How A Quiet Place Is Slowly Destroying Its Legacy
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 23 июн 2024
- When it first debuted, A Quiet Place shocked audiences not only with it's mostly silent audio, but the world it created felt familiar and unique at the same time. First time director John Krasinski caught lightning in a bottle with the first A Quiet Place movie, so naturally a sequel was fast tracked, and when A Quiet Place 2 dominated the box office, it was only a matter of time before it got the prequel treatment with A Quiet Place Day One. The only question is, are franchises doing them selves a disservice by over saturating their own market with sequels and prequels?
#aquietplace #johnkrasinski #aquietplacedayone #nerdstalgic 
Развлечения
"Not Every Successful Property needs its own Franchise."
Couldn't have said it Better myself.
This sounds like a quote that the meme guy says to business execs before getting thrown out of a high rise window.
For our sins we deserve eternity in hell, but God loves us so much he came as Jesus to pay the price of our sins through living a perfect life for us, his death and his resurrection so we can be forgiven and receive eternal life if we follow and obey him in faith FOR LIFE , Jesus loves u and desires to have a personal relationship with you of love, peace, redemption and obedience ✝️ May Jesus bless you, repent of your sins and turn to Christ before it's too late 🙏🏿❤️❤❤
@@IamWone Do you think spammers get into heaven?
Horror works as part of the unknown. The more we know, the less interesting it gets. With very few exceptions, such as Aliens which completely changes tone and style whilst keeping the Xenomorphs secretive, turning horror into franchises turns them into diluted shadows of their former self.
this! this is why people love cosmic horror movies like alien or newer ones like Annihilation. you don't know what's going on that's the fucking horror.;
Agreed. I think Aliens could be classified as an action more so than horror, which I think only strengthens your point
Speaking of the topic of both properties, I heard from first reactions that A Quiet Place: Day One is the Aliens of the franchise whereas the first 2 films are like Alien.
@@theSuperviLLain_est the Alien went from a stalker/serial killer horror to swarm action horror like zombies and kept the same spirit of fear and there is still so much we never learn
Aliens is better than Alien so hopefully this new Quiet Place is at least better than the second one.
The concept of "Franchises" really has destroyed a lot of properties. Trying to turn everything into a cash cow usually has negative consequences overall. Sometimes, an idea is best left as a singular idea.
Do you have a career or a job? The concept of franchise is the only thing that work. People like you complain a lot, but you're not going to watch original movie and then they flop in the box office.
There is no negatives consequence "overall" just the last/latest movie flop. The first and second movie were profitable. If the 3rd one fail. What "overall" consequence?
Since Marvel turned out as big as it did, everyone wants their own Marvel now.
Horror movies have been doing this since... Forever?
I just rewatched the second one and thought it was pretty damn great. I hate this idea that “bad” sequels ruin the greatness of the original. There’s 3 pretty poor Jaws films that follow that perfect original and no one seems to care.
Bad sequels totally ruin everything if they are too canon
Those movies are kind of seen as a joke. It's not that they make the original less great, it's that they dilute the concept juat for a cash grab. The movies are easy to ignore but what about all of the time and resources spent to make them. Wouldn't they be better spent on another original concept?
I'm with you. I loved the second. And it appears this new one is great. A bad sequel or prequel doesn't ruin anything.
@@rafresendenrafresenden.1644 The sequel to the Jean Claude Van Damme movie Kickboxer kind of ruined the first movie for me because the main villain used a gun to kill the main characters from the first movie. How "happy" can an ending to a movie be if you know that "canon" will cause the main heroes to all get machine gunned within a few weeks after the film?
I also had a problem with THE SCORPION KING by Dwayne "The Rock" Johnson because the canon of the Mummy films establishes that he turns into a terrifying monster.
And if you decide that the sequel is not canon then the original is still great but the sequel becomes pointless.
@@Magdalena8008sFor what it's worth, someone did mention that for them a bad sequel can ruin the original-- they said liking the original will be disappointing because it'll make them want to watch the sequels even though they know the sequels are bad. When a good movie ends and there are no sequels, no one will be itching for more. But if there are sequels, some people will feel compelled to keep watching. I personally can isolate every movie but that's only because I always expect sequels to be disappointing. But for some viewers, if the sequels are disappointing it could actually detract from the enjoyment of the original film. That was an interesting perspective someone shared and I found it insightful.
I quite enjoyed watching a quiet place 2 and didnt see anything wrong with the story and how it affected the original. Their are definitely other movie franchise's that suffer from sequels but a quiet place is definitely not one of them.
They got one great movie... and then started milking it non stop destroying the whole magic of the 1st one
Yeah, pretty much.
"Milking it non stop"... aren't we only on the 3rd film in the franchise? And the last one 4 years ago?
@@atlasrises4Why not just make 3 original films instead of trying to milk as much as possible out of one concept?
Hollywood is really good at that, the Matrix entered the chat.
@TheMusicRoomWA still with the "milking"? It had 2 sequels in basically 6 years, a pretty normal rate for sequels
This should be a criticism of BAD sequels, not good ones. "Milking" a franchise has a negative connotation because It stems from soulless executives cranking out soulless movies just as a cash grab. There is nothing wrong with sequels when they are cared for.
Finally someone speaking the truth here
There’s nothing wrong with sequels but the quiet place franchise is at risk of following a similar route a bad movie franchises. That’s what nerdstalgic is trying to say.
Well Part 2 is bad so
@@WowItsJake 91% critic score and 92% audience score. While you may not like it, most people did
@@WowItsJake It most definitely is not. Not as good as the first one, but it is by no means a bad movie, or a bad sequel.
The concept of Day One seems reasonable to me. This is something where you could show how different people dealt with the same scenario. The first movie shows us how a family dealt with it (though not on day one until the sequel). Now Day One is showing us how people in one of the biggest loudest city handle it. They could branch out and make international versions that make their own commentary (like Godzilla)
It’s just complaining for the sake of it. People want to act like they’re not “preserving the sanctity” of the first film by making more, even though it really changes nothing. Besides, horror movie concepts tend to suck, so getting multiple films with a concept that actually works just makes sense.
You’re part of the problem
@@ninjanibba4259 cope
@@EdmundSnow98 that’ll be you
@@ninjanibba4259 And what is the problem exactly? People enjoying things instead of whining and crying?
They should have just jumped straight to "Day One" after the first film, this world has so many things to explore through different protagonists.
Agreed 💯
There's literally only been one other movie
Pissed me off in Saw X how the woman knew John Kramer was Jigsaw, she talks about him likes he's a celebrity....but it's in the timeline between Saw I and II barely anyone but Amanda and a few cops knew about Jiigsaw let alone his real name...If they jump around in timelines too much they should never make these kind of errors.
John Krasinski knows a thing or two about how to keep a series way past it's prime.
The first movie was so good that a sequel was kind of pushing it in that case. Of course, it's inevitable when a movie does that well, but seeing them line up different projects at once makes me feel like it's already less special.
By streaming standards ‘Birdbox’ was extremely successful. If I’m not mistaken I think it is still the most streamed original movie on any streaming service.
Unpopular opinion...they could do many more of these and I'd be here for it. The concept leads to so many realities for people around the world who had to survive
Agree
I agree, it could explain more of the monsters backstory
@@Vertex_vortex that's honestly what the franchise is missing.
I agree with you. I really enjoyed the second one and I thought it was really well done. I'm excited for this 3rd one
No, it’s the same thing no matter what
You’re part of the problem
Artistic Bankruptcy
Arcadian definetly took inspiration from the film.
Could you start putting movie titles in the corner of clips, like Studio Binder? I really want to know what film 7:23 is from
It's from Alien: Covenant (2017)
@@Miq__06 thank you so much! Cheers :)
Not every movie needs a sequel 😔
Agreed, "The Iron Giant" from 1999 is a perfect example in my opinion.
@@sirbughunter9972
I wouldn't be surprised if we saw a live action adaptation.
i like the first 2. And i might like this one, haven't see it yet. BUT what i wish they had done first was wrap up the story we were working on. When last we left the family was separated. Regan had made it to the radio station and her mother had saved her brother. But then what? Give me something to wrap it up have the humans beat these stupid monsters and lets call it a day. THEN if you want to do a day one prequel in a city, fine. Could be a fun spin off. Just seems out of order and gives the kids more time to grow up and look older. At this point i'd say they need to do a time jump if they come back with a third film to the original story.
I like the part where after driving in the car honking to attract the alien, parking at the house, putting kids in closet to hide, go into the garage and then proceed to LOUDLY argue why you need to leave to save YOUR family only to get taken out by said alien. Like wtf was the whole purpose of that dude? He lasted all of 10 minutes and died like a chump
Honestly, the first film was a rare occurrence of me actually wanting more information. I love Part 2 as much as Part 1, I’m very excited for Day One, and hope they end after part 3.
They thought they were doing something after the first movie. Like it it was just okay 😂
They changed horror forever!!! 😂
The more we know there's less to fear for the future
The first film was all you needed. It was so unique. Using sound, deafness, and sign language.
I actually really liked the second movie; except for the part where Djimon Hounsou's character suddenly decides to go back to the village after honorably luring the creature away from it, then gets himself killed in the process.
This same character by the way, is in the upcoming 3rd part. I'm not quite sure how they will make him look like any less of a doofus after a move like that.
Don't be so judgemental if still haven't seen Day One. Part 2 was a worthy successor and it could have been a disaster.
The first movie is the poster boy for “Silence is Golden”
I have a feeling(hope) it's Paramount forcing John Krasinski ala WB with The Wachoski siblings and Matrix sequels
Uhh no dude I hope the exact opposite.
I hope he actually has a vision and cares about maintaining the quality of this franchise, and isn’t just making cash grabs out of it.
@@haphapp7282they are cash grabs
@@haphapp7282 very optimistic of you, but very often it's greedy studios in this current time with their "franchise" and IP driven model that are pushing creatives to milk as much as they can from each property.
They will keep milking it. Because no matter how much we whine for new original ideas. We do not want to spend time and money on something we are unsure of. The main reason for the first film's success was because of the positive reviews, and word of mouth. Now, here we are six years later with a prequel coming out, a game releasing later this year, and a fourth movie releasing next year. They are milking this as much as possible before most people get sick of it. I still consider the first to be the best.
Okay how the hell are you guys doing these text effects? Where they’re behind the characters in the scene. I assume it’s done in After Effects, but I can’t figure out how.
Finding a way to fight back at the end of the first movie COULD have led into a good actionized sequel, had they committed to a full genre change like aliens did, I don't know if it would have been a good movie, but having a proper action sequel with a group of people actively hunting the death angels would have at least been more interesting world building than the toe the line sequel we got that wasn't sure if it wanted to be action or horror so it settled on being nothing
I can’t wait for A Quiet Place: The First Hour
So what you're saying is, they pulled a Halloween.
It’s the new Cloverfield, which is ironic since they were going to try to make this be apart of that universe
I will never understand the love for a Quiet Place. I walked out of the theater so deeply confused. The entire concept of the movie was undone by the waterfall scene, and when you dig into the logic after that the whole movie falls a part.
I haven't seen it but it never appealed to me. The rule of being quiet is so uninteresting. Like I can already see the places you could take that concept before I watch the movie. Its scope is very limited. Also, I like dialogue. It makes scenes more interesting and relatable, regardless of what kind of movie it is. The whole quiet thing seems like a novelty gimmick instead of a terrifying situation. And not a fun novelty like a ball and cup. More like a pet rock. 😂
@@TheMusicRoomWAit’s fine if you don’t enjoy the concept but many people such as myself really enjoyed it. Not everything needs to be catered to everyone
One movie would be enough in my opinion but i really like part 2 as well.
My only issue was the monster design. It felt too much like a generic scary videogame/movie monster. It's scary enough through it's presence and actions and i hoped for a more memorable design.
I'd like for the 3rd one to be a "actions have consequences" kind of thing. For them to notice "hey our movies got louder" and so in the third one everyone is playing fast and loose with their sound, to seemingly no problems but then it's just a MASS attack on all the people from the aliens who have been slowly surrounding all these burgeoning places of gathering.
Then it it cuts back down to people going "oh shit, right, quiet" and the final act of the movie goes back to the style of 1 where people are ultra careful about their noise.
Id argue that getting louder each movie could represent man rising up against the aliens
How did they get named “Death Angels”? Was that shown in the film? Is it what the entire world had agreed on?
In the first film, they had a wall with a collection of newspaper clippings. One of the headlines called them 'Death Angels', so fans just took that and started calling them that.
I thought the first one was kinda revolutionary, and the second one feels like a totally different tone. I think the ending of the first one is so powerful, you feel for the family, you root for them, and then the second has this sort of invincible thing, where it seems impossible that they would survive but through luck they do. If they really wanted to make a second movie, I think they should've done the prequel thing with the family, and not a sequel. I will be watching the prequel now, but I think it will be more anchored in action than horror.
Jeepers Creepers, Cube, and Taken come to mind for movies that had a strong start, a sequel that had its good points, and then just kept going off into the unwatchable territory after that.
I really hope this third installment will be good. I like action, horror, sci fi, etc and I think what may help this new movie work over the second one was something this video points out. He mentions that the second felt like it was stuck between the first movies more family oriented story and it trying to get into more action. it felt stalled between two ideas. What this one has is an entirely new cast, so as long as they give us a reason to want these characters to live and give us something new then I think it will do well. I always like the idea of horror movies expanding into its universe when done well like what marvel did during its first couple of phases. I like the idea of knowing how others survived something and especially in a city. Its just that usually these franchises aren't written well but I really want to be optimistic lol. All I know is I like horror, action/horror, etc so Ill still probably enjoy it given that Lupita can do no wrong in my eyes with whatever she's given.
Hollywood doesn’t care about quality after a first good movie. It then becomes solely about making money.
It makes me think of something I hear Quentin Tarantino say in some interview and I'm paraphrasing... "The Matrix was one of my favorite movies until the sequels came out"
I think Day 1 has the potential to show us something interesting. A combination between action sequences and slowly working out how to avoid the creatures. There's opportunities for gun fights and loud sequences, but also tense moments and stress. If they do it right, they can do part of what made the first movie so good whilst keeping its, ironically, both original and cliche 😂
I liked the sequel and looking forward to part 3
I still have never seen any of these but I did notice how the franchise seems to be being milked currently. Which, doesn’t make me even want to watch the first one now because I know how much I’ll like it and then be upset when I see any of the sequels.
Interesting. I didn't realize how sequels affected enjoyment of the original. Or I couldn't explain it at least. Thanks
Also someone mentioned canon, like if we're supposed to believe the sequel exists in the same world as the original (which is the point of a sequel), then obviously there's going to be a sense of continuity. It's weird to make a sequel that's like "Ok, here are all your favorite characters back to continue their adventure! Oh, but if you don't like it just pretend it's not the same adventure!" LOL canon is canon. Of course the sequel affects the original. That's what it's supposed to do.
The box office success of the second film speaks for itself. When something is really good, people want more of it. The internet has made everyone think they’re some sort of art preservationist that gets upset when a piece of media “can’t be allowed to stand on its own”. This is how the film industry has always been and there’s a reason for that.
@@dustinwalters2728 that’s really funny. This whole time I thought my comment was about my personal opinion and how it affects how I consume modern movies. But just like your…whatever comment about the “internet”, it’s also littered with people who just want to argue for the sake of arguing. Case in point.
I wasn’t even aware there were sequels until now
The second movie was great though. Well-acted and didn't reveal too much information to us. And the world/setting is interesting enough for me to be curious about it's origins. I'm personally excited for the prequel and am actually hoping they release *another* movie after this that goes back to the original family.
I tried to give the 2nd film benefit of the doubt back when it was released. But goddamn its literally the same fucking movie
I like the first movie but I just can't really suspend my disbelief that the world fell to blind melee aliens that you can still kill in 35 million different ways.
The scale should've been more like the Mist, where it's a town or a single city that's fallen to these creatures, cut off from the rest of the world somehow.
Dairy milking refers to the practice of raising cows to produce milk for human consumption.Separation of mothers and calves: Cows naturally form strong bonds with their calves. In dairy farms, calves are separated from their mothers shortly after birth so the milk meant for the calf can be collected for human consumption. * Artificially increased milk production: Cows are bred to produce much more milk than they would naturally for their calves. milk is meant for their calves, not humans.
Shout out to the No One Will Save You movie. A home invasion/alien movie with no dialogue!
I hype for Day 1(ones up in the air for Roman’s dad), but after that am checking out.
I got to 3:02 and realized this wasn’t a silent read along video, my headphones just didn’t connect to my tv 😂 so I was actually watching it in silence, not because I had to.
The aliens are the same as The Future Predator from Primeval.
It’s not milking anything it’s giving fans more stories and more situations that without expanding the movies we wouldn’t get quit being so negative
What do you mean slowly after the first it was just a 90 degree drop
Cmon dude let’s be real the sequel was decent
I love this channel, but day one hasn’t even come out yet and nerdstalgic is already saying that this franchise is destroying its legacy! SMH
I still don’t understand what’s wrong with prequels needing to flesh out how the events occur leading up to the other movies that follow
Yes, I want to see the 3rd film and i'm excited about it. But something told me that the critics would be coming out of the swamp to disparage it.
I know Terminator 2 and Aliens (shown here as an example of successful genre-leaping sequels) are highly regarded but I still very much prefer the tones of their original predecessors as well.
This is only adding to the “I want to complain about this, that and other” crowd of movie goers (knowing they’re going to go see it). The first one was excellent and I loved the sequel. I forward to seeing “Day One “ this weekend.
I think at least if the sequels are good I could care less if they make it a franchise like if it’s not a jaws situation then who cares if they milk it
Watch out, A Quiet place creatures taking up with Bird Box creatures in "Avengers, Age of Creatures" coming to a cinema near you.
The _Purge_ Universe only went where the audience led it. The first film was criticized for setting itself with in the McMansion of a wealthy white family, avoiding showing the actual Purge Night the movie was centered on and making its message about classism an afterthought. The future movies, well-reviewed or not, show the carnage, focus on the victims, and answer questions about the implementation of the event.
I was taken with the novelty of the movie using so much silence that it could also make attending audiences equally as quiet (quite the change from the phone using, food munching, whisper/talkers in most movies). But like 3D, the novelty is not enough when you apply some logic scrutiny to how some things play out. I'll let the scientistic and writers hash those points.
It was good, it's good enough for me, but not great anymore
IF they want a bombastic prequel, makes sense.
Saw Day One yesterday and so far there’s been 3 very good movies imo. Yes I think the first one is a classic, but the other films have been dope and very well directed man. I look forward to the next one.
I mean the guy that directed Pig is directing quiet place day one so I’m all in.
Seeing that the 416 honey badger is a real bullet n those things react to sound with violence, posting up with a decoy that makes noise out there n waiting for them to come in. Theres nothing organic a 416 can't get through
Quiet place part 3 is being release in 2025 right?
You could say that it's been "QUIETLY" falling apart!
I thought that would have been a better title too
what legacy? it was a movie that was a bit different. then they milked it some more and I care even less
Yes, it was extremely unique and one of a kind. But I don't mind returning to that universe. The second movie was great too. I hope # 3 is likewise strong... but I'm not put off by the return to the universe. I rather like learning about the landscape of that reality.
The problem with A Quiet Place 2 we thought we were getting Day 1 we had only seen the trailers showing us Day 1 and that was the marketing for a Quiet Place 2. Day One is still a great idea and a great movie. Also I understand by not making a sequel and all that but this movie made a lot of money so it’s going to get one. They would be stupid not to make one and A Quiet Place Day One is needed that’s the movie 99% of the people asked for. Yes we wanted to know and The First Purge that came out 2018 was the best one so I mean I get it but it works
What the what? I thought that was Shia LaBeouf. My memory is messing with me.
Show dont tell is always a great way to go
I wasn't too big on the second A Quiet Place movie and the upcoming prequel... seems fine, I guess. Although, a friend of mine gave me an interesting perspective. His eleven-year-old son enjoys horror movies, but obviously, he doesn't get to watch rated R movies. So, movies like A Quiet Place (rated PG-13) are huge for him because it's a new horror movie that he can actually watch.
As much as I dislike the concept of good movies ending up into rotten franchises, Day One is actually something I'm really interested in seeing, because, the franchise here is doing something most horror/post-apocalyptic media don't do -- it sets the movie right at the start of the apocalypse, so you can see how civilization reacts and falls to the cataclysm in real time. Most other franchises chose the route of "let's just have a little exposition or flashback of the past while the main show/movie itself takes place years after the apocalypse and follows a stereotypical group of survivors in a lonely world."
My family saw the first Quiet Place. We loved it. But then we didnt think about it again. We didnt see Part 2 and we have no interest in seeing Day One. Im sure i will watch them all eventually because I have to finish a series once ive begun it, even if it takes years. But eventually I'll get to it
7:22 what film is this?
Alien Covenant I think
@@m0n4rch24 thanks!
That's how it goes...
I may or may not have seen the movie through those pre-release survey things, and it may or may not be a very good movie.
I’ve loved everything the quiet place has done so far so if they keep this quality up idc how many they make I’ll keep watching them. The great things about movies are you don’t have to watch them and you can ignore and forget the bad ones. So no I don’t think bad sequels/prequels ruin great original movies the concept has always been ridiculous to me. I can understand loving a movie and not wanting to see something negative or bad associated with it but the only thing that can ruin a movie is if say 25 years later they re-edited it into something you don’t like then only release that version of it from then on and all the original releases are destroyed/lost or the format isn’t playable on modern devices or something but how often does that happen in the modern day lol that’s like losing a license to print money, especially if the movie was a hit
Hollywood studios: "yeah, but we LOVE money!"
I just have to say that I saw a trailer for “the first quiet place “ or whatever tf they’re calling it and had to laugh out loud that the tactic they were going with was the director sitting in front of the character and “reassuring” us that this one is different and new . Like dude imagine the trailer for the movie being someone selling you the movie bc you already know it’s shit 😅
If a sequel ruins a movie for you, that’s more a matter of personal fragility than it is the movies problem. And if a sequel sucked I could understand that feeling a little more, but Part 2 was a phenomenal sequel. At this point I think people just want to bitch for the sake of bitching.
exactly people don’t realize that shit all in they head.
While the sequel is decent, but I can’t forget (or forgive) the thing they did to the guitar-amp…when there actually are battery powered amps, which that one clearly wasn’t! That scene was so frustrating to watch 😅
What's wrong with pounding synth scores?
What are yall on the first two are amazing , this is only the third movie with a A Quiet Place name
How’s that, they’ve made two excellent movies & if the new one is on that par with the other two then they’ll be in the conversation for best trilogy
It just feels like they're dragging it out. If theres more to this do it in a tv show.
What's Next After Day One
Day Two
Never seen any of them...don't plan on starting now.
"Bird Box" was a novel written years before "A Quiet place."
I saw the first. Haven't been interested in watching anymore after that great movie
Stick with the first one.
The mist does not have a weak ending (IMO)
theres also a quiet place game coming up lol
MMMM I thoroughly disagree I'm loving where they are going and slowly getting close to finding out more about the creatures and how things all started
It did in the first place
lol
I didnt realize there was 3 movies. I thought day one was rhe second 😅