Why Has Egypt Closed its Borders to Palestine? | Albert Mohler
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 12 май 2024
- John and Dr Mohler discuss the intricacies of the Hamas and Israel conflict.
Dr Albert Mohler is President of the Southern Baptist Theological Seminary. He is the author of many books, and his daily podcast The Briefing, analysing the world from a biblical perspective, is heard worldwide. His latest book is Tell Me the Stories of Jesus: The Explosive Power of Jesus’ Parables.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Conversations feature John Anderson, former Deputy Prime Minister of Australia, interviewing the world's foremost thought leaders about today's pressing social, cultural and political issues.
John believes proper, robust dialogue is necessary if we are to maintain our social strength and cohesion. As he puts it; "You cannot get good public policy out of a bad public debate."
If you value this discussion and want to see more like it, make sure you subscribe to the channel here: / @johnandersonconversat...
And stay right up to date with all the conversations by subscribing to the newsletter here: johnanderson.net.au/contact/
Follow John on Twitter: / johnandersonac
Follow John on Facebook: / johnandersonac
Follow John on Instagram: / johnandersonac
Support the channel: johnanderson.net.au/support/
Website: johnanderson.net.au/
Podcast: johnanderson.net.au/podcasts/
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
/ albertmohler
/ albertmohlersbts
/ albertmohler
/ @albertmohlerofficial
"Why Has Egypt Closed its Borders to Palestine?"
With 75% of Palestinians reportedly supporting Hamas, I should think ANY country would be daft to allow the migration of Palestinians into their country.
Which begs the question as to why Australia's current communist "government" and communist bureaucracy decide to let in 330 Palestinians with another 1,943 Palestinians granted visas.
Simple. Albo is pro-Palestinians. Been that way all his adult life, but as PM he has to temper his words.
Palestinian = HAMAS
Labor vote= islam party vote. Labor is Islam.
In 1992 Denmark took in 320 palistinensians. By now, 64% of them has convictions on hard crime...
There always needs to be a group of islamists fighting in behalf of Islam . Egypt knows this and puts on a front of blocking their fellow Muslims in Gaza . It's all for the greater good . Just ask Allah and his prophet Mohammed. Prove me wrong
Because the neighbouring Arab countries saw what Palestinien immigrants did to Lebanon & Labour want to bring them here!
Not just Lebanon, but Jordan as well with the Black September coup by the PLO.
Egypt has had its own troubles with the Palestinians coming into Egypt killing Egyptian civilians, police, and military personnel.
They have actually strengthened the Rafah border.
Palestinians have caused trouble in Arab nations before
@@cohort075 yup exactly. They betrayed Kuwait too. Kuwait accepted them too, some were given ministerial posts. But when Iraq invaded Kuwait, instead of defending Kuwait, they looted Kuwait. Even refrigerators were looted🤣🤣🤣. The problem with the Gazans, you give them an inch, they want a whole mile, you give them a mile, they want the whole country🤣🤣🤣
@@MargaretCampbell583 and look what they are doing right now all over the US
Why 52 Muslim countries like Indonesia not taking Palestinians?
Why is Indonesia getting away with East Timor and the on going genocide in West Papua?
Would you?
@@philmckrakin6752 very good question and with the recent American CIA supported stooge hummm
Because They want them to fight the Jews in the name of islam. Palestines = Israel problem 😢
They serve as a tool to their Nazi agenda sadly
I am a South African and I support Israel... God bless and protect Israel... 🇿🇦🇮🇱
I am an American and I support and pray for the good people of South Africa.
God bless and keep you.
are you a white south african?
@@bwana-ma-coo-bah425 found the racist!
White Afrikaans I guess. No one supports an apartheid evil state.
Isreal and apartheid south Africa were best buddies
From Canada. I stand with Israel
Canadian also, and absolutely disgusted with the response of the Trudeau/Liberal government! All of the Palestinians in Canada that supports in any fashion the continued existence of Hamas and their actions on October 7/23 should be stripped of Canadian citizenship or residential status and shipped back to Gaza at their own expense!
From Scotland we stand with Palestine 🇵🇸 we are totally against genocidal Israel
😂
Even a casual knowledge of what Palestinians did in Jordan and Lebanon gives all the answer required.
If "Palestine" is real then so is Narnia.
In this vein, so it Jerusalem or David...all fictitious.
@@ZxumaPalestine is a fictional nation and country that never existed and never will
The “Palestinians” are mostly from Jordan.. Egypt has said this itself.
@@Zxuma one's been around 100 years, the other's 10,000
@@goji059: Are you referring to similar fiction like WAKANDA?!!
Yes, absolutely true.
The big problem hatred of Jews didn't go away with the NAZIS.
No in the Middleast they hate every colonizer equally whether he is Muslim/Christian/Jew/Athiest.
Mayabe we hate Polish and Ukranian invaders just slightly more to be truly honest.
It has nothing to do with religion trust me.
It's becoming crystal clear that Western governments only believe in free speech when it serves their interests. If it's something such as pro Palestinian activism, people are censored, banned, and even arrested. Hypocrisy! Hypocrisy!
Hypocrisy!!
It’s in their Quran
@@heerasubedi234 Do you have proof of what you claimed, or should everyone provide you with blind trust?
Israel use rockets to protect their women and children. Hamas use women and children to protect their rockets
There's no country or state called Palestine
Historically, there has never been a country / state called Palestine. And there will never be.
@@davidbenjamin4798unfortunately, the UN formally recognised it last week.
@@jamesgreig5168
@@davidbenjamin4798 If that is the case, how do you explain the existence of coins and stamps with the name Palestine on them? I know Israel has a habit of ignoring UN Resolutions whenever it suits them, but the rest of us recognise them.
@@davidbenjamin4798 And yet Golda Meir held a Palestinian passport.
Every Arab who calls himself a “ Palestinian “ should be required to take a short course in the history of the Middle East.
Are you certain that they can read?
the vast majority of today's pal-ians are the descendants of Egyptians who were forced to move there in the early 1900s. Most have Egyptian family names, not Arab names. Egyptians take umbridge at being called Arab.
Have you studied the 'History of the Middle East'? It would seem not given your statement.
@@johnwilson5637 Oh please, take your ignorance someplace else. The quote I'm leaving doesn't even include the main forcing of Egyptians into the area in the early 1900s. "In the late 18th and early 19th centuries, Egypt experienced significant waves of emigration to Palestine. One notable influx occurred in the 1780s due to a severe famine in Egypt. According to one estimate, approximately one-sixth of the Egyptian population migrated during this period, with many settling in Palestine.[5]
Between 1831 and 1840, during Muhammad Ali's conquests and later under his son, Ibrahim Pasha, Egyptian settlers and army dropouts settled in Palestine. These immigrants primarily settled in well-established cities such as Jaffa and Gaza, where they founded sakināt (residential districts). Some dispersed into villages. Historically, there were 19 villages in the southern coastal plain and near Ramla with families of Egyptian descent. Today, remnants of this migration can still be seen in the northern parts of the Samaria region, particularly in the 'Ara Valley, where a significant population of Egyptian descent resides.[6
@@johnwilson5637 In the late 18th and early 19th centuries, Egypt experienced significant waves of emigration to Palestine. One notable influx occurred in the 1780s due to a severe famine in Egypt. According to one estimate, approximately one-sixth of the Egyptian population migrated during this period, with many settling in Palestine.[5]
Between 1831 and 1840, during Muhammad Ali's conquests and later under his son, Ibrahim Pasha, Egyptian settlers and army dropouts settled in Palestine. These immigrants primarily settled in well-established cities such as Jaffa and Gaza, where they founded sakināt (residential districts). Some dispersed into villages. Historically, there were 19 villages in the southern coastal plain and near Ramla with families of Egyptian descent. Today, remnants of this migration can still be seen in the northern parts of the Samaria region, particularly in the 'Ara Valley, where a significant population of Egyptian descent resides.[6
While most Australians would condemn China's brutal treatment of Muslims, it is becoming easier every day to understand why the CCP did what they did. They recognised a threat to their society and dealt with it. In contrast, many Western countries invited the enemy in and let it metastesise in our schools and universities under the misguided notion that indiscriminate multiculturalism is good for the country.
China did not treat Muslims brutally.
Where did you get that false notion?
Except what has the Uighur done to deserve being sent to modern day versions of concentration camps?
Being Muslim ain't a qualification.
Everyone scared of Islam because it is true and superior.
There are ways, and there are other ways. I would hope you aren't suggesting that internment camps be set up in Australia.
@@flankspeedHahaha, Australia started life as an internment camp.
There will always be an Israel. There will never be a Palestine.
It is interesting that no Arab nation has offered sanctuary to Gazan Arabs, the reason being that gazan Arabs cause disruption and trouble wherever they go. In Jordan for instance Yasser Arafat, the PLO and refugees disrupted and caused unrest in Jordan to such an extent that the Jordanian government took military action against them and expelled them from the country. Similarly in Lebanon Hezbollah has become such a powerful force in Lebanon, so much so that the Lebanese government cannot get rid of them militarily but would like to see the back of them due to their destabilizing presence. Egypt is simply preventing the same thing happening in their already fragile political situation.
In Egypt they assassinated their premier! Egypt never happier than when they sealed off Gaza in 1979 and ordered Israel to deal with it. Black September in Jordan saw expulsion and death of 25,000. Kuwait deported 300,000 for supporting Sadam invasion. Funny thing is ... They’re all technically Roman Palestinian... Gaza, Israel, Jordan, Syria, Lebanon, even part of Iraq was roman Palestine. The West Bank is where Jordan invaded Israel territory and dumped insurgents!! Other Muslim nations have more common sense than the west does.
Continued prayers for the IDF the hostages and their families for Jewish people across the world we stand with Israel bring them home🙏🌼🤝
Nethanyahu is not going to bring the hostages home, it doesn't serve his agenda. He also propped Hamas many years as it served his agenda.
God bless Israel ❤️❤️❤️❤️
In1948 with the establishment of Israeli the same deal was offered to the Arabs, but they declined.
It's the way the Palestinians conduct themselves as the victim while going on the attack...EVERYONE has had enough.
It's the way the *Israelis* conduct themselves as the victim while going on the attack...EVERYONE has had enough.
There, fixed it for you.
I remember when I was an underground mining apprentice going to union meetings , the rep started talking about Palestine??? All we wanted was more safety and dollars. I didn't even know where Palestine was.
Well, there is a Palestine, Ohio and a Palestine, Texas. There is no Palestine in the Middle East.
What is the connection between the purpose of the meeting you mentioned and Palestine, which you included in a crude and unjustified manner?
@@mohamedali2858No connection, that’s his point.
@@littlecatfeet9064 Tell a rational person something that does not make sense, then if he believes it then he has no rationality .
@@mohamedali2858 The connection is that I had no knowledge of the Palestine and yet somehow our union was fighting the same fight? I was only told one side of the conflict from a socialist point of view and after seeing Palestinian kindergarten children singing songs about killing Jews , I have since formed my own opinion.
With all due respect they've seen what they did to Lebanon, once they let them in .....CHAOS AND TROUBLE
How do you know what they 'did' in Lebanon? Believe in your sources much?
@@johnwilson5637 For those of us who were alive at the time, we remember the WAR THEY STARTED. They destroyed Lebanon, and Beirut too. Yasser Arafat was running a 'state within a state'.
@@imisstoronto3121 History is not a valid argument.
It is not taught in school anymore either.
So those of us that know it are watching it repeat.
@@johnwilson5637 ask every country they went to. You will be surprise
@@johnwilson5637 Ask the people in Lebanon , best sources
I can’t for the life of me figure out why nearby Arab nations will not take in the Palestinians. After all, think of how much they improved Lebanon when they moved into there in the 1970s!
You must be joking. Lebanon was a peaceful and prosperous Arab Christian nation. Hezbollah and Palestinians have ruined it between them.
@@SuperMikado282 man I’m pretty sure he was joking?!
😂 and iraq and Syria and jurden and Egipt.
@@SuperMikado282That went so far over your head it was into orbit.
They moved to Lebanon because they were finished with making Jordan a safe place with their Black September party.
Perfectly true.
Superb enquiry and presentation. Sorely needed. Please continue to produce more such videos.
Thanks for saying it John.
Albert Mohler is a brilliant thinker.
Such a pleasure to hear his views on these issues.
Great stuff John. I think Australia needs you back in politics.
Still young enough to be PM for at least 2 terms.
Not just Egypt, it is my understanding there are many muslim countries that have had experience of taking in 'refugees' from Lebanon who done basically what the mulims who are rising up and agitating people to riot and chaos in the west currently done in their countries back then - they were swiftly deported back from whence they came and that is why those countries are not prepared to invite their 'muslim brothers and sister' in because they know hidden in plain sight comes all the insurgents along with them - some people learn from their experience and some learn from the experiences of others - the current western governments and those of the fairly recent past it seems does neither. Unless of cuorse there is a reason for them to allow the massive influx they have of these great swathes of muslims most of whom are single young men but even the legal immigration figures are outrageous so one can't help but think someone very high up is being coerced into allowing this for personal gain because the countries are being destroyed, physically, financially and morally
Exactly.
Being a Canadian I have seen our corrupt Liberal government bring in “refugees” from Muslim countries on a massive scale so they will vote for the Liberals. It’s terrifying and causing huge issues here.
Well said you are completely correct.
Amen, God Bless Israel.
Excellent
It’s not ‘Palestine’ it’s Gaza.
Judea ❤️
@@Verastasianope - Gaza has actually been around since the time the Canaanites and Philistines inhabited the land. Different story with the 'West Bank however.
Egypt controlled Gaza, but when the Palestinians moved in, they were given the opportunity to re-establish control, to which Egypt said no thanks to Israel, you can deal with the Palestinians yourselves.
We know why we object against nazism.
We know why we object against racism.
But do we know why we object against semitism?
Do you even know what those terms mean?
Do you know what a 'Semite' is? Clue: Very few current Israelis are 'Semites' having roots in Western Asia or Eastern Europe. The Palestinians were there long before current Israel came into existence.
@@johnwilson5637 Then me, and the rest of the world need to be educated about that!
So basically what you are suggesting is the the use of the term “antisemitism” by the current Israeli is misleading, if not a false victimhood cry?
@@robertholland7558 Palestinian Arabs are more entitles to the term 'Semitic' than the current Israeli as has been proven by numerous DNA tests. So much so that the Israeli government have banned DNA tests in Israel except for very special cases.
@@johnwilson5637 No sweetie they werent. Jews=Judea, ARabs=Arabian Peninsula. Islam didnt coeme into existence till about 500 AD. and we've been around easily since 2000 BC
We shall know them by their fruit. Which Muslim area is fruitful?
"The world's Muslims pose a threat to the West - they want to exercise a controlling power over Western societies"
"The world's Jews pose a threat to the West - they want to exercise a controlling power over Western societies"
Why do Western institutions consider the first statement to be rational legitimate political commentary, while deeming the second statement to be "irrational hate"?
Why is the first statement legal "free speech" while the second has been made illegal by the IHRA antisemitism definition adopted by the US government?
London 😂
Joke. London is a s h I t h o l e
If it wasn't for oil, they would still be herding sheep.
@SuperMikado282 and the oil was always there. It wasn't until the white man came along and did something with it. SA, UAE would collapse into tribal wars within months, probably weeks, if whites left them to it. Everything was designed and set up by Brits and Americans. They would collapse into savagery again, truly within weeks. Not all but most.
Highest birth rate in the world: Niger (7)
Lowest birth rate in the world: S.Korea (0.73)
Birth rate for a "stable population": 2.1
UK birth rate: 1.6
Muslim birth rate in Britain: 2.9
Well said 😊
Very true words, we need to wake up
Well put
These people who are siding with Hamas, I’m at a loss to understand how these people can call themselves intelligent. And yet they are at Uni and still they haven’t looked at history.
I guess they need to feel that true HAMAS experience. And if they can talk about it afterwards, maybe they can compare notes with the Israeli hostages.
Even their own people hate them.
That's an explosive question.
How absolutely right !! Egypt!!!!
where are you in all this?
trying to avoid confronttions with Israel AND Hamas. They definitely do not want any Palestinians to slip into Egypt hiding amongst Civilians. Maybe the best thing to do is not allow any men from the age of 10 up. Yes HAMAS recruits them young
Well said 🇿🇦🇮🇱
There is no country called Palestine.
It almost seems people are regressing instead of progressing. I don't understand the thinking behind this.
Lack of thinking is the problem.
Where is Fakestine?
It's only in Fantasyland...
There is no islamic unity only when there iss violence to be done they unite. A bit.there is no love for each other no brotherhood no unity😂
Why did the incompetent Albanese government allow 250 Palestinians to come to Australia? It’s insanity and the Australian people did not want this to occur. Labor must go and deportation must begin.
If the UN can do anything in this, it would be to recognize how their effort over generations has trapped these people in victimhood. They are dependent on foreign aid to the point that such aid is enabling terrorist goals. Hamas was confident to do the outrageous Oct 7 attack because they knew the UN would have their backs.
the difference between, education and intelligence.....just look what the educated are currently doing
They are trouble thats why their neighbours will not have anything to do with them.
EXACTLY
Even Jordan shuts its doors on the Gazans.
Their own country
Maybe because they don't want terrorists in their own back yard?
I bring it up all the time Shortly after October 7th There was a major televised interview with the queen of Jordan She was lambasting the Israeli response But I noticed she wasn’t inviting Palestinian refugees to her country Why not ? Nobody addresses that
and Biden wants them to clme to America
Why would anyone want these things anywhere near you?
It's hilarious that an American and an Australian are weighing in on this matter, given their western colonial-settler heritage.
Egypt closes the border but not the smuggling tunnels?
Moral compass, you cannot commit genocide
Revealingly appropriate assertion!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Egyptians want to protect their goats.
Can’t close your borders to a place that does not exist and never has..,
I am certainly not a fan of some of the things the John Howard/John Anderson did (such as instituting the capital gains tax discount which has slowly led to the house price absurdity of Australia now which has all sorts of flow on effects) but when talking about Israel/Palestine I think he is 100% correct.
FOR THE SAME REASON SEWER PITS HAVE BACK FLOW PREVENTERS.
Egypt and other Arab countries won't take Palestinians for this reason
Jordan took in the Palestinians who then rose up and tried to take over Jordan it's host
One of the greater blasphemys is to rise up against your host
And they've done it to most Arab countries
How can Egypt close its borders to a non-😊existing nation called 'palestine' (small p) ❓
🇬🇧♥️🇮🇱
The Gazan Arabs have been marginalized and excluded by the Egyptian Arabs, the Syrian Arabs, the Lebanese Arabs, the Jordanian Arabs, the Saudi Arabs, the Yemeni Arabs...
Mmmmmm🤔 there seems to be a bit of a pattern here?
@@cohort075 Known as history.
I don't like seeing it repeated, again.
Today, the ICJ ordered ISR to open the Rafah crossing. The Rafah crossing is controlled and was closed by Egypt. Really makes you think.
THE PROMISED LAND - Genesis 15:18-21 - On the same day the Lord made a covenant with Abram, saying:
_“To your descendants I have given this land, from the river of Egypt to the great river, the River Euphrates- the Kenites, the Kenezzites, the Kadmonites, the Hittites, the Perizzites, the Rephaim, the Amorites, the Canaanites, the Girgashites, and the Jebusites.”_
Zechariah 12:2-3 - _“Behold, I will make Jerusalem a cup of drunkenness to all the surrounding peoples, when they lay siege against Judah and Jerusalem. And it shall happen in that day that I will make Jerusalem a very heavy stone for all peoples; all who would heave it away will surely be cut in pieces, though all nations of the earth are gathered against it."_
Hmmm? Biblical and historical facts!
Exactly! Now Egypt is upset that Israel took the Rafah crossing!
No they’re not, they’re just making the right noises to stay in the good books with the other Arab countries.
The problem for the Palestinians is that the other Arab countries are doing the exact same thing.
The concept of Islamic unity is an oxymoron
Most times I don't even watch the full video, I just go to the comments, because they make more sense than the speakers in the video.
I'm finding my patience for listening to people drone on and on dwindling
It shows us who not to trust.
🙏✝️
Someone suggested to me, it’s because; “How can they spread it if they all stay in the same place!”
That loss of intelligence Mr Anderson references, began with the Government Public School system.( as distinct from the UK's version of Public Schools) ... I was fortunate enough to have parents that put me through the Sydney Catholic Private Schools. I was given and exposed to a system of free thinking and critical thought based upon Facts, not opinion. That system taught me to search for truths , not indoctrinate me to a false narrative.
Why is this a question? Would Australia allow every single Kiwi refuge within its borders? How about 7 million Indonesians? Or 7 million Indians?
If this is what they do to their own kind imagine what they'll do to you
Because they already know what they are like.
From an Egyptian Muslim here, Palestinians have distaste towards Arab countries neighbors (it’s not just about Israel) especially Egypt. The reason why is, because they assassinated our minister of culture during president Sadat’s era because he supported the peace treaty with Israel and hijacked a civilan airplane. You can google Abu Nidal group also they helped and cooperated with isis branch of Sinai and the military killed a lot of ex Hamas terrorists fought with them
Closed the doors to their indistinguishable Arab brethren
Ask the eygeption rigime that you backup so hard
The question in the title is not being answered at all 😢
Egypt has a security agreement with Israel and allowing Gazans into Egypt poses a risk to that.
Perhaps movement in Europe may have something to do with mass immigration not being properly controlled
People are easily fooled these days 😢😢
Yup, RUclips University diplomas are free.
People still give up their common sense for it though just like a real university student does these last couple three decades.
Exactly.. Who is Hamas? Children of Palestinians....
And not one Egyptian has ever wondered how are those trucks coming up out of and going down into the desert near the border. . . Yeah right.
Hamas shed the “blood of war” in a time of peace! David spoke briefly about the “blood of war” in 1st Kings 2:5
Because pharoahs curse starts in egypt
There is as much a humanitarian obligation on Egypt to receive Palestinians fleeing Gaza owing to its border proximity as that on Israel itself.
Pretty much as Israel; Egypt is despised and hated by Palestinians. This is due to the peace treaty reached in the seventies by president Anwar El Sadat.
If Egypt let Gazan's get into Sinai they will definitely and unabashedly orchestrate terrorist attacks on Israel just like they did on 7th of last October and the result will be a war between Egypt and Israel.
Some necessary clarifications that everyone should be aware of regarding repeated conflations:
The term "Arab" in Egypt's official identification is a remnant of a brief time in the sixties when the megalomaniac socialist dictator Gamal Abdelnasser renamed the country as "The United Arab Republic".
It was somewhat a "merger" between Egypt and Syria whose names and borders dissolved to give way to what Nasser aimed for which was a super state from Morocco to Saudi Arabia unified under the - various dialects of - Arabic language with a common duty to purge these lands from every contribution/meddling by French and British colonization, nonetheless the latter's major contribution in the establishment of the Jewish state in 1948.
Egyptian ethnicity isn't 'Arab', and by the logic of considering Egypt an Arab country because the spoken language has Arabic roots then Italy, France, Spain, and Portugal should be identified as Latin countries.
Also, Egypt isn't an Islamic country. It is governed by a constitution, not shari'a.
If there are any refugees arab countries should take most if not all
Because Egyptians know palestinians are hamas supporters!
Because you can't trust them.🕌💥🕌
That's right the Zionists have generally shown themselves to be untrustworthy.
Ask a Muslim which muslim country, they will go and live.?
Because they like them so much😉
Caliphate died in 850 CE, after nearly dying in 750 CE.
Yes the Palestinian have been a marginalised
Same reason that Kuwait deported over 300,000 Palastinias.
Wouldn’t you?
I have NEVER heard from the Palestinian snowflakes mention how Egypt HAS A BORDER WITH GAZA AND REFUSES TO LET THEM IN!! So much for the claim Islam is the religion of peace and caring for their brothers and sisters!!!
If you havent figured it out yet, Arab countries do NOT care about their fellow coreligionists. They just dont. If they did they would be up in arms how Muslims are being treated in China. The Uyghyers are confined in concentration camps, and tortured.
De facto?
To make momey on all who import goods through underground tunnels.
They betrayed Kuwait to the Iraqi Army too