So tough! Jenifer so powerful and has so much vocal clarity that is unmatched...but Fantasia has grit and soul that is also unmatched. Im gonna say its a draw and depends on the song being sung!
When i hear fantasia sings and performs it takes me way back to my african roots where i can feel the beat of the drums coarsing through my veins what a great performer
They both are wonderful. But I would go with Fantasia only because she is more personal with her music she is not just sing but telling a story and sending a message to her fans and you can feel it. Especially when she sings gospel Glory! the spirit can hit u when she sings
Jennifer was singing her heart out, really feeling it, truly connected with the song. The people who knew the song connected with the song and with Jennifer's passion. Fantasia connects with the people to get the message of the song across to them. It's not just her singing a song. It's her and the people in communication together. Singing by herself, she connects with the message of the song, just as Jennifer does. Both are very, very powerful, inspirational singers, each great in their own way. I am in awe of both of them. They battled it out in a song called, "I'm His Only Woman" at the Fox Theatre Atlanta, in April 2009. They were referred to as the Reincarnated Patti LaBelle & Aretha Franklin.
I feel like Jennifer Hudson's knowledge of music stretches back to about 1990 and that's it. Fantasia connects a couple of centuries of musical tradition and delivers it with incredible sincerity and true feeling.
We should not be comparing these two amazing, powerful, talented performers because they are both GIFTS to music, to our community, to the world. Let’s praise that and not play them out against each other. THEY ARE BOTH AMAZING AND THEY BOTH PRIASE THE LORD THROUGH MUSIC AMD EMOTION EVERY TIME THEY OPEN THEIR MOUTHS. Let’s love that and them. I want them to do an album together where they lead, follow and pair with each other. THAT would be the TRUTH!
Fantasia is the boss because of her sound, Hudson can go as high as she likes but Tasia's sound reigns supreme. Similar with Aretha - she was the greatest voice in recording history because of her sound - Labelle and others went higher but it's meaningless - Franklin's sound like Tasia's was simply greater, more beautiful, more instinctive and more soulful and awe inspiring.
I so agree but I like Fantasia too but I feel like Fantasia over does it with the riffs and runs and I just want to hear singing and not over doing it in my opinion. Jennifer she sangs and does riffs and runs but does them tastefully, she knows not to over do them. Jennifer Hudson hands down won.
Any singer knows Fantasia wins this battle 99 Times out of 100. I give J HUD a one percent chance because she is so talented. But yeah. Singers know this. It is said.
Fantasia is too skilled....she would win hands down And yes....they can sing the exact song But fantasia will deliver while Jennifer is too busy trying to find the right key to aim for the scream or long belt Fantasia just KNOWS what to do!
It's not a competition. Jennifer Hudson is by far the best singer (vocally)God himself has ever created. Fantasia, excellent vocals, and has better showmanship, but Jennifer is definitely on a whole nother level. Lov'em both ❤❤
Fantasia does not have to compete with anyone. God blessed her with a gift of song. Jennifer has her place in the music world . She should give thanks to God and go forward and share her gift.
My co-workers and I had this debate today and I said I feel Fantasia's vocals are more amazing and she more entertaining than Jennifer. But both are amazing singers.
Jennifer wins by far fantasia sounds like she's crying. and plus this comparison isn't fair they sung two different categories of songs Jennifer sung some else and fantasia sung gospel.
I think at this point, it’s all about personal preference because technically, they both are on the same level. Personally, I prefer Jennifer by a mile but that doesn’t she is "better" than her only because of my opinion.
Baby tasia is skitt skattin that stage down! Yall quit playin yall know Fantasia won American Idol with more than 64 million votes!? Thats it and thats all.
For those of you who chose JHud, I respect it. BUT.... how can you overlook the pitchy-ness? Fantasia is never pitchy. She isn’t as “powerful” a singer as Jen but come on. Pitch & Control > Power all day everyday. Plus Fanny’s power is just right. Jen is beastly tho. I won’t deny it.
You are judging on this one performance but if you look at this youtube video of JHUD performance for Aretha tribute Jennifer Hudson is that better vocals in my opinion. Here's the link ruclips.net/video/4BbT98KFIx0/видео.html
I gotta go with Jenny I'm a fan of Fantasia too but I'm a bigger Jhud fan Jhud misic has helped me get through so much when I going through it I'm not gonna lie it's a hard decision cause Fantasia sho nuff can sing but like I said I gotta with Jennifer that's my singer
First these two power house could only do a battle “IF” they both sang Gospel Music! That would be the only way it would be a true and fair battle. Their singing style is different otherwise, but let them battle singing gospel music. Anything else would just be one great concert. My opinion.
Jennifer vocals all day, but Fantasia stage presents and her ability to connect to her audience makes her slightly better. But as far as vocals, Jennifer!
Jennifer is a damn good singer but Fanny will sing anybody under the rug. Le’Andria Johnson maybe. Ledisi a big maybe. Maybe even Keke Wyatt but Jennifer no lol
B K I state of nothing but facts. Kierra Sheard has more range and resonance. Her runs are more intricate her technique is much better. She has more power on her voice and she can sing with just as much emotion and anointing as Fantasia can. I know what I'm talking about we can debate this all day
@@spiralplex8813 Kierra is her mama's daughter so that's no surprise. Keke is also phenomenal. But Fantasia has something special going on that lets her hold her own against such vocal beasts. I don't know of practically any singer of her generation that is as convincing, as emotionally involved, as spellbinding as she is. It goes beyond technique and crosses over into how much you believe in what she sings. Especially when she does gospel.
if your a fan of fantasia you would knw that voice is a gift from god him self wat difference does her sound from on american idol till now as a matter a fact her voice is growing n glowing
Видеоклипы
Also check out this vocal battle between Tyrese & tank! ruclips.net/video/uaMkPmGPQ4o/видео.html
So tough! Jenifer so powerful and has so much vocal clarity that is unmatched...but Fantasia has grit and soul that is also unmatched. Im gonna say its a draw and depends on the song being sung!
Jayreeziee34 Moncada i agree. Im slightly biased for Fantasia...but cant deny Jen’s talent.
When i hear fantasia sings and performs it takes me way back to my african roots where i can feel the beat of the drums coarsing through my veins what a great performer
Fantasia + anointing = winer by a landslide
They both are wonderful. But I would go with Fantasia only because she is more personal with her music she is not just sing but telling a story and sending a message to her fans and you can feel it. Especially when she sings gospel Glory! the spirit can hit u when she sings
Jennifer was singing her heart out, really feeling it, truly connected with the song. The people who knew the song connected with the song and with Jennifer's passion. Fantasia connects with the people to get the message of the song across to them. It's not just her singing a song. It's her and the people in communication together. Singing by herself, she connects with the message of the song, just as Jennifer does. Both are very, very powerful, inspirational singers, each great in their own way. I am in awe of both of them.
They battled it out in a song called, "I'm His Only Woman" at the Fox Theatre Atlanta, in April 2009. They were referred to as the Reincarnated Patti LaBelle & Aretha Franklin.
Jennifer is a excellent singer. The power is there and so is the range. I favor Fantasia though. The rasp and growl is what I love about her singing.
I feel like Jennifer Hudson's knowledge of music stretches back to about 1990 and that's it. Fantasia connects a couple of centuries of musical tradition and delivers it with incredible sincerity and true feeling.
@one sided loyalty is for suckas Please don't embarass yourself.
They are both two powerful singers. But Fantasia can sing anything and deliver it.
amen i agree that's why she won American idol Fantasia can sing anything
They both can sang but I give it to fantasia!
@@lalagonegaga No you don't embarrass yourself.
You Can’t compare them fanny is traditional and timeless and Jenny is a jack of all trades gospel broadway soul they both are UNMATCHED 😍😍😍😍😍😍😍 QUEENS
Fantasia is Broadway, also Fantasia is naturally talented Jennifer voice is trained, but both are good....
I would never choose between the two ..both are great
Fantasia for me
Jennifer has a bigger voice range, fantasia has a very unique voice. Both are simple amazing
Perfectly said.
They both good but ima go with Fantasia because Fantasia takes me to church and to special place
Fantasia win by far in my book!!
Fantasia for voice,control and thecnique. She is amazing !
Both has a anointing voice that few had blessed with. Both are amazing vocalist. Their soul are over flowing whenever they sing.
they BOTH!
Earl Rodgers THIS give me both anytime along with Patti Aretha keke wyatt Jasmine Sullivan AND CALLIE DAY CHECK HER OUT
FANTASIA (before I even watched video) !!! Sorry Jen.....gotta fast forward to Fantasia....
Fantasia
Jennifer is fire, but there is a reason Fantasia won and Jennifer didn't.....
Because people like her annoying singing
Hand down my girl Fantasia!🤷🏽♀️
JENNIFER HUDSON JENNIFER HUDSON JENIFEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEER
We should not be comparing these two amazing, powerful, talented performers because they are both GIFTS to music, to our community, to the world. Let’s praise that and not play them out against each other. THEY ARE BOTH AMAZING AND THEY BOTH PRIASE THE LORD THROUGH MUSIC AMD EMOTION EVERY TIME THEY OPEN THEIR MOUTHS. Let’s love that and them.
I want them to do an album together where they lead, follow and pair with each other. THAT would be the TRUTH!
Fantasia is the boss because of her sound, Hudson can go as high as she likes but Tasia's sound reigns supreme. Similar with Aretha - she was the greatest voice in recording history because of her sound - Labelle and others went higher but it's meaningless - Franklin's sound like Tasia's was simply greater, more beautiful, more instinctive and more soulful and awe inspiring.
Fantasia, of course. Jennifer can sing but Tasia will take you someplace.
Im more of a Jennifer lover
I so agree but I like Fantasia too but I feel like Fantasia over does it with the riffs and runs and I just want to hear singing and not over doing it in my opinion. Jennifer she sangs and does riffs and runs but does them tastefully, she knows not to over do them. Jennifer Hudson hands down won.
Any singer knows Fantasia wins this battle 99
Times out of 100. I give J HUD a one percent chance because she is so talented. But yeah. Singers know this. It is said.
one sided loyalty is for suckas lmao cool 🤐
Period
Fantasia!!!
Fantasia is too skilled....she would win hands down
And yes....they can sing the exact song
But fantasia will deliver while Jennifer is too busy trying to find the right key to aim for the scream or long belt
Fantasia just KNOWS what to do!
fantasia all the way
Jennifer is no competition for Fantasia..Period !
Tasia voice is more unique. Jennifer has a clear strong voice. I find more natural soul from Fantasia’s voice🎤 she won
Unique... Its annoying
@@terencedavids3836CLOSE YOUR EARS! 😂
They’re all goddesses of vocals
Jennifer voice is powerful
Fantasia is unique. Both in church wow
Fantasia!!! If you’re a singer you know this. Ppl who don’t have a musical ear wouldn’t understand this.
fanny gets me every time at 5:03
Jennifer Hudson ❤ going to win this one
Fantasia hands down!! Jennifer Hudson sings good to but too hard!
Jennifer sing so effortlessly. My God!!
It's not a competition. Jennifer Hudson is by far the best singer (vocally)God himself has ever created. Fantasia, excellent vocals, and has better showmanship, but Jennifer is definitely on a whole nother level. Lov'em both ❤❤
Not really!!
fantasia in my opinion is THE BEST baby patti labelle
Fantasia bring church but both are my idols tho !!! They both can sang they butts off shoot I love to see both of em perform
Mi preferida es Fantasia 😍
Fantasia hands down and she has amazing stage presence!!!!
Fantasia does not have to compete with anyone. God blessed her with a gift of song. Jennifer has her place in the music world . She should give thanks to God and go forward and share her gift.
Fantasia hands down
FANTASIA all day, everyday!
Sue C yessss
Jennifer Hudson for me both are great when she sings I always want to tear up
Jhud has her vocally,
I think so too
Yes she does I agree.
If so she would have won the American idol against fantasia but fantasia beat her
@@ASIANPRINCESS-jc5yu she beat her in life. 🥲
Can’t compare THEM !
Fantasia!!!!
Fantasia is better !!!!
Tasia
Never mind its fantasia
Fantasia all day
I Truly Love Fantasia!
My co-workers and I had this debate today and I said I feel Fantasia's vocals are more amazing and she more entertaining than Jennifer. But both are amazing singers.
Jennifer has a better range but Fantasia is way more versatile
Jennifer!
I say tie because the th both have completely different voices so I say tie
I can't pick which one of them is the winner because they both gives goosebumps.
Jennifer
Jennifer wins by far fantasia sounds like she's crying. and plus this comparison isn't fair they sung two different categories of songs Jennifer sung some else and fantasia sung gospel.
But fantasia won agains her at American idol
Let’s just remember that Fantasia beat Jennifer on American idol so we clearly know who sings better duh 🙄
Levelz 1 yes son but who has won more awards? And who’s richer? Jennifer Hudson!!
I think at this point, it’s all about personal preference because technically, they both are on the same level. Personally, I prefer Jennifer by a mile but that doesn’t she is "better" than her only because of my opinion.
Levelz 1 wide
Levelz 1 Didn’t Jennifer also won American Idols?? 😒
She did not win... But she's more famous and rich Id say then Fantasia... Got an Oscar also
It's like asking me a hamburger or a hot dog. I'll take both. Tom or jerry both .mustang or camaro both
You should have picked a better Jennifer performance because it was the best fanstasia live performance, Jennifer has sang well better live
I think the song I'm Here
If you’ve heard one J HUD vocal you’ve heard them all. She never changes or switches. But Fantasia always shows different sides to herself vocally.
I completely agree, Fantasia has so much variety in her voice and she captures the audience in every time she opens her mouth. SHE IS TO BE RESPECTED
Y'all shouldn't compare them to one another. Every singer have their own style of singing.
Baby tasia is skitt skattin that stage down! Yall quit playin yall know Fantasia won American Idol with more than 64 million votes!? Thats it and thats all.
Thank u enough said even tho Jennifer Hudson’ is a power house but fantasia man fantasia is going to make her look like nothing
Fantasia is better
I gotta say both are equal but in vocal range Jennifer wins for vocal range cuz she has such a long vocal range
For those of you who chose JHud, I respect it. BUT.... how can you overlook the pitchy-ness? Fantasia is never pitchy. She isn’t as “powerful” a singer as Jen but come on. Pitch & Control > Power all day everyday. Plus Fanny’s power is just right. Jen is beastly tho. I won’t deny it.
You are judging on this one performance but if you look at this youtube video of JHUD performance for Aretha tribute Jennifer Hudson is that better vocals in my opinion. Here's the link ruclips.net/video/4BbT98KFIx0/видео.html
@@sweetreny1155 that's the point. To judge off this performance. Not saying your point is invalid but still.
Jennifer is never pitchy😂
Fantasia always❣️
I gotta go with Jenny I'm a fan of Fantasia too but I'm a bigger Jhud fan Jhud misic has helped me get through so much when I going through it I'm not gonna lie it's a hard decision cause Fantasia sho nuff can sing but like I said I gotta with Jennifer that's my singer
💞💞💞💞💞💞💞
There is no battle. They're both tied at the very top tiers
battle of the Short hair cut
My girl beat Jeniffer so duh we know who the better vocalist is FANTASIA 💯
Jen
Jennifer Hudson 😍
Jennifer 🥇
Shhhh... I ain't choosing! JS
Same here
First these two power house could only do a battle “IF” they both sang Gospel Music! That would be the only way it would be a true and fair battle. Their singing style is different otherwise, but let them battle singing gospel music. Anything else would just be one great concert. My opinion.
Jennifer vocals all day, but Fantasia stage presents and her ability to connect to her audience makes her slightly better. But as far as vocals, Jennifer!
Where was jen singing?
jennifer hudson is indeed dramatic soprano
Spinto soprano
@@reggiemitchell5198 dramatic soprano
@@danclarkcastillo7178 Jennifer isn’t a dramatic she’s a spinto. A true dramatic soprano is Vivian reed
@@reggiemitchell5198 jennifer hudson's voice is heavier, bigger, and darker than vivian reed's
@@danclarkcastillo7178 it’s the way she sing but naturally it’s not. She’s a spinto
i see a comment about fantasia screaming lol if you new something about music you would
J Hud is the GOAT🎉
Jennifer is much better control,tune , power, clearity,power and emotion
Jhud for ever!!!
FANTASIA WINS HERE ! BUT JENNIFER ALWAYS QUEEN OF VOCAL
Tie
JHud for me... I can’t take all that damn screaming from Fantasia. Jen voice is just better to me
Jennifer Hudson Power voice
Ummm is that Fantasia's mom @10:43?! 🤯🤯🤯
Jennifer is a damn good singer but Fanny will sing anybody under the rug. Le’Andria Johnson maybe. Ledisi a big maybe. Maybe even Keke Wyatt but Jennifer no lol
Sorry to start trouble but Kierra Sheard will kill Fantasia
Spiral plex you must be on something
B K I state of nothing but facts. Kierra Sheard has more range and resonance. Her runs are more intricate her technique is much better. She has more power on her voice and she can sing with just as much emotion and anointing as Fantasia can. I know what I'm talking about we can debate this all day
Spiral plex your ears don’t work it’s ok
@@spiralplex8813 Kierra is her mama's daughter so that's no surprise. Keke is also phenomenal. But Fantasia has something special going on that lets her hold her own against such vocal beasts. I don't know of practically any singer of her generation that is as convincing, as emotionally involved, as spellbinding as she is. It goes beyond technique and crosses over into how much you believe in what she sings. Especially when she does gospel.
Jennifer Hudson.!!
If you screaming all of time yes Fantasia. Don't forget she had vocal surgery because of way she sings. Jennifer will blow you out of the water..
if your a fan of fantasia you would knw that voice is a gift from god him self wat difference does her sound from on american idol till now as a matter a fact her voice is growing n glowing
She didn’t have surgery from the way she sings.
@@kylesummers2462 Haters will try anything.
@@do440 agreed
Rasp, growl and squall is not screaming
Cover up Fantasia !
Jennifer Hudson all day and most of the night too. I like Fantasia though but Jennifer has those pipes.
Cant compare