Road Wheel Showdown - Zipp, Reserve, Enve, Roval, Bontrager

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 25 дек 2024

Комментарии • 143

  • @bikemellon
    @bikemellon 2 месяца назад +13

    this video looked like a total pain to make - thanks for going through with it and giving us that good stuff! keep up the great work

  • @pauldunne3094
    @pauldunne3094 2 месяца назад +7

    I have so many subscriptions, absorb so much content and you two are my favourite. Perfect balance of natural friendship inspired humour with valuable trade insights and attention to detail. Top job....love it

  • @eumundy8452
    @eumundy8452 2 месяца назад +9

    My Reserve 52/63 in a 240 hub weigh 1,558g. I believe the Reserve 42/49s in a 240 hub should sit around 1390g to 1420g. Killer wheels!
    Another issue with the bontragers is that the rim strips that come stock with them weigh close to 75g a wheel, which is a tonne!

  • @LMKF
    @LMKF 2 месяца назад +1

    Great video! As usual you express your opinions and thoughts clearly and directly! Even if you sell these wheels you are very transparent and honest.

  • @atgnicyclist
    @atgnicyclist 2 месяца назад +2

    Feel so good after watching this and reading the Grandfondo article. I’ve just bought some Reserve 52/63. Crappy zipp hubs but they’ll do until next year and then I’ll swap them for some DT 180.
    Great video fella.

  • @sidelnik
    @sidelnik 2 месяца назад +7

    Good comparison. Would love to see a similar video with gravel wheels (e.g., Reserve 40/44 GR, Zipp 303 xplr, Roval Terra, etc.)

    • @bicyclestation
      @bicyclestation  2 месяца назад +7

      That’s in the works. Gotta buy some new wheels lol

  • @alainpfammatter8224
    @alainpfammatter8224 2 месяца назад +1

    Thank you very much for this interesting test. I know its a lot of effort and work but its worth it. Thats the test we cycling nerds wanna see.

  • @timfarhaven9647
    @timfarhaven9647 2 месяца назад +5

    Loved the video and loved the results, since I have a set of Reserve 52/63 with the DT 240's. When I weighed mine (with rim tape, no valves) the total was 1549 gram. So not sure if Reserve is being on the safe side with the claimed weight or I got lucky with a light set.
    Again, loved the vid and can't wait for future content. Keep up the great work!

  • @karlmustermann6005
    @karlmustermann6005 2 месяца назад +5

    After testing the reserve wheels it would be so interesting if you would get the CRW Works 50-60 they are like 1250g for the set same profile and not that expensive.

  • @grith1983
    @grith1983 15 дней назад +1

    I've got 303 firecrest on my road bike, 303s on a gravel bike and reserve 40/44 on my titanium gravel bike. I've only ridden the reserves a couple of times but they're fast really fast even with a nobbly tyre on the road. The build quality feels better than zipps as well.

  • @BrotherMichigan
    @BrotherMichigan 2 месяца назад +5

    For true consistency, rather than setting the pressure to be the same for each wheelset, you should set the pressure to obtain the same drop when loaded with a rider. Since that's actually a huge PITA, using something like the Silca tire pressure calculator to set the pressure according to the measured width of the tire (which aims to basically achieve the same thing) would also work.

    • @bicyclestation
      @bicyclestation  2 месяца назад +6

      That’s fair. I think what we did is more real world though. Most customers know what pressure they run and don’t divert from that once they decide.

  • @DP-PhD
    @DP-PhD 2 месяца назад +3

    Informative and entertaining. Great content guys!

  • @duncancycles
    @duncancycles Месяц назад +2

    Farsports, Magene, and No.6 wheels !

  • @garyfan3526
    @garyfan3526 2 месяца назад +3

    My mind is ready

  • @Dali6266
    @Dali6266 2 месяца назад +1

    Great vid guys 👍 I may have missed it during your introduction, what tyres were you running & do you recommend them❓Keep up the great work👌

  • @BOYDDAWLER
    @BOYDDAWLER 5 дней назад

    4 months into using Reserves 3437 on my gravel. 5stars in every category I can think of.

  • @Graz23
    @Graz23 8 дней назад

    353 are good also for gravel?

  • @ChinCycling
    @ChinCycling 2 месяца назад +2

    I would’ve liked to see the Enve 4.5s instead of the 3.4s

  • @MGPCycling
    @MGPCycling 2 месяца назад

    dang, wish you had been able to add Princeton Wake Evolution 6560 to the mix! great roundup overall though.

  • @jordanyoung8868
    @jordanyoung8868 2 месяца назад

    Would love to see you guys do an overview or review on the new gen checkpoint. Been riding it myself and have really enjoyed it.

    • @bicyclestation
      @bicyclestation  2 месяца назад

      We will be doing an in depth review of the checkmate I know that for sure. We haven’t gotten a checkpoint in yet

    • @jordanyoung8868
      @jordanyoung8868 2 месяца назад

      @@bicyclestation Awesome to hear that about the checkmate. Thanks for the reply.

  • @Vinch22
    @Vinch22 2 месяца назад +6

    I have Roval Rapide CLX II and CL II very fast even in climbs and stable in crosswinds too! Based on experience, they are worth the price. I am delighted to own them.✌

    • @EddyCat1234
      @EddyCat1234 2 месяца назад

      I recently purchased the Rapide CL II thinking the cheap ones would be fine as they are the same rim. Do the CLX II performance any better? Also, is there much difference in weight? Thanks!

    • @LOGICAL-JAY
      @LOGICAL-JAY 2 месяца назад +2

      ​@EddyCat1234 CLii and the CLXii are the same shape..the CLXii just uses different hubs and bladed spokes..but honestly I own both and I still can't feel the difference..I love my CLii wheels on my SL7 because of the 350 hub which is so easy to clean, maintain and swap out ratchets ..my CLXii wheels are on my newer s-works tarmac SL8 and they feel great as well..the weight difference is so small between the CL and CLX wheels that the average rider probably wouldn't feel the difference..they say the CLXii wheels spin better because of the ceramic hubs and less rolling resistance due to bladed spokes..I like both

    • @EddyCat1234
      @EddyCat1234 2 месяца назад

      @@LOGICAL-JAY thx Jay. Much appreciated

    • @LOGICAL-JAY
      @LOGICAL-JAY 2 месяца назад

      ​@EddyCat1234 anytime bro..you're welcome..

  • @SNS1212
    @SNS1212 2 месяца назад +2

    I was hoping the tree boys would make another appearance.

  • @disloyalyou5455
    @disloyalyou5455 2 месяца назад

    The rovals with the white decals look real good in the s5

  • @davidlau2467
    @davidlau2467 2 месяца назад +1

    Science is great. Naturally the Reserves would come out on top as they were designed integrally with the Cervelo S5. Naturally the Zipp 353NSWs should be the slowest, being less deep than the rest and the tyre blowing out to be wider than the wheel itself.

  • @thomasabbott2277
    @thomasabbott2277 9 дней назад

    Please put time stamps in the next version of this video should you do one

  • @alexjohnson6462
    @alexjohnson6462 2 месяца назад

    Do you guys do overlanding with your trucks? Or at least go camping with them? Either content would be interesting.
    There is a bit of content overlap between the bikepacking community and the overlanding or truck camping community. I see more and more guys bringing their bicycles along (gravel or mountain) to do some exploring of the jeep trails when they set up camp for the night with their truck.
    You guys are close enough to northwest Arkansas to do a road trip down there to maybe join some fellow RUclipsrs at Ozark Overlanding on one of their weekend outings. Maybe ask them to do a channel collab and tell them to take you on one of the easier (not too technical) offroad trips with your truck... and then you Bicycle Station boys can set out on your own and do some mountain biking on the jeep roads after truck camp set up for the day.

  • @christophercarr7971
    @christophercarr7971 2 месяца назад

    I'm 195lbs, should I be afraid of failure on 454s? Looking at a bike that comes with them, on the fence because of the Zipps. You guys are awesome!

    • @nickspano4709
      @nickspano4709 2 месяца назад

      I would avoid the 454s just because you weight & the fact those zipps are hookless. For a road setup, this would mean your optimal tire pressure is going to be closer to the maximum pressure of 72psi for hookless. I would go with a hooked wheel at your weight even if you do run lower pressure than the limit. I would take a look at the new 42/49 Reserve wheels, I bet you would love them. They are bombproof, hooked rim, super fast & light for their depth + lifetime warranty.

    • @christophercarr7971
      @christophercarr7971 2 месяца назад

      @@nickspano4709 Thanks Nick. I was thinking the 52 63. Im 6'4" and ride an XL, thinking I need the bigger wheels to look good on an XL Canyon Aeroad.

    • @nickspano4709
      @nickspano4709 2 месяца назад

      ​@@christophercarr7971 Those would be a great option for a pure aero wheelset. I recommend the 42/49 because they are still super fast for their depth & were designed a bit more recently. Also they will be lighter & have better crosswind stability.
      That said, I am sure being 6'4" and riding XL you know how to handle the winds a bit better than small guys and those deeper wheels would definitely look better on the XL frame imo. Try to snag the version with DT240 or 180 and you won't be let down.

  • @JFomo
    @JFomo 2 месяца назад

    The Reserves also have the regular zipp hubs found on the firecrest wheels. Zipp has some explaining to do as to why there NSW wheels aren't as fast.
    Edit: Just remembered those Reserves where made specifically for the Cervelo. This might explain their performance.

    • @bicyclestation
      @bicyclestation  2 месяца назад

      I mentioned that but I think our editor cut it out. The nsw wheels are the oldest on text. I think that’s why they didn’t do as well. Everything is wider now.
      To be fair I still think the 353 is the best possible shallow wheelset

    • @JFomo
      @JFomo 2 месяца назад

      @@bicyclestation The nsw has the cognition hubs which is supposedly the upgraded hubs from the ZR1 found on the firecrest wheels - and if I'm not mistaken also found on the Reserves.
      I'm only a little salty because I have both Zipp 404 Firecrest and 353 NSWs. Still love Zipps.

    • @bicyclestation
      @bicyclestation  2 месяца назад

      I wouldn’t be salty about owning the zipps. I seriously think the 353s are great. They never were ment to be aero which is all we tested in this video

  • @himalvin1670
    @himalvin1670 2 месяца назад

    The rovals are good-looking, but they are heavy like 15xxg. I am thinking about the Cadex ut 50🤔

  • @chrissheldon2681
    @chrissheldon2681 2 месяца назад

    I am wondering how much of the heaviness of the Reserves is down to the Hub/Spokes vs just the rim, if the rims aren’t horrible, a 180 hub+ plus some sapim carbon spokes could make a dent.
    Do yall ever just buy the rims from reserve?

    • @bicyclestation
      @bicyclestation  2 месяца назад +1

      I just looked it up. It’s like 80 grams lighter for the 180 hubs. You’re right but it’s still significant at this scale. Don’t know the math on the spokes. Reserve says the 180 version weighs 1576

  • @mohamadjamil3164
    @mohamadjamil3164 2 месяца назад +4

    No truck stuff

  • @rayF4rio
    @rayF4rio 2 месяца назад +2

    I'm confused...about bicycle wheels.

  • @MagicM66
    @MagicM66 Месяц назад +1

    Where are the Princeton carbonworks

  • @realekm
    @realekm 2 месяца назад +7

    A few seconds difference among these wheels. Just buy what you can afford. All these wheels perform well imo.

  • @razorree
    @razorree 2 месяца назад

    they say 105% or 110% (rim wider than the tire)

  • @MazharAliz
    @MazharAliz 2 месяца назад

    Would've been nice if PCW Wake 6560 was included in the review

  • @JRopes.
    @JRopes. 2 месяца назад

    Do you think that that time advantage on the reserves could be partly due to them being designed along side the Cervelo?

  • @paytufo
    @paytufo 2 месяца назад

    Miss Princenton Wheels in the compare

  • @antoinetran900
    @antoinetran900 2 месяца назад

    I havent watched the video yet, but just dropped an ungodly amount of cash for zipp nsw over cheaper enve. hopefully i am not disappointed with the results

  • @bicyclestation
    @bicyclestation  Месяц назад

    Shop: www.thebicyclestation.com

  • @DanielVanderkemp
    @DanielVanderkemp 2 месяца назад

    Any reason you excluded the wheels that the TDF winner and world champion rides?

    • @atgnicyclist
      @atgnicyclist 2 месяца назад

      They couldn’t get the tyres inflated on them in the test.
      When I’ve had this I usually put a few layers normal narrow electrical tape on in the centre Chanel before putting the tubeless tape on. Helps make the inner channel make the tyre tighter.
      I’m sure there’s something about that in the enve instructions.

    • @DanielVanderkemp
      @DanielVanderkemp 2 месяца назад

      The GOAT rides ENVE 4.5’a not 3.4’s

    • @bicyclestation
      @bicyclestation  2 месяца назад

      We had 4.5s but then someone bought them so we didn’t have them to test anymore. Definitely good wheels. Just didn’t work out logically

  • @SMor42
    @SMor42 2 месяца назад +1

    Have you guys ever ridden any of the Chinese Farsports wheels? I wonder how they would compare considering how much cheaper they are.

    • @bicyclestation
      @bicyclestation  2 месяца назад +6

      Chinese wheelsets are cheeper because they don’t have employees you can call or functional warranty departments. I think they would perform fine. The issue is when they have a problem. That’s why western companies charge more. They have employees who you can talk to about the problems. The salary of these employees is wrapped up in the price of the product.

    • @jou3708
      @jou3708 2 месяца назад +2

      I have Farsports and Enve. Farsports quality of carbon is quite low. Its like different material than Enves. Stones hits (or whatever reason) cause pieces of rim lamination (or whatever it is) to chip. My wheels look like 10 years old after 2 years. Hubs are alright as they are DTswiss. Enves are bombproof rims and I suspect will last 10-15 years quite easily with intense use.

    • @bam0505
      @bam0505 2 месяца назад

      I’ve had a set of farsports with 240exp hubs and DT spokes. Price of the rim was like $100 doing the math so always figured if there was an issue I could replace the rim. And recently swapped them from hg to xdr in 10 seconds. The new stuff with proprietary hubs and carbon spokes is ridiculous. They might be decent quality, but if you break a spoke or need a new hub part….

    • @DanTuber
      @DanTuber 2 месяца назад +1

      @@jou3708 I have Farsports and they have been fine. No delamination. Yes they get scratched but nothing major and no different to any other wheels.

    • @jou3708
      @jou3708 2 месяца назад +1

      @@DanTuber yes, they are fine for average joe (in good way) with limited budget and moderate use, but in long term (let say 6-10 years) and more intense use, something like Enve will be cheaper and way more trouble-free option.

  • @crane1bl
    @crane1bl 2 месяца назад +1

    Not surprised, I googled it and humpback whales can only go like 16 mph. They didn't stand a chance.

  • @biirdm4n
    @biirdm4n 2 месяца назад

    6:07 your tire is on backwards

  • @CyclespeedTours
    @CyclespeedTours 2 месяца назад

    LOL, my pair of wheels weighs only a bit more than your back wheels......

  • @Zeben84
    @Zeben84 2 месяца назад +22

    Why are you not comparing them with fair priced wheels like Elitewheels, Yoeloe, Ican, Farsport and others ?

    • @bicyclestation
      @bicyclestation  2 месяца назад +56

      We own all these wheels sets and don’t own any of thoes wheelsets. Would be happy to if the brands wanted to send us a pair. Recently a brand I won’t name from China reached out and wanted us to make a video about their wheels. But with that they sent this insane contract where we had to shill them so hard we turned it down. We purchased all these wheels and don’t have to lie to yall about it. Also the reserves are sub 2k for reference.

    • @Zeben84
      @Zeben84 2 месяца назад +3

      @@bicyclestation Ok, not cool about this contract thingy, i'm sure if you reach out to them with your terms, some brands would gladdly send you some of their wheels. :)
      The Reserve wheels are pretty heavy tho, even with the lightest DTSwiss hub :/

    • @bicyclestation
      @bicyclestation  2 месяца назад +29

      I don’t really have an incentive to reach out to them unfortunately. We make money via selling customer builds and aftermarket parts from the manufacturers we highlight in these videos. It would be hard to convince a wide audience to suddenly jump on a Chinese wheelset. In our own experience with them, LUN sent us a wheelset pre us doing RUclips. It exploded and their warranty department was so bad I’d never recommend them again. I don’t wanna put our customers through that headache.
      Exactly. That’s why I think the rapids are the better set light and fast.
      -Jesse

    • @petersouthernboy6327
      @petersouthernboy6327 2 месяца назад +5

      Because these wheels reviewed in this video can be serviced and warranted through a local dealer network in many parts of the World. The mainland Chinese brands OP mentioned have a considerable timezone cost and shipping issue that makes timely warranty claims, service, and parts a major challenge.

    • @songjoseph3314
      @songjoseph3314 2 месяца назад +3

      Cuz he rides super bikes like madone SLR and sworks. People who buying sworks won’t rides a hyper d45 on them. I had hyper d45 they are cheap and fast on my training bike but i probably don’t wanna use it on my super bike.

  • @neilfox9540
    @neilfox9540 2 месяца назад

    So the Tarmac SL8 is 'harsh' - can we expect Nero Show Chris Miller and Jesse to dedicate a whole pod to that? I'm guessing no because they have an agenda.

    • @bicyclestation
      @bicyclestation  2 месяца назад +2

      Definitely appreciate the exposure from that but yea. I didn’t intend for that video to start so much drama. Trey said that like a year ago when the channel was smaller. I disagreed with him at the time. But we both agreed that the gen 7 Madone was more comfortable then the sl8. Unfortunately the gen 8 ends up being harsher than any other bike we’ve tried.

    • @LOGICAL-JAY
      @LOGICAL-JAY 2 месяца назад +1

      I don't find the s-works SL8 tarmac harsh at all..its alot smoother than my older SL7..the S5 cervelo has a harsh ride..the most comfortable aero bike I've road yet was my trek madone SLR gen7 which I sold a few months back..

    • @neilfox9540
      @neilfox9540 2 месяца назад +2

      @@bicyclestation I guess comfort is in the 'ass' of the beholder. I've seen lots of Madone owners on forums etc saying gen 8 is more comfortable than gen 7. It annoyed me how Chris & Jesse jumped on your review as it feels like they were waiting for it so they could drive some engagement and because they don't like the direction that Trek have taken. To label the bike 'a dog' was ridiculous, it wasn't balanced against other reviews and their owm personal experience of the bike is very limited.

    • @ChrisMillerCycling
      @ChrisMillerCycling 2 месяца назад

      We have an agenda?

    • @bicyclestation
      @bicyclestation  2 месяца назад +1

      Cycling deep state lol. Btw thank you for all the support you sent our way! We really appreciate it.

  • @Lockeness86
    @Lockeness86 2 месяца назад

    Very cool video. One thing: there is no need to do 300 watt efforts. If you just give your favorite AI app your data, it will calculate your CdA for the effort based on whatever power you did. I’d be happy to help you guys analyze this data more

  • @DanielVanderkemp
    @DanielVanderkemp 2 месяца назад

    DT Swiss are great hubs but not perfect. Major advantage of other brands like Enve Inner Drive, Carbon Ti, HED AAND Chris King are one piece axles. Combines with thru axle much stiffer than DT Swiss that rely on end caps.

    • @petersouthernboy6327
      @petersouthernboy6327 2 месяца назад

      I've always thought that my Chris King hubs rode better than my DT 240's.

    • @LOGICAL-JAY
      @LOGICAL-JAY 2 месяца назад +1

      I always had to baby my Chris king hubs and maintain them more than my D/Tswiss 350, 240, 180 hubs..I find dtswiss easier to maintain..

    • @LOGICAL-JAY
      @LOGICAL-JAY 2 месяца назад

      ​@@petersouthernboy6327try the dtswiss 180s

    • @petersouthernboy6327
      @petersouthernboy6327 2 месяца назад

      @@LOGICAL-JAY I don’t baby my DT Swiss or my Chris King hubs. They’re both great IMHO.

    • @LOGICAL-JAY
      @LOGICAL-JAY 2 месяца назад

      @petersouthernboy6327 yes indeed they're both great hubs..

  • @whatwouldjacobdo
    @whatwouldjacobdo 2 месяца назад +1

    That PNS kit isn’t even realtree smh

  • @ssam98
    @ssam98 2 месяца назад +1

    Yes please truck stuff, f150 over here

  • @michprent
    @michprent 2 месяца назад +3

    We need truck stuff!

  • @valiantabello
    @valiantabello 2 месяца назад

    My body is ready

  • @biirdm4n
    @biirdm4n 2 месяца назад +2

    Princetons?

  • @robarena7564
    @robarena7564 2 месяца назад

    You need to test the CRW 65/75 wheelset. They are lighter, faster, less expensive and sprint better than any of the wheelsets you tested. Bonus - they are wide too and can run 30+ with ease and remain aero.

  • @jamiefarrell6496
    @jamiefarrell6496 2 месяца назад

    I have Roval tastes but Reserve disposable income…

  • @xian1999
    @xian1999 Месяц назад

    Syncros Capital SL the Best

  • @MTBScotland
    @MTBScotland 2 месяца назад

    would literally not buy any of those wheels. All way overpriced. My prime 56mm wheels are 23mm internal & 30mm external. 1620g and cost me £500. These companies rip the piss.

    • @bicyclestation
      @bicyclestation  2 месяца назад

      You don’t have to buy them. No one is forcing you to.

    • @MTBScotland
      @MTBScotland 2 месяца назад

      @@bicyclestation Its a comment on the cost.

    • @bicyclestation
      @bicyclestation  2 месяца назад

      Prime claims those wheels weigh 1795 btw. So the price of a product is determined by a bunch of different factors. Employee overhead, rnd development cost, marketing. Just tons of factors. Prime seems to be cutting cost in places to hit that price point. It’s always a trade off. Not saying what they are doing is wrong. But they have clearly positioned themselves to be a budget option.

    • @MTBScotland
      @MTBScotland 2 месяца назад

      @@bicyclestation claim of 1590g for my model.

  • @DanTuber
    @DanTuber 2 месяца назад +1

    How to scratch your wheels. Lay them down on a bed of loose stones.

    • @bicyclestation
      @bicyclestation  2 месяца назад +1

      I think it’s funny. Sorry to stress everyone out

  • @kubackjeee
    @kubackjeee 2 месяца назад +4

    Zipps are crap they should not even be in the mix

    • @bicyclestation
      @bicyclestation  2 месяца назад +4

      Idk man. The 353 has been probably the best most consistent wheelset I’ve ever owned. I’ve been running them for 3 years now. Everyone also loves the firecrest also

    • @kubackjeee
      @kubackjeee 2 месяца назад +2

      @@bicyclestation maybe in USA where they believe in their marketing and the hookless bs :)

    • @jou3708
      @jou3708 2 месяца назад

      ​@@kubackjeee You misundersood sth. He just uses those wheels, like great nr of other guys. It you who believe in sth and try so hard to spread your very important belief😂

    • @bicyclestation
      @bicyclestation  2 месяца назад +4

      I have ridden thousands of miles on them. I don’t understand what your issue is. All of my MTB wheels are hookless and have been for years.

    • @saysthetedd
      @saysthetedd 2 месяца назад

      I was prepared to hate the 353. Overpriced and gimmicky I thought - absolutely incredible wheels. My favorite gravel wheel set by far