I can see why she has been given Carl Sagans old office as her sense of awe and wonder is palpable and infectious. A super guest and I really enjoyed this episode. More please.
This doctor was one of my favorite guest you've had on in a long time. Her knowledge, joy, optimism, and imagination were such a pleasure to listen to. Thank you for bringing this amazingly intelligent person into my sphere of knowledge.
@@blubard6105 What the hell are you going on about? Who's entitled? It sounds like you think all smart people have to sound like soggy old people. Heaven forbid a scientist finds joy in their work and expresses that joy when they speak. I'd really love to know what your problem is.
Dr Lisa has absolutely amazing voice, combined with her enthusiasm and how well she communcates her knowledge it's definitely my favourite episode in a while. Amazing guest, from a top of my head only dr. Kipping can rival her.
My favourite nighttime channel. Sip a camomile tea and listen to first half hour then head on pillow and light out for second half hour. Asleep around programs end. Perfect.
I tend to wake a lot, always nice to find another episode on with something interesting I can tune into again until I'm back off to sleep. Helps my sleep immensely. Rather than waking to worry about the stress ahead or getting back to sleep.
dr. Lisa Kaltenegger is so passionate about the video subject that i can feel an energetic vibe to make you watch the video enthusiastically. i love it. i love it. tyvm for posting this splendid video.
Sixteen minutes in and can already tell fantastic guest. I don’t know how you get such genus and charismatic guests. Whatever we’re doing everybody, run this train until it runs off the tracks.
Holly crap this was one of the best EH episodes I have ever listened to. Its like listening to audio Nyquil. Both John and Lisa have such soothing voices I can only imagine that this is how dogs feel when their owners go out and leave the radio on.
I really enjoy listening to Dr Kaltenegger... she is a great speaker that seems to be able to convey the wonder she feels in her voice, not just her words...
Let me start off by saying I'm looking through a window that has the exact view of what Carl Sagan was seeing, is such an incredibly low key hard flex. Jealousy now fills my heart beat
I watched Carl Sagan documentaries as a child. His passion, empathy and wonderment is what made him a giant. I remember him with some numbers with zeros on them trying to give some numerical rationalisation of planets and thus the potential for life.... So many zeros.
First heard of him when I saw him on the Johnny Carson's Tonight Show when I was a kid. I was fascinated by him and his explanations of science and space. Then when he hosted that "Cosmos" documentary on PBS I became a fanatic about science and space! Thank goodness for today's technology because we can still have him with us to hear and see besides reading his books!
You can _hear_ in Prof's voice how her eyes light up. And when your Prof's eyes light up, yours do too! She lectures a level 2 course in planetary astrophysics and herds two 4/6 IS courses. Ah, the happy few! Don't miss her Xwitter: there are both science-how about a stable 6-star system, a planet where CO₂ and H₂O rotate at different speeds (a liquid ocean?!!), Europa's iron core or the poor Ingenuity still working as a stationary observer and a future platform test-bed?-and art, and not only lesser known artsy PR images, but also space-themed paintings by one of her grads!
In my opinion, to think that we sit on the only earthlike planet is impossible. With what is probably an infinite universe with more galaxies than grands of sand, im sure their or many of every size you can imagine. It is mind-blowing.
Thank you, John and Lisa. I felt like I was out back relaxing with friends around the fireplace, stretched into one of the hammocks, slowly drifting off to visions of a splendid discussion. 😊🤙
Such a lovely voice to learn from. Her voice is very inviting and at the same time demands your attention, and she describes things in good ways as well. Nice mate 👍
The way Dr. Lisa Kaltenegger describe earlier alien Earth with fascination - is inspiring. While I (hear/feel) amazing -> death, amazing -> death, amazing ->death...
@@MrIamestrangeddon’t mean to sound offensive, but that’s a bit of a far-fetched question for this channel lol. That comment is more appropriate for channels like “Bright Insight”, you know, the channels who are comfortable taking anecdotal and subjective evidence and present it as fact, often accompanied by their own spin (as if it wasn’t far-fetched enough).
I can not imagine anyone more suited to sit in Carl Sagan's office. She has the exact same allure when explaining. Can't wait to hear more from her in the future.
JMG might have found his match. If both made a conversation with a constant back and forth, I'd only not be cold out in seconds because it was so highly interesting!
I must ask this question so, the discovery of one of the planets orbiting a dwarf star assuming the planet survived the explosion of the star would it be possible that the dwarf star simply adopted a rogue planet?
Ms Lisa was entirely enjoyable to listen to. Looking forward to listening to this video in its entirety, and then watching it again to fall asleep to. Cheers.
I love how dr. Lisa Kaltenegger speaks about this stuff. You can feel how much she loves her subject! Thanks a bunch for the interview, John!!! 😃 Stay safe there with your family! 🖖😊
at about 22:54 discussing life on an explanet of white dwarf . . . in the far future could a star spanning civilization - even with sublight starships - build a Dyson Swarm there? They could if asteorids and comets survived or a gas giant remnant still with plenty of hydrogen. Life does need water.
I'm not going to lie... Lisa's voice is very soothing with the Event Horizon music. That being said, this was a great episode. I loved the back and forth, there were some really good questions and answers here!
at about 52:16 discussing oxygen level . . . at about 36% too easy for ""forrest fires" so that's maximum but minimum? New rocks - plate tectonics / volcanism crreates minerals needing oxygen to form. That was the other contributor to the K/T (also called Cretaceous-Paleogene or K/Pg) extinction, the Deccan Traps, with SO2 and CO2 as well to mess with the climate even more.
That would probably be way too many. I understood this as a theoretical estimate. There are only 2-3 hundred confirmed rocky planets out of the total several: it's naturally easier to observe star occultations by close orbiting giant hot Jupiters (the dip is deeper and repeats once per their few-days-long year), but that doesn't mean that most planets in the Galaxy are hot Jupiters: their size and distance heavily bias observations. But there are enough observations to build good theories of planetary system formation from the protodisc and estimate the true number of the Earth-class, farther-orbiting planets with a good precision from them. I'm not betting an arm and a leg tho' that I fully grokked it.
I just can't, don't know exactly what it is but after 10min of listening i find the interviewees talking cadence and accentuation increasingly off-putting in an interview setting.. would probably sound amazing as a narration though
@@anaguma90 it was such a bizzare experience so I wanted to share, I've watched every single event horizon podcast and JMG video and this is the first time this happened.. actually first time in any podcast I've watched ever
Professor Kaltenegger should do ASMR. She has the exact cadence for it. So easy to listen to. Though, I must confess, I did struggle to fully concentrate on the actual information
I started re-writing my big SF. Novel in ‘91, finishing the TV-pilot manuscript in 99, by the time my setting had evolved into a post collapse star-system, still orbiting their White Dwarf star, two surviving gas giants (Xerxes and Daedalus) , each with a single inhabited (human colonized) moon; much closer in I left one “surviving” rocky world, now a blasted lava rock named Blaspheron. The gas giants had migrated inwards and were now well within the iron-rich nebula, the magnetic fields of which well encompassing their moons. That nebula is glowing with the dying light of their Star Solara, though a low level of lightning, never knowing a complete darkness. …until the (human) villains’ attack causes a “nuclear winter,” that is.
Every time I listen or watch people that are educated passionate and much smarter than me talk about anything universe it blows my mind! Its simply amazing! ✌️
I was really worried when she started using her talking-science-to-toddlers-voice, but about 10 min in you managed to bring her back to talk like a scientist again. I understand why scientists in a public outreach position are prone to do this, but it is off putting to me. The most fun I have is when your guests not only talk in scientific terms, but also just right out use their domain specific lingo as if we where all PHDs from their institute. Your channel is where I like to hear about new things, about the little specific things that those scientists have to figure out and what the current challenges are.
If there aren't other planets very similar I suggest that implies a very diverse make up of planets and that we are more likely to discovered life on planets not so much like earth.
I can see why she has been given Carl Sagans old office as her sense of awe and wonder is palpable and infectious. A super guest and I really enjoyed this episode. More please.
She has one of the most pleasant voices Ive heard in a while, but you can still hear her enthusiasm & passion! Great episode
This doctor was one of my favorite guest you've had on in a long time. Her knowledge, joy, optimism, and imagination were such a pleasure to listen to. Thank you for bringing this amazingly intelligent person into my sphere of knowledge.
🎉
She sounded like a cross between a reader at a kids library and a yoga instructor. :) Is that a slight German accent?
@@mc1543 TO me, she sounded like a cross between a very smart, well informed scientist, and someone I would love to have a beer with
@@blubard6105 What the hell are you going on about? Who's entitled? It sounds like you think all smart people have to sound like soggy old people. Heaven forbid a scientist finds joy in their work and expresses that joy when they speak. I'd really love to know what your problem is.
Sbe is annoying . Why does she speak with such phony fake enthusiasm?
Dr Lisa has absolutely amazing voice, combined with her enthusiasm and how well she communcates her knowledge it's definitely my favourite episode in a while.
Amazing guest, from a top of my head only dr. Kipping can rival her.
My favourite nighttime channel. Sip a camomile tea and listen to first half hour then head on pillow and light out for second half hour. Asleep around programs end. Perfect.
Or pack a bowl 🤘👽❤️
Yep i pack a bowl too but after reading that comment, i think i now need tea.
Pillow pilot.
Takes me about 2 weeks of sleeps to get through it all. 😂
I tend to wake a lot, always nice to find another episode on with something interesting I can tune into again until I'm back off to sleep. Helps my sleep immensely. Rather than waking to worry about the stress ahead or getting back to sleep.
Love the enthusiasm of Dr. Lisa. So easy to listen to with her calming voice on a fantastic subject.
Hearing someone with such a love and knowledge of her work is a real treat. I could listen to her talk about planets all day!
oh wow, 5mins in, and I feel love listening to Dr. Lisa Kaltenegger
dr. Lisa Kaltenegger is so passionate about the video subject that i can feel an energetic vibe to make you watch the video enthusiastically. i love it. i love it. tyvm for posting this splendid video.
Well said!
Dr Kaltenegger has the voice of a storyteller, and that made this amazing. Thanks to you both.
Sixteen minutes in and can already tell fantastic guest. I don’t know how you get such genus and charismatic guests. Whatever we’re doing everybody, run this train until it runs off the tracks.
Genius*
"I'm sitting in Karl's office right now" is such an awesome flex.
Holly crap this was one of the best EH episodes I have ever listened to. Its like listening to audio Nyquil. Both John and Lisa have such soothing voices I can only imagine that this is how dogs feel when their owners go out and leave the radio on.
you may like paralax nick, they call him the space poet 😌
yes indeed, i could listen to this combination endlessly...👍
Love listening to Lisa Kaltenegger
I don't. She sounds annoying with her fake enthusiasm.
I really enjoy listening to Dr Kaltenegger... she is a great speaker that seems to be able to convey the wonder she feels in her voice, not just her words...
More of this please! Her positivity and your insight…. Guhh. This. More. Much love to all.
Let me start off by saying I'm looking through a window that has the exact view of what Carl Sagan was seeing, is such an incredibly low key hard flex. Jealousy now fills my heart beat
Wow I could listen to Lisa speak all day! 2 fantastic voices and super interesting discussion.
I watched Carl Sagan documentaries as a child. His passion, empathy and wonderment is what made him a giant. I remember him with some numbers with zeros on them trying to give some numerical rationalisation of planets and thus the potential for life.... So many zeros.
First heard of him when I saw him on the Johnny Carson's Tonight Show when I was a kid. I was fascinated by him and his explanations of science and space. Then when he hosted that "Cosmos" documentary on PBS I became a fanatic about science and space! Thank goodness for today's technology because we can still have him with us to hear and see besides reading his books!
You can _hear_ in Prof's voice how her eyes light up. And when your Prof's eyes light up, yours do too! She lectures a level 2 course in planetary astrophysics and herds two 4/6 IS courses. Ah, the happy few!
Don't miss her Xwitter: there are both science-how about a stable 6-star system, a planet where CO₂ and H₂O rotate at different speeds (a liquid ocean?!!), Europa's iron core or the poor Ingenuity still working as a stationary observer and a future platform test-bed?-and art, and not only lesser known artsy PR images, but also space-themed paintings by one of her grads!
Thank you as always JMG! Lisa is a wonderful guest, a joy to listen to.
“Are there other earths?” Is such a simple and short question, but it shakes me to the core.
In my opinion, to think that we sit on the only earthlike planet is impossible. With what is probably an infinite universe with more galaxies than grands of sand, im sure their or many of every size you can imagine. It is mind-blowing.
I could listen to her for hours ❤
Very exciting guest, enjoying the enthusiasm
Thank you, John and Lisa. I felt like I was out back relaxing with friends around the fireplace, stretched into one of the hammocks, slowly drifting off to visions of a splendid discussion. 😊🤙
Such a lovely voice to learn from. Her voice is very inviting and at the same time demands your attention, and she describes things in good ways as well. Nice mate 👍
Wonderful Episode John. Definitely Dr. Lisa Kaltenegger is one of my new favorite guests.
I adore this guest! Dr Kipping has a great interview with her on his Cool Worlds podcast too! Great interview John!
What a fantastic interview! Like many others I'm listening late at night but unlike some I'm staying awake for the whole thing! ☄🛰🚀🌠🌌👏
The way Dr. Lisa Kaltenegger describe earlier alien Earth with fascination - is inspiring.
While I (hear/feel) amazing -> death, amazing -> death, amazing ->death...
Great timing! I just finished an episode and there is still an hour left in my work day :)
Perfect!
@@EventHorizonShowany thoughts on if Planet 9 sent the wow signal ?
@MrIamestranged wouldn't it repeat the signal?
@@superkittyshow1782I dont know. Maybe they have. But thats why I asked the big guy !
@@MrIamestrangeddon’t mean to sound offensive, but that’s a bit of a far-fetched question for this channel lol. That comment is more appropriate for channels like “Bright Insight”, you know, the channels who are comfortable taking anecdotal and subjective evidence and present it as fact, often accompanied by their own spin (as if it wasn’t far-fetched enough).
What's the soing at 1:07:00?
I can not imagine anyone more suited to sit in Carl Sagan's office. She has the exact same allure when explaining. Can't wait to hear more from her in the future.
Is so refreshing to find people passionate about their mission on life.
That "Quark" star made me smile. Thanks for that
JMG might have found his match. If both made a conversation with a constant back and forth, I'd only not be cold out in seconds because it was so highly interesting!
Finally, some truly long form content from my favorite RUclips channel. Sweet! 🎉🎉🎉
I must ask this question so, the discovery of one of the planets orbiting a dwarf star assuming the planet survived the explosion of the star would it be possible that the dwarf star simply adopted a rogue planet?
Ms Lisa was entirely enjoyable to listen to.
Looking forward to listening to this video in its entirety, and then watching it again to fall asleep to. Cheers.
Lisa's voice is ELITE
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
I love how dr. Lisa Kaltenegger speaks about this stuff. You can feel how much she loves her subject!
Thanks a bunch for the interview, John!!! 😃
Stay safe there with your family! 🖖😊
That voice, so full of enthusiasm and joy for the subject, really draws you in. What a first class presentation 👍
Glad you liked it!
Fascinating topic, amazing interview, and at last but not at least: holly Molly, her voice is even more soothing than JMG's!
Terrific guest and Interview! So enjoyable.
at about 22:54 discussing life on an explanet of white dwarf . . . in the far future could a star spanning civilization - even with sublight starships - build a Dyson Swarm there? They could if asteorids and comets survived or a gas giant remnant still with plenty of hydrogen. Life does need water.
Interesting subject, and Dr. Lisa Kaltenegger is very, very good at making it even more interesting. The both of you truly nailed this one :)
I'm not going to lie... Lisa's voice is very soothing with the Event Horizon music.
That being said, this was a great episode. I loved the back and forth, there were some really good questions and answers here!
Lisa is a truly fantastic person. She's great to have on the show.
What a wild ride through our past, our scientific present … and our potential future. Fascinating!
Glad you enjoyed it!
@@EventHorizonShow Certainly did. :-)
Stephen Baxter's book "Titan" described life awakening on Titan when the sun gets into its Red Giant phase.
Great video and information !
I love this show but for some reason it doesn't show on podcasts anymore.
Love her descriptions, very Saganesque!
!!!
This is one of your most relaxing videos, you both have very soothing voices. Definitely one of my favorite interviews! Thanks to you both!
I was wondering, are these interviews still being put up as a podcast?
We have a podcast archive on Spotify and apple.
Thanks guys for the great content! My evening sorted.
undoubtedly with the different gravity variables causing all kinds of different evolution streams
I could listen to her speak for days on end. She has such a pleasant voice.
at about 52:16 discussing oxygen level . . . at about 36% too easy for ""forrest fires" so that's maximum but minimum? New rocks - plate tectonics / volcanism crreates minerals needing oxygen to form. That was the other contributor to the K/T (also called Cretaceous-Paleogene or K/Pg) extinction, the Deccan Traps, with SO2 and CO2 as well to mess with the climate even more.
What a fantastic speaker; I kept thinking i was listening to an audiobook 👌
Dr Lisa is very poetic when discusses science
Her voice is so beautiful and soothing.
40:17. She said 1 in 5 red dwarfs have rocky planets. Doesn't she mean that 1 in 5 has transiting stars in our plane of view?
That would probably be way too many. I understood this as a theoretical estimate. There are only 2-3 hundred confirmed rocky planets out of the total several: it's naturally easier to observe star occultations by close orbiting giant hot Jupiters (the dip is deeper and repeats once per their few-days-long year), but that doesn't mean that most planets in the Galaxy are hot Jupiters: their size and distance heavily bias observations. But there are enough observations to build good theories of planetary system formation from the protodisc and estimate the true number of the Earth-class, farther-orbiting planets with a good precision from them. I'm not betting an arm and a leg tho' that I fully grokked it.
I'm not the 1st but it feels damn good to be here so soon. Thursdays wouldn't be Thursdays without Event Horizon! 🙌 ✨️
Earth discovered during the dino's-
So somewhere out there.There's a stellar chart of planets and written over ours is: "there be monsters there"
I'm hopeful her book can be found in Texas college libraries
So my granddaughter can expand her knowledge
I'm happy when there's an upload very happy, Even more happy when it's a longer episode!
John and this lady should make relaxation videos. Two such soothing voices....
Ok this may have been even better
OK so I know this obvious but ill say it anyway. Dr. Lisa needs to become a regular on Event Horizon PERIOD. I have spoken, this is the way.
Curiosity is not a maybe. It is a prerequisite for ANY technological civilization. No curiosity, no technology.
33:00 Ah, I see. It's a Quark star.
More content with Lisa pleasssseeeee!
What a amazing voice she has, I think we found the female version of JMG! ❤
Planet formation is common life might be common as well
She makes me fall sleep each time I try to listen to this episode lol 😜
I just can't, don't know exactly what it is but after 10min of listening i find the interviewees talking cadence and accentuation increasingly off-putting in an interview setting..
would probably sound amazing as a narration though
You could have just clicked off the video instead of commenting about it
@@anaguma90 it was such a bizzare experience so I wanted to share, I've watched every single event horizon podcast and JMG video and this is the first time this happened.. actually first time in any podcast I've watched ever
I personally like it. Very soothing.
Holy hot jupiter you guys gotta hire this lady partime 🎉😂
Carl Sagan ... still miss him. But I would be shocked if any type of life was found anywhere else in our solar system, galaxy or the entire universe.
Dr kaltenegger has this almost primal maternal voice that throws you back to being a little child listening to mommy telling you a bedtimestory.
Lisa, do you narrate your books for Audible?
I hope so!
From everything I've witnessed so far tells Me that the Weirdest & Rarest Planets we're going to find is the ones that closely resembles Earth
She has same style of talking as professor David Kipping. 😊
An amazing guest.
John, an excellent interview and audio 👍, a comment for the algorithm 😉
Professor Kaltenegger should do ASMR. She has the exact cadence for it. So easy to listen to. Though, I must confess, I did struggle to fully concentrate on the actual information
I believe that the info of dinosaurs being on the decline leading up to the extinction has fallen out of favour in recent times
I heard they were declining due to changing o2 levels in our atmosphere.
We’re going to do an episode on this soon.
@@EventHorizonShow cool look forward to hearing it
I started re-writing my big SF. Novel in ‘91, finishing the TV-pilot manuscript in 99, by the time my setting had evolved into a post collapse star-system, still orbiting their White Dwarf star, two surviving gas giants (Xerxes and Daedalus) , each with a single inhabited (human colonized) moon; much closer in I left one “surviving” rocky world, now a blasted lava rock named Blaspheron.
The gas giants had migrated inwards and were now well within the iron-rich nebula, the magnetic fields of which well encompassing their moons. That nebula is glowing with the dying light of their Star Solara, though a low level of lightning, never knowing a complete darkness.
…until the (human) villains’ attack causes a “nuclear winter,” that is.
Love Kaltenegger!
How to find one. Build another Webb with kippings terra scope idea.
"You have fallen into event horizon"
Ok, I guess Im trapped here and having to listen the whole thing 👽
Every time I listen or watch people that are educated passionate and much smarter than me talk about anything universe it blows my mind! Its simply amazing! ✌️
LISA WAS GREAT 😊
Well, I guess I have another book to buy...
I was really worried when she started using her talking-science-to-toddlers-voice, but about 10 min in you managed to bring her back to talk like a scientist again. I understand why scientists in a public outreach position are prone to do this, but it is off putting to me. The most fun I have is when your guests not only talk in scientific terms, but also just right out use their domain specific lingo as if we where all PHDs from their institute.
Your channel is where I like to hear about new things, about the little specific things that those scientists have to figure out and what the current challenges are.
Creepy when people talk like that.
(According to my mother it's perfectly fine to just be normal.)
If there aren't other planets very similar I suggest that implies a very diverse make up of planets and that we are more likely to discovered life on planets not so much like earth.
We'll just have to wait for an Earth to come here and land on Earth. Then we'll have an alien Earth.
Earth doesn't care about life. It grows cold and warm and the sun will pown us in the end... We are ticks :) on earth
Have her again please 🙏🏻
Her voice is so soothing to listen to. Does she also have a podcast? (asking before Ive finished the video lol)