I use the Alligator - Alien 220mm rotors on my custom 50kg ebike. I have twin front rotors. I could feel the braking performance increase going from the original 200mm tektro rotors. I would say not only braking force was slightly increased but also modulation, there is more range of feel and relative force of braking with that feel. But mostly wanted to upgrade because DINNER PLATES!!!! ...... I gave my friend my old 200mm rotors to replace his 160mm magura disks and it is night and day in terms of performance increase, so even going from 160 to 200mm i would defo recommend.
I have been running these disks on my Turbo Levo for over a year, to better manage overheating on big downhills. This has worked well. However recently I have developed a warp that has now caused rubbing, on the rear disk. And I have tried bending it some, which has worked before on solid discs. I have now discovered the rivets are loose where the warp is and I believe this is enough to allow the disk to be slightly untrue. (If I figure out a way to tighten the rivits I would know) Anyway I am going to put a new disk on. I just wondered if you have an opinion on my theory. And would you consider this normal wear, which seems reasonable, considering how hard I ride thes rear brakes. The front disk is fine. Thanks (California, USA)
Your theory sounds plausible, a year sounds reasonable if you're riding hard on an e-bike as it's amazing how much heat they can generate. Nice bike btw.
Magura MT7 Raceline with 220mm, doesn't feel that much of a difference over stock w/ 1 piston imo. It's not as Massive as the Brembo RCS19 on the R6 w/ SS lines. Huge difference.
I changed my Shimano Mt900 rotors to Magura Rotors (Storm HC) and i believe the shimano ones are shit. They are fragile, bend easily, they are way thinner and I don’t believe the ventilation system really helps that much since their aluminium core makes them so soft. The 2mm thickness of Magura rotors really make a difference.
Great video! Which rotor is that when you are demonstrating play in the rivets? I have seen some riders have quite a bit of movement in their MDR-P rotors, have you experienced anything like that ?
I ordered these rotors but some photos show one style and other photos another style. What’s the difference? I noticed the center were the bolts go are different but not sure if they will work
I use this exact model of rotor with M7120 calipers. You just need to push your pistons as far back as possible and really dial in your caliper centering. You'll get brake rub for maybe 2-3 rides. Keep adjusting and then suddenly they all just click. The servo-wave mechanism helps in giving you more pad clearance in the caliper.
Do you have the part number for the rear rotor adapter? I just purchased the same rotors but I’m having problems getting the right mount for the rear, thx
I've ran 220 MDR-P's on my YT Decoy for a few thousand miles now. Best rotor on the market for ebikes IMO.
you run 220mm on front and rear ? what bracket adaptor part # did you use? have a core 3 decoy but can't find qm45 in stock
from my experience is a worst rotor you can buy :D
@@wolkuz What 220mm rotor did you test, and what is the best for you ? Need for a surron who makes 220mm warp 9 warp ^^
@@surronzak8154 SwissStop CATALYST PRO rotors works for me very well.
Run these rotor's aswell with the Magura Mt7 brakes. Not a bad word to be said so far 👍
The 2 piece design is so sick. It looks like a motorcycle rotor.
I use the Alligator - Alien 220mm rotors on my custom 50kg ebike. I have twin front rotors. I could feel the braking performance increase going from the original 200mm tektro rotors. I would say not only braking force was slightly increased but also modulation, there is more range of feel and relative force of braking with that feel. But mostly wanted to upgrade because DINNER PLATES!!!! ...... I gave my friend my old 200mm rotors to replace his 160mm magura disks and it is night and day in terms of performance increase, so even going from 160 to 200mm i would defo recommend.
I have been running these disks on my Turbo Levo for over a year, to better manage overheating on big downhills. This has worked well. However recently I have developed a warp that has now caused rubbing, on the rear disk. And I have tried bending it some, which has worked before on solid discs. I have now discovered the rivets are loose where the warp is and I believe this is enough to allow the disk to be slightly untrue. (If I figure out a way to tighten the rivits I would know) Anyway I am going to put a new disk on. I just wondered if you have an opinion on my theory. And would you consider this normal wear, which seems reasonable, considering how hard I ride thes rear brakes. The front disk is fine. Thanks (California, USA)
Your theory sounds plausible, a year sounds reasonable if you're riding hard on an e-bike as it's amazing how much heat they can generate. Nice bike btw.
You can try widening the dangling aluminum links with a hammer and plumb bob or similar metal tapered tool. The main thing is not to overdo it))
Magura MT7 Raceline with 220mm, doesn't feel that much of a difference over stock w/ 1 piston imo. It's not as Massive as the Brembo RCS19 on the R6 w/ SS lines. Huge difference.
you should compare weight to other ones you got
Fantastic review my friend, 😉🤘
Thanks 😄
Are the XT rotor better? I run them a long time they were ever good but now i need new and these MDR disks looking good. I dont know.
I changed my Shimano Mt900 rotors to Magura Rotors (Storm HC) and i believe the shimano ones are shit. They are fragile, bend easily, they are way thinner and I don’t believe the ventilation system really helps that much since their aluminium core makes them so soft. The 2mm thickness of Magura rotors really make a difference.
Great video! Which rotor is that when you are demonstrating play in the rivets? I have seen some riders have quite a bit of movement in their MDR-P rotors, have you experienced anything like that ?
Thanks, it was a Uberbike Radiator rotor, I haven’t had any movement yet but if I do I’ll post an update.
nice review 🚴👍
I understand only organic pads vs metallic pads for these rotors right? This wasn't mentioned in your review.
How have the trickstuff and hope rotors worked in terms of staying true and noises?
Both have been good, I normally don't get any noise from Hopes unless they have gone past the wear limit.
Hi! Can it be used with mt200 shimano?
That wouldn't be smart... The brake costs less than 1 rotor
I use it now
@@jehyor3997 well, that isn't actually smart
I ordered these rotors but some photos show one style and other photos another style. What’s the difference? I noticed the center were the bolts go are different but not sure if they will work
The design changes slightly with the different sizes and options but they all work fine with standard 6 bolt hubs.
@@jedmtb I’m getting them this weekend we will see what version I going to get each have different pictures
My Manitou Mastodon Pro Forks say Max 203mm Rotors. Is there a issue running 220mm?
warranty will be void
I have bought magura Mt 07 brake callipers with 203 mm magura discs can I upgrade to magura 220 ml , is this a straight swop or do I need an adapter?
You defiantly need an adapter!!! Also, prior to getting huge rotor, not all forks will fit the rotor.
Are you still using these rotors or switched to different ones since?
Yes I’m still using them and also testing out some Hope 2.3mm rotors.
@@jedmtb nice! I just heard about those 2.3 rotors from Hope. I'm waiting on 246 mm Galfer rotor for my front on TRP DHR Evo brakes 😋
@@EMTBCruz The 246mm should look impressive, the 220’s already look huge.
should the magura top peace of the disc move when breaking? I have like 1mm play when im braking and it makes my wheel bump.
Mine doesn't move.
I have the same issue
What was wrong with the other rotors?
Hope vs Magura rotors?
The Magura as they’re thicker and seem to control the heat better.
How are you getting on with these @jed MTB?
They’ve been great so far.
Nice evil in the back! Would you sell it?
I don't think you'd want it as the downtube is cracked :)
@@jedmtb Sell it =D
When it just says mdrp rotor, does it come with 2 or just the front
They are sold individually
Can I have a link to both if possible
Where can I buy both rotors for surron
of ebay there £50 just for one disc
hi can i use magura rotors on shimano slx
brakes?
They should work fine, I’ve had no issues with my Deore or XTR
@@jedmtb agree!
How about on a guide R?
I use this exact model of rotor with M7120 calipers. You just need to push your pistons as far back as possible and really dial in your caliper centering. You'll get brake rub for maybe 2-3 rides. Keep adjusting and then suddenly they all just click. The servo-wave mechanism helps in giving you more pad clearance in the caliper.
@@shieldren do you find the pads are lined up correctly on the rotor? interested as my ice tec ones keep warping!
Do these come in 160mm?
180mm is the smallest size unfortunately.
Thickness of Magura is 1.85mm, Shimano is 1.75, Trickstuff is 2.05. Makes a big difference in practical use!
wrong, magura 2mm, Shimano 1.8mm
Do you have the part number for the rear rotor adapter? I just purchased the same rotors but I’m having problems getting the right mount for the rear, thx
I used the HBMM but here is the chart so you can check which you need. www.hopetech.com/_repository/1/documents/BrakeAdaptorChart2021.pdf
These rotors definitely look cool, but they're junk IMO. They make way too much noise
I've had mixed results, one set had no issues but the e-bike set developed play and a rattle. I've moved all my brakes over to 2.3mm discs now.