Many people might think that speaking pure english is more impressive for filipinos but it’s actually being able to be well spoken in pure Filipino that is more impressive to filipinos
There's no such thing as "pure Filipino" since the Filipino language is consisting of Tagalog+Spanish+English, I think you're referring to "pure Tagalog".
@@NoVisionGuy Taking an exerpt from Nolasco, Ricardo (2007) chairperson of KWF, a foremost linguist expert, unfortunately you are mistaken. According to him, Filipino is identical to Tagalog grammatically and substantially, but differentiated by class-meaning Filipino can be thought of as *high Tagalog* or formal Tagalog as opposed to the Tagalog spoken in the provinces e.g., Bulacan, Laguna, Batangas, which are all forms or dialects of Tagalog.
Because Vietnam isn't trying to destroy the world order by threatening to Invade an island critical to the entire modern civilization nor threaten a majority of Asian islands due to its size. Vietnam could never militarily get away with it. China has been building expressly for that purpose.
Well Filos and Viets tend to view each other as brethren from the Vietnam war to ASEAN, so if there are issues between the Philippines and Vietnam in the WPS/SCS I am pretty sure they can work things out through diplomacy and not harrass each other, I mean PH did it with Indonesia, one of PH's closest brother, in the Southern Seas of Mindanao so yeah... And also Vietnam is still treated as the only and closest communist ally of the Philippines and Vietnam view Philippines as its ally and brother as well so I know they can work things out unlike with China...
It's nice to see that a lot of Filipino people are not blindly believing in what is being portrayed in the mainstream media and feels skeptical about the aims of the US presence in the Philippines on the other hand, China hasn't been the best neighbor as well. This topic is kind of complicated actually to be honest but it only goes to show na nag iisip na ang mga Pilipino.. I applaud us for that.
HISTORY has proven that US is not a friend! TAKE NOTE, lahat ng magagandang gusali sa Pilipinas, ang US ang sumira during world war 2! kunwari ina attack mga Hapon pero bansa natin ang binobomba! so I will never trust US. better to try our luck with China!
to all Filipino, never start or join a war unless your country is under attack i mean real attack such as foreign troops are on your land because in this situation stand any side will just hurt your country dont let big power countries turn your country into Afghanistan
@@iamhardwell2844 unfortunately too many stupid filipinos do not know history. our country was the best in asia. until we got involved in ww2. no thanks to uncle joe. now we are worst in asia. soon if we dont smarten up we will be worst in the world
I enjoyed listening to all of their comments and opinions. Most of them are very aware of the political and military instability affecting the region. I wonder if Fil-Ams are at all concerned of what’s happening back home. That should be the next topic to be discussed I think.
It will depend on the generation but some first generation like me are invested into the development of the region as many of us were naturalized here vs being born in the US like other generations. Sadly many of them are more concerned about being called Pacific Islander than Asian...this shows how distant they've become from the Philippines.
Most Fil-Ams I know (I’m a first Gen FilAm but born & grew up first in the Phil) are misguided about Filipino politics. Most unfortunately look at it in a American/bourgeois lense. Very simplistic POV and assuming It’s like the democratic vs republican situation in the US. Some who studied abroad with me in the Phil often live far differently from experiencing what normal Filipinos in the Philippines live like so they don’t often understand the political nuance and the struggles of the masses. When it comes to the China issue though they obviously support the US but they understandably won’t often know the whole situation and why some Filipinos may be against the US as well.
si kuya from 6:59 whe he said, the US helped us from Spanish colonialism, i think what he meant was the American-Spanish war also known as the Manila Mock Battle, where both country’s staged the battle to deceived Filipinos that they are the liberators and that they will free us, but the truth is, Spain already sold us to US at that time for $20M😅
@@SelenaJoyArcenal research pa more ma'am. they let us go because at that time, dumadami ang mga us citizens na against sa colonialism. same din sa nagyari sa vietnam, there were mass protests to stop the war so they pulled out of the war that was going nowhere, only resulting in death and disabled soldiers going back home. us is the only country thats constantly involved in wars, they killed more civilians than enemies. they've wiped out entire villages in every war they got involved in (also happened during the filipino-american war that a lot of filipinos nowadays are not even aware of). our so called friends now, i have ancestors who died because of them (one of my grandfather's cousins was even killed by a korean under the japanese military in ww2, my father was even born in the middle of a jungle while the family was hiding from the japanese). i dont have ancestors or current relatives who suffered from chinese hands.
"I shall return" sounds great but it was McArthur abandoning the Filipinos to face the Japanese on their own during the WWII. And Philippines is forever grateful for that.
The Spaniards were actually close to being defeated by the a guerrilla group of Filipinos, but they didn't want to admit being defeated by the Philippines, so they make up the fact that they were defeated by the US and took the money... Both Spaniards and Americans aren't really your friend. US /China are going to use your country to be the battle ground for to get Taiwan
Yes true, but the Philippines won the arbital rulings which the basis of the illegality of china artificial islands and the basis that Indonesia used to stop China in occupying Natuna Island. Perhaps thats the reason why China is more actively provoking us.
There's no free lunch. The US will expect something in return for providing enhanced security in the region. A resolution of the South China Seas territorial dispute would be great for so many countries. Of course the first country to make a claim was the Republic of China in 1947 which occupied Taiping Island to the west of Palawan. ROC (Taiwan) forces remain there to this day. I believe they even evicted Philippine nationals in the islands at one point and arrested them.
The compromise is thr military bases. We want them to corner china. That literally is the thing we are getting. We aren't just protecting the Philippines out of good will.
What the US gets in return is use of Filipino land to put their military bases to stop China... which also helps protect Filipinos from authoritarian China taking over. I think this is probably something the Filipinos want. Unless they want to be colonized a *third* time (Spain, US, then China)
Yeah. The US just recently a few weeks/months ago wanted the Philippines to house temporary refugees from the Middle East..Not sure what happened with that but that issue became controversial.
Just to clarify what the girl said about the US not having a significant impact on the Russo-Ukrainian war at 8:58 is false, the amount of aid the US has sent to Ukraine is higher than the next 5 organizations/countries' aid combined via Statista, additionally what kind of military aid Ukraine has been getting is also vital, in the first 2 months of the war; in the Kyiv front the use of Western-made NLAWs and Javelins helped bog down and force the Russians to abandon their objective of taking Kyiv. Apart from that, Ukraine started to gain the initiative when M777 Howitzers and HIMARS were delivered (this was back in September-October 2022 in Kharkiv Oblast where Ukraine battered Russia's First Guards Tank Army or just generally the elements of the Russian Army in Kharkiv Oblast and forced them to withdraw to Svatove-Kreminna Line), as well as during the winter when Russia was hitting Ukrainian energy infrastructure. Currently, while Ukraine continues to push for their Spring Counteroffensive in Zaporizhzhia Oblast the American-made Bradley IFVs along with other Western-made tanks such as Leopards of diverse variants have been praised by the AFU for their crew protection capabilities. One more thing, with the delivery of the Patriot SAM System, comes greater air protection an example is how Russia's "unstoppable" Kh-47M2 Kinzhal Hypersonic Missile was shot down, and once Ukraine's Air Force receive F-16 fighter jets it'll be safe to assume that Ukraine will have a favorable contested airspace which would mean that these donations have made a significant impact in the war.
@@hiskandar still doesn't change the fact that western weapons and munitions had a big impact, whether Ukraine lost more territory after some time; Ukraine would've inevitably lost more territory than they did now if Western weapons weren't in Ukraine. My opinion was that Western weapons had significant impact in the war. What you said is not really tackling what my main point was.
@@hiskandar your username reminds me of the Iskander missile of Russia, with relate to that did you know that after Patriot SAM missile defense systems were donated to Ukraine in adequate numbers all of Russia's hypersonic missiles that were used in recent attacks were shot down
@@rzjnbtg1546 Yeah, I heard that, but did you hear those HIMARS etc still don't make any difference in the final results that Ukraine now has lost more territories than before? I suggest you to use Chatgpt and ask there how many territories has Ukraine lost after Russia Special Military Operations in Feb 2022. The AI really helpful in data mining or gathering information.
@@rzjnbtg1546 This arm race happens from WW1 all the way until today. So definitely weapon development has impact. But it is NOT something that make a much different results when youur opponent can keep up with you Have you heard Russia blow US million dollars tank with just cheap drones? Do you see what I mean?
Something that interest me in this street interview is that older people seems more aligning themselves with China whereas the young seems more aligning with USA.
Media consumption and older people lived through what was essentially American occupation, which is beginning again since Phillipines under Marcos Jr. is allowing US forces on the island again.
@@patrickco2398 The "America is so cool" effect. This is soft power in action. Making you think someone who colonized you and abused you for 50+ years is actually your best friend.
Not surprising. Young minds are easily conditioned and are gullible to spins and propagandas. Older minds are far wiser and experienced plus they are very familiar with history the unadulterated version.
Not really. It's nerve racking for countries with incompetent, corrupt leaders maybe. Simply look at how Vietnam deals with things. Vietnam has good relations with both US and China (especially China), yet does not host a single US military base anywhere on its territory, and actively rejects the US from doing so for decades. Is the fastest growing economy in the world. Philippine leaders lack pragmatism and competency. As for why I said Vietnam has especially good relations with China, it is because China is actually several tiers above the US in terms of cooperation and partnership in Vietnam's own cooperation tiers. The US is actually just a basic tier 1 level of cooperation on Vietnam's list. So don't listen to what the troll propagandist US and CIA media outlets say. Vietnam and China is actually on very good terms.
@@saint8257 A well written and informative reply on RUclips!? Be still my heart! I didn’t think such a thing possible. I had no preconceived notions of Vietnam’s relations with China or any others for that matter. I am quite ignorant of South Asian politics. Hence my appreciation for the enlightenment and perspective your reply provided. It’s quite interesting.
@@damiansutube yes it is though not to the same extent as South Korea. There was even of a somewhat local joke where Filipinos should go when China starts sending nukes our way. Southeast Asia will be a hot topic the next few decades, the economies have been developing rapidly hence the importance of geopolitics in the region.
Is it me, or are the responses a mix of English, Spanish & Tagalog? Does Tagalog have some Spanish words. The guy at 11:34 looks more Spanish than Asian. Philippines is a fascinating country! I must visit in my lifetime! 🇵🇭
The responses are a mix of English and Tagalog. Tagalog itself is a melange - language of aboriginal natives, English, Spanish, Malay, Chinese, among others. As a native speaker of English myself, what I find surprising is NOT that there are words borrowed from other languages. Rather, it is that the borrowed words are pronounced using the original native accent and intonation. For me, that results in my "...What!?! Am I hearing English or Spanish... or WHAT (language) am I hearing!?!!" reaction. 😄😄😄❤😄😄😄
Tagalog belongs to the Austronesian language family, the same family as Bahasa Melayu, Bahasa Indonesia, and the aboriginal languages of Taiwanese natives. Over the years, Tagalog incorporated many loan words from Spanish (due to colonization), Hokkien (due to massive immigration of Han-Chinese people from Fujian within the last 500 years), and Sanskrit (due to our ancient Buddhist/Hindu past). The guy at 11:34 looks like a standard Austronesian from Southeast Asia and Taiwan; he doesn’t look Spanish. Our ancestors originally came from southern China (non-Han Chinese) about 8,000 years ago, migrated to Taiwan, and then dispersed to the Philippines, Indonesia, Malaysia, etc.
@@wherestheoptoutoptionmfs I think that's not a cultural thing, it's more of a "let me digest these questions about a potential war in a few years" thing
They are using the usa card to gain more from china when dealing. Economic for china and military for usa. Balance foriegn policy which may come back to bite them
thanks but believe me they don't. It just so happens that this issue is very important. But in other historical contexts in other parts of the world, they are not.
No they don't have cause they have forgotten how their grand father was beheaded,hanged naked,children were massacred,women were brutally raped and to cover all of this dark story America have tried to do everything and which worked which these young fool generation will never realise but at the very end poor slave will be always slave who cares.💩💩💩💩💩💩🤮🤮🤮🤮
Nah f that i am from nepal and i am disappointed from Philipines and their foreign policy and sitting in lap of colonizers forgeting the sacrifices of their forefathers even philpino soliders got involved in iraq,abstain the vote in un for ceasefire of gaza if you think us occupation in philipines is over you never learn anything
Filipinos should not kid themselves. US is not really concerned with the country's national security. They're building additional military bases here to serve their geopolitical and economic interest. While I don't like how some of China's navy or privately owned fishing vessels attack Filipino fisherfolks, I am not in favor of US' increasing military presence either.
Sadly, like most people around the world, Most of these people dont know the history and the real cause of the dispute in the south China sea or west Philippine sea. The Philippines and china are not the only ones that lay claim on these islands. Vietnam, Malaysia, Brunei and even Taiwan are also claiming the disputed islands for themselves. Its naive to think that the US is getting in the mix because it "cares" for Filipinos. Like the Chinese, the americans are also only looking after their own selfish interests. The addition of 5 more US military bases in the Philippines is never about protecting the Philippines from foreign invasion, its about the US protecting its interests in Taiwan's microchip industry which it's very reliant on for its weapons manufacturing industry to continue it's domination and hegemony across the world. China on the other hand also wants to take control of the region to protect it's shipping because it's economy depends on the shipping lanes through the south China sea. China nor the US don't care about the Philippines and neither do other countries. Filipinos are just too brainwashed by Western propagandists and are just too gullible. Masyado tayong sumasamba at mga uto uto ng mga kano at mga dayuhan saka sobrang corrupt ng mga pulitiko natin kaya di tayo umuunlad. Kung di tayo magbabago baka tayo na lang ang maiiwang mahirap sa ASEAN at puro mga katulong at boy na lang ang magiging eksena natin sa mundo
The United Nations Permanent Court of Arbitration ruled in 2016 that China’s claims to the Spratly Islands were invalid and that China had violated the Philippines’ sovereign rights in its exclusive economic zone. US and PH have a long relationship and have mutual defense treaties. The re-opening of US-bases are required to counter Chinese aggression.
@@markus711 there's no such thing as "required". The US -ph defense treaty is not a guarantee that the US will immediately defend the Philippines in case of an attack by a foreign power. That still has to be debated and approved by the US congress while my innocent Filipino countrymen are dying because our lame politicians continue to be lapdogs of both the US and china and even the EU.
@@roderickpineda5886 The United Nations Permanent Court of Arbitration ruled in 2016 that China’s claims to the Spratly Islands were invalid and that China had violated the Philippines’ sovereign rights in its exclusive economic zone. How do you interpret this?
The UN did not conclude that the spratly islands belonged to the Philippines. It said that Chinas claims were illegitimate but did not assign territorial rights to either the Phillipines or china. It is still disputed. So the guy was wrong. The islands do not belong to the Phillipines.
"Still disputed" you said that. The Arbitral Award, by itself, affirms that under UNCLOS the Philippines can exclusively exploit the natural resources, including the oil and gas, in the Philippine exclusive economic zone in the West Philippine Sea without interference from any other coastal state.
Yeh so much brainwashing and fake news spreading around. This is how facts get misconstrued. The arbitration ruling ruled that China had no legal basis on "historical claims" to those islands, because NO country can make claims on any territory based on historical claims with our current maritime laws, including the PH. If China reversed the role and initiated this ruling, the same thing would have applied to the PH - that PH cannot claim those islands based on "historical" records as well.
The UNCLOS is Clear all the Natural Resources in Philippine Exclusive Economic Zone is Exclusive to Pilipino people so its not disputed China Delusional Claim isn't valid even with your wildest dreams 😂
@@aaron199x sorry but all that part is now part of the US control, the US have military presence in taiwan, the philippines, south korea and japan. all "suposeltly china's claim is under US control
As a filipino-American, I really don't want my country, the U.S., to waste money on resources on a country thousands of miles away that doesn't have much to offer Americans in terms of trade. If you want peace, prepare for war... But let's hope filipinos pay for it all by themselves.
We can prevent are country involve in the war, If all Filipino people understand what happened in Ukraine, but sadly most Filipino believe that US coming here is defend us , and the fate news and propaganda by mainstream media
Wisdom comes with age. These young kids think the America is so cool effect. This is soft power in action. Making you think that someone who colonized you and abused you for 50+ years is actually your best friend. Never forget how many Filipinos the American killed almost 1-2 million! It is really scary how influential the US media and soft power is in the Philippines. A lot of what the US does to the Philippines both currently and historically gets brushed aside either by lack of awareness or misinformation (western biased media) regarding the matter. Why isn't anyone talking about the fact that Vietnam has more claimed (3x) territories than China? As a Filipino, I don't want my country to end up in an American Proxy war like Ukraine. This video shows you have naive and simple minded the youngster are, the view from the elderly is far more rational they have lived long enough to know. The Philippine Media paints such a rosy image of the US, and China as selfish materialistic and nation motivated by self interest. It's like they have never met Americans before. The US is not the saviour that these Filipinos think they are. Simple Question. How many countries has China invaded, colonized, and built military bases in? Now ask yourself the same question about the US. The colonial mentality is strong in Filipinos. Their country has been exploited by the US for economic and military gain while its people proudly hail them as saviours. It's largest trading partner is China, contributing to largest economic growth in decades. Althewhile receiving military aid and protection that solidifies its position as cannon fodder. Self hating Asians.
I also hate this about my countrymen. US didn't save us from Spaniards. The Spaniards were already losing against our Katipuneros and Rebolusyonaryos. US came into the view to "buy" the Philippines, staging a mock battle against Spain to make it seem like US saved the Filipinos. During WWII, the American leaders literally abandoned Philippines. It was our Guerillas who fought hard for our country. And when everything's almost settled down, US came to Philippines again to "save" Filipinos. It's so nauseating. There are so many unsung heroes in the Philippines that many Filipinos aren't aware of, yet here they are proclaiming US as the heroes.
You make a valid bias perspective. Do you believe that if the Philippines would be better off with China than the Us? Do you really think that if somehow the Philippines chooses to align with China, China would stop bullying the Philippines? You try to speak of history as if you understand it. US, China or Russia, all of them are superpowers that crushes softpowers beneth them. The one that causes less harm would be the best option. You think that would be China? Do you really believe that the communist China now is the same pacifist dynasty before?
@@patryk88 , You sure have poor knowledge of Asia! America had colonized Philippines for 48 years and now under the US control with 9 military bases in Philippines. What did US do for Philippines since 1898 to 2024? Please tell the world!
It is important to distinguish between the American people and American government. Likewise the Chinese people and the Chinese government. The American people dont have an issue with Chinese people. Nor do the American people have an issue with the Filipino people. We are all similar just trying to live peacefully and support our families. Being married to a Filipina when we are visiting the Philippines i do my best to avoid political issues.
Tell me about it. It's like I can't visit my home town without getting bombarded with NPA-CPP communist propaganda and threats whilst also berated by anti-Marcos activists. Just let me take care of my grandparents in peace. 🙄🙄
but the Filipino people are at odds with the American Government. likewise with the Chinese Government. we don't trust both foreign governments, we only seek to have a transactional relationship, when it comes to economic, military, and technological affairs. the Filipino people and its government only seeks to be independent and to continue to economically and military grow, like what is happening now, expand our economy, to continue to strengthen our military, to deter both US and Chinese aggression in our area. basically like Switzerland.
@@herrkommandank675 you are trying to put the people and the government of the Philippines in one basket like the people of the Philippines have control over the government does . Same as the US and Chinese government, the every day average people don't control the government nor does the governments care about what the people need . You want your government to be neutral but Philippine government has already chosen the US side.
@@herrkommandank675 The United Nations Permanent Court of Arbitration ruled in 2016 that China’s claims to the Spratly Islands were invalid and that China had violated the Philippines’ sovereign rights in its exclusive economic zone. US and PH have a long relationship and have mutual defense treaties. The re-opening of US-bases are required to counter Chinese aggression.
@@pharaohsanakht6839 You're an American citizen, of course you'll side with the US. But for the folks who were born and are citizens of this country, we are pragmatics. "already chosen the US" and that's why we're decoupling, we are sick with the US interventionism here in the country. THe dependence towards the US has been problematic all these years. That's why we're having a level-headed diplomacy wth China. A Pew Research Center Report indicated that 67% of Filipinos want to engage business ties with China, as it will further amplify our economic growth. The history of the US was subjugation, the moment we first met them and until now. We seek neutrality, not obliging to the US, neither to China. We acknowledge the aggressions of China, but as I reiterate, we will prioritize economic growth in order for us to have more resources for our development and military to deter China and not be reliant towards the US
Regarding the US presence in the Philippines, opinions within the Filipino population are diverse. Some view the strong military ties between the Philippines and the US as a necessary means to bolster our defense capabilities and deter potential threats in the region. The annual military exercises with the US can be seen as a demonstration of cooperation and mutual support in times of geopolitical uncertainty. Many Filipinos hope for a diplomatic and cooperative approach to addressing territorial disputes and regional tensions. We seek a stable and secure environment that promotes mutual respect among nations and upholds international law.
@@shinchan-F-urmomThat’s a China-exclusive job post. You couldn’t even come up with your own term - typical Chinese copycatting and lack of imagination. At least there are official evidences that the Chinese have been and are being paid to spread propaganda and disinformation on social networks. The opposite hasn’t been demonstrated.
@@shinchan-F-urmom US don't need to pay people to support it. Only loser governments with no friends (including no friends among its own people) do that
5:30 When will Phillipines get rid of it's colonial mentality? It's sad to see it being reinforced in younger faces, and older faces who lived through those times are still proper bitter about it but seemingly ignored. Though this guy explains it pretty well. Phillipines media paints such a rosy image of the US, and it's hilarious to me that China/Chinese are portrayed as selfish and materialistic and as a nation motivated by it's self interest, it's like they never met Americans before or haven't studied American history on their own time.
As Filipinos, we had to learn our own history (which is a lot of colonialism) and also world history ... and now you are demanding for us to learn a lot of American history??? Isn't that a bit much?? Also... The Oligarchs of the upper class are pretty much pro-US... they have really impacted the perception of Philippines to both countries
Both China and America are selfish and self-interested. The main difference is China is threatening the Philippines' territory - the US's motives are also self interested, but at least they aren't eating up islands and swallowing the EEZs of most of east and SE Asia.
I would be curious to know the opinions of folks from the rural areas as well. Also, I know folks from Luzon usually have different views from Visayas and Mindanao. I feel that most of the time only views of people from Luzon are accounted for in Asian Boss.
To be fair, Asian Boss showed a good balance here of showing the pros and cons from different backgrounds, because if you talk to the rural areas, you'll see either indifference, or overwhelming pro-US anti China stance.
As an analyst and advisor to the team working with the Philippine government I can say there is no benefit to the USA developing bases in PI except for a radar installation which we were willing to put anywhere in any country that wanted it. A radar installation means the US will spend big $$$ in that country and PI is smart enough to know that. China could run over PI quite easily, but if a US base is there then no. We will likely have a carrier group visit a PI port to tell China 'do not touch' and hopefully that will be sufficient to ensure PI sovereignty. Nobody wants to challenge a US Carrier group, China doesn't even want to be within 400 miles of a US Carrier group.
Nobody wants to challenge a US carrier group? Seriously? What a wishful thinking. What I heard from sources from Chinese military, they are eager to challenge it.
Without US presence in the Phillipines bases, China will have no interest whatsoever to attack the Phillipines if Taiwan war breaks out. It's a terrible mistake to let the US to use the Philipines bases. The pressure is just too much, and finally the political leadership just yielded to the demand, even if it's detrimental to the Philippines.
@@elok3 And cities have their government leaders as well, that doesn't make New York City a country for example. Even small towns with 300 people have their government leaders. They're called mayors.
Being Neutral just isn't realistic anymore, the Russian-Ukrainian War has shown that countries do choose sides because they have to and it serves their interests. The Philippines are leaning towards the US because their leaders have a better understanding of what China is doing and what kind of government the CCP is...
What is China "doing"? The CCP lifted 800 million Chinese out of poverty in the last decades while there's an increasing homelessness in US. What part of that is hard to understand?
What did US gave to Philippines apart from genocide more 200000 during their occupations. Almost as bad as the Japanese and Spanish. Till this day, they are still slaves to Imperial Colonisers.
@@markus711 guesse maybe you say china but earlier on that covid in wuhan they are already recorded covid in some part of EU specially in spain but they did spread the news i did say china is clean but technically it was the elite or pharma who spread that virus and china is part of the game.
China which is purely mercantile in nature is sometimes confrontational to prove a point but the militaristic USA exports conflicts to expand its hegemonic agenda. Though China browbeats the Ph it never ever went to invade it. Whereas the USA have killed 2 million Filipinos during its colonization attempt in the PH-US war. At any given point in time, America is at war or involved in a conflict or destabilization with other countries worldwide. Ph had known and traded with China for centuries as far as pre-colonization period. No conflict ever occurred or attempts to invade. Oldest Chinatown in the world is in Manila. USA colonized Ph by deceit in connivance with Spain and killing 2 million Filipinos in the process. Ph was dragged into WWII due to its US military installations of Clark, Subic and Corregidor. Ph was never repatriated under Marshal plan for collateral damages incurred fighting for the Americans. We were given a hasty independence by the USA to avoid spending war rehabilitation. Chances are you’re have a relative or friend who has Chinese blood rather than American. Lastly, while unaware, your life is surrounded by everything Chinese. From going to your favorite malls, fastfoods, from buying online goods to seeing mega-structures build around the country. Heck, even your clothes, underwear and mobile phone are all made in China. China and Ph is closely interlinked by trade and blood throughout the century. Ask yourself why China feels betrayed that Ph should take sides with the Americans despite all of this shared history and culture.
LMAO so you're going to turn blind eye on the west philippine sea issue? your so called shared history and culture did nothing to stop china from getting our islands, and fish lol. f**king selective thinking you got there man.❤
China has left us with no choice but to side with the US. We had already removed the EDCA back in the 90s and legally appealed in the UNCLOS to stop island reclamation. Former President Duterte flirted with China. Despite all that, the militarization continues, leaving us no choice but to side with the US.
It really is scary how influential the US media and soft power is in the Philippines. I feel like a lot of what the US does to the Philippines both currently and historically gets brushed aside either by lack of awareness or because of misinformation regarding the matter.
@@whatever1661 their work is through piracy, smuggling, drug dealing, and copying others' work and now hacking into people's PC to get the work of the people.
I think both US and China have their own self interests but I choose US because their interests somewhat align with our interests as Filipinos USA wants to deter/contain China, The Philippines wants to protect it's ocean by detering China Nothing comes for free, USA has their own interests and we have ours, it just so happens that we can both get what we want through our cooperation and that's why I prefer USA China on the other hand didn't even let our fishermen fish in our own sea even when Duterte was nice to them, their interests goes against Filipinos' interests since in no way are they gonna budge and let us access our own damn sea!
I am a Chinese. You are smart. I agree with you except the last sentence. Your fishermen do can fish in your own sea. Do you know China's contribution to Filipine because of Duterte? The sea dispute can be resolved by negotiation. Two countried can explore sea together.
@@KuangWen0 Marcos Jr. visited China prior to calling the Americans to reopen military bases in The Philippines, he likely tried to negotiate but since he called America, he likely just felt threatened.
@@justdont2378 Negotiation is a long and hard progress and may take many years. Both countries would not easily give up more interests, otherwise the leaders will be condemned by its own people. I would do the same thing if I am Philippine President. Philippine should tighten the relationship with America. Small countries should carefully keep balance between superpowers. Ukraine and Iraqi Presidents are stupid. What is good to piss off a superpower? I do not care about American military bases. There are already too many American military bases around China. And the result of war is not decided by number of military bases, but by comprehensive national power including production ability, human resources and technology. Though, military bases do have combat advantage. China and America will never fight again because there is no winner.
@@KuangWen0 I am on the same page as you when it comes to the "China and America will never fight again because there is no winner" the loss from war and the risk of it being a nuclear one will simply surpass what we will all gain from it, both China and USA know that At the same time though this issue has been here for decades already with many other countries also against China for them claiming their waters, Malaysia, Brunei, Vietnam and somehow China even claims an island all the way in Indonesia Yes negotiation takes a long time but a lot of us have likely tried to negotiate over all these years and we barely got any progress, none of us know how long it will take so we're just doing what we can which is cooperating with The United States.
@qiaoyankuang8406 you do know that our fisherman can't fish in west Philippine sea and Scarborough shoal because your navy are telling them to leave because it's a Chinese territory? Duterte? He's a joke.
The US is there at the request of the Philippine government. Stop playing victim. You want the help or not? The US has nothing to gain by being there. What do we care if China harasses Filipino fishermen? Own your own problems and defend your own borders.
@@gravityissues5210 US was forcing our government too to build bases in our country where we didn't even ask for because we have friendly relations with China so the US is not that good as you think it is Btw im from Pakistan 🇵🇰
@@gravityissues5210 exactly, US doesn't care about Philippines they just want to use it as a forward base like Ukraine and will sacrifice it to keep itself safe. The US uses small countries to use as cannon fodder to keep its enemies at bay. Without sacrificing US citizens. That is the US strategy both spoken by US top general and Lindsey Graham a US senator.
@@gravityissues5210 the US is there to have more military presence in the Asia- Pacific. With the Philippines, the US will have a belt of military bases in the region extending to Japan and South Korea and Singapore in the south. Look at the maps for perspective!
Philippines should not follow the US blindly but I think the history is clear that US values are more aligned with Philippines. US soldiers died in world war 2 to free Philippines from Japanese invasion. And after the war, the US agreed to Philippines independence and self-governance. The US isn't claiming any Philippines land, that is China now stealing what islands they can from Philippines. Philippines needs US to counter balance China's aggression but also not become blind follower of US. It is a balance and I hope that Marco Jr. can find that.
I think it's the other way around, the Filipino soldiers died for the war that isn't theirs. America used (still is) the land but they don't want the responsibilities that comes with it. In the Treaty of Paris, they have the right to take advantage of our resources as if they are Filipinos. They wanted the land, but not the people. So there. They gave the Filipinos the "independence" because it's too much money to rehabilitate the country after the war. Also, they said that we're not white enough to be able assimilate to their culture. So don't make it appear like they're the saviours. They used us and are still using us for their advantage. Now between US and China, I am siding with neither. They can kill each other, just don't use us as a pawn.
@@BanigNation I’m not saying US isn’t self interested, I just think that engagement with the US has generally helped nations that took that path. Japan, Singapore, and Korea chose close US engagement with good results. Same for Europe. Every country needs friends. No friend is perfect. Philippines needs someone to stop China from taking more and more land. Being totally neutral isn’t an option because Ph will be alone and get squeezed by China and keep losing land.
@@LiveWell6 Japan, Singapore and South Korea had good results. It should follow that the Philippines, which got the most US aids from the start, should have done even better. What happened there? China presented carbon dated documents from the Tang Dynasty (600s A.D.) identifying these disputed islands as part of the southern Chinese territories. But why should that be recognized when conflicts among these claimants play very well into US hands? And why should Filipinos, who like the Americans are so lacking of any sense of history, know this when "English" is the medium they can understand. They said there's WMD in Iraq, too. How did that go?
1:14 No, the reality is that PH does NOT have sovereignty over those islands. When the US handed over its sovereignty to the PH, they SPECIFICALLY said it did NOT include the Spratly islands etc. So PH does NOT have legal sovereignty over those islands. PH just wish they did, and made their citizens to believe its theirs. 7:28 This guy is uninformed. Its not "illegal" per se if its no laws against it. ESPECIALLY when its disputed territory. PH does NOT have sovereignty over the islands, so its not "theirs". Its called "disputed territory" for a reason. Many countries claim these territories, not just China and PH. 7:35 You "won" because China was not even there to defend themselves. China was not there because China knew it was useless to go, as the current international laws present is incompatible with a countrys sovereignty claims. What that means is the current international maritime laws only define whats considered a countrys territory based on the 12nm distance from a countrys coastline, EEZ etc, but has no laws to define whether a piece of territory falls under the sovereignty of Country X or Country Y. 7:51 No, you cant forcefully implement it because that court you won that case from has ZERO authority to enforce anything. Even the US cant. 12:44 No, it was not "proven that it belongs to the PH". This is how facts get misconstrued. The arbitration ruling ruled that China had no legal basis on "historical claims" to those islands, because NO country (including PH) can make claims on any territory based on historical claims with our current maritime laws. If China reversed the role and initiated this ruling, the same thing would have applied to the PH - that PH cannot claim those islands based on "historical" records as well. 0:21 Taiwan isnt a "country". Why is Asian Boss allowing their host to spread misinformation? No world power in this world recognises "Taiwan" as a country. And Taiwans very own constitution specifically refers to Taiwan as a province of China.
Yes China is illegally occupying areas that should be within the EEZ of the Philippines. While Philippines or China cannot say this rock or that shoal is part their respective territories, the only thing clear is that some areas being ILLEGALLY occupied by China fall within Philippines EEZ by international law
@@pongpong123able4 EEZ means Exclusive Economic Zone. That only means a country has special rights to exploit the economic resources there. But the area is NOT part of their sovereign territory. So how did China "illegally occupy" something thats not "owned" by any country? Just because you have special rights in exploiting resources there doesnt mean its magically part of your sovereign territory. A countrys sovereign territory only extends up to 12nm from its shoreline, not the 200nm mark for EEZ. So what did China allegedly "illegal occupy" again and from who? All these people thinking they know "international law" when the fact of the matter is there is literally no law that prevents any country from "occupying" rocks or creating artificial islands. So no, nothing "illegal" based on international law.
@@yerri5567 yes its not part of Philippines' territory but is for their own exclusive exploitation. China has built an island there ILLEGALLY because no country has business building an island on a sea that is not its territory. Is that area a part of China? NO. SO WHY IS CHINA SQUATTING AND BUILDING ISLANDS THERE? IS THAT ILLEGAL? YES Not only has China ILLEGALLY squatted on the sea, it prevented Filipinos from enjoying its EEZ, in violation of international maritime law. Illegal? yES Some people claim they know international law but can't put facts together. You say that is only part of Philippines' EEZ which is correct. Then why is China treating it like its own territory?? Patrolling the area, driving away Filipino fishermen who are supposed to be there legally, and building islands. Is that part of Chinese territory? No. So why are you saying that China's actions there are not illegal?
@@pingmeup5908 Looks like my comment was deleted.. "So how did China "illegally occupy" something thats not "owned" by any country?" Something is only "illegal" if a law states that its prohibited. There is NO law that states anything about occupying territory not owned by anyone, ESPECIALLY when China is the FIRST country in the region to lay claims on those territories in the 1940s. It was only in the 1970s when oil was found in the region that Vietnam, PH and the likes started claiming areas in the SCS. So as the first country to lay claims and was uncontested, it should be theirs imo. So again, China did not "illegal occupy" those territories. Your words are showing extreme bias. "It goes both ways as well" Where was your comment that PH was "illegally occupying" territories in the SCS too? "if this is not owned by any country but is currently being used by the said countries as an EEZ, , then why build islands and harass fishermen that is just trying to fish?" I never said its "owned" or "not owned" by any country. The territories are called "disputed territories" for a reason. YOU were the one that said China were supposedly "illegally occupying" it. Im telling now that theyre not "illegally occupying" anything. Theres NO law that prohibits buildings islands outside of another countrys sovereign territory, thus Chinas actions cant be deemed "illegal". And although I dont agree with the harassing of fisherman in the area, again, theres no laws against that in international law, so nothing can be done about that. "china does not own the place right? then why act as if they own it?" I spoke NOTHING on whether country X owns or does not own territory Z. Its called "disputed territory" for a reason. Many parties claim that they own the territory, including the PH. But China has the strongest claim on the area as they were the first country in the region to lay claims to the islands in the 1940s, while others made their first claim in the 1970s... "shouldnt it be joint extraction since no country owns it?" And thats not how the world works. Especially since China was the first to lay claim in the region and was uncontested. So to them its theirs, so why should they split something that they deem as theirs? If your neighbour suddenly claimed half your house 30 years after you, would you split it with them?
Mga kapwa Pilipino, kailangan natin maging neutral. Dapat may mga sarili tayong opinyon. Hindi dahil tutulungan tayo ng US e kaibigan na natin sila at hindi dahil may mga problema tayo sa Tsina, kaaway na natin sila. Sana makahanap tayo ng gitna. Gusto lang naman natin ng kapayapaan at katahimikan.
walang neutral sa mundo. naniniwala ka pa rin sa fantasy na yan? Lahat tayo may biases. And this is politics. You have to TAKE SIDES. Tignan mo nga nung pumutok ang giyera sa Russia-Ukraine, natakot karamihan at sinuportahan ang Ukraine. Walang neutral. walang ganon. You have to choose your side.
Ukraine is an example on why it's fatal to be neutral. the 3 baltic states Estonia, Lithuania and Latvia join NATO earlier. While Ukraine didn't, now they are paying the price. Look at Sweden and Finland abandoning their neutrality after the Russian invasion of Ukraine. Now they join NATO to not repeat the same mistake that Ukraine made. If Ukraine had join NATO earlier after Estonia, Lithuania and Latvia then they are protected by NATO's Article 5. meaning all of NATO are obligated to come to its aid militarily. Meaning Putin had to think twice before invading because they have to deal with 30+ countries and 3 of them have nukes.
The U.S. is not responsible for acting as the world's police. Look at their sloppy withdrawal from Afghanistan. After two decades of of military presence, the Taliban was able to retake the country with the U.S. leaving behind over $7B worth of equipment. The U.S. is not the savior that these Filipinos think they are. Also, every country should be vested in its own self-interest first. There's nothing selfish about forging nationalism.
Filipinos do not need saviour. PH needs allies to protect and help the PH. PH and USA is a long time ally. What is the purpose of the mutual defense treaty of the PH and US if USA is not there to help the PH? The US equipments that is left in Afghanistan serves a purpose. Taliban will use that weapons and equipment to fight Iran which is also the enemy of US. 😊
A Nationalist movement always holds the possibility of becoming a racist, supremacist dictatorship. So it's a tricky thing. Once a nation is established there is no need for an overly nationalistic movement.
@@ClassicallyMish You're living in the past. Colonization is a long time ago. Alliance is the new word. PH and USA is a long time standing ally. The modern colonizer is Russia and China. China has annexed Tibet. Thats your mental colonizer.
I really like Filipinos as they have built a unique culture within a hundred years which added vibrancy to Southeast Asia, but Filipinos need to learn to see through the motives of protracted soft power and western influence.
I think we wont ever grow from western media influence, especially the affluent parts. The greatest alternative to western show for example is mostly limited to Korea and japan due to k drama and anime.
The United Nations Permanent Court of Arbitration ruled in 2016 that China’s claims to the Spratly Islands were invalid and that China had violated the Philippines’ sovereign rights in its exclusive economic zone. US and PH have a long relationship and have mutual defense treaties. The re-opening of US-bases are required to counter Chinese aggression.
@@markus711There are no US bases being opened, all those bases belong to the Philippines and Americans only has limited use. The base commander is Filipino, and Americans can't do things as easily as they wish since it is the Philippines that calls the shots.
Weird, considering the Philippines is the one that came to the US asking for help with China. But why bother with facts, when you can just spew the same boring "the US is the worst country in the world trying to take over" rhetoric. I mean, what do I care if China takes over the Philippines? Sounds like you'd be happier, too.
looking past what all the leaders/governments are doing, and looking at the people, i've met many chinese people who were incredibly nice and friendly and helpful to me and i have met a few americans who have wronged me. my only point is pls do not judge people by their government and do not let political issues affect your impression of the humans who live in the same planet as yours. the common people just want to live a life/survive while the leaders play their game of chess
Yet, if China attacks the Philippines, it will not be the incredibly nice, friendly and helpful Chinese who will do anything to fix the situation but the so-called nasty American. Whether Filipinos like it or not, US is their only real friend, NOT China. The concerns about US colonizing the Philippines is just nonsense. Those days of colonization is long over and is not going to happen again. Not a single person in the US will support such a move against a friendly country. Most Americans have a very positive opinion about Filipinos in general.
Very wrong question …. It should be --why choose US /China if you can have them both in your side. China for trade US for security. There is power in ambiguity
As a Filipino, I still believe in the superiority of the US-Philippine Alliance over the "friendship" China is offering to us. Having a superpower ally is still the best deterrent against another hostile superpower, especially when our AFP is still far beyond what they call the "minimum credible defense". With China as the biggest adversary, I don't think "minimum" is even enough. Superpowers are fickle and questionable, but it's better to have a democratic superpower whose leaders can be replaced, whose policies can change, and whose people's opinions are relatively more open to expression. Good luck protesting in Moscow or Beijing. But I also believe that the Philippines should NOT be dependent on the Americans alone to protect our national interests. The Philippines' primary responsibility is to build up its own defense capabilities and seek help from other democratic allies. Having an American presence is nice, but not the endgame aspiration. On the other hand, it cannot be denied that China has an economic and cultural influence on us, but we must learn to stand against authoritarianism. It would have been ideal for Sino-Philippine ties if China was a multiparty democracy like ours. But we make do with what we have. Overall, the Philippines remaining with the democratic camp is still the best option, but if there are ways to remain friendly with China without compromising our sovereign rights, we can try them. The foreign policies of Aquino II and Marcos II are far better than what Duterte ever tried. Best to stay with their course.
The US alliance is a folly, we benefited more from the Asian-centric policies of Duterte compared to the past two decades than the US "alliance." When it comes to Duterte, they're only viewing the relationship between China, but won't even bother to the fact that we strengthened ties with Japan, South Korea, Israel, and expanded ties with India, Turkey, ASEAN, the Middle East, and etc. It's for Duterte that we're able to acquire new advance weaponries, such as state-of-the-art helicopters from Turkey, Supersonic missiles from India, Sabrah Light Tanks from Israel, because he expanded ties to the countries we often called "unorthodox". We even had various transfer of technology deal with the JSDF of Japan and its military-industrial complex and with Israel. To establish minimum credible defense is to establish expanded diplomatic ties with various countries, to support you on your military modernization efforts, that's what Duterte did right, instead of fully relying on the American who can't even commit to assisting us, other than giving us some 2nd used hardware that has a shelf-life of 10-15 years. Don't get me started with the various economic policies that propelled the continous economic growth of the country, such as the infrastructure program, liberalization, and etc.
@@herrkommandank675 The United Nations Permanent Court of Arbitration ruled in 2016 that China’s claims to the Spratly Islands were invalid and that China had violated the Philippines’ sovereign rights in its exclusive economic zone. US and PH have a long relationship and have mutual defense treaties. The re-opening of US-bases are required to counter Chinese aggression.
@@markus711 Dependence towards the US is problematic. We we're able to continue modernizing our military without the aid of the US. In addition, growing our economy is also as important to modernization, to ensure more resources for our military expansion. Reaping the benefits of economic globalism.
China's longstanding focus has consistently centered on Taiwan, with the South China Sea representing an additional point of contention. Similarly, the United States' interest has also been directed towards Taiwan, as China's potential acquisition of Taiwan could significantly impact U.S. influence across the Pacific Ocean. This underscores China's strategic importance, given its geographical confinement by numerous neighboring nations. Consequently, Taiwan serves as a pivotal asset for China to unlock access to the broader expanse of the Pacific Ocean.
Taiwan holds a lot of secrets to semiconductor manufacturing, its been a primary manufacturer for apple as well through foxconn, taiwan being occupied by China will make US very dependent or their tech will go into China's hands China already has good idea of hardware manufacturing, only thing they have been lacking a bit is semiconductors, it will pull a lot of business away from US if China occupies Taiwan
Your info was correct like 20 years ago, now China is prioritizing the south China sea over Taiwan, because of its significant importance for the security of resource importation.
@@crassuschan You really believe in that? 😅 South China Sea is way troublesome, there's a lot of country has interest on it. China just putting show, deceiving everyone thinking they are targeting South China Sea, but their goal never left on Taiwan. Once they get it, they will be free for being strangle by a lot of countries. Which makes them benefit than South China Sea. Although there's a lot of resources coming from it, they would still be strangled and trapped by a lot of countries. Conquering Taiwan would improve their Navy.
U do know that China is smarter than what the US wants right?? All this time US has been egging on China to declare war. Many times US has been encircling China by air or sea way too close, it has been done for decades. Now US has been getting antsy and doing more in the name of protecting democracy, they just getting scared and really wants to fight bc that’s how America makes money. Thru wars thru arms weapons selling to other countries. China hasn’t taken the bait and will not. They’re too smart for that and honestly have been very patient imo in this whole situation they only will defend by doing Defense strategies atm. Funny to say as well I read up on this China and Taiwan issue, u do know both claim to be the legitimate China? U should read upon it more
I am a Filipino and it is not right to say that it is all Filipino opinion. Since regionally every Filipinos has different opinion in this topic. My opinion is that it is not a tension between China and the US will drag the Philippines into a war. But Philippines and China tension would drag US into a war. Many always used U.S and China issue to an extent they use it as an excuse to have a pacifist stand. US and Philippine relation goes back after WW2. Also US is a deterrence that will make China think to not engage into a confrontation with the Philippines. US is one of the trusted nation for the Filipinos. Why ask if it is obvious, we need US to defend our rights in "WEST PHILIPPINE SEA" and US need the Philippines as a strategic location to deter Chinas aggression. It is both beneficial for both parties that's its a partnership.
The comment the one lady made about US military presence in the Ukraine vs Russia is totally false. We have set down all branches near neighboring countries aiding Ukrainian fighters and freedoms fights who were retired military forces. Ukraine is holding the fight due to allied aid. Not just by themselves..
I am Filipino American with my entire family being Born in the Philippines. In the next few years we're all moving to Quezon City. I have the dilemma of having to renounce my US Citizenship in order to stay. But besides that I might be a bit biased but my family and I fully support the US presence in Asia. One thing that Filipinos and Taiwanese want most of all is the status quo. We want help from the US but we do not want an armed conflict with China or Russia. The Philippines, Taiwan, and Japan do not have the capability to defend themselves against the super powers like China or Russia. Maybe Korea can to an extent. If more US bases in PH is a good enough deterrent to keep the region peaceful I'm all for it. My greatest fear is imperialist China taking over South Korea Japan and the Philippines. I believe all democratic countries must be protected.
As a half-Taiwanese, I think the Philippines is far more dangerous than Taiwan at the moment. Taiwan currently has no U.S. troops deployed. The economies of Japan, South Korea and China are deeply tied, and they have a certain degree of independence, and they will be very cautious about direct wars. After the Philippines became a U.S. military base, the nature of the conflict between the Philippines and China has completely changed, and this has gone far beyond the scope of island disputes. One thing is certain, as long as the United States and China break out in a local war in the South China Sea, the United States will be the first to activate the US military base in the Philippines. The consequence will be that the Philippines will be covered by Chinese missiles first, not Taiwan, and the entire Philippines will be engulfed in flames, not just a few islands. I don't stand on any side, but I strongly suggest that Filipinos should pay close attention to the development of the relationship between the United States and China. As a frontline position, the situation in the Philippines is more dangerous than any other region at the moment. Americans can live safely on the North American continent, but Filipinos are not..No matter how much the allies of the United States pay lip service to the Philippines.
The US has no real reason to support the PI, Japan, Australia, Vietnam, or even Taiwan. We should, in theory, keep propping up China. We're here because we made allies of these countries, and we're here helping them at their request. We don't need TSMC, so who cares if the PRC takes over Taiwan and enslaves you like they do mainlanders? No need for Americans to die to protect you when we gain nothing. Yet you claim somehow it's all our doing. We don't need another Vietnam or Afghanistan, dying to help people who don't want help. Fight your own war with China.
Also the fact that they will not blindly destroy Taiwan due to the chip manufactuing... Afterall, why would you go destroy something you want to takeover? But the Philiipines? China economy isn't tied into it.. nor would the US care much about it.. the US is more worry about their aircraft carrier being destroyed than some islands in the Philippines
just sayin, Japan and South Korea (Japan has 120 US Military Bases) have way more US Military Bases and US Troops in their countries than The Philippines, Japanese Government is paying US Forces for their Bases there to stay especially in Okinawa because it acts as deterence, Also The US Military Facilities in The Philippines are not full blown US Bases those bases are owned by Armed Forces of The Philippines the U.S Military are just tenants after 1992. (Post 1992 when all Full blown US Armed Forces Bases in Philippines were transferred to The Armed Forces of The Philippines)
Filipinos doesn't like war we have learned from our great ancestors what had happened back then but we also don't tolerate China's bullying....We have tried to settle it in diplomacy by all means but its doesn't mean we just simply give up our territory what ours is ours even if this country is belong to third world country we are willing to give our life to defend our Nation in case of invasion...
Asian Boss, thanks for the video. Not surprise with the comments. As usual, most younger Filipinos prefer the US. Can't blame them bcos of media influence and lack of awareness of what is really happening in the outside world. Both Spain and America colonised the Philippines and killed thousands of its people, yet Spain is the bad guy and America is the saviour. This goes to show how naive and simple minded these youngsters are. The view of the two elderly gentleman is more rational. They lives long enough to know. Everyone is for their self interest. Trust neither but work with both the US and China but keep them out of your country.
Yet another Biased Asian Boss interview that doesn't even come close to reflecting how a nation feels!... Let's arrive to our hotel in Manila and only interview a bunch of kids who have no idea what's going on to push a narrative!
YAWN. The US couldn't care less about the PI. We're there at their request. What do we gain dying in yet another war to save people who don't want to be saved? Rather go on about 100 years ago than losing your territorial claims to China today. Fine by me, go fight your own war with China.
The old guy was "more rational" was he? He didn't provide any reasons for his positions. If he provided reasons for his positions, he might have been more convincing. Go ahead and choose China as your ally. Then you can be colonized a *third* time by a state that commits genocide and has a horrific human rights record. Have fun with that. But don't beg the US to come running back to "help" you then. You chose to be slaves of China and lose your freedoms. Enjoy.
America's only interest in the region is to stop China from stealing land from our allies or attacking our allies. Also US colonialism is taught in both American and Filipino schools, its already very well known lol
Were you asleep the past few years? The Duterte administration sought closer ties to China and both countries agreed to a peaceful resolution regarding the disputed islands through cooperation. Duterte went as far as to cancel joint exercises with US after the falling out between him and Obama. China took this opportunity to increase their presence by the Philippines to maintain their blockade of the disputed islands, continued it's fortification and harassed local Filipino fisherman from entering its fishing territories. Does this sound like China was cooperating? China had no intention of sharing it's claimed territories.
Bro EDCA bases do not control our Judiciary, Legislative and Executive branch. its quite the opposite. Legislative and Executive are the once calling the shot on where to put these bases and how many.
ASEAN countries are caught between the conflict and foreign interests of 2 global powers. It would be extremely naive for anyone to believe either the US or China cares about the interests of these countries. I do think it’s weird that so many Filipinos have forgotten what the Americans did to the Philippines in the Philippine American war though, and I wonder what their schools are teaching to kids. The American military isn’t in the Philippines out of the goodness of their hearts, but there to protect their national interests. ASEAN countries should resist imperialism and colonial attitudes from all foreign powers, be it from China or from the U.S.
I'd love, for once, for one of you people spewing this drivel to answer my question: WHAT DOES THE US HAVE TO GAIN FROM THIS?!? We're there because the Philippines ASKED us to be. The level of ignorance is incredible. People would rather whine and play victim than own their own actions. Let me see if you can finally answer that question--with something concrete, not stereotypes and tropes you picked up from TikTok about how the US is some "colonizing imperial superpower." I need hard numbers and clear motivations here, not fuzzy "hurr durr" nonsense, like every other commenter here.
So does everyone else lol. Ask what the Chinese, koreans and Japanese think of us. People don't understand that the west is not the only ones r@cist to us. funny is at least the west knows they have a problem, in asia people don't see that as much of a problem.
I am a chinese. I agree with you. You are smart. If I am a Filipinos, I will befriend both China and America. Filipinos can negotiate with China to resolve the sea dispute.
@@KuangWen0 China will only accept negotiations if the Philippines gives what they want. They've been expanding their territory to our seas and have been harassing our coastguards and fishermen. We have been friendly with them to the point of the former president being a lap dog. They're not stopping the harassment because they know our government won't retaliate. There are hundreds of illegal mainlanders here now with hundreds of fake birth certificates claiming to be Filipino-Chinese even if they are not Filipinos. If you do not know about the Alice Guo POGO case, you can look it up on RUclips or social media. The Philippines has already been discreetly sold to China.
Vietnam. India. Tibet. As in post WW2. And how many parts of other nations are they currently claiming? As in in the South China Sea? And of course the cancer that is North Korea exists because of China. The oppressed of North Korea must be truly grateful....
As per my observation Filipinos have diverse opinion regarding US presence and building military bases may be because pro-US media is more dominant in Philippines. According to history US international politics and relations always revolve around self-interest. Look at US foreign policy today at Ukraine and Afghanistan or where US is involved, if it serves their purpose they dump in their armaments and spread the concept so called 'protection or safeguard democracy' but once it's starts hitting them hard they will quietly left as we have witnessed what happened in Afghanistan. For me as Asian it's time for us to unite and counter West hegemony and it's time for Asia to rise because it's been many century that West and Europe has colonised us and dominated us and we have been ill treated so we should not keep bowing to them and keep serving their purpose. Just my opinion love from India
I'm sorry, bu the fact is Asian Boss tried to be unbiased here. But the reality is 85-90% of the Filipinos according to the most reliable surveys are pro-US. Overwhelming number of Filipinos, even with Chinese blood such as myself, or pure Chinese from China, at anti China with regards to the West Philippine Sea (South China Sea) issue.
That would be great, if the alternative wasn’t just another hegemon vying for power. The Japanese tried that a couple of years ago, and well… look what happened there…
You make it sound like Asia is as united as the West is. The West, although shady history, currently supports borders and nations sovereignty. China wishes the US would leave Asia so it could take over areas of it's neighbors. So, if your wish came true and the US left. You'd rather deal with China taking parts of India, Taiwan, and a lot of the South China Sea. You can hate the US/West, but currently China has been the one making moves all over Asia. And from personal experience, Chinese hate Indians as they look down on them.
It's a dispute because both sides claiming the same thing. The thing is Philippines only existed as an entity only a hundred years ago while China has been there for thousands of years. Just look the number of ethnic Chinese in South East Asia and who are the one running the economy. Not to mention, If a frontier is up for grabs by all, South East Asian countries are late to the game by a long stretch. Even if you are to follow the international treaty of sorts, China drawn up their 11 Dash line long before Philippines even realize what they want in addition. For those who don't know, PRC only claiming 9 Dash line because of good will for Vietnam during the Vietnam war against Americans. Who's the greedy one ?
The perspective of the common Filipino folk is basically neutrality. It does not seek to entrench with the barbarism of both countries, with China's aggression and with the opportunistic tendencies of the US. The country only seeks to continually economically grow and strengthen its own military further to fend off both powers. The PH is not pro-US, nor pro-China, it seeks to be neutral, while reaping both the economic and military benefits of both countries through trade and diplomacy. It wants to be diplomatically and military like Switzerland.
but the government did choice for them. let the US build military bases it means choose to be enemy of China，and be a frontline of a possible US_China war in future.
As far as I see it there are no truly neutral countries, even Switzerland has taken sides. It all depends on the conflict though, because at the end of the day each nation looks out for their own interests. When looking at the Philippines situation a war between China and the US will force all nations in the region to pick sides, because the US and China are the biggest investors in those foreign economies (example: North Korea can’t survive without Chinese support or investment, just like how South Korea can’t survive without European and US support and investment)
Hi American here, just wanted to say that I support you and your country on its way to independence. Although I’m not certain how our government feels as every government is materialistic. I’m gonna keep this note here as a time capsule that I’ll hopefully never have to dig up.
I am a US Navy vet. I served proudly with many Filipinos who have historically served in the US Navy. The US Navy devastated the Japanese navy in WW2 while supplying the Nationalist Chinese forces who held Chungking while the communist hid in the hills. I hope there is not a conflict, but I would recommend Beijing study the naval battles of WW2 before they challenge the US Navy. The Chinese can't "own" the South China Sea if their ships are at the bottom of it.
US nuclear bombs can easily strike Chinese territory. . On the flip side, China's nuclear warheads can also cover the entire US territory in just 15 minutes. It doesn't matter how the ship sank or anything
I recommend u learn how to communicate with Chinese. Bcz u American army failed every time against Chinese communist. No matter it is Korean War or Vietnam war. USA is more like a loser than China. USA do have 11 or wtever proud aircraft. They all can be destroyed in only 30mins by missle. I sincerely recommend u to be a humble person. Don’t try to provoke any conflict.
So u betrayed us Nationalist Chinese in support of CCP into the UN and now u betray the CCP. All just to F with Chinese interests throughout history. U and ur military should get the F out Asia where u don’t belong for once.
According to the U.S. Department of Defense, China’s shipbuilding capabilities now exceed U.S. capabilities in manufacturing munitions. They have most of the world's shipbuilding capacity, and the tonnage of warships launched every year is equivalent to the entire French navy. Even if China's shore-based strike force is not considered, it would be unwise to conflict with the Chinese navy in the South China Sea. In fact, the events of 2016 have proven this judgment. In that incident, the US commander even gave the order to fire, but his men refused to carry out the order. He was subsequently fired and transferred to South Korea, where he became a minor figure.
it’s interesting to see people are voluntarily willing to give up their own countries sovereignty by letting another country to build military base in their own territory and think that it will help protecting their country😅.
At this point, it is what it is. i have no problem if china wants to fish near our island as long we can fish in ours. but my only concern and hate about is the abuse that even us cannot fish on our own waters so if peace can still be talked out and agreed that both interest would meet. i really dont care if there are Chinese ships as long there is no abuse. but most likely that wont happen. so lets just watch on where things otherwise im still ready to defend my country no matter what
@@kimeli yes there is east but you're lucky if you live there, how about the people living in fishing areas in the west? some of them are just using a small motor boat to fish and its not economical to go that far (east) to fish if they can just go in their local area.
@@kimeli kung isa kang maralitang mangingisda na kapos ang bulsa mo makabili ng gasolina papuntang Philippine East Sea na taga Mindoro, Palawan, Zambales, Marinduque, Pangasinan, Cavite, Bataan, paano ka makapangingisda sa sinasabi mong East Sea?
The Philippines and US both have Mutual Defense Treaty. If war break out with China either the US or The Philippines both will depend each others against China...I believes the S.Korea, Japan, Indonesia, Australia, EU and other countries will help the Philippines.
US Congress has to deliberate about it first before they make a move to help the Philippines... by the time they act, the Philippines is goners. I think that's what many Filipinos don't realize.
@@Yarxk-j7w They are giving Ukraine second rate tools and intel, they don't have soldiers or heavy assets in Ukraine. War with China would be different, it would mean direct confrontation, not proxy support like in Ukraine.
The media in the Philippines is highly controlled by the United States, and I wouldn't expect most Filipinos to have any good reviews of China. Please learn from the old gentleman in the video, read more and think more. Every Filipino I have met is very friendly, and the Philippines is also a beautiful country. I hope the Philippines must be smart and maintain a balance among major powers, and never learn from Ukraine.
I can see who is educated well, and who isn't. Anyways, the US has had military bases in the Philippines for a long time and closed many of them already. The US let the Filipinos join the US military and they easily became US citizens with a much higher income than their local countrymen. The US Navy has an unbelievable number of Filipinos in it. I'm sure the other services do also. And something not mentioned in the video is the local economies around the military bases grows a lot. The US military, and their members spend a lot of money around the bases. Also defense costs a lot of money. The US will give defense to the Philippines which the Philippines can't even afford. Countries like Japan and South Korea have been getting defense for cheap or free for a long time. Look at their economies now.
I was actually surprised that the "well educated" people had such a rosy view of the US history in the Philippines, the civilian cost in the Philippine-American War was crazy. As a well educated American we never learned about it in school, and I was astounded when I only recently became aware of it... I guess it's not emphasized much in Philippines schools either, and the cultural memory has mostly faded/healed since it was over 120 years ago. Not that this would/should outweigh the current geopolitical bullying China is doing---it's just possible to acknowledge that the US did really shitty things in the past and has been a helpful ally more recently.
people in Japan have a hard life bro and good and rich korean only in his big city many could not pay their mortgages and living expenses don't believe what you see on tv A good government is a government that makes its people prosperous, not a government that has a large stock of missiles
@@mingwu-v3f china will also make them work for cheap labor. Since american/western buy cheap stuff from them. so yea let china colonize other asian counties and the philipiines i want my cheap stuff. LOl
@@goatmeal5241in ph we learned it at school. We learned how spain colonized us for 300 yrs, how US betrayed us( we even have a decorated hero killed by americans in battle of tirade pass). We also learned about the atrocities that the japanese did to us. But what people must learn is how to forgive and move on. Spain, japan, and america are now friends. We must never forget the past but we cannot let the past in hinder us from moving forward.
I wish I was interviewed. I'll choose Indonesia and India. If we choose the US, China will become more aggressive because the US is increasing its presence here to control the South China Sea. If they control the sea, they can paralyze the economy of China to contain its growth. If we choose China, the US and its allies will retaliate and can economically punish the Philippines. Our real best friend is Indonesia. Our very own Southeast Asian neighbor. We don't need to look farther. Our best friend is located in the South. We can also strengthen our relationship with India. South-South cooperation is more important than ever. (Global South are the developing countries). The guy in white shirt is ignorant in his own country's history. Yes, the US promised to help us to become independent from Spain but they betrayed us in the Treaty of Paris. They committed genocide, killing 250,000 Filipinos. They ordered to kill all Filipinos over 10 years old.
Totally Agree. I choose ASEAN also to work together if ever that I'll interview as well. Malapit lng din satin din eh. Although naka base nmn sa military base ng US but let's be honest tlga. Nanjan ang neighbors natin din❤️
Indonesia and India can't protect you from China, at all. If China decides the ocean around the Philippines and it's islands belong to them that's it you are done. Unless the US decides to step in. I will not deny that the US committed genocide in the Philippines but saying they ordered everyone over 10 to be killed is so stupid, there literally would not be a Philippines if that was the case, the deaths would have been in the millions.
Many of them choosing China confuses China to ethnic chinese, which has a longer historical connection with the Philippines, but they are oblivious to the fact that many of the Chinese who came to the Philippines escaped mainland China during Mao's time, the Americans have a colonist past relations with the Philippines, but it has made up for it and build up relations since the japanese occupation going forward. The Chinese on the other hand specifically the current CCP government has expansionist ambitions, and the current bully and colonizer in the region. Threatening independent democratic Taiwan, suppressing their ethnic Uyghurs, Tibetans Mongolians, neighboring India, claiming territories of Vietnam, Philippines Malaysia, Brunei etc. in the west Philippine sea, using obscure historical map. If I have a map of the world does it follow that I own the world? The west Philippine sea has been claimed by many including the Philippines but it has been free to fish and passage of nearby nation, as well as international commercial traffic, the US & other western nation freedom of navigation is essential to keep the area clear of CCP China's greedy grasp. We are already entangled in the US-China conflict the moment CCP China claimed our territories, militarized the islands and terrorized our fishermen.
They actually requested the Philippines for a legal lease with the aim of continuing to exert geopolitical dominance against China. It's the same modus operandi already followed within NATO, they're actually trying to involve NATO in this whole business. Any idea about friendship or actions without contracts in our 2023 world are just fairytales. Just go past the headlines, read the small print: reality is always different from the hype.
The US was not invited by Ph. It volunteered since it needs the position of Ph to deter Chi for Taiwan and to hamper its control in the Pacific. US only saw the importance of Ph during former Pres Du30 when he was siding with Chi. Both US and Ph benefit from their partnership. US for control. Ph for protection.
Wow America is so generous to Philippines. They offer all this military protection for absolutely no benefit to themselves. They are helping Filipinos purely out of the generosity of their own hearts.
@@alterzy5197The US Twice stood up the Philippines as an independent Nation. Once before the Japanese invaded and once again after driving the Japanese off. At great cost in American lives. And no the US did not Colonize the Philippines. It was a Spanish Colony deeded to the US after the Spanish American War. To be honest the US never really knew what to do with it. Contrary to popular myth the US for most of its history has actively avoided any foreign holdings beyond a few that had clear National Security purpose. Hawaii, Guam and Somoa for example were needed fueling stops for the Navy in the 19th and early 20th century. And Hawaii due to its position is critical to defense of the Eastern Pacific.
I said: 0:21 Taiwan isnt a "country". Why is Asian Boss allowing their host to spread misinformation? No world power in this world recognises "Taiwan" as a country. And Taiwans very own constitution specifically refers to Taiwan as a province of China. 1:14 No, the reality is that PH does NOT have sovereignty over those islands. When the US handed over its sovereignty to the PH, they SPECIFICALLY said it did NOT include the Spratly islands etc. So PH does NOT have legal sovereignty over those islands. PH just wish they did, and made their citizens to believe its theirs. 7:28 This guy is uninformed. Its not "illegal" per se if its no laws against it. ESPECIALLY when its disputed territory. PH does NOT have sovereignty over the islands, so its not "theirs". Its called "disputed territory" for a reason. Many countries claim these territories, not just China and PH. 7:35 You "won" because China was not even there to defend themselves. China was not there because China knew it was useless to go, as the current international laws present is incompatible with a countrys sovereignty claims. What that means is the current international maritime laws only define whats considered a countrys territory based on the 12nm distance from a countrys coastline, EEZ etc, but has no laws to define whether a piece of territory falls under the sovereignty of Country X or Country Y. 7:51 No, you cant forcefully implement it because that court you won that case from has ZERO authority to enforce anything. Even the US cant. 12:44 No, it was not "proven that it belongs to the PH". This is how facts get misconstrued. The arbitration ruling ruled that China had no legal basis on "historical claims" to those islands, because NO country (including PH) can make claims on any territory based on historical claims with our current maritime laws. If China reversed the role and initiated this ruling, the same thing would have applied to the PH - that PH cannot claim those islands based on "historical" records as well.
Don't forget that you are not blonde and blued eyes.. And you are not white. They are not same species. Will look down on you Filipinos, always. In contrast, China is the way to go in long run, period.
We don't pick sides. But worse comes to worse, China. I don't see US invading us. You have a silent but deadly predator behind you and you provoke it by inviting his enemy? Marcos' move really is very idiotic
I support independence for 1. Nagaland 2. Kashmir 3. sikkim For years, their women were raped by Indian soldiers and their men were killed by Indian soldiers for years they were impoverished and the wealth of their land was plundered by new delhi for years the people were beaten and racist by the indians It's time for them to be independent from India
Interestingly, with just a tiny bit of research from any independent source, you'll notice the Philipines never claimed any island in the South China Sea until recently with the "help" from the Yankees
The condition of the Philippines is tough. Winnie the Pooh want to expand their territory like what they did with their neighboring countries like Tibet, Uighur, Qinghai, Inner Mongolia, and many others, Mr. Dementia don't want to get rid of their rule in the world and continue their business of selling weapons of war of destruction, because that's where they make a lot of money if there's no war. Their economy is weak, so the condition of the Philippines is in a very difficult situation. The best thing to do is strengthen their military capabilities, and hopefully, the Philippine government will wake up and stop the culture of corruption so that the development of the Philippines will continue.
@@w.z.6062 Did you already forget about China's outrageous new "map" they released in September? Say what you will about the USA, China has shown very clearly that they want the land and seas of their neighbors.
I can't help but notice that the pro US people appear to be more educated, wearing more expensive clothes, and are more well spoke than those that are against the US. I wonder if there is an economic class or blue collar/white collar class distinction going on here. Anyone from Philippines know the answer?
I think that's a stereotype you might have. I don't know how we can classify the «well-spoken» thing when we foreigners can't understand half of what they're saying (since it's Tagalog), apart from the bits in English, and (in my case) the many other bits in Spanish. Unless for «well-spoken» you actually mean «mostly using English». I actually perceived the opposite: the few strongly pro-US people spoke showing some bias, lacking many bits of modern reality and history. Very clear contrast with the eldest, who didn't forget. The pro-independence (I think the majority) were balancing their historical background together with the current events and their geostrategical value. Those seemingly favouring China were actually pro-independence, however cleverly stating you should get along with your neighbours first. In any case, it's just a random street interview, with no statistical value. Very interesting, though.
@@duozuo Let’s get along with our bully neighbour who’s CURRENTLY seizing our territory, sinking our fishermen and interfering with our elections at any given opportunity. Sure 😂 The old folks might have learned something from the past (if anything, the US has granted them independence), but the young have let go and are looking with fresher eyes. It’s pretty obvious that China is the friend of no country besides other dictatorships. It only seeks to turn its neighbours into vassal states and shamelessly exploit their resources. The US is the only force able to counterbalance and withhold this temporary excess of “ambition” from China (until it soon collapses), therefore Filipinos as well as every countries of the Pacific have everything to gain in siding with them to contain and defend them from this bully.
I think OP’s comment is ok if you separate the sentences, but combined it does read like saying Filipinos used to not be educated and well spoken. But in the 50s, Manila was considered as the Paris of Asia
I agree kay tatay dapat both sides china and Us at kaibiganin nang PILIPINAS para miwasan ang tensyon o digmaan na mangyari.pero in the other side for me I think ang USA use Philippines as a weapon kasi Bago paman nagsimula ang tensyon nang Philippines at china The US is first has have a tensyon to china .and I hope we should always aware of that
It's only the opinions of 5-7 people in Manila. It is a random pick so, the opinions of 7 people don't really speak for the whole Filipinos. Maybe I would agree if 1 of those 7 people said he/she is pro-China, and the rest is pro-US. I agree with more reliable surveys such as Pulse Asia coz the surveys they are conducting say it ranges to 85-90% are pro-US, next is those who are undecided and only a small number say they are pro-China.
There are many misconceptions around the SCS dispute, like how our ASEAN neighbors also have a claim in the Spratlys, or how the 2016 UNCLOS ruling only addressed the matters around EEZs and not territorial sovereignty. With that out of the way, our disputes with China is something we should address among ourselves. Dragging the US along will draw even bigger risks and implications that'll sever what little mutual understanding we have left with China. If we keep acting rashly and drag the US over this dispute, god fobid, we will become the next Ukraine, and we will be a little footnote as to why World War III broke out. The more US bases we have, the more likely that we become the battleground while the actual Americans are safe on the other side of the world.
@@fredy241m the British and Canadian Embassies made statements condemning the water cannon incident in the Ayungin Shoal but they still called that body of water "South China Sea". "West Philippine Sea" is a name unheard of outside the Philippines because it was an 2012 invention made to assert our claim in the Spratlys.
If people are rational enough and have read through the South China Sea arbitration tribunal ruling, then they should know that the ruling itself is useless, it does not help the situation at all. The ruling of the arbitration tribunal can only be legally binding when both parties that have willingly participated in the proceedings, by international law if China reject and does not participate in the proceedings then it is pretty much a shitshow. If every county choice to ignore bilateral negotiations and all follow what Philippines does just go ahead and filed a lawsuit against another country and then uses the outcome to pressure the other country to back out their claim, sooner or later the world will be plunder into chaos. Filipinos think the US is help them in the matter, but whats really happening was the US used Philippines and worsening the dispute between China and Filipinos so that Filipinos have no choice but to side with the US. Funny how after 6 years and the Filipinos still dont really understand what the US did to them. China and Philippines's relationship is much larger than the dispute, the US made it so that the dispute is all there is between the Chinese and Filipinos.
Well china is been ignoring PH you can't blame us to depend on US china didn't even tell pH what they building in the island. And now china want to be friend to Philippines. The audacity
You don't know anything dude china been attacking pH fisherman for so many years they building near pH and it's so close to Palawan which is my hometown china didn't even tell what they doing on that island.
@@HABIBIBIBIBIBI50 I'm hearing lot of finger pointing, lot of emotion. How do you know the Chinese and Philippine government never talk about the dispute, how do you know there was no progress, do you expect a negotiations can be reach in just 2 meetings or more? In terms of attacking fisher man, I saw lot of video footages many years ago of Philippine military carrying out physical abuse and torture of Chinese fishman, do you not call those crimes? The way I see it, the Philippine side was not so good either. All of those footages were published by the Philippine side, non from the Chinese. This is what I mean by when people are not in their right mind and incapable of rational thinking, everything get distorted. You are seeing what you want to see and using all the reason you can find to justified your reason for taking China to court and did what you did. This type of thinking is called conditioning, you been conditioned to think you have done the right thing, but are you sure about that? Just by reading the history, you guys has stolen an island from Republic of China during the 80s when a typhoon hit and when the ROC troops return find out it was stolen by your government, do you not call this stealing? By using your logic, does that mean the PLA should just go in and throw you guys off the island? The way they see it, every belong to ROC is now part of PRC, stealing from ROC is the same as stealing from PRC. At the end of the day, if this is all your people are capable of, then you will always be used as a tool for the Americans. To date, you hold on to a hate toward China purely based on propaganda.
This is so true. When i pointed this out in Twitter.. I was labeled pro-Chinese...😂 And said this to me "do you side with oppressors".. so fcking woke.. a Kakampink
im glad that our independence was fight by the blood. our fertile country was from our ancestor blood nurturing the motherland itself. in a sense that, our freedom is TRULY FREE. we earned it. we really earned it. congratulations, to all indonesians. happy 78th anniversary, the Unitary Nation of Republic Indonesia.
Many people might think that speaking pure english is more impressive for filipinos but it’s actually being able to be well spoken in pure Filipino that is more impressive to filipinos
English?
Otherwise?
Yes!
Casual: Taglish (Filipino+English)
Business Casual: English
Formal and educated: Pure Filipino
There's no such thing as "pure Filipino" since the Filipino language is consisting of Tagalog+Spanish+English, I think you're referring to "pure Tagalog".
@@NoVisionGuy Taking an exerpt from Nolasco, Ricardo (2007) chairperson of KWF, a foremost linguist expert, unfortunately you are mistaken. According to him, Filipino is identical to Tagalog grammatically and substantially, but differentiated by class-meaning Filipino can be thought of as *high Tagalog* or formal Tagalog as opposed to the Tagalog spoken in the provinces e.g., Bulacan, Laguna, Batangas, which are all forms or dialects of Tagalog.
@@NoVisionGuy But I think you have a point. I’m no language expert 😅
Why isn't anyone talking about the fact that Vietnam has more claimed territories than China?
😂😂😂
Because Vietnam isn't trying to destroy the world order by threatening to Invade an island critical to the entire modern civilization nor threaten a majority of Asian islands due to its size. Vietnam could never militarily get away with it. China has been building expressly for that purpose.
Because Vietnam is not harassing Filipino fishermen. Because Vietnam is not puting nukes in their islands.
Well Filos and Viets tend to view each other as brethren from the Vietnam war to ASEAN, so if there are issues between the Philippines and Vietnam in the WPS/SCS I am pretty sure they can work things out through diplomacy and not harrass each other, I mean PH did it with Indonesia, one of PH's closest brother, in the Southern Seas of Mindanao so yeah... And also Vietnam is still treated as the only and closest communist ally of the Philippines and Vietnam view Philippines as its ally and brother as well so I know they can work things out unlike with China...
@@Darius0109 they ARE the world order, a task neither China nor Russia can succeed in
It's nice to see that a lot of Filipino people are not blindly believing in what is being portrayed in the mainstream media and feels skeptical about the aims of the US presence in the Philippines on the other hand, China hasn't been the best neighbor as well. This topic is kind of complicated actually to be honest but it only goes to show na nag iisip na ang mga Pilipino.. I applaud us for that.
HISTORY has proven that US is not a friend! TAKE NOTE, lahat ng magagandang gusali sa Pilipinas, ang US ang sumira during world war 2! kunwari ina attack mga Hapon pero bansa natin ang binobomba! so I will never trust US. better to try our luck with China!
truly spoken like a commy. kung di dahil sa pera galing sa mga ofc sa states at elsewhere baka patay ka na sa gutom.
You must believe nazi japan and usa
They are your father and mom
to all Filipino, never start or join a war unless your country is under attack i mean real attack such as foreign troops are on your land because in this situation stand any side will just hurt your country dont let big power countries turn your country into Afghanistan
@@iamhardwell2844 unfortunately too many stupid filipinos do not know history. our country was the best in asia. until we got involved in ww2. no thanks to uncle joe. now we are worst in asia. soon if we dont smarten up we will be worst in the world
I enjoyed listening to all of their comments and opinions. Most of them are very aware of the political and military instability affecting the region. I wonder if Fil-Ams are at all concerned of what’s happening back home. That should be the next topic to be discussed I think.
It will depend on the generation but some first generation like me are invested into the development of the region as many of us were naturalized here vs being born in the US like other generations. Sadly many of them are more concerned about being called Pacific Islander than Asian...this shows how distant they've become from the Philippines.
Nope, most of their knowledge came from news in their country
no fil-ams don't care about philippines. most of them are whitewashed
Fil-ams republicans or democrats got their own fantasy.
Most Fil-Ams I know (I’m a first Gen FilAm but born & grew up first in the Phil) are misguided about Filipino politics. Most unfortunately look at it in a American/bourgeois lense. Very simplistic POV and assuming It’s like the democratic vs republican situation in the US. Some who studied abroad with me in the Phil often live far differently from experiencing what normal Filipinos in the Philippines live like so they don’t often understand the political nuance and the struggles of the masses. When it comes to the China issue though they obviously support the US but they understandably won’t often know the whole situation and why some Filipinos may be against the US as well.
si kuya from 6:59 whe he said, the US helped us from Spanish colonialism, i think what he meant was the American-Spanish war also known as the Manila Mock Battle, where both country’s staged the battle to deceived Filipinos that they are the liberators and that they will free us, but the truth is, Spain already sold us to US at that time for $20M😅
any credible source? what did they get in return and why did they let the Philippines have its own government!
@@SelenaJoyArcenal research pa more ma'am. they let us go because at that time, dumadami ang mga us citizens na against sa colonialism. same din sa nagyari sa vietnam, there were mass protests to stop the war so they pulled out of the war that was going nowhere, only resulting in death and disabled soldiers going back home. us is the only country thats constantly involved in wars, they killed more civilians than enemies. they've wiped out entire villages in every war they got involved in (also happened during the filipino-american war that a lot of filipinos nowadays are not even aware of). our so called friends now, i have ancestors who died because of them (one of my grandfather's cousins was even killed by a korean under the japanese military in ww2, my father was even born in the middle of a jungle while the family was hiding from the japanese). i dont have ancestors or current relatives who suffered from chinese hands.
Wow, OP is deeply delusional. Lets hope that nobody falls for that rubbish.
"I shall return" sounds great but it was McArthur abandoning the Filipinos to face the Japanese on their own during the WWII. And Philippines is forever grateful for that.
The Spaniards were actually close to being defeated by the a guerrilla group of Filipinos, but they didn't want to admit being defeated by the Philippines, so they make up the fact that they were defeated by the US and took the money... Both Spaniards and Americans aren't really your friend. US /China are going to use your country to be the battle ground for to get Taiwan
Fun Fact: Vietnam has more occupied islands within 200 Nautical Miles of EEZ of Philippines than China.
Vietnam also holds the record for the most amount of artificial islands 4 times more than china
I heard that happened because of a drinking session 😂
Vietnam are not being Aholes about it thats literally the main thing
Yes true, but the Philippines won the arbital rulings which the basis of the illegality of china artificial islands and the basis that Indonesia used to stop China in occupying Natuna Island.
Perhaps thats the reason why China is more actively provoking us.
There's no free lunch. The US will expect something in return for providing enhanced security in the region. A resolution of the South China Seas territorial dispute would be great for so many countries. Of course the first country to make a claim was the Republic of China in 1947 which occupied Taiping Island to the west of Palawan. ROC (Taiwan) forces remain there to this day. I believe they even evicted Philippine nationals in the islands at one point and arrested them.
The compromise is thr military bases. We want them to corner china. That literally is the thing we are getting. We aren't just protecting the Philippines out of good will.
What the US gets in return is use of Filipino land to put their military bases to stop China... which also helps protect Filipinos from authoritarian China taking over. I think this is probably something the Filipinos want. Unless they want to be colonized a *third* time (Spain, US, then China)
Ha, good old whataboutism, always there to put things in an unhelpful, distracting perspective.
Yeah. The US just recently a few weeks/months ago wanted the Philippines to house temporary refugees from the Middle East..Not sure what happened with that but that issue became controversial.
@@bmona7550 hell no lets not accept temporary refugees, have you seen what is happening in Europe right now.
This is the kind of stuff I want to know. Good video. I want to hear people's honest opinions from all over the world. Just regular good common folk.
Just to clarify what the girl said about the US not having a significant impact on the Russo-Ukrainian war at 8:58 is false, the amount of aid the US has sent to Ukraine is higher than the next 5 organizations/countries' aid combined via Statista, additionally what kind of military aid Ukraine has been getting is also vital, in the first 2 months of the war; in the Kyiv front the use of Western-made NLAWs and Javelins helped bog down and force the Russians to abandon their objective of taking Kyiv. Apart from that, Ukraine started to gain the initiative when M777 Howitzers and HIMARS were delivered (this was back in September-October 2022 in Kharkiv Oblast where Ukraine battered Russia's First Guards Tank Army or just generally the elements of the Russian Army in Kharkiv Oblast and forced them to withdraw to Svatove-Kreminna Line), as well as during the winter when Russia was hitting Ukrainian energy infrastructure. Currently, while Ukraine continues to push for their Spring Counteroffensive in Zaporizhzhia Oblast the American-made Bradley IFVs along with other Western-made tanks such as Leopards of diverse variants have been praised by the AFU for their crew protection capabilities. One more thing, with the delivery of the Patriot SAM System, comes greater air protection an example is how Russia's "unstoppable" Kh-47M2 Kinzhal Hypersonic Missile was shot down, and once Ukraine's Air Force receive F-16 fighter jets it'll be safe to assume that Ukraine will have a favorable contested airspace which would mean that these donations have made a significant impact in the war.
Fast forward today in 2024 Jul, Ukraine lost more territories even after those military equipment donated as you mentioned in your long paragraph.
@@hiskandar still doesn't change the fact that western weapons and munitions had a big impact, whether Ukraine lost more territory after some time; Ukraine would've inevitably lost more territory than they did now if Western weapons weren't in Ukraine. My opinion was that Western weapons had significant impact in the war. What you said is not really tackling what my main point was.
@@hiskandar your username reminds me of the Iskander missile of Russia, with relate to that did you know that after Patriot SAM missile defense systems were donated to Ukraine in adequate numbers all of Russia's hypersonic missiles that were used in recent attacks were shot down
@@rzjnbtg1546 Yeah, I heard that, but did you hear those HIMARS etc still don't make any difference in the final results that Ukraine now has lost more territories than before?
I suggest you to use Chatgpt and ask there how many territories has Ukraine lost after Russia Special Military Operations in Feb 2022. The AI really helpful in data mining or gathering information.
@@rzjnbtg1546 This arm race happens from WW1 all the way until today. So definitely weapon development has impact. But it is NOT something that make a much different results when youur opponent can keep up with you Have you heard Russia blow US million dollars tank with just cheap drones?
Do you see what I mean?
This comment section is a proxy war😂
WW3
Internet edition
yeah 50cent warriors and IO storming this video like its a threat to xi jingping
Something that interest me in this street interview is that older people seems more aligning themselves with China whereas the young seems more aligning with USA.
Wisdom comes with age. Very sad that the next generation isnt well informed abt historical contexts
Media consumption and older people lived through what was essentially American occupation, which is beginning again since Phillipines under Marcos Jr. is allowing US forces on the island again.
@@patrickco2398 The "America is so cool" effect. This is soft power in action. Making you think someone who colonized you and abused you for 50+ years is actually your best friend.
American soft power at play
Not surprising.
Young minds are easily conditioned and are gullible to spins and propagandas.
Older minds are far wiser and experienced plus they are very familiar with history the unadulterated version.
It must be nerve racking to be caught between two giants trying not to get stepped on.
Uh, the US is there because they asked us to, they're the ones that want the help. The US has no real interests in that region.
Not really. It's nerve racking for countries with incompetent, corrupt leaders maybe.
Simply look at how Vietnam deals with things. Vietnam has good relations with both US and China (especially China), yet does not host a single US military base anywhere on its territory, and actively rejects the US from doing so for decades. Is the fastest growing economy in the world.
Philippine leaders lack pragmatism and competency.
As for why I said Vietnam has especially good relations with China, it is because China is actually several tiers above the US in terms of cooperation and partnership in Vietnam's own cooperation tiers. The US is actually just a basic tier 1 level of cooperation on Vietnam's list. So don't listen to what the troll propagandist US and CIA media outlets say. Vietnam and China is actually on very good terms.
@@saint8257 A well written and informative reply on RUclips!? Be still my heart! I didn’t think such a thing possible.
I had no preconceived notions of Vietnam’s relations with China or any others for that matter. I am quite ignorant of South Asian politics. Hence my appreciation for the enlightenment and perspective your reply provided. It’s quite interesting.
We just don't play our cards right..
@@damiansutube yes it is though not to the same extent as South Korea. There was even of a somewhat local joke where Filipinos should go when China starts sending nukes our way. Southeast Asia will be a hot topic the next few decades, the economies have been developing rapidly hence the importance of geopolitics in the region.
Is it me, or are the responses a mix of English, Spanish & Tagalog? Does Tagalog have some Spanish words. The guy at 11:34 looks more Spanish than Asian. Philippines is a fascinating country! I must visit in my lifetime! 🇵🇭
The responses are a mix of English and Tagalog. Tagalog itself is a melange - language of aboriginal natives, English, Spanish, Malay, Chinese, among others.
As a native speaker of English myself, what I find surprising is NOT that there are words borrowed from other languages. Rather, it is that the borrowed words are pronounced using the original native accent and intonation. For me, that results in my "...What!?! Am I hearing English or Spanish... or WHAT (language) am I hearing!?!!" reaction. 😄😄😄❤😄😄😄
@@claudiawoods4382 it’s fascinating!
Tagalog belongs to the Austronesian language family, the same family as Bahasa Melayu, Bahasa Indonesia, and the aboriginal languages of Taiwanese natives. Over the years, Tagalog incorporated many loan words from Spanish (due to colonization), Hokkien (due to massive immigration of Han-Chinese people from Fujian within the last 500 years), and Sanskrit (due to our ancient Buddhist/Hindu past).
The guy at 11:34 looks like a standard Austronesian from Southeast Asia and Taiwan; he doesn’t look Spanish. Our ancestors originally came from southern China (non-Han Chinese) about 8,000 years ago, migrated to Taiwan, and then dispersed to the Philippines, Indonesia, Malaysia, etc.
@@Deng_Xiaoping_is_my_fatherthanks for the education! It’s much appreciated 🙏
@@Deng_Xiaoping_is_my_father Are you suggesting that Filipino people are "originally" Chinese?
The using of Filipino and English at the same time when speaking is very interesting to hear as an English speaker.
Agreed. Also, the lack of eye contact while speaking, particularly from the men.
@@wherestheoptoutoptionmfs I think that's not a cultural thing, it's more of a "let me digest these questions about a potential war in a few years" thing
I actually thought that they spoke less English in this episode than some videos before.
The philippines was invented by America.
@@wherestheoptoutoptionmfs I notice philippine men tend to be shy and feminine. Not like it's a bad thing per se.
Filipinos look from both perspective and have a lot of knowledge about history and geopolitical circumstances . Love from Nepal🇳🇵❤
They are using the usa card to gain more from china when dealing. Economic for china and military for usa. Balance foriegn policy which may come back to bite them
thanks but believe me they don't. It just so happens that this issue is very important. But in other historical contexts in other parts of the world, they are not.
No they don't have cause they have forgotten how their grand father was beheaded,hanged naked,children were massacred,women were brutally raped and to cover all of this dark story America have tried to do everything and which worked which these young fool generation will never realise but at the very end poor slave will be always slave who cares.💩💩💩💩💩💩🤮🤮🤮🤮
Ikw nmang exspert kya lhat ng pinoy hahahaha.
Nah f that i am from nepal and i am disappointed from Philipines and their foreign policy and sitting in lap of colonizers forgeting the sacrifices of their forefathers even philpino soliders got involved in iraq,abstain the vote in un for ceasefire of gaza if you think us occupation in philipines is over you never learn anything
Filipinos should not kid themselves. US is not really concerned with the country's national security. They're building additional military bases here to serve their geopolitical and economic interest. While I don't like how some of China's navy or privately owned fishing vessels attack Filipino fisherfolks, I am not in favor of US' increasing military presence either.
Sadly, like most people around the world, Most of these people dont know the history and the real cause of the dispute in the south China sea or west Philippine sea. The Philippines and china are not the only ones that lay claim on these islands. Vietnam, Malaysia, Brunei and even Taiwan are also claiming the disputed islands for themselves. Its naive to think that the US is getting in the mix because it "cares" for Filipinos. Like the Chinese, the americans are also only looking after their own selfish interests. The addition of 5 more US military bases in the Philippines is never about protecting the Philippines from foreign invasion, its about the US protecting its interests in Taiwan's microchip industry which it's very reliant on for its weapons manufacturing industry to continue it's domination and hegemony across the world. China on the other hand also wants to take control of the region to protect it's shipping because it's economy depends on the shipping lanes through the south China sea. China nor the US don't care about the Philippines and neither do other countries. Filipinos are just too brainwashed by Western propagandists and are just too gullible. Masyado tayong sumasamba at mga uto uto ng mga kano at mga dayuhan saka sobrang corrupt ng mga pulitiko natin kaya di tayo umuunlad. Kung di tayo magbabago baka tayo na lang ang maiiwang mahirap sa ASEAN at puro mga katulong at boy na lang ang magiging eksena natin sa mundo
You've said it all .
Who is disrupting China’s shipping lanes?
The United Nations Permanent Court of Arbitration ruled in 2016 that China’s claims to the Spratly Islands were invalid and that China had violated the Philippines’ sovereign rights in its exclusive economic zone. US and PH have a long relationship and have mutual defense treaties. The re-opening of US-bases are required to counter Chinese aggression.
@@markus711 there's no such thing as "required". The US -ph defense treaty is not a guarantee that the US will immediately defend the Philippines in case of an attack by a foreign power. That still has to be debated and approved by the US congress while my innocent Filipino countrymen are dying because our lame politicians continue to be lapdogs of both the US and china and even the EU.
@@roderickpineda5886 The United Nations Permanent Court of Arbitration ruled in 2016 that China’s claims to the Spratly Islands were invalid and that China had violated the Philippines’ sovereign rights in its exclusive economic zone. How do you interpret this?
The UN did not conclude that the spratly islands belonged to the Philippines. It said that Chinas claims were illegitimate but did not assign territorial rights to either the Phillipines or china. It is still disputed. So the guy was wrong. The islands do not belong to the Phillipines.
"Still disputed" you said that.
The Arbitral Award, by itself, affirms that under UNCLOS the Philippines can exclusively exploit the natural resources, including the oil and gas, in the Philippine exclusive economic zone in the West Philippine Sea without interference from any other coastal state.
China claiming the whole South China Sea including West Philippine Sea ( inside Philippines EEZ) using their myth 9 dash line .
Yeh so much brainwashing and fake news spreading around. This is how facts get misconstrued. The arbitration ruling ruled that China had no legal basis on "historical claims" to those islands, because NO country can make claims on any territory based on historical claims with our current maritime laws, including the PH. If China reversed the role and initiated this ruling, the same thing would have applied to the PH - that PH cannot claim those islands based on "historical" records as well.
The UNCLOS is Clear all the Natural Resources in Philippine Exclusive Economic Zone is Exclusive to Pilipino people so its not disputed China Delusional Claim isn't valid even with your wildest dreams 😂
IO is on the move huh
A little note, the South China Sea is NOT the West Philippine Sea, The WPS is the part of the SCS within the ECZ of the Philippines. Thank you!
When we say WPS we are talking about the area that is within the ECZ of the Philippines and its not part of SCS
@@Krahmhil86 look at a map and tell if the Philippines doesn’t have a portion of its EEZ on the SCS, i’ll wait 😆
WPS is the part of the SCS??? Wahahaha
@@Krahmhil86 and the Aegean is not in the Mediterranean 😂😂😂 LOL ; someone doesnt have map 😘
@@aaron199x sorry but all that part is now part of the US control, the US have military presence in taiwan, the philippines, south korea and japan. all "suposeltly china's claim is under US control
As a Filipino I really don't want my country to end up in an American proxy war like Ukraine
No way you can avoid that ask Vietnam, Korea.
As a filipino-American, I really don't want my country, the U.S., to waste money on resources on a country thousands of miles away that doesn't have much to offer Americans in terms of trade.
If you want peace, prepare for war... But let's hope filipinos pay for it all by themselves.
We can prevent are country involve in the war, If all Filipino people understand what happened in Ukraine, but sadly most Filipino believe that US coming here is defend us , and the fate news and propaganda by mainstream media
Pick your poison
Sure. Let China take over then. 🤷🏾♂️
Wisdom comes with age.
These young kids think the America is so cool effect. This is soft power in action. Making you think that someone who colonized you and abused you for 50+ years is actually your best friend.
Never forget how many Filipinos the American killed almost 1-2 million!
It is really scary how influential the US media and soft power is in the Philippines. A lot of what the US does to the Philippines both currently and historically gets brushed aside either by lack of awareness or misinformation (western biased media) regarding the matter.
Why isn't anyone talking about the fact that Vietnam has more claimed (3x) territories than China?
As a Filipino, I don't want my country to end up in an American Proxy war like Ukraine.
This video shows you have naive and simple minded the youngster are, the view from the elderly is far more rational they have lived long enough to know.
The Philippine Media paints such a rosy image of the US, and China as selfish materialistic and nation motivated by self interest. It's like they have never met Americans before.
The US is not the saviour that these Filipinos think they are.
Simple Question. How many countries has China invaded, colonized, and built military bases in?
Now ask yourself the same question about the US.
The colonial mentality is strong in Filipinos. Their country has been exploited by the US for economic and military gain while its people proudly hail them as saviours. It's largest trading partner is China, contributing to largest economic growth in decades. Althewhile receiving military aid and protection that solidifies its position as cannon fodder.
Self hating Asians.
Finally a great comment and observation! Thank you!
I also hate this about my countrymen. US didn't save us from Spaniards. The Spaniards were already losing against our Katipuneros and Rebolusyonaryos. US came into the view to "buy" the Philippines, staging a mock battle against Spain to make it seem like US saved the Filipinos. During WWII, the American leaders literally abandoned Philippines. It was our Guerillas who fought hard for our country. And when everything's almost settled down, US came to Philippines again to "save" Filipinos. It's so nauseating. There are so many unsung heroes in the Philippines that many Filipinos aren't aware of, yet here they are proclaiming US as the heroes.
So sad to see so many people in Philippines are brainwashed by America.
You make a valid bias perspective. Do you believe that if the Philippines would be better off with China than the Us? Do you really think that if somehow the Philippines chooses to align with China, China would stop bullying the Philippines? You try to speak of history as if you understand it.
US, China or Russia, all of them are superpowers that crushes softpowers beneth them. The one that causes less harm would be the best option. You think that would be China? Do you really believe that the communist China now is the same pacifist dynasty before?
@@patryk88 , You sure have poor knowledge of Asia!
America had colonized Philippines for 48 years and now under the US control with 9 military bases in Philippines. What did US do for Philippines since 1898 to 2024? Please tell the world!
It is important to distinguish between the American people and American government. Likewise the Chinese people and the Chinese government. The American people dont have an issue with Chinese people. Nor do the American people have an issue with the Filipino people. We are all similar just trying to live peacefully and support our families. Being married to a Filipina when we are visiting the Philippines i do my best to avoid political issues.
Tell me about it. It's like I can't visit my home town without getting bombarded with NPA-CPP communist propaganda and threats whilst also berated by anti-Marcos activists. Just let me take care of my grandparents in peace. 🙄🙄
but the Filipino people are at odds with the American Government. likewise with the Chinese Government.
we don't trust both foreign governments, we only seek to have a transactional relationship, when it comes to economic, military, and technological affairs.
the Filipino people and its government only seeks to be independent and to continue to economically and military grow, like what is happening now, expand our economy, to continue to strengthen our military, to deter both US and Chinese aggression in our area.
basically like Switzerland.
@@herrkommandank675 you are trying to put the people and the government of the Philippines in one basket like the people of the Philippines have control over the government does . Same as the US and Chinese government, the every day average people don't control the government nor does the governments care about what the people need . You want your government to be neutral but Philippine government has already chosen the US side.
@@herrkommandank675 The United Nations Permanent Court of Arbitration ruled in 2016 that China’s claims to the Spratly Islands were invalid and that China had violated the Philippines’ sovereign rights in its exclusive economic zone. US and PH have a long relationship and have mutual defense treaties. The re-opening of US-bases are required to counter Chinese aggression.
@@pharaohsanakht6839 You're an American citizen, of course you'll side with the US.
But for the folks who were born and are citizens of this country, we are pragmatics. "already chosen the US" and that's why we're decoupling, we are sick with the US interventionism here in the country. THe dependence towards the US has been problematic all these years. That's why we're having a level-headed diplomacy wth China.
A Pew Research Center Report indicated that 67% of Filipinos want to engage business ties with China, as it will further amplify our economic growth. The history of the US was subjugation, the moment we first met them and until now.
We seek neutrality, not obliging to the US, neither to China. We acknowledge the aggressions of China, but as I reiterate, we will prioritize economic growth in order for us to have more resources for our development and military to deter China and not be reliant towards the US
Regarding the US presence in the Philippines, opinions within the Filipino population are diverse. Some view the strong military ties between the Philippines and the US as a necessary means to bolster our defense capabilities and deter potential threats in the region. The annual military exercises with the US can be seen as a demonstration of cooperation and mutual support in times of geopolitical uncertainty. Many Filipinos hope for a diplomatic and cooperative approach to addressing territorial disputes and regional tensions. We seek a stable and secure environment that promotes mutual respect among nations and upholds international law.
Legit yung interview, may maririnig ka tlgang lato lato na background eh.
Here's your 50 cents by US state department
@@shinchan-F-urmomThat’s a China-exclusive job post. You couldn’t even come up with your own term - typical Chinese copycatting and lack of imagination. At least there are official evidences that the Chinese have been and are being paid to spread propaganda and disinformation on social networks. The opposite hasn’t been demonstrated.
@@shinchan-F-urmom US don't need to pay people to support it. Only loser governments with no friends (including no friends among its own people) do that
Ukraine 2.0
5:30
When will Phillipines get rid of it's colonial mentality? It's sad to see it being reinforced in younger faces, and older faces who lived through those times are still proper bitter about it but seemingly ignored. Though this guy explains it pretty well. Phillipines media paints such a rosy image of the US, and it's hilarious to me that China/Chinese are portrayed as selfish and materialistic and as a nation motivated by it's self interest, it's like they never met Americans before or haven't studied American history on their own time.
As Filipinos, we had to learn our own history (which is a lot of colonialism) and also world history ... and now you are demanding for us to learn a lot of American history??? Isn't that a bit much??
Also... The Oligarchs of the upper class are pretty much pro-US... they have really impacted the perception of Philippines to both countries
@@yachishairclips2250 you don't think you should learn more about a country that has so much influence on yours?
Both China and America are selfish and self-interested. The main difference is China is threatening the Philippines' territory - the US's motives are also self interested, but at least they aren't eating up islands and swallowing the EEZs of most of east and SE Asia.
because they are under the mao effect
I would be curious to know the opinions of folks from the rural areas as well. Also, I know folks from Luzon usually have different views from Visayas and Mindanao. I feel that most of the time only views of people from Luzon are accounted for in Asian Boss.
Travelling to Visayas and Mindanao is kinda expensive. Asian Boss does not earn enough from every content; they rely on investment and donations.
I hope some day Asian Boss can interview people in Cebu
@@chibchan3765 they can probably just work with locals there instead of sending a crew over.
To be fair, Asian Boss showed a good balance here of showing the pros and cons from different backgrounds, because if you talk to the rural areas, you'll see either indifference, or overwhelming pro-US anti China stance.
Manila was the center, so ano ineexpect mo? kahit nga sa ibang bansa kung san center don sila
As an analyst and advisor to the team working with the Philippine government I can say there is no benefit to the USA developing bases in PI except for a radar installation which we were willing to put anywhere in any country that wanted it. A radar installation means the US will spend big $$$ in that country and PI is smart enough to know that. China could run over PI quite easily, but if a US base is there then no. We will likely have a carrier group visit a PI port to tell China 'do not touch' and hopefully that will be sufficient to ensure PI sovereignty. Nobody wants to challenge a US Carrier group, China doesn't even want to be within 400 miles of a US Carrier group.
Nobody wants to challenge a US carrier group? Seriously? What a wishful thinking. What I heard from sources from Chinese military, they are eager to challenge it.
Geopolitics is like playing 3D chess
Can they? 500 million people from china died starvation dude if they start the war get real
Without US presence in the Phillipines bases, China will have no interest whatsoever to attack the Phillipines if Taiwan war breaks out. It's a terrible mistake to let the US to use the Philipines bases. The pressure is just too much, and finally the political leadership just yielded to the demand, even if it's detrimental to the Philippines.
@@Liboch don't worry cuz we didn't need your opinion we protect our territory here is most important than to try to china friend
0:22 Since when is Taiwan a country? Does your government officially recognize Taiwan as a country?
Asian Boss is total BS
Since they have there own government leaders
@@elok3 Hong Kong does. And Macau. And the number of autonomous regions in the mainland. Texas too. Are they countries?
@@elok3 In the USA, every state has their own government leaders
@@elok3 And cities have their government leaders as well, that doesn't make New York City a country for example. Even small towns with 300 people have their government leaders. They're called mayors.
Filipinos are lovely, peaceful people. In what depends on southeast Asia, there would never be a conflict.
completely useless and corrupt government though
o lord
Don't forget, gullible bunch with heavy colonial mentality.
Yeah no conflict, until the US built its bases
I disagree, your country followed US into Vietnam war, they had US bases then there also.
Being Neutral just isn't realistic anymore, the Russian-Ukrainian War has shown that countries do choose sides because they have to and it serves their interests. The Philippines are leaning towards the US because their leaders have a better understanding of what China is doing and what kind of government the CCP is...
What is China "doing"? The CCP lifted 800 million Chinese out of poverty in the last decades while there's an increasing homelessness in US. What part of that is hard to understand?
@Hazard2005 Sooo the PH doesnt have a good understanding what the US is doing and what kind of government the US is?
@@yerri5567oh, ph usndertands US well so we don't need enlightenment from CCP bot.
@@Brydsteaxs Sooo based on your logic, the only people on here are CCP bots, CIA bots and PH bots?
@@Brydsteaxs And questions are supposedly "enlightenment" now?
I'm confused, to all Filipinos, what support did China gave the Philippines? 09:26
Do research i answer one covid vaccine while america said no.
What did US gave to Philippines apart from genocide more 200000 during their occupations. Almost as bad as the Japanese and Spanish. Till this day, they are still slaves to Imperial Colonisers.
@@fatimafaris3544 And who gave Covid to the world?
@@markus711 guesse maybe you say china but earlier on that covid in wuhan they are already recorded covid in some part of EU specially in spain but they did spread the news i did say china is clean but technically it was the elite or pharma who spread that virus and china is part of the game.
China which is purely mercantile in nature is sometimes confrontational to prove a point but the militaristic USA exports conflicts to expand its hegemonic agenda.
Though China browbeats the Ph it never ever went to invade it. Whereas the USA have killed 2 million Filipinos during its colonization attempt in the PH-US war.
At any given point in time, America is at war or involved in a conflict or destabilization with other countries worldwide.
Ph had known and traded with China for centuries as far as pre-colonization period. No conflict ever occurred or attempts to invade. Oldest Chinatown in the world is in Manila.
USA colonized Ph by deceit in connivance with Spain and killing 2 million Filipinos in the process. Ph was dragged into WWII due to its US military installations of Clark, Subic and Corregidor. Ph was never repatriated under Marshal plan for collateral damages incurred fighting for the Americans. We were given a hasty independence by the USA to avoid spending war rehabilitation.
Chances are you’re have a relative or friend who has Chinese blood rather than American.
Lastly, while unaware, your life is surrounded by everything Chinese. From going to your favorite malls, fastfoods, from buying online goods to seeing mega-structures build around the country. Heck, even your clothes, underwear and mobile phone are all made in China.
China and Ph is closely interlinked by trade and blood throughout the century.
Ask yourself why China feels betrayed that Ph should take sides with the Americans despite all of this shared history and culture.
LMAO so you're going to turn blind eye on the west philippine sea issue?
your so called shared history and culture did nothing to stop china from getting our islands, and fish lol. f**king selective thinking you got there man.❤
China has left us with no choice but to side with the US. We had already removed the EDCA back in the 90s and legally appealed in the UNCLOS to stop island reclamation. Former President Duterte flirted with China. Despite all that, the militarization continues, leaving us no choice but to side with the US.
It really is scary how influential the US media and soft power is in the Philippines. I feel like a lot of what the US does to the Philippines both currently and historically gets brushed aside either by lack of awareness or because of misinformation regarding the matter.
It's not like China didn't work hard for it too
Right? Lets get influenced by China instead. Long live President Xi!
@@whatever1661 their work is through piracy, smuggling, drug dealing, and copying others' work and now hacking into people's PC to get the work of the people.
Yeah, the nation that gave the Pines their independence is totally the bad guy here.....
@@45641560456405640563 philippines took their own independence lol. America didn't give us anything.
I think both US and China have their own self interests but I choose US because their interests somewhat align with our interests as Filipinos
USA wants to deter/contain China, The Philippines wants to protect it's ocean by detering China
Nothing comes for free, USA has their own interests and we have ours, it just so happens that we can both get what we want through our cooperation and that's why I prefer USA
China on the other hand didn't even let our fishermen fish in our own sea even when Duterte was nice to them, their interests goes against Filipinos' interests since in no way are they gonna budge and let us access our own damn sea!
I am a Chinese. You are smart. I agree with you except the last sentence. Your fishermen do can fish in your own sea. Do you know China's contribution to Filipine because of Duterte? The sea dispute can be resolved by negotiation. Two countried can explore sea together.
@@KuangWen0 Marcos Jr. visited China prior to calling the Americans to reopen military bases in The Philippines, he likely tried to negotiate but since he called America, he likely just felt threatened.
@@justdont2378
Negotiation is a long and hard progress and may take many years. Both countries would not easily give up more interests, otherwise the leaders will be condemned by its own people.
I would do the same thing if I am Philippine President. Philippine should tighten the relationship with America. Small countries should carefully keep balance between superpowers. Ukraine and Iraqi Presidents are stupid. What is good to piss off a superpower?
I do not care about American military bases. There are already too many American military bases around China. And the result of war is not decided by number of military bases, but by comprehensive national power including production ability, human resources and technology. Though, military bases do have combat advantage. China and America will never fight again because there is no winner.
@@KuangWen0 I am on the same page as you when it comes to the "China and America will never fight again because there is no winner" the loss from war and the risk of it being a nuclear one will simply surpass what we will all gain from it, both China and USA know that
At the same time though this issue has been here for decades already with many other countries also against China for them claiming their waters, Malaysia, Brunei, Vietnam and somehow China even claims an island all the way in Indonesia
Yes negotiation takes a long time but a lot of us have likely tried to negotiate over all these years and we barely got any progress, none of us know how long it will take so we're just doing what we can which is cooperating with The United States.
@qiaoyankuang8406 you do know that our fisherman can't fish in west Philippine sea and Scarborough shoal because your navy are telling them to leave because it's a Chinese territory? Duterte? He's a joke.
It is always hard to be a chess piece in a game of the two of biggest players in the world.
The US is there at the request of the Philippine government. Stop playing victim. You want the help or not? The US has nothing to gain by being there. What do we care if China harasses Filipino fishermen? Own your own problems and defend your own borders.
US is there to stoke the conflict between Philippines and China, as part of their plan to contain China@@gravityissues5210
@@gravityissues5210 US was forcing our government too to build bases in our country where we didn't even ask for because we have friendly relations with China so the US is not that good as you think it is
Btw im from Pakistan 🇵🇰
@@gravityissues5210 exactly, US doesn't care about Philippines they just want to use it as a forward base like Ukraine and will sacrifice it to keep itself safe. The US uses small countries to use as cannon fodder to keep its enemies at bay. Without sacrificing US citizens. That is the US strategy both spoken by US top general and Lindsey Graham a US senator.
@@gravityissues5210 the US is there to have more military presence in the Asia- Pacific. With the Philippines, the US will have a belt of military bases in the region extending to Japan and South Korea and Singapore in the south. Look at the maps for perspective!
I'm pro Philippines ,both countries have their own personal interest .
Philippines should not follow the US blindly but I think the history is clear that US values are more aligned with Philippines. US soldiers died in world war 2 to free Philippines from Japanese invasion. And after the war, the US agreed to Philippines independence and self-governance. The US isn't claiming any Philippines land, that is China now stealing what islands they can from Philippines. Philippines needs US to counter balance China's aggression but also not become blind follower of US. It is a balance and I hope that Marco Jr. can find that.
I think it's the other way around, the Filipino soldiers died for the war that isn't theirs. America used (still is) the land but they don't want the responsibilities that comes with it. In the Treaty of Paris, they have the right to take advantage of our resources as if they are Filipinos. They wanted the land, but not the people. So there. They gave the Filipinos the "independence" because it's too much money to rehabilitate the country after the war. Also, they said that we're not white enough to be able assimilate to their culture. So don't make it appear like they're the saviours. They used us and are still using us for their advantage. Now between US and China, I am siding with neither. They can kill each other, just don't use us as a pawn.
@@BanigNation I’m not saying US isn’t self interested, I just think that engagement with the US has generally helped nations that took that path. Japan, Singapore, and Korea chose close US engagement with good results. Same for Europe. Every country needs friends. No friend is perfect. Philippines needs someone to stop China from taking more and more land. Being totally neutral isn’t an option because Ph will be alone and get squeezed by China and keep losing land.
@@BanigNation Who else is gonna help the Philippines take back those islands and territorial sea that China forcibly occupied?
@@LiveWell6 did anybody ever mention the 11-dash line that was drawn by ROC with US approval before the Philipines became an independent country?
@@LiveWell6 Japan, Singapore and South Korea had good results. It should follow that the Philippines, which got the most US aids from the start, should have done even better. What happened there? China presented carbon dated documents from the Tang Dynasty (600s A.D.) identifying these disputed islands as part of the southern Chinese territories. But why should that be recognized when conflicts among these claimants play very well into US hands? And why should Filipinos, who like the Americans are so lacking of any sense of history, know this when "English" is the medium they can understand. They said there's WMD in Iraq, too. How did that go?
1:14 No, the reality is that PH does NOT have sovereignty over those islands. When the US handed over its sovereignty to the PH, they SPECIFICALLY said it did NOT include the Spratly islands etc. So PH does NOT have legal sovereignty over those islands. PH just wish they did, and made their citizens to believe its theirs.
7:28 This guy is uninformed. Its not "illegal" per se if its no laws against it. ESPECIALLY when its disputed territory. PH does NOT have sovereignty over the islands, so its not "theirs". Its called "disputed territory" for a reason. Many countries claim these territories, not just China and PH.
7:35 You "won" because China was not even there to defend themselves. China was not there because China knew it was useless to go, as the current international laws present is incompatible with a countrys sovereignty claims. What that means is the current international maritime laws only define whats considered a countrys territory based on the 12nm distance from a countrys coastline, EEZ etc, but has no laws to define whether a piece of territory falls under the sovereignty of Country X or Country Y.
7:51 No, you cant forcefully implement it because that court you won that case from has ZERO authority to enforce anything. Even the US cant.
12:44 No, it was not "proven that it belongs to the PH". This is how facts get misconstrued. The arbitration ruling ruled that China had no legal basis on "historical claims" to those islands, because NO country (including PH) can make claims on any territory based on historical claims with our current maritime laws. If China reversed the role and initiated this ruling, the same thing would have applied to the PH - that PH cannot claim those islands based on "historical" records as well.
0:21 Taiwan isnt a "country". Why is Asian Boss allowing their host to spread misinformation? No world power in this world recognises "Taiwan" as a country. And Taiwans very own constitution specifically refers to Taiwan as a province of China.
Yes China is illegally occupying areas that should be within the EEZ of the Philippines. While Philippines or China cannot say this rock or that shoal is part their respective territories, the only thing clear is that some areas being ILLEGALLY occupied by China fall within Philippines EEZ by international law
@@pongpong123able4 EEZ means Exclusive Economic Zone. That only means a country has special rights to exploit the economic resources there. But the area is NOT part of their sovereign territory.
So how did China "illegally occupy" something thats not "owned" by any country?
Just because you have special rights in exploiting resources there doesnt mean its magically part of your sovereign territory.
A countrys sovereign territory only extends up to 12nm from its shoreline, not the 200nm mark for EEZ.
So what did China allegedly "illegal occupy" again and from who?
All these people thinking they know "international law" when the fact of the matter is there is literally no law that prevents any country from "occupying" rocks or creating artificial islands.
So no, nothing "illegal" based on international law.
@@yerri5567 yes its not part of Philippines' territory but is for their own exclusive exploitation. China has built an island there ILLEGALLY because no country has business building an island on a sea that is not its territory. Is that area a part of China? NO. SO WHY IS CHINA SQUATTING AND BUILDING ISLANDS THERE? IS THAT ILLEGAL? YES
Not only has China ILLEGALLY squatted on the sea, it prevented Filipinos from enjoying its EEZ, in violation of international maritime law. Illegal? yES
Some people claim they know international law but can't put facts together. You say that is only part of Philippines' EEZ which is correct. Then why is China treating it like its own territory?? Patrolling the area, driving away Filipino fishermen who are supposed to be there legally, and building islands. Is that part of Chinese territory? No. So why are you saying that China's actions there are not illegal?
@@pingmeup5908 Looks like my comment was deleted..
"So how did China "illegally occupy" something thats not "owned" by any country?"
Something is only "illegal" if a law states that its prohibited. There is NO law that states anything about occupying territory not owned by anyone, ESPECIALLY when China is the FIRST country in the region to lay claims on those territories in the 1940s. It was only in the 1970s when oil was found in the region that Vietnam, PH and the likes started claiming areas in the SCS. So as the first country to lay claims and was uncontested, it should be theirs imo. So again, China did not "illegal occupy" those territories. Your words are showing extreme bias.
"It goes both ways as well"
Where was your comment that PH was "illegally occupying" territories in the SCS too?
"if this is not owned by any country but is currently being used by the said countries as an EEZ, , then why build islands and harass fishermen that is just trying to fish?"
I never said its "owned" or "not owned" by any country. The territories are called "disputed territories" for a reason. YOU were the one that said China were supposedly "illegally occupying" it. Im telling now that theyre not "illegally occupying" anything. Theres NO law that prohibits buildings islands outside of another countrys sovereign territory, thus Chinas actions cant be deemed "illegal".
And although I dont agree with the harassing of fisherman in the area, again, theres no laws against that in international law, so nothing can be done about that.
"china does not own the place right? then why act as if they own it?"
I spoke NOTHING on whether country X owns or does not own territory Z. Its called "disputed territory" for a reason. Many parties claim that they own the territory, including the PH.
But China has the strongest claim on the area as they were the first country in the region to lay claims to the islands in the 1940s, while others made their first claim in the 1970s...
"shouldnt it be joint extraction since no country owns it?"
And thats not how the world works. Especially since China was the first to lay claim in the region and was uncontested. So to them its theirs, so why should they split something that they deem as theirs? If your neighbour suddenly claimed half your house 30 years after you, would you split it with them?
Mga kapwa Pilipino, kailangan natin maging neutral. Dapat may mga sarili tayong opinyon. Hindi dahil tutulungan tayo ng US e kaibigan na natin sila at hindi dahil may mga problema tayo sa Tsina, kaaway na natin sila. Sana makahanap tayo ng gitna. Gusto lang naman natin ng kapayapaan at katahimikan.
hanggat kaya pa ng diplomasya jusko please tuloy lang
walang neutral sa mundo. naniniwala ka pa rin sa fantasy na yan? Lahat tayo may biases. And this is politics. You have to TAKE SIDES. Tignan mo nga nung pumutok ang giyera sa Russia-Ukraine, natakot karamihan at sinuportahan ang Ukraine. Walang neutral. walang ganon. You have to choose your side.
Ukraine is an example on why it's fatal to be neutral. the 3 baltic states Estonia, Lithuania and Latvia join NATO earlier. While Ukraine didn't, now they are paying the price. Look at Sweden and Finland abandoning their neutrality after the Russian invasion of Ukraine. Now they join NATO to not repeat the same mistake that Ukraine made. If Ukraine had join NATO earlier after Estonia, Lithuania and Latvia then they are protected by NATO's Article 5. meaning all of NATO are obligated to come to its aid militarily. Meaning Putin had to think twice before invading because they have to deal with 30+ countries and 3 of them have nukes.
The U.S. is not responsible for acting as the world's police. Look at their sloppy withdrawal from Afghanistan. After two decades of of military presence, the Taliban was able to retake the country with the U.S. leaving behind over $7B worth of equipment. The U.S. is not the savior that these Filipinos think they are. Also, every country should be vested in its own self-interest first. There's nothing selfish about forging nationalism.
Filipinos do not need saviour. PH needs allies to protect and help the PH. PH and USA is a long time ally. What is the purpose of the mutual defense treaty of the PH and US if USA is not there to help the PH? The US equipments that is left in Afghanistan serves a purpose. Taliban will use that weapons and equipment to fight Iran which is also the enemy of US. 😊
Yes, let's defend ourselves against China! Surely that will work because we have enough men and resources to do that.
@@simonriley118The US is your mental colonizer. They wouldn’t bother with Philippines or Taiwan is they weren’t located near China.
A Nationalist movement always holds the possibility of becoming a racist, supremacist dictatorship. So it's a tricky thing. Once a nation is established there is no need for an overly nationalistic movement.
@@ClassicallyMish You're living in the past. Colonization is a long time ago. Alliance is the new word. PH and USA is a long time standing ally. The modern colonizer is Russia and China. China has annexed Tibet. Thats your mental colonizer.
Here in New Zealand our military spending is about $3 Billion (USD), while Philippines is $4 Billion (USD)
Good to know.
However, NZ is quite not in the risk of a war. Besides, it still is a baby of UK. ;)
@@blackflame1683 right
Because your country too small and protected by australia and uk so no needs strong military
@serriajohn go spew your propaganda somewhere else, I am not interested
@serriajohnCCP wumao?
I really like Filipinos as they have built a unique culture within a hundred years which added vibrancy to Southeast Asia, but Filipinos need to learn to see through the motives of protracted soft power and western influence.
I think we wont ever grow from western media influence, especially the affluent parts. The greatest alternative to western show for example is mostly limited to Korea and japan due to k drama and anime.
The United Nations Permanent Court of Arbitration ruled in 2016 that China’s claims to the Spratly Islands were invalid and that China had violated the Philippines’ sovereign rights in its exclusive economic zone. US and PH have a long relationship and have mutual defense treaties. The re-opening of US-bases are required to counter Chinese aggression.
@@markus711 The US are not reopening their bases here. They are simply using our bases but no US owned base.
@@markus711There are no US bases being opened, all those bases belong to the Philippines and Americans only has limited use. The base commander is Filipino, and Americans can't do things as easily as they wish since it is the Philippines that calls the shots.
It is so naive and stupid to think that the USA is trying to help the Philippines when in fact they are just using the Philippines.
Exactly, people have no idea about what the US did to Afghanistan and Ukraine, the words "aid", "Support", Their side" is literally a false hope
Weird, considering the Philippines is the one that came to the US asking for help with China. But why bother with facts, when you can just spew the same boring "the US is the worst country in the world trying to take over" rhetoric. I mean, what do I care if China takes over the Philippines? Sounds like you'd be happier, too.
@@jayq2571 you sure about that, because of the US Ukraine is kicking Russia's ass.
@@PsychoSpartan7 😂😂😂😂 that’s what the west media is showing you. How is it that Russia isn’t yet defeated then? And Ukraine is still in grief?
Let's deny US support cause we can fend off China by ourselves. Surely we can do that.
looking past what all the leaders/governments are doing, and looking at the people, i've met many chinese people who were incredibly nice and friendly and helpful to me and i have met a few americans who have wronged me. my only point is pls do not judge people by their government and do not let political issues affect your impression of the humans who live in the same planet as yours. the common people just want to live a life/survive while the leaders play their game of chess
Yet, if China attacks the Philippines, it will not be the incredibly nice, friendly and helpful Chinese who will do anything to fix the situation but the so-called nasty American. Whether Filipinos like it or not, US is their only real friend, NOT China. The concerns about US colonizing the Philippines is just nonsense. Those days of colonization is long over and is not going to happen again. Not a single person in the US will support such a move against a friendly country. Most Americans have a very positive opinion about Filipinos in general.
Well said
Chinese Communist Party naman kalaban eh di naman yung mga regular chinese.....for your info. 100million and member ng CCP sa china
你说的很对，其实普通人就是棋子而已，不管是在哪个国家
As a Filipino, I agree.
Historically, among China, Japan, Spain, Netherlands, and the US… which of these countries invaded/occupied/colonized the Philippines and here people?
How do you think China land spread widely?
Very wrong question …. It should be --why choose US /China if you can have them both in your side. China for trade US for security. There is power in ambiguity
As a Filipino, I still believe in the superiority of the US-Philippine Alliance over the "friendship" China is offering to us. Having a superpower ally is still the best deterrent against another hostile superpower, especially when our AFP is still far beyond what they call the "minimum credible defense". With China as the biggest adversary, I don't think "minimum" is even enough. Superpowers are fickle and questionable, but it's better to have a democratic superpower whose leaders can be replaced, whose policies can change, and whose people's opinions are relatively more open to expression. Good luck protesting in Moscow or Beijing.
But I also believe that the Philippines should NOT be dependent on the Americans alone to protect our national interests. The Philippines' primary responsibility is to build up its own defense capabilities and seek help from other democratic allies. Having an American presence is nice, but not the endgame aspiration.
On the other hand, it cannot be denied that China has an economic and cultural influence on us, but we must learn to stand against authoritarianism. It would have been ideal for Sino-Philippine ties if China was a multiparty democracy like ours. But we make do with what we have.
Overall, the Philippines remaining with the democratic camp is still the best option, but if there are ways to remain friendly with China without compromising our sovereign rights, we can try them. The foreign policies of Aquino II and Marcos II are far better than what Duterte ever tried. Best to stay with their course.
The US alliance is a folly, we benefited more from the Asian-centric policies of Duterte compared to the past two decades than the US "alliance."
When it comes to Duterte, they're only viewing the relationship between China, but won't even bother to the fact that we strengthened ties with Japan, South Korea, Israel, and expanded ties with India, Turkey, ASEAN, the Middle East, and etc.
It's for Duterte that we're able to acquire new advance weaponries, such as state-of-the-art helicopters from Turkey, Supersonic missiles from India, Sabrah Light Tanks from Israel, because he expanded ties to the countries we often called "unorthodox". We even had various transfer of technology deal with the JSDF of Japan and its military-industrial complex and with Israel.
To establish minimum credible defense is to establish expanded diplomatic ties with various countries, to support you on your military modernization efforts, that's what Duterte did right, instead of fully relying on the American who can't even commit to assisting us, other than giving us some 2nd used hardware that has a shelf-life of 10-15 years.
Don't get me started with the various economic policies that propelled the continous economic growth of the country, such as the infrastructure program, liberalization, and etc.
@@herrkommandank675china invaded the philippines because of being lax by duterte adminstration..
@@herrkommandank675 The United Nations Permanent Court of Arbitration ruled in 2016 that China’s claims to the Spratly Islands were invalid and that China had violated the Philippines’ sovereign rights in its exclusive economic zone. US and PH have a long relationship and have mutual defense treaties. The re-opening of US-bases are required to counter Chinese aggression.
@@markus711 Dependence towards the US is problematic. We we're able to continue modernizing our military without the aid of the US.
In addition, growing our economy is also as important to modernization, to ensure more resources for our military expansion. Reaping the benefits of economic globalism.
@@markus711 There's no doubt that China is problematic, but the US is also problematic as well, we prefer a level-headed approach with both countries.
China's longstanding focus has consistently centered on Taiwan, with the South China Sea representing an additional point of contention. Similarly, the United States' interest has also been directed towards Taiwan, as China's potential acquisition of Taiwan could significantly impact U.S. influence across the Pacific Ocean. This underscores China's strategic importance, given its geographical confinement by numerous neighboring nations. Consequently, Taiwan serves as a pivotal asset for China to unlock access to the broader expanse of the Pacific Ocean.
Taiwan holds a lot of secrets to semiconductor manufacturing, its been a primary manufacturer for apple as well through foxconn, taiwan being occupied by China will make US very dependent or their tech will go into China's hands China already has good idea of hardware manufacturing, only thing they have been lacking a bit is semiconductors, it will pull a lot of business away from US if China occupies Taiwan
China has no interest in access to Pacific. They have interest in making China whole again with Taiwan
Your info was correct like 20 years ago, now China is prioritizing the south China sea over Taiwan, because of its significant importance for the security of resource importation.
@@crassuschan You really believe in that? 😅 South China Sea is way troublesome, there's a lot of country has interest on it. China just putting show, deceiving everyone thinking they are targeting South China Sea, but their goal never left on Taiwan. Once they get it, they will be free for being strangle by a lot of countries. Which makes them benefit than South China Sea. Although there's a lot of resources coming from it, they would still be strangled and trapped by a lot of countries. Conquering Taiwan would improve their Navy.
U do know that China is smarter than what the US wants right?? All this time US has been egging on China to declare war. Many times US has been encircling China by air or sea way too close, it has been done for decades. Now US has been getting antsy and doing more in the name of protecting democracy, they just getting scared and really wants to fight bc that’s how America makes money. Thru wars thru arms weapons selling to other countries. China hasn’t taken the bait and will not. They’re too smart for that and honestly have been very patient imo in this whole situation they only will defend by doing Defense strategies atm. Funny to say as well I read up on this China and Taiwan issue, u do know both claim to be the legitimate China? U should read upon it more
I am a Filipino and it is not right to say that it is all Filipino opinion. Since regionally every Filipinos has different opinion in this topic. My opinion is that it is not a tension between China and the US will drag the Philippines into a war. But Philippines and China tension would drag US into a war. Many always used U.S and China issue to an extent they use it as an excuse to have a pacifist stand. US and Philippine relation goes back after WW2. Also US is a deterrence that will make China think to not engage into a confrontation with the Philippines.
US is one of the trusted nation for the Filipinos. Why ask if it is obvious, we need US to defend our rights in "WEST PHILIPPINE SEA" and US need the Philippines as a strategic location to deter Chinas aggression. It is both beneficial for both parties that's
its a partnership.
What happen to PH trust the US the first time.? They said they pro8to free Ph from Spain. Thry turn around and backstab PH.
Ukrainians used to think so, too.😅
How naive and ignorant. It sums up the majority of Pinoy youngsters. Glad other South East Asia countries are not such US bootlickers
Beneficial ONLY for the U.S. Their country is far away from the conflict.
95% of Filipinos is pro-US
0:22 Your reporter should avoid calling Taiwan a country. As Asian Boss you should know this better than anyone.
It's a country tho. Tf u talking about
@@relaxingmusicchannel3224 Lol not even Taiwan acknowledges itself as a country.
The comment the one lady made about US military presence in the Ukraine vs Russia is totally false. We have set down all branches near neighboring countries aiding Ukrainian fighters and freedoms fights who were retired military forces. Ukraine is holding the fight due to allied aid. Not just by themselves..
I am Filipino American with my entire family being Born in the Philippines. In the next few years we're all moving to Quezon City. I have the dilemma of having to renounce my US Citizenship in order to stay.
But besides that I might be a bit biased but my family and I fully support the US presence in Asia. One thing that Filipinos and Taiwanese want most of all is the status quo. We want help from the US but we do not want an armed conflict with China or Russia. The Philippines, Taiwan, and Japan do not have the capability to defend themselves against the super powers like China or Russia. Maybe Korea can to an extent.
If more US bases in PH is a good enough deterrent to keep the region peaceful I'm all for it.
My greatest fear is imperialist China taking over South Korea Japan and the Philippines.
I believe all democratic countries must be protected.
I quite agree with you. I'm ａ Japanese live in Taiwan. I love Taiwan Formosa.
As a half-Taiwanese, I think the Philippines is far more dangerous than Taiwan at the moment. Taiwan currently has no U.S. troops deployed. The economies of Japan, South Korea and China are deeply tied, and they have a certain degree of independence, and they will be very cautious about direct wars. After the Philippines became a U.S. military base, the nature of the conflict between the Philippines and China has completely changed, and this has gone far beyond the scope of island disputes. One thing is certain, as long as the United States and China break out in a local war in the South China Sea, the United States will be the first to activate the US military base in the Philippines. The consequence will be that the Philippines will be covered by Chinese missiles first, not Taiwan, and the entire Philippines will be engulfed in flames, not just a few islands. I don't stand on any side, but I strongly suggest that Filipinos should pay close attention to the development of the relationship between the United States and China. As a frontline position, the situation in the Philippines is more dangerous than any other region at the moment. Americans can live safely on the North American continent, but Filipinos are not..No matter how much the allies of the United States pay lip service to the Philippines.
The US has no real reason to support the PI, Japan, Australia, Vietnam, or even Taiwan. We should, in theory, keep propping up China. We're here because we made allies of these countries, and we're here helping them at their request. We don't need TSMC, so who cares if the PRC takes over Taiwan and enslaves you like they do mainlanders? No need for Americans to die to protect you when we gain nothing. Yet you claim somehow it's all our doing. We don't need another Vietnam or Afghanistan, dying to help people who don't want help. Fight your own war with China.
Also the fact that they will not blindly destroy Taiwan due to the chip manufactuing... Afterall, why would you go destroy something you want to takeover? But the Philiipines? China economy isn't tied into it.. nor would the US care much about it.. the US is more worry about their aircraft carrier being destroyed than some islands in the Philippines
USA is not gonna be a superpower in the future so good luck with that 😂
China and India will be the next superpower
My thoughts also
just sayin, Japan and South Korea (Japan has 120 US Military Bases) have way more US Military Bases and US Troops in their countries than The Philippines, Japanese Government is paying US Forces for their Bases there to stay especially in Okinawa because it acts as deterence, Also The US Military Facilities in The Philippines are not full blown US Bases those bases are owned by Armed Forces of The Philippines the U.S Military are just tenants after 1992. (Post 1992 when all Full blown US Armed Forces Bases in Philippines were transferred to The Armed Forces of The Philippines)
i think it would be unwise to get closer to either china or USA, just playing between them to extract the most benefit would be the best way forward
super agree
Filipinos doesn't like war we have learned from our great ancestors what had happened back then but we also don't tolerate China's bullying....We have tried to settle it in diplomacy by all means but its doesn't mean we just simply give up our territory what ours is ours even if this country is belong to third world country we are willing to give our life to defend our Nation in case of invasion...
Asian Boss, thanks for the video. Not surprise with the comments. As usual, most younger Filipinos prefer the US. Can't blame them bcos of media influence and lack of awareness of what is really happening in the outside world. Both Spain and America colonised the Philippines and killed thousands of its people, yet Spain is the bad guy and America is the saviour. This goes to show how naive and simple minded these youngsters are. The view of the two elderly gentleman is more rational. They lives long enough to know. Everyone is for their self interest. Trust neither but work with both the US and China but keep them out of your country.
Yet another Biased Asian Boss interview that doesn't even come close to reflecting how a nation feels!...
Let's arrive to our hotel in Manila and only interview a bunch of kids who have no idea what's going on to push a narrative!
YAWN. The US couldn't care less about the PI. We're there at their request. What do we gain dying in yet another war to save people who don't want to be saved? Rather go on about 100 years ago than losing your territorial claims to China today. Fine by me, go fight your own war with China.
The old guy was "more rational" was he? He didn't provide any reasons for his positions. If he provided reasons for his positions, he might have been more convincing. Go ahead and choose China as your ally. Then you can be colonized a *third* time by a state that commits genocide and has a horrific human rights record. Have fun with that. But don't beg the US to come running back to "help" you then. You chose to be slaves of China and lose your freedoms. Enjoy.
America's only interest in the region is to stop China from stealing land from our allies or attacking our allies. Also US colonialism is taught in both American and Filipino schools, its already very well known lol
Were you asleep the past few years? The Duterte administration sought closer ties to China and both countries agreed to a peaceful resolution regarding the disputed islands through cooperation. Duterte went as far as to cancel joint exercises with US after the falling out between him and Obama. China took this opportunity to increase their presence by the Philippines to maintain their blockade of the disputed islands, continued it's fortification and harassed local Filipino fisherman from entering its fishing territories. Does this sound like China was cooperating? China had no intention of sharing it's claimed territories.
As a Filipino American. It is sad to see some Filipinos turn their back on the free world.
What is free world? What is not free world?
So u forgive the invaders for your dead ancestors,did u ask those victims if they agree or not😂
Just like ukraine
Lol
Bro EDCA bases do not control our Judiciary, Legislative and Executive branch. its quite the opposite. Legislative and Executive are the once calling the shot on where to put these bases and how many.
ASEAN countries are caught between the conflict and foreign interests of 2 global powers. It would be extremely naive for anyone to believe either the US or China cares about the interests of these countries.
I do think it’s weird that so many Filipinos have forgotten what the Americans did to the Philippines in the Philippine American war though, and I wonder what their schools are teaching to kids. The American military isn’t in the Philippines out of the goodness of their hearts, but there to protect their national interests.
ASEAN countries should resist imperialism and colonial attitudes from all foreign powers, be it from China or from the U.S.
I'd love, for once, for one of you people spewing this drivel to answer my question: WHAT DOES THE US HAVE TO GAIN FROM THIS?!? We're there because the Philippines ASKED us to be. The level of ignorance is incredible. People would rather whine and play victim than own their own actions. Let me see if you can finally answer that question--with something concrete, not stereotypes and tropes you picked up from TikTok about how the US is some "colonizing imperial superpower." I need hard numbers and clear motivations here, not fuzzy "hurr durr" nonsense, like every other commenter here.
Philippines don’t remember but usa / Europe think of Philippines as substandard people who possies run off of rice. True statement .
So does everyone else lol. Ask what the Chinese, koreans and Japanese think of us. People don't understand that the west is not the only ones r@cist to us. funny is at least the west knows they have a problem, in asia people don't see that as much of a problem.
Id rather have the country that upholds the value of democracy, or freedom for their people.
Filipinos chose Filipinos. We know that both US and China have their own interest.
I am a chinese. I agree with you. You are smart. If I am a Filipinos, I will befriend both China and America. Filipinos can negotiate with China to resolve the sea dispute.
@@KuangWen0 China will only accept negotiations if the Philippines gives what they want. They've been expanding their territory to our seas and have been harassing our coastguards and fishermen. We have been friendly with them to the point of the former president being a lap dog. They're not stopping the harassment because they know our government won't retaliate. There are hundreds of illegal mainlanders here now with hundreds of fake birth certificates claiming to be Filipino-Chinese even if they are not Filipinos. If you do not know about the Alice Guo POGO case, you can look it up on RUclips or social media. The Philippines has already been discreetly sold to China.
Simple question. How many countries has China invaded, colonized and built military bases in? Now ask yourself the same question about the US.
US invades many countries, but with the goal of leaving. China invades few countries, but with the goal of staying.
Tibet
Vietnam. India. Tibet. As in post WW2. And how many parts of other nations are they currently claiming? As in in the South China Sea? And of course the cancer that is North Korea exists because of China. The oppressed of North Korea must be truly grateful....
Tibet, Korea, and Vietnam
WuMao Talking Point number 1,443, page 83 of the spreadsheet, copy-pasted directly. Fifty cents to you, Little Pink!
As per my observation Filipinos have diverse opinion regarding US presence and building military bases may be because pro-US media is more dominant in Philippines. According to history US international politics and relations always revolve around self-interest. Look at US foreign policy today at Ukraine and Afghanistan or where US is involved, if it serves their purpose they dump in their armaments and spread the concept so called 'protection or safeguard democracy' but once it's starts hitting them hard they will quietly left as we have witnessed what happened in Afghanistan. For me as Asian it's time for us to unite and counter West hegemony and it's time for Asia to rise because it's been many century that West and Europe has colonised us and dominated us and we have been ill treated so we should not keep bowing to them and keep serving their purpose. Just my opinion love from India
I'm sorry, bu the fact is Asian Boss tried to be unbiased here. But the reality is 85-90% of the Filipinos according to the most reliable surveys are pro-US. Overwhelming number of Filipinos, even with Chinese blood such as myself, or pure Chinese from China, at anti China with regards to the West Philippine Sea (South China Sea) issue.
That would be great, if the alternative wasn’t just another hegemon vying for power. The Japanese tried that a couple of years ago, and well… look what happened there…
Accept your point of view。
Philippines is heavily westernised. would be difficult for them
You make it sound like Asia is as united as the West is. The West, although shady history, currently supports borders and nations sovereignty. China wishes the US would leave Asia so it could take over areas of it's neighbors. So, if your wish came true and the US left. You'd rather deal with China taking parts of India, Taiwan, and a lot of the South China Sea. You can hate the US/West, but currently China has been the one making moves all over Asia. And from personal experience, Chinese hate Indians as they look down on them.
It's a dispute because both sides claiming the same thing. The thing is Philippines only existed as an entity only a hundred years ago while China has been there for thousands of years. Just look the number of ethnic Chinese in South East Asia and who are the one running the economy. Not to mention, If a frontier is up for grabs by all, South East Asian countries are late to the game by a long stretch. Even if you are to follow the international treaty of sorts, China drawn up their 11 Dash line long before Philippines even realize what they want in addition. For those who don't know, PRC only claiming 9 Dash line because of good will for Vietnam during the Vietnam war against Americans. Who's the greedy one ?
The perspective of the common Filipino folk is basically neutrality. It does not seek to entrench with the barbarism of both countries, with China's aggression and with the opportunistic tendencies of the US. The country only seeks to continually economically grow and strengthen its own military further to fend off both powers.
The PH is not pro-US, nor pro-China, it seeks to be neutral, while reaping both the economic and military benefits of both countries through trade and diplomacy. It wants to be diplomatically and military like Switzerland.
but the government did choice for them. let the US build military bases it means choose to be enemy of China，and be a frontline of a possible US_China war in future.
As far as I see it there are no truly neutral countries, even Switzerland has taken sides. It all depends on the conflict though, because at the end of the day each nation looks out for their own interests. When looking at the Philippines situation a war between China and the US will force all nations in the region to pick sides, because the US and China are the biggest investors in those foreign economies (example: North Korea can’t survive without Chinese support or investment, just like how South Korea can’t survive without European and US support and investment)
Hi American here, just wanted to say that I support you and your country on its way to independence. Although I’m not certain how our government feels as every government is materialistic. I’m gonna keep this note here as a time capsule that I’ll hopefully never have to dig up.
No thanks. not all Filipinos like you some of us seeing you as wolf with a cloth of a sheep.
I love Chinese food I love hamburgers, I don't want to live in a world where I can't love both❤😂
you even get chinese-American food in the US. screw the commies.
I am a US Navy vet. I served proudly with many Filipinos who have historically served in the US Navy. The US Navy devastated the Japanese navy in WW2 while supplying the Nationalist Chinese forces who held Chungking while the communist hid in the hills. I hope there is not a conflict, but I would recommend Beijing study the naval battles of WW2 before they challenge the US Navy. The Chinese can't "own" the South China Sea if their ships are at the bottom of it.
US nuclear bombs can easily strike Chinese territory. . On the flip side, China's nuclear warheads can also cover the entire US territory in just 15 minutes. It doesn't matter how the ship sank or anything
I recommend u learn how to communicate with Chinese. Bcz u American army failed every time against Chinese communist. No matter it is Korean War or Vietnam war. USA is more like a loser than China. USA do have 11 or wtever proud aircraft. They all can be destroyed in only 30mins by missle. I sincerely recommend u to be a humble person. Don’t try to provoke any conflict.
So u betrayed us Nationalist Chinese in support of CCP into the UN and now u betray the CCP. All just to F with Chinese interests throughout history. U and ur military should get the F out Asia where u don’t belong for once.
According to the U.S. Department of Defense, China’s shipbuilding capabilities now exceed U.S. capabilities in manufacturing munitions. They have most of the world's shipbuilding capacity, and the tonnage of warships launched every year is equivalent to the entire French navy. Even if China's shore-based strike force is not considered, it would be unwise to conflict with the Chinese navy in the South China Sea. In fact, the events of 2016 have proven this judgment. In that incident, the US commander even gave the order to fire, but his men refused to carry out the order. He was subsequently fired and transferred to South Korea, where he became a minor figure.
America should deal with discrimination against people of color first. The Anglo-Saxons don't know what equality is😅
it’s interesting to see people are voluntarily willing to give up their own countries sovereignty by letting another country to build military base in their own territory and think that it will help protecting their country😅.
At this point, it is what it is. i have no problem if china wants to fish near our island as long we can fish in ours. but my only concern and hate about is the abuse that even us cannot fish on our own waters so if peace can still be talked out and agreed that both interest would meet. i really dont care if there are Chinese ships as long there is no abuse. but most likely that wont happen. so lets just watch on where things otherwise im still ready to defend my country no matter what
there is a whole ocean to your east.
@@kimeli yes there is east but you're lucky if you live there, how about the people living in fishing areas in the west? some of them are just using a small motor boat to fish and its not economical to go that far (east) to fish if they can just go in their local area.
Before UNCLOS, are those waters are yours?
@@kimelidamn your stupid, so we should adjust for them and let them take our fishing waters?
@@kimeli kung isa kang maralitang mangingisda na kapos ang bulsa mo makabili ng gasolina papuntang Philippine East Sea na taga Mindoro, Palawan, Zambales, Marinduque, Pangasinan, Cavite, Bataan, paano ka makapangingisda sa sinasabi mong East Sea?
The Philippines and US both have Mutual Defense Treaty. If war break out with China either the US or The Philippines both will depend each others against China...I believes the S.Korea, Japan, Indonesia, Australia, EU and other countries will help the Philippines.
US Congress has to deliberate about it first before they make a move to help the Philippines... by the time they act, the Philippines is goners. I think that's what many Filipinos don't realize.
Prepare for war, a local war between China and the US is imminent (not more than 5 years at most). It is best to choose to prepare weapons now
LMAF, they can't even help Ukraine.
@@Yarxk-j7w They are giving Ukraine second rate tools and intel, they don't have soldiers or heavy assets in Ukraine. War with China would be different, it would mean direct confrontation, not proxy support like in Ukraine.
@@obligatoryusername7239
China alreay fight with the US in Korean war without anything, this time our productivity are 50X stronger
The US gave us independence but we are still dependent on them in terms of national security.
because in theory its literally impossible for the Philippines to surpass China in terms of military strength. Not even in a hundred years.
The straight answer would be none.
The media in the Philippines is highly controlled by the United States, and I wouldn't expect most Filipinos to have any good reviews of China.
Please learn from the old gentleman in the video, read more and think more.
Every Filipino I have met is very friendly, and the Philippines is also a beautiful country.
I hope the Philippines must be smart and maintain a balance among major powers, and never learn from Ukraine.
I can see who is educated well, and who isn't. Anyways, the US has had military bases in the Philippines for a long time and closed many of them already. The US let the Filipinos join the US military and they easily became US citizens with a much higher income than their local countrymen. The US Navy has an unbelievable number of Filipinos in it. I'm sure the other services do also. And something not mentioned in the video is the local economies around the military bases grows a lot. The US military, and their members spend a lot of money around the bases. Also defense costs a lot of money. The US will give defense to the Philippines which the Philippines can't even afford. Countries like Japan and South Korea have been getting defense for cheap or free for a long time. Look at their economies now.
I was actually surprised that the "well educated" people had such a rosy view of the US history in the Philippines, the civilian cost in the Philippine-American War was crazy. As a well educated American we never learned about it in school, and I was astounded when I only recently became aware of it... I guess it's not emphasized much in Philippines schools either, and the cultural memory has mostly faded/healed since it was over 120 years ago. Not that this would/should outweigh the current geopolitical bullying China is doing---it's just possible to acknowledge that the US did really shitty things in the past and has been a helpful ally more recently.
people in Japan have a hard life bro
and good and rich korean only in his big city
many could not pay their mortgages and living expenses
don't believe what you see on tv
A good government is a government that makes its people prosperous, not a government that has a large stock of missiles
Let China gain a military base in Philippines. China can do all the things what the us do.
@@mingwu-v3f china will also make them work for cheap labor. Since american/western buy cheap stuff from them. so yea let china colonize other asian counties and the philipiines i want my cheap stuff. LOl
@@goatmeal5241in ph we learned it at school. We learned how spain colonized us for 300 yrs, how US betrayed us( we even have a decorated hero killed by americans in battle of tirade pass). We also learned about the atrocities that the japanese did to us. But what people must learn is how to forgive and move on. Spain, japan, and america are now friends. We must never forget the past but we cannot let the past in hinder us from moving forward.
Interesting. Thank you for this video.
All my Pinoy homies, stay safe 🤘
What the hell is "pinoy?!" Speak ENGLISH!
I wish I was interviewed.
I'll choose Indonesia and India. If we choose the US, China will become more aggressive because the US is increasing its presence here to control the South China Sea. If they control the sea, they can paralyze the economy of China to contain its growth.
If we choose China, the US and its allies will retaliate and can economically punish the Philippines.
Our real best friend is Indonesia. Our very own Southeast Asian neighbor. We don't need to look farther. Our best friend is located in the South.
We can also strengthen our relationship with India.
South-South cooperation is more important than ever. (Global South are the developing countries).
The guy in white shirt is ignorant in his own country's history. Yes, the US promised to help us to become independent from Spain but they betrayed us in the Treaty of Paris. They committed genocide, killing 250,000 Filipinos. They ordered to kill all Filipinos over 10 years old.
Totally Agree. I choose ASEAN also to work together if ever that I'll interview as well. Malapit lng din satin din eh. Although naka base nmn sa military base ng US but let's be honest tlga. Nanjan ang neighbors natin din❤️
Indonesia and India can't protect you from China, at all. If China decides the ocean around the Philippines and it's islands belong to them that's it you are done. Unless the US decides to step in. I will not deny that the US committed genocide in the Philippines but saying they ordered everyone over 10 to be killed is so stupid, there literally would not be a Philippines if that was the case, the deaths would have been in the millions.
Many of them choosing China confuses China to ethnic chinese, which has a longer historical connection with the Philippines, but they are oblivious to the fact that many of the Chinese who came to the Philippines escaped mainland China during Mao's time, the Americans have a colonist past relations with the Philippines, but it has made up for it and build up relations since the japanese occupation going forward. The Chinese on the other hand specifically the current CCP government has expansionist ambitions, and the current bully and colonizer in the region. Threatening independent democratic Taiwan, suppressing their ethnic Uyghurs, Tibetans Mongolians, neighboring India, claiming territories of Vietnam, Philippines Malaysia, Brunei etc. in the west Philippine sea, using obscure historical map. If I have a map of the world does it follow that I own the world? The west Philippine sea has been claimed by many including the Philippines but it has been free to fish and passage of nearby nation, as well as international commercial traffic, the US & other western nation freedom of navigation is essential to keep the area clear of CCP China's greedy grasp. We are already entangled in the US-China conflict the moment CCP China claimed our territories, militarized the islands and terrorized our fishermen.
At least China didn't kill as many of your fellow ancestors in your home as the United States did.
The US didn't take these military bases by force. They were invited to use them by the Philippines to counterbalance China.
They actually requested the Philippines for a legal lease with the aim of continuing to exert geopolitical dominance against China. It's the same modus operandi already followed within NATO, they're actually trying to involve NATO in this whole business. Any idea about friendship or actions without contracts in our 2023 world are just fairytales. Just go past the headlines, read the small print: reality is always different from the hype.
The US was not invited by Ph. It volunteered since it needs the position of Ph to deter Chi for Taiwan and to hamper its control in the Pacific. US only saw the importance of Ph during former Pres Du30 when he was siding with Chi. Both US and Ph benefit from their partnership. US for control. Ph for protection.
Wow America is so generous to Philippines. They offer all this military protection for absolutely no benefit to themselves. They are helping Filipinos purely out of the generosity of their own hearts.
Loool!
At least people didn't claimed all the islands which belong to Philippines as China did
@@kujuakusg China claims those islands. What will the US claim?
@@alterzy5197The US Twice stood up the Philippines as an independent Nation. Once before the Japanese invaded and once again after driving the Japanese off. At great cost in American lives. And no the US did not Colonize the Philippines. It was a Spanish Colony deeded to the US after the Spanish American War. To be honest the US never really knew what to do with it. Contrary to popular myth the US for most of its history has actively avoided any foreign holdings beyond a few that had clear National Security purpose. Hawaii, Guam and Somoa for example were needed fueling stops for the Navy in the 19th and early 20th century. And Hawaii due to its position is critical to defense of the Eastern Pacific.
@@andrewtaylor940 of course another colonizer denying a colonization once again. what a surprise
Why is my main comment not showing? Is Asian Boss censoring truth comments now?
I said:
0:21 Taiwan isnt a "country". Why is Asian Boss allowing their host to spread misinformation? No world power in this world recognises "Taiwan" as a country. And Taiwans very own constitution specifically refers to Taiwan as a province of China.
1:14 No, the reality is that PH does NOT have sovereignty over those islands. When the US handed over its sovereignty to the PH, they SPECIFICALLY said it did NOT include the Spratly islands etc. So PH does NOT have legal sovereignty over those islands. PH just wish they did, and made their citizens to believe its theirs.
7:28 This guy is uninformed. Its not "illegal" per se if its no laws against it. ESPECIALLY when its disputed territory. PH does NOT have sovereignty over the islands, so its not "theirs". Its called "disputed territory" for a reason. Many countries claim these territories, not just China and PH.
7:35 You "won" because China was not even there to defend themselves. China was not there because China knew it was useless to go, as the current international laws present is incompatible with a countrys sovereignty claims. What that means is the current international maritime laws only define whats considered a countrys territory based on the 12nm distance from a countrys coastline, EEZ etc, but has no laws to define whether a piece of territory falls under the sovereignty of Country X or Country Y.
7:51 No, you cant forcefully implement it because that court you won that case from has ZERO authority to enforce anything. Even the US cant.
12:44 No, it was not "proven that it belongs to the PH". This is how facts get misconstrued. The arbitration ruling ruled that China had no legal basis on "historical claims" to those islands, because NO country (including PH) can make claims on any territory based on historical claims with our current maritime laws. If China reversed the role and initiated this ruling, the same thing would have applied to the PH - that PH cannot claim those islands based on "historical" records as well.
need to interview Chinese people who lives in Philippines. what they think about China taking Filipino islands
Don't forget that you are not blonde and blued eyes.. And you are not white. They are not same species. Will look down on you Filipinos, always. In contrast, China is the way to go in long run, period.
Ideally both China and US should stay away from SEA but if i really have to pick a side, I'd choose the winning side😂😂😂
How about the side that allows you freedom of speech and the ability to disagree with your leaders? (US) China won't ever allow you that.
That's actually the most clever choice, the choice of the true survivor. 😂
China is definitely the winning side
Plus it's our flipping neighbour
USA is far away
We don't pick sides. But worse comes to worse, China. I don't see US invading us. You have a silent but deadly predator behind you and you provoke it by inviting his enemy? Marcos' move really is very idiotic
Weird this comment has 5 replies but only 1 actual reply
Tatang speaking the truth!! ✊🏼✊🏼🪡
India supports Philippines 🇮🇳 ❤️🇵🇭
I support independence for
1. Nagaland
2. Kashmir
3. sikkim
For years, their women were raped by Indian soldiers and their men were killed by Indian soldiers
for years they were impoverished and the wealth of their land was plundered by new delhi
for years the people were beaten and racist by the indians
It's time for them to be independent from India
@@jimmyellys5990okay Chinese baby bra warrior 😂
Since when Asian boss choose a side to stand? I see double standards and hypocritical ideologies in these video.
Interestingly, with just a tiny bit of research from any independent source, you'll notice the Philipines never claimed any island in the South China Sea until recently with the "help" from the Yankees
The condition of the Philippines is tough. Winnie the Pooh want to expand their territory like what they did with their neighboring countries like Tibet, Uighur, Qinghai, Inner Mongolia, and many others, Mr. Dementia don't want to get rid of their rule in the world and continue their business of selling weapons of war of destruction, because that's where they make a lot of money if there's no war. Their economy is weak, so the condition of the Philippines is in a very difficult situation. The best thing to do is strengthen their military capabilities, and hopefully, the Philippine government will wake up and stop the culture of corruption so that the development of the Philippines will continue.
all the ethnicities you mentioned live a better life than the majority of people in your country
you don't know what you are talking about. it is so full of errors, it would take pages to point them all out.
You revealed your ignorance from your talk. 🙂
@@w.z.6062 Did you already forget about China's outrageous new "map" they released in September? Say what you will about the USA, China has shown very clearly that they want the land and seas of their neighbors.
@@obligatoryusername7239 what’s your preconceived perception, I would say that’s disputed spaces that every country will depend.
I can't help but notice that the pro US people appear to be more educated, wearing more expensive clothes, and are more well spoke than those that are against the US. I wonder if there is an economic class or blue collar/white collar class distinction going on here. Anyone from Philippines know the answer?
Interesting observation! Now I have the same question as you. Can anybody answer?
The Filipino educated class is louder against EDCA. Uniforms do not make "expensive" clothes. Just cleaner from being confined in classrooms.
I think that's a stereotype you might have. I don't know how we can classify the «well-spoken» thing when we foreigners can't understand half of what they're saying (since it's Tagalog), apart from the bits in English, and (in my case) the many other bits in Spanish. Unless for «well-spoken» you actually mean «mostly using English».
I actually perceived the opposite: the few strongly pro-US people spoke showing some bias, lacking many bits of modern reality and history. Very clear contrast with the eldest, who didn't forget. The pro-independence (I think the majority) were balancing their historical background together with the current events and their geostrategical value. Those seemingly favouring China were actually pro-independence, however cleverly stating you should get along with your neighbours first.
In any case, it's just a random street interview, with no statistical value. Very interesting, though.
Educated class===brainwashed class
@@duozuo Let’s get along with our bully neighbour who’s CURRENTLY seizing our territory, sinking our fishermen and interfering with our elections at any given opportunity. Sure 😂
The old folks might have learned something from the past (if anything, the US has granted them independence), but the young have let go and are looking with fresher eyes. It’s pretty obvious that China is the friend of no country besides other dictatorships. It only seeks to turn its neighbours into vassal states and shamelessly exploit their resources. The US is the only force able to counterbalance and withhold this temporary excess of “ambition” from China (until it soon collapses), therefore Filipinos as well as every countries of the Pacific have everything to gain in siding with them to contain and defend them from this bully.
First time watching this channel. It has surprised me how well spoken people in Phillipines are. It seems that the country is progressing very quickly
alot of filipinos have always been well spoken even from long time ago. maybe just do ur research more
@@aapjm could be, i am from the other side of the world 💁🏻♂️. Either way great form them
I think OP’s comment is ok if you separate the sentences, but combined it does read like saying Filipinos used to not be educated and well spoken. But in the 50s, Manila was considered as the Paris of Asia
They can elaborate their balanced thoughts 80% more if they speak their mother tongue and not english.
@@aapjmpeople in philipines were still living on trees 20 years ago.
I agree kay tatay dapat both sides china and Us at kaibiganin nang PILIPINAS para miwasan ang tensyon o digmaan na mangyari.pero in the other side for me I think ang USA use Philippines as a weapon kasi Bago paman nagsimula ang tensyon nang Philippines at china The US is first has have a tensyon to china .and I hope we should always aware of that
fact is. china or usa has more trade with philippine?
It's only the opinions of 5-7 people in Manila. It is a random pick so, the opinions of 7 people don't really speak for the whole Filipinos. Maybe I would agree if 1 of those 7 people said he/she is pro-China, and the rest is pro-US. I agree with more reliable surveys such as Pulse Asia coz the surveys they are conducting say it ranges to 85-90% are pro-US, next is those who are undecided and only a small number say they are pro-China.
cannon fodder is good choose...
Pro-china Filipinos are the NPAs 😂
Why would you favor a country that is harrasing and stealing your islands?
There are many misconceptions around the SCS dispute, like how our ASEAN neighbors also have a claim in the Spratlys, or how the 2016 UNCLOS ruling only addressed the matters around EEZs and not territorial sovereignty. With that out of the way, our disputes with China is something we should address among ourselves. Dragging the US along will draw even bigger risks and implications that'll sever what little mutual understanding we have left with China.
If we keep acting rashly and drag the US over this dispute, god fobid, we will become the next Ukraine, and we will be a little footnote as to why World War III broke out. The more US bases we have, the more likely that we become the battleground while the actual Americans are safe on the other side of the world.
If you call that SCS then it is China's. That's not SCS. On Filipino's point of view that is WPS so then, it is Philippines'.
@@fredy241m the British and Canadian Embassies made statements condemning the water cannon incident in the Ayungin Shoal but they still called that body of water "South China Sea".
"West Philippine Sea" is a name unheard of outside the Philippines because it was an 2012 invention made to assert our claim in the Spratlys.
If people are rational enough and have read through the South China Sea arbitration tribunal ruling, then they should know that the ruling itself is useless, it does not help the situation at all. The ruling of the arbitration tribunal can only be legally binding when both parties that have willingly participated in the proceedings, by international law if China reject and does not participate in the proceedings then it is pretty much a shitshow. If every county choice to ignore bilateral negotiations and all follow what Philippines does just go ahead and filed a lawsuit against another country and then uses the outcome to pressure the other country to back out their claim, sooner or later the world will be plunder into chaos. Filipinos think the US is help them in the matter, but whats really happening was the US used Philippines and worsening the dispute between China and Filipinos so that Filipinos have no choice but to side with the US. Funny how after 6 years and the Filipinos still dont really understand what the US did to them. China and Philippines's relationship is much larger than the dispute, the US made it so that the dispute is all there is between the Chinese and Filipinos.
Well china is been ignoring PH you can't blame us to depend on US china didn't even tell pH what they building in the island. And now china want to be friend to Philippines. The audacity
You don't know anything dude china been attacking pH fisherman for so many years they building near pH and it's so close to Palawan which is my hometown china didn't even tell what they doing on that island.
@@HABIBIBIBIBIBI50 I'm hearing lot of finger pointing, lot of emotion. How do you know the Chinese and Philippine government never talk about the dispute, how do you know there was no progress, do you expect a negotiations can be reach in just 2 meetings or more? In terms of attacking fisher man, I saw lot of video footages many years ago of Philippine military carrying out physical abuse and torture of Chinese fishman, do you not call those crimes? The way I see it, the Philippine side was not so good either. All of those footages were published by the Philippine side, non from the Chinese. This is what I mean by when people are not in their right mind and incapable of rational thinking, everything get distorted. You are seeing what you want to see and using all the reason you can find to justified your reason for taking China to court and did what you did. This type of thinking is called conditioning, you been conditioned to think you have done the right thing, but are you sure about that? Just by reading the history, you guys has stolen an island from Republic of China during the 80s when a typhoon hit and when the ROC troops return find out it was stolen by your government, do you not call this stealing? By using your logic, does that mean the PLA should just go in and throw you guys off the island? The way they see it, every belong to ROC is now part of PRC, stealing from ROC is the same as stealing from PRC. At the end of the day, if this is all your people are capable of, then you will always be used as a tool for the Americans. To date, you hold on to a hate toward China purely based on propaganda.
This is so true. When i pointed this out in Twitter.. I was labeled pro-Chinese...😂 And said this to me "do you side with oppressors".. so fcking woke.. a Kakampink
@@HABIBIBIBIBIBI50looks like you are the one who doesn't know.
im glad that our independence was fight by the blood. our fertile country was from our ancestor blood nurturing the motherland itself.
in a sense that, our freedom is TRULY FREE. we earned it. we really earned it. congratulations, to all indonesians. happy 78th anniversary, the Unitary Nation of Republic Indonesia.
Indonesian?
@@Userkangjihoon23451 malaysia...
That's just a choice between 'Who's the lesser evil.
Sadly
11:49 this guy based his opinion from other people's opinion on the internet