Het grootste nadeel van deze uitvoering vind ik dat, als ie eenmaal aan staat, ik ‘m met geen mogelijkheid meer af kan zetten...! Weelderig, hallucinaties verwekkend mooi...! Dank...!
There is something to this piece of music that makes it click into my brain again and again, but still makes me long for more. Like an unfinished mathematic formula.... its like a musical fractal.
Like Steve Reich's, this music makes you wonder how you hear music and how its can gradually transform you. These "minimalist" composers have a thing - or two - to teach us. Thank you to Simeon ten Holt. And, by the way, incredible performance with amazing attention of the musicians to each other... Thanks !
Prachtig stuk, en prachtig uitgevoerd! Al jaren mijn favoriete muziek om me op iets moeilijks te concentreren, vooral als ik voor mijn werk lange stukken moet schrijven. Ik vind er iedere keer weer mijn ''flow'' mee. Dank jullie wel!!
Dear Maestro VanVeen, thank you for uploading this magnificent performance of this iconic piece. Humbly, my favorite version of this composition that I have heard so far.
You know you enjoy a piece of music when it's two and a half hours long, and it gets to the end and your thought is "oh. is that all?" :D Brilliant performance. :D
Scott Lawrence Your comment is probably the best evidence of the lack of true repetition in this music which is based on phasing and the musicians' focus on each other. I couldn't agree more with you. :o)
I think what he was saying is that although on the surface, it seems to be identically repetitive, in actuality, there are enough nuances from the performance and the musicians' interactions that change that there's something there to keep it interesting and exciting to listen for.
Simeon ten Holt died a year before this was published on RUclips. I find it very intriguing to learn about great works or great people after their death. There's something entrancing and mysterious partly in the genre and in how the music sounds but also in the effect that those who have passed have some keen essence to be appreciated about them.
I know! I've listened to classical music all my life, with a fondness for the moderns, and I heard about this guy through RUclips a few years ago. Sheesh! His canvas is small, but these are perfect paintings
Dit stuk blijft prachtig, virtuoos en schept mogelijkheden voor andere vormen van kunst. We hebben het Canto O. eens in de Domkerk Utrecht gehoord (op orgel) terwijl een derwish daarbij zijn dans uitvoerde. Inspirerend en ontroerend, zo intens, écht prachtig. Hartelijk dank voor deze prachtige vertolking op vleugel !
Love Canto ostinato so much!!! Unluckily never heard it live (bought tickets for Groningen but missed out). You've got 1000 reasons to perform it at BBC Proms!
This is without a doubt one of the best performances of perhaps the best piece for four pianos! Each musician’s clarity, nuance, and sustained vigilant attention to ensemble piano is without parallel. The excellent lighting, videography and sound engineering only enhance the performance. I would loved to have been present for this live recording. I suspect this particular performance far exceeds the expectations Simeon ten Holt could imagine his composition to achieve.
Some day in the 21st century with amazing electronic devices to meet virtually all human needs, including self-driving automobiles, one would think that musicians would no longer need to interrupt themselves by reaching up by hand to turn a printed page. 26 March 2018
Wat een schitterende muziek! Ik ben al enige tijd bezig iets moeilijks te schrijven over een mix van kosmologie, kwantumfysica en filosofie. Deze tonen vertolken mijn gedachten.
Ja, Rien van Sijl, een prachtige combi! Ik schreef "Exploratie" waarin ik vooral op zoek ben naar het tijdsbegrip. Dit stuk is voor drie piano's en neemt ongeveer 2h15m in beslag: ook in dat werk komt de tijd als het ware stil te staan. Wel jammer, dat bij het thema van Canto voor de eerste keer een vertraging wordt uitgevoerd: alsof het moeite kost om daarna weer op gang te komen
Many years before I discovered Philip Glass (in Stuttgart 1984: Premiere of Akhnaten), Steve Reich, Wim Mertens, Michael Nyman, John Adams, Arvo Pärt (all still living, thank God) ............ and why not him up to-day, August 25th, 2015 (+ 2012, RIP)?
the truth is, and the same thing applies to the very all major tracks i 'm found of, they sounds so familiar, as we already / ever knew them from a very long time , deep in our soul, even through all these lifes we never had. (i don't see an easier way to say this, as english is not my native words, so this one sound weird and tricky ! )
Could this the the definitive performance?! Thanks, Jeroen, for posting these complete performances on RUclips. Very much appreciated. But what about the other pieces by ten Holt?
Nice indeed but when will there ever be another 5+ hours performance like in Vredenburg end of the 80's/begin 90's? It looks like CO has a kind of standard format nowadays.
There is a cd-album of Sandra and Jeroen (and friends) called Canto Ostinato XXL, which contains a single performance of this piece with a duration of 4 to 5 hours.
i'm coming to realise that i like the piano more than any other instrument. because there's no nonsense about it. the similarites to michael nyman's music for 'the piano', 1993, is at times overwhelming. i trust nyman has acknowleged this?
@@Drabkikker then beautiful both section 74 and 95 haha tbh I played forward the vid to find that motiv which I thought was section 74 and had no idea 95 existed... Happy to know now even though they're pretty similar :D Thank you! haha
Mijn beste ziels vriendin heb me dit mooie spel der tonen laten horen ze is nu in spirit en na haar verlosing was ik buiten in bergen een steiger aan demonteren en toen uit een verlaten huis kwam dit stuk wouw
Zodra er serieus werk (grafisch ontwerp) verzet moet worden, zet ik dit op. Naast dat ik het simpelweg prachtig vind, boort het een bepaalde mate van 'focus' aan, die ik anders niet bereik. Heel bijzonder.
I know cat videos are more up everybody's alley but If you have a few minutes, I'd love to get your thoughts on my songs/videos. I'm always trying to improve. I know how busy we all are and truly appreciate you taking a moment to watch. Thanks! Tiff
Like it or not, both the composer's piece and the performers are all displays of 'talent.' Disliking this is O.K. To say 'no talent' just shows a near complete ignorance of what it takes to compose a piece or to perform it. The score requires/allows for a myriad of variants as determined by the performers in the moment. The nature of this piece is of a quiet virtuosity; the concentration -- and stamina -- required of the performers is intense.
Видеоклипы![Ten Holt: Canto Ostinato - Complete - Live [HD]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/JDCsOL2vBJc/mqdefault.jpg)
![Ten Holt: Canto Ostinato - Complete - Live [HD]](/img/tr.png)
![Newmen - Canto Ostinato (2023) [Full Album] w/ Synthesizers](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/kB_piDsORAk/mqdefault.jpg)
Het grootste nadeel van deze uitvoering vind ik dat, als ie eenmaal aan staat, ik ‘m met geen mogelijkheid meer af kan zetten...! Weelderig, hallucinaties verwekkend mooi...! Dank...!
There is something to this piece of music that makes it click into my brain again and again, but still makes me long for more. Like an unfinished mathematic formula.... its like a musical fractal.
Maths and music are the same 😀
If you need to study, put this music on. It'll help you.
Bana klasik müziği sevdiren karsu'ya buradan selamlar
En nog steeds raak ik in een schrijfflow met dit stuk magisch mooie Canto Ostinato.
Als 60 jarige ontdek ik deze schitterende compositie helaas nu pas.Bedankt voor jullie prachtige uitvoering
Lekker man
Moving water never bores.
dé video waarmee ik altijd mn tentamens doorkom!
Like Steve Reich's, this music makes you wonder how you hear music and how its can gradually transform you. These "minimalist" composers have a thing - or two - to teach us. Thank you to Simeon ten Holt. And, by the way, incredible performance with amazing attention of the musicians to each other... Thanks !
Heerlijk dat repeterende! Vooral heel meditatief als ik aan het koken ben of gewoon wil luisteren. Zen! Een meesterwerk! Chapeau!
KArsuuu selaaaaaaam
Prachtig stuk, en prachtig uitgevoerd! Al jaren mijn favoriete muziek om me op iets moeilijks te concentreren, vooral als ik voor mijn werk lange stukken moet schrijven. Ik vind er iedere keer weer mijn ''flow'' mee. Dank jullie wel!!
Dear Maestro VanVeen, thank you for uploading this magnificent performance of this iconic piece. Humbly, my favorite version of this composition that I have heard so far.
ben verliefd op dit stuk. Hoorde het voor het eerst in het reality-tv programma utopia. Mijn dank aan Nicoline Smalbraak die dit organiseerde
So glad i found this piece. Incredible!
Thank you Veldhoven. Thank you everyone. Achievements at so many levels and life-changing music.
Was er bij, erg mooi en kan zeer waarderen dat ik dit nog eens kan herbeleven hier. Dank je.
Teşekkürler KARSU vizyonun muhteşem.
You know you enjoy a piece of music when it's two and a half hours long, and it gets to the end and your thought is "oh. is that all?" :D Brilliant performance. :D
Scott Lawrence Your comment is probably the best evidence of the lack of true repetition in this music which is based on phasing and the musicians' focus on each other. I couldn't agree more with you. :o)
I think what he was saying is that although on the surface, it seems to be identically repetitive, in actuality, there are enough nuances from the performance and the musicians' interactions that change that there's something there to keep it interesting and exciting to listen for.
Scott Lawrence
Dead right. Thanks ! :-)
I enjoyed listening to it in a live concert in an old church in central Amsterdam...
How did I get to be so old and not know this man's music?
I said the same thing. Glad I finally made it.
HA..Yes. for me its well better late than never.
Fredrick Zinos Yep! And I found it purely by chance!
Simeon ten Holt died a year before this was published on RUclips. I find it very intriguing to learn about great works or great people after their death. There's something entrancing and mysterious partly in the genre and in how the music sounds but also in the effect that those who have passed have some keen essence to be appreciated about them.
I know! I've listened to classical music all my life, with a fondness for the moderns, and I heard about this guy through RUclips a few years ago. Sheesh! His canvas is small, but these are perfect paintings
Dit stuk blijft prachtig, virtuoos en schept mogelijkheden voor andere vormen van kunst. We hebben het Canto O. eens in de Domkerk Utrecht gehoord (op orgel) terwijl een derwish daarbij zijn dans uitvoerde. Inspirerend en ontroerend, zo intens, écht prachtig. Hartelijk dank voor deze prachtige vertolking op vleugel !
The mysterie to be one with music.....
How brilliant, how thrilling. Thank you for posting. Shame that I have only just discovered this music.Thank you R3.
Love Canto ostinato so much!!! Unluckily never heard it live (bought tickets for Groningen but missed out). You've got 1000 reasons to perform it at BBC Proms!
This is without a doubt one of the best performances of perhaps the best piece for four pianos! Each musician’s clarity, nuance, and sustained vigilant attention to ensemble piano is without parallel. The excellent lighting, videography and sound engineering only enhance the performance. I would loved to have been present for this live recording. I suspect this particular performance far exceeds the expectations Simeon ten Holt could imagine his composition to achieve.
Rien de mieux...Que de bonnes bases pour commencer dans cette vie et entrevoir l'autre...En musique.
Een fantastisch stuk! Elke keer als ik er naar luister kom ik helemaal tot rust. Supergaaf!
What wonderfull music! Thanks for this performance!
This is perfection.
Спасибо Анне Виленской за такое открытие! :)
Я тоже открыл для себя тен Холта благодаря её лекциям!
Fantastic! Thank you 👏👏👏
Dit werkt fantastisch! Wat knap dat je dit kunt spelen trouwens, ik heb diep respect voor de concentratie die daarvoor nodig is.
Het blijft fantastisch en verrassend. Streling voor oor en geest
Simply wonderful!!
Heel meditatieve muziek. Echt heel mooi en eigentijds!
Karsudan geldim❤️❤️ arada gelip dinliyorum …
Some day in the 21st century with amazing electronic devices to meet virtually all human needs, including self-driving automobiles, one would think that musicians would no longer need to interrupt themselves by reaching up by hand to turn a printed page.
26 March 2018
Most jazz musicians use i pads nowadays
Wat een schitterende muziek! Ik ben al enige tijd bezig iets moeilijks te schrijven over een mix van kosmologie, kwantumfysica en filosofie. Deze tonen vertolken mijn gedachten.
Ja, Rien van Sijl, een prachtige combi! Ik schreef "Exploratie" waarin ik vooral op zoek ben naar het tijdsbegrip. Dit stuk is voor drie piano's en neemt ongeveer 2h15m in beslag: ook in dat werk komt de tijd als het ware stil te staan.
Wel jammer, dat bij het thema van Canto voor de eerste keer een vertraging wordt uitgevoerd: alsof het moeite kost om daarna weer op gang te komen
Amazing fantastic
Many years before I discovered Philip Glass (in Stuttgart 1984: Premiere of Akhnaten), Steve Reich, Wim Mertens, Michael Nyman, John Adams, Arvo Pärt (all still living, thank God) ............ and why not him up to-day, August 25th, 2015 (+ 2012, RIP)?
Heel mooie uitvoering. Misschien ook even de componist noemen:
* Simeon Ten Holt! *
May he rest in peace, en be played for ever and ever..
dank je wel! heel ontspannen, ook tijdens leren!
Потрясающе! Просто невозможно оторваться!
So many variations possible in this seemingly repetitive phrase!
How very elegant.
Magical.
This so lovely, all in joint effort
This is fabulous! Where can I find 3 more pianists and 4 grand pianos to play it? It sure is real fun
Absolutamente brilhante! Uma obra-prima do Século XX, muito superior a qualquer peça atonal.
I am only 16 but i enjoy this wonderful music
the truth is, and the same thing applies to the very all major tracks i 'm found of, they sounds so familiar, as we already / ever knew them from a very long time , deep in our soul, even through all these lifes we never had. (i don't see an easier way to say this, as english is not my native words, so this one sound weird and tricky ! )
It feels like they have found you, rather than you found them. I have the same feeling sometimes when I read philosophy.
Great spiritual sound foundations u got
you're awesome, Pierre! "weird and tricky", indeed but I love it! :D
Why do u think, that every one here should know thats ur 16?
100 comments! im making a song rn like this but way shorter and i use this song to listen to while studying
Could this the the definitive performance?! Thanks, Jeroen, for posting these complete performances on RUclips. Very much appreciated. But what about the other pieces by ten Holt?
Mooie uitvoering, weer anders dan vorige gehoorde, inspireert bij alles wat je ondertussen ook kunt doen ( of niet)
Jullie zijn nog niet eens begonnen of ik heb er al zin in. Wat een mooi werk ook, nu even verder luisteren.
Nice indeed but when will there ever be another 5+ hours performance like in Vredenburg end of the 80's/begin 90's? It looks like CO has a kind of standard format nowadays.
There is a cd-album of Sandra and Jeroen (and friends) called Canto Ostinato XXL, which contains a single performance of this piece with a duration of 4 to 5 hours.
i'm coming to realise that i like the piano more than any other instrument. because there's no nonsense about it. the similarites to michael nyman's music for 'the piano', 1993, is at times overwhelming. i trust nyman has acknowleged this?
For a visual representation try a Mandelbrot figure. The start is about defining the fractal
2:04:32 beautiful section 74
@@Drabkikker really? Then I think I cannot hear the difference lol I'd still swear that's section 74! Please enlighten me :)
@@Drabkikker then beautiful both section 74 and 95 haha tbh I played forward the vid to find that motiv which I thought was section 74 and had no idea 95 existed... Happy to know now even though they're pretty similar :D Thank you! haha
Mijn beste ziels vriendin heb me dit mooie spel der tonen laten horen ze is nu in spirit en na haar verlosing was ik buiten in bergen een steiger aan demonteren en toen uit een verlaten huis kwam dit stuk wouw
Obstinate pleasure
Karsu'dan sonra gelenler?
Just try to to listen to this during a slideshow of van Gogh's paintings.
Zodra er serieus werk (grafisch ontwerp) verzet moet worden, zet ik dit op. Naast dat ik het simpelweg prachtig vind, boort het een bepaalde mate van 'focus' aan, die ik anders niet bereik. Heel bijzonder.
Very slow climax, that odd note keep ringing but then music adds more and makes that odd note sound so adventurous
SIMEON TEN HOLT HEETTE HIJ !!!!!!!!
Why do they switch places at 1:21:10 and 1:22:06 ?
In five... all the way, lol.
Karsu'ya bir tesekkur de benden..
Aşk kadın ❤️
Wonder if this was written or built on improvising
Or improvised and written down for many students to try
It took the composer 3 years to write it ('76-'79). He wrote other peaces like this one. But Canto Ostinato is the best.
zzzzooooo mmmmoooiiii
Kafa dinlemek için birebir
Wonderful piece. And aren't the performers wiped out after playing it? It seems like it would require immense physical and mental stamina.
I know cat videos are more up everybody's alley but If you have a few minutes, I'd love to get your thoughts on my songs/videos. I'm always trying to improve. I know how busy we all are and truly appreciate you taking a moment to watch.
Thanks!
Tiff
Nee hoor, ik ben fan, maar deze uitvoering begint te houterig. Het brengt mij niet meteen in extase.
BTf!!
ik vind philop glass toch beter, dit is gepruts op de piano voor kinderen misschien....
de start is al niet goed, amateurs..
Ik heb jou het anders niet beter horen doen. Over amateurs gesproken.... We wachten wel totdat jij het beter doet
show without real talent...
Comment with no positive intent. Or are we now all supposed to recognise your superiority?
Like it or not, both the composer's piece and the performers are all displays of 'talent.' Disliking this is O.K. To say 'no talent' just shows a near complete ignorance of what it takes to compose a piece or to perform it. The score requires/allows for a myriad of variants as determined by the performers in the moment. The nature of this piece is of a quiet virtuosity; the concentration -- and stamina -- required of the performers is intense.