08 Table of Contents Part Two
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 4 июл 2024
- Chad and Dan discuss the second half of the table of contents of Let the Stones Speak and highlight some important arguments and findings.
Join the discussion! To interact with Dan and Chad about Dan’s research, please visit nabataea.net/cinema/2023-vide...
Dan’s latest book Let the Stones Speak: Archaeology Challenges Islam is available as a free PDF, or as a hardcover for purchase, here: nabataea.net/shop/history/let...
Dan’s documentary The Sacred City can be viewed in a multitude of languages, for free, here: nabataea.net/cinema/sacredcity/
Thank You Sir Gibson🙏🙏
Hello.. I just discovered you on RUclips. I am writing from Ankara, the capital of Turkey. I liked your videos very much and found them very logical. I am a Muslim TURKISH. I also study many religious books and it is in my area of interest. I have never doubted the QURAN. But about Mecca, I always asked why Mecca? Your explanations and translation are very nice. If you come to Turkey, I would like to see and host you. Regards.
madem okudun ablacım, bu salak adamın söylediklerine değil kitaplara bak. neden mekke. HZ ibrahim kabeyi aramak için neden kudüsü bırakıp mekke tarafına kuş uçmaz kervan geçmez yere gitmiş? neden arafatta toplanıyor hacılar?Adem ile havvanın dünya üzerinde ilk buluştukları yerdir arafat. ayrı yere inmiş ve uzun zaman birbirlerini aramışlardır. Kabenin temelini hz adem atmıştır. brahim araması için oraya gönderildi. Bu adamın diğer videolarınıda seyrettim sürekli manipulasyon peşinde.Eğer gerçekten inanıyorsan dikkate alınmaması gereken birisi.İnanmıyorsan zaten problem yok.
Abla nasıl inanırsın bu gerzeklerin uydurmalarına bunlar İslama çamur atmak için yalan söylemekten çekinmiyor bunu da kendi inandıkları dine hizmetetmek için faydalı yalanlar olarak görüyorlar dünyanın kabul ettiği celal şengör hoca ki kendisi inançsızdır bunların söylediğini söylemiyor
I have downloaded the PDF of "Let the Stones Speak". I have a suggestion: it would be nice if in the index had internal hyperlinks to each chapter. I would make the page number the index shows the hyperlink. And also make the page numbers link back to the index.
It's fascinating to see how your research has developed over the years, Dan! I'm glad you have Chad to work with you. Looking forward to hearing more.
Fascinating information, thank you both🙏. When I visited Petra in 2017 I had a few discussions about this topic with local Muslims. The standard argument against Mohammed and the birth of Islam being set it Petra was that it was controlled by the Byzantines and that no pagan worship was permitted there at all. I'm glad to now have these background facts.
@@sirac4600: The Muslims of Jordan don't all know this...🙄
@@sandytatham3592 My friend, No Muslim knows about these things because they are followers of illiterate man. Only a few those who study higher level of Islam knows about it and they are keeping silent about it so how can their uneducated people learn the Truth?
So thanks for pointing out Muslims of Jordan don't know about it. Even they (poeple of Jordan) do not know that they are children of Lot!
I find it so interesting that this is used as an argument by every day people against the Petra issue. The fact that the edict against pagan worship was issued multiple times should be enough to suggest something's fishy. But when I dug around for accounts of pagans in Byzantium at the time, there was just no end (never mind the war). I'm glad we could provide a little clarity.
@@chaddoell
Many thanks for your reply, Chad. I got a similar but fairly angry response from a tour guide in the north of Jordan at the historic Jerash site as from a couple of men in Petra. It seems like it's a standard argument that Muslims tell people like me because they don't have any real rebuttal. But it caught me off guard at the time.
@@childofgod4862as long as you believe in holy books, do you know that all human beings were born as a result to a sexual relation between sister and brother (killer, he killed hus brother to rape his sister).
In addition to the fact, that Ruth (so mentioned in Bible and old testament) she is from Moab, and she is the grand mother of king David .
And don't forget that most of Egyptians pharaohs were married there sisters and many other civilisations did this until recently
💯👏
Appreciated the insightful connections between the relationship of “The Way” with later Christianity ✝️ & that of “the Turning” (Hanafiyya) with later Islam ☪️
bismAllab
قُلۡ إِنَّنِي هَدَىٰنِي رَبِّيٓ إِلَىٰ صِرَٰطٖ مُّسۡتَقِيمٖ دِينٗا قِيَمٗا مِّلَّةَ إِبۡرَٰهِيمَ
حَنِيفٗاۚ➡️
وَمَا كَانَ مِنَ ٱلۡمُشۡرِكِينَ
(161) Say, "Indeed, my Lord has guided me to a straight path - a correct religion - the way of Abraham, inclining toward truth. And he was not among those who associated others with Allāh."
6:161
salaam
I'm eager to see this but you should link to Part 1 because I saw this first in my feed
Sir your sound is not clear. Pls get a good microphone. Keep up the good work
good effort lads
the other interesting Quibla note: from my location in Western Canada, shortest path isn’t East, it’s over-the-pole North, same as an airplane would fly it. 😂 so, there’s an interesting dichotomy, 2 people praying towards the exact same place could be facing nearly 90-degrees apart. 😮
Excellent info. No Muslims scholars have done anything to search the Truth about Islam but our Christian brothers have spend their time and money to investigate about the Root of Islam. God bless them especially Dan Gibson and his assistants
The statistical and navigational information is highly persuasive. One of the basic questions is whether a pattern that the eye sees (the arrows sort of point to Petra or the Between or Mecca) is statistically significant. It looks like a reputable statistician has used the data and shown that this is the case. Another basic question of statistical analysis is data quality. Dan has clearly done enormous work gathering the data and compiling it in such a way as to be independently verified. Even a determined critic such as Dr King has come around to accepting the veracity of the data. Given the statistical significance of the data, it becomes necessary to posit a means available to the early Muslims to accurately point qiblas towards Petra. It looks like Dan has done this, finding a method that was available at the time. This method deserves independent research too: Were Muslim merchants documented among those typically using this method? What errors typically would occur using this method and do the errors we find match this expected scale of error?
I have a question. Dan, may I send it by email?
doesn't the Petra Kaba point towards Alexandria, if you follow the Qibla logic?
Dear Mr.Dan ,I watch all videos just I want to ask very important question my question is if CABE is at Petra, so why is ZAMZAM WATER at Mecca ?
Zamzam was originally in Petra. When the QIbla switched to Mecca, they simply renamed the well in Saudi as Zamzam. The names all moved, not the original places.
come to the city of Derbent in the Republic of Dagestan, there is a very old mosque
I have researched both the Derbent Friday Mosque and the Friday Mosque of Sheikh Muhammad Yaragsky. The later mosque faces 290 km north of Jerusalem, and I have not firmly established the direction of the Derbent Friday Mosque but it appears to face almost south. Both mosques appear to be very poorly aligned. Is there another old mosque in this city?
It is claimed that in 733, one mosque was built in each of the 7 mahallahs of Derbent but I have been unable to locate any of the remains of these mosques. The Derbent Mosque was built in addition to these early mosques for the common Friday prayer. I have not been able to clearly date any of the existing mosques before 1368 although it appears locals like to think it was built in 733.
@@DanGibsonFilms Dan, I don't have enough information about mosques, but there is another mosque of the 9th-13th century, in the settlement of Kala-Koreish 90 kilometers from Derbent, they say this mosque of the Seljuks of the Khazars who converted to Islam, there are also their cemeteries there.And there is also an 11th century mosque in the village of Richa, also about 80-100 km from Derbent, If I can help you with anything, I will be happy to help, at what email address can I contact you?I would also like to add that Derbent was conquered without a fight by Salman and Abd ar Rahman ibn Rabiya (according to Islamic history), the governor of Derbent Shahrbaraz voluntarily surrendered the city and agreed to be the guide of the Arabs, back in 650. I can also inform you that in the place where Nizami Ganjavi Park now stands, there was an old cemetery, most of which is buried under a construction site
Dan Gipson, are you Muslim yourself?
When did the Jordan area become a Muslim nation…that is an important question and something I have never heard of…also in the Quran it says be Muslims and then when your heart truly believes then you become a Momin ❤
Hi dan.
Very interesting !
Hi Dan, can you please search for the roots of Islam or For Islamic history depending on historical evidences and not depending on Islamic books. No one can trust books were written in mid. Asia, thousands of kilos far from our area, they speak different language and they wrote their books after around 200 years after Mohammads time
This is my question to .
I hope you answer.
Thanks.
HOW ABOUT " AL ULA" ? OLD CITY OF NABATIAN IN ARAB SAUDI.
I cover Meda'in Saleh, the old name for al'Ula on the website: nabataea.net/explore/medain_saleh/ No mosques faced this city, Just the city of Rekem, known today as Petra.
I want to share with you an important verse from the Quran that I believe has a geographical connection to your thesis.
This verse tells us that the sea is close to the Sacred House
Surah 5.Al-Maida (95 & 96)
96. To hunt and to eat the fish of the sea is made lawful for you, a provision for you and for seafarers; but to hunt on land is forbidden you so long as ye are on the pilgrimage. Be mindful of your duty to Allah, unto Whom ye will be gathered.
P.S. Do not forget also to look at verse 95, as it lays out the consequences of breaking the prohibition order. Therefore, it is very important that the sea be very close to those in the Sacred House, as religion is a religion of ease, not a religion of hardship.
We are looking at the truth as it is. Currently, I am very interested in your thesis. I see that it carries a lot of logical arguments.
original islam wasn't a religion. it was a call to submission to peace amongst all the other competing religions and beliefs.
If Petra is a new Mecca, How could possibly Prophet Muhammad SAW travel for over 1000km to perform his first pilgrimage from Medina?
The distance is actually less than 1000 km. But it is a long distance, but it is not impossible. Caravans had been traveling from Yemen to Gaza via Petra for many years, so the caravan routes were well known, and watering spots were all identified.
@@DanGibsonFilms😅😂 Bad Scandal you're trying. PSEUDO science is Crime, you're Too Much Obsessed dan gibson ! I see your your MASK😅
@@RAMZ1Kid go to school
Hi dan.
First to comment
Dan Gipson, are you Muslim yourself?
No he not, he a Christian, but this is a Channel about Archaeology
dan gibson 😂😅are you sleeping 😅Wake Up. I know dan gibson, Actually you're Only Try make your own people Got dream come true 😅😂pity poor dan gibson
The term is "home in," not "hone in." It's distracting to hear a smart, educated influencer make such an elementary mistake
I suggest you should back to 1st grade
This is the typical kind and level of "argument" you get from Muslims. Name-calling.