GTA 3 Definitive Edition Comparison - PS2 / Xbox / PC / Mobile / Remaster
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 9 ноя 2021
- Grand Theft Auto 3 Remastered - The Definitive Edition vs GTA 3 on PS2 vs Xbox Original vs PC vs 10th Anniversary version Mega Comparison in 4K Ultra HD by GTA Series Videos
► RUclips: / gtaseriesvideos
► INSTAGRAM: / gtaseriesnews
► FACEBOOK: / gtaseriesnews
► TWITTER: / gtaseries
► DISCORD: / discord
#GTA3 #DefinitiveEdition #GTATrilogy #Remaster #GTASeriesVideos
ABOUT US
GTA Series Videos is a dedicated fan-channel in no way tied to Rockstar Games or Take-Two Interactive.
Here you can find all the latest news, video walkthroughs and official trailers of the most successful video games published by Rockstar Games, including Grand Theft Auto series, Red Dead Redemption, Max Payne, L.A. Noire, Bully and many others.
ABOUT GTA: THE TRILOGY - THE DEFINITIVE EDITION
Three iconic cities, three epic stories. Play the genre-defining classics of the original Grand Theft Auto Trilogy: Grand Theft Auto III, Grand Theft Auto: Vice City and Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas updated for a new generation, now with across-the-board enhancements including brilliant new lighting and environmental upgrades, with high-resolution textures, increased draw distances, Grand Theft Auto V-style controls and targeting, and much more, bringing these beloved worlds to life with all new levels of detail. 
Игры
I mean I knew the Definitive edition would look "better" but I'd completely forgotten how massive a leap it was between the original PS2 versions and the original PC
Except they still managed to fuck up everything. From the dark atmosphere of this game to general look of the picture.
@@Disquse i cant with you people, its so obvious that yall are makeing up shit to hate on, im dying of cringe
The PS2 and PC versions are basically the same, but on PC you can run the game at a much higher resolution
@@talpatv512 ikr if they wana complain mind as well they can f**k off the gta community if they hate this shit.
They can play other games simlilar to this then complain same shit
@@talpatv512 Console versions looked better than PC, especially Xbox (search for GTA 3 Xbox mod for PC and see how big improvements it made)
But, you are seeing that PC is better, why?
Because PC in this recording was set to 2160p as PC's now are better than before. If you would run this game on 2002/2003 PC with GeForce 2 MX on 640x480 or maybe 800x600 you wouldnt say that PC looks better. Console graphics were way superior (seriously look up this mod I mentioned above before saying it wasnt, textures on Xbox were 2x bigger, models had A LOT more polygons).
Original Xbox is still OG Xbox and on PC we can play on resolutions that were unheard then.
So "completely forgotten how massive a leap it was between the original PS2 versions and the original PC" is not really true. You couldnt run GTA3 on 2160p back then on PC. You can now. You havent "forgotten" anything, its just one of things that is better on PC's than in consoles - you can easily bump the resolutions after some time and make games look better.
Not gonna lie: the environments feels like modded GTA IV.
Almost like R* did a minimal equivalent to the work fans have done for the last few years😶
Yes shadows I think so anyway old version of RAGE is unreal engine ☺️😅
Oh yeah GTA 4 liberty city is from updated GTA 3 city
This remaster ran on Unreal Engine.
@@EZOnTheEyes gimme a gta 3 mod that looks like this
They really did a huge number on 3, VC, & SA Ngl
I always like seeing the different iterations of Claude’s pants.
Honestly kinda surprised the 10th anniversary edition looks as decent as it does
except the trees looked funky
For a mobile port it’s pretty decent
Especially for 2011
@@ghosttoast8610 That's cap
@@Xeno574 Why?
Compared to San Andreas and Vice City I personally think GTA 3 got the most improvement in this remastered.
As it should have, it’s the oldest in the trilogy.
the engine of the cars are still 2d
@Mach-Infinite exactly, thank you king.
No its awful compared to SA
GTA SA is by far the best
Claude’s face in playstation 2,xbox,pc original,10th anniversary: 🙂
Claude’s face in Definitive edition:😦
Actually the PlayStation 2, PC face is more like 😐
No in GTA 3 10th anniversary mobile and pc Claude's face is like: 😠
@@bradley2978Even in the xbox version
Dan Houser leaving the company was a clear sign that the Rockstar we knew and loved is long gone!
Wdym dawg this looks good as hell
@@Jackaattackkk Yeah, for amateur tier. This is the kind of work 1 single person would do, converting a game in UE4. We have seen it many times, but companies have stopped them, with copyright claims.
@@sokol5805 well probably because this remaster was in fact made by a bunch of amateurs at Grove Street Games instead of Rockstar.
Leslie Benzies too.
@@Jackaattackkk
When modders by themselves can make it better, it’s a clear sign R* stopped caring. Once I found out it was Grove Street Games doing the remaster, I knew this was coming.
They should’ve gave Claude a poker face, he looks depressed n confused af lmao
...
@@karicz7172 ...
Life in Liberty City is hard
@@ViceXXII yea i know
@@karicz7172 WTF
Can't decide how I feel about the remasters. In some ways it's a massive improvement but I wish it had more of that purple-ish colour grading. The night scenes are cool yeah but the daytime makes everything look a bit plain and more like the sims or something.
tbf compared to the other two, gta 3 is by the far the most plain and generic looking even tho it’s a great game. vice city and san andreas really let the individual styles of the eras and locations they took place in shine through.
it was green color grading but yeah
The oceans in Vice City during the day look terrible. That's the only thing that bothers me about that version.
@@GunsNGames1 Exactly my thoughts,Vice City looks more cartoonish than the others especially during the day,for me Vice City is the worst looking remaster of all three,not too mention the hideous npc models it has compared to GTA 3 and San Andreas.
@Him "Wanting the OG colour pallet in 2021 = wishing for too much from a multi-million $ company who easily could've hired better devs other than Grove St. Games" Got it 👍
3, looks the best to me from the trilogy I feel like they put more effort and time because it’s the oldest
San Andreas looks the best. Vice City on the other hand is the worst out of the three.
@@MsMRkv ye
@@MsMRkv Well it was true when the original ones were released.
As a kid I was shocked that GTA 3 older than Vice City and still looked far better to me. Than they released San Andreas and it looked so much better. XD
I agree
@@StArShIpEnTeRpRiSe Vice City was originally supposed to be just a DLC
0:26 Claude seems genuinely heartbroken
What do u mean, that's his face the entire game, he looks dead inside
the game feel odd, it like" gta 3 hd 4k mod 200mb apk+data"
.....
@@bluruckuscrx8124 ....
@@skinnypotato4452 ....
The NEWSPAPERS on the ground are missing in the Definitive Edition!!
The city doesn't look gritty anymore. :(
The remaster looks great, I can’t wait to re-experience perpetually failing the ‘Bomb da base: act 2’ mission just like the good old days.
That mission has just happened to me and it was very difficult
Yeah, that mission stinks haha... but for whatever reason after I watched a walkthrough that does the obvious "kill everyone" I managed to do it first try and I have no idea why
Difficult? Just stand on the Roof and snipe everyone from the Boarding Ramp on the Left until the End on the Right of the Ship.
You gotta find the adrenaline pill near some crates then go to the roof and snipe everyone.
@@FierceDeityAndrew That works too for the last Auntie Poulet Mission in Gta Vice City.
all versions 0:29 claude : what the heck?
definite edition : claude : chill
3 and vice city look trash but sa looks dope
More like dead inside
Ken Rosenberg looks kawaii in Remastered than a nerdy-looking lawyer.
Claude in the original games had a different model specifically for cutscenes.
What are you talking about he looks dead inside in every other version
I love how you can aim regularly with the m16 now
@Mors whats vc
@Mors ok
GTA3 theme song smells like 2001. Brings back old memories! I miss the PS2 era.
PS2 era when we got actual complete games on the release day, bought a game inserted it into the console and just play. Nowadays all that is gone. We live in masochistic era where people buy trash, even some after complaining about it still go out and buy another trash. No one is learning on mistakes and think funding trash without content is gaming.
@@DJGodaryD86True.
In Remastered version the facial expressions tones are totally disrupted
Yep indeed dont like it 😔
That's a hardware thing if you're on PC
@@Mewtwo_150 no thats literally how they made the definitive editions models
They fucked up on the model bone weights. They added bones but didn't compensate on the animations. Here's the result
@@RedWithTheObviouslyLongHandle Tones/textures are dependent on what specs your console/PC use
Part III is the only GTA I ever finished and it was hard as hell.
The other ones are easier.
Yeah I didn't finished it ,this time I will
@@El_Neon_20180 Say that to demolition man
Same, I always loved this GTA, by far my favourite one.
@@dexter27ll6 Say that to Supply Lines.
1:59 good that they left their way of walking, it's so cool
like if you love Claude's way of walking too :D
...
@@karicz7172 *sniff* such wise words!
Definitive beat them all but original always will stay in my heart.
Um ok?
Um ok?
Yeah
Yeah okay
Um ok?
I think it's time to go back to grab the most dangerous M16 in the game history and start rampage over the city
@H O L L O W thing shoots as fast if not faster than a PPSH-41. It’s insane.
destroys a car in 1 second - there is barely even a point in using the rocket launcher.
@H O L L O W GTA 3 describes how the M-16 rifle is a monster in real life too.
That gta 3 music in the background and the original Comparison vid from Gta series vids is perfect. Feels like We are back in the old GTA era
This looks so good, I mean so little edits yet you have old feel. Nice job.
The GTA III Theme will never get old
Not really
Idk how to feel about it. Part of me appreciates the fact that they tried, the other half was expecting more specifically some changes to physics. Sure the graphics look nice but if you give a car with a shitty paint job a coat of gloss doesn’t make it necessarily look nice.
..
Changing the physics would give the game a different 'feel' while you're driving and running around. The wonky, ridiculous physics were part of the original charm of the classic GTA trilogy. It was part of the fun. Re-releasing a game with enhanced graphics and some quality of life improvements is great; but I think it's going too far if you change the physics of the game, or other things pertaining to the game engine. Re-release a game to LOOK different; not to FEEL different.
@@DeadPixel1105 ...
@@karicz7172 Come ova for dinna
@@DeadPixel1105 👏👏👏👏👏
Graphics improved but still having this original atmosphere. And I like it
The atmosphere is gone in the remaster.
I wouldn't say the atmosphere is exactly the same, it's definitely less gloomy due to the lack of color correction although it's still recognisably Claude and Liberty City, so that's good.
Ok?
@@mr.marvin It's still there but improved
Umm... it’s obviously more colorful and the classic blue filter is completely gone
Oh how I missed these graphical comparisons. For sure gonna blow up
Cladue looks handsome in the definitive edition
Catalina looks beautiful in the definitive edition
Why did they even make Catalina beautiful in the Definitive edition?!?!
Idk why people are getting angry over the graphics. It's a remaster, not a remake, and that too a good one.
And the art style is good too.
Your dam right it is not remake a remastered which only improve graphics but r* did it well
So many damn babies out there.
Two complaints:
1. The Cartel are still hostile even tho we can't actually access the island in the beginning, maybe Triads too.
2. What's up with the SA menu sound effect on 3 and VC? I can't believe that was overlooked lol.
First one is forgivable, considering that they explicitly stated that these games shall give the same classic feel but for the second one? Not saying that I won't play these games but jeez took them prolly years to remaster this.
And why did they remove dismemberment?
I still feel like it's lacking for some reason. It just doesn't seem like all it could have been.. I think the Mafia Remaster was just a whole other level that I was hoping other remasters would continue. Also, in the beginning rain of GTA3 I think they should have kept the fog, it added to that eerie aspect, and paired well with the music too. maybe that's just my nostalgia, though
@@sudev29 because the technique they used originally doesn't work with the new models
@@dinosoarskill17 the mafia "remaster" wasn't a remaster, it was a remake
@@sono5468 then Rockstar should've put some effort and did a remake instead of this half-ass excuse of a $60 game. Rockstar should've just did a remake of San Andreas.
I still think the PS2 version will always be the definitive edition and it can't be replicated ❤️
The correct answer
wrong xbox is the best are you blind?
@@razanamzani2668 ps2 has better atmosphere
@@razanamzani2668The xbox version has some downsides
I love the PC original the most. Just tickles me differently.
Me too
The original versions will always be amazing but nice touches like trees, sidewalks, and water look great in the definitive edition. I just wish the rest of the definitive edition looked as good as those aspects, most textures look soft and remind me of card stock paper
Can't wait to see the mods the community will bring upon us with this new software engine used
Highly doubt there will be anything because those people quit, even if we get a greenlight to mod again, we wont. You will have some kids make meme trash content and that is it.
Claude now looks severely anxious.
Only just realised when watching this video that I've actually played all of these versions of gta 3 except gta definitive of course:
(will do tomorrow) 20 years later I'm still hyped to play it
Bro these kids don't understand how good this shit looks bro just look at it🔥
The definitive edition seems to have lost a lot of the atmosphere and character of GTA III. Somehow the faces have become less detailed and expressive, which is mind blowing. They also seem to have upped the poly count on some characters but not others, and it is weird when the old blocky ones interact with the smoothed out ones. They also added fingers, but they didn't do anything with them, so it actually looks way more awkward when people make the pointing gestures with hook hands now with fingers.
Newspapers on ground etc...........
They look like puppets 🤔
Finally someone said something about this. The characters look really cartoony for some reason and idk if I really like it or not. The whole thing looks like it was made by a rookie unity developer
something about the shading is off too, their skin doesn't look anything like human skin
They literally used the old character models as blueprints and smoothed them out which feels a little uncanny because the original aim wasn't to look so cartoony, it was simply a limit of the technology. In my mind GTA was never cartoony. It was real world.
Still really happy overall. For a remaster it's pretty darn good.
Man, definitive edition's Claude's model looks like an action hero of the 90s.
Yes
Idk, i don't get it... why are some people losing their minds? They kept the same tone/atmosphere! I been with this series since GTA1 on PC when my ex' brother had the game and i discovered it and only a couple years later GTA3 landed and i KNEW it was going to be HYPE just had no idea it would change the entire industry.
Anyway i digress... this looks fantastic. I expect nothing less from R* but a polished, and fun game.
Damn these guys are fast
Ah fuck we're reaching Skyrim levels of releases
Great edit!
I legit had a tear remembering how I would play this game during my early childhood so many memories thank for rockstar for making this game thank you for all the good memories of my life
Idk… the original version by itself looks more advanced compared to the Definitive Edition. The faces and details aren’t spectacular but they made an attempt to make them lifelike but the Definitive Edition looks like it was all smoothed out and shined up too much losing that intentional realistic appeal.
people used to say "Pls remaster gta sa, vc and iii" and now that they finally remastered them, people are saying "the remaster sucks" like duuude. what did y'all expected? GTA V graphics? adding GTA V graphics into the remaster is impossible unless they remake the game. and the remaster is way better than the original so be happy with that guys. stop complaining.
@@ImaFunGamer "people are saying "the remaster sucks" like duuude. what did y'all expected? GTA V graphics?"
Yes. Exactly that... but legit a lot better...
I can feel the rush of nostalgia already! Fun fact: I was 17 when I first played GTA III & Vice City, now as I'm about to turn 34 I'll be replaying them in remastered.
Have fun bro.
Does anyone know if you can add your own custom music playlist to any of the remasters like you could on the PC and Xbox versions
Don't you just love when youtubers show off their early copies of games you preorder & patiently waiting for the release day?
Honestly,the rain looks so weird in definitive edition version
im glad the company itself decided to comeback for their old versions and remaster them
This kinda restores my faith in rockstar that there showing love to the games that made them
@@JackTal0s You should research more before commenting praisals towards RSG and T2.
How can this channel produce some much great content in a short amount of time?
I was playing the Trilogy on PC back in the day so it never looked bad to (relatively speaking) but wow the difference between PC version and PS2/Xbox version is like night and day.
People give the graphics a ton of shit, but considering that they were trying to maintain that PS2 feel, while touching it up, I think they did a pretty sweet job all things considered!
Makes me tear up that they kept the dark theme and made it look like how those who played it at original launch thought it looked.
It looks cool comparing to older versions. In some points changes are mindblowing. Atmosphere is darker and less gray. But to me characters look like wax figures. Claude looks pretty good though. In general it's a good remaster but not without some issues.
That intro music is something else.
10th anniversary looks decent👌🏻
For gta 3, I cant resist, how they transform vegetation to look like gta v. Moving leaves, little wind, shadow from the trees. From first generation of 3D gta to HD Universe, absolutely beautifull. But i still curious, is the non solid ground turn to solid ground in the upstate?
Most likely no, because as far as I can see they didn't touch the map at all... Even the old bugs are there, like the one about shooting moon.
@@v.nd.tt.s8943 the shooting moon one isn't a bug it's present in a lot of GTA games and developers put it in the games on purpose
Grazie per il tuo lavoro👍🏾🇮🇹
I just can't believe it's been 10 years since the 10th anniversary.
This is just GTA's version of Super Mario 3D All Stars
Limbs don't even come off when shot in the ""remaster"". 0/10
some HUD inconsistency :
- they retained the original style of the selected weapon (only using the yellow-ish color and black)
- they did NOT retain the same style of the radar which was very original and kind of iconic. I know it was ambiguous but with the now included in-game map and GPS route system, players would do just fine.
I don't like how the border of the radar circle is plain color with no sort of shadow whatsoever. It looks very dull. Again-some additional black border would do wonders).
Best comparison
And The Comparison That I’ve wanted :)
(And then We need GTA VC And SA)
Damn, seeing people impressed by this really shows me how low some people's standards have sunk.
I kind of like the 10th Anniversary edition the best. Slapping realistic textures on those boxy character models and then drowning them in shadows doesn't really look that appealing to me. I like the balance the 10th Anniversary has even if it's a little bright.
Exactly, the definitive edition just looks so bland and soulless compared to the originals. Not to mention how rockstar cooked this crap up instead of a dlc for rdr2 or gta6
@@lumbagoboi1649 Rockstar didn't even make this lol
@@Rude_Boi okay... and? It still looks like crap, and rockstar still advertised it.
@@lumbagoboi1649 All I said was they didn't make this. I'm not arguing with whatever else you said.
@@lumbagoboi1649 you people always saying gta 6 you guys want a new cyberpunk right you guys just want the game and when they will launch it because you consumers pressured them and it’s trash you guys will complain and say why did they launch it when it wasn’t ready
I forgot how long it took to get your hands on a cheetah lol oh the nostalgia. Getting used to the clumsy camera and aim physics is a new challenge.
I own every version shown in this video! Can't get enough of GTA 3.
This was much better view than the one on live stream, i was a bit disappointed after what I saw on live stream here GTA 3 Definitive Edition is actually good looking
I switched from watching the recent videos on my phone to my 4k tv and it’s night and day how much better it looks on the TV RUclips app.
They did a good job with the definitive edition. People need to comprehend the difference between REMAKE and REMASTER. These are remasters. Point blank period. It’s giving the games a graphic/performance update while playing like the original but with some modern controls.
Joey's hair looks like it's more spray on than before but everything else I'm fine with
0:26
Claude got less and less pissed off over the years
He went from I’m gonna kill you to please don’t hurt me I’m scared and confused
Ps2 graphics might be legendary but I like the definitive version even more
haha obviously, generation:)
They did a good job, you can’t lie
Woah, someone who’s actually satisfied and not shitting on the game 24/7? I’m impressed
With a lot of assets, but not all of them
Bullshit
Yeah with the originals. DE looks like a baby's first unity project.
Sorry gonna piggyback off you being the top comment to ask this - but how much of a difference is there between the Xbox One X and the Series X ?
Anyone know if I'd be missing out on anything major?
Would like to see another comparison video on Vice City.
GREAT QUICK COMPARISON. Cant wait to use that M16 to wreck havoc on LC streets!!
Definitely could see myself playing 3 all the way through now
Me too
I love the police , ambulance & fire missions
Good old liberty city
If the graphics put you off then you dont really deserve it in my opinion
@@Official__RILO nah dude the gameplay aged very badly in GTA 3, that's why. San Andreas had much better shooting mechanics. Driving is fine though.
I swear, the definitive graphics remind me so much of that Coca-Cola commercial from like 10 years ago where it parodied GTA games.
It definitely looks like an old CGI render but in motion, like the commercial you mentioned or the Super Mario 64 promotional art, it's almost uncanny
Thanks to the UE4 ... 😁
From when I was a kid in the year 2000 gta 3 was the first game a played and now seeing this in 2021 is truly amazing
1:13 Nice, I like how the Mini map resembles GTA SA style, it looks much easier to navigate as well.
Does GTA 3 now have a Map on the pause menu and waypoints can be set now?
Yes
I can't get over how bad the faces look in the definitive edition.
It's still good
The environment is beautiful but the character are ugly and shiny
The definitive edition doesn't even look improved, to me it just looks more plastic and cartoony and the lightings a bit darker that's it there's literally no point in this remaster just to get new fans introduced to the old GTA games
Nice footage
the switch version comes tomorrow and i can’t wait to play it
the artstyle just isnt the same
it feels like they just replaced the most obvious, cars, peds, lighting and left everything else as is
the dark gloomy tone is gone and those reflections dont fit at all
We're so spoiled by all the mods (that R* were idiots to remove forcefully..) that this doesn't look too different :D Nonetheless they did a great job with the remasters :)
Which mods did they take down?as far as I know you can mod those games any way you want,the only thing they took down was a remake project some fans were doing from the ground up but that's a very different thing than modding an old game.
@@wendellnovais they took down vice cry and other graphics mods for 3 and SA. Then by also removing the original games from stores you'll have to pirate them and then find the mods somehow
3:24 on the right, I thought this was GTA IV lool
The graphics looks nice the map looks a lot like Gta IV now but the its good to see that they kept the dark environment. Only thing I am little disappointed in is that Claude cannot climb walls like CJ and the rest of the protoganists. Further of I like how they made the game so far its really refreshing.
I love this ,I’m asking my parents for the trilogy for Christmas
Nah you too young for this then kid.
Better try to find the original trilogy bud
@@9MAYHEM6 all people played gta being 10 years old
I dont like the mission name being in the middle of the screen tbh
The game that started it all and also one of my favorite
Nostalgia-Nostalgy Back-Return!!!!👍👍❤❤
Man, I think those who didn't like GTA 3 just didn't like it because of its graphics and gameplay. Now they won't know which game to play :D
ngl The Xbox Version looks so good compared to even the 10th Anniversary version
Anniversary edition runs at higher resolution, but it's downgraded in many ways (missing reflections, low poly vegetation, missing fog, blocky texture compression, etc.).
yeah it had many improvements, it even had fingers with animation
@@PabloB888 missing reflection ?
also the 10th anniversary edition is based on the OG Xbox
Can you do a video on cut content to see if it’s worth getting it?
Id rather have the same old graphics with modern weapon aiming controls
Wonder if we’re going to get a 10th anniversary for GTA V
They will probably just give us a t-shirt, a couple hundred dollars, and the worst looking livery you’ve ever seen in GTA online and call it a day.
@@ArkSucksAtGames probably
1:29 Is it just me or the audio synced so well that you thought the guy was rapping.
Has it REALLY been 20 freakin' years?! My god.
i honestly think the remaster looks "technically" better but it doesnt really have the spirit. the ps2 and xbox versions win. they have that "little something" magical thing that makes the game much more interesting and mystical to look at.