unattainable height. So you are saying that it is impossible at one and the same place to take a breath or exhale. He does it with a unique accuracy. That's when you understand his uniqueness and accept it, that's when you will not dig and look for what is not, but instead enjoy his unique singing. Personally, I'm absolutely not against if he sometimes uses the sound recording to save his voice, to protect the ligament... Because I want him to sing for a long time... And he works on wear and tear...Even at the closing of the Vitebsk festival, when all the singers were singing the final song to the soundtrack, Dimash was standing among them without a microphone and was just smiling, because he doesn't sing to the soundtrack.
Lip synced clear to hear 👂. Don’t mean he a bad singer. But agreed it was prerecorded
THE VOCAL LEXICON, if you are a vocal coach, you know how to perform a professional composition analysis to identify the use of the phonogram. What you told is funny, but not scientific. Dimash perfectly knows Russian, but easy accent vsetaki is. So the pronunciation at the rehearsal and at the concert does not always match. There are other differences ... I think, to determine the synchronization you need to use the appropriate hardware and software, and not guessing on the coffee grounds. I do not have anything against synchronization if necessary, but I against looking for synchronization where it does not exist.
Lika Falcon vsetaki 🤣👍
It's playback. Just admit it and be happy about it. I'm fan of dimash and like it knowing it's playback. What's wrong with you guys
Anis Berhil I wrote that the "analysis" on the video can not be proof. If there is a desire to prove, do it right or do not do it at all. You know something, I know something. But as long as we do not provide scientifically grounded arguments, people have the right to doubt. And have the right to believe in what they think is right.
I think you said more respectfully and better what I intended to say. I am with you on this.
Anis Berhil nothing wrong. it was live. Dimash’s dad said to director in the beginning (rehearsal): he’s gonna sing it first time, let’s give him time. And Mr.Revzin answered: yes, of course, but we don’t have any time
When the singer sings high notes, his larynx goes up, and the hole is formed in the throat under the larynx. Try to get the following effect when you're lipsyncing.
what are you talking about???? lip sync? people can't you just believe that Dimash is not just ordinary singer as you are he is a genius he can sing absolutely identical in rehearsal and live performance. he is capable. stop making rumors out of nowhere just to promote your channel.
No doubt Dimash is extraordinary. However, *generally speaking,* extraordinary and lip sync aren't mutually exclusive. Do I believe Dimash's extraordinary-ness extends to millisecond second timing? Maybe, but most likely not. Is it possible that's what happen here? Always.
Will finding out Dimash lipped here change me into liking Dimash less? Nope. Will finding out Dimash didn't lip here change me into liking Dimash more? Now that's impossible 😁 . I already crowned him the King. King, not God ;) .
I believe that Dimash is a precision singer fully capable of perfect timing in rehearsal and in concert, to the millisecond. The key to his vocal success is precision, it is everywhere in his songs. He pays attention to the most finite details in every aspect of the human voice and brings mastery to perfection. His dedication to precision is unequalled. I agree with Ulviya Rahimova.
Great Music Dilettante No one says that he is a God, but it is not right to drag someone's hard work through the mud just because you had an impression that he was lip syncing. That is all I wanted to say. Have a nice day
Peter Kinberger an expert said the rehearsal n live is different. Glysendo part longer at the rehearsal.
@@ulviyarahimova8452 Maybe you've never called him a god, but others have, or treat him like one, apparent by the way they comment, or even used verbatim the word "god". Granted, that behavior is not limited to just Dimash. All fandom seem to have a few of these, people who diefy the artist/actors/sport figures/politicians/etc. About that dragging mud thing, I don't think that was what TVL Frank did. He gave his honest analysis with zero bashing whatsoever. People who are offended by lip syncing still don't comprehend it's the very same artist who recorded the performance. They say they understand, but deep down they don't get it.
common, he is trained how to manage the breathing, however exactly the pronunciation shows these are two different live performances, the way he pronounce "daj mne" (give me) and further lyrics sounds very differently. But you can hear it only if russian is your mother tongue. Check some videos of his english lyrics performances, that would be more professional from your side
LANVEEN я тоже слышу разницу в произношении, особенно в слове зелье.
@@anumbrella8598 я не слышу никакой разницы в "зелье". Could you give me another moment to compare, cause I don't hear any difference? Maybe I was too fast with conclusions. I like Dimash. I don't care if it is just a playback. Everybody knows, that in Russia most of the shows are playback, and not because people cannot sing
first time in zelie в "зелье" sound L was very hard, very kazach style, while in second time L was more tender, but definitely strong accent - this is what makes 100% sure these both are different perfomances
@@LavendelGreen that's what happens when you love dimash blindly and don't wanna accept this is playback
I feel sorry for people who are like that. I love him too and have no problem knowing this is lip syncing
haha i do not love Dimash, i hate fake suggestions
I listened both rehearsal and actual performance over and over countlessly and I realized that some hard parts are too close or the same which might indicate lip-sync, but I also realized that some parts are different; at some points, pronunciations varies. I'm not professional, but the breath timing really proves lip-sync? he is a professional singer, not a kid to miss rhythm. another vocal coach, Emre Yücelen mentioned in his Unforgettable Day(Gakku) analyse video that his stage presence, mic holding position etc must be pre-prepared with exact these words: "he is not just a singer, he is a storyteller, a man on the street"; knowing that makes me think that "maybe", we know that this arrangement is totally different from the original A-Studio song, the additions, runs and also that breath to give effect/depth to the song "maybe" pre-prepared and I don't really get it why its timing should be different if there is a purpose to make that breath sound at that exact timing which also "suits rhythm", gives him a small break space etc. I'm neither professional nor amateur, I'm just a random guy on the planet and I don't really know too much about technical stuff, but I can't really understand how breath timing proves lip-sync. If you said that arabic motif part is lip-sync, yeah, I could understand that because it requires more energy, plus it's hard to do exactly the same way for the second time, but breath timing... :S you counted, 1-2-3-4, and that indicates rhythm, right? professional singers miss rhythm occasionally? :S breath timing seems more likely weak link to the lip-sync at best, instead of exact proof. :S
theres a possibility theres 2 versions 1 for the rehearsal and 1 for the actual official performance hes very smart but its not the first time a rehearsal has been off check out the very beginning of auld lang syne rehearsal he looks like he lipsynced slightly too late but theres a reason for that one is because the Chinese new year festival is the biggest event of the year so he was probably forced for his lack of mandarin and for this performance its also possible he was forced I have heard from other Dimash fans that its very common in Kazakhstan and Russia to lipsync but since he has got so popular he doesn't lipsync no where as much as before since he wasn't expecting to get popular so the only times he does lipsync is when forced mainly
Emre Yücelen é o melhor para analisar o cantor Dimash.... Amos as análises desse músico.
china banned lip-sync. it is forbidden and it is "crime". there are regulations and institutions that controls whether someone lip-sync. so, lip-sync in china is not very common. other effects can be used though, but not lip-sync.
lol yes but they get a fine they don't care they make a ton of money from them events a woman was caught in 2016 at the Chinese festival its really that common its only if you have a fail then they will get a fine and like I said that is worth nothing for them :D the woman even said she would do a better job lipsyncing next time
@@bullypunch8253 😂😂😂The lady's respond made me LOL 🤣🤣🤣 Thanks for that 👍👍👍. At the same time, it reminds me how investment bankers also practises the same way. They do unethical banking practises, mostly unnoticed, and when caught, even when fines are in the billions, that's a mere slap on the wrist as they've already made many, many folds of that for years. Now I'm bummed ☹ .
I love your channel and your vocal breakdowns and usually agree with you but this time I think you are overthinking things. I strongly believe Dimash didn't lipsynch on this and here's why. Yes, he is forced to lipsynch occasionally when he's performing a duet with someone, but even then he usually sings over his own recordings. However, this wasn't his only performance that day. They only had the monitors on at the beginning of his performance of Adagio and they had to turn up his microphone to the speakers because the audience couldn't hear him. It's definitely a live screw up. ruclips.net/video/3XcXMYiJx_I/видео.html
Dimash has perfect pitch along with his unbelievable vocal control. This is how he can sing a song several times and it sounds virtually identical. It is much like a pianist playing a piece of sheet music they have practiced a hundred times. They can make each performance sound identical because muscle memory comes into play and unless a conscious effort is made to alter a portion, the song will sound the same. I believe this is the reason Dimash has started performing every song he sings a little differently than in a previous performance because many people were saying that he had to be lipsynching for them sound the same every single time. I don't know of another singer who is capable of this so it is understandable that some people don't believe it is real. I just watched another vocal teacher talk about Dimash after seeing him live and meeting him in person. I think you would enjoy hearing what he has to say about Dimash's voice after hearing him live. It's very interesting! ruclips.net/video/wT8cow20K64/видео.html
Take care and keep up the good work! 😙💕
hi smylyface can I show you a video can you explain it ik you made a video about Dimash lipsyncing before and putting the rumours to rest but can I show you the video? also I do believe his adagio is live but the sinful passion might not be because its in Russian but since adagio is in English they don't care since there main audience only speaks Russian :) theres other times I believe he has lipsynced but on the same show he has also sung live for example is Slavic bazaar 2015 SOS is live blizzard again is live and daididau hes lipsyncing his old autotuned song watch the first 2 and then watch daididau then you will notice also if you like to have the link to the performance im talking about reply and I want to see how you explain it :)
BullyPunch A sound engineer put his rehearsal audio and performance audio through a computer to compare his vocals. They are similar but not the same. It was live.
yes ik that person its dilettante and he said quite the opposite if you check the comments also i have found a tugan zher performance which shows the autotuned runs he makes with his mouth maybe lipsynced basically he autotunes his runs and lipsyncs them very noticeable in his oy zhailau old performance and i think he used it in 1 of his song when he was around 13 he also used it in his daididau theres even an official video of it and you can tell it was overautotuned theres has been a video of a Chinese youtuber exposing his diva dance bastau where he does autotuned like runs there and its not the first time either but since he doesn't lipsync much anymore that's why he used a whistle there in his shenzen concert instead and in singer2017 was staccato i can show you the unforgettable day (i meant tugan zher im a lil tired lol) performance right now but i put in a separate comment or this message might not show up
ruclips.net/video/Ivquvf3CYf4/видео.html
you see the link? in that performance you can tell he was a lil bit too happy and wasn't concentrating much on his lipsinging and didn't put his mouth to the mic fast enough
This is official programme issued by organizers of the festive for each day... I am posting it for the first day for all those unbelievers who try to prove that Dimash sang soundtrack.
Live broadcast of the creative evening of a'STUDIO and the 1st day of the competition from the concert hall "New Wave Hall" in the Olympic Park of Sochi.
The timing for the convenience:
00: 00: 03 last preparations
00:04:25 Arrival of the members of the jury of the contest "New wave 2018" Director of MUZ-TV Arman Davletyarov, composer of Dimitris Kontopoulos
00:17:35 Weaning "New wave"
00:19:04 Keti Topuria and A'studio - Remember this (live)
00:23:00 Hello leading of Timur Rodriguez and Baigali Serkebayev
00:26:50 Philip Kirkorov - Night-girlfriend (live)
00:35:40 Leonid Agutin and Tomas N Evergreen - Julia (live)
00:43:32 Interactive for the audience hall of the New Wave Hall from co-host Sergei Demidov and Victor Abrahamian
00:46:20 Alsou - Love-the river (soundtrack)
00:52:53 Sergey Lazarev - Still in love (live)
01:00:01 Alekseev - the rainy Season (live)
01:05:15 Timur Rodriguez - S. O. S. (live)
01:10:20 The Jigits - Unloved, Soldier of love (live)
01:15:38 Julianna Karaulova - Stop the night (live)
01:22:37 Dimash Kudaibergenov - Sinful passion (live) !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
01: 29: 30 Thanks to the sponsors of the competition from the host Timur Rodriguez
01:31:20 Victoria Zhuk, Anton Belyaev and Therr Maitz band - Fly away (live)
01:37:59 Keti Topuria and A'studio - Fashion girl (live)
01:42:01 Interactive experience for the audience hall of the New Wave Hall from co-host Sergei Demidov and Victor Abrahamian
01:44:35 A STUDIO Keti Topuria and all the stars - White river (live)
01:47:00 fireworks!
01:50:31 Thanks to the sponsors of the competition from the world's leading Timur Rodriguez, Sergey Demidov and Victor Abrahamian
There's no bad thing about lip sync because whether it is lip sync or not.. it is his own voice so ..there is no big issue with that...
Exactly!
He sang live. It is big matter!
If you think that 2 LIVEs are almost the same is difficult? is lip-sync? I will say, you are wrong, this is very easy do it for Dimash.
I give you a example. You can look for < ocean over the time > on youtube, and compare to MV and LIVE Performance versions. I am sure you can't hear the difference between the two, Similarity is almost 99%. But for people who understand Chinese, I can fully know that he is LIVE Performance. Because his pronunciation is completely different in 2 versions.
As someone in the comment said, "Sinful Passion" He is LIVE, Because the pronunciation of rehearsals and performances 2 versions are completely different. I even can see his throat moving and changing, and blue veins appear in his throat. These are impossible to appear in lip-sync.
I won't say that he has never do a lip-sync, he has, but this is not what he can control, when he is required to do it. BUT, "Sinful Passion" performance is LIVE, I am only referring to the facts and the truth, no matter what you think.
芳芳 yes, I remember that performance at The Great Wall of China! 👍
@Just want the Best voiceWhen Dimash sang Ocean Over the time in live, He had known that It was the only chance for his dears to hearing the song. He gave us a perfect version with better pronunciation to review. He was over criticized by Chinese pronunciation before.
Oh, same in Russian. Different pronunciation is the key. And it is strange, that it helps him to make haters angry ))
🤦🏼♂️
Dears, can we please respect Dimash's wishes and not engage in arguments or try to prove something? We who love him know what his work ethic is. I honestly don't care what other people think. He speaks to my heart and my soul and that's enough for me.
Thank you! that´s what I´m trying to say. As I see it all this is not helping him
You're welcome, Isabel xx
May I ask, if lipsync, then why still needs to rehearsal before performance? For me I don't think it is lipsync. How you rehearsal (practice) to sing the song. Then when you go on stage perform the song of course will be the same.
To be able to successfully lipsync, you need to practice as well. It's so easy to screw it up.
@@TeaOnTue Very true. One can even argue, it takes more practice to perfect a lipped performance than actually sing live without worrying the exact9 millisecond you have to move your mouth, jaws, lips, etc. A simple yet fun exercise to proof that is to record your own singing, then record your attempt lipping to that first recording :) .
This can not proof it is lipsync.
You are correct, as just you can't proof it's not lipsync simply because there was rehearsal either. From a logical debate standpoint, this is called an impasse. In other words, rehearsal (or the absent of it) is not a valid indicator to conclude whether or not someone lip sync or not.
True... Lipsync mostly playback from the singer's song. So they know exactly the song. So rehearsal just for koreo n stage blocking. Not check sound n singing..
But u miss a thing... When he said to the audiance after sing tht song... Did u notice tht the mic echo and sound similiar with the mic sound when he sang
Как дошли до этого? Уже людям не интересно наслаждаться его пением, а только волнуются фонограмма или нет. Как обидно, вы же все прекрасно знаете его способностей. Для тех, кто не знал, когда Димаш был на "I am singer", в его родном городе Актобе решили на одной радиостанции один день посвятить Димашу и каково было их удивление, коода они не нашли готовых записей, позвонили к его маме, на что она ответила никогда не было обходимости в этом, он всегда поет вживую. И они искали его песни с телевизионных записей. Прошу перевести это для иностранных слушателей. И не нужно просить реакционеров распознать фонограмма это или нет, скоро все превратится только в такой хайп.
Гугл перевод: How did they get there? Already people are not interested in enjoying his singing, but only worry about the phonogram or not. How insulting, you all know his abilities very well. For those who did not know when Dimash was on "I am singer", in his native city of Aktobe they decided to devote one day to one radio station to Dimash and what was their surprise when they did not find ready records, called his mom, on what she answered there was never a need for this, he always sings live. And they searched for his songs from television records.
👍👍👍
мама же не может врать такого не бывает
Gracias por la información, se música y canto nivel bajo pero tengo buen oído y tempo, es fácil darse cuenta de la genuina voz de DImash, que para las competencias lo hace perfecto tanto que personas inescrupulosas inventan mentiras como que hace playback, no señores los que inventan no pueden aceptar que hay un ser humano que dedico su vida entera a perfeccionar su canto, el nació para cantar, desde los dos años ya participaba en eventos locales, quisiera que ya no se hable mas de ese tema, tratando de desprestigiar, nosotros hemos averiguado mucho a traves de los fan clubles mundiales , los kazajos y rusos, por eso estoy de acuerdo con Nurgul Ibrayeva. nuestro Dimash es auténtico le duela a quien le duela, el seguirá su camino lleno de éxito y su voz que tiene para ampliar mas su rango vocal, hará historia, he dicho.
How did they get there? Already people are not interested in enjoying his singing, but only worry about the phonogram or not. How insulting, you all know his abilities very well. For those who did not know when Dimash was on "I am singer", in his native city of Aktobe they decided to devote one day to one radio station to Dimash and what was their surprise when they did not find ready records, called his mom, on what she answered there was never a need for this, he always sings live. And they searched for his songs from television records.
Друзья, вам не кажется что некоторые реакционеры, такие как THE VOCAL LEXICON
за счет Димаша стараются продвинуть свой канал? Какая вам разница, поет под фонограмму артист или вживую, если вы знаете, что этот артист может это спеть даже без микрофона? Я удивлена. Мне лично все равно, поет он под фонограмму или вживую. Он настоящий артист и Человек с большой буквы, несмотря на свой юный возраст. Это его голос и он не обманывает своих слушаталей, увеличивая свои головые данные. Он талант, признайте это и перестаньте пжл мусолить эту тему, это по меньшей мере оскорбительно. Уважайте труд Артиста!!!
Это больные люди. Это разновидность навязчивости. Вряд ли они могут справиться со своим состоянием. Наверно, нам придется сталкиваться с этим снова и снова. Им кажется, что это так естественно, петь под полную фонограмму, как принимать душ или бриться, и это для них просто веселое развлечение: определять, липсинг или нет, и обмениваться мнениями, какие песни или концерты еще липсинг, а какие нет. Они не понимают, что оскорбляют артиста. До них это не доходит, сколько не объясняй!
У этого реакционера еще есть видео где он сравнивает Ди с какой то певицей( имени не помню) кто лучше берет свистковые или головные ноты,не знаю как называются правильно.Вот тоже спрашивается для чего ?Ведь делал же раньше просто реакции ,хорошие,мне нравилось,теперь опустился ищет чего то,копается,сравнивает.Хайпит мужик ,я отписалась от него,надеюсь многие фаны Димаша так же сделают,и пусть находит себе подписчиков.В детектива решил поиграть.А главное эти записи тоже гуляют с репетиции везде вот их теперь будут всем сувать хейтеры.
вот ради эксперимента вогнала оба видео в программу, и там слышна разница сильно, даже не для русскоязычного; просто эмоциональная подача слегка разная, кое-где разные ноты. При том официальное заявление организаторов, что выступление было живое, - игнорируется. ну Адажио они конечно уже не могут так загнобить хоть какая то польза от криворуких звукорежиссеров
Готовьтесь - скоро таких видио будет валом. Если кто не в курсе, то в интернете работает целая армия фрилансеров, которая пишет "правильные отзывы", заливает "правильное видео" и делает массу иных не очень порядочных, но очень хорошо оплачиваемых вещей.
LANVEEN что за программа? Как это можно послушать?
Лучший комментарий под этим "анализом" от Натальи Макаровой:
"Под видео с прямым эфиром этого концерта на ютуб был расписан тайминг, с указанием имени артиста и как он будет петь (живьем или под фонограмму). Так вот, под фонограмму на вечере А-Студио пела только Алсу. Уважаемый вокальный тренер, не нужно искать подвохов там, где их нет. Как -то нелепо Вы выглядите при этом. К тому же, посмотрите видео с репетиции этой песни."
Подписываюсь. Всего-то нужно зайти по ссылке и увидеть.
Прямая трансляция творческого вечера группы A’STUDIO и 1-го конкурсного дня из концертного зала «New Wave Hall» в Олимпийском парке Сочи.
ruclips.net/video/frvEkvoTz_k/видео.html
Тайминг для удобства:
00:00:03 Последние приготовления
00:04:25 Прибытие членов жюри конкурса "Новая волна 2018" Директора МУЗ-ТВ Армана Давлетьярова, композитора Дмитриса Контопулоса
00:17:35 Отбивка "Новая волна"
00:19:04 Кети Топурия и A’STUDIO - Помни это (живьём)
00:23:00 Приветствие ведущих Тимура Родригеза и Байгали Серкебаева
00:26:50 Филипп Киркоров - Ночь-подруга (живьём)
00:35:40 Леонид Агутин и Tomas N’Evergreen - Джулия (живьём)
00:43:32 Интерактив для зрителей зала New Wave Hall от соведущих Сергея Демидова и Виктора Абрамяна
00:46:20 Алсу - Любовь-река (фонограмма)
00:52:53 Сергей Лазарев - Ещё люблю (живьём)
01:00:01 Alekseev - Сезон дождей (живьём)
01:05:15 Тимур Родригез - S.O.S. (живьём)
01:10:20 The Jigits - Нелюбимая, Солдат любви (живьём)
01:15:38 Юлианна Караулова - Стоп, ночь (живьём)
01:22:37 Димаш Кудайбергенов - Грешная страсть (живьём)
01:29:30 Благодарность спонсорам конкурса от ведущего Тимура Родригеза
01:31:20 Виктория Жук, Антон Беляев и группа Therr Maitz - Улетаю (живьём)
01:37:59 Кети Топурия и A’STUDIO - Fashion girl (живьём)
01:42:01 Интерактив для зрителей зала New Wave Hall от соведущих Сергея Демидова и Виктора Абрамяна
01:44:35 A’STUDIO, Кети Топурия и все звёзды - Белая река (живьём)
01:47:00 Салют!
01:50:31 Благодарность спонсорам конкурса от ведущих Тимура Родригеза, Сергея Демидова и Виктора Абрамяна
Hi Frank..did you are last night performance Adagio???? You should watch..the mic was not working...no sound...and Anyway what was the point if all this ???? You are saying that he is not an amazing Singer , Unique and One of the best??? Because if you brought up this ...you just opened the door for the green of envy haters....You saw Dimash singing without a mic..and without any kind of effect..pitch PERFECT ..
And is not that us... his fans can't take the fact that sometimes he is required to lyp sync...it is because of that people want to take his merits and put him down..
Lyp sync or not I want to see anyone daring to do a cover of one of Dimash song...
LOL you opened a can of worms with this one. But I know you did it because you believe it is true.
As for me, I don't particularly care whether Dimash lipsynced at Sochi or at other venues. (Yeah, I'm a vocal ignoramus.) Because even if he does lipsync, he would only do it with material he has already sung in the studio. It's still Dimash. And his glorious transcendent crazy-awesome vocals. (Love ya, Dimash!)
For the record, I believe he sang it LIVE.
First of all, I'd like to say that I love your React videos. Thank you Jang for your great work here.👍👍👍
❤The song is just fantastic and phenomenal.❤
I also do not care if many say he's just lip sync. How many musicians sing like that and where it is just taken like that. We all know Dimash his performance and what he can show on stage.
I'm from Germany and sometimes it's hard to understand the text. ❤ But if you can make Dimash feel his music and his voice, then it does not matter which language it is. The goose bumps are there and you just want to close your eyes and listen to the music.❤
And that's what makes Dimash fantastic, he can just enchant people for a brief moment when he sings. There is no day I am not here on RUclips to listen to Dimash and when I hear some songs two or three times. It's always awesome and I'm glad that Dimash is there and he shows how people can dream and forget all worries for a little while. Dimash you're the best, keep it up.❤❤❤
And please, watch the Video from Gloria Wu: [ENG SUB]Dimash PhantaCity
Here is ruclips.net/video/frvEkvoTz_k/видео.html the full version of this concert with timing.
After the name of the singers write they sing live (живьем) or phonogram (фонограмма).
01:22:37 Димаш Кудайбергенов - Грешная страсть (живьём) (Dimash Kudaibergen - Sinful Passion (Live))
If the time is the same, this means that Dimash is working on every pause and breathing for the drama of the song.
When Dimash sings S.O.S., he always makes a loud sigh at the end of the song. But we know, that it's live.
Isn't.
Why do we even bother finding out if it was lip synced? I believe Dimash would only sing live but this is not the point. Lip sync or not he’s the ONLY person who can ever sing this song the way it was presented! I don’t believe there’s another artist out there who can ever sing this song the way Dimash can! So if we all love Dimash, then we should stop the war now and just keep loving and supporting him no matter what! I know I will! ❤️
Thank you! Yes stopping the war seems like a good suggestion to me too. And yes no one can sing this song the way he did no matter what technological help they use
You are dead wrong this time...There is an official list of who sang live and who sang playback...and guess which group Dimash was...this list was printed before the actual performance that day...this was intended for sound engineers info only.....I also looked at Dimash's neck muscles, Adam's apple....as you should know if singer goes up in voice sound, the Adam's apple disappears or moves up ...check the video again...this is 100% live performance...end of discussion...
1.There are songs Dimash prefers not to change, like Adagio or Belovejskaya push'a. This is not enough to draw a conclusion it's a playback. Simply because there was a similar situation with 'Ocean over time'. Official MV for that song was suspiciously identical to its live version on a Great Chinese Wall, performed later same year. However, Chinese people heard substantial difference in pronunciation (Live 'Ocean over time' has in fact much better Chinese than the Official MV. This proved there was no lip sync.
Besides, why would Dimash improvise on a newly arranged by Erlan Bekchurin (he arranged all Dimash's songs for Singer 2017) song like this, if he had never sung it in public before?
2. This is the first time Dimash 'sets foot' on a big stage of Russia. He was invited by a producer of that "New Wave" contest, a respectable maestro, composer, Mr I.Krutoi, meaning basically the official recognition of Dimash by the Russian music industry moguls.
3. Under the official full A-Studio music band evening RUclips video there is timing of each singer with a note whether this singer performs live or not. Only once famous singer Alsu was reported (not live). FYI: famous A-Studio music band originated in Almaty (Kazakhstan). Pianist Baigali Serkebaev is a composer of this song's original.
For those curious to see the graphical representation form: ruclips.net/video/iT4A2PVzVFc/видео.html ( Dimash - Sinful Passion - Sochi - Audio Comparison of Rehearsal and Fancam ).
There are videos of him singing at little gatherings. Which proves how great he is. Singing in a big space , its essential to have reverb ,especially reflective reverb.
Could you please react to his performance for Adagio at the same venue (Sochi) where his mic was having technical issue and tell us if he lip sync????DKIFC/SG
That one was definitely live. Sinful passion is a playback
Why should they let him sing one song live, and the other lip-synced? It doesn't make sense.
Oh Anis..so pick and mix now????
@@noraapex have problem with that? One song is live, another isn't. Is it unheard of?
@@lailanis1 it's not true. There are differences between the rehearsal and the performance. Someone did a REAL comparison that went really in depth and there were many differences. In timing, melody, pronunciation etc. They're small, but they're there.
Hey Frank, you know I love you so much but this is very romantic song and he always show us his breathes, so when you sing a song you must know where you will breath or not :) Just my opinion but you judged him so quick I guess :) He can do lip sync of course, but its not neccessary, he has a violin in his cords haha :)
Well now you put your foot in your mouth....Do you not realize by now, that there are people who start these rumors because they are anti-fans or just malevolent....It is so very difficult for these people to recognize that Dimash is as good as he is...If they (or the person they are a fan of) can't be that good, Dimash must be cheating....You will notice from our Russian Dears..that they could tell the difference... Sorry to say, you should have left this one alone.....
Take the Lip Synching rumors and shove it....we all know he sings live and he can sing identical...he didn't from the rehearsal to the performance...he changed the end....so sick of this....this is not the reason I came here...I came for your reaction...not whether or not to prove someone one right or wrong...Bye....
Watch at 2:58 in the show, you can see his tongue flutter while holding a note with vibrato. If he was really lip syncing, I don't believe that would happen. Also wouldn't his larynx basically stay in the same position during the song if he was lip syncing ??
*IN A PERFOMANCE IN CHINA(LAST YEAR) HE WAS WITH COLD,BUT HE WANTED SO MUCH SING THAT HE'S WAS SWEATING,HE WAS PALE,IT'S SAD TO SEE THAT PERFORMANCE,IN SOME PARTS...HE ALMOST GAVE UP BUUUUT...HE SING LIVE...AND THIS IS NOT HEALTHY!I THOUGHT THAT HE WOULD PASS OUT THERE!SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO IF HIM DO LIP SYNC ON DAY...SO WHAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAT??IF ONE SINGER DO LIP SYNC ONE DAY...WHAT??*
almost a lifetime of dimash was spent just to practice singing, even he went through his childhood just to practice singing and learning musical instruments ... after all his hard work from children until now, and now he has become a great singer, very clear lip syncing is not an option for him ... you who say dimash is 8 wonders of the world, why now you doubt the ability to sing above the reach of other singers? it is very ironic that you declare something that cannot be proven accurately, even your statement can harm your reputation and dimash credibility ... sorry you should not judge others only from your point of view, which is not necessarily the truth ...
In the grand scheme of things does it really matter if he lip synchs? It is still his voice, It is not changed. A true dear knows he can sing like that live. And a true dear would think no less of him. Go Dimash!!
Lip synth or not, doesn’t matter to me. I’m a huge fan of Dimash, and he’s the only singer that I listen to everyday.
What kind of nonsense did I just see? I looked through almost all of Dimash's performances, and the only one where he sang with a phonogram was his performance at the opening of the Universiade.
Exacting a specific way to sing is the mark of a professional. A singer, dancer, athlete, laborer, etc. that are great at what they do have a "down pat" way of execution of their task. It is muscle memory. A game plan. Can you imagine expecting dancers to change up their count, go on 3 instead of 4 this time or an infielder's precise movement needed for a successful double play. My father/coach worked our infield until it was second nature. Backlash is hard to take but things grow and evolve when there is friction and if processed in a positive way can produce a pearl such as a grain of sand and a oyster.
Seriously who gives a fuk ? He doesn't have to prove himself anymore and he will always be one of the greatest and most gifted performer of my Z generation. I have learnt to accept that Dimash will always have the same ole same ole group of haters trolling , disseminating each and very one of his performances no matter how good he performed.
A true fan will cherish and support him no matter what, till time immemorial.
God Bless Dimash Kudaibergen !
PROOF THAT HE DOESNT LIPSYNC THIS PARTICULAR PERFORMANCE :
ruclips.net/video/iT4A2PVzVFc/видео.html
Pay attention closely to the red and purple lines... the peaks... the thickness of the lines... etc
if he lipsynced those red and purple lines would look EXACTLY the same. It is even so clear in 4.45 to 5.00. So different!! 😉😉
What are you talking about!!! How can you make such statement based on your opinion...just because the timimg is close does not make him lip sync...is it NOT POSSIBLE that he is so good that he can replicate the timing almost identical??? just because you or anyone else have not seen it done by another singer does not mean it can not be done...same idea that just because we have not heard anyone that can sing the range that Dimash can do...then we say it is not real...come on guys...lets not make statements UNLESS you can prove it 200% based on facts rather than based on your opnion and own analysis !!! I am truly disppointed in your statement in your video....I use to enjoy very much on your reaction but this is just not right !!!! How can you count manually with your fingers and call it scientific conclusion...come on really....???
its lip sync
He would rather not sing or pretend to sing，because he strictly demands himself, his rehearsal will be the same as the live.But if you listen carefully, you will hear many different details.
So this has been bothering me, i tried to sync both performance as much as i could, you can ear that they overlap perfectly, ergo they're a recording. Check it out for yourselves: www.youtubemultiplier.com/5c05b4b407587-sound-comparison-dimash.php
Just unsubscribed. 👋
Nope....i hear different pronouncations....and i been comparing for hours.
vanessaraerae i agree . Check out this comparative video. End of the issue. 👍
and your verdict is ???
@@adamscott9413 he was not lip syncing
Hi there I thought that was what you meant, just need to hear your confirmation ... this half arse wannabe vocal coach needs to take back what he said here.. thanks darl :)
@@adamscott9413 i agree hun
I guess when you're the best in the world, this happens. Very hard to believe when the sound quality is perfect.
You see, his fans can eat you alive when you say something slightly bad about Dimash. But it's up to you, to tell the truth and be hated or just pretending that dimash isn't faking his singing as everyone else to get likes and views
This performance was part of 2 hours concert tribute to the 30th anniversary of A-Studio group. It is Kazakh/Russian group based in Moscow. All Russian pop stars, including Dimash, performed covers of this group songs. Below is the link to the entire concert put out by the person affiliated with this festival. In the first post he put the list and timing of each performer and also put in the brackets if the performance was live or recorded. It is in Russian and I don't want to translate the full list because it is only contains time and names of the singers and indication (live or recorded). My point is Dimas is listed as a "live performance". Also comparing 2 videos, on the rehearsal Dimash sings longer the run at the end, in the live performance he cut it short, although music continued. Because it is mix concert with about 13 performers I can assume it might be per-recorded in order not to interrupt the flow of the concert, but most likely Dimash sang over that record, otherwise concert organizers would not call it live performance. Nevertheless, I respect your opinion Dear The Vocal Lexicon! Thanks for the honesty.
Sorry, the link with listing is here ruclips.net/video/frvEkvoTz_k/видео.html
One more point, this is one of the most viewed music festival/ contest in Russia held annually in city of Sochi. It includes performances by famous and established pop stars and the song contest of the new singers. Most audience is more interested in the star's performances rather than contestants. Dimash was not contestant but invited as a guest performer like other Russian pop stars. Dimash is not known to the Russian audience, therefore, again he had to do a showcase to demonstrate all his vocal abilities and range and impress Russians. It was the first time for him to perform before the large Russian audience. It would be strange if he did lip syncing while trying to introduce himself and prove himself before the large Russian audience that watched him not only in Sochi city but on the major Russian TV. Russian media would immediately call him baloney, if he lip sang, none Russian media did.
I am not expert in sound and stuff. But at the end of the rehearsal you can see man in shock. It is sort of director/producer of the show. Why to be shocked if he is not live. At the end of the actual performance there is a man giving standing ovation. It is executive producer. Again why would he bother if Dimash wasn't singing live. BTW, it was like 3 hour show and Dimash only one who got standing o from him. Must be sign
thnks to his many acapela version on an interview kind of show, for again n again he wins of my doubts
iam not gonna even finish ur vedio to say this sir " Dimash never did nor will he ever lip synch or auto tone etc etc etc " READ MY LIPS !! 😊 i rest my case ☺️ hello ? seriously ? how dare ... this guy is a legend on his own !! people just cnt accept the fact that Dimash can do only what he can do !!!! duhhhh shame on those who do accuse such !!!
Making decision without asking a singer sounds like u have to apologize in front of him publicly
Sigh, it's hard when Dimash is so perfect
And too...Even if a single chance he was.....ummmm he still sang just like that..in rehearsel....no added crap....to begin with soooooo.....ummm lip syncing to his master piece that he literallly did hours before...does it reallly matter. But people will alwaysss try to put down someone who is perfect no matter what...always someone negative....but back to dimash.....watch his throat...his mouth....his lips.... Listen to e act sounds n words I relistened to this etc.....and i clearly hear the difference so i dont believe he did. Hes proven to us time and time and time again hes a perfect live singer no fakeness about his talent and abilities
I wondered if it was lip synced this time, as so many similarities and the music track was largely recorded anyway in my opinion. But I think his body language shows live singing. I always look at his eyebrows strangely enough, as his face is so expressive. 😌😩However, I don't think it takes anything away from him if he synced. He's still on the way to becoming a LEGEND! Thank you for clarifying points raised 🙏🏻💐
Regardless if it's live or recording... I doubt D lipsync but instead sang with the recordings in this performance.. and to make the same sound and effect above the recordings at the precise timing is commendable..
Thus, I believed he sang live but over the recording (as there are fans who went to watch the show live) which is fine as well.. still loving those notes coming from him..
Great analysis! I KNOW! It's difficult to determine if he is lip synching or not. When I was in choirs, back in the day before computers, I remember being rehearsed and rehearsed and rehearsed to practically identical perfection...particularly with where the breath will be and how much it is to be enunciated or accented to pace the song and to afford a breath off phrase. I think it's more the actual hearing of Dimash's breath is deliberate as part of the feeling of the song "Sinful Passion". The gasping breath of passion. Therefore, it would occur perfectly at the same time. His words are deliberately breathed in a gasp and a whispered breath--as if close to a lover's ear--nearly throughout the entire song. During all of his videos, I watch Dimash breathe. He has so many technical approaches to breathing. I'm most impressed with the ones that look like he's breathing clear to the bottom of his feet (and they're silent to the mic). That's when he really sustains a note/riffs/phrases. I'd say his breathing mastery is the foundation to his singing...along with instantly shaping his vocal cords in any position.
incorrect
Nobody disagrees he not an exceptional singer but this like some of his performances were actually prerecorded. It’s clearly lip synced
для русскоязычных
он говорит и делает вывод на основе своего анализа что Димаш спел под фанеру.
но я как то не очень доверяю "специалисту" сидящему на табуретке на фоне стены окрашенной дешевой краской.
вы наверно тоже слышите его разный акцент в этих выступлениях? я филолог и отлично слышу разницу
Я не слышу разницы в акценте. Прослушала обе версии 976677 раз. Это однозначно плюсовка. Хотя , какая разница. На закрытии он всем показал, на что способен,несмотря на бардак со звуком.
sorry, русский Ваш не родной ?
Это вы мне? Родной. Роднее не бывает. Я не живу а России много лет. Но родной.
может поэтому не все слышите :-( у него акцент сильно слух режет и по мне, это единственное, к чему действительно можно придраться
Mister coach are you really a professional? You had 100 arguments/proofs to show that he is singing live and 1 very weak argument that goes against it and you used it to conclude this? Furthermore, producing the same sound and breath is not an argument ,in Dimash's case especially he is classically trained , you know what it means and a perfectionist on top of that, with rare musical qualities you have already highlighted yourself in your previous videos. Any person who has minimum knowledge in singing should know that It is NOT impossible for a singer to produce the exact same sounds. You know Dimash isn't just any singer...
Why haven't you taken account of those for your analysis here? You know how important the words of a person of influence like you have but you neglected that, you didn't go till the end of the analysis and did't mention all the factors and actors and all the other possibilities .... which in my eyes showcases your lack of professionalism ..really disappointing. I am not offended by your final" judgement", that is your opinion and im fine with it but the process towards that judgement is to blame indeed.
There are many close up fancams of this performances , you may want to watch them .. who knows, maybe you have accused somebody wrongly and lead others to believe on falsehood with this influence of yours and you would like to clear up things someday...
I wondered the same thing
yeah... his analysis isn't satisfying... Dimash is already trained... He know perfectly the timing for his singing... and this analysis of him lip sync is based on wrong knowledge. I wonder if this person is actually a vocal coach or just a self-claim one.
its lip sync
Funny analysis and what you say is not true 😊in reality this is a live performance , As being Russian I clearly see the difference between words and his pronunciation especially give me , (For foreigners if you knew Russian language you will understand the difference)since for Dimash Russian is second language this difference is obvious , the fans were on his repetition I believe in words and reviews of people who saw him live ☺️and not people from the screen . And as many says Our Russian genius composer Igor Krutoi invited Dimash on this event and he wouldn’t give standing ovations for lip synce, you didn’t saw his adagio rehearsal , it’s interesting for me will you claim that his adagio rehearsal lip sync too ?😊 because it’s obvious live , don’t know why you bring this lies on your channel ? Enjoy his singing instead of spreading rumors .
Unsubscribed , i don’t want to watch Rumors
Отписывапюсь не хочу слушать Сплетника для меня он умер как реакционер, ну а вокальным коучем и подавно никогда не был (кто он ?? человек по ту сторону экрана) Я верю людям, которые сидели в метрах от Димаша на репетиции и сказали ,что это живое выступление, ну а репетиция адажио доказала, что Димаш поёт в живую! Зачем полез с этой темой , зависть пробилась? или продвинуть свой канал? одного индийского реакционера нам уже хватило он потом угрозами и обвинениями в Димаша сыпал , всякий бред про таблетки писал, угрожал что что-то там распространит - ужас!. Нет уж хватит.
its lip sync
Drop The Mic Lolol. You are from America aren’t you? 😂
Dimash the best singer 😂👍
EMINEM is the best Singer lmao
It is very unnecessary to make a video about the use of technologies in the songs that Dimash interprets (my clear opinion), we know that today it is impossible to escape from this technology, even for Dimash. Even though I'm so lazy in music, I know a singer can not always sing live. However, this does not diminish at all the charm that this young Kazakh talent has shown to the world's quantum. Here in Brazil there are singers who start singing well from day to night ... that's a shame and a lie. But Dimash no, he is an eighth wonder of the world. Long live at Dimash.
DID DIMASH Lip Synch LIKE SOME SAY? I Do Not Attempt To Watch This Video For Obvious Reasons. I am my own judge of what I see and hear in a performance and certainly do not rely on 'some say doubters' and, particularly from a vocal coach's perspective, he should not rely on 'some say doubters' which this seems the case to verify an opinion. This kind of posts can only court controversy. Miracle: An event described by those to whom it was told, by somebody who didn’t see it.
Sir,you must look Dimash sing sinfull passion from fancam The Pearl of Dimash Hongkong Fan Club.it makes me 100% Dimash performance live.not lipsync.please u react.
Ребята, не верьте очередному "разоблачителю". Димаш поёт в живую. Это на 100%. Под фанеру он пел только на открытии Универсиады в дуэте с Зариной Алтынбаевой (надеюсь, правильно написал), во всех остальных выступлениях - только живой голос. Да и подстава (или лажа) с микрофоном во время исполнения песни "Адажио" 9 сентября на "Новой волне" вполне доказывает то, что никакой фонограммы там и не было. Товарищ мог бы проверить ту дезу, которую он решил здесь ретранслировать. Диз ему за это.
I think you can just put the two sound tracks together, and find their patterns are different..
Don't you hear other people's voices when Dimash sings? There is Mr. Igor Krutooy watched and after that Igor became Dimash's mentor
haha just admit the fact that no one ever can sing like him.
You really should make some research before posting your opinion based on absolutely nothing relevant.
Lots of coments already stated why Dimash DIDN'T lip sync but I'll give you one more:
The member of the band and the composer of this song (the pianist) was there and I really don't think they would do it. No way.
Besides, have a look at how he moves his body, when he wets his mouth and how he opens it as well. Not to mention his Adam Aple.
He may used lip synch ... I*m not sure. But if its the case, I dont mind.. cause its his voice and he have a great talent. He is the BEST! Tanks for you reaction, you do a great job!
COACH .......We ....we Are DON'T CARE....what Other People Think ABOUT DIMASH......MILLIONS PEOPLE OUT THERE .....LOVE DIMASH
......WHY YOU'RE WAITED YOUR TIME FOR THOSE PEOPLE ....THEY'RE DON'T KNOW WHAT THE MUSIC ARE ....COMON..IT 'S FOR REAL???🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔
I'm not interested his lipsync, but It's nice to be back France Gall's "Ce soir je ne dors pas" in 1976 arranged so nicely. I like Dimash so much. ;D
Lipsync didn't need rehearsal n checksound, didn't need to check out the mic. It is pre recorded so you don't have to sing just learn your koreo n stage blocking. The most that everyone forget it was the feel. He got the feel better than his rehearsal. When he sang that forest song at vitebsk, wow amaxing Improvisation you know he did exactly the same part at 2016 already.. Actually it is not difficult to See the differences between singing and pretended to sing. Idol group's lover must expert about this.. Why don't we Analyze he was lipsync or not in his MV?
Вот, под этим видео автор пишет, кто как поет. Некоторые - под фонограмму. А Димаш - "живьем", как автор изволит выражаться. Новая Волна 2018. Полная версия HD (05.09.2018). Творческий вечер группы A’STUDIO. ruclips.net/video/frvEkvoTz_k/видео.html
My only take is that, this usually happens with Sinful Passion only. I'm quite interested at the reason why.
Exactly!
Disappointing. and insulting not only towards Dimash's hard work but also to all those professionals who met him and saw him live and acknowledged him. Now what are you doing? With a limited knowledge, making claims, starting rumors.. I suggest you to learn more about singing first because one never has total knowledge, there is always more to discover and two, about Dimash ,before making ANY claim, he isn't just a voice or a singer. His sensitivity and comprehension of music is far more advanced than you think. Many senior singing teachers and other respected professionals said that he is a musical genuis, that they see him as equal and some seniors even said he was superior to them.
Honeslty sir do review yourself please. Do watch other fancams of this song,you will see that your argument about the same breath and same sound isn't even an argument, Dimash masters breathy singing, he is pitch perfect, he has perfect control over his whole instrument in its tiniest details.
Disclaimer ; im absolutely not offended when lip-sync and playback and autotuned is used. But when it's not it's just not. no matter people's different opinion. There is only one truth and there is no point in debating about the truth
Bravo!
Franchement ,on s 'en fout de tout ce battage .La seule personne qui puisse répondre n'est autre que Dimash .
You answered your own disclaimer with another disclaimer. Lol
Again, he only showed the perfectly played backtrack that was used and it was obvious. Can Dimash sing? No doubt. Can artists lipsync and get caught? They do! I mean look at the Mariah and she still sound the same whether its "live" or from her decades old recordings. LOL
C A obvious? Don't think so, since there is a process to follow to be able to judge whether a singer lip syncs or not, and even with that one can't guarantee at 100% that judgement will be correct if it's based on a audio recording. To make sure, you should 1) be at the live concert 2) have educated ears and eyes ( 3)ask for mic's audio )
What to argue, if there is reliable information?
Whoever wanted, found and saw.
ruclips.net/video/frvEkvoTz_k/видео.html
Live broadcast of the creative evening of A'STUDIO and the 1st day of the contest from the concert hall "New Wave Hall" in the Olympic Park in Sochi.
Timing for convenience:
00:00:03 Last preparations
00:04:25 Arrival of members of the jury of the contest "New Wave 2018" Director of MUS-TV Arman Davletyarov, composer Dmitry Kontopoulos
00:17:35 The "New Wave"
00:19:04 Keti Topuria and A'STUDIO - Remember this (live)
00:23:00 Greeting of the leading Timur Rodriguez and Baigali Serkebaev
00:26:50 Philip Kirkorov - Night-girlfriend (live)
00:35:40 Leonid Agutin and Tomas N'Evergreen - Julia (live)
00:43:32 Interactive for the spectators of the New Wave Hall from co-host Sergey Demidov and Victor Abramyan
Alsu - Love-river (soundtrack)
00:52:53 Sergey Lazarev - I also love you (live)
01:00:01 Alekseev - The rainy season (live)
01:05:15 Timur Rodriguez - S.O.S. (live)
01:10:20 The Jigits - Unloved, The Soldier of Love (live)
01:15:38 Julianna Karaulova - Stop, the night (live)
01:22:37 Dimash Kudaibergenov - Sinful passion (live)
01:29:30 Gratitude to the sponsors of the contest from the host Timur Rodriguez
01:31:20 Victoria Zhuk, Anton Belyaev and the band Therr Maitz - Fly away (live)
01:37:59 Keti Topuria and A'STUDIO - Fashion girl (live)
01:42:01 Interactive for spectators of the New Wave Hall from co-host Sergey Demidov and Victor Abramyan
01:44:35 A'STUDIO, Keti Topuria and all the stars - White River (live)
01:47:00 Salute!
01:50:31 Gratitude to the sponsors of the contest from leading Timur Rodriguez, Sergey Demidov and Victor Abrahamyan
Hi, there is timing list of A'studio evening, according to it, only Alsu used Lip-sing, of course, it just timing, you can not believe it, but officialy, he sang live. And I liked your video! It great, that you actually tried to analyse this issue, thinking is always better than blind love.
First of all, yo
as much as I respect WWrahmania also known as ME ntertainment the only things she got rid of was the comments who said anything that could ruin her evidence she is just like many of the ppl who disliked this video one sided also rehearsals don't mean nothing he could have 2 different studio version 1 for rehearsal 1 for the official performance its like his old unforgettable day song he has 2 versions that sounds exactly the same but 1 of them has an extra run
just started thinking about it but I also believe she might have blocked me so no one can see my comments if that's true then shes definitely one of those one sided fans because I have never ever said anything that would get me blocked I don't swear in this community everything I say I always back it up with why Dimash might have done it and always find a good reason why he would lipsync and im not one of those ppl who say he cant sing which is obviously not true I believe he will take over the world with his voice
BullyPunch I am glad you were not there sir, or you were going to faint
even the performances that i believe are lipsynced give me goosebumps believe me you are right i would faint but im just giving you explanations and i even have 3 lipsync fail + playback fail videos and 1 of them was hard to find which might be proof to tell you that rehearsal fancams and moving larynx and being their in person means nothing at all it could still be lipsynced :) Vitas lipsyncs also very common in Russia just like Kazakhstan and hes no where near as good at lipsyncing as Dimash and he got away with it for 15+ years and ppl still believe he doesn't lipsync
I could care less what jealous salty people say.
1. He is clearly gifted, one among billions, to have natural talent, willpower and privilege to train since he was 5 yo
2. Now that we agree that he is one of so many, we have to accept the fact that for the accusation of lypsinc to work, he has to sing that song perfectly beforehand.
Next, what makes people think that while for others it's impossible to have the same breathe during singing, it's extremely possible for him? Especially when we know that he clearly can control his breath perfectly (the screams, the whistle tone and all). He managed to be able to do things that nobody in the world thought to be possible, and yet, he did.
Незнаю , всегда мы с супругой смотрели его реакции.Если ,честно из за Димаша! Если он так оскорбляет Димаша! Надо,просто он него отписаться ХОРОМ! и он поймет,что сделал ошибку!
Thanks, you is suuper
I like u lex but will not waste my time with this cuz why would he lip sync when he is taking over the world besides adagio In closing ceremonies was just as live! If I believed everyone about lip syncing he would never sing a song live cuz it has been said about hello, songs on singer every song so who actually sings for dimashi! This is just jealous rumors!
Don´t forget the intimate airport interview- ``He (Dimash) said that he
has a pretty normal attitude to criticism. And he feels very bad when his fans attack any kind of criticism expressed towards him turning it all to a horrible experience. He worries about that a lot and considers this kind of behavior unworthy.´´ Some parts of this comment section looks very close to a horrible experience to me. We´re not helping him at all. Frank was respectful and I get this feeling that Di wouldn´t like all this unpleasantness. Some comments are very respectful while others, sadly, are not.
isabel fahlen there is a difference between cticism and accusations. Mind you Dimash's team ALWAYS cleared up any false accusations towards them that were a threat to his integrity and career. You are not helping him either by accusing him of lipsync you know ? Don't use Dimash's honest words to defend blameworthy things. Why should one be able to criticize others and others no be able to criticize that person? Stop hypocrisy please...
I have not shared my opinion on this matter anywhere because I realize how many things I´m ignorant of. I love and respect my Di, I would never EVER accuse him of anything in public. Where did I write he lip-syncs? Nowhere. And I´m not defending anyone, just stating what I observe. Di always behaves politely and respectfully, some of these comments are not. But as you say, if his team always clears up false accusations, then how on earth can all these angry comments be of any further help for him? From what I see some haters only use them as fuel for their fire, saying we´re crazy fanatics. We all know too little, Di and his team with the proper knowledge will take care of it in the proper way.
isabel fahlen what do you mean??? Nobody cares about what haters say neither does Dimash. I said Dimash's team clear up the matters that aims to destroy his reputation and career cause it is illegal in the first place and things can end up at court. Stupid haters will always find bad things to say no matter what even turning good things into bad. That's why we don't care. But seeing bad things said among the fans is more shameful and protecting "fans" that say bad things using Dimash's speech instead of denouncing them isn't ok either !
I will NOT protect ``fans´´ who say bad things about him. Never. Stupid haters will always find bad things to say no matter what, whatever comments we write to try and defend him they will inevitably turn to their own advantage, accusing us of ``blind ignorant fan-girling´´. That´s why I´m not comfortable either when dears discuss matters like these in public forums like youtube. I seriously worry about him. I agree that not saying anything is bad, but some comments here are worse than not saying anything at all. This video has now been published (nothing I can do about it) and I´m trying to think rationally what respons from us will benefit Di the most, and I´m not sure denouncing accusers in this manner will have any profitable impact. It won´t change the minds of haters, it won´t change the minds of dears who love him. It will just make us look (for want of a better word) a bit desperate to prove our point
What an interesting analysis! Thank you, Frank! I consider myself a big fan of Dimash and I'm not shocked if he didn't sing live. Like you said musicians have lots of reasons to lip sync, so I believe they did it for his best. And.. We all know what he is capable of! :)
Dimash did not do sync lip at all.
Fr PHILIPPINES
the end part of the rehearsal is different from the actual.. so you mean to say, the accompaniment or the orchestra were just joking there.. or a drawing? Seems youre using dimash for your channel.. “little learning is dangerous” this is you..that event was a prestigious one. I dont think so the organizers will allow such kind..
In my opinion if it was a lip sync, then at least it should be known to the organizers, sound specialists. If this were true, they would be the first to tell it to the whole world.
For a 2 hours plus concert, I'm okay if the singer lip-sync 1 or 2 songs since they have to protect their voice. But not the whole concert through. But recording or not, he is still the one singing. Listened to him live and recorded, I'm okay either or since he can actually sings. 👌👌
вообще не понимаю кто надоумил вас сделать такой анализ? зачем это надо было делать? Ваш канал я больше смотреть не буду.
The rehearsal is DEFINITELY DIFFERENT from the main show's version: ruclips.net/video/8O2QxWJ62Y8/видео.html
🙄
Dear sir,
I'm so disappointed in you 😔😔 I thought you can be more professional in analyzing. I thought you know that there are a lot of things that need to be taken into consideration to prove a lipsync. 😥😥😥
You let someone got into your head and you made a video using her method. That's not fair!!
You are a vocal coach. I expect better from you. I thought you will be analyzing his mouth, jaw, tongue, reverb, etc. But counting? 😧😧
You are not an amateur but why does your argument so amateurish??
Just saying.
I hope you read all the comments here and think about a lot of things. You have done well in ruining someone's reputation.
I'm not saying he has never done a lipsync (he did it in KZ when he was young and there was a universiade performance), but to accuse a 100% LIVE performance of lipsync... 😡
He has worked hard for this, to achieve perfection, and you just slapped him on the face with this video!! 😔😔 all his efforts have gone to the gutter. Great!!
I would like to mention that the individual who claimed that he was lip syncing based his comment upon listening to his rehearsal of this song and in parallel listening to his live performance claiming that they are precisely the same in every aspect, for me it does not diminish anything from our great Dimash but your opinion would be interesting, thank you
So what you're saying is..... you rehearse to then sound different during the live show? Never heard of this. When I had my band and we rehearsed we played it and I sang exactly the same during the live performance. Only if I was sick or had a bad day would I sound different, but other than that, you rehearse for a reason dude. If he did lip sync then it is what it is, but you sound extremely confident that this was a fake performance, interesting , from someone that has seen him soooo many times. Dimash even said it , he doesnt like to lip sync.