GTA San Andreas Definitive Edition Comparison - PS2 / Xbox / PC / Mobile / Remaster

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 9 ноя 2021
  • Grand Theft Auto San Andreas Remastered - The Definitive Edition vs GTA San Andreas on PS2 vs Xbox Original vs PC vs 10th Anniversary version Mega Comparison in 4K Ultra HD by GTA Series Videos
    ► RUclips: / gtaseriesvideos
    ► INSTAGRAM: / gtaseriesnews
    ► FACEBOOK: / gtaseriesnews
    ► TWITTER: / gtaseries
    ► DISCORD: / discord
    #GTASanAndreas #DefinitiveEdition #GTATrilogy #Remaster #GTASeriesVideos
    ABOUT US
    GTA Series Videos is a dedicated fan-channel in no way tied to Rockstar Games or Take-Two Interactive.
    Here you can find all the latest news, video walkthroughs and official trailers of the most successful video games published by Rockstar Games, including Grand Theft Auto series, Red Dead Redemption, Max Payne, L.A. Noire, Bully and many others.
    ABOUT GTA: THE TRILOGY - THE DEFINITIVE EDITION
    Three iconic cities, three epic stories. Play the genre-defining classics of the original Grand Theft Auto Trilogy: Grand Theft Auto III, Grand Theft Auto: Vice City and Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas updated for a new generation, now with across-the-board enhancements including brilliant new lighting and environmental upgrades, with high-resolution textures, increased draw distances, Grand Theft Auto V-style controls and targeting, and much more, bringing these beloved worlds to life with all new levels of detail.
  • ИгрыИгры

Комментарии • 1,3 тыс.

  • @Fallen_Ninja
    @Fallen_Ninja 2 года назад +963

    Some of these cutscenes need lighting adjustments or artificial lights placed.

    • @R-Jacky6698
      @R-Jacky6698 2 года назад +132

      smoke = smiling teeth black guy in the dark

    • @diamondswish
      @diamondswish 2 года назад +7

      U right

    • @notyourbusiness1352
      @notyourbusiness1352 2 года назад +19

      exactly. Joined their stream last night, I kept my expectations low but still very disappointed.

    • @maziusclavo8021
      @maziusclavo8021 2 года назад +5

      As expected Richstar dont care to make good versions of these games, they just want people to play the new gtas, thats why every new version of the classics is worse than the previous so the people end shifting to the new gtas.. Not to mention its flashy for kids as rockstar needs to milk them too

    • @wuzzierash578
      @wuzzierash578 2 года назад +7

      THANK YOU, I feel like people talk too much about the char models and not the interior lighting

  • @gabriels1869
    @gabriels1869 2 года назад +1711

    I’m still mixed on the draw distance thing. Yes on paper it’s better, but they also removed haze, fog, dust, smoke and mirrors stuff which gave each city its own unique atmosphere. Wish they could have a middle ground closer to PC version, improve draw distances but still trick the player into thinking the map is larger than it actually is. It’s gonna be weird being able to see Los Santos from Angel Pine

    • @wittywolk
      @wittywolk 2 года назад +127

      and clouds.

    • @TheAprizzle92
      @TheAprizzle92 2 года назад +222

      I'm hoping they can fix this with a software update, it's making the map seem way smaller. You're not supposed to see all the cities at once, the mystery is gone.

    • @nonameman7114
      @nonameman7114 2 года назад +23

      @@TheAprizzle92 is it even possible to do all that in an update ?

    • @Rude_Boi
      @Rude_Boi 2 года назад +138

      Exactly! There's this clown in a previous video that is arguing that the increased draw distance and removal of the fog isn't a problem, when it clearly is. The map looks so small now, and being able to see the desert from Los Santos is a problem.

    • @TheAprizzle92
      @TheAprizzle92 2 года назад +65

      @@nonameman7114
      Nothing is impossible, but this is done by Grove Street Games. They're the ones responsible for ruining the "10 year anniversary version" that was on the PS4.

  • @watcherdev
    @watcherdev 2 года назад +2165

    Looks good, I just miss the heatwave effect from the original.

    • @elgiganten6154
      @elgiganten6154 2 года назад +39

      Stop complaining

    • @elecsane1057
      @elecsane1057 2 года назад +555

      it’s not even complaining lmao, all he is saying is that he misses a feature

    • @watcherdev
      @watcherdev 2 года назад +184

      @@elgiganten6154 you stop first 😏

    • @nonameman7114
      @nonameman7114 2 года назад +100

      That and also miss the fog

    • @goodxd701
      @goodxd701 2 года назад +69

      @@elgiganten6154 cry

  • @anthonyfernandez82
    @anthonyfernandez82 2 года назад +633

    The more realistic lighting makes the characters harder to see

    • @alexsilva28
      @alexsilva28 2 года назад +45

      Realistic? Lol I've seen Roblox gameplay with more realistic lighting than this. The lighting might be more accurately simulated in this version but I wouldn't call it realistic

    • @anthonyfernandez82
      @anthonyfernandez82 2 года назад +67

      @@alexsilva28 I didn't know anything else to say. The new lighting

    • @pedrobeckup456
      @pedrobeckup456 2 года назад +11

      @@alexsilva28 né! na vida real, da para ver claramente nas sombras. Nesse jogo, é como se a luz não refletisse para onde o sol não bate...
      I dont speak inglish

    • @jjvc3888
      @jjvc3888 2 года назад +20

      They need to add fake lighting to cutscenes like in GTA V

    • @SuperKilroy123
      @SuperKilroy123 2 года назад +6

      @@alexsilva28 it is far more realistic in comparison to the original lighting

  • @TheOneTrueLeo2002
    @TheOneTrueLeo2002 2 года назад +785

    CJ is still a straight busta in every version.

    • @watcherdev
      @watcherdev 2 года назад +23

      Always a buster…😞

    • @unlightings
      @unlightings 2 года назад +50

      Even in 4K, CJ can't escape from Ryder calling him a busta lol

    • @Ahmad1234-c5l
      @Ahmad1234-c5l 2 года назад +17

      Ryder is also a busta

    • @JLD5500
      @JLD5500 2 года назад +7

      Big smoke Piped CJ’s mom

    • @chuckyyes
      @chuckyyes 2 года назад +8

      GTA SA CJ not a busta edition

  • @martinvr12
    @martinvr12 2 года назад +527

    Miss the ps2 orange filter tho, it always gave me the 90's feel.

    • @alexsilva28
      @alexsilva28 2 года назад +17

      Yup. Definitely adds to the feel of the game

    • @average__height8033
      @average__height8033 2 года назад +5

      Definitive definitely looks better tho

    • @jonathanbohm6489
      @jonathanbohm6489 2 года назад +26

      A lot of movies had the orange tint during the 90s too like Bad Boys it’s cool but hey it’s new

    • @g.e131
      @g.e131 2 года назад +9

      I know exactly what you mean. Good times, good times.

    • @riec4482
      @riec4482 2 года назад

      Am I the only one that doesn't like it? It's too blurry for me lol

  • @pedinhuh16
    @pedinhuh16 2 года назад +391

    It baffles me how the PS2 art style had and still has the best atmosphere.
    LS really needed that orange tint..

    • @TerminatorZXY
      @TerminatorZXY 2 года назад +27

      It worked on PS2 because it was a bit blurry and far more cartooney. The remaster does have the orange tint a bit more than other versions, but since it's a HD version, it would probably look like some apocalypse, it would probably fit less in a "realistic" world, even less than the character models.

    • @maziusclavo8021
      @maziusclavo8021 2 года назад +8

      As expected Richstar dont care to make good versions of these games, they just want people to play the new gtas, thats why every new version of the classics is worse than the previous so the people end shifting to the new gtas.. Not to mention its flashy for kids as rockstar needs to milk them too

    • @thesaviordj1987
      @thesaviordj1987 2 года назад +10

      @@maziusclavo8021 lmao dude do you hear yourself? Blinded by nostalgia and irrational hatred for the new games. The remaster removed the heatwave and fog effects because they were the result of graphical limitations, and were no longer needed. If rockstar had their way and didn’t have to deal with technical limitations back then, they probably wouldn’t have been in the game in the original releases. The remasters are fine.

    • @maziusclavo8021
      @maziusclavo8021 2 года назад +17

      @@thesaviordj1987 Just visit gtaforums and look up what people think about this, simply the worst gta version ever. Calling this amateur outsourced crap definitive or even a remaster its an utter scam, isnt worth even pirating the game let alone doing mods for it as rockstar sued some modders that did better before releasing this.

    • @brutusthedane2457
      @brutusthedane2457 2 года назад +3

      @@maziusclavo8021 if you don't like how it looks then don't play it
      It is simple as that

  • @dkraz
    @dkraz 2 года назад +680

    Let's see what the patches and the mods community can do

    • @forkq5720
      @forkq5720 2 года назад +61

      rockstar is against mods and modification of his game thats why they launched in their platform to have it more controlled

    • @zagorim7469
      @zagorim7469 2 года назад +176

      @@forkq5720 still going to happen

    • @forkq5720
      @forkq5720 2 года назад +19

      @@zagorim7469 you still read right? when you said that and the people upvoting, you know they are suing people right? the community is so blinded "Take-Two still wants to kill the modding community with DMCA takedowns and lawsuits" thats what the news says, keep buying shark cards

    • @BL41D3R
      @BL41D3R 2 года назад +70

      @@zagorim7469 some modders are against doing any type of mod for the DE because they would get shot down by rockstar and because it is Grove Street studio's problem to fix the shitty bugs in their "remaster"

    • @zagorim7469
      @zagorim7469 2 года назад +42

      @@forkq5720 lol wtf man buying shark cards, i'm not even playing gta v, chill. Also i'm pretty sure they aren't suying people for modding single player. Whatever they do people will keep modding anyway.

  • @unsortedguy
    @unsortedguy 2 года назад +128

    The entire drive-thru cutscene was ruined in the definite edition..
    Really seem they put little to no effort in making this.

    • @1ZosoLZ
      @1ZosoLZ 2 года назад +2

      How? Tf

    • @unsortedguy
      @unsortedguy 2 года назад +24

      @@1ZosoLZ the interior space of the car is completely dark and you can't see them ordering the food... Then the other scene you can't even see though the window.

    • @tcapfan4190
      @tcapfan4190 2 года назад

      Good

    • @ContentCrypt
      @ContentCrypt 2 года назад

      Some people don't remember San Andreas' cutscenes are completely live in-game, so the time of day and weather conditions apply to them.
      You can test it by starting a new game, the lighting will be different every time; makes comparisons hard. The creator should've used weather cheats to make it a fairer test in that respect.

    • @1ZosoLZ
      @1ZosoLZ 2 года назад +1

      @@unsortedguy looked normal to me when I was playing that mission

  • @CALAdmin88
    @CALAdmin88 2 года назад +748

    Staggering how they still can't replicate the PS2 version's atmosphere.

    • @ary5092
      @ary5092 2 года назад +41

      SkyGFX for PC

    • @TheCrazeturk
      @TheCrazeturk 2 года назад +212

      People vastly underestimate the importance of atmosphere in videogames.

    • @chillvibed
      @chillvibed 2 года назад +10

      They never will. They would have to make a new game on ps2 basically.

    • @ScaryMoldyToast
      @ScaryMoldyToast 2 года назад +6

      Check out Updated Classic San Andreas for PC

    • @ThatBallHockeyGoalie
      @ThatBallHockeyGoalie 2 года назад +52

      Oh yeah it looked so good everything being fuckin orange lol

  • @ROCKSTARMANIC12
    @ROCKSTARMANIC12 2 года назад +192

    One thing I do feel like need to be done atleast in SA is lessen the draw distance. Should have added back the fog and such to make it feel like an actual State of San Andreas, not a huge city.

    • @jgooner894
      @jgooner894 2 года назад +7

      That was there cause of the hardware limitations though. I think it’s fine to see the world in a new light like this.

    • @JuriSins
      @JuriSins 2 года назад +14

      @@jgooner894 hell noo

    • @jgooner894
      @jgooner894 2 года назад +3

      @@JuriSins The draw distance was very small. Don’t think they can get away with having a load of fog which there wasn’t before either in some parts, it seemed like you were looking into the end of the world instead of fog. You can’t have that with these new graphics.

    • @RafaelPereira-dc9ir
      @RafaelPereira-dc9ir 2 года назад +3

      Glad I’m not the only 1 thinking

    • @RafaelPereira-dc9ir
      @RafaelPereira-dc9ir 2 года назад +4

      @@jgooner894 At least it had an good point to surprise us to discover new things specially after doing that mission from Truth to reaching SF 1st time it felt epic good

  • @MovieGuy1998
    @MovieGuy1998 2 года назад +576

    They should have used the orange lightning effect around los santos like in the PS2 version.

    • @TheAprizzle92
      @TheAprizzle92 2 года назад +28

      %10000

    • @nafisalalim
      @nafisalalim 2 года назад +36

      I respect your opinion but I have to disagree

    • @stevenbaksh5545
      @stevenbaksh5545 2 года назад +13

      Nah it looks bad to me

    • @shaunp253
      @shaunp253 2 года назад +42

      Agreed. Made it really feel like we were really in southern California.

    • @average__height8033
      @average__height8033 2 года назад +1

      Just looks odd with the more updated feel you know

  • @TaeringYT
    @TaeringYT 2 года назад +158

    1:28 Ah, finally
    "OHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH" in 4K HDR
    Now I can die peacefully

    • @26savage69
      @26savage69 2 года назад +3

      Wait till we see it in 8k lol

    • @bruhmomento5082
      @bruhmomento5082 2 года назад +2

      **OOOOOOOOOOOOH

    • @KellanGDM
      @KellanGDM 2 года назад +8

      Means shit when you can't even see big smoke properly

  • @DipperPines1986
    @DipperPines1986 2 года назад +58

    Las Venturas and the desert originally had very beautiful purple nights. In the remaster, the night skybox is the same in all cities.

    • @RafaelPereira-dc9ir
      @RafaelPereira-dc9ir 2 года назад

      At least the daytime looks better in DE with a bit of dusk

    • @curiousmind_
      @curiousmind_ 2 года назад +7

      That was one of the best features of the game, every city had a special atmosphere, San Fierro was cloudy most of the time...
      They just ruined the game

    • @velvetblueco2422
      @velvetblueco2422 2 года назад +1

      I agree man i miss the unique atmosphere in each area. Those varying sky colors were so cool. As well as those gorgeous purple nights, i've encountered a blood red sky a few times. Looked so insane

  • @Yourcheerz
    @Yourcheerz 2 года назад +174

    PS2 had glossy cars and perfect early 90s atmosphere. On 480p CRT TV it was something magical

    • @Disissid19
      @Disissid19 2 года назад +17

      We will never get that PS2 look. Because technical limitations often create a "look" for games. But honestly. I think the 10th anniversary is not that bad. But the realistic lighting against the janky animations and stuff character models makes it the less definitive version to play

    • @skonafid
      @skonafid 2 года назад +9

      Ps2 version is definitive version. Or pc with mods

    • @crazyworldoutthere4379
      @crazyworldoutthere4379 2 года назад +4

      @@skonafid Xbox version is better than ps2

    • @anen9332
      @anen9332 2 года назад +1

      @@crazyworldoutthere4379 You wouldn't know it from this video: the uploader seemingly is running the OG Xbox at a sub-native output.
      Xbox ran this game at 480p, whereas the PS2 -- as was typically the case for the console -- ran the game in 480i (a notable step down in resolution).
      It's dispiriting to see an uploader push false ideas about different ports; the Xbox version of this game is technically superior, yet it looks like it's running at a lower res than the PS2 version in this upload.
      Rather shameful manipulation.

  • @martinvr12
    @martinvr12 2 года назад +142

    Wow didn't remember how low the draw distance was on the og consoles specially ps2, but It always gave me the feel that it was really big map with so much mystery behind that foggy distance.

    • @chrisonaldo0936
      @chrisonaldo0936 2 года назад +7

      Ps2 Version is legendary and i have a sealed one in a sealed trilogy 😁
      Who wants to buy?

    • @stakoman
      @stakoman 2 года назад +2

      Yeap true, that was actually because it was easier ( due to the technical limitations back then) to make the map seem bigger than i was...so they hit two birds with one stone!
      Looking at the game now? The effect it's difficult to justify.
      Imagine RDR2 the draw distance is huge, and it makes sense.
      It is what it is I guess,the important is too have fun.

    • @glopsnopper3806
      @glopsnopper3806 2 года назад +2

      @@chrisonaldo0936 $4

    • @sandres9098
      @sandres9098 2 года назад +7

      @@chrisonaldo0936 if I was you I wouldn't sell it, this is a relic

    • @Blitzinity
      @Blitzinity 2 года назад +2

      @@sandres9098 Yep, hold it. It gets valuable over time

  • @soundofreality
    @soundofreality 2 года назад +174

    Is way too dark, till the point that you can't see Big Smoke ordering two number 9s...

    • @JackTal0s
      @JackTal0s 2 года назад +4

      Then turn up your brightness

    • @bemlok
      @bemlok 2 года назад +10

      I don't understand why they made everything so dark and over saturated.

    • @thedeadzonemaniac5
      @thedeadzonemaniac5 2 года назад

      He also ordered a #9 large and a #6

    • @Raven-Purple
      @Raven-Purple 2 года назад

      it actually hurts

  • @lucio2010111
    @lucio2010111 2 года назад +61

    The lights are so weird in remaster, sometimes CJ bright when he's in dark and other times it's too dark to see who's in inside somewhere

    • @ells101
      @ells101 2 года назад +6

      That one where smoke's sister is leaving to see Cesar and you couldn't see her face in broad fucking daylight?? Lighting is one of the easiest ways to make things look better... this is nuts

    • @squadingo6395
      @squadingo6395 2 года назад +8

      @@ells101 that isn't smokes sister it's carls'

    • @PS2GAMER100
      @PS2GAMER100 2 года назад +3

      @@ells101 lol smokes sister 😂

    • @ells101
      @ells101 2 года назад +1

      @@squadingo6395 hahaha fucking yes im quite proud of that freudian slip, thanks for pointing it out fellas

    • @RatedSupreme
      @RatedSupreme 2 года назад

      I got CJ a lower back tattoo and I took his shirt off... And sometimes the lower back tattoo looks like CJ got a burn mark on his back. Is weird.

  • @ells101
    @ells101 2 года назад +211

    The lighting is pretty fucked in the Definitive Edition in many of those scenes

    • @maziusclavo8021
      @maziusclavo8021 2 года назад +21

      Its Richstar as expected, they dont care to make good versions of these games, they just want people to play the new gtas, thats why every new version of the classics is worse than the previous so the people go to play the new gtas.. this definitive is the worst version an utter scam already debunked on gtaforums, and its for kids because cockstar needs to milk them too

    • @ells101
      @ells101 2 года назад +10

      @@maziusclavo8021 agreed! it's also the reason why they got rid of the originals on steam, you can still buy keys though...

    • @Zand3rax
      @Zand3rax 2 года назад +10

      ​@@maziusclavo8021 True, this definitive version is full of red flags. But those die-hard fans was still saying "ugh, you wouldn't understand they keep the old looks because muh nostalgia"

    • @ells101
      @ells101 2 года назад +4

      @@Zand3rax I get their point, they're just happy to see a new game with a new lick of paint...but judging from comments on youtube it looks like even the fanatic fans are starting to see the cracks. I forecast a lot of refunds after release...I'm going out on a whim here but I think this "remaster" will have a lot of new bugs baked in. I'm going to die on that buggy hill. But hey, maybe Rockstar will give us some new speedrun strats lol

    • @rudraacharya8247
      @rudraacharya8247 2 года назад +3

      @@ells101 it's developed by Grove Street Games, which is the new name for wardrum studios... What can we expect, and yeah I was a fanatic fan but I'm really disappointed now.

  • @PALATA-Gaming
    @PALATA-Gaming 2 года назад +61

    Facial animation is far better in the older versions.

    • @zepic9093
      @zepic9093 2 года назад

      Even in gta 5 its really bad

    • @notyourbusiness1352
      @notyourbusiness1352 2 года назад +14

      @@zepic9093 how??

    • @Aidan977
      @Aidan977 2 года назад +15

      @@zepic9093 thats just false

    • @joskjj3625
      @joskjj3625 2 года назад +2

      @@zepic9093 that’s so false,don’t let nostalgia control you

    • @YellowSabre
      @YellowSabre 2 года назад +4

      @@zepic9093 You’re straight up spitting
      Just spitting

  • @landerphoon
    @landerphoon 2 года назад +307

    The vegetation in definitive edition looks incredibly mindblowing

    • @feloniousbutterfly
      @feloniousbutterfly 2 года назад +37

      Honestly indistinguishable from free assets you can get in unity.

    • @colestogsdill9268
      @colestogsdill9268 2 года назад +4

      Agreed

    • @zeroikaze6471
      @zeroikaze6471 2 года назад +4

      That's just vegetation assets bru

    • @gabrielfmm5465
      @gabrielfmm5465 2 года назад +28

      @@feloniousbutterfly jesus christ, its trees and bushes, all tress and bushes will look the same unless they are a cartoon version. People are making up shit to hate on this

    • @gabrielfmm5465
      @gabrielfmm5465 2 года назад +5

      @@zeroikaze6471 dont you say? everthing is a asset, hes talking about how good the asset models are.

  • @ThetrueHeero
    @ThetrueHeero 2 года назад +59

    The cutscenes are so dark I can’t tell what’s going on

  • @Inspire6
    @Inspire6 2 года назад +73

    The drive by mission..... Why is big smoke in such darkness during the daytime? 😂

    • @luisbravo5452
      @luisbravo5452 2 года назад +1

      lol yeah

    • @namanhchu898
      @namanhchu898 2 года назад +4

      because he's sitting in the car, pretty realistic lightning effects to be honest

    • @alexsilva28
      @alexsilva28 2 года назад +8

      Because this is the second half assed cash milking remaster of this game made

    • @KellanGDM
      @KellanGDM 2 года назад +5

      @@namanhchu898 that makes no sense. I could take a picture from outside of a car in the exact same angle and time of day and I'd be able to see everyone inside. + nevermind the fact that rockstar purposefully took out the front window of the car in the original so you could see the characters without the glass reflexion and grove street games put it back, making it impossible to see anyone when it switches to that shot.

    • @Inspire6
      @Inspire6 2 года назад +1

      @@namanhchu898 do you live in darkness? The back seat of a car being pitch black isn't realistic 😂

  • @jonathanbohm6489
    @jonathanbohm6489 2 года назад +46

    I really wish they did a San Andreas Stories game maybe where you could be Brian or Sweet in the 80s when Carl was gone would’ve been cool to see but the psp probably couldn’t handle the size of the map or amount of features but they did port those to ps2 so they could’ve made that an exclusive or something

    • @ralfsegle3119
      @ralfsegle3119 2 года назад +3

      in 2011 i wanted to buy a ps vita because i expected gta sa stories to come out on it :D

    • @RafaelPereira-dc9ir
      @RafaelPereira-dc9ir 2 года назад

      I mean GTA LCS and VCS with cutscenes and few other mechanisms ( specially cheats ) made the game badass with an hardware limit being good * btw wouldn’t Brian still had to explore SF , LV and other areas ? Unless you only play in LS City only

    • @Slicky_
      @Slicky_ 2 года назад

      There's a dyom mod for that

    • @superplayerex2431
      @superplayerex2431 2 года назад +1

      The PSP would very well be able to handle it, it's just that they decided to work on other projects instead. Unfortunately, since the chance for that game to be made was missed a long time ago, it will never happen now.

  • @MrRazer94
    @MrRazer94 2 года назад +14

    man they could've done more with this remaster. Adding pedestrian density, adding ragdoll physics, faster transition in buying items, cutscene ligthing, fogs. This "Definitive Edition" only look and feel like a mod, with pre-2010 hardware demand.

    • @NEELZE99
      @NEELZE99 2 года назад

      I agree

    • @RDDAMAN819_
      @RDDAMAN819_ 2 года назад

      Pedestrian density is the biggest disappointment to me. The cities still look lifeless and empty, with all the new hardware they could have had streets full of NPCS!

    • @matthewfreant9548
      @matthewfreant9548 2 года назад

      They already talked about why they didn't mess with it much. go read the interview they did with rockstar.

    • @MrRazer94
      @MrRazer94 2 года назад

      @@matthewfreant9548 coordinate, pls

  • @AK-sq1jl
    @AK-sq1jl 2 года назад +115

    What's crazy is the PC original actually looks almost as good and in some cases even better than the Definitive version.

    • @dancefoxks
      @dancefoxks 2 года назад +7

      Bruh u trippin

    • @AK-sq1jl
      @AK-sq1jl 2 года назад +2

      @@dancefoxks Maybe so cuz I've never played either version but just from what I saw in this video that's my take on it.

    • @featheryfemme
      @featheryfemme 2 года назад +6

      The only changes this game needed, in my opinion, is the PC version's resolution and the PS2 version's lighting. That's all I want. I think the Definitive Edition looks pretty bad, actually. Individually, everything looks pretty good, but together it just doesn't fit. Not just the characters vs environment, but just everything in general. It looks like models and textures were taken from a bunch of different sources and put together without any alteration to actually blend. Kinda like a mobile game. It just looks wrong.

    • @AK-sq1jl
      @AK-sq1jl 2 года назад

      @@featheryfemme I finally got to play the SA one last night and for me I think everything looks amazing from the ground but when you go high up it makes the world look like a theme park because of the draw distance lol

    • @featheryfemme
      @featheryfemme 2 года назад +1

      ​@@AK-sq1jl Definitive Edition? I don't have it, but I've only formed my opinion from the videos I've seen. I might change my mind if I play it, but as for now, I think the PC version looks best.

  • @Jun.H.T.
    @Jun.H.T. 2 года назад +35

    why is everything so dark in definitive edition

    • @mrl3044
      @mrl3044 2 года назад +1

      Different engine makes better graphics better graphics are usually a little darker

    • @damianslipknot666
      @damianslipknot666 2 года назад +12

      @@mrl3044 hell no , it seems you dont know the existence of indirect lighting

    • @Skellist
      @Skellist 2 года назад

      Because they completely changed the lighting, but didn't any new light sources to compensate for the new lighting system. It's really amateurish

    • @mrl3044
      @mrl3044 2 года назад

      @@damianslipknot666 seems I played a unfinished buggy game and I'm never giving war drum studios/Grove Street games any money beyond this point I hope they go bank rupt for this mess I would sympathetic but it seems everyone they make a game its about as glitchy as these games

    • @megakarlachofficial
      @megakarlachofficial 2 года назад +1

      The reason is mostly new lighting system, but also poorly applied Ambient Occlusion effect.

  • @UrBloodOnMyFace
    @UrBloodOnMyFace 2 года назад +74

    I really wished the definitive edition had the sunset/heat wave from the PS2 version

    • @RafaelPereira-dc9ir
      @RafaelPereira-dc9ir 2 года назад

      What happens if you the sunny cheat with the heatwaves ? Will it work ?

    • @UrBloodOnMyFace
      @UrBloodOnMyFace 2 года назад

      @@RafaelPereira-dc9ir honestly I haven't tried it out I still don't have the game yet

    • @velvetblueco2422
      @velvetblueco2422 2 года назад

      i agree 100%

  • @frjoethesecond
    @frjoethesecond 2 года назад +104

    PS2 version has an atmospheric touch that all other versions lack. It has a sort of dusty hot haze thing going on that suits the world very well IMO.
    You also get it on the PS4 version.

    • @gatoarabeclipes
      @gatoarabeclipes 2 года назад +26

      That yellow sunset atmosphere is so characteristic...

    • @RyanSaotome
      @RyanSaotome 2 года назад +5

      Yeah, I sure loved not being able to see more than 30 feet infront of me and everything being so blurry that you had to use your imagination for what stuff was supposed to be

    • @TheAprizzle92
      @TheAprizzle92 2 года назад +7

      50/50, there's a reason why people prefer the PS2 version the most. Look at the price of the PS2 version on Ebay mint condition, some of them have reached almost $1500 overnight. I have the PS4 version, it's the "10 year anniversary" made by Grove Street Games, a lot of people hate it. It's just not the same and a lot of content is missing.

    • @eliwallace3825
      @eliwallace3825 2 года назад +5

      that yellow/orangey haze is so nostalgic. i can see it in beautiful 480p quality

    • @frjoethesecond
      @frjoethesecond 2 года назад +10

      @@TheAprizzle92 Yeah, the 10 year anniversary is too clean. It's got no character or charm. Plus the controls are weird like the mobile version.
      The PS4 version is just an upscaled PS2 version with AA, widescreen support, trophies and new control schemes. Best of both worlds IMO.

  • @Aquarious
    @Aquarious 2 года назад +63

    2:04 this increased draw distance is terrible. Now the map looks tiny and the sense of scale is gone.

    • @udobybreak6393
      @udobybreak6393 2 года назад +8

      You're right.

    • @lolcatzidk
      @lolcatzidk 2 года назад +2

      I have to squint to even see the HP. Imagine while playing in-game

    • @cityplanner3063
      @cityplanner3063 2 года назад +10

      I don’t mind increasing draw distance but this new one is just to much. You fly a plane and you can see the whole map.

    • @chrisonaldo0936
      @chrisonaldo0936 2 года назад

      @@cityplanner3063 its bullshit

    • @nickrustyson8124
      @nickrustyson8124 2 года назад

      @@cityplanner3063 Though in that case, it's probably a good thing the draw distance was increased, because if you don't remember, the flight school has some broken missions because of the draw distance

  • @xXgtagod369Xx
    @xXgtagod369Xx 2 года назад +8

    There is a sick nostalgic vibe with the PS2 version. The heatwave and the color pallet is so nostalgic.

  • @FreeAimDog
    @FreeAimDog 2 года назад +3

    i am happy with the ps2 port on ps4 it has nice weather and orange tint that makes it look beautiful so i will just stick with that and play south park season 1 to 3 in the background to feel like the good old days.

  • @arhimaaljerrari3438
    @arhimaaljerrari3438 2 года назад +3

    I love how you always pick the perfect spots to comparison 👌

  • @man1699
    @man1699 2 года назад +17

    The character models from the PC original feel better than the definitive edition.

    • @YunethAlwis
      @YunethAlwis 2 года назад

      the texture work is better in the old, ryt?

  • @julianorozaa
    @julianorozaa 2 года назад +75

    PS2's art direction is still better than every version that came after.

    • @MovieGuy1998
      @MovieGuy1998 2 года назад +14

      Agree, the other versions lack the great atmoshere of the PS2 version.

    • @chillvibed
      @chillvibed 2 года назад +2

      I'm glad these games came out on ps2 now that I think about it. They would have never been as good if made even just a few year later.

    • @shahaffiq5860
      @shahaffiq5860 2 года назад +1

      I disagree

    • @nazdoesstuffYT
      @nazdoesstuffYT 2 года назад +2

      10th anniversary massacred San Andreas

    • @Sgt.SharkShock
      @Sgt.SharkShock 2 года назад

      @@MovieGuy1998 because the problem is when rockstar release pc version most of the re releases after that are simply pc versions and pc version was released in 2005 and at that time we didn't have good technology so rockstar should've re released ps2 version improved instead for other new versions because every re release is pc version modified except ps4 version

  • @Rainquack
    @Rainquack 2 года назад +9

    0:35 - It's interesting that they didn't really remake that cop seal thingy in some way.
    It looks like they processed the original texture through one of those neutral network algo based upscalers - there's some pretty characteristic artifacting particularly on the text.
    (The rest is still fine, but at least the text could've easily been remade, cause issues are most visible on it - they're a big point that those scalers still struggle with.)

    • @curiousmind_
      @curiousmind_ 2 года назад

      What do you expect from a developer named Grove Street Games lol

  • @Marlo_189
    @Marlo_189 2 года назад +13

    San Andreas look the best out of the remasters in my opinion best gta game of all time

  • @budaroddy
    @budaroddy 2 года назад +45

    Def. Edition with all this new engine and graphics, and PS2 one still have the most unique lighting effects

    • @stakoman
      @stakoman 2 года назад +1

      The nostalgia effect helps... but yea I understand what you are saying

    • @Jiterdomer
      @Jiterdomer 2 года назад

      OG PC version has achievements mod alongside SkyGFX.

  • @glopsnopper3806
    @glopsnopper3806 2 года назад +5

    2:05 fucking hell that is immersion breaking lmao

  • @ennizodev
    @ennizodev 2 года назад

    Finally out, I just waiting for this moment, thanks GTA videos for the comparison between this amazing game

  • @thecollectorsinged113
    @thecollectorsinged113 2 года назад +39

    Legit can't wait what the modders has instore for us, specially that it is now using a better software engine

    • @alexsilva28
      @alexsilva28 2 года назад +3

      Too bad Rockstar will probably send them cease and desist claims

    • @dava_arvarabi
      @dava_arvarabi 2 года назад +2

      It's difficult to mod UE4 compared to renderware, in fact I've heard UE4 is impossible to mod due to it using hex.

    • @majorwicket2261
      @majorwicket2261 2 года назад

      I bet it must come with lot of new bugs too haha

    • @megakarlachofficial
      @megakarlachofficial 2 года назад +2

      @@alexsilva28 They didnt this time tho, some modders was able to made it through, and Rockstar/GSG takes note such as Rain fix.
      btw, Take-Two is actually the one who send cease & desist and lawsuit towards modders, not rockstar mainly.

  • @theknownunknown3904
    @theknownunknown3904 2 года назад +3

    So basically a game made in 2004 + remastered in 2021 = a game which looks like it was made in 2010

  • @bemlok
    @bemlok 2 года назад +3

    I remember loving just driving a car crossing the map, just feeling the different atmospheres. Now is everything the same dark shadows and oversaturated colors...

  • @dnkypnch7442
    @dnkypnch7442 2 года назад +3

    I hope they have all the original radio stations and songs. Definitely the best out of all the gtas

    • @jagarske
      @jagarske 2 года назад +1

      They are missing a sizable chunk of songs from the originals.

  • @slemangerdy8407
    @slemangerdy8407 2 года назад +2

    after watching this, i am so damn impressed, by the original pc vs ps2 wow, the pc one is such an upgrade from both ps2 and xbox

  • @CJHaven
    @CJHaven 2 года назад +4

    I am surprisingly happy with the definitive edition. The only thing that absolutely sucks about the definitive edition is that they removed the co-op mode, I know it wasn't the best co-op mode in the world but it was still a lot of fun to play with your friends.

  • @darrendelanois1790
    @darrendelanois1790 2 года назад

    Bro been waiting for this

  • @metaljunkie8393
    @metaljunkie8393 2 года назад +1

    I love the open hands they still got when they interact or talk 👐

  • @killersg.8290
    @killersg.8290 2 года назад +1

    Tbh, the jet pack is the best thing I’ve ever seen, those flames r so good

  • @Roy3.16
    @Roy3.16 2 года назад +2

    no matter which version you're playing but nothing can beat the original PS2 version, that big west coast California Sun, that orange atmosphere, those props inside and outside of The Four Dragons Casino and more.. though I never played any game on PS2, PS3, PS4 or PS5 but I can honestly say the PS2 version of San Andreas is incomparable

  • @TheBestGamingCritic
    @TheBestGamingCritic 2 года назад

    Thanks for that big smoke order. It's been a minute.

  • @jessenthebenezer
    @jessenthebenezer 2 года назад +2

    Having grown up without a console, I kinda miss not experiencing the heatwave effect everyone is so fond of

  • @jmanaa9969
    @jmanaa9969 2 года назад +7

    The only thing I don't like is draw distances, at least they should be restricted between cites/areas. It really kills the sense of the map if you can see las venturas from mount chilliad.

    • @FootLettuce
      @FootLettuce 2 года назад +2

      2:04 the countryside and the forest look as if it was a part of the beach's theme park now

    • @YunethAlwis
      @YunethAlwis 2 года назад

      Grove Street Games remove their fog from every game they make, idk why

  • @rustedyoda7339
    @rustedyoda7339 2 года назад +40

    the remaster looks great in so many ways but it really comes off as a unreal engine 4 fan remake.
    like it can look downright gorgeous in many spots, and the characters are all much higher quality
    but it feels weird to me playing it, just doesn't feel like a rockstar created remake.

    • @arzugultekinguler4736
      @arzugultekinguler4736 2 года назад +11

      It is not done by them

    • @alexanderraz.
      @alexanderraz. 2 года назад +1

      It's Made by War Drum Studios lol

    • @alexsilva28
      @alexsilva28 2 года назад +5

      It definitely reeks of fan made product

    • @jessenthebenezer
      @jessenthebenezer 2 года назад +2

      Shows how insanely ignorant the post gta v fanbase is 🤣

    • @kobi7955
      @kobi7955 2 года назад

      Stop calling it a remake dumbass

  • @ankitbharad
    @ankitbharad 2 года назад +1

    Great edit GTA series team!

  • @heitorgodinho4560
    @heitorgodinho4560 2 года назад +7

    I love the PS2 version. Maybe it is for nostalgia, but playing it on a CRT screen is just something else. It’s the way I prefer to play it.

  • @adhwaithvnair4093
    @adhwaithvnair4093 2 года назад +4

    Rockstar really messed up the draw distance.. seeing multiple locations at once from a single point spoils the fun..

  • @LucasTowers__
    @LucasTowers__ 2 года назад +5

    not at all sold with the DE but damn gotta love the feel.

  • @DIEGANGSTER.
    @DIEGANGSTER. 2 года назад

    Wow!! El efecto del Jetpack está buenísimo

  • @nismogtr3702
    @nismogtr3702 2 года назад +1

    Will be playing the hell out of this when it comes out tomorrow

  • @microtheguyfromearth
    @microtheguyfromearth 2 года назад +2

    Man the graphics went up so much.. I never realized the PS2 was that "bad"

  • @KaiBane
    @KaiBane 2 года назад +5

    I can't wait to play this beauty on my Nintendo Switch.

    • @KoolAidDinkyTV
      @KoolAidDinkyTV 2 года назад +1

      Its going to look horrible on switch it looks better on PS5 or Xbox series X

    • @reaperoutfit9384
      @reaperoutfit9384 2 года назад

      @@KoolAidDinkyTV it looks like poop anyways, and still it is the only gta the switch has ever gotten. I love having a hacked switch so everything is freee

  • @dreadfullyd1701
    @dreadfullyd1701 2 года назад

    That Jetpack tho… My most spammed cheat code when I was 10 y/o.. Gorgeous.

  • @MrTeton
    @MrTeton 2 года назад +1

    I absolutely love that original Ps2 color palette! It's super nostalgic and it has that very warm feeling to it

  • @adrianacevedX2
    @adrianacevedX2 2 года назад +9

    Cutscenes are so dark

  • @Hilda1204
    @Hilda1204 2 года назад +23

    There are scenes were it's dark I can't see and the Definitive Edition looks like a fan made remake using Unreal Engine or reshade mod

    • @trevorphilips9065
      @trevorphilips9065 2 года назад

      It's not a remake

    • @Evanxbdlt
      @Evanxbdlt 2 года назад +1

      The fact definitive edition is made using unreal engine tho

  • @zypwrld
    @zypwrld 2 года назад +1

    Awesome comparison

  • @RyanTidwell
    @RyanTidwell 2 года назад +1

    I’m so glad you Big Smokes order in 4K.

  • @dann1185
    @dann1185 2 года назад +5

    I miss the glow the ps2 had during sunsets so nostalgic

  • @Lasqsam
    @Lasqsam 2 года назад +5

    Definitive edition? Or darkest edition? Everything looks with NBS series mood but a Lot of problems of lights and illumination

  • @AtsukoR33
    @AtsukoR33 2 года назад

    Hey Gta Series Video! Does GTA SA Definitive edition still have circlular spray patterns when shooting any gun? I really wonder if they changed that.

  • @ghostrideronthestorm
    @ghostrideronthestorm 2 года назад +1

    I don't know if it's nostalgy kicking in but i love the orange effect from ps2

  • @rainer_3260
    @rainer_3260 2 года назад +17

    0:56 La vegetacion esta espectacular gg rockstar en ese apartado del juego la hicieron re bien

    • @Walt2005
      @Walt2005 2 года назад

      Esa una kk hermano, ni se gastaron aunque fuera en meter animaciones al estilo gta v y los modelos mejorados, tanto en vehículos como en físicas.

    • @KellanGDM
      @KellanGDM 2 года назад

      @@Saymon-X.Oficial its a remake, the game runs in a different engine. They remade the game. They remade some models.

    • @YellowSabre
      @YellowSabre 2 года назад

      @@KellanGDM Did you seriously respond to a Foreign reply in English

    • @KellanGDM
      @KellanGDM 2 года назад

      @@YellowSabre I understand spanish + youtube has a translate button for them.

  • @igor4217
    @igor4217 2 года назад +2

    as good as the remaster looks, nothing beats the original pc ver. for me. grew up on that one and its a straight up classic, looks the best for me 😅

    • @chrisonaldo0936
      @chrisonaldo0936 2 года назад +1

      Ps2 Version is the best my friend 😉

  • @EQOAnostalgia
    @EQOAnostalgia 2 года назад +2

    I just want these graphics in Multi Theft Auto mod. Right after and play and beat this absolute BALLER of a game. Pun intended. Wait was that a pun? That was a pun right smoke?

  • @blaquenoise
    @blaquenoise 2 года назад

    I still have my OG Xbox and OG trilogy box disc set. But what will happen with a Xbox One X update patch? Will it be graphical only and/or will certain tracks be locked out because of licensing deals?

  • @Jdogg4089
    @Jdogg4089 2 года назад +7

    I noticed some scenes are too dark

  • @lukash.p.6631
    @lukash.p.6631 2 года назад +3

    I feel like sometimes a game need to be A world where you immerse yourself into and not OUR world, sometimes it dosnt need to be closer to Our World, closer to reality and just be A reality, the PS2 version have some many cool and atmospheric effects, that despise not been so real or having a clear image, its still is immersive. 1:49(pause)

  • @spideyworld1543
    @spideyworld1543 2 года назад +1

    0:48 this will never get old still legendary 🔥🔥🔥❤️

  • @MrCrispyNips04
    @MrCrispyNips04 2 года назад

    It's weird, I love the old videogame styling and models with a modern rendering, looks really cool, reminds me of those Ultra graphics mods you can get for games like this

  • @jiggy7376
    @jiggy7376 2 года назад +9

    Not so impressed but it looks cool. Just a remaster of an old school game. of course not 2021 graphics, I wouldn’t want that either. Still feel the classic game. But if u played the original one. Its not worth it to pay 70$ for all of them. I would pay maybe 30/40 for all 3 of them. Way too expensive just for story mode

  • @Nemesis2508.
    @Nemesis2508. 2 года назад +2

    Surprised there's no clutter and stuff in the alley way you start it. If I'm not mistaken, that was remedied by a mod.

  • @YamiGenesis
    @YamiGenesis 2 года назад

    3:00 look how straight those bullets are in the definitive edition lol

  • @frosoftairgamer6454
    @frosoftairgamer6454 2 года назад +1

    It will be fun to see the gta remastered in sa:mp and mta it would be awesome

  • @MovieGuy1998
    @MovieGuy1998 2 года назад +21

    PS2 is the definitive version of the game!

    • @kobi7955
      @kobi7955 2 года назад +1

      I'd say the Xbox version is the definitive version but the PS2 version happens to be more popular

    • @MovieGuy1998
      @MovieGuy1998 2 года назад

      @@kobi7955 The PS2 version has this 90s feel. The orange lightnig effect around Los Santos and Las Venturas for example.

    • @kobi7955
      @kobi7955 2 года назад +1

      @@MovieGuy1998 The graphics are noticeably better on the Xbox, even better than the PC version in some aspects and runs significantly better than the PS2 version which is better than some orange filter imo.

    • @JM-io2uv
      @JM-io2uv 2 года назад

      @@kobi7955 fr personally I feel the xbox is better than the ps2 because that orange filter used to look weird when I was ab 9 in 05 and also unlike the pc version you cant see too far into the distance which makes the map jus look bigger tbf

    • @kobi7955
      @kobi7955 2 года назад +1

      @@JM-io2uv Def agree

  • @gatoarabeclipes
    @gatoarabeclipes 2 года назад +9

    DE looks really dark and over saturated :/

  • @Roy3.16
    @Roy3.16 2 года назад +1

    3:19 wow that PS2 atmosphere

  • @DiaraAmaheza
    @DiaraAmaheza 2 года назад +1

    the definitive version with the jetpack is speechless

  • @WillSmith-yi4ez
    @WillSmith-yi4ez 2 года назад +6

    I hope they make seperate titles. Because as of now only improved game is GTA SA. Vice city and 3 don't look good. In fact originals in these 2 look better except San andreas of course.

  • @aldinhzek4082
    @aldinhzek4082 2 года назад +1

    I think when it gets to breathing new life to old games devs should just do complete remakes of them. Better graphics and effects don't usually go well with older games' stylistic choices due to their hardware limits at the time.

  • @YungBeezer
    @YungBeezer 2 года назад +1

    San Fiero can be seen from Los Santos just like San Francisco can be seen from LA! Love this attention to detail!

  • @iquickscope52
    @iquickscope52 2 года назад

    legend for addin the "ah shit, here we go again"

  • @FouadYounes940407
    @FouadYounes940407 2 года назад +5

    Miss the heatwaves the fogs the not overly absurd darkness and contrast i miss when its not simpson clay petroleum jelly charachters!

    • @Marcelg13
      @Marcelg13 2 года назад

      than just play the ps2 game and stop complaining 🙄

  • @mr.raccoon.
    @mr.raccoon. 2 года назад +6

    compared to gta3 and vice city, in San Andreas they did a better remastered

  • @KellanGDM
    @KellanGDM 2 года назад +1

    rockstar purposefully took out the front window of the car in the original so you could see the characters without the glass reflexion and grove street games put it back, making it impossible to see anyone when it switches to that shot.

  • @mrmafiahat3852
    @mrmafiahat3852 2 года назад +1

    "Ah shit, Here we go again." Indeed it's time to complete the story again

  • @pedropeixoto8769
    @pedropeixoto8769 2 года назад +8

    I'm not racist but on DE, sometimes I can't see CJ

  • @iamiqbal6369
    @iamiqbal6369 2 года назад +6

    Why Definitive Edition look so dark:(

  • @Sunsetradi0
    @Sunsetradi0 2 года назад

    I'm wondering if the music is there or of we are not getting the original music back

  • @minnieswimmie9180
    @minnieswimmie9180 2 года назад +1

    It's much harder to see the character's face in general due to the lighting change. It'd be nice if they did something to fix this.