1,000+ Harvard Students Walk Out of Commencement to Support Classmates Barred from Graduation
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 23 май 2024
- Support our work: democracynow.org/donate/sm-de...
More than a thousand Harvard students walked out of their commencement ceremony yesterday to support 13 undergraduates who were barred from graduating after they participated in the Gaza solidarity encampment in Harvard Yard. Asmer Safi, one of the 13 pro-Palestinian student protesters barred from graduating, says that while his future has been thrown into uncertainty while he is on probation, he has no regrets about standing up for Palestinian rights. “This is an ethical stance that we’re taking,” Safi says. We also hear from history professor Alison Frank Johnson, one of over 100 faculty members who voted to confer degrees on the 13 seniors, who describes Harvard’s punishment of them as an “egregious departure from past precedent,” as was the board’s subsequent overruling of faculty. “We hoped then that the Corporation, as it has always done in the past, would accept our recommendations for degree recipients and allow the 13 to graduate, which they chose not to do.”
Transcript: www.democracynow.org/2024/5/2...
Democracy Now! is an independent global news hour that airs on over 1,500 TV and radio stations Monday through Friday. Watch our livestream at democracynow.org Mondays to Fridays 8-9 a.m. ET.
Subscribe to our Daily Email Digest: democracynow.org/subscribe
I’m a 79 year old citizen of the USA 🇺🇸 and I stand with the students. They still have their moral compass 🧭
Me too!
Me too!
They have been totally brainwashed by Marxists and Islamists.
I always want to ask the people who are against the student protests, when have College students protesting AGAINST: War, Genocide and APARTHEID ever been on the wrong side of History??
They have NEVER been!!!
Hell yeah. It's Vietnam all over again, eh?
Respect to students and faculty who stood up for free speech and right to peaceful protest.
Hell no. No respect for these pro-HAMAS criminals.
Clearly the administration (which either hasnt given reasoning or wasnt presented in the video) feels they violated the overall code of conduct that is the agreement which grants people who abide by it the protest rights. For argument’s sake, this sure sounds like “2,000+ people violated our code of conduct, but only these 13 went far enough that we feel punishment that deters one of the key tenants of our academic mission is warranted.”
@@GraceCole-qy6ul It seems likely to me that these 13 were the most righteous threat to Harvard's corrupt complicity with Zionist genocide.
Amen
No it is not a free speech. They are support terrorism
I am 69 years old and about to witness the fall of my country
What a sad state of affairs
I'm 72 and feel the same way.
I'm 74 and I fear for my grand children's future
Putin and Xi love the new America dearly, all 3 countries are at the same level 🤣
Unfortunately it’s been a long time coming..
I'm 59, and the fall of the country is in no way guaranteed. What about us, and what we do about it? The sad state of affairs is that millions of Americans have not risen up over many years to make the country better. Why do we sit by and let things happen that we say we don't like? Has the country ever been what it should have been? Why do well-meaning people keep voting for Democrats when they've done nothing significant for working people since Medicare in 1965? The Affordable Care Act did help millions of people to get health insurance, but millions of others still can't afford it, so it was not a solution. But we didn't need more private health insurance that may or may not approve to pay for a treatment. We should have had Medicare for All, which Obama said he supported as a Rep. in Illinois. We should have long ago increased the Pell grant to pay for tuition, but Jimmy Carter gave us increased student loans. We should have turned the minimum wage into a living wage, but Democrats put it at $7.25/hr in 2007. We should have strengthened unionization, subsidized child care salaries, put Pre-K salaries on the same level as other teachers, lifted the Soc Sec tax cap, etc, etc. We can have all those things if we do something to get them. Vote for someone who supports them all. Fill the government with people who care about us.
Like Prof Richard Wolff said, private universities don't pay taxes and they get enormous subsidies, also their grants effectively come from the government. So they are public-private instiutions funded largely by taxpayers so they should be accountable to taxpayers.
Similar to churches?
FBL.
For what
money buys evil over and over again, the USA is finished as a moral leader.
It's always about the money.
"Harvard Corporation". Let that sink in.
All higher ed institutions are running on the corporate model. A shame.
Approx 1 $$$ BILLION $$$ in FOREIGN admittance GRAFT, in 2019 alone. (largely UN-reported FBI investigation)
USA is also a registered corporation😊
Charvard Lubovitch....life in putsched usreal😢😮😮😮😮
@@kareemsalessiUnited States of Aiipac?
Shame on Harvard. What a cruel joke.
Truly cruel
But you still want their degree right?
We all knew it was a globalist training center, right?
Y'all were totally onboard when South Africa got stymied...80 years of propaganda ain't fixing that.
@@Abrakadabra_fokus_pokusUNIVERSITIES RECEIVE PUBLIC FUNDS. HOW THEY SPEND OUR MONEY IS A PUBLIC MATTER.
This just proves how far this university has fallen and is failing higher learning.
u sound like a trumper lol.
its the fact that uni are doing what they should be doing that students are protesting..... lmao
seems more like everything is about the same as in modern history
Oh boy the poorly educated speaks.
@@Krack2805 ROFL Go team blue 🤑🤑🤑💰
@@tyronewashington230 lol and all u know is red vs blue. high school dropout
@@Krack2805 There is only team blue 🤑💰🤑
How can they deny students from graduating? This is not charity, students pay a lot of money to attend Harvard University and in return they are denied their diplomas after studying for 2/3 years... 😳
Is it legal to do that in the US? They should be sued, it's outrageous!
There are literal scholarships
He FAFO😂
Down with ALL elitism!
Down with the world wide Empire! All of them and restore the real world.
You all are FOR islamism?
@@EnchantEmerson It looks like you misread the message within the original comment.
Fund public universities.
@@Klppp556 really?
Feeling so bad for the 13 students that were not allowed to graduate. SHAME ON HARVARD😡
They should wear it like a badge of honor
Same! I’ve always dreamed of going to Harvard but now I am disgusted by them!
🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
@@MJ18888💣🧒💣🧒💣🧒💣🧒👿 Netanyahu 👿 Netanyahu
Exactly! Ridiculous 🙄
They have to realise who donates to universities in the US.
Mostly the Arab Gulf countries.
American Taxpayers
Many universities are private you donate nothing
@@charleenmcdade9168false
@@MultiDaniella14 thank you!
Good on these students. To walk out instead of taking their degrees. To say no to Harvard. To say no to having a Harvard degree.
Hello, in the Real World, a Harvard degree is now USELESS. Businesses for example, will no longer hire these communist kids. They are on high alert to avoid all graduates.
She is 100% right and Harvard should be ashamed.
Way
Nah, Harvard did the right thing. Antisemitism shouldn’t be tolerated.
Mind Begs the Question:
▪︎If a Govt/Corporates/College
▪︎Criminalize protesting against
▪︎Starvation,Death Camps,Gas Chambers/White Phosphorus,Dehumanization,Pogroms,Mass Graves,Ethnic Cleansing,etc
▪︎Pro Democracy or Pro Nazi?
@@davidc9214 Protesting the horrific Israeli treatment of the Palestinians is not anti-semitism, son. It is exactly what places of higher learning should be bringing attention to.
@@HumanBeingsRThinkingBeingsProtesting for the "right" of Hamas to commit genocide against Israeli civilians, and use the homes of 2.4m Gazans as cover for their terror tunnels (a crime against humanity, btw) is not as admirable as you may think. It's a shame our universities became factories of anti-Western Marxist Leninst indoctrination, instead of centers for inquiry
I am a 50 year old Aussie man and I LOVE these students. The future is bright and those now in power should fear it.
I love them too. I wish I could say the future is bright, though.
Vietnam was highly protested too, but the generation after those protesters were the baby boomers - the worst generation in American history... I worry that those in power are functionally beyond consequences.
@@monsieurdorgat6864 I understand but I think with the advent of social media and non mainstream propaganda we now see people looking behind the veil of lies and secrecy. They have been exposed and the damage is only going to get worse for them. Hence the banning of tik tok and censorship legislation coming in. They now need to control the flow of news. They’re panicking.
@@monsieurdorgat6864 Ironically my original response below was deleted 😂 I will adjust so it hopefully doesn’t get deleted.
i said, it’s a different time now because we have social media and people can now get the truth. People are leaving paid corporate media. They’re banning free speech because they can’t control it. This time is different.
@@monsieurdorgat6864 I tried to write a response stating this time is different. People now have social media and get the truth without the mainstream propaganda. It’s different now. (twice I have tried to post this and ironically got deleted both times 😂)
@@monsieurdorgat6864 I tried to write a response stating this time is different. People now have social media and get the truth without the mainstream. It’s different now. (I have had to re write this 4 times. Ironically it keeps getting deleted😂)
Don’t go to this university stand for human rights
Then why they are still there 😂😂😂.
Their are millions of students are waiting outside for an opportunity to study. Not for protesting. Ok you have your own opinion, but college campuses is not for protesters. If you want to protest, first you must resign from the college and student visa. Go Gaza and westbank stand with the people who are victims (from your point of view).
That is the exact place where you talk for human rights, btw, you wont even get admission to harverd. you are a low level thing.
@@sarathchandran3503 LMAO, YOU ARE DEF AN ILLITRATE, have you ever read history? every single revolution started from college campus. you guf
@@sarathchandran3503 your name is indian or srilankan, who are you to give your opinion? do you even have citizenship of US?
America is not America anymore
Indeed, many of its citizens will not sit idly by as it aids/funds a genocide!
It never really was
When was America America? Please explain. We saw the same during the Civil Rights Movement, Vietnam, South Africa, Iraq... I am not sure what America you are referring to.
Do not get me wrong. It is not like America does not have good qualities. It certainly does. But NO rights have ever been given without an immense fight and consequences. The ruling class(es) will neve give up any rights unless pushed to the abyss...
@@EleneDOMIt was never " GREAT" for Black People 🤦🏾♂️.
It was founded on the genocide of one race and the slavery of another. It was never free to begin with. Nowadays ordinary Americans are robbed with their taxes going to war lords instead of benefiting American citizens.
Universities: We encourage you to think critically.
Also universities: no, not like that.
Critical thinking, huh? You are joking right?
Those "educated" idiots know nothing about the history of that land or the conflict. All they are capable of is bleating the childish talking point of the day.
That is the result of being taught what to think instead of how to think. They have unknowingly melded into the monocular leftist hive mind. That is pathetic.
Accurate
You're not allowed to think critically about Israel in the USA. Or you will be deemed a terrorist and hamas supporter.
lol brain rot
No wonder your gov is captured by Israhell .Thats why the rest of the world called it the US of Israel
Harvard is NOTHING without their students
LOL Wrong, they are nothing without the money.
I believe you can pretty much say that about every university.
@@srsmopar3808 Not funny. What they are *with* the money simply should not be respected.
@@srsmopar3808 they get their money from the students tho. they get their money from the prestigious name that the students bring them because they go on to become lawyers, doctors etc. so without the students they are nothing
Those who Don't Learn From History, are Doomed to Repeat it....
The decadence of the US colleges and universities started on October 7th, 2023. There is no future in USA with this people. Very disappointed.
ELITES LIKE TRUMP FAMILY SUPPORT THESE SCHOOLS.
Stop our tax payer money from funding Harvard!,
Dems forci. Certain students to leave. The colleges couldn’t protect them from Dems. Imagine that. Jewish students. Told you can’t come to college. Thats Biden’s 🇺🇸. They’re worried about 🇵🇸 while poor & Blk communities suffer here. Look how full of h8 & division they are. Come party with us checkout all pro Trump rap songs. Stop listening to lib media that wants you to be ashamed to be 🇺🇸. But celebrate stuff that was already excepted. You just want to push communism behind fake oppression. Lib media never mentioned Billy Chemirmir. 22 elderly women. But all Wht in Biden’s 🇺🇸. Why didn’t the media cover it. Cause violence sells & so does division. To get Dems to peacefully protest Blk communities down.They have to do out of freedom. And never fix it . “we make Dems first while they keep us last” Malcolm X. Biden’s 🇺🇸 amazing
Elites fund Harvard. Folks like Trump family.
Lol. Ur country sucks.
Huh? It's a private university, funded by donors, research and exorbitant tuition.
@@girasoljardin3314 Stop all public funding of schools. Send all the tax funds to the parents in the form of a education credit card and let them fund the schools they think are best for their kids.
Well done, Shruti Kumar! Bravo. Congratulations!
More power and best wishes to all those 13, who are discriminated against.
not discriminated against. Legally protesting is good, illegally protesting is not.
Yes. Well done. Viva all students.
Who gets to decide what protesting is illegal. That is bogus, it is discrimination.@angeloscalabrin3982
How can you say it's not discrimination when none of those undergraduate students are white, but of other nationalities? As far as I've seen, all of the protesting students on all these universities are exercising their rights according to our First Amendent and are protesting peacefully. Maybe you need a copy of our Declaration of Independence and the Constitution of the United States of America. Hillsdale College has them available for free.
Genocide lover @@angeloscalabrin3982
There are freedom fighters at Harvard! Love this! There is hope for our youth!
Very proud of them.
LOL, the most privileged, highly educated, dolts.
Do you also care about the Hamas leaders earning billion of dollars, they have cars, houses, everything and the Palestinians get NOTHING? Do you know that shouting free Palestine means to be against basic human rights and to be for a terror organization that has been a catastrophe for the people in Gaza? For all the arrogance of the radicals of Islam, many victims of it, of sharia law have found asylum in democratic nations like Israel and America/the West. When you continue to shout free Palestine, you continue to be against Western democracy because Hamas is not a freedom organization, they want Israel and the West to be destroyed and you are just one of the few puppies they control. BE smarter. 🇺🇸🇮🇱
I have hope for the future because of these brave young people standing up for their RIGHTS!!!
@@christinepeach8213 They have zero future after being arrested for supporting terrorists.
“Our expression of solidarity became punishable” THAT PART was done over and over and over again to many students with unnecessary violence against them all over America. They should all sue for that.
You have no right to freely choose solidarity, if you are a citizen, your solidarity should be with that country and its policies
SO proud of those students who walked out standing for the right to protest. Sickening that other students are penalized for speaking out against REAL crimes against humanity so savage as to be almost incomprehensible.
As Benjamin Franklin said: YOU KNOW WHO HOLDS THE POWER WHEN YOU KNOW WHO IT IS YOU CANNOT CRITICIZE. It is crucial for ALL Harvard professors to not prostrate themselves to that power before it crushes us entirely.
The best point; the actual moral of the story!
I notice the "academics" sat around her all pulling neutral facial expressions, fearing any expression of enthusiasm might amount as support. "Facecrime" is now a real thing
Yes I noticed it too
No love is what we are practicing
If we choose not to be fair to all blood pressures inside of us
Stop hurting or using energy for subtraction of ourselves
Maybe they didn't support her hate mongering, terrorist supporting and antisemitic views spoken from a place of privileged victimhood. Like freedom of speech means anything to these people unless it is theirs.
omg lol
Face criminals..
Good! Stand up for your rights. That university had absolutely no right what so ever from denying those 13 undergraduates diplomas just for using their Freedom of Speach.
They do, your mixing up protest and occupation, and public and private property.
@miller486a no they don't. Protesting is not related to education
@@miller486a Did you also speak out against Palestine OCCUPATION?
@@StarrlaRoThey do. Those “students” did not hold up their side of the agreement.
@@mohamedismail2485blah blah blah
And Harvard dare to put VERITAS on the university emblem. Shame on those who protest against "Freedom of Speech."
What ? Veritas shouldn’t get the same rights as YOU ? Freedom of speech as long as it’s in your favor, right? 😊you clown 🤡
We need to open quality, non corporate influenced colleges. Knowledge is free. Access to it needs to be, too.
She has more balls than all of the faculty behind her.
(Edit) Consider this: three of the five in the majority SCOTUS decision, Citizens United, v SEC were Harvard law grads. This decision was an interpretation of the 1st amendment that basically gave more power for freedom of speech to wealthy individuals, institutions, etc. Yet students protesting genocide are being denied their 1st amendment rights. And because of Citizens United, AIPAC is able to earmark $100,000,000 to oppose Democrats who are not supportive enough of Israel. I won't even get into the neoliberalism of universities and the control of universities by donors. Nor will I address academic incest or excellent sheep.
I have great respect for this woman. But some comments seem more concerned with "prestige" or choice of turn-of-phrase than with freedom of the individual or the 36,000 Palestinians murdered.
The people on that stage is university administration for the most part. The top dogs are always very far removed from faculty and students. Trust me. They are on another planet and all they care about is pleasing the BOT.
Duty of Uni admin include facilitating peace for study, They cannot allow freedom to disrupt. Condemning them for doing their duty is insane.
she got balls i couldn't tell
OVARIES for her, not "balls".
Hearing her speaking, tears came to my eyes and I was unable to hold them from flowing along my cheeks. Powerful speech.
What a brave young woman. We applaud you for standing up for us all.
She has a clear-eyed understanding of the situation and the moral strength to face down those on the wrong side of history.
Will you ever speak up for Armenia tho?? We have ALREADY BEEN ETHNICALLY CLEANSED FROM OUR GAZA BY THE HANDS OF ISRAELS GENOCIDIAL ALLY AZERSHTSTAN. WHY WE ARE ALWAYS BEING FAILED BY HUMANITY😢
Go Shruthi Kumar….proud of you….a future President in the making…..congratulations….keep up the Strength….the World supports you for your Courage and Peer Support…..👍👍👍🙏🙏🙏❤️❤️❤️🇺🇸
Speak for yourself, because I don't applaud her one bit, do your own research
Brave, Brilliant Shruti Kumar. Her parents must be so, so, so proud of her.
Congratulation to all the students who tried to say the ugly truth. Free speech.
PROTEST YOUNG PEOPLE . ALWAYS DO IT IN PEACE AND RESPECT. FOLLOW THE LAWS . ALWAYS SHOW THE WORLD THE INJUST TREATMENT FOR PALESTINE. AND TOO MANY OTHER CULTURES THAT ARE LIVING WITH HUNGER. NOT HOME. NO OPORTUNITIES. NO SOCIAL JUSTICE.
YOUNG STUDENTS PURSUE THE TRUTH. THE RIGTHS THAT ARE DENIED TOO MANY.
Congratulations to these brave patriots who stopped other American students from attending classes and moving freely within the Universities. I'm sure they will write books about themselves and leave the parts about their hatred for their neighbors out of them. True heroes.
I am proud of the protesting Harvard University students.
These young people are making me proud everyday!
Another person who never got an education.
@@ms-zi4wc Why the hate? I am a professor and exceptionally proud of our students!
Some young people are a curse of the world. They demand freedom to distroy and distrupt.
Do not give them a good job
maybe you can offer them a job. Doubt they're capable of doing anything substantive.
The world hears you loud and clear. BRAVO BRAVISSIMO for standing up for Palestine ❤❤❤
Harvard and its open admissions policy will backfire soon enough. Look at the idiots they let in thee days. DEI? Let 'em have it.
🛑🛑🛑🛑🛑🛑
WHY THE CHRISTIAN PRINCE WROTE A BOOK TITLED SEX and ALLAH!
WHY IS AGAINST THEIR LAW TO QUESTION ISLAM?
WHY THE CHRISTIAN PRINCE KEEP EXPOSING ISLAM AS AN EVIL BUTCHER BLOOD THIRSTY CULT?
ALONG WITH THEIR Allah god. WHICH IS NOTHING MORE THAN A TORSO WITH 2 RIGHT ARMS.REALLY? HE SAID . ( GOOGLE THE IMAGES OF THEIR Allah god) AND DISCOVER THE MONSTER. ALL SUPPORTED BY THE Quran Sura 5:64.
WHY 50,000 THOUSAND MOSQUES HAVE BEEN CLOSED IN IRAN? SO MANY QUESTIONS .
WHO STAR THE WAR❓
🛑🛑🛑🛑🛑🛑
These are the foundation of which our great Democracy was built on . We chose, not to eat AIPAC 's BS. Because we have a mind
Wait a minute, these are the most brave and gifted young men and women, the American future, period.😮
If it weren't for the young people of this country -- who have not yet become jaded and cynical -- America would be lost. It's the young people who keep the idealistic heart of this nation beating.
❤🎉❤🎉
You are milking Western democracy go to any Arab country and stand bold and talk
@@maxdok10Da heck're you talking about?!? Americans live and work in lots of Arab countries.There are American doctors in Rafah.
@@maxdok10You think Arabs don’t protest?
Very Good People of ALL ages, religions, race, nationality (and whatever else identifies them) stand up for justice but empire, capitalism and exploitation works to suppress dissent so that the message doesn't catch on and the people who stand up for justice will feel more alone.
She made the Israeli lobby piss their pants 😂
And some of those sitting robed behind her! 😂
😂😂😂😂 exactly
Yeah look at their faces 😂
One black lady sitting behind them could not mask her joy and pride she felt hearing a student speak truth to power.
Saame as the iof
The two Harvard students who spoke have everything: a moral compass, education, intelligence and youth. All success to them.
SHE SHOULD READ OUT THOSE 13 NAMES SO WE ALL KNOW WHO THE HEROES ARE.
The heroes who denied other Americans from their liberties based on the race. They taught the government a lesson by openly showing hatred to their fellow American students.
So proud of our young people! They are more than smart but also with a conscience! Bravo
They're the black & white generation. They'll take the lead to change the world.
Say that again when they are blacklisted and unemployed! 😂
👏 👏 👏
You were barred from graduating because you were a very good boy! Peaceful protest is what you say you do, but I believe that you were not peacefully protesting that is why you were barred! Especially when you’re out there saying death to America and death to Israel! I hope you’re sent home too!!!
Why weren’t you able to say the truth here, I wanted to hear that. They didn’t mention what you did to deserve to be barred from graduating, that was left out. tell the whole story, maybe show some videos of why they barred you. I’m very interested to know why, otherwise I can’t sympathize with you.
I'm sure you were proud of the Brown shirts and the Black shirts. Never a problem finding ignorance and prejudice out there.
If this young lady is what we have to look forward to with our children, I'm overwhelmed with hope for the future of our country. Bravo to her. Much respect.
Free America from AIPAC
Free Americans from CAIRO.
All around the world people are proud of you for future of real democracy and social justice in America and around the world 🌎.
Perhaps you should understand what democracy is. The elites rule the peasants. No different that what is happening
We need a university system not captured by corporations and the government.
It’s there own greed
Will you donate to help finance that?
@@jon123xyz
Yeah, it's called taxes, which are being squandered on the Pentagon.
Harvard is a university captured by Nazis and pro terrorists instead.
@@jon123xyz I would say to maintain its integrity they would have to have limitations on the size of donations or you just end up with Harvard.
We protested the Vietnam War.
We protested South African Apartheid.
Now we protest the crimes of Israel.
We are students, and we know our strength!
Hell
Yes
✊🏾
Will you ever speak up for Armenia tho?? We have ALREADY BEEN ETHNICALLY CLEANSED FROM OUR GAZA BY THE HANDS OF ISRAELS GENOCIDIAL ALLY AZERSHTSTAN. WHY WE ARE ALWAYS BEING FAILED BY HUMANITY😢
And we are always right in the end
Student protests are an American tradition ✨✊✨
How dare you comparee the Vietnam War with responding to rape and brutal sadistic murder by people who cross your border and kill unarmed civilians? Are you really that stupid? r just venal (look it up)?
Open for those who will value education.
Their are millions of students are waiting outside for an opportunity to study. Not for protesting. Ok you have your own opinion, but college campuses is not for protesters. If you want to protest, first you must resign from the college and cancel your student visa. Go Gaza and westbank stand with the people who are victims (from your point of view).
Well, they need to learn about following laws too!
No university has the right to deny a degree to a student that has satisfactorily completed the required course. I call that abuse of power. Shame on Harvard!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
How did you come to that conclusion?
How did you come to that question? Emotion or Logic...?
Je croyais qu le premier amendement existais … ces n importe quoi parce que des sionistes gouverne Harvard en donnant de l argent ..aux moins ils ont étaient courageux de garder leurs avis et franchise .vous avez emporté 2 fois votre diplôme bravo
True. Harvard took money in exchange for a certificate. What students believe is irrelevant.
Total nonsense, NO STUDENT has been denied a degree. As I explained all 13 will get their degrees, just not at commencement, I call your post full of. ignorance, lacking in facts and knowledge that are easily obtained just by reading basic newspapers. I'm an alumna and we all know exactly what;'s happening . This isnt even new. Any student not in good standing for any reason ( incomplete course, didnt pay tuition, whatever) is treated the same. You march wtih your class. And yes you get your degree. read The Boston Globe, The NY Times, The Harvard Crimson ( you can see free online instead of the utter garbage on this board. ) Shame on YOU for poor reading comprehension and failure to obtain facts.
Nothing but respect for these young people standing up for the Palestinian people.
And for their own freedom too.
Lol what happened to they fight when they killed over 50,000 kids in Syria or the 20,000 in Lebanon or how about all the killing going on in Africabut sure as soon as Israel defended her self that when they care
@@iamlight3020 A massacre is a massacre,by any means. Israel and "Africabut" what ever that means. It's not defence it's Genocide. and the world knows now.
@@iamlight3020did you say Israel is defending itself. Where is your brain
They had better sit down, and do their research on Palestine, some people just go with the crowd
I've always loved faculty that prioritize and love their students. Those are great teachers, and they deserve to get paid BANK for that.
Proud of this professor . Glad she said she’s supporting them
Harward's students. You are heroes 👍👌👏👏👏👏👏👏
In my book too
YAWN!
International shame on Harvard
These young people are amazing!
Thank you students for following your moral standards
Most "professors"/Careerist are trying to maintain their tenure ... very cowardly
As if they didn't know this was gonna happen absolutely dense.
Yes how dare they want to keep food on their tables like you and anyone else and want to educate students. Statements like this smell more and more like fascism every day.
@@janewright315 Then you clearly are clueless on the definition of fascism. Let's just say: you didn't graduate from Harvard. :)
@@steelguitarunionhall lol the personification of dunning kruger here trying to school people.
@@janewright315 What happened to the other 314 Janewright's?
I can’t tell you how much it means to me that this brave young woman stood up for life and for freedom. I’m an American living in Egypt for 18 years now, not far from Gaza, where my son’s best friend lives. His name is Yusuf, he is 15 years old, and running from place to place in Gaza to try to save his life and his mom’s and two brother’s lives. Yusuf calls my son as often as he can to tell him he’s still alive and ok. There is a name and a face to each human being you at Harvard are standing up for, and you gave something so precious you have been working for: your futures, your time, all those hours you studied hard to graduate, your hearts and souls, to stand up for those being murdered in Gaza, those bright young students in Gaza who will never graduate. I needed hope myself, I needed to see someone in my country cared, you gave that to me, and to the people of Gaza. The Gazan’s know you are doing this for them, and just to know you care means the world. I love all you students so much!
Beautiful. Thank you!
♥♥♥♥ Beautifully said. Thank you for sharing your story. I pray that Yusuf and his family will be safe. I pray for all of our Palestinian brothers and sisters. Sooner or later, justice will prevail, and everyone will get what they deserve.
🤡
Why haven't you invited your son's BEST FRIEND AND HIS FAMILY a safe place to come to like your house? Apparently it's not that important that you are willing knowing that they could be killed and you sit there in your safe space doing nothing to help...
@@annmhmoore0771 People can barely get humanitarian aid IN to Gaza, you think that they are going to let anyone leave? You think that the people in Gaza haven't already tried every avenue of escape possible? Your response reeks of arrogance born from ignorance.
I LOVE her confidence!! Her stance gives me chills. I feel her emotion and this left me teary-eyed.
That's the spirit Harvard! In this case to protest is not only a right but a duty! Defend you integrity! Go Harvard!
Hear here!
‘If liberty means anything at all it means the right to tell people what they do not want to hear.’
-George Orwell
The students did! But you can't infringe on other people civil rights. That's unlawful! Encampments in non-zone areas. Unsafe structures were put up. The hazardrous sanitation was involved. Unlawful check points on others, students' right to study without interruption and tension. All campuses provide an area to debate. Did they get a permit to protest? All students signed an affidavit to follow campus rules. They were city ordinances that were broken regarding hazardrous waste. There is no open room to get an ambulance in case of an emergency. Think breaking traffic laws! It brings caois.
"The world is like a ride in an amusement park, and when you choose to go on it you think it's real because that's how powerful our minds are.
The ride goes up and down, around and around, it has thrills and chills, it's very brightly colored, it's very loud, and it's fun for a while.
Many people have been on the ride a long time, and they begin to wonder, "Hey, is this real, or is this just a ride?"
And other people have remembered, and they come back to us and say, "Hey, don't worry; don't be afraid, ever, because this is just a ride."
~ Bill Hicks ~
That also includes the right to suffer for your actions.
@@elainestone6151OK boomer
may God protects these rightful students, God bless them Amen
I feel bad for those students and their parents . It's a shame what we have seen and heard from our authorities behaviors lately. We can't believe it sincerely.
Their are millions of students are waiting outside for an opportunity to study. Not for protesting. Ok you have your own opinion, but college campuses is not for protesters. If you want to protest, first you must resign from the college and cancel your student visa. Go Gaza and westbank stand with the people who are victims (from your point of view).
Free US from AIPAC
Exactly. It is their capture of these institutions and our government that is at the root of a majority of this country's problems.
Good luck. At least for now!
AIPAC Campaign contributions: $6.3 Million. Lobbying $3.9 million
Meta/Facebook Campaign contributions: $1.4 million. Lobbying $19.9 million
Soros pumps more than $28 million into Democratic groups for 2020
Free US from Qattar!
Yes, free and brave for openly showing their hate to the races of students who their teachers hate. So brave and noble.
Thank God for the students who won't be silenced
Sure. Harvard Corporation, let that sink.
Students are our strength while majority is us are cowards.
13 Phds in morality humanity and awareness have been earned !
👏👏👏👏
💯📠✊🏾
Send them to Gaza with their degrees. Let's see them apply what they leaned. Entitled ingrates. You can have them.
WOW WOW WOW! I admire all you brave students! Thank you!!!
Wish you bright future!!!❤
How beautiful to be unbiasedly human. Love you wholeheartedly
Same "OLD" Corporate RACISM!
How can this be legal? These students have paid for their years of education, haven't they? In my country, this decision would be immediately sanctioned by the Ministry of Education, the University would be blamed and obliged to give these students their diplomas.
Welcome to the capitalist state of america
In your country, you don’t have an extremely rich of white members on the board dictating policy at a private college who can do whatever they want.
🤷🏽
In our country that same minister presses for more students to be deprived of their rights
They Should All Sue ⚖
What a firebrand. Go girl. Made my hair stand on end. This is the voice of a new America speaking. The old guard better listen up.
The Women are Rising!!!
OUR FUTURE BRIGHT LEADERS OF THE WORLD. I AM SO PROUD OF THESE COURAGOUS STUDENTS
The courage of these young people is inspiring. Thank you for having more integrity than those in power!
Resistance is hard and tedious but will pay out without any doubt.
Beautiful! A lot of fidgeting and blood pressure rises going on on stage behind the first speaker!
😂😂😂yes I noticed too
LET THEM WALK
We must continuously exercise our freedom of speech, to keep our rights. LET FREEDOM RING.✔💯❤
The students are right! Hold strong. Shame on USA.
The students are ignorant. They need to get a job and read a book.
All those students need to have their degrees cancelled, just my opinion.
I have great respect for the students
@@ms-zi4wc Nah, I think you're the one who needs to do some basic research. And stop believing what FOX tells you. 🙄🤦♀️
Idiots, hooligans, no need of such students,when you come to university campus,you come to study, America be Strong
Honor for those brave young students who dare to confront the injustice in a country were the color people's civil rights are violated on a daily basis.
Respect to the students rights to be manipulated
Good let them keep walking~
How dare these college deprive our students from graduation and from having their degree after 3+ years at college and taking their tutition . Shameful behavior of this and other colleges and university. Road scholar deprived kidding me. Well done young man. May God bless you always.
Those barred students should sue Harvard University!
@@Xioxermi2024 I’m sure they could get crowd funding to do so
You know they only have the right to have the opportunity to be there, right? Not the right to graduate no matter what?
@@GraceCole-qy6ul Harvard is enslaved to its Zionist-linked donors. The corrupting effect of that on the education Harvard offers is obvious.
Never happened and that speaker knew . Everyone of those 13 marched and will receive their degrees when they have their disciplinary issues sorted out. that was never in doubt. Please learn to read -The Harvard Crimson, NY times, Boston Globe ,anythign with actual facts.
The face of anger of some of the self-important people in the back. “HOW DARE THEY STAND UP TO GENOCIDE???!!!”
Why is this “genocide” more important than the at least 3 other ongoing ones right now?
Wicked assholes!!
That's university top brass administration. They inhabit a parallel universe from faculty and students. Trust me.
Their are millions of students are waiting outside for an opportunity to study. Not for protesting. Ok you have your own opinion, but college campuses is not for protesters. If you want to protest, first you must resign from the college and cancel your student visa. Go Gaza and westbank stand with the people who are victims (from your point of view).
You have thought about this for no more than 3 minutes to conclude what you said. Give it time and question it yourself. Say "hmm what if I'm thinking wrong about this". See where you might end up if you give it more time and patience. @@sarathchandran3503
Love everyone standing up for the rights of the downtrodden.
Freedom of speech does not mean freedom from its consequences.
Agree!
A college degree vs fighting to save 5.4 million lives. Its not a moral dilema.
I pick the 5.4 million people every single time.
@@MsHarpsychord Better option: do both. (I got my degree and worked for 4 years for an NGO in Guatemala & Jamaica.) It takes more effort, but much more effective
Kudos to these magnificent young people who will lead the Planet to a new era. A new paradigm is emerging and has no place for colonialism.
Arab leaders colonized their own people, stop 🛑 milking and abusing Western democracy if you don't practice one
Exactly 💯
Yawn!
I want ALL leftists who hate colonialism REMOVED immediately for they are colonialists, too. Hello! My family came to the New World way back in 1600. All my ancestors lived on the frontier for the following 4 centuries. 99% of the USA are IMMIGRANTS who INVADED North America. So all must leave NOW, right, you young communists. GO HOME.
Well spoken! America has been falling apart for a long time. Injustice, inequality and the lack of democracy, human rights, freedom of speech and choice is deeply disturbing.
Uhm wow yes absolutely... go to Teheran and tell me
Its just for pictures and parents anyway. You still graduated when you completed your requirements. No loss.
That's right! Stand up for your fellow students. You are the great future of the USA! STAY STRONG. NO MATTER HOW HARD THEY TRY, THEY CAN'T STOP YOU NOW!!! 👊✊ THE REVOLUTION WILL NOT BE TELEVISED;💞💞💞💞💞
Such a brave lady.
Well done & God bless you & all those who still have their humanity intact.
One day and somewhere these students will be honored in the best way they deserved….
Let them go and hold on to their graduation dilomas
It's great to see young people finally beginning to understand the irrevocable value of free speech .
Except that they are often branded as "woke"!
Well said!!!
How is it well said? Speech Supporting terrorists or being antisemitic? I don't think so not in this country.
This country is tottering if this i# our future
@@barbaraschwimmer1338 The country has been tottering under the lunacy of woke . What is happening now is a good sign .
behind her they sit... thin-lipped, with no minds of their own. In front of her... the future speaking out
They can't believe what they hear from this courageous young woman.
Behind her they sit thinking of the woke new generation full of entitlements
That is messed up what they doing to you guys Harbour I would never send my kid to it. Just raining money.
What a crock!
Those people who were sitting behind her had no shame!
They clearly did. Did you see the looks on their faces?
We hear you here in South Africa. Raise your voice louder. Don't tire.