Yellowstone Season 5, Episode 4: Beth Discovers Jamie's Secret Son

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 26 окт 2024

Комментарии • 172

  • @Khmergirl31
    @Khmergirl31 Год назад +164

    I’m sick of Jaime being the punching bag, they really need to change the storyline of Jamie and Beth

    • @wasteland1072
      @wasteland1072 Год назад +28

      and every fan of this show hates Jaimie cuz of how manipulative beth is lol, she be making him look like a monster... whole time SHE the monster lol

    • @wasteland1072
      @wasteland1072 Год назад +15

      but honestly, if I were in Jaimies position, I would've taken her to get the sterilization too, I mean what kinda mother do people think she'd be? she'd be a terrible mother and the show already showed that lol

    • @Khmergirl31
      @Khmergirl31 Год назад +3

      @@wasteland1072 exactly

    • @jalynneepp7080
      @jalynneepp7080 Год назад +10

      ​@@wasteland1072she is the way she is because of what she has experienced in life.

    • @wasteland1072
      @wasteland1072 Год назад +13

      @jalynneepp7080 I mean Jamie was treated like shit by all of them, he doesn't have to like them or share information with them 🤷🏽‍♂️

  • @joelburgos69
    @joelburgos69 Год назад +144

    Jaime has been the punching bag of the family for decades, John Dutton named him "The Son I Regret" in the last episode, and because of his weakness he is a easy target.
    For his story, the logical conclusion is to leave Montana and that family behind, he will never grow as an individual if he stays there, but if Beth harm the kid he will have to take her down permanently...

    • @Omega1867
      @Omega1867 Год назад +13

      I’d say she would try and use Jamie’s child as an effort to keep him under John’s thumb. (But she IS hinting to John that they needed to kill Jamie soooo…. 🤷‍♀️ I can’t stand her)

    • @mitchjames9350
      @mitchjames9350 Год назад +8

      I reckon the same thing, sell up and either get out of town or Montana indefinitely. That family is dragging him down with the constant abuse.

    • @inesamormino1838
      @inesamormino1838 4 месяца назад

      ​@@Omega18673:07 No la soporto....

  • @Omega1867
    @Omega1867 Год назад +66

    We all pray to god that Jamie finally snaps (after being reduced to the family punching bag for years, plus having whiny toxic Beth come back and manipulate John against him) and takes Beth out of the equation. The show would be so much better without her. And I hate her constantly calling Jamie a bastard among other things. The adoption was legal so he is a Dutton.
    The writers are doing their damnedest to convince us that “all Beth needs to do is reproduce and she WILL BE FULFILLED and a better person” but then turn around and show her physically and emotionally abusing that teen she ‘adopted’ in season 4 not to mention that she doesn’t even see that kid as hers. So yeah. She’ll be a good parent alright. 🙄 But look at her examples….
    It seems that Taylor Sheridan is perfectly content making Jamie “the bad guy” simply because he is the adopted child. NOT COOL. And don’t even get me started on Sheridan taking something that was forcefully done to thousands of Indigenous women and girls and using it as a backstory for his incredibly toxic, refuses to evolve as a human being, WHITE female character. To be frank, Beth is an undiagnosed schizophrenic psychopath. She needs serious help.

  • @moniquedanielle43
    @moniquedanielle43 Год назад +102

    My opinion. Beth got pregnant at a young age, that’s on her. Jamie did what he thought was best for her. Beth has always been a emotional mess, especially after her mom died. Jamie is going to be the one to take her down this season

    • @johndillinger8482
      @johndillinger8482 Год назад +28

      agreed. Beth is being way too unreasonable with her actions.

    • @mvzv3913
      @mvzv3913 Год назад

      No he lied to her. And his bastards child will ruin the family

    • @batbullet3315
      @batbullet3315 Год назад +14

      The only mistake that Jamie made was not telling his sister the full ramifications of the clinic if he had told her they could have figured something else out

    • @johndillinger8482
      @johndillinger8482 Год назад +29

      @@batbullet3315 it was the clinic's responsibility to make sure she knew everything that was done.Putting it on Jamie was lame.

    • @karencarver8094
      @karencarver8094 Год назад

      Yes Beth made a mistake but that did not give Jamie the right to make her sterile. Jamie is weak and not a true Dutton.

  • @rezbaron
    @rezbaron Год назад +21

    Beth is the reason I stopped watching this show. They have it scripted where she never loses an argument, fight or has the last famous words in every scene. Her revenge and immaturity is getting old with her bitterness of what happened when she was teenager. The train station for her soon I hope lol

  • @Melissatn
    @Melissatn Год назад +65

    Beth is more of a problem than Jamie. She constantly pushes Jamie's buttons and tries to push him to do things for John to hate him. He hasnt betrayed any of them, he is constantly pushed by her and Beth is going to push him too far. John clearly loves Kaycee and Beth way more than Jamie. The love isn't the same and he clearly told Governor Perry something along the lines that he knows that Jamie seeks his approval and thats how they can control him. He may care for him in his own way but not the same as he does Kaycee and Beth. If they (Beth) would stop pushing him so much and stop trying to drive more of a wedge and make John hate him, there would be less problems and they'd be unstoppable. What Jamie did to Beth when they were kids idk if I could ever forgive that but Beth takes that anger and grudge way too far and SHE is the biggest threat to the family because of that. Even if Jamie were to do something against the family, she is the behind it. I like her and Rip mainly because Rip deserves happiness etc but she's a problem.

    • @yvonnereed2978
      @yvonnereed2978 Год назад +9

      They both were young when she asked him to get rid of it. I don't think he understood with what being sterile ment and what they would do. I would of thought they would tie her tunes or something as you notice they never talked about that part in depth.but Beth is annoying and she needs to take responsibility to.

    • @Omega1867
      @Omega1867 Год назад +11

      The entire family is messed up but Beth is the one that needs SERIOUS help. In season 5 so far, it seems that Jamie is working against John but there’s just that one line he says which makes me think he’s actually helping John instead from behind the scenes.
      Beth is just determined to hate him and make John hate him but what annoys me most aside from her not shutting up about the abortion is the fact that she (and John to a slightly lesser extent) is trying to destroy Jamie’s relationship with Kayce. I also hate that she constantly abuses Jamie but he can’t get her back because she’s a woman. And that we’re supposed to think it’s okay because she’s a woman hitting a man. Double standards and all that.
      Rip has made it clear that he never wants kids already but watch the writers make him do a complete 180 should Beth tell him about her teenage pregnancy. I’ll bet anything that’s what’s gonna happen.

  • @bobloss2269
    @bobloss2269 Год назад +19

    Beth blaming Jamie for his entire life for something THEY did as kids is insane. And he nearly gets them killed by attacking him whiles he's drive. Beth is great at defending the ranch but she's legit a bad person.

    • @mynameiswoman
      @mynameiswoman 8 месяцев назад +4

      I think she resented him more because her mother liked him more. She also knew she caused her mother's death, and instead of taking accountability, she looked for every reason to hate him. She's a psychopath.

    • @o.gparamount3099
      @o.gparamount3099 8 месяцев назад +1

      ​@@mynameiswomanEXACTLY💯🎯 her karma's coming

  • @malsila3696
    @malsila3696 Год назад +36

    Both were Kids ... Jamie did what he thought was Right ... Beth needs to take more responsibility for her Situation ... Always playing victim Beth ... Tired of her sulking over her Regrets ... They'll probably end up killing each Other ...

    • @mitchjames9350
      @mitchjames9350 Год назад +5

      Beth pressured him and he wasn’t that much older than she was either. If anything Beth should of gotten Rip to help get an abortion not put it on Jamie.

    • @isaaccerna1022
      @isaaccerna1022 Год назад +3

      The real problem is the clinic secretary plot hole. Yes, she told Jamie what would happen, but both she and the Doctors must had Warned Beth about the procedure and give her a Heads Up: "hey, you will be infertile forever after this, sure you wanna go on?" It makes absolutely no sense they wouldn't tell her and just have it for granted that she already knew because Jamie told her

  • @azraiel1984
    @azraiel1984 Год назад +20

    This episode sharply and permanently cemented my disdain for Beth, anyone threaten my son, I'd lose it too.

  • @gantashiro978
    @gantashiro978 Год назад +53

    What Jamie did when they were kids was awful and unforgivable... But that being said they were kids so taking her revenge by harming a little boy isn't right. And even if it doesn't mean harming the child but taking Jamie away from him, a child deserves to have both their parents in their lives especially since Jamie hasn't shown any signs of being any sort of bad father to his son. Beth has the right to be mad but not seek revenge because of it. Especially not on an innocent child, it's not like the kid did anything wrong.

    • @johndillinger8482
      @johndillinger8482 Год назад +12

      he didnt do a damn thing.

    • @macfly6237
      @macfly6237 Год назад +28

      It’s sad and disturbing reading comments of people defending Beth abusing her brother and her antisocial behaviors. Jaime was a kid, it was HER choice to have the abortion, and using Beth’s logic she should have been branded for causing her mom’s death. However for the latter she isn’t.

    • @mvzv3913
      @mvzv3913 Год назад

      He lied to her and caused her to be infertile. All their work is useless.

    • @paulriccio5508
      @paulriccio5508 Год назад +3

      @@macfly6237 thank you

    • @ashleybaltz4584
      @ashleybaltz4584 Год назад +4

      #1- I don’t know why Beth thinks that revenge will fix anything.
      #2- Yes she has a right to be mad, but I don’t see why she’s not any less mad since she atleast has Carter to love.

  • @Ian-ky5hf
    @Ian-ky5hf Год назад +5

    He was a 17 year old boy! He doesn’t deserve this constant hate! The more of the show I watch the less I like Beth.

  • @joshuarosen1862
    @joshuarosen1862 Год назад +7

    I will never understand a woman's pain of never having kids, but I do understand is how many paybacks is it worth torturing someone who feels horrible about it? Jamie can live with Beth, not forgiving his mistake, but she can't just do all these acts he's done everything he could, and he just gets treated like a slave and now she's threatening to take or kill his son wherever he is she's already beyond too far if she goes any further beyond his limit I hope he does talk about the train station he might loose office and spend time in prison but he could get 5 or 10 years on parole and he could get out early since he knows how our countries system works

  • @joe3755
    @joe3755 Год назад +23

    Oh, but you're gonna keep lying to Rip, you hypocrite? That's why Beth is so unlikable: 0% accountability.

  • @USARightPatriot1
    @USARightPatriot1 Год назад +8

    I've been don't with Beth for a long time. But she's crossed a line she's got no right to.

  • @mitchjames9350
    @mitchjames9350 Год назад +9

    I am tired of Beth, she put on it Jamie her being pregnant pressured him to help get an abortion and they both panicked and had no choice to go to the Indians to abort the baby. Jamie needs to grow a back bone and stop letting her abuse him and not to grovel any more.

  • @sandrameesala6804
    @sandrameesala6804 Год назад +12

    What is she gonna do? Kidnap the kid? That's a sure way she'll never be a mom

    • @hannahyoung6762
      @hannahyoung6762 25 дней назад

      she has an adopted/foster son Carter but no bio children.

  • @steffnic13
    @steffnic13 Год назад +14

    We have zero proof that Beth told JD anything about Jamie. In fact, seems she didn’t even try, nor tell him she needed to talk to him later.

    • @deadhead8323
      @deadhead8323 Год назад

      John doesn't know as you said. He just trust that beth made sure jamie is compliant. Honestly if jamie wants to hurt the duttons I would go after rip first. And expose the dead bodies at the "train station". There's alot of missing people that most likely can be connected to the ranch. And expose the governor of abusing his power for the gain of his ranch.

    • @gantashiro978
      @gantashiro978 Год назад +7

      If anything I don't think Beth would want to tell him because he'd probably tell her to not do anything to his son. John would surely know that doing anything to that innocent boy isn't right regardless of her hatred for Jamie.

    • @mitchjames9350
      @mitchjames9350 Год назад +4

      John would protect Jamie’s son, which is why Beth hasn’t told him. The only two options for Jamie is sell up and take his kid and get out the state and away from that family. Or tell John why Beth hates him and about his son, that way John can prevent Beth splitting the family and protect Jamie’s child.

    • @gantashiro978
      @gantashiro978 Год назад

      @@mitchjames9350 And neither option is gonna happen cuz did you see the final episode? Jamie is planning on having the Duttons killed similar to what his dad did he's asked that girl he's sleeping with if she knows any hitmen that'll kill them for him. And Beth is suggesting to John that they kill Jamie now... So yea protecting Jamie's son is out the window.

    • @deadhead8323
      @deadhead8323 Год назад +1

      @Mitch James They need to conclude this story with her and jamie Because so far I see her as the villain. Yes what jamie did was horrible but that doesn't mean the audience should forgive her when she does horrible things to others.

  • @waynesalisbury
    @waynesalisbury Год назад +8

    At one moment I thought she was gonna be happy for him and then she just snapped😂😂 kinda funny

    • @Ian-ky5hf
      @Ian-ky5hf Год назад +5

      I am getting sick of Beth she blames everybody else but herself.

    • @deadhead8323
      @deadhead8323 Год назад +2

      @@Ian-ky5hf I understood her popularity as time went on. But now she's too villainous and has become a bigger liability.

  • @julesjefferson3568
    @julesjefferson3568 8 месяцев назад +3

    Beth deeper issue is with her mom.

  • @bobloss2269
    @bobloss2269 Год назад +5

    If Beth were kidnapped after she got in the car after the Jamie fight... she would have blamed Jamie.

  • @ashleybaltz4584
    @ashleybaltz4584 Год назад +16

    I can’t wait to see how Rip reacts when he finds out the secret that the baby they aborted was actually his.

    • @Anonymous_joe445
      @Anonymous_joe445 Год назад +12

      Yeah he’s gonna be mad at Jaime but Beth is not out of fault she had a hand in it to she knew what an abortion was

    • @porobotboyxxx
      @porobotboyxxx Год назад +17

      @@Anonymous_joe445 From the way Beth will present it, she’ll say that Jamie forced and dragged Beth out to the Abortion Clinic back when they were young. Instead of telling Rip that she pressured Jamie to help get an abortion.

    • @Anonymous_joe445
      @Anonymous_joe445 Год назад +14

      @@porobotboyxxx yep she’s a conniving women who bends things to make her look without fault like when she told john about it she acted like Jaime just went and forced her

    • @porobotboyxxx
      @porobotboyxxx Год назад

      @@Anonymous_joe445 Beth’s an amoral psychopath who admits she has no conscience. The fact that John and his late wife managed to instill “love” and form connections with people she “cares” about is an act of God of itself.

    • @Anonymous_joe445
      @Anonymous_joe445 Год назад

      @@porobotboyxxx yeah she probably was a evil little girl always twisting things

  • @waynecheeseman8774
    @waynecheeseman8774 Год назад +6

    When will Jamie stop being the one always being crapped on? They need to change the storyline or something. Beth’s character is awesome but somebody needs to knock her ass down a few pegs.

    • @HotPink-jz6rn
      @HotPink-jz6rn 8 месяцев назад

      Beth isn't awesome. She's the stereotypical bad bitch Hollywood peddles out in the name of strong female character. She's mean volatile and seems immature...takes no personal responsibility...hardly awesome

  • @kenjohnson5156
    @kenjohnson5156 Год назад +2

    The road this was filmed on is not that long a drive. If you look closely you will noticed the same businesses in the background repeat over and over.

  • @alexjimenez8545
    @alexjimenez8545 9 месяцев назад +2

    Jaime takes it because he feels he needs to. Most of Beth's rage is really meant for herself. If Jaime does, she would probably kill herself.

  • @kca3346
    @kca3346 7 месяцев назад +1

    Does anyone here actually think Beth would be a good mother anyway? Rip might be a good dad but Beth isn't really mother material. She justifies all the horrible things she does by saying that it's for her father. If she actually had a child they'd just be another excuse she has for doing the horrible things she does. She'd be like Cersei Lannister from GOT.

  • @shanebracken8358
    @shanebracken8358 3 месяца назад

    Beth gets mad at Jamie a lot, but this time I understand why, you can tell Beth was so hurt when she found out

  • @JoelsCreed141
    @JoelsCreed141 6 месяцев назад

    If you pay attention a lot of what Beth says about Jamie is actually just her projecting onto him her own insecurities, now is Jamie a saint hell no, but Beth’s disdain and pettiness towards him is borderline demonic at times. Regardless of what Jamie did what kind of sane person would target a child to hurt the person who wronged them

  • @kathyburks9994
    @kathyburks9994 Год назад

    I hope the second half of season 5 Beth and rip get a little spicy

  • @filipbuskovic3373
    @filipbuskovic3373 6 дней назад

    Why you just don't release the entire scene but give stupid comments. I will report the video for abuse

  • @allwinwellington6230
    @allwinwellington6230 4 месяца назад +2

    I am shocked at the number of people that think Jaime was right and also blaming it on his youth. He knew what he was doing and it isn't something you can ever take back. He deserves everything coming his way. He still justifies what he did. That pisses me off even more

    • @MsLLorena
      @MsLLorena 4 месяца назад +2

      Same

    • @Caleb17-ym6pq
      @Caleb17-ym6pq 3 месяца назад

      Lol, I would to. I think Jamie is a humanitarian for preventing someone life Beth from ever reproducing and inflicting her spawn on mankind.
      I wanted to feel bad for Beth but that didn't happen because her behavior and actions are despicable.
      It wasn't the sterilization that made her what she is, it was the issues and problems she has with he parents. She even said to Monica that she was a sh*t person even before the abortion.

    • @DogForever-vn9yx
      @DogForever-vn9yx Месяц назад +1

      He literally said in this in this scene that it was the biggest regret of his life. What else do you want from this guy? The man already got on his knees to plead Beth not to destroy him and the last thing he has that's worth fighting for, his son.
      You simply cannot justify even 10% of her treatment and actions towards Jamie. Her and John pushed him into becoming a villain and it's hard not to understand why he's choosing to antagonize his family.

  • @ShamrockdYA
    @ShamrockdYA Год назад

    Okay so is Jamie not Johns son? I’m so lost. I just started watching by the way.

  • @smc65714
    @smc65714 Год назад +4

    Finally the Sick /dis function side of Beth,Comes out.

    • @jaimealbiter1973
      @jaimealbiter1973 Год назад

      Finally? She's always been dysfunctional

    • @mattbryant8320
      @mattbryant8320 Год назад +5

      Finally?

    • @n0wheregrrl
      @n0wheregrrl Год назад +3

      That's literally the only side she has ever had. It's actually disturbing how many people regard her as an admirable character rather than the complete sociopathic monster she truly is.

  • @kathyburks9994
    @kathyburks9994 Год назад +2

    U KNOW PEOPLE ARE RAGGING ON BETH.FOR THE FIGHT WITH SUMMER. SUMMER DESERVED EVERY BIT OF IT.

  • @rogueryder3285
    @rogueryder3285 3 месяца назад

    Whether he's a father or not is none of her business. She threatened his baby and expected him to be coll with it? Nuh uh

  • @oscarkoop2548
    @oscarkoop2548 10 месяцев назад +1

    Beth is going to skin jamies kid and wear his face as mask lol

  • @WiiMan1133
    @WiiMan1133 Год назад +4

    “…and God gave you a boy?!”
    “No it was actually a girl”
    “Oh ok. Whatever.”
    Seriously, the dialogue in this show. It’s so stupid it should at least be funny

    • @WiiMan1133
      @WiiMan1133 Год назад

      @GH0ST_ I referring to this line in particular. Some of it is great, but then there are lines like this...

  • @mayajohnson4357
    @mayajohnson4357 Год назад +15

    I see a lot of comments about Beth taking it too far with her hate for Jamie... her hate for him is getting old. But, in my opinion she is totally justified in her anger. She trusted him to help her and he robbed her from ever having children. Ever having her own family with Rip. I'm rooting for her revenge. Jamie is a slime ball!

    • @deadhead8323
      @deadhead8323 Год назад +28

      I get her hatred and jamie deserves it. But now she going after his child. That childs mother is innocent and has done nothing to beth. Going after them out of spite for jamie is taking it far. They found a way to make me like her once the reasons for her hatred was explained. But now they are starting to make me hate her again 😒

    • @yolandachisholm177
      @yolandachisholm177 Год назад +18

      If that’s the case she should have went to her dad. She went to him, he didn’t go to help her. Hell she still keep on a destructive path that she started. She should have kept her legs closed. Sometimes you need to take blame for what you did. It’s my opinion

    • @deadhead8323
      @deadhead8323 Год назад +6

      @@yolandachisholm177 I think she feared that she would've been forced to keep the child. And also worried john would've done something to Rip. Sure rip is like a son to him now but in those days he probably would have dropped him at the train station.

    • @yolandachisholm177
      @yolandachisholm177 Год назад +3

      Deadhead maybe. But by now uoure to old to go blaming everything you did on someone else. Get over it and get a DR.PHIL. And this show needs to let Jamie explode twice. Once on Old Dear Dad then on MOTHER TERESA ( BETH)

    • @johnhenry4844
      @johnhenry4844 Год назад +19

      I mean Jamie should have told her about the consequences of the abortion, but they were both just kids panicking, Beth made a mistake and so did Jamie

  • @BrandonClarke7
    @BrandonClarke7 Месяц назад

    i am so sick of beth and her shit. she is so toxic and horrifying to jamie. jamie gets no respect and he neede to leave that family behind and start somewhere fresh

    • @noahsawyer7155
      @noahsawyer7155 6 дней назад

      She would make Chernobyl look like a dream getaway