Это видео недоступно.
Сожалеем об этом.
Why Are India and Pakistan Fighting Over Kashmir?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 1 мар 2019
- India and Pakistan have been at each other's throats for quite some time over the disputed Kashmir region between the two.
Fund My Windmills (Patreon):
/ historywithhilbert
Join in with the banter on Twitter:
/ historywhilbert
Enter the Fray on Facebook:
/ historywhilbert
Music Used:
Eastern Thought - Kevin MacLeod
River Io - Kevin MacLeod
Sunday Dub - Kevin MacLeod
Opium - Kevin MacLeod
Jalandhar - Kevin MacLeod
Pachabelly - Kevin MacLeod
Dhaka - Keivn MacLeod
Tabuk - Kevin MacLeod
Send me an email if you'd be interested in doing a collaboration! historywithhilbert@gmail.com
#India #KashmirConflict #Pakistan
India: KASHIR IS OURS
Pakistan: KASHMIR IS OURS
UN: WHO DID THIS
UK: yeah righht who did this :/
Gotta keep quiet...
Kashmir will be separated from india very very very soon. Pakistan will be saved very very very soon
@@Ahmar312😂😂
Ladakhis are not tibetan
Ladakhi have its own identity
And language
wat r u saying...once ur saying Ladakhi r Tibetan n next ur saying Ladakhi r not Tibetan... ..🤔🤔
@Good Boy
Yup
R u lakhahi... If u r then u r right to say if u r not... Then go fck ur self with ur communist gov
There are snowflakes in that land?
Ladakhis and Kashmiri are slightly related to Tibetan but more more sino and Koranic due to the infamous kangnidun-zhizhu
Kashmir is obviously Serbia
On my screen this comment appeared right next to the comment "Kashmir je Srbija!"
I guess this proves it
I don't get it?
Do they mean that Serbia has the same issues as kashmir?
Muhammad Mirsab with kosovo yes they do also after hearing war time serbian music you will be convinced the whole world should be serbia
@@Mirsab it's a meme. The Serbs claim everything lol
@@circlesareround2351 doesn't Kosovo belong to Kosovo?
Great Britain AKA the worst mediator of all time.
Mayank Sikarwar With British you don’t have Railroads
@@drzoidberg844 it was established to more effectively move goods and minerals out of India to Britain. Indians, squeezed into third class, still paid the highest third-class train fares in the world at the time. Indian freight rates, in comparison, were some of the lowest.
Nah, islam cannot be reasoned with. They wanted a partition, so Gandhi and Jinnah made this East-West Pakistan shit up.
@@drzoidberg844 Without Britain, tens of millions of people don't die
beware of british rant in this comment section
Small correction: Urdu is written in Nastaliq, or Persian script, not Arabic script. It's based on the Arabic script, but it was created during a renaissance of Persian culture in Iranian cultural regions. One of the main differences between Hindi and Urdu is that Urdu is deeply influenced by Persian language, with a large number of Persian and Iranian loanwords.
@@BlackLotusVisualArchive It's worth noting as well that the Urdu version of Nastaliq has letters added in addition to those already added by the Persians. There are something like 10 letters added to the Arabic Script, between Persian and Urdu, to the Nastaliq used in Pakistan.
There are also some differences with diacritics and retroflexes, but I suspect those are a bit technical for someone like me, who doesn't speak or read Urdu.
The script is called, at least in English, Perseo-arabic
@@finnianquail8881 Nastaliq refers to the specific type of Perseo-Arabic being used in Pakistan. Farsi, for example, is written in a different script. As as previously mentioned, there are fairly substantial additions to the alphabet used for Urdu. The ultimate point being, it's not really correct to say it's "written in Arabic".
@Hyper Red Spoken Hindi and Spoken Urdu are fairly similar, but Official Hindi and Urdu are apparently quite different.
True, but Nastaliq is also written fairly differently, Urdu has even more letters to represent sounds not found in Persian (but found in Indian languages), and a regular Arabic typeset is used on most signs due to lack of compatibility with Nastaliq in Pakistan (and to some extent even neighboring Afghanistan and Iran)
Only Kashmir is problem not whole jammu and Kashmir
Ladakh people want to became seprate from jammu and Kashmir
Even We from Jammu Wants a Different State.. Kashmir is a Stain on Both of Us
@@imviiku You should be expelled from the country
@@atharvapawar6344 right
Let's us crown you both Kings asap then Chalo Chalo Chalo.
All states should become UT, Boooz will be cheaper everywhere!!
Kargil war was in 1999 not 1991.
Also you missed one of the most important events in 1989, i.e the Exodus of the Kashmiri Pandits.
are kashmiri pandits like outlaw pandas?
@@Cailean_MacCoinnich pandits=priests/religious leaders.
@@Cailean_MacCoinnich lol no, pandits were there Hindus present there.
@@Cailean_MacCoinnich I don't know what you really mean. But if you genuinely want to learn more about Kashmiri Pandits watch this video.
Link- ruclips.net/video/EKpJZjs-j_w/видео.html
Wiki- en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exodus_of_Kashmiri_Hindus
Pandits are #Hindu community which was living in #Kashmir valley, but in 1989 the Pakistan sponsored terrorists ethnically cleansed and genocided the Pandits.
Truth is Pakistan will never get Kashmir in another 200 years, India will never give up, dear pakiatanis stop trying, it's not worth it.
@@alviwajahat ok brainwashed man ok.
Secularism works with similar religions not with Islam..
Secularism is working pretty good in Rest of the India just not in that area. All the Hindus and Buddhist was Slaughtered by Muslims.
@Daw very nice analysis. let's see a broader view before pulwama attack Ramlingam was killed as he was talking about conversion guess which religion, hindu population is on decline meanwhile muslim population is on incline in india.The kashmir that paksitan claimed (pok) now want freedom from pakistan because they failed providing basic needs. Many temples were broken down to dust but i am saying not all muslims are bad some of them are good. clearly your views are biased you may have read only one side of the story or you are muslim. you cannot justify the killings of kashmiri pandits
Bangladesh is a secular nation with 89% Muslim population
Christianity,islam,judaism are all abrahamic religions very similar to each other, I basically feel your gospels just give you instructions on what to do, whereas in Hinduism our gospels give us insight and to benefit from it and how to worship god like no other, but yeah, secularism can not go along with islam, either you’re an islamic nation or you’re not, our Pakistani neighbors can never take India into OIC(islamic countries union) although we have a large islamic population living in peace, the problem lies in fundamental islamists brainwashing kids and turning them into jihadi fidayeens.
Daw there is no hate for modern day islam, some islamic countries are progressive, I’m strictly against radical islam spreading terrorism and infiltrating young minds with their radical ideology ordering them to kill anyone who is not a muslim.
Let me put forward the Indian point for you
Imagine if you have a house, you 10 people living there from 1000s of years, 2 New people come in. You allow them in. They bread faster compared to your people. After 50 years, your 10 people because of slow normal breading have now turned to 15 people and those 2 have now turned into 30 people and they claim your house and when you try to discuss they start killing your people so you run away to save life of your family and than its 30 people of them living in your house and they ask for referendum of your house where you have no vote as you are living as refugees with your family in your neighborhood.
What a stupid way of explaining. The Kashmiris mass converted to Islam, thats how Hindus became minority. Not because they were outbred (though Hindus were impotent as always no doubt). Look at the surnames of Kashmiri Muslims you'll see the truth. Even the so called Mughal and Sayyid communities have Kashmiri blood.
Talking about Kashmiri Hindus they comprise at the most 5% of the total Indian Occupied Kashmiri population within and outside India whoch is currently 8 million (it was 9% in 1990). Muslims are willing to accept them back but their votes will make little difference in an azadi referandum which India knows very well and due to which India masterminded the Brahmin exodus in the early 90s (since of course India had nothing to lose by kicking the Pandits out and making it look like the handiwork of local Muslims)
@@Muhammed-fv5kv i am talking about centuries
Islam was spread more through the sword. Other factors dont weigh as much.
@@Muhammed-fv5kv I am a Kashmiri Hindu, and we dont want to live with muslims. If you can have referendum for separate state we also want refrendum for seprate state.
@@user-iw4cw9lx8t I'm Pakistani so I'm not anyone to decide where and with whom you should live. But your words show your racist and biased way of thinking. You Pandits lived freely in Kashmir as long as you were friendly with Muslims. What about Jammu and Dalhi, how are yiu treated there? Do Dogras in Jammu see yiu as brothers or as outsiders encroaching on tgeir land?
We think of Kashmir as a mountainous region of mostly nothing with some people in it. There are some 19-20 million people in the region from all three countries. It has over 20 times as many people as south Dakota and it's about 5000 mi2 or ~13000 km2 smaller.
@@TheWebsOfCorruptionNeverFail actually the birth rate of India is only about 2.33 per women. The real reason India has so many people is because the plague didn't ever really come to India, so it just had more people to start with. Remember there are ~2.4 times as many people in the Indian subcontinent than in the European (should be sub)continent.
considering its a less then a % of their total population....
Well kashmir is a 6000 years old civilization. Recently world's oldest supernova rock was found in kashmir's burzahom. Central Asian, Persian, Greeks, Turks, Mongols, everyone has history in kashmir. Silk route went through kashmir.
What's with this Muslim majority region and successionist movements? Look at Chechnya, Bosnia, Xinjiang, Rakhine, Marawi, first, they ghettoize a place, then they kick out other religious minorities and then ask for a seperate country. UK is also scared that's why they are so hell-bent on Brexit and immigration policies ruclips.net/video/UC2VQjSgpso/видео.html
@@trollwizard7613 because ALAH AKBARRRRRRRR
Hindi and Urdu are nearly the same language, but Hindi has much more of a Sanskrit influence, whereas Urdu has a more Perso-Arabic influence.
Uh... Xinjiang is north and Tibet south...
Seriously, how the hell did he mix those two up?
I know where Tibet is, Xinjiang? Nah. Mistakes happen.
He probably was thinking about media portrayals of Tibet that show it as cold, snowy and mountainous (uncharted 2 for example).
Based on that you'd assume it was to the north rather than the south.
I believe he's mispronouncing the Chinese name for the administrative region of Tibet, which is Xizang
@@TorvusVae Well he does say Tibet, so...
It is JAMMU and KASHMIR , KASHMIR is just 5 district out of 22 district , There ladak , Jammu.. Which have No probem which 17 district in combine
@@Muhammed-fv5kv keep wanting!
Daw though, it can be amended?
@Daw dude then u should look at Indian kashmir and Supreme Court of India will abandon this law and make the India unite
This makes the whole kashmir worried off
@Daw because of stupid dick nehru for political gain went to UN for resolution if left the issue to Patel it would have different don't say Pakistan has Kashmir people , after 1947 they want to gobble up whole j&k area with pumping of their pigs and forcefully evacuating locals if you don't know shit about what happened dont come with your shit please refer to UN resolution and wiki pages on Kashmir for other details
If religion is not involved, solution to this would be a piece of cake. After independence, India became a secualr and democractic country, where as Pakistan became Islamic republic. India holds 43% of Kashmir, other hand, Pakistan and China holds remaining 57% Kashmir. See the picture or google u will find. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Line_of_Control
Also kashmir is religiously a very significant part of Hinduism. India will never ever give up kashmir. No not even by a million cuts. So if anyone wants to be part of the 'amazing' Pakistan.. Can always catch a train and be gone for good. The real estate will remain with India. And also read the UN declaration on Kashmir.. Pakistan needs to hand over kashmir to India before any referendum can take place. Fact.
Can u provide me the link of un declaratuon cuz there is a butthurt pakistani whi thnks that what terrorist are doing is a great thing to take revenge for kashmiris.
Delusional Indians
@@RatherA True that!
@@saniyapatel8060 unscr.com/en/resolutions/doc/47 Read under "Restoration of peace and order" in page 4.
Restoration of peace and order is for jammu and kashmir not azad kashmir totally different places
I am From Jammu & i Love My Country 🇮🇳 & so does Muslims living in Jammu.. All The Problem Resides In Kashmir
which country do you support........
Vivek as a fellow Sharma stay strong vro the king decided the land was to go to India and so it will, wish the idiots back in 1947 took care of shit then and there instead of looking upto UN for bullshit directions.
@@AryanSingh-xi8de ...........can you read ...... ?
"i Love My Country 🇮🇳"
@@oneforallah ilove my country india
@@AryanSingh-xi8de good to know also do yourself a favor and learn to read.
After 70 years of partition both the countries are highly proficient in IT sector
India - Information Technology
Pakistan - International Terrorism.
@Prabhas Rawat Information Tech?? Lmao more like proficient street shitting and scamming innocent people.
@@tripleastacz372 well I am a performance engineer in Dell International. Not all are scammers. We have 1.3 billion peoples so everything comes in a large scale.
@@tripleastacz372 OK...let me explain....
Many people are easy to be hired in India for you to give 10 people contact number and say to call all of them....they will do it...about toilet..only 2℅of population do that...
In Singapore we are taught that the capital of Rape and Scam is India.
@Sudhanva Kashyap Explain all the rape then, the capital of Rape in the world is India....
I think we can blame the British. The same people we can blame for the Levant issues. They really have a bad history dealing with territories that are no longer theirs. Still, love you Brits.
Don't be a prick. Partition was entirely an Indian initiative. Blame Jinnah and Nehru.
@@Alan_Mac nehru and the Congress didn't want it. It was mostly Muslim legue who wanted it. The British did the damage by inciting hatred between Hindus and Muslims after the revolt of 1857 in which both communities fought together. If anything blame the British policy of divide and rule for the animosity between the two countries
@Ketan Srivastav savarkar said about it even before Muslim league . Jinnah entered later .
Brits has nothing to do with this. Come out of white guilt. Study the radical ideology.
In this video, he propagated the Pakistani perspective. He didn't mention the deeds of Sikandar Butshikan the idol breaker. Code of Umar being applied on non-Muslims by Aurangzeb the Mongolian Muslim leader & Hindus getting Dhimmi status.
@@Alan_Mac perhaps you'd want to read BBC's account of the events that led to partition. Hear it directly from the horse's mouth.
I am From Jammu & Kashmir...Its Not Kashmir its Jammu and Kashmir..
It Has 3 Adminstrative Divisions
Jammu , Kashmir , Ladakh
Jammu is Hindu Majority & People of every Religion Living in Jammu Loves India
Ladakh is A Mix up of Shia Muslims n Buddhist & Also Loves India
Kashmir is Muslim Majority & Either wants to Merge with Pakistan Or Wants to Become an Independent Country ( Reason being They Are Muslims.. Yup Silly Reason ).. We the people from Jammu & Ladakh Wants a Separate State & UT Because Kashmir has Always Bring Negative Publicity to both of us Even though We Have no problem whatsoever..
You did not mentioned about the genocide of Bengalis by #Pakistan.
Khushal Badhan it has nothing to do with Kashmir dumbass
@@dtssnapback2002 He has covered a lot of that history and left out that detail. It should be included therefore.
Fool
I am a Kashmiri, this is the first mostly accurate description i have found on this conflict
@Sub to PewDiePie No it should be some sort of autonomous region
@@darali568 If you had to choose Pak or India which one?
@@loudfiend4051 I personally wont prefer either ...but i think it would be safe to say if most Kashmiris were given this choice they would choose Pakistan
@@darali568 bro you know that the plebiscite cannot happen now, right?. A lot of things have happened in the last 70 years.
@@preetikushwa7032 obviously I understand we need a different solution now .... But that would start with acknowledgement of the problem .... Not complete denial by repeating Kashmir is a integral part of India again and again ....that is not convening anyone ..... Also there needs to be some accountability for the security forces , they are also responsible for grave human rights abuses...
Ey what it do...ethic Kashmiri here. Kashmir belongs to the Nords
It belongs to queen Daenarys Targaryen
It’s a sealandic enclave
It belongs to Ragnar Lothbrok
ZakPhobic like Skyrim belongs to the nords great u did lighten up the mood a bit 🤣🤣
What these stormcloaks dont realise is that its the Empire thats jeeping the Aldmeri dominion out of Kashmir
The UK, not "Great Britain". You should know better!
So yr forgetting Northern Ireland
@@richardhills6952 ? Northern Ireland is in the UK.
Agreed. Either way, Britain isn't so great anymore.
Not great anymore, you people are puppets of america.
Your map of india is wrong ....not in the north but in west gujarat (region)
Hello, that region of Gujarat is actually submerged half the year so some maps show it like that
I'm exited to see what the end of the world war trilogy is gonna be like
First one was kinda boring, second one really took the series to a whole new level tho
@@rafindrasetiawan1915 but the third one is gonna be the bomb, nothing comin after that, we will have "closure"
Whose profile pic do you have man .
Muhammad Abdul Bari MaximilianMus
Sean Stone Age or extraction
Well done Hilbert. A difficult subject handled with as much tact as is possible from the other side of the world.
Roland Felice he made quite a few errors, but good research, pakistan actually kicked all the hindus out when they took the small part of Kashmir. Kargil war:1999 not 1991, soviet union had helped India during 1971 while US aided pakistan not china, china was a very economically backward country back then.
He propagated the Pakistani perspective. He didn't mention the deeds of Sikandar Butshikan the idol breaker. Code of Umar being applied on non-Muslims by Aurangzeb the Mongolian Muslim leader & Hindus getting Dhimmi status.
@@psuyog bruh wtf does Aurangzeb a 16 century ruler have to do with the present day mess of Kashmir
@@psuyog Pakistani perspective? If international perspective aligns with Pakistani perspective wouldn’t it be more likely that that perspective is probably correct, time to check your perspective
India: Kashmir is mine!
Pakistan: No! Kashmir is mine!
China: Bú! Its palt of South Xingjiang
Britan: How dare you? Its part of British India
Me an Intellectual: Its actually part of "The Republic of North Macedonia" Long live Alexander the Great!
Regarding the referendum, it was not the part of instrument of assesion but a solution to conflict suggested by UN while it was asked to mediate. Also for this referendum to take place Pakistan was to remove all of it's military presence from whole of the J&K and then India would remove most of the forces while keeping a minimal military presence to ensure stability, under these conditions the referendum was supposed to take place. These steps were to be followed in chronological orders. But Pakistan never removed their forces from it's occupied land which was the first step hence Pakistan is the real reason there is no referendum in J&K. This is all written in UN's suggestion of referendum please read it if you won't believe me.
Stop lying Pakistan can hold referendum today and remove its forces but its India with its 700,000 forces in indian occupied kashmir who refuse to do referendum and remove its forces.
@@purpleaceheart did you have any idea what he said?
@@purpleaceheart Remove the forces and face another war like Kargil? Kashmir is a state of India not Pakistan.
@@purpleaceheart where do you get these facts from ISI or JeM?
Total indian army strength is only like 1 million+ which includes the CRPF and BSF even if you add the whole police force in Kashmir it does not add up.
@@AmitSingh-ks9zk if u have already decided its state of India without doing that 'Referendum' it clearly shows India's intention.
@Avadhut Patil chronological orders? really, lol. I have read that report and there is nothing like that in it.
Being an outsider i would suggest UN should send its forces, both countries withdraw their soldiers. Held a referendum which should be transparent and without anyone's influence and proceed with the results.
I know this is not that simple but if both countries want to be prosper they need to solve this issue otherwise this issue will keep leading to war.
Jammu and Kashmir rightfully belongs to India. 🇮🇳
@Carl Johnson Yes because there ruler decided to give this land to India when he died.
No
You’re British you started this whole mess so be quiet.
@@saniaamirbaaz8850 I'm not British. I am a proud Pennsylvanian, born and raised. I have the British flag because I like British history and am an Anglo-phile. I am also a monarchist so Britiain kind works with that. I believe the American states should secede from the corrupt Marxist empire that the United States has become and form independent nations. I would love to see an independent Pennsylvania one day.
There is problem in every corner of world where Muslim population grows. Once they are in certain majority, demand of Separate state based on Sharia law and in name of Islam is common. China, Myanmar, Phillippines have already started taking precautionary measures against growing Islamic terrorism. Europe is on edge and hope it wakes up sooner than later...
You were wrong about the referendum. When India and Pak went to UN about the conflict. It was the UN's resolution that had roughly following steps:
1. Pakistan should take it troops back to International border back from LOC.
2. India should take its troops back to India and leave troops that are needed for defense and administration.
3. A referendum will be held then and then only.
This has not followed because of the mistrust between two countries as both think that take away troops means giving a free hand to the other and as Pakistan has to withdraw first, it will essentially lose its control over the gained land If India doesnt comply to UN resolution. And between all of this politics, the people of both the countries and especially those living in POK and J&K are suffering.
About China invading India, it can also be said that India violated Chinese borders first. Because of the mess that the Brits left in that region both India and China were holding different documents that said different about what the actual border was. India used it forward first policy and had installed outpost according to their thinking what the international border was which actually was behind the line of the Chinese troops and hence was seen as chinese as border incursion by the Indian troops. This was the conflict that should have never happened as it could have been easily solved diplomatically. But this rift that happened between India and China has had great negative implications on development of India and its conflict over Kashmir with Pakistan.
We need someone like you in media for India to prosper.
@@karthikchalla4490 If people are made aware of the facts there will be a major backlashes for politicians on both the sides and hence no one wants the facts known. Spreading of hate is easier then spreading of love.
You should have mentioned the Kashmiri Hindu Pandit Genocide by kashmiri Muslims in 1990's.
That's fake news. The pandits left on there own
@@astrognosis
Stop giving Stupid Replies.
@@astrognosis go and check Wikipedia or Google ya ignorant fucktard
France and England once fought a hundred years war (and many more wars). Give it time, in a few hundred years Pakistan and India will be allies.
Bob Joe well I think not in few years Pakistan will be an economic colonie of China and u know why
Pakistan is gonna lease itself for thousand years to China
POKALA EMPEROR.DINESH exactly
@ what is wrong with leasing Pakistan to China (although I doubt that's going to happen)? If the people end up better off that way, then why not. It might be good for them.
God forbid that. We can never be like them. We are sane people.
Kashmir je Srbija
the hero of the German war of 1860 said at the time the next major European conflict would be sparked by a foolish incident in the Balkans.
bad bot
Bro..... KASHMIR IS BANGLADESH
Lol
@@Ivan_Drago. yes
Not 700,000 there are only 300,000 army which includes many doctors, nurses, teachers, drivers, engineers etc. there are only 100,000 armed soldiers for security & some of them are peace making army...
700,000 military personnel not only army and never trust government figures they always lie to general population......
@@ameerhamza4046 India has 1.4M troops and 700,000k deployed in just Kashmir. Are you an idiot?
@@jirachi-wishmaker9242 you're an idiot there are two fronts in Kashmir Pakistan and china .... You clearly never been to LOC and LAC they literally have to patrol every inch to stop the movement of rebel groups and Chinese troops incursions ...
@@ameerhamza4046 you are idiot there is one front in kashmir & one in ladakh.
"clearly you have never been to LoC & LAC"
i think you forgot to mention 1990 kashmiri pandit genocide, that's the reason why there are no hindus in ladakh, when there was majority of hindus and buddhists before 1990
He did at the end. You guys always whine about this don't you?
I have respect to all people but where Islam goes there is always war or slow decline of economy and then revolution
True
There are numerous inaccuracy.
1) Pashtuns were incident by Pakistan to destabilized the Kashmir region.
2) You forgot to mention the numerous Human Rights abuse on Bangladesh by Pakistani Army
3) Kargil War happened on 1999 (not on 1991).
4) You also forgot to mention that how Pakistan train and aid terrorists to carry out insurance accross India.
There are many abuses on Pakistan Occupied Kashmir as well and not only that POK is also a hub of terrorism, whose only job is not to fight for Kashmir freedom but fought a war against India.
>You forgot to mention the numerous Human Rights abuse on Bangladesh by Pakistani Army
What does this have to do with kashmir ?
Why do people always forget about the 1947 massacres ? Pashtuns didn't just attack Kashmir for no reason , they were motivated because Hindus and Sikhs were slaughtering up to 100K Muslim in Kashmir with the support of the maharaja .
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1947_Jammu_massacres
Also you forgot to mention that there existed another pricently state that was majority hindu but with a muslim ruler and India just annexed it "because Hindus should join India" and Pakistan didn't object to that . But how dare Pakistan try annexing a muslim majority princely state .
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indian_annexation_of_Hyderabad
He also skips over the fact that only the muslims wanted partition. And the fact that there are many MAAAANY muslims living in India today, but almost no hindu's living in Pakistan!
And as you said, he pooped the Kargill war, and totally didn't discuss what's been happening last couple of weeks... :o
@@toprob20 How dare muslims want a country of their own , right ?
@@user-sx1mm1sl6u
Free Kashmir and Kashmir under Pakistan is not the same Thing.
Simple thing Kashmir always belonged to India .It was during mughal period that muslims came there , displaced natives and settled their own people.Roots of indian culture in kashmir existed way before mughals came.So you can decide on your own
Great video. Just a few points i would like to add:
1) In the video, you narrated that the Pakistani Pashtun tribesmen who invaded Kashmir in 47 were the kin of local muslim Kashmiris. That's not quite correct. Pashtuns and Kashmiris are quite different from each other with huge geographical distance between them separated by valleys and mountain ranges. Kashmiris are habitants of the Himalayas meanwhile Pashtun tribes are mostly settled around Hindukash mountain range around rivers Kabul and Swat. Pashtuns and Kashmiris can't even understand each others language. The hybrid ethnic group residing between both of them is the Hazara people who speak Hindku. Kashmiris and Hazaras can easily understand each other.
2) You said that Pakistanis went into Kashmir when it was ascertained that Kashmiris will not be allowed to vote on which side they want to join. Well, that's a misstatement as the concept of voting only originated only after the case fire took effect in 48 and the matter was referred to the UN Security Council. The British rules of partition for all princely states where that they could either join India or Pak or choose to stay independent and that decision was to be taken by the Raja (ruler) of that princely state. It was never meant to be democratic. Swat, Chitral, Bahawalpur, Sangar and many other princely states agreed to join Pak only because their ruler opted to do so.
3) The reason why Pakistan wants Kashmir so desperately is because its only source of water (Indus river) flows through Kashmir. And till Kashmir is in Indian hands, Pakistan will always be at Indian mercy. It would have been better if that point was highlighted with more emphasis because that's extremely important.
3) Adding the Bangladesh story was irrelevant to the Kashmir conflict. They are both unrelated and only increased the length of the video.
Edit detected, opinion accepted.
Love From- J&K ✌️India
@@user-jj7yh4vb3j you are from jammu* not kashmirb
1. Both of them are the same religion sect and have very similar or same skin colour and both of them are indo Aryan
2. That’s one of the reason but India has always persecuted Muslim before partitions (congress tyranny) and after partition (biggest example Kashmir) even tho India is about 5 times bigger than Pakistan in almost everything Pakistan has attained a significant amount of land if it was in the mercy of India it would have been taken into India
3. Yes
@@rooh8258 Im from J&K and ain't from jammu.
I don't think anybody here needs the specifics.
And i think u shd attend ur geography lessons correctly and learn about UT of J&K.
I think I agree most with the Kashmiri(?) who want to go start their own country instead of putting up with Pakistan and India squabbling. It's like when two kids can't agree over who gets to play with a toy and it gets taken away, except the toy is the one taking itself away.
It's easy to just comment for a by-stander without any stake.
There was a chance for plebiscite after the independence of both India and Pakistan say 1950s but since Pakistan having changed demography of its side of occupied Kashmir and funding terrorists into Kashmir and creating Exodus of Hindus from Kashmir has absolutely sealed all deal of Giving any right to voice of Kashmir that has completely been under propoganda since independence (thanks to congress).
It's time to just call it quits for both nations and Kashmiris need to stop feeling entitled.
They have enjoyed such amazing privileges for 75 years with noone in India having any say or able to buy anything in Kashmir and only pushed themselves towards radicalism.
Once those Tyrants that rules Kashmir under Congress govt lose the whip , the prosperity and peace will come to Kashmir and issue will be solved.
Very thought provoking, well researched and relevant as ever! Thank you
@Swapn Lok This is not the textbook in your country to sing your song. He tried his best to be impartial. As a Pakistani, I agree with him. He just explained the facts. India has 700000 pera military force for this purpose which is not included in the 1.3 million regular force. As the world is opening up by the social media your culprit gov brutalities will be in front of the international community and soon Kashmir will be free for foreign occupation. Modi psychopath is trying his best to cover up everything by blaming Pakistan. But remember truth will always prevail.
@Swapn Lok That's all well and good, but the plebiscite isn't in effect, for one simple reason: India hasn't signed it.
@@younasmarwat5205 where is the fucking proof that there are 700k Indian troops in kashmir? Are you mad? Have you ever looked at India's borders? India has 7561 km of border with China, bangladesh, myanmar nepal Bhutan. Do you really think that narrow 100×40 km area of Kashmir valley will have 700000 troops? Did you count them? Who the fuck said that? Indian army hasn't even confirmed that. Fucking propagandist
He propagated the Pakistani perspective.He didn't mentioned the precondition of UN before taking election. He didn't mention the deeds of Sikandar Butshikan the idol breaker. Code of Umar being applied on non-Muslims by Aurangzeb the Mongolian Muslim leader & Hindus getting Dhimmi status.
17:28 why are you so good at pronouncing these groups xd
Ikr? I played that part again, his pronunciation was perfect. I think he might be Arab.
He's Dutch
Kashmir belongs to India, how much is actually Kashmir is where the real problem is
The place surrounded by 700k armed Indian force with foreign faces and language bringing with them indian hereditary r*pe problem
@@RatherA no, it borders with Pakistan with hereditary castration problem. Hereditary terrorism problem. Etc.
All of it. All of it is Kashmir.
India can keep their side of Kashmir. we and the inhabitants of Pakistani Kashmir are content with ours
that's the only way to maintain peace.
I agree with you from India. 🇮🇳♥️🇵🇰
As a 50% Indian I reckon that India would probably have been in a better position in the modern world had it become part of the British commonwealth later. They’re doing alright now but the bitter rivalry between Pakistan and India could have been avoided had the British not split the country apart. On top of that the countries in the commonwealth nowadays are generally doing well and considered “developed”.
However, given the circumstances I can understand why British India wanted independence. The British (as most colonial rulers throughout history) weren’t particularly kind to the locals and were more worried about economic gains than supporting the country.
Either way, I’m glad the whole region is doing better now. I hope the Kashmir issue dies down and no war occurs.
(It seems to be a theme in history that stuff goes wrong when outside rulers make decisions that ignore the locals... (the Middle East after WW1 for example).)
kikivoorburg you.... I like you
Indeed you talk sense.
The Flying Dutchman I don’t believe they wanted to ever fully develop the country as that would not make sense for he British to do. They also did not want India to be independent but they knew it was inevitable. That’s why they did what they did. Either leave peacefully or a civil war would ensure, and the British could not deal with one, especially on the verge of war
The Flying Dutchman
Sounds intriguing, I’ll have a look if I can find any info on this. Though I do agree with Ruchik Animations’ response in the sense that it seems somewhat unlikely.
That being said I’m absolutely no expert on this subject. I honestly haven’t learnt much about India itself since I live in the Netherlands and, despite living abroad for a large part of my life, have never lived in India.
I’ll do some digging to see what I find!
10 OG don’t forget about the time the USA tried to keep India from making their own nukes but they did under the nose of the CIA
Why did you not talk about the 10 genocides of hindus and buddhists between 1300 to 1980s?
Anyways good video tho
@@RatherA so, thats the reason why there is majority Hindu population in Kashmir. Right?
@@RatherA more than 3k died. The number of death of kashmiri hindus was inflated so that riots do not take place in whole of India.
The killing of muslims in Jammu is a hearsay. It would have been a partition violence in which same number of hindus were also killed.
@Daw I don't know about anything called Indian Propaganda but you really sound like spreading anti-national propaganda
He can’t he will get trouble RUclips will ban him
Daw proof where is the evidence
Sadly we have seen this kind dividing up regions before, for example the Middle-East and Africa. And there too, are many conflicts. And in the middle of all this are the inhabitants of these regions. The effects of poorly done decolonization are still felt to this day.
I don't think kashmir was really peacefull before colonization. You should probably blame human nature or Nationalism instead.
@@konradvonschnitzeldorf6506 It wasn't there were 11 exodus of Kashmiri Hindus before Sikhs took the power. The Sikhs took sword on request of Kashmiri Hindus to help them from second class citizens under sharia rule.
The Sikandar Butshikan Meaning the idol breaker took power in Kahsmir around centuries before. Code of Umar being applied on non-Muslims by Aurangzeb the Mongolian Muslim leader & Hindus getting Dhimmi status.
wrong that pakistan claims kashmiri referendum was unlawfully put off..
fact: UN mandated resolution for plebiscite requires
1) pakistan should withdraw forces from the so called azad kashmir and gilgit/baltistan
2) india has to maintain sufficient forces in the territory to maintain law and order
3) after the UN is satisfied that the situation is conducive, referendum for deciding the fate of kashmir should be organised...
you cannot randomly say india doesn’t want the plebiscite, india is a secular democracy, when will pakistan vacate the parts its occupied unlawfully? i think their answer would be... never...
India was forcefully made Secular.
@@cataclysmal5315 India as a geographic entity was always pluralistic...
Pluralism is confused in India as secularism...🤦
Bring secular is not being associated with any religion, and our secularism is trying to please minority religious 🤦 stupidest concept ever...
@@satyasubhash8869 Are you on nationalistic drugs? India is no different from Pakistan. They abuse minorities such as Christians and Muslims while the police turns a blind eye. Your prime minister uses the death of those Indian soldiers that died to the terrorist attack for his own political propaganda. He is no different to those Islamic terrorists running amok in the middle east. Shame on everyone.
UN resolution for plebiscite has been rendered obsolete because the Chinese have annexed largest chunks of land. Pakistan has severed Gilgit and Baltistan from the original Kashmir thereby invalidating what was Kashmir. The issue of homeless Kashmiri Pundits has not been resolved yet.
@@ravisharma167 couldn't agree with you more... But the subject of referendum keeps coming back over and over again without knowing the meaning and implication of the word...🤷
What a political, cultural and religious nightmare. But don't worry guys trust the almighty Republic of China to arbitrate everything.
Winnie the pooh, I mean Pandas for everyone!
NB : congratz on this one Hilbert, quite a tricky but unfortunately key topic
Taiwan is Republic of China. The one ruled by Pooh bear is People's Republic of China.
1) India hasn't signed the plebiscite, meaning Pakistan doesn't have to abide by it.
2) With 300,000 (as you claimed) along with 35,000 CRPF occupying Kashmir, whose people number 12.5 million, it truly becomes increasingly apparent who the true aggressor is. Kashmir must become independent, its people are dissimilar to the rest of India.
@@rottingdog6798 Kashmir is not alone there are parts like jammu and ladhak which are pro India. So it is a mess which will be solved politically once pakistan stop sending jihadis.
@Godd Howard What do you mean "Laughs"? is that a singular laugh rather than a plural laugh?
1. Republic of China is the government that cuttrntly rulling Taiwan not mailand China. The red China is called the People's republic of China.
2.Republic of China(Taiwan) Claims all the region in Kashmir that PRC claim, as well as some of the Pakistan control part. They also claim about 50%'s land of Tajikstan (yes 50%), northern Burma and some part of Russia which PRC gives up the claims. ROC is about 9.85 million square km, makes her even 5% larger than PRC on paper work. LOL
Genocide of Bengalis is not mentioned as the cause for split.
19:50 7 lakh army men in Kashmir is a fake number Pakistan has come up with. Total strength of Indian army is 12 lakhs, how can 7lakh be in a small region that is valley of Kashmir leaving rest huge border of India to just 5 lakh of army men. Some logical argument from Pakistanis would be a welcome.
where did you get this info Indian news 🤣🤣
How can there will be peace if religion of peace is there.
Lol
@@mrcrazychickengaming7918 Haven't you already tried 4 times?
@@Elixir6 what do mean? Both Pakistan and india didn't have nukes back then. Although I love to see Pakistan or China lauch a nuke at shitty india, that would be awesome.
@@mrcrazychickengaming7918 In 1999 both India and Pakistan have nuclear power and keep thinking that your beloved china going to nuke India while what China is actually capturing Pakistan without nuking them and your government keep giving their land to them.
@@Elixir6 Anyway, why is india a dog of israel? Lol😂🇮🇳
I'm a Pakistani 🇵🇰and I respect 🇵🇰🇮🇳army # peace not war
#MakeChaiNotWar
Dude, no one wants war.
But we do want JeM, Lashkar and Taliban dead.
@@r.d.x7403 the first 2. maybe u can try to uproot them but Taliban ? no way dude, they have the right to govt as they represent a huge majority in Afg, also do u really think u can root them out when the biggest superpower after 17 years is in table talks with them ? lol
Heat Ray there's no power on earth that can destroy 🇵🇰 good luck with that
Respect Pakistan from Turkey🇵🇰🇹🇷🇵🇰🇹🇷
I would like to add a few things to your quite well made video.
1. At 15:24 you said Kargil War took place in 1991. It actually took place in 1999.
2. Between 3:50 to 4:20 you said during partition 30% was Hindu. Then you mentioned that Kashmir Valley had 4% Hindu. You should have added that 4% was the figure much later today (includes non permanent residents). In 1947 Kashmir valley was around 10% Hindu, with capital Srinagar having 20% Hindu
www.dailyo.in/politics/jammu-and-kashmir-pakistan-gilgit-baltistan-hindus-sikhs-1947-partition-karan-singh-poonch-muzaffarabad/story/1/12632.html
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exodus_of_Kashmiri_Hindus
3. The indigenous people of Kashmir are Kashmiri Pandits who are Hindus. These Kashmiri Hindus faced genocide and were driven out completely between 1989 to 1991. These indigenous Hindus were majority throughout history and they faced genocide multiple times before they were turned into a minority. They have no where to go and no place to call home and can definitely not be safe in Islamic Pakistan. For them to have a homeland and be safe it is necessary for Kashmir to be in Secular India. Also they are indigenous to the land and they want to be a part of India.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kashmiri_Pandit
kashmirstudygroup.com/images/maps_images/Fig4_v6.jpg
4. East Pakistan had 28% Hindu till 1971. After genocide committed on Hindu Bengalis by Pakistan army their population declined to less then 15%. Today indigenous Bengali Hindus are just 6% of Bangladeshi population. That 30% is what kept East Pakistan more secular and thus was a thorn in the way for Islamic Pakistan. Thus the genocide committed. Not to mention in 1947 East Pakistan was about 40% Hindu. Look for Noakhali genocide.
Good video otherwise.
Kashmir belongs to Sri Lanka
Sri Lanka belongs to akhand Bharat...and so does aghanistan, Pakistan, Tibet, Bangladesh, mayanmar, Indonesia, Vietnam , Nepal and Malaysia
@@abhinavbharadwaj13 and China, korea, japan, australia, iran, and afghanistan
@@abhinavbharadwaj13 and Iran, Saudi, Japan, Russia, USA, UK, UAE :v
No kashmir belongs to me,i'm the king hahaha...😂😂😂
Great video! Your neutrality is appreciated :)
Kevin MacLeod is a talented man, for sure. Looks like he's in high demand too.
Also, who here's just been blasting Led Zeppelin this whole time and singing the riff in people's faces? * holds up hand *
Why not Just let the Kashmiris decide on Kashmir would that be the most moral and best thing to do
After changing the demographics of Kashmir ?
Kashmir is named after Kashyap Rishi🚩
i am kashmir we want freedom from india its our Democratic Right, when will so called land of liberty help us?
which "Land of Liberty" are you referring to?
@@ritikshaw5868 the country that invade countries incase of human right violations and for democracy
then go to pakistan. Your brothers are waiting for you.
Azad Kashmir isn't Azad (free)😂
its not kashmir , its punjab . Sikhs merged it with Kashmir for administration .
@Mr K you are Pakistani
@Mr K Oh you belong to country of better.
Yeah it is Ghulam Kashmir.
Why are India and Pakistan fighting over Kashmir ?
Short answer : because of Islam (and also the brits a little bit)
Because each side lays claims on the very same region.
@Swapn Lok You are right. Islam does have a bad habit of claiming home lands and important religious cities of other people's.
Like Israel and Jerusalem with Judaism, Anatolia and Constantinople with Christan Greeks, Kosovo with Serbia and so on.
Swapn Lok Exactly! That’s the very nature of this evil and violent religion.
Mr. White Good luck! 😉👍🏻
Obest The Blue Maccabee Islam is nothing, but a dark satanic cult.
173 my IQ Really?
9:01 No. Aksai Chin was under Chinese control since 1899. The Chinese had already built a road passing through Aksai Chin connecting Tibet and Xinjiang in the 1950s. No territory was lost in the 62 war.
Surely you missed geography classes during the topic of TIBET
Thanks for laughing at my horrible joke to
Islam in East Bengal was not intermixed with Hinduism... religion was not a factor in conflict between the two.
They came in, they bread 5 times faster than non Muslims, they claim the land as Islamic and ask for referendum and independence. No doubt why people in Myanmar are kicking out those Rohingya's, they dont want another Kashmir there.
Pak initiated the attack three times and got pushed back
now the militant groups of kashmir have direct and open relations with the pak government, this is not going to do any good
I am Indian and I understand my country's problem too, governments over the time have been using the area for their political campaign, media is facing its worst condition.
I still believe there should be a vote for all three options.
Kashmir will be separated from india very very very soon. Pakistan will be saved very very very soon
1948 - Gilgit Baltistan and half of Kashmir became part of Pakistan. 1965 - Lahore and Sialkot are still part of Pakistan. 1999 - Stalemate
The Pakistan Army offered prayer in delhi mosque on 1965 war
MM Alam destroyed 5 indian planes in less than a minute in 1965
@@Ahmar312 Bangladesh is now a new country bro 🤣🤣 and you are talking about some barren land captured by your army. And go see the video where Pakistani soldier surrendered all of their weapons. Indian army never surrendered. My comment was about this anyways
you know what? why cant we give it to Switzerland
yeah problem solved yuhu
@@Kashmirisheir123 i forgot i made that comment
@@weewodon 😅🤣
THIS WHY IM SO LUCKY LIVE IN INDIA 🇮🇳 😬🇮🇳😬🇮🇳 @ THE CLEANEST COUNTRY IN THE WORLD, WE NEVER DO SCAM! AND WE GIVE RESPECT TO ALL MUSLIM AND WOMEN THEY CAN WALK SAFELY ALONE AT NIGHT AND WE HAVE CLEAN FOOD AND TOILET EVERYWHERE 🇮🇳
KNOW MANY POOR PEOPLE JEALOUS WITH
SUPER RICH INDIA 🇮🇳 😬🇮🇳😬🇮🇳
When the colony of British India became independent from Britain, Muslims following their leader Jinnah got their own independent country called Pakistan. Kashmir had a nominal Hindu princely ruler Hari Singh and a representative Muslim political leader Sheikh Abdullah, who jointly decided to become an independent country of their own. This terrified Jinnah, the leader of the newly forming Pakistan, because he was worried that if Kashmir went its own way, then other groups could likewise go their own way to form their own independent countries instead of joining Pakistan - which would mean the stillbirth and collapse of Pakistan. Jinnah was particularly frightened that the restless and heavily armed Pashtun tribes would form their own independent Pashtunistan, in imitation of Kashmir. So Jinnah decided to despatch a group of armed Pashtun mercenaries to attack Kashmir, and take possession of it for him. When the Pashtun mercenaries attacked, Hari Singh and Sheikh Abdullah fled to Delhi, India and pledged to join India if it would help to repel the Pashtun invaders. India accepted their pledge and sent the Indian Army's Sikh Light Infantry to fight off the Pashtun mercenaries. The fighting then escalated as Pakistan sent its army into the fight. The Viceroy of India, a Brit named Mountbatten, was fearful that the British officers embedded among the Indian and Pakistani forces would be forced to fight and kill each other - something that he as a Brit wished to avoid at all costs (even though he was in the pay of India's new govt and was supposed to be loyal to India's interests, he was more worried about his fellow Brits.) So Mountbatten convinced Indian leaders to take the case to the UN and pursue a ceasefire. The area has then remained in contested standoff ever since.
14:40 Sikkim belongs to India and the Gujarat part is also wrong
By the way the word is "Muhajirs" not "Mujahirs".
i am Pakistani and i think People of Kashmir should be given a chance to decide their future!
Khurram Zubair dude you know China’s just gonna take it if India and Pakistan leave it alone
You mean people of kashmir who are extremist muslims should given a chance to decide their future? Why? Did they give chance to hindu kashmiri brahmin pandits? 65 percent hindus lived in kashmir in 1930s. Now thats almost 20 percent. And now these muslims say that land is theirs and we want to decide fate it. Like wtf?? how about you shut the fuck up and live in India. Tomorrow some other part of India will have majority of muslims and even they'll ask for other country lol. India can't give everyone they want. Kashmir is Indian territory. Period.
Nothing but fabricated right-wing Hinduvuta nonsense. The PRE-independence census of 1941 recorded that Muslims made up 72.41% of the population. The Hindu pandits made up 6-5% of the population, and even then, these Hindus weren't native to Kashmir. They were a remnant of Dogra transplanting his army from their native homelands to Kashmir in the 19th century.
PakMan but it still won’t be independent
Who cares what the population was in the past, what matters is what is now. A referendum really needs to be held before ww3 starts. Kashmir can be broken into 5-10 sections and each will join the country they vote for. And no independence option as that’d create more problems than it resolves.
Today, When a kashmiri pandit(hindu) goes back to kashmir and wishes his land/property to be freed from occupying muslims.. No one helps them, no court listens to then, no police comes to their aid, also, if they somehow manage to file a complaint they can't fight or follow it in court simply because they are hindus. They can't even rent a room in Kashmir bcs muslims don't rent them.. even the judge sitting in the lower court tells the kashmiri hindu to let poor muslims to occupy their land😑 there has been a complete failure of Indian system.
Yeah maybe that's why hindu shops are so popular in kashmir? You an idiot
It's Jammu and Kashmir,not kashmir,big difference.
*Easy solution* : Do a referendum in the Whole Kashmir Province, so Kashmiri people get the right to choose. Period.
yes. thats democracy
I am absolutely for a referendum. It seems like the most civilized way to solve the conflict. However the problem with having a plebiscite now is that a significant population of Hindus from the region (who would probably vote to be with India) have been driven away from Kashmir by terrorists. There are various accounts / news reports which state that LeT terrorists will routinely walk into a Hindu dominated village and slit the throats of child, women, and men. Hence the exodus. The demographic change will have an effect on the result of any such referendum
Drive away and cleanse the place of the natives of the land. Occupy said land and make a huge and cry when the natives assert their ownership of the said land. Now make more and more copies of yourself in that land and claim that that is your land. Wah. Kya logic Hain. Uttamam bhrata uttamam.
@@prateek752 The fuck you sayin' man.
Hilbert there are three countries at each other's throats over the Kashmir. China hasn't done any serious engaging over the land since the war they fought over the region to cement their control over the northern section but they indirectly oppose India through being Pakistan's largest weapons supplier and weapons tech (like missile technology)
So Kashmir is the Balkans of Asia.
As a half Indian and half Pakistani, I believe that my opinions regarding this are completely neutral, and only based on factual evidence.
When asked, the leader of Kashmir claimed that he wanted Kashmir to be an independent state: in other words, neither part of India or Pakistan.
If that cannot be enforced today, I do believe that there should be a vote among the Kashmiri people.
Technically speaking, the reasons for Pakistan wanting Kashmir was understandable; Kashmir was overwhelmingly Muslim, and as we know, the whole purpose of the split was to segregate all the Muslims into Pakistan and Hindus into India.
However, when Pakistan carried out an invasion into Kashmir, the leader of Kashmir did not have a big enough army to fight it alone. He turned to Nehru (the leader of India at the time) for help to fight the Pakistani rebels. Nehru was about to, but...
Lord Mountbatten (the British colonial at the time), told Nehru not to give the Indian army to Kashmir for nothing in return. Therefore, Nehru wrote an agreement: that India would only send Kashmir their army to help, if Kashmir agreed to be a part of India in return.
The leader of Kashmir, under duress, signed the treaty. India kept pushing Pakistan back, until the current partition. This is because, the Pakistanis had been pushed back onto the mountainous area of Kashmir, whereas the Indian army was still on a flat surface. They knew that the Pakistanis were at an advantageous height, and that they would kill all the Indian soldiers if they carried on trying to push back, so that is where they drew the border.
So there are many questions.
1. Should Pakistan have Kashmir?
- The whole purpose of the divide was religious
- Pakistan argues that this was initial agreement (religious divisions) that all the countries agreed to together
2. Should India have Kashmir?
- Legally, there is a document that the leader of Kashmir signed, and this document states that Kashmir will go to India in return for Indian aid
- But is this document still legal, if it was signed under duress?
3. Should Kashmir be independent?
- Although the main purpose of the split was religious, each head of state in ( what was at the time India) was asked which country they wanted to be part of
- If the leader of Kashmir wanted to remain independent, then do India or Pakistan claim a right to Kashmir?
@Sub to PewDiePie lol if they are independent they'll be annexed by Pakistan or china. They won't be able to survive between three nuclear states. Moreover, division on the basis of religion is never successful. Look at India we have 180 mil muslims and paxtan has 200mil. Not so much. But everything is way better in India. The Indian administered kashmir has gdp $22B and the Pakistani occupied one has mere $3B. India has given a special status to kashmir so that no Indian from other parts of the country can buy land or settle in kashmir but kashmiris can settle in india. But Pakistanis have taken advantages of this by ethnically cleansing the hindu population by spreading the radicalized Islamic propaganda.
@@ambujbhaskar9288 Those are just your opinions.
oh...man....You are the worst kind of human being. Not your comment. Just the fact to hear that you are half'n'half of "those two" makes my skin crawl.
@@ambujbhaskar9288 "India has given a special status to kashmir so that no Indian from other parts of the country can buy land or settle in kashmir but kashmiris can settle in India."
This did NOT age well.
Kashmir is a Hindu seat of Learning & Shaivait Hindu university, our holy land. Soon Kailas mountain range & Nilam-zelam Valley will be part of Indian Union.
17:15 #relegion of peace
India did not let Kashmiri vote because in UN resolution .
People could only choose India or Pakistan if Pakistan army moved out of the region which they didn't.
Like this if Kashmir belongs to Britain
Only 🐎 💩 belongs to 🇬🇧
The legacy of British colonialism continues...
10:19 " *wtf father country of both* "
would it be best scenario to have a independent kashmir state, or have it be part of india/pakistan? Or would there be a better option
As he mentioned, the water source comes from Kashmir and feeds in downstream towards pretty much the agricultural basket for both countries. Having an independent state may cause some troubles since both countries would try to gain leverage on that state and it may cause even further problems. However at this rate, both countries will be at each others throats until a major war erupts and that would be catastrophic. Also you have terrorists in the region and from what we know from Afghanistan, they'll never go away so it's a strange situation.
I guess there is no better option, its a bizarre situation and the people are paying the price of political power. Both countries should be ashamed but they have no shame.
Sadly, no. It is too weak both militarily and economically to stand on its own and the moment the other two powers leave the nation alone, one will most likely take control. Most likely,however, is that Kashmir will fall in the hand of terrorists
Pascal d'Achard van Enschut I say kill everyone there and that will end any disputes
Yes.
Kashmir should be Switzerland of Asia. It sure is prettier than Switzerland tbh.
Pakistan has repeatedly asked for a referendum on Kashmir but India blocks it again and again, even the UN have decreed that Kashmir required a referendum but Indian Brahim Hindutva BJP extremists instead choose to slaughter and massacre Kashmiris as they know they want either Independent Kashmir or Pakistan, definitely not India.
One of the best explanations I've seen, well done and thanks.
wow! what a great vedio. being a kashmiri i want to add here some thing . the problem is minority regions like Ladakh and jammu have not see any mass rapes and massacre by indian troops thats why they don't have any problem with india.
But we kashmiris can not forget what indian army has done here in kashmir.
#we_will_die_brave_not_slave
#we _want_referendum
unhoon ne referendum nehi deni , isse behtar bandook pakr ke unki gand pharde
Yes a referendum might be the best solution.
In my opinion the best solution is the Independence of Kashmir. Make Kashmir a separate country and let the Kashmiris live peacefully🙏🙏
The economy of Kashmir is too weak for that
It can never be. It would become a hotbed of Islamic terrorism as Pakistanis have kept it poor and underdeveloped.
India has tried to bring it up with Crores of investment. But the military takes a large chunk of money.
If one of the three powers withdraws than the other would race to capture the land.
Pakistan would never free the land they hold because they are focused on the conquest and distraction India.
If the would where to be freed than China would just race to capture it as well.
The best thing is the status que.
That’s not a good idea as economically it can’t stand on its own. And it is too militarily weak. I’d expect that once it gains independence a much larger country(China probably) will attempt to either annex or puppet it, as it has practically no military
Yes, exactly what India and the world needs - another failed Islamic state that breeds terrorists and provides them a base
You forget that Pakistan gifted some parts of Kashmir to his father
He didn't . He mentioned Pakistanis gave away some land to China.
Kashmiri Independence?
Muslim Kashmiri to Pakistan?
Hindu Kashmiri to India?
Buddhist Kashmiri to China?
FIND OUT MORE
In the Next Episode of Dragon Ball Kash!!
70k soldiers on kashmir soil😂😂
The number comes from Paxtan's magical number churning machines
A well-made unbiased video as always Hilbert! Thank you for the insights.
Solution: Kashmir becomes the Autonomous State of Hashmir, is administered from Amsterdam as a World Recreation Park, Pakistan, China, India no longer have claim to any areas and remove all of their police and military.
Change my mind.
better think of making Tibat free from jaws of China as Jammu & Kashmir is entirely a democratic state which is burning owing to terrorists trained by Pakistan
i wonder which position kashmir takes on the list of "top ten regions where people hate each others guts the most"
1:15 Kasmir means goddess Durga in Sanskrit.
Lot of holes.. First one is Hindus and Muslims can't get together?? So that's why they divided the Indian Sub-Continent??
It's all part of the 'Great Game' and the 'Great' colonial enterprise of British.
Last one is on 'Islam' itself that took over Kashmir, financed by Pakistan.
In between many holes. You're right on India in Kashmir but if other holes are filled, you get a different picture.
jesshu22 well the Hindu Muslim issue is complex. First there is the fact that Hinduism is polytheistic and well Islam has had a rough history with those kinds of faiths. Then the fact that Muslims came as conquerors and Muslim rulers often oppressed Hindus. As a result the Hindus are now doing the same to Muslims which isn’t easing the tension. The British also didn’t make it better by fueling the hatred between the two groups. It’s a rough history between the two and it isn’t helped by the British or the creation of Pakistan.
There's holes in your thing aswell... The Brits didn't want to split India and the Hindu's didn't want to split India but Jinnah didn't want the muslims to become a minority in the new state! How would they opress people who think differently otherwise?!?
Both of you two people who replied thinking people in terms of religion rather than human beings. People are sensible enough to solve problems when they live next each other rather than forming communes. Of course there's brutal history of Islamic Invasions but there are peaceful times during Muslim rule too.
@@jesshu22 Well, there never was a real period of peace in the muslim world... But the people in 1947 India where swept up in communal conflict and hatred. Fanned by the muslim league who didn't want to live with the hindu's.
ofcoarse people had been living right next to eachother for generations. But many villages and neighborhoods where divided by etnicity nonetheless.
Your thinking is based on secular thought, which developed when the westerners came to conclusion that religion is not the solution to their problems. Eventually it became a universal concept because of western dominance. It was transplanted in other societies, which were functioning on fundamentally different dynamics. Moghul empire functioned differently as 'princely states' were governed by their own monarchs, and they were to govern their states and swear allegiance to Moghul empire and provide for revenue and soldiers for central government. Religion came to the equation later, when British East India played this card to divide polity and cement their control. By end of British Raj, Muslims were fearful that the Hindu dominance would be to the detriment of Muslim rights as a minority and their religious freedom. That was the crux of Two Nation Theory, i.e. Hindi and Muslims have a different value system and it's best that they were given independent countries. While secular society may work for western civilization, with some problems like assimilation and resistance of sub cultures to accept the dominant culture. The secular system is under stress in India, where Muslims are at odds with growing Hindu culture under PM Modi, as they are forced to give up their religious freedom, such as restrictions of practice of religion and prosecution at the hands of government.
If you read the UN resolution it has three parts. First, Pakistani forces would return to their side; Second Indian forces would draw down leaving enough to ensure peaceful conditions; and Third a plebiscite would be held to ascertain the will of the people.
Step One never took place, nor did the others. And there you have it.
Fuck UN. You seriously think they're the epitome of democracy and justice?
Thanks for this video, great research and explaining. You earned a subscriber.