I just heard an Andrew Yang talking point from Joe Biden. We need someone that is generational not chasing the buzz words that are resonating in the public debate.
I don't understand what generational has to do with deep critical thoughts and proven solutions over major challenges as climate change and automation cutting jobs.
I remembered this interview when he was elected. A reminder that we need a sane compassionate and thoughtful person in power to exemplify the good traits that I know Americans still have
@jakesully Ok that's not true, he's at 4% rn, number 4 or 5 in the polls (yang)... honestly I think that's because of his reduced airtime. this would be a great opportunity for him to go on the show. So your argument is actually an argument in my favor
I think Biden is a nice man. But he is not who we need as president. We need real change in this country, not someone who isn’t willing to take us to the next level.
Yeah, getting into politics can do that to you. No joke! Look at a before and after image of nearly every dignitary just one year after they got elected.
He talked about it without understanding the problem. He stole a few lines from Yang but offers an absolute zero solution. Yang understands this inside and out and offers tons of solutions.
L PT I’ve heard that Joe Biden told yang he wants to have a conversation about the middle class, but not that he supports ubi. Only candidates that support ubi other than yang are Tulsi Gabbard and Marianne Williamson
Right, but Yang has a policy to handle it. The result of this revolution will be that the rich people who the government and economy is _for_ don't need us, they won't need us, they won't hire us.
If Joe's sourcing his ideas from Andrew Yang on 4th Industrial Revolution/Automation/A.I.... then we need to make sure the true leader Andrew Yang gets elected.
skymorality I liked you three times. Once to like it. Twice to try and like it again. Third time to make sure it was liked cause the second time actually unliked it. 😁👍🏽
@@discipleofsakura Andrew Yang and Bernie Sanders are two leading anti-establishment/military -industrial complex/fossil fuel industry. They should team up. What a force we'd be Yang Gang and Bernie Bros.
He is so old and confused he became an Asian man who likes math. That was weird. Google Andrew Yang. Sounds like Biden did. Imitation is the sincerest form of flattery.
Joe Biden is NOT stealing from Andrew Yang. Whilst Andrew Yang has used the "4th industrial revolution" talking point throughout his campaign, it is unfair to characterize Biden as stealing this idea from him. The term "4th industrial revolution" was coined by the German economist Klaus Schwab in an article for Foreign Affairs back in December 2015, www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/2015-12-12/fourth-industrial-revolution. Klaus Schwab is the chairman of the world economic forum, famous for organising a meeting every year in Davos of the best and brightest business leaders from around the globe. In January 2016 around a month after Schwab coined the phrase, Joe Biden was invited to the world economic forum where he gave speech about, you guessed it, the 4th industrial revolution. Biden was vice president at the time and was welcomed on stage by Klaus. You can see the speech for yourself here on RUclips ruclips.net/video/wvxeqc2V4PI/видео.html. Joe Biden was the first american politician to take this term seriously and is probably responsible for introducing the term into political discourse, remember this was before the election of Trump. I get why it seems like Biden is stealing from Yang since it has been a big part of Yang's campaign. Just see that Biden was actually one of the first US politicians to use the phrase well before Yang.
Yang has no claim on the issue of automation. You're being a fool, just like the Sanders fanboys from 2016. It will get Trump re-elected, you have to be focused.
E Ha ha yes. Yang is the one who invented everything, including AI. He found Google, Apple, Microsoft, Amazon etc. No one knew what fourth industrial revolution is before the tech pioneer, genius IQ Andrew Yang decided to grace us with his presidential campaign. Wow, even sarcastically I'm starting to sound like you Yang bots.
Obama sees Yang, but cannot openly endorse him yet. He's been promoting the some of the same conversations Yang has since he left office. Some examples: his speech in South Africa about the rise of automation and AI, and the necessity for some sort of universal basic income; he also had a big hand in the new Netflix documentary, American Factory, which points to Yang's campaign's central platform.
@@joeyphoshowey true...the documentary alone speaks volumes for where obama's head is at right now. i wish he could endorse, but sadly he probably won't, at least not until the democratic candidate is named.
"Either I win, or whoever does sounds exactly like me." - Andrew Yang He called this at the beginning of 2019. I've heard several candidates parroting his talking points lately. His prediction is coming true more than I ever thought it would.
Tyler N. Creed Ha ha yes. Yang is the one who invented everything, including AI. He found Google, Apple, Microsoft, Amazon etc. No one knew what fourth industrial revolution is before the tech pioneer, genius IQ Andrew Yang decided to grace us with his presidential campaign. Wow, even sarcastically I'm starting to sound like you Yang bots.
Kinda wished Colbert had turned around and said "4th industrial revolution" who is the first politician to have mentioned that and has solutions? #YangGang
Richard Willford rightfully his? You sound like a DNC member there. I’ll choose who’s rightfully the best option. Trump would mop the floor with Biden.
Ha ha yes. Yang is the one who invented everything, including AI. He found Google, Apple, Microsoft, Amazon etc. No one knew what fourth industrial revolution is before the tech pioneer, genius IQ Andrew Yang decided to grace us with his presidential campaign. Wow, even sarcastically I'm starting to sound like you Yang bots.
He took Yang's talking points but gave no solutions for it. That is Joe Biden and he doesn't even understand what he is talking about... That is the irony.
Baloney. Andrew Yang could learn a lot from Joe Biden. I like a lot of what Andrew Yang has offered but sometimes the teacher learns from the student AND sometimes the teacher teaches the student.
@@dr.catherineelizabethhalse1820 , yes when given a choice between Joe Biden and Trumpty Dumbty, going with Joe Biden. You have a problem with that? Tough. Trumpty Dumbty has taken OUR COUNTRY back to the racist past and we are better than this. His days of bigotry baiting and dividing our country are over. Bye bye or Das badonya comrade.
Joseph Hsiao What *HE* calls the 4th industrial revolution? The whole world has been calling it that for years now. Yang has brought it into discussion in politics. Biden is a joke.
Joe Biden is NOT stealing from Andrew Yang. Whilst Andrew Yang has used the "4th industrial revolution" talking point throughout his campaign, it is unfair to characterize Biden as stealing this idea from him. The term "4th industrial revolution" was coined by the German economist Klaus Schwab in an article for Foreign Affairs back in December 2015, www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/2015-12-12/fourth-industrial-revolution. Klaus Schwab is the chairman of the world economic forum, famous for organising a meeting every year in Davos of the best and brightest business leaders from around the globe. In January 2016 around a month after Schwab coined the phrase, Joe Biden was invited to the world economic forum where he gave speech about, you guessed it, the 4th industrial revolution. Biden was vice president at the time and was welcomed on stage by Klaus. You can see the speech for yourself here on RUclips ruclips.net/video/wvxeqc2V4PI/видео.html. Joe Biden was the first american politician to take this term seriously and is probably responsible for introducing the term into political discourse, remember this was before the election of Trump. I get why it seems like Biden is stealing from Yang since it has been a big part of Yang's campaign. Just see that Biden was actually one of the first US politicians to use the phrase well before Yang.
@@peterobermeyer Like "Automation is going to become a problem?" I've heard warren and Booker say the same thing. Talking about the same issue isnt ripping people off.
Wow, I'm glad to hear Joe making Yang's talking points on 4th industrial revolution, but I would of respected him more if he said Yang was the one that opened his eyes.
Alexander Stone Please, Yang is the first to admit he will take any good idea from anywhere and he wouldn’t stop there. I’ve heard him credit the authors of a few ideas he’s used, not to mention that he keeps crediting how Thomas Paine, Nixon and MLK JR, etc had same goals in mind, UBI. As in it’s not his ideas. It’s not about him, it’s about us. Humanity. Yang is a real leader and real leaders know how to surround themselves with smart people as well as develop others. The people are responding so well to him, Biden isn’t the only one taking queues from Yang, and you know it.
@@jayguilloty6560 Yang wouldn't even be a possibility if it weren't for Bernie Sanders and the Occupy movement. Don't squander a good thing. Experience matters.
Gonzalo Chocano Ha ha yes. Yang is the one who invented everything, including AI. He found Google, Apple, Microsoft, Amazon etc. No one knew what fourth industrial revolution is before the tech pioneer, genius IQ Andrew Yang decided to grace us with his presidential campaign. Wow, even sarcastically I'm starting to sound like you Yang bots.
Can you believe that interview 😩 she just looked and sounded so stupid, especially when she tried to accuse Bernie of stealing ideas from Andrew Yang I was just like WTF are you talking about Bernies policies and stance have been around for decades. Whats even worse is he got zero credit for raising minimum wages in so many corporations
"What I call... other people call... the 4th Industrial Revolution." The "other people" is Andrew Yang - he's basically using Yang's talking points, including talking to the truckers. Sheesh. This problem needs Andrew Yang.
@@denises9936 If you're saying he's been acknowledging automation and the dangers of job displacement from AI longer than Yang, you're wrong. If you're talking about a career as a politician, correct. Joe hasn't had any other career, which I see as a huge negative.
@@denises9936 You can't compare a con artist, born into money, who lost a lot of it in bankruptcies while scamming his contractors to Andrew Yang. Yang is self-made, and as soon as he had success he left private industry and started a non-profit to push talent to upcoming/revitalizing cities instead of the coasts. The problem with Trump is not that he's from outside politics, it's that he's an egomaniac and a fool. Joe is partially responsible for Trump being elected. Why? While the world was burning in Michigan, Ohio, Pennsylvania -- as future Trump voters were losing their jobs -- he and Obama's administration ignored the problem. What did he do? He's not a leader. And now, he's speaking about this as "4th industrial revolution" -- which has been Yang's talking point for over a year, AND presenting the WRONG solutions to that problem. When he was in a position to make a difference to those people, he failed them. Under his watch, the democratic party left behind the working class. He is not a leader, and we need a leader to beat Trump.
Jesse Thompson A moderate or an independent or even a Republican who can’t stand Trump isnot going to vote for a left wing candidate. And Yang knows nothing about governing or foreign policy or passing legislation. And his gimmick of $1000 a month is reminiscent of Trump’s ridiculous promises that smart people knew were pie in the sky. Yangs a big no for me.
Get Andrew Yang on here please so he can properly explain the 4th industrial revolution. He says @ 11:14 other people have said, That other people is Yang!
You act like Yang coined the term when its been in use for years. Biden may of stolen the term from him, I don't know, but don't act like Yang invited it, here is a video 3 years old talking about it; ruclips.net/video/kpW9JcWxKq0/видео.html
Im not saying he coined the phrase. He was the only one talking about it. Now other candidates are jumping his ideas and that's a good thing. That'll force some back and forth on the debate stage and that's when I think AY will shine. That video sounds like mark of the beast stuff where we evolve technically and regress spiritually and empathetically. Pretty interesting and scary, thx. Check this one out. fwd to 4:17:25. Chapter 15. Talks about how we implode from the inside. ruclips.net/video/MC25cPvp4zg/видео.html
TheNzFox Because automation didn't start yesterday. It could still have been hot topic in 2016. But no politician have run on it. Trump only blamed it on mexicans
I wonder if Colbert is on the Biden train. I really do. And he isn't very kind to Bernie. The rich people out there want Biden because they know he won't be aggressively coming after their MILLIONS of dollars. And, yeah, Biden is just rolling on other people's ideas. So, right now it's between Bernie, Biden, and Warren as, at this point, I highly doubt that any of the other contenders are going to magically rise to the top. I'm not really sure if Warren has what it takes to helm a superpower. We need her more right where she is, in the Senate. That leaves Bernie since Biden is falling hard. And even though a lot of people seem to think that Biden could beat Trump, Trump would practically eviscerate him. That and Biden won't get people to go to the polls. We need someone who is going to get things done and not just coast through their term as president, like Biden did throughout his entire career. :/
@@CybershamanX dude, all msm is on biden's side. He represents the establishment, the status quo, and old power. This is in the interests of those in power currently, because them having power is the status quo. Those in power own the media. The media must back Biden. It's beautifully circular
@@isaacpicon169 Hardly. He may indeed be "in charge, but he's doing nothing but his best to be a two bit dictator. And it's pushing our country's system of checks and balances to the limit. Far from actually doing anything of any real positive consequence, he's just playing "king" while others maintain things regardless of what he _wants_ to do. We constantly hear stories of how Trump's underlings actually hide things from him so that he won't get involved. It's beyond embarrassing. :/
Bernie and Warren ARE the relevant progressives they're polling neck and neck with Biden. Yang is at 3% and he's not exactly a progressive. His stance on climate change is awful.
Ha ha yes. Yang is the one who invented everything, including AI. He found Google, Apple, Microsoft, Amazon etc. No one knew what fourth industrial revolution is before the tech pioneer, genius IQ Andrew Yang decided to grace us with his presidential campaign. Wow, even sarcastically I'm starting to sound like you Yang bots.
Random User no one ever claimed any of that. Yang gives credit to policies he got from others like Thomas Paine, Martin Luther King Jr etc. Unlike Biden who spouts problems and no real solutions. Stop trying to blow things out of proportion.
That's the only different from Yang to the other candidates is he talks about all that ubi stuff. Vote for someone that puts health care and climate change as there main talking points. Bernie2020
Biden taking all the Yang talking points! I'm glad the important issues Yang is raising is getting airtime but if you want to hear more coming from AY himself.. google "Andrew Yang"
Anyone watching this should watch Andrew Yang’s interview with Joe Rogan from February. Yang said all the good parts that Biden said, but offers MUCH better solutions... Biden basically copied Yang’s assessment of our country’s situation, but it doesn’t seem like Biden has a very well thought through solution... Continuing education is not going to be a viable option for MOST people when automation leaves them jobless. Yang, to me, has a better pulse on where we are as a country and on what we need to do to bring unity and progress. As Yang says, “Not right. Not left. Forward.”
I like Rogan but if you don't, here is another great interview with Yang getting asked hard questions by a economist. ruclips.net/video/ZCREBV_m8dY/видео.html
I wish I had came up with it but someone said that on twitter and it made me bust out laughing... !!! It's just so good that I just had to share it with the community at large. :) #yang2020 #yanggang
When did Biden decide to support Yang? He's quoting the opposition now. I guess that's okay. He was quoting Obama; he won. Now he's quoting Yang... I mean I respect Biden but... if you steal the quotes then give the credit.
@@GECKman88 yea but yang already said it a million times before he did and now that the #yanggang is gaining popularity joe biden starts to sound like yang... by pure chance? lmao not a chance
Andrew Yang kept talking about fourth industrial revolution and truckers losing their job to self driving trucks. Thank you Joe Biden for heeding Yang's words. Let's hope America listens just as well
Lafayette Smyre Yang never said he invented the name the 4th industry evolution. The concept has been there for years, Yang is the first one who brought it up in a presidential campaign and had a solution for it. This sleepy Joe know nothing about AI or automation.
Is this just part of the 4chan thing? Seriously. Any video with a Democratic candidate has a bunch of random comments supporting Andrew Yang, who is terrific and smart and has zero chance of getting the nomination. It seems like a right-wing troll "joke."
The thing about short memories is every day's a new day! Joe has completely forgotten that Andrew yang was just there talking about it the night before.. what amaze me was how hes able to memorize it word for word...lol just kidding when they start to sound like Yang that's a good thing ANDREW YANG 2020
I’m glad America has caught up. Joe Biden was fine for a time, but we don’t need him right now, and we don’t want him! Let’s get someone in the White House worth 4 years of America’s time. Bernie for president. He’s what we’ve always needed.
0031badboy it’s still amazes me that so many Bernie and warren fans have not seen the truth yet. It’s soooo obvious and blatant. If you just opened your eyes and ears a little bit, you would realize Yang is the much much better candidate/leader/trump defeater. Hope you see the truth soon enough. Good luck.
Timothy McCaskey seriously?? Polls?? Lol 😂. if there is one thing dems/progressives/mainstream media should’ve learned from 2016...is that polls cannot be trusted. Do you not recall how many libs were weeping in defeat and agony because the polls lied to them that Hillary was going to win because she had a YUUUUUGE lead. Yang2020. Mark my words.
That was a really uncomfortable interview to watch. A string of ramblings with no actual substance. Honestly felt like a mockery of the horrendous atrocities the Trump administration have committed on multiple topics. We get Biden can regurgitate obvious talking points, but what's his actual plan? All I got from that is Hillary 2.0. Please get Bernie on for an actual discussion!
Hillary 2.0 is the perfect way to describe the Biden problem. I still have respect for Stephen Colbert, but I lost some of that respect with this interview... same as when he interviewed Trump. I want to see a joint discussion with Bernie and Elizabeth Warren
If you're seriously backing Yang, who has no shot at getting the nomination, let's be honest, you should be excited Joe, the front runner in the race, is making part of Yang's platform part of his own. Yang's ideas are much more likely to happen now. Four years ago, Bernie was the only one talking about Medicare-for-all. Now it's part of most Democrats' platforms. That's how it happens, if you're too young to have seen it before. Happened with Obama too. In 2008, he didn't support gay marriage but other candidates did. Eventually the whole party adopted it. No one accused Obama of stealing ideas, for essentially doing the right thing. That's just how it works, a minor candidate brings an issue to light and in time, the whole party adopts it.
So same talking points Yang brought to the table. That’s ok, Yang doesn’t care. To Yang, as long as he brings attention to these issues and solutions, that’s all he needs. That’s winning to him. #yanggang
@@ruofanyu6699 He is a very very very big longshot..Biden right now is your only hope to beat tramp and after all that should be the main goal of the elections Without gaining the WH you have nothing but tramp and his family They will never leave
@@carollawrie2414 Biden is the same old same old. Also would NOT win the election against Trump. That's a misconception peddled by the establishment and the Biden campaign. Biden is among the least likely to win against Trump. Trump could easily exploit Biden in a debate, call him names, rally his base against him, point out the various flaws in his candidacy. Yang and Sanders, on the other hand, are the only two candidates with >10% support among Trump voters. Yep that's right, Yang, who had no name recognition at the time of the poll, already has >10% support among Trump voters. His message resonates with everyone once you actually hear him talk.
Yeah, especially since he thinks the government should give every adult in America, one thousand dollars a month! Twelve thousand dollars a year. Sounds insane to me.
@@rustynails.8550 And he wants to pay for it by putting a regressive sales tax on everything, even food. Take from the poor, to give to the rich. It was originally Richard Nixon's idea. Yang will steal from anyone in his desire to be president.
Rick Toles insane? What’s insane is huge companies like Amazon paying zero in taxes. Others making money off our data, and we seeing nothing from all that. The dividend is our share of technology advancing and displacing jobs and our data
@@deborahfreedman333 I just browsed the details on his website. I'm seeing a 10% value added tax (flat) and "Taxes on top earners and pollution. By removing the Social Security cap, implementing a financial transactions tax, and ending the favorable tax treatment for capital gains/carried interest". Sounds progressive to me. What am I missing?
Me neither. He's part of the swamp (which is on both sides of the aisle). Another millionaire politician. Clearly his mind is going, but people who aren't paying attention think he is the same guy from years ago. His name is inspiring fond memories, and that is putting him high in the polls. But when people listen to him, the more he gets out there, the more his numbers slip. Frankly, he reminds me of a grandpa, not an uncle. And it is time he was put out to pasture. His age and doddery walk just emphasizes the truth that we need age limits.
@@lafayettesmyre1094 I see. But I don't think anyone is saying Yang invented the that phrase. Just that he didn't steal it from another Presidential candidate.
Biden please drop out, you don't have to do this to yourself and your family. It was actually sad seeing you sundown at the climate townhall Google Andrew Yang.
@@eliyafethsoto1309 What are you talking about??? Ummm first, get polls out of the conversation. That has no relevance. So it's a logical fallacy straw man grasp move. We are talking about Talking points from candidates, Which Uncle Joe took word from word from another candidate called Andrew Yang. Please reread.
@@nikovz4719 you act like Yang invented the term when a quick google search would show you its been used for years, Klaus Schwab first coined the term in 2015 in an article in 'Foreign Affairs' Biden may be stealing the talking point, but he is not stealing the term
Saying you should be president because you’re better than Trump isn’t really an argument. By that logic about 99% of the US population should run for President...
They should! Literally anyone is better than Trump. When the worst guy in the world is President and making mistakes devastating to the fabric of the country -- your best argument is to say I'm better because I'm the exact opposite.
@@blacknrd05 I'd rather have a candidate like Bernie Sanders or Elizabeth Warren. They are more in line with me politically and cater more to the interests of millennials. I would take anyone over Trump though.
@@scottmoltzan8646 thanks for having common sense. Joe fits in politically with me and electability is a big thing for me. We democrats lost the middle of the country. Joe will help get it back.
Interesting how this video's comments are about Andrew YANG and not biden :) These comedians such as colbert, maher ... etc are out of touch with normal people now.
*Borrrrrrrrrring Joe. The DNC never learned from their last presidential election loss by shoving Hilary Clinton as the nominee, and now another cliche candidate Joe. His interview put me to sleep. The same old tired talking points. The democrats are making it way to easy for Trump to get reelected for a second term.*
To be fair, in his interviews, Steven is always really kind to all of his guests. He was even kind to Trump when he was interviewing him, despite him being almost never saying something nice about the sitting President.
@@deborahfreedman333 Difference between Yang and Trump is that Yang is more intelligent and knows what he's talking about when coming to solutions about our problems in this country. And Trump, well, we all know that story...
When I saw this broadcast I thought to myself three things. One, I remember Andrew Yang saying even if he doesn't become president it would be amazing if his policies be heard and eventual echoed through the other democratic candidates. Two, how nice it would've been to hear Joe Biden mention Andrew Yang (maybe some day). And three, Bernie Sanders also took a page out of Yang's book when speaking to Joe Rogan on the JRE podcast. I have a feeling Andrew Yang's voice will resonate with others even much longer than just these debates.
@@TheProcrastinator6 well uh, I pointed out, uh... look, folks... my dad used to have an expression, "Don't compare me to a competent Vevo commenter, compare me to the alternative" And, look, that's what this blog is all about, folks.
Maison David he will, I know America’s not that stupid to not realize sleepy Joe’s boring and has nothing to say, and that he copied Andrew Yang. But seriously, he’s sooo boring, and he has no knew ideas except for making pre-schoolers kindergarteners...🤣🤣🤣🤣💀💀💀💀
Research Andrew Yang. Biden is a good guy but he’s actually using Yang’s talking points during this interview. I will vote for Yang during the primaries.
Deborah Freedman Cmon... you think Biden didnt take this from Yang who has been saying this constantly. He even corrected himself, when he said “i call, what others call...”
@@lafayettesmyre1094 Andrew Yang is the ORIGINAL candidate to bring it to mainstream attention and to make it an important topic within policy. So yes the other candidates are on his bandwagon. And...Joe Biden VERBATIM copied Andrew Yang's speech. That is called plagiarism. If he were a college student, he could be expelled. Thanks for defending cheaters. 👍🏽 I will use you as an example when speaking to my students about cheating.
@@rachelherrera5867, Yang is the first to make you and many of the folk who've written posts on this commentary but the idea has been around since yang was in high school. Yang should be content that others are touting the idea. If he's really serious about it, he won't care who gets it done.
@@lafayettesmyre1094 naw...we're more than happy to accept that.. just don't wanna see no old folks on subject they don't know nothing about... otherwise you're just setting up the tone for some future bull*****...
"I'm being straightforward." Translation: "I'm saying nothing about corporate ownership of government and I'm not going to mention I'll be keeping it in place."
Trump said he would do something, something along the lines of "draining the swamp", but quite the opposite has occured: Trump's Cabinet has been a revolving door of hires and fires, On a regular basis Trump would attempt things like executive orders to bypass congress on a regular basis. Trump himself is has been under investigation for numerous crimes for which there is evidence that he himself attempted to obstruct which is crime in of itself; nevermind the fact that dozens of former colleagues have all wound in legal hotwater as a result of the investigation. At the point I'm prepared to say that almost ANYONE would better than Trump when comes to fighting corruption in politics as Trump is great steaming pile of it.
@@Jormungrandrserpent Trump drains the swamp into the WH and when it gets too full of sewage now and then he flushes it into the street to make room for more. I agree that just about anybody could get us back to "pre-Trump normalcy," which is STILL corporate ownership of government, and Biden/Harris/Buttigieg/others are running to do just that. The DNC and MSM have found ways to limit coverage (other than derisive coverage) for candidates who break the cardinal rule and don't give the ruling class a chance to buy a piece of their campaigns. In Tulsi's case the freeze-out, from shrunken on-mike time to not asking her any meaningful questions to outright exclusion from the debate floor, is naked revenge because Tulsi did the one thing even more unforgivable than funding integrity. She was in line to be the next DNC chair and instead resigned from the committee to campaign for Bernie. This when she knew the committee had decreed behind closed doors that Hillary would be the nominee. Disobeying marked her for naked revenge. Removing Trump is important for a shipload of reasons but preserving corporate ownership of government will fuel the frustration and anger that led to Trump's election.
And a horrendous voting record over the course of his whole career, dudes been on the wrong side of history his whole career. And he clearly hasn't learned from life long failure because he still brags about what he's done as if any of it's good.
At last! A comment that isn’t (rightly) about how Biden ripped off Yang! This is the first one I’ve seen in the comments! Still critical of Uncle Joe, though, loving the backlash.
Kobaloi Green there’s many of us really - REALLY - trying. He’s got a veritable army of grassroots support. The elite-centrist-money class though is doing everything possible to stop him.
@Eileen Farrar let me guess...you are from the countryside and you are wearing aluminum hat and are fearing to fall of earth when you reach the plates edge ;)
He's talking about giving more money for 'research and development' to the people who are waxing the American public right now, get outta here dude. Sanders 2020
steve crawford age doesn’t matter you dumbass it’s about you’re policies and where you stand on the issues. That’s identity politics and they are the worst way to vote.
Bernie has been saying the same thing 4 over 30 years and has been ahead of the times when it comes to social political and corporate fairness. Not to mention he is healthy mentally Sharp as a tack never stumbles in his words. Bernie Tulsi 2020✌
This is a good thing! Andrew Yang has said that if another politician acknowledges these problems it's a huge win for everyone! I do hope Yang wins it in 2020, he's by far my favorite.
@@deborahfreedman333Yang mentions past American figures who proposed the idea of a basic income. He never claimed that he came up with UBI all on his own. He even mentions that the idea for a basic income isn't a new one. Biden here is using some of Andrew Yang's most well known talking points and acting like these are his very own original concerns. That's very dishonest to me. And also, I'm not sure what you mean by, "made them worse." Different, yes, but definitely not worse. Automation is indeed growing and Yang making that a focal point in this campaign is why many of us side with his ideas.
It's great he's picking up on the problems Yang is addressing, but its a shame he didn't pick up on the solutions.
that would be too obvious copy cat, as if it's not obvious he's stealing ideas from Yang already lmao
Job training for everyone!
He's probably studying and reciting Yang's solutions atm. Lmao.
@@mysticbigmac8782 is it copycat? they are public ideas and frankly good ideas
I just heard an Andrew Yang talking point from Joe Biden. We need someone that is generational not chasing the buzz words that are resonating in the public debate.
I don't understand what generational has to do with deep critical thoughts and proven solutions over major challenges as climate change and automation cutting jobs.
love yang - but this is serious - biden has probably the only real chance
@@thomaswschaller no he doesnt. He cant even talk and is frequently confused. He has dementia or something. Trump will mop him in the debates.
yes, Mr. Biden seems a bit "out of touch".
Joe biden on the ticket will guarantee trump win.
Who's here after he's announced as the president.
I remembered this interview when he was elected. A reminder that we need a sane compassionate and thoughtful person in power to exemplify the good traits that I know Americans still have
Genuine. Real. Empathetic. Light years better than Orange man.
Trumpless
Damn, every other comment here is about the #yanggang Man, the world was so different pre-Covid
@Mary Naz ...grown arse woman with a stupid joke.....we all know who wears the diaper
Can you have Bernie and Yang on the show too?
All we need bro!
He had Bernie on the show twice.
@Bolton take a beat buddy, they both have the same goals
@@emhex exactly
@jakesully Ok that's not true, he's at 4% rn, number 4 or 5 in the polls (yang)... honestly I think that's because of his reduced airtime. this would be a great opportunity for him to go on the show.
So your argument is actually an argument in my favor
I think Biden is a nice man. But he is not who we need as president. We need real change in this country, not someone who isn’t willing to take us to the next level.
You said it spot on.
That's why Trump was elected and will be again. MAGA
Spencer Steward Lol there’s only a need for one Comedian on this video and Colbert has it covered, you’ll have to practice your comedy elsewhere
@@JB-xl2jc Colbert is a comedian? I thought he was a DNC talking head.
@@spencers1485 That will never happen lol.
Damn Yang has turned white and gotten a lot older all of a sudden. Weird.
Yeah, getting into politics can do that to you. No joke! Look at a before and after image of nearly every dignitary just one year after they got elected.
He talked about it without understanding the problem. He stole a few lines from Yang but offers an absolute zero solution. Yang understands this inside and out and offers tons of solutions.
Have you ever heard the name Klaus Schwab? I'd check him out before you give to much more (unoriginal) credit to the Asian guy.
😂😂😂...Biden’s the most overrated guy in politics I’ve ever seen...
Despite the bribe offers it looks like Yang's main source of publicity is the comments section of a RUclips channel.
Holy crap Biden ripped the "4th industrial revolution" line so hard from Andrew Yang.
Yang has said a couple times that Joe is the candidate most open to UBI and the rest of his ideas.
@@lpt5839 Where?!?!
L PT I’ve heard that Joe Biden told yang he wants to have a conversation about the middle class, but not that he supports ubi. Only candidates that support ubi other than yang are Tulsi Gabbard and Marianne Williamson
Except that he apparently doesn't know that our retraining works about 0-15% of the time.
Right, but Yang has a policy to handle it. The result of this revolution will be that the rich people who the government and economy is _for_ don't need us, they won't need us, they won't hire us.
If Joe's sourcing his ideas from Andrew Yang on 4th Industrial Revolution/Automation/A.I.... then we need to make sure the true leader Andrew Yang gets elected.
skymorality I liked you three times.
Once to like it.
Twice to try and like it again.
Third time to make sure it was liked cause the second time actually unliked it. 😁👍🏽
no chance
@@thomaswschaller Yang is a visionary leader, Biden unfortunately is at best a follower...
The true leader is Bernie. #Bernie2020
@@discipleofsakura Andrew Yang and Bernie Sanders are two leading anti-establishment/military -industrial complex/fossil fuel industry. They should team up. What a force we'd be Yang Gang and Bernie Bros.
He is so old and confused he became an Asian man who likes math. That was weird. Google Andrew Yang. Sounds like Biden did. Imitation is the sincerest form of flattery.
dude fantastic move you did there..
#yanggang
It's endorsement so he can retire. Yang will be a landslide victory.
Joe Biden is NOT stealing from Andrew Yang.
Whilst Andrew Yang has used the "4th industrial revolution" talking point throughout his campaign, it is unfair to characterize Biden as stealing this idea from him.
The term "4th industrial revolution" was coined by the German economist Klaus Schwab in an article for Foreign Affairs back in December 2015, www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/2015-12-12/fourth-industrial-revolution.
Klaus Schwab is the chairman of the world economic forum, famous for organising a meeting every year in Davos of the best and brightest business leaders from around the globe.
In January 2016 around a month after Schwab coined the phrase, Joe Biden was invited to the world economic forum where he gave speech about, you guessed it, the 4th industrial revolution. Biden was vice president at the time and was welcomed on stage by Klaus. You can see the speech for yourself here on RUclips ruclips.net/video/wvxeqc2V4PI/видео.html.
Joe Biden was the first american politician to take this term seriously and is probably responsible for introducing the term into political discourse, remember this was before the election of Trump.
I get why it seems like Biden is stealing from Yang since it has been a big part of Yang's campaign. Just see that Biden was actually one of the first US politicians to use the phrase well before Yang.
i was waiting to hear what kind of UBI he was going to propose
Yang has no claim on the issue of automation. You're being a fool, just like the Sanders fanboys from 2016. It will get Trump re-elected, you have to be focused.
Yo man you should have Yang and Bernie on for extended interviews, please. Would really appreciate, and I’m Canadian.
This isn't an "extended interview". It's just the full appearance not chopped into pieces for RUclips...
U u u
My extended interview favorites are Bernie Sanders (2020!) and Elizabeth Warren (VP 2020!)
Hafiz Music
It would be nice if we could get the extended (uncut) version of all the interviews.
the interview trevor noah did with bernie sanders was great check that out.
Damn, Yang really aged on this campaign trail.
LMAO!
Insane !!!!
Lmao!
E Ha ha yes. Yang is the one who invented everything, including AI. He found Google, Apple, Microsoft, Amazon etc. No one knew what fourth industrial revolution is before the tech pioneer, genius IQ Andrew Yang decided to grace us with his presidential campaign. Wow, even sarcastically I'm starting to sound like you Yang bots.
Random User ok thanks for your efforts
“The opposite of Donald Trump is an Asian man who likes math - Andrew Yang”
- Joe Biden
The opposite of Trump is another businessman who wants to become president?
@@trumpetmusic5672 Comparing Trump to Yang is idiotic to the extreme highest levels.
LMAO This went right over people's heads
"Joe, you don't have to do this"
-Barack Obama
*Speaking on after his son died*
Obama sees Yang, but cannot openly endorse him yet. He's been promoting the some of the same conversations Yang has since he left office. Some examples: his speech in South Africa about the rise of automation and AI, and the necessity for some sort of universal basic income; he also had a big hand in the new Netflix documentary, American Factory, which points to Yang's campaign's central platform.
EXACTLY
yeah, I mean joe seems like a very likeable person, but he's not the one we need in the white house.
@@joeyphoshowey true...the documentary alone speaks volumes for where obama's head is at right now. i wish he could endorse, but sadly he probably won't, at least not until the democratic candidate is named.
Fourth Industrial Revolution?
Remember when Andrew Yang taught you about that during the first debate?
"Either I win, or whoever does sounds exactly like me." - Andrew Yang
He called this at the beginning of 2019. I've heard several candidates parroting his talking points lately. His prediction is coming true more than I ever thought it would.
Tyler N. Creed Ha ha yes. Yang is the one who invented everything, including AI. He found Google, Apple, Microsoft, Amazon etc. No one knew what fourth industrial revolution is before the tech pioneer, genius IQ Andrew Yang decided to grace us with his presidential campaign. Wow, even sarcastically I'm starting to sound like you Yang bots.
Random User - Ok, then you must be a Russian bot.
"The opposite of Donald Trump is an Asian man who likes math." -Joe Biden
André Delhaise - and again, Biden took the same words from Yang.
Kinda wished Colbert had turned around and said "4th industrial revolution" who is the first politician to have mentioned that and has solutions? #YangGang
At least he should give credit to Yang !
"The opposite of Donald Trump is an Asian man who likes math. Thank you. Vote Biden 2020" - Joe Biden, 2019
Richard Willford rightfully his? You sound like a DNC member there. I’ll choose who’s rightfully the best option. Trump would mop the floor with Biden.
When did he give credit to yang?
@@Name.is2 He never did and probably never will
Exactly what I thought too.
YANG YANG YANG!!! Give him an extended interview and he will captivate you.
Yang Yang Yang
Yang's been on Colbert already
@@joseranth00 not an extended interview though.
@@joseranth00 5 mins
@@joseranth00 and Colbert was condescending and cutting him off
He copies Yang, but does not have concrete solutions. He rambled on the solutions portions with no real answer
How is he just taking Yangs talking points? If you want real solutions to automation go to yang2020.com
Ha ha yes. Yang is the one who invented everything, including AI. He found Google, Apple, Microsoft, Amazon etc. No one knew what fourth industrial revolution is before the tech pioneer, genius IQ Andrew Yang decided to grace us with his presidential campaign. Wow, even sarcastically I'm starting to sound like you Yang bots.
He took Yang's talking points but gave no solutions for it. That is Joe Biden and he doesn't even understand what he is talking about... That is the irony.
@@randomuser5237 ah... the same message again. You must be on the Biden campaign..
@@randomuser5237 lol thats what biden does lol. Look at his 1988 campaign. He had to drop out after stealing Margaret Thatcher opponent's speech.
Random User Well we actually didn’t claim Yang invented everything. He is the one who came up with a solution that no one else talks about.
Glad joe has learned from Andrew Yang’s speech and policies
Baloney. Andrew Yang could learn a lot from Joe Biden. I like a lot of what Andrew Yang has offered but sometimes the teacher learns from the student AND sometimes the teacher teaches the student.
@@amyreynolds3619 are you seriously defending Biden? Good luck with another 4 years of Trump with that attitude.
Joe has no idea.
Spoiler alert: it's all lies
@@dr.catherineelizabethhalse1820 , yes when given a choice between Joe Biden and Trumpty Dumbty, going with Joe Biden. You have a problem with that? Tough. Trumpty Dumbty has taken OUR COUNTRY back to the racist past and we are better than this. His days of bigotry baiting and dividing our country are over. Bye bye or Das badonya comrade.
Sounded alot like Andrew Yang. I wonder why..
He needs to join #Yanggang!
Biden plagiarized!
“What I call the 4th industrial revolution...”
#yanggang2020
Joseph Hsiao What *HE* calls the 4th industrial revolution?
The whole world has been calling it that for years now. Yang has brought it into discussion in politics. Biden is a joke.
Should've said "What ANDREW YANG calls the 4th industrial revolution". Biden is a disingenuous tool.
Joe Biden is NOT stealing from Andrew Yang.
Whilst Andrew Yang has used the "4th industrial revolution" talking point throughout his campaign, it is unfair to characterize Biden as stealing this idea from him.
The term "4th industrial revolution" was coined by the German economist Klaus Schwab in an article for Foreign Affairs back in December 2015, www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/2015-12-12/fourth-industrial-revolution.
Klaus Schwab is the chairman of the world economic forum, famous for organising a meeting every year in Davos of the best and brightest business leaders from around the globe.
In January 2016 around a month after Schwab coined the phrase, Joe Biden was invited to the world economic forum where he gave speech about, you guessed it, the 4th industrial revolution. Biden was vice president at the time and was welcomed on stage by Klaus. You can see the speech for yourself here on RUclips ruclips.net/video/wvxeqc2V4PI/видео.html.
Joe Biden was the first american politician to take this term seriously and is probably responsible for introducing the term into political discourse, remember this was before the election of Trump.
I get why it seems like Biden is stealing from Yang since it has been a big part of Yang's campaign. Just see that Biden was actually one of the first US politicians to use the phrase well before Yang.
I'm pretty sure he quickly corrects himself. Listen to it again.
@@douglasjones7840 youre trying too hard to make joe relevant. he had nothing until yang came on to the scene
11:35 Plagiarizing Yang's issues without offering meaningful solutions... If you think it's a problem too, Joe, perhaps you should join the #yanggang
Agreed! #YangGang
Talking about automation? Thats not ripping people off. Next your going to say talking about climate change is ripping off Jay inslee.
@@xanderbeutel9239 You're right that talking about automation isn't ripping people of, but some conspicuous similarities to Yang's language...
@@peterobermeyer Like "Automation is going to become a problem?" I've heard warren and Booker say the same thing. Talking about the same issue isnt ripping people off.
Yang plagiarized Richard Nixon. You are just too young to know all his ideas are old as dirt.
Hey Joe, you forgot to copy one last line, "The opposite of Donald Trump is an Asian man who like math."
It's funny because Joe Biden had to drop out of one his previous presidential races because he had a plagiarism scandal.
Wow, I'm glad to hear Joe making Yang's talking points on 4th industrial revolution, but I would of respected him more if he said Yang was the one that opened his eyes.
Biden can't do that, but Colbert definitely should've mentioned Yang at that point.
Yang is a product of the Democractic party, and you underestimate how much Yang has taken from other candidates.
Alexander Stone Please, Yang is the first to admit he will take any good idea from anywhere and he wouldn’t stop there. I’ve heard him credit the authors of a few ideas he’s used, not to mention that he keeps crediting how Thomas Paine, Nixon and MLK JR, etc had same goals in mind, UBI. As in it’s not his ideas. It’s not about him, it’s about us. Humanity. Yang is a real leader and real leaders know how to surround themselves with smart people as well as develop others. The people are responding so well to him, Biden isn’t the only one taking queues from Yang, and you know it.
@@jayguilloty6560 Yang wouldn't even be a possibility if it weren't for Bernie Sanders and the Occupy movement. Don't squander a good thing. Experience matters.
UBI won't stop you from medical bankruptcy, Bernie Sanders will.
This guy just starts taking Yangs talking points like he's thought of them originally
I'd rather people steal good ideas then not do them at all.
Except it seems he really doesn't understand Yang's message - just the phrases. Poor Joe has a team of handlers, just like Hillary did.
Literally too yang's talking points. Yang's rising
@@connorbroderick7148 that's a great attitude!
Gonzalo Chocano Ha ha yes. Yang is the one who invented everything, including AI. He found Google, Apple, Microsoft, Amazon etc. No one knew what fourth industrial revolution is before the tech pioneer, genius IQ Andrew Yang decided to grace us with his presidential campaign. Wow, even sarcastically I'm starting to sound like you Yang bots.
It's 2019. The internet is a thing. You can't plagiarize another candidate's message without getting called out for it. Yang 2020
I hope you're willing to give Bernie an extended interview. Apparently people like Whoopi Goldberg (The View) still have no idea what Bernie is about.
Yea she came off so ignorant
Whoopi has no idea about what anything is about.
It's not like this extended interview makes Biden look good...
Can you believe that interview 😩 she just looked and sounded so stupid, especially when she tried to accuse Bernie of stealing ideas from Andrew Yang I was just like WTF are you talking about Bernies policies and stance have been around for decades. Whats even worse is he got zero credit for raising minimum wages in so many corporations
That interview was embarrassing for Whoopi
"What I call... other people call... the 4th Industrial Revolution." The "other people" is Andrew Yang - he's basically using Yang's talking points, including talking to the truckers. Sheesh. This problem needs Andrew Yang.
He’s been doing it a lot longer than Yang
@@denises9936 If you're saying he's been acknowledging automation and the dangers of job displacement from AI longer than Yang, you're wrong. If you're talking about a career as a politician, correct. Joe hasn't had any other career, which I see as a huge negative.
L PT yes I’m talking about his career as a politician. We really don’t need another non politician in the White House. That hasn’t worked too well.
@@denises9936 You can't compare a con artist, born into money, who lost a lot of it in bankruptcies while scamming his contractors to Andrew Yang. Yang is self-made, and as soon as he had success he left private industry and started a non-profit to push talent to upcoming/revitalizing cities instead of the coasts. The problem with Trump is not that he's from outside politics, it's that he's an egomaniac and a fool.
Joe is partially responsible for Trump being elected. Why? While the world was burning in Michigan, Ohio, Pennsylvania -- as future Trump voters were losing their jobs -- he and Obama's administration ignored the problem. What did he do? He's not a leader. And now, he's speaking about this as "4th industrial revolution" -- which has been Yang's talking point for over a year, AND presenting the WRONG solutions to that problem. When he was in a position to make a difference to those people, he failed them. Under his watch, the democratic party left behind the working class. He is not a leader, and we need a leader to beat Trump.
Jesse Thompson A moderate or an independent or even a Republican who can’t stand Trump isnot going to vote for a left wing candidate. And Yang knows nothing about governing or foreign policy or passing legislation. And his gimmick of $1000 a month is reminiscent of Trump’s ridiculous promises that smart people knew were pie in the sky. Yangs a big no for me.
Thank you Stephen Colbert for not cutting off Biden. You let that old man ramble on long enough and he just turns into Andrew Yang.
*Copies Andrew Yang
I'm not on the left, I'm not on the right, I'm senile! And that's how I'll beat Trump in 2020!
@@arnauddelacroix6423 lol 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
🤫
Get Andrew Yang on here please so he can properly explain the 4th industrial revolution. He says @ 11:14 other people have said, That other people is Yang!
You act like Yang coined the term when its been in use for years. Biden may of stolen the term from him, I don't know, but don't act like Yang invited it, here is a video 3 years old talking about it;
ruclips.net/video/kpW9JcWxKq0/видео.html
Im not saying he coined the phrase. He was the only one talking about it. Now other candidates are jumping his ideas and that's a good thing. That'll force some back and forth on the debate stage and that's when I think AY will shine.
That video sounds like mark of the beast stuff where we evolve technically and regress spiritually and empathetically. Pretty interesting and scary, thx. Check this one out. fwd to 4:17:25.
Chapter 15. Talks about how we implode from the inside.
ruclips.net/video/MC25cPvp4zg/видео.html
11:21 he says IT instead of AI
TheNzFox Because automation didn't start yesterday. It could still have been hot topic in 2016. But no politician have run on it. Trump only blamed it on mexicans
Lenmil, Yang was on his show, but they didn't seemed to have taken him seriously, in my opinion.
Andrew Yang called.
He wants his talking points back. 🤦🏻♀️
I hope he follows through, Yang will probably be on the administration which will help. We are all in this together.
The fact that #StephenColbert ducked the The #YangGang policy rip and went on list Bernie and Warren as the relevant progressives was super shady.
I wonder if Colbert is on the Biden train. I really do. And he isn't very kind to Bernie. The rich people out there want Biden because they know he won't be aggressively coming after their MILLIONS of dollars. And, yeah, Biden is just rolling on other people's ideas.
So, right now it's between Bernie, Biden, and Warren as, at this point, I highly doubt that any of the other contenders are going to magically rise to the top. I'm not really sure if Warren has what it takes to helm a superpower. We need her more right where she is, in the Senate. That leaves Bernie since Biden is falling hard. And even though a lot of people seem to think that Biden could beat Trump, Trump would practically eviscerate him. That and Biden won't get people to go to the polls. We need someone who is going to get things done and not just coast through their term as president, like Biden did throughout his entire career. :/
@@CybershamanX don't take much to run your country, Trump is doing it.
@@CybershamanX dude, all msm is on biden's side.
He represents the establishment, the status quo, and old power. This is in the interests of those in power currently, because them having power is the status quo. Those in power own the media. The media must back Biden.
It's beautifully circular
@@isaacpicon169 Hardly. He may indeed be "in charge, but he's doing nothing but his best to be a two bit dictator. And it's pushing our country's system of checks and balances to the limit. Far from actually doing anything of any real positive consequence, he's just playing "king" while others maintain things regardless of what he _wants_ to do. We constantly hear stories of how Trump's underlings actually hide things from him so that he won't get involved. It's beyond embarrassing. :/
Bernie and Warren ARE the relevant progressives they're polling neck and neck with Biden. Yang is at 3% and he's not exactly a progressive. His stance on climate change is awful.
Great to see Biden using some of Andrew Yang's phrases, although let's just have the original thing instead!
Ha ha yes. Yang is the one who invented everything, including AI. He found Google, Apple, Microsoft, Amazon etc. No one knew what fourth industrial revolution is before the tech pioneer, genius IQ Andrew Yang decided to grace us with his presidential campaign. Wow, even sarcastically I'm starting to sound like you Yang bots.
@@randomuser5237 copy and pasting the same message I see. Work for the Biden campaign???
Random User no one ever claimed any of that. Yang gives credit to policies he got from others like Thomas Paine, Martin Luther King Jr etc. Unlike Biden who spouts problems and no real solutions. Stop trying to blow things out of proportion.
That's the only different from Yang to the other candidates is he talks about all that ubi stuff. Vote for someone that puts health care and climate change as there main talking points. Bernie2020
Biden taking all the Yang talking points! I'm glad the important issues Yang is raising is getting airtime but if you want to hear more coming from AY himself.. google "Andrew Yang"
Yeah, and Yang will take other people's talking points. That's politics.
Thank you Biden for sneaking Andrew Yang past the media blackout. #googleandrewyang
Lololol
Anyone watching this should watch Andrew Yang’s interview with Joe Rogan from February. Yang said all the good parts that Biden said, but offers MUCH better solutions... Biden basically copied Yang’s assessment of our country’s situation, but it doesn’t seem like Biden has a very well thought through solution... Continuing education is not going to be a viable option for MOST people when automation leaves them jobless. Yang, to me, has a better pulse on where we are as a country and on what we need to do to bring unity and progress. As Yang says, “Not right. Not left. Forward.”
And Andrew Yang would get a great job in the new Democratic Administration -- see Cabinet.
@Absynthe The Artist Let's trade one non-politician for another. Another brilliant idea.
I like Rogan but if you don't, here is another great interview with Yang getting asked hard questions by a economist. ruclips.net/video/ZCREBV_m8dY/видео.html
"The opposite of Donald Trump is an Asian man who likes MATH" - Joe Biden 2019.
kyoko703
Hilarious if he said that lmao
Haha!
Lmao
lol
I wish I had came up with it but someone said that on twitter and it made me bust out laughing... !!! It's just so good that I just had to share it with the community at large. :)
#yang2020 #yanggang
When did Biden decide to support Yang? He's quoting the opposition now. I guess that's okay. He was quoting Obama; he won. Now he's quoting Yang... I mean I respect Biden but... if you steal the quotes then give the credit.
You know that Yang isn't the first or only person to come up with that saying? It's been around a while now...
@@GECKman88 yea but yang already said it a million times before he did and now that the #yanggang is gaining popularity joe biden starts to sound like yang... by pure chance? lmao not a chance
Andrew Yang kept talking about fourth industrial revolution and truckers losing their job to self driving trucks.
Thank you Joe Biden for heeding Yang's words. Let's hope America listens just as well
I’m sorry but anyone with half a brain has seen the automated revolution, including self driving trucks, coming for decades.
@@jochem1986 I like the guy whos ready to do something about it before it gets worse. None of these elderly politicians have even attempted.
@@jochem1986 Yes but how manu have actually gone down on the geound to speak with those truckers and factory workers to collect data? *ONE*
Just in case you someone reading this doesn’t know - all of these policies and ideas Biden is bringing up are Andrew Yangs 🤙🏼
Why do you think that Yang hasn't been able to resonate with the public like some of the other Progressives?
These aren’t his ideas andrew. Yang himself says that his interests are not new but rather truly american.
Thanks genius. As if every other comment hasn't already pointed that out
Good to see Joe Biden endorsing my boy Yang. #Yang2020
Google Klaus Schwab, then you can say Yang is copying as well.
Lafayette Smyre Yang never said he invented the name the 4th industry evolution. The concept has been there for years, Yang is the first one who brought it up in a presidential campaign and had a solution for it. This sleepy Joe know nothing about AI or automation.
You seems a nice guy, but far from the level of Yang, Bernie and Warren. We need far more knowledge.
Beware of Yang! ALL THAT GLITTERS IS NOT GOLD. We must have people in office who love America and speak TRUTH😔
@@2dasimmons Thats what he does, Yang 2020
Is this just part of the 4chan thing? Seriously. Any video with a Democratic candidate has a bunch of random comments supporting Andrew Yang, who is terrific and smart and has zero chance of getting the nomination. It seems like a right-wing troll "joke."
Ooo.. oo00OO00oo.. let them all work as a collective.. split the dough ..
And yang can pay me 1000 bucks a bribe. I mean month.
@@2dasimmons beware of yang.. uh huh huh .. uhhh Huh huh huh..
I’m surprised Colbert didn’t call out Biden that Andrew Yang has said those exact same thing first on his own show!
Colbert was awful to Yang.
Colbert is disturbingly establishment dem.
Colbert sucks
The thing about short memories is every day's a new day! Joe has completely forgotten that Andrew yang was just there talking about it the night before.. what amaze me was how hes able to memorize it word for word...lol
just kidding when they start to sound like Yang that's a good thing
ANDREW YANG 2020
Holy crap! I expected him at the end of the interview to peel his face back and reveal he’s really Andrew Yang.
It'll be hilarious if yang go to his next interview wearing Joe Biden's facial mask. Deliver is talking point then take out his mask lol
Mind as well join #Yanggang
Brad Nickel well, that is actually possible. Technology today is so advance that we can clone animals. 😂
Maybe he's who cares vote him in..anyway.
I’m glad America has caught up. Joe Biden was fine for a time, but we don’t need him right now, and we don’t want him! Let’s get someone in the White House worth 4 years of America’s time. Bernie for president. He’s what we’ve always needed.
🤣🤣🤣🤣 #TRUMP 2020🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸
0031badboy it’s still amazes me that so many Bernie and warren fans have not seen the truth yet. It’s soooo obvious and blatant. If you just opened your eyes and ears a little bit, you would realize Yang is the much much better candidate/leader/trump defeater. Hope you see the truth soon enough. Good luck.
Timothy McCaskey seriously?? Polls?? Lol 😂. if there is one thing dems/progressives/mainstream media should’ve learned from 2016...is that polls cannot be trusted. Do you not recall how many libs were weeping in defeat and agony because the polls lied to them that Hillary was going to win because she had a YUUUUUGE lead. Yang2020. Mark my words.
That was a really uncomfortable interview to watch. A string of ramblings with no actual substance. Honestly felt like a mockery of the horrendous atrocities the Trump administration have committed on multiple topics. We get Biden can regurgitate obvious talking points, but what's his actual plan? All I got from that is Hillary 2.0. Please get Bernie on for an actual discussion!
people literally clapped him for saying putting children in cages is wrong.
Hillary 2.0 is the perfect way to describe the Biden problem. I still have respect for Stephen Colbert, but I lost some of that respect with this interview... same as when he interviewed Trump. I want to see a joint discussion with Bernie and Elizabeth Warren
@@marcelomeirelles6039 ironic that those "cages" were built while he was vice president.
His campaign is based on an obvious lie, apparently he never actually watched the Charlottesville speech.
Edgar Pryor Says who?
#Yang2020 because I cannot take this man seriously.
Trump 2020
Thanks so much for acknowledging that Andrew Yang’s platform is valid. Now you can drop out and endorse him. #yang2020
Please, God, if Yang doesn't get the nomination, don't get angry and not vote for Biden or whomever does.. Trump can't win. Please acknowledge that.
If you're seriously backing Yang, who has no shot at getting the nomination, let's be honest, you should be excited Joe, the front runner in the race, is making part of Yang's platform part of his own. Yang's ideas are much more likely to happen now. Four years ago, Bernie was the only one talking about Medicare-for-all. Now it's part of most Democrats' platforms. That's how it happens, if you're too young to have seen it before. Happened with Obama too. In 2008, he didn't support gay marriage but other candidates did. Eventually the whole party adopted it. No one accused Obama of stealing ideas, for essentially doing the right thing. That's just how it works, a minor candidate brings an issue to light and in time, the whole party adopts it.
@@sorayaalcyone2726 haha lol if yang doesn't get the nomination (probaby won't honestly, but I hope he does) I'm voting for Trump
So same talking points Yang brought to the table. That’s ok, Yang doesn’t care. To Yang, as long as he brings attention to these issues and solutions, that’s all he needs. That’s winning to him. #yanggang
these talking points have been around since the 1970's it's just now more people are listening..
Except that he apparently doesn't know that our retraining works about 0-15% of the time.
@@carollawrie2414 don't downplay Yang's and his supporters' contribution. There is still more work to be done spreading the message.
@@ruofanyu6699 He is a very very very big longshot..Biden right now is your only hope to beat tramp and after all that should be the main goal of the elections Without gaining the WH you have nothing but tramp and his family They will never leave
@@carollawrie2414 Biden is the same old same old. Also would NOT win the election against Trump. That's a misconception peddled by the establishment and the Biden campaign. Biden is among the least likely to win against Trump. Trump could easily exploit Biden in a debate, call him names, rally his base against him, point out the various flaws in his candidacy. Yang and Sanders, on the other hand, are the only two candidates with >10% support among Trump voters. Yep that's right, Yang, who had no name recognition at the time of the poll, already has >10% support among Trump voters. His message resonates with everyone once you actually hear him talk.
He's copying Andrew Yang at 11:15.
Joe seems like a nice guy but Andrew Yang is who we need as president.
Yeah, especially since he thinks the government should give every adult in America, one thousand dollars a month!
Twelve thousand dollars a year.
Sounds insane to me.
@@rustynails.8550 And he wants to pay for it by putting a regressive sales tax on everything, even food. Take from the poor, to give to the rich. It was originally Richard Nixon's idea. Yang will steal from anyone in his desire to be president.
Rick Toles insane? What’s insane is huge companies like Amazon paying zero in taxes. Others making money off our data, and we seeing nothing from all that. The dividend is our share of technology advancing and displacing jobs and our data
Toob247 Toob247 You might not. But millions of Americans would benefit from a dividend of 1k in huge ways.
@@deborahfreedman333 I just browsed the details on his website. I'm seeing a 10% value added tax (flat) and "Taxes on top earners and pollution. By removing the Social Security cap, implementing a financial transactions tax, and ending the favorable tax treatment for capital gains/carried interest". Sounds progressive to me. What am I missing?
Bernie Sanders 2020!!!!
"The opposite of Donald Trump is an Asian man who likes math... and that's me...." -Joe Biden
The opposite of Hunter Biden is somebody that doesn’t have sex with their 14-year-old niece on their laptops real high standards
How are we gonna fix it? First we have to acknowledge. 😂 good job. You acknowledged Andrew Yangs talking points. 🤣 his idea was preschool?
Yang's talking points are stolen from the originator of the 4 th industrial revolution, namely Klaus Schwab. Google his name and get enlightened.
Lafayette Smyre but the difference is that Andrew yang acknowledges it and doesn’t take credit for the idea.
@@theerlife148 , Vice President Biden, didn't take credit for the idea. He simply used it.
I really don't want Joe Biden as president
He doesnt want to be president either
@@IamTonyStark1, is that why he's running for the 3rd time?
He's hillary 2.0, "but it's my turn".
don't worry. If he gets the nomination, there's little hope he would beat trump.
Czeckie come on
Me neither. He's part of the swamp (which is on both sides of the aisle). Another millionaire politician. Clearly his mind is going, but people who aren't paying attention think he is the same guy from years ago. His name is inspiring fond memories, and that is putting him high in the polls. But when people listen to him, the more he gets out there, the more his numbers slip. Frankly, he reminds me of a grandpa, not an uncle. And it is time he was put out to pasture. His age and doddery walk just emphasizes the truth that we need age limits.
here comes joe biden taking policys and talking points from Andrew Yang. if you want a real candidate vote for Yang. #yang2020
Drop out, Joe. You're probably a nice man, but stop stealing other people's ideas! #YangGang
fountainPoison sorry but I don’t see Asian as president of this country, no offense to amazing Yang but he has no chance of winning
11:10 - complete rip off of Andrew Yang. This is validation that Yang must become the nominee.
Agreed
Biden was named "ill figure it out as i go along" nominee. Now he stole the best lines.
When did Biden talk to truck drivers? At least other people reference Andrew Yang when they use his material.
Really nice to hear that Joe is a Yang fan also.
Talking like we are still in the 1900's. Give me Yang.
Yang stole his talking points from Klaus Schwab, the originator of the phrase 4th industrial revolution.
@@lafayettesmyre1094 I see. But I don't think anyone is saying Yang invented the that phrase. Just that he didn't steal it from another Presidential candidate.
Lafayette Smyre yang never stated he made nor invented it
@@lafayettesmyre1094 stole? lol Yang always says "What the experts are calling"
Biden please drop out, you don't have to do this to yourself and your family. It was actually sad seeing you sundown at the climate townhall
Google Andrew Yang.
So. Uh, wanna pick up a coffee and...you know. Talk about it?
@@xeanderman6688 there’s a lot to talk about
@@romankotas448 let's talk then
@@xeanderman6688 okay
@@romankotas448 so, uh. What's your opinion of the previous and current administrations?
HAHAHA 11:09 "WHAT I WOULD LIKE TO CAL... OTHER PEOPLE CALL(ANDREW YANG)
#YangGang
Hear it straight from the person's mouth themselves
Yang2020.com
Stop plugging a Candidate below 10 percent
@@eliyafethsoto1309 What are you talking about??? Ummm first, get polls out of the conversation. That has no relevance. So it's a logical fallacy straw man grasp move.
We are talking about Talking points from candidates, Which Uncle Joe took word from word from another candidate called Andrew Yang.
Please reread.
@@eliyafethsoto1309 yet still 6th place and about to surpass Pete. Polling doesn't matter especially when it's skewed.
@@eliyafethsoto1309 Bill Clinton was at 1% in the primaries around this time 1991.
@@nikovz4719 you act like Yang invented the term when a quick google search would show you its been used for years, Klaus Schwab first coined the term in 2015 in an article in 'Foreign Affairs'
Biden may be stealing the talking point, but he is not stealing the term
Wow Andrew Yang’s talking points. As if he mixed the scripts 😂
Yea I noticed that right away 😂😂😂
Really? Biden was working with Obama before Chinese guy appear. Typical bullshit from andrew's lover
I can see a cult here. Similar to Bernie bots. Chinese bullshit
@@antoniomartinez6722 Andrew Yang is an American... Can't just dismiss all his supporters as Chinese (bots).
But I do agree that you can't say whose points is who's because they can all have the same information & solution.
Coping the smart Asian guy without credit. Biden and Buttigieg both guilty. How stereotypical. #Yang2020
DanielzeGreat yang is going to drop out
Im voting trump before i vote for biden
MAGA 2020
Saying you should be president because you’re better than Trump isn’t really an argument. By that logic about 99% of the US population should run for President...
That’s not what he said lol
99.99999999%* XD
K A When asked why people vote for him he said ‘look at the alternative” then proceeded to talk about what Trump has done to the country...
They should! Literally anyone is better than Trump. When the worst guy in the world is President and making mistakes devastating to the fabric of the country -- your best argument is to say I'm better because I'm the exact opposite.
MlSSFIT But that isn’t a reason for him to get the nomination...
Thanks, but I'm good, byeeee
This channel doesn't have any content
den
Please explain your reasoning other than he's not cool or he's too old?
@@blacknrd05 I'd rather have a candidate like Bernie Sanders or Elizabeth Warren. They are more in line with me politically and cater more to the interests of millennials. I would take anyone over Trump though.
@@scottmoltzan8646 thanks for having common sense. Joe fits in politically with me and electability is a big thing for me. We democrats lost the middle of the country. Joe will help get it back.
Interesting how this video's comments are about Andrew YANG and not biden :)
These comedians such as colbert, maher ... etc are out of touch with normal people now.
*Borrrrrrrrrring Joe. The DNC never learned from their last presidential election loss by shoving Hilary Clinton as the nominee, and now another cliche candidate Joe. His interview put me to sleep. The same old tired talking points. The democrats are making it way to easy for Trump to get reelected for a second term.*
I'm not a Trumper but Biden is the cure for insomnia.
these yang comments aged horribly 💀
president: no
mayor of nyc: no
It warms my heart to see everyone acknowledging that he stole Yangs lines #YangGang
It annoys me that Stephen makes ageist jokes about Bernie but seems to revere Biden, despite his gaffes and corporate shilling.
Because Stephen is a religious nut... so is joe.
Bernie keeps his faith out of his politics.
To be fair, in his interviews, Steven is always really kind to all of his guests. He was even kind to Trump when he was interviewing him, despite him being almost never saying something nice about the sitting President.
he pokes fun at biden all the time. he just doesn't want to be mean to his guest's face.
@@joanwaters6410 and Mr lincoln. I'll call that a good point. Fair comment.
For a second there I thought sleepy Joe was gonna say he’s an Asian man who likes math. Yang2020
Man I was hoping he would say go to yang2020.com at the end of the video lol
Ger Xiong You mean Yang 30330
Sorry but Yang isn't going to purchase the presidency but I do admire his openness with his bribe offers.
Yang 2020!!! We need someone that knows what they're talking about.
He just took one of Yang's talking points!
What we don't need is another businessman who has no idea how government works, and steals all his ideas from Richard Nixon.
@@deborahfreedman333 Difference between Yang and Trump is that Yang is more intelligent and knows what he's talking about when coming to solutions about our problems in this country. And Trump, well, we all know that story...
I hate when every politician/commentator say "LOOK,..." to begin a sentence. It's annoying!!
Yeah. It's condescending.
Look... it's not a big deal. lol Sorry. I had to.
Look.... it is what it is
@@calebmatthews2026 Look, don't get us started on the asinine statement, "it is what it is".
And "at the end of the day" is another one they like.
When I saw this broadcast I thought to myself three things. One, I remember Andrew Yang saying even if he doesn't become president it would be amazing if his policies be heard and eventual echoed through the other democratic candidates. Two, how nice it would've been to hear Joe Biden mention Andrew Yang (maybe some day). And three, Bernie Sanders also took a page out of Yang's book when speaking to Joe Rogan on the JRE podcast. I have a feeling Andrew Yang's voice will resonate with others even much longer than just these debates.
Joe's just happy to be back in Vermont
Joe's just happy to be back in 1990...
Joe's just happy to have the endorsement of President Ramrock Myboss.
lol
@@mosaiqcode6780 wow can't believe you don't know obama's first name, it's Raprock
@@TheProcrastinator6 well uh, I pointed out, uh... look, folks... my dad used to have an expression, "Don't compare me to a competent Vevo commenter, compare me to the alternative"
And, look, that's what this blog is all about, folks.
You could have really given him some harder questions and pushed back more. Softball interview.
Colbert is an establishment hack that loves Biden's "nothing will fundamentally change" campaign, of course he's going to serve up softball questions.
@@RichO1701e this.
Yang 2020; vote for the guy who made it up not Grandpa Xerox.
Yeah . . . Joe Biden sounding eerily like Andrew Yang 😂. I’d like to see AY debate Biden and dismantle his lack of understanding about automation!
Felix Zhang
Damn i hope AY really goes beast mode and expose Biden
Maison David he will, I know America’s not that stupid to not realize sleepy Joe’s boring and has nothing to say, and that he copied Andrew Yang. But seriously, he’s sooo boring, and he has no knew ideas except for making pre-schoolers kindergarteners...🤣🤣🤣🤣💀💀💀💀
"I'm for good things and against bad things. BIDEN 2020"
To bad he rips off #AndrewYang
Joe "Sorry, my time is up" Biden.
Research Andrew Yang. Biden is a good guy but he’s actually using Yang’s talking points during this interview. I will vote for Yang during the primaries.
How do we "RESTORE the SOUL in this country"?WE work on increasing our LOVE.
Some of what he says is almost a direct quote from Yang
YANG 2020
He's been saying a lot of this since before Yang was out of diapers. Who's quoting whom?
@@deborahfreedman333 If you can find me a clip of Biden saying 'Fourth Industrial Revolution' before this interview I'd be impressed.
Deborah Freedman Cmon... you think Biden didnt take this from Yang who has been saying this constantly. He even corrected himself, when he said “i call, what others call...”
@@deborahfreedman333 Not at all.
Wow...sounds like he memorized Andrew Yang's speeches. 😆😆😆😆🤦🏽
Sorry Joey, Andrew sounds better...he's the originator.
No he's not the originator of the 4th industrial idea, that idea is from Klaus Schwab. So in actuality Yang is a copy cat too.
@@lafayettesmyre1094 Andrew Yang is the ORIGINAL candidate to bring it to mainstream attention and to make it an important topic within policy. So yes the other candidates are on his bandwagon. And...Joe Biden VERBATIM copied Andrew Yang's speech. That is called plagiarism. If he were a college student, he could be expelled. Thanks for defending cheaters. 👍🏽 I will use you as an example when speaking to my students about cheating.
@@rachelherrera5867, Yang is the first to make you and many of the folk who've written posts on this commentary but the idea has been around since yang was in high school. Yang should be content that others are touting the idea. If he's really serious about it, he won't care who gets it done.
@@lafayettesmyre1094 naw...we're more than happy to accept that.. just don't wanna see no old folks on subject they don't know nothing about... otherwise you're just setting up the tone for some future bull*****...
@@lafayettesmyre1094 how and where is much appreciate it... but we all about the Man who has the balls to make it happen.. at this fine moment!
I see all these people dissing Joe Biden in the comments.... boy do I have some news for you!
Period lol
"I'm being straightforward."
Translation: "I'm saying nothing about corporate ownership of government and I'm not going to mention I'll be keeping it in place."
Trump said he would do something, something along the lines of "draining the swamp", but quite the opposite has occured: Trump's Cabinet has been a revolving door of hires and fires, On a regular basis Trump would attempt things like executive orders to bypass congress on a regular basis. Trump himself is has been under investigation for numerous crimes for which there is evidence that he himself attempted to obstruct which is crime in of itself; nevermind the fact that dozens of former colleagues have all wound in legal hotwater as a result of the investigation. At the point I'm prepared to say that almost ANYONE would better than Trump when comes to fighting corruption in politics as Trump is great steaming pile of it.
@@Jormungrandrserpent Trump drains the swamp into the WH and when it gets too full of sewage now and then he flushes it into the street to make room for more. I agree that just about anybody could get us back to "pre-Trump normalcy," which is STILL corporate ownership of government, and Biden/Harris/Buttigieg/others are running to do just that.
The DNC and MSM have found ways to limit coverage (other than derisive coverage) for candidates who break the cardinal rule and don't give the ruling class a chance to buy a piece of their campaigns. In Tulsi's case the freeze-out, from shrunken on-mike time to not asking her any meaningful questions to outright exclusion from the debate floor, is naked revenge because Tulsi did the one thing even more unforgivable than funding integrity. She was in line to be the next DNC chair and instead resigned from the committee to campaign for Bernie. This when she knew the committee had decreed behind closed doors that Hillary would be the nominee. Disobeying marked her for naked revenge.
Removing Trump is important for a shipload of reasons but preserving corporate ownership of government will fuel the frustration and anger that led to Trump's election.
What a ridiculous amount of applause for someone with no real policy substance.
You should watch Cory Booker's interview
Ghost of Obama, that's all.
They passed out free Jello shots laced with X just before they introduced him.
And a horrendous voting record over the course of his whole career, dudes been on the wrong side of history his whole career. And he clearly hasn't learned from life long failure because he still brags about what he's done as if any of it's good.
Colbert's audience is made up of mostly upper middle class to wealthy people. The Warren/Buttigieg demographic.
18:00 “look at my record. Everything I’ve ever done has been significant”
Sounds like Andrew Yang .. #Yang2020
Except that he apparently doesn't know that our retraining works about 0-15% of the time.
Joe "nothing will fundamentally change" Biden. Sorry. Not what America (and the world) needs.
At last! A comment that isn’t (rightly) about how Biden ripped off Yang! This is the first one I’ve seen in the comments! Still critical of Uncle Joe, though, loving the backlash.
It will be really honourable for Joe to drop and endorse Yang..
I hope you guys get Bernie as President, would be a real hope for the whole world.
Kobaloi Green there’s many of us really - REALLY - trying. He’s got a veritable army of grassroots support. The elite-centrist-money class though is doing everything possible to stop him.
I prefer Andrew Yang over Bernie Sanders. Yang2020
@Eileen Farrar :) Ivan? Really funny. I'm from Europe but probably for you it`s the same :)
@Eileen Farrar let me guess...you are from the countryside and you are wearing aluminum hat and are fearing to fall of earth when you reach the plates edge ;)
Yang's leading the conversation, all the other candidates are just starting to follow
Biden: I've been saying "4th industrial revolution" for 25 years!
He's talking about giving more money for 'research and development' to the people who are waxing the American public right now, get outta here dude. Sanders 2020
steve crawford age doesn’t matter you dumbass it’s about you’re policies and where you stand on the issues. That’s identity politics and they are the worst way to vote.
Bernie has been saying the same thing 4 over 30 years and has been ahead of the times when it comes to social political and corporate fairness. Not to mention he is healthy mentally Sharp as a tack never stumbles in his words. Bernie Tulsi 2020✌
He is basically endorsing Andrew Yang for president. Ya congrats Andrew Yang..
all those yang top comments r from bots, ur doing their worlk for them by repeating their msg
Cerbyo what bots?
Looks like Joe should join the #YangGang
So we taking Andrew Yang points now, Joe? 4th industrial revolution, AI, trucking... I really can't see why anyone would support this man.
This is a good thing! Andrew Yang has said that if another politician acknowledges these problems it's a huge win for everyone! I do hope Yang wins it in 2020, he's by far my favorite.
Yang took his ideas from Richard Nixon, and made them worse. Why would you support that?
@@deborahfreedman333Yang mentions past American figures who proposed the idea of a basic income. He never claimed that he came up with UBI all on his own. He even mentions that the idea for a basic income isn't a new one. Biden here is using some of Andrew Yang's most well known talking points and acting like these are his very own original concerns. That's very dishonest to me. And also, I'm not sure what you mean by, "made them worse." Different, yes, but definitely not worse. Automation is indeed growing and Yang making that a focal point in this campaign is why many of us side with his ideas.