I like the Barracuda, but i'm surely biased because i love the old 1016. People despise 'clomages' and oftentimes correctly, but i believe that long discontinued watches (or references, in this case) shouldn't be treated like that since the real ones are essentially unobtainable today anyway.
@@liasummers1824 He mentions the watch being easily available, so is the movement. He also mentions the quality for the value, which is also there in the NH36. So, what are you trying to say? That it’s basic? It still ticks off those boxes. Makes no sense lol
Great vid. I like your approach comparing them on their own merits vs any sort of point system like some reviewers do. I do really like the patina of the WMT. Not sure I'd buy it as my only Explorer homage though, at least not that version. The Smiths is great as well. I like the Islander, esp if you prefer an 'inspired by' approach rather than a strong homage. I bought an 36mm Alpha for cheap and... it was OK, but just feels relatively cheap. It's fine on wrist but when handling it, it is pretty subpar. No Miyota stutter on mine. Then I got a Tisell a while back. I went for the 39mm. They are creeping up in price. Mine was $225 when I bought it. Some may say it is too derivative but it doesn't say 'Rolex' so I prefer to think of it as a very close homage. Great bracelet and clasp as well though I usually wear it on a grey vintage leather strap. It's a top five watch for me. Maybe top three.
The smiths everest is truly a great watch. The anti magnetism at that price totally blow any competition away. Its truly a watch that can be that one watch collection..
Really cool video. Well done. Personally I love the Smiths version, it just has that little something. I love the Serica and it has been on my radar for a while. Glad I did not buy it when it came out initially after the terrible issues with the crown.
I own three Smiths: an Everest, Commando (with acrylic crystal and tropical dial) and a Silver Jubilee (with aventurine dial and jubilee bracelet). All 3 are superb watches. I also own a 124270 Explorer, which I love. Great channel, subscribed!
I used to own a smiths I sold it because it looked tiny compared to a rolex explorer. The islander sits to proud makes it look odd. And the other one I don't like the dial
Very nice variety! I’ve got my Lorier Falcon II that sort of scratches that itch. I really like the acrylic crystal on it. I’d still love an Explorer, though. Did you see the Rangemaster collab this week between TGV & Marc from LIW? They looked really nice!
If you’re ever able to get your hands on the Falcon 3 I highly recommend it. Definitely scratched that explorer itch for me while also not being a direct copy. Feels very much like it’s own thing.
Islander watches came out with the Rangemaster a couple years back and it takes inspiration from the Rolex explorer, Tudor ranger, Seiko Sarb033, etc, it’s 38mm 100 meters wr, sapphire glass with AR coating, solid links with solid female end links, BGW9 superluminova and finally a Miyota 9039 Hi-beat automatic movement inside.
I love the explorer and one day I will own one. My personal favorites that are in my collection that fit in the place of the explorer are the Tudor BB36 mines in blue but the black version would probably be a better explorer alternative. The Lorier Falcon I have the gen 2 but the new Gen 3 is good alternative. And out of left field is my Sinn 556. It can go anywhere and do anything, wonderful quality and impressive specs, 200m, high and low pressure resistant, and anti magnetic. The bracelet even comes with a dive extension even though its not a diver. But there's tons of options because the explorer is a legend and is probably favorite Rolex model.
@@igorz.3972 I currently own the Sinn 556 A RS and I've also owned the Sinn 556IB blue dial with applied markers which I regret selling. Even though they are the same watch having both didn't seem repetitive because they looked so different. I sold the 556IB because I just got the Tudor BB36 in blue as well as a Lorier Falcon 2 in blue and I didn't want 3 similar watches but now that I have the BB36 in blue and it is a gorgeous watch I think the Sinn 556IB really did give it a run for it's money. The specs are better. The brushed finish with that dial and fine link bracelet had amazing light play. I personally think its better looking than the Oyster Perpetual as well. The Sinn 556A RS is like my "explorerish" watch that I take with me on my weekend outdoor/vacation stuff. Regular people don't know what it is so I don't have a chance of getting stalked and robbed over having a nice watch on and it's up to any task. The 556 can literally go anywhere do anything the bracelet even has a dive extension. If you want a more dressy watch I'd get the one with applied indices and a wicked dial. If you want a under the radar rock solid tool watch get the Regular 556A or 556I. I liked the 556A RS because I like 3,6,9 dials because it's easy to tell the time at a very quick glance and in the dark due to it having more lume. The red seconds hand throws in just a pop of color.
How would you compare the Smiths Everest PRS-25 with the Lorier Falcon? They are about the same price, but what would the pros and cons be of either as an explorer alternative?
Nice review but so many miss the best homage. The Zeno super precision is very very good, like the original it uses acrylic and and a new old stock AS movement that has been serviced. The newest ones are now using Miyota movements but you can still find some with the AS if you take the time to look around.
Love the explorer im wearing a great little tisell explorer Sapphire, glide lock, super accurate miyota 9015 , great lume . Didn't really get the explorer hype at first but i get it now. Mark and islander watches are amazing and continue to get better. He is plugged in and pays attention to the watch community and delivers great quality at a great price and is top notch business.
Nice review(s). Just liked & subscribed. I previously owned a Z-serial 114270. I loved the design & execution, but it was just too small for my 7.5" wrist. Then I tried the Exp 39mm Mk1. Kept it for 8 yrs, but finally couldn't take the short hands, lol. Now I'm collecting Exp homages. Steinhart, Tisell, Addiesdive, San Martin, and a beautiful 40mm PRS-25 Smiths Everest. Super-happy with all of them and I'm looking to add a few more, lol. Will check out your other reviews.
Hey, at the end of the day, it’s what ticks boxes. They all tell time and it’s not always worth spending thousands for a Rolex. The T-Rex if funny looking 😄😄😄. Out of homages I think the Lorier Falcon does it for me the most 🙋🏻♂️🥃
Hi Leo Nice vid. Would prefer the Smiths as it has the same history. Can always prepare a defense going “why the Smiths is really better as a watch and a better choice” (-for a poor bummer such as me😆)... No, off cause the Explorer is the King. But honestly I really would prefer the Smiths as an alternative. Wouldn’t say that Rolex’s isn’t worth the money, but the prices are downright shameless...
The Smiths is a great choice, if bought at the retail price is an insane value. I’ve seen them on eBay for 1000. That’s also shameless 😂😂😂. The Expl 1 truly is an astonishing watch.
Nice job, very smooth music background. Based on "This gives you the exact same feeling on the wrist" I just ordered another Islander. Just can't wait. Thank you Sir!
Marc is a great guy, and I have several Islander watches, but if I bought the Islander Explorer I'd have to replace the hands. Even stick hands would be better.
@@maciej6293 The hands are flieger hands, not appropriate for this kind of watch. I'd replace with stick hands (like a field watch) or cathedral hands, like the Explorer.
Great review, all of the watches appeal to my taste I particularly like this style of watch and yeah being of a certain age nostalgia is becoming my thing
I have a San Martin Explorer homage and have an Islander Manhasset on the way. I think the San Martin is too much of a direct copy of the Rolex. I also barely wear mine because it’s 40mm, not the size i’d like. Personally after having multiple San Martins and Islanders, I prefer Islander. Imo the only thing San Martin does better is their beautiful case finishing. At the price it’s arguably unmatched, however I think islander has better lume, customer service, and overall dial selection.
I own an Explorer 39 carbon copy Steinhart Adventure. Fake it till you make it, baby. From this selection, the Smiths appeals the most to me, but the only way to be sure would require handling them in person.
@@LeoVinteler Ya, its priced well for what it offers, especially the grade 2 Sellita movement. The aesthetic design is highly derivative, but nobody can tell the difference between a Rolex and a Timex anyway, much less identify it as an Explorer.
I like the Barracuda, but i'm surely biased because i love the old 1016. People despise 'clomages' and oftentimes correctly, but i believe that long discontinued watches (or references, in this case) shouldn't be treated like that since the real ones are essentially unobtainable today anyway.
Islander is not trying to hard to be a direct copy, its avaliable easily and is amazingly good quality and value.
Can’t agree more 🙋🏻♂️🍷
not with that basic movement
@@liasummers1824 He mentions the watch being easily available, so is the movement. He also mentions the quality for the value, which is also there in the NH36. So, what are you trying to say? That it’s basic? It still ticks off those boxes. Makes no sense lol
Trying *too* hard
Nice watches. When you clanked the Rolex and smiths together. My eye twitched 😅
My ❤️ did 😃😃😃
Just got an Islander. Thoroughly scratches the itch. I appreciate the large numbers and the elegant handset.
It’s a nice piece. I enjoyed it 🙋🏻♂️🍷
I appreciate your review style. Very hard to find channels that review watches based on their own merits. Thanks for sharing
Thx brother. I really appreciate you saying that 🙋🏻♂️🤝🍻
Good vid. I have an Isl 73 in 38 mm. Love it!
I just got an Addiesdive AD2023, it looks as good as these with sapphire glass, for £39 delivered! How that's a bargain!
Great video brother. Keep up the amazing work 👏
Great vid. I like your approach comparing them on their own merits vs any sort of point system like some reviewers do. I do really like the patina of the WMT. Not sure I'd buy it as my only Explorer homage though, at least not that version. The Smiths is great as well. I like the Islander, esp if you prefer an 'inspired by' approach rather than a strong homage. I bought an 36mm Alpha for cheap and... it was OK, but just feels relatively cheap. It's fine on wrist but when handling it, it is pretty subpar. No Miyota stutter on mine. Then I got a Tisell a while back. I went for the 39mm. They are creeping up in price. Mine was $225 when I bought it. Some may say it is too derivative but it doesn't say 'Rolex' so I prefer to think of it as a very close homage. Great bracelet and clasp as well though I usually wear it on a grey vintage leather strap. It's a top five watch for me. Maybe top three.
Cheers friend. There are allot of options out there 🙋🏻♂️🍻
I own all of the above watches. The islander is by far the most preferred for daily wear , on par with the Rolex
If you ever think of selling your wmt please let me know.
The Islander wins on three counts: I don't care for Mercedes hands, I like the lower cost, and I went to school in Manhasset!
It was my favorite also. 😂🍷
The smiths everest is truly a great watch. The anti magnetism at that price totally blow any competition away. Its truly a watch that can be that one watch collection..
I have to say, it’s very close to a one watch piece 🙋🏻♂️🤝🍻
Really cool video. Well done. Personally I love the Smiths version, it just has that little something. I love the Serica and it has been on my radar for a while. Glad I did not buy it when it came out initially after the terrible issues with the crown.
The Smiths is very nice. What Serica are you referring to? The field watch?
@@LeoVinteler Sorry, I thought you knew. The 5303. First batch plagued with crown problems.
@@johnswatchjoint I did hear about it. It has been resolved for a while, from what I’m told by a few owners. 🙋🏻♂️🍻
I own three Smiths: an Everest, Commando (with acrylic crystal and tropical dial) and a Silver Jubilee (with aventurine dial and jubilee bracelet). All 3 are superb watches. I also own a 124270 Explorer, which I love. Great channel, subscribed!
Cheers 🥃💪🏻
Smiths on that jubilee looks the business 👍
I know right. I wonder what the Explorer looks on a jubi, but the oyster bracelet is sooooo good tho
@@LeoVinteler I’m just staring at mine now. It’s a handsome thing!
I used to own a smiths I sold it because it looked tiny compared to a rolex explorer. The islander sits to proud makes it look odd. And the other one I don't like the dial
Well than a Lorier Falcon would do. Or just the Explorer 1 🙋🏻♂️🍻
I like the smiths, dont know how they do it for the price though. They could charge double and still sell out in a day.
Idk either 😂😂 but it’s a hell of a watch 🙋🏻♂️🍷
Smiths for me. 😊👌
Very nice variety! I’ve got my Lorier Falcon II that sort of scratches that itch. I really like the acrylic crystal on it. I’d still love an Explorer, though.
Did you see the Rangemaster collab this week between TGV & Marc from LIW? They looked really nice!
Same, I've got the white dial variant and wear it as my daily driver. Still would love a black dial with arabic numerals, though, what can I say!
@@ten_oclock_scholar4690 Mine is the black/gilt…I really like that white/silver, too! That is a nice-looking watch.
I had the blue one for a week or so. Sure is a cool piece.
If you’re ever able to get your hands on the Falcon 3 I highly recommend it. Definitely scratched that explorer itch for me while also not being a direct copy. Feels very much like it’s own thing.
The rangemaster looks interesting, have to get one in hand to feel the magic 🙋🏻♂️🍷
Does the 36mm Islander Manhasset bracelet fit on the 36 mm Smith’s Everest case?
I don’t know. Didn’t swap bracelets
@@LeoVinteler I would appreciate if you could try and let me know? I am looking for a replacement bracelet for my Smiths Everest. Thank you.
Smiths
Have yet to see the entire video, but I already love it!!! 3 minutes into it!!!
Hope you enjoyed it!
Islander
Abbigail Ramp
Loved the video - subscribed !!! Planning to buy SMITHS EVEREST PRS-25 - 36MM - GILT DIAL
Sure is a looker 🍷 hope you get one 🙋🏻♂️
The wmt looks great
The islander looks cheap. It just doesn't carry the same balance as the others. It looks like a knock-off... To me, at least.
You missed the very best Rolex 1016 homage and that is the Zeno Zex super precision using a refurbished AS movement.
EYE Lander 😂 Got rid of the ice and still can't say it right 🤣
I’ll never get it 🤦🏻♂️
Have you looked into any of the Pagani, Steeldive, Addiesdive, Tandorio versions?? Check ‘em out
How about Traska watches
Solid video Leo.
Thx my friend.
Smiths wins for me, numbers look too big on the islander IMO
Smiths is very nice, no doubt. Islander 369 look nice in person.
A good watch with history is nivada watch. Similar to Rolex explorer.
I hear that, just recently I saw one. 🙋🏻♂️🍷
@@LeoVinteler but I do like the Smith, owing that to your video. I'm on their waiting list. Thank you.
@@praktikalpinoytechgsm8496 it’s a very nice piece 🙋🏻♂️🍷. Hope you quick 1-2 min and it’s sold out 😂👍🏻
Like most the TGV/Islander. Thx 4 yo review. Get going 🚀
Islander watches came out with the Rangemaster a couple years back and it takes inspiration from the Rolex explorer, Tudor ranger, Seiko Sarb033, etc, it’s 38mm 100 meters wr, sapphire glass with AR coating, solid links with solid female end links, BGW9 superluminova and finally a Miyota 9039 Hi-beat automatic movement inside.
I know. I’ve seen one. 🤌
I couldn't watch you scratching up the watches against each other :D may God be with you
I love the explorer and one day I will own one. My personal favorites that are in my collection that fit in the place of the explorer are the Tudor BB36 mines in blue but the black version would probably be a better explorer alternative. The Lorier Falcon I have the gen 2 but the new Gen 3 is good alternative. And out of left field is my Sinn 556. It can go anywhere and do anything, wonderful quality and impressive specs, 200m, high and low pressure resistant, and anti magnetic. The bracelet even comes with a dive extension even though its not a diver. But there's tons of options because the explorer is a legend and is probably favorite Rolex model.
Which Sinn would you recommend 556i or 556a ?
@@igorz.3972 I currently own the Sinn 556 A RS and I've also owned the Sinn 556IB blue dial with applied markers which I regret selling. Even though they are the same watch having both didn't seem repetitive because they looked so different. I sold the 556IB because I just got the Tudor BB36 in blue as well as a Lorier Falcon 2 in blue and I didn't want 3 similar watches but now that I have the BB36 in blue and it is a gorgeous watch I think the Sinn 556IB really did give it a run for it's money. The specs are better. The brushed finish with that dial and fine link bracelet had amazing light play. I personally think its better looking than the Oyster Perpetual as well. The Sinn 556A RS is like my "explorerish" watch that I take with me on my weekend outdoor/vacation stuff. Regular people don't know what it is so I don't have a chance of getting stalked and robbed over having a nice watch on and it's up to any task. The 556 can literally go anywhere do anything the bracelet even has a dive extension. If you want a more dressy watch I'd get the one with applied indices and a wicked dial. If you want a under the radar rock solid tool watch get the Regular 556A or 556I. I liked the 556A RS because I like 3,6,9 dials because it's easy to tell the time at a very quick glance and in the dark due to it having more lume. The red seconds hand throws in just a pop of color.
The extensions on watches aren't just for dive suits, they are also used over the top of flight suits.
The wrist check would have been hilarious if you had on a Rolex Explorer.
How would you compare the Smiths Everest PRS-25 with the Lorier Falcon? They are about the same price, but what would the pros and cons be of either as an explorer alternative?
The smiths looks just like a Rolex, let’s be honest. Nice watch but a homage 💯
The Falcon is different, see my video Falcon VS the Explorer 🙋🏻♂️🍻
Amazing review! This is exactly what i needed to see. Side by side comparisons to a real explorer!
Hope it helps 🙋🏻♂️
I bought the Smiths Everest, so beautiful, but on my 7.5" wrist it looks tiny.
It does look small, even on my 6 3/4 wrist, but amazing at the same time 🙋🏻♂️🥃
Nice review but so many miss the best homage. The Zeno super precision is very very good, like the original it uses acrylic and and a new old stock AS movement that has been serviced. The newest ones are now using Miyota movements but you can still find some with the AS if you take the time to look around.
Check out the Nivada Grenchen Antarctic. By far the best alternative to the Explorer 1.
Love the explorer im wearing a great little tisell explorer Sapphire, glide lock, super accurate miyota 9015 , great lume . Didn't really get the explorer hype at first but i get it now. Mark and islander watches are amazing and continue to get better. He is plugged in and pays attention to the watch community and delivers great quality at a great price and is top notch business.
Absolutely, Marc does listen and makes great pieces. Yes, The Explorer is one amazing piece 💪🏻
Nice review(s). Just liked & subscribed. I previously owned a Z-serial 114270. I loved the design & execution, but it was just too small for my 7.5" wrist. Then I tried the Exp 39mm Mk1. Kept it for 8 yrs, but finally couldn't take the short hands, lol. Now I'm collecting Exp homages. Steinhart, Tisell, Addiesdive, San Martin, and a beautiful 40mm PRS-25 Smiths Everest. Super-happy with all of them and I'm looking to add a few more, lol. Will check out your other reviews.
Hey, at the end of the day, it’s what ticks boxes. They all tell time and it’s not always worth spending thousands for a Rolex. The T-Rex if funny looking 😄😄😄. Out of homages I think the Lorier Falcon does it for me the most 🙋🏻♂️🥃
Nivada Grenchen Antarctic -- the best alternative.
The Nivada Antarctic 3-6-9 is an amazing option
WmT, looks very vintage
Hi Leo
Nice vid. Would prefer the Smiths as it has the same history. Can always prepare a defense going “why the Smiths is really better as a watch and a better choice” (-for a poor bummer such as me😆)...
No, off cause the Explorer is the King. But honestly I really would prefer the Smiths as an alternative. Wouldn’t say that Rolex’s isn’t worth the money, but the prices are downright shameless...
The Smiths is a great choice, if bought at the retail price is an insane value. I’ve seen them on eBay for 1000. That’s also shameless 😂😂😂. The Expl 1 truly is an astonishing watch.
Very nice video. Thank you for this. I would like to buy the WMT. Too bad it's not available.
It is at times. 🙋🏻♂️
my heart is aching. you are rubbing the watches against each other... gosh :D
No aching here. These are tool watches, not porcelain collectibles.
Nice job, very smooth music background. Based on "This gives you the exact same feeling on the wrist" I just ordered another Islander. Just can't wait. Thank you Sir!
Cool man. Enjoy. Cheers 🙋🏻♂️🥃
What is your wrist size?
6 3/4. 🙋🏻♂️🍷
This Serica is such a stunner. I like the Smiths the most personally. Have you ever checked out the Traska Summiteer? It's a nice one too.
The Serica is amazing. Did not see a Traska yet 🙋🏻♂️🍷
Check out the Nivada Grenchen Antarctic. By far the best Explorer 1 alternative.
@@atticus6572 heard good things about that one too!
Great comparison, love WMT, Smiths, Rolex then Islander in that order
Subscribed & will watch your previous👍🏻
Thx Jon. Cheers brother 🙋🏻♂️🍷
Marc is a great guy, and I have several Islander watches, but if I bought the Islander Explorer I'd have to replace the hands.
Even stick hands would be better.
Why? What's wrong with the hands?
@@maciej6293 The hands are flieger hands, not appropriate for this kind of watch.
I'd replace with stick hands (like a field watch) or cathedral hands, like the Explorer.
Smiths 👍
Great review, all of the watches appeal to my taste I particularly like this style of watch and yeah being of a certain age nostalgia is becoming my thing
Thx Brian. Cheers 🙋🏻♂️🍷
@@LeoVinteler 👍
Smiths
i just found your channel and i love it please keep it going
Thank you 🙋🏻♂️
Nice job
Superb comparison. Thank you.
Cheers 🥂
I dare you to buy or borrow a San Martin explorer homage. I resisted the brand for a long time but the quality for $ is unmatched.
I have a San Martin Explorer homage and have an Islander Manhasset on the way. I think the San Martin is too much of a direct copy of the Rolex. I also barely wear mine because it’s 40mm, not the size i’d like. Personally after having multiple San Martins and Islanders, I prefer Islander. Imo the only thing San Martin does better is their beautiful case finishing. At the price it’s arguably unmatched, however I think islander has better lume, customer service, and overall dial selection.
I own an Explorer 39 carbon copy Steinhart Adventure. Fake it till you make it, baby. From this selection, the Smiths appeals the most to me, but the only way to be sure would require handling them in person.
The steiny is really nice. I seen one recently. Not bad
@@LeoVinteler Ya, its priced well for what it offers, especially the grade 2 Sellita movement. The aesthetic design is highly derivative, but nobody can tell the difference between a Rolex and a Timex anyway, much less identify it as an Explorer.
@@LeoVinteler I like the 39 Steinheart as well. Swiss made, drilled lugs, nicely done dial. You should do a review on it.
@@waynehatton4136 I don’t hav one 😂😂 or know anyone who has one