I saw something on the internet that was about the bones of a girl found in a cave whose DNA showed that she was half Neanderthal and half Denisoven. It isn't hard for me to believe that I could have that kind of blood in me because my family blood comes from Scotland, Ireland, and Sylvania. I think it is Awesome! Thank you for putting this on the internet for me to see! I am now 86 years old as of January 3rd, 2023 and I love the internet. 👵🐈⬛🐈⬛ me, my 2 kitties Teo and TwoTwo
We all Europeans have their DNA because 750 million of us come in some way from the original settlers of Europe alongside further waves that came, the Neolithic, the Yamnaya, etc etc... If you have Haplogroups U (like myself) you know your maternal line goes back all the way to Ice Age Europe. But even if you have H (a Neolithic farmer haplogroup) since we are all so mixed up you still have DNA from them (just not your haplogroup). I for example have R1b, which is Yamnaya, pastoralist from the Russian Steppe that came into Europe bringing the Horse, the wheel, and warfare 5000 years B.C. While my maternal haplogroup U5 is from 15 000 years ago, the Ice Age Glacial maximum. Meaning foreign men mixed with local women.
I am romanian, I studied geography at university but never heard about the cave in Romania with that amazing descovery...true my specialty was geomorphology, but still such a discovery should have been known
They did realize they were on the verge of Extinction. All hominins thought it was the end of the world. The sun did not shine they were starving. There was no grass, , the food chain collapsed. The real miracle is how any humans survived at all.
I'm 2.9 Neanderthal, 97.1 Modern Human, mostly Northern European. Don't know where or when, but I'm glad of it, although the Neanderthal fat-reserving trait has caused me grief in my adult life. I loved the entire CLAN of the CAVE BEAR series, by Jean Auel, whose six book series of great reads absolutely set the eighties on fire!
I’m 6% and it’s getting harder to force myself to fast periodically with at least one month long fast every year, now that I’m in my 60s Haven’t been able to do it for a few years now. I’m 30 pounds over my fighting weight now without being flabby. But I don’t feel like a high energy Neanderthal anymore
There is never just one reason for things to happen. It's various conditions one on top of the other that pushes things to happen, ie extinction. The Neanderthals were absorbed into our culture and therefore they exist via us. They've 'evolved' into us. This is a brilliant documentary. Thank you so much for uploading it.
The Africans committed genocide via breeding. The colonized Europe. So from now on when I hear about how awful white people are, I think I’ll use this.
Wow! Superb, mesmerizing storytelling. I was hooked from the first few words. I'm running around here, doing housework, and kept needing to backtrack the narrative. I want to let you know that I subscribed, and will begin working through your offerings immediately. You guys rock!
Neanderthal’s strength and stamina, their intelligence and endurance-along with so many unique attributes-has always impressed me. I suppose the more evidence that turns up, the more modern humans will have to appreciate-and be appreciative of-the fact that Neanderthals were just as human as “we” are. And not to be disparaged as stupid or brutish. Thanks for the great watch!!
I remember some years ago now that they were presented as being brutish and unintelligent but I saw the volume of their brain pans were generally greater than so-called "anatomically modern man." I remember telling people that they were men (of man kind). And that with a bit of grooming would easily pass as one of us. I am pleased that idea has become evident to other scientists.
Neanderthals loved laughed had a sence of humor they invented things that matched their time era. They made cloths jewelry blankets & toys for their kids. The kids laughed ran around played games explored made toys got into trouble. At camp fires at the end of the day an uncle banged out nice sounding vibrations on a hallow log while others made singing sounds like howling. The clan was a close family & they morned their dead
Perhaps we Neander's were even MORE human than you modern ones. In the true realities and ways "human" is defined. Once again, the modern humans annihilated whatever they decided to "own". That is what they have done since then too.
grooming?? Only when they look like you are they acceptable?? WE were (are) the actually superior creatures, but like so many (cuz they did not look like you) cultures have discovered, perhaps the so called moderns were the BRUTES!! Wiping out in horrible ways, whomever looked differently or lived differently from you. Or whomever they were able to take land and resources from.@@donfronterhouse4759
WHY DO YOU ONLY ACCEPT OTHERS IF THEY DO IT LIKE YOU. WE NEANDERS WERE DIFFERENT AND THE OTHERS TRIED TO WIPE US OUT FOR THAT. BUT SOME OF US ARE STILL HERE, VERIFIED BY DNA ANALYSIS. STILL HERE WATCHING QUIETLY AS THE 'SUPERIOR RACE' TOTALLY RUINS THE WORLD WITH WARLIKE WAYS. SIGH!@@sallymay3643
the area where the neaders lived was destroyed when a caldera in italy went up and made 6 volcanos go off at one in the area of modern middle east , 6k miles of devastation . they ate the men and bred with the women for about 100k years the male offspring were sterile but not the women so and so it went . controversial anthropology but it is gaining traction . especially since any human bones found in neanderthal had all kinds of chew marks on them matching neanderthals teeth .
Took a dna test and was amazed to find out I’m almost 5% Neanderthal. Its one of the highest possible percentage of Neanderthal dna in modern day “humans” and this is something that makes me feel unique!
Close to that myself, which might explain some dreams I've had of what California looked like when the sea level was a few feet higher....(not really of course because we came from Europe, but it's fascinating to consider, isn't it?). Cheers...
I got Neanderthal DNA. too..its spliced in some of us modern humans even if its a small percentages ..just try to be proactive which what you can hit with the genetic lottery, unfortunately, I got Crohn's disease...Supposedly that's leftover from Neanderthal DNA...You'll have to look at the recent studies on a goog..its pretty interesting.. I guess diabetes and Lupus are from Neanderthal DNA too.
I got Neanderthal DNA. too..its spliced in some of us modern humans even if its a small percentages ..just try to be proactive which what you can hit with the genetic lottery, unfortunately, I got Crohn's disease...Supposedly that's leftover from Neanderthal DNA...You'll have to look at the recent studies on a goog..its pretty interesting.. I guess diabetes and Lupus are from Neanderthal DNA too.
I think the extra aggressive/rage played the biggest factor cause when someone is raging it's harder to think, if you're always angry you're going to make a lot of mistakes.
That constant fight or flight high cortisol state. Imagine how quickly it aged them. If they made it to say 20, their bodies probably very healthy yet aged at least twice that. So interesting 🤔
I’m twice that, smoke, done a lot of drugs, pissed all the time but not a violent human animal. Look nothing like those skulls, I am so messed up I’m back out the other side passing for normal 🤔
Wowwww I have no idea YELLOWSTONE WAS ABOUT DUE FOR ANOTHER ERUPTION. OMG. WHY AREN'T WE PLANNING FOR THIS. We would be LAUNCHED INTO CHAOS AND SAVAGERY. WE WOULD HAVE TO EAT EACH OTHER, MASSIVE RAPES, FIGHTING, AND KILLING.
@@Metal_Horror ...because some "genius" thinks between commercial breaks the viewers forget everything told so far, meaning they assume the audience is a bunch of dumb idiots. Btw. it is NeanderThal with a 'T' not an english 'TH', the narrator gets it right, but the en. based scientists can't even pronounce a name in their field of expertise right - awesome, or are this just hobbyists ?
@@Metal_Horror Advertisers know that we forget most of what they tell us, so they tell us again, over and over. Programme makers have to do the same thing so that the essentials of the story get into our thick skulls.
This is a fabulous video documentary! The information I learned in it could be considered life-changing. For the whole world and the planet, not just for myself.
I have learned about "our Cascadia Zone and the Cascade mountains from Nick Zentner a Geologie professor at Central Washington University in Ellensburg, Washington He has said that Yellowstone is a "Hot Spot" like the Hawaiian Islands. He mentioned that it last "blew up" when it was in Idaho because of plate tectonics. As the narrator mentioned 64,000,000 years ago.
Yellowstone is definitely a hot spot, but I think you got the number wrong, I think you mean 640,000 years ago. Best evidence suggests that Yellowstone erupts on average every 725,000 years ago and that its last super-eruption happened 631,000 years ago.
I am getting confused myself. I am by no means a Neanderthal buff, but over the years I have heard theories on them and other ancient cousins of ours that totally conflict with each other. I guess it is to be expected with science and new technology growing and changing all the time.
A constant supply of protein/food would be needed, and I think they would have seen animals trapped in mud and also in tangled undergrowth so would have naturally developed trapping methods as well; it's likely that younger, weaker members would have devised simple traps. They had to be intelligent to have thrived in extremely cold areas, they would have had a constant need to understand how to keep warm and feed their bodies to survive - even modern man can die very quickly in such environments with the best of equipment. Making a fire and having enough wood would have been vital in the snow areas. Thanks for an interesting look into the latest thoughts and findings on these ancestors. Regards to all.
the eskimos had no fire in the past. There was no wood in icy north. They had very warm furcloth and snowiglus. They eaten fresh warm raw fish and robs.
You know there are parts to all this I just have a hard time believing cause at the end of the day they are theories or you can call them a hypothesis, whichever you prefer. It just doesn't make sense how species that were that hardy and managed to survive for as long as they did, what over 330,000 yrs just died off. It wasn't really until we showed up, you know the killer of all things that the the last two of our relatives went extinct. Now keep in mind that interbreeding could only happen between a Homo sapien man and a Neanderthal woman due to her birth canal and not the other way around. So there are still lots of what-ifs. Until we can travel back in time and observe them we are never going to know the truth. My take is they met us and it went as well for them as the Aztecs meeting the Spanish.
Thrilling story……beautifully done and very understandable…..I am 88 yo and fascinated with the study of man since I was 10 yo. Wonderful vlogs and I’m watching them all !!
@@get.factualditto! Human evolution and ancient humans/civilizations, and generally anything ancient Britain are my favorite and you’ve done a great job keep folks like me happy and entertained lol
@@get.factual Why do intelligent, well studied, educated, minds: 🔹 seemingly set aside the "Standards of Science and Research" (excerpts: "Mind fully open, free of any predetermined Beliefs, Theories, Opinions, allowing the Research Methodologies to extract the greater facts"). The "Standards" are an established guide for the Academic and Researcher to apply for the Purpose of "Self Discipline", to prevent the Human Ego Mind from claiming a subject or point is fact to support a hypothesis or theory, ("that in some fashion is serving their perceived desire, opinion, , and in doing so presents inaccurate information as accurate, as fact, thereby offering the Academic/Researcher a gain, fame, a variable serving the Ego Mind if the individual, and misguiding others into an area that is not serving actual Science/History facts and advancement.") Therefore theres Value in the opportunities for the Academics/Researchers having "Freedom of Thoughts", "Opportunities to present Hypothesises, Theories, that allows for the forward advancing of Exploration and Discoveries, Advancements, not hindered by bureaucracy, personal/private/group interests. This is at the very foundation of Science, Academic and Research ethics, integrity, the fluid motion towards greater facts findings, allowing for the necessary and desired gains of advancements. 🔹Logic is a center stone of Academia and Research, a Cognitive value and a tool serving to balance direction and give opportunities to alternatives. There's a Flaw in the current "Administration of Academia" and their Camp, the "Mainstream Academics", as they have established their perspective on a "19th Century Theory based Paradigm and Linear Timeline" (Theory) being used as (Fact) and this is a Fatal Flaw in their Perspective, Paradigm, further it has allowed the (Lower Mind, aka Ego Mind, aka Adolescent Mind) to taint the "Value of the Scientific Integrity" and it has soread throughout the entire scope of the Academic Contents. Countless examples of Academics breaking from the Scientific Standards, in their behaviors, actions, and works, in their ignoring of "Peer Reviewed Science" and their Statements, in Professional settings and Publically. 🏹 Theres an obvious need gor the adding of an exercise of "Academic Higher Minded, aka Mature Minded application of Thought Practice, for the Higher Mind is where Wisdom resides, and behaviir follows Thought and Thought Perspective. During the early 20th Century, someone took the opportunity to redirect Western Academia, on a chiisen Paradigm, although their purpose is yet unclear to me. A forcing of the "Darwinian Model" being used as Fact and the full acceptance then resulting un Teaching the Model as Fact. 🏹 Highly undesirable actions (cause and effect) has resulted, countless Peer Reviewed Findings that do not support their M8del, current finding remain filed that literally prived the Darwinian Midel as inaccurate, most notably those of Genetics/DNA studies/findings. 🔹Studies resulting in finding's statements that include: 🏹 "Modern Humans are a redult if Intervention, rather than linear Evolution". Observing from a Sociological Behaviorist point provides some understanding, but ut leaves much ti be explained, and the 1st area of question to be answered is:. Who? (Who made this decision?) then Why? It is was affected through a University effort and then is observanle as centered around the Smithsonian. The Academics whom adhere to the "Standards of Science and Research" are "Authentic Academic". Beth Bartlett Sociologist/Behavioralist and Historian (an "Authentic Academic")
It isn't a " mystery" why the neanderthal went extinct. It was obviously a combination of factors. The ice age was ending, modern humans were competing for the same food, and interbreeding. Their population was never big to begin with. The larger population just absorbed them. That's why Europeans and Asians are 2 to 5 percent neanderthal DNA. There had to be a lot of interbreeding. They would have been gone even without any factors. The interbreeding alone would have done it.
Many people don’t realize that Neanderthals were also inbred. As a result their reproduction fitness was lower than Sapiens about 40%. They also interbred with the Denisovans, the added genetic diversity helped their compatibility with Sapien DNA thus further contributing to their absorption by Sapiens.
When I was young and first heard of the neanderthal it was like they were thick headed and stupid, I did not believe this and I asked my teachers about them and I got no sense from them. I knew that no way could they be that way, they were our type of kin and have followed every bit of news about them and now i am happy that knew info is coming about these people and glad to have about 2 percent of their DNA in me.
Nice to know that you are proud to be associated with a species that has been, for a long tine, the "Other" human race. Since this new evidence of Neanderthals not being "stupid", or black, I have been amazed by the new acceptance of Neandethals being more than we thought.
They were literal gorillas and could rip a regular humans head off. In hand to hand combat 1 of them could slaughter whole groups of us. I think they tuned into Bigfoot
And yet they are still here- within us. We are all hybrids, and thus a little bit different from each other, while calling ourselves " sapiens". Just as , one day, all our current "races" and such will be homogenized-
I thought some of the logic was that neantherthals tended to be in smaller groups/tribes. and modern humans tended to gather in larger numbers...and thats what was more likely to have led to neantherthals dying out. smaller groups tend to be more susceptable to not surviving extinction events like bad weather and poor crops etc etc.
It was an informative and scientific introduction documentary about Neanderthals, their's specifically and characteristics....thank you (Get.factual) documentary channel
I like your point but there is still a chance "we" wiped out the Neanderthals that remained OR that the remaining Neanderthals joined groups of homo sapiens. We, most probably, will never know for sure... There used to be several theories about how dinosaurs were wiped out - and the latest theory is the meteor theory. 😉
I think what they are forgetting is with a stand off throwing spear you are far enough away to not be injured by a wounded animal that your hunting. Unlike the close up Neanderthal technique where you have to thrust a spear at close range subjecting the hunter to being injured or killed by the animal being hunted. This difference could have affected the different populations because of hunting deaths and injuries.
Click bait of the worst kind. They keep asking the question "What Caused the Extinction of the Neanderthal"? And never answering it. They go on to show the Neanderthal was stronger (more muscular), built to be able to better able to withstand icy weather, and better adapted in all ways to their territory. Then we are supposed to believe that the invasion of that territory by modern Homo Sapiens (less strong, less adaptable) was the cause of Neanderthal extinction? Hello? So... WHAT WAS THE CAUSE? Thumbz all the way Down.
A very fascinating and compelling argument. With populations and geographic isolation being as they were, it's hard to believe that there ever could have been a "World War Zero" between Neanderthals and modern humans that wiped out an entire branch of humanity. With the idea that Neanderthals were just as capable at survival as modern humans in their own particular way, it lends credence to the idea that a super eruption decimated both Neanderthals and modern humans in Europe and the Near East.
300000 years of stable existence, superior visual processing, larger brains and no sign of the self terminating characteristics of homo loco. Ontologically superior for sure.
Interesting. The physical strength of the Neanderthals would be of little use in facing off against projectile weapons such as throwing spears, slings, or primitive bows. Then again, I'm assuming the Neanderthals also had at least some such weapons; but perhaps they were less effective with them for some reason. On the other hand, maybe humans were outbreeding the Neanderthals, and we overwhelmed them by sheer numbers.
After watching this excellent documentary, here's my understanding of it if anyone is interested... Neanderthals were superior to us in strength and vision, particularly spatial awareness, and their ability to tolerate the cold. They were our equal in intelligence. They had massively increased aggression caused by heightened muscle mass producing chemicals. We were superior to Neanderthals in our ability to run and also form into larger groups. I believe these two traits are what led to our continued survival. I think the Neanderthal propensity towards aggression led to their reduced group size. They simply couldn't form larger groups without killing each other so the size was limited to close family that they wouldn't kill. They couldn't run so they were ambush hunters, this means they're tied to one particular environment, open grassland was an impassable barrier to them. Due to their reduced group size, Neanderthals might be able to send out one group of five or six men to ambush hunt. Our larger group size meant we could send out perhaps three or four groups to persistence hunt. At a time when pooling resources meant the difference between meat and starvation, larger groups increase everyone's chances. Also, our ability to run meant we could cross or colonise any environment. In short, Neanderthals were superior to us in some aspects but they were too specialised to survive. Our specialist traits lay in running and cooperation, two generalised traits that almost guarantee survival.
I think what people don't take in consideration everyone was trying to survive and reproduce so everything was competition. They fought us they bred with us.
First question: If we studied Neanderthals and other hominids as though they were not relatives, but any other animal taxon, would taxonomists use the same methods for classification? Second question: In the alternate paradigm of study, a species not closely related to the observer, would the hypothesis presented differ, and how? To me, it seems simple. If a population of arctic wolves suffered population decline from climate change, and a population of grey wolves took the opportunity to access a friendlier environment and spread over more territory, would we be pouring over evidence for an explanation?
Im guessing they were just as intolerant of us if not worse. After all, they didnt live in large groups, which would suggest they werent tolerant of each other either. We current humans figured out that safety was in larger numbers. Did they interbreed? Sure, but that doesnt mean we got along. I dont believe Neanderthals were as ignorant as were led to believe. Maybe more barbaric then were use to? How do we know if we werent always being attacked by them?
You can't teach seeing in the 'dark', or seeing faster, or thinking faster, or having greater muscle mass due to genetic adaptation, or having less inclination to fear or anger.
I am 2.3 neanderthal and 2.4 densonion according to n.geographic....rather proud ...and now here i am, a unique person, like all of us......amazing to the point of unimaginable ....it is truely awesome.
Knowing how smarth Neans were, I strongly doubt they were simply charging big animals, they surely trapped them somehow before killing. They could as well chasing to death wounded animals same as some people still do nowadays e.g. Tarahumara in Mexico or Bushmen in Calahari.
We were very smart, creative, artistic, and family oriented. We were not expecting the more warlike ways of your people. We were both wiped out and assimilated by your race. But some of us are still here. You will know us by our fair skin and beautiful auburn hair, as well as our different way of viewing nature and the world. Our intelligence and abilities, our peaceful ways. We are still among you. And by the way...we made amazingly accurate and lethal hunting tools. We did not just chase them around, hopping onto their backs for goodness sake!!! Don't confuse us with yourselves. Most information that is true about us is still not knowable by your people.
@@beckythornton6470your incorrect, burials show men were buried with traditions women were discarded as well as children. DNA shows women were passed around to men . Unclear what “ race “ you are referring to but at most you have what 2-3 % Neanderthal. Killing your own people also leads to extinction.
2% Neanderthal 98% Scandinavian. Considering how so many societies choose to develop based on greed over compasion and empathy a super eruption or two may be an appropriate natural response.
4% Home sapien neanderthalensis and equal parts Scandinavian, British Isles and German with a pinch of jew. If history has shown us anything it's that all species eventually go extinct and I we will be an exception, probably won't even come close to the amount of time Neanderthals survived.
@@allencooke2356 From what I have researched, all Europeans have Neanderthal DNA in them. Only Africans don't have Neanderthal in them I have discovered.
Strikes me that the documentary is possibly missing something (so far, I'm abut 2/3 done). The lighter, flung, spears of humans would enable the hunter to carry and thus throw more projectiles per person into the intended victim from a safer distance (9-12 feet is less dangerous than 0"). Also, the argument has been that the physical structure of Neanderthal, for all the advantages it would afford the species, would limit the population... less ability to cover greater distances quickly would mean less successful hunting in terms of volume. Homo sapiens on the other hand were relatively lithe and could more easily cover greater ground than Neanderthal. Hence they had a greater population than Neanderthal... which may have added to the causes of extinction.
It is much like American Indians vs European invasion. The native Americans did not have the disease immunity the Europeans had. So they died from disease like the common cold.
Let's not forget that Native Americans were decimated by disease coming from a different continent. I believe this to be a very plausible reason for their unfortunate demise. ☹️
Another theory, which is only briefly touched upon is this video, is that homo sapiens was more warlike and agressice than Neanderthals. Even if Neanderthals were phyically stronger and just as intelligent as homo sapiens, they might have been wiped out by them if they were less inclined to fight and expand their territory than homo sapiens. One of the experts on this program does point out that history does demonstrate that homo sapiens is an extremely agressive and warlike species. If the Neanderthals were more peaceful and less aggressive than modern humans, homo sapiensa could have wiped them out over a period of several thousand years.
they said Neanderthals had more androgens = male hormnes - e.g. more tostosterone - as visible in their bones (those hormones effect can be "read" from the bones) - sothey ware for sure a little more agressive, not less
neantherthals survived in an inhospitable ice age europe, they hunted big game like mammoths and wooly rhinos, they have conflicts with other tribes. they were resilient creatures. thus, more aggressive.
It’s so crazy that new findings with latest technology get challenged with older estimations/older technologies and the older ones are often considered stronger just because it’s been believed for longer!! It’s so obvious these days that allot of our old beliefs are just wrong!
Well, if the cycle of the 12000 years of the earth not only "theory", as well that the super-vulcan Campi Fregrei soon or later will go to erupt, as all sign's showing, better to learn some survivor techniques, learning from the history, also by videos like this one. As they're saying, the history repeats itself.
I was surprised my dna also showed significant Neanderthal dna, but my ancestors are from southern Germany and it explained many traits related to strength, sight, and endurance in comparison to my peers-
Thanks for this great video. But it’s still not clear why the Neans should go extinct and not Modern Humans. Both survived west and north-east of the ash-affected area, as the simulation maps show. The eruption may have been a factor, but surely not the only one, and probably not the most important one. So paleontologists and other researchers can be glad to have yet much work ahead!
This looks super interesting and I'm adding it to my watch later playlist and commenting for the algorithm. It's just that I'm in a tough place and trying not to go extinct myself right now, so I can't handle anything remotely sad LOL. I will watch the video later.
As explained, it took about 10,000 years after the appearance of modern humans before they dissapeared. You can do a hell of a lot of interbreeding in 10,000 years
@peggyjones3282 Yes, but they also talked like the Neanderthals were no more. But if this were so that it wouldn't show up in our DNA, would it??? My blood line is strange. Neanderthal, S Africa, N Africa, over toward India, then from upper Russia, Mesopotamia, Viking, Iran, Ireland and finally Scotland to the USA.
The way we determine species is very vague. You technically have 2% neandethal DNA, but because 98% is Homo Sapien you are considered Homo Sapien. Adding a dash of salt to a batch of cookies doesn't make them salty cookies. It's just cookies.@johnbethea4505
I saw something on the internet that was about the bones of a girl found in a cave whose DNA showed that she was half Neanderthal and half Denisoven. It isn't hard for me to believe that I could have that kind of blood in me because my family blood comes from Scotland, Ireland, and Sylvania. I think it is Awesome! Thank you for putting this on the internet for me to see! I am now 86 years old as of January 3rd, 2023 and I love the internet. 👵🐈⬛🐈⬛ me, my 2 kitties Teo and TwoTwo
We all Europeans have their DNA because 750 million of us come in some way from the original settlers of Europe alongside further waves that came, the Neolithic, the Yamnaya, etc etc... If you have Haplogroups U (like myself) you know your maternal line goes back all the way to Ice Age Europe. But even if you have H (a Neolithic farmer haplogroup) since we are all so mixed up you still have DNA from them (just not your haplogroup). I for example have R1b, which is Yamnaya, pastoralist from the Russian Steppe that came into Europe bringing the Horse, the wheel, and warfare 5000 years B.C. While my maternal haplogroup U5 is from 15 000 years ago, the Ice Age Glacial maximum. Meaning foreign men mixed with local women.
My ancestors must have come from Doggerland - DNA of Scandinavia, Northern Europe, England and Scotland.
Qual seu tipo de sangue 🩸?
Happy belated birthday, that's my Grandma,s birthday too, please pet Kitty's for me
I hope you have a wonderful day....
Happy birthday 🎂 hope you had a wonderful birthday ❤🫂🙏🏼
I am romanian, I studied geography at university but never heard about the cave in Romania with that amazing descovery...true my specialty was geomorphology, but still such a discovery should have been known
They did realize they were on the verge of Extinction. All hominins thought it was the end of the world. The sun did not shine they were starving. There was no grass, , the food chain collapsed. The real miracle is how any humans survived at all.
I am in love with you.
I'm 2.9 Neanderthal, 97.1 Modern Human, mostly Northern European. Don't know where or when, but I'm glad of it, although the Neanderthal fat-reserving trait has caused me grief in my adult life.
I loved the entire CLAN of the CAVE BEAR series, by Jean Auel, whose six book series of great reads absolutely set the eighties on fire!
Eat meat, not grains. Neanderthals didn't make bread.
Hello cousin, I’m same percent as you and also loved the Clan of the Cave Bear. I identify as Neanderthal! Hehe
The fat shall inherit the earth.
23 & me says I’m more Neanderthal than 87% of customers.
I guess we’re related, sorta.
I’m 6% and it’s getting harder to force myself to fast periodically with at least one month long fast every year, now that I’m in my 60s Haven’t been able to do it for a few years now. I’m 30 pounds over my fighting weight now without being flabby. But I don’t feel like a high energy Neanderthal anymore
I find this video utterly fascinating. It makes you pause.
Don’t you mean “Paws”?
@@GuitarUniverse2013 No, as in a pause to think about it's ramifications in modern thought about the origins of man
There is never just one reason for things to happen. It's various conditions one on top of the other that pushes things to happen, ie extinction. The Neanderthals were absorbed into our culture and therefore they exist via us. They've 'evolved' into us. This is a brilliant documentary. Thank you so much for uploading it.
The Africans committed genocide via breeding. The colonized Europe.
So from now on when I hear about how awful white people are, I think I’ll use this.
I HAVE 3 PERCENT NEANDERTHAL DNA! I'M VERY PROUD OF IT 😅D !
@@joannecalafiura9864 hello fellow ooga booga
Wow! Superb, mesmerizing storytelling. I was hooked from the first few words. I'm running around here, doing housework, and kept needing to backtrack the narrative. I want to let you know that I subscribed, and will begin working through your offerings immediately. You guys rock!
Concentrate on the housework though...😊😉
Doing housework is racist.
😂
@@dondamon4669 😉
I'm such a nerd and I love these documentaries. Thank you!
Hello my sister nerd!❤❤❤
If being a nerd means loving knowledge and a keen interest in history, then count me in.
@@henryottis295 Hello brother! 🤣 🥰🥰
Hello twin nerd 🤭🤭🤭
I LIVE FOR THESE TOO 💛
Neanderthal’s strength and stamina, their intelligence and endurance-along with so many unique attributes-has always impressed me. I suppose the more evidence that turns up, the more modern humans will have to appreciate-and be appreciative of-the fact that Neanderthals were just as human as “we” are. And not to be disparaged as stupid or brutish. Thanks for the great watch!!
I remember some years ago now that they were presented as being brutish and unintelligent but I saw the volume of their brain pans were generally greater than so-called "anatomically modern man." I remember telling people that they were men (of man kind). And that with a bit of grooming would easily pass as one of us. I am pleased that idea has become evident to other scientists.
Neanderthals loved laughed had a sence of humor they invented things that matched their time era. They made cloths jewelry blankets & toys for their kids. The kids laughed ran around played games explored made toys got into trouble. At camp fires at the end of the day an uncle banged out nice sounding vibrations on a hallow log while others made singing sounds like howling. The clan was a close family & they morned their dead
Perhaps we Neander's were even MORE human than you modern ones. In the true realities and ways "human" is defined. Once again, the modern humans annihilated whatever they decided to "own". That is what they have done since then too.
grooming?? Only when they look like you are they acceptable?? WE were (are) the actually superior creatures, but like so many (cuz they did not look like you) cultures have discovered, perhaps the so called moderns were the BRUTES!! Wiping out in horrible ways, whomever looked differently or lived differently from you. Or whomever they were able to take land and resources from.@@donfronterhouse4759
WHY DO YOU ONLY ACCEPT OTHERS IF THEY DO IT LIKE YOU. WE NEANDERS WERE DIFFERENT AND THE OTHERS TRIED TO WIPE US OUT FOR THAT. BUT SOME OF US ARE STILL HERE, VERIFIED BY DNA ANALYSIS. STILL HERE WATCHING QUIETLY AS THE 'SUPERIOR RACE' TOTALLY RUINS THE WORLD WITH WARLIKE WAYS. SIGH!@@sallymay3643
Best of the Neanderthal docs so far! Very sensible and realistic.
the area where the neaders lived was destroyed when a caldera in italy went up and made 6 volcanos go off at one in the area of modern middle east , 6k miles of devastation .
they ate the men and bred with the women for about 100k years the male offspring were sterile but not the women so and so it went .
controversial anthropology but it is gaining traction . especially since any human bones found in neanderthal had all kinds of chew marks on them matching neanderthals teeth .
Took a dna test and was amazed to find out I’m almost 5% Neanderthal. Its one of the highest possible percentage of Neanderthal dna in modern day “humans” and this is something that makes me feel unique!
Close to that myself, which might explain some dreams I've had of what California looked like when the sea level was a few feet higher....(not really of course because we came from Europe, but it's fascinating to consider, isn't it?). Cheers...
I have a friend with a very prominent brow ridge. If he said he was part Neanderthal, I’d believe it.
@@wayne9518; Or your friend took a lot of drugs ... It's proven that drugs cause a heavy brow .
I got Neanderthal DNA. too..its spliced in some of us modern humans even if its a small percentages ..just try to be proactive which what you can hit with the genetic lottery, unfortunately, I got Crohn's disease...Supposedly that's leftover from Neanderthal DNA...You'll have to look at the recent studies on a goog..its pretty interesting.. I guess diabetes and Lupus are from Neanderthal DNA too.
I got Neanderthal DNA. too..its spliced in some of us modern humans even if its a small percentages ..just try to be proactive which what you can hit with the genetic lottery, unfortunately, I got Crohn's disease...Supposedly that's leftover from Neanderthal DNA...You'll have to look at the recent studies on a goog..its pretty interesting.. I guess diabetes and Lupus are from Neanderthal DNA too.
"I started working with Neanderthals in when I was in graduate school"
I've been dealing with them my all life, mate..
Bro lol
5 5555😮😢i😢😢😅@@SubvertTheStatekķ
Did they teach you how to speak?
They are thriving in Chicago
Yo mama so old when I showed her a pic of a Neanderthal she was like THATS MY EX !!!
I think the extra aggressive/rage played the biggest factor cause when someone is raging it's harder to think, if you're always angry you're going to make a lot of mistakes.
That constant fight or flight high cortisol state. Imagine how quickly it aged them. If they made it to say 20, their bodies probably very healthy yet aged at least twice that. So interesting 🤔
I’m twice that, smoke, done a lot of drugs, pissed all the time but not a violent human animal. Look nothing like those skulls, I am so messed up I’m back out the other side passing for normal 🤔
That is one of the most fascinating documentaries I’ve seen in my life very very interesting. I’m gonna have to save this one to watch again.
This is a wonderful documentary. Thank you.
I loved this ! Thank you so much ! So very interesting and so well researched !
EXCELLENT VIDEO. THANK YOU. I enjoyed this very much.
Very interesting episode and I love to keep learning new things. Thanks for posting.😊
Possibly the best and most diverse documentry I have watched on the subject..
Kind regards,
Robert.
とかがかみぎぎが２ががぎかまくきまけ66
Wowwww I have no idea YELLOWSTONE WAS ABOUT DUE FOR ANOTHER ERUPTION.
OMG. WHY AREN'T WE PLANNING FOR THIS. We would be LAUNCHED INTO CHAOS AND SAVAGERY. WE WOULD HAVE TO EAT EACH OTHER, MASSIVE RAPES, FIGHTING, AND KILLING.
'diverse'?? Never mind, I don't know what documentry means. Apologies.
This documentary repeats itself over and over again.
It's because it was made with TV commercial breaks in mind, genius.
@@Metal_Horror ...because some "genius" thinks between commercial breaks the viewers forget everything told so far,
meaning they assume the audience is a bunch of dumb idiots.
Btw. it is NeanderThal with a 'T' not an english 'TH', the narrator gets it right, but the en. based scientists can't even pronounce a name in their field of expertise right - awesome, or are this just hobbyists ?
@@Metal_Horror Advertisers know that we forget most of what they tell us, so they tell us again, over and over. Programme makers have to do the same thing so that the essentials of the story get into our thick skulls.
Fascinating! Thank you!
Really enjoyed this. Shows the link from Them to US. Nicely done. Thanks much😂
This is a fabulous video documentary! The information I learned in it could be considered life-changing. For the whole world and the planet, not just for myself.
Most is now false
I have learned about "our Cascadia Zone and the Cascade mountains from Nick Zentner a Geologie professor at Central Washington University in Ellensburg, Washington He has said that Yellowstone is a "Hot Spot" like the Hawaiian Islands. He mentioned that it last "blew up" when it was in Idaho because of plate tectonics. As the narrator mentioned 64,000,000 years ago.
Yellowstone is definitely a hot spot, but I think you got the number wrong, I think you mean 640,000 years ago. Best evidence suggests that Yellowstone erupts on average every 725,000 years ago and that its last super-eruption happened 631,000 years ago.
I am a Nick nerd
😊 keep listening you'll get get the hang of it with
" millions vs billions"
For the last couple years I have been very intrigued by the Neanderthals and earlier species.This was really interesting ,watched couple times now.
Some of them are your ancestors.
That's interesting for everyone to know, or did you think you were txing a friend?
@@brianSalem541and yours
I am getting confused myself. I am by no means a Neanderthal buff, but over the years I have heard theories on them and other ancient cousins of ours that totally conflict with each other. I guess it is to be expected with science and new technology growing and changing all the time.
THE MORE I LISTEN THE MORE YAKUB STORY MAKE SENSE. HYBRID CREATION. DESTRUCTIVE NATURE. FALLEN ANGELS
A constant supply of protein/food would be needed, and I think they would have seen animals trapped in mud and also in tangled undergrowth so would have naturally developed trapping methods as well; it's likely that younger, weaker members would have devised simple traps. They had to be intelligent to have thrived in extremely cold areas, they would have had a constant need to understand how to keep warm and feed their bodies to survive - even modern man can die very quickly in such environments with the best of equipment. Making a fire and having enough wood would have been vital in the snow areas. Thanks for an interesting look into the latest thoughts and findings on these ancestors. Regards to all.
the eskimos had no fire in the past. There was no wood in icy north. They had very warm furcloth and snowiglus. They eaten fresh warm raw fish and robs.
Their technology remained stagnant for tens of thousands of years, it didn’t advance.
You know there are parts to all this I just have a hard time believing cause at the end of the day they are theories or you can call them a hypothesis, whichever you prefer. It just doesn't make sense how species that were that hardy and managed to survive for as long as they did, what over 330,000 yrs just died off. It wasn't really until we showed up, you know the killer of all things that the the last two of our relatives went extinct. Now keep in mind that interbreeding could only happen between a Homo sapien man and a Neanderthal woman due to her birth canal and not the other way around. So there are still lots of what-ifs. Until we can travel back in time and observe them we are never going to know the truth. My take is they met us and it went as well for them as the Aztecs meeting the Spanish.
😂
Neanderthals are still here. They are among us and inside of us. Man has evolved.
Great new information presented interestingly and professionally
Thrilling story……beautifully done and very understandable…..I am 88 yo and fascinated with
the study of man since I was 10 yo. Wonderful vlogs and I’m watching them all !!
I’ve seen this but really glad to see the channel putting out great content on ancient and prehistory!
Thank you, much appreciated🤍
I wish I could be that sure about man’s evolutionary past. The evidence just isn’t strong enough for us to look that far back in time.
@@get.factualditto! Human evolution and ancient humans/civilizations, and generally anything ancient Britain are my favorite and you’ve done a great job keep folks like me happy and entertained lol
@@saturn722
Evolution is a false religion.
@@get.factual
Why do intelligent, well studied, educated, minds:
🔹 seemingly set aside the "Standards of Science and Research" (excerpts: "Mind fully open, free of any predetermined Beliefs, Theories, Opinions, allowing the Research Methodologies to extract the greater facts").
The "Standards" are an established guide for the Academic and Researcher to apply for the Purpose of "Self Discipline", to prevent the Human Ego Mind from claiming a subject or point is fact to support a hypothesis or theory, ("that in some fashion is serving their perceived desire, opinion, , and in doing so presents inaccurate information as accurate, as fact, thereby offering the Academic/Researcher a gain, fame, a variable serving the Ego Mind if the individual, and misguiding others into an area that is not serving actual Science/History facts and advancement.")
Therefore theres Value in the opportunities for the Academics/Researchers having "Freedom of Thoughts", "Opportunities to present Hypothesises, Theories, that allows for the forward advancing of Exploration and Discoveries, Advancements, not hindered by bureaucracy, personal/private/group interests.
This is at the very foundation of Science, Academic and Research ethics, integrity, the fluid motion towards greater facts findings, allowing for the necessary and desired gains of advancements.
🔹Logic is a center stone of Academia and Research, a Cognitive value and a tool serving to balance direction and give opportunities to alternatives.
There's a Flaw in the current "Administration of Academia" and their Camp, the "Mainstream Academics", as they have established their perspective on a "19th Century Theory based Paradigm and Linear Timeline" (Theory) being used as (Fact) and this is a Fatal Flaw in their Perspective, Paradigm, further it has allowed the (Lower Mind, aka Ego Mind, aka Adolescent Mind) to taint the "Value of the Scientific Integrity" and it has soread throughout the entire scope of the Academic Contents.
Countless examples of Academics breaking from the Scientific Standards, in their behaviors, actions, and works, in their ignoring of "Peer Reviewed Science" and their Statements, in Professional settings and Publically.
🏹 Theres an obvious need gor the adding of an exercise of "Academic Higher Minded, aka Mature Minded application of Thought Practice, for the Higher Mind is where Wisdom resides, and behaviir follows Thought and Thought Perspective.
During the early 20th Century, someone took the opportunity to redirect Western Academia, on a chiisen Paradigm, although their purpose is yet unclear to me. A forcing of the "Darwinian Model" being used as Fact and the full acceptance then resulting un Teaching the Model as Fact.
🏹 Highly undesirable actions (cause and effect) has resulted, countless Peer Reviewed Findings that do not support their M8del, current finding remain filed that literally prived the Darwinian Midel as inaccurate, most notably those of Genetics/DNA studies/findings.
🔹Studies resulting in finding's statements that include:
🏹 "Modern Humans are a redult if Intervention, rather than linear Evolution".
Observing from a Sociological Behaviorist point provides some understanding, but ut leaves much ti be explained, and the 1st area of question to be answered is:. Who? (Who made this decision?) then Why?
It is was affected through a University effort and then is observanle as centered around the Smithsonian.
The Academics whom adhere to the "Standards of Science and Research" are "Authentic Academic".
Beth Bartlett
Sociologist/Behavioralist
and Historian
(an "Authentic Academic")
Fascinating Documentary 💯
It's so wild because we could be totally wrong about them socially. . . Wild
We're more wrong than right. All they are doing is guessing what happened hundreds of thousands years ago
It isn't a " mystery" why the neanderthal went extinct. It was obviously a combination of factors. The ice age was ending, modern humans were competing for the same food, and interbreeding. Their population was never big to begin with. The larger population just absorbed them. That's why Europeans and Asians are 2 to 5 percent neanderthal DNA. There had to be a lot of interbreeding. They would have been gone even without any factors. The interbreeding alone would have done it.
Many people don’t realize that Neanderthals were also inbred. As a result their reproduction fitness was lower than Sapiens about 40%. They also interbred with the Denisovans, the added genetic diversity helped their compatibility with Sapien DNA thus further contributing to their absorption by Sapiens.
Also there were only ever about 10,000 Neanderthals alive at any given point of their existence.
When I was young and first heard of the neanderthal it was like they were thick headed and stupid, I did not believe this and I asked my teachers about them and I got no sense from them. I knew that no way could they be that way, they were our type of kin and have followed every bit of news about them and now i am happy that knew info is coming about these people and glad to have about 2 percent of their DNA in me.
Nice to know that you are proud to be associated with a species that has been, for a long tine, the "Other" human race.
Since this new evidence of Neanderthals not being "stupid", or black, I have been amazed by the new acceptance of Neandethals being more than we thought.
I've been thinking Neanderthals need an anti-defamation league.
Yes, indeed. And a new respect for your elders.@@AgnesC1111
Another genocide covered up and “white” made to look dumb. Predator first POC took them out
@@BoB-Dobbs_leaning-leftfor awhile they recently were selling insurance to modern humans !!! So tell me who is smarter ! 😂😂😂
It's a great watch. Kudos to the creators 👏
Some chick once called me a Neanderthal at a bar in Dallas back in the 80’s
I said thank ya darlin’
I am mighty successful
Great stuff !
I really love doc movies about history.
Me too!
😮It is great, but it is PREHISTORY
So far they have not mentioned the greater pain tolerance these people had
Perhaps too great of a great pain tolerance 🌝👀
They were literal gorillas and could rip a regular humans head off. In hand to hand combat 1 of them could slaughter whole groups of us. I think they tuned into Bigfoot
And yet they are still here- within us. We are all hybrids, and thus a little bit different from each other, while calling ourselves " sapiens". Just as , one day, all our current "races" and such will be homogenized-
@@crispyone2564 lol turned into Bigfoot
They were really should probably a white person but not the average blackman
I thought some of the logic was that neantherthals tended to be in smaller groups/tribes. and modern humans tended to gather in larger numbers...and thats what was more likely to have led to neantherthals dying out. smaller groups tend to be more susceptable to not surviving extinction events like bad weather and poor crops etc etc.
I agree with this Hypothesis. It makes sense.
It was an informative and scientific introduction documentary about Neanderthals, their's specifically and characteristics....thank you (Get.factual) documentary channel
Thank you!
I wish I was one who lived with them in their fresh air and natural habitats. Thanks. ❤
Just abandon your house and go into the woods then 2:20
move someplace like that with a few friends.
Yes you can. There`s a hood in Detroit that exhibits similar characteristics.
Be careful what you wish for..😉
Same
really nice video great
I'm just glad this proves that modern humans did not wipe out the Neanderthals.
😢😊
I like your point but there is still a chance "we" wiped out the Neanderthals that remained OR that the remaining Neanderthals joined groups of homo sapiens. We, most probably, will never know for sure... There used to be several theories about how dinosaurs were wiped out - and the latest theory is the meteor theory. 😉
This isn't proof of anything.
I think what they are forgetting is with a stand off throwing spear you are far enough away to not be injured by a wounded animal that your hunting. Unlike the close up Neanderthal technique where you have to thrust a spear at close range subjecting the hunter to being injured or killed by the animal being hunted. This difference could have affected the different populations because of hunting deaths and injuries.
Click bait of the worst kind. They keep asking the question "What Caused the Extinction of the Neanderthal"? And never answering it. They go on to show the Neanderthal was stronger (more muscular), built to be able to better able to withstand icy weather, and better adapted in all ways to their territory. Then we are supposed to believe that the invasion of that territory by modern Homo Sapiens (less strong, less adaptable) was the cause of Neanderthal extinction? Hello? So... WHAT WAS THE CAUSE? Thumbz all the way Down.
A very fascinating and compelling argument. With populations and geographic isolation being as they were, it's hard to believe that there ever could have been a "World War Zero" between Neanderthals and modern humans that wiped out an entire branch of humanity. With the idea that Neanderthals were just as capable at survival as modern humans in their own particular way, it lends credence to the idea that a super eruption decimated both Neanderthals and modern humans in Europe and the Near East.
I wonder what the last Neanderthal alive felt as he or she awaited their own passing.
Nah more like they got old n died + their kids mixed with the Western Hunter Gatherer / subsequent tribes that came in
300000 years of stable existence, superior visual processing, larger brains and no sign of the self terminating characteristics of homo loco. Ontologically superior for sure.
Interesting. The physical strength of the Neanderthals would be of little use in facing off against projectile weapons such as throwing spears, slings, or primitive bows. Then again, I'm assuming the Neanderthals also had at least some such weapons; but perhaps they were less effective with them for some reason. On the other hand, maybe humans were outbreeding the Neanderthals, and we overwhelmed them by sheer numbers.
Humans absorbed them through inter mixing.
The number of Neanderthals was indeed much smaller due to harsh environmental conditions.
After watching this excellent documentary, here's my understanding of it if anyone is interested...
Neanderthals were superior to us in strength and vision, particularly spatial awareness, and their ability to tolerate the cold. They were our equal in intelligence. They had massively increased aggression caused by heightened muscle mass producing chemicals. We were superior to Neanderthals in our ability to run and also form into larger groups. I believe these two traits are what led to our continued survival.
I think the Neanderthal propensity towards aggression led to their reduced group size. They simply couldn't form larger groups without killing each other so the size was limited to close family that they wouldn't kill. They couldn't run so they were ambush hunters, this means they're tied to one particular environment, open grassland was an impassable barrier to them.
Due to their reduced group size, Neanderthals might be able to send out one group of five or six men to ambush hunt. Our larger group size meant we could send out perhaps three or four groups to persistence hunt. At a time when pooling resources meant the difference between meat and starvation, larger groups increase everyone's chances. Also, our ability to run meant we could cross or colonise any environment.
In short, Neanderthals were superior to us in some aspects but they were too specialised to survive. Our specialist traits lay in running and cooperation, two generalised traits that almost guarantee survival.
Excellent !!!
I think what people don't take in consideration everyone was trying to survive and reproduce so everything was competition. They fought us they bred with us.
I love this thank you .
First question: If we studied Neanderthals and other hominids as though they were not relatives, but any other animal taxon, would taxonomists use the same methods for classification?
Second question: In the alternate paradigm of study, a species not closely related to the observer, would the hypothesis presented differ, and how?
To me, it seems simple. If a population of arctic wolves suffered population decline from climate change, and a population of grey wolves took the opportunity to access a friendlier environment and spread over more territory, would we be pouring over evidence for an explanation?
Awesome film! 🥰🥰🥰
Neandertals evolved in an extremely cold climate. As the planet warmed, it was harder and harder for them to survive.
That was wonderful. Now I’m terrified
Considering how intolerant we modern humans are to each other, i suspect we probably wiped them out
You bet it was modern humans... these idiots think it was Neanderthals driving SUV's wiped out their climate. lmao
We might be as ray-pee as we are violent…. So I’m thinking…. Interbreeding, thoughts?
Correct African Homosapiens white Neanderthals out
@@OwlCMedicinemainly killed off, a few Neanderthal women survived that was all.
Im guessing they were just as intolerant of us if not worse. After all, they didnt live in large groups, which would suggest they werent tolerant of each other either. We current humans figured out that safety was in larger numbers. Did they interbreed? Sure, but that doesnt mean we got along. I dont believe Neanderthals were as ignorant as were led to believe. Maybe more barbaric then were use to? How do we know if we werent always being attacked by them?
Sonday 15 December 2024,Belgium.
Maybe later i would watch this great video again 😉
I wouldn't be surprised if neanderthals taught humans how to survive in the colder environments.
You can't teach seeing in the 'dark', or seeing faster, or thinking faster, or having greater muscle mass due to genetic adaptation, or having less inclination to fear or anger.
@tunneloflight You're slow. Learn about European explorers near the north pole and how the locals helped some and the others died except Norwegians.
They may have been just outnumbered. Or lacked war tactics. Man they must have been tough as railroad spikes
I am 2.3 neanderthal and 2.4 densonion according to n.geographic....rather proud ...and now here i am, a unique person, like all of us......amazing to the point of unimaginable ....it is truely awesome.
Oh
You are asian ?
Knowing how smarth Neans were, I strongly doubt they were simply charging big animals, they surely trapped them somehow before killing. They could as well chasing to death wounded animals same as some people still do nowadays e.g. Tarahumara in Mexico or Bushmen in Calahari.
We were very smart, creative, artistic, and family oriented. We were not expecting the more warlike ways of your people. We were both wiped out and assimilated by your race. But some of us are still here. You will know us by our fair skin and beautiful auburn hair, as well as our different way of viewing nature and the world. Our intelligence and abilities, our peaceful ways. We are still among you. And by the way...we made amazingly accurate and lethal hunting tools. We did not just chase them around, hopping onto their backs for goodness sake!!! Don't confuse us with yourselves. Most information that is true about us is still not knowable by your people.
@@beckythornton6470 My race? which is?
@@beckythornton6470your incorrect, burials show men were buried with traditions women were discarded as well as children. DNA shows women were passed around to men . Unclear what “ race “ you are referring to but at most you have what 2-3 % Neanderthal. Killing your own people also leads to extinction.
@beckythornton6470 you could be a novelist. Very well written
2% Neanderthal 98% Scandinavian. Considering how so many societies choose to develop based on greed over compasion and empathy a super eruption or two may be an appropriate natural response.
4% Home sapien neanderthalensis and equal parts Scandinavian, British Isles and German with a pinch of jew. If history has shown us anything it's that all species eventually go extinct and I we will be an exception, probably won't even come close to the amount of time Neanderthals survived.
Do Scottie have any neanderthal?
@@allencooke2356
Yes
@@henryottis295 thanks
@@allencooke2356
From what I have researched, all Europeans have Neanderthal DNA in them.
Only Africans don't have Neanderthal in them I have discovered.
I was Erectus in high school, Neanderthal in the military until marriage, been Sapien for the last 48 years. 😊
Every morning one part of my body is also erectus, but not homo ...
😂
Strikes me that the documentary is possibly missing something (so far, I'm abut 2/3 done). The lighter, flung, spears of humans would enable the hunter to carry and thus throw more projectiles per person into the intended victim from a safer distance (9-12 feet is less dangerous than 0"). Also, the argument has been that the physical structure of Neanderthal, for all the advantages it would afford the species, would limit the population... less ability to cover greater distances quickly would mean less successful hunting in terms of volume. Homo sapiens on the other hand were relatively lithe and could more easily cover greater ground than Neanderthal. Hence they had a greater population than Neanderthal... which may have added to the causes of extinction.
I find it hard to believe that hunters could get close to 8 meters from pray like they say in the video.
11 minute mark. "temperatures drop by as much as 20° degrees" ok. 20° degrees what?!
Farenheit or Celcius?
Fahrenheit,
@@booze_walkEvidently. Because 20 degrees Celsius is not that cold.
Please made a documentary on summerian civilization
Very interesting ❤
It is much like American Indians vs European invasion. The native Americans did not have the disease immunity the Europeans had. So they died from disease like the common cold.
Facts. Based on a Geico commercial.
Why must Documentaries contain such annoyingly loud music.
Probably because they think the music is more important than their message.
89
Side effect of a rough remix from a sound sound source to stereo
A proper remix would be expensive for the poster.
To stir emotions I guess.
Im glad they are getting their due through
We bred with them, a mate of mine looks like one ,and his second toe is bigger than his big toe
Natural Variation is what that is called
Did he have the normal number of toes?
Adorei os vídeos sobre os antecessores da humanidade na idade da pedra
The Neanderthals are ALSO OUR DIRECT ANCESTORS. 😊
Let's not forget that Native Americans were decimated by disease coming from a different continent. I believe this to be a very plausible reason for their unfortunate demise. ☹️
But they are not extinct are they?!
Another theory, which is only briefly touched upon is this video, is that homo sapiens was more warlike and agressice than Neanderthals. Even if Neanderthals were phyically stronger and just as intelligent as homo sapiens, they might have been wiped out by them if they were less inclined to fight and expand their territory than homo sapiens. One of the experts on this program does point out that history does demonstrate that homo sapiens is an extremely agressive and warlike species. If the Neanderthals were more peaceful and less aggressive than modern humans, homo sapiensa could have wiped them out over a period of several thousand years.
they said Neanderthals had more androgens = male hormnes - e.g. more tostosterone - as visible in their bones (those hormones effect can be "read" from the bones) - sothey ware for sure a little more agressive, not less
neantherthals survived in an inhospitable ice age europe, they hunted big game like mammoths and wooly rhinos, they have conflicts with other tribes. they were resilient creatures. thus, more aggressive.
It’s so crazy that new findings with latest technology get challenged with older estimations/older technologies and the older ones are often considered stronger just because it’s been believed for longer!! It’s so obvious these days that allot of our old beliefs are just wrong!
100 %
I love science!
This documentary awakened my inner Neanderthal.
I have more Neanderthal dna than 96% of users on 23andme.
I’m up there with you as I have more than 94% of users. I think I have a little more stocky and muscular body structure. Hmmm..
@@anitawaters2890when people see you are they afraid of you because you look strange like a neantherdal.
SUPERB!
They loved oysters too. We learned that from them.
Excellent!!!!!!
Well, if the cycle of the 12000 years of the earth not only "theory", as well that the super-vulcan Campi Fregrei soon or later will go to erupt, as all sign's showing, better to learn some survivor techniques, learning from the history, also by videos like this one. As they're saying, the history repeats itself.
Facinating!
Isn't it?
What some suspect to be an ancient murder, could have easily been an ancient hunting accident.
Agreed.
Great 🎉🎉🎉
Homo erectus descendant here, Kenya🇰🇪
Erect Homo here, USA
@@hokeywolf3416 Actually that would explain why they died off.
I was surprised my dna also showed significant Neanderthal dna, but my ancestors are from southern Germany and it explained many traits related to strength, sight, and endurance in comparison to my peers-
Thanks for this great video. But it’s still not clear why the Neans should go extinct and not Modern Humans. Both survived west and north-east of the ash-affected area, as the simulation maps show. The eruption may have been a factor, but surely not the only one, and probably not the most important one. So paleontologists and other researchers can be glad to have yet much work ahead!
Many thanks
they never vanished they are us....
Yeah! look at heavy mental, sorry i mean heavy metal?
Cannibal
@zolisamaine3518 A fan of Haitian BBQ?
I think as a distinct species they did.
This looks super interesting and I'm adding it to my watch later playlist and commenting for the algorithm.
It's just that I'm in a tough place and trying not to go extinct myself right now, so I can't handle anything remotely sad LOL. I will watch the video later.
Did u watch ?yet 😂
Ive always felt the Neanderthals were the more advanced society and their extinction had to have been a planetary force of some kind.
Aaaliens
A most excellent video....Thanks
this video does not explain how super-volcanos killed the neanderthals but but spared homo sapiens who happened to be there at the same time
The Mount Toba super-eruption didn't kill the Neanderthals, or are you thinking about another super-eruption?
. Italy
@@dannybrown5744
There are no super volcanoes in Italy.
Apparently we went underground in Anatolia. They have vast vast underground metropolises
@@DaveKeenan1956 Mount Vesuvius??
Thank you 👵🏻👩🌾❣️
If the Neanderthal died out, how comes my DNA has Neanderthal from 40,000 years ago.???
As explained, it took about 10,000 years after the appearance of modern humans before they dissapeared. You can do a hell of a lot of interbreeding in 10,000 years
They talk about this in the video. Evidence of interbreeding and the presence of Neanderthal DNA in modern humans.
@peggyjones3282 Yes, but they also talked like the Neanderthals were no more. But if this were so that it wouldn't show up in our DNA, would it??? My blood line is strange. Neanderthal, S Africa, N Africa, over toward India, then from upper Russia, Mesopotamia, Viking, Iran, Ireland and finally Scotland to the USA.
The way we determine species is very vague. You technically have 2% neandethal DNA, but because 98% is Homo Sapien you are considered Homo Sapien. Adding a dash of salt to a batch of cookies doesn't make them salty cookies. It's just cookies.@johnbethea4505
@@johnbethea4505damn your mamma got passed around!
While it is repetitive,I found the video informative.