I have said it before and will say it again. Malcolm Nance is a national treasure and hero. He has spent decades literally ‘throwing himself into harms way’. He succinctly imparts his wisdom with such ease. I love him❤
We need to hear more from Malcolm, just as we need to hear more from former Ambassador Michael McFaul. Both men should be given as much media space as they think they can wisely fill as they feel they need it to make their thoughts known.
I've looked into the history of Jesus Christ and I came to the conclusion that he was either from Iran or Yemen or possibly Iraq or somewhere around that region of the former Persian empire , he was not Jewish or Palestinian or Arab , he was probably Persian , now keep in mind that I am not religious so I might be a little naïve when it comes to religious history but that is my own theory
well I suppose you could be right but I think he was from western Iran , there is no conclusive evidence about his linage other than the two major empires at the time were Rome and Persia @@carolinamoonbeam
Knowing about your background, I wanted to hear what you have to say about this situation. Thank you for your service to both the US and Ukraine. 🙏🏻 I appreciate you sharing your knowledge and fighting for democracy.
It is complicated and there are many twist and turns --but there was an invasion by Zionist that's the main issue, everything after that is just nuance. As far as the Palestinians are concerned, they have lost a lot, they endured the first invasion in 1948 where they villages were bulldozed into the ground by the advancing Zionist Army so the Palestinians could not return, millions of Palestinians were displaced and still live in refugee camps. Believe me, Its all outlined very well in a book by Ilan Pape a Jewish Historian and other books by other brilliant Jewish historians writers such as Naomh Chomsky, Professor Norman Finkelstein, and eyewitness accounts from Jewish writers such as Miko Peled. The justification for this is in the Bible the return to the promised land thousands of years later --and now with Israeli policy to use new converts to Judaism to grab land because there are not enough real Jewish people willing to do this work. A lot of this is being driven by religious fanatics both Christian and Jews --who are waiting for for the return of the Messiah when the promised land finally is returned to the jews, that will mean all the land from the Euphrates river in Syria all the way down to the Red Sea must be joined , and some land in Lebanon and some more land in Jordan will have to be conquered --a continuous war in the Middle East for many decades to come maybe many centuries to come . There was never going to be a Two-State solution and the move by Trump at the request of the Israeli government to move the capital to Jerusalem is all the proof we need as this was to be the Palestinian capital as part of the Two-State solution . One final point, the biggest and most vocal supporters of the Palestinians plight are Jews, Jewish scholars like Chomsky, Michael Horovitz, Zygmunt Bauman and others like Stephen Fry and Michael Rosen, hardly anti-Semites.
Because deep state spooks aren't on the ballot and they're a dime a dozen. I already knew his take before the video started because it's just regurgitated CIA talking points.
I second that !!! I'm in on this. Tired of fighting maga over the bridge collapse...lack of infrastructure... a barge bumping into a bridge shouldn't topple down the entire bridge !!!!
This is a huge service that you are doing, to give the general public a background, demystify some things for us! I educated myself as well as I could about the Jewish faith when my 2nd son was due on Yom Kippur, and his brother had already been born on a previous High Holy Day. Then, as I knew no Muslims, I got nicely immersed in their quotidian comings and goings, as my son lives over a mosque in Amsterdam. I went and stayed with him for a couple weeks, and from what I observed, my heart is more generous toward them. So, learning, familiarity, these are wonderful things.
That might be the case , but as usual he leaves out the crimes perpetrated on the Palestinian people , the stealing of the land the the expulsion of 750,000 people from their farms , houses into refugee camps like in Gaza . These are horrific crimes and the West especially the United States is complicit in the crime . A good start for a solution would be to admit the crime and seek to rectify it .
I agree with you. They have ghettoized the Palesti Ian's and the settlement stuff, imo, is the same as US settlers taking Native American's land. I respect Jimmy Carter's knowledge, experience and Biblical ethos and he had a lot to say about the horrible ways the Palestinians were treated.
Except he’s wrong , you cannot justify the stealing of farm today because you’re ancient ancestors might have lived there 3000 years ago . It’s BS and everyone sensible knows it , this nonsense is why Hamas exists .
That might be the case , but as usual he leaves out the crimes perpetrated on the Palestinian people , the stealing of the land the the expulsion of 750,000 people from their farms , houses into refugee camos like in Gaza . These are horrific crimes and the West especially the United States is complicit in the crime . A good start for a solution would be to admit the crime and seek to rectify it .
Once again from ignorance we have strife, from education we get empathy and understanding. Thank you for the clarity and wisdom, I will be sharing this and the upcoming videos. Hopefully discussions following these informative sessions will have fruitful results.
@DocZom So leaving out little bits like one example of Middle East turmoil is because it was carved up into little pieces by British Colonial rule after WWI ? I'm sharing because it's educational. If you want more information there's plenty of other sources out there.
@SPODA-73 I think they're saying, this isn't what academics and warfighters would use in a decision chain. The ommissions are more than minor. They were committed in such a way to truly miss the scope of displaced people during all stages of the Israelification of the region. As well as avoiding the landscape which presents all the parties and their claims or at least reasons for fighting. As with most things, there are many moving parts, but due to the nature of the arid environment, it makes THIS place a flashpoint that deserves more than a Westmoreland style history lesson then a big jump to our allies position. It comes off like the sloppy/deliberate ommissions that get soldiers deployed and people dead when they didn't need to be.
Except he’s wrong , you cannot justify the stealing of farm today because you’re ancient ancestors might have lived there 3000 years ago . It’s BS and everyone sensible knows it , this nonsense is why Hamas exists .
Except he’s wrong , you cannot justify the stealing of farm today because you’re ancient ancestors might have lived there 3000 years ago . It’s BS and everyone sensible knows it , this nonsense is why Hamas exists .
Great tutorial Malcolm! My father served in Arabia, he refused to call it Saudi Arabia, during WW2 and he had a very warm place in his heart for the emerging nation of Israel. Once we get rid of Trump and the Israelis get rid of Netanyahu maybe we can broker another peace accord like the one cobbled together by Carter and Arafat.
Glad to see Malcolm Nance admit that all of the United States is actually the territory of Indigenous American tribes. Good on him! I look forward to his video wherein he supports Land Back initiatives.
This is EXACTLY what I was thinking as he was talking... I like Senior Chief, but he has been missing the mark (I think purposely) with Israel and Palestine...
@@29thizzle He understands the history of the land, which you tend to ignore. If you think history began in 1948 you are more likely to be supportive of the Palestinians. If you recognize that the Jews are the indigenous people of the land, you tend to back Israel. The Palestinians have declared Israel, Gaza and the West Bank as Palestinian land while the government of Israel contends that it is Israeli land. Jews have lived in the West Bank and Gaza since ancient times. The Judea and Samaria Area of the West Bank covers a portion of the territory designated by the biblical names of Judea and Samaria. Both names are tied to the ancient Israelite kingdoms: the former corresponds to part of the Kingdom of Judah, also known as the Southern Kingdom; and the latter corresponds to part of the Kingdom of Samaria, also known as the Northern Kingdom. After the War of 1948 17,000 Jews were expelled or *ethnically cleansed from Jerusalem and an estimated 40,000 from Gaza and the West Bank.* Jews were prohibited from living in those territories during Egypt's and Jordan’s occupation from 1948 to 1967. Jews began to settle in the area again after it was captured by Israeli forces in the defensive war fought in 1967. Gaza has archeology evidence in the form of pottery of the Philistines who were from Greece and the Aegean Sea • Gaza has a Roman cemetery. • Gaza has mosaic flooring from the Byzantine era. • Gaza has ruins of a Christian monastery. • In 1965 Egyptian archeologists found a synagogue mosaic in the Rimal District of Gaza City - with the inscription King "David" in Hebrew. You know what they have never found? They have never found any archeological evidence of Palestinians existing in Palestine until the 7th century. That is when the Jews were conquered by the Islamic Rashidun caliphate Umar (634-644). “We didn't take a foreign land and we didn’t exist on the spoils of other nations, but on the lands of our fathers that through the years was illegally seized by our enemies. We, when we had the opportunity, restored our birthright.” _- Simon Maccabeus (135 AD)_ Simon Maccabeus led a Jewish army to defeat of the Seleucid Empire (Greek). This was prior to the migration of Arabs into Israel from Egypt, Jordan and Syria in the 7th century AD.
I've looked into the history of Jesus Christ and I came to the conclusion that he was either from Iran or Yemen or possibly Iraq or somewhere around that region of the former Persian empire , he was not Jewish or Palestinian or Arab , he was probably Persian , now keep in mind that I am not religious so I might be a little naïve when it comes to religious history but that is my own theory
It’s started when the US the UK and the UN supported the invasion of Palestine and the expulsion of 1.2 million ( not 700,000 as is often suggested)people from their homes , houses ,farms etc , when they were gone they then Bulldozed the villages into the ground so these people could not return .Most of these people ended up in Gaza as refugees, they still have the deeds of the stolen land ,handed down from father to son . The story told to Americans is that when Israel was founded the surrounding countries attacked it and that’s true , but the fail of course to tell you about the invasion in 1948 . You can go back to the Bronze Age if you want to somehow justify what has been done to the Arabs that live in Palestine, that’s going back over 3000 years , so the logic is this , you arrive to a farmhouse in the middle of Palestine, you knock on the door and you say this farm belongs to me , the Arab farmer obviously laughs in your face but 6 months later the “ land dispute “ ends up in an Israeli court in which the Judge finds for the illegal settler , this is happening every day in Israel and it’s why HAMAS exists . Without the illegal invasion of Palestine in 1948 , Hamas would not exist . This is the truth , the facts are indisputable.
It’s started when the US the UK and the UN supported the invasion of Palestine and the expulsion of 1.2 million ( not 700,000 as is often suggested)people from their homes , houses ,farms etc , when they were gone they then Bulldozed the villages into the ground so these people could not return .Most of these people ended up in Gaza as refugees, they still have the deeds of the stolen land ,handed down from father to son . The story told to Americans is that when Israel was founded the surrounding countries attacked it and that’s true , but the fail of course to tell you about the invasion in 1948 . You can go back to the Bronze Age if you want to somehow justify what has been done to the Arabs that live in Palestine, that’s going back over 3000 years , so the logic is this , you arrive to a farmhouse in the middle of Palestine, you knock on the door and you say this farm belongs to me , the Arab farmer obviously laughs in your face but 6 months later the “ land dispute “ ends up in an Israeli court in which the Judge finds for the illegal settler , this is happening every day in Israel and it’s why HAMAS exists . Without the illegal invasion of Palestine in 1948 , Hamas would not exist . This is the truth , the facts are indisputable.
@@slimdugger99As a teacher of Middle Eastern, General Jewish, Persian, Ethiopian, medieval and modern German and American Jewish history, I can say that you are correct BUT everyone needs a base from which to start. One must begin early and put in a solid base of just facts and basic common sense thinking. Will tell you this though, as much as I hold Mr Nance in very high respect, he also makes mistakes. Small ones but all humans make mistakes, what matters is how one makes them.
It’s not really complicated. If you read Deuteronomy 28, Moses tells the people what would happen to them if they obeyed or rebelled. That is the foundation right there and has been true since Moses spoke. Take a look at it.
@@bechet12your reference is an origin myth. It may make sense to you if you follow that particular religious text, but it only makes sense BECAUSE you follow that particular religious text. Even people with a religious background aren’t going to all have such a literal reading, or even necessarily believe the modern state of Israel to be a continuation of the short-lived, long defunct kingdom… because it is a somewhat outlandish premise that heavily romanticizes history with the facts on the ground. Short answer is you are making a religious argument based on your interpretation of your religion. Don’t expect other people to adhere to your religious perspective.
🤩🗽LOVE YOU SO... though we have never met....your books..your words ..your vast experience... Totally astounds me ..humbles me...MOTIVATES ME ..BLESS YOU MALCOLM.. saving USA...and our FKIN sanity.❣️🤟
Knowledge is power and heaven knows many people are not knowledgeable about this subject 😊 Thank you Malcolm for sharing your insights 🧐 Stay safe 💙💙💙🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸💙💙💙💙🇺🇸
One problem. Knowledge is power, but we, the American people, seem to prefer to be ignorant of knowledge. We want to make up our own knowledge and set of facts. Thus, many Americans have the audacity to call Israel a genocidal occupier, while in protest marches those Americans shouted, "From the River to the sea!" That chant is a call for the complete destruction of the State of Israel. The hypocrisy of that is remarkable. Malcolm spoke about misinformation and disinformation, yet reading some of the comments, it would seem that several folks missed that point. They do not have the proper knowledge from which to draw a logical conclusion. And it seems they have no interest in questioning their own "knowledge." Sad.
Except he’s wrong , you cannot justify the stealing of farm today because you’re ancient ancestors might have lived there 3000 years ago . It’s BS and everyone sensible knows it , this nonsense is why Hamas exists .
One has got to love this wonderful man. These folks have been at it since Hannibal Barca invaded Europe and held Spain hostage. What a fantastic lesson. Malcolm is about the most well-read warrior this nation has ever had. Bravo
Thank you for this. What I'm hearing elsewhere makes no sense. Later: This is the most convoluted history I've ever heard, and it's just the first part? No wonder the area is a mess.
When I was a kid I asked my mother what was going on in the Middle East. She became immediately exasperated and didn't want to discuss it. And she was educated and well read.
Malcolm, Thank you for all you do and have done in service to other's. I am always excited seeing that another new posting of yours has arrived. It's almost as if I were still in uniform serving in South Korea and have just recieved a letter from home. I know that you know that feeling...its what keeps us going! I think that you are a treasure. Thank you for providing a continuing education for us all to benefit from. Please stay safe! 🇺🇸
When I want to be a better citizen, I just go straight to the best one I know-- Malcolm Nance. Stay strong brother and keep preaching TRUTH! 💪🙌🕯️🕊️❤️🩹
VERY EXCITED for this series. This first video FINALLY made the history of these lands clear in a succinct form. The maps are excellent. Thank you Malcolm Nance! I value your work so much. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
That might be the case , but as usual he leaves out the crimes perpetrated on the Palestinian people , the stealing of the land the the expulsion of 750,000 people from their farms , houses into refugee camos like in Gaza . These are horrific crimes and the West especially the United States is complicit in the crime . A good start for a solution would be to admit the crime and seek to rectify it .
OMG. 7:58 The Holy Roman Empire was NOT the Byzantine Empire. Malcom, you got so much wrong about history in the first seven minutes I was trying to decide just how much I would try to correct. But this one takes the cake! Malcom, who was Charlemagne?
This is fantastic! So many people have never heard a word of this. It's been decades since I've seen a comprehensive map of the historical area. I was lucky I grew up at a time when these things were taught in school without a religious bias. This will be another great endeavor by Malcolm, can't wait to see it all. Thank you sir.
Malcolm you really glossed over alot. I cant really back this analysis. It ommits the alot of the why's for Jewish migration back to the area. It ommits the satuaration of Jews vs the Arabs tribes and Christians that lived in the region prior and during the British administration if the area. The ensuing terrorism and bombings against the British by the Hagganah, the Stern Gang, etc. The frustrations of the British with the "Zionist" influx which, brought violence and modern definition genocide to the population then. Forced migration due to violence being the primary tool. You just jumped to Yasser Arafat from the British administration. That can seem a bit disingenuous. This was one- sided.
He’s playing to an ignorant American audience, he’s just looking for Subs and avoiding being called an antisemite. Telling the real truth bid very risky in the US . Except he’s wrong , you cannot justify the stealing of farm today because you’re ancient ancestors might have lived there 3000 years ago . It’s BS and everyone sensible knows it , this nonsense is why Hamas exists .
@TheDoorspook11c, brother, you hit the nail on ALL HEADS. I am beginning to think that Senior Chief is bought and paid for by the Israelis or one of their affiliate groups like AIPAC. This has to be the second or third video where he completely glosses over the facts of the Arab part of the story he tells. I can't co-sign off on any of that....
Agree! What BS ~ it’s not history when you say the arabs who ‘left in the 48 war’ are who we now call Palestinians. They hardly just ‘left’ ~ expelled / displaced / violently forced out would be more historically accurate and informed. But of course this wouldn’t fit your saccharine script!
I’m so glad your voice is still out there. We need you my friend! Always enjoyed your voice, experience, and truth telling depth. We are blessed to have you “on it.” ❤ God Bless
Thank you, Malcolm! I was indeed very confused and really wanted and really needed the exact history lesson that you’re doing. I’ve been a fan of yours for several years now. ❤
Glad to hear Mr. Nance explaining the indigeneity of Jews to Israel. This is why so many Native American tribes support the Jews and their return to their ancient homeland, rather than supporting the children of the Muslim invasion. And let's not forget that ALL people are welcome in Israel, as long as they are peaceful and productive. Fully 21% of Israelis are Arab Muslims, and they consistently say they would rather live in Israel than anywhere else in the Arab world. When people say they are "anti-Zionist but not antisemitic" be sure to ask them what they would say to the Israeli Muslims, who want to live in Israel, NOT some official Palestinian state.
Right on Officer Malcolm...looking forward to your new serie to reduce our lack of knowledge of the , 'as you put it' very complicated history of that region. We appreciate and cannot wait to your story-telling sagas. God bless you
The United States needs people who are intelligent,reasonable and competent like Malcolm to lead the country. Malcolm for president. Vote responsibly. 👍🗳🇺🇸☘️
Malcolm your videos are insightful and informative. As always you are spot on with historic facts, without bias. I really couldn’t understand having to learn ancient history at 13, but so please I did now.
I have said it before and will say it again. Malcolm Nance is a national treasure and hero. He has spent decades literally ‘throwing himself into harms way’. He succinctly imparts his wisdom with such ease. I love him❤
He's never stopped serving, first his country and his community.
We need to hear more from Malcolm, just as we need to hear more from former Ambassador Michael McFaul. Both men should be given as much media space as they think they can wisely fill as they feel they need it to make their thoughts known.
I've looked into the history of Jesus Christ and I came to the conclusion that he was either from Iran or Yemen or possibly Iraq or somewhere around that region of the former Persian empire , he was not Jewish or Palestinian or Arab , he was probably Persian , now keep in mind that I am not religious so I might be a little naïve when it comes to religious history but that is my own theory
@@sinabagherisarvestani8924 Jesus was fully Jewish, descended from the family line of King David. His lineage was very well known. 🙂
well I suppose you could be right but I think he was from western Iran , there is no conclusive evidence about his linage other than the two major empires at the time were Rome and Persia @@carolinamoonbeam
Melcolm Nance, Please stay well&safe.
Thank you, be safe, and I pray for all God's children to live in peace.
Never stop LEARNING...
Amen sister!
Knowing about your background, I wanted to hear what you have to say about this situation. Thank you for your service to both the US and Ukraine. 🙏🏻 I appreciate you sharing your knowledge and fighting for democracy.
It is complicated and there are many twist and turns --but there was an invasion by Zionist that's the main issue, everything after that is just nuance.
As far as the Palestinians are concerned, they have lost a lot, they endured the first invasion in 1948 where they villages were bulldozed into the ground by the advancing Zionist Army so the Palestinians could not return, millions of Palestinians were displaced and still live in refugee camps. Believe me, Its all outlined very well in a book by Ilan Pape a Jewish Historian and other books by other brilliant Jewish historians writers such as Naomh Chomsky, Professor Norman Finkelstein, and eyewitness accounts from Jewish writers such as Miko Peled.
The justification for this is in the Bible the return to the promised land thousands of years later --and now with Israeli policy to use new converts to Judaism to grab land because there are not enough real Jewish people willing to do this work. A lot of this is being driven by religious fanatics both Christian and Jews --who are waiting for for the return of the Messiah when the promised land finally is returned to the jews, that will mean all the land from the Euphrates river in Syria all the way down to the Red Sea must be joined , and some land in Lebanon and some more land in Jordan will have to be conquered --a continuous war in the Middle East for many decades to come maybe many centuries to come .
There was never going to be a Two-State solution and the move by Trump at the request of the Israeli government to move the capital to Jerusalem is all the proof we need as this was to be the Palestinian capital as part of the Two-State solution .
One final point, the biggest and most vocal supporters of the Palestinians plight are Jews, Jewish scholars like Chomsky, Michael Horovitz, Zygmunt Bauman and others like Stephen Fry and Michael Rosen, hardly anti-Semites.
Over 99% of people on any ballot in the U.S do not garner the respect and admiration that I have for Malcolm.
I totally agree with you.
He’s totally wrong about Palestine, he’s typical American, he conveniently forgets the invasion in 1948
Because deep state spooks aren't on the ballot and they're a dime a dozen. I already knew his take before the video started because it's just regurgitated CIA talking points.
I second that !!! I'm in on this. Tired of fighting maga over the bridge collapse...lack of infrastructure... a barge bumping into a bridge shouldn't topple down the entire bridge !!!!
@@johhny711 You mean when 5 Arab countries invaded the newly formed state and Israel went to war over it?
Always on the case! Love you Malcolm!!!
What a treat🎉 Thank you Malcolm.
This is a huge service that you are doing, to give the general public a background, demystify some things for us! I educated myself as well as I could about the Jewish faith when my 2nd son was due on Yom Kippur, and his brother had already been born on a previous High Holy Day. Then, as I knew no Muslims, I got nicely immersed in their quotidian comings and goings, as my son lives over a mosque in Amsterdam. I went and stayed with him for a couple weeks, and from what I observed, my heart is more generous toward them. So, learning, familiarity, these are wonderful things.
That might be the case , but as usual he leaves out the crimes perpetrated on the Palestinian people , the stealing of the land the the expulsion of 750,000 people from their farms , houses into refugee camps like in Gaza .
These are horrific crimes and the West especially the United States is complicit in the crime .
A good start for a solution would be to admit the crime and seek to rectify it .
I agree with you. They have ghettoized the Palesti Ian's and the settlement stuff, imo, is the same as US settlers taking Native American's land. I respect Jimmy Carter's knowledge, experience and Biblical ethos and he had a lot to say about the horrible ways the Palestinians were treated.
Thank you to Malcolm Nance and team!
I love history.
Except he’s wrong , you cannot justify the stealing of farm today because you’re ancient ancestors might have lived there 3000 years ago .
It’s BS and everyone sensible knows it , this nonsense is why Hamas exists .
That might be the case , but as usual he leaves out the crimes perpetrated on the Palestinian people , the stealing of the land the the expulsion of 750,000 people from their farms , houses into refugee camos like in Gaza .
These are horrific crimes and the West especially the United States is complicit in the crime .
A good start for a solution would be to admit the crime and seek to rectify it .
Thank you Malcolm, we
need to understand.
Looking forward to the rest of this series Tx Mr Nance you have a wonderful voice
Thanks, Mr. Nance.
Thanks brother for teaching and reminding man he's not the teaching but the leaner
Thank you Malcolm!
Most Excellent History Class..! Thank You Malcolm..!
Once again from ignorance we have strife, from education we get empathy and understanding. Thank you for the clarity and wisdom, I will be sharing this and the upcoming videos. Hopefully discussions following these informative sessions will have fruitful results.
Don't share this as if it is accurate. It is not. Malcom gets a lot of it wrong and leaves out hugely important facts.
@DocZom So leaving out little bits like one example of Middle East turmoil is because it was carved up into little pieces by British Colonial rule after WWI ? I'm sharing because it's educational. If you want more information there's plenty of other sources out there.
@SPODA-73 I think they're saying, this isn't what academics and warfighters would use in a decision chain. The ommissions are more than minor. They were committed in such a way to truly miss the scope of displaced people during all stages of the Israelification of the region. As well as avoiding the landscape which presents all the parties and their claims or at least reasons for fighting. As with most things, there are many moving parts, but due to the nature of the arid environment, it makes THIS place a flashpoint that deserves more than a Westmoreland style history lesson then a big jump to our allies position. It comes off like the sloppy/deliberate ommissions that get soldiers deployed and people dead when they didn't need to be.
Except he’s wrong , you cannot justify the stealing of farm today because you’re ancient ancestors might have lived there 3000 years ago .
It’s BS and everyone sensible knows it , this nonsense is why Hamas exists .
Except he’s wrong , you cannot justify the stealing of farm today because you’re ancient ancestors might have lived there 3000 years ago .
It’s BS and everyone sensible knows it , this nonsense is why Hamas exists .
Great tutorial Malcolm! My father served in Arabia, he refused to call it Saudi Arabia, during WW2 and he had a very warm place in his heart for the emerging nation of Israel. Once we get rid of Trump and the Israelis get rid of Netanyahu maybe we can broker another peace accord like the one cobbled together by Carter and Arafat.
If trump gets backs in we're done.
Abraham Accords. Learn about it.
Excellent. Thank you Malcolm Nance!
Glad to see Malcolm Nance admit that all of the United States is actually the territory of Indigenous American tribes. Good on him! I look forward to his video wherein he supports Land Back initiatives.
This is EXACTLY what I was thinking as he was talking... I like Senior Chief, but he has been missing the mark (I think purposely) with Israel and Palestine...
@@29thizzle He understands the history of the land, which you tend to ignore. If you think history began in 1948 you are more likely to be supportive of the Palestinians. If you recognize that the Jews are the indigenous people of the land, you tend to back Israel.
The Palestinians have declared Israel, Gaza and the West Bank as Palestinian land while the government of Israel contends that it is Israeli land. Jews have lived in the West Bank and Gaza since ancient times. The Judea and Samaria Area of the West Bank covers a portion of the territory designated by the biblical names of Judea and Samaria. Both names are tied to the ancient Israelite kingdoms: the former corresponds to part of the Kingdom of Judah, also known as the Southern Kingdom; and the latter corresponds to part of the Kingdom of Samaria, also known as the Northern Kingdom. After the War of 1948 17,000 Jews were expelled or *ethnically cleansed from Jerusalem and an estimated 40,000 from Gaza and the West Bank.* Jews were prohibited from living in those territories during Egypt's and Jordan’s occupation from 1948 to 1967. Jews began to settle in the area again after it was captured by Israeli forces in the defensive war fought in 1967.
Gaza has archeology evidence in the form of pottery of the Philistines who were from Greece and the Aegean Sea • Gaza has a Roman cemetery. • Gaza has mosaic flooring from the Byzantine era. • Gaza has ruins of a Christian monastery. • In 1965 Egyptian archeologists found a synagogue mosaic in the Rimal District of Gaza City - with the inscription King "David" in Hebrew. You know what they have never found? They have never found any archeological evidence of Palestinians existing in Palestine until the 7th century. That is when the Jews were conquered by the Islamic Rashidun caliphate Umar (634-644).
“We didn't take a foreign land and we didn’t exist on the spoils of other nations, but on the lands of our fathers that through the years was illegally seized by our enemies. We, when we had the opportunity, restored our birthright.” _- Simon Maccabeus (135 AD)_
Simon Maccabeus led a Jewish army to defeat of the Seleucid Empire (Greek). This was prior to the migration of Arabs into Israel from Egypt, Jordan and Syria in the 7th century AD.
@@29thizzleHow Malcolm speak Arabic and not be Muslim
Read Malcolm’s Books. I read them all. You will learn so much.
Thank you Malcolm, you are the best, God keep you safe.
Awesome! Thank You!
Malcolm moves again in favour of humanity and knowledge.
Can't thank you enough Malcolm Nance and warm greetings from Quebec Ca.
I've looked into the history of Jesus Christ and I came to the conclusion that he was either from Iran or Yemen or possibly Iraq or somewhere around that region of the former Persian empire , he was not Jewish or Palestinian or Arab , he was probably Persian , now keep in mind that I am not religious so I might be a little naïve when it comes to religious history but that is my own theory
Since when the genocide that started on May 15, 1948 qualifies as “humanity”?
God Bless You Malcolm ❤
Excellent narrative Malcom. being a black Jew very refreshing. I say thank you!!!!
It’s started when the US the UK and the UN supported the invasion of Palestine and the expulsion of 1.2 million ( not 700,000 as is often suggested)people from their homes , houses ,farms etc , when they were gone they then Bulldozed the villages into the ground so these people could not return .Most of these people ended up in Gaza as refugees, they still have the deeds of the stolen land ,handed down from father to son .
The story told to Americans is that when Israel was founded the surrounding countries attacked it and that’s true , but the fail of course to tell you about the invasion in 1948 .
You can go back to the Bronze Age if you want to somehow justify what has been done to the Arabs that live in Palestine, that’s going back over 3000 years , so the logic is this , you arrive to a farmhouse in the middle of Palestine, you knock on the door and you say this farm belongs to me , the Arab farmer obviously laughs in your face but 6 months later the “ land dispute “ ends up in an Israeli court in which the Judge finds for the illegal settler , this is happening every day in Israel and it’s why HAMAS exists .
Without the illegal invasion of Palestine in 1948 , Hamas would not exist .
This is the truth , the facts are indisputable.
shalom mr thurman
I say, do your own research and think for yourself. Accepting someone else’s understanding of the situation is a sure recipe for being misled.
It’s started when the US the UK and the UN supported the invasion of Palestine and the expulsion of 1.2 million ( not 700,000 as is often suggested)people from their homes , houses ,farms etc , when they were gone they then Bulldozed the villages into the ground so these people could not return .Most of these people ended up in Gaza as refugees, they still have the deeds of the stolen land ,handed down from father to son .
The story told to Americans is that when Israel was founded the surrounding countries attacked it and that’s true , but the fail of course to tell you about the invasion in 1948 .
You can go back to the Bronze Age if you want to somehow justify what has been done to the Arabs that live in Palestine, that’s going back over 3000 years , so the logic is this , you arrive to a farmhouse in the middle of Palestine, you knock on the door and you say this farm belongs to me , the Arab farmer obviously laughs in your face but 6 months later the “ land dispute “ ends up in an Israeli court in which the Judge finds for the illegal settler , this is happening every day in Israel and it’s why HAMAS exists .
Without the illegal invasion of Palestine in 1948 , Hamas would not exist .
This is the truth , the facts are indisputable.
@@slimdugger99As a teacher of Middle Eastern, General Jewish, Persian, Ethiopian, medieval and modern German and American Jewish history, I can say that you are correct BUT everyone needs a base from which to start. One must begin early and put in a solid base of just facts and basic common sense thinking.
Will tell you this though, as much as I hold Mr Nance in very high respect, he also makes mistakes. Small ones but all humans make mistakes, what matters is how one makes them.
Thank you. Malcolm blessings from Queensland Australia
We appreciate all you do, Malcolm!😊
Thank you, Mr. Nance. This is such a complicated history, for most of the world. We appreciate your explanation.
It’s not really complicated. If you read Deuteronomy 28, Moses tells the people what would happen to them if they obeyed or rebelled. That is the foundation right there and has been true since Moses spoke. Take a look at it.
@@bechet12 Blah,blah blah, Your BS fairy tales are are not a foundation of anything except a cult of morons.
@@bechet12 That is simply BS.
@@flyingfishsurf please tell me why
@@bechet12your reference is an origin myth. It may make sense to you if you follow that particular religious text, but it only makes sense BECAUSE you follow that particular religious text.
Even people with a religious background aren’t going to all have such a literal reading, or even necessarily believe the modern state of Israel to be a continuation of the short-lived, long defunct kingdom… because it is a somewhat outlandish premise that heavily romanticizes history with the facts on the ground.
Short answer is you are making a religious argument based on your interpretation of your religion. Don’t expect other people to adhere to your religious perspective.
Thank you and I look forward to your next episode.
Thank you Malcolm, stay safe and look forward to your reports! 🤜🏾🤛🏼🤙🏼💪🏾
🤩🗽LOVE YOU SO... though we have never met....your books..your words ..your vast experience... Totally astounds me ..humbles me...MOTIVATES ME ..BLESS YOU MALCOLM.. saving USA...and our FKIN sanity.❣️🤟
I can't Thank you enough Malcolm! ❤️
Thanks Malcolm. I love history.
Thank you!!
Thanks again, Malcolm! A true American- thanks for your candor and very educational posts!
Knowledge is power and heaven knows many people are not knowledgeable about this subject 😊 Thank you Malcolm for sharing your insights 🧐 Stay safe
💙💙💙🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸💙💙💙💙🇺🇸
One problem. Knowledge is power, but we, the American people, seem to prefer to be ignorant of knowledge.
We want to make up our own knowledge and set of facts.
Thus, many Americans have the audacity to call Israel a genocidal occupier, while in protest marches those Americans shouted, "From the River to the sea!"
That chant is a call for the complete destruction of the State of Israel.
The hypocrisy of that is remarkable.
Malcolm spoke about misinformation and disinformation, yet reading some of the comments, it would seem that several folks missed that point.
They do not have the proper knowledge from which to draw a logical conclusion.
And it seems they have no interest in questioning their own "knowledge."
Sad.
Awesome start to the series Malcolm. Thank you! Looking forward to the rest. Stay safe.
🙏🏾❤️STAY SAFE SOLDIER, YOU ARE LOVED !!✊🏾❤️🙏🏾
Oh my goodness yes.
Thank you, Malcom. Lots of info here.
Thank you Malcolm for helping me understand. I am grateful you share your knowledge. I'm also lucky I found you.
Thank you
Historical Context, Context, Context! Thank you Sir Malcolm.
Thank you, Malcolm.
This was an excellent layout of the history of this part of our world. Thank you Malcolm
Never miss an episode 🙌
Thank you for all you do.
We appreciate such a consise & truthful reports.
So much info!! I will need to listen to this several times so it sinks in!! Ty 4 the class!
Thanks Chief. As always, great information on an extremely troublesome topic.
Except he’s wrong , you cannot justify the stealing of farm today because you’re ancient ancestors might have lived there 3000 years ago .
It’s BS and everyone sensible knows it , this nonsense is why Hamas exists .
Much thanks and admiration to you and all those helping you put this together. I pray for you and us all...God bless all of us. Thank you Mr. Nance.
You are an excellent teacher Mr. Nance. You capture my full attention and you make learning interesting.
Thank you for this teaching. Outstanding!!!
Can't wait! Wish you had been my history teacher! TY!
Malcolm, you are amazing !love you!
Very Interesting segment, Malcolm!!!
Thank you Malcom for your dedication for the cause of freedom, democracy basic human rights and dignity for all!
Thank you for the crucial information and education…
I appreciate you!
Thank you so much 😊 I will be watching this more than once❤
I was just thinking the same thing!
One has got to love this wonderful man. These folks have been at it since Hannibal Barca invaded Europe and held Spain hostage. What a fantastic lesson. Malcolm is about the most well-read warrior this nation has ever had. Bravo
Hi !!!! Malcolm good to see you again.
Thank you for this. What I'm hearing elsewhere makes no sense. Later: This is the most convoluted history I've ever heard, and it's just the first part? No wonder the area is a mess.
When I was a kid I asked my mother what was going on in the Middle East. She became immediately exasperated and didn't want to discuss it. And she was educated and well read.
@@blondiegreeneyes4802My mother would roll her eyes "A bunch of stupid men who should know better." LOL - Mom was a feminist.
Malcolm,
Thank you for all you do and have done in service to other's.
I am always excited seeing that another new posting of yours has arrived.
It's almost as if I were still in uniform serving in South Korea and have just recieved a letter from home. I know that you know that feeling...its what keeps us going!
I think that you are a treasure. Thank you for providing a continuing education for us all to benefit from.
Please stay safe!
🇺🇸
When I want to be a better citizen, I just go straight to the best one I know-- Malcolm Nance.
Stay strong brother and keep preaching TRUTH! 💪🙌🕯️🕊️❤️🩹
Thank you Malcolm you’re one of my favorite educators and certain subjects so appreciate you and your time so much. Thank you.
VERY EXCITED for this series. This first video FINALLY made the history of these lands clear in a succinct form. The maps are excellent. Thank you Malcolm Nance! I value your work so much.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Thank you for your info. I know it’s the truth
Truth be told! Thank you, Malcolm, for creating these edifying videos on Israel-Hamas. I am looking forward to part 3!
Thank you for educating the public about the lengthy history of Eretz Israel.
Outstanding history lesson! Well done!
That might be the case , but as usual he leaves out the crimes perpetrated on the Palestinian people , the stealing of the land the the expulsion of 750,000 people from their farms , houses into refugee camos like in Gaza .
These are horrific crimes and the West especially the United States is complicit in the crime .
A good start for a solution would be to admit the crime and seek to rectify it .
I will have to replay this a few times. I dont know this history. Thanks Malcolm.
Ditto
Thank you ❤Malcolm❤
Thank you ! Very helpful and informative! Stay well and enjoy your trip abroad.
OMG. 7:58 The Holy Roman Empire was NOT the Byzantine Empire.
Malcom, you got so much wrong about history in the first seven minutes I was trying to decide just how much I would try to correct. But this one takes the cake!
Malcom, who was Charlemagne?
“Eastern Roman Empire”
Agreed 💯
This is fantastic! So many people have never heard a word of this. It's been decades since I've seen a comprehensive map of the historical area. I was lucky I grew up at a time when these things were taught in school without a religious bias.
This will be another great endeavor by Malcolm, can't wait to see it all. Thank you sir.
Malcolm you really glossed over alot. I cant really back this analysis. It ommits the alot of the why's for Jewish migration back to the area. It ommits the satuaration of Jews vs the Arabs tribes and Christians that lived in the region prior and during the British administration if the area. The ensuing terrorism and bombings against the British by the Hagganah, the Stern Gang, etc. The frustrations of the British with the "Zionist" influx which, brought violence and modern definition genocide to the population then. Forced migration due to violence being the primary tool. You just jumped to Yasser Arafat from the British administration. That can seem a bit disingenuous. This was one- sided.
He’s playing to an ignorant American audience, he’s just looking for Subs and avoiding being called an antisemite.
Telling the real truth bid very risky in the US .
Except he’s wrong , you cannot justify the stealing of farm today because you’re ancient ancestors might have lived there 3000 years ago .
It’s BS and everyone sensible knows it , this nonsense is why Hamas exists .
It is very one sided. Surprised and disappointed by Nance. I’ve been following this for 25 years, and Israel is not the victim.
And all my comments stating the real history were blocked .@@lorraineclark2307
@TheDoorspook11c, brother, you hit the nail on ALL HEADS. I am beginning to think that Senior Chief is bought and paid for by the Israelis or one of their affiliate groups like AIPAC. This has to be the second or third video where he completely glosses over the facts of the Arab part of the story he tells. I can't co-sign off on any of that....
Agree! What BS ~ it’s not history when you say the arabs who ‘left in the 48 war’ are who we now call Palestinians. They hardly just ‘left’ ~ expelled / displaced / violently forced out would be more historically accurate and informed. But of course this wouldn’t fit your saccharine script!
I’m so glad your voice is still out there.
We need you my friend!
Always enjoyed your voice, experience, and truth telling depth.
We are blessed to have you “on it.”
❤
God Bless
Malcolm you are a true patriot
Excellent recounting of historical facts Mr. Nance! thank you!
Very interesting! Love to hear your take on the Israel and South Africa during the apartheid time period.
Much appreciated 🇨🇦
Thank you, Malcolm! I was indeed very confused and really wanted and really needed the exact history lesson that you’re doing. I’ve been a fan of yours for several years now. ❤
Thank you🙏🕊🌐
Thanks for your honest reporting!
Glad to hear Mr. Nance explaining the indigeneity of Jews to Israel. This is why so many Native American tribes support the Jews and their return to their ancient homeland, rather than supporting the children of the Muslim invasion. And let's not forget that ALL people are welcome in Israel, as long as they are peaceful and productive. Fully 21% of Israelis are Arab Muslims, and they consistently say they would rather live in Israel than anywhere else in the Arab world. When people say they are "anti-Zionist but not antisemitic" be sure to ask them what they would say to the Israeli Muslims, who want to live in Israel, NOT some official Palestinian state.
Thank you sir, for all you do!
Right on Officer Malcolm...looking forward to your new serie to reduce our lack of knowledge of the , 'as you put it' very complicated history of that region. We appreciate and cannot wait to your story-telling sagas. God bless you
My Goodnes Malcolm thank you for the history lesson....much appreciated!
great video . thanks malcolm . this videos should get millions of views
Thank you for great video.❤❤❤
Thank you so much for this.
I’m really looking forward to learning more about what’s really going on.
Keep up the interesting work 👍
Excellent show
Thank you, Malcolm. Looking forward to learning this history. ❤
Thank you for your information and it's cutting-edge need to know.
The United States needs people who are intelligent,reasonable and competent like Malcolm to lead the country. Malcolm for president. Vote responsibly. 👍🗳🇺🇸☘️
I'm curious to see if what you plan on teaching us matches the history that's easily available for reading. Looking forward to this. Most curious
An excellent overview of the region history.
Malcolm your videos are insightful and informative. As always you are spot on with historic facts, without bias. I really couldn’t understand having to learn ancient history at 13, but so please I did now.
Holy cow, Malcolm. Thank you so much.