Roger Waters, Thank you for coming back to Canada one last time, and making the fondest memories.. That was the first time My friend and I got to see you. We waited for 5 long months, but it was worth every minute of it.
Saw this in Vancouver 5 days ago it was my first big concert and it was absolutely breathtaking the guitarist on this song was changing it up a bit and molding the solo perfectly back and forth between solo riffs and made it sound SOOOOOO!!! AWESOME! Best Experience I'll Ever Have!
Was at that show! Probably same amount of rows back but to the right of the stage, great show! Rogers Center was hot boxed by the end of the show, onced they turned the lights on i laughed so hard, so many no smoking signs! Best live performance I've ever seen, sounded great, and the show alone was amazing, loved how they paid tribute to fallen soldiers
I have been playing lead guitar for 28 years now and ,This is what is said we expess our innerself to you by playing music that you all can take with you inside your innerself and keep it to release or increase or build on something that last forever,like the guitarist he does such a great lead in and out that everyone just floats with him on some of his wriffs he plays.I know he carries my head off make me listen to his awesome talent.
@catalystmaker The show was off the charts (and watching the footage from last night was awesome!) I'm coming back for the show in NJ - can't wait! Have fun in Buffalo!
I was there for opening night. Awesome show. Everyone was using cameras and no one said anything. They were only watching for serious camera equipment going in. If you're going to comment on whether Gilmour was there or this was just a cover band, you've missed the point. This was a total theatrical show. The Wall ws the star!
@WildRaikouSpirit dont freak, if you live in the states though. Roger is re touring the states with an outdoor version of the wall! I am really excited!
seen this last night in denver, what a mind trip man, love is the only word i can use to describe this performance, RIP Syd, Richard, gilmour get your ass up there please and no offense to this guy playing gimours parts he really did an amazing job
@WildRaikouSpirit my words, i saw the dark side of the moon tour at 2007 and in 7 hours i see this show in zürich. it will be the best show in my life, i know it
Anyone know the list of songs that was played before the show start ? I'm looking for the song sung by a lady in a jazzy voice. It was played a few songs after Imagine. Thanks !
Thx for posting!!! I agree w/most of ya''. Who the fuck cares if Gilmour is there? SO much talen on that stage without himt! Unfucking believable!!!! Can't wait for the Tampa show!
You's guys should stop saying about wishing Gilmour was there. He had his chance to be there, Roger invited him to come on the whole tour, and David refused.
@BrunoSantosOrg - Roger Waters IS the story behind The Wall. If you had gone to the show you'd realize that your comment was absolute nonsense. This show was so well performed you never had time to cry about Gilmore's absence. It was a masterpiece of a live show. Videos don't do it any justice. You missed out.
Was there in MSG on Sat , a stunning show way beyond belief . They should get back together again and use the money to set up a bunch of Pink Floyd Schools/ Heath Clinics for those in need . What a legacy ????
Sorry but Comfortably Numb is NOT Comfortably Numb without David doing it. Delicate Sound of Thunder tour David did it so amazingly it brought tears to my eyes
The Wall without Gilmour is just a fence! Saw it in 1980 and that was the real deal. Roger brings a very good cover band out to play. Very nice video work tho.
did anyone else get a litte pissed when people wouldnt stop singing along. im mean the man who wrote these songs is standing right in front of you sing them live and its the only time youll ever get to hear him sing it in person and you just want to fuck it up for everyone else. shut up and listen.
David Gilmour is, of course, by far the best guitarist to be a part of this song, but I think the touring guitarist has filled Gilmour's shoes rather well. I bet he was dreaming about playing that guitar solo ever since he was a little kid.
@holdemxpert No this is ole rogers Karaoke Floyd and bless em they try hard but no luck Davids Floyd sounded fjust like Floyd and no lipsyncing back then, 3-1 is far superior sounding then 1-3
you will be comfortably numb during this show, guaranteed... i went twice, i suggest u do too.. so get your tix in advance... don't be on floor ppl stand up and will block ur vew... in order to see all the details of the show, it's better to be at a raised level... i know that i tried 3 diff spots...
Dave Kilminster is fantastic, but his solo on this song doesn't really do it for me, I don't whether it's his note choice or choice of phrasing, or both.
@darksideka Gilmour proved he couldnt write a damn thing when he hired writers to "sound like PF" for Momentary Lapse, and just gave up and put out the trash that was Division Bell. He hasnt had a good, original musical idea since Free Four. The only lip synching in this show was the kids, BFD. Try to picture Gilmour putting on this show...you cant, because he doesnt have the vision or the chops anymore.
It was the most beautiful, extraordinary and marvelous thing I've ever experienced in my life. The memory will last forever in my mind.
Roger Waters, Thank you for coming back to Canada one last time, and making the fondest memories.. That was the first time My friend and I got to see you. We waited for 5 long months, but it was worth every minute of it.
best concert of my life ... thanks for recording, helps the memories ... hah
4:30 onwards .... goosebumps every. single. time.
Saw this in Vancouver 5 days ago it was my first big concert and it was absolutely breathtaking the guitarist on this song was changing it up a bit and molding the solo perfectly back and forth between solo riffs and made it sound SOOOOOO!!! AWESOME! Best Experience I'll Ever Have!
Was at that show! Probably same amount of rows back but to the right of the stage, great show! Rogers Center was hot boxed by the end of the show, onced they turned the lights on i laughed so hard, so many no smoking signs! Best live performance I've ever seen, sounded great, and the show alone was amazing, loved how they paid tribute to fallen soldiers
I have been playing lead guitar for 28 years now and ,This is what is said we expess our innerself to you by playing music that you all can take with you inside your innerself and
keep it to release or increase or build on something that last forever,like the guitarist he does such a great lead in and out that everyone just floats with him on some of his wriffs
he plays.I know he carries my head off make me listen to his awesome talent.
Thanks Catalystmaker!!! I went to Fort Lauderdale last saturday. The best part is the minute 5:50 of this song ... I almost cried.
The greatest songwriter of all time, and the leader of the greatest band who ever lived. Roger Waters. I love David just as much do.
saw this show Tuesday night in Philly unbelievable. Wish I was going tonight.
This show was so amazing! Im still in shock
WOW!!!!! That was amazing. its going to be a long 8 months until he arrives in London. Great camera work!!
fantastic show I would love to see it. super clean mix for a live show :)
@catalystmaker The show was off the charts (and watching the footage from last night was awesome!) I'm coming back for the show in NJ - can't wait! Have fun in Buffalo!
Fantastic!!! i can't wait for december.
awesome Terry great mix for live... Rock On Bro !!!
DAAAAAAMN!!! THATS A GOOD HD VIDEO, IM GONNA GO TO THAT CONCERT IN DECEMBER 14 HERE IN L.A., PLUS THATS MY FAVORITE SONG... VERY COOL... ;-)
I was there for opening night. Awesome show. Everyone was using cameras and no one said anything. They were only watching for serious camera equipment going in. If you're going to comment on whether Gilmour was there or this was just a cover band, you've missed the point. This was a total theatrical show. The Wall ws the star!
@WildRaikouSpirit dont freak, if you live in the states though. Roger is re touring the states with an outdoor version of the wall! I am really excited!
I have the same reaction. EVERY time I watch this.
@TheNight3434 he played the exact solo from the album, its awesome that waters respect that huge piece of melody...
Nice!!! Hope you had a great time.
seen this last night in denver, what a mind trip man, love is the only word i can use to describe this performance, RIP Syd, Richard, gilmour get your ass up there please and no offense to this guy playing gimours parts he really did an amazing job
@catalystmaker The Solo with the Wall is just Epic, can't go wrong...
6:00 was better when I saw it in Seattle, WA. Totally different. STILL INCREDIBLE!
@MrEstpas i'm going to the arnhem show too! I can't wait 4 it!
Roger waters is a timeless idol.
Epic!
aaaaahhhh que concierto... :D
@catalystmaker I have a panasonic lumixTZ1 and I video a lot and I love this camera. Although I do want one with hd video and more zoom.
@TheNight3434
Wise words. I wish He was there
@WildRaikouSpirit
my words, i saw the dark side of the moon tour at 2007
and in 7 hours i see this show in zürich.
it will be the best show in my life, i know it
You know when the guitarist did a fucking good job when he gives you shivers at 5:52 :)
@TheNight3434 have you watched the video of the same concert in london? gilmour showed and did the solo with him.. awsome video!
wow!!!
simply magic!!!
PINK FLOYD 4EVER!!
@catalystmaker I saw the Wall in Tampa, FL, sooo fuckin Epic!!!!!
@bls4life8 It was Gilmour who made the music for this song.
Best concert for me in the last 30 years. Period. Yes it was awsome. Better than U2 360.
Anyone know the list of songs that was played before the show start ? I'm looking for the song sung by a lady in a jazzy voice. It was played a few songs after Imagine. Thanks !
Thx for posting!!! I agree w/most of ya''. Who the fuck cares if Gilmour is there? SO much talen on that stage without himt! Unfucking believable!!!! Can't wait for the Tampa show!
What type of device (phone/camera) did you use? This is absolutely awesome!!!
I'm seeing this at MSG in a few weeks... It sure would be epic if Gilmour appeared during this song...
geilo Solo geilo the WALL....
@rdaws73 in fact, Gilmour did do so much on this album, it was basicily Roger Waters who did the whole album
section 108 row 9
fucking amazin concert
You's guys should stop saying about wishing Gilmour was there. He had his chance to be there, Roger invited him to come on the whole tour, and David refused.
im saving money to flight to london the the show in may :)
would love to have seen Gilmour play these solos, but fair play to this guy, he did just as good a job as the original
I will forever regret not going to the LA show....
@BrunoSantosOrg - Roger Waters IS the story behind The Wall. If you had gone to the show you'd realize that your comment was absolute nonsense. This show was so well performed you never had time to cry about Gilmore's absence. It was a masterpiece of a live show. Videos don't do it any justice. You missed out.
@RocketScience92 Probably the best experience ill ever have in my life was doing just that. Brisbane, 2nd night =]
I fully agree with the others about David Gilmour's solo; I've also missed his deep voice. But Snowy White is a very respectfull successor!
@i014720 i went last night! it was REDICULOUS. They put on one hell of a show.
@bls4life8 The music transcends the musicians, to be sure.
Is that Jon Carin singing up there (sounds similar, but looks a bit different)? AND where's Snowy?
Was there in MSG on Sat , a stunning show way beyond belief . They should get back together again and use the money to set up a bunch of Pink Floyd Schools/ Heath Clinics for those in need . What a legacy ????
@MrBumblebore he will be at one of the concerts to perform c numb, dont worry!
@jkhshsh Very Nice, the Solo is tooo epic!!!
Sorry but Comfortably Numb is NOT Comfortably Numb without David doing it.
Delicate Sound of Thunder tour David did it so amazingly it brought tears to my eyes
@n0cloo
It was probably Billie Holiday - "Strange Fruit"
5:51... I wish I was there...
@tdurden77007 Panasonic Lumix DMC-ZS7 Best cam for concerts!
@MNWLKR Noone has disliked it yet....
@WildRaikouSpirit Yup...we (who enjoy real music) were all born too late! It sucks! Long live real studio/live music!
@memoom0528
Your intelligence comes shining through.
The Wall without Gilmour is just a fence! Saw it in 1980 and that was the real deal.
Roger brings a very good cover band out to play. Very nice video work tho.
did anyone else get a litte pissed when people wouldnt stop singing along. im mean the man who wrote these songs is standing right in front of you sing them live and its the only time youll ever get to hear him sing it in person and you just want to fuck it up for everyone else. shut up and listen.
@mouloudo He confirmed that it will be a north american show.
@MrBumblebore he will on one show... probably London :( Im sad because I will see em in Zurich lol and I highly doubt that Dave will come to Zurich XD
5:50 the camera man almost got it right
Who's doing David Gilmour's part?
@HeadheldHigh93 noone even was there for a patdown for security.. cameras got in no problem
David Gilmour is, of course, by far the best guitarist to be a part of this song, but I think the touring guitarist has filled Gilmour's shoes rather well. I bet he was dreaming about playing that guitar solo ever since he was a little kid.
@MrBumblebore These songs without Gilmour are just like Guns' without Slash: they, just, don't sound the same. Ever.
how great is gilmour, roger although has a good singer and a good guitar player, still is the absence of David. Thanks David ...
@kleban10 I'd probably get a heart attack.
Is roger just singing this show??
David Gilmour needs to quit the orb and rejoin waters in a 2011-2012 tour. How fucking awesome would it be to have the real Pink Floyd back again?
@holdemxpert No this is ole rogers Karaoke Floyd and bless em they try hard but no luck Davids Floyd sounded fjust like Floyd and no lipsyncing back then, 3-1 is far superior sounding then 1-3
you will be comfortably numb during this show, guaranteed... i went twice, i suggest u do too.. so get your tix in advance... don't be on floor ppl stand up and will block ur vew... in order to see all the details of the show, it's better to be at a raised level... i know that i tried 3 diff spots...
fuck it there is no snowy white
damn the guitarist did a fucking! good job. BUT would have been better if Gilmour was there.
tatica
im going on the athens show..
@BrunoSantosOrg
Yeah, they sound better
@TheFloydGiver oh ok :( lucky bastards! lol
ARGH, I HAVE THE SHITTIEST SEATS EVER TO THE CONCERT IN STOCKHOLM, FUCK MY GODMDANFIWIWEWE
WELL...
At least I'll see it ;__;, kinda.
Dave Kilminster is fantastic, but his solo on this song doesn't really do it for me, I don't whether it's his note choice or choice of phrasing, or both.
no acid needed!
@darksideka
Gilmour proved he couldnt write a damn thing when he hired writers to "sound like PF" for Momentary Lapse, and just gave up and put out the trash that was Division Bell. He hasnt had a good, original musical idea since Free Four.
The only lip synching in this show was the kids, BFD.
Try to picture Gilmour putting on this show...you cant, because he doesnt have the vision or the chops anymore.
fantastic show I would love to see it. super clean mix for a live show :)
@catalystmaker I have a panasonic TZ1 and I video a lot and I love this camera. Although I do want one with hd video and more zoom.