Neil degrasse tyson explains Oppenheimer scenes!
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 14 янв 2024
- Please check my website where I write blogs on physics and mathematics 👇(it's actually good 😊):
phymathinfo.blogspot.com/
#TysonExplainsOppenheimer #ScienceHistory #NeilDeGrasseTyson #OppenheimerScenes #ScientificInsights #ManhattanProject #PhysicsExplained #HistoricalPerspective
#Astrophysics #ScientificCommunication #EducationalContent #CosmicPerspective #PhysicsHistory #AtomicBomb #QuantumPhysics #Cosmology #ScientificNarrative 
Наука
Please check my website where I write blogs on physics and mathematics 👇(it's good 😊) "link in bio"
“I thought my boi has lost it!”
-Neil DeGrasse Tyson 😂
Maybe he was exploring entropy or chaos theory or murphy's law. Basically seeing a small explosion.
@@KR-Phe was, basically testing out the second law of thermodynamics which states that entropy will always increase meaning that some time later it is possible the shattered glass assembled itself back together but the chances are extremely low
It was to get the implosion perfectly
The first explosion needed to be equally distributed perfect enough for it to work
In the first oppenheimer movie its told
Its more of a documentary
I really liked his answer. People like to poke fun, but the way he sets up his answer like he’s going to open our minds about the inner workings of a brilliant scientist, only to end with, “I thought my boy lost it.” Is pure comical
For anyone wondering how glass protects from radiation: Polarization has nothing to do with it. What he claimed was that he did the math and realized that a sheet of glass would block enough UV that he could safely see the bomb without eye protection.
The brightness can still be damaging (as anyone who deals with high power lasers will warn you), but apparently at that distance, it would not be permanent.
He reportedly saw everything purple for hours afterward, including the after-image of the fireball, similarly to what happens after you go to the ophthalmologist and they shine a bright light right into your retina. 💡
> Be me, casually working outside 🛠️
> Suddenly, blinding burst of light from a truck's headlight hits 💥
> Remembering Feynman's glass wisdom 🤔
> Grabs 5 nearest random pieces of plastic
> Plastic shield ACTIVATED - It actually works! 🤯
> It was just a truck's headlight all along 🤦♂️
Anyone got wild makeshift safety hacks?
Depends on the wavelength UVB is blocked by glass UVA is not
But what will protect the glass
Creepy
It's crazy to even try to comprehend how it most have felt to have your eyes closed tight trying to hide yourself from having literal X-Ray vision. Seeing not only your own internal bone structure but those around you. No doubt it would be an eary, unforgettable moment that has haunted those men their entire lives. To top it off, having classified information & not being able to talk about it either. Fuck me.
If you are wondering about the throwing of the glasses...if you read the screenplay, which you can buy as a book, it says: "I SMASH a glass, and ANOTHER, and ANOTHER, WATCHING THE SHARDS skid across the floor, CATCHING AND REFRACTING LIGHT."
If you ask Neil the way to the bathroom, he will explain everything, but how to get there
They should call this the Boredom Accelerator: smashing together two guys who never shut up so we can study what happens.
@@cisium1184 😂😂😂 good one
Exactly, Neil is the single most useless astrophysicist who does everything except his own study.
Bathroom is an extraordinary invention by mankind. It.....
He just said he didn’t know.
Learning from school: ❌
Learning from RUclips: ✅
Yeah good luck with that….
😂
Jokes on I learned the entirety of English from RUclips@@thelambsauce7307
I hope science teachers play MelodySheep channel on youtube for youth now. It's free, informative and entertaining. ✅️
@@thelambsauce7307 You know in this day and age, it has now been like that.
The amount of knowledge you can gain from others never ceases to amaze me.
My interpretation is that the glass is teaching him about particles, atoms, and what would happen if those bonds received the right energy needed to spilt and what that would look like physically.
He's doing it over and over to see if there's any difference visually when throwing with different levels of force.
Smaller shards show him the success of a split. Larger shards show he needs more energy/force to make smaller shards and truly split the bonds. Seeing the broken pieces spread out shows him that matter, when split, the particles spread and continue to split, like a wave. Like a blast wave from a nuke.
@lion_2ooo_ita867 🤣 I have no PHD in this subject. Any proper scientists who are physicists are welcome to correct me. But I'm just guessing Nolan wanted us to see what splitting atoms look like. Because "Theory can only take you so far." Once you see the results of that theory, from seeing it physically, through a practical process, you understand it better. I appreciate the compliment.
He already knows all of that
@@kostismetallo8697 Then why didn't he say that?
@@SanctusPaulus1962 I don't know. Entertainment and actual meaning are two different things.
@@ghostly1178 Clever shmever, you are a genius with that explanation!
The throwing of champagne glasses symbolizes chain reaction. How all these atoms are bonded together and the right amount of impact can break this bond, spread them all over!
I think that when the class breaks its atoms colliding and spreading out
Rolling his eyes with that tie on is.. ironic
Born-Oppenheimer approximation. Electronic transitions occur so quickly that the nuclei do not have time to move. The glass breaking represents energy traveling through a material. The fracture pattern is related to the crystal structure i.e. nuclei location. If you look at the breaks they go for long sections in a straight line then deviate. The idea is at the point of deviation is a nuclei. So the energy is significantly faster because the nuclei don't move out of the way. Therefore to this day we use the Born-Oppehiemer approximation to cut out all changes in nuclear coordinates to simplify solving the Hamiltonian for computational analysis. Then the nuclear coordinates can relax to the new electronic state or treat changes to nuclear coordinates as pertubations. Either way it will reduce the complexity of the calculation by multiple orders of magnitudes.
Right after he is congratulated for his seminar paper on molecules. I.e. The Born-Oppenheimer Approximation
BRO THE BONGOS EDITING HAD ME ROLLING WHY DID YOU USE THAT SOUND EFFECT 😂😂😂
Later in the movie, they pitch an idea to set the chain reaction in motion. And it's throwing the fissionable material into a dense core which would then shatter.
The throwing of glasses into the wall doesn't seem that removed from it
Watching Neil nerd out over Oppenheimer is a treasure
Proceeds to not answer the question
He said he doesn't know, what do you want
Damn, guess your attention span didn't allow you to make it to the end huh?
Everyone : WHAT DOES THE WINE GLASS SCENE MEAN ? WE NEED TO KNOW !
Oopenheimer : HeHe look, i throw the glass and it breaks, this is quite fun
I think it means that he was thinking how atoms can break away from each other and/or not pass through eachother while being so empty
“Never play bongs while walking down the stairs” If you know 😂
He was visualizing the glass as he was most likely a visual learner and needed something for his brain to visualize as something else. Probably wouldn’t need to be a glass but was probably readily available and easy to grab when I’m the the zone kinda like how they would show jimmy neutron having a brain blast.
My fav part was when dude wanted to know what Einstein said about him and he was like did you ever consider the possibility he wasn't even talking about you 😑 or however it went. And then what he actually said just stuck with me and broke my heart.
I actually thought this was him testing the probability of decreasing entropy. As seen in tenet i assumed that Oppenheimer theorized that if entropy could decrease naturally under low probability, the glass should fix itself, or at least a piece or two
surely you're joking mr feynman is one of my favorite books ever and i'm not even a science nerd. he's just a genuinely curious interesting person
Whys this so intense for no good reason
peak neil degrasse tyson. didn’t answer jackshit
I thought of him throwing the glasses as seeing how a chain reaction would happen since he didn’t know if the nuclear test would cause a chain reaction and end the world so he thought that throwing glasses like that would show if a chain reaction would happen or not or something like that
If you don't know the answer but the question is too important to leave in the exam hall😂
Glass clip my guess fission. Sorta resemble the neutrons splitting then being made smaller neutrons. Glass is still glass when it breaks but how many times will it break before stopping. If it doesn't stop, it ignites the atmosphere. So the glass is like the neutral splitting. Remember start of movie said fission and the glimpses are like fission
I’m not sure why I just laughed so hard 🤣
Oppenheimer was something like wat MCU OR DCEU IS TO US… dude became a fan boy😅
On rewatch, I can tell when the guys explaining the throwing glass scene. Neil had no fucking clue what he was doing.
it shatters
You're first mistake was to ask this guy.
Bro doesn’t even know why g.o.a.t. grandson of bombs threw a Champaign glass… smh 🤦♀️
Yeah, it doesn’t make sense to ask an astrophysicist about a movie of a famous physicist.
Bro started yapping about nothing 💀💀💀
He may be studying entropy
Imagine light passing through a rock. It doesn't. The rock absorbs the energy. Same thing happens with glass and UV radiation. If you could only see with UV radiation, glass would look opaque. However, the light is so bright it's like looking at the sun. And we all know that's not a good idea
What do you guys think about Oppenheimer’s grandson saying the movie is historically incorrect in so many scenes … for example the poisoned apple. He says no evidence at all that he tried to kill someone. Thoughts ??
Great work ❤
Dude awesome video!
richard freymann
BGM❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
The difference between a smart person's focus and Stephen's.
Chaos Theory
This is how my ADHD brain works...I don't see an apple, I see it grow from a seed, to a tree, to a blossom, then to a fruit...😂 just makes sense to my brain❤
A nerd with personality
Why do American talk show hosts talks so much instead of interview?
Yes, that was a cringy scene.
I thought he was gona say some scientific $hit that would blow our mind
I have no idea I thought my bio has lost it 😂
Oppenheimer throwing wine glasses might mean, that he wanted to witness the probability of the wine glass bouncing rather than breaking, i mean he was studying quantum mechanics, and its all about probability. Thats my interpretation of the scene
I was thinking that too. Entropy and probability.
😮
I don't like Colberts show or his style at all but that was a good question
Neil always says alot of things and yet he still doesn't say exactly what needs to be said..just my opinion ig
Why does the unrelated music is so loud?
it's the biggest part of the official soundtrack when he's having that montage they mention.
Check the movie out for sure
how the fuck he can know that?
Black science man likes Oppenheimer
They glorifying him and the movie but nothing about how evil it was to drop 2 atomic bombs on Japanese civilians when they could have negotiated… terribel
NDT doesn't know s**t about anything
you sure do though tyler6419
@@shyshka_ I don't know s**t but NDT acts like he has the answers to everything
Obviously you dont ask astrophysicists questions that are ment for therotical physicists
RUclips is better for learning kids...
Watch more RUclips 😂😂😂
Non answer
All that just to say he doesn't have a clue? Dude really is an academic
you ask neil about something he will go on for 30mins and still dont give an answer.
Guys did he really poisoned the apple?
Never been confirmed.
Obviously, he threw it in a trash can regretting what he did
Yes he did and he is also said to have tried to strangle a friend who told him about his engagement. While a PhD student in Gottingen, his classmates petitioned to stop him from interrupting seminars.
I think this was kinda showing how genius verges on the insane... did he or didn't he and even he can't remember...
Like and subscribe 😊
Neil has no credibility says women can compete with men in sports 😂 Trump24'
He never said that dummy.
When did he say that?
😂😂😂😂😂
He is just so tiresome to listen to.
I thought the glass throwing was for inspiration
"He was maybe experimenting with motion, repetition, or muscle memory". Google says this. Idk
The movie sucked
🤣🤣🤣🤣
Talk shit of a story and still don't know the answer
Anyone who knows why he is throwing champain glass?
Probably for oppenheimer to simulate/visualize atoms bursting apart in a nuclear chain reaction. In the movie its suggested that it doesn't really have a purpose other than keeping his thoughts going.
He was trying to find a pattern in a task with billions of possibilities. He wanted to know if the glass shattering is as chaotic as it is, or there can be an explanation, and possibly, control, over the glass particles. In his mind, he was trying to find a solution to "control". He was asking himself: Is there a way to know how much of the glasses remain after shattering? One of the biggest questions he should have been able to answer was: Will a nuclear bomb destroy the atmosphere in a chain reaction? Or will it stop at a certain point? The scene is an over exaggeration of his mind. He had not yet faced that question then, but the question was asked at the beginning of the movie.
He doesn't want to clean the glasseds. Too much effort for a genius. Better than call the cleaning lady.
That movie was mediocre at Best
Overrated movie.
I really dont like this dude.
Lmao movie sucked
this bum is now a film critic? 😂
this movie is dogshit
Go watch Marvel movies. This movie is not for everyone.