This is maybe my favorite of the Schubert lieder i've listened to (arghh no it's not i love a lot of them). These videos are great because it lets us read the lyrics/translation at the same time we listen to it. The poem is so beautiful!
Beautiful video and excellent subtitles which enhance the magnificent performance.The same applies to your other Fischer-Dieskau Schubert videos.Thanks for these.
I enjoy your posts so much, Karen. This was just beautiful - the performance is just incredible. Schubert is always great no matter what. Thanks so much!
First, I'm sorry bc my english it's not that perfect...but I hope if someone likes this video and sometimes check the commentaries posted here...so, if it's not that difficult or bothering, anyone of you all knows which paintings they used to do this video? The song is so nice - music, poem, but it wouldn't be so relaxing, depending of your mood to listen this kind of music, if they didn't use these paintings ...so, if it's not a problem, anyone of you knows the painters or the name ...i don't know the paintings.. so I can Google them. Thx.
I am accompanying my son for this song, and having learned it (almost) I thought I would look for interpretations of the master performers. Sacrilege perhaps, but I think this performance is a bit over-complicated, too much trying to be cute. I can't figure out the rubato in the introductions for a start. I would prefer to feel the flow between introduction and voice entry. In Verse 3 where the semiquavers start, I think Gerald throws away the potential of the "choral" left hand. Still, it serves as an interesting comparison. In the last verse, the voice is really accompanying the piano isn't it. That is more convincing, but really the version by Ian Bostridge and Julian Drake gets the balance much better.
![Felix "Unfair" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Oswujxm2Ag0/mqdefault.jpg)
selbst ich als 19 jähriger taugenichts und schläger freue mich über so ein lied un deine arbeite danke
Exquisite interpretation of another masterpiece from the mighty Schubert.
One of my favs, now enhanced with this lovely presentation... thanks Karen!!
This is maybe my favorite of the Schubert lieder i've listened to (arghh no it's not i love a lot of them). These videos are great because it lets us read the lyrics/translation at the same time we listen to it. The poem is so beautiful!
Beautiful video and excellent subtitles which enhance the magnificent performance.The same applies to your other Fischer-Dieskau Schubert videos.Thanks for these.
I enjoy your posts so much, Karen. This was just beautiful - the performance is just incredible. Schubert is always great no matter what. Thanks so much!
💛
One of Schubert masterpiece songs. A monument of Deutsch Lied of his great works.
우연히 들러 감상 잘하고 갑니다.
심연 속 숨은 나의 그어떤 것이 울컥 솟네요..
Thank you for reminding me of the song and this wonderful interpretation. The images are thoughtfully and artistically added, too.
Thank you very much!!
Very good. Thanks.
Sencillamente hermoso!!!
Beauty and didactic Job!. Congrats. Thanks.
That coda sends shivers down my spine!
Sublime!! Thank you!!
Grazie Prof
R.I.P.
Grandes interpretes de Schubert adoro suas vozes
THanks for all your videos where you have taken the trouble to give us the translation.
wunderschön! thank you so much for making & sharing:D
19세기 배경으로 ..산과 들 자연들이 엄국한 자태라할까, 침묵이 무겁게 깔려있는 분위기,.즐겁기보다 왠지 맘이 무겁고 찥은 안개같은 슬픔이 나의 맘을 감까고, 마으이 무거움을 느꼈음.....
Septembre 1815(Schubert a 19 ans;Erlköning vient 2 mois plus tard).
This song is lit
Wonderful! I would like to know the titles and the painters of the pictures shown in this video
@gatmancain Und ich für meinen Teil freue mich über so ein rührendes Kommentar ... Daumen hoch!
Sorry but I beg to differ. BOTH versions are brilliant in their own way. You should re-listen to the first version. I sing it to myself all the time.
First, I'm sorry bc my english it's not that perfect...but I hope if someone likes this video and sometimes check the commentaries posted here...so, if it's not that difficult or bothering, anyone of you all knows which paintings they used to do this video? The song is so nice - music, poem, but it wouldn't be so relaxing, depending of your mood to listen this kind of music, if they didn't use these paintings ...so, if it's not a problem, anyone of you knows the painters or the name ...i don't know the paintings.. so I can Google them. Thx.
comp.21 f.s. At 3:57 it's a painting by Caspar David Friedrich, a romantic painter. I haven't recognized the others, but if I do i'll tell you.
cette chanson je dois l etudier en fm
I am accompanying my son for this song, and having learned it (almost) I thought I would look for interpretations of the master performers. Sacrilege perhaps, but I think this performance is a bit over-complicated, too much trying to be cute.
I can't figure out the rubato in the introductions for a start. I would prefer to feel the flow between introduction and voice entry.
In Verse 3 where the semiquavers start, I think Gerald throws away the potential of the "choral" left hand. Still, it serves as an interesting comparison.
In the last verse, the voice is really accompanying the piano isn't it. That is more convincing, but really the version by Ian Bostridge and Julian Drake gets the balance much better.
Hier wächst FS nicht zur Höhe des Texts auf.
Hast du irgend Verbindung für die Bilder?
wunderschön! thank you so much for making & sharing:D