I don't think you are stereotyping french music at all, even to us other europeans back in 2021 this was the frenchest french entry to ever french haha they went full 1000% and it was excellent
Is it just me, or it is a joy to watch this two guys to react to Eurovision? Their commentary is so smart, relaxed, goofy... it's delightful. I just hope that they react someday to the video with all the winners of Eurovision from 1956-2023
Brit here 🇬🇧 No, you’re right this is the frenchest thing ever, and Edith Piaf was indeed also French! You’re also right Voilà means “there/here it is”. There are so many French words in English because the (Norman) French invaded England in 1066 and ruled the country for about 300 years - the upper classes and rulers spoke French in England until about the 14th century. And so many French words made their way into English.
Edith Piaf is not a bad reference actually! And the song was middlingly successful in France but it does sound like a good version of what other countries think France sounds like.
The countries taking part get to design the lights, led screens, the camera work, etc. Some countries invest a lot in it, others less. But yes the year's organizers have a huge responsibility creating the stage, planning the hosting and middle acts, the camera work during the performances, etc. It's an enormous production. Some years it's better, other years a bit less so, but it's not too serious as we're sort of used to it not being perfect every year and it's just the way it is. Awkward moments with hosts and unentertaining middle acts are a part of Eurovision
Barbara actually worked closely with the camera man and mentioned him often. They fist-bumped after this performance. It was a super intimste performance on a huge stage. And her shadow dispersing into birds gets me every time. I am Swiss and to me this was the most French entry ever, as well.
Actually about 55% of the words in English are originally French. And the rest are Old English (i.e. Germanic). It's because for centuries we had a French-speaking aristocracy ruling over commoners speaking Old English, and eventually they basically just merged into one language. It's why we have so many words with a pair of synonyms: one French, and one Germanic. For example "pensive" (French) / "thinking" (Germanic); "beef" (French) / "cow" (Germanic); "fraternal" (French) / "brotherly" (Germanic); "purchase" (French) / "buy" (Germanic) - and *lots* more. It's also why English has about twice as many words in it as either French or German - we basically decided not to choose between them, we just kept everything.
@@lovisalindstrom7920 the roots are not Old Norse, they’re Old English, which was the language spoken by the Anglo-Saxons. The reason they are similar to Old Norse is because the Nordic languages are *also* Germanic languages.
And a lot of the mordern european languages derive from Latin, you can find roots from english and french especially and obviously Italian. Most European languages come from the same place :)
@@la.uralox not exactly, most modern European languages are either Germanic, Slavic, or Romance (from Latin), with a handful of other smaller roots. But Germanic and Slavic languages have very little derived from Latin. English is unique because it doesn’t fall into one family. Even though it is categorised as a Germanic language, over half of its lexicon is Romance (from Old French). It is a true mongrel language.
I am so glad you guys are doing more Eurovision, we’re all big fans here in Europe 😀 I’ve been watching Eurovision every year since 2002! So if you want to continue this journey, here’s my suggestion for the next five: 1. Conchita Wurst - Rise like a phoenix, Austria 2014 (winner) 2. Alexander Rybak - Fairytale, Norway 2009 (winner) 3. Lordi - Hard rock Hallelujah , Finland 2006 (winner) 2. Sergei Lazarev - You’re the only one, Russia 2016 ( not actual winner, but it was controversial. And it will blow your mind how they managed to do that things on stage) 1. Duncan Lawrence - Arcade, Netherlands, 2019 (winner) Good luck 😊
As a French person, love your comments lol 😂 We do love our cheese and wine 🍷 and yes, raw artistry is very valued here 🇫🇷😉 Mimes are French also lol, « mimer » literally means imitating
Check out the lyrics, they are nice... it is about her being an artist bearing herself and her vulnerability to the audience... she says Voila! as in Here I am, this is me, and my art :)
European here. This song is perfect. It should have won, in my opinion. It's so emotional.. Here I am , look at me, all my flaws, all that I am before you, love me. This is all I have to give, I just want to write my own stories and share them with you. I'm just a girl with a dream...
i like this song on first hearing. when someone have sucha a bacic stage and keeps you all 3 minutes watching that is definition of good song. But then i saw lyrics and everything got even more sense. Song is about artist who is unsecure in hes abilities and will ppl apriciate what that artist do. Basicly it is about her, and that explains pasion with which she sing this song.
2021 was SO GOOD. So many entries singing with their own languages, and still getting the message through clear as daylight. I don't speak french, but MAN I felt this passion/pain. Great performance!
So much the better if you like it, it was made for it. The staging, the play of lights and the camera are super skillful and clever. But if I can give you my opinion as a Frenchman, I find that this performance is too caricatured French, it is really a production to please a foreign audience by activating the "nostalgia" of an idealized France of the 50s. And fortunately you don't understand the lyrics, cause they are quite weak, it's a "facebook" lament to have friends and be loved... As a Frenchman, I am really disappointed that it is this well-produced and well-formatted song that has brought the most points to France in recent years, our French artists are capable of doing so much more creative and more original...
She commented during an interview that she listened to all previous winners and, at the end, the common thing in all of them is the presence of emotion. I think she tried to give it as much emotion as she could. The song was hers so the connection was obvious.
2021 Eurovision was full of amazing songs, the production was of the highest level. I really liked this song, the simplicity of the arrangement and the emotions she conveyed (I’m Italian).
Beyond her sheer elegance, raw emotion and the song's Jacques Brel-esque composition, the real genius in this performance was the intimate staging - despite the raucous arena setting around her, it seemed as though she was making this passionate plea only to you, the viewer, with increasing intensity until the very end. A truly gorgeous entry.
2021 was the best Eurovision year. Every single performance from the top 5 really deserved to win in my opinion, and I never could tell which one I loved the most, bcs they were just perfect each in their own way. But what I can say - this French performance is my absolute favorite from all French entries.
I heard her saying on some show about her background. Her mother is Iranian and father is Serbian. So, she is a child of immigrants stereotyping French culture as well. But she did it so good and with so much charm, I can't stop singing.
Greetings from Ireland. I love that you guys are loving Eurovision. I always assumed that Americans wouldn’t get it. It is quirky after all. Yes Edith Piaf was French and yes I agree that this performance was very much in the style of Piaf. Great song and performance.
You guys are hysterical. You portray yourselves as a couple of Amer rubes, but your intuitive calls are spot on. The last part of Voila is Barbara (new Edith) as throwing herself frenetically onto a musical carousel (into the chaos for our entertainment) and holds on desperately as it spins faster and faster until she explodes. Take that! She says. There it is! Voila’… by the way, the term for that style is French Chanson. Maybe check our Lara Fabian on Je T’aime live. She’s the modern version. And, of course, Emma Kok which is how people find their way here in the first place. Great job.
I'm not Franch myself, but I believe this performance would be better described as Jacques Brel more than Edith Piaf, even though Barbara is definitely more Edith Piaf than Jacques Brel (except Edith always wore a classic little black dress... always. If you're running off to research Jacques Brel now, and you should be, you should start with his rendition of Amsterdam (the song, not the city) Franche have been putting in very Franch songs ever since they last won the contest in 1977, and I hope they never stop, they're generally amongst my favourites and I hope it's not too long before they win again. I enjoyed this one, she was unlucky not to win.
As a French person, while I love this song and Barbara to death, this not at all what kind of music the average french person listen to. If you look at french streaming numbers, it's mainly about french hip hop, on the radio it's avout french pop, and then you can add all the international hits american listen to. At Eurovision, people expect us to do some french chanson, which is a strength because it stands out, but a weakness because it's not what our actual music industry produces. When it comes to french stereotypes, the french bashing in the American world can be explained by France not always blindfully following the US, whether it was NATO or the Iraq war, combined with the historical UK v France dynamic that has translated to American culture. I would say France always surrender is very much historically inacurate, that we're not more racist than our neighbors, and probably not as arrogant as it is believed. When I was younger, navigating the web centered around American culture was quite hard, considering the jokes on the fr*nch that were on there but I got used to it I guess. Everyone has to deal with their stereotypes, I'm sure all the "America: fat, guns, bad healthcare" are annoying to get over and over.
I love France (especially Normandy / Bretagne / Pays de la Loire area) and we’ve been driving a lot around there. I often turn the radio on and I always find it interesting that basicly it’s really hard to hear anything but french hiphop on the radio 😄 Like is that all that everyone listens to? You should definitely send french hiphop to Eurovision!
(UK here) I’d agree with you on this, I can see this doesn’t represent current French music but it absolutely delighted the UK. Why? Because despite all the tired old jokes in the right wing press that resonate with a particular generation, we are mostly suckers for anything French. Most people will put France up there as their favourite European country and have a lot of respect for the strong voice of the French people. It wasn’t just the French sound Barbara brought though, the passion and the performance were absolutely captivating. Stereotypes are infuriating I think for any country, and whist Voila might play on them a bit, it was a wonderful entry. Should have won!
In Italy trap is top streaming and selling, but when you see some entries and some song you can tell if it is ‘typical’ italian. This is the most french song the same way.
Regarding English having words from other languages. It also has many words from Old Norse, from the time when the Danish Vikings invaded the British isles and ruled parts of it. Examples are window, steak and egg.
Also interesting face about Eurovision 2021 is that it was held in Rotterdam in The Netherlands and Nikkie De Jager-Drossaers was a co host of the evening she is more know under Nikkietutorials on RUclips
@WeeklyTop5 You guys should do a top 5 of Stromae, a Belgian international artist who was the first exclusively French-singing performer to sell out Madison Square garden. He worked with Kanye West, Lorde, Coldplay, Camila Cabello...
I think it woulf be cool if you guys closed or opened these weeks with a reaction to the recap of the whole year. To get an idea of all the songs not just the top 5 which honestly aren't always that interesting and always leave out certain countries or underrated entries.
Phoenix, justice, air, daft punk, David Guetta, indila, Aya Nakamura… I’m sure you know more about current French music than what you think ;) regarding this Eurovision song, it’s just made for Eurovision, playing on a modern Edith Piaf style, no one listens to that there otherwise. ;)
Eurovision Week #5 - Bizarre Masterpiece Performances 1. Hard Rock Hallelujah - Lordi [Finland] - 2006 - Winner 2. Toy - Netta [Israel] - 2018 - Winner 3. Party for Everybody - Buranovskiye Babushka [Russia] - 2012 - 2nd Place 4. In Corpore Sano - Konstrakta [Serbia] - 2022 - 5th Place 5. UNO - Little Big [Russia] - 2020 - Contest Cancelled due to Covid, but Most Watched Eurovision Entry of All Time 1-4 - Watch their grand final performances 5 - Watch their Eurovision Official Music Video
An article was saying Barbara started out in pop, but switched to the traditional French style Chanson (is that the correct word?) and never went back. So yes, it will sound very French, but it should, bc it's a French style. It's unfortunate that this reviewing duo did not include a copy with the lyrics. The lyrics are very important to the intensity. She wrote the song with two others to mark a moment where she realized she could create, and she could do, to mark the change in phase in life. If anyone is wanting to go down the rabbit hole of French history in contradiction to the Anglo-Saxon view, there's a cool book written by a comedian called 1000 Years of Annoying the French. It's a thick book, and a laugh, and tells you everything you need to know about French history and the evolution to French culture today.
As others have said there are so many French words in English. I believe the French say CV (curriculum vitae) as we do in the UK, rather than resumé, as used in the US.
Voilà means “there you go”! Voici means “here you are!” English vocabulary is about 40% French, and about 30% Latin. The rest is made up of Old German, old Norse, Celtic languages, and whatever you’re having yourself. Did you never hear of William The Conqueror from Normandy? The English aristocracy spoke French for four centuries after 1066. In fact, their motto “Dieu et mon droit” is still to this day written in French, not in English. And in European English (Ireland 🇮🇪, the UK 🇬🇧, Malta 🇲🇹) we use a lot more French words when we speak English than you do in the US. As an Irishman who teaches English 🏴 and French 🇫🇷 in Mexico 🇲🇽, this becomes apparent when my students ask me why I spell English words “the French way”?! eg. Metre, centre, colour, flavour, criticise, advertise etc.
I hastily watched through the comments and didn't see a comment about it, but it's interesting how you happened to pause on the one picture where her hand is, which is the sign for females to give the bartender/restaurant/whatever place that means "help me, call the police or get this person away from me, PLEASE".
Why are there so many french words in English? Because England was ruled by the Normans for nealry 100 years from 1066, and the nobility and courtiers all spoke in french....Lots of french words stuck.... 'Voila!' literally means 'See there!' so you say it when presenting something. This was a very different presentation of a song, with pretty much just her, standing there. No team of dancers to back her up.
Now you need to react to Salvador Sobral's "Amar pelos dois", Portugal's entry from 2017 (it was the winner that year). Pretty romantic, slow paced song
Yeah the stereotypes about us suck ass but we also do have our own share of stereotyping the hell out of everyone ( mostly Belgians and Americans 😅 ) , now I’ll say there’s still that Edith Piaf and French art aspect in France now but it’s mostly modernised I mean there’s everything French rap everything like really there are multiple cultures here and it depends with the region of the country
When you are going to Eurovision 2019, YOU MUST WATCH NORWAY!!!!! I can't wait to see your reaction to Spirit in the sky. It's one of the greatest song robbed by jury of all time (almost the same as cha cha cha) (the contest not hold in 2020 due to covid.)
As Italian myself I must advise you that France is our best "frienemy", so I dont give a thing easyly to them, But I must say, I finf a lttle ingratefull from US citizen to have bad stereotips over France wend Whitout them you will be under the emglish crown for who know how much time :)In any case, French music between the end of the 19th century and 1960 was very important and actually used precisely these stylistic features that Pravì has now proposed to us again. With a slightly older arrangement it could easily be part of the repertoire of Piaf or Aznavour.
@@luisfilipe9272 Come on, it's a generalisation. It's a widespread feeling for us as much as for them but, at the same time, you will never find an individual who really hates the French as such. I believe the underlying reasons for the friction are based on a certain competitiveness between peers, opinions on who produces the best wine, the best cheese or the best bread. As well as the fashion and design competition. Then there are also some historical reasons, the acquisition of Corsica was a half-scam to the detriment of the Republic of Genoa, while the transfer of Nice and Savoy which were given in exchange for support against the Austrians left a bad taste in the mouth. to the inhabitants of the same regions. Then in the twenty years of fascist Italy we were the ones who declared war on the allies (France and England) without any justification but I would find it unfair to blame the Italians as a people for the mistakes of an authoritarian regime that they too suffered. Anyway. Even historically, the two peoples have at different times made an enormous impact on Western culture, obviously not alone, for example with the Renaissance at the end of the Middle Ages and the Risorgimento in the mid-19th century for Italy and with the Enlightenment and the French Revolution for France. Evidently it is a competition that bears fruit.
It's very Parisian, which is what foreign people think of as French since the early last century. And sure it has been/is a treasured style in the country. It's somewhat of a conundrum for France, since every time they send anything else, it doesn't do well because people go "well that's not French". The whole stereotype of "THIS is French music" is sort of a handicap. For instance, when they sent Alvan & Ahez with "Fullen", a lot of people outside of France were like "that's not France", when in fact it is. There was even backlash because it had similar vibes to Spain's second choice in their national selection (a Gallician band), even tho the french team had composed it first, the resemblance just came from Celtic roots. There's dozens of local cultures in France (Breton culture, which is more Celtic, Corsican culture, which musically could be described as a mix between Bulgarian and Italian, Creole culture, Alsacian culture, a mix between French and Southern German, Provençale culture, which goes more towards traditional Northern Italy with some French, Basque culture, whose language predates Indo-European ones and is the oldest still alive in Europe, predating Latin and long gone Celtic languages.... and many more). Modern French culture is very very similar to others in Europe because, well, modern world. But it's full of mixed-and-matched ancient Identities people are proud of, and are trying to keep alive, sometimes even facing the adversity of former hostile governments (Breton for instance was suppressed by authorities until quite recently, same for singing styles in Creole Culture, some of which were outright illegal). So it's a bit disheartening when some bands try to herald that on the broader scene of Europe and get told off as invalid. Quick sidenote: in the region of Bretagne, they have been holding a festival called "Interceltiques" since 1971, where they invite celtic artists from around the world to showcase how the culture was and how it is evolving. They have a country "guest of honor" every year that is more featured, and you get bands and artists from Bretagne (obviously), Scotland, Ireland, Wales, Cornwall, the Isle of Man, the Asturias, Galicia, but also the diasporas of Celtic communities in Chile, Mexico, New Zealand and Australia, the USA, Cuba, Argentina... It's held every year in August in the city of Lorient. Second sidenote regarding Eurovision and France: one of the reason France avoids selections by the public most of the time is because the French WILL vote for their more folk/ethnic styles to be sent, and the board knows it won't do well.
Hi, please react to Eurovision 2016, was a wonderful year in sweden, my recomendation Russia (3rd Place) , Ukraine (1st Place), Australia (2nd Place), France (6th place) and Latvia (15th place). Russia won the public vote and Australia de Jury vote but both loose in front of Ukraine 2nd in public vote and 2nd in jury vote. By the way i saw all your reactions of eurovision, my favorite FINLAND with cha cha cha. Great Reaction.
Очаровательная песня😊❤... Как грустно , но и чуть радостно вспоминить 2021, этот последний мирный год, когда было счастье, надежда на освобождения планеты от эпидемии, какие то весёлые планы на будущее и всей Европе было так важно, интересно, какая же песня выиграет на Eurovision 🎉!!! Всего лишь через полгода вся "беззаботность" и фантазии будут разрушены, навеки😒... Но тогда победа была такая великолепная и яркая‼️ Как я понимаю , выступление Måneskin, будет, естественно, абсолютно заблокировано, как всегда 😔... но надеюсь, вы получите удовольствие от их роскошного номера , хотя лучше всего группа выступает полностью live🔥. У них скоро заканчивается второй world tour с полным sold out, год назад вышел их альбом с супер профессиональным, но ,не вполне подходящим им звуком и за этот год на концертах они просто сделали чудо -- превратили довольно холодное, commercial звучание в энергичные , ироничные rock, glam, punk песни🤟❤️🔥! Благодарю вас за эти приятные воспоминания и эмоции, PEACE 🤍🕊
Ой, а що ж сталося за півроку? Якось не зрозуміло з вашого тексту… може хвороба якась? Чи велика автокатастрофа? Може виверження вулкану? Не зрозуміло…
@@user-redin67d Да я просто не хотела писать здесь мимоходом... это не уважительно к этой страшной теме... Мне просто тоскливо, что пыня тогда разрушил и мою жизнь и всех... но здесь , наверное, не место писать подробнее, здесь жизнерадостные люди, далёкие от всего ( чтож, их счастье 😏...) Ведь наверняка, они не будут слушать ни Måneskin, ни тот же Gasoline и разбираться в его содержании и антивоенном послании ( разве что, если им вдруг понадобится сотня- другая новых подписчиков) Так что, это были только мои эмоции, возвращение к тому, чего никогда больше не будет 😑...
If you are going to cointinue down the eurovision road here are some of my personal favourites: 1- fairytale by alexander rybak 2- fuego by eleni foureira 3- arcade by duncan laurence 4- la forza by elina nechayeva 5- soldli by mahmood
Eurovision 2020 Week!!! The 2020 Show was cancelled. There’s were the top 5 fan favorites. 5. Norway - Ulrikke -Attention 4. Bulgaria - Victoria - Tears Getting Sober 3. Iceland - Daõi & Gagnamagniõ - Think About Things 2. Switzerland - Gjon’s Tears - Répoundez-moi 1. Lithuania - The Roop - On Fire
The man on the right knows edith piaf like 90% of people on this planet and may be be others french artists like daft punk or 8:19 david guetta etc... but the one on the left....
I feel like it's the chanson genre that most non-French people see as "stereotypical French music", I mean Edith Piaf was at the roots of the modern chanson and Voila is definitely of this genre Also Europe might be stereotyping France harder than you'll ever do since more modern French songs actually do worse at the ESC than the one like this
I heard in one of your videos that someone said that 2021 was the best year in Eurovision, well that person must be young as hell xto say that and dont know anything about Eurovision b4 they were born. The best ever era in Eurovision is clearly the 1980´s, meaning 1980 to 1989, then Eurovision took a turn to the worst when Televoting came along and semi-finals were invented and when Internet leaked all the songs before the final. Before nobody was able to hear all song before a week of the final, me being swedish knew the swedish song and the danish song bcos I only had swedish and danish tv to watch. These days it isnt Eurivision Song Contest anymore but Eurovision Preformance Contest, nobody cares if the singer have a singing voice or not, its what happens on stage that counts, like Finland getting 2nd place last year, he couldnt even sing. 2021 according to me is one of the worst years in Eurovision history, maybe 5 good songs that year.
French entries are not my cup of tea, they all seem very sterotypical and on the boring side (this is just my opinion, Fulenn was the exception). But this is why the staging is so important in Eurovision, it's an equal part in the production and impression it will achieve among the viewers.
I don't think you are stereotyping french music at all, even to us other europeans back in 2021 this was the frenchest french entry to ever french haha they went full 1000% and it was excellent
lol I'm Lithuanian. That is exactly what I was thinking at the time as well!
To me it was a bit boring, a fine performance of course but soo French...
French modern music it's not that !
I'm Spanish and this looked full baguette to me, but she would have been my winner if there was not Måneskin there
And then in 2023 they went even more french.
Ugh, 2021 truly was one of the best Eurovision years of the 21st century. So many good entries.
And as #1 will be Spain, so many great songs will still be left out 💔
@@Prafik614Don't you mean Italy?
@@tamaravanhees1749 oh dear YES 100%!!! What of an embarrassment 🫣 Thank you for correcting 🥰
@@Prafik614Thank you for thinking Måneskin were Spanish ❤😂
Also, 2022 ❤
Is it just me, or it is a joy to watch this two guys to react to Eurovision? Their commentary is so smart, relaxed, goofy... it's delightful. I just hope that they react someday to the video with all the winners of Eurovision from 1956-2023
They are great, so relaxed so focused on what they're hearing and seeing
Brit here 🇬🇧 No, you’re right this is the frenchest thing ever, and Edith Piaf was indeed also French! You’re also right Voilà means “there/here it is”. There are so many French words in English because the (Norman) French invaded England in 1066 and ruled the country for about 300 years - the upper classes and rulers spoke French in England until about the 14th century. And so many French words made their way into English.
Edith Piaf is not a bad reference actually! And the song was middlingly successful in France but it does sound like a good version of what other countries think France sounds like.
Kudos to the organizers for creating such atmosphere for the entries with some lights and shadows, Eurovision is amazing in that aspect as well.
The countries taking part get to design the lights, led screens, the camera work, etc. Some countries invest a lot in it, others less. But yes the year's organizers have a huge responsibility creating the stage, planning the hosting and middle acts, the camera work during the performances, etc. It's an enormous production. Some years it's better, other years a bit less so, but it's not too serious as we're sort of used to it not being perfect every year and it's just the way it is. Awkward moments with hosts and unentertaining middle acts are a part of Eurovision
Barbara actually worked closely with the camera man and mentioned him often. They fist-bumped after this performance.
It was a super intimste performance on a huge stage. And her shadow dispersing into birds gets me every time.
I am Swiss and to me this was the most French entry ever, as well.
Actually about 55% of the words in English are originally French. And the rest are Old English (i.e. Germanic). It's because for centuries we had a French-speaking aristocracy ruling over commoners speaking Old English, and eventually they basically just merged into one language.
It's why we have so many words with a pair of synonyms: one French, and one Germanic. For example "pensive" (French) / "thinking" (Germanic); "beef" (French) / "cow" (Germanic); "fraternal" (French) / "brotherly" (Germanic); "purchase" (French) / "buy" (Germanic) - and *lots* more. It's also why English has about twice as many words in it as either French or German - we basically decided not to choose between them, we just kept everything.
Voilà !
Germanic??? Old norse is brother, cow, thinking, so don't know what you mean with germanic. It is Viking language.
@@lovisalindstrom7920 the roots are not Old Norse, they’re Old English, which was the language spoken by the Anglo-Saxons. The reason they are similar to Old Norse is because the Nordic languages are *also* Germanic languages.
And a lot of the mordern european languages derive from Latin, you can find roots from english and french especially and obviously Italian. Most European languages come from the same place :)
@@la.uralox not exactly, most modern European languages are either Germanic, Slavic, or Romance (from Latin), with a handful of other smaller roots. But Germanic and Slavic languages have very little derived from Latin.
English is unique because it doesn’t fall into one family. Even though it is categorised as a Germanic language, over half of its lexicon is Romance (from Old French). It is a true mongrel language.
I am so glad you guys are doing more Eurovision, we’re all big fans here in Europe 😀 I’ve been watching Eurovision every year since 2002!
So if you want to continue this journey, here’s my suggestion for the next five:
1. Conchita Wurst - Rise like a phoenix, Austria 2014 (winner)
2. Alexander Rybak - Fairytale, Norway 2009 (winner)
3. Lordi - Hard rock Hallelujah , Finland 2006 (winner)
2. Sergei Lazarev - You’re the only one, Russia 2016 ( not actual winner, but it was controversial. And it will blow your mind how they managed to do that things on stage)
1. Duncan Lawrence - Arcade, Netherlands, 2019 (winner)
Good luck 😊
Great list!
As a French person, love your comments lol 😂 We do love our cheese and wine 🍷 and yes, raw artistry is very valued here 🇫🇷😉
Mimes are French also lol, « mimer » literally means imitating
Please, write 5 modern French songs to made us to understand modern French music! Maybe they are going to do french week. It is will be interesting!
@@user-redin67dIndila, mc solaar, tayc, calogero, Orelsan, Gims, julien Doré
Check out the lyrics, they are nice... it is about her being an artist bearing herself and her vulnerability to the audience... she says Voila! as in Here I am, this is me, and my art :)
Thrilled to see you reacting to this year.
European here. This song is perfect. It should have won, in my opinion. It's so emotional.. Here I am , look at me, all my flaws, all that I am before you, love me. This is all I have to give, I just want to write my own stories and share them with you. I'm just a girl with a dream...
This is my winner from 2021. Simply impeccable.
i like this song on first hearing. when someone have sucha a bacic stage and keeps you all 3 minutes watching that is definition of good song. But then i saw lyrics and everything got even more sense. Song is about artist who is unsecure in hes abilities and will ppl apriciate what that artist do. Basicly it is about her, and that explains pasion with which she sing this song.
2021 was SO GOOD. So many entries singing with their own languages, and still getting the message through clear as daylight. I don't speak french, but MAN I felt this passion/pain. Great performance!
So much the better if you like it, it was made for it. The staging, the play of lights and the camera are super skillful and clever.
But if I can give you my opinion as a Frenchman, I find that this performance is too caricatured French, it is really a production to please a foreign audience by activating the "nostalgia" of an idealized France of the 50s. And fortunately you don't understand the lyrics, cause they are quite weak, it's a "facebook" lament to have friends and be loved...
As a Frenchman, I am really disappointed that it is this well-produced and well-formatted song that has brought the most points to France in recent years, our French artists are capable of doing so much more creative and more original...
She commented during an interview that she listened to all previous winners and, at the end, the common thing in all of them is the presence of emotion. I think she tried to give it as much emotion as she could.
The song was hers so the connection was obvious.
The frenchies French song coming out of France. I liked it a lot and I still do.
2021 Eurovision was full of amazing songs, the production was of the highest level. I really liked this song, the simplicity of the arrangement and the emotions she conveyed (I’m Italian).
Look for Stromae - he is singing in french. U can make even top 5 from him
5 Fils de joie
4 Tout les memes
3 Papaoutai
2 Alors on Danse
1 Formidable
That vibe is so french and I love it.
Beyond her sheer elegance, raw emotion and the song's Jacques Brel-esque composition, the real genius in this performance was the intimate staging - despite the raucous arena setting around her, it seemed as though she was making this passionate plea only to you, the viewer, with increasing intensity until the very end. A truly gorgeous entry.
2021 was the best Eurovision year. Every single performance from the top 5 really deserved to win in my opinion, and I never could tell which one I loved the most, bcs they were just perfect each in their own way. But what I can say - this French performance is my absolute favorite from all French entries.
My winner that year, without a doubt. ❤️
I heard her saying on some show about her background. Her mother is Iranian and father is Serbian. So, she is a child of immigrants stereotyping French culture as well. But she did it so good and with so much charm, I can't stop singing.
Greetings from Ireland. I love that you guys are loving Eurovision. I always assumed that Americans wouldn’t get it. It is quirky after all. Yes Edith Piaf was French and yes I agree that this performance was very much in the style of Piaf. Great song and performance.
You guys are hysterical. You portray yourselves as a couple of Amer rubes, but your intuitive calls are spot on. The last part of Voila is Barbara (new Edith) as throwing herself frenetically onto a musical carousel (into the chaos for our entertainment) and holds on desperately as it spins faster and faster until she explodes. Take that! She says. There it is! Voila’… by the way, the term for that style is French Chanson. Maybe check our Lara Fabian on Je T’aime live. She’s the modern version. And, of course, Emma Kok which is how people find their way here in the first place. Great job.
KONSTRAKTA - IN CORPORE SANO 2022 (Serbia)
I'm not Franch myself, but I believe this performance would be better described as Jacques Brel more than Edith Piaf, even though Barbara is definitely more Edith Piaf than Jacques Brel (except Edith always wore a classic little black dress... always. If you're running off to research Jacques Brel now, and you should be, you should start with his rendition of Amsterdam (the song, not the city)
Franche have been putting in very Franch songs ever since they last won the contest in 1977, and I hope they never stop, they're generally amongst my favourites and I hope it's not too long before they win again. I enjoyed this one, she was unlucky not to win.
Jacques Brel is Belgian
Il est bien belge, mais il chantait généralement en français.@@firstsurname7099
This year was so hard to choose the winner... there was great songs... this is one of them... so so beautiful... she gives me chills
As a French person, while I love this song and Barbara to death, this not at all what kind of music the average french person listen to. If you look at french streaming numbers, it's mainly about french hip hop, on the radio it's avout french pop, and then you can add all the international hits american listen to. At Eurovision, people expect us to do some french chanson, which is a strength because it stands out, but a weakness because it's not what our actual music industry produces. When it comes to french stereotypes, the french bashing in the American world can be explained by France not always blindfully following the US, whether it was NATO or the Iraq war, combined with the historical UK v France dynamic that has translated to American culture. I would say France always surrender is very much historically inacurate, that we're not more racist than our neighbors, and probably not as arrogant as it is believed. When I was younger, navigating the web centered around American culture was quite hard, considering the jokes on the fr*nch that were on there but I got used to it I guess. Everyone has to deal with their stereotypes, I'm sure all the "America: fat, guns, bad healthcare" are annoying to get over and over.
I love France (especially Normandy / Bretagne / Pays de la Loire area) and we’ve been driving a lot around there. I often turn the radio on and I always find it interesting that basicly it’s really hard to hear anything but french hiphop on the radio 😄 Like is that all that everyone listens to? You should definitely send french hiphop to Eurovision!
As a non-french european, I find the anti french attitude of the anglo-saxons so irritating and arrogant
(UK here) I’d agree with you on this, I can see this doesn’t represent current French music but it absolutely delighted the UK. Why? Because despite all the tired old jokes in the right wing press that resonate with a particular generation, we are mostly suckers for anything French. Most people will put France up there as their favourite European country and have a lot of respect for the strong voice of the French people. It wasn’t just the French sound Barbara brought though, the passion and the performance were absolutely captivating. Stereotypes are infuriating I think for any country, and whist Voila might play on them a bit, it was a wonderful entry. Should have won!
I know it’s probably not stereotypical French either but I loved your song Fulenn. Surprising, intriguing, wonderful! ❤
In Italy trap is top streaming and selling, but when you see some entries and some song you can tell if it is ‘typical’ italian.
This is the most french song the same way.
Regarding English having words from other languages. It also has many words from Old Norse, from the time when the Danish Vikings invaded the British isles and ruled parts of it. Examples are window, steak and egg.
Many Americans think they have invented English!! 🙄
2021 is my favourite Eurovision in maybe 10 years
Totally agree! First 10 songs all a good different songs! Malta, Lithuania and russia was cool to!
Also interesting face about Eurovision 2021 is that it was held in Rotterdam in The Netherlands and Nikkie De Jager-Drossaers was a co host of the evening she is more know under Nikkietutorials on RUclips
@WeeklyTop5 You guys should do a top 5 of Stromae, a Belgian international artist who was the first exclusively French-singing performer to sell out Madison Square garden. He worked with Kanye West, Lorde, Coldplay, Camila Cabello...
2021 was a damm good year for eurovision.
France is big in the house/electronic music with Daft punk, David guetta, dj snake and many others internationally known
For me this was No 1 that year. You should check out Serbia's entry for 2022, just make sure you turn on English translation
I think it woulf be cool if you guys closed or opened these weeks with a reaction to the recap of the whole year.
To get an idea of all the songs not just the top 5 which honestly aren't always that interesting and always leave out certain countries or underrated entries.
We need a french weeek ! Indila, mc solaar, orelsan, matt Pokora, julien Doré
Definitely worth listening to Emma Kok's rendition of Voila with Andre Rieu
Phoenix, justice, air, daft punk, David Guetta, indila, Aya Nakamura… I’m sure you know more about current French music than what you think ;) regarding this Eurovision song, it’s just made for Eurovision, playing on a modern Edith Piaf style, no one listens to that there otherwise. ;)
Great point we definitely know and like most of those artists. Sometimes mid video we just don’t remember!
Polo & Pan, Fakear
That was wonderful. Like a modern Edith Piaf.
Eurovision Week #5 - Bizarre Masterpiece Performances
1. Hard Rock Hallelujah - Lordi [Finland] - 2006 - Winner
2. Toy - Netta [Israel] - 2018 - Winner
3. Party for Everybody - Buranovskiye Babushka [Russia] - 2012 - 2nd Place
4. In Corpore Sano - Konstrakta [Serbia] - 2022 - 5th Place
5. UNO - Little Big [Russia] - 2020 - Contest Cancelled due to Covid, but Most Watched Eurovision Entry of All Time
1-4 - Watch their grand final performances
5 - Watch their Eurovision Official Music Video
"I have no idea about the modern musical culture of France..." me... daft punk, david guetta, martin solveig, bob sinclar, Willy William etc..
You never go wrong with France and you always know what to expect. Just hope Hard Rock Halleluja by Lordi would be on your list.
An article was saying Barbara started out in pop, but switched to the traditional French style Chanson (is that the correct word?) and never went back. So yes, it will sound very French, but it should, bc it's a French style. It's unfortunate that this reviewing duo did not include a copy with the lyrics. The lyrics are very important to the intensity. She wrote the song with two others to mark a moment where she realized she could create, and she could do, to mark the change in phase in life. If anyone is wanting to go down the rabbit hole of French history in contradiction to the Anglo-Saxon view, there's a cool book written by a comedian called 1000 Years of Annoying the French. It's a thick book, and a laugh, and tells you everything you need to know about French history and the evolution to French culture today.
As others have said there are so many French words in English.
I believe the French say CV (curriculum vitae) as we do in the UK, rather than resumé, as used in the US.
Voilà means “there you go”! Voici means “here you are!”
English vocabulary is about 40% French, and about 30% Latin. The rest is made up of Old German, old Norse, Celtic languages, and whatever you’re having yourself.
Did you never hear of William The Conqueror from Normandy? The English aristocracy spoke French for four centuries after 1066. In fact, their motto “Dieu et mon droit” is still to this day written in French, not in English.
And in European English (Ireland 🇮🇪, the UK 🇬🇧, Malta 🇲🇹) we use a lot more French words when we speak English than you do in the US.
As an Irishman who teaches English 🏴 and French 🇫🇷 in Mexico 🇲🇽, this becomes apparent when my students ask me why I spell English words “the French way”?! eg. Metre, centre, colour, flavour, criticise, advertise etc.
I hastily watched through the comments and didn't see a comment about it, but it's interesting how you happened to pause on the one picture where her hand is, which is the sign for females to give the bartender/restaurant/whatever place that means "help me, call the police or get this person away from me, PLEASE".
Why are there so many french words in English? Because England was ruled by the Normans for nealry 100 years from 1066, and the nobility and courtiers all spoke in french....Lots of french words stuck....
'Voila!' literally means 'See there!' so you say it when presenting something.
This was a very different presentation of a song, with pretty much just her, standing there. No team of dancers to back her up.
90's ESC reactions wishlist: Iceland 1997, Spain 1995, Poland 1995, Norway 1995, France 1991
So great!
This was the frenchiest french song France has ever frenched in Eurovison xD
Now you need to react to Salvador Sobral's "Amar pelos dois", Portugal's entry from 2017 (it was the winner that year). Pretty romantic, slow paced song
you should check Merci from France too
FOR THE VERY FIRST TIME I SAW HER AND HEARED HER i said edith piaf VIBES ,,,
I learned new word today. Franch 🤣
She is France/Serbian and she should have won
This was my winner 😢
Please react also to the interval act 'Sweet Water by Davina Michelle' of this years (2021) Eurovision.
Yeah the stereotypes about us suck ass but we also do have our own share of stereotyping the hell out of everyone ( mostly Belgians and Americans 😅 ) , now I’ll say there’s still that Edith Piaf and French art aspect in France now but it’s mostly modernised I mean there’s everything French rap everything like really there are multiple cultures here and it depends with the region of the country
When you are going to Eurovision 2019, YOU MUST WATCH NORWAY!!!!! I can't wait to see your reaction to Spirit in the sky. It's one of the greatest song robbed by jury of all time (almost the same as cha cha cha)
(the contest not hold in 2020 due to covid.)
As Italian myself I must advise you that France is our best "frienemy", so I dont give a thing easyly to them, But I must say, I finf a lttle ingratefull from US citizen to have bad stereotips over France wend Whitout them you will be under the emglish crown for who know how much time :)In any case, French music between the end of the 19th century and 1960 was very important and actually used precisely these stylistic features that Pravì has now proposed to us again. With a slightly older arrangement it could easily be part of the repertoire of Piaf or Aznavour.
Why Italians do not like French? I am from Portugal but I do know, most French love Italy.
@@luisfilipe9272 Come on, it's a generalisation. It's a widespread feeling for us as much as for them but, at the same time, you will never find an individual who really hates the French as such. I believe the underlying reasons for the friction are based on a certain competitiveness between peers, opinions on who produces the best wine, the best cheese or the best bread. As well as the fashion and design competition. Then there are also some historical reasons, the acquisition of Corsica was a half-scam to the detriment of the Republic of Genoa, while the transfer of Nice and Savoy which were given in exchange for support against the Austrians left a bad taste in the mouth. to the inhabitants of the same regions. Then in the twenty years of fascist Italy we were the ones who declared war on the allies (France and England) without any justification but I would find it unfair to blame the Italians as a people for the mistakes of an authoritarian regime that they too suffered. Anyway. Even historically, the two peoples have at different times made an enormous impact on Western culture, obviously not alone, for example with the Renaissance at the end of the Middle Ages and the Risorgimento in the mid-19th century for Italy and with the Enlightenment and the French Revolution for France. Evidently it is a competition that bears fruit.
Top 3 could have been in any order tbh, and I wouldn't have objected.
It's very Parisian, which is what foreign people think of as French since the early last century. And sure it has been/is a treasured style in the country. It's somewhat of a conundrum for France, since every time they send anything else, it doesn't do well because people go "well that's not French". The whole stereotype of "THIS is French music" is sort of a handicap. For instance, when they sent Alvan & Ahez with "Fullen", a lot of people outside of France were like "that's not France", when in fact it is. There was even backlash because it had similar vibes to Spain's second choice in their national selection (a Gallician band), even tho the french team had composed it first, the resemblance just came from Celtic roots. There's dozens of local cultures in France (Breton culture, which is more Celtic, Corsican culture, which musically could be described as a mix between Bulgarian and Italian, Creole culture, Alsacian culture, a mix between French and Southern German, Provençale culture, which goes more towards traditional Northern Italy with some French, Basque culture, whose language predates Indo-European ones and is the oldest still alive in Europe, predating Latin and long gone Celtic languages.... and many more).
Modern French culture is very very similar to others in Europe because, well, modern world. But it's full of mixed-and-matched ancient Identities people are proud of, and are trying to keep alive, sometimes even facing the adversity of former hostile governments (Breton for instance was suppressed by authorities until quite recently, same for singing styles in Creole Culture, some of which were outright illegal). So it's a bit disheartening when some bands try to herald that on the broader scene of Europe and get told off as invalid.
Quick sidenote: in the region of Bretagne, they have been holding a festival called "Interceltiques" since 1971, where they invite celtic artists from around the world to showcase how the culture was and how it is evolving. They have a country "guest of honor" every year that is more featured, and you get bands and artists from Bretagne (obviously), Scotland, Ireland, Wales, Cornwall, the Isle of Man, the Asturias, Galicia, but also the diasporas of Celtic communities in Chile, Mexico, New Zealand and Australia, the USA, Cuba, Argentina... It's held every year in August in the city of Lorient.
Second sidenote regarding Eurovision and France: one of the reason France avoids selections by the public most of the time is because the French WILL vote for their more folk/ethnic styles to be sent, and the board knows it won't do well.
The song is very french indeed but it worked, almost won
Im surprised you didn’t react to Duncan Laurence yet?!
Edith Piaf was indeed a french singer 😊
This is so Parisian. Even someone from Marseille or Bordeaux wouldn't sing a song like this
Half of English language is french and german.
What do they teach you in school over there?!
Hi, please react to Eurovision 2016, was a wonderful year in sweden, my recomendation Russia (3rd Place) , Ukraine (1st Place), Australia (2nd Place), France (6th place) and Latvia (15th place). Russia won the public vote and Australia de Jury vote but both loose in front of Ukraine 2nd in public vote and 2nd in jury vote. By the way i saw all your reactions of eurovision, my favorite FINLAND with cha cha cha. Great Reaction.
Please hear the version of Emma Kok ❤
Очаровательная песня😊❤...
Как грустно , но и чуть радостно вспоминить 2021, этот последний мирный год, когда было счастье, надежда на освобождения планеты от эпидемии, какие то весёлые планы на будущее и всей Европе было так важно, интересно, какая же песня выиграет на Eurovision 🎉!!!
Всего лишь через полгода вся "беззаботность" и фантазии будут разрушены, навеки😒...
Но тогда победа была такая великолепная и яркая‼️
Как я понимаю , выступление Måneskin, будет, естественно, абсолютно заблокировано, как всегда 😔... но
надеюсь, вы получите удовольствие от их роскошного номера , хотя лучше всего группа выступает полностью live🔥.
У них скоро заканчивается второй world tour с полным sold out, год назад вышел их альбом с супер профессиональным, но ,не вполне подходящим им звуком и за этот год на концертах они просто сделали чудо -- превратили довольно холодное, commercial звучание в энергичные , ироничные rock, glam, punk песни🤟❤️🔥!
Благодарю вас за эти приятные воспоминания и эмоции,
PEACE 🤍🕊
Ой, а що ж сталося за півроку? Якось не зрозуміло з вашого тексту… може хвороба якась? Чи велика автокатастрофа? Може виверження вулкану? Не зрозуміло…
@@user-redin67d Да я просто не хотела писать здесь мимоходом... это не уважительно к этой страшной теме... Мне просто тоскливо, что пыня тогда разрушил и мою жизнь и всех... но здесь , наверное, не место писать подробнее, здесь жизнерадостные люди, далёкие от всего ( чтож, их счастье 😏...)
Ведь наверняка, они не будут слушать ни Måneskin, ни тот же Gasoline и разбираться в его содержании и антивоенном послании ( разве что, если им вдруг понадобится сотня- другая новых подписчиков) Так что, это были только мои эмоции, возвращение к тому, чего никогда больше не будет 😑...
If you are going to cointinue down the eurovision road here are some of my personal favourites:
1- fairytale by alexander rybak
2- fuego by eleni foureira
3- arcade by duncan laurence
4- la forza by elina nechayeva
5- soldli by mahmood
Eurovision 2020 Week!!!
The 2020 Show was cancelled. There’s were the top 5 fan favorites.
5. Norway - Ulrikke -Attention
4. Bulgaria - Victoria - Tears Getting Sober
3. Iceland - Daõi & Gagnamagniõ - Think About Things
2. Switzerland - Gjon’s Tears - Répoundez-moi
1. Lithuania - The Roop - On Fire
The man on the right knows edith piaf like 90% of people on this planet and may be be others french artists like daft punk or 8:19 david guetta etc... but the one on the left....
“Are bird a French things ?” Well… Piaf (like in Edith Piaf) is a word for Bird in French
I feel like it's the chanson genre that most non-French people see as "stereotypical French music", I mean Edith Piaf was at the roots of the modern chanson and Voila is definitely of this genre
Also Europe might be stereotyping France harder than you'll ever do since more modern French songs actually do worse at the ESC than the one like this
Please do Anitta, Bang, Sim ou Não, downtown, boys dont cry and envolver. She is amazing artist!
You don't know who Edith Piaf is?? Jeez..
Edit Piaf 2
France are in the habit of sending as french acts as possible, they try to out-french themselves every year.
Le balls a terra.
I heard in one of your videos that someone said that 2021 was the best year in Eurovision, well that person must be young as hell xto say that and dont know anything about Eurovision b4 they were born.
The best ever era in Eurovision is clearly the 1980´s, meaning 1980 to 1989, then Eurovision took a turn to the worst when Televoting came along and semi-finals were invented and when Internet leaked all the songs before the final. Before nobody was able to hear all song before a week of the final, me being swedish knew the swedish song and the danish song bcos I only had swedish and danish tv to watch.
These days it isnt Eurivision Song Contest anymore but Eurovision Preformance Contest, nobody cares if the singer have a singing voice or not, its what happens on stage that counts, like Finland getting 2nd place last year, he couldnt even sing.
2021 according to me is one of the worst years in Eurovision history, maybe 5 good songs that year.
Well, Eurovision fans must be very young then because in many Eurovision videos on RUclips the comments saying that 2021 was one of the best editions.
French entries are not my cup of tea, they all seem very sterotypical and on the boring side (this is just my opinion, Fulenn was the exception). But this is why the staging is so important in Eurovision, it's an equal part in the production and impression it will achieve among the viewers.
Loved Fulenn... Although I did think the grand final performance was significantly worse than their original one sadly.