some a2k opinons i have now that the show finished
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 8 ноя 2024
- what do you guys think of VCHA's lineup?
intro & outro song: ep&tbw by lesserafim
Sub Count: 2409!
about me!
★ name: vivi (she/her)
★ ult groups: got7, blackpink, izone, p1harmony
★ i use vn editor & capcut
tags:
kpop unpopular opinions kpop confessions line distribution color coded lyrics mnet mama bts blackpink dance practice jyp entertainment survival show stray kids sixteen twice nizi project season 1 season 2 part 1 part 2 niziu jy park jypapi a2k lexus kg cristina savanna kaylee yuna kendall mischa melissa camila gina niziu nina miihi mako ayaka rima mayuka maya rio riku stray kids bang chan lee know changbin hyunjin han seungmin felix in episodes dance performance vocal performance competition show survival show twice nayeon jeongyeon momo sana jihyo mina dahyun chaeyoung tzuyu nct nation survival show opinions top picks r u next chanelle funa wonhee ily1 kishida ririka vcha savanna kg kendall lexi camila kaylee
had to change the title of this video because yt studio saved it incorrectly 😭
dude I was seriously so sad that cristina got eliminated. I totally thought that she would debut because she had ranked pretty high on all of the rankings and she was skilled dance, rap, stage presence, and she had good vocal potential. Also I feel like her attitude and personality would have added a lot to the group because she seems more outgoing than most of the other girls who debuted.
exactly :(
Yes!!
samee
I totally agree!!!
I liked her, but she definitely needed to improve her vocals. I think her vocals are what held her back.
For Cristina and Gina - JYP hinted that the staff evaluations is what kept them from debuting
gina and christina really were so skilled..
they all were skilled. All of A2K contestants. A2K survival show was based on Korean standards. The things that held back the contestants were lack of stage presence (Mischa and Gina lacked these) and lack of proper vocals (Christina didn't make it because of this). Yuna didn't make it because she couldn't hear timing. I honestly think, had Yuna gotten the timing thing down, she would have made it as a member. But not having proper timing on dance and dance moves looks really bad on stage and would have been a great hindrance to the group. They were already taking a lot of time helping her with the dance as it was. You're only as good as your weakest member. I hope she spends time to get an ear for these things--if she can. She had potential. Stage presence, however, is hard to teach. If you don't have it, it's hard to learn it. Anyway, that's my 2 cents.
that's correct, and i personally don't think yuna and mischa were ready either. but i really think gina and christina had what it took to make the group, just that they didn't fit the group as well. @@calripplebear1293
@@calripplebear1293100% agree on this, my exact thoughts. People constantly complain about those that didn’t debut, but Yuna could not figure out how to dance on beat for the life of her. Christina’s vocals were pretty awful at the last performance compared to the others and she had a hard time being on stage. Gina failed to show emotion and have stage presence consistently throughout many of the performances. Those that debuted all had stage presence, even if their skills were mediocre. Finally a comment that is clear and hits the nail on the head.
I think Christina and Gina's elimination was due to external pressure, not JYP's will. According to unofficial info, there was pressure to drop more people and select only a few people, but JYP increased the number of people.
I mostly agree with your all opinions. However, I have noticed that Gina and Christina would be eliminated. In teams performance, there were two groups, so JYP must have selected one of four members who would got eliminated.
Based on their skill and previous rankings, from first group Camilla, Savana, and Gina would have debuted, then the second group Christina, Kaylee, and KG would hace debuted.
However, JYP has already stated, their character also would be considered for eliminating. We have already known that Lexus was always in the top 3 of character evaluation. Then, Kendall has an excellent attitude according to the trainers. Therefore, they both could made it to the final line up.
JYP was right. Eliminating both Gina and Christina was a hard choice. They are great talents, yet they are just not suit with the group concept either😢
Gina did rank 3rd for character evaluation. Remember lotte park where Lexi, Camilla and Gina hanged out?
Kendall was voted last by teammates and that wasn't considered. I wonder why she was the lowest? And how come they never mentioned her character evaluation by teacher until the last minute to explain her debut. Still shady. The teachers could have said anything
@@Kaybye555I was LITERALLY wondering the same thing. Like I didn’t want to bring up favoritism (I honestly thought Gina would’ve been more favored due to her being a JYP trainee) but Kendall was definitely getting some favoritism and I think that’s partially due to her looks. Ya know visuals get the most love/attention, and it’s not necessarily a bad thing but it diminishes the talents and personality of the others. Kendall has great stage presence, there’s no denying that, but she definitely needed improvement here and there especially in her singing. I just hope she actually works hard on that and really shows why she deserves to be there. Not saying she doesn’t deserve it though, I just don’t see how she was better than Gina or Christina. Even Yuna improved to the point where her elimination/low ranking didn’t really make sense to me ???
@@nunugirlswag109I agree with everything you said, however yuna her improvement definitely wasn't "enough" compared to the others
@@tsuyuasui7297 yeah her solo performance wasn’t that great I will be honest, she could’ve done better or needed a bit more practice but I think she definitely proved herself during their Alcohol-Free performance
JYP said there were other factors and he didnt decide alone . some "staffs" snd part of the show voted for them not to debut
its really sad because the 2 has great skills . even mischa and others who were eliminated earlier have great potentials too. but hey its their decision :(
He has staff who input is valued by him. They are all experts in their field. He was left with no room to select Cristina and Gina. We only see some of the behind the scenes.
1. for GINA and cristina , i love them both and they are probably talented than some od the final members but i think the lineup is perfect cristina was criticized for looking nervous on stage and gina for me doesn't have the JYP image she's more of a yg artist
2.i wish jyp what to do with this group and doesn't mess them up and really got surprised that they promoted in korea before NIZIU cuz they will kill it
3. i think the leader was chosen based on trainers and staff not the membres cuz lexi was first from staff but second from the members behind camilla
Their song is giving popular 12 year old influencer makes a song that gets traction because of their popularity and fans alone 😭
Wow honestly agree of your opinions,as much as i loved yuna i really felt that she will not on the debut members but dang! cristina and gina? it was really puzzling why jyp decided to make it only a 6 member group when it can be an 8 member group instead
They def set Kendall up, and she got hate because of it and the favoritism and it’s crazy. I loveeeee Yuna and misha but was it was kinda obvious they were gonna get eliminated and we have to accept that but some people still can’t, they did improve a lot after their eliminations were showed though
Cristina was the best dancer in the group and also had the look but somehow JYP did not like her. Her body line when she dances is really pretty. I hope to see her on Girls Planet and it would be nice if she sturdy Korean too.
It will be called Island 2.
I think most members of Vcha recommended Camila as a leader, but she declined to be, because she knew that she is the type who are moved to emotion.
yeah, especially in JYP groups, the oldest member is usually the leader, except in some cases (ex. TWICE's Jihyo, who is not the oldest). otherwise, i mean there's Bang Chan from Stray Kids, Itzy's Yeji, Haeweon from NMIXX, etc.
kinda weird considering that Lexi is a bit younger than Camila and yet lyric channels are already ordering the group with Lexi before Camila with the rest being in their respective spots according to age.
Debut Cristina, Savanah, Camilla, KG, Lexus and Kendall.
I just think Gina and Kaylee should of been kept in JYP dungeons as trainees and debut in the next girl group. I was hoping for JYP to give them a Wonyoung and Yujin popularity promotion like make them mini IT Girls in Korea and America cuz they’re both 13/14.
Yeah and i also find it unfair that KG was 3rd place because,she didnt even dance,like yes she got great Vocals but the other girls danced so it was more difficult to sing
Kendall sure isn’t at fault but girl was sneaked into that group JYPs favouritism is crazy she sure could be an idol but I think she needed more training
Bruh i miss cristina so badly
The only opinions I could agree with 🙇🏻♀️
KG was only 3rd bc JYP wanted her on the theme song
KG placed 2nd. Pretty sure she ranked high because she improved the most.
@@bukojoetheslapsoils8273 The person is talking about the individual mission.
omg ur righttt
"kendall was the most talented" is this person on drugs? kendall is 4th for dancing, 4th or 5th for vocals and 4th for rap. just because she "conveys her emotions well" does not by any means she's the most talented in the group be so serious.
my opinion: Lexi is the leader because shes been teaching dance classes since she was 14-15 and is a World Champion for KPop dance. Also throughout the whole show everyone mentioned how and where they obtained their skills from, but Lexi never mentioned she was a pro dancer - showing modesty but hidden confidence. She also had to over come improving her vocals. Between her and Savanna, they are almost on par skill wise but Savanna was gifted with more developed vocals. Lexi showed that she is willing to out work her peers, but be modest at the same time. Lets go 🧀🦖!
There's nowhere for them to promote in the States with the strike, and they've been doing a lot of interviews for English magazines. Plus, all the SNS engagement has been fine. Plus, it was only two shows, and that's it. It wasn't an official debut.
NiziU will debut in time in Korea. They are busy in Japan right now.
They’ve got to change that name. It’s horrendous
OMG I agree with all your opinions!!
I agree with KGs ranking being a bit high-it shocked me too. In K-pop, dance is a very important factor. Even her stage presence wasn't wonderful. You could see her smile, but rarely saw that 'umph' of personality that bleeds out of talent with stage presence. You saw it in Kendall, Kaylee, Lexus, Savannah, and Camilla--but rarely in KG. But I rarely saw KGs personality come out in her dance. Not the way Korean Kpop industry likes, anyway. I think they judged based on the hidden factor of potential. In the time they had to get better--she had shown not only a lot of improvement but also quick learning and to them, that was promise enough that in the years to come, she would become a k-pop sensation. At least, that's what I would imagine them thinking.
She is also away from her parents control. Which allows her to be herself. Not how they wanted her to be.
WHAT?! Camila isn't the leader?!
I was surprised too. I think Lexi was chosen because she’s not the oldest and has had background experience with k-covers along with her team dancing wadada with Kepler that one time.
Camila proved her leadership on the show twice. So I was definitely surprised cause as far as I remember, I didn’t see Lexi take the leadership role in any evaluation, and that’s not to discredit how she helps her teammates.
Sometimes, leaders can’t be the oldest because if they are, they or the rest would feel like they’re somewhat “scary” to their younger teammates, and they don’t wanna put the others through discomfort because they’re the oldest. And I’m like, if you have what it takes to be leader and you happen to be the oldest, you should be leader no matter if you’re older. But kudos to Lexi still.
Lexus is leader cause she ranked 1st
@tzuxluvq Well you don't necessarily become the leader bc of your ranking. What if an idol is debuting and they got leader because they ranked 1st, but they don't have leadership skills? You usually give the center to whoever ranks 1st (even though I think you should give the center to the one who has the best stage presence and fits the group concept best regardless of their ranking). But this isn't me invalidating Lexi as a leader at all. She got 1st because she pretty much got the highest score. But I also think character counted in the criteria, so I can see why you think she got leader because she won 1st.
@@c.lineofficial From what I have read so far. Camila didn't want to be leader.
@@PolarticaStorm oh. ok then. I understand.
Lol @ KG sings in cursive. I love the tiktoker that does those videos. Hilarious
Actually "bichO" is bug in spanish not bicha, and it sounds alike but nobody really is bothered by it, instead we joke that the fandom name is gonna be "Vchota" wich sounds like bichota a word that Karol G popularized and is empowering lol
I thought cristina will debut actully
Sorry but how can they call themselves "k-pop group" if they don't have any Korean lyrics? Like, yes, their dances, voice, and everything is so good! But, the whole point of k-pop is a mix of Korean and English words.
They didn't call themselves korean group girl and they will probably debut in korea after 2 or 3 years like niziu did
3:22 3:25 😂lol
The lineup is meh
HERES MY TAKE BOTH CHRISTINA GINA ARE SOLO ARTISTS . IT WAS OBVIOUS TO JYP FROM THE START. HE WAS LOOKING TO MAKE A GROUP THAT WHOULD STAY TOGETHER, LIKE TWICE.
First!!
Omg if you are going to hide your voice then don’t do a RUclips channel.
Seeing the group concept now Gina wouldnt have fit the group. She could debut but with the right group conecpt. Shes skilled and she will kill it in whatever she does!
Thank u. Their group name is horrible
2 White, 2 Black and 2 Asians. Thats the line up. Christina and Gina did not fit the JYP image despite their talents.
Gina cannot show emotions when she dancezsing.She is not enjoying.She is dancing and singing bcz she has to.She only showed emotions on back door perfonmance.She didn't improve like others.Ex:Kg couldn't dance but she worked on her dance
What? There's 1 White, 1 Black, 3 Asians, 1 Latina?
@@SmallcowLoLsavanna is half Latina. Her mother is from Venezuela and her father from Trinidad and Tobago
Uhm what other black girl do you see besides Savanna 🤔
@@moonlightstay It's easier to improve when you start from nothing...and Gina ranked 2nd at the LA bootcamp so no, she was not only showing emotion on Back door...
I think Kg was one of the best because she showed so much improvement I think that's one of the reasons Jyp favored her. And I agree. She's unique and has amazing vocals. And also a lot of charm. Her dancing skills also improved a lot. So at the end of the show she definitely deserved to be one of the top contestants.
And don't forget we only see what they want us to see. There is a lot happening behind the cameras. So please take that into evaluation.
Also I'm still mad about Gina and Christina not making it. Especially Christina. She had so much charm and she was definitely keeping the group together at some level. She took that awkwardness away.