Keeping Too Much Money
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 6 окт 2022
- The plaintiff says she and her mother hired the defendant to sell some of their antiques, but they allege the defendant is keeping too much of the money. They’re suing for what they claim they’re owed. The defendant says she paid the annoying plaintiff every penny owed per the contract.
Case: 25-418
#PeoplesCourt #RealityTV #Court 
Развлечения
![NoCap - Maliboo [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/FUV7E0QyniU/mqdefault.jpg)
I’m glad the defendant turned in the paperwork and ultimately won the case cause I could tell the plaintiff was full of it. So annoying.
Exactly! It’s like shut-up lady! Ugh! ANNOYING!
Bad enough to be annoying but annoying and lying is too much.
@@leetakamiya Right! Geesh!
Spoiler alert
I think she wanted to be paid twice.
It kills me when any litigant says they didn't get time to talk when they actually talked too much.
She talked way too much, but she didn’t say anything!
@@The_Real_Mierthis is something I look for when I first strike up a conversation with someone, the Plantiff has a victim mentality
I agree!
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
That annoyed me when she said it like are you serious
As somebody with sick relatives, I absolutely HATE when people use the health of their family members as bargaining chips.
“My mother with a heart condition”.
It's a handy excuse! I have an ex daughter in-law that used to use guilt as a bargaining tool!!
What is the likelihood that an 85 year old doesn’t have a health condition? Like how is that relevant?
Her mother owned the items!!!
@@allywainwright978it’s relevant because she wanted to be called.her point was her mother finally ended up calling even though she doesn’t need that stress. This is common in the antique business…they frequently underestimate the value of elderly people’s antiques and sell them, for big bucks. They aren’t past lying about the value to get things for practically nothing. In fact, in all my years dealing with antique people I’ve met very few honest ones.
The plaintiff is definitely annoying
Side note;
JM giving the defendant more time makes it so clear to me that she too, finds the plaintiff annoying😂
plaintiff is beer , and defendant is champagne . people need to stay in their own lane . plaintiff should have just tried to sell the items herself if she wanted to get cash sooner .
And the defendant found the paperwork so like I thought the plaintiff was full of 💩💩💩
@@marleonetti7 Seriously, give your head a shake. The plaintiff is not beer...she is PISS! The defendant was waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaay too patient with that lunatic and the judge saw it.
The plaintiff’s behavior was so outrageous, the judge gave the defendant more time to win her case 🤣
You can tell the Plantiff smokes or needed a cig🤣 🚬
Who cares about her 85 yo mother's heart condition? Not the defendant's problem.
@@davemathews7890 She said that is if it was at all relevant to the case. The ultimate Karen.
How about that justice.
@@dragastarr2926 She tried to make it relevant. She was actually going to sue the defendant for causing her mother's heart condition. You know, not returning a phone call causes angina.
The plaintiff is one of those people that if things don't go her way, she doesn't understand.
Like everyone in her generation
@@christi7733 Yes, we are all like that.
@@christi7733 Yes, hence Karen boomers.
Yes!!
@@wackybrattyx Ahh, you must be of the "entitled I'm smarter and better than anyone else" generation! 😂
“Roll your eyes at me one more time. Do it!” Love it!
I say the same thing to my kids hahahahaha
I wish she did. The case would have been over! Ruling for the defendant!
Just because your stuffs old doesn’t make it antique! 😂
And just because it's an antique doesn't mean it's worth anything.
That defendant is SUPER competent. That plaintiff is a monster.
“I didn’t even get to speak” She’s been doing nothing but talk this entire time…
She did stop speaking long enough to roll them eyes!😂
@@r1vermanAs well as long enough to loudly SIGHHHHHH…! 😂
I love this Judge!!!! She's the Best 😅
That's a real piece of work that lady blaming her mom's heart condition for sympathy and conning.
Whew! When Judge Milian told her to “roll her eyes at her one more time. Do it!” I hollered! 😂
Me too....savage
Beautiful profile pic 😍
@@manthony777 yours too! are you a purple M&M?
😂 loved it
@@TopherGrant 😅😅😅
As a law student, it KILLS me when she doesn't bother to read a ONE PARAGRAPH contract.
Right? Why the hell would the defendant have to explain the contract to that lady. Ridiculous!
Of course she read it . She is a liar .
i dont think you have to be a law student to appreciate the negligence of that
As a layperson you had better understand the five elements of a contract and make sure everything is worded and understood in the simplest and most comprehensive manner. Just as someone who does not understand calculus, had better understand 9th grade math if they want to be able to manage their finances and their life.
I'm happy the defendant found the email and the rude plaintiff lost.
"I didn't even get a chance to talk!"
::in Maury's voice:: the lie detector determines, THAT was a lie!
“There is none so blind than she who cannot see” I love it when JM quotes these quips 😂 and then “ROLL YOUR EYES AT ME ONE MORE TIME! DO IT!!!” Do not challenge JM!!!
I was waiting until the very end of the case to hear the update - so glad the defendant found the email and won the case! JM picked up upon how annoying the plaintiff was pretty quick - "roll your eye's at me one more time, do it"! Way to go JM! I understand why the defendant just wanted to email the plaintiff - she needed to have proof of the information relayed cuz plaintiff was just crazy enough to sue them!
I’m so happy she found proof as well. When you’re dealing with a customer or vendor that has amnesia, it’s imperative to do all communication through email. These type of people prefer verbal, so they can twist reality when it’s convenient. I’m glad the defendant won.
@@LeeoGoneWild Agree!
She knew if she talked to the plaintiff on the phone, 1, she'd never get her off the phone and 2, she was just going to get a ton of verbal abuse.
So was I defended was sure she had the text that why the judge gave her 24 hrs.
I bet the defendant had the email in her papers, but was so frazzled dealing with this plaintiff that she couldn't think straight. Plaintiff was so annoying, even JM couldn't take her non-stop rants. Glad JM gave the defendant more time. And....I think we all know who's to blame for the plaintiff's mother's heart condition.
I wish we could've seen the plaintiff's reaction to the update 🤣
This woman has to understand she is not the ONLY customer
This plaintiff has never been wrong in her ENTIRE LIFE
Because she’s a Karen
I almost missed what Harvey said right at the very end - but I was so glad to hear the defendant ended up winning the case when she later found the email she'd been looking for!
The plaintiff is horrible, and ignorant... blaming the defendant for her mother's heart problems is ridiculous
Good day everyone..did the plaintiff really say that the defendant caused her mom's heart problem..the plaintiff just pissed the judge off😂😂
Plaintiff at the end also called defendant a liar, but Harvey at the end statement made plaintiff the real liar. !
it was too many ham n cheese sandwiches, or acting like the plantiff for 75 years that caused her heart problems if this is the plaintiffs daughter can you imagine her mother ?
High blood pressure can cause a heart condition. Several things can cause a heart condition. Her selling her mothers things thru consignment doesn’t cause a heart condition or any health issues 😂
Im betting that the plaintiffs mother never even saw a dime of that money from the sales she did get payments for.
The daughter spent the money on that brown suit and her turtle necklace. 😂
@@AminaBeans205 😂
Her mother and every other elderly parent of today's adult ''children''. THEY ARE PARASITES.
Grandma has probably been dumped in a home , while her daughter is off to a new life with all the money from the furniture and the house .
@@AminaBeans205 🤣😂🤣😂
I'm so glad the defendant won! The plaintiff is lazy and a liar.
The plaintiff is the epitome of how the loudest voice in the room is usually the STRONG WRONG. She clearly did not understand the process and refused to try.
But she won bc the defendant couldn't provide any evidence
@@echomumford6690 If you watch it till the very, very end, the defendant found the email so the plaintiff ended up losing
@@echomumford6690 no she didn't!
She said the defendants been speaking the whole time she spoke for 2 minutes 😂
I'll bet the plaintiff blew her top when she found out the defendant found the email....LOL...
Right?!? Exactly what I was thinking 😂 I actually let out an unexpected WOO HOO when I heard the update… Lol
Would have love to see her blow her top ! Then it would be her with the heart problems not her mother.
Defendant has a pleasant voice
LOVE that final UPDATE!! That plaintiff did NOT read her contract!
Plaintiff seemed an expert manipulator well versed in playing the victim. She even invoked her mother’s age and heart condition to try to get her way. Wow!
Had the plaintiff not been so insolent the judge wouldn't have given the defendant a chance to get those emails. The plaintiff is a "Karen" who may never learn.
Plaintiff is nuts. Typical, wants everything for nothing.
you can tell by looking at him/her.
@@kyoto32001🤭
That is the most obnoxious plaintiff. No wonder they fired her!
There are some customers in life you just do not want... No matter how much money they have.
"Roll your eyes at me one more time!" Is something you'd expect to have to say to a teenager. But when a grown woman is acting that way...
That plaintiff was so bad saying that a judge doesn’t understand a contract while she’s looking at it and she is lying so much and it’s funny to me that she thinks just talking will get her out of trouble when people have emails and receipts
Wow.. rolling your eyes at a judge is not a good move lady 🙄
"Lady"?
@@beautifulwonderful4391 Lol.. I wasnt trying to get reported for calling her out her name 🤣
@@badgurl5758 lol
I have a bad habit of rolling my eyes when I hear something I don't like.
@@mymobilebuddy4392 Break that habit asap!!
I would've thrown the plaintiff out the first time she rolled her eyes...I counted 4 times shes did and the sneaky heifer made sure the judge wasnt looking...grrrrrrr...the entitlement and disrespect
Plaintiff acts like she was their only client and could drop everything anytime day or night to update her.
Exactly
Lmao judge ain't having no eye rolling😂😂
I feel sad for the plaintiff because she actually thinks she's right and I'm sure in her world people have allowed her to loud talk them so she can get her way. The daughter is embarrassed bc she gets it. 🤭🤭
I never would have seen it that way but now that you mention it, it's true. She's not trying to be deceitful but rather truly believe she's right even after reading the contract multiple times to her. People like this are dangerous
In my circle, we call someone like her a 'bulldozer'. She'll loudly run you over or whatever it takes to tear and run you down to get her way.
I think she’s being deceitful and hoping that her vagueness means she doesn’t have to abide by the contract.
The judge told her the contract does not have to be told to you, you have to read it…she agrees and then repeats it another way.
She is feigning helplessness for the hope of pity.
It’s passive aggressive and it’s a pet hate of mine lol
Plaintiff was mad because her items weren’t worth as much as she thought they were. Couldn’t even follow her reasoning , first it’s the contract then the worth of items then money owed, she was all over the place. She either understood or she didn’t either way she wasn’t happy with the contract and wanted out.
I wish the Defendant had the email with her in the courtroom so we could watch the plaintiff explode. SMH
Reading reply’s I was thinking about that. Wonder if producers held back email just so audience wouldn’t be able to see her lose it all , because she looks and acts like she would have thrown a fit.
So, I have to admit that I let out a rather loud “Woohoo” when the defendant provided the paperwork. 😂
"I never spoke to her. I emailed with her" 🤦♀️🤦♀️🤦♀️ same damn thing
It’s really not. One leaves a paper trail, one is just hearsay.
Right
I just love it when Judge Milian says "okay, stop talking now" and the litigants have to do what she says. It would be nice to have that power in everyday life. I think that could be considered one of her catch-phrases.
In a real courtroom, this is a standard. If they don't, they get a contempt of court charge and a court fine.
I say this often 🤣
You SHOULD use it in your own life too!
You’ll be amazed how well it works.
First practice on the confident, convincing tone to say this in though, making sure you’re NOT crossing that delicate line of sounding too authoritative, because that will ruin the effectiveness of it (and in fact lead to the opposite!) 😉
Judge Milian to the young lady sitting next to the benched plaintiff: "Who are you to her?" Young Lady: "Her daughter." And then comes the snicker afterwards. 😆 Poor kid. I'd love to be a fly on her wall when the plaintiff learned she ended up losing the case after all.
I would pay good money to see Judge Judy handle this plaintiff!
Judge never snickers at anyone.
Omg, we know the daughter had to listen to her mom venting the WHOLE way back home. Poor daughter.
You would want to hear MORE of this lady b*tching?? Not me.
@@trekgirl65 Um... I meant the kid snickered.
The defendant was credible and proved it.... I have been involved with machinery auctions and I have also hired people to sell estate items.. This defendant is far better than anyone I have ever worked with..
Can y'all imagine if Judge Judy ruled on this case & how she'd react to the Plaintiff? 😂
Judge Judy would have asked Byrd to put the plaintiff out since she can't control herself; "put her out".
😂😂😂😂😂
Judge Milian- "ROLL YOUR EYES AT ME ONE MORE TIME DO IT!!"
Why couldn't she have brought that email to court?! I am forever robbed from seeing the Plaintiff's reaction!!
You did not watch til the end!
P
I also wish the defendant had brought that email to court. I bet the look on the plaintiffs face would’ve been priceless. I wonder what she would’ve said to try to weasel her way out of that one? She’s a horrible woman who thinks she’s always right.
It is quite likely she did have that email in court, but when you are flustered by having to find something instantly it is easy to miss the one page in a pile of papers.
I understand why she would only email her
I feel so bad for the daughter, imagine having a mom so exhausting like that. Everyone was frustrated with the plaintiff, I could only imagine how it is doing business with her.
Really? Most antique dealers are scammers. This one was no different.
That plaintiff was absolutely infuriating!
The plaintiff thinks she can just talk her way out of anything LMAO.
I’m glad she found the email!
I’m convinced there’s some sort of parallel that happens with a person’s comprehension of fashion and their perception of how life works
😂😂😂
😂😂😂 that suit and shirt were horrendous!!
"DO IT"!!!!!!!!!!!! Don't mess with Judge Milian....LOL!!!
“My mother is 85”. We got that.
It makes them no less culpable. When some 85 year olds want something, they sure know how to go about it.
They need to just sell the stuff themselves
... yes ...
They'll never do that. It's way too much work. The plaintiff is really upset over the fact that the defendant was unable to sell all of the antiques quickly for top dollar, not realizing that the value of an antique is only what you can get for it, not a book value.
Well I guess the defendant is accurate on being annoying 😂😂 she even got on the judge nerves after 3 minutes 😂😂
I Absolutely LOVE when the updates happen at the end and the plaintiff's wind up losing their case... LOVE IT!!!! It all comes down to Reading the Contracts!!! The time to question or seek clarification on the contract is BEFORE it's signed.
That is what I miss with the Covid episodes where Harvey doesn't give an update like they would. If he has its very rare and I don't recall.
The plaintiff's main complaint was that they physically didn't speak. The defendant kept in touch with them very well and kept them up to date. The plaintiff was just complaining that they didn't get a phone call.
That "woman" is a handful and very annoying. Entitled and manipulative.
Did the Judge really have to ask who that girl was to her ! 😂😂 they are twins .
I’d be so embarrassed if my mom was acting like that
The plaintiff is a client from hell. God help the next company she uses for a tag sale.
Oh can’t believe she is the worse customer that lady has had because any drive thru window employee could tell you horror stories. 🤣🤣😂😂
Thank GOD she found that damn email!!!!! The plaintiff was pissing me off! I wish she could've found the email during the hearing so the judge could've stuck it to the plaintiff!
Even the daughter is like yeah u c what I have to deal with here? 🤨😫🤬🤣🤣🤣🤣
If they don't tell you until you get the cheque 90 days after that something has sold, how do you pick up the unsold items after 60 days??
The whole thing is sketchy. If she owns everything after 60 days, she has no incentive to sell anything for the first two months. She can just put everything away and then sell it on the 61st day and keep all the proceeds.
After 60 days of the contract ending maybe???
@@michelepaccione8806 You're supposed to pick up your unsold items before the end of the 60 days, if you still want it. The seller is incentivized to sell in the 60 days because they risk getting zero for their efforts, if you come pick up your stuff that they didn't sell. The wrap-up at the end said the defendant had proof (an email) that she told the plaintiff to come pick up her stuff before the 60 days.
Easy, on the 60 day mark you show up at the store and take what's yours, that hasn't sold.
Everytime I see the Plantiff, the Godfather theme plays in my head.
Lmbo
Thank you for making my day lol....
@@richardb7999 😊
I can't wait for the new season to begin a week from this Monday.
Thank you, Douglas!!
I’m just upset we didn’t get to see the look on the lying plaintiffs face when the email was presented to the judge..
"Roll your eyes at me one more time!" ... Hell *I* even backed up in my chair an inch LOL.
RIP for anyone who didn't watch the final few seconds, because it completely changed the case.
Funny how the plaintiff kept complaining the defendant was lying when in fact it was herself! 😅
poor Officer MacIntosh! I know it's his job, but having to arrange stuff between 2 warring parties must be a terrible pain!!
Your items are only worth what someone else will pay for it.
Edit: It's so flustering to provide paperwork in the moment with a client that clearly has made contact a frafillion times. Glad she was given more time to actually go through everything.
The plaintiff is annoying lol
"Roll your eyes at me one more time..DO IT! Savage
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 the fact that the defendant entered the paperwork and won made me happy at the end!
So happy to hear that the defendant won ❤️😂😂😂 I just wish we saw it!
I love how she thinks emails back alnd forth are not "talking to each other".
Classic .. when a client feels they are the only client and want individual attention
I'm so confused about the timeline of when Harvey shows vs. when the actual trial is lol.
I can’t! Plaintiff is not okay lol
Plaintiff, “I’d ask them for what was sold and they’d never tell me!”
*judge reads email where they give an itemized list within an hour*
Honestly the defendant should’ve used her company name. Because I thought she was a horrible person who takes advantage of the elderly in the beginning and she proved that no, they’re great very flexible and understanding company and it’s a great ad for the company.
I watched this twice because it was so juicy. The plaintiff not reading the contract and then not understanding it caused this whole thing. And I still can't believe the judge read from the contract word for word and plaintiff said, "that's not how it works." TWICE!! Cmon man.
This show always makes me laugh I love watching this hahaha
People attach sentimental value to items vs being subjective about what they’re actually worth. And want to yell you down when it’s not worth what they think it is.
Yeah Judge Milian was like oh I see she is annoying!
Glad the defendant won
How can you not shut your mouth while in court when you're not being questioned?
This plaintiff is rude and annoying and obviously a type A personality.
The plaintiff was obnoxious
I managed a consignment shop for several years and you would not believe the amount of people who do NOT read the contract or have an understanding of the time/terms. As most people casually ask while shopping because they want to bring in things of their own, we verbally explain the process and it was simple. We have it posted throughout the store. We then explain it again to them while they sign a contract and bring in their items and show them the terms written that we just explained. Just as this lady did, there is an itemized statement listing each item sold with the check that was cut on the 1st of each month. People would not call or come by to pick up checks, phone numbers get disconnected and I'd have some checks for almost 1 year. At the end of the year, we void the checks (they were 90 days only anyway although we'd issue another one upon request) and in some cases you never hear from the person until over a year later and they want to pick up their item. We say we sold it and they get mad. Then they want the check, we voided it as it was over a year old. In most cases we'd cut a check but in a few where there were issues, the owner went by the contract so I was not able to cut a check. During my last year, we revised the contract to include "storage fees" after a certain date that had to be paid in order to pick up the item or it was ours. The large bookcases, antique dressers and other large dining pieces people would leave there for storage while they went out and put ads on craigslist and facebook marketplace and if it sold they'd come pick it up and pay us nothing.
The plaintiff keeps saying she didn't get a chance to speak when the judge gave her too much time to speak. Let's you know what the defendant had to deal with...... also, I love that Harvey Levin at the end tells you about the follow up which occurred the next day, unlike some Judge Judy cases where we are left hanging.
I love the Uno reverse card at the end!
Omg this plaintiff is so annoying. She’s not understanding how this works. Even the Judge was getting annoyed with her. It’s like she has tunnel vision & only has her eyes set on what she wants & nothing else.
I'm surprised the defendant didn't want her business named. Seems like she operated properly and even catered to a frustrating customer.
Someone needs to tell that girl, you don’t now anyone on Craigslist.