(For real though thank you for making this awesome video!! It makes me incredibly happy to see people enjoying my stuff and I seriously could not have done it without all the amazing folk that have been on board to do the funny voices!) ♥
I think it’s important to note that Binky is Muffy’s dad, and Muffy said in the first one, “Parents know best, you should do as you’re told at all times…”
It's also a reference to the episode where there's some father/child picnic or something and Buster wants to attend, but his dad isn't around after his parents' divorce. So, Arthur and friends decide that Binky will be Buster's replacement father for the event, as he's a year older. It's pretty hilarious seeing Binky try to be a dad, going fishing with Buster, spilling hot cocoa on himself, wearing a suit, playing catch, speaking down to Buster, calling him "my boy" etc. He actually was a pretty good "dad"...As good a dad as a nine-year-old can be to an eight-year-old.
@@SheilaDeBonis Haha I remember that. I don’t remember the line before it but my favorite part was when after the idea was brought up Binky was like, “I don’t see a line of dads behind me.” and he looks behind his shoulder.
High quality shitposts in the form of a surreal-ish (idk if surreal is the right word but hopefully you know what I mean) digital horror series is something I can’t say I’ve ever seen before it absolutely works here lmao
The funny thing is, is that Binky is totally the type of person to say he's gonna do your mom. If the show wasn't aimed at kids I could see that being a re-occurring joke for him in the series.
What I love about this is unlike other analogue horrors I don’t feel like Binky’s going to harm me, I feel like he’s going to harm the other characters.
Yea I have a theory that, binky does not want to go beyond his reality, either because he simply chooses not to or he is unable to, and he goes on a killing spree to finally end his world.
So I think I pieced the story together: Over the course of the series, Binky gains power by feeding off of the other characters moral dilemmas, and eventually becomes the omnipotent ruler of the game. At one point, he takes control of all the characters minds (which explains Miffy’s submission to him) and eventually *becomes* them. But because (as PAD pointed out) there are no problems because it’s now a Binky hivemind, Binky can no longer feast on the moral dilemmas of others. So he brings the other characters back so he can continue to prey on their problems, but has full control over the narrative. Free will has essentially been abolished. All hail Binky
I've seen many "You've Got To Be Kidding" memes and not only this channel's are one of the funniest I've seen but also makes such a good transition from quality comedy to literal horror. "Binky is my father too" and then his father saying "help me" made me roll in the floor.
“Everyone has a right to sleeping with your mother. I’m sorry if that makes you feel uncomfortable” 1. She would absolutely say that 2. everytime I see that message I fucking die of laughter (and binkey)
how does comedy devolve into literal horror I love this series because it's not really serious and it's based off a series I like because it's just a joke
I love this one because they don't take it too seriously. You can tell they're having fun with it, and I enjoy that way more than the melodrama that dominates the genre
I wouldn't classify this series as analog horror, considering how it's shown in a digital format. If anything, I'd say that this is another addition from the Digital Horror genre, ESPECIALLY with the latest installment, having it set on a kids' computer game.
The most horrifying part of this is the revelation that his name is Arthur Read. Read with an A. Imagine being the only kid in class with glasses and your last name is Read. The bullying that poor kid must have endured.
"You Gotta Be Kidding" is the perfect example of how even a shitpost can be turned into one of the most intriguing and genuinely terrifying pieces of web horror of recent. Although it still keeps it's shitpost nature in certain episodes.
No joke, this whole series feels like an episode that would come out of the first 5 seasons (I mean they do a noose joke and Arthur says he wants to sell his sister in another episode.
@@dontkickmychick6076 This is when Arthur tells DW that he's going to sell her ruclips.net/video/fhIXeGKD134/видео.html It's actually a pretty funny scene 😆
@@dontkickmychick6076 There are alot of savage moments like this one- DW: "Hey Francine can I tell you something?" Francine: "Sure anything!" DW: "Why don't you go back to your own house, and stop bothering us!" Basically DW told her to fuck off 😭
I think the reason why Binky tells you not to interfere is because he probably fears you. He knows you're the only one capable of taking him down and defeating him. The only one with enough power to completely strip him of his powers.
I remember seeing the first one and going back to the channel to show my sister because I thought it was funny... I saw they had a second part and we decided to watch it, expecting the same lighthearted humor... we opened a wormhole to something we could never understand.
Imagine spending the night with someone's mom only for her to reveal that she's an eldritch beast that will curse you with an obsession with murder which will eventually lead to you having a state of complete control over what you understand as your world
Someone alert PeanutButterGamer. Also, am I the only one who wonders if the eyes belong to something else? Perhaps some monster that resides inside Binky like a parasite and is posing as him?
the very first one of these was a meme image that went around for a few years before someone did this with it! it was nuts seeing this unfold video by video lol "Tip: I am so fucking mad" still makes me laugh my ass off
The part where 'You gotta be kidding April fools' where Binky is talking to other Binkys, it kinda gives me a vibe where a serial killer is talking to themselves lol Like (in the movies) how they're saying "The problems(which is people) are gone but what do I do now?" And the voices are like "It's time to end other problems" which would lead to more killing spree Idk it's just my opinion :|
Status list (so far(also spoilers (duh))) --arthurs old dad- : dead and cucked by binky Arthurs mom: no information Binky/arthurs new dad/ muffys new dad/ god: a god binky binky and might be asleep Alan/ brain: dead/turned into a binky? DW: eyeless but no further info That library: Probably dead or something The poodle girl (IDK) Mr. Ratburn: Maybe turned into binky George: deformed James: deformed That ginger girl: deformed Buster: was fused into buthur and died Arthur: was fused then killed and used for decor Idk the full lore so if I got something wrong or missed something tell me (and tell me their real names)
The teachers name is Mr. Ratburn Moose guy is George I believe the bunny boy with glasses is named James And the bunny fused with Arthur is named Buster Baxter I forgot the others names tho
My favorite part of this series is in the April's fools video when Binky's smile turns into the Jerma sus guy smile and I could instantly tell where it was from 😂
What started as an Arthur Shitpost not meant to be taken as more than a joke evolved into a deep, psychological analog horror thriller revolving around deep seeded childhood innocence, its theft, and how one must cope with it. It's truly an amazing piece of art and history that made me reflect upon myself.
I used to watch Arthur with my neice and nephew in my early 20's, and even at that age I kinda enjoyed it. The humor was always on point. I think one of my favorite jokes of all time was when we find out Binky has dyslexia, and calls a kid "fudus" instead of "dufus."
If you're ever looking for something different, this account is currently hosting an analog horror series set in the JJBA universe. It's like 13-14 episodes in, midway through there's a style change that kinda makes it an experimental animation/analog horror series. But yeah like if anybody ever wanted that, it's here lol. also thanks for covering this series it goes crazy fr lmao
You know, a lot of meta sentient characters in games seem to want to escape their game, like Monika from DDLC, or is tormented by the whim of the player and is aware of it, but cannot stop it. I don't think I've seen a horror series where the antagonist is sentient, but seemingly doesn't want to escape and isn't tormented by the player. The world and its inhabitants are his dollhouse and dolls, and he wants to be left to his own devices. The ethical dilemma is that the inhabitants seem just as alive as he is, just unaware that they're in a game. After all, they aren't just parroting pre-programmed problems, they're coming forward with new problems in response to what Binky does. It's actually a pretty interesting and unique situation to think of.
Im GLAD someone is bring up this channel, I remember when I found the first part and the joke was "Haha Binky wants to fuck Mrs. Read" and then it slowly got darker and darker
I actually watched the you gotta be kidding videos before this and Someone covering it..was not something I expected. Also the title is wrong this is “digital horror” not “analog horror” and the link in the description for his channel doesn’t work. But other then that pretty cool.
I’ve followed this ARG since the first installment of it, and I’ve loved seeing it go from super niche to really well known. Absolutely love this series, it’s so funny and terrifying at the same time lol
best quotes ever “ I’ll take your place Arthur “ “ Nobody said you cant join us, Arthur. “ “ you should go to bed, son “ “ I will remain. “ “ Do not worry, there is no problem. “ “ You have sealed you’re fate. “ “ This world is coming to an end, the way it should end. “ “ But i have something else planned for you Alan, something far more worse. “ “ A celebration will be had, at the top of the twelve steps. “ “ Well Binky, I must really say, there is no problem at all, now that its just me i feel that all my problems are solved. “ “ You are the only company you need. “ “ This is fantastic news. Im glad that it turned out this way. “ “ You’re exactly right Binky, I’ve never felt better. “ “ I agree. “ “ Actually, I have one problem. “ “ Whats the problem, Binky? (x4) “ “ Now that there are no more problems, what happens now? “ “ I haven’t thought about that… “ “ We don’t need problems Binky, We have ourself and that is perfect. “ “ But if we don’t have problems, how will we continue existing? “ “ Thats the thing Binky, W҉E҉ W҉O҉N҉’҉T҉ .҉ “ “ I’ll talk to her, Emily. “ “ I’ll be your friend now, Emily. “ “ We should go play outside. “
9:22 w h a t s t h e p r o b l e m b i n k y what’s the problem bingi I laugh my ass off each time I hear the tiny what back voice saying “what’s the problem bingi”
I'll take your place, Pixels.
(For real though thank you for making this awesome video!! It makes me incredibly happy to see people enjoying my stuff and I seriously could not have done it without all the amazing folk that have been on board to do the funny voices!) ♥
@@BaileyFeesh you did the voices? bro you did good!
Haha thats awesome that you found your way here. Great series, I’m glad I found it.
you've got to be kidding!
@@trashboat4759 i think someone helped them with it.
I love "You gotta be kidding" it has to be the best and fastest shift from comedy to horror that I've seen
Gilbert Garfield did that faster.
This series feels like a dark comedy going off the rails.
That’s what I was thinking when I saw the title
@@realroforb7676
If I'm being honest they are both somewhat funny still yet unnerving
@@realroforb7676 🤓
I think it’s important to note that Binky is Muffy’s dad, and Muffy said in the first one, “Parents know best, you should do as you’re told at all times…”
🤨🤨🤨
Oh no...
It's also a reference to the episode where there's some father/child picnic or something and Buster wants to attend, but his dad isn't around after his parents' divorce. So, Arthur and friends decide that Binky will be Buster's replacement father for the event, as he's a year older. It's pretty hilarious seeing Binky try to be a dad, going fishing with Buster, spilling hot cocoa on himself, wearing a suit, playing catch, speaking down to Buster, calling him "my boy" etc. He actually was a pretty good "dad"...As good a dad as a nine-year-old can be to an eight-year-old.
@@SheilaDeBonis Haha I remember that. I don’t remember the line before it but my favorite part was when after the idea was brought up Binky was like, “I don’t see a line of dads behind me.” and he looks behind his shoulder.
I like the pfp u got going on
This is honestly the most hilarious horror series I’ve seen in such a long time
High quality shitposts in the form of a surreal-ish (idk if surreal is the right word but hopefully you know what I mean) digital horror series is something I can’t say I’ve ever seen before it absolutely works here lmao
The funny thing is, is that Binky is totally the type of person to say he's gonna do your mom. If the show wasn't aimed at kids I could see that being a re-occurring joke for him in the series.
The YFM song dropped when I was around 11, and everyone at my school was saying it. So yeah.
binky put himself in a paradox
No he's not, Binky is NINE.
@@tell-me-a-story-
*"Jimmy's mooom~" intensified*
Off-Topic but I thought this was an old comment of mine because of the pfp lol
What I love about this is unlike other analogue horrors I don’t feel like Binky’s going to harm me, I feel like he’s going to harm the other characters.
i feel like he’s gonna do more than just kill everyone, he will do worse, he will binky, binky.
Yeah it’s like we’re watching, but we can’t do anything
Yea I have a theory that, binky does not want to go beyond his reality, either because he simply chooses not to or he is unable to, and he goes on a killing spree to finally end his world.
I was the 1 thousand like
Pe
So I think I pieced the story together:
Over the course of the series, Binky gains power by feeding off of the other characters moral dilemmas, and eventually becomes the omnipotent ruler of the game. At one point, he takes control of all the characters minds (which explains Miffy’s submission to him) and eventually *becomes* them. But because (as PAD pointed out) there are no problems because it’s now a Binky hivemind, Binky can no longer feast on the moral dilemmas of others. So he brings the other characters back so he can continue to prey on their problems, but has full control over the narrative. Free will has essentially been abolished. All hail Binky
Binky has a Peanut Allergy
im baffled by every sentence of this explanation
@@laurabeane8862 shhh don't spoil the way he is going to be defeated
Just Binky.
I think there's some 'free will', there reactions are there its just they cant act against binky
I like that you can hear the voice actors laughing in the background while making the videos
Yeah lol
Funny
I miss that about the show
I've seen many "You've Got To Be Kidding" memes and not only this channel's are one of the funniest I've seen but also makes such a good transition from quality comedy to literal horror. "Binky is my father too" and then his father saying "help me" made me roll in the floor.
DW being the only one to have enough sense to leave took me out 😂.
Even the most recent one have humour
"Here's a tip! Jesus fucking christ"
I believe I've stumbled upon that first one you talked about, i didn't know it was a whole series. 💀
moufronn
Same, another one popped into my recommended a couple weeks ago and was thrown off by the direction it took
Me neither! My twin showed it to me and I couldn’t stop laughing! I had no idea this was some sort of horror arg!
I think the first one is the original. Everything else was made for the series.
i keep on seeing you every now and then, i guess ill say hello each time
love how the creators of this series leave in the laughing. love to see that theyre having a good time making these lol
“Everyone has a right to sleeping with your mother. I’m sorry if that makes you feel uncomfortable”
1. She would absolutely say that
2. everytime I see that message I fucking die of laughter (and binkey)
“Yes, are you ready?!”
She really would say that wouldn't she? 😂
this started out as like 4 friends in a discord call making a funny arthur joke and now it’s full on analog horror 💀
how does comedy devolve into literal horror
I love this series because it's not really serious and it's based off a series I like because it's just a joke
"Get over it, it's just a joke."
You know what they say, comedy and horror are just two sides of the same coin
The same way a crack au devolves into angst
@AdrianCasasantaits not 2013
its campy and silly.... giving old horror movies w the funny stuff
I love this one because they don't take it too seriously. You can tell they're having fun with it, and I enjoy that way more than the melodrama that dominates the genre
Exactly. This is the strenght is this serie.
I wouldn't classify this series as analog horror, considering how it's shown in a digital format.
If anything, I'd say that this is another addition from the Digital Horror genre, ESPECIALLY with the latest installment, having it set on a kids' computer game.
moufronn
@@moufronn moufronn
Le swaggy g
@@a_randomaccount moufronn
Like Chezzkids, has a strong analog horror vibe but used on a different medium
The most horrifying part of this is the revelation that his name is Arthur Read. Read with an A. Imagine being the only kid in class with glasses and your last name is Read. The bullying that poor kid must have endured.
Ik you all must have missed my beautiful face, sorry for the weird background. Working on a new setup so for now... enjoy the dawgs shooting pool.
I was suffering from pixels after dark withdraw
moufronn
They're good dogs, Brent.
This ARG Was NUTS
@@setsers1 what are you talking about pls tell me
"You Gotta Be Kidding" is the perfect example of how even a shitpost can be turned into one of the most intriguing and genuinely terrifying pieces of web horror of recent. Although it still keeps it's shitpost nature in certain episodes.
The “binky took D.W’ eyes” will never fail to make me laugh cuz of how chill she says it
No joke, this whole series feels like an episode that would come out of the first 5 seasons (I mean they do a noose joke and Arthur says he wants to sell his sister in another episode.
Really? Dang this show was more based than I thought
@@dontkickmychick6076 This is when Arthur tells DW that he's going to sell her
ruclips.net/video/fhIXeGKD134/видео.html
It's actually a pretty funny scene 😆
@@dontkickmychick6076 There are alot of savage moments like this one-
DW: "Hey Francine can I tell you something?"
Francine: "Sure anything!"
DW: "Why don't you go back to your own house, and stop bothering us!"
Basically DW told her to fuck off 😭
@@T_E_G this was when she wasn't invited to that bday party so she was so upset.
This went from Binky doing a Your Mom joke to Binky becoming an Eldritch God that controls the Arthur Universe.
Well, he did also make a Your Mummy joke, apparently
I think the reason why Binky tells you not to interfere is because he probably fears you. He knows you're the only one capable of taking him down and defeating him. The only one with enough power to completely strip him of his powers.
on god it went from a "hahah funny shitpost" to "binky is an eldrich god" and this is the best possible timeline for this series
I love that the VAs are just enjoying themselves while helping out with this.
This isn't analog horror, it's analog comedy.
Analog humor*
analog horror + comedy
Digital comedy*
@@schemesthefox1255 Digital horror-comedy.
Digital humor
Jesus. I'm a night nurse and was watching this laughing so much that I woke a patient. Holy hell. I tried to be quiet, but wtf. Amazing.
I remember seeing the first one and going back to the channel to show my sister because I thought it was funny...
I saw they had a second part and we decided to watch it, expecting the same lighthearted humor... we opened a wormhole to something we could never understand.
Jeez Binky- I can't tell if his first answer to Arthur's problem was creepy in horror or creepy in the other way
I think it's y e s.
Ive had the "tip: I am so fucking mad" picture on my phone for years and never knew where it came from
Lmaoo
I can’t believe I have seen the series before you covered it-
I’m honestly surprised no other channels similar to mine covered this yet. Each entry has like millions of views
@@PixelsAfterDark to be fair, it really just seems like a funny parody of horror.
@@PixelsAfterDark and memes too
I have a wild theory. What if Arthur's mother turned out to be an eldritch horror creature that possessed Binky at the end of the first episode
This makes sense actually
Imagine spending the night with someone's mom only for her to reveal that she's an eldritch beast that will curse you with an obsession with murder which will eventually lead to you having a state of complete control over what you understand as your world
@@justanotherspookyskeleton The eldritch's on that Kenjaku type shit
@@UltraCenterHQ I don't know anything about Jujutsu Kaisen (if that's what you're referencing in the first place) so I'll just assume that's correct.
@@justanotherspookyskeleton basically, Kenjaku possessed a woman to get backshots from a dude and then killed him a few years later
First one will always be my favorite because of how they all broke into laughter at the end.
Someone alert PeanutButterGamer.
Also, am I the only one who wonders if the eyes belong to something else? Perhaps some monster that resides inside Binky like a parasite and is posing as him?
Agreed!, he'd love it
Great idea!
I feel like binky said "dont interfere" as if in "Dont ruin my plans, dont get rid of me, etc"
The "You've Gotta Be Kidding" series on RUclips is amazing
It's always a good day when pixel after dark uploads.
moufronn
@@moufronn bro think he "funk!"
@@sprungle moufronn
@@moufronn yes.
@@sillyperson1610 moufronn
the very first one of these was a meme image that went around for a few years before someone did this with it! it was nuts seeing this unfold video by video lol
"Tip: I am so fucking mad" still makes me laugh my ass off
Honestly, there can be a analog horror series about anything at this point.
Hell, there can even be a analog horror series about a burger!
"I surely hope that thing doesnt get me"
I said to myself, after the comically large burger appeared behind me
Would you like a BEESECHURGER?
@@alebree6983 no one out-pizzas the hut.
The Ronald Files
@@alebree6983 pizza time pizza?
I’m glad this became an actual series, it’s so crazy how it went from a joke to something scary
The part where 'You gotta be kidding April fools' where Binky is talking to other Binkys, it kinda gives me a vibe where a serial killer is talking to themselves lol
Like (in the movies) how they're saying "The problems(which is people) are gone but what do I do now?" And the voices are like "It's time to end other problems" which would lead to more killing spree
Idk it's just my opinion :|
I’m at a weird age where I’m slightly too old for Arthur but my younger sister watched it.
The thing about Arthur is that you can watch it at any age and still enjoy it.
i can still watch some kids shows as an adult and like the escape of them form reality
I love how most of this is Bikky just saying "Haha the world is crippling under you feet!"
I feel like Marc Brown, the creator of Arthur, would appreciate the creativity that went into this horror series.
Binky becoming what he was always destined to be.. a lovecraftian horror creature!
Marc Brown would be so proud !!
Status list (so far(also spoilers (duh)))
--arthurs old dad- : dead and cucked by binky
Arthurs mom: no information
Binky/arthurs new dad/ muffys new dad/ god: a god binky binky and might be asleep
Alan/ brain: dead/turned into a binky?
DW: eyeless but no further info
That library: Probably dead or something
The poodle girl (IDK)
Mr. Ratburn: Maybe turned into binky
George: deformed
James: deformed
That ginger girl: deformed
Buster: was fused into buthur and died
Arthur: was fused then killed and used for decor
Idk the full lore so if I got something wrong or missed something tell me (and tell me their real names)
The teachers name is Mr. Ratburn
Moose guy is George
I believe the bunny boy with glasses is named James
And the bunny fused with Arthur is named Buster Baxter
I forgot the others names tho
@@bakedbaker9882 thank you
This whole thing feels like a dream you'd have after playing the You've Gotta Be Kidding! game.
To see someone finally acknowledge this series is vindicating as hell. I love this!
Fr, there's no memes of this series
Ik this is kinda old, but I agree!
OH YES IT’S THIS, I KNEW IT WAS GETTING ARG-ISH, I LOVE THIS SERIES SO MUCH.
My favorite part of this series is in the April's fools video when Binky's smile turns into the Jerma sus guy smile and I could instantly tell where it was from 😂
What started as an Arthur Shitpost not meant to be taken as more than a joke evolved into a deep, psychological analog horror thriller revolving around deep seeded childhood innocence, its theft, and how one must cope with it. It's truly an amazing piece of art and history that made me reflect upon myself.
“I’ll take your place Arthur”
Hmm binky is not only creepy but sus
It's Binky who said that, not Buster.
@@bakedbaker9882 haha I hate when I type something wrong! :’D
13:12 I love how, post-distortion, Binky’s face turns into the same face he makes in You’ve Gotta Be Kidding!’s selection screen.
I used to watch Arthur with my neice and nephew in my early 20's, and even at that age I kinda enjoyed it. The humor was always on point. I think one of my favorite jokes of all time was when we find out Binky has dyslexia, and calls a kid "fudus" instead of "dufus."
That sounds like something that would be on south park or any adult show
It's weird enough having a 9-10 year old bathe with a friend's mom, but sleeping together is the REAL horror.
I love how they try to cry and yet if they actually cry it's because they can't hold their laughter
I’m happy that people are paying this attention, it’s great that something that was satire is now actually being scary.
the first "You've gotta be kidding" video is from an old 4chan shitpost thread, I'd remember because I was there for it all unfolding
The last minute or two of this video is just great
Thank you :)
dude i remember seeing screenshots of some of these conversations online! i didn’t know they were actually apart of something lol.
The way he says "that's the thing you won't" is so haunting. It's like realty really good collapse in that moment
I keep finding myself watching this over and over again. Very excited for the next episode if it does come
“Parents know best! You should do as you’re told at all times!”
*”I’ll take your place arthur”*
i saw the first two videos when they were first uploaded, and i had no idea any of... this happened. this is amazing lmfao
Same, Baley just took the idea and ran with it
Boob
6:50
The moment that Brain was sent to the void, RUclips immeditealy gave me a RUclips Premium ad
Truly, a fate worse than death
'Tip: I am so fucking mad' has lived in my head rent-free for years
I love You've Gotta Be Kidding so much. Been my favorite video series for 2 years.
If you're ever looking for something different, this account is currently hosting an analog horror series set in the JJBA universe. It's like 13-14 episodes in, midway through there's a style change that kinda makes it an experimental animation/analog horror series. But yeah like if anybody ever wanted that, it's here lol. also thanks for covering this series it goes crazy fr lmao
Link?
@@thepikachuboy43 its on my youtube
AY Junius how you doin?
I love how even in the horror sense, everyone laughs
1) Binky's VA is killing me (in a good way).
2) THE SCREAM 💀
10:40 11:02
Is that who i think it is?
Is that Mr "I pissed on the fucking moon" "I am now sans undertale" PaperBoxHouse?
It definitely sounds like him!
Ah, what a lovely day on the internet
...
good lord.
What a wonderful kind of day!
7:23 “cuz he’s smaaaat” I will never get over that accent 😂😂
One of my fav yt series hands down. I simply love all of that stuff. Binky's madness, his voice, how cool he is, please have mercy on me binky
12:47
You did that on purpose.
Made me fear for my life AND my overheating GPU
Whoever voices Binky is amazing.
I didn’t actually think this was gonna be about youve gotta be kidding but somehow i absolutely KNEW this would be about youve gotta be kidding
You know, a lot of meta sentient characters in games seem to want to escape their game, like Monika from DDLC, or is tormented by the whim of the player and is aware of it, but cannot stop it.
I don't think I've seen a horror series where the antagonist is sentient, but seemingly doesn't want to escape and isn't tormented by the player. The world and its inhabitants are his dollhouse and dolls, and he wants to be left to his own devices.
The ethical dilemma is that the inhabitants seem just as alive as he is, just unaware that they're in a game. After all, they aren't just parroting pre-programmed problems, they're coming forward with new problems in response to what Binky does.
It's actually a pretty interesting and unique situation to think of.
13:37 Am I messed up for absolutely having a laugh at what sounds like Blood curdling screaming happening over the Super Mario Overworld Music?
'i"ll take your place arthur" i almost died from that
Im GLAD someone is bring up this channel, I remember when I found the first part and the joke was "Haha Binky wants to fuck Mrs. Read" and then it slowly got darker and darker
This whole video just consisted of me yelling/laughing
binky is a lovecraftian entity
At the end of the 3rd love how while Binky is telling Alan he’s about to die the fun kiddy music is still playing
10:40 11:02 ALFRED!?!?!
10:43 11:05 SOPHIE!?!?!
I don’t know who Sophie is, but yeah that sounds like Alfred!!
@@imaghost2961 IT IS THEM THE DESCRIPTION TOLD ME
this feels like a mix between shitpost material and straight up harrowing 2000's content
Finally somebody is talking about you gotta be kidding me! Holy shit i gotta check if there's new episodes
Arthur is over it ended
I actually watched the you gotta be kidding videos before this and Someone covering it..was not something I expected. Also the title is wrong this is “digital horror” not “analog horror” and the link in the description for his channel doesn’t work. But other then that pretty cool.
I love that it went from a joke to an analog horror, and I still can't take it seriously.
“It’s ok Arthur, Binky is my father too”.
Never knew I needed an analysis of one of my favorite series of memes/obscure videos on youtube 😂
I’ve followed this ARG since the first installment of it, and I’ve loved seeing it go from super niche to really well known. Absolutely love this series, it’s so funny and terrifying at the same time lol
The 11:30 Got me dead man💀💀💀
"You've Gotta Be Kidding!" bro was NOT kidding around😭😭🙏🙏🗣️🗣️🗣️
How tf did a shit post turn into an analog horror series?
And why do I love it?
Sad to see, after a great first episode it just went downhill because people always think it must become more outrageous or grotesque or horror like.
HE’S FINALLY BACK!
best quotes ever
“ I’ll take your place Arthur “
“ Nobody said you cant join us, Arthur. “
“ you should go to bed, son “
“ I will remain. “
“ Do not worry, there is no problem. “
“ You have sealed you’re fate. “
“ This world is coming to an end, the way it should end. “
“ But i have something else planned for you Alan, something far more worse. “
“ A celebration will be had, at the top of the twelve steps. “
“ Well Binky, I must really say, there is no problem at all, now that its just me i feel that all my problems are solved. “
“ You are the only company you need. “
“ This is fantastic news. Im glad that it turned out this way. “
“ You’re exactly right Binky, I’ve never felt better. “
“ I agree. “
“ Actually, I have one problem. “
“ Whats the problem, Binky? (x4) “
“ Now that there are no more problems, what happens now? “
“ I haven’t thought about that… “
“ We don’t need problems Binky,
We have ourself and that is perfect. “
“ But if we don’t have problems, how will we continue existing? “
“ Thats the thing Binky, W҉E҉ W҉O҉N҉’҉T҉ .҉ “
“ I’ll talk to her, Emily. “
“ I’ll be your friend now, Emily. “
“ We should go play outside. “
9:22 w h a t s t h e p r o b l e m b i n k y
what’s the problem bingi
I laugh my ass off each time I hear the tiny what back voice saying “what’s the problem bingi”
6:54 - It got right there when the evil spirit takes Binky, the unspikkable ad plays.